All About Change - Olivier Bernier - My Son Deserves to Be Included
Episode Date: May 15, 2023Olivier Bernier is an award-winning director and documentary filmmaker who lives and breathes to tell stories that explore the human condition. When Olivier and his wife Hilda’s son was born with do...wn syndrome they were entirely unprepared. Inspired, Olivier Bernier decided to document his family experience so he applied and won grant money to make a film about inclusive education. However, his family’s experiences with Emilio’s journey took the film in a slightly different direction. Forget Me Not became a documentary film that shares a family’s fight to have their son with Down syndrome included in the country’s most segregated school system in the country, the New York City public school system. Forget Me Not offers a rare look at what a truly inclusive education can look like and how it can lead to a more inclusive society so that everyone has the opportunity to achieve their full potential. The production crew also included several young people with disabilities, as seen in the closing credits of the film. In this conversation with Jay, he talks about his journey as a father advocating for his child’s inclusive education in one of the most segregated school districts in the US - New York City. Please find a transcription of this episode: https://allaboutchangepodcast.com/podcast-episode/olivier-bernierSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
If we want to look at the society we want to live in, that really has to start in the classroom.
Hi, I'm Jay Rudiman, and welcome to All About Change, a podcast showcasing individuals who
leverage the hardships that have been thrown at them to better other people's lives.
This is all wrong.
I say put mental health first because if you don't...
This generation of Americans has already had enough.
I stand before you not as an expert, but as a concerned citizen.
And today on our show, Olivier Bernier.
The problem with most school districts, and especially New York, is that they use these
evaluations to find reasons to segregate the
children from an early age. Olivier Bernier is an award-winning director and documentary filmmaker
who lives and breathes to tell the stories that explore the human condition. When Olivier and his
wife Hilda's son was born with Down syndrome, they were entirely unprepared. I think that if at a very
young age you tell someone that you don't belong,
you start disenfranchising them
and you don't give a person a reason to live.
But though he was unprepared emotionally,
he did have his camera on him and was filming
from the very moment the doctor broke the news.
Inspired, Olivier Bernier decided to document
his family's experience.
Forget Me Not became a documentary about Olivier's son Emilio,
but it also talks about a much broader issue.
The film sheds light on families fighting to have their children included
in one of the most segregated school systems in the country,
the New York City public school system.
I think the most important thing is that Emilio's story just happened to be the one I filmed,
but Emilio's story represents millions of other kids around the country and around the world that are going through the same thing.
So you're not alone.
Olivier, it's a pleasure to welcome you as my guest on All About Change.
I want to tell you I really enjoyed your film, Forget Me Not. It resonated with me
on so many different levels. I've been involved in the work of inclusive education for most of
my career. But I think film has a way of really drawing people in and making them feel and live
what the experience is really like. You start the film in an abandoned institution. And can
you talk a little bit about why you chose to start
this film that way? Yeah, well, when we started making the film, it was more of a cerebral look
at what inclusive education was. And part of that was just my discovery of inclusive education.
As we got into making the film, I started to realize, well, segregation is actually the norm.
to realize, well, segregation is actually the norm. And where did it all start? It started in these institutions. So there's a couple of reasons why I think that institutions are really relevant.
One, because it's the worst form of segregation. But also it shows, to me, a sense of optimism,
because just 50 years ago, if my son was born in a hospital, it would have been recommended that he go into an institution.
Today, we're past that.
And it shows that as a society, we can change and we can move forward.
Right.
And I think later on in the film, you show some of the real horrors that were uncovered when cameras went into these institutions and showed people with disabilities essentially being treated as animals.
and show people with disabilities essentially being treated as animals.
And I think we've come a long way from then,
but we still have a long way to go,
which is what your film essentially points out.
This is a very personal film.
The birth of your son is prominent,
and his growing up and the trials that you and your wife go through in terms of his education.
