99% Invisible - Mini-Stories: Volume 19
Episode Date: December 17, 2024Cheeky highway signs, Jane Fonda’s surprising side hustle, a dynamite twist on legacy, and the Greeks’ ideal foot obsession—expect the unexpected.Mini-Stories: Volume 19 Subscribe to SiriusXM Po...dcasts+ on Apple Podcasts to listen to ad-free new episodes and get exclusive access to bonus content.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This is 99% Invisible.
I'm Roman Mars.
Everything outside might be frightful, but a new batch of mini-stories are here to make
the next 30 minutes or so absolutely delightful.
So grab something warm, gather the kids around the old wireless transceiver, and enjoy stories
about funny and surprisingly controversial highway signs, Jane Fonda saving you money
on rent. The most
famous act of contrition of all time, or possibly the greatest PR comeback of all time, depending
on who you're asking. And we learned together that the most accomplished artists of the classical
world have all agreed that I, your host, have the most beautiful feet that a person can have. Let's go.
person can have. Let's go.
So I'm joined by a producer, Chris Berube. Hey, Chris.
Roman, it is the most wonderful time of the year. Uh, great to be here.
It's a delight to have you. So what is the story you have for us today?
So Roman, I know I'm always comparing America to Canada as resident Canadian guy on the show.
Yes, I'm well aware. Yeah.
Look, my New Year's resolution, I'm going to tone down the Canada stuff for next year on the show. Yes, I'm well aware. Look, my New Year's resolution,
I'm gonna tone down the Canada stuff
for next year on the show.
I don't think you have to,
but you do what feels right to you.
Okay, okay.
But I feel like I'm always making these comparisons
that are like, this is better in Canada,
this is better in Canada.
One thing I do prefer in America
is the electronic highway safety sign.
Like a light board and it has text on it.
And it's a thing that will say like left lane closed ahead,
something like that, right?
Got it, got it, got it.
Okay, so why do you like the ones in the US better?
In Canada, the signs are always bland, right?
They will say something like, don't drive drunk.
And then it will also say that same thing in French, right?
But to express the same message in the US,
I have found there are often jokes.
So let me give you an example.
Pennsylvania recently, they had a highway sign around the 4th of July that read, don't
drive star-spangled hammered.
Okay, here I can give you some other ones.
These are all over the country.
So in Mississippi, they ran a sign this year that said, four eyes in Mississippi, two eyes
on the road.
That's pretty good.
In Massachusetts, it's use ya blinka.
I like this one in New Jersey, they have one that said,
slow down, this ain't Thunder Road.
So a joke for the Springsteen dads.
And this phenomenon, it's actually across the country.
So Roman, have you actually seen any of these?
I don't think, these are very prominent in California,
but I'm enjoying these are very prominent in California,
but I'm enjoying these quite a bit.
Yeah, they're fun.
So I was curious about these and it turns out
it's a very involved process to put these up.
I would imagine so.
So tell me more.
I actually found this out because I talked to somebody
who writes these signs.
My name is Matt Burding.
I'm the press secretary
at the Ohio Department of Transportation.
What ODOT does is make sure that the snow is cleared in the wintertime, make sure that
the roads are passable in the summertime.
We also have a big role to play in safety projects across the state.
Oh, wow.
He has the modulation of an AM radio broadcaster.
He's a good voice.
Yeah, actually, he was a radio broadcaster for many years before he was at the Ohio Department
of Transportation.
So that's why. That makes sense.
Wow.
So Matt works at ODOT, Ohio Department of Transportation, and they have about 200 of
these electronic highway signs.
And Matt says their primary goal, it's to convey emergency information or information
like left lane closed ahead, right?
But most of the time they don't have messages like this they need to share so they have all of this free space on the signs. And Matt says a couple years ago
ODOT started playing around with the funny signs and they kept doing it because according to Matt they just make a much bigger impact.
Think about the Super Bowl and you watch the ads during the Super Bowl.
Which ads are you most likely talking about Monday morning?
You're talking about the ones that made you laugh or the ones that made you have an emotional
reaction.
