60 Minutes - Sunday, December 4, 2016
Episode Date: December 5, 2016Speaker of the House Paul Ryan tells Scott Pelley that he and President-elect Donald Trump have patched things up. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices To learn more... about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
When does fast grocery delivery through Instacart matter most?
When your famous grainy mustard potato salad isn't so famous without the grainy mustard.
When the barbecue's lit, but there's nothing to grill.
When the in-laws decide that, actually, they will stay for dinner.
Instacart has all your groceries covered this summer.
So download the app and get delivery in as fast as 60 minutes.
Plus enjoy $0 delivery fees on your first three orders.
Service fees, exclusions, and terms apply. Instacart. Gro delivery fees on your first three orders. Service fees,
exclusions, and terms apply. Instacart, groceries that over-deliver.
He answers his cell phone. I probably shouldn't say that on TV. Don't want to get his number out.
Don't give me the number, but... He just answers the phone.
You call Donald Trump on his cell phone? All the time.
The Speaker of the House talks about his plans for getting things done on Capitol Hill with President-elect Trump,
from repealing Obamacare to retreating from a promise of mass deportations.
Tonight, Paul Ryan makes news on the priorities of the new Republican-led government.
Donald Trump's a very, he was a very unconventional candidate.
He's going to be an unconventional president.
After all the talk during the election,
you might be surprised to hear that manufacturing jobs are coming back to America.
And a good place to see that happening is the home of the Bulldogs,
a place called the Golden Triangle, led by the toughest Bulldog
of all.
The only way we win any deal is to tear off everybody else's face.
We've got to kill everybody to win the deal.
$170 turned into $1.75 billion.
Do the friggin' math.
Ever heard of a Google lawsuit?
Or how about a drive-by lawsuit?
We've found thousands of these suits being filed around the country
for violations of the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Many business owners think they're nothing more than a shakedown.
Businesses here hate you.
Well, I would say that.
How many lawsuits have you filed?
2,000, 2,500.
I mean, I don't really keep track.
Do you know how much you've made in the 2,000 cases you filed?
I wouldn't dare to say.
Millions?
Yeah, I would say that.
I'm Steve Croft.
I'm Leslie Stahl.
I'm Bill Whitaker.
I'm Anderson Cooper.
I'm Scott Pelley.
Those stories tonight on 60 Minutes.
Welcome to Play It, a new podcast network featuring radio and TV personalities
talking business, sports, tech, entertainment, and more.
Play it at play.it.
For Donald Trump's agenda to become reality,
it must pass through the office of the Speaker of the House, Paul Ryan.
Ryan didn't want Trump to be president.
The men threw ugly names at one another.
And Ryan refused to campaign for Trump.
But elections have a way of proving that old adage that politics makes strange bedfellows. We spoke with Ryan on Thursday in his Capitol office
about a partnership that may become the most scrutinized in Washington.
How often are you speaking to the president-elect? About every day.
Do you call him or does he call you? Both.
When you call over to the... He answers his cell phone. I probably shouldn't say that on TV.
He just answers the phone. You call Donald Trump on his cell phone?
All the time.
And how does he answer?
What does he say?
He says, hi, hello.
He doesn't say, this is the president-elect?
No.
He's a pretty casual guy.
He calls me Paul.
I call him Mr. President-elect because I have a reverence for the office.
But yeah, he's very casual about it.
Hey, this is Paul, and here's something I'm thinking about.
Yeah, yeah.
How long do those conversations go on?
20 to 45 minutes.
Have you told him being president is not being CEO of the United States,
that the Congress is going to have a say?
Oh, we've talked about that extensively.
We've talked about the Constitution, Article I on the Constitution, the separation of powers.
He feels very strongly, actually, that under President Obama's watch,
he's stripped a lot of power away from the Constitution, away from the legislative branch of government, and we want to
reset the balance of power so that people in the Constitution
are rightfully restored. And that's what Donald Trump believes?
He believes in the separation of power? You don't think he thinks he's going to run this
country the way he wants to? No, I think he understands there's a Constitution
and that those separate but equal branches of government give us a limited government. And he believes
that you call Donald Trump a racist. No, I didn't. I said his comment was, uh-huh. Well,
I'm not sure there's a great deal of daylight between those two definitions, but he definitely
called you ineffective and disloyal. Have you patched it up? Yeah, we have. We're fine.
