60 Minutes - 3/7/2021: The Unequal Recession, The Long Shot, Back to the Moon

Episode Date: March 8, 2021

Low wage workers are bearing the brunt of the coronavirus recession. Scott Pelley travels to Ohio and talks to people who have lost their income and homes. A 40-year-old antidepressant and a Californi...a horse track are connected in what could be another treatment of COVID19. Sharyn Alfonsi tells us more. And Bill Whitaker introduces us to NASA engineer, Jodie Singer, who is in charge of building the rocket aimed at putting first woman on the moon. Those stories on this week's "60 Minutes." To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 There are very few things that you can be certain of in life. But you can always be sure the sun will rise each morning. You can bet your bottom dollar that you'll always need air to breathe and water to drink. And, of course, you can rest assured that with Public Mobile's 5G subscription phone plans, you'll pay the same thing every month. With all of the mysteries that life has to offer, a few certainties can really go a long way. Subscribe today for the peace of mind you've been searching for. Public Mobile. Different is calling. Why do fintechs like Float choose Visa?
Starting point is 00:00:33 As a more trusted, more secure payments network, Visa provides scale, expertise, and innovative payment solutions. Learn more at visa.ca slash fintech. The COVID recession is the most unequal in modern history. And to understand what that looks like, we visited this Ohio food bank. Who are these people? Our neighbors. It's people that are just struggling, people that lost jobs because of COVID,
Starting point is 00:01:10 seniors that are shut in. We actually had a 14-year-old say to us, it's not my day to eat. What do horse racing, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and treating COVID have in common? I have a responsibility to do the best for my patients. A kind of trifecta that makes up our story tonight. If you had told me what the odds were at the start of this, I might have reconsidered doing this. It was a long shot. For sure.
Starting point is 00:01:45 NASA's new mission to the moon is called Artemis, after Apollo's mythical twin sister. And the goal is for the next astronaut's footprint on the moon to be made by a woman. I would point to the moon being a proving ground, a waypoint, for us to learn how to live in deep space when we're only days from home. I'm Leslie Stahl. I'm Bill Whitaker. I'm Anderson Cooper. I'm Sharon Alfonsi.
Starting point is 00:02:13 I'm Scott Pelley. Those stories and more tonight on 60 Minutes. Wendy's most important deal of the day has a fresh lineup. Pick any two breakfast items for $4. New four-piece French toast sticks, bacon or sausage wrap, biscuit or English muffin sandwiches, small hot coffee, and more. Limited time only at participating Wendy's Taxes Extra. What's better than a well-marbled ribeye sizzling on the barbecue?
Starting point is 00:02:41 A well-marbled ribeye sizzling on the barbecue that was carefully selected by an Instacart shopper and delivered to your door. A well-marbled ribeye you ordered without even leaving the kiddie pool. Whatever groceries your summer calls for, Instacart has you covered. Download the Instacart app and enjoy $0 delivery fees on your first three orders. Service fees, exclusions, and terms apply. Instacart. Grocer groceries that over-deliver. Soon, President Biden is expected to sign a third COVID recession relief plan just days before emergency unemployment benefits expire.
Starting point is 00:03:18 For many, the need is great, in part because this recession is the most unequal in modern history. This past Friday, new jobs numbers confirmed that middle and high-income workers are returning, but the jobs of low-income Americans have been annihilated. Relief checks have been a lifeline, but temporary. Many, like the Americans you're about to meet, were already struggling in poverty when COVID pushed them over the edge. As they fall, the pandemic is cutting away at the safety net. For 23-year-old Courtney Yoder, the cruel recession hit just as she was saving enough from her job to move out of a tent, anticipating the birth of her first child.
Starting point is 00:04:11 Working actually was something good for me, and then when I lost it, it was like now I have nothing, you know what I mean, to look forward to because I actually felt good about myself. I felt accomplished. I felt like I was doing something in my life. I had stacked up three checks. I was actually trying. And then all that gets taken from me. There wasn't much to take from Courtney Yoder. She had lived in and out of foster care from age three. On her own at 18, she pitched a tent in Columbus, Ohio,
Starting point is 00:04:39 and found a job in a restaurant. COVID comes, and I take it the restaurant closed. Yes, yeah. You went back to the tent. Yes. And thought what? What am I going to do now? So I'm not working. I have no income. I'm waiting on unemployment. I have no way to get to and from anywhere. I can't go to the library. All the places are closed that we usually go to to eat or, you know, going to during the day. She couldn't even go back to her tent. It was slashed by someone who left a warning that she was on railroad property.
