American Scandal - Listen Now: OnlyFantasy

Episode Date: May 21, 2026

Is what’s happening on OnlyFans real? Or is it only a fantasy?In this provocative investigation into OnlyFans—the adult platform where subscribers around the world spent more than $7 billion in 2024—journalist Leon Neyfakh teams up with comedian and OnlyFans creator Gracie Canaan for a one-of-a-kind exploration into the current state of human connection. Throughout, they discover that the site originally built for spicy adult content has quietly and surprisingly become something more complicated— an emotional marketplace where desire, performance, care, fantasy, and vulnerability seemingly blur together.As Neyfakh and Canaan navigate timely questions about autonomy, performance, and profit, a question emerges: is connection mediated by a screen still authentic? To find the answer, they meet creators building lucrative businesses, subscribers who believe they’ve found something real, professional “chatters” who are paid to simulate affection, and pioneers who have helped engineer intimacy at scale.Captivating and tender, OnlyFantasy is ultimately about the cost of loneliness, the seductive power of desire, and how the rules of human intimacy are being rewritten online.Listen to OnlyFantasy wherever you get your podcasts. Or binge all episodes of OnlyFantasy ad-free right now on Audible. Start your Audible subscription in the Audible App or on Apple Podcasts.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

I'm Leon Nafak, best known as the co-creator of Slow Burn and Fiasco. I'm a 41-year-old writer, podcaster, and dad. I had, of course, heard of OnlyFans, but always with a distant and quiet skepticism, a silent judgment, you could say. Who was actually using this platform? So when I found out that my own sister had started an OnlyFans account, my journalistic curiosity got the best of me. And to my surprise, it led me down a year-long reporting journey.

Luckily, I found the perfect co-pilot for this wild ride. Hi, I'm Gracie Canaan, OnlyFans creator and comedian. Not Leon's sister, I might add. Let's just say I had a different POV on OnlyFans and why people use it. Our podcast, OnlyFantasy, is a show about the changing nature of adult content, sex work, and human intimacy itself. We're about to play a clip from Only Fantasy. You can listen to the show wherever you get your podcasts,

and Audible subscribers can binge all episodes of Only Fantasy. fantasy, ad-free right now. Start your audible subscription in the Audible app or on Apple Podcasts. Oh, it's definitely that house. Which is funny because it's like all the houses around it are just regular ranch homes. Last summer, our team flew out to Los Angeles, the home of the adult entertainment industry. Look at that. Whoa.

That is not discreet. And in this moment, we were pulling up to a huge house in the middle of an unassuming neighborhood in the valley. To anyone not in the know, it might have looked like any regular. old mansion. But to me, it was the modern Playboy mansion. Right here. Creators Inc. When we walked up to the house, we were greeted at the gate by a woman in California casual attire. Pink Gene Cutoffs, Doc Martins, and a Creators Inc. baseball cap. And don't forget the most important L.A. accessory of all. A dazzling, perfect smile.

Welcome to Creators Inc. I'm Kayla Parcell's co-founder and C.O. And where are we, Kayla? We're at our content house here in Encinoc. California. Creators, Inc. is an agency that represents some of the most successful creators on OnlyFans. And this was their content house. Imagine a we work, except it's a mansion with photogenic lighting and a pool. A pool that no one was actually swimming in, by the way, which was telling, because more than anything, this place was a set, designed so that every corner, every room, could serve

as an attractive backdrop for photos and videos. We can kind of do anything in this space and just having it be that canvas for what our creators want to do and use their vision and ideas, and we make that come to life for them. We were here to get a glimpse of the day-to-day operations of elite creators and the teams of professionals who support their careers. We wanted to see how the business of only fans was conducted. I've never been one to covet the glamorous influencer life, but in the weeks leading up to this trip, we'd been reading about and talking to creators who were bringing in wheelbarrows of money each month. And seeing those numbers made me hungry.

not just to make money so I could pay the bills, but for real wealth, like prosperity. Because as an OF creator, it actually felt within reach for me for the first time in my life. So stepping into this house, I was like Eve looking at the apple, which I guess made our girl Kayla the ultimate creator. I never do interviews. I am strategically the person out of the picture. You know, I hide in the background. It's not about us. It's about our creators and letting them shine and making sure we give them the best opportunity. Kayla, a former gymnastics coach at MIT turned entrepreneur, presided over the scene kind of like a benevolent RA. She gave us the grand tour of the place, where on any given day you can find young women from the Creators Inc. roster and a few men, working out, shooting videos, and lounging. This is our spa. So if you're into the cold plunge and the infrared sauna, this is your place.

The cold plunge is a very popular spot, especially today when it's 100 degrees. I couldn't help but notice Gracie's office. light up every time Kayla showed us another amenity at the house. A few feet from the cold plunge, there was a pop-up shop of Creators Inc. bikinis, because apparently it was L.A. Swin League. I thought you were coming to shoot for CI Swinwear. I thought you were like someone from the ART. I mean, I'm asking.

You want to? Since you're here, we'd love to have you. But I really thought that's what you would have one. If my coworkers weren't right here, I feel like it would be so, like, do you guys want to go away for 45 minutes? No, but I'll be literally like, I'm here. often, so I'll hit you up. And also, maybe you want to work with this, yes. Okay, Grace, you'd be honest, how

badly did you want to do this photo shoot when Kayla asked you? Oh my God, could you tell? Yes. I was, I couldn't help it. I was so embarrassed how badly I wanted it because it was like one bikini away from being a creator's anchor girl. That's right. Ten feet from stardom. 10 feet picks from stardom.

Sorry. Not to ask a good question, but like, do you people film sex here, too? No. Okay. Is that a rule? I prefer it that way. It was funny how awkward it felt to bring up sex, as if it wasn't at the center of the Creators Inc. business model.

Though, honestly, walking around the house with its pastel color scheme and ample nooks, you wouldn't know porn had anything to do with it. I mean, ample nooks sounds pretty porn-y to me. But to be clear, I don't think Kayla meant there was no nudity allowed in the house, just that actual sex on camera was frowned upon. They definitely keep the creator's inkhouse clean on purpose. Kayla told us she regularly invites family members of creators to come see the house so they can be reassured that their daughter or sister isn't being forced to work out of some shady brothel.

There is a dark, scary place that women can fall into, and this is a really wonderful, safe, supported. Fifth Wave feminism is what I like to call it. Yeah, where we're kind of flipping that, and you are making this something much more positive. I'm going to be honest, this. This house wasn't really giving me Audrey Lord vibes. And much like those parents Kayla mentioned bringing to the house, we were definitely getting the shiny, rosy version of OnlyFans. But still, I believed Kayla when she said she wants more for her clients than just being

famous as OnlyFans creators. She told us, Creators Inc. has helped women launch skin care lines and fashion brands. She even introduced us to one woman who had used her OnlyFans income to start a trucking company back home in Texas. The way Kayla sees it, OF is simply the best way for these women to bankroll their ambitions, whatever they may be. This is the new Hollywood, and basically, you know, if you're going to set yourself up for the rest of your life, like this is your opportunity. Hollywood felt like the opposite of what I thought OnlyFans was supposed to be. Instead of focusing on building one-on-one genuine connections between creators and subscribers,

here was a factory churning out hyper-c curated and highly produced images of so-called authentically. of course that didn't mean Kayla was wrong it just made me think only fan stardom was more complicated than I'd realized binge all episodes of only fantasy ad free right now on audible start your audible subscription in the audible app or on apple podcasts