When you first started to look into or had the interest in making this film, did you intend it to be such a personal
look into your own life? Absolutely not. When we started the film, we started with the idea that
we want to see what an inclusive education system looks like. When my son was born, I was
completely unprepared for him. I didn't know what Down syndrome was in a real way. And in some ways,
I thought that he would be stuck in a room for the rest of his life. And part of that was my
ignorance. But as I looked at it, you know, I went to a school of 3000 people, a high school,
and I never met anyone with Down syndrome or significant disability.
And I started to realize that it wasn't necessarily only my ignorance, it was the ignorance of society
in general, that we keep people with disabilities hidden. And then what we do is we create a river
between us. When my son was born, being unprepared for him really made me want to look at how can I
change that? How can I do something that makes this world a unprepared for him really made me want to look at how can I change that?
How can I do something that makes this world a little better for him growing up?
And as he was turning two, education was on our minds.
What is education going to look like?
And we decided that we probably want him to be included just because we want him to be included everywhere.
At the time, we were taking him to swimming lessons, to every kid's group, music group.
And why would school be any different?
So the filming of the birth, was that separate from the film?
That was like a personal, like, I'm going to film my son's birth.
And then later, you decided to include that in the film.
Does that sound about right?
Yeah, I was a filmmaker before my son was born. So I was like any dad just filming everything. I just had fancier
cameras to do it with. And when my son was born, it was a pretty dramatic birth for a couple reasons,
oxygen levels, all the reasons why births are never like they are in the movies.
And at the time, I thought I had put my camera down, it was around my neck,
and I forgot to stop recording. And I caught the moment that the doctor tells us that Emilio shows
five markers of Down syndrome. A couple of things we noticed, the eyes are slightly up slanted,
and the toes are slightly widened, there's a crease on the palms. Some subtle findings everywhere that may indicate Down syndrome.
Okay?
And so we're not sure.
I'm sorry to say this, but I think it's important to tell you right away,
even though we're not sure, just so you guys know.
The scene where the doctor sort of says, you know,
there are indications that your son may
have down syndrome what did you think of the way he delivered that information at at such a time
i mean how did that hit you it took a moment that i thought would be one of the best in my life and
made it one of the worst i thought i don't know that it was necessarily the way he delivered it
it could be i don't know if there's any easy way to deliver it.
But the fact that he kind of created some doubt, it wasn't certain that he had Down
syndrome and he was very apologetic for it.
I wonder if that was maybe the best way to go about it.
Knowing what I know now, Down syndrome is not doom and gloom.
Down syndrome is just another thing.
It's just another way, just another way of living.
And I wish that perhaps I was better informed and that
it was more presented a little differently. Let's put it that way.
Right. So there were no indications during the pregnancy and all of the tests that someone goes
through before the actual birth that your child may have had Down syndrome?
No, there was absolutely no indication that we would have a son with Down syndrome.
And in fact, statistically, we were at very low risk of it.
So it was a complete shock in the moment.
I think had we had a little preparation for it, it might have been a little easier of a moment.
But it was just the next 24 hours after his birth were very dramatic.
Right.
Your wife, Hilda, features prominently in the film.
Was that something that from the start she wanted to be part of this film?
Or was it a discussion between the two of you?
How did that come about?
Yeah.
So when we started making the film, like I was saying, it was more of a cerebral look
at inclusive education.
So I was filming with experts and just trying to understand what inclusive education is.
Why is it not everywhere?
And how does it work?
But as I was making that film, we started to see our own son going down a path of segregation.
And at that point, I started filming it.
And I spoke with Hilda and we had a discussion.
started filming it and I spoke with Hilda and we had a discussion and we both came to the conclusion that if we don't at least try to capture this then what are we doing because I think that as
you said earlier true change happens when people can see and believe at that moment we didn't know
what would be in store for Emilio but we knew that it wasn't looking good so that's why we decided to
start filming Emilio so closely. And
ultimately, that became a large part of the film. And we kind of pivoted from the film we were
making to the film you see today. I definitely didn't intend to ever appear in the film.
Let's put it that way. Had you ever made a film in the past where you were featured?
No, no, I'm not that kind of director. I much prefer to be behind the camera.