We're not looking back. That's behind us. We're way beyond that. Now we're talking about
how do we fix this country's problems? You know, I'm curious, though, how did you patch it up?
Who apologized to whom? How did that conversation go? We went fine. It was pretty much the day after
the election or maybe two days after the election. And we basically decided to let bygones be bygones
and let's move forward and fix this country's problems.
And it was over and done with, and ever since then,
we've had nothing but extremely productive conversations.
Paul Ryan has led the majority in the House just over a year.
He took the job reluctantly when his predecessor gave up
on trying to pull the fractured party together.
Ryan is 46 from
Wisconsin and an expert on the budget. What is the first bill you intend to pass? Well,
the first bill we're going to be working on is our Obamacare legislation. You're going
to repeal it first? Yes. You're not pulling the rug out from under the 20 million people
who already have Obamacare? No, no. We want to make sure that we have a good transition
period so that people can get better coverage at a better price. So what are we talking
about, months, years? I can't give you an answer to that. We're still make sure that we have a good transition period so that people can get better coverage at a better price. So what are we talking about, months, years?
I can't give you an answer to that. We're still working on that.
But people have talked about three years in terms of a transition.
I don't know the answer to that right now.
What we know is we have to make good on this promise.
We have to bring relief as fast as possible to people who are struggling under Obamacare.
What do Republicans intend to put in its place?
Patient-centered health care
that gets everybody access to affordable health care coverage so that they can buy what they want
to buy. So people will still get coverage regardless of their pre-existing condition?
Yeah, we think pre-existing conditions are a very important feature of any health care system.
Children will stay on their parents' plans until the age of 26? Yeah, that's something that we
actually have always had in our plan as well. And women will pay the same as men? That didn't used to be the case. It depends on the
age of a person. So we believe that we should have support based on age. The sicker and the
older you get, the more support you ought to get. If you're a person that has low income,
you probably should have more assistance than a person with high income, for example.
Is your plan going to cover everyone in America?
We will give everyone access to affordable health care coverage.
In the first year, what else do you expect to get through the Congress?
We really want to focus on economic growth and growing the economy.
There are a lot of regulations that are really just crushing jobs.
Look at the coal miners in the Rust Belt that are getting out of work. Look at the loggers and the timber workers in the paper mills in the West Coast.
Look at the ranchers or farmers in the Midwest with the regulations.
Are you talking about rolling back environmental regulations, safety regulations?
We're talking about smarter regulations that actually help us grow jobs in this country.
We want to have good stewardship and conservation of the environment and economic growth.
We have a real economic growth problem in America.
We are limping along, wages are flat,
and jobs aren't being created near to the extent that they could and should be. So we think
regulatory relief is very, very important. And that's something we're going to work on day one.
Bryan told us that he can now support Trump's changed positions on immigration,
from deporting all 11 million illegal immigrants to focusing on only those who have committed crimes,
and from building a 2,000-mile wall to something less.
Now, we're not working on a deportation force.
Here's what we're working on with respect to immigration, securing our border, enforcing our current laws.
He talked about criminal aliens.
That's just enforcing laws for people who came here illegally, who came and committed violent crimes. We should enforce those laws. But really what we're focused on is securing our
border. Well, Trump said he was going to build a wall. Yeah, I think conditions on the ground
determine what you need in particular areas. Some areas you might need a wall, some area you might
need double fencing. My own view on this is whatever kind of device or barrier or policy
to secure the border is necessary to secure the
border, then do it. How big will the tax cut be for the middle class? Well, again, we haven't
written this bill, but if you want to get a sense of what we're looking at, it's virtually identical
with the one that Donald Trump rolled out in the campaign. It means everyone gets lower tax rates,
but we plug loopholes to pay for it. But give me a number. What is the tax cut for the
average middle class family? When I have a bill, I'll tell you the number. Let's do this again.
Well, you've thought this through. You've been thinking it through for years. What would you
like to see? So the tax rates that we talked about for individuals, we'd have a 15% bracket,
I think a 25% bracket and a 33% bracket. We have seven brackets. We consolidate down to three.
The other thing that's really important in tax reform
is making sure that we don't tax American businesses
at much higher tax rates than our foreign competitors tax theirs.
It is costing us jobs.
It's one of the reasons all these American companies are moving overseas.
What should the corporate tax rate be?
Well, our plan says 20% and Donald Trump's plan says 15%.
It's now 35%.
