Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard - Michelle Williams
Episode Date: May 19, 2025Michelle Williams (Dying for Sex, Manchester by the Sea, Brokeback Mountain) is a Golden Globe-winning and Oscar and Tony-nominated actress. Michelle joins the Armchair Expert to discuss what... constitutes an apex dinosaur skeleton, thinking she may have had one of the the last great American childhoods, and missing getting into good trouble and trying to recreate those opportunities for her kids. Michelle and Dax talk about why nature is the greatest impartial teacher of danger and safety, not realizing that she’s the type of person that makes people nervous, and becoming emancipated at 15 before booking Dawson’s Creek. Michelle explains whether she sensed what Brokeback Mountain would become while she was making it, seeing her work as a record of herself to leave for her kids, and being overwhelmed by emotion listening to the source material for Dying for Sex.Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Watch new content on YouTube or listen to Armchair Expert early and ad-free by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ now.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Wondry Plus subscribers can listen to Armchair Expert early
and ad free right now.
Join Wondry Plus in the Wondry app or on Apple podcasts,
or you can listen for free wherever you get your podcasts.
Welcome, welcome, welcome to Armchair Expert.
I'm Dak Shepard.
You know, I saw a comment.
I said Dan Shepard, as I do often.
And someone wrote, why Dan?
And I wrote, I know you're a new listener, welcome.
Oh, nice.
And then the person wrote, you're right.
I started listening like eight weeks ago or something.
Oh, fun.
Yeah, yeah, and I said,
oh, I just get bored saying my name.
Right.
Yeah.
I get bored easy.
I thought maybe he was asking like,
what's, is there an original impetus for it?
I mean, I always think of the worst thing, right?
That's my gift.
So my assumption when someone says that is more like,
they've found out Dax was a bullshit name.
Like it was my stage name.
Oh.
That's what I maybe fear people think.
Oh, that's funny.
Anyways, I'm joined by Monica Lilly Padman, real name.
Real name.
On your birth certificate and your driver's license.
Today we have one of the most acclaimed actors
we've had on the show, Michelle Williams.
Oh, she's so good.
I wish it said right here, but I wanna say
it's like five Academy Award nominations or something.
Bonkers, definitely four and I think maybe five.
Emmy win, Tony nomination.
Yeah, she's just a powerhouse.
Blue Valentine, Dawson's Creek originally.
That's where we fell in love with her.
Brokeback Mountain, my week with Marilyn.
Manchester by the Sea, my favorite.
Five nominations.
Five nominations.
And her new series that's out now
with my former boss, Liz Merriwether, Dying for Sex on FX and Hulu.
Right now, I urge everyone to go watch it.
It's very bold.
It goes horrid.
Yeah, it does.
Please enjoy Michelle Williams.
If it's a flat or a squeal, a wobble or peel,
your dread's worn down or you need a new wheel.
Wherever you go, you can get a pro, like Tread Experts. Until May 30th, purchase four new Michelin passenger You know those creepy stories that give you goosebumps?
The ones that make you really question what's real?
Well, what if I told you that some of the strangest, darkest, and most mysterious stories
are not found in haunted houses or abandoned forests, but instead in hospital rooms and
doctor's offices?
Hi, I'm Mr. Ballin, the host of Mr.ollin's Medical Mysteries, and each week on my podcast,
you can expect to hear stories about bizarre illnesses no one can explain, miraculous recoveries
that shouldn't have happened, and cases so baffling they stumped even the best doctors.
So if you crave totally true and thoroughly twisted horror stories and mysteries, Mr.
Bollin's Medical Mysteries should be your new go-to weekly show.
Listen to Mr. Bollens Medical Mysteries on the Wondry app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen early and ad-free right now by joining Wondry Plus in the Wondry app or
on Spotify or Apple podcasts. He's an up-chance-boy.
He's an up-chance-boy.
He's an up-chance-boy.
He's an up-chance-boy.
I know what I'm talking about.
That's a tour bus.
My neighbors think Aerosmith's spending the night.
Guys, that's so fun and amazing.
Kids must love that.
They do.
In fact, last year we were going to go up to Idaho
and everyone was busy.
So Kristen was like, let's just fly.
We had driven the previous four years in the bus.
And the kids were like, we're not going
unless we're on the bus.
I'm so jealous.
They have bunk beds.
That's my absolute dream for my kids.
I went to Stig Matilda and an RV on a big road trip
and I was like, this is the greatest.
This is the greatest.
Oh my god, it's incredible for kids.
I want to get an old VW bus and retrofit it.
Make it cute.
A micro bus?
Yes.
Yes.
Yes.
Give me a micro bus.
What would you like to drink?
We have coffee.
You got to go pee-pee?
I know I'm great. I wouldn't mind a water. It's an extra iced matcha if you want one. Oh, yes. What would you like to drink? We have coffee. You gotta go pee-pee?
I know I'm great.
I wouldn't mind a water.
It's an extra iced matcha if you want water.
Are you coming from France?
You don't want an extra iced matcha?
I don't know, I have to think about that.
It might be a little too late for me.
I might need to up all night.
You said that.
So flirty.
I know, it's so playful.
Too late for me to go to a party.
I got up at early.
Yeah.
It's my favorite thing about coming to LA
because by nine o'clock I'm totally comatose
and I can't even fight it and pretend to stay up
and keep accomplishing.
It feels like just being drugged.
I feel like I'm put under and I love it.
We wanna thank you.
We haven't been up here in a long time.
Oh really?
Yeah, we've been downstairs where there's video.
And so we haven't been in the attic for a long time.
We used to only do this
and then we were forced to add video.
But we like it. Now we like it.
We've been doing it a lot.
But this is the original space and it's really nice.
It's so cozy. I'm very happy to be here.
A lot of tears in here.
A lot of laughter. A lot of everything.
A lot of probably toots.
There's been some unfortunate toots.
So a small room for tooting.
Yeah, well, we invite it.
I don't ever do it when there's guests,
but Monica would sit where you're at for the fact check.
This is a questionable distance, right?
It's also that chair is like a sound absorber.
It really is.
A sound absorber and just a muffler in general.
And probably absorb... Well, I know absorbent.
And so a lot of times I'm like,
yeah, I think that's far enough away for me to try one.
And I've gotten away with most of them.
I usually out myself.
No, yeah, you do a good job.
I have a lot of integrity, Michelle.
That's so honest.
I have a lot of toot integrity.
Why were you late?
What have you been doing?
Not to out you for being late.
Podcasting.
You've been bopping around.
You were on a previous podcast?
Radio.
NPR?
Yeah, I was at NPR.
Which show were you doing?
Were you with Larry Mantle?
No, I was not with Larry Mantle.
Do you know Larry Mantle?
No.
Okay, this is one of my wife's huge crushes.
I don't know who that is.
Oh, she's in love with Larry Mantle.
He's a longtime KCRW, NPR.
He hosts a few shows.
He's got a very steady, calming voice.
He's older, but that's not who you're with.
You have a very steady, calming voice.
Oh, thank you so much.
Yeah.
Where are you talking to? My God, Dex just exploded. I with. You have a very steady calming voice. Oh, thank you so much. Yeah. What were you talking about?
My God, that just exploded.
I have to tune in, you know, it's a tough day for NPR.
I know.
It hasn't been cut,
but it's being threatened to be cut, that and PBS.
Yeah.
I rely on frontline.
I can't.
I can't.
The fact that these are real things happening.
Yeah, these are things that must go.
Yeah. You're good.
What are we gonna do? What's the plan?
I think the plan might be to get in your bus.
Is that a skull T-Rex?
We have a lot to catch you up on.
Monica and I want to invest in a real T-Rex skull.
They're very expensive,
but we want to monetize it
by renting out the mouth and turn it into a sex hotel.
Cause people would love to have sex in the mouth
of a T-Rex.
It's very novel.
I'm sad nobody can see my face right now.
What do you think?
Whoa.
Yeah.
Is that like, whoa?
Positive?
Yeah.
Whoa. Or just mind blowing in general. Is it the level of creativity that like, whoa? Positive? Yeah. Whoa.
Or just mind blowing in general.
Is it the level of creativity that has your mind blown?
Yeah, kind of.
I'm also just like thinking,
like what would I do in that school?
Right?
Yeah, you would hold onto a tooth at some point, I think.
You guys go for it.
Each room has a tooth.
Michelle, they're so expensive.
We heard that Leonardo DiCaprio has a full skeleton.
And I used to know the price tag on it.
We looked it up once, I forget.
It's outrageous.
They're very pricey, limited edition.
One of my little guys, this is Dino Man.
And we just got that new Apex
at the Museum of Natural History.
Ooh.
What's Apex?
It's a perfect stegosaurus specimen.
That's cool.
Just landed.
Ooh, they call it an apex if it's perfect.
Have you read?
That's its name. I think, I think. Look, I'm working an apex if it's perfect. Perfect. Have you read?
That's its name.
I think, I think.
Look, I'm working really hard to catch up
to his level of dino knowledge.
Yeah, it's hard to compete.
They gobble it up.
Have you read Unstoppable Us to him?
No, I don't know that one.
It's Yuval Harari who wrote Sapiens.