Starting point is 00:05:13 When we met, she was eight months pregnant and had to push herself to keep fighting. Because there was times where I wanted to give up and, you know what I mean, not be alive anymore and just be like, you know what I mean, things are never going to get better. Courtney Yoder is among the Americans suffering the most. COVID killed the jobs of low-earning workers in restaurants, hotels, theaters, and shops, jobs held mainly by women and minorities. You know, some of those aren't going to come back. Some of those jobs won't come back.
Starting point is 00:05:46 In Columbus, retired firefighter Steve Roth and nurse Jackie White are discovering the wreckage of the recession. For 22 years, Roth has shouldered relief for the homeless. Now there are newcomers to those, as he puts it, who live on the land. You guys home? Before the pandemic hit, who live on the land. You guys home? Before the pandemic hit, they were just making it. They were just making their bills, and now the rugs pulled out from under them. People who were just hanging on when everything was normal.
Starting point is 00:06:18 Those people that had multiple jobs even before things got bad. How bad is measured in Ohio's unemployment claims, which are higher in the pandemic than the last five years combined. Nationwide, COVID took nine million jobs. The crush of new unemployment claims has delayed benefit checks. Hey, we're Mount Carmel. Are you doing okay? Steve Roth works for Mount Carmel, a not-for-profit hospital system that has brought compassion to the homeless for 32 years and watched the need grow with every recession. All right, my friend.
Starting point is 00:06:58 We have our mobile medical clinic that sets up at various locations throughout the city. We have two exam rooms, x-ray, pharmacy, a place for our physician or our nurse practitioner to work, and then also our nurses. We can do just about anything that a doctor's office can do, and then we also have a specific team that goes out to the homeless camps and provides care out there.
Starting point is 00:07:23 What are their needs? DR. JOHN YANG They need someplace warm. They need a tent. They need shoes, clothes. They need blankets. They need sleeping bags. And those are all things that we provide for them. JOHN YANG And their medical needs or what?
Starting point is 00:07:37 DR. JOHN YANG Unfortunately, a lot of what we deal with right now is because of addiction. But they also have high blood pressure, they have diabetes, they have skin issues, everything that everybody else has, they have also. You guys need anything? How you feeling today? All right.
Starting point is 00:07:54 Yeah? In the pandemic, Mount Carmel has increased its rounds from two days a week to five. Where are we? So we are on the south end of Columbus, behind a big shopping center. Before the pandemic, a census counted more than half a million homeless Americans. COVID is likely to crowd the camps with another quarter million, according to a study by the Economic Roundtable. How has COVID changed the world for these people?
Starting point is 00:08:22 There were a lot of places throughout the city where they could get resources, clothes, food. They could go somewhere to get warm, like a library. Those are done. They can't have any of that stuff. JOHN MCCORMICK, When COVID closed soup kitchens, Mount Carmel started delivery. JOHN MCCORMICK, Mid-Ohio Food Bank made lunches for us, and we were passing out 100 lunches a day to people. And when it first happened, they were so thankful for that food.
Starting point is 00:08:49 They said, oh, my gosh, I haven't eaten for two days. Well, here's a lunch. The Mid-Ohio Food Bank tells the story of how COVID threatens the lifelines to the newly unemployed. Every aisle is filled up like this one, so how long does this food last you? If we didn't bring any more food in today, this would be less than 30 days. We'd move all the food that's in this building out.
Starting point is 00:09:17 Mid-Ohio Food Bank's CEO, Matt Habash, ordered three times more food than usual for the emergency, but then COVID took away his most important resource. We have 13,000 volunteers put in about 70,000 hours of packing, and we were going to lose them all. Figure senior citizens are being told to stay home. And more than half of our wonderful volunteers are corporate volunteers, and they were all being told to stay home.
Starting point is 00:09:41 So Ohio ordered in the National Guard. More than 300 troops have distributed 90 million pounds of food in Ohio. Nationwide, the Census Bureau says four and a half million people who lost jobs to COVID don't have enough to eat. What is your understanding of how much the need has increased?
