60 Minutes - 3/8/2015: Who Killed the Prosecutor?, Coming Home, The Maestro

Episode Date: March 9, 2015

Lesley Stahl reports on the untimely death of Alberto Nisman; Scott Pelley reports on combat Marines adjusting to civilian life; and, a profile of the Metropolitan Opera's music director James Levine.... To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Meet Tim's new Oreo Mocha Ice Caps with Oreo in every sip. Perfect for listening to the A-side, or B-side, or Bull-side. Order yours on the Tim's app today at participating restaurants in Canada for a limited time. It's a mysterious death that has made world headlines. The victim was found with a bullet in his head. He was an Argentine prosecutor with 10 bodyguards and a long list of enemies, including the country's president and foreign minister. One of the great mysteries is whether Mr. Nisman killed himself or whether he was murdered. So what do you think? That I am part of that mystery. I don't know.
Starting point is 00:00:49 Lance Corporal Jonathan F. Stroud. Lance Corporal Gregory A. Posey. This was September 2009. We were there as golf companies stood rigid in a mud-walled memorial service. It was the first time the troops had come to grips with the terrible loss signified by seven battlefield crosses. And we wondered, what's become of them? We caught up with them on a field trip, part of their Washington reunion. What do they think of their war? Was coming home the homecoming they hoped for? When he made his comeback, Levine, now in a wheelchair,
Starting point is 00:01:37 before even lifting his baton, got a standing ovation. He would conduct Mozart's Cosi Fantuti, one of his favorites. If you could see music as well as hear it, you would see it in the face of James Levine. I'm Steve Croft. I'm Scott Pelley. I'm Anderson Cooper. I'm Steve Croft. I'm Scott Pelley. I'm Anderson Cooper. I'm Laura Logan. I'm Bill Whitaker.
Starting point is 00:02:11 I'm Leslie Stahl. Those stories, including one of the last completed by our colleague Bob Simon before he died, tonight on 60 Minutes. Wendy's most important deal of the day has a fresh lineup. Pick any two breakfast items for $4. New four-piece French toast sticks, bacon or sausage wrap, biscuit or English muffin sandwiches, small hot coffee, and more. Limited time only at participating Wendy's Taxes Extra. Why do fintechs like Float choose Visa? As a more trusted, more secure payments network,
Starting point is 00:02:42 Visa provides scale expertise and innovative payment solutions. Learn more at visa.ca slash fintech. In the late hours of a January night in Buenos Aires, a dashing, driven Argentine prosecutor was found dead in his apartment, bullet to the head. It was the day before he was to publicly present his evidence that the country's president, Christina Kirchner, had secretly conspired with Iran to cover up Iran's involvement in Argentina's worst terrorist attack 20 years ago. It immediately became an international whodunit, in great part because of the key players, a hard-charging, high-profile prosecutor and a fiery, populist president with a penchant for high drama. What everyone wants to know is, was it murder? Was the government somehow involved? Or was it suicide?
Starting point is 00:03:40 Forensic teams scoured the crime scene for clues. Only the victim's DNA was found. His name was Alberto Nisman, 51, a father of two. He was a prosecutor with 10 bodyguards and a long list of enemies. In the days before his death, he had grown worried for his and his family's safety. Just hours before he died, he asked Diego Lagra Marcino, a tech worker in his office, to loan him his gun. So as far as we know, you were the last person who saw Nisman one day before he died.
Starting point is 00:04:17 Did he say why he wanted the weapon? He told me, do you know how it feels that your daughters don't want to be with you because they're afraid that something will happen to them by being next to you? I had never seen Nisman so concerned. Didn't you say to him, why do you need a gun? You have 10 bodyguards. Yes, that's the first thing I asked him. And he answered, because I don't trust my bodyguards. Sunday morning, January 18th.
Starting point is 00:04:46 Nisman is up in his apartment, here up on the 13th floor. But things aren't quite right. He doesn't respond to repeated phone calls from his bodyguards. We know from the coroner that he died around 3 p.m. in his bathroom, his body slumped against the door. He had been struck by a bullet at point-blank range above his right ear. Did it enter your mind at all ever in being with him that he might use this weapon on himself? No. No sense that he was going to kill himself? No.
