American History Hit - President Harry Truman: From Farm to Oval Office and the Atom Bomb
Episode Date: February 27, 2025The end of the Second World War. The start of the Cold War. The dropping of the Atomic Bomb and the growth of the Civil Rights movement. When FDR passed, the 33rd President of the United States was tr...uly thrown into the deep end.In this episode of American History Hit, host Don Wildman discusses Truman's presidency with Mark Adams, Director of the Harry S. Truman Library and Museum.Produced by Freddy Chick. Edited by Sophie Gee. Senior Producer was Charlotte Long.Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe. You can take part in our listener survey here.All music from Epidemic Sounds.American History Hit is a History Hit podcast. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Want to explore even more history?
Sign up to History Hit, where you will discover history from around the world.
From the American Revolution to prehistoric Scotland, there is plenty to discover.
With your subscription, you'll unlock hundreds of hours of exclusive documentaries
with a brand new release every week, exploring everything from the ancient world to World War II.
Just visit historyhit.com slash subscribe to bring the past alive.
There are an awful lot of iconic photographs taken of Harry S. Truman.
The man was unusually photogenic with a flare for the dramatic.
Here's one taken in July 1945,
Truman sitting confidently in a wicker chair with Churchill and Stalin by his side.
All three men at the Potsdam Conference poised at the brink of the Cold War.
Here's Truman also seated at his Oval Office desk,
the nameplate famously stating, the buck stops here.
And then this one, grinning ear to ear, holding up a newspaper with the headline
Dewey defeats Truman. Classic. But one lesser-known image is a favorite of mine. It's from the Democratic
National Convention in the Chicago summer of 1944. It captures the moment just after Truman was
selected as Franklin Roosevelt's vice presidential running mate, his hand being held loft by the
convention chairman as camera bulbs flash. It's funny when you look closer. It's almost as if
Truman is dangling from the man's arm, his expression conveying a genuine sense of startled surprise.
By collie, that's me, Truman reportedly said, hearing his name called out on the convention floor.
A minute earlier, he had been standing in a concession line buying a hot dog.
Less than a year later, in 1945, this son of a Missouri farmer, this college dropout and failed haberdasher,
this every man American plucked from the masses, would then be held aloft by history.
suddenly named the 33rd president of the United States.
All welcome to American history hit on Don Wildman.
Harry S. Truman served as president from April 12, 1945 to January 20th, 1953,
eight years that would set the post-World War II agenda for the United States
and for much of the Cold War to come.
The month Truman succeeded FDR, April 45.
Mussolini was killed in an Italian village,
and Hitler committed suicide in his Berlin bunker.
Three months later, the first ever atomic bomb was tested successfully in the New Mexico desert.
It would be Truman who made the faithful decision to use it, ushering in the nuclear age
as the Iron Curtain descended across Eastern Europe from the Baltic Sea to the Adriatic.
Here at home, the modern civil rights movement found traction confronting southern segregation and racial violence.
And in American homes everywhere, the television age, brought programs into the living rooms,
like The Ed Sullivan Show, and I Love Lucy.
Singing in the Rain made fun of the talkies
while Orwell's 1984 warned of a dystopian future,
and Ralph Ellison's Invisible Man spent 16 weeks on the bestseller lists.
That's the general context for a presidency we will discuss today
in the company of Mark Adams,
who is the director of the Harry S. Truman Library and Museum in Independence, Missouri.
Welcome, Mark, to American History Hit. Nice to have you.
Thank you, Don. Thanks for the invitation.
Mark, before we get going, listeners will,
soon be able to tell you are an Englishman. I'm curious what drew you halfway across the world to
the Truman Library. It was the barbecue, wasn't it? Kansas City. I discovered the barbecue after I got here,
but if I'd have known, I would have come sooner, I think. Yeah, I'm originally from Liverpool,
Don, and emigrated in the early 90s. I have family here close by, and after I visited them a few times,
decided to stay, and I've actually been at the Truman Library for 28 years.
It's a fantastic place. I did an interview with Harry Truman's grandson there not too many years ago.
So let's begin at the beginning, the famously humble beginnings of Harry S. Truman.
You couldn't find a more complete antithesis to the aristocratic upbringing of, say, Franklin Roosevelt.
Truman was reared on a Missouri farm, or a couple of them, born in Lahar, Missouri. The Truman's eventually settle in independence, where you are today.
Farming is a life he doesn't particularly like, but he works for the family farm until he's in his 30s.
By the way, what does the S stand for?
The S actually stands for nothing,
but also stands for two different grandparents' names Solomon Young
and then Shipp Truman.
So when he was with one side of the family,
he would use one of those names,
and when he was with the other side of the family,
he would use the other.
But it really didn't really stand for either one.
It just was an S,
but he would kind of alter that,
depending on which family he was visiting that day.
I see.
The family finances are as rocky as the fields they plan,
This prevents Truman from the education.