Do you think the rich will benefit the most from your tax reform plan?
Here's the point of our tax plan.
Grow jobs, get this economy growing, raise wages, simplify the tax system so it's easy to comply with.
You're a little shy when I ask you
about the rich receiving the greatest part of the tax cuts. Well, here's the problem when you ask
these things. Most of that income is small business income. You have to remember, eight out of ten
businesses in America, they file their businesses as individuals, as people. And so we think of that
as the rich, but it's that business in the business
park outside of Janesville, Wisconsin, that has 50 employees. And do I want to lower their tax
rates? You bet I do. Mr. Trump promised a $1 trillion infrastructure program. What are you
going to build and how are you going to pay for it? Well, I think that should be decided by the
marketplace. That should be decided by the needs in the particular states and communities as to what is built or rebuilt.
And it's going to be one of our high priorities that we're going to be addressing this year.
One of your high priorities that we heard almost nothing about during the campaign is poverty.
Actually, I've talked to him a lot about that.
We feel very strongly about making work pay, about getting people transitioned from welfare to work,
get people skills they need, help they need so they can get on the ladder of life.
Ryan told us he has no plans to change Social Security, but government health insurance,
including Medicare, is a fire, he says, burning in the budget.
If you want to take the fire that's burning, it is the fact that
the baby boom generation, no offense, there's a lot of you. I qualify. Yeah, you qualify. And
we're just not ready for the retirement of the baby boomers, and we better prepare for that.
What changes do you plan for Medicare? Here's the problem. Medicare goes bankrupt in about 10 years.
The trust fund runs out of money. So we have to make sure that we shore this program up.
And the reforms that we've been talking about
don't change the benefit for anybody who is in or near retirement.
My mom's now enjoying Medicare.
She's already retired. She earned it.
But for those of us, you know, the next generation on down,
it won't be there for us on its current path.
So we have to bring reforms to this program for the younger generation
so that it's there for us when we retire
and so that we can keep cash flowing the current generation's commitments.
And the more we kick the can down the road, the more we delay, the worse it gets.
But you are going to kick the can down the road for the next year or two.
This is not your top priority.
I haven't even discussed this with Donald Trump yet.
But it is an issue that we have to tackle. From his balcony, the speaker is watching the rise of Donald Trump's
inauguration platform. But for Ryan, the best view in Washington isn't a pretty sight. You know,
one thing I noticed during our interview inside was that every time you talked about the evils
of Washington, you glanced out the window.
I do, because that's where all the bureaucracies are.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's right.
And you think of this town as part of the problem, not part of the solution.
Absolutely, I do.
If you look down, I can see HHS, education, EPA.
The two most prominent things on the skyline from this vantage point are the Washington Monument and the new Trump Hotel.
That's right. I knew you were going to say that.
The new Trump Hotel.
Yeah, he actually noted that when I took the appearance.
I bet he did. He probably told you what a great place it was.
He said something like that.
Is that a reminder of who's boss?
The Washington Monument's the tallest one.
And by the way, the dome, it's a little higher.
Beneath the dome, Ryan will have a front row seat to Trump's swearing in.
Did you believe he could be nominated? Really?
Yeah, no, I didn't see this one coming. He knows that.
I don't think most people in the country saw. If you would have put
last year into a movie script and taken it to Hollywood two years ago,
they would have laughed you out of the room because it would have been believable.
Did you see election night coming?
No, not really. I think...
You expected Hillary Clinton to win.
I thought the odds were clearly in her favor. So I was a little surprised, pleasantly so.
Do you trust him?
Yeah.
Here's something many people wonder. Does he say the same bizarre things to you in private that he says in public?
And it's an important distinction.
I think there is a bit of a difference between the private person and the public person.
And the private person is a conversation like this.
And it's all about how to get things done.
So every conversation I have almost always revolves around, you know, personnel and policy focused on producing results. Trump tweeted in
the last week or so that he had actually won the popular vote if you deduct the millions who voted
illegally. Do you believe that? I don't know. I'm not really focused on these things. Wait a minute.
Wait a minute. You have an opinion on whether millions of Americans vote illegally? I don't know. I'm not really focused on these things. Wait a minute. Wait a minute.
You have an opinion on whether millions of Americans vote.
I have no way of backing that up.
I have no knowledge of such things.
You don't believe that.
It doesn't matter to me.
He won the election.