He did a kids version of Sapiens.
We've read it to our kids several times.
It's incredible.
Fantastic, his birthday's coming up, thank you so much.
They found many of these dinosaurs,
ding ding ding, in your birthplace.
Isn't Montana a big site for these skeletons?
I think it's why my son loves me.
It's a big point of connection for us,
that Montana is home to so many dinosaurs,
especially the Myasora, the great mother lizard.
Ooh.
You know your shit.
We're deep in.
And so my real claim to fame inside my home
is that I am also from Montana,
land of many dinosaurs.
Were you close to Billings or some city?
I grew up in a town called Kalispell,
which was quite small when I was growing up,
but now it's become kind of a big box town.
Kalispell is a beautiful place,
but it's close to Whitefish Lake, Flathead Lake.
And God bless you.
Sorry.
God bless you.
Thank you.
I'm embarrassed.
I've seen a lot of cute smiles in my life.
I know.
I think Michelle's might be the cutest.
It's very disarming.
It is.
I just imagine a guy pointing a gun at you
and saying like, give me your money,
and you hit him with that smile.
Do you think this is my best defense?
Yes.
And he would go, I feel so silly, what am I doing?
How could I hurt this little being?
That's good to know, because somebody told me recently
that you should just go for the eyes,
but I think instead I'll just give a big smile.
Because it's so disarming, and then boom to the eyes.
Yeah, I thought that was actually really helpful.
I hadn't heard the eye thing before,
that was new information to me.
That feels like a high probability of failure.
Because you gotta practice. And who are you gonna practice on? Exactly. Wait, that's another information to me. That feels like a high probability of failure. Because you gotta practice.
And who are you gonna practice on?
Exactly.
Wait, that's another thing we could invent.
A practice dummy.
Oh, with some kind of gooey eyes.
Squishy eye.
Polyurethane eyes.
That's a great one.
And it could also double as a, what do they call it?
Like a sensory.
Slime, fidget toy.
Yeah, slimy fidget.
All that kind of stuff.
This is a brainstorming addict.
We're trying to come up with at least seven good ideas
per interview.
Okay, so Montana, you were there till nine.
I was.
Have you taken the bus?
Actually, I have.
In fact, I was towing an obnoxious trailer
and we went, I'm embarrassed to admit,
but like one of these conferences
and it was at Yellowstone, that fancy place,
and then everything is set for you,
but I had to call ahead and I said,
so I have a 45 foot bus and a 22 foot trailer.
Is there any place to park for me?
And they're like, no, we're gonna have to meet you
at this service lot with the snow plows.
So we had to park there and then get shuttled into there.
Was there a real learning curve with that thing?
For most people, yeah, but I grew up working
for General Motors and I've been driving really large things
since I was young.
So you're very comfortable.
Some would argue too confident.
Got it.
Kristen often says she can't wait for the day
that she sees me parallel park as quick as I do and fuck up.
She's like, you know, your powers are going to fade
and I just can't wait till you just fucking blast into a car
or take out the side of the bus.
She's really looking forward to that.
But Montana, did you have that childhood
I would fantasize about?
I really did.
I think I had the last great American childhood
except for your children.
Okay.
Because they have bus life
and you're taking them into the national park system.
I'm jealous of them.
They're getting what I had.
They have as many motorcycles as I have.
They are so well equipped.
I love this.
So do the motorcycles go on the bus?
They go on the back of the bus. If we don't have the trailer, then we have this big tray.
And I put my 11-year-old daughter's motorcycle, now 12. Her motorcycle, my motorcycle,
and then two electrics for the non-enthusiasts.
And is her motorcycle gas?
Gas. But they have electric as well.
Matilda, my daughter grew up with electric vehicles.
It's a very good esteem builder.
The theory I had was she'll be sitting in class next to somebody and she'll be feeling
insecure, but she'll go, I ride a dirt bike and they don't do that.
And that's just one thing.
You just need something to cobble together a little confidence.
I couldn't agree more.
Real confidence based on doing things that are scary and knowing that you are capable
and that you can trust yourself and that you have good judgment.
I'm going to add it's a real bonus to if even the boys in your class can't do it.
Exactly.
For girls especially.
You were fishing and you were shooting guns as a kid, right?
We were clay pigeons shooting, but I didn't go hunting necessarily, but I went fishing and I had a lot of those experiences
in nature of getting confidence through practical life skills
that required some level of attention because of possibility
for accident.
Yeah.
Horses, skiing, motorcycles, fishing,
all of these things are so important.
You think of them as they're typically male,
but they're most especially important for girls.
Did you grow up with motorcycles?
No, I didn't have any dirt bikes when I was growing up,
but they were a part of my program for Matilda
when she was growing up.
Wow.
Your program.
Yeah.
So when I grew up in Montana, my big experience there
was being on my great-grandparents' farm.
They had cattle, wheat, and horses.
We lived in town, where the grocery store was.
Town in quotes?
Yeah, town.
And they lived more in the middle of the state and they lived on the farm in a much more
rural environment.
And that's where a lot of my exploring happened.
But we were also skiers.
Mind you, do I ski now?
No. Do I ride a dirt bike now?
No. Do I fish? No. But I have all of those things inside of me. They really were formative
in my ideas about who I could be. So that when you're sitting in class and you're next
to some jerky guy who's trying to stick his finger in your nose,
you're like, no, no, no, no, no. I know myself to be worth more than this.
They're also really great little trials of being afraid. All these things you
would start with fear unless something's wrong with you. So just these little
ways to confront fear and then get comfortable and then have the pride of
having confronted it. All those things are really good.
How about even on Grandparents Farm, going on a long walk
where you're like, oh yeah, I'm a little scared.
That was my whole childhood every day was come back when you hear the dinner bell.
And we were free to do whatever we wanted as long as we came home
when we heard the dinner bell.
And so it gave us so much time to meander and explore
and go down these dirt roads and ride bikes
and discover little things and find treasures
and take them home and hide them
and then take them out in the middle of the night
when they thought that we were sleeping
and you're just getting into good trouble.
And I miss it so much for my own children.
I'm constantly thinking about how to create these experiences.
But as you know, it's difficult.
It requires a lot of infrastructure and undertaking if you live in an urban environment
to try and get them out.
So can I please come on?
Oh, absolutely.
There's room for a family of six.
Uh, yes, we will make room.
I might have to tow another living quarters behind it.
You would love to get another bus going.
But I can't drive both at one time, or can I?
Michelle can drive it. I actually can't.
Okay, great, you saw it.
Fuck it, take it for a rep when this is all done.
We'll give you a little test drive.
But you know what else is happening on those walks?
You scare yourself, that's fun.
But then also your imagination's on fire.
Because as beautiful it is, it's also boring.
You gotta now pretend on this bike ride
that you're doing something important.
I had to make myself some explorer,
and you're really trying on all kinds of different fun pretend identities.
You're starting acting.
You have to start to story tell with the landscape too.
What is that abandoned house?
We shouldn't go in it.
There's probably a witch.
Yeah.
Yeah. There's a witch that lives in that house,
and then that becomes part of the play and part of the fantasy,
but it just requires tremendous boredom,
tremendous freedom and a total lack of supervision.
And where are you gonna get that these days?
I know.
So how do you do that here,
aside from getting out of here?
We have been criticized for this publicly.
We let our kids go.
I've encouraged them.
If you wanna walk to the store, go to the store.
We were in Denmark and there's the Trafoli Park.
And so in the morning we just say to the girls,
goodbye, here's a credit card.
You can spend X amount and then here's the time
you got to meet us.
So we're very big into just turning them over
to the world and hoping for the best.
It's worked so well.
Do you know Leonora Skanezy?
She is this proponent of free range parenting.
She's great.
We interviewed her and she was letting her kid ride the subway at a very young age, but
he had mastered the subway.
People called her the worst mom in America.
Abuse claims.
And the kid's fine and did great.
So we're proponents of that.
Yeah, I'm with you guys.
Also, Jonathan Haidt, he has the new book, Anxious Generation.
This is sort of his antidote to all the stuff that's happening with kids and the isolation
is make them have a community but leave.
Go send them off to go explore.
Unsupervised as you said, that's the key.
But yeah, crossing a river and this had to happen to you a ton.
You got to cross the river and you got to jump on the different rocks to get over there.
But you need a story in your head of why we must cross this river because we're being chased.
It's so good.
The other thing that happens when you're in a natural environment
is that you are learning so many lessons.
You're in a receptive state, not a defensive state
because it's not your parent, it's not your teacher.
It is the thrill of your skin in the wind
and the understanding that your survival depends on you
and only you.
And so you're constantly assessing your own comfort
with danger and your own ability to
keep yourself safe.
So when you learn that with an impartial teacher like nature, you can take that into the rest
of your life and really fall back into yourself and say, I know myself to be a person who
makes good decisions.
I know myself to be somebody who can keep myself safe
and balanced.
And that feedback loop that a child gets
when they decide which rocks are the safe rocks,
which one isn't slippery, which one isn't too pointy.
When they're quite literally getting their footing,
it is feeding their body with information
about how to take risks.
It's very challenging to figure out how to do that today.
