20/20 - Blood and Water: 'Facts Don't Lie'

Episode Date: May 20, 2026

Decades after Leslie Preer's murder, two detectives take a fresh look at the case. To get new episodes early, follow "Blood and Water" for free on ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Apple Podcasts���⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Spotify⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Amazon Music⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This is Deborah Roberts here with another weekly episode of our latest true crime series from ABC and ABC audio, Blood and Water. Remember, you can get new episodes early by following Blood and Water on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you're listening right now. Here's the next episode of Blood and Water. Every family has its secrets. But what happens when you discover that your dad has been living a double life? That is not the look of an innocent man. Is everyone lying to me about who they are?

I felt such desperation. I felt it was what I had to do. Listen to Deep Cover the Family Man, wherever you get your podcasts. It was three weeks after his wife's murder that Sandy Prier told investigators he was no longer going to talk to them. My attorney said not to answer any more questions. And again, I don't need to show me any disrespect to you guys at all. Once Sandy said he was done talking, the detectives seemed to realize this could be their last chance

to get what they wanted from him. They started pressing him to confess. You've got to do the right thing, man. You've got to. I think I am. In fact, I know I am. And I'm just telling you one thing you've got, the wrong guy.

Sandy Prier was the wrong guy. But that only became clear much, much later. More than 23 years after Leslie Prier's murder, when police arrested someone else. New evidence had led police to this other man, and ultimately, that evidence cleared Sandy Prier of any wrongdoing. But until that arrest in 2024,

Sandy remained to a lot of people the likely culprit. Here's his daughter, Lauren Prier. My father and my mom's family used to be so close, but my mom's family believed he killed her. Not all of them. Some of my uncles

and some of my cousins were like, there's no way. I mean, I think my dad-dad ever broken heart. Sandy Prier did not live to see his name cleared. In 2017, he died suddenly after an illness. Lauren's friend Lisa says the news was yet another gut punch for Lauren. It came out of the blue. I mean, she just got a call one day from the ICU that her dad was there. And it was just so unbelievably traumatic for her, especially after losing her mom, you know, she was an only child. So I think then having her dad ripped away from her and it being so unexpected,

it was just such a huge blow. To this day, Lauren describes a sense of disbelief about what she and her dad went through. It's just unreal. And it happened to our family. You never think anything that's like that would ever happen. And he had to live with that until 2017. And he still didn't know. But all did that. As the years passed, Lauren says she kept prodding police for updates in her mother's case. I never gave up. I never gave up. I called all the time. I knew someone knew something. You know what I mean? So I just didn't give up. And finally, one day my phone rang and and I didn't even answer because I didn't know the phone number and then I got a message saying,

we're calling about your mom, Leslie Prier, and I said, what? The phone call was from a detective with the Montgomery County Cold Case Unit. A new set of detectives had picked up the investigation into Leslie's death. These detectives would re-examine the 20-year-old evidence in Leslie's case file.

And with the help of new technology, they would finally crack the case wide open. From ABC Audio in 2020, I'm Stephanie Ramos. This is Blood and Water. Episode 4, Family Tree. The office of the Montgomery County Cold Case Unit is in the basement, underneath police headquarters. The room is windowless, glamorous it is not, but it's the sort of hidden away place where no one bothers you, where a detective can disappear into their work.

The office is cramped with heavy-duty shelves. On these shelves sit dozens of boxes. With any cold case, we're going to take the box out, and it's usually a big, dusty box with lots of files. It could be several boxes. And you just kind of go through each file, one at a time. This is Detective Alison Dupoy. Detective Dupoy spends her days here among the boxes.

that represent Montgomery County's unsolved crimes. And of course, behind every unsolved homicide or sexual assault or kidnapping, there are the victims and loved ones who never got answers. When you're in the cold case unit, you get to reconnect with families who have otherwise probably have failing like they've been forgotten by the police department. And we get to make contact again and kind of try to give them maybe some hope and just let them know that we're thinking about this case.

and taking a fresh look at it. Leslie Per's murder has been open for over 20 years. When I got to the cold case unit, it was one of many boxes that are sitting on our shelves. And when Tara joined our unit, she just picked right up on it. Tara is Allison's partner, Detective Tara Augustine. Over her 20-year career in the police department, she had long hoped to join the cold case unit.

