20/20 - Cold Blooded: Receipts

Episode Date: August 13, 2025

Dr. Eric Garcia was a collector of valuables. Could the theft of hundreds of thousands of dollars of luxury items lead police to answers? To catch new episodes early, follow "Cold Blooded: Mystery in Alaska" for free on ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Apple Podcasts⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Spotify⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Amazon Music⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This is Deborah Roberts here with another weekly episode of our latest series from 2020 and ABC Audio, Cold-blooded Mystery in Alaska. Remember, you can get new episodes early if you follow Cold-blooded Mystery in Alaska on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen to your podcasts. Now, here's the episode. Get to Toronto's main venues like Budweiser Stage and the new Roger Stadium with Go Transit. Thanks to Go Transit's special online e-ticket fairs, a $10 one-day weekend pass offers unlimited travel on any weekend day or holiday, anywhere along the Go Network. And the weekday group passes offer the same weekday travel flexibility across the network, starting at $30 for two people and up to $60 for a group of five. Buy your online go pass ahead of the show at go-transit.com slash tickets. When Eric Garcia was a boy growing up in Puerto Rico, his dad,

introduced him to coin collecting. In the 50-odd years that followed, Eric Garcia collected a lot of coins. Big, small, new, old, and the one constant through it all was that connection to his dad. Once Eric grew up, became Dr. Garcia, and took jobs far away from his native Puerto Rico. He'd placed long-distance calls and wind the east. evening away, telling his dad about his latest coins. Once he had a bit more coin of his own, Dr. Garcia's collections expanded.

In a makeshift storage space under a staircase, inside his home in Ketchikan, Alaska, Dr. Garcia filled shelf after shelf. There were watches that retailed for several thousands of dollars, bottles of high-end liquors, several hundreds of them, including Scotch's age, for 20 years, 30 years, or more, and of course, a lifetime's worth of rare and commemorative coins. Police estimated the value of Dr. Garcia's valuables could total as much as half a million

dollars. But now, the valuables were gone, and Dr. Eric Garcia was dead. Police had discovered his body on a couch near his second-story deck. A toxicology report came back positive for a morphine overdose. The tox report also found dangerously elevated levels of carbon monoxide in his system. Those high levels of carbon monoxide tracked with what police discovered around Dr. Garcia's body, a barbecue grill in a nearby doorway, a partially burned charcoal briquette, and a charcoal stain on Dr. Garcia's body. white t-shirt. On top of that, every smoke detector in the house was missing. They were later discovered at the bottom of a nearby ravine.

To police, it looked like someone was trying to hide evidence. And of course, Dr. Garcia's collection of luxury items had vanished. Officer Devin Miller. Knowing that the missing valuables were gone, it really, changes things immensely. It was a major theft. And so Ketchikan police faced two mysteries, a suspicious death and a major theft. In the next two episodes, this one and the next, we're going to focus on the theft investigation because it was in the whirlwind process of searching for Dr. Garcia's valuables

that police uncovered what happened to the man. From ABC Audio in 2020, I'm Chris Connolly, and this is Cold Blood. Mystery in Alaska. Episode 3. Receipts. What began as a simple welfare check had now grown into a sprawling, two-part-whodunit. A theft of this size, coupled with a mysterious death, would be a head scratcher in any municipality. For police in Ketchikan, population 8,000, it was an investigation that would challenge the department in ways it had rarely been challenged before.

Dr. Garcia, Officer Miller. Police Department. Officer Devin Miller was on the scene the day Dr. Garcia's body was found. Miller knew Dr. Garcia. He had been his patient. Now that Dr. Garcia was dead and his worldly possessions were missing, Miller was tasked with figuring out where it all went. Anyone who knew him and knew about those valuables was under suspicion.

Working alongside Miller was Sergeant Eric Matson. He had been called in a day after the body was found to scrutinize the scene and look for clues. One of the most striking clues police found was the missing smoke detectors. And that's not all they noticed. The house was not broken into. There was no forced entry. So the items were removed unsuspectingly. I would say by somebody that had a direct relation with Dr. Garcia.