You know, I think it happened even in the earlier cuts. I was very resistant to it. I thought that
I had plenty of opportunity to speak just through the filmmaking and that I didn't feel like I
needed to be visible. But then it became apparent. It looked like I was kind of an absent father to
Emilio if I didn't appear in the film. So we started to,
the editor started to add more and more of me into the film. And that's kind of how I ended up in the film. Right. And your wife is obviously extremely emotional through the whole process of his birth,
his growing up, his education before he enters into the official New York City school system.
Did she hold any reservations at any time about having such a
prominent role in the film? Ilda is a very strong woman. And I think she saw the vision pretty
quickly about how important this was, because she was a special educator, but she had never been on
this side of the table. And she had no idea what it was like to be on the other side of the table.
And she had no idea what it was like to be on the other side of the table.
So she felt like it was an important and valuable resource to other parents and other teachers to show what was happening.
So I don't think she had reservations about being on camera. But she did at some point have reservations about inclusive education because being a professional in the field, she believed that we should listen
to the other professionals, that they know what they're doing. That's maybe where there was some
resistance on her part because all the professionals are saying Emilio would do better in a small
segregated class where he's separated from all the other children. And I just didn't see it that way.
And as soon as she visited the Henderson School, she didn't see it that way either. Right. When you put three-year-olds
together, three-year-olds think it's normal to be different. And we embrace differences at age three.
Somewhere around age eight, we start to qualify differences. And we start to say some people are
just not intelligent. Some people are gifted and talented and they should be separated. We disagreed. We kept all of our students together.
And we rose to be one of the highest academically performing elementary schools
for students with and without disabilities. So the Henderson School is a Boston public school.
And the only difference is that 40% of the people that attend the school have a disability
and 20% of those people have a significant disability.
And they're all included in the same class.
There's not a single segregated special class.
When I first read about the school, I was like, oh, well, that's interesting.
It seems like a place we should visit.
And as soon as you open the doors to this school, it's your whole world changes.
You see something that you're like, this is exactly what school should be like.
This is the school I wish I went to.
And we spent about two weeks in the school filming.
And what I learned is that inclusive education is very possible.
It just takes the right people to make it happen.
Right. And I think it's striking that it is part of the Boston public school system,
and you juxtapose that to what happens throughout much of the film of your experience with the New
York City public school system, which is set up in a very different way. There's a quote in the film,
which is a statistic from a conference at the UN.
Good morning and welcome to the eighth annual Down syndrome day.
That they said in 1985, the average life expectancy of a person with Down syndrome was 25.
Was just 25 years.
At the time of the film, it is 61.
I think there's multiple things there.
There's definitely the medical field has advanced and has been able to help people with Down syndrome, especially at birth.
There's a lot of heart defects.
There's a lot of issues that we dealt with with our own son.
And those have been amazing advances.
I think what you really have to look at, though, is how we value people in society and self-worth and what that does to a person.
I think that if at a very young age you tell someone that you don't belong,
you start disenfranchising them and you don't give a person a reason to live. How does anybody
survive in a world where they're not wanted? And I think that's the biggest leap we've taken
is starting to value people with disabilities and showing the world how much they're worth to us.
I'm struck in the film how when you film Emilio as a very young child, he has a lot of therapy done at home, speech therapy and some other forms of therapy.
And he seems to be making tremendous progress in speaking and being able to communicate.
And you juxtapose that to when you go into the system in the New York City school system.
What is an IEP evaluation?
Why is it done as early as the age of two or three years old?
And how that can essentially affect the future of their life.
Yeah, IEP is another one of those educational acronyms, but maybe the
most important for someone with a disability. It's an individualized educational plan. And the
point of an IEP is really to draw up a strategy for how we're going to accommodate and help a
child succeed. What ends up happening is the IEP process is really a way to segregate children. The IEP is mandated by law
and the law says that you should start in the least restrictive environment. So at two and a
half years old, child transitions from the medical model, which is early intervention where people
come in, therapists come in, and in our case did a wonderful job with Emilio. We just saw so much
advancement and we said, well, this IEP is going to be a breeze to go into the educational system. And in our case, did a wonderful job with Emilio. We just saw so much advancement.
And we said, well, this IEP is going to be a breeze to go into the educational system.