He dearly wanted.
And I just want to underscore a fact I just blew past there.
He worked on this farm until he was in his 30s, a man who will be president just a few decades
later.
It's amazing.
Let's talk about the early years of Harry's education and so forth.
Yeah, so he's the last president not to go to college.
He does graduate high school, but then he works in a few banks and jobs like that.
He's trying to find his way.
The family calls him back to the farm.
in 1906. He graduated high school in 1901. So he was in his early 20s at that point. But as you're right,
he works on that farm for the next 11 years. Unfortunately, in 1914, his father dies. So then he's
actually in charge of the farm, so even more responsibility and leadership. But then works on the farm
for another three years until the United States enters World War I. And he jumps at the chance and
volunteers to join the military.
He had wanted to go to West Point, but couldn't because of poor eyesight.
That's right. His eyesight failed him, and there's a lot of discussion that when he did
volunteer for World War I, he actually memorized the eye chart.
That's right.
So he could get in.
He was actually too old for the draft, but he actually volunteered because he was in his
30s and too old for the draft.
So he was either really patriotic or wanted away from the farm.
I think it's a little bit of both.
Interesting.
He became a very talented artillery man.
in the infantry and served in France with much distinction. It's an experience there that really
changes him, isn't it? It really does change him. He does a lot of training in Oklahoma before he leaves.
He does some training in Western France to really learn how to fire the French guns.
But that leadership that he has to endure and the really tough group of soldiers that he had to
captain really gave him the confidence to lead in the future and really sets him on a political
path because those veterans that he served with become his biggest political supporters when he comes
home. He comes under intense fire. I mean, this man really did see combat several times in
very famous battles there. You can't help but wonder if how much that will come into play later
on when he makes certain other decisions in his life. When he returns to the states,
he is in Kansas City with big ideas of not returning to farming. This is a guy now in his 30s at this
point, starts a store, a haberdashery with an army buddy, which does well.
at first and then ultimately fails because of the economy, right?
That's right.
And in fact, he would recognize when soldiers came in, he'd be excited maybe they've come in
to do some business and buy some men's clothes.
But more often than not, they were coming in to him to ask for loans and for bailouts.
And so he realized pretty quickly that it was not going to be a going concern.
And so they end up going bankrupt.
How does he eventually make his way into politics?
So you mentioned World War I.
he had to introduce to one of the political bosses.
His nephew was in World War I with Harry Truman.
So that family is the Pendergast family.
And they're notorious in Kansas City.
But basically kind of like the Chicago political scene,
they kind of ran the Kansas City political scene.
He meets one of the nephews of the boss, Tom Pendergast,
in World War I.
He gets introduced.
And then Tom Pendergast puts him forward.
Really for like a county commissioner position,
They call it a county judge.
It's not a legal position, but it is an elected position.
And so he's elected in the early 1920s to serve on what we call Jackson County, which
is the county independence is in, to serve on the county commission essentially.
1922.
He is 38 years old at this point.
This is a grown man we're talking about who is really not seeing a big future for himself
at this point in life.
It's just so ironic.
Yeah, and it's a challenge because, you know, he just got married in 1990.
when he came back from the war.
And his wife is actually from better means than him,
has a little bit more money.
And he's really trying to live up to that
and try and make a living, make a career.
Yeah, 1934, I'm skipping about a decade now.
He runs for Senator.
And this is out of that same democratic machinery
run by Tom Pendergress.
He wins, but he wouldn't have gotten there
without Pendergast, would he?
No, he wouldn't.
It's certainly key to his political success,
having that relationship with Pendergast
really set him on the,
the right path. If you're not chosen by Pendigas, you may not necessarily win, but you certainly don't have a
chance without that support. This will become a bit of a controversy later on down the road for him.
Jumping ahead, in 1944, more than halfway through his second senatorial term, he is nominated
to replace Henry Wallace as Roosevelt's vice president. Now, 1944, we're in the middle of World War II
at this point. We've come through the Depression. This has been an enormous amount of history that
Truman has come through. How was he chosen for this position? I mean, Wallace, I know, was a
divisive figure. Yeah, I think that people felt that Wallace was going more and more to the left,
and they were looking more to maybe someone who's more appealing to the center. For those that know
the geography of the United States, Missouri is pretty much in the center part of the country,
maybe affiliated more with the South, particularly in the Civil War. And so he was seen as maybe a
kind of a Midwestern Southern candidate that might balance FDR, who's seen as this East Coast
Liberal, and he's just gone through all of these New Deal policies. So it's to kind of try and
balance the ticket. But it was still a surprise to Truman going into that convention. He did not
expect to be nominated. He's actually supporting other candidates at the beginning of that convention.