I mean, that certainly makes sense to me.
So where do these specific jokes come from?
Like who writes the jokes?
So Robin in Ohio where Matt works, they actually have a writer's room coming up with these
jokes.
Of course. That's great. So four times a year, they have a writer's room coming up with these jokes. Of course, that's great.
So four times a year they have a meeting, everybody comes to this meeting with like
a list of ideas, they debate them and then they set a lot of couple that are going to
end up on the signs.
I mean, sometimes I'll bring, you know, a couple dozen ideas and 30% of them don't fly.
And sometimes you bring, you know, just a handful of them and they all go.
So it just varies.
Yeah, that sounds like every pitch room I've ever been in.
I mean, 30% is a pretty good failure rate, honestly.
I was going to say, yeah, if our pitch meetings went that well, I think we'd be having a
really good pitch meeting.
But according to Matt, they're coming up with these jokes and there's a couple of parameters
they have to work with.
So obviously, first thing, it has to fit on the sign, right? But according to Matt, they're coming up with these jokes and there's a couple of parameters they have to work with so
Obviously first thing it has to fit on the sign, right? Right in Ohio Most of the signs are about 17 characters across three lines. So that's not nothing but that's not an unlimited amount of space
So first thing it has to fit on the sign. Mm-hmm. It also obviously shouldn't be offensive shouldn't hurt anybody's feelings things like that
But above all it has to make everybody in the room laugh.
Yeah, which is probably the hardest criterion of all,
because humor is subjective, you know?
Of course, yeah.
And Matt says part of how they correct for that
is they always try to make sure they have people
from different generations at each meeting.
So he says they always make sure there's like
a Gen Z staff person in there, there's a Gen Xer, you know,
and if everybody's laughing, then it's probably
going to work with the general public.
There has to be someone there to tell you what cap means.
Exactly.
That's super smart.
So what kind of jokes work for that whole room?
Matt told me there's a couple of subjects that always tend to work pretty well.
So the first one is holidays.
So a couple of years ago, ODOT had this sign for the holiday season.
It was visiting
in-laws, slow down, get there late.
Solid. One of them, for example, around Thanksgiving that we run every year is Turkey Says Buckle
Buckle. It's goofy. It's one of those things that I can certainly hear a dad saying as
he's driving with his family to grandma's house for Thanksgiving dinner. And the kids are all probably rolling their eyes going,
great dad, awful joke.
Yeah, it's on the sign.
You guys are all buckled up, right?
Second inspiration is local references.
So you'll make a joke about a football game coming up.
Be like, you know, don't be like Michigan,
drive defensively.
I don't know, I'm just making up an example.
I don't know if Michigan's football team is bad at defense,
but you'll make some
joke about a geography pun, right?
A lot of states do this.
And Matt says the ODOT team actually will steal signs from other states and then just
update them with their own local references.
I'm going to be honest with you.
Look, we all talk to each other.
So, you know, what's a good idea in Colorado is probably a good idea in
Ohio too. I don't remember which state it was. I want to say maybe it was Utah that
did camp in the mountains, not the left lane. We don't really have mountains in Ohio, but
we did camp in Ohio State parks, not the left lane. I think Missouri does camp in the Ozarks,
not the left lane.
Matt says this is like part of the process is that states loves to steal from each other
and like they'll meet up at a conference
and they'll trade these jokes and be like,
oh, that works, I could do this for mine.
So you got geography, you got holidays.
The signs that get the most attention though,
these are the ones in Ohio and across America
that everybody seems to love.
They are inspired by pop culture.
So these are the signs that go viral.
These are the signs people are posting on social media.
Roman, could I share a couple of the pop culture jokes?
I would be disappointed if you did not.
Okay, so here we go.
Arizona, they ran this one around Christmas
a couple of years ago.
Yippee-ki-yay, sober drivers.
Oh my God, okay.
So that's of course a diehard reference.
Yeah, of course, the ultimate Christmas movie, yeah.
More recently, Mississippi ran one that said,
texting and driving, say, hi, it's me.