Denmark is a great place to do that.
You were just doing what the Danes do.
I mean, that's the Danish way.
Oh, even better, you see like up in Sweden and stuff,
they leave their babies outside in the pram in the cold.
They're going to the store, there's just babies lined up.
And don't they have playgrounds there
that are specifically to get kind of her design
so that there's just a little-
Tools and stuff. Yeah.
Yeah, to play with and nails and real shit.
Yeah, exactly.
We should raise some children in a commune.
I think we're in lockstep.
We are so like-minded.
I mean, don't get me started talking about cell phones.
Yeah.
Okay, so you moved to San Diego when you were nine.
Why did we move to San Diego?
The weather.
Okay, you had enough of those winters.
My parents did.
I was quite happy there.
It was such a good life.
But the winter that we moved,
it hadn't gotten above 40 below.
So off to San Diego we went.
And how did you take to San Diego?
That's a big cultural shift.
Yeah, it was a real shock.
I don't think I'd seen a freeway before.
I was surprised that everybody's house
looked like everybody else's house.
These big swaths of tracked housing developments
built along a freeway.
And you know, when you're a kid,
you don't really feel the cold.
It doesn't register with you as something
that you have to gird yourself for
because you have so many fun things
that you can do in the cold.
Yeah. Yeah.
Now at 44, I'm like, woo, I'm cold.
Can't handle it. Can't handle it.
I've gotten cold in my old age.
It's amazing how quickly you adjust
to that California lifestyle.
So I'm gonna go by the lore.
Some of this might be apocryphal,
but you see the adventures of Tom Sawyer.
You see that play and you're intrigued.
Yeah, we went to go see a play in,
my memory is sort of an abandoned shopping mall
and the ceiling is dripping
and the folding chairs are metal
and you walk through a backstage
where you see these child actors
in various stages of hair and makeup
and playing games and braiding each other's hair
and costumes.
And so I saw the kind of inner workings
and then we watched this play.
That's interesting that you saw that first.
That's what I really love.
Right, right, right.
That's my favorite part.
The behind the scenes, the people, the community,
the friendships, the safe space, the chosen family.
That's the stuff that I really get excited about.
Yeah, the combined goal, all the business that goes into it.
I just remember holding onto my seat,
thinking it was gonna take off like I was on an airplane
because I was so transported into this play
that I was watching with kids my age.
And they seemed like they were having so much fun
and singing and dancing.
And I thought, oh, I'd like to be a part of this,
whatever this thing is.
And so that continued to be something that I did
the whole time that I was in San Diego.
Always more of a chorus girl,
more like an orphan sans name, just back row tapper.
Because Annie was your first thing.
I think so, I was a back row orphan.
I think Annie's a gateway drug.
Oh yeah.
Because my daughter's about to do it in a month
and our other friend's kid is currently doing Annie
at the same time.
Songs like that, they hook into you
and then you think you just should spend your whole life
singing them and you would be a happy person.
Yeah, did you wanna be a singer?
Yeah, I really wanted to sing and dance.
That just looked like a whole lot of fun to me.
But were you good at singing or dancing?
No, no.
Born with just enough talent to cobble together
the ability to do this, a passable voice
and some workable feet, but not prodigious.
You sang as Marilyn.
Yeah, I have enough musicality
that I can pull certain things off
and also have an ear for accents.
I was talking about this with a friend last night
because I went to the Beyonce concert
and this is a very, very good singer I was with
and we decided that you can kind of,
with training, raise yourself three degrees.
If you're born as a seven, which is very high,
you could get to a 10.
But if you're born a three, you're not getting to a 10.
Even if you work so hard,
you're probably gonna max out at a six or seven.
It's so true.
With singing and dancing, I think.
But do we think that could extend
to some other things like comedy?
I don't think you can train yourself from a three.
To me, I think comedy is a more learned skill in general.
Singing.
Right, you have some anatomy that's gonna lift.
Exactly.
You have to have a range.
Yes, that's it.
Comedy, I think, if you're in the right circumstance,
if you have enough trauma.
See, that's the thing. I think there's an archetype of the brain that's it. Comedy, I think, if you're in the right circumstance, if you have enough trauma. See, that's the thing.
I think there's an archetype of the brain that is similar.
Yeah, and your trauma could come later,
so your humor could develop.
Exactly.
Yes, it's never too late to be a great comedian.
And if you're around comedy a ton,
you do start infiltrating that a little bit more.
You learn some tricks.
You can listen to as much music as you want.
You're not gonna be Beyonce.
No, you're not.
I need to admit something to you.
I don't know that I've ever done this, but you make me really nervous.
Oh, no.
Yeah.
What?
I think it's a good feeling though.
It's a good kind of nervous, but I don't really get nervous and I can feel nervousness in
my body.
I'm kind of nervous too.
Are you?
Yeah, yeah.
I was just wondering.
You guys, this guy?
Yeah, that smile really took a turn.
It's like kind of maniacal.
It's so cute and scary. It's like kind of maniacal.
It's so cute and scary.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha.
That's the best combo.
I've never been described like this
and I didn't know that I had the ability to unnerve anyone.
Do you think maybe you were just missing it
and no one told you?
What was I missing?
You're powerful and you make people nervous.
Bum ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba ba.
Oh good, I got her.
She sure was looking at me.
Ha ha ha ha ha. I know what it She's starting to get it.
I know what it is.
Tell me what it is.
You are very measured and in control of yourself.
It also seems clear in a beautiful way.
You're not gonna go anywhere you don't wanna go.
You have full control.
And I'm sloppy.
And I'm like, I want the interplay to be right,
but yeah, I'm a sloppy mess that I somehow landed.
Yeah, I'm like, we don't deserve to be doing this.
Hey, Dex, I think we should stop.
You know what Kristen did tell me?
I said, you know Michelle a little bit, right?
And she said, yeah, I love her.
We have a lot of mutual friends,
which makes me feel closer to her than we actually are.
But she said she speaks very poetically.
I love how she speaks.
I've already gotten that.
You guys, just get me on that bus.
Let me show you when there's not a microphone in my face.
Okay?
It is a compliment.
Let's take it elsewhere.
I'm obsessed with your wife.
She changed our life.
You can include me.
I wrote the essay.
Did you?
Yeah, I wrote the thing that went viral.
I didn't need to take credit for that.
A really good version of me would have just let her have credit for that.
She did more, ultimately, than I did.
But I wrote a thing, I was so upset.
I just put it on Tumblr.
Okay, when Lincoln was born, there were paparazzi living on the driveway for a long time,
and every time we left, we covered her with a blanket.
We went to so many lengths to not let a photograph of her get taken.
And we were at the Hanson's House, Deep Valley.
I wasn't even thinking of leaving their house.
And then my mom texts me like, oh, I'm so sorry.
And it's a picture of Lincoln.
And I was, I can even say now maybe over, but I was just so fucking upset about it
that I wrote this long thing and I put it on Tumblr and then somehow I got picked
up by the Huffington Post and all these places.
And then that led to talk shows inviting us to argue with Paparazzi, which we did.
And this is where she deserves all the credit.
Kristin, she built a coalition of other actors,
basically saying we will no longer participate in these magazines
if they don't stop showing kids.
It was called the No Kid Policy.
And she got all the photo houses to commit to that,
which was pretty powerful.
And I do give her all the credit for that.
It was incredible.
I remember the day that People magazine said that they would
stop publishing photos of children.
And I was like, wow, this whole structure collapsed.
Because it had been such a problem for us for so many years
and had limited our life.
You had a really rough version of it.
Unmanageable, unlivable.
But I didn't know what to do.
I just cried and moved to a different place.
Then to see these ideas that you guys were having and then this action around it and
then this change.
I wrote to her at the time and I sent her a picture of Matilda smiling on the beach
because before that, Matilda didn't like to have her photo taken
because that experience was taken from her
and she didn't feel ownership over her image.
And so even with friends and family,
that was a place where she could express a boundary
and say, no, I don't want my picture taken.
But when that system crumbled,
she smiled for the camera on the beach.
Oh, that's so sweet.
And they sent that.
Yeah, she came in and read that to me.
That was really nice of you to send.
Even forget the cameras, just imagine you take your kids out
and there's seven men in fatigues
that just run in a circle around you.
That's such a bizarre human experience for a little kid.
For anyone.
It's kind of nuts, this shit, when we look back,
what was totally acceptable.
You look at Brittany's life at the apex
and you're like, that's just an assault.
I think that what happens is that people assume
those children have other advantages
and so they aren't able to empathize with them.
Yeah, it's just the price you have to pay.
And they're right in some degree,
at least saying you chose that, right?
And I would agree.
You go into acting, you would have to have your head
in the sand to think that if I get popular enough,
I might not have to deal with that.
Now, we could have another debate about whether you really
need to deal with that because you want to act,
but your kids didn't choose that.
That's an insane proposition that the kids made the decision
to be born to the parents who made the decision.
That's like sins of our fathers stuff.
Yeah, has it really just gone away?
I believe so.
By the way, the added benefit for us was
we're always with our kids,
so we don't really deal with it at all.
I also think part of what has changed is Instagram.
This is maybe the positive part of Instagram.