Starting point is 00:10:06 Major General John Harris commands the Ohio Guard. The demand has increased fourfold, fivefold, just here. Families coming to get food. Families who've never, ever had to come to a food bank for food are coming now. I'm reminded of a story a soldier told me about people who worked in the food bank where he was working. People who had previously volunteered at that food bank are now worked in the food bank where he was working. People who had previously volunteered at that food bank are now coming to the food bank to get food because their families are in need. So that places pressure on our folks to ensure those people leave here with
Starting point is 00:10:36 their dignity. Hunger is reaching into middle-income families too. More than 17 million Americans have told the Census Bureau they've relied on free food during the pandemic. Who are these people? Our neighbors. It's people that, you know, are just struggling, people that lost jobs because of COVID, seniors that are shut in. A lot of them are kids, and that's probably the scariest thing to me is making sure those kids get enough food. We actually had a 14-year-old say to us, it's not my day to eat. 17-year-old Nathan Majeed did not skip a day of eating, but when his parents lost their jobs in a hotel and a shoe store, his diet grew thin,
Starting point is 00:11:16 just as he was writing his college applications. Food-wise, we just had to make different approaches towards certain foods. So we would basically just stock up on rice, and that would be a main part of our diet, pretty much. Columbus students told us about hunger, cutting back on electricity, and living in the family car. Twelve-year-old Shonalee Archie and her 11-year-old sister Sarah told us their parents lost their janitorial jobs, then lost their home before the eviction moratorium. Still, their mom and dad fought back
Starting point is 00:11:52 like parents who've seen the shadow of hunger creep too close. My family has always, always, always made sure we were okay, has always gave us somewhere to stay, you know, has always kept food in our stomachs, have always kept clothes on our backs. It just, you know, it hits my mom the worst because she felt like she was a bad mother. How did you help your mother through that? I told her that she can talk to me, you know, about anything, whatever. She's the reason why I'm here today, you know. She's my world.
Starting point is 00:12:30 A shelter couldn't take her family right away because it had cut capacity for social distancing. So four kids and two adults lived in this minivan. How long were you living in the car? Just about a week. After that week, there were six weeks in a shelter, and now this rental paid for by a charity. Sarah told us the van wasn't so bad as she put it, I'm small. I'll fit wherever. But other young people don't seem to fit anywhere.
Starting point is 00:13:03 Some abused or pregnant teenagers kicked from the home. We found them waiting in line at a shelter, hoping they would not be turned away. This is the first time that we've had that line that you're talking about. Previous to the pandemic, we were open 24-7, and we were the only place in central Ohio where a young person around the clock could have immediate access to safety. Ann Bischoff is CEO of Star House, a refuge for young people 14 to 24. What has the pandemic taken away from these young people? We have typically, pre-COVID, a range of partners who
Starting point is 00:13:41 would come in and offer on-site education, on-site jobs. Health care has fallen off as well. Typically, we would have 15 hours of medical care. Now they're coming in, but it's every other week. Always glad to see you guys every night. COVID-related staff shortages mean Star House is now closed from 2 p.m. to 10.30 at night, and its capacity is limited. And so I'd come in, and they'd be like, oh, we're at capacity.
Starting point is 00:14:13 And you're like, I just want something to drink. I just want something to eat. I just want to lay down. Courtney Yoder relied on Star House while she was saving to get out of her tent. I felt like I'm working so hard. I have, you know, a job, and I'm getting off work, getting off the bus, and I have my clothes still on, and I want to shower, and I'm coming in,
Starting point is 00:14:35 and, oh, we're at capacity, Courtney. And I'm like, back to the tents. I can't even shower for tomorrow to go back to work. I can't even change my clothes. Star House would be dimmed by COVID even further, but it received money from last year's federal relief. Courtney Yoder is one of the shelter's successes. Recently, she got an apartment through a charity, the Homeless Families Foundation. Being in a house and actually being able to say, like, I'm going home. Like, being actually being able to say I'm going home, like, that's so much to me.
Starting point is 00:15:13 With Shelter, she found two jobs, 70 hours a week, and then took time off beginning this past December when she became a single mother to a boy named Ryder. You're still a believer in the American dream. Yeah. I'm still fighting, and I feel like I fought this hard because, you know what I mean, I wouldn't have eventually gotten to meet my son and love him and care for him and just make sure that he's safe.