But how, we asked, does he negotiate with a man whose word or tweets cannot always be believed?
Look, like I said, he's going to...
The way I see the tweets you're talking about,
he's basically giving voice to a lot of people
who have felt that they were voiceless.
He's communicating with people in this country
who felt like they've not been listened to.
He's going to be an unconventional president.
I really think we have a great opportunity in front of us to fix problems,
produce results, and improve people's lives.
That's why we're here in the first place.
And so that's what's going to matter at the end of the day.
Did we improve people's lives?
Did we solve the problems that the American people need solved?
Are we addressing the concerns of people who are tired of being tired?
And who cares what he tweeted, you know, on some Thursday night,
if we fix this country's big problems? That's just the way I look at this.
Welcome to Play It, a new podcast network featuring radio and TV personalities talking
business, sports, tech, entertainment, and more. Play it at play.it. This past week, Donald Trump cut his first deal as president-elect. He leaned on Carrier,
the heating and air conditioning company, to keep 1,000 jobs in Indiana from going to Mexico.
The company got a generous tax break in return. In the last few decades, America has lost millions
of factory jobs offshore.
But you might be surprised to learn U.S. manufacturing is showing signs of coming back due to cheap energy, proximity to customers, and a rising cost of labor in China.
Nearly a million manufacturing jobs have been created since the Great Recession.
About 350,000 are unfilled because factories can't find properly trained American workers.
The new plants demand more brain power than brawn.
It's called advanced manufacturing,
and if you want to see what it looks like,
you need to go to a place off the beaten track,
the Golden Triangle.
That's a bit of a misnomer
because it's one of the poorest regions in the
poorest state, Mississippi. If you have heard of the Golden Triangle, it might be because of this.
Mississippi State football. Around here, everybody loves the Bulldogs.
And Bulldog is an apt description of the man who runs economic development for the area, Joe Max Higgins.
He considers job creation a full-contact sport.
The only way we win any deal is to tear off everybody else's face.
We've got to kill everybody to win the deal.
Ferocity is a job requirement.
During the recession, unemployment in some parts of the triangle got as high as 20 percent.
We're going to come up with a program. At six percent, unemployment is now just above the
national average, and a lot of people here credit Joe Max Higgins. He has attracted six billion dollars of
advanced industry including this mill run by Steel Dynamics. It's one of the
most high-tech steel mills in the country. He got this helicopter factory
up and running. Truck maker Packar used to build engines only in Europe. It
opened its first US plant in Triangle. Companies were moving
around this offshoring. They were going to countries where everything was cheaper. For some
companies, offshore wasn't as great as they thought it was or as it was portrayed to be.
Many of the companies said, hey, if it's going to be consumed in the U.S., we can produce it in the
U.S. cheaper and more efficiently than we can elsewhere and bring it in.
They save money by being here in Mississippi.
Higgins has brought in 6,000 jobs to the Tri-County area since 2003.
That might not sound like a lot to people in big cities,
but to the people here in the small towns of the Golden Triangle,
it amounts to about half the manufacturing jobs
lost during the last 25 years. Through the 1990s, factories here produced textiles, toys, and tubing.
One by one, they shut down, and thousands of low-skilled jobs vanished. So where'd all those
jobs go? Well, a lot of those people just left. They were so devastated by Artex closings, flexible flyers closing,
blazon tube closing.
How about that?
I mean, just bam, bam, bam.
The hits just keep on coming.
Joe Max Higgins was hired away from his economic development job in Arkansas
to stop the hemorrhaging here in the Triangle.
He makes $250,000 a year,
paid by a partnership of the three counties and local
businesses. People here will tell you he earns every penny. He's like a very demanding head coach.
There's no taking plays off, never, okay? I tell our staff, if you leave our office
and you didn't do something to make our place a better place today, then you need to
find another job. You sound like a coach. Well, that's probably what I should be. Right away,
he coached his small staff to the Triangle's biggest win in 50 years. They beat out Louisiana,
Missouri, and Arkansas, convincing the steel mill that building here was its smartest and cheapest option.
Since 2007, 24 hours a day, scrap metal is dumped into giant buckets,
lifted into an electric furnace, and melted down in a fiery display.
In the old days, a mill like this would have needed 4,000 workers.
Here, it takes only 650 to churn out more than 3 million tons of steel a year. Electrician Jared Glover took us as close to the blazing
furnace as you can get. This is all automated. All the workers were just a small force.