I'm the problem, it's me.
I mean, it's a simple one, but you know,
Taylor Swift was really big that summer,
that makes sense. Yeah.
And pop culture jokes are great because, you know,
they're more relevant than your kind of dad jokey,
turkey gobble gobble jokes,
but it's kind of high risk too, right?
Because not everybody is going to get the joke
necessarily.
Yeah, no, that makes sense to me.
We don't all consume the same pop culture,
especially today. Yeah.
Right. And that can be really alienating, right?
So Matt actually has a perfect example of this,
where they tried a pop culture one and it just went wrong.
Being in Ohio, if you know the movie, A Christmas Story,
very popular in Ohio because it was filmed in the Cleveland area.
So one year we put on the message boards, life is fragile, slow down.
And we spelled out phonetically fragile because if you're familiar with The Christmas Story,
you know the scene where the dad opens up the, you know, gets the box of the big prize that he wins and, you know, Fragile must be Italian.
There are people who have not seen a Christmas story,
believe it or not, who read that and were like,
what in the world is ODOT trying to say here?
You're driving on the highway at 70 miles an hour.
We can't explain it to you.
You just got to get it.
And if you don't get it,
then that's probably not a good message to run.
So in general, people love these signs.
You know, they're popular, they get shared on social media,
but there is a problem.
One group in particular really does not like them.
And that group is the Federal Highway Administration.
Oh no, those guys.
Those guys.
Well, the FHWA, they're in charge of highway safety
for the United States, and in their
opinion these signs can be kind of a distraction.
So a couple years ago, they actually made New Jersey take down one of these signs.
So the sign said, hold on to your butts, help prevent forest fires.
Ha ha ha, funny joke.
But what happened is people were actually slowing down to take pictures of the sign,
which is obviously not safe.
It's kind of working at cross purposes to what the sign is supposed to be doing.
So they actually told the state, you have to take this down.
That is disappointing.
I get where they're coming from, though.
Right?
But earlier this year, the FHWA, they put out their national guidelines for highway safety.
They update these every couple of years.
And it was a little bit like mom and dad turning on all the lights at a party and telling everybody
to go home because they included guidelines for what a highway safety sign should say.
They said it should be informative.
It should be sober.
So here it is.
This is the FHWA example of a good highway sign.
They say unbuckled seat belts equals fine plus points.
Oh no, that's dreadful.
It's really dry, yeah.
So is that it?
Is that the end for the funny highway sign?
Well, the guidelines came out in January
and suddenly there were all these newspaper stories
that were saying like funny signs will be banned,
say goodbye to the highway signs.
It's actually not quite what's happening here
because these are guidelines, right?
But Matt says it's really important to him
to keep some humor in the signs
because there's evidence of this.
There's studies that show this.
When you're being entertained,
you're more likely to retain these kinds of messages
and it makes people think about their driving.
So in that way, it does save lives.
I don't think we're gonna suddenly see
a huge swing in fatalities or crashes because of these,
but I think we are taking little bites at it
and it's worth it.
It doesn't cost the taxpayers anything extra
and I certainly don't think it makes it worse.
So if it makes it better for even a handful of people,
then I think it's worth that effort.
Now, Roman, if you have an idea for a funny highway sign, I have some good news. You can
share your pitches with ODOT. There's a website for it and Matt says they consider every pitch
that's sent in.
Oh my God.
If you enjoy the institution of the funny highway sign, you have an opportunity. It's
at the website, zero deaths dot Ohio dot gov.
So check it out.
I'm going to spend some quality time on this.
Well, thank you, Chris.
This is delightful.
Thanks, Roman.
Okay.
So we're here with 99 PI producer Vivian Lay.
What do you have for us this year?
So I wanted to share a story that was one of the more interesting detours that I stumbled
upon while reporting another story.
So you remember an episode that we did in early 2024 that's also in contention for the
longest podcast title ever.
It was called warning this podcast contains chemicals known to the state of California
to cause cancer or other reproductive harm.
Of course.
It's one of my favorite titles ever.
So it's such a good title.