These are all major crimes. They're either homicides or rapes. And I like the challenge of trying to look at everything with fresh eyes and not take the same viewpoints that the previous investigators had. And when it's successful, it's a huge satisfaction that you're able to do something for the families and give closure. Back in 2001, detectives Augustine and DuPoy were college students living in and around D.C. It's funny because she and I didn't know each other then,

But we also used to go hang out with friends in all the same places in Chevy Chase. And we may have even crossed paths with Lauren at some point in our lives and not realized it because we were all in the same area at the same time but didn't know each other. Did the case appeal to you more because the areas that were mentioned in the case were so familiar to you? It definitely did. It made me, I guess, have more of a connection to it. As the two detectives began working on the case, they got to no longer. Lauren Prier.

Lauren, who was 23 when her mother was killed, was now in her mid-40s. Her mother's murder and the mystery of what really happened that day had hung over Lauren for almost half her lifetime. It was very, very emotional for Lauren. I mean, she could just see it on her face and in her demeanor that she was just so grateful that somebody was looking at this and thinking about her mom again. And really, she wanted to clear her dad's name. That was really important to her to let everybody know that her dad didn't do this.

And soon, these detectives would find the evidence to prove just that. Today I want to tell you about our friends at Miko. Miko has built an air purifier that works hard so you can breathe easy. It works powerfully and consistently to deliver top quality results giving you cleaner air in any room of your home. Unlike other air purifiers, Miko is designed to be ultra-quiet so it can work in the background while you work or sleep and go completely unnoticed. And you get the quiet efficiency without sacrificing performance.

The three-stage HEPA filtration system is considered the best of the best, proven to remove close to 98% of particles, allergens, and odors. It comes with built-in aromatherapy. And the sleek, elegant design blends right into any room of the house, whether it's your bedroom, a nursery, or an everyday living space. Breathe a little easier with Miko in your corner. With our unique deal, you can get their powerful air purifier for 50% off, and enjoy free shipping for a limited time.

That's right, 50% off and free shipping. Don't wait. Get an unbelievable air purifier for an even more unbelievable price at ABCsecret Savings.com slash 2020. That's ABCsecret Savings.com slash 2020. Star Wars is back on the big screen with the Mandalorian and Grogo. Gangsters, war criminals. I'll take out every bad guy in your deck of cards.

This Friday, feel the force. On the biggest screen possible. The old protect the young, and the young protect the old. This is the way. Buckle up. Always wear your seatbelt. Star Wars, The Mandalorian and Grogo. Ritted PG-13 may be inappropriate for children under 13.

In theaters Friday. Get tickets now. Hey, fleece and Walter. My new comedy special, it was an accident, is now streaming on Hulu. I'm pissed off so often lately. If I had known we were headed toward the Handmaid's Tale and I was going to be wearing that big red cape, I wouldn't have cut out carbs. I mean, I know what mindfulness is because my kids told me,

but I've seen the way I eat and I'm pretty sure I don't practice it. I don't know why I can't find a fella. Don't miss, it was an accident. Now streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for fundal subscribers. Terms apply. Last summer, I spent some time

with detectives Augustine and DuPoy. We went through some of the materials in Leslie Pryor's case file. This evidence collected two decades earlier was their starting place. We spread everything out across a big table. It was a big mess of photos, documents, pieces of a puzzle. The most difficult to look at were the crime scene photos taken inside the Prier's home.

So this here, this is the foyer of the house. Yes, this is the front door right here. So this is what Sandy and Brett Reedy would have seen when they came into the house. There was blood throughout the Prier home. including some crucial spots in and around the kitchen. So this is the back door in the kitchen, and this is a drop of blood that was smeared. And there's a doorway right here that separates the dining room from the kitchen.