So very different political conventions than that we have today where it's all sealed and signed
before they even start the convention. Then it was really up for grabs.
aspect of this story that never gets the attention is how much were people aware of FDR's
impending really death? I mean, he looked like a man on the edge. Would Truman and his ilk have
known about this? Would they have been expecting this to happen? You know, it's hard to say
that one. There's nothing really, there's not much evidence to it. It's not like people
wrote about it or he documented FDR's illness. We have an amazing photograph in our museum,
actually of FDR and Truman meeting after Truman has been nominated as vice president.
They're similar in age.
They're just a couple of years apart.
Truman looks in vibrant health.
He's wearing this crisp white shirt, big beaming smile.
And then you see FDR sitting next to him and he's got bags under his eyes and his whole face is gorned and drawn.
And just looking at that photograph, we use that in our museum to show the health of FDR in 1944,
in 1945.
Whether really people talked about it, we don't have much evidence of that.
But just looking at the physical appearance, FDR certainly wasn't well.
Yeah, just common sense would have said a lot, I think.
And Truman, therefore, would have known he was stepping into a very likely replacement role.
Nonetheless, these two men barely knew each other, FDR and Truman.
They'd only met twice enduring his vice presidency.
And Truman did what vice presidents usually do.
the Senate duties and official greetings and parties. But very famously, FDR did not instruct him of
anything that was going on as far as the war was concerned. I mean, FDR was in his fourth term at this
point. So people just kind of gave over to him, didn't it? Yeah, and FDR, his style was to have a very
small inner circle of advisors. Truman was not one of those. And you're right. The role of the
vice president in the 1940s was very different than it is today, where the vice president, in current
terms has a much stronger role. FDR goes to the Yalta Conference in February after they're
inaugurated in January. Truman doesn't is not invited. Truman doesn't get to go, which is kind of
ironic because in July, Truman goes to the Potsdam Conference as president and has never met Churchill
and Stalin up to that point. So it was completely unprepared.
Listeners must keep that in mind as we approach these events that happened in the summer of 1945,
how utterly unprepared Truman was for this role of president, no experience in international affairs to speak of.
And yet he handles this incredibly resourcefully, incredibly professionally.
It's amazing.
Yeah, it's really interesting.
He does make this transition with no preparation.
In fact, when he goes to that Potsdam conference in the summer, he decides to go by ship rather than by plane.
So he has two weeks to prepare for the conference and reads all the briefings and meets with some of the advisors that,
were at the altar conference, like James Burns and others.
So he's very well prepared by the time he gets to meet with Stalin and Churchill.
He is a voracious reader from when he's a child.
And so he just reads and reads and reads and gets himself up to speed.
And he surrounds himself with really good people.
Over the first 12 months of his presidency, he essentially replaces all of the FDR's cabinet
with his own people and his closest advisors really come through for him.
Yeah.
I mean, he's had two senatorial terms.
to get used to federal governance, and he's a big presence on the hill.
But nonetheless, this is another level altogether.
Let's talk about the story of the moment when Truman finds out he is president.
This is April 12, 1945.
He's about to start a poker game when the phone rings, and he's asked to come to the White House.
Right. He's in the Speaker Raybourne's office when he gets that call, probably a few drinks with that poker game, too, I would imagine.
It's late afternoon, early evening, and he's.
rushed over to the White House. He contacts his wife Bess and his daughter Margaret, who's 20 years
old in 1944, so 21 in 1945. She's about to go on a date. And so her mother has her change
clothes into something a bit more sensible and meets him in the White House. And he meets Eleanor
Roosevelt there. And they do the inauguration at the White House right immediately around
just after 7 o'clock in the evening. And FDR had passed away late.
afternoon in Georgia. Eleanor Roosevelt is there and he asks Eleanor, you know, is there anything I can do
for you? And their famous response is, Harry, you're the one that's in trouble now. Is there anything
we can do for you? So he has thrust right into the limelight immediately. Yes. And so begins this
amazing journey that he is about to undertake. He not only has to, of course, step into the
official duties, but he has to emotionally carry the nation forward, a nation that has for 12 years,
I suppose, been handled by FDR through the Depression and through World War II.
It's an incredible time.
Whole generations have been born into this time.
And suddenly this man has this unenviable task to help them understand this and to make this transition with him.
Yeah, it's a really incredible time.
He comes in in April.
Falling month, Germany surrenders.
You know, we have to decide what to do with Germany.
Are we going to do like we did at the end of World War I and treat them harshly?
you know, what are we going to do in Western Europe?
And then attentions, of course, turned to Asia,
and the war in Asia is still being very violently fought
until he dropped the atomic bond in August.
And he's already looking ahead to international alliances
like the United Nations very shortly after that,
in the late 40s, the creation of NATO,
creation of the CIA,
all of these things are all coming into fruition.
Not to mention the domestic issue,
that he's going to face with all of these soldiers coming home and wanting jobs
and also the issues of civil rights when you've had African-American soldiers fighting in Europe
but coming home to segregated society.
So it's just so many issues to look at.
It is overwhelming.