You don't need to go to the grocery store
and flip through this horrible magazine
to find a picture of someone's kid.
A lot of people post pictures of their kids
that are chosen and they're curated, of someone's kid. A lot of people post pictures of their kids that are chosen
and they're curated, so it's available.
Also, you're getting a photo in their house of them smiling.
You have this new access that they're in control of,
so it's more interesting.
I do think that overall just kind of crippled that industry.
Although there seems to be a market still for Ben Affleck
and Justin Bieber.
Those two seem to still be living in prison, yes.
Also, we started the beginning of this conversation
talking about the importance of kids being able to be out
in free range and running around.
And if they can't,
because there are people taking pictures of them,
that's an added layer of what they're imprisoned by,
which is so unfair.
Yeah, something that they shouldn't have to think about.
Also then you add in they're the kid
that's arriving at school with a gang.
It's already hard enough to fucking go to school.
So embarrassing.
Oh my God.
Yeah, oh my God, I know.
You need to do more than ride motorcycles to overcome that.
That deficit, you've assumed.
Okay, now, this is a thrilling part of your story.
You start acting, you're on Baywatch as your first one.
Incredible, how old were you on Baywatch?
Probably 12.
Wow, that's young for Baywatch.
You were a temptress to a young man?
Was that the storyline?
No, I was just a girl running in a bikini
on the beach and inviting him to a party.
Wait, were you really?
Oh yeah.
At 12?
Oh no! Oh no.
Wow.
Times really have changed.
Yes, just a girl jogging in a bikini.
As we do.
Very normal.
And then you were in Lassie, and you were in Step by Step.
You were in Home Improvement.
You were like working.
Yeah, I really was.
That's a three, four year span of time.
So it was guest thing here, guest thing there,
commercial here, commercial there,
enough to keep going and to be sustenative.
You're going out on three things a day.
And you're in San Diego, so you're going to LA a ton.
Yeah, so we're like going back and forth.
Are you taking the train or are you driving?
Driving.
Mom's driving you?
Yeah, mom's driving.
There's some other kids in San Diego
and there's just kind of this idea in the air
that hey, you can go to LA and you can audition for things
and then you might be in Hollywood.
And there were some people who fell under that spell
and there were some minivans doing that shuttle
back and forth and you'd go to your cattle call
and then you'd go get a cookie at the mall
and you'd turn around and do your homework
in the back seat by a little car light and go home.
Okay, now this is the part that's really unique is you got emancipated at 15 and you had to
do all of high school in nine months.
I did.
When I got emancipated.
When I read that I was like, can that be done?
I know.
I'll tell you what, it really makes me feel like that skull right there.
I'm like, wait, how long ago was that?
Are you sure that that was this lifetime that we're talking about?
Because surely you can't do that anymore.
It's a very strange thing
because you have all these child labor laws
and when you're a child actor, you need to have a tutor.
You can only work a certain number of hours
and you need to have the guardian, like a social worker
who's concerned with your safety.
And if you do something called being emancipated,
you don't have to have any of those.
You're an adult.
Nobody's looking after you, nobody's teaching you and you can work
whenever you want.
Whatever they want.
Exactly.
Was this your idea?
It was an idea.
Other kids were doing it.
There was a movie of the week about it.
Oh, okay, great.
That's helpful.
It looked fun.
Then it just sort of happened.
Because I was a child,
I don't fully know the ins and outs of it.
I would guess you have two vastly different perspectives.
One now is an adult who's been around 13 year olds
and 15 year olds, and then the 15 year old you
who probably thought you were 26.
Yeah, who couldn't really see into the future
to understand ramifications
or what practical life would look like.
Then now looking back and feeling I'm just so lucky.
It could have gone crazy.
What age were you when you moved to Burbank?
15.
I was sort of bouncing around those valley apartments.
Were you ever at the Oakwood?
Sure was.
Oh, did you see the documentary about it?
No, I don't think I can.
Oh, I think you should.
It'd probably be so PTSD for you.
I probably have some friends from the past.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare.
We are supported by Airbnb.
Oh, do I love an Airbnb.
We love Airbnb.
I love traveling with friends and making communal dinners
and gathering outside.
I know, and just hanging at night.
Oh, it's the best.
Some trips are better in an Airbnb.
And we're gonna tell you why later in this episode.
Everyone's got a pro.
Need tires?
I've got a pro.
Car making a weird sound?
I've got a pro.
So who's that pro?
The pros at Tread Experts.
From tires to auto repair, Tread Experts is always there.
Helping you with Michelin tires you can trust.
Until May 30th, receive up to $70 by prepaid MasterCard
with purchase of four new Michelin passenger or light truck tires.
Find your pro at your local Tread Experts.
From tires to auto repair, we're always there.
TreadExperts.ca
At 24, I lost my narrative, or rather it was stolen from me.
And the Monica Lewinsky that my friends and family knew
was usurped by false narratives, callous jokes, and politics.
I would define reclaiming as to take back what was yours.
Something you possess is lost or stolen.
And ultimately you triumph in finding it again.
So I think listeners can expect me to be chatting
with folks, both recognizable and unrecognizable names
about the way that people have navigated roads to triumph.
My hope is that people will finish an episode of Reclaiming
and feel like they filled their tank up.
They connected with the people that I'm talking to and leave with maybe some nuggets
that help them feel a little more hopeful.
Follow Reclaiming with Monica Lewinsky on the Wondery app or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to Reclaiming early and ad free right now by joining Wondery Plus in the Wondery app or on Apple podcasts. And were you living on your own at 15?
Yeah, I got emancipated at 15 and a half.
And then I got Dawson's Creek when I was 16.
So then I was transported very quickly to Wilmington,
North Carolina, which was a much safer,
sounder environment to be a young person on their own.
You said at one point, and I will get it wrong,
but something to the effect of there's a lot of scary people
or dangerous people in LA, and I met many of them
during that period.
Was it fucking terrifying?
That sounds insane.
Yeah, I think it was.
And I thank God that I got that show
and that it plucked me out and landed me
on this sleepy southern coastal town and that I had that show and that it plucked me out and landed me on this sleepy Southern coastal town
and that I had a job to go to
and a place to be responsible to
and met a few people there that are still in my life
that I love very much, that are so much a part of me
and had some kind of stability.
Okay, so yeah, when you got Dawson's Creek,
you got very lucky.
That's kind of a little life raft at that moment.
It was really great and I really wanted it
and I was so excited.
And you know, when you go on so many auditions
and you get down to the wire on things,
there's so many heartbreaks that you go through
as a child actor.
The things that you almost get
or the things that you never hear from again,
even though you wanted them so badly.
Your heart endures a lot when you are a kid
trying to deal with mass rejection daily.
And the stress of supporting yourself in Burbank.
Yeah, it was weird.
What was the age of the other folks? Were they a little older than you?
They were legal adults, 18, 19, 20.
They didn't do high school in nine months.
But they did not do, let's be honest, it was correspondence school.
Did you get a GED?
Is that what you ended up with?
Pre-internet.
So I'd like for you to imagine what that might look like.
Yeah, that's great.
You wouldn't know it while talking to you.
It's a testament to forgetting about school.
Exactly, this is not a good endorsement for school.
The only thing that matters to me
is when a kid's going to college.
Were you a reader?
I did read, I loved books.
So I had that on my side.
I could always just turn to a book if I had a question about something in life.
And it's expanding your vocabulary.
Yeah, and I would read novels, but I would also read books about history.
I mean, the gaps in my knowledge, they're everywhere.
So I would go to Barnes and Noble, and not only would I get the novels that I wanted
to read, but I would also get an incomplete education or a beginner's guide to world geography.
We've had a few people who have left school early
and they're always the smartest people in the room
because of this.
They have this idea that the reason they don't know things
is because of their lack of schooling.
So they're making up for it.
Whereas if you've gone through all this schooling,
you're like, yeah, I just don't know that
because I don't know.
There's no hangup about it.
Does that make sense?
Yeah, so that's one theory.
That's a good theory.
My theory is almost similar to me going to college.
Like I retained so much from college
and other people didn't,
but I wasn't there because I had to be there.
I got to study whatever I wanted.
I was not trying to get a career in anything.
So I think if you weren't educated
and then you set out to learn, you want to.
It's not something you're forced to do.
It's like the decision to pursue this.
And that just makes all the difference in the world.
Yeah, when you really want it.
Yeah, I remember distinctly arguing a guy drunk in Detroit
when I was 19 and he just mopped the floor with me.
I didn't know what the fuck I was talking about.
I didn't know it was Egypt 10 years ago
or was it like 900 years ago?
And it was 3000 years ago. I remember
just being humiliated with how little I knew in that argument and that was like a big motivator
for me. I'm like, oh, I'm stupid.
Yeah. And you want to be able to cross-pollinate and to be able to sit next to anybody and
have a point of contact for their frames of reference. That became clear to me.
Did you have an interesting relationship with adults since you were a kid, but behaving
as an adult?
Did you seek the safety of other adults in your life?
Yeah, I think I thought I was an adult.
The people that I was on the show with, they weren't not my age, but they were also a little
bit older where they were like, she's 16, okay.