And on that doorway, there's another drop of blood that was found. These drops of blood contained that unknown male DNA, the DNA that was not Sandy's. authorities learned of this other DNA a few months after Leslie's killing. It was significant because it suggested that someone else had been in the house when Leslie was killed. And yet, even after the discovery of the unknown male DNA, investigators back in 2001 still believed that Sandy Prier remained a viable suspect. Some 20 years later, detectives Augustine and DuPoy examined the evidence collected. by the earlier detectives,

and they came to a different conclusion. One detail police had noted in the original investigation was Sandy's demeanor at the crime scene. Police officers will go and they'll draw their weapons to search a house. And Sandy made a joke about, you know, they're really taking this seriously. The exact quote in the police report was, You guys mean business.

There's blood at the scene, his wife is missing, and he makes a joke. Yeah. Well, how did that land with you when you read that? You know, these kinds of circumstances, you don't know how you're going to deal with it. Some people make jokes. Some people might be hysterical. Some people might not take it seriously at all at first. And some people take it very seriously.

So I think you have different ways of dealing with this stuff, but certainly that did not help Sandy's case. Another thing that didn't help Sandy's case was that he failed the polygraph test. But as Detective Augustine points out, lie detector tests aren't exactly infallible. Polygraphs are tricky. They're not admissible in court. They're an indicator that the person is having a response in their body, a physical response to whatever questions are being asked. Detective Augustine says Sandy took that polygraph shortly after detectives told him that Leslie's death was considered a homicide. She says Sandy understood immediately.

that was bad news for him. This is the first time he realizes that and he even says to them, I know where this is going. He knows in his mind that they suspect that he's the killer and he volunteers to take a polygraph. So his stress level is pretty high already.

He goes right from this interaction with the detectives, follows them, and goes to the police station and takes a polygraph immediately after. I can see how he would have failed because it's a very stressful situation. The police think that he killed his wife and he didn't.

Detective Augustine and DuPoy know today that Sandy Pryor did not kill his wife. So they also know that certain pieces of evidence, the failed polygraph, the odd jokes, aren't what they first seemed. This is part of what makes police work so difficult. Investigators not only have to uncover evidence, but they have to decide what that evidence actually means, if it means anything at all. Still, given the prolonged and ultimately incorrect focus on Sandy, I had to ask detectives Augustine and DuPoy. Did investigators focus too closely on Sandy Prier? Did that focus distract them from finding the actual killer?

I think at the time, especially before the presence of the unknown DNA was available to them, he was the prime suspect. and I think there was good reason for them to focus on him. Once the presence of the unknown DNA was there, it was almost as if they were trying to find a reason why Sandy was acting so suspiciously because a lot of his movements, a lot of his reactions, the failed polygraph, they all were mounting up to probable cause.

And had it not been for that unidentified male DNA under her fingernails and in the crime scene, he probably would have been charged. Instead, no one was charged in the death of Leslie Prier for the next 20-plus years. And over those two decades, there were few promising leads. That is, until detectives took that unknown DNA and began trying to find its family tree. Road to the NBA Finals is happening now on ESPN and ABC. It's make a break now.

Best on best now. Watch him sit with his chest now. Greatness is up for grabs. And the world is watching. Just win. On the home of the NBA finals. All the work. All the sacrifice.

The NBA playoffs, presented by Google, continue on ESPN and ABC. Whoa. We need some water. I need a martini. I love a sign of cooking. It's a suck of music. It is. I'm Stanley Tucci, and I want to invite you on a journey through the country that I love, Italy.

Join Stanley Tucci for a new season. You are a good cutoff. Babe. Of National Geographic's Tucci and Italy. All right. Should we eat? National Geographic's Tucci in Italy. An all-new season is now streaming on Disney Plus and Hulu. ESPN presents the Stanley Cup playoffs.

The most exciting playoffs out there. A two-month roller coaster filled with Sudden Death Oathes. overtimes and good old-fashioned chaos. Unbelievable! Every shift matters. Every series is a statement and everyone gets their shot at the cup. The Stanley Cup playoffs presented by Geico. Continue on ABC, ESPN and the ESPN app.