I mean, it's really fair to say that, in my opinion,
Truman is the first modern of our time, a U.S. president,
because he really does have to turn the wheel and change direction completely.
on major issues that have been taken for granted for better or worse by many Americans.
You mentioned already something I want to say before we get into the heavy-duty international stuff,
obviously, in the summer.
The reconversion is the term that I didn't even, wasn't familiar with before getting ready for this.
Reconverting the economy from war to peacetime is the whole process of sort of reabsorbing all these soldiers who are coming home.
Yeah, it's really challenging because these soldiers have been gone.
you know, America comes in the war in 1941, you know, two years after it starts in Europe.
And those soldiers have been there both in Europe and in Asia and, of course, other parts of the globe too, in Africa and other places.
Bringing those soldiers home and, as they say, reconverting them back into domestic jobs.
Many women had taken those jobs while the men have been gone.
And so many of those women don't want to necessarily go back to being housewives.
But then it's also things like during the war, you had price.
controls. And so do you keep those price controls as they are to keep the economy stable? Do you let
those price controls lapse, but then worry about inflation? The industries have kept controls on all of
the goods like steel and raw materials for industry for the war. Do you then let them increase
those prices of raw materials? So there becomes a lot of strikes, a lot of unrest in the factories
as there's wrestling about price controls.
And the Republicans and the Democrats actually disagree on that.
It actually becomes an election issue in 1948 as well.
So the economy side of things is very difficult to manage for Truman.
Yeah.
And so inflation is a huge problem.
I mean, it's just spiking prices all over the place.
He creates what's called the fair deal.
I mean, he's a solid new dealer.
He's carrying on the same agenda of his predecessor,
but kind of re-ups it as what's called the fair
deal. What generally was that changing? So he's looking primarily at domestic issues. So he's looking,
but he's looking at everything. And in fact, he makes a major address in September after the Japanese
surrender in 1945. He puts forward many, many points on health care, education, civil rights,
labor. You name the domestic issue. He covers all of it, but it's way too ambitious. He comes
back. He gets some of it through Congress, but he comes back in January of 1949 in his second
term and puts forward many of these proposals again because he has a more favorable Congress at
that point. Again, some of it is passed, but a lot of it is blocked or he gets partial
accomplishments. But one of the key things about that fair deal is that many succeeding
presidents go back to that and actually pass some of that legislation. So like Lyndon Johnson
in the 1960s, passes legislation for Medicare and actually signs that at the Truman Library
and Independence with Harry Truman on the stage and gives Harry Truman and his wife the first
two cards as a nod to Truman trying to pass that in the 1940s.
So there's a long legacy there for those third deal programs.
If you want to understand the stability of the U.S. governance on the federal level,
it really is one hand to the next, from the FDR to Truman to even Eisenhower.
straight through to LBJ with Kennedy in there.
It's amazing.
In July, Truman is now the third of the big three.
He meets at Postom, as we've mentioned in Germany, with Stalin and Churchill.
Churchill is then replaced by Adley halfway through.
And this is all about finalizing the terms of the close of World War II,
in particular the fate of Poland.
Everything was really about Poland to start with, wasn't it?
It was.
Yeah, and it's one of those, I think, Churchill really fought the hardest for Poland.
and was really digging his heels in.
But unfortunately, for Churchill and Truman, the Red Army is already there.
They're already in Germany.
You know, they're already in East Berlin.
And so those lines have been drawn.
And to push them back, that's reopening another conflict.
They try to get democratic elections and make all kinds of compromises, but ultimately it fails.
And this failure to create those elections, to, you know, the self-determination
of Poland really is the first moment for Truman about the Cold War, isn't it? This is, he realizes
who he's dealing with and it's not going to be compromised. Yeah, some historians argue the Cold War
starts at Potsdam. Others say it comes a little bit later in December of 1945 with a crisis in Iran
where the Soviets don't pull out of Iran as they had promised as well. And others would argue,
you know, Churchill's I and current speech in March of 1946. But either way, the signs of there,
Truman is trying to negotiate with Stalin and really just not, he's getting frustrated with him.
It's interesting because at the beginning of the conference in our, in our archives,
we've got 1,300 letters.
Harry Truman writes to his wife, Best Wallace, over their lifetime.
And he writes from Potsdam.
And the first impression he says to his wife, best, I like Stalin.
I can deal with him.
But that's day one.
By the end of the conference, he's become increasingly frustrated and because he sees
no negotiation there. The Red Army's in place and it's hard to shift that. Yeah, maybe it's his logistical
mindset, the mind of an artillery man, you know, strategizing the future and how far his firing
will go. He is such a methodical guy, Harry Truman. You can kind of backtrack, you know,
hindsight and see where all of these big themes come from. And then they sort of move forward. I guess
that's true of most presidencies, but especially so with Truman. Yeah, and I felt, I think he feels like he's a
negotiator. You mentioned he was in Congress for 10 years. He worked with both sides of the aisle as
president. The domestic issues he gets through, he does with great Republican support on some of those
issues like the Marshall Plan. He couldn't have got that pass without Republican support. And he's a
Democrat, of course. And I think he thought he could negotiate in the same way with Stalin. But
there were a few compromises. His main goal actually was to get Stalin to agree to invade Japan,
to help bring the war to an end quickly.