Starting point is 00:05:22 Do you think he did commit suicide? I don't know. It looked like a suicide, but there was no note and no gunpowder residue on Alberto Nisman's hands, and a forensics team hired by his ex-wife ruled it a murder. It's a mystery, with roots going back 20 years to this crime. The suicide bombing of AMIA, the Buenos Aires Jewish community center that killed 85, burying them under the rubble. It was the worst terror attack in this country's history. It was long believed that Hezbollah operatives carried it out. But who sent them? After 10 years with no answer, Alberto Nisman was named special prosecutor in 2004 to find out. He believed in it as a mission.
Starting point is 00:06:16 He always thought that through justice you can defeat terrorism. Gustavo Perednik, a close friend who wrote a book about the case, said that Nisman, after investigating for two years, charged Iran with ordering and financing the attack. He went right to the very top of Iran and accused the topmost people of approving the bombing. And thanks to him, they have to be in Iran all the time, because if they leave Iran, the Interpol can look for them.
Starting point is 00:06:52 That's because Interpol issued red alerts, the equivalent of arrest warrants, to several high-ranking Iranians, including the defense minister. Alberto Nisman would spend the rest of his life trying in vain to get them into an Argentine court. So he was stunned when two years ago his country's foreign minister signed a memorandum with Iran in which the two countries agreed to interrogate the accused officials together. The memorandum itself is a joke because it meant basically that Argentina had to give to Iran all the results of its investigation against Iran for the Iranians to check. That was absurd.
Starting point is 00:07:33 Prosecutor Nisman felt betrayed, saying this was negotiating with the terrorists responsible for the attack. He saw it as part of the government's tilt toward anti-Western regimes, shepherded by the foreign minister, Hector Timerman, who agreed to talk to us at the foreign ministry. There's been a lot said about your government shifting policy, foreign policy, away from the United States. Why do you think that an alliance with the United States is the only way a country can have a foreign policy. We have an independent foreign policy. AMY GOODMAN. Independent of the United States?
Starting point is 00:08:10 GERALD NEUMANN. Independent foreign policy. AMY GOODMAN. But you used to be very close to the United States, and that is no longer the case. GERALD NEUMANN. I don't think it is so good to be close to anybody. AMY GOODMAN. Problem is, Alberto Nisman was close to the Americans and stayed close.
Starting point is 00:08:25 According to leaked State Department cables, Washington was always pressuring him to keep the focus on Iran. Do you agree with those who say that Mr. Nisman was a puppet of the United States and the CIA? Well, puppet is a very strong word to use by a foreign minister. Under the sway of? Mr. Nisman used to go to the American embassy here in Argentina and tell in advance what he was going to do. Do you know if Mr. Nisman was about to lose his job? Was he going to be fired? No, he was not going to lose his job.
Starting point is 00:09:01 You've read these speculations. That was a speculation in the media, but there was no way that we ever discussed taking the job away from Mr. Nisman. To this day, the case of the bombing of the Jewish community center remains unadjudicated. The evidence gathering dust in a giant warehouse in downtown Buenos Aires, over a half a million yellowing documents, folders, audio cassettes. And now Argentina has a new mystery, because two months ago, Prosecutor Nisman went on television with an explosive accusation. That President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner and her foreign minister had negotiated a secret deal with Iran to improve trade in exchange for dropping those red alerts.
Starting point is 00:09:51 Perednik said Nisman saw this as colluding with the enemy. This time he said, I'm going to put them in jail. I'm going to put them in jail. And them is the president and the foreign minister. But four days after his accusation, Nisman was dead. President Kirshner, not one to hold back, immediately took to Facebook to suggest it was suicide, then abruptly backtracked and called it murder. People took to the streets in protest, calling for justice. Polls show a majority here think he was assassinated, and the president's opponents think she had a hand in it.
Starting point is 00:10:32 This country has a history of assassinations. For years, under military dictatorship, political rivals simply disappeared. But Argentinians thought they had put that behind them. I've heard people talk about Argentina being drawn back into its dark past. Assassinations. It's impossible. We're talking about things that were terrible, terrible. One of the great mysteries is whether Mr. Nisman killed himself or whether he was murdered. So what do you think? That I am part of that mystery, I don't know. He's part of the mystery because he was one of Nisman's targets.
