60 Minutes - 07/26/2026: Vaccine Court, Chess Boxing, Amy Sherald

Episode Date: July 27, 2026

With vaccinations increasingly a point of political tension, correspondent Jon Wertheim reports on the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program – a “no fault” vaccine court that ba...lances the public health benefits of widespread vaccination with rare cases of harm to individuals. Founded in the 1980s, the program has paid out billions of dollars to thousands of Americans. Denise Schrier Cetta is the producer.Brains meet brawn in the world of chess boxing, a sport in which competitors face off on the chess board and also in the boxing ring. Chess boxers win by checkmate or knockout — whichever comes first. Correspondent Bill Whitaker reports from the World Chess Boxing Championships in Serbia and meets Team USA as they go for gold. Heather Abbott is the producer.Correspondent Anderson Cooper profiles painter Amy Sherald, best known for her portrait of Michelle Obama. He traces her rise from obscurity to becoming one of America’s most celebrated living artists. Sherald explains why she canceled her own career retrospective at the Smithsonian’s National Portrait Gallery, and reflects on the resilience behind her vibrant, optimistic work. Graham Messick is the producer.  

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 The chances of serious vaccine injury have been likened to lottery odds, lightning strikes. But if you are one of the unlucky few, you can file a case in vaccine court. I represent both vaccine injured children and adults. Most of them will start the conversation by saying, I'm not anti-vax. Why do you think they need to tell you right off the bat they're not anti-vax, but? There's a lot of public pressure that people think you're some kind of a crazy person or you're out there. And also because most people have never heard of a vaccine injury. they're rare.
Starting point is 00:00:39 Fighters from 18 countries are here, trying to knock each other's heads off. There's the bell. But wait, now the fighters strip off their gloves and play chess? This is chess boxing. Chess is battle on a board, and boxing is chess with my body.
Starting point is 00:00:59 So when someone combining those two, I was like, yes, here's what I was made for. Amy Sherrill's paintings have sold for as much as $4 million. and are often compared to work by the great masters of American realism. Does that make sense to you in any way? It's technically what I want it as a black woman, artist, American, for people to be like, yeah, Amy Cheryl, Norman Rockwell, Edward Hopper, like, I'm in the room with the guys.
Starting point is 00:01:27 And so I think I'm okay with it. Yeah, I think I'm okay. Not a bad room to be in. No, yeah. I'm Bill Whitaker. I'm John Wertheim. I'm Anderson Cooper. I'm Leslie Stahl.
Starting point is 00:01:40 Those stories tonight on 60 Minutes. If you've never before heard of the National Vaccine Court, you're hardly alone. As we first reported in October, it sits inconspicuously a few hundred yards from the White House and stands as a model of effective public policy, balancing the societal good of widespread vaccination with rare individual harm. Founded in the 1980s, the court has, with little fanfare, paid out billions of dollars to Americans who have claimed injury after getting a lot. a vaccine. Today, with vaccine's skepticism rising and given voice in the highest ranks of government,
Starting point is 00:02:25 we wondered, can this singular court block out the noise, withstand the political winds, and stay true to its mission? You ready to go? Yeah. All right, say, go. Go. Jacob Thompson is 13 years old. He loves airplanes, swimming, and chick-fil-a. But Jacob can speak only a handful of words, and never. needs help walking more than a few yards. Jacob was born in St. Louis on New Year's Eve, 2011, rounding out a family of four with sister Maylee and parents, John and Wally. He a pilot for FedEx, she, a recent immigrant from China.
Starting point is 00:03:05 We had this perfectly normal, happy little baby. He would be able to jump up and down on my wife's lap and very alert, recognized who mom and dad was. At his six-month checkup, Jacob, received a combination shot that included the recommended childhood vaccinations against diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis, or detap, all deemed safe and effective in clinical trials. Hours later, Jacob began to seize. Doctors hoped it was a one-time reaction.
Starting point is 00:03:36 It wasn't. Within, I'd say six months or less, he didn't know that we were mom and dad anymore, and he was slithering on the floor like a snake. Unrecognizable from the child you knew. Yeah. By age two, Jacob could suffer up to 700 seizures in one day. He was diagnosed with a rare and severe form of epilepsy. Is he getting blue?