And Stalin did agree to do that.
I think they regretted that a little bit later
because Stalin went straight into Manchuria
in early August of 1945.
But I think Truman saw the end goal
that of trying to end the war as quickly as possible
and used his negotiation there to get Stalin
to get involved on that side of the war.
Let's talk about that.
In August comes, of course,
the fateful decision to use the atomic bomb
to end the war with Japan.
referring listeners to our past episode number 99, entitled Oppenheimer, What If America Never Drops, and our first episode of the entire series in September 22 was the atomic bomb in the Secret City.
There's a lot to talk about here, of course.
But as far as Truman is concerned, what is his basic reasoning?
Have we learned all we're going to know about why he decided to use the weapon?
You know, it's a lot simpler than people think in terms of his motivation.
he wanted to end the war as quickly as possible to save American lives as quickly as possible.
And once that technology was put in front of him, that would achieve those two aims.
Get out of the war, save American lives.
Seems rather blunt and simplistic, but everything I've read in the 28 years I've worked at the Truman Library,
he never wavers from that at the time.
And then in his writings and interviews he does later on, he never wavers from that position.
It was my father's favorite lesson to me.
He was in the Philippines waiting for that attack on the home islands, and he said, you
wouldn't be here without Harry Truman.
That was what he always talked it up to, whether that was correct or not.
That was my dad's version of things.
I was going to say, we hear that a lot from museum visitors that come through the museum,
whether it's veterans themselves or children of veterans that come through our museum.
Many leave the museum actually weeping as they appreciate Truman's decision because it's
safe to family member.
He writes in his journal, well, it's a
quote from the Potsdam days, actually, we have discovered the most terrible bomb in the history of the
world. It may be the fire destruction prophesized in the Euphrates Valley era after Noah and his
fabulous arc. I mean, he was aware of the ratifications of what was happening. He was aware of how big
this was, certainly militarily, but scientifically, I suppose, right? Yeah, certainly after the first
reports came through from Hiroshima, once those reports landed on his desk, he actually did something
really, really important that's often overlooked is that he takes the control of the atomic bomb away
from the military and it becomes under the president. So once it was available in August, he gives
the military carte blanche to use it initially. After the second bombing of Nagasaki, he then takes
that back and says any future use by anybody has to be at the direction of the president and not
any military general. And that's the way it is today, and that's a huge legacy of the atomic age
and of Truman's decision to do that is incredibly important. As mentioned earlier, it's
useful to see Truman's presidency in two parts, obviously defined by his election in 1948.
Before that, he's stepping into the role. But even before that, in May of 48, there's the founding
of Israel, which I dare say most Americans forget was on Harry Truman's watch, that all this happened.
was a huge advocate of Israel, recognized them 11 minutes after they announced the nation against
the wishes of some of his closest aides? Yeah, it's one of those decisions we examine really
closely at the museum because it's one of the very few decisions where cabinet members,
his own cabinet members, some of them disagreed with him. And that's pretty unusual for
the Truman administration. Most notably, George Marshall, who's the Secretary of State,
is adamantly opposed to this. And they, there's a very important.
a famous meeting a couple of days prior to the recognition of Israel that they have in the
Oval Office, which is known now as the showdown in the Oval Office, where they had Clark Cliffordish
Council is advocating for the recognition of Israel, and George Marshall is arguing very strongly
against it. The really important thing to remember here is that George Marshall is a hero of
Harry Truman's. Harry Truman describes him as being the most important living American
obviously his role in World War II is legendary.
And Truman really has him on a pedestal more than any other advisor.
So for him to go against Marshall,
it really shows his strength of the decision he's going to make,
the character that he has.
He kind of dances around it in the meeting and says,
you know, we'll just adjourn the meeting and we'll think on it
and then have his advisors go talk to Marshall
and try and get him to come around,
which they eventually do.
But that is a really tough decision.
swayed by two people. He's swayed by his army friend and the friend that he opened the clothing
store with. Eddie Jacobson is a World War I veteran. He's Jewish and it was the Truman and Jacobson
clothing store, the Haberdasherie. So they've been friends, you know, since World War I. And Eddie Jacobson
advocates for the recognition of Israel. But Eddie Jacobson also does something really important.
And that is he introduces Harry Truman to Hime Wiseman, who is going to, is the leader of the Zionist,
organization is going to become one of the first leaders in Israel once the government is established,
and he has a couple of secret meetings in the White House with Heim Weisman.
And once Harry Truman meets Weisman, who's a very charismatic figure, Truman's decision is made.