Starting point is 00:11:19 The day after he died, the prosecutor was scheduled to appear before Congress to publicly present a 300-page report backing up his charges. He said that you in 2011 met in Syria with your Iranian counterpart. He said that you said, and this is a quote in the report, Argentina is no longer interested in solving the attack, the bombing here. It prefers to improve its trade relations with Iran. Well, that's a lie. That's a total lie. I never said that. Mr. Nisman never showed any evidence that I said that. He didn't have that on tape or anything like that? He cannot have something on tape because I didn't say it. Nisman says that you offered to lift the red alerts.
Starting point is 00:12:08 That is, it's totally logic. I mean, you have to read the law. The only one who can cancel the red notice is a judge. So I cannot lift the red alerts, okay? I am not allowed. You could not make a deal to, you could not promise to. I cannot do it. So is it possible that the prosecutor's charge against the president and foreign minister was without merit?
Starting point is 00:12:35 In an evidence room stacked two stories high with investigation documents, we met the Argentine judge who issued those original red alert arrest warrants. You were the judge who made the request of Interpol to arrest these people, those red alerts. Yes. Did this government ever ask you to ask Interpol to lift the red alerts? No, never. Never? No government, no person, nobody.
Starting point is 00:13:02 It seems Interpol never got a request to lift the arrest warrants from anyone. Two days after Nisman made his accusation, the former head of Interpol sent this letter to the foreign minister, affirming that the government was 100% committed that the red alerts remain in effect. So 180 degrees from what Nisman said.
Starting point is 00:13:24 And I read that in public. How could such a seasoned prosecutor make such a huge mistake? President Kirshner speculated that her enemies fed Nisman the erroneous information, then killed him, hoping she would get blamed. She pointed, for example, to the man who gave him the gun. So the president named you as someone suspicious in this case.
Starting point is 00:13:50 She says that you're an agent of the opposition. No. Here are some of the rumors we've heard about you. That you're a spy. I am not a spy. That you're an agent for a foreign government. Iran, Israel. No.
Starting point is 00:14:09 We haven't seen any evidence to back up the president's charges about Lago Marcino. A more credible target is this man, Jaime Stuzo, a powerful and shadowy spymaster who was Nisman's main source for years. One theory is that Stuzo concocted the accusation against the president in revenge after she fired him. Stuzo was fired December, the end of December. Right. And 14 days later, Mr. Nisman accused the president and myself. Ah, you see a connection there.
Starting point is 00:14:44 Oh, yes. The foreign minister suggests that the spymaster manipulated Nisman into coming out with a sensational indictment against the Argentine government before the details could be verified. Those who believe it was suicide think the prosecutor came to realize he had been duped and snapped. Is it possible in your mind that he thought to himself, oh my, I got this terribly wrong and now I don't want to be embarrassed and have to testify publicly? Is that in your head?
Starting point is 00:15:17 I cannot imagine what can go through the mind of a person like Nisman. And I don't want to speculate because the man is dead, he cannot defend himself, and so I will not speculate on what happened with him. There's a new building and memorial at the site of the 1994 AMIA bombing, a crime the prosecutor dedicated the last 10 years of his life to. Now that he's gone, the families of the victims fear they will never have justice. At the Jewish cemetery in Buenos Aires, Luis Cicceschi visits the grave of his daughter, Paula, often. Just steps away is a fresh grave,
Starting point is 00:16:01 that of Alberto Nisman. when the in-laws decide that, actually, they will stay for dinner. Instacart has all your groceries covered this summer. So download the app and get delivery in as fast as 60 minutes. Plus, enjoy $0 delivery fees on your first three orders. Service fees, exclusions, and terms apply. Instacart. Groceries that over-deliver. Sometimes historic events suck. But what shouldn't suck is learning about history. I do that through storytelling.
Starting point is 00:16:46 History That Doesn't Suck is a chart-topping history-telling podcast chronicling the epic story of America, decade by decade. Right now, I'm digging into the history of incredible infrastructure projects of the 1930s, including the Hoover Dam, the Empire State Building, the Golden Gate Bridge, and more. The promise is in the title, History That Doesn't Suck, available on the free Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts. Two and a half million Americans served in Iraq and Afghanistan, and we wondered what's become of them long after they cut down the yellow ribbons and the camo went into hiding in the back of the closet. What do they think of their war? Was coming home the homecoming they hoped for?