Love it.
Yeah.
And if other listeners missed that one, it was essentially about the history of this
law in California that passed in 1986 that required all California businesses to put
a warning label on any products that contain cancer-causing chemicals.
And a big part of the reason why that law originally passed was because Jane Fonda was a huge proponent
of that proposition.
Yes, yeah.
I mean, she was the one who kind of rounded up
a ton of these celebrities and, you know,
they went on this bus.
Um...
You know?
And it actually brought, like, a lot of good attention
to this proposition.
Yes, exactly. Chiffy Chase was there.
It was a whole thing.
But while I was researching that story,
I found out that that victory might not have been possible
if it weren't for the Jane Fonda workout tapes.
Roman, would you care to hear more?
Yes, absolutely, I wanna hear more.
Okay, so Jane Fonda has been a huge progressive activist
for literally decades.
She's probably somewhere
getting arrested at a climate rally as we speak. But back in the 1970s, Fonda was this
huge anti-war activist. And doing that work, she met another fellow anti-war activist turned
state assemblyman. His name was Tom Hayden. And Hayden and Fonda eventually got married.
And together they realized that
they needed to influence politics from within the system. So the mid-ish 1970s, they founded
a political action committee called the Campaign for Economic Democracy. And one of the big
goals of the CED, I call it the CED for short, was trying to get progressive new left candidates into local office.
But the problem was that political action committees take a lot of money to run.
This was a statewide organization that made a huge difference in California.
This is Jane Fonda in an interview with Democracy Now.
We elected people that are still serving in public office in California. And so we had to raise a lot of money because we had a lot of chapters and there was a recession.
You see, the CED had to pay for, you know, field offices, staffers put on events, pay for political advertising, all that stuff that helps fund local campaigns. So Fonda was trying to solve this question of how to realistically keep the CED
going financially, which was hard because Fonda and Hayden's politics were considered pretty outside
of the mainstream at the time. But she says that she got an idea one day after she saw a story about
a very controversial politician. I read an article that Lyndon LaRouche, that really bad but very
wealthy guy had a computer
business that would fund people that would hold those signs at the airports.
And I read an article that said that he supported all that with his computer business.
So Roman, do you know who Lyndon LaRouche is?
I mean, I know the name.
Like I kind of know it.
I mean, I kind of think of him as this, as I was growing up, this perennial presidential
candidate.
I know he was referenced on The Simpsons, which is probably why it's stuck in my head.
Of course.
Yes.
But let's say for purposes of this story, like, no, tell me more about Lyndon LaRouche.
Okay.
So Lyndon LaRouche was a very prolific conspiracy theorist who spouted a lot of terrible anti-Semitic
and homophobic and racist views.
He also claimed that Queen Elizabeth controlled the world's drug trade.
Anyway, so LaRouche is also known for unsuccessfully running for president eight consecutive times
in a row.
He actually holds the record for that.
But as you can imagine, Roman running for president even unsuccessfully takes a lot
of money.
So Fonda read that he was able to fund his political aspirations privately through his
computer consulting, software and printing businesses on the side.
So I thought, okay, what business can I go into that could make money?
And it was the workout.
The workout.
Wait, so the Jane Fonda workout.
Yep.
So did the workout exist already? Or workout exist already or did she came first?
A little bit of background on the Jane Fonda workout.
Exercise is something that had been really important to Jane Fonda for a really long
time.
But in 1978, around the same time that the CED was getting going, she broke her foot while
filming a movie.
And she was looking for some new low-impact form of exercise that would be less taxing
on that part of the body.
And she ended up meeting an exercise instructor named Lenny Kasdan, who introduced her to
these long total body workouts, and she fell in love with it.
And she ended up opening a bunch of exercise studios and then eventually releasing the Jane Fonda workout book, which was wildly popular.
And talk about how much money we're talking about here.
You blew everyone away.
Tens of millions.
How long were you on the New York Times bestseller list for?
Two years.
Two solid years.
That is what caused the New York Times to start separating it out into categories, because
to have the workout book competing with, you know,
Philip Roth or somebody didn't make any sense.