He's going to go forward with that.
Much to the disappointment of George Marshall and much to the disappointment of the U.S. delegation to the United Nations who are completely unaware that Truman is going to make this decision.
And why does he make the decision?
reason. Well, I think a lot of it is, you mentioned the Bible a couple of times. Truman is a Christian.
You know, he grows up, you know, he's not a church every weekend or anything like that, but he sees
this as being kind of foretold in the Bible of the Jews going to return to the homeland. And so he
sees some of it there. I think the reports of the Holocaust, which have come through to his death by then,
of course, really hit home, emotionally and morally, to find a place for them. And he feels like
the Jews cannot go back and live in Germany and Poland and all of these places that they've faced
anti-Semitism. And so I think he feels like this is the best option for the Jews to go to
the land of Palestine. Interesting how the fate of Poland in the Potsdam Conference plays through
to the founding of Israel, isn't it?
There is a connection there for sure.
But I think it's really more of a moral decision, I think, rather than the political one.
George Marshall, though, does question the political motives.
He thinks there's an election later that year, thinks that he's going after Jewish votes.
And there is some argument there.
Some historians have made that argument.
But New York, where the most Jewish votes are, the candidate that he's running against Thomas Dewey is the governor of New York.
and Dewey is always going to win the New York Electoral College votes.
So that was kind of out of play.
But certainly that was an argument that's been made by George Marshall and then some historians since then as well.
It immediately sparks a war with the Arabs.
I mean, it's an incredibly faithful decision.
Immediately the next day, yeah.
He didn't regret it in the face of that war?
No, and in fact, by January of 1949, Israel has won that war against five Arab nations.
They were far stronger on the ground.
built up a militia. And by January of 1949, the compromise that Truman made with Marshall is that
Israel would have democratic elections, which they do. And in January of 1949, Truman gives
full legal recognition to Israel because they are now an established nation and they've had elections.
Not too long after, June 1948, the Berlin airlift begins. Now, understand, this is to anyone who's not
familiar. Berlin is actually, surprisingly, in East Germany. So,
when the divide happens as a result of various circumstances, West Berlin, which we're taking care of,
is in the middle of East Germany. So at that point, Salon wants to sort of take over West Berlin.
Truman stands up to this and begins what's called the Berlin airlift, which just goes on for a
very long time, more than a year from June 48 to September 49. They do 277,000 flights into
Templehof Airport, making it forever a shrine of this Western rescue effort.
It's an incredibly interesting moment that Harris Truman really is the architect of, isn't he?
Yeah, it's an amazing episode in history. It's the largest humanitarian effort in world history at that time, which is rather remarkable.
As you're right, Germany itself had been divided into four zones with the Russians, United States, the British and the French dividing up into kind of four quarters, if you like.
But you're right, Berlin is inside of that Soviet zone. And that city of Berlin is also divided into four.
Now, the British, the French and the Americans all unite together to merge their zones into one.
Stalin blocks off the trains, the canals, the roads. So the only way in is by a flight.
There was really strong concerns by the military that any flights going in might be shot down if they brought in supplies.
and Truman took that risk to do that with a number of other pilots from other countries as well,
British pilots, Australian pilots, Canadian pilots.
It was a kind of a national effort.
It was one of those you see now with these relief efforts that are multinational.
It was one of those first of that nature as well.
It's an incredibly logistical effort to bring in flights from the different zones to land in, West Berlin,
and really help two million of Berlin.
to survive. There's two million people. There are some argument that they're actually receiving so
much food and goods and the United Kingdom is still in rations in 1948 that the West Berlin
population was actually eating more food than they were in the United Kingdom. But that's just
one of those side steps of the story. It really becomes an incredible story. And if you think about
it, it's only three years since Germany was the enemy. So it kind of goes hand in hand later on
with the Marshall Plan of how to rebuild your enemy, not treat them like you did after World War
1, which Truman was very aware of.
It defines that the overall Cold War mission of the West, and certainly the U.S.,
to contain and address Soviet expansion, that becomes the cause for decades to come.
It starts really with Berlin Airlift.
Yeah, containment is the right word, and that was the policy that they used under George
Kennan's writings and so forth to go forward.
containment. There's a key part of that it is to stop the spread of communism, but it's to do so
without going to war as much as they could. That ultimately fails when it comes to Korea in
1950, but in 1947 with Greece and Turkey and with the Berlin airlift in 1948, they really
try to halt the spread of communism as much as they can, either with military aid or with economic
aid. It will be the beginning of what becomes the Truman Doctrine to stop the dominance,
no theory from unfolding.
To me, this is so interesting to look at Harry Truman's presidency because everything's so
packed, so much happens.
I mean, we're not even to his elected term yet.
And all this incredible stuff has happened.
If not for someone like this man who could jump into the deep end of the pool and just
swim, it's hard to believe this would have been such a successful unfolding of the American
century.