So, with an eye toward anyone who might know Dr. Garcia personally, police began to dig into every aspect of the doctor's life. During the course of this investigation that involved the theft, we don't look at just the physical property there, but there's also other financial assets, bank accounts. When police examined Dr. Garcia's accounts, they noticed a transfer made six days before the doctor's body was found. $900 was sent to someone named Logan Cruz. Police recognized that name, Logan. Nobody's heard from him yet. Remember the calls from out of state requesting a welfare check on Dr. Garcia? Okay, and what's your name?

My name's Logan. My real name is Jordan Joplin, but everybody calls me Logan. Sorry. Logan, a.k.a. Jordan Joplin, was one of Dr. Garcia. his friends. For the sake of clarity, we're going to stick with his legal name, Jordan. Jordan was there outside Dr. Garcia's house when police found the body. He had driven up to the scene in Dr. Garcia's red pickup, and he had the keys to his house. To police, Dr. Garcia's relationship with Jordan was a mystery. Dr. Garcia's loved ones didn't know what to make of it

either. Bob Jackson, Dr. Garcia's realtor-turned-friend we met last episode. He had met Jordan Joplin once before, in passing. This was a few months before Dr. Garcia died, and it all started when Dr. Garcia's passion for amassing luxury goods got him in trouble at work. Dr. Garcia was cut off by the hospital for getting packages. They wouldn't allow personal packages to be delivered to the hospital anymore. He was kind of miffed about that. And I said, don't worry about it. Have him shipped to my office. I'm happy to do it. He came in the office. He was his jovial self. He had ordered a several thousand dollar coffee machine. And I was giving him a bad time about how much money he spent on. It was like $3,000. It was foolish.

This was typical for Bob and Dr. Garcia. Dr. Garcia would splurge on something. Bob would roll his eyes and chide him for it. Dr. Garcia would remain undeterred. This was their usual dynamic. He was in a great mood and all of a sudden this gentleman got out of his truck. It was parked right in front of my window and he got out and walked in and the fellow that came in, his physique was very well built and he had a shirt that looked like it was painted on. And Dr. Garcia looked Like, he'd just seen, you know, something crazy. His face changed. He was ready to go, and he didn't want his friend talking.

But his friend did talk. He said his name was Jordan. His friend ended up very chatty and, honestly, kind of likable. Told the whole office where he was from. And anyhow, it was, I didn't know what to think. I was just surprised. And what was more surprising than meeting Jordan was Dr. Garcia's face, and his face was like, oh, no, he did not want that man coming in and visiting with us,

and he did. But Dr. Garcia was done. He was done talking at that point. All he wanted to is leave, and they did leave. And, of course, after they left, we all, at the office, sat around going, who the hell was he? I had quite a few different notions in regards to Jordan. A few of them were just a little unsavory. Don Hink was Dr. Garcia's friend and colleague at the hospital.

When she wasn't helping patients, Dawn sometimes handled tedious tasks the busy surgeon did not want to deal with. One task in particular was taking up more and more of her time in the years after Dr. Garcia befriended Jordan. Dawn says she got call after call from credit card companies, flagging suspicious activity on Dr. Garcia's accounts. It sure seemed like any time Eric was anywhere near this character, something hokey would be going on with his finances, and it just didn't sit right. Dawn had met Jordan in person only once.

Dr. Garcia's truck battery had died, and Don drove out to jump it. When she got there, Dr. Garcia was with Jordan. standing side by side the two men made an odd pair one a buttoned up surgeon in his 50s the other a chiseled 31 year old in tight-fitting attire Dawn didn't want to pry

but she says the frequency of the calls from credit card companies worried her I would get to a point where I would get frustrated enough to begin to voice it and Dr. Garcia would shoot me down just about every way possible. And to me, that was him saying he wasn't ready to discuss it with me.