Starting point is 00:17:26 Recently we joined an annual reunion of men that we first met five years ago. It was back in 2009 that Gulf Company, 2nd Battalion of the 8th Marines, was taking the highest casualties on Afghanistan's most lethal battlefield. When we met them again last summer in Washington, we found that their searing experience had made them brothers in war and peace. We caught up with them on a field trip, part of their Washington reunion. They fell in without uniforms, weapons, or the passing of years. They're mostly civilians now, gathered in one place they could be together, the place they could say things that had been left unsaid, or deliver news of the last five years.
Starting point is 00:18:18 Golf companies Lance Corporal Burrow and Lieutenant Bourgeois were enlisted in the ranks of Arlington National Cemetery, each stone arch a gateway through time. Lance Corporal Jonathan F. Stroud. Lance Corporal Gregory A. Posey. This was September 2009. We were there as golf companies stood rigid in a mud-walled memorial service. It was the first time the troops had come to grips with the terrible loss signified by seven battlefield crosses. First Sergeant Robert Pullen called the roll of the dead.
Starting point is 00:18:57 Lance Corporal Patrick W. Schimmel. Lance Corporal Dennis J. Burrell. Lance Corporal Javier Olvera. Lance Corporal David R. Hull. The seven Marines had died fighting to clear and hold the Taliban heartland. Exhausting months negotiating around landmines and skeptical elders. Back then, their orders were to use restraint, and Corporal Jonathan Kiseno told us what he thought of that.
Starting point is 00:19:34 It sucks. I don't know another word to say it. It sucks because all you want to do is get that guy. You just want to get them for everything, for revenge, to say the least. Revenge for the death of his friend, Nick Exaros, who was killed in 2009 by a roadside bomb. Five years later, Kiseno had used his veterans benefits for college, and now he's selling retirement plans for Lincoln Financial outside Philadelphia. He moved on, but he never let go of Exaros. It's because of people like him that I want to continue to push harder in life and succeed, because it's the good ones that pass. And I can't let that be in vain. It drives me, it motivates me. Is there anything that you miss about Afghanistan and the Marine Corps?
Starting point is 00:20:27 Absolutely. The brotherhood. There's no question about that. You miss the sense of purpose, right? You had a mission. You felt accomplished with everything that you do, even at a young age. I think when you transition into the real world, you have to find out what your mission is. You know, a lot of people would think you would try to forget Afghanistan, and it seems to me you're trying to remember it. I don't want to put it behind me. I want it to be real in everything that I do because it gives me something to live for.
Starting point is 00:20:58 It gives me something to stand for. I love the camaraderie and everything that came along with it. There's nothing like it? Nothing. I haven't found anything like it. Golf company's Rory Hamill was so dedicated to the camaraderie, he went back to Afghanistan for another tour in 2011. I suppose it was to try and get back at the guys that killed my brothers. Tell me about the day you were wounded.
Starting point is 00:21:20 I came across a local national who gave us some intelligence on the ground that there was an IED in a compound next to his house. I took the minesweeper off my point man's back and I jokingly said, see you on the other side. I got about three quarters of the compound swept and then I stepped on a low metallic pressure plate. And my leg was instantly sheared off. I remember it seemed very surreal. My vision went gray. There was a lot of ringing, dust everywhere. When the dust settled, his right leg was gone, halfway up the thigh. At Walter Reed Medical Center, President Obama brought him an honor. He ordered me with a purple heart. It was amazing. It was an amazing experience. You must have been in a pretty dark place otherwise. Oh yeah. The first two weeks,
Starting point is 00:22:15 a lot of the thoughts going through my head were, why didn't I die? What am I going to do now with my life? Were there times that you wish you hadn't survived? Yeah, I was contemplating taking my own life, but sitting and thinking about it, realizing that I have children that depend on me, I knew that that was not the right course of action. Urged onto a different course by his father, Hamill pressed through counseling and physical therapy. He's found work managing logistics in a Navy program for wounded warriors. Having been through everything you've been through, would you do it again? In a heartbeat. And maybe the man I am today. Whether they like it or not, I still feel responsible, you know, for them.