Yeah, I think his character comes through.
he's not afraid to make the decision to get the advice of the right people, to put the right people
around him. But what you're really hinting out there is the legacy afterwards. All of these
decisions he makes, it redraars the map of Europe, it begins the creation of NATO. The Marshall Plan
ultimately leads to the European Union and the United Nations is created in June of 1945.
All of those things set the stage for the rest of the 20th century.
Yeah. This is a college dropout who was farming in his 30s.
Truman's 1948 campaign is overlooked for how much it also redefines 20th century federal politics.
I mean, his choices, especially regarding civil rights, specifically to do with African Americans in the military and in the federal workforce, those are in direct conflict with the holdovers of Jim Crow segregation.
Truman breaks that political logjam in the Democratic Party, in that convention.
It starts with him.
Yeah, it's an amazing story.
It's a political gamble in a way because part of his party walks out of the convention in 1948
when they pass the civil rights plank that the Democrats are going to forge.
He'd actually made a deliberate an address, a written address rather than a speech in February of
1948 laying out his civil rights message.
They carry that through in the convention in the summer.
And what we call the Dixiecrats or the Southern Democrats actually walk out of the convention
and form their own party on the right wing of the party.
And at the same time, we mentioned Henry Wallace a little bit earlier.
He's on the left wing of the party and was the former vice president under FDR.
He forms his own party, the progressive party on the left.
So suddenly in this convention, the party is split three ways.
So everybody thinks there's no way Harry Truman can win when his party's been split in that way.
This convention really changes the political calculus of the Democratic Party.
In the early era of the 1900s, you have W.B. Du Bois and black intellectuals who are really addressing Jim Crow, and that leads to the NAACP.
There's a tremendous groundswell of really intellectual and political daring due in the black population of America.
That is joined then after World War II by this faction of the Democratic Party led by Harry Truman.
That's the beginning of the civil rights movement that spawns Martin Luther King Jr.
And all the rest of it.
It's amazing journey that goes on.
And Truman is squarely in the middle of that timeline.
Yeah, it's really interesting because for a long time here in the United States,
you know, the school textbooks talk about the civil rights starting in the 1960s.
And now they're starting to push that back to World War II.
And even World War I, quite frankly, there's quite a number of movements there too.
But certainly in terms of presidential actions,
Truman is the first that takes that step with executive orders in the summer of 1948.
Again, right before that election in November, in July of 1948, is when he integrates the military
and integrates the federal workforce.
The other thing, though, too, you mentioned the NACP.
He actually was the first president to address that group in the summer of 1947 the year before.
And so that really plays well.
And then when he's campaigning in the 48 election, he's the first president.
to go to Harlem and makes a speech in Harlem right just in the week before the election itself.
Yeah, it's interesting. It is in this convention that Hubert Humphrey emerges as a leader from
Minnesota. Paul Douglas, Illinois. These are the guys who are really pushing this white Democratic
party to think differently about the civil rights plank, which will, of course, they know
alienate all those Southern Democrats who had such power. You know, it's kind of you're replaying
everything from the Civil War in some other version right now.
And this is where, you know, those Dixie Crads go off with Strom Thurman and you end up,
we've lost the South, which is what eventually creates Nixon's whole power base.
But nonetheless, and this is the theme of Harry Truman.
He forges onward.
He understands how this is going to work, but he knows where his values are.
And that is really very clear with Truman where it comes from for him.
Yeah, I think it's the center of it is really his moral character.
He realizes it's the right thing to do.
And if he doesn't get elected, then at least he stood up for his morals.
It's really interesting, though, because he comes from a southern background.
His grandparents on both sides of his family owned slaves.
His own wife has been accused of being racist and other friends write to him.
Like, what are you doing?
You know, they're really questioning his decision.
But he stands firm on it.
Yep.
It's two weeks after that convention.
July 26, 1948, Truman signs two executive orders.
9980, 9981. They should be etched in stone in Washington, D.C., but they're forgotten.
Those two executive orders order the desegregation of the U.S. military and of the federal workforce.
Huge moment. This is turning around what Woodrow Wilson did decades earlier.
Huge moment in American life, largely overlooked. Thank you, Harry Truman.
Well, the thing to say about the two is when you think about it, that means in 19, you know, during World War II, the African
American soldiers who fought bravely were actually did so in segregated units. And then think about
what they're fighting against, which was Nazi Germany, practicing racial policies, and you've got
segregated troops fighting against that, it doesn't compute, right? So when they come home,
it's a real struggle. And Truman should deserve and does get a lot of credit. You mentioned Executive
Order 998.1, if I may, I was very fortunate to go to the National Archives building in Washington, D.C.
last year for a civil rights symposium. And they had the original Executive Order 9981 on display.