So I just left it at that. On the evening of March 26, 2017, the night before police searched Dr. Garcia's house, Dawn got a phone call from Jordan Joplin. By the time of that call, Dawn, along with Dr. Garcia's other loved ones, had not heard from the doctor in several days. They didn't know where he was, or what, if anything, had happened to him. They were starting to panic.

Jordan, too, sounded panicky. As soon as I answered the phone, and he just starts, we don't know where Eric is, and what's happened to him, and do you think something horrible is going on, and do you think he would hurt himself? And I definitely felt like we got to work together, to figure out what's going on.

For more than a week, Jordan had been calling Ketchikan police, asking for welfare checks, and he seemed frustrated that police were not doing more. He told Don he was flying into Ketchikan with his girlfriend the next day and asked for a ride into town. The next morning, I picked him up from the airport. You could pick him out of a lineup of anybody, but even after just meeting him once,

he surely didn't fit in Ketchikan. He had on glamorous jeans and jewelry and muscle t-shirt, and it's March and freezing cold with three feet of snow. Dawn, Jordan, and his girlfriend took the ferry from the airport to downtown Ketchikan. When they reached Lamb, Jordan said Dr. Garcia's truck was parked nearby and that he and his girlfriend would drive it up to the house. I follow them up the hill, and as soon as I saw the police cars, I knew it was going to be an interesting day.

I see two vehicles drive up the driveway. On the morning of March 27, 2017, Officer Devin Miller was standing outside Dr. Garcia's house. One was Don Hink, and in the second one, it was. a red truck, a red ford truck, which I knew Dr. Garcia drove a red ford truck. Officer Miller had gotten a call earlier that morning from Jordan Joplin. Jordan had told Miller that he had landed in Ketchikan and that he and Don Hink were coming to do a welfare check at Dr. Garcia's house. Miller wasn't sure what to make of Jordan. Jordan Joplin, it was unusual that he was driving the doctor's vehicle.

But I think Mr. Joplin was given quite a bit of credibility since Don Hink also was with him. Jordan also seemed genuinely affected by the news Dr. Garcia had died. After police told him, Jordan said he had chest pain. No, I don't blame. But I have a heart issue, I don't think. Okay. But if you need to go to the hospital, we can get you in the hospital. Jordan recovered from the initial shock.

After that, officers interviewed him. Sergeant Bob Cheatham led Jordan into the front entryway of the house. Their conversation was recorded on the sergeant's body camera. So we just came in the door and just get some privacy. Would you have a few questions for you? Okay. So how often do you come up? to catch camp.

I've been up here quite a few times. Okay, for work or just for visiting? Is it? Okay. How did you guys meet? I'm just curious. I know you're a massage therapist. Was it through that?

That was the very first time, yeah. Okay. Jordan said he had been working as a massage therapist. He would say later that he had given Dr. Garcia a massage and that the two stayed in touch afterward. So how did Dr. Garcia and Jordan go from a masseur client relationship to Jordan having the keys to Dr. Garcia's house and car. The answer to that question would have to come another day.

Because over the course of this interview, Jordan kept saying things that made Ketchikan police suspicious. Here's Officer Devin Miller. Jordan was starting to act in an unusual way. When was the last time you were physically in Ketchken? not that long ago. Jordan's answers were vague. He said he'd been in Ketchikan roughly two weeks earlier,

visiting Dr. Garcia. He remembered going to Walmart together. But besides that, Jordan was hazy on exact dates. He was hazy on other things, too. You said you have power of attorney? I have a paper that he did that says power of attorney, Okay. Okay.

Can I ask you a question? Can you explain to me what a power of attorney is exactly, because I had no idea. Jordan informed Sergeant Cheatham that he had a power of attorney, but he couldn't explain what a power attorney was, and he didn't have it with him. Where is it at? It's my house. Down in Washington? Yeah.

Okay. And you talked to Don last night? Yeah. I was actually talking to her about me when we got to her. When Jordan had called Don Hink the night before, he mentioned this legal document that Dr. Garcia had supposedly given him, Officer Devin Miller again. Don Hink knew about this, Jordan, saying that he had a power attorney and specifically told him to bring it to town when he came, and he didn't bring it. In the body camera footage of this interview with police, Jordan seems distracted. You could see that he was paying more attention to his phone than he actually was the interview

itself. Can you know of any high-value items in the house? Oh, no. In the interview footage, Jordan is swiping away at his smartphone, leading the sergeant to repeat questions. You're not aware of any high-valued items in the house? Yeah, actually. Okay.

I'm asking you about it because... Oh, yes. So you need to be truthful with us. When I ask you, is there any high-valued items? You first said no, and I understand yes. So what high-value items do you know about? All that stuff that's in there. I don't know what that.

You need to explain... Vases that are from overseas that he's collected. Okay. Anything else? Um... He knew about some vases that were... purchased out of country, and that was about all he knew. He said he didn't know what kind of valuables were in the house. Remember, Dr. Eric Garcia was known to give gifts, valuable gifts, to both friends and near-perfect strangers. He would give rare coins, expensive bottles of liquor,

and more. On top of that, Dr. Garcia was often eager to discuss his flashy watch or designer Cologne, that a close friend who had keys to both Dr. Garcia's house and car would only know about some vases? Police found that suspicious. All right. We're going to lock up and we're going to get going. If you got any questions, just call. I have a car somewhere. is back in dramatic fashion. This is more stressful than Cinderella at the ball. Welcome to the runway.

Heidi Klum returns his host. One day you're in. And the next day, you're out. I'm here to show them who's the queen. With Christian Seriano. I'm excited. And judges Nina Garcia and Law Roach. I hated your dress.

Hate is such a big word. It's a short word. It's only four letters. Project Runway. New episodes Fridays. Stream on Hulu and Disney Plus. The Twisted Tale of Amanda. is coming to Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus on August 20th.

Amanda, where did you go to the night of Meredith's murder? Do I need a lawyer right now? Inspired by the infamous story. We cannot do our jobs unless you are honest with us. I swear to God, I'm innocent. You only thought you knew. For 15 years, I've been defined by something I didn't do. Watch the new Hulu original series,

The Twisted Tale of Amanda Knox, August 20th. Streaming on Hulu and Hulu on Disney Plus for bundle subscribers. Terms apply. King, man. Oh, wow, emotional. King of the Hill is back. They got a Bob's in the airport now. Oh, that's Bobba. World has changed, Dad. Bobby wants to bring that new girl over for dinner. The Vegas. What the hell am I supposed to feed her? Can't we just put some grass in a bowl?

From Mike Judge and Greg Daniels. Ready to make some memories, Dad. Let's freaking go. A Hulu original series, King of the Hill. All episodes now streaming on Hulu. You've seen the headlines. debates. The three-point ball has created a monotonous rhythm to the game. Has the three-pointer ruined basketball? And how did we get here? The rise of the three-point shot can be partially traced to an eccentric Kansas genius named Martin Manley, whose story didn't turn out quite the way he imagined. I decided I wanted to have one of the most organized goodbyes in history. 30 for 30 podcast presents

chasing basketball heaven. Available now, wherever you get your podcasts. We're our WMBA champion. We can't get enough of the WNBA. A fresh draft class has arrived. Dallas Wing select Hage Beckers. Teams stacked with new talent. Jewel is a complete dog. The Valkyries take flight in the bay.

We've got more stars and more heat than ever. WNBA on ESPN, presented by Google. We can't get enough. We have a down. Spacecraft. Fax's Alien Earth, all new Tuesdays. This ship collected specimens from other worlds. Invasive species.

Creditor. From creator Noah Hawley and executive producer Ridley Scott. We don't lock them down. It will be too late. What did you do? Fax's Alien Earth, all new Tuesdays on Fax and Hulu. On March 28th, the day after Dr. Eric Garcia's body was found.

Police got a warrant and searched his truck, the Red Ford pickup that Jordan Joplin had been driving. In the glove compartment, sat a bombshell. Again, Sergeant Eric Mattson. We found a shipping receipt from Alaska Marine Lines. It's a local barge company that transports goods all through Alaska along the coast down to the state of Washington. The receipt was for a transaction involving three shipping containers.