This is what advanced manufacturing looks like. A small, highly trained workforce keeps the automation humming.
Jared Glover used to work at a lumber mill, living paycheck to paycheck.
Now he earns more than $100,000 a year, about three times his old salary.
What has that meant to you and your family?
I had two kids coming here, and now I've got four.
We've got a bigger house.
We got a little more land.
You know, they got a good school they go to, and everybody's happy.
How you doing?
I'm well. How are you?
Joe Max Higgins is the very definition of down home.
But don't be fooled.
It's a good bet he's got more hard-edged business savvy than many Harvard MBAs.
$170 turned into $1.75 billion. Do the friggin' math. he's got more hard-edged business savvy than many Harvard MBAs.
$170 turned into $1.75 billion. Do the friggin' math.
He outwits the competition with a bag full of tricks. He can twist your arm or kill you with kindness. He can wear you down. He lobbies relentlessly and so far has rounded up a half
billion dollars in generous tax breaks and cash incentives from state and local politicians.
Here, there's $4 million in here. Let me tell you how this is structured.
Joe Max Higgins has vision, and we don't mean 2020.
He can see what others don't. He took us up to show us.
Joe, when I look out here, I see beautiful, green, agricultural land. What do you see?
Well, when I look at the land, I see it as product for us to develop.
He bet the farm that in this state with weak labor unions,
he could attract industry like a magnet
if he turned that land down there into massive industrial-ready sites.
If you build it, they will come.
Yeah, we're installing the water, we're installing the water, we're installing the sewer,
we're installing the roads, and we're getting everything ready so when that company comes to
locate, they're eliminating all risk. I mean, that lot's there ready to stick a shovel in and build.
Higgins had to convince county supervisors to spend almost 12 million dollars on that first
site where Steel Dynamics now sits. He has since built up three other so-called mega-sites
and envisions more. It wasn't an easy sell at first. He told us people in the Golden
Triangle were paralyzed by the decline and poverty. He saw an area rich in assets, an
airport, railroads, waterways that ran north to the Great Lakes and south to the Gulf Coast,
and a quality engineering program at Mississippi State.
I said, these guys should be winning.
You know, something's not right.
They didn't see these advantages.
Correct.
They didn't realize that they were big and strong and fast.
Nobody had ever told them they were big and strong and fast.
They just thought they were, you know, slow and stupid, I guess.
He would say, you just have a losing attitude.
You expect to be a loser.
You don't expect to be a winner.
Allegra Brigham, the former CEO of the local power company,
and John Davis, a bank executive,
served on the search committee that recruited Higgins.
They thought his brash style would shake up the status quo.
Before Joe came in, what would have been considered a success?
The mayor at that time said,
if you will just get us a new movie theater,
we'll consider your job a success.
A movie theater, which was hardly any jobs in there,
and they're all high schoolers.
So when did he start to turn things around?
Immediately.
He pressed the county to fork over $400,000 for water and sewer to get the helicopter plant off the ground.
Today, 200 workers handcraft about 50 helicopters a year, mostly for the Army and law enforcement.
The average pay on the factory floor? $50,000 a year, plus full benefits.
They made the helicopter we flew in.
What sort of impact did that have on the community?
I think the helicopter plant kind of transformed this region, and here's why.
It was literally making something that flew.
That was the project that gave us some reason to believe.
We can do this.
Just when it seemed things were taking off, the triangle was blindsided.
Its biggest industrial employer, Sarah Lee's century-old pork processing plant, shut down.
It once employed 2,500 people. This is the factory
today. Single mother Nina Head worked on the slaughter floor for 14 years until the day it
closed. She had six young children at home. That was the heartbeat of the Golden Triangle.
The heartbeat? Yes. And when those jobs went away? He had a lot of unemployment.
He had a lot of uncertainty.
It was Joe Max Higgins' biggest challenge.
He became obsessed with winning the next deal.
He found out PACCAR was considering building its engine plant in Jonesboro, Arkansas,
near where he grew up.
He got on his motorcycle and rode home to scope it out.
When he got back, he convinced county supervisors to build this substation
to undercut Arkansas with cheaper power.
He won the deal.
Today, it's a $500 million facility filled with robots and about 500 humans.
When PACCAR began hiring, 3,000 people applied for the first 50 jobs.
Is the workforce here prepared for these new jobs coming in?
Nobody in the Golden Triangle made engines.