And so for the first time in my life, I got to see that original document at the National Archives
Rotunda in Washington, D.C. So that was really, really, really special moment to see Harry Truman's
signature on that document. My wife is African American and her aunt, her grandmother, beloved woman
in her 90s. I were talking on the phone the other day. And she said, yeah, I like that Harry Truman.
she said to me. And that is a common... That's high praise, right? Yeah, the common feelings about that
from that generation, about Truman's courage. Taking this whole thing to task was really on his
watch. Let's talk about that election, the famous newspaper photograph I referred to in the opening,
which is, you know, Dewey defeats Truman. It was going to be a close election, certainly made
no easier for himself by alienating the South as he did. How does this all play out and how come
he wins? It's a really good question. We just actually had an exhibit about that 48 election.
that I curated here at the museum. It's an amazing story. It's kind of the probably the biggest
surprise election victory in U.S. political history. I think a lot of it is he kind of focuses on
very few messages. He doesn't attack his opponent, Thomas Dewey, very much. He does once or twice.
His main opponent tends to be the Republican Congress that came in in the 1946 midterm elections.
The Republicans won the House and the Senate for the first time in a generation. So in the
the summer of 48 after the conventions as they start to strategize, they really start this campaign
in September through November. And most of his speeches are attacking what he calls the do nothing
Congress. He kind of calls them out in the convention speech and, you know, says if you're
promising all of these things because the Republican convention had been the week before,
then go ahead and pass him. And the Republicans don't pass that legislation. It's all false
promises. And he reminds the audiences as he travels 30,000 miles on the train around the country
in his famous whistlestop campaign, that this Congress is doing nothing. Can you need to reelect
a Democratic president, a Democratic Congress? And ultimately, that's what happens. But I think a lot of
it, too, is the momentum he builds with these campaign speeches. He goes to every small town,
every large city. He goes to everywhere crisscross in the country numerous times. And the
Momentum just builds through September and October to early November the time of the election.
The momentum just keeps growing as he campaigns.
So much of that first elected term, I mean, keep in mind, he could have run again in 1954
constitutionally. He had only served one. He'd been only been elected once.
That second term will be defined by the Korean War and the creation of the Truman Doctrine,
as I mentioned. And that eventually leads to Vietnam. Then there's the Cold War really heating
up under Truman. So let's take this question, and primarily we're talking about these years that
we've discussed today, him taking over the presidency and then the first term. Harry Truman lands
on the good side of history, always listed in the top quarter of American presidents, but somehow
despite the amazing events that occurred on his watch, these decisive moves made by him that changed
American history, the man really doesn't get the credit he deserves. Why do you think that is?
Well, I think a lot of this unpopularity in the second turn becomes about because of the Korean War.
It evolves into a stalemate by 1952 when the election would have taken place.
And it's bogged down and they can't seem to weigh out of it.
And I think that as he leaves office, he's got a pretty low approval rating, as you suggest.
But really, I think it takes until in 1970s before he's reevaluated.
Some of that is the process of time.
and you see what happens in Vietnam.
But I think the biggest issue there is Richard Nixon.
When Richard Nixon is forced to resign, people then start hearkening back to presidents
with moral character and behaved better in the White House, let's put it that way.
And they start getting nostalgic about that kind of president.
And Truman is the shining light of that when people look at that.
And then, of course, he dies in 1972 as well.
So it's right in that year in 1972, 1972, 1973, that he gets a boost through his demise,
which seems an odd thing to say.
And then a number of biographies come out.
Those mostly come out, his own autobiography, but then I think the other one in the early 1990s
is the biography of Truman by David McCuller and then ultimately an HBO movie in 1995.
Those two things, the Watergate scandal are Nixon and Truman's death, and then 15, 20 years
later the David McCullough biography, those two things start to elevate. I think to the end of the
Cold War in 1989, we look at, well, that wouldn't have been possible if Truman had not drawn the
line in Berlin and things like that. Yeah, right. So a number of things, but those three seem to stand out.
And let us not discount James Whitmore and give them hell Harry. Right. Right. And Chicago,
you know, pining for Harry Truman in their song. So. Yeah, exactly. It's really fascinating. I'm
excited by the fact that we have not told this whole story because it goes on after this,
and we will do so in a following episode.
Mark Adams is the director of the Harry S. Truman Library and Museum.
In Independence, Missouri, I encourage folks to go see that.
Even this summer, who knows, it's a really fascinating day.
That will give you a real interesting view of this man.
Thank you so much, Mark.
Thank you, Don. It was a real pleasure.
Hello, folks. Thanks for listening to American History Hit.
Each week, we release new episodes,
two new episodes dropping Mondays and Thursdays.
All kinds of great content, like mysterious missing colonies to powerful political movements,
to some of the biggest battles across the centuries.
Don't miss an episode.
By hitting like and follow, you help us out, which is great.
But you'll also be reminded when our shows are on.
And while you're at it, share with a friend.
American History Hit with me, Don Wildman.
So grateful for your support.
Thanks so much.