I mean, two years on the bestseller list.
That's really something.
Yeah, it's a lot.
How long was the 99PI book on the bestseller list for?
On the bestseller list?
I mean, it was like in the top 10 for like three weeks.
So I was pretty proud of that.
That's pretty good.
It's still pretty good.
But if it wasn't for her splitting out the list, we would not have ranked because we
were on the non-fiction list and not competing with the fiction bestseller list.
Interesting.
Jane Fonda, thank you again for all of your work.
But yeah, so, you know, eventually in the 1980s, like the early 1980s, Fonda was approached
to bring her workout to this
new fangled technology called home video. And she said that she was at first actually
very hesitant to put out a workout tape. You know, she was a movie star at the time and
she thought it would be terrible for her acting career. But she agreed to do it because, you
know, a, nobody would ever watch it because this was such a new technology that she barely
knew anybody who owned a VCR
And B she thought it might bring some extra cash in for the CED and that must have been even more successful
Because I didn't even know there was a book, you know, like so like the like me growing up
It was the Jane Fonda workout tapes. So it must have even eclipsed those. Oh, yeah, totally
She she ended up selling over 17 million tapes
And it's actually thought
that the Jane Fonda workout tapes were so popular that they led to an increase in VCR
sales. And Fonda says that pretty much all of that money went straight into the campaign
for economic democracy.
Wow. Well, that's incredible. I mean, in addition to like pushing VCR sales, did the tape sales
actually move forward the politics of the CED?
Did it actually change California or world politics?
Yeah.
So the CED invested in a bunch of progressive causes in California, like investing in solar
power, labor rights, anti-war initiatives, women's rights, of course, proposition 65.
But I think one of the biggest, most tangible successes of the CED was getting rent control
laws passed in Santa Monica.
And this is something that has actually had a lasting impact on the city and it still
exists today.
Wow.
So if you live in a rent controlled apartment in the city of Santa Monica, this is essentially
because of Jane Fonda and the Jane Fonda workout tapes.
Wow.
Yes, exactly.
And I actually do have a friend who lived in a rent controlled apartment in Santa Monica
for like 14 years and he only just recently moved out to start a family.
And when I learned about this, I texted him and I was just like, Brandon, if you ever
meet Jane Fonda, you better thank her for saving you thousands and thousands of dollars.
That's perfect.
Oh, it's such a fun little side story. I'm glad we could take this little
detour as a little bonus from your Prop 65 story, which people should go listen to if
they haven't heard it. It's like one of my favorites from recent memories.
Thank you.
Awesome.
Merry Christmas to me.
Thank you, Vivian.
Thank you, Roman. Coming up, why the ancient Greeks who believed in a perfect version of everything were obsessed
with feet.
And how the man who invented dynamite came back from the dead, sort of, to clear his
name and ended up creating the most famous prize in the world.
That's after the break.
In October, we released an episode with the great Steven Johnson,
talking about his latest book, The Infernal Machine,
all about how the invention of dynamite
drastically changed the political landscape in the US
when it became the weapon of choice by domestic terrorists.
Dynamite unleashed a new kind of horrific, violent, destructive power that the world had never seen before.
Which was people being fully blown up. Like the physical damage to the body,
there's all this kind of newspaper reports like we were not able to identify the remains of this other person.
Like if you were right on top of a dynamite explosion, you know, you were
reduced to small little pieces of human flesh.
And that was something that had not really happened to the human body before.
And it suddenly started happening all the time.
Dynamite was invented by Alfred Nobel and it made him one of the richest men in
the world, but it took a death in the family and a case of mistaken identity
for him to truly understand what
the public really thought of him.
Author Stephen Johnson talked me through this amazing story.
His brother died and a couple of French newspapers got confused and thought that Nobel himself
had died.
So he was put in the somewhat unusual position of getting to read his own obituaries
in the paper and they were not positive. And the kind of the famous headline was, the merchant
of death is dead.