What they do is they bring evaluators. They sit down with Emilio for about half an hour, an hour in some cases, and they test
them.
They give them essentially an IQ test and different types of tests for physical ability.
And from that, they're supposed to determine what Emilio needs.
The problem with most school districts, and especially New York,
is that they use these evaluations to find reasons to segregate the children from an early age.
A child might have their first IEP at five or six years old
if it's determined that they need an IEP once they start schooling.
But Amelia was born with Down syndrome, and many people are aware of the challenges of
Down syndrome, so he was immediately booked for an IEP.
I think still today that the IEP is both an amazing advancement in education, but also
problematic, because as soon as you start to determine what a child is capable of
based on tests that are really kind of archaic at this point, you start to run into problems.
Touch blue. Touch my blue. Blue. I know I'm pushing too much. I know,
Bo. I know. You already did so much. The film does an awesome job at sort of
showing how in a home environment, when he's working with people that he knows he's making tremendous progress.
And I think that the filming of the first IEP evaluation, which I do not believe was done in the home, that he was sort of just shutting down.
First of all, I would say it's really impactful that you filmed that.
But maybe you can talk about what that felt like at the time. Yeah, I think as a father, it was very
confusing at times because one half my brain's thinking as a filmmaker half is thinking as a
father as a father, I was a little sad, I was thinking that this isn't going to look good.
And people are going to judge him based on this one moment. And he just woke up
today thinking like it was like any other day. And he's been stuck in this weird gray room with
this person he doesn't know and told to stack things. And it's not the evaluator's fault.
The evaluator was doing exactly what she was tasked to do. But at the same time,
Emilio was having a bad day. And my wife and I both knew that that was potentially going to determine his path that
one half hour test. And, you know, it's hard, hard to hard to
really wrap your head around that.
I feel like I like I have not done enough, which, you know, I
cannot beat myself over this because I have done everything I
can. But it does make me feel because I have done everything I can.
But it does make me feel like I have not done enough.
When Emida was not sitting at the right time, I had to think about it.
How am I going to get him to sit by himself?
When he was not rolling, how am I going to get him to roll?
How am I going to get him to crawl?
How am I going to get him to walk?
How am I going to get him to crawl? How am I going to get him to walk? How am I going to get him to speak?
And I get so excited every time he accomplishes something.
And like everything he does is so big for me that I don't see the delay.
Everything he does is so wonderful.
So I just celebrate everything. that's all I can do
so was that the turning point for Hilda
when she saw that evaluation
was that when she started to say
oh this may be problematic
in terms of determining my child's future
yeah there was that moment
I think that was probably the start
of it, looking at it. Because early intervention, and for listeners who don't know exactly what it
is, is from the age of zero, people come into your home and help your child. But Emilio was
making such progress, and we were so happy with the work he was doing. And he was focused, and
we knew that in the right setting he could succeed in school.
But when we saw that test, we realized that we're up kind of against a bureaucratic wall
that we don't really fully understand how to get behind.
Maybe you could talk a little bit about the New York school system, public school system,
and how it has been set up to segregate children. In fact, there's a whole
another school where people with disabilities, children with disabilities go and they're
essentially not seen by other children without disabilities. Can you talk a little bit about
how the system works in New York? The school system in New York is over a million children. It's enormous. It's the largest in the country. The school system absorbed a lot of children with disabilities when they shut down the institutions in the early 80s. And what they did was build an institution within the school districts. So they created what's called District 75 to absorb these children.
District 75 is a segregated school district that basically is co-located in buildings around the
city. And it contains only children with IEPs. And these children never see any other children
during the day. They only see the children in District 75. They use separate
entrances. They don't go to lunch together. They don't go to gym together. And largely, they're
invisible to all the other children. So what we have is a school district within a school,
and it's as segregated as you can get. Now, mind you that a lot of schools also have special classes. Not
every child goes to District 75. But the fact that District 75 exists is very problematic.