Starting point is 00:23:01 They're still your Marines. They always will be. Gullf's battalion commander was Lieutenant Colonel Christian Cabaniss. responsible for them. They're still your Marines. They always will be. Gulf's battalion commander was Lieutenant Colonel Christian Cabaniss. In this summer of decision in Afghanistan in 2009, you are going to change history. Living the dream, one minute at a time. Today, he's Colonel Cabaniss, and he joined this reunion. Why do you think some of the Marines are still struggling after they've come home, after five years? I think in some ways we all do when we come back.
Starting point is 00:23:33 It's because we're trying to put that experience into perspective. I joked, I'm never more popular coming home from a deployment than right before the bus door opens. Superman's coming, Superman's coming, Superman's coming. The door opens. Oh, it's just him. And they expect you to fall back into those roles, husband, father, brother, nephew, cousin, uncle, as if nothing changed. There were definitely times when I questioned what we were doing over there. Five years ago, Dan O'Hara was a fresh second lieutenant leading his first combat platoon. What's the biggest threat to your Marines? The biggest threat would be the improvised explosive devices. He told us then that he
Starting point is 00:24:19 joined the Marines because he didn't want to regret not serving. It turned out we met on what would be his worst day. We should be good pushing up through here until we get near that IED site. It was a mission to defuse a landmine, and it went exactly according to plan. But on the way back, Lance Corporal David Hall detonated a second bomb. And the next day, O'Hara tried to give meaning to Hall's death. So just understand, we're doing the right things. We're doing good work. We're making a difference here. You know, we're here fighting for the people of Afghanistan. We're here ultimately fighting for our country.
Starting point is 00:24:54 Should we have been in Afghanistan? I don't know. Maybe the answer is yes. Maybe it's no. And so when I run into people who say, tell me about Afghanistan, what were our goals there? Should we have been there? I think I'm in the same boat where I would say, you know, to be honest with you, I don't know. After two tours and a lot of questions, O'Hara's been recruited into General Electric's program for returning vets. He's a project manager for GE Oil and Gas, and sometimes he thinks about running for office. I had done what I wanted to do in the Marine Corps. I could say I deployed twice in the defense of my nation,
Starting point is 00:25:31 so that was something I was proud of. There's certainly a part of you that says, I'm glad that that's over with. Goodbye to all that. Yeah. Goodbye to Afghanistan. I won't be seeing you again. Those images are burning your head, man. They never go away. They never go away. Afghanistan did not leave golf company's Devin Jones.
Starting point is 00:25:57 Like many others, Jones brought the war home. It was rough. I didn't do anything during the day. I moved at night. That was it. The anxiety of post-traumatic stress left him isolated and jobless. You're getting closer and closer to being on the streets. You're getting eviction notices. You're getting those, and you're just like, man, this is bad. Did you lose the apartment? Yeah, I ended up losing it. Where'd you go? For a little while, I stayed in my storage unit. You were living in a storage unit?
Starting point is 00:26:30 Yeah, yeah. Stayed in the storage unit. Why aren't you reaching out for help? I felt like a complete idiot, like a complete failure. I went from being a very proud combat veteran to another percentage of the homeless vets. It's so much easier to give up. You go from having a job, a stable job,
Starting point is 00:26:57 having everyone that cares about you around you 24-7 to being alone, broke, eating saltine crackers, living in a storage unit. Who wouldn't want to die? But what torments Jones is that he isn't alone. There is the persistent presence of his friend Dennis Burrow. After Burrow was killed by a landmine, Golf Company put his name on a combat outpost so he wouldn't be forgotten. But it turns out that isn't the problem. The dead are immortal in the mind. Were you there when Burrow died? Yes.
Starting point is 00:27:36 Yes, I was. What happened? I'm not sure if I really want to go into detail on that too much. You know, I don't want to be the person that the family hears that from if they don't already know. You know, it's not easy to think about that day. Because, um... That was a pretty rough day. Sorry. I'm sorry that it's so hard to remember that it's alright
Starting point is 00:28:31 you're still looking out for Burrow yeah you never stop looking out for your team your team's everything. I've had nightmares where I've just been sitting there just staring at them. Did you sometimes think you'd like to trade places? Every day.