Yeah, stay away.
I made some local friends, but again, they weren't my age.
And I am very close with Marybeth Peel,
who played my grams.
I felt like it was an ageless relationship,
but I don't know if I had met another 16 year old
who was at the local high school,
that I would have been like,
what are you doing after school today?
Right, yes, cause you're gonna go home
and cook dinner for yourself.
I'm gonna go make a box of pasta
and heat up some tomato sauce.
Were you lonely there?
I've never really felt lonely, to be honest,
because I had all those early rambling experiences
in nature and so I was sort of conditioned to that.
I didn't feel lonely at all.
I had a car, there were three bookstores,
there was a record store, I lived near the beach.
Maybe I'm just saying that in retrospect,
but it was a great place to be young.
And then Bizzy joined the show.
I don't know, how old were we?
18 or something, I can't really remember,
but we've been best friends ever since,
so that was the end of anything
that I might have experienced as loneliness.
Oh, okay.
I love parasocially watching the two of yours relationship.
It's so lovely.
We're like the odd couple. It's so lovely. We're like the odd couple.
It's so sweet.
We're like, those two things shouldn't go together.
And yet they do.
And yet they do.
Female friendship is so beautiful.
We're talking about it more.
We'll come up when we talk about your show.
But seeing it out in the world is really nice for young girls.
Because there's a lot of competition also amongst girls.
And it's good to see.
These two people are soulmates.
That's exactly the word that I would use.
It's an A storyline, not a B storyline.
And it's enough to sustain years, decades, a lifetime.
Yeah, beautiful.
If you can find that, that's what I want for any young person.
I only have three pieces of advice for young men.
Get a best friend, learn to dance,
and try to learn a few jokes,
and everything's gonna work out just fine.
I'm gonna tell my boys, thank you.
Well, you can send them to my school,
it takes about seven minutes.
I'm already sending them to bus school.
I thought we had an agreement.
Yeah, they must know how to back up a trailer
by the time they're 18, that's another skill.
Okay, so during the whole Dawson's Creek experience, you clearly had your mindset on establishing
yourself in projects that were totally kind of opposite.
Was there tension between the gratitude for having such a great, safe job and then also
not being in the things that you were dying to be in?
No, because there was room for both.
I did this movie when I was young called Me Without You
that shot in the UK and they accommodated it
in our work schedule to allow me to go back and forth
to do this movie that I was dying to do.
It's also not like I was getting a million offers
to go do other things.
There was enough for me.
But you were playing a Brit in that movie.
I did. I think that Dawson's Creek was even nice enough to let me me. But you were playing a Brit in that movie.
I did.
I think that Dawson's Creek was even nice enough to let me dye my hair
and then wear a wig on their show.
So it was allowing for a variety of experiences.
And then we got that summer break, because I think we shot nine months
a year, and then you would have the opportunity to go do something else
during the summer if something came up.
The things that you did in that period, which were Kill Joe, Dick,
If These Walls Could Talk, Me Without You, was it hard to get cast and stuff like that,
given what you were currently known for?
Was that a challenge?
I would say so.
Because from the outside, it would appear like,
you're on this thing, but you know you want a career
at some point that's going to be much heavier,
and that you're going to have to establish yourself
as quick as possible before you're just
Permanently in one type of role or was that not happening in your head? I didn't really think in the future like that necessarily. I wasn't career focused
I was just finding myself yearning for something drawn towards it
Living in all the desire for it and then would occasionally have the opportunity to do it and be given these chances
Some of it I think I got lucky.
Like, they didn't even know what Dawson's Creek was.
I did a Vin Venders movie.
I couldn't believe that I'd been cast by Vin Venders.
I was like, well, this is it. I quit.
I'm going to fold my cards. This hand is too good.
And then he saw a picture of me from Dawson's Creek
or something, and he was like, oh, if I had known,
I would not have been cast.
Oh, no!
Well, that's kind of the point I'm circling.
So I think I probably was up against something externally, And he was like, oh, if I had known I would not have cast. Oh no. Well that's kind of the point I'm circling.
So I think I probably was up against something externally,
but internally it was just a very pure yearning on my part
to make contact with other kinds of work
and other kinds of human experiences.
So much of it is just staying in the game
and staying calm and staying patient.
And then there's a serendipitous and domino effect,
which is me without you, A.V. Kaufman had seen that.
Is that true?
Oh, I don't know, is that?
I read that A.V. Kaufman had seen that
and that was what urged her to push for you
in Brokeback Mountain.
Oh wow, then I owe somebody a thank you.
I did not know that.
Maybe that's true or maybe it's not true.
Half the stuff I read is not true.
Oh, Station Agent, that's a big fun movie
that you did in that period at Dawson.
Did you fall in love with Dinklage the way my wife did?
Everybody does.
There's a handful of folks
and he is definitely at the top of that list.
A magnetic human being.
Powerful charisma.
She is head over heels.
No.
If I were to pass in a fiery crash,
her first phone call, I don't know if he's wet or not,
but I think it would be to him.
He's wedded.
Yeah.
And he's childhood.
Oh, okay.
Blended family.
But like we said, friendship can be deep.
No, no, no, no.
When you're making Brokeback, are you sensing what it is?
You don't know about you, but I do some things
and I thought they were gonna be great
and then some things I thought were gonna be bad and then they're good. I don't know that I'm but I do some things and I thought they're gonna be great, and then some things I thought were gonna be bad,
and then they're good.
I don't know that I'm a very good barometer
when I'm inside of something.
I still feel like that.
I'm like, well, who knows?
Because an ecstatic experience doesn't always relate
to a great thing and a terrible experience.
Sometimes you're like, they polished that turd.
It's so hard to, when you're in something,
really have an idea of how it's going to be received.
I would say impossible.
And at that point, I hadn't really been in anything either
that had enjoyed a reception.
So it certainly wasn't on my mind.
Yeah, you get nominated for Academy Award
at the end of it all.
No, that was not what I was thinking.
Although one thing can happen, I've never met Ang Lee,
but did you sense from him he had a spirit that was special
and that somehow that was going to be present
in the product?
For sure, I mean, he's such a beautiful artist
and has this incredible body of work
and the Annie Proulx story that it's based on
and then the adaptation, it's undeniable material
and so brought together under Ang Lee
probably is gonna be a good thing,
but would anyone see it?
It's about gay men, which was not really being done.
We're in a post-Broke Mountain world
where we take for granted that story could be successful,
but prior to that, we don't have that.
That was a first.
Yeah.
I don't know if you're comfortable talking about Heath,
but I'd feel obligated to say that I knew him a little bit
when he was getting sober,
and I don't know that I've ever fallen in love
with someone so quickly.
This is one of the most special boys I've ever met,
and I can feel the weight of the world on him
in a very special way that kind of broke my heart.
I was very, very sad, and I thought he was just so special.
So special, so special.
Thank God there's, so special.
Yeah.
Yeah, thank God there's Matilda.
Yeah, what a guy.
I feel very lucky that I, yeah, just got to,
there's like a handful of people I've met like that
in my life where I'm just like,
oh wow, there's something, there's this heart here
that's just leaking out everywhere.
And incredible sensitivity.
Yeah, great taste in motorcycles too.
He had a 2006 Sport 1000 yellow,
that's what I also drive.
That's what you drive?
Wow, look at that.
But also with Brokeback, all of you guys turned out to be huge stars,
and not just stars, the best of the best as far as acting accolades.
And it's fun to me that he obviously could see that in all of you
and put this cast together.
It wasn't an obvious cast.
You now take for granted it feels like it was an obvious cast
because you've seen the proof that everyone was brilliant,
but it's not an obvious cast.
It's a really beautiful way to look at it.
I like that.
How was the life-altering shift of,
you're gonna be at the Academy Awards,
was that a natural transition?
No, with a baby.
But I suppose maybe it's a good thing about being young
is that you don't have so much life experience
that you can contextualize
things so you're really just going with the flow.
Yeah, because I was going to say another theme I see present when I look at your life in
its totality and I doubt you reflect back on it in its totality, but you have had many
moments where you seem to have an incredibly healthy relationship with the job.
Because I think having a baby on the heels of an Academy
Award nomination, most people are like, okay, get me the list
of all the directors I can now work with, and it's time to go.
And that seems like a very healthy relationship that you
were like, no, it's time to have a baby.
Kids are such great life checkers.
They force you to put your best self in front of them.
You can't abdicate your life and your work and your own desires,
but you do have to put them in check and figure out which master you're going to serve.
Because the truth is, if work is going well, somebody else is taking care of the kids.
And if you're in a high point with your kids, the work is shoved to the side.
So you can't be equally good at them at the exact same time
and you have to allow for that give and take,
but then also replenish the other things.
If you have a big period of being at home,
you need to go back to what you've left unattended
and put some light over there.
So I think it's just this constant back and forth,
but making sure that you don't leave one of them
unattended for too long.
This is my main thing I've taken from parenting,
is it right-sized all my other concerns and pursuits.
In a very helpful way, ironically.
I kind of thought, oh, you have kids,
they'll be so distracted, there'll be no time.