Furthermore, with New York, New York is still a very segregated school system. And in fact,
parents have to sue often to get out of that segregated setting. So in 2021, I believe that New York City spent a billion
dollars on both lawsuits and sending children to private schools. So it's clear that New York City
is really failing at inclusion. Right, which is shocking because when, you know, we think of New
York City as one of the most progressive cities in the United States. But when it comes to education of children
disabilities, it seems like they're really towards the bottom. They absolutely are. And
that was my thinking as well. When Amelia was born, I was like, at least we're in New York City
where people value other people of different cultures, different races, all different types
of people. Yeah, when it gets to the school school system it is the most segregated in the country my recommendation is still a 12-1-2 but we found a location a school
that is willing to provide integrated the integrated program and they did let me know
that it's 14 students that they have so it's not the initial recommendation but it's partial
part of it so you're not changing the recommendation well it it's partial. It's part of it. So you're not changing the recommendation?
Well, it's a partial service.
I'm ecstatic that he's going to have this opportunity to be in an integrated setting.
I just don't see the point of making that recommendation if you're truly recommending
him for an integrated setting.
Well, I'm not truly recommending him for an integrated setting. Well, I'm not truly recommending him for an integrated setting. We keep the 12-1-2 on for right now,
then it goes to next year,
and then we hit kindergarten.
So just to clarify one last time,
if we reconvene this time next year,
then he does great.
Then we make it integrated.
Can you talk a little bit about
what happens after the initial IEP?
Because there's a whole process and maybe you could talk about due process and what that means
and what you're doing as a family at that point in time. Yeah, so after Emilio's first IEP,
he was recommended for a segregated setting at just under three years old. At that point,
for a segregated setting at just under three years old.
At that point, we didn't accept the recommendation, and we decided that we needed to get an advocate on our side
because even though Ilda was a professional,
they really didn't listen to us, and we didn't have any input.
In fact, the recommendation was already written before we entered the room.
And as a parent, your only recourse is due process,
which was written into the law, the IDEA, and allows a parent to fight a recommendation.
But it takes a lot of resources and it takes a lot of time. an exception where he was still recommended a segregated setting, but they would allow him to go to this one preschool in Queens that was willing to work with us to have him included.
And if he was successful for a year in that preschool, then they would change the IEP to
fully inclusive or as they call it in New York, integrated setting. And he was successful. So, you know, we went into the second year IEP
thinking that this is going to go smooth. We were really, there was an eerie calmness actually
looking back on it because we were confident. We've seen a lot of progress. You know, he can do
a lot of things. He knows a lot of letters. We knew that his teacher was happy with his performance.
We knew that Emilio was enjoying school.
All the things that you want out of a two and a half year old.
And he was really more advanced than other children his age because he had received so many lessons at home growing up to that point.
You know, we went into the second year IEP.
All right. So give me a second. I think you could pause.
And things didn't go our way.
I'm going to have to stick with my recommendation of a 12-1-2.
And if the family wants to proceed with their due process, they can.
At this point, this is what we're going to end up doing.
What I believe is the most appropriate setting for him is a 12-1-2.
I have to do my due diligence as a CPSC administrator,
as an employee of the Department of Education,
and this is what I believe is most appropriate.
It is not. You don't know Emilio.
You don't know him.
You've seen him once for a few hours.
You don't know him.
You don't know what's appropriate for him.
What happens at that point?
Where do you go?
You're at loggerheads with the school system in New York City.
They're saying we want Amelia to be in a segregated environment.
You want an inclusive environment.
You have an advocate working with you to try to get him into an inclusive environment.
At that point, we first go to mediation.
First go to mediation. So with mediation, we were able to have a temporary resolution where we were able to negotiate a six-month trial period, so to speak. But we knew that wouldn't exactly last.
Had they not given us that opportunity, we would have had to go to court.
Once they had that opportunity, did it lead to him being in an environment that was inclusive?
Yeah, well, it was an interesting time because they gave him a six-month window to try inclusive
education. And we were probably in the most segregated setting in history where every child
was learning from home on a laptop. So it was a complicated time for everyone, but especially for
Emilio. And I came out of that, the pandemic and the lockdown and all that, and schools being shut
down, thinking that people are really going to get this inclusion thing.