Starting point is 00:29:02 Every single day. How do I deserve to be here? It's been a long time, bud. Miss you, dude. Nothing else to really say. Just look after us. Look after, you know, everybody else, man.
Starting point is 00:29:25 Just know I'm thinking about you, bud. The men do look after one another. Phone calls at 3 a.m. to be reminded that what got them through combat will get them through whatever they're fighting now. There is a bond that only a vet can know that does not loosen with time. Where do you think these Marines will be five years from now? What I really hope is, you know, five years from now, they're still coming together to see each other, to talk to each other,
Starting point is 00:29:57 and they're talking about their kids and the things that are going on in their lives so that they've been able to put that experience in perspective and use it as a foundation. Because I said that these kids are our next greatest generation, but not necessarily because of what they did on the battlefield. It's going to be because of what they did when they got home. James Levine is America's greatest living conductor in the judgment of many music lovers, including our late colleague Bob Simon, who could often be found attending Levine-led performances at the Metropolitan Opera. Before we lost him in a tragic car crash last month, Bob completed a story on the 71-year-old maestro, who has directed and defined New York's incomparable
Starting point is 00:30:46 Met for almost half a century, has guided and inspired three generations of the world's best singers, and become America's most influential maestro since Leonard Bernstein. Under his baton, the Met became the house of Levine. Four years ago, a terrible accident left him partially paralyzed. As Bob Simon reported, only believers in miracles thought Levine could return to the podium. But after a two-year absence, he did. When he made his comeback, Levine, now in a wheelchair,
Starting point is 00:31:24 before even lifting his baton, got a standing ovation. That usually happens at the end of an opera, not at the beginning. He would conduct Mozart's Cosi Fantuti, one of his favorites. If you could see music as well as hear it, you would see it in the face of James Levine. I was just grateful beyond words. It was clear that I could still do this work and that the orchestra and the company and the audience wanted me to do it. And, oh, it felt like I had a chance to get my life back. Are you aware of how sad, even desperate,
Starting point is 00:32:37 many of the musicians and singers were when you weren't around? Yes, Bob, I'm very aware of it. They called me, they wrote me letters, and the messages were always, we need you, get well, come back as quick as you can. It was a fantastic, motivating thing for me. I didn't conduct for really two seasons, and it felt like forever.
Starting point is 00:32:59 It also seemed like forever not only to The Met, but to the entire world of opera. He's been conducting here since he was 27, but has been making music since he was a toddler. He grew up in Cincinnati, the son of a former big band leader and a Broadway actress. He wasn't just your garden variety prodigy, and everyone seemed to know it. He did too. Was there ever a single moment when you weren't sure you wanted to devote your life to music?
Starting point is 00:33:29 Never. I knew it was one of my earliest awarenesses that I loved music, and it was what I was happiest doing, always. In 1976, Levine became music director of the Met, where he's conducted more than 2,500 performances. He's also conducted every major orchestra in America and Europe, and coached the greatest singers of our time. Leontine Price and Marilyn Horne.
Starting point is 00:34:14 Renee Fleming. And he participated in what was probably the most popular classical music event in history. He brought opera to the masses with the three tenors, Domingo, Carreras, Pavarotti. He is one of the greatest conductors in the history of conducting. Peter Geld is the general manager of the Metropolitan Opera. Can you describe what distinguishes Levine from other conductors? He taught the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra to listen to singers. He made them into a truly great opera orchestra.
Starting point is 00:35:08 And his ability to get the best out of the performers is another hallmark. He's a conductor for the ages in that regard. Levine's career seemed destined to accompany him into old age brilliantly and seamlessly. But then starting in 2000, his body began to fail him, a host of ailments. He canceled performances. There were times when I really couldn't work or I had to work in so much pain it was a big distraction.