Yeah, and it gets worse because the first line of his obituary reads, Dr. Alfred Nobel,
who became rich by finding ways to kill more people faster than ever before,
died yesterday.
Which is a real gut punch.
Yeah, yeah.
You'd hate to read that.
If you're still alive.
And so, you know, this whole career that he'd spent, you know, unleashing this explosive
force on the world designed to help it modernize
and build railroads and skyscrapers
and subways and sewer systems, all of which had happened
and which had made him one of the wealthiest people
in the world.
At his alleged death, what was remembered
was that he had unleashed all this terrible,
catastrophic violence on the world
thanks to the political radicals
who had stolen his technology and put it to
nefarious uses.
But that is definitely not how he is remembered today, because of one person.
And so Nobel had developed, before this point, a long enduring friendship with a peace activist
named Bertha von Sutner.
And she had argued to him that he should use his prodigious fortune in the service of the peace cause that was kind of on the rise at that point.
And something in the accidental reading of his obituaries and the recognition that his legacy was likely to be very tarnished,
and his long conversation with Suttner led him to change his will and take the vast majority of his fortune to endow
now the thing that is actually most associated with Nobel's name, not dynamite, but the Nobel
prizes and most famously the Peace Prize, which was a very unusual, it was one thing
to have a kind of a scientific prize, a Nobel Prize in physics and chemistry seemed to make
sense and particularly made sense with something like chemistry where Nobel had been a pioneer in chemistry himself.
But the idea of a Peace Prize was a very unusual thing, and it is now arguably like the most
prestigious prize that one can receive in the world.
And von Suttner actually was one of the early recipients of it.
So part of her legacy was advocating for peace and also advocating for Nobel to create the Peace Prize,
which then became a force for good in the world
in many ways and enduring to this day.
Steven Johnson's most recent book
is called The Infernal Machine.
I loved it, you're gonna love it, it's dynamite,
as are his other 13 books about science,
technology and innovation,
even though the others are not actually about dynamite. Only this one is, but they're all dynamite nonetheless.
So Joe Rosenberg, what do you have for me today?
Well, Roman, this story starts just a couple months ago when I'm at home and I'm walking
around barefoot and I go into my roommate's room to ask her about something.
And before I can even get a word in,
she just blurts out,
Oh my God, what the hell is wrong with your feet?
And I look down at my feet, I look up again,
and I say, what do you mean?
Because she sounded truly alarmed.
At which point she goes,
your big toe is shorter than your second toe.
Yeah, and it's true.
My big toe is slightly shorter than my second toe.
But genuinely, before this moment,
it had never once occurred to me
to think about the lengths of people's big toes
relative to their other toes, much less my own.
You know, now that you mention it,
my second toe is also longer than my big toe,
but if you were to tell me to draw a foot,
I think I would draw them in sort of a kind of
straight diagonal progression from big toe to little toe.
Oh, okay, so your big toe is also shorter
than your second toe.
That's right, that's right.
I'm one of you.
Oh, okay, well this is, okay, well then,
in fact, this story is gonna have,
suddenly the stakes just got a lot higher.
Okay.
So most feet, you know, yeah, they form more or less
that kind of diagonal line with the big toe being biggest.
And my feet, and apparently your feet, do not.
At least in my case, the end of my foot instead
just kind of forms this gentle curve.
But my roommate was just adamant about this,
that the length of my big toes,
or specifically their lack of length,
was just plain wrong.
And so how did you take this in, like, emotionally?
Externally, with grace.
Okay.
Internally, I am freaking out.
I already have other things about my body
that I'm not pleased with.
And so I do the only thing I can do at that moment, which is to rush back I already have other things about my body that I'm not pleased with.
And so I do the only thing I can do at that moment, which is to rush back to my room,
go on my computer, and look up what it means when your big toe is abnormally short.
What did you find?
I mean, what did the internet tell you?
Not that I put a ton of credence on the internet when it comes to like what thing is going
on with my body.
But still, what did the internet tell you?
Well, in this case, you should put total credence in the internet because I found total vindication.
Oh, excellent.