Starting point is 00:15:39 Can you carry that? Yeah. Okay, man. Thank you, brother. All right, man. Steve Roth of Mount Carmel is meeting people who are new to living on the land. Do you want a lunch? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:15:52 And there will be more. All right. Low-wage jobs will not recover until 2024, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Until then, Americans who were the first to lose their jobs and will be the last to get them back will be depending on an uptick. Yep, we've got plenty of socks. In the index of human kindness.
Starting point is 00:16:17 All right, you guys take care. Sometimes historic events suck. But what shouldn't suck is learning about history. I do that through storytelling. History That Doesn't Suck is a chart-topping, history-telling podcast chronicling the epic story of America, decade by decade. Right now, I'm digging into the history of incredible infrastructure projects of the 1930s, including the Hoover Dam, the Empire State Building, the Golden Gate Bridge, and more. The promise is in the title, History That Doesn't Suck.
Starting point is 00:16:51 Available on the free Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts. The race to find vaccines for COVID-19 has dominated the headlines, but there's been less news about how to keep people with COVID out of the hospital. Tonight, we're going to tell you a story about one possible treatment. It's called fluvoxamine. The generic drug was developed 40 years ago as an antidepressant and has been primarily used to treat obsessive compulsive disorder. Now, a small but ingenious clinical trial and a series of coincidences have led scientists to look closely at fluvoxamine as a possible tool to keep newly diagnosed COVID-19 patients from becoming severely ill.
Starting point is 00:17:34 So how did a pill that costs 60 cents become a dark horse to treat COVID? We went to a place that knows all about long shots to find out. We're off and running at Golden Gate Fields. Golden Gate Fields is in Berkeley, California. The stands have been empty since COVID hit last year. But the races go on. There are 1,200 thoroughbreds here, trained and cared for by more than 500 people.
Starting point is 00:18:05 Last November, COVID went on a rampage in the barn area where many workers live. We had four cases that were initially reported. And because we have a community living back there, we decided to test everybody. And that's when we saw the first round of testing reveal 200 positive individuals. Wow. What was your reaction when you heard 200 positive cases right here? Shock and dismay. We took care of them. Dr. David Seftel has been the physician for employees and their families at Golden Gate Fields for 20 years. He's originally from South Africa and is Harvard educated.
Starting point is 00:18:44 Who was sick? Was it the jockeys? Was it the guys who work in the stable or their families? It was really across the entire spectrum. And what's interesting about our community is that it really is a mirror image of the community that is most affected by COVID. A predominantly Latino community, incredibly hardworking. They don't have the luxury of working from home or working on Zoom. They have to be out there every single day. But there are few early treatment options for COVID. The handful of drugs that have been approved are for high-risk patients and must be delivered intravenously, often in a hospital. Deep breath in and hold it. When I looked at this community, I said, I know the numbers. I know the stats.
Starting point is 00:19:26 There are going to be deaths and there's going to be disability unless I take action. Is that what you were thinking as the numbers kind of rolled in? This was a disaster in the making. Dr. Seftel felt his only choice to keep his patients from getting sicker was to act on a tip he got just hours before. The doctor offered them the antidepressant fluvoxamine. To understand why, you have to go back to the starting gate of our story. Eight months earlier in March, Dr. Angela Rayerson, a child psychiatrist at Washington University in St. Louis, was home sick with COVID symptoms and thinking about old medical studies
Starting point is 00:20:05 she'd read. Most people, when they're home sick with COVID, they say, look, I just want to sit on the couch and ride this out. Well, I didn't want to just sit there and be sick. I was really kind of driven to try to find answers. Dr. Rayerson remembered a study published a year earlier by these researchers at the University of Virginia on mice. They found fluvoxamine stopped sepsis. Sepsis is a runaway immune response in which inflammation gets out of control, damages organs, and can be deadly. It's believed a similar phenomenon occurs in COVID patients. And I thought, well, I wonder if we could use fluvoxamine to
Starting point is 00:20:46 treat COVID and prevent that clinical deterioration. You thought this is something that might be able to stop inflammation from going into overdrive. Right. Either stop the inflammation from going into overdrive or shut it down once it had started to prevent our own bodies from destroying ourselves, basically. So then I emailed Eric Lenz and just kind of explained the whole rationale behind it in an email. Dr. Eric Lenz is also a psychiatrist at Washington University. He specializes in finding new uses for drugs already approved by the Food and Drug Administration. Did you have some skepticism at first? Amazingly, I did not.