It's like, oh, no, no, actually,
I will now approach the work
with kind of the stakes that it deserves,
which is I like to do this and maybe I'm good at it, but it's not anymore the most important thing.
There's some liberation in that.
I think it's been helpful for me work-wise.
My best day with my children is better than my best day at work.
I am more thrilled with that high than I am with a work high.
So I returned to that feeling, you know,
when am I really, really at my happiest?
And it's when I feel like things are going well with my kids.
I've got them in a good place and they're feeling understood.
And how about just the notion that your best day at work
is you accomplish the thing you would hope to accomplish.
Your best day at work isn't when someone else in a scene
was their best ever, but weirdly the joy of the kids
is like they do something, right?
It's not like your best day is because you were your best
self, it's just they do something that's so spectacular
and you feel so lucky to have witnessed it.
It's kind of the opposite.
I used to say to Matilda,
it tastes better to me when you eat it.
Oh, that's so sweet.
And that's kind of the feeling that I get with them.
But again, I want them to see their mom working, all of my kids.
So it's not something that I want to neglect for too long,
but the kids really pull at you more convincingly.
Did you always know you wanted to have kids?
Some women, they're five and they're like,
I know I'm going to be doing this.
I think I always just assumed that I would,
but I wasn't a natural babysitter or have a lot of dollies.
That wasn't my thing, but I just assumed,
yeah, I'm gonna be a mom,
but I really wanted to be like a mom of a teenager.
I was like, I can't pretend a teenage girl.
You wanted to go to the mall with a teenage daughter.
I just wanted to do it right.
I just wanted to be like in there with her
and understanding her and taking her side.
That's where I wanted to be.
Yeah.
It's about the, yeah, whatever,
I could go six hours on kids.
Same.
Can we do a sidebar?
We should do a kid podcast.
Some of the stuff that I think gives people anxiety
about having kids is my absolute favorite stuff.
Once they have some shit to get into,
I'm like, let's party.
I've done it all.
I've fucked up in every way possible.
It's go time.
It's so rewarding.
I similarly learned by parenting,
oh, actually, when I make mistakes in front of my daughter
and own up to them and apologize,
it teaches her to make mistakes and say,
oopsie, mommy, I'm sorry.
And it's not a big deal.
It's a part of life and we move on.
No shame, no blame, just you made a mistake.
Beautiful.
I made five already today.
I'm not gonna blame anyone in my parenting circle,
but I could not make a mistake.
Maybe it was self-imposed.
If I fucked something up, I would just lie.
Obviously. Yeah. What else was there? Iosed. If I fucked something up, I would just lie. Obviously.
Yeah.
What else would you do?
I know, and the fact that my kids fuck shit up
and then they come tell me and I'm like,
oh my God, this is incredible.
They're better than me.
I was hiding things I broke.
That's because you thought there was a reason
to hide things.
Something that you were afraid of.
Well, again, it's not her fault,
but single mom, three kids, it was fucking chaotic.
I couldn't put anything on her plate.
I just did not want to be another burden
in her very burdened life.
So I think kind of self-imposed.
But then you corrected it, now your kids pass that on,
and it stops with you.
At least that one part.
I catch myself all the time, do you do this?
This is last night.
I catch myself being annoying in the exact same way
my mom and dad were annoying to me.
I wanna play and I'm always petting their hair
or I'm pulling their ear.
And most of the time they like it
and then a lot of times they'd look at me
and I'm like, oh my God, I know this so well.
This is my dad like, just fucking watch TV.
Why do you need my attention right now?
Just watch TV.
But it's so hard not to fondle their little tendrils of hair on their head.
Their little earlobes are so soft.
Okay, I have selfish questions.
When you did Synecdoide, I can't pronounce it.
Synecdoide.
Synecdoide?
Yeah, you got it.
I saw that at the Cannes Film Festival.
I saw it.
I was there in college.
I studied abroad at the Cannes Film Festival and we snuck our way into some of the movies. Were you there? Yep. Yeah, I was there in college. I studied abroad at the Cannes Film Festival and we snuck our way into some of the movies.
Were you there?
Yep.
Yeah, I was there.
Oh my God.
Did you get a picture of her?
Probably from very, very far away.
Very, very far away.
What is Charlie Kaufman like?
I never met him and I only have adaptation to work off of.
I wish that I could be the person
to answer that question for you
and give you the fulfillment and satisfaction,
but what is Charlie Kaufman like?
Other than an artist without parallel,
but I can't get in there, I don't know.
Yeah.
Okay.
That's a big one.
I wanna have a dinner with him
and I would be nervous too.
Okay, Blue Valentine,
I know you already talked about this a lot,
this 15 years old,
but I'm still fascinated by the notion
that you guys were urged to live together
for a month before filming.
We took a break in the filming.
We shot the first part when they're young and in love
and everything's going really well.
And then we took a two week break
and we lived together office hours, baby, like nine to five.
Okay.
Yeah.
Not cohabitating.
Professional situations.
So we did these improvisations during the day,
honestly, to figure out ways to annoy each other.
Sure, sure, sure.
And to destroy this thing that we had made.
Because we weren't even going to take that break,
but we were having such a hard time letting go
of the thing that we loved.
Derek was like, we got to mess this up,
and we need to burn it down.
And we did a ceremonial, burned our wedding photo.
And then we learned how to annoy each other.
That movie is so perfect. Thanks. did a ceremonial, burned our wedding photo. And then we learned how to annoy each other.
That movie is so perfect.
Thanks.
It is incredible.
It's so heavy and beautiful.
Were you on your own for these eight hour improv things?
Yeah, a lot of it.
Derek, the director, would come in
and give us a kind of-
Scenario.
Yeah, and then we would be left to do it. And then he would say,
after you've had this frustrating day,
now you're gonna go take your daughter
to the amusement park and try and have a good time.
Oh. Yeah, wow.
Yeah, it's fun.
I don't know if anybody could work like that again,
because you've got a crew that's on hold,
you're paying people.
I mean, it was such a small movie,
so low budget and a small crew,
but you're taking a big down period
in the middle of the thing.
And to what end?
Playing, you know, exploring,
try and justify that to a producer.
But that's what we did.
You get it in the movie.
That would be a big challenge for me.
Because I just want you to like me,
especially if we met two months ago.
I know, it was horrible.
I don't want to give you reasons to hate me.
Those will come in a couple years.
Obnoxious, yeah.
We were having such a good time.
The party has to be over so soon.
That's kind of heartbreaking.
Yeah, it was.
Was it rough that second half?
Were you feeling the heartbreak of that?
Yeah, I really wasn't.
I was younger then.
It's a hard day at work for me now.
I feel it and I go through it,
but I definitely know that I get to go home.
I can really close the door on it.
When I was younger, it would definitely seep under the door. Yeah, I can imagine coming home and feeling heartbroken
or not liked, maybe.
Yeah.
My worst fear.
Also, such a magnifying glass on your flaws.
Did you learn about your own flaws via this?
I was like, you don't have to hate me.
Now I hate me because I hate annoying.
And we are calling forth to all of our worst qualities
and now you can't hate me more than I hate myself.
That's intense.
Back to Charlie Kaufman, if I had a list,
it'd be really hard, but definitely in the top for me
would be Eternal Sunshine.
Just for the scene at the end when she's like,
no, but I'll annoy you and I'll do this and you'll do that
and I'll hate this and he goes, yeah, I know,
and I still want to.
And I was like, oh, my God, it was so heartbreaking.
Well, it's like the end of Some Like It Hot.
And he's like, but I'm this, and I'm this, I'm a man.
And he says, well, nobody's perfect.
Yeah.
I know, because when you're young, oh, man, you can get annoyed.
And then in retrospect, you're like, what was that?
Why don't you care?
There's no one you're gonna meet who doesn't annoy you.
Everyone is annoying when you're young.
Michelle, if you heard me,
and you'll hear me when we live in the bus together.
In the morning, me starting this machine up,
sometimes I hear myself, I'm pretty immune to it.
I'm clearing my throat and I'm coughing.
And sometimes I'll just be at the mirror
and I'm like, my family,
what they hear every morning from me
and that they still love me is a miracle.
And actually it's not, but it's with,
that actually that is exactly who they love.
It's inclusive of that.
It's because of that.
Yes.
In spite of it.
No, not in spite.
It's because these are the human pieces because of that. In spite of it. No, not in spite, it's because.
These are the human pieces.
Yeah, when you love somebody,
you have to take the whole pie.
And so it's a because, so enjoy your ability
and the way that they love you in that moment,
because they do.
And they have so much fun making fun of me about it.
That's the beauty.
Okay, now I already learned
that this is not gonna be the case,
but it would appear again that you're in a very popular thing
and then you do a bunch of kind of smaller things.
Then we go to Oz the Great and Powerful.
You had not done a big-ass movie like that in a long time.
Was that seemingly abrupt?
No, I was dying to do that.
I had an eight-year-old daughter
and I was gonna play Glinda the Good Witch.
I've cooked up a real steak for us on this one, darling.
I'm like, wait till you come to mommy's job,
and you go to the costume department,
and we put some rhinestones on your face,
and there's a flying monkey.
This is going to be so fun.
And we had the best time.