Starting point is 00:35:34 Then in 2011, he took what turned out to be a catastrophic fall. I fell down a flight of steps onto the grass, and gradually over the rest of that day and the following day, the feeling went out of my legs, and I couldn't move them. He had fractured his spine, took an indefinite leave of absence. Was there a moment when you realized, I think I'll be able to conduct again? No, but there was a moment that I remember
Starting point is 00:36:03 after what seemed like an endless number of days. I kept saying to my leg, go on, move. And one day I said, go on, move, and it did. It listened. And I said, you really did that, didn't you? Can you do that again? And it did it again. That miniscule movement brought hope back to the Met and to Levine's closest buddy, Placido Domingo. They'd been making music together for decades. When he was at the point that he couldn't move his legs, did you ever doubt that he'd be able to come back? I have seen him already suffering in the last years, you know,
Starting point is 00:36:44 and always he was coming back. I just cannot imagine Jimmy was not going to be at the Met or he was not going to be conducting. Jimmy, the comeback kid. The comeback kid, yes. But how would he come back? Hello, excuse me. It took a lot of engineering. Hi. It took a lot of engineering.
Starting point is 00:37:09 Bement designed a portable podium dubbed the Maestro Lift. It works like an elevator. It goes up and down and allows him to turn. Good morning, everybody. I drove here in my chair. Which is why I'm a few minutes late. In any case, let's do act two, please. One, two, one, two. There we are. You have been number one for over 40 years. What do you do that number 10 does not do?
Starting point is 00:37:38 Oh, Bob, I have the faintest idea. Oh, yes, you do. No, I don't. My job is to keep making it better. Which gets subtler and subtler the better you get. We went with Levine to rehearsal Ziverdi's comedy, Falstaff, to find out how he makes it better. The opera is about a shameless rogue and the women who are determined to track him. Levine's credo? When you think you've finished rehearsing, rehearse again.
Starting point is 00:38:11 Lustier, a little bit unrestrained. One, two. Less Than Perfect isn't less than perfect. It's wrong. No, excuse me. It's wrong. No, excuse me. It's slightly... Levine has conducted Falstaff 55 times and says he's still trying to get it right. What'd you say? Wow.
Starting point is 00:38:42 He's been working with the great American mezzo-soprano Stephanie Blyde since she was a student of his 20 years ago. The man understands singers. He understands the psychology of singing, which is not easy. What is the psychology of singing? Well, everyone's different, you know. We're like a load of snowflakes up there. When you're up on the stage, there's an enormous amount of fear that goes along with that. You can't take a risk unless you're brave. And you can't be brave if you're
Starting point is 00:39:20 looking down in the pit and you see the top of someone's head. Good stuff. And he gives you confidence. He gives you an enormous confidence. Singers call him the best coach in opera because he always tells them how good they are before pointing out how they can and must do better. That's it. Hey, wait a minute. Wait.
Starting point is 00:39:41 That was a nice one. In other words, then the voice goes together with your smile, which is wonderful, and your cheekbones and your eyes, which are beautiful. I try to make a rehearsal room a very safe environment for a singer so that we can make improvements. When's the last time you screamed at a singer? Screamed?
Starting point is 00:39:59 Got really mad. I don't scream at people. You like it if people scream at you? No, not at all. Not at all, but people do. Well, I don't scream at people, and people don't scream at me. Instead, they just sing their hearts out. Not too much crescendo, folks. Under the voice. When the ladies leave, Levine does too to that other New York landmark, Central Park, the great outdoors.
Starting point is 00:40:56 And here, too, the tempo is allegro. That really goes at a fair clip. It can go pretty fast. I bet you can outpace me. The park's a miracle. It's in a way like a mini vacation, just to come in for a couple of hours. What do you plan for your retirement? I don't understand why people think they want to retire.
Starting point is 00:41:19 He never plans to. Maestros rarely do. But he's focused on his legacy, shaping and molding the next generation of singers. 35 years ago, he created the Metz Lindemann Young Artist Program. Even when he couldn't conduct, he kept on working with his students. Today he's coaching Mary Jane Lee from Canada. She's taking on one of the most heartbreaking arias in all opera, the doomed Desdemona in Verdi's Othello. Levine has conducted Otha more than any other opera and with the greatest divas of the century. But watch him with this young student.
Starting point is 00:42:15 He seems as moved as he's ever been. You did a lot of great work on that piece, didn't you? Yes. I'm so happy living in music, working on music, that if I'm not working on music, I'm looking forward to the next time I will be. You take it into your nervous system and into your ears and into your heart and into your intellect directly. You're guaranteed from the minute the music starts until it stops, nothing is in there except that.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.