Starting point is 00:04:00 The Thompson's became increasingly convinced that his condition could be traced back to his six-month vaccinations, and they began to seek accountability. They took their case to attorney Renee Gentry. That's circumstantial evidence, because it's not direct evidence. She's a leading vaccine injury litigator and director of the vaccine. injury litigation clinic at George Washington University Law School in Washington, D.C. Perfect. I represent both vaccine injured children and adults.
Starting point is 00:04:28 All of my clients are vaccinated. Most of them will start the conversation by saying, I'm not anti-vax. Why do you think they need to tell you right off the bat they're not anti-vax, but? There's a lot of public pressure when you say that you have a vaccine injury, that people think you're some kind of a crazy person or you're out there. And also because most people have never heard of a vaccine injury. They're rare. So rare that, while hard to quantify precisely, the chances of serious vaccine injury have been
Starting point is 00:04:54 likened to lottery odds, lightning strikes. Bear in mind, in total, global immunization has saved an estimated 154 million lives, six lives each minute. But when an injury does occur, families can come to vaccine court, seen in this informational video. Part of the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, the court was established in response to a public health scare in the 1980s. The health of millions of children may be at stake.
Starting point is 00:05:24 When families of injured children went to civil court and successfully sued the manufacturers of the DTP vaccine, an older version of DTAP, it caused all but one of those drug companies to pull out of the market, resulting in vaccine shortages. Congress acted, crafting a bipartisan bill that partially shielded drug manufacturers from liability, so they would continue to develop life-saving vaccines. And at the same time, Congress acknowledged that vaccines can cause injury. As Bill's sponsor, Senator Ted Kennedy described, when children are, quote, the victims of an appropriate and rational national policy,
Starting point is 00:06:03 a compassionate government will assist them in their hour of need. It was hailed as such a unique accomplishment back in the day because you had these disparate groups. You had the parents of vaccine-injured children together in the room with the manufacturers. And everybody agreed that this was the best case scenario. Is that fair to the public? They think they have an injury caused by a vaccine,
Starting point is 00:06:25 but they can't sue the vaccine manufacturer directly. You can still opt out of this program and sue a manufacturer. You have to just start in this program. But it's a lower burden of proof in our program, so it's an easier thing for vaccine injured people to get compensation. Drug companies are not only not being sued, they're not part of the proceedings. Vaccine court is a no.
Starting point is 00:06:45 no-fault court, meaning in cases like Jacob Thompson's, negligence does not need to be proven, just that the vaccine, more likely than not, cause the injury. Vaccine court is not your typical court. There's no jury. Cases are decided in front of one of a judges called Special Masters. Since the program began in the late 80s, 12,000 Americans have received almost $5 billion in payouts. There are no financial windfalls for lawyers. The court pays them by the hour. Where does all this money come from? A 75-cent tax imposed on recommended childhood vaccines goes into a trust fund, earmarked for vaccine injury compensation. Last July, the Thompson's received a judgment of $2.1 million, based on the special
Starting point is 00:07:33 master's ruling that it was more probable than not that Jacob's six-month vaccinations aggravated and underlying genetic mutation. Jacob also received a lifetime annuity to cover his future care. Is there any doubt that the vaccine caused Jacobs injury? We can't ever prove scientific certainty on it. Does that not mean, though, that some cases are being compensated when in fact the science might not support it? Sure. And that's what Congress intended. There's very clear indication that said it would be better to compensate somebody that wasn't injured than to miss somebody who was. How do you feel about that? I think that's fine. While vaccines are critically important public health tools, they're not magic. You know, you can have an allergic reaction to aspirin. So,
Starting point is 00:08:15 it's a lot of different factors come into play to have a person be injured by a vaccine. Their genetics, their immune system, that's why the no-fault part is critical. The vaccine caused it, but there's no bad actor in this case. The program is structured around a vaccine injury table, basically a conversion chart of vaccines and eligible injuries. If your child, for instance, got a rebella vaccine and developed chronic arthritis, within 7 and 42 days, you may be eligible for damages. The most common compensation is for shoulder injuries suffered from a misplaced injection.