We lived in Detroit, and she went to school there,
and we had friends there. We were in Birmingham Detroit and she went to school there.
And we had friends there.
Where? What town?
We were in Birmingham and she went to Roper.
Oh!
You know about Roper?
You've heard this story.
In fifth grade, a teacher said,
he's not dumb, he's really, really smart.
There's this school, Roper, that could tend to his needs.
You have to take an IQ test to get in.
I got in, my dad said, no fucking way.
Is he going to school with eggheads? And he pulled the plug on that. So I didn't go, but Roper's the thing I always wanted to get in. I got in, my dad said, no fucking way. Is he going to school with eggheads?
And he pulled the plug on that.
So I didn't go, but Ropers, the thing I always wanted to go to.
Should have been you.
I know.
Was it special?
It's a great school.
Boy, oh boy, I thought, well, maybe we should just live in Detroit.
We're very happy here.
We still have friends from that time, people that we're still in touch with.
We lived in a neighborhood.
We lived in a house.
We had a community.
I had friends.
She had friends.
And I was a fairy princess every day.
So it was great, and it was directed by the wonderful
Sam Raimi, who gave Matilda the best experience.
He would let her call action, and she would sit
in the director's chair, and she would come,
and he would say, there is my most honored guest,
Matilda, make way, everyone.
I'm always impressed when people are in circumstances
where they have so much going on,
they see an opportunity for somebody
who needs a little extra, and they go to it,
even though they have their hands full.
And he did that day in, day out.
Did you do any lake business?
Did you get on the lakes at all?
Michigan, lake life.
Yes, we did.
Isn't it Eden?
Are we living the wrong life?
Dax is adjusting.
We're finishing a house right now on a lake in Nashville.
Lake life.
Just got our first pontoon boat.
Man, you guys really figured it out, didn't you?
I don't want to make you jealous.
You can still do it.
I'm already jealous.
I saw that bus and I'm jealous.
That bus is driving to the lake house in June.
How long does that take?
Well, we had to stop in Idaho for two days.
We sleep in the Walmart parking lot in the bus.
I'm so happy for you and jealous for me.
Okay, you're invited.
I can't even tell you how into this I am.
I once for Thanksgiving rented an RV in Nevada, drove with Matilda to spend Thanksgiving at the animal shelter where you could sleep
with a variety of animals in your room.
Oh my goodness.
Pigs.
Oh, yes we did.
Dogs.
Yes we did.
Cats.
You could have animal sleepovers.
Wow.
So we did an animal sleepover, animal sanctuary Thanksgiving, and then we went to Zion in our
RV. Have you done that park? Not in the RV, but yes, then we went to Zion in our RV.
Have you done that park?
Not in the RV, but yes, I've been to Zion.
What a place.
But I thought I had done enough by renting an RV.
I was like, pretty good.
Mission accomplished.
Look at me, I'm driving an RV.
No, you need to check clearances.
You have to check park entrance and exit time.
I hadn't really masterminded the situation
and then found corkscrewing down to the bottom of Zion
and our RV wasn't allowed to pass back up
for our sunset horseback ride
because of a height requirement.
I was like, no, this isn't happening.
I have taken on more than I should have,
but I want to get back into the RV life,
but I'm a little.
Michelle, it's exactly back to being a kid
and crossing the stream,
because numerous times we are in that bus
and I'm getting into a tighter and tighter
and tighter situation.
And I'll say out loud, I don't know guys,
we may be backing down this mountain
in that thrill of will we get through?
It's exhilarating.
That was me.
I love that life.
I want that life.
And just as a little sidebar tidbit,
I think you'll appreciate it.
In COVID, we had had a baby and because of COVID,
my mother hadn't been able to meet the baby.
And she decided she was fed up with that.
And they had a little boat
and they sold their little boat
and instead they bought a camper,
attached it to their pickup
and they drove from Seattle, Washington
to upstate New York so that they could meet the baby.
Oh.
Deep COVID, she had packed the freezer
with enough food to last for a week,
didn't enter a grocery store, arrest, stop, anything.
RV life all the way.
Oh, nice. I know, it's in my blood. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, RV life all the way.
I know, it's in my blood.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, you come by it honest.
Okay, after the Oz and Powerful,
you do two Broadway shows.
You won a Tony for Blackbird.
Just nominated.
You were just nominated?
Yeah, I'm sorry to correct that fact.
No, you won.
Thank you.
Maybe it's a premonition.
Maybe it's coming up.
You love that?
The schedule for me seems very scary.
It's a terrible schedule.
But when your children grow up and they aren't as able to drop into the Roper school for
half a year and they really need to put roots down, you realize, oh, like I'm a plane that's
been grounded.
We have to give her a sense of permanence and structure and dependability.
So I need to work from home. And And looks like that Broadway is not going anywhere,
so is this something that I can learn in enough time
to figure out how to do it and make it a part of my life
so that I can have the opportunity to work from home?
That's what drove that decision.
And then you were great at that fucking asshole.
Okay.
Yeah, do you think, okay,
earlier just four minutes ago,
you said you'd bit off more than you could chew
with the RV.
Is that a motto?
Yes, that's me.
I'm feeling this as a through line.
You just take on a lot.
That's how I like to do things,
figure it out while I'm plummeting.
Which I honestly really do relate
to that childhood and nature.
I really see a direct correlation
from that kind of risk taking
to the kind of risk taking that I enjoy in my work.
Because in my life, I'm not like a thrill person
or a roller coaster person or highs kind of person,
but I enjoy it in my work
and I think it's because I learned it as a child.
Is your hack to just commit to it
before you actually think you can do it?
Some things I look at, I'm like, I have no idea.
There's no spark.
The rest of the time, there's a tiny little spark
and then a big cloud around it,
but it's the spark that I stay connected to
and that's what makes me say, I'll try.
But there has to be just this teeny tiny little mustard seed.
If you dare.
Okay, now my favorite thing you ever did was Manchester by the Sea. That is so funny.
You like to suffer. That's all I can conclude.
It's been a minute since I suffered.
No, no. You're skimming over dick and lots of fun things in there.
Lots of laughs.
Boy, that movie.
Did you already figure out how to not let things
seep in at that point?
That was harder.
Yeah, you guys are both so fucking heartbreaking
and good in that movie.
Okay, Fosse, Verdant, Incredible,
won an Emmy and a Golden Globe.
Well done.
I feel like this is in memoriam or something.
I'm like, have I come to the end of the...
Do you want to hear the funniest two minute story
about the in memoriam?
I've only been to the Oscars one time.
We went long ago and I directed a car chase movie
with Kristen for a million dollars, very few people saw.
And I worship Brad Pitt, would do anything
to make out with him.
And I've gone out to go to the bathroom and I'm coming back
and I've never met Brad at that point.
I've come up my aisle and I'm walking towards my seat
and as I'm getting close to Kristen,
she goes, he's talking to you.
I go, what?
She goes, Brad Pitt is talking to you.
And I turn around and he's like three rows ahead.
He's standing and he says, we loved your movie.
At that moment, I kind of forget I've even made him a movie.
And I go, what movie?
And he goes, hit and run, we love hit and run.
I can't believe this is happening.
I sit down, Kristen's like, oh my God, are you so,
I go, I can't, I'm smiling so big
and they immediately start the in memoriam.
I can't stop smiling.
I'm the happiest I've been since I got into this business.
And Kristen looks at me, she goes, stop.
Like, I'm so happy everyone died.
Oh!
They cut to you.
Yes.
They could have ended my life if they just cut to me.
I am glowing in that moment and it's all the people
are dying and I'm so happy.
That's amazing, thank you for that.
And I can't wait to see the movie.
It's like, what's wrong with him?
You gotta get the B-roll from that fucking award show.
I would kill for that footage.
It's just me so fucking happy.
I can see it now.
Okay, so again, now here's another moment
where it appears that you have a really,
really impossibly healthy relationship,
which is you take a two and a half year break
after Fableman's.
Had another baby.
That definitely imposes.
Do you love being pregnant?
I'm very lucky I have totally manageable pregnancies.
Yeah, yeah.
Kristin loves it.
You're gonna have another baby.
I have a vasectomy.
If we have one, it won't be mine,
but I'll raise it with love and understanding.
I know you would on the bus.
I have in the past taken off pretty big chunks of time
because when you work 15 hours a day for six months on something,
you really need to slow down and recharge
and reestablish your routines and your life. And then in there, there was COVID and two strikes.
You picked a good time to take a break.
A whole host of things. Yeah, I was really thrilled when we had a baby in COVID. That
really livened things up. I was like, welcome to the quarantine. Nuck you in.
So you know, we're not always home all day long, but currently we are.
For the next year and a half,
you're gonna think life works like this.
Do you have the tension, I know Kristen does a bit,
I know a lot of working moms do,
where it's like when you're working a lot,
you have some guilt about parenting,
and then when you're parenting a lot,
you have some guilt about not working.
I'm starting a job on Sunday and it hurts.
I don't know that I would call it guilt necessarily.
It hurts me and it feels biologically incorrect that I am going to spend this certain amount
of time away from my children. But it feels like the correct model to give them. So it
hurts my heart, but my head I think understands it. then when I'm with them, I just try to let them feel my full presence
so that when I'm not with them,
I can really extract and go do the work that I need to do
and the way that I need to do it.