Like, we've seen a lot of aggression with children.
We've seen a lot of depression.
We've seen all these bad effects of what happens when a child is segregated.
And it wasn't the case.
We actually see more segregation today And it wasn't the case.
We actually see more segregation today than we did before the pandemic.
Right.
There's a quote by an educator in the film that I think is very powerful.
I think we should look at it similar to the way we looked at desegregation in the civil rights movement.
It's providing opportunities and having the mindset that kids are capable.
And exclusion is something, the construct of the adults, right, that we impose on kids.
What does that mean to you?
Well, going back to the Henderson School, when you walk into the school,
you see children of all different types, of all different abilities,
playing together, hanging out, learning together, learning with
each other. And children don't see the disabilities. They see differences, but they don't see it as a
disability. They just see it as a difference. And they celebrate those differences, but they,
and they're friends, they help each other. It's adults that teach children that they're different
and to not look, to not ask questions, to be shy, to look
away. Those are the things I was taught. I really, you know, wish that wasn't the case. If we want to
look at an inclusive society and if we want to look at the society we want to live in, that really
has to start in the classroom. And, you know, those children that go to those inclusive settings,
they're going to grow up seeing people with disabilities in a very different light.
of those inclusive settings, they're going to grow up seeing people with disabilities in a very different light. Sure. Yeah. I think it's one of the most powerful aspects of an inclusive education,
the impact it has on children without disabilities. Did you ever give any thought to
during this whole process of like, well, maybe we don't want to be in New York. Maybe we want to
move up to Boston or move into a community where this will be a little bit easier for Emilio?
I actually looked at real estate in Dorchester to see if it was something we could afford,
which is where the Henderson School is.
What's interesting is the Henderson School has almost no waiting list for people with
disabilities, but has a very long waiting list for neurotypically developing children.
And the school is so highly regarded that the real estate around
the school has skyrocketed. But that aside, it's really troubling to think that someone would have
to move from their community where they plan to raise their child in order to find inclusive education, which is really a civil right and
in my mind, a human right.
If you really just take a quick look at the socioeconomic picture of the IEP and what
it does to children of lower means, I had the opportunity to make a film about Emilio
and to learn, to talk to the leading experts all over the country, some all over the world.
And I still had to bear down and fight to get Emilio included.
I can't imagine what it's like if you don't have that opportunity.
And by the way, Emilio's mom is a special education teacher with a master's degree.
Right.
You know, and it still was difficult.
So I just, there's definitely
inequity built into the system. When your film ends, we don't really know what the future,
what Amelia's future is going to be. Can you talk about what's happened since the end of the
filming? Where has he been educated? Yeah. So during the pandemic, we actually moved
back to New Jersey. We had a second child,
Camilla. So Emilio is a big brother now. And the school district, thank you. The school district
that we're in has been, for the most part, pretty supportive. They've pushed back here and there,
but they've been pretty supportive of wanting to include Emilio. And today,
Emilio is fully included in kindergarten. He's the most popular kid in his class from what I'm told.
He gets invited to all the birthday parties and he's got a lot of friends.
And it's just really amazing to see him flourish in that setting.
We've seen him advance in so many ways.
His maturity has increased.
His ability to communicate has flourished.
We're very happy with Emilio's progress and what he's doing
today, but most importantly, he's a happy kid. And that's what we want. I think that's all we
ever want for our children. I keep telling my kids who are a little bit older, I said,
find your happiness. I mean, that's where you want to be. What advice would you give to families that
are struggling with New York City's special
education system?
And what do you want them to take away from your experience?
I think the most important thing is that Emilio's story just happened to be the one I filmed.
But Emilio's story represents millions of other kids around the country and around the
world that are going through the same thing.
So you're not alone.
But second, I would say that the
biggest impact you can make and the biggest difference you can make is to fight with
everything you have to get your child included. Because for every child that breaks that barrier,
for every child that gets included in general education, they're opening the door to many
children behind them. So I would say, you know, stay strong and trust your gut. They're going to
tell you along the way that it's not the trust your gut. They're going to tell you
along the way that it's not the right setting, that they're going to do so much better in a
small class, even though no studies support that. But just know that all the trouble is worth it
and that you're making the world a little better by doing it. Why wouldn't you want Aiden to be
in a segregated setting, what's known as a special class with no typical children.