Starting point is 00:08:48 You can file for an injury not on the table. Overall, half of all claims have been dismissed. Today, vaccines on the table have jumped from the original 6 to 16, including the annual flu shot, though notably not COVID. As for the eligible injuries, autism is not one of them. That decision did not come easily, as retired special math, Denise Vowell and George Hastings explained. There's been a lot of talk lately about a possible link between vaccines and autism.
Starting point is 00:09:21 This has been litigated and decided in your court 15 years ago. You know, I spent many, many years of my life almost full-time, looking at that issue. In the early 2000s, cases alleging vaccinations caused autism flooded the court. Vowell, Hastings, and a third special master oversaw, oversaw what was a class action of sorts, a vaccine court proceeding that spanned almost a decade, incorporating testimony from dozens of medical experts
Starting point is 00:09:51 and hundreds of scientific articles. What did you ultimately conclude? Ultimately concluded there simply was not the evidence. I hoped there would be. Why? Because the parents of children with autism go through so much. But Val said she could not decide cases. based on sentiment.
Starting point is 00:10:13 I had to apply the law, and the law was that if there is a preponderance of evidence of vaccine causation, I rule for them. If there isn't, I rule against them. All three special masters concluded there was no link between vaccines and autism. On appeal, eight additional federal judges unanimously upheld the vaccine court decisions. This has not been persuasive to Robert F. Kennedy Jr. After 30 years, steady rises and autism rates, I don't know we know the answer. We should know the answer. We wanted to know RFK Jr's views about vaccine court, the court his uncle championed,
Starting point is 00:10:54 because today, as Secretary of Health and Human Services, he is imbued with the authority to add or redefine injuries on the vaccine table. He declined our request for an on-camera interview, but said via email that, yes, he would like to expand the table. which he hopes will create an easier path to compensation. In particular, he wants to broaden definitions for seizures and encephalopathy, two neurological conditions that can be associated with autism. Although the original intent was idealistic, compassionate, and sensible,
Starting point is 00:11:28 the court, RFK Jr. told us, has become a disaster for the families of injured children. Its effective function is delayed denial and systematic cruelty. Yeah, right there. Vaccine court delays are something Ryan Farrell knows only too well. Husband to Angela and father of three, Ryan worked as a lineman for a Boston area power company, hanging electrical wires 100 feet high. On the job in 2017, Ryan cut his hand on rusty metal and got a tennis shot.
Starting point is 00:12:01 A few days later, the pain started. I felt like my back was just like being stabbed. He would take a shower. He was like, I feel like there's razor blades. hitting my skin. Over the next few years, Ryan was hospitalized multiple times. Doctors diagnosed him with a rare autoimmune disease. I didn't want to live for a long time.
Starting point is 00:12:22 You know, that's how I felt. When did you make the link that had this vaccine? Maybe there's some correlation here. I mean the correlation. Like most Americans, Angela Farrell had never heard of vaccine court, but she stumbled upon it online and found a lawyer. They filed a case in 2019. And only last July did the special master rule, the tetanus shot more likely than not led to Ryan's illness.
Starting point is 00:12:48 Do you feel like you were treated with compassion? I mean, the special master was kind to be and my family when we were in the courtroom. Court was intended to compensate people for vaccine injuries. I want to quote this quickly, easily, and with certainty and generosity. That couldn't be further from the truth. What do you mean? I feel like they made it way too long. Ryan remains unable to work, and seven years in, he has yet to receive his full damages.
Starting point is 00:13:16 The court acknowledges the delays. Siting a backlog of more than 3,000 cases, its chief special master has, in documents obtained by 60 minutes, asked Congress for more resources four years running, saying it becomes more difficult each year to resolve the huge number of case filings in the expedient fashion they deserve. Congress has yet to act. Our reporting suggests that this inaction is in part because vaccination has become such a loaded, heavily politicized issue that legislators are reluctant to wait in. The Thompsons are not invested in the heavily charged vaccine debate. They're invested in their son, Jacob, an anguishing exception harmed by what's otherwise a public health force of good. I do wonder if people aren't going to hear your story and be terrified. of giving their kids vaccinations. We're definitely not anti-vaxxers.