DNA evidence can be very useful if you get a match. But back in 2001, after tests were run on the DNA found at the DNA, found at the the scene of Leslie Prier's murder, no matches were found. Not in the federal CODIS database of violent criminals and not among Leslie's family and friends. In hindsight, this dead end showed the limits of forensic DNA in 2001. That federal database of violent offenders, well, by definition, it's limited to violent offenders. That's a pretty small pool of potential matches, at least compared to what came next. Tonight, an arrest,

and authorities say they used a family genealogy website to make that arrest. About a decade ago, law enforcement began using a new kind of database, a pool of DNA, wider and deeper than anything before. It's a cutting-edge genetic tool, now heating up the coldest of cases. A genetic profile created from crime scene DNA

was uploaded to a public genealogy database. If you're a criminal and you've left your DNA at the scene, you might as well turn yourself in now. Genetic genealogy has revolutionized detective work, especially in cold case investigations. It began with the excitement around at-home DNA tests and ancestry websites. As everyday people spat in tubes and mail them off, new databases began to grow. Soon, these databases contained the genetic information of millions of people. people. Today, these databases are big enough and DNA tests sensitive enough that you can build family trees containing the names of people who never submitted their DNA at all. These

tools were a revelation for people interested in their ancestry and for law enforcement as well. Police, often working with outside labs, began using some of these databases, building family trees with the DNA of suspects at the center. In 2022, detectives Tara Augustine and Alison DuPoy sent some 20-year-old blood to a lab. Soon, the detectives received a list of partial matches for that unknown male DNA. We get shared matches of people from all over the place, and they can be really low matches, which means that they share a very minimal amount of DNA with our suspect. The higher matches, that's more DNA, so that's going to be maybe a little bit easier of a family tree to build. Detectives spent months building family trees. They used not only the DNA test results,

the lists of online profiles that were high or low matches, but another source as well, historical documents. Obituaries, marriage documents, census record, all of those things. That's what we have to do when we're building the family trees. So it's a little bit of like history detective as well as regular detective work. This work often resembled that of an amateur genealogist. Except, instead of trying to track down their ancestors, they were trying to track down a potential murderer. Genealogy databases have genetic information for people all over the world.

But things like census records and obituaries, they're not always that easy to find abroad. So detectives started building family trees featuring lots of American families, searching for someone who might have been in Maryland in May 2001. The problem was the Americans who populated these family trees, they shared, on average, less DNA with the unknown male subject. They were multiple degrees removed from the possible killer. In the end, these lower matches got detectives nowhere. It had been about a year and a half of working on these low matches, and I just wanted to, why don't we explore these higher matches?

The higher matches tended to lead back to people who lived outside the United States. One match led them to, of all places, Romania. Just doing basic Google searches and looking at publicly available data, I was able to find out a lot of information about this family line from someone that actually. had done a lot of genealogy work that is in the family. Specifically, the detectives found a blog, maintained by a sort of family genealogist. It featured lengthy posts written in Romanian, interspersed with black and white photos

and scans of newspaper articles. Precisely the kind of primary sources the detectives needed. This person had done a really thorough job of documenting a lot of that stuff. And in one of the blog post, I came across the name Virgil Gleegor. Virgil Gleigor. That kind of clicked in my head because I remembered the name Glegoor and I knew it was in the case file.