There was less students in the class with teacher to student ratios more intensive,
6-1-1, 8-1-1, 12-1-1. It would seem that that's something you would want to do.
But there's no study that supports placing them in a segregated setting is actually good for the child.
However, there's literally hundreds of studies that support integrating children.
And what happened to the case?
There's an attorney outside of New York City who is bringing the school system to court, even though his child was already aging out of the school system.
Do you know what happened with his case?
And if any changes came about as a result of him challenging the system?
Yeah, well, I'm excited to announce just two weeks ago that he finally won the case.
I believe they went to the New York State Supreme Court and they decided in favor of
Aiden.
That case took eight years.
So Aiden is going to be attending his local high school for the first time at 21 years old.
That's amazing.
But it's amazing that so much has, I mean, I think that Aiden's father dedicated himself to a cause, not just for Aiden's benefit, but for the benefit of other children coming after him.
But also, do we really need that? Do we have to
fight the system so hard in order to create the change that benefits everyone? It's depressing
that we have to go through that, that he had to go through that in order to achieve justice.
Absolutely. I think that the most important thing to remember is the law is quite clear,
and it's pretty strong in terms of integrating children into general education.
This is a law that was written in the late 90s. It was signed by Bill Clinton in the late 90s.
And it's the law of the land that a child must start in the least restrictive environment.
Unfortunately, laws aren't the end all because there's loopholes. Like we all know,
there's loopholes in laws and people skirt
around it and school districts have gotten really savvy at doing it and for a school district for
some reason that a reason that i still can't wrap my head around they rather spend eight years in
courts fighting a child being included versus spending that money on including them and i don't
know if this is born out of the institutional era or where the
thinking is coming from, but some people just believe people with disabilities don't belong
with other children. I think that more than writing stronger laws, what we have to do is really
inform and educate our society as to what it means to be included and what it means to be segregated.
I think one thing that I didn't know before making this film
is that an inclusion class is actually a better environment for all learners,
no matter what the ability level.
There's more educators in the classroom.
There's different ways of teaching a lesson.
Everybody benefits from that.
And never mind the component of empathy that's learned.
There's so many soft
skills that are learned that you can't really put numbers to. Well, I think that this is often the
case that you can have laws that try to correct injustices, but unless you change societal
attitudes, that's the real challenge. And I think that's where a film like Forget Me Not comes in. And can you tell me
how many people you think have seen this film and where it is right now and what impact you've
been able to see that the film has had? When we were making the film, we really didn't know
what would happen with it. At some point, there was the thought of like, why are people going to
want to watch this film about my family?
What we've seen since the film's release is just an enormous response, especially from the disabilities community. Parents reaching out to us saying thank you.
They see their own struggle reflected in the film.
And thank you for shining a light on it.
These IEP meetings are kept in the dark.
Nobody knows about them.
And I think one of the biggest impacts we're having
is we're screening the film to a lot of educators. So that's the future teachers that are going to
be entering the field. That's the future administrators, the future principals that
are going to be running schools, and they're seeing the film. And I hope that they take
something away from it about inclusive education, how important it is.
Actually, just today, we're screening the film for the Special Education, the Office of Special Education Programs, OSEP, which is part of the federal DOE.
And they're screening the film and hopefully going to have a really good discussion about it.
But I think that people forget this is going on because it's kept in the shadows.
And I hope the film continues to shine a light. There's on our website, there's a way to set up community
screenings, which a lot of people have been taking advantage of sharing the film with two,
five, 10 people. It gets word out there and it helps spread the message of inclusion.
If someone wants to see the film, where's the best place for them to go to see it?
A good starting point is our website.
You can go to fmndoc.com or forgetmenotdocumentary.com.
And on the website, there's a list of all the streaming services.
There's new ones being added all the time.
Amazon's a really popular one.
And then there's a service called Tubi where the film's actually screening for free.