Starting point is 00:14:12 We think, I mean, vaccines are great. They've done a lot to help people. But I think that parents need to know what can happen. If what you care about are vaccine-injured people and then being compensated, then you want this court to work and you want this court to be here. I mean, we have this program that incentivizes the manufacturing of vaccines, but also acknowledges that in some rare cases,
Starting point is 00:14:37 there are injuries and damages. It's bipartisan. It takes everyone's views into account and everybody compromises, which is a dirty word now, but that's the goal of it. And it's helped these people. Jacob will be taken care
Starting point is 00:14:51 for the rest of his life because of this program. Sometimes it feels like the news is full of things that have never happened before, and that is not exactly true. In fact, it may have happened this very week,
Starting point is 00:15:07 hundreds or thousands of years ago. I'm Sally Helm, host of the podcast History This Week from the History Channel. Trade embargoes? Thomas Jefferson tried them. Rent too high? We've been arguing about that for a while. Each episode is proof. The past isn't that far away. Listen to History This Week, available now on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts. When we first heard about chess boxing, we thought it was a joke.
Starting point is 00:15:38 Chess boxing? Could it really be a thing? Turns out it is. And it's just what it sounds like. alternate rounds of chess and boxing. You can win by knockout or checkmate, whichever comes first. Don't laugh. This odd couple made it to the Paris Olympics as an exhibition match. Russia is the reigning champ. But as we first reported last fall, an upstart American team swung for the medals. Still think we're kidding? Come with us to the world chess boxing championships in Serbia. It's a quiet September Sunday in Loznizza, a sleepy balkan town in western Serbia. But inside the local sports arena, the bells are ringing for a different reason.
Starting point is 00:16:31 The German comes out fast, jabbing and punching. He batters his Russian rival until a roundhouse sends him down. Fighters from 18 countries are here trying to knock each other's heads off. There's the bell. But wait, now the fighters strip off their gloves and sit down. It's chess time. Competitors have three minutes to vanquish their enemy on the board. If they don't, it's back to the slug fest for three more minutes.
Starting point is 00:17:04 It's gloves on, gloves off, until checkmate, knockout, or judge's decision. This is chess boxing, where Knuckle meets nerd. When you first heard about it, did you know that it was? a real sport? No. No, I thought it was like a Saturday Night Live skit. It was so absurd to me that someone would combine these two things. I have to admit, when I first heard about it, I laughed.
Starting point is 00:17:31 It sounds crazy. It's the best thing about the sport. Chess is battle on a board. And boxing is chess with my body. So when someone combining those two, I was like, yes, here's my yin and yang. Here's what I was made for. Ladies and gentlemen, chess boxing fans around the world, thank you for you. Matt Thomas is a chess boxing evangelist.
Starting point is 00:17:50 When we get to the later round, and coach of Team USA. He's built a squad of 15 American contenders from all walks of life. There's the lawyer, a Cornell math major, a military veteran. In 2018, Thomas became the first American to compete for a world chess boxing title. And you won. And I won, which the person who was the most surprised about that was me. So did you win by hook or by rook? Good question. It was actually by Rook, yeah.
Starting point is 00:18:25 Thomas dropped out of law school and went all in. Double jab, triple jab. He's a promoter, commentator, and fundraiser for a sport hardly anyone has heard of. No wonder, chess boxing started out life in a French graphic novel. It was pure fiction until 2003, when it turned into fact at a real life match in Berlin. It was an instant hit, especially in Russia. Now, America is catching up, one fighter at a time. I had the body of a chess player. I was just like a scrawny kid, you know. Meet William Gambit Man Graef, a New York State chess champ. He's been playing competitive chess since the age of five.
Starting point is 00:19:10 Yep, good, good, good. We saw his take-no-prisoners approach. How'd I get in this horrible position? When he demolished four of us at once just for fun. Check me. Check me. Grafe told us he added 30 pounds of muscle to become a chess boxer. He's still only 160 pounds. Are you scared in any way? I'd be a little crazy not to be terrified.