Starting point is 00:21:26 Angela presented a very compelling and innovative case for this drug, and it turns out that there's a lot of properties of psychiatric drugs, like safety and ease of use, and the fact that they can get into the body quickly. That makes them actually ideal for repurposing. The doctors got $20,000 from Washington University last April to launch a small randomized clinical trial on fluvoxamine. But getting patients to try an antidepressant for COVID was hard. How'd you sell
Starting point is 00:21:59 it? Yeah, and that was a real steep learning curve for us as well that we're doing with this antidepressant drug that we usually use for obsessive-compulsive disorder. Imagine you're a patient at home sick with COVID and you get a phone call like that. Patients who agreed didn't have to leave their homes. Researchers would drop off a paper bag containing fluvoxamine pills to half of the COVID patients. The other half would get a
Starting point is 00:22:26 placebo with instructions to take the pills for 15 days. Our team was acting like couriers or, if you will, delivery men, dropping it off at their house, and then we would work with them through the phone and the internet. By May, we were kind of running on fumes as far as the funding went. Fortunately, it was at that point that I read in the New York Times, of all places, about the COVID Early Treatment Fund. Hi, I'm Steve Kirsch, the CEO. Steve Kirsch is the founder of the group Lens read about. Kirsch is a Silicon Valley entrepreneur who made a fortune developing the optical computer mouse.
Starting point is 00:23:02 He put up a million dollars of his own money and then assembled a panel of scientists to decide which COVID research he should fund. Tell me about the first conversation you had with Dr. Lenz. You know, we were like, oh, we got a grant application. This is thrilling to us. And it's for $67,000. And so it's a very modest amount. So we ran it through the scientific advisory board and they said, you know, this is novel.
Starting point is 00:23:29 Steve Kirsch cut the check, which allowed Dr. Lenz to finish recruiting the 152 patients he needed for his trial. It was completed in August. So the results were really pretty incredible. Out of the 80 people who received fluvoxamine, none, zero of them deteriorated versus 8% of the people who got placebo. You heard that right. The patients on fluvoxamine did not deteriorate to the point of severe lung damage. And he goes over the results and I'm like, holy moly. You probably wanted to scream it from the rooftops at that point. Oh, absolutely.
Starting point is 00:24:07 And how did Dr. Lenz and his colleagues react? He said, well, look, we have to get this published or nobody's going to believe it. We want to submit it to JAMA, the Journal of the American Medical Association, because that is the top journal for this. Once you put it in JAMA and they publish it, then everybody will believe it. It was published in November. But while the editors offered high praise for the study's methodology, they said the results should not be used as a basis for current treatment decisions. That's because the editors wanted confirmation in a larger trial, not the speed
Starting point is 00:24:43 Steve Kirsch is used to in Silicon Valley. I imagine you think the next morning you're going to be front page news on the New York Times. And everybody starts taking it and all the doctors start, you know, people start demanding it. But that did not happen. No. You ended up on a webinar. Yes, I ended up on a webinar. This is the webinar that night about COVID.
Starting point is 00:25:03 Your doctor may not necessarily even know about this drug. It was for Harvard Business School alumni, and the host was David Seftel, the racetrack doctor. It was just hours after Dr. Seftel hosted the group that he learned about the massive outbreak at Golden Gate Fields. Friendly out the doors, got it. Had he heard about flu vox main at that point? No. So he hears it from you on the webinar. He hears about it from me on his webinar.
Starting point is 00:25:29 Were you skeptical at all about what he was saying? Absolutely. And I'm a born skeptic. Right after the webinar, I took a deep dive into the science. And then I looked at Eric Lindsay's paper, a paper that was selected out of 10,000 other papers by the JAMA for publication because its methodology was strong. This is something that I felt comfortable with taking to patients. So Dr. Seftel decided to offer a 15-day prescription for fluvoxamine to the track workers with COVID.