There's just a little bit of advertising before the film. And other than that, there's DVDs that are available for educational and for
personal use. And as I mentioned, there's a screening request button where the distributor
will help set up a screening. And then looking even further, we're hoping to raise money and
find partners to screen the film on PBS eventually. So that's the long-term goal.
Well, I think it's a very powerful film because of the personalities involved, because
Emilio and Hilda and yourself personally going through this, I think it draws people in. And I
would encourage everyone who's interested in inclusive education to access it and to watch it. I just want to ask you as a
filmmaker, what do you see the role of cinema or entertainment in terms of generating activism and
change in our society? I got into filmmaking because it gave me a window to the world.
Since humanity, we've always learned through storytelling. And I feel like cinema and
filmmaking is one of the most complete forms of storytelling where it's experiential and we get to live in someone's shoes. It's extremely important to continue the tradition of making films that's easily corrupted and one that we can't
form our own opinions. I think you should watch Forget Me Not. I think you should watch films.
Maybe there's pro-segregation films out there. I don't know, but you should be able to form your
own opinion. And I think that's the power of filmmaking and filmmaking is only as powerful
as the people that see the movie. So, you know,
I think that's the most important thing. You mentioned at the end of the film,
some action items that you want the viewers to take to effectuate change. Could you talk about
some of them? Absolutely. I think that the credit roll is just as important as the movie.
We charge people with the task to call their school and to ask how many classrooms
are inclusive in their school. And if there's none, ask why not. And if there are, ask to put
your child in it. And I'm not just saying children with disabilities, I'm saying put your neurotypical
children in it. Because in order to affect change, we can't just do it with children with disabilities,
it has to be everyone that's on board for a more inclusive classroom. The second component is that we made the film with an
inclusive crew. And I think the inclusive workplace is equally as important. So I hope people take
something away from that as well. Yeah, I thought that was really powerful as the credits were
rolling and you saw, you know, the crew and that there were
many people with disabilities in the crew. Was it difficult to get the crew together?
Yeah, it was a learning process for me personally. It was a little bit of a challenge to find people
to work on the film that had a disability. And then with the documentary, often you're just two
or three people. interview setups we were
a little larger and we brought on people with disabilities to help us out and we taught them
what we knew some some people had already been on film sets and knew a lot and in fact were teaching
me some stuff so i think overall the experience was was really great it was a learning experience
for me and one that I think
was also an exploration because I have a, maybe it's a bias and I'm not going to push it on Emilio,
but I hope one day he, he joins me on set. Wow. That'd be awesome.
My name is Emilio Andres Bernier. I want to be someone that grows up with the same
opportunities as everyone else. I want to be surrounded by people
that love me for who I am and all my strengths.
I want to be as independent as possible
so I can explore all the beauty and diversity of this world.
Most importantly, I have so much to offer and can't wait to show everyone
what I am capable of. I wish you a tremendous amount of success as you continue in your career.
I think the film was so powerful. I'm going to urge all
my listeners to find a way to see Forget Me Not. I want to wish you and Hilda and Emilio all the
best as you go forward, because I think watching the film, we all fell in love with your family.
So thank you so much, Olivier, for being my guest today on All About Change,
and may we all go from strength to strength. Thank you so much, Olivier, for being my guest today on All About Change. And may we all go from strength to strength.
Thank you so much.
Thank you.
All About Change is a production of the Ruderman Family Foundation.
This show is produced by Yochai Meytal and Mijon Zulu.
As always, be sure to come back in two weeks for another inspiring story.
I'll be talking to Chris Henning, professor
of law at Georgetown and director of the Juvenile Justice Clinic, where she represents youth accused
of delinquency in the D.C. Superior Court. Our conversation quickly got deep into race,
adolescence, and policing. So that's what's coming to your ears in two weeks. In the meantime,
you can check out all of our previous content live on our feed and linked on our website, allaboutchangepodcast.com.
Lastly, if you enjoy our show, please help us spread the word.
Tell a friend or family member or consider writing a review on your favorite podcasting app.
I'm Jay Ruderman, and I'll catch you next time on All About Change.