Starting point is 00:19:35 But why are you willingly deciding to step into a ring where you can get your head beaten in? Yeah, you sound like my mother. One of the things is sort of the opportunity to tell my story. here of like a kid who played chess growing up throughout school and was to an extent ridiculed and ostracized for being a scrawny chess player. Exactly. Okay, you know, I've been doing chess for a very long time. What better time to sort of try something new and challenge myself. Like his teammates, Graf paid his own way to get here. There's no prize money in chess boxing, just the warmth of your country's flag. Matt Thomas told us,
Starting point is 00:20:20 That was enough to unite his rag-tag team against the 800-pound gorilla, Russia. We're by far the underdogs. We're coming in with the red, white, and blue trying to upset people. No one thinks we're going to do well. No one thinks we're going to win. The Russians are the best? By a long shot. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:20:39 So why? What makes them so good? They have it in over 500 schools and universities where kids are growing up with chess boxing. It is their sport, their focus. Making his chess boxing world championship debut, Wayne Clark! Wayne God King Clark was about to run into that Russian machine. A former Harlem Globetrotter, Clark traded hoops for the ring 11 years ago. He's got the stare down perfected.
Starting point is 00:21:07 His chess? A work in progress. We first met God King in Times Square, where he'd taken out a billboard to drum up interest in the sport. Clark told us he had one uncle who was a boxer and another who was a chess master. And the next thing you know, the chess board would roll out and they would be playing chess till one and two o'clock in the morning, and I was just always around it. And so when I heard of chess boxing, I knew I was destined for it. Yeah. So chess and boxing are part of your family's DNA. Absolutely. And have you seen this becoming more popular, more well-known? Yes. You know, We actually are doing a chess boxing tour in schools right now.
Starting point is 00:21:48 So we started this last year, and the hope is that we can grow that all throughout the United States and introduce it to students' brains and brawn and how they both work together. In Serbia, we watched on the big screen as Clark made his opening moves. The chess boxing crowd cheers as loudly for a captured queen as an uppercut, and they're not shy with advice. Focus, focus, focus. Clark knew he had to win at boxing, but in the ring, his mojo deserted him. There was more wrestling than boxing.
Starting point is 00:22:23 The Russian coach spurred his fighter on. Without a knockout, it was back to the board, headsets on to block out coaching from the crowd. Clark tried valiantly to fend off the Russian attack. Too late, checkmate. How are you feeling right now? I didn't do my game plan. I didn't stick to my game plan at all. I wasn't the Wayne Clark.
Starting point is 00:22:46 I know I am in boxing at all. Is this harder than you thought it would be? Oh, the chest, yeah. The boxing was just stupid errors. I take full accountability for that. Through 75 fights. Representing Russia. Russia won victory after victory.
Starting point is 00:23:00 Russia. Russia. Russia. But there were other contenders, too. We saw knockdowns and knockouts. There was a little blood, a lot of sweat, but no tears. We saw fighters who flexed and grizzled veterans who tried. We saw nervous newbies and women fighters who pulled no punches.
Starting point is 00:23:23 Immediately a knockdown to start to fight by France. Then it was showtime for chessmaster William Graf. Coach Matt Thomas told us chess players may look meek, but they are cutthroats. Those guys are Mike Tyson, but in the head, they want to tear you apart and make you doubt yourself and want to quit in the same way that a boxer would pick someone apart, they're picking you apart with their brain. In his first match, Graf shredded his French opponent.
Starting point is 00:23:55 Now he was facing a German champion. Graf attacked lightning fast chess moves, setting him up for the win. When they got to the ring, Graf channeled his inner rocky and let loose with a flurry of punches. But it wasn't enough. Representing Germany.
Starting point is 00:24:13 He lost on points. I'm really proud of that I did this, and I'm really proud of the way I went out. Do it all over again. As Iron Mike Tyson once said, everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face. Most people on the surface when they hear about chess boxing, they think that the battleground is the chessboard or the boxing ring. And it is. You have to be good at both.
Starting point is 00:24:37 But the real battlefield is the minute in between rounds. Thomas told us the best chess box. learn how to control their breathing to switch from a high-octane fight to cold calculation. So the more that you can down-regulate, lower your heart rate, dump the adrenaline out of your system, and let your amygdala chill out for a round, the more of your potential chest strength you're going to be using in the chest round. So this transition, this is key. Key. It's still, to this day, a competitive advantage that I think Team USA has over the rest of the world. Not as many people are putting as much time, effort, and preparation into the minute-in-between rounds.