Nobody made any of this stuff.
So what you're really looking for is, do our citizens have the acumen for work?
Do they have the work ethic?
Are they skilled enough to be trained to do jobs?
And the answer is yes, yes, and yes.
Joe Max Higgins enlisted the community college to provide customized training for PACCAR
so when the plant was ready, the workforce was ready.
Nina Head now works there doing quality control.
She makes $10,000 a year more than on the kill floor at Sarah Lee.
When you first got here, did you have the skills required for this job?
I'd never worked with robots, so I had to be trained to do that.
But I had the skills because I went to school to learn how to get the job.
The school now gears its training for each manufacturer coming in.
Higgins told us it's the critical part of his business plan.
The promise of a trained workforce caught the eye of his biggest catch yet, Yokohama Tire.
The Japanese company plans to employ 2,000 workers
not far from the old Sara Lee plant. It considered every county in the continental U.S., so Higgins
pulled out all the stops. He tracked the tail number of the private plane shuttling Yokohama
executives from site to site to find out who his competitors were. When the executives came
to the triangle, Higgins had researched their shoe sizes and had galoshes ready for them to
tour the muddy site. This is not just about making executives feel comfortable. No. This is hard-nosed
financial negotiation. Yeah, financial negotiations. I call it watching game film.
You know, if we were a football coach, we're watching game film. What's the competition doing?
What do we need to do to be successful? What are their power rates? What are their demands? Can we
meet this? Can we meet their time schedule? How do we do what we do? What Joe Max Higgins has done
is burnish the Golden Triangle. Local tax revenue is going up. This construction site is an expansion of
the steel mill. People now expect the coach to win. Higgins has his eye on 10 more advanced
industry projects and 4,000 more jobs. So the people who say that the glory days of American
manufacturing are over. You say?
I think that's not right.
These plants, they pay well.
Most of the working conditions are very good.
And those are the jobs that are in demand.
If we can create those types of industries,
those types of jobs,
I think the sky's still the limit for the United States.
Sky's the limit?
I think it can be, yes. Welcome to Play It, a new podcast network featuring radio and TV personalities
talking business, sports, tech, entertainment, and more.
Play it at play.it.
The Americans with Disabilities Act has helped improve the lives of tens of millions of people.
It's lessened discrimination against them and made everyday life more accessible.
Because of the law, every business that serves the public, all 7 million of them in America,
has to make sure disabled customers have equal access. And if businesses don't comply,
they can be sued without warning. You might think you have to be a customer of a business to file
a lawsuit against it, but in some states you don't. You
can simply drive by a store or restaurant, and if you see a sign in the wrong spot or a ramp that's
off by a few inches, you can sue. They're called drive-by lawsuits, and some lawyers are filing
hundreds of them against businesses that often have no idea they've done anything wrong.
At first glance, this convenience store in Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
may appear to be in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act.
There's a parking space for the disabled and an access ramp to the store.
But the Americans with Disabilities Act has thousands of very technical regulations,
and this store is in violation.
What we see here are really sort of the typical red flags that attract lawsuits.
So, I mean, there is a parking space.
There is a space. It's not the right dimensions. It needs to be a van space.
That means this has to be eight feet. This has to be five feet.
Attorney Nolan Klein says that disabled parking sign is also in the wrong spot,
and it doesn't say the
words van accessible. That access ramp isn't right either. What's wrong with it? Under the law, this
is not an access ramp, so this has to be on an accessible route, which is sort of the area that
they tried to create here, but this is supposed to be five feet long. Mike Zayed, who's owned the
store for 18 years, says no disabled customer had ever complained
about the ramp, the sign, or the parking space. But that didn't stop him from having to hire
attorney Nolan Klein when he got sued. The person who sued you, you don't believe they were actually
a customer in the store? No. You think they just drove by or stopped outside? That's what I believe
the lawyer, he just driving around. That's why it's called a drive-by lawsuit,
when a lawyer or disabled person notices violations outside a business and files suit.
Mike Zayed doesn't think the person who sued him was a real customer
because the man claimed he encountered barriers inside the store that didn't exist.
To me, I feel it's not fair because to me, I feel like that's stealing.
We work hard for our money and these people just driving around in their car, that didn't exist. To me, I feel it's not fair because to me, I feel like that's a stealing.
We work hard for our money and these people just driving around in their car.