Yeah, it turns out that this is a thing in the art world
because in the Western artistic tradition,
throughout its long history of depicting the human form,
there are three major foot shapes that you'll see come up.
And they are Egyptian, Roman, and Greek.
And so I'm assuming that's because this is how the Egyptian, Romans, and Greek, like sculptors
and painters each portrayed feet.
Exactly.
But also, each of these three categories corresponds to types of feet commonly found worldwide.
And broadly speaking, an Egyptian foot is when your big toe is longer than your other toes.
And that is far and away, as mentioned, you know, the most common type of foot worldwide.
In one study, it's something like 70% of the global population.
Then there is the slightly rare Roman foot, that is when your big toe is the same length
as your second toe and often third toe. And that's like 25% of people.
And then there is what you and I have, the Greek foot,
which is when your big toe is shorter than your second toe.
And the Greek foot is the rarest foot of all.
In this same study, only 5% of people have it.
Wow, I would have never thought such a thing.
So given that it's so rare,
what determines whether or not you have a Greek foot?
It's a little unclear.
You'll be shocked to learn that toe length
is not a top priority in the medical community right now.
And to be clear, there's no definitive study of the numbers.
They can vary quite a bit.
But it pops up more in a few populations
throughout the world.
So according to, again, different studies,
maybe like 30% of the Ndoma
in Nigeria have it. Possibly a majority of people with Ainu ancestry in northern Japan
have it as well. But the important part for you and me is that according to no lesser
source than Wikipedia, my foot, my much maligned and ridiculed foot with its short big toe was not only depicted, but treasured by the ancient Greeks
who believed, and I kid you not,
that it was the platonically ideal form of the human foot.
Right. Well, take that unnamed roommate.
That'll show her making fun of Joe Rosenberg's feet.
That's right. And I'm obviously, I'm not going to disclose her name.
I'd hate to humiliate her in front of our audience.
That's embarrassing. Yeah.
Yeah, and it gets better because it says
that throughout most of Western artistic history,
it was, quote, an idealized form
which has persisted as an aesthetic standard.
So like you and I have won like the foot lottery.
The Western canon has determined that we have beautiful beautiful feet
We do and I need to insert a brief PSA here, okay, which is that in the medical world?
There's actually a name for it. It's called Morton's toe
Okay, and it can lead to gait issues that lead to leg and back pain later on in life
So, you know if you feel like you have an extreme version of this maybe go check it out with your doctor
But that is not relevant to what we're discussing today.
We're going to move on to the more important stuff here.
Okay, so how did that aesthetic idea come about?
How did the Greek foot initially become considered this, you know, the quote unquote, persistent
aesthetic standard?
Well, perhaps not surprisingly, something like 40% of Greeks have it and possibly, yeah,
like a majority of Greeks have it and possibly, yeah,
like a majority of Greek men.
So the ancient Greeks just looked down on their feet and just decided, oh, this toe
configuration is the best.
Obviously.
Yeah.
Right.
And if you think back to your high school history class, you might remember that when
classical Greek culture came about, the Greek philosophers and artists were just obsessed
with the idea that you could find the ideal form of every little thing.
Right. The Greeks thought they could deduce this idealized form of the perfect tree. The
Platonic ideal is what I was taught.
Yes, exactly. And there was actually a famous Greek sculptor, Polykleitos, who apparently
laid out the perfect proportions of a human male body in a treatise.
And sadly, all the exact measurements from this treatise
are lost to history.
But one thing that Polykleitos
and the other Greek artists believed
was that the big toe absolutely had to be shorter
than the second toe.
And how much shorter are we talking here?
Admittedly, it's a little unclear,
and it's also honestly not clear what their rationale was
besides the fact that so many Greek people had it.
Every article I've found on this likes to say
it might have been due to the golden ratio,
but what exactly toe length has to do
with the golden ratio, no one ever bothers to explain.
Yeah, as soon as the golden ratio is brought into something,
I'm like, okay, this is a bunch of nonsense.
Yeah, nevertheless, the Greeks end up having
a disproportionate cultural impact.