Starting point is 00:25:18 Halfway through the tournament, the scrappy underdogs of Team USA had two gold medals. But the Russian march to first place continued. We are this great rival for everybody. Peter Zukov is a Russian businessman and the founder of the Russian Chess Boxing Federation. He told us chess and boxing. are hardwired into Russia's history. In Soviet, old-school Russian boxing gyms, they would play chess after boxing training.
Starting point is 00:25:51 They would just do it to develop certain qualities in their fighters. They play chess and checkers. To work a different part of your mind? Yeah. Zukov was ringside for the last and most coveted title of the championships, the super heavyweight final. No surprise to see a Russian fighter here, His challenger?
Starting point is 00:26:12 Hailing from the United States of America, James Canty. Michigan's James Cante was the last American standing. A professional chess player, Cante, has been boxing for only two years. He was up against a brawler with years in the ring. Canty knew the Russian would be looking for his head. The Russian charged, lashing out with a punishing right hook. Canty danced and dodged, taking blow after blow. Counter him in the neck, hands up!
Starting point is 00:26:47 But he hung on. Jack! And on. Canty on the road. And then, in the third round of chess, check me. James Canty the third had beaten the odds... We got it done. To become the new super heavyweight chess boxing champion of the world.
Starting point is 00:27:06 He needed a chair. It's like when you went back in for that second round, Yeah. It's like the longest three minutes you ever went through. Of my life, bro. Longest three minutes of my life, I ain't gonna lie. But you took a licking and kept on your ticket. I did.
Starting point is 00:27:20 You did? I did. And I'm a world champ. And you're a world champ. Coach Matt Thomas was giddy with excitement. God, I couldn't be proud. I mean, to have a USA-Russia final, to close out the seventh chess boxing world championship
Starting point is 00:27:35 and to beat Russia for a goal. Let's go, baby. Russia blitz the medals for first place. But Team USA took nine, enough for second, surprising everyone. Already hyped for next year's slugout, they were going home on a high. I love a happy ending, don't you? When Amy Cheryl was selected to paint the official portrait of Michelle Obama nine years ago, Many people in the art world didn't know who she was.
Starting point is 00:28:32 They do now. At 52, Sherald has become one of America's most celebrated painters. She had three major museum retrospectives last year, but it was another exhibition last fall at the Smithsonian's National Portrait Gallery that made headlines. Sherald canceled it, fearing museum officials, under pressure from the Trump administration, were going to try and censor a painting. As we first reported last October, Cheryl has faced much bigger challenge. than that. Like many of the people she paints, Amy Sherald has found a way to make her way.
Starting point is 00:29:07 In Amy Sherald's paintings, her subjects, Black Americans, stare silently straight out from the canvas. There's something in their eyes that draws you in, something knowing in their gaze. They appear unapologetic, unafraid, posed against monochromatic backgrounds, or in scenes as bright and bold as they are. In this painting, a farmer leans atop an impossibly pristine John Deere tractor surrounded by blue sky and green grass. In so many of your paintings, the subject is looking out at the viewer. I think that's important.
Starting point is 00:29:43 I don't think these portraits are confrontational, but they are present, and they do want you to sit with them and have an exchange. They have jobs. They're doing their jobs, you know. They're being beautiful. They're being colorful, but they also have work to do in the way. the world. And they're doing that work in your painting. By standing there and being present and looking at you and meeting your gaze, that's the work. They don't have to say anything,
Starting point is 00:30:10 but every time you look at that portrait, something is happening inside of you. Amy Sherrill's work hangs in the most prestigious museums in America and in the rooms of major collectors and some smaller ones, including me. Last summer, she gave us a private tour of her show American Sublime. while it was at the Whitney Museum of American Art in New York, home to some of the greatest artists of the 20th and 21st centuries. Sherald had been dreaming of having a show here for years. I would sit in my studio every day, and I would meditate and visualize myself in this space.
Starting point is 00:30:46 How does it compare to the fantasy? It's exactly like it. Is it? Yeah, it's perfect. Her paintings are portraits, but not in the traditional sense. The people in them are real, but their names are rarely used. She's cast them in a visual story all her own. The process starts with a photograph.
Starting point is 00:31:05 After I randomly come across some person that I'd like to say, like my energy recognizes their energy or there's something there, right? And just kind of hold it like you're... They come to the studio and either I already have a vision in my head of what I want to create or they are the walking vision of what I want to make and I photographed them. She's used friends, models, dancers, strangers she's seen on the street. The clothes they wear are often thrift store finds. Cheryl has racks of them in her studio.
Starting point is 00:31:39 I've had this for probably five years. Just waiting for the right person. There were only two paintings in Cheryl's show of people whose names were used. This is her portrait of a very alive, Brianna Taylor, painted after she was shot to death by police in 2020 in a botched raid on her apartment. And this is Cheryl's most famous work, the former first lady titled Michelle LaVon Robinson Obama. Unveiled in 2018, it made headlines around the world. Did you know how important this was going to be for your career?
Starting point is 00:32:14 Yes. Did you think about that? I think in the moment, I wasn't thinking about that because if I did, I probably would have just freaked out. You know, I just stayed out of my head and stayed in the painting. What stands out to you? When I look at it now, the dress, like I'm deeply in love with this dress, just the red, the pink, the yellow, and then the black and gray. I wanted the dress to also have some kind of symbolism and almost be a painting in and of itself. Before coming to the Whitney American Sublime was at the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art.
Starting point is 00:32:51 Sarah Roberts was the show's curator. I wasn't sure we could do Amy Cheryl for some. 60 minutes because I'm not sure that cameras really capture the work. It's a very different experience to see it in person. There's a luminescent quality to it. There's a quality to the color that is impossible to catch on camera. They have a majesty and a tactility when you see them in person that they lose in reproduction.
Starting point is 00:33:16 How does she do that? She's an incredible painter. I mean, just the technical skill. Cheryl's style of painting is called American realism. It's a way of depicting the ordinary and American life. It has meant slightly different things to the different painters it's been applied to, and she is creating images that say something about America right now, ideas of freedom, ideas of individualism, freedom of expression,
Starting point is 00:33:46 and a lot of kind of Americana ideas. There's the cowboy and the beauty queen and the white picket fence. She's reimagining them and redeploying them to make sure that that idea of America includes everyone. Everybody has a seat at the table. A place on a museum wall. It was this painting on a museum wall that Amy Sherald says changed her life. She saw it on a class trip to the city art museum in Columbus, Georgia when she was a teenager. It was painted by an American artist named Bo Bartlett.
Starting point is 00:34:20 There was a figure in it that was an image of a black man. And I realized in that moment that I had never seen a black person in a painting before. In any painting, you had not seen a black person. What did you think? I thought I want to do this, too. You knew in that moment you thought that I want to do this. 100%. It turned on the light.
Starting point is 00:34:41 Her parents, Amos and Geraldine Sherald, hope she'd be a doctor. But in college, she broke the news to them she was going to devote her life to art. She spent more than a decade painting by day and waiting tables at night. night. Did you ever think this is not going to work out? Yeah, but I couldn't give up. Like I always say, the world is full of quitters. And most people don't want the discomfort and most people don't want the risk. So if I kept at it, then eventually something would have to happen. What happened was not what she expected. Cheryl, an avid runner, was training for a triathlon in 2004 when she was diagnosed with a rare heart condition. My doctor said, you're lucky to be alive. He's basically
Starting point is 00:35:24 say, like, don't do anything to get your heart rate up because you could have a tachycardic episode and you could die. She nearly did eight years later. She collapsed in a drugstore and spent months in the hospital before receiving a heart transplant. She was 39 years old. The donor was a young woman named Kristen Lynn Smith. Does it feel different to have somebody else's heart?
Starting point is 00:35:49 It doesn't anymore, but it does. I'd say for, like, the first five years. Wow. For five years. Yeah. You think about it a lot. I have moments where I think of her, and usually when I'm doing something
Starting point is 00:36:03 that I wouldn't have been able to do. So, like, whenever that happens, I have on my Instagram account, I hashtag it Adventures of Kristen and Amy so that I can mark all the big moments and include her in those moments. And when I sign my name, I put a little heart on the end for her.