The name Gleegor was in the case file because it was the surname of a Eugene Gleegor, Lauren Prier's high school boyfriend. Eugene Gleegor had been the subject of a tip Detective Scott back in 2002. A lady that lived in the neighborhood where this individual Eugene Gleegor lived said, I know that he used to date the victim's daughter, and he was getting in trouble in the neighborhood for noise complaints and just nuisance things where the police had come out there. For some reason, he stuck out to her, and she said,

I just want to let you guys know, look at this guy. It was just a hunch. The detective who took the tipster's call back in 2002 did act on it. He went by the residents that the tipster had given to try to locate Eugene or to get any information about him. And it appears that he hit a couple of dead ends. And that was it. It seems like, you know, Eugene at that time may have just fallen into the list of people who knew the family and who were acquainted with the family. And, you know, maybe it would have been a knock and talk and a request for DNA, but they weren't able to locate him.

and it's just one of those, you know, loose ends that was never tied up. It's worth emphasizing. According to law enforcement, police had no probable cause connecting Lauren's high school boyfriend with her mom's murder. The two had broken up a few years before Leslie's murder. By all accounts, the breakup was perfectly amicable. And at the time of the murder, Lauren and Eugene weren't really in each other's lives anymore. There never was any indication that there was a bad relationship between Lauren and him or Leslie and him.

And it just, his name was brought up and they looked at him and they said, well, you know, he's gotten in a little bit of trouble with the police. But nothing raised flags to say, hey, this guy's a killer. But there was someone else suspicious of Eugene. Even before Leslie was murdered, here's Lauren. My dad never liked him. He thought there was always something off. And you know a dad's instinct. And of course, as being a teenage girl, I was like,

Daddy, you're just being a protective dad. What's your mom say about that, knowing that your dad wasn't 100% on board with Eugene? She would just say, you're being overprotective. He's a good kid kind of thing. And then after she was gone, he said, you think Eugene could be a part of this. It was mentioned more than one time. And again, of course, I said, no. Like, what are you talking about?

Her high school boyfriend, killing her mom? Lauren didn't buy it. And police say Eugene Gleegor didn't have a rap sheet that screamed, Murderer. Eugene did have some police interactions throughout the years. At some point, he had been charged with marijuana possession. There were a couple of incident reports for thefts or burglaries where he was listed as a suspect,

but he was never charged because either there wasn't enough evidence or the families decided not to go forward with anything. So these findings didn't really paint a picture of a brutal, bloody murderer, did it? No. Not at all. No. No. And yet the discovery seems significant.

a partial genetic match that had led detectives to a name that had come up during the original investigation, a name that was in the case file. I remember I was downstairs in our office and I said, Allie, come over here and look at this, look at this and make sure it makes sense. And I think this is something really good. And she came over and she was like, oh, wow. And I thought, this is a really good lead. Like, this is like the biggest break we've had up to this point.

detectives looked into Eugene Gleegor. What they learned was troubling. I ended up leaving that house that night. I did not stay there because I was afraid of him. She thought he might go after her. Once I saw that, that kind of changes things to where he might be capable of actually killing someone. Blood and Water is a production of ABC Audio in 2020, hosted by me, Stephanie Ramos, produced by Madeline Wood, Shane McKeon, and Kiara Powell.

With help from Emily Schutz and Caitlin Schiffer, edited by Gianna Palmer, our supervising producer is Susie Lou. Music by Evan Viola. Mixing and mastering by Bob Mallory. Scoring by Kiara Powell. Special thanks to Katie Dendos, Janice Johnston, Sean Dooley,

Chris Donovan, Camille Peterson, Christina Corbin, Gail Deutsch, Amanda Carr, Ellie Jostad, NG Adam, and Michelle Margulis. Josh Cohen is our director of podcast programming. Amon McNiff is our executive producer.

Sunday nights on ABC. What happens when the person you love the most turns out not to be who you think they are? Everything he told me was a lie. I was betrayed from the number one true crime podcast. Betrayal. He's been living a secret double life. My marriage ended with a 911 call. The tape is blood curdling.

Betrayal. Secrets and Lines. So many people are living with their own betrayal. Sunday nights at 10-9 Central on ABC and stream on Disney Plus and Lulu. No. Oh, no. Welcome to Get Real. I got something to say. A weekly talk show for the reality TV obsessed.

Oh, my God. It's got to be deliciously desperate. Why do these girls forget her? She has a soft spot for troubled men. Boo, bloody. This is your show. Find Get Real wherever you get your podcasts. Love runs deeper than we know.

And stream new episodes Thursdays on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus.