20/20 - Night Terror

Episode Date: August 10, 2024

A husband and wife are found dead at home. Did a teen murder his own parents? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

This story begins on a quiet Sunday night in rural Texas where a husband and wife are sitting on a couch watching TV. Depression number 24. You haven't taken a dive in this news report. That's getting you recovered on the answer. The events that happened on this Sunday night, this family will never be the same. I believe maybe even the community will never be the same. A double murder is sending shockwaves through a normally quiet North Texas community. The Hunt County Sheriff's Department

is investigating the murders of a husband and wife who were found dead inside their rural home in Royce City. We'll never know every detail of what took place in that house that night, but we do know that the family of this couple is still reeling from the pain of what happened there back in 2005. October of 2005 was kind of a new beginning for the Woodruff family. Both the kids had left for college, and they were empty nesters. Charla, the older daughter, was in college in Arkansas,

and their son, Brandon, had just gone off to school at Abilene Christian University. Heading straight down the highway, I'm moving on to someplace new. The parents, Dennis and Norma, were in the process of moving. They were moving out of the suburbs of the Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex and going to a place that's more rural. They were moving to a place called Royce City, whose motto is a friendly touch of Texas. They were attempting to save money with the two

kids in college. It accumulated credit card debt so they were downsizing. Financially they were stretched 300 grand in debt. The Woodruffs, Dennis and Norma, really did not like to deprive their children of anything. In 2005, the Woodruffs had been married for 23 years. They were high school sweethearts. Dennis told me one time, said, I would never want to live without Norma. And I knew it was true love, him saying that. Growing up, Brandon and Sharla were like a lot of kids who were not very far apart in age. At times they got along really well, but I mean there were times they fought. I have seen many of them. Brandon was a character. He was definitely the center of attention.

He was kind of more of the pampered child. You know, he was the baby. Play it for Papa. Play it. It's a minute. Tap off. Play it. I think one thing that kind of sums up Brandon a lot, there was some open casting calls for the Dennis the Menace movie. Hey, Mr. Wilson!

He auditioned for it, and he showed up probably with 2,000 other little kids. Mischievous, impish, blonde little Brandon, he would have been a natural for it. Didn't get the part. But after another year, I have a shiny nose. Charla was an amazing person.

She was very thoughtful. Anything that needed to be done, Charla was gonna do it. I mean, she was very dependable. She was 13 months ahead of Brandon, and adorable in her own right. The Woodroves had raised their children at a very nice home in the city of Heath, which is a bedroom

community of Dallas. You kind of have these McMansions. And yet, on the other hand, you'd still have people who were much more of a cowboy culture or ranching culture. Norma, Sharla, and Brandon loved animals. Their house was kind of like a wonderland. They had animals galore.

Norma was, you know, jeans, T-shirt, get her hands dirty. She was a CPA by day, but her heart was the ranching kind of lifestyle. Dennis and Norma were completely opposites. Dennis did more of like the cooking, cleaning. He loved music. Oh, he loved the Divas. Dennis had what was called the Dolly Room. He had a dolly pinball machine, he had dolly wigs, he had dolly dresses.

So I remember going into the Dolly Room for the first time and just never seeing anything like it. I mean, it was full dolly, amazing. Don't your man's got guns that are way more bigger? He was just funniest person you'll ever meet. Dennis and Norma were completely involved in their kids' lives. Norma, she loved working with her kids with 4-H, Future Farmers of America. 4-H and Future Farmers of America involves kids adopting an animal when it's very young and raising it, grooming it, feeding it.

You get involved in 4-H when you are like four or five years old. This is the lifeblood of these communities. Every September, the town has its annual corn and livestock show. Charla and Brandon were very successful in raising and showing animals. Brandon in particular. Getting blue ribbons, getting grand champion designations. Brandon would have had a Dr. Doodle's gift of talking to the animals. And that's what he excelled at.

And these animals thrived under his care. Always had dogs, cats, birds, horses, lambs. Rabbits and sheep and cows. He had a cockatoo. He had it from Norma. Norma had a love for animals like no other. For Norma and Dennis, their new home in Roy City had plenty of space for their menagerie of animals. They were very busy moving things from their home in Heath, which they still hadn't sold, to Royce City. This was a very much do-it-yourself move, and Norma had a big truck. You could pull a horse trailer. It's a lot of going back and forth. There's still some animals at the Heath property.

This was more rural, and they were set apart from the rest of the community, a little more isolated. For Dennis and Norma, yes, it might have been a tiny step down, but for them, hey, this is worth it. Charla and Brandon were both hours away at college, but they hadn't heard from their parents since Sunday night. It was now Tuesday, which was odd since they normally talk to their parents every day. There was a lot of people concerned. Charla called me and said, have you talked to mom and dad? And I said, no. And she said, I talked to them Sunday night,

and I haven't been able to talk to them since. I've called their work, and I get their voicemail. I call their cell phones. I've flip messages. There is no reason my parents should not have answered the phone all day Monday or Tuesday. Charla called me and I just remember a sound I will never forget. It was almost like a scream. Charlie and Brandon hadn't heard from their parents since Sunday night. It was now Tuesday.

They're not answering their phone. They're not answering their phone. They're not at work. This is ringing alarm bells. They call a family friend who goes to the house to check on them, essentially. The house was locked. Windows were locked. So family members say, do what you have to do, just get in that house. So he did.

And he sees the last thing he ever could have imagined. Norma and Dennis slumped over on the couch covered in blood. They're clearly dead. This friend is in a state of shock. He called back and said they're both here and they're both dead. And I just remember I couldn't think of what to say to him. I was so shocked. My son Randy came in the house, and he just said, sit down.

Then Randy told me that they had found Dennis, and he was dead. Then they said that Norma was also dead. That's unthinkable. What my mom had decided to do was send somebody to go to Brandon and then her and Linda were gonna go to Charla. Charla called me and I was just a kid so I answered the phone and I just remember a sound I'll never forget.

It was almost like a scream. There are certain parts that still, like, really hurt. And the hurt in her voice that day hurts. She knew immediately. We all assumed that it was carbon monoxide, because they moved into a new place. All windows appear to be secure. Meanwhile, the police walk in and they find an absolutely gruesome murder scene. They're going to have two victims on the couch. Two law enforcement agencies became involved.

You have your local county sheriff and then you have your Texas Rangers. I don't try to get emotional, but sometimes emotions do come into play. I could picture my own parents in that situation. What would I do if I found my parents that way? This kind of hits you hard as an investigator. The condition that Dennis and Norma are found in is very significant from a law enforcement standpoint. Norma has been shot multiple times,

and there's a huge gash across her neck. Dennis had been shot in the face once and stabbed nine times. This would indicate to me that the person killing Dennis or stabbing Dennis was stabbing him to inflict additional injuries after he was dead. And when that occurs, that shows anger on the killer's part. Looked like the killer had a personal issue with Dennis for some reason. What begins to take shape very quickly is that the Woodruffs knew their killer, that they trusted their killer.

Dennis still had a cup in his hand that he was using as a spit cup. Neither one of them appeared, you know, to be alarmed or frightened or scared or trying to flee or defend themselves in any way. It's just like somebody had walked in and just boom, boom, and they're dead. Nothing appeared to be taken from the house.

You've got jewelry. You've got televisions. You've got computers, laptops. At the scene, you have things that are valuable that could easily be taken and pawned, so whoever came and did this wasn't interested in taking the valuables. The house was locked from the inside, which would indicate that the perpetrator actor had a key or had some way of obtaining access to the house.

The only thing that we knew when we walked out of the autopsy is that we had a large caliber projectile, either a.44 or a a large caliber projectile, either a 44 or a 45 caliber projectile. So although the 45 caliber projectile is not something that's uncommon in the state of Texas, those are rather large projectiles. So police believe that Dennis and Norma had been dead for a couple of days. Another clue that makes investigators think this was not a stranger is the fact that there is a trail of blood from where the bodies are into the bathroom. That suggests that maybe whoever was in the house was

comfortable walking into that bathroom and perhaps cleaning up the crime scene. I mean... Everybody gathered at my home. The whole family was at my house. Brandon seemed so upset. He was kind of more of a rock than Charla. Charla was absolutely a basket case. I mean, she just really was having a hard time functioning. It was awful.

One of those things like this is not happening to me. How could it happen to me? And I just kept thinking that I was gonna wake up from some bad dream and that my mom and my dad were gonna be there. At this point, the family still had no real details about what happened to Norma and Dennis. But as luck would have it,

a reporter knocked on the door of the family members and asked them to comment on the murders of Dennis and Norma. We didn't know who to think that might have done that. We couldn't imagine anybody doing that. There's no one that I could think of that would want to hurt them because they were good people. It was very traumatizing at that point. I think the entire rest of my high school I slept with a knife under my bed.

Before that I never thought bad things could happen to people because it never happened to us before. As soon as we learned that it was somebody you know the questions go through your head like somebody have an affair, a bad neighbor, somebody that came to work on their place. I mean we went through lots of scenarios. I couldn't imagine anybody hurting him. The individual definitely had some issue with Dennis, no doubt. Do you think that it's possible that either one of your parents were having an affair with somebody?

Two years ago, there's this lady that, like, is real. That's with my dad. The devil's gonna come when the sun goes down. It's only been four days since Norma and Dennis' bodies have been found, and the emotions are still very raw. The pain so deep. This is a tight-knit family, and they've all gathered in Arkansas to pay their respects. Everyone had come in and filled this church. There was so many people. It was sad. It was

honestly like the hardest thing I think I've ever done. The funeral was very emotional and the songs were really great. They played one with Dolly, When I Get Where I'm Going. It fit Dennis and Norma. Yeah, when I get where I'm going, there'll be only happy tears. At the funeral, Brandon and Charla had their arms around each other holding each other up. Charla, she was very upset. Brandon was very stoic.

I was just in shock. You're numb. That's what you're numb. I've learned to deal with it, but... My grief was really bad for a long time, especially when I went to the cemetery. I've lost my mother and dad, my husband, but there's nothing like losing your child. From day one, the family's in constant contact with investigators on this. The family members all agree to be interviewed by the police. And this is a very important part of an investigation like this. This crime scene does scream out that it's somebody that knows the family. They must interview everyone connected with the family because it helps them build a timeline.

Timeline is everything. What was happening around that time that will help them glean the events that took the lives of Norma and Dennis. Brandon and Charla are both interviewed by a Texas Ranger named Jeff Collins and by a sergeant at the Hunt County Sheriff's Department named Terry Jones. The interviews of family members are recorded and they're in black and white, which if you go back to 2005 probably is not uncommon in police departments it was hard being interviewed because just lost the closest people

to you and you're having to go through and talk about everything we have to know as much as we possibly can about your parents what i call the the good, the bad, and the ugly. It was just painful to even get there, because you're not ready to talk about anything yet. Do you know of any problems that your parents may have been having, and would they confide in you if they had any problems? I think that they probably would, or say something.

What kind of parents were your parents? Um, the best. And was their relationship a very loving relationship? Yeah, like they always did. I thought it was gross. That's your parents. They were always together, like always. As investigators are speaking to family and friends,

they're able to put together a picture of Norma and Dennis' last weekend. They were still in the process of moving from the Heath home to the Royce City home. Brandon, like his dutiful son, would come down most weekends to help them in that process. So Brandon came down that weekend. When is the last time that you actually saw your parents?

It was Sunday. Like, we ate dinner that day. We ate at the house. And I know my dad left about 6 something. Okay. And he got back. It was just right down the street. I'm a lot on his pizza.

Okay. And we ate dinner. And then I left. Right after you ate? Yeah, because I was already running late. And I had to go feed all the animals at the old house. After that, he drives to pick up his friend, Robert, who is a classmate at college.

Once he picks up Robert, they decide that rather than going right back to college, they're going to go dancing. And that's what they did. They're going to go dancing, and that's what they did. Now, Charla, on Sunday night, was in Arkansas, visiting her grandmother Opal, who's Norma's mother. We know you're saying that on Sunday night,

between 8.45 and 9 is when you know that your mother talked to her mother. Right, and I was like, my grandma hung up the phone,. She said, your mom told you to be careful going home. So I was like, all right. As far as anyone knows, that's the last time anyone had spoken to Norma. When Charla gets back to school, she attempts to contact her parents, which is sometime after 11 o'clock that night on Sunday.

And she's unsuccessful. Nobody picks up the phone. So investigators are able to hone in on that time between 9 and 11 as sort of being the most likely period of time on Sunday night that they'd been murdered. Do you suspect anybody of this? Honestly, I don't because, in my own opinion, I don't know how any human could do something.

I think a freak would have to do this. If there's anything at all that you can think of that we need to know or that you can, even if we don't need to know, talk to us. Get it out, and then, because it may mean something to us later. So during the course of their interviews, both Charla and Brandon both bring up the name

Mike Etherington. They each suggest to the police that they should talk to Mike. He was a kid that Brandon hung out with. He was in the FFA with him. They had a best friend group, and he was one of the best friends. They were just thick as thieves. Something went wrong after they graduated, and they started to get further and further apart.

My brother's going to come in here and tell you there's one kid that keeps causing him havoc. Don't let him forget to tell you about it. Who's that? Mike Ellington. About two or three weeks ago, and at about 11 o'clock, I get a text message saying, I've grown up a lot in high school. Remember my name, Michael Etherington. You're going to need it one day. Well, that was followed by about 16 to 18 text messages until 4 o'clock in the morning.

Detectives asked for the spelling of his name. E-T-H-E-R-I-N-G-T-O-N. It turns out investigators were already speaking to him, and Mike Etherington had a lot to say. It's a big, long little story. podcast. Listen to the life or death experiences of people who have survived animal attacks, natural disasters, and deadly parasites alike. Hear how a triathlete is attacked by a shark while training and manages to escape after being pulled underwater. And how a hiker in Alaska survives a 1,000-pound moose attack after the animal crushes her limbs. I Was Prey features audio from hit shows like This Came Out of Me, Nature's Deadliest, and Still Alive, and Monsters Inside Me.

Listen to I Was Prey wherever you get your podcasts. A nightmare grew from the American dream. Neighbors in this quiet community near Royce City are on edge tonight the day after cops found a couple murdered here police aren't saying how the couple was murdered but say the Woodruff's died violently as word gets out about this double murder members of the community start calling the police trying to help and one of the callers was Mike Etherington, the same person brought up by both Charla and Brandon. Mike Etherington.

Michael Etherington. Clearly at this point, Charla and Brandon have no clue that Mike is already talking to law enforcement. While Mike's first conversation with police wasn't recorded, eventually he comes in and the police take a videotaped statement. You know we're investigating capital murder and I believe you contacted us just because of some current concerns that you had. Yes. He's been friends with Brandon for years. They grew up together. We were both in 4-H. We were both in FFA. I was president of FFA. He was president of 4-H. Brandon and Mike were extremely close for most of high school.

They were part of a tight group of four-guy friends. They would call themselves the kickers. We were all really, I mean, really close, like brothers, seriously. Everywhere we'd go, you'd find the other. These guys would dress like country guys. I mean, they were jeans, they were cowboy boots. So they looked very Texas. Mike Etherington is a fascinating interview.

For no other reason than the fact that he comes to the police. They don't have to knock on his door. He essentially describes how Brandon was kind of an attention seeker. He's always the crazy one, you know. I have pictures in the yearbook where senior year, he put on his sister's old cheerleading outfit, had his face painted and stuff,

and he'd go to the games and, you know, he'd get down and he'd be the clown. But then Mike tells investigators how he thought Brandon started to change their senior year. He started hanging out with wealthier kids in town instead of their core group. Gone were the cowboy outfits. Started wearing all his preppy clothes, you know, like Armani. He'd always brag about his clothes.

You know, my shirt's better than yours. It's a $92 Armani shirt and stuff. Mike tells police that things came to a bit of a head when Brandon got into a fistfight with one of his friends. They're just fighting and scuffing all over the ground. Brandon's shirt is just torn to shreds. Here we are in the middle of a murder investigation, and you're hearing about these very juvenile spats that are going on i'm sure police are wondering okay so how does this play into the fact that brandon's parents are murdered things start to take a more serious turn he begins to describe some really dark stuff. Mike described that Brandon was cruel to animals.

He goes, I went ahead and I got the shovel, hit the mom cat over the head. I'm like, we're gonna hit the kittens. He's telling us that he's gonna throw them out on a bridge. And in a homicide context, that's hugely significant. Brandon denies ever killing a cat and throwing kittens off an overpass. Mike has his own version of the relationship between Brandon and Brandon's parents.

He goes, I hate your parents, blah, blah, blah. He goes, they're always doing this crap to me, you know, and just need to go to hell and stuff. He says that Brandon had a post on myspace where he said he hated his parents and wished they were done it had been said on there you know my parents i hate them they need to go to hell you know they wish they just die and go to hell police sit up and take notice of this comment one of the things that's interesting is comparing the interviews between Brandon and Charla. What kind of parents were your parents?

The way that Brandon describes the family life and Charla describes the family life, it's almost like two different families. So Brandon kind of describes this idyllic relationship with his parents and how they never fought. And Charla describes that their family had issues like every other family that their dad sometimes wasn't on his best behavior my dad whenever i was younger had a very bad temper and she says that brandon inherited that temper charla tells police that when the two were little, there was emotional and sometimes even physical abuse. And she describes how he would beat her with a buggy whip.

He beat the snot out of me, too. He came in and did all the horse whip thing. All he heard was just me screaming, bloody murder. Brandon has denied ever abusing his sister, and Charla has said that as they got older, the relationship got better. When you have people tell you that there was an abuse issue, you would listen to that very intently.

Interviewing Brandon is critically important, not only just to try to put together a list of suspects, but also to eliminate Brandon as a potential suspect. And so establishing a timeline is critically important. Based on what Brandon is saying and what police already know from other people, it appears Brandon is the last person to see his parents.

At 7, you left the parents' house over in Royce City, and you go over to Heath, feed the animals and parent and all that. How long does it take to get from Royce City to Heath? To get to Royce City, to Heath, maybe 20, 25 minutes. Okay. 30 at the most. Okay. I might have been there at the most for 30 minutes.

So you think probably by 8 o'clock then you're headed towards Denton? Yeah. So far, Brandon is just answering all the questions. And then Ranger Collins drops a bomb. I got an eyewitness that saw you and Heath at 11 p.m. on Sunday night. at 11 p.m. on Sunday night. A neighbor has contacted us and said on Sunday night, I saw Brandon at the Heath address.

Apparently, a neighbor around the Heath house tells police that he specifically remembers going to bed and he hears a noise. I got up and looked out the window and I saw it was Brandon in the white truck. This neighbor is sure that it was sometime around 10 or 11 p.m. So this raises huge, huge questions. Brandon said he was at the Heath house at 7.20, 7.30. The neighbor says it was 10 or 11 p.m.

Brandon, did anything happen with you and your parents? No. There's like, that's the dead truth. Like, there's, I know, that's crazy. I know, but I've seen crazy stuff happen. Something flies off, something snaps, okay? I'm asking you, Brandon, straight up, if something happened with you and your parents, get right.

And that's the way you get help. But it didn't happen. OK. So you're telling us straight up that you did not kill your parents? No. That's crazy. After they interviewed him, he was a prime suspect.

He couldn't believe that they'd think he did it. I felt the same way, the way Brandon felt. Police get a phone call from someone who's missing a gun, and they quickly learn that it could be the same type of gun and the same caliber of gun they believe was used to commit this murder. Brandon has been dating a high school classmate named Morgan Lee on and off for two years. They were kind of like an it couple. When they went anywhere, they made a statement because they were dressed to the max always. From what I saw, he treated her very well.

Her family was very loving of her and him together. Morgan's mother, Michelle Lee, really adored Brandon. I loved Brandon to pieces. I really felt he was a good guy. Brandon and Morgan, they loved horses, so they rode horses together. He could let his stallion horse get in the arena, and they would literally play. Brandon would run after him, and the horse would would spin around and then he'd chase Brandon. Brandon came home from college that weekend and on Saturday he went to visit

Morgan. Morgan needed a lamb so Morgan and Brandon went on this big adventure where they went and got a lamb. He was there kind of early. Morgan still sound asleep and I said, well just go up there and wake her up. And pretty soon they come down and you know they're laughing and cutting up and acting like they do. Days later when Brandon's parents are found dead, Michelle and Morgan are fiercely by his side. They meet him at the airport when he flies home from school, and they drive him hours to be with his family in Arkansas. Michelle and Morgan Lee, who by their accounts, they say that Brandon was visibly upset that he was just destroyed by the news.

It looked like he kind of cried himself out. Sometime after, Michelle Lee discovers that something is missing from her home. We had old Western gun and cowboy decorations in the house. I mean, this is classic Texas, right? So they've got some decorations, which include a Colt Long 45 handgun that's on display, along with live ammunition.

That was, oh my gosh, old as dirt. The gun wasn't loaded, but the bullets were in the belt that went around the perimeter. I didn't even know the gun would work. It looked like it was right out of, you know, tombstone or something. And sure enough, the gun was gone. And the leather loops that used to hold the bullets in place on the belt, they were broken and there were bullets missing. We could have taken that gun last weekend. I was like, you're crazy. Don't even think like that. Brandon wouldn't do that to his parents.

It is possible that it could have been stolen prior to Brandon being there by someone else. I had a lot of inner struggle with, do I share this with law enforcement people that a gun is now missing? And I had to make a decision quickly she told us she had in her possession an old western style holder that had the bullet loops in in the holster but no gun michelle's first conversation with police isn't recorded, but eventually she comes back in and the police take a videotaped statement.

I said, first and foremost, I want you to know that I love Brandon Woodruff and I don't want to appear as though I'm accusing him of anything. It just really bothered me that I had a missing gun and that Brandon had been at our house the same weekend that his parents died. It was absolutely the hardest thing I have ever done. I don't want you to think that I should think Brandon did anything because I'm telling you this. She felt guilty for coming forward with this information

and wanted to protect Brandon and spoke very highly of Brandon and then would turn around and say, but this is strange. and then would turn around and say, but this is strange. Tests were done on the slug found in the couch with bullets that still remained in the Lee home, and those experts said these are consistent. So the odds are reasonable that the weapon is the weapon used to shoot them, but to absolutely corroborate that, you couldn't do it until you actually find the weapon used to shoot them. But to absolutely corroborate that, you couldn't do it until you actually find the weapon.

The police at this point are putting together an affidavit for Brandon's arrest. Detectives have cleared Charla, as well as people brought up in the investigation, including Mike Etherington and the woman who was supposedly obsessed with Dennis. In this case, the fact that Brandon had some pretty big holes in his timeline, according to his interview with the Texas Rangers, and combined with the fact that he had been in a home that had a gun stolen from it,

that was pretty much it for him. It was just like a normal morning. I was getting ready for school and then all I remember was just a swarm of police coming into our house. I just heard my grandmother scream. I said, what in the world are y'all doing? I told him that we loved him and you know I believed in him. I had the radio on in the car and I heard that Brandon Woodruff had been arrested. It just gave

me goosebumps. The Brandon that I knew I would never ever imagine that he would harm his parents, let alone kill them. I was shocked. I never in my life would I imagine my little brother would be arrested for anything much less the murder of our parents. I did not think he did it. They made a mistake, and it was going to be cleared up soon. It was the most horrible thing to see Brandon with his wrists shackled. He had

his ankles shackled. Because Brandon always was the one on the other end. He was the one that could put a collar on any type of dog and have them sit, stay, come at his command. And now Brandon was the one that was in chains. The family started splitting. Immediately, the Woodruff side definitely believed there was some kind of mix up. The Johnson side, I don't know at what point,

but at some point, they very much believed that he did it. You have yet to hear the whole story. There were wild revelations still to come during the investigation of this case. Investigators called me and said, are you sitting down? I wish I had been sitting down. When you really care about someone, you shout it from the mountaintops. So on behalf of Desjardins Insurance, I'm standing 20,000 feet above sea level to tell our clients that we really care about you. Home and auto insurance personalized to your needs. Weird, I don't remember saying

that part. Visit Desjardins.com slash care and get insurance that's really big on care. Did I mention that we care? Did I mention that we care? We're talking about somebody who went in with very quick precision, murdered two people. The Hunt County Sheriff's Department is investigating the murders of a husband and wife who were found dead inside their rural home in Royce City. This is the house where the Woodruffs were murdered. And I said, Brandon, I'm scared for you. They have evidence against you, and you're screwed.

They had rumor, innuendo, and suspicion, but they had no hard evidence. I hate to tell you this, Mike, but I'm just about ready to struggle with you. Are you sitting down? We found where Brandon was getting all of his money from. You have these two separate lives that Brandon was working so hard to maintain. At some point those two lives had to collide. Brandon was wonderful with animals.

He's almost like a horse whisperer. Brandon would ride when it was always just a little more fun and free. He had different ways of doing things with his horses that was just almost magical. They jived, I mean, they were together. He's got the horse kneeling for him. He's doing this, the horse is kneeling. And he was only 17, 18, he was doing that. He had the patience and the understanding of these animals

to deal with them on their terms. He had a love for horses, and the horses knew. He just had a gift. But now, 19-year-old Brandon is behind bars, accused of killing his own parents. Well, it's a horrible situation. You can't believe it. But he always assured me, you know, that it's going to be okay. They're going to find out the truth and I'm coming home. Brandon's supporters say he shouldn't have been arrested in the first place.

They point to Brandon's MySpace page and they say that nowhere does it say that he hates his parents like Mike Etherington claimed. There is no evidence that that statement that Mike made about him saying that ever happened. Ranger Collins puts Mike Etherington's statement about the MySpace page in the probable cause affidavit and you know, they go look at it and says uh i love my parents lol you know seriously i do investigators reach out to myspace to see if the page could have been altered but they don't keep records to show if anything was changed now they need to go back to mike and say wait where's this post where brandon supposedly said I hate my parents, I wish they were dead?

Supposedly, it had been said on there, you know, my parents, I hate them, they need to go to hell, and I wish they'd just die and go to hell. Well, now you're saying supposedly, but over the phone, you said that was on there. I did not see with my eyes. All right. Give me just a minute, Mike. This is more than a huge problem for the investigators

because they've included that in their affidavit for probable cause that Brandon committed these murders. Somebody says, you know, he hates his parents and wishes they're dead. We'd call that a clue in the death of somebody's parents, right? But then they find out that mike has heard that brannon had put that up which is a completely different thing that's hearsay that's unusable mike here's the thing though that you got to understand because you're on the telephone and i was i was in the room on the speakerphone listening to you give out that information

and that information was very matter of fact, firsthand knowledge, and that's not what you're telling me right now. This is not a good thing. You know, I've seen all that on tape. They knew they shouldn't have ever arrested Brandon in the start. I mean, I hate to tell you this, Mike, but I'm just about ready to strangle you. You know what I mean? I understand 100%. And I just want to step out for just a moment, and I just want to regain my composure. This investigator is so upset, and for good reason.

Yes, a posting on MySpace, I hate my parents and wish they were dead, would be very important to proving your case. But it's still a good case without it. proven your case, but it's still a good case without it. So at this point in the investigation, it is absolutely critical that law enforcement speak to as many people as possible. This includes his friends in the area as well as his friends at the university. And you don't mind us taking a look, going over to your dorm room and all that? I mean, we want you to understand that that's, you know... It's a little messy right now. Well, that's all right.

Brandon's roommate, Eric Gentry, said that Brandon's dagger was missing from his dorm room. So he had this dagger, kind of medieval-looking dagger, and he brought that to school and had it in the closet. When was the last time you saw him? A month or two ago, probably. Now you've got a connection to Brandon with a Colt.45 revolver, and you've got a connection with Brandon to at least one knife, and they're both missing.

Abilene Christian University, this is a very strict school. It's a Christian school. There are rules, no drugs, no alcohol, no sex of any kind and there are curfews. He had a lot of friends at ACU. He got involved in the theater department. We have this thing called Freshman Follies. He did some little skits between each act. Might I say, you are all looking fantastic today. He loved it. In fact, he really wanted to get involved in the theater and drama here at ACU. Brandon was never that good a student, but he always got by.

At college, he began staying out too late, sleeping in, missing classes, his grades were falling. If you miss three or four classes, you're just out of the class. You don't get credit for anything. And that's how Brandon was flunking out. My name is Jansen Barnett and in October 2005 I was a student at the University of North Texas and I was dating a boy named Robert. He was attending ACU and that's where he met Brandon. Police are interested in talking

to Jansen and Robert who were both with Brandon the night of October 16th. They say Brandon was supposed to give Robert a ride back to Abilene Christian University that night. Sunday comes, and he calls about 30. He goes, well, we're going to leave in around 6 or so. And I was like, okay. Then he called again. He's like, well, it's going to be a couple more hours.

He knew that we would be calling him. He wasn't answering his phone for whatever reason. We were just kind of frustrated. I called him at 10, and he answered. I called him at 10, and he answered, and he was kind of, you know, when you run or when you kind of get caught in doing something, you're going to breathe hard. Like you got excited or something, but he was breathing hard. Brandon finally tells Robert Martinez, you know what, I'm not going to pick you up at your girlfriend's house. I'm going to pick you up at a Denny's outside of Dallas.

I think by the time we finally met up with Brandon, it was probably between 10, 30, 11. But that's not what Brandon told police just days earlier. So you think probably by eight o'clock then you're headed towards Denton? Yeah. Okay. It's one thing to be off a few minutes. It's another to be off three hours. And that's clearly what you have here. I would have never questioned Sunday evening until he got arrested. And then it was like, okay, I wonder if this is why he wasn't answering. And Brandon did something else later that night that also has police wondering. There's two suitcases in the back and I go go to open Brandon's, and he flipped out. Did he really? He goes, no, don't open it, don't open it.

This is the house where the Woodroves were murdered. Brandon says he had dinner with his parents that night, and then... We know that Brandon's mother, Norma, was still alive at 9.15 because she made a phone call to her mother at that time. You had several hours of missing time that Brandon was not accounting for. And it was during those hours of missing time that the murder was committed.

The timeline the state put out didn't make any sense because they're saying, okay, we're assuming that the Woodruffs were killed around 9.15. It would have taken Brandon 23 minutes if he had left, if they had died right at 9.15 and Brandon immediately got in his car and drove toward the Heath house. That doesn't work because they also said somebody had to clean up the crime scene. Brandon got to the Denny's in Dallas at 11, and Robert Martinez is saying, what's going on? So they end up going to Alex Rooley's house in Plano

and then y'all hung out for a little bit at your dad's house a little bit my dad's house and then we went to a club station four what time did you get there um probably around 12 12 12 15. I'm sorry we all kind of branched off and everyone went solidly over some friends so I didn't see him much that night or okay that's probably 2 to 30 this is kind of the weird part Brandon drove this Dodge Ram pickup just a single cab he got back that Monday and he had a new trip and what kind of trip Chevy 2500 I think or Chevy 1500. You'd never seen him in this truck before? No but he had told me he got a new truck. He'd be like I got this new truck and Tuesday we rode around it and just like show me your new truck and so we went out and rode around. It was the new um the Chevy four-door I don't know if it was a Chevy or something.

I don't know. The KTU that was his truck? Yeah, he said it was his. That was Norma's truck, which meant you don't take this without permission. You only use this when I know you're using it, and then you bring it home. The truck. My mother would never, ever, ever let my brother drive that truck to Abilene. Are you sure about that? Hot. Okay. That was kind of her pride and joy, that truck? Yeah. When police ask Alex if anything stands out from that night, he describes a strange incident when they're driving home from the club.

There's two suitcases in the back. I open the first one, we're just kind of playing around with stuff in there. And I go to open Brandon's and he flipped out. Did he really? He goes, no, don't open it, don't open it. Turned around and he really would not face forward. And he's driving. And he's driving.

So we're like, turn around, calm down, we're not going to open your suitcase, just drive. The investigators, when they heard about Brandon being so protective of his bag, they assumed that maybe there's a murder weapon in there. They got possession of that bag and they sent it straight to the lab. There was nothing that would indicate that Brandon had any involvement in the crime. What's he afraid of them finding? It later turns out that there's something else in that bag that he's desperate for certain people not to learn about. Well, I asked him the him the next day you know why'd you freak out like that he said he just had some uh gay stuff in there or something that he didn't want his friend to see

because he said rob was straight and didn't want to you know now that's something too because he's he's telling us that no i'm straight i've got a girlfriend and all that but we're hearing from friends you know that that he is gay which i mean we don't care one way or another but i mean if you're gonna lie about something little like that then you know are you gonna lie about something big i mean if you can lie something about your sexual orientation then you ought to be able to lie about something big. To make a statement like that is just totally ridiculous. Everybody lies. They lie especially about sex. Are you kidding me? Is he lying or is he just still coming out of the closet? If you've known anyone who has struggled with coming out, it's one of the hardest

things to do. It takes a monumental amount of strength. I noticed Brandon dressing like a little different. And I noticed that he was like a little more feminine. I was like, I've always known. Now one person in Brandon's family who appears not to know about his sexuality is his sister, Charla. I said, Brandon, are you gay?

He said, no. And what she says next will forever change their relationship. I said, you were part of this. There's no doubt in my mind that you had something to do with this. Days after Brandon is arrested and charged with murdering his parents, his sister, Charla, visits him in his jail cell. My grandmother comes running out and says that he wanted to see me.

So I went back there and I sat down and grabbed the phone. It's an emotional conversation. Charla seems to be struggling with what authorities say are inconsistencies in Brandon's timeline and the parts of his life that he hid from her. I think mainly what she confronted him about was he lying to her about being gay. I feel like she probably did feel some betrayal. After confronting Brandon, she immediately reaches out to police.

Now, you said that you went down and visited him? Oh, yeah. Before you came up here? I said, Brandon, are you gay? He said, no. I said, are you gay? And he said, Brandon, are you gay? He said, no. I said, are you gay? And he said, no. Charlotte basically says, look, if my brother has been lying to me about his sexuality,

he could be lying about anything. I said, a lot of people are saying you're gay. If you lie about little things, but you're telling the truth about the big things, they're going to know you're a liar. They're not going to believe you. You need to tell the truth. They've already marked you as a liar. And I said, Brandon, I'm scared for you.

They have evidence against you, and you're screwed. You have no doubt in your mind that you did it. She kind of launched into this false tautology. Well, if you're lying to people about being gay, Brandon, you know, they're going to say you're going to lie about the big things too. You know what? We don't care if he's gay or not. I don't care if he's gay. It doesn't have anything to do with anything, really. He could be lying about this is the whole thing.

I think Brandon's mindset was not only scared, I think confused. He's finding out that people that Brandon thought he could rely on were kind of backing away from him a little bit. Obviously, I don't want to lose my brother, but if that has to happen, it has to happen. More than that, I don't want to lose my own life. Right. And if they let him out, I'm gone. Why do you say that? Because if he really did this,

I don't know who he is. According to family and friends, Brandon underwent a major transformation in the year before his parents were murdered. When Brandon came back from Abilene Christian College, Brandon was different, a lot different. His appearance was pristine. He had a gorgeous tan. He had highlighted his hair. Morgan was like, wow, this is different. Morgan was like, wow, this is different. He said that he would be in the next Armani catalog.

And so I know my dad was looking forward to that. He was really proud of him. In fact, at some point he even mentions that he's flying to New York because of some modeling gig. It sort of builds up these images as I'm a model, I'm glamorous. A picture that he had painted of affluence and success. Freshman year of college, Brandon is really focused on presenting himself as coming from wealth. He displays his very expensive clothes. Problem is Dennis and Norma Woodruff don't come for money. They've literally had to downsize their house

in order to pay for the college. Brandon is 18 years old. He's going off to college. It's a private college. He is with some wealthier people on a daily basis at college. He wanted to fit in. He was somehow afford wearing all these clothes and he would go and he would spend three, four hundred dollars at the mall. He would spend crazy amounts of money and I would assume

he was getting it from modeling. When asked where that money was coming from, all of his friends said, well, he's modeling and he's going to New York, and he's going to Florida, and he's doing these modeling gigs. Investigators called me and said, are you sitting down? We found where Brandon was getting all of his money from. What we found was that Brandon had been going to Florida, not modeling, but he was part of these productions.

He was working, but it was just a different industry than what everybody was led to believe. That different industry that Ranger Collins is talking about? Brandon was getting paid to appear in gay pornographic films. I was very much shocked when I found out that Brandon was doing the movies. It's one thing to be gay, but it's another thing to be portrayed in a film. Brandon did have extra cash that he was having to somehow justify getting. Given he's at Abilene Christian University, one, he's not going to want

to advertise he's making porn. Number two, he's not going to want to advertise he's making gay porn. So to explain his money or his clothing, I think he thought, well, you know, it's kind of like modeling. I think it was a little bit of a white lie fib on his part because I don't think he wanted to be expelled. Then in June of 2008, more than two years after the murders, Brandon's Aunt Kathy makes a startling discovery in the barn at the Woodruff's old house. at the Woodruff's old house. Today is June 12, 2008. We're at Lawrence Drive in Heath, Texas. Remember, at the time of the murders,

Dennis and Norma were in the process of moving out of that house in Heath. It was a very long clean-out process. That barn was a mess. There was a ton of crap in there. Somewhere among all these boxes, in a very bottom box, she found a very small dagger-like thing. She found that, and she had to turn it in.

Of course, you know, it just made trouble for Brandon. The police knew Brandon was at the Heath home because the next-door neighbor saw him there. Brandon admitted he was there. They searched the because the next door neighbor saw him there. Brandon admitted he was there. They've searched the place. They sent eight guys down there and a canine team, multiple agencies, but they didn't find anything of evidentiary value. This dagger is unique.

It's ornate and it's almost like a pirate dagger. When they forensically examine it, they find human blood on the dagger, and in that human blood is Dennis Woodruff's DNA. Eric Gentry told investigators that the dagger is the same one Brandon had in their dorm room. But the medical examiner could not say one way or the other if the stab wounds on the victims were caused by this weapon. There are so many questions in this case that only Brandon can answer. So I paid him a visit and for the first time Brandon gives his side of the story.

Brandon if you didn't kill your parents, then who did? Finally, in March of 2009, three and a half years after the murder, the trial is underway. Brandon was charged with capital murder. The state waived the election to seek the death penalty. So that meant if Brandon was found guilty, he was facing life in prison without parole. Based on the evidence that was presented to us, it was very clear that it was someone that the Woodruffs knew they were comfortable with

in their home. Our strategy was to chip away at the state's case by pointing out at every opportunity that they had no case. They had rumor, innuendo, and suspicion, but they had no hard evidence. The state paints a picture of Brandon as a liar, living two lives, deceiving both his friends and his family. Brandon's mother had a truck that they talked about throughout the trial. This was her prized possession was this truck. So when Brandon went back to school the night of the murder, he told all his friends that his mother gave him her truck.

Another motive that's presented by the prosecution is the financial motive here. Brandon is a free spender. He projects himself as coming from wealth, which he does not. He's about to fail out of school, and this gravy train that he's been on, where his parents are essentially supporting his college education, is about to come to a crashing end. My dad had told him that he had one semester to do right. And if he failed out of school, then he was coming home. My parents weren't going to fund him going up there and just being a slacker. Dennis was talking to his sister on the phone.

And he said, we're going to have a meeting tonight with Brandon and we're going to bring up all these questions that I have for Brandon. His gay lifestyle, his failing grades, and that's the day the homicides happened. The Hunt County Sheriff's Department is investigating the murders of a husband and wife who were found dead inside their rural home in Rory City. You have these two separate lives that Brandon was working so hard to maintain. The persona over here and the persona over here, at some point those two lives had to collide.

here and the persona over here at some point those two lives had to collide it's my belief that that collision took place in the residence on the night that dennis and normal wood were murdered in the west they're gonna have two victims on the couch there's a lot of theories like the double life, the financial motive, all the rest of it. This case comes down to the timeline and it comes down to Brandon Woodruff lying about it. From the perspective of the prosecutors in this case, these people are murdered between 9 p.m. and 11 p.m. and Brandon Woodruff cannot account for his whereabouts. Brandon's neighbor, Randall Luntz, who lived right here, says he saw Brandon outside his house during the 10 o'clock news that night. That would mean he was here between 10 and 10.30. When you factor in the drive time, Brandon would have had between 20 and 45 minutes, approximately, to commit

the murders. When the jury breaks to deliberate, they need to ask themselves, did Brandon have enough time to commit those brutal murders of both his parents, clean up the crime scene, and then get to that house in Heath. The jury deliberated for five hours. I remember standing up for them to give the verdict and thinking that it was going to be not guilty. When it was guilty, my grandma just broke down and ran out and I just ran with her.

I did not want her by herself after that. Well, it said guilty. It cut through me like a knife. But there's nothing you can do. He was sentenced to life without possibility of parole in Texas State Prison. It's 5.30 in the morning, still dark out there, and I'm about to take off on a two and a half hour drive from Dallas to a state prison in East Texas. Brandon Dale Woodruff now calls this place his home. He's finally agreed to talk to us and tell us his side of the story.

Is Blackbird on the other side? Yes, ma'am. Okay. How long have you been in here? About 15 years, 16 years total. What has life been like in prison all these years? Some days it's good days, some days it's bad. It's prison. You just kind of basically wake up every day and you hope for the best. What is the real story? That I'm innocent. I did not kill my parents at all. Brandon, I have interviewed a lot of people in prison and in jail, and so often they say,

I didn't do it, I didn't do it. Why should we believe you? I think that you should look at the totality of the evidence. Brandon pushes back against the accusation that he purposely lied about his timeline on the night of October 16th. I told a lot of people that I really couldn't consider myself staying there for a couple of hours, but, you know, I fed the cats, I fed the dogs, I got ready to go that night.

So maybe, you know, it did take a little bit longer. I wasn't one to sit here and look at my watch every moment of every day. So I did the best I could. I told them where I was at. I told him what I did. And that's just the truth. But what about the story that Brandon wanted his mother's truck? My mother would never, ever, ever let my brother drive that truck to Abilene. I mean, the neighbor said that I drove it all the time. I got a ticket in that truck, and now all of a sudden, this truck is this huge deal, and it's like, I mean, it doesn't make any sense to me.

Brandon points to the fact that he was a registered driver on the truck's insurance policy. Brandon, almost three years after the murders, someone finds a dagger in your old parents' house. Yes, sir. I don't know of how anybody could actually look at a, and I'm calling it not a dagger, but a sword, because it's about this big. Did you use that sword to kill your parents? No, sir. No, sir.

Did you know it existed? No, sir. Did you use that gun that was taken from your girlfriend's house to kill your parents? Absolutely not. No, sir. Did you use that gun that was taken from your girlfriend's house to kill your parents? Absolutely not. No, sir. Brandon admits that he was struggling academically at ACU, but he says that was no reason to kill his parents. You had dropped some of your classes at the university, and investigators said that your parents were angry and that you killed them because they were going

to cut you off financially. Yeah, no, sir. Absolutely not true. School just wasn't my thing. But never once did my parents ever tell me they were going to cut me off. Never once did my parents say, this is your last chance. Brandon has spent his entire adulthood behind bars.

To this day, there is a strong group of supporters who say, that jury got it wrong, and Brandon is an innocent man. Hear his appeal. Brandon's case has about as many red flags as you could ever expect to see in a wrongful conviction. Help us right this wrong. Brandon was wrongfully judged. A murder now, I know Brandon didn't do that. Someone else is letting him take the blame for it.

Someone else is letting him take the blame for it. Shame on Texas justice. Judges of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, do your job. Free prison. Small but vocal group went to deliver an online petition to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals asking that Brandon be granted a new trial. Basically just asking them to go ahead and reopen the petition, vacate the judgment or you know they'll realize that Brandon is innocent.

Help set him free. Brandon's case has about as many red flags as you could ever expect to see in a wrongful conviction. The theory of the state's case was Brandon is leading a double life. He is portraying to his conservative friends at college that he is straight man, that he has a loving girlfriend back home, when in fact he has boyfriends. Do you feel you were charged and prosecuted and eventually convicted in large part because you're gay? I do believe that that's a major factor. I felt like the investigators were able to use that.

They were saying, well did you know that he was dancing in gay bars? Did you know that he had a boyfriend? When we did the general voir dire of the panel, we were asking about people's views on homosexuality. I'm not entirely certain you get entirely honest answers on that. But the $64,000 question that they asked was, do you feel or think that being homosexual or gay is immoral? Guess what? In 2005, people still felt that homosexuality was immoral because eight of the twelve jurors on Brandon's case specifically said it was immoral. But they were allowed to serve on the jury after promising the court that they could still be fair to Brandon. We all want to have confidence that if somebody's convicted of

something like this, it had 0% to do with that. It turns out that eight of the members of the jury polled said that they believed homosexuality was morally wrong. Do you think that played into your conviction? I think it played a part in it, which is sad. It's sad that you would actually even have to ask that question. That does not make you who you are. Your sexual identity, your orientation, none of that makes,

I'm Brandon, I'm not gay Brandon, I'm not straight Brandon, I'm just Brandon. ABC News spoke with several jurors, and they told us that when it came to deciding guilt or innocence, Brandon's sexuality was not a factor for the jury. I don't recall that issue coming up as we were deliberating of anyone saying, well,

I think he's guilty because he's gay. That wasn't even a discussion. No. No. That would be unfair. The prosecution's case against Brandon relied heavily on a timeline they say proved that Brandon was at the scene of the murders that night.

But the Innocence Project points to cell phone records they say further compressed the window of opportunity to commit the murders. The friend that was in Dallas waiting for Brandon to come pick him up, that was in Dallas waiting for Brandon to come pick him up. He called at 9.49. We know that at 10.10 that Morgan called Brandon. So if you look at these times where Brandon is talking to people, then literally the only way that could have happened

between 9.20 and 11 o'clock is if Brandon kills his parents at the most 19 minutes, like he has to act fast, or he is taking calls during the course of committing these murders. That's the only way the timeline makes sense, that he does something to one of his parents and then takes a call and chats with Morgan

like nothing's wrong. In addition to the timeline, the other biggest potential breakthrough in this case is DNA evidence from Norma. In Norma's hand, police found a clump of longer blonde hairs. That would normally be an indicator that she had somehow grabbed her attacker and that she pulled his or her hair. And that's the hair that's in her hand. Law enforcement never tested that hair. And one of the things that we've been fighting for in this case

is trying to figure out who has that hair because we want it tested. The idea of testing the hair that's located in or around her hand is a very savvy move by the defense because it could be hugely significant for an appellate court in determining whether or not Brandon gets a new trial. The Innocence Project has brought Brandon new hope. But can his relationship with his sister ever be healed? They haven't spoken since 2005.

I mean, my own sister told the ranger, well, if he could lie about something so small, then he could lie about something big, and it's not true. It still brings tears to your eyes. Yes, sir. I'm sorry. If you could talk to Charla right now, what would you tell her? But I really don't even believe he did it. I've gone back and forth over the years, but mainly my heart stayed. I don't think he did it. We all still are a family unit. We all love one another.

If people can live with what they think, I can live with what I think because I know the truth and the truth is going to come out. And we wanted to believe that he was innocent even though we thought, I thought in my heart of hearts that Brandon could very very well be guilty. No matter what Brandon has done, did do, he's still Brandon. He's just, he messed up, and I wish he hadn't. It's hard living every day without my mom and my dad here.

He's my only brother and my only sibling. My parents are gone and I feel like, yes, he was found guilty, he's in prison, but I have no answers, none. After the guilty verdict, Charlo, your sister reads a statement that says, "'The horror and pain came back "'and leaves me at a loss for words. Brandon, you made me plan a funeral,

your sister said. That thought still disgusts me. I'll never forget it. And it hit you hard? Very, because I know I didn't kill my parents. And I just wonder, why is she publicly so against me? For what reason?

If you could talk to Charla right now, what would you tell her? I would tell her that I didn't kill mom and dad. I did it. I did it. Do you love your sister? Yes, sir. How often do you think about your parents? Every day, John.

Once a person is tried and convicted, they can go up on direct appeal. After direct appeal, the conviction is considered final. That's already happened in Brandon's case. His case is, in the eyes of the state of Texas, done. Now his only chance to get out of prison is if he can prove to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals that he is 100% actually innocent. That's a tough road to hoe. As it stands right now, if we don't have a break in the case, then there's nothing we can do for Brandon.

The real uphill climb is that every arrow of suspicion points directly at him. If you get out of here, what is the first thing you'll do? Give my grandmother a big hug. That's the first thing. That's the very first thing, is I'll probably pick her up. You think that'll happen? Yes, sir. You'll ever get out of here? Yes, sir. Yes, sir.

Because I'm not going to stop. I'm going to keep fighting, and I'm going to keep fighting to prove my innocence. Brandon's grandmother remains convinced that her grandson is innocent. The family remains divided. Meantime, the Innocence Project of Texas continues to work towards Brandon's exoneration. That's our program for tonight. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Debra Roberts. And I'm David Muir from all of us here at 2020 and ABC News. Good night.