Starting point is 00:36:22 So she lives in all your paintings? She does, yeah. Amy Cheryl's studio is in this warehouse in New Jersey. She makes about a half dozen new paintings here a year. In a closet, there's a wall full of paints in colors she's mixed herself. This is the gray scale that I paint from when I'm doing the skin. Skin color in her portraits is something Cheryl has given a lot of thought to. If you hadn't noticed, she doesn't use brown or black.
Starting point is 00:36:52 She paints her subject's skin in shades of gray. Right now, we're in the mid-tone phase, where I'm still shaping the face. At first, she says she just liked the way the gray looked. It reminded her of old family photographs she grew up with. This one is of her maternal grandmother. You want somebody to see the humanity in your subject? I think that's where it starts. That's why I chose to use the gray scale instead of brown.
Starting point is 00:37:22 I think that it offers the viewer an opportunity to pause and consider something else before we get to that. If they had brown skin in your painting, would that be the first thing that people noticed? I think so. I mean, I think we still look at each other through our phenotypes anyway. Phenotypes is what? Phenotypes are your eyes, your nose, your lips. You can look at somebody and say like, oh, because this person is probably Caucasian and this person is probably not Caucasian, you know, but they look black. I can't take blackness away from them.
Starting point is 00:37:58 But the lack of color allows for a different entry point. When did you realize that? When I became afraid to paint brown people because I was afraid that the work would be marginalized and not be able to be in conversation with other artists, just it be put in the black corner. That certainly seems unlikely now. At auctions, her paintings have sold for as much as $4 million
Starting point is 00:38:24 and are often compared to work by the masters of American realism, Edward Hopper, Andrew Wyeth, even Norman Rockwell. Does that make sense to you in any way? It's technically what I want it as a black woman, artist, American, for people to be like, yeah, Amy Cheryl, Norman Rockwell, Edward Hopper, like, I'm in the room with the guys. And so I think I'm okay with it. Yeah, I think I'm okay.
Starting point is 00:38:51 to be in. No. Yeah. Before we left her studio, Cheryl showed us this model made in preparation for the canceled exhibition of American Sublime at the Smithsonian's National Portrait Gallery. You get to see how it flows and then what kind of story is telling as the viewer walks through. She told us she backed out of the show last July after learning Smithsonian officials were concerned about this painting of a trans person posing as the Statue of Liberty and wanted to to display it alongside a video they said would, in their words, contextualize the piece. The Trump administration had for months been criticizing the Smithsonian as being too woke and promised to review its exhibitions.
Starting point is 00:39:35 When Cheryl canceled, the White House applauded, calling the painting, quote, divisive and ideological. There were conversations about the work being censored. The show is American Sublime. It was a whole narrative. And a trans woman is a part of that narrative for me. Any kind of contextualization around the work would have been unacceptable
Starting point is 00:39:58 and it would have deviated from how the work was originally conceived. And because of that, I felt like my only choice was to pull out. Do you see your work as political? Today, I do. I don't think that it's in its true nature from where it comes from inside of me, political. But it lives in the world. and therefore can be art on Monday and political on Tuesday, you know.
Starting point is 00:40:25 It's like the pinnacle for me. Cheryl's paintings weren't hidden away for long. After she canceled the show in Washington, the Baltimore Museum of Art offered to exhibit American Sublime. It's now at the High Museum in Atlanta. Do you consider the word patriotic? Yes. I don't think there's anybody more patriotic than a black person.
Starting point is 00:40:47 How so? I mean, we've been here since the inception of this idea of what American is. We are deeply ingrained in the fabric of this country. This country would not be if it was not for us. So I have to claim that patriotism. Otherwise, I'm just handing it over to somebody to give me the definition of what it means to be American. But I know what the definition of what it means to be American is, and I'm the definition of an American. So I've had three
Starting point is 00:41:23 Amy Sherald on her triptic Ecclesia This is the exclamation point of this exhibition It's like the pinnacle for me At 60 Minutes Overtime.com I finished and Hey gang, it's Jill Schlesinger I'm launching a new show. It's called
Starting point is 00:41:38 Money Moves and We are gonna move. We are going to answer your financial questions and take the mystery out of your financial life. Follow and listen wherever you get your podcasts.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.