A portion of that receipt showed how much weight was in the three containers. The container weight was total about 4,400 pounds. 4,400 pounds, two tons of cargo. The destination for all this cargo was also listed. The receipt was in the name of Jordan Joplin, listing the doctor's address as a shipper address, to Jordan Joplin in Maple Valley, Washington. Remember, Jordan had told police he didn't know about Dr. Garcia's valuables beyond a few vases.

But now, police had a strong hunch as to where those valuables were and where they were headed. Around the same time police found the shipping bill, they uncovered another receipt, this one to the local Walmart. Walmart that Walmart had come up before um would you have a few questions for you okay Jordan Joplin had mentioned Walmart when he talked to police on the day Dr. Garcia's body was found when asked about the last time he was in catch again Jordan said he and

Dr. Garcia went to Walmart together I think it was because he 16th is what I used this truck okay because you'd have to return the truck to him well he was with me So we went to Walmart. Police reviewed Walmart surveillance footage from the day in question. A camera overlooking the parking lot captured a red Ford pickup, driving up, and parking. I viewed the truck coming into the parking lot, park. Only one individual got out of that truck, which was Jordan Joplin. Cameras inside the store showed Jordan filling a shopping cart with heavy plastic bins.

kind you might use for storage or moving. Footage shows Jordan, gathering up so many bins that he eventually filled his cart. He had an employee from Walmart help him with another cart because he had that many bins. The footage shows Jordan exiting the store, pushing a cart stacked with bins, and an employee trailing after him with another. So once all those items were loaded back into the truck, Mr. Joplin got back in. the truck and depart of the parking lot. He was the only person that I saw exit and enter that truck. I did not see Dr. Garcia on the Walmart footage from that day.

Police realized that Jordan had lied about his trip to Walmart. He went there alone, not with Dr. Garcia. Police went back to the local shipping company and reviewed their security footage. While we were watching that, we saw a red Ford pickup and a male wearing a red sweatshirt that was unloading cargo and on the property around those three cubes. Those three cubes, meaning the three shipping containers, listed on the receipt inside the pickup. The shipping company had a manager on site, and he told police he remembered the guy who'd been there on the day in question. When we were talking to the manager, he had stated that he had talked to that person or that mail that was by the three containers. We were able to get a photo, and the manager positively identified the mail that we saw on the red sweatshirt that day, Ms. Jordan Joplin.

Jordan Joplin had told police he didn't know about Dr. Eric Garcia's vast collection of valuables. And yet, here he was. on camera, loading 4,000 pounds of something into containers. Just days before, police discovered the valuables were missing. Police had also caught Jordan in a lie about his trip to Walmart. He said he went with Dr. Garcia, but the surveillance footage showed that he was alone. So what was Jordan Joplin hiding? For police, the next steps were clear.

Search those three shipping containers and interview Jordan Joplin again. But there was a problem. We learned that the containers had already left Ketchikan. Next time on cold-blooded mystery in Alaska, the hunt for Dr. Eric Garcia's valuables takes Ketchikan police to the lower 48. Cold-blooded. Mystery in Alaska is a production of ABC Audio and 2020, hosted by me, Chris Connolly, produced by Camille Peterson, Shane McKeon, and Kiara Powell, edited by Gianna Palmer. Our supervising producer is Susie Lou. Music and mixing by Evan Viola.

Special thanks to Liz Alessie, Katie Dendos, Janice Johnston, Joseph Reyes. Gary Wynne, Zander Samaris, Christonovar, Michelle Margulis, Tom Berman, Sandy Evans, and Pat LaLama. Josh Cohan is our director of podcast programming. Laura Mayer is our executive producer. The top stories, biggest headlines, entertainment buzz, and viral moments. You give us less than 10 minutes and will give you what you. you need to know. Your new daily must-have habit. Start your day with what you need to know. Now streaming on Disney Plus.