And so there's basically been like 2,500 years
of Western art in which the depiction
of the human form has been influenced by the Greeks.
And so when it comes to the great works of Western art,
Artaud's Roman are in very good company.
Needless to say, I prepared a small slideshow.
Let me start you off with what is arguably the most admired
and well-preserved ancient Greek bronze of all time.
It's called Boxer at Rest, in which this very handsome guy,
who I personally think kind of looks like Paul Mescal,
sits in this kind of beautiful, exhausted repose.
Okay, let me click on this one.
Okay.
Oh yeah, yeah, that's nice.
And here is a detail, of course, of one of his perfect Greek feet with its slightly smaller
big toe.
Yeah, this is very subtle, but I can see this is a lovely idealized foot.
Absolutely.
And lest you think this is restricted to men,
let's move on to Renaissance painting
with no less than Botticelli's Birth of Venus.
Oh yeah.
Venus, I will remind you, is the goddess of Roman beauty.
And here are her even more pronounced Greek feet.
Oh goodness, yeah, they really are leaning in hard.
It looks like a finger almost.
Yeah, and the list of Greek feet goes on.
You know, Leonardo's drawings of the ideal human form,
you know, the one in the circle.
Oh yeah, yeah, yeah.
Michelangelo's David,
and my personal favorite example of Greek feet,
the Statue of Liberty.
Oh wow, yeah, I've never noticed this before.
Is that like the biggest short big toe
on display in the world?
It might be.
I, you know, there's only a few challengers Is that like the biggest short big toe on display in the world? It might be.
I, you know, I, there's only a few challengers
and I probably should check them out.
I've never looked at her feet before.
Like not only is the second toe quite long,
the pinky toe is weirdly far back.
It looks bizarre.
Yeah, no, it is truly bizarre looking.
I personally think that my Greek feet
are better than her Greek feet.
And I should add, I think we also might actually make
great foot models if we ever needed the extra cash.
Because I can't confirm this,
but a quick Google search for foot related products
like sandals suggests that a disproportionate number
of foot models also have Greek feet.
So I think the modeling agencies
might need to give us a call.
Yeah, I think that makes total sense to me.
This is opening up a dark doorway.
Yeah, I mean, do you know about wiki feet, Roman?
I do, I mean, I heard that name before,
but I've never dared to look.
I do know that at one point,
I posted a picture on Instagram
of a piece of art in my house and we don't
wear shoes in my house and so my feet were on display and my stepdaughter texted and
said, you put your feet on the internet?
And I was like, what?
So I'm aware of this, but I have not opened that door.
Like this is not a subculture.
I'm like going to explore greatly, I don't think.
Well, but at least you know now that you have truly beautiful feet.
Well, you have beautiful feet too, Joe.
Oh my God, thank you, Roman.
Yeah, don't hate us because we're beautiful.
Don't hate us because we're beautiful.
Thank you so much, Joe. This was fun.
This was a lot of fun, Roman. Thanks.
99% Invisible was produced this week by Chris Barupe, Vivian Ley, Jacob Medina-Gleason, and Joe Rosenberg.
Edited by Christopher Johnson, mixed by Martin Gonzalez, music by Swan Real.
Fact checking by Laura Bullant.
Cathy Tu is our executive producer, Kurt Kolstad is the digital director, Delaney Hall is our
senior editor.
The rest of the team includes Emmett Fitzgerald, Gabriella Gladney, Lashma Don, Nina Potok,
Kelly Prime, Jason DeLeon, and me, Roman Mars.
Taylor Shedrick is our intern.
The 99% of visible logo was created by Stephen Lawrence.
We are part of the Stitcher and SiriusXM podcast family, now headquartered six blocks north
in the Pandora building, beautiful uptown Oakland, California.
You can find us on blue sky, which is definitely the best mass social media
site that anyone can hang out on.
We're going to make a go of it there.
So give it a try, or you can connect with us on our discord server where
there's over 5,000 people talking about the power broker and talking about
architecture, talking about bunch of other stuff.
There's a link to that as well as every past episode of 99PI at 99PI.org.