Starting point is 00:25:58 Did you feel like you were placing a bet on these patients at all? No, because I weighed the risk and reward. And in this particular circumstances, strong biochemistry, great initial clinical results, minimal downside. I felt I had to act. Dr. Seftel's decision to use a prescription drug off-label is an accepted medical practice with patient consent. The most common side effect of fluvoxamine is slight nausea. How many of them ended up taking the fluvoxamine and what was the outcome? 65 patients elected to take fluvoxamine, 48 declined. 12.5 percent of all those who refused fluvoxamine ended up hospitalized and one died.
Starting point is 00:26:46 In the group that did take fluvoxamine, none of them were hospitalized. Once again, none of the COVID patients taking fluvoxamine deteriorated. Since you started the fluvoxamine last week, how have you felt? Good. Could it have been a fluke? I don't believe so. You cannot influence a virus that is as wily and as wicked as COVID with a fluke. But to be trusted by the wider medical community, fluvoxamine needed a larger trial. So Steve Kirsch's fund put a half million dollars behind a new trial led by Dr. Eric Lenz.
Starting point is 00:27:26 Paper bag deliveries have been replaced by FedEx boxes that the team plans to ship to more than a thousand COVID patients around the country and Canada. I have to be a scientist about this. We've tested it in one study, but in my view, it needs to be confirmed in a larger study. Is it reasonable to think that this drug could be an answer? Fluvoxamine could certainly be something you want to put in the tool chest, because it looks as if it has the promise to reduce the likelihood of severe illness. Dr. Francis Collins is the director of the National Institutes of Health.
Starting point is 00:28:04 As part of the pandemic response, Collins oversees the federal effort to identify drugs to repurpose for COVID treatment. It's a priority because of concerns that new COVID variants could make vaccines less effective. Dr. Lenz is a great example of a physician scientist who probably never planned to work on an infectious disease and yet approaches it with appropriate skepticism about anything that isn't absolutely certain because you don't want to make that recommendation unless you know for sure.
Starting point is 00:28:37 And how closely will you be watching what he reports? The whole scientific community is watching his study and trying to see whether there's a way we can help. In our own trials, we're strongly considering adding an arm to one of those trials to test fluvoxamine to further add to the data that could be generated. There's been great caution about recommending repurposed drugs for COVID after the malaria drug hydroxychloroquine was promoted as a potential game changer by former President Trump before it was tested in a large clinical trial on COVID patients. What is the bar for a drug like fluvoxamine to be widely used? Well, it's the FDA who will have the job of figuring out whether to give an approval for this use of that drug. And it will be about benefit and risk.
Starting point is 00:29:27 And the benefit is maybe even a reduction of 20% of the chances that you're going to end up in the hospital. That's probably a good thing. That should be added to the mix. The first results from the national trial could come next month, a little more than a year after Dr. Angela Rayerson sent Dr. Eric Lenz that email about fluvoxamine. Your colleague had to read the study. Silicon Valley guy had to step in.
Starting point is 00:29:52 Then there's some people at a racetrack that are going to try it out. It seems unbelievable. If you had told me what the odds were at the start of this, I might have reconsidered doing this. It was a long shot. For sure. Twelve American men have walked on the moon. The last Apollo astronaut left his footprint there in December 1972. Now, a half century later, NASA is planning to send people back to the Moon. The new program is called Artemis, after Apollo's mythical twin sister, and the goal is that the next footprint on the Moon will be made by a woman. The astronaut who gets that assignment hasn't been chosen yet. As you're about to see, this new push to the Moon has been plagued by doubts,
Starting point is 00:30:43 cost overruns, and delays. But we found something else interesting when we visited NASA. The Artemis program isn't just named for a woman. It's largely being run by women. So there's no place on launch day that I would want to be but right here. Charlie Blackwell Thompson is NASA's first female launch director. And launch director copies. In a year or so, she'll give the gopher launch command for the first Artemis moon rocket
Starting point is 00:31:13 in historic firing room one at Kennedy Space Center, which she first visited more than 30 years ago as a college graduate interviewing for a job. It's the same room that the Apollo 11 mission was launched from, and it is the same room that we will launch the first flight of the Artemis missions. When that young woman walked in here for the first time, did you truly say to yourself, I want to do this one day? I absolutely did. My thought was, how do I get a seat in this room?
Starting point is 00:31:50 And now you have the seat in the room. I have a pretty nice seat in this room. All the Apollo moon missions were launched atop huge Saturn V rockets. At the time, the most powerful in the world. NASA's new rocket is even more muscular. Can you put it into words how powerful this new rocket is? The core stage will have hundreds of thousands of gallons of propellant, over 8 million pounds of thrust at liftoff. The most powerful rocket ever is called the Space Launch System, or SLS.
Starting point is 00:32:32 In development for a decade, it has yet to fly and has only fired its four main engines once in a test. It is hard work cheating gravity. Jody Singer, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center,
Starting point is 00:32:50 NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, NASA Space Flight Center, It is built for going to deep space. And right now, it's the only vehicle that exists that can carry the Orion and take what it does to be able to go to deep space. The Orion is the capsule that astronauts will ride on top of the SLS rocket. The first one is ready to go. The lunar lander is still in the concept stage,
Starting point is 00:33:24 but NASA doesn't really need it until the third Artemis moon mission. Artemis 1 is about testing out this integrated vehicle, SLS with Orion. Artemis 2 is about the incorporation of the crew and preparing us for Artemis 3, where then we will go to the surface of the moon. Do you hear yourself? You know how cool that sounds? It does sound pretty cool. Another cool piece of the Artemis plan is a space station called Gateway, meant to orbit the moon. NASA intends to use Elon Musk's company, SpaceX, to launch Gateway's components on one of its Falcon Heavy rockets. The Falcon Heavy is already flying. Its first launch sent Musk's Tesla Roadster towards Mars
Starting point is 00:34:13 a couple of years ago. Yes, that really happened. Jody Singer says SpaceX is an illustration of NASA partnering with commercial launch providers. We work together, and I think working together, that is how we will be able to deliver on the Artemis program. We both bring great things on this partnership. When that partnership will actually deliver women and men to the moon is uncertain. Donald Trump set 2024 as the goal. That was seen by insiders as unrealistic. President Biden hasn't set a timetable,
Starting point is 00:34:48 but his White House has given the idea of Artemis an early thumbs up. Another man and a woman to the moon, which is very exciting. What does it say about NASA that you are in these positions in what used to be a totally male-dominated sphere? Well, number one, I'd say we've come a long way. You know, Charlie and I, we know we've known each other for at least 20 years. We liked each other, but also we were, you know, sometimes the only women in the room. Not anymore.
Starting point is 00:35:20 Charlie Blackwell Thompson says that on launch day, 30% of the engineers in what's now her firing room will be women. Have you always been interested in space, when you were a little kid even? I remember the last Apollo missions, the last couple, and I can remember this sense of curiosity and awe. I could go outside and I could look up at the sky and that our astronauts were visiting the moon. The pool of 18 Artemis astronauts has already been chosen. Nine women, nine men, six of whom are test pilots, four have PhDs, three are medical doctors. It's not known yet which of them will fly to the moon,
Starting point is 00:36:09 but two are in space right now on the International Space Station. Why the moon? Why put out the expense to return to the moon? We are still learning from the samples that were returned during the Apollo program. There is so much science, so much scientific discovery to come from returning to the moon. Scientists are especially tantalized by recent evidence that there's a lot of ice near the moon's south pole. That's exactly where Artemis is meant to land. Ice means H2O, which means water to sustain life and hydrogen and oxygen to potentially turn into rocket fuel. I would point to the moon being a proven ground, a waypoint for us to learn how to live in deep space when we're only days from home versus months or years for destinations like Mars.
Starting point is 00:37:08 And it will be great when we go back. And we especially will be great if we this time can stay. Lori Garver was the number two official at NASA during much of the Obama administration. She wants America back on the moon, but believes the current approach is the wrong way to get there. I would not have recommended the government build a $27 billion rocket when the private sector is building rockets nearly as large for no cost to the taxpayer. She's talking about rockets like Elon Musk's Falcon Heavy. Garver was an early advocate of turning all the development of big new rockets over to
Starting point is 00:37:53 private companies like SpaceX. But the Congress had a different goal. Their goal was really to extend the contracts and jobs in their districts. At the time, 2010, the space shuttle was about to be grounded. Touchdown. And members of Congress feared that aerospace jobs in their districts would go away too. The SLS, the Space Launch System, is mockingly referred to as the Senate Launch System. Can you explain to us why it's got that nickname?
Starting point is 00:38:28 In this case, it was the Senate who came to us at NASA and said, No, we don't like your plan, and we are going to make you build it this way. So Boeing, prime contractor for the space shuttle and longtime NASA partner, became the prime contractor for the space shuttle and longtime NASA partner, became the prime contractor for the SLS. The industry said they would do it for $6 billion in six years. That was the rocket. It's been $20 billion in 11 years. NASA's Jody Singer acknowledges the delays and cost overruns, but insists it's the right model. The Space Launch System, I'm proud to say, has work that's over 45 states and over 1,100 vendors.
Starting point is 00:39:13 So the Space Launch System is a national vehicle. That means jobs. That means that across the nation, for the SLS alone, there's over 25,000 people that have jobs. It's ironic, honestly, that NASA, the very symbol of a democratic and capitalist society, has done a lot of its human spaceflight programs in more of a socialist way. More in a socialist way. More in a socialist way. I think many of the senators whose districts are getting these NASA jobs would balk at that description. You will plant the potatoes in March.
Starting point is 00:39:56 You will build your rocket in my district. That's what it is. The top-down approach, Garver says, has produced a NASA SLS rocket that'll cost more than $2 billion for every launch. Falcon Heavy is headed to space. While SpaceX flies its Falcon Heavy for a fraction of that. NASA's SLS can launch a heavier payload, but it's a use-it-and-lose-it rocket.
Starting point is 00:40:23 None of its parts can be reused. By contrast, SpaceX booster rockets make soft landings after launch, so they can be used over and over. Two of its first stages have already been launched eight times each. Am I missing something in saying that this is the new way and what's going on with NASA is the old way? Well, I probably wouldn't characterize it as the new way and the old way. I would probably characterize it as just different ways. I would say that our rocket was designed based on proven technology. So you wouldn't say it's old, it's proven. I would say it's proven. Still, the SpaceX rockets are proven enough... Godspeed, Bob and Doug!
Starting point is 00:41:09 ...that NASA now trusts them to carry its astronauts to the International Space Station. Welcome to the space station. Those successful missions should not be confused with an entirely new rocket called Starship that SpaceX is testing in Texas. Three test flights so far, all three ending in spectacular explosions. The latest one just last week. So should NASA pivot and start relying on SpaceX and commercial launchers for the moon and beyond? Undoubtedly. We should have before now.
Starting point is 00:41:52 Is NASA capable of making that shift? Oh, of course. I mean, NASA is capable of more than they realize. Considering all you have told me, will Congress let NASA make that shift? Probably not. For the moment, the core stage for the first Artemis mission sits in a test stand in Mississippi, the same stand used for the Apollo missions. It's awaiting a test firing after technical glitches cut the first one short. And we got it shut down.
Starting point is 00:42:30 There are six American flags on the moon, one for each Apollo landing. But the newest flag there is Chinese, left last year by a robotic lander that collected samples and brought them back to Earth. Beijing eventually plans to send astronauts. Aren't we in a space race with China? There's not a race to go to the moon. We won it. We won it six times. And I have no doubt that we will be back again with people before anyone else goes.
Starting point is 00:42:57 And Charlie Blackwell Thompson will be the woman to launch them from her seat in the firing room. We talk a lot about the moon, and I think the moon is phenomenal, and I can't wait to go back. But when we talk about those young people that may be like me when I was younger, looking up at the night sky and looking up at the moon, I want them to look up at the night sky and not be limited to the moon. Tonight, another original 60-minute story is available on the new Paramount Plus streaming service. This past week, FBI Director Christopher Wray told Congress the white supremacy movement is a top domestic threat.
Starting point is 00:43:46 60 Minutes Plus correspondent Lori Siegel talks with a former supremacist insider for a chilling look at his group's goal, race war. They wanted to create such a strain on the logistics of the country, the police, fire, EMS, that they wouldn't have any obstacles in killing the people they wanted to kill, to where they could go out and shoot minorities without having to face the law. I'm Scott Pelley. We'll be back next week with another edition of 60 Minutes.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.