There you go. This violation here. Do you know other store owners? I have two guys I know in Broward. They get sued twice. Same lawyer. Same lawyer, same guy. If you think drive-by lawsuits
hatch from the comfort of a car or a novel way to enforce a law, there's another kind of lawsuit that requires less work.
Lawyers call them Google lawsuits.
What's a Google lawsuit?
A Google lawsuit is where the suspicion, at least,
is that the property was spotted on Google, Google Earth, Google Maps, whatever the case may be.
And you could see certain things from Google.
You could see if there's a pool lift or not.
A pool lift is a seat that can help disabled people get in and out of the water.
Since 2012, all hotels and motels in America are required to be accessible to the disabled,
which in most cases means having a lift permanently attached to the side of their pool.
This is what a pool lift looks like from Google Earth. In the comfort of your own home,
with a few clicks of a mouse, you can see if a pool near you has one. And if they don't appear to have a pool lift, like many of these hotel pools we looked up, you can file a lawsuit just
like that. Perry Pustom runs the Adobe Hacienda Motel in Hollywood, Florida. He has a pool lift
now, but says he didn't know he
was required to install one until he got sued in what he suspects was a Google lawsuit.
Did a disabled person actually come here and want to use the pool?
At no point in time we ever had a customer on the property that requested it, or that was even in a
room that requested it. It turns out the same man who sued him sued dozens of other motel owners as well,
all for pool lift violations. It was about 60-something lawsuits and 50-something days.
60 lawsuits in 50 days? 60 plus, yes. And less than 57 days. All from the same attorney? Same
attorney using the same client. At last count, that attorney has sued nearly 600 businesses in
just the last two years,
many for not having pool lifts.
Perry Pustum ended up paying $3,000 to buy a lift that, so far, no one has ever used.
He also spent thousands of dollars in attorney's fees.
He told us he believes these lawsuits are sometimes simply a money-making venture for lawyers because, under federal law, business owners have to pay both sets
of attorney's fees. And if you don't settle, it can end up costing you hundreds of thousands of
dollars in court. It's a game for these attorneys. Basically, that's what it is. Every private
business in America that's open to the public, millions of shops, restaurants, movie theaters,
grocery stores, laundromats, nail salons, and more have to be compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act.
But business owners we spoke to say it's almost impossible to be totally compliant with the law
because the requirements are very specific, and there are thousands of them.
You can find them in this 275-page manual that details everything from the exact height of a mirror in a bathroom
to the maximum thickness of carpeting to the angle at which water can come out of a drinking fountain.
Every doorway, every door handle, every surface you walk on, every light switch, outlet, counter,
you name it, are all covered by the Americans with Disabilities Act, which was first passed in 1990.
In theory,
businesses only need to comply if it's readily achievable to do so. But in reality, if you're not meeting every single requirement, you can be sued without warning. Essentially, you're saying
that after 25 years, there's really no excuse for any business not to be compliant. Well,
people say that they need a grace period.
I would say 25 years is a grace period enough.
John Wodatch is the retired chief of the Department of Justice's Disability Rights Section and was part of the team that wrote the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Is the law, as it's written, too specific that a mirror has to be 40 inches off the ground
as opposed to 39 or 41?
My first answer is no, it's not.
I think specificity is needed because inches matter.
If you have a lip on a curb ramp,
a wheelchair user is likely to tumble into the street
and injure him or herself.
Wodatch points out the number of disability access lawsuits
is small compared to the tens of millions of Americans who out the number of disability access lawsuits is small compared
to the tens of millions of Americans who have some form of disability. Are some people taking
advantage of the law? I think some people are. There are some people who are engaging in what I
think people have called shakedowns or frivolous lawsuits where they are not really looking at
significant change for people with disabilities.
They're looking to use the law to make some money.
When the Americans with Disabilities Act was being written,
the Department of Justice was concerned about people taking advantage of this part of the law.
They intentionally did not include monetary damages for plaintiffs in federal lawsuits.
The problem is now many states do provide for damages,
and John Wodatch says that has led to abuse, most notably in California, where, with limited
exceptions, business owners have to pay not only lawyers' fees and remodeling costs, but also a
minimum of $4,000 in damages each time a disabled customer visits a business with a violation.
That can add up to hundreds of thousands of dollars in some cases.
Attorney Tom Frankovich is one of the top filers of disability access lawsuits in California.
Businesses here hate you.
Well, I would say that.
How many lawsuits have you filed?
2,000, 2,500. I mean, I don't really keep track.
Do you know how much you've made in the 2,000 cases you filed? Oh, I wouldn't dare to say.
Millions? Yeah, I would say that. A couple million? Could be. Is it fair to say you're scaring people to comply with the law? I hope.
You hope?
I hope.
So when people call you an extortionist, when people call you a shakedown artist, you say what?
I'm acting as a private attorney general, and I'm enforcing a law that precludes discrimination by you against people with disabilities.
When you're filing hundreds of lawsuits for one client, is that fair?
You know, it's more than fair, Anderson, because what people don't realize is that I represent activists.
What you find is that it takes courage to be an activist.
But not everyone is an activist.
Some attorneys are being accused of recruiting disabled clients to file these lawsuits.
Daniel Delgado owns a medical equipment repair shop in Madeira, California.
He's in a wheelchair due to childhood polio and has a learning disability.
He didn't know much about the Americans with Disabilities Act until he says he was approached by attorneys Randy and Tanya Moore. What did they say to you?
He goes, how would you like to make $100,000, $200,000 a year? And he goes, all you got to do
is ADA. I said, what the heck is ADA? He says he was told he would make $1,000 per lawsuit and
would help improve access for the disabled.
They were saying to you, not only were you going to make this money, but it was actually going to improve life for disabled people.
Exactly.
And that's important to you?
That was more important to me than anything.
Daniel Delgado told us Randy and Tanya Moore sent him to businesses he would not have otherwise visited with instructions to buy something and get a receipt.
He signed off as a plaintiff on dozens of cases
and says he was asked to recruit some of his disabled friends,
including John Morales, to file lawsuits as well.
What kind of businesses did you visit, John?
A variety. I went to grocery stores.
I went to restaurants.
I went to a couple of just, like, different stores. I went to restaurants. I went to a couple of just like different stores.
And she would tell me, look for if there's accessible seating, if there's a table for
the handicapped, or if there's a restroom that you can go into. She told me what to look for,
so I started doing that. John Morales says the law firm assured them businesses would get a warning before being sued.
Is that what happened?
Never happened, as far as I know.
Do you think that's fair?
No, I don't.
Why?
And I wasn't happy with it.
Why don't I think it's fair?
I just don't think it's fair.
I think that the business owner
should have the opportunity to fix that.
You know, everybody should have a second chance, you know?
Both men say they were paid, but nothing close to what they were entitled to under the law.
The Moores say that John Morales and Daniel Delgado both signed fee agreements that gave
them unlimited power of attorney to initiate lawsuits and negotiate settlements. Delgado
and Morales say they only saw the last two pages of the contracts and didn't know the details of the agreements they signed.
When lawsuits were settled, did you know how much money the attorneys were making?
No, never did.
We wanted to talk to Randy and Tanya more, but they refused our request for an on-camera interview.
They deny asking Daniel Delgado to recruit disabled clients
and say they never told him or John Morales
that businesses would get advance warning before being sued.
The Moors have filed more than 1,000 lawsuits
related to the Americans with Disabilities Act
and have earned, by our estimate, at least $3 million doing so.
They are now being sued by Daniel Delgado and John Morales for fraud. Both men say while
the lawsuits did improve access for the disabled, they've also made some business owners wary of
dealing with disabled customers. You think, John, this is having a negative effect on businesses'
perception of disabled people? Yes. And so instead of us doing a good thing, I felt like we,
because of the advantage
they took on us coming against all these businesses, we did more harm than good.
In places like California and Florida, there's little doubt that disability lawsuits have led
to improved access. Most states in the District of Columbia currently award cash damages for
plaintiffs who file such lawsuits.
And with so many businesses around the country still not in compliance,
it may not be long before you start hearing about these kind of lawsuits in a town or city near you.
Now an update on a story we called In God's Name. In October, we interviewed a young Somali-American
who became an ISIS recruiter in Minneapolis, sending young American Muslims to Syria.
Abdirazak Warsami cooperated with prosecutors after his arrest, and as he awaited sentencing,
he explained to us how he became radicalized. Now, a federal court has sentenced Warsami and
eight other members of the conspiracy to terms ranging from time served to 35 years. Judge Michael
Davis told Warsami, I'm not convinced you're still not a jihadist, as he gave him two and a half years.
I'm Scott Pelley. We'll be back next week with another edition of 60 Minutes.