It's like a back and forth.
It's not how I would like to live.
I'm very creature of habit.
It's hard for me to jump in and out all the time,
but that's what I tell myself,
is how to just kind of manage
my feelings around it.
That sounds like a very good framing of it,
which is it's fine to hurt,
but the guilt and the judgment's not part of it.
That's kind of how guys have gotten it for a long time,
which is no guy feels guilty that he's going to work.
Societally, he's never been asked to feel guilty about that.
He should feel guilty about that.
He should feel proud of that.
But you feel sad that you're not with your kids.
Yeah, it does a few things.
For a long time as a single mother, that was how I supported us.
Of course, it's in total utter necessity.
It is how our life runs.
And now, being in a marriage, I contribute to my family
and to mainly the desires and needs
and what I want to put in front of my children.
But I also am leaving a record of who I am and who I was.
And the things that I was interested in,
because you know, when you're a kid,
you look at your parents and you're like, you're my mom.
You don't have any desires or passions or dreams.
You were born to be my mom and that's it.
Yeah, and I throw a plate on the floor and-
You deal with it.
You kind of deal with it.
So I've often thought about work as a way
to leave a record for my children
should they want to pick it up about who I was
in my entirety.
Mothering is the large piece of the pie,
but there are other aspects.
What if we don't have enough time
to get to know each other more completely?
If you want to pick up some artifacts along the way,
these parts were also me.
I was just listening to Malcolm Gladwell talking about this,
but he might have been referencing someone else.
He was talking about the passing of his father,
and he said, I know him better now
than I did when he was alive.
Whew.
Which is such a beautiful thing
that you can keep knowing these people
in ways you could never have known them
when they were your mom or dad.
This is why I save my journals and all my stuff
and just think you might not be curious about it at all.
Right.
You might be like, yeah, no, I've had enough of her.
I think of that all the time, I've had enough of her.
I think of that all the time,
because I've journaled every single day
for almost 21 years as a sobriety commitment.
Often I'm journaling and I'm not editing for them.
And then I think they will one day have all these
and they can read all them.
And then I go, definitely we can open one of them up.
I don't know, I think they will.
I would.
I'd like to read what my dad was feeling
like at my exact age.
I would.
Yeah.
Okay, dying for sex.
In this two and a half year break, this got to you.
Was it a spec at that time or was it already set up?
It was a podcast and then Liz Merriweather
had written one script.
So there was just a pilot episode and the podcast
and the one, two punch of them,
I was like, oh, there's the spark and the cloud
and now I have to go figure this thing out.
But then I got pregnant again.
And so it put it on a hiatus.
And then after I was through postpartum
and breastfeeding fog and all that stuff,
I picked up the phone and I was like,
did they ever make that show I really wanted to do?
Who did that?
And they said no one.
And I was like, oh, great.
Then Liz and I picked up our conversation again
and never stopped.
I did a show for her for two years.
She's a Michigander.
Oh, that's right.
Yeah, yeah.
What a sense of humor.
My god.
Yeah, yeah.
It is unstoppable, even at times where it may or may not be a country.
It's rare you're afraid a woman will get canceled.
Let's just say that.
I think that's the best way I can euphemistically say
it's very rare to be afraid of a woman.
And I'm like, oh, you're okay.
I'm gonna go back to Brooklyn and give her that warning.
You had a lot of brave roles,
but this one, there's so much sex in it.
There's so much sexuality.
You're all.
And forget the sexuality.
I can hook up with people, that's fine.
So much masturbation.
So much.
We were just discussing this on a different episode
where I was like, as liberated as I am sexually,
when I've been caught jerking off,
not hiding the fact that I jerk off,
but getting caught is really humiliating.
Well, even that you're using the word caught.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah, if someone walks in and you're doing it,
I'm humiliated.
So for me, singing and masturbating on camera would be rough.
I'm going to write you a part where you get to do both.
At the same time.
Coming round the mountain when she comes.
Oh, God.
Oh, no.
Oh, look, I did it.
I did it.
I got to do the comedic version.
Oh, you're so brave.
Did that stuff spook you or do you commit to it and then you're like, I'll just come
to terms with that when we start shooting or what was that?
Yeah, I actually think that's a pretty good way to put it.
I'm not going to let small fears get in my way because I want the totality of it.
And if there are some things along the way that make me a little bit uncomfortable,
I'm going to figure out a way through them.
It's kind of the theme of the show.
Yeah, it really is.
Yeah, so your character has previously had cancer,
went into remission, and in the pilot,
we learn that your cancer's back,
and in fact, it's metastasized and you have stage four.
Now, this is one of the heartbreaking parts of the show.
I love J. Duplass.
He's the best.
He's such a wonderful, wonderful guy.
I hated to have to see him be a very annoying husband
who I'm rooting for you to leave.
And he's weirdly so good at it, even though he's the most
menshy, wonderful human.
He has really studied the other side and come back to
stick it to them in the form of this character.
You're like, oh, the good guy, the good husband who really is
actually just afraid of your inherent feminine power
and ideas and intelligence, but has somehow
managed to get along under the guise of good guy.
There are so many scenarios in the show
and so many different sexual encounters
and positions that I've never found myself
in working on a TV show before.
And so my memories of it are so strong
because humor is such a grounding force
for a memory. You don't want to remember
the thing that's so sad. You want to remember
the thing that has humor attached
to it. And my recall
for certain pieces of work can be so
spotty. And this, I can bring
it all back in my mind because I was like, oh, that was that wonderful actor that I peed
on. I'll never, ever, ever forget him. It's so indelible because they are all first time
experiences and they're all with the baseline of Liz's dangerous sense of humor.
That's what I love. It feels very dangerous, which is my favorite humor.
I really have to tell Liz to watch out for herself.
Because she got like a whip on her pen or something.
So your character has also not been intimate
with her husband for two years,
I think we learned in the show, maybe even three.
She's gone through a diagnosis and breast reconstruction
and a huge medical process.
And she desires connection and pleasure and
satisfaction even with her husband. And he's no longer able to see her as a sexual being.
She's a patient for him.
And even worse, maybe like a moon child's a source of confirming his identity as the
good guy.
Yeah, the caretaker. And then she gets a terminal diagnosis in the midst of all of this,
which is just a lightning bolt.
And she cleaves her life down the center
and splintered it off and gets in this little boat
and off she goes and she grabs her best friend.
And she's like, we're moving away from here.
And we're gonna go into uncharted territory
and let's do it together.
Yeah, I'm not gonna die alone,
but I'm gonna die with my best friend, Nikki.
It's a podcast.
Did you listen to the podcast?
I listened to the podcast twice and it just unraveled me.
I was so overwhelmed with emotion,
which is kind of an unusual experience.
I don't wanna cry, I don't really want to feel.
You're satiated in that department work-wise.
Yeah, a little work-wise, personal. I can take it on, but I can more deal with it in my head.
Or abstract suffering.
That is something that now I process through my brain instead of my heart.
And this show is like an arrow in me and I couldn't understand how it had bypassed all
these defenses that I thought I had put up.
Got behind the wall.
I think it was her bravery to live her death
as she lived her life, which is to make it her own,
and to really open it up and look at death
and look at how to stay creative inside of it.
How to not become a fixed identity cancer patient
when something so catastrophic happens to you,
to fight for other aspects,
to stay in that room, to be a whole person.
Yet have another storyline going other than dying.
Yes, even though you know that it's happening,
which is really the storyline of all of our lives.
Yeah, true.
The storyline of our life is dying.
It's just a timeline issue,
but we are able to kind of protect ourselves from it
and pretend that it's far enough away
that we don't need to deal with it
or really even know what it is,
what happens, what it looks like, what it feels like, and how you can be in charge
of it. Yeah. How did it work? I stopped working in the era of intimacy
coordinators. This one probably had a ton. That's why he stopped. You didn't want somebody telling you what you couldn't do.
Hold on, I'm out. Had you worked with them before?
No, I'd always just put on two pairs of pantyhose,
you know what I mean?
Sure, sure, sure.
I always just gave the famous Jack Nicholson line,
I'm sure you've heard it,
sorry if I get erect and sorry if I don't.
Oh God.
Neither's good.
Oh my God.
70s. Wow. Yeah, right? Can you imagine if that was a deal? Neither is good. Oh my God. Seventies.
I could imagine if that was a deal.
Really no response to that.
No.
No, the times they are a-changing.
I really enjoyed it. I wasn't sure how I was going to feel.
Because I definitely don't like to be told what to do.
I like to do my own thing.
I just don't like things in my way.
I like to have my space.
And it truly was much more like the experience
of having a choreographer who's really helping you
and not school marming you,
who's really helping you to create
a convincing simulation of something.
Also to make sure, you know, if you get into this business,
there's probably something wrong with you.
I mean, it's the circus.
You don't run away and join the circus
if you're not running away from something.
So I think that that means that performers bring with them a rich personal history.
And I applaud this move forward.
Maybe you don't need an intimacy coordinator, but you don't know what your co-star has been
through.
You don't know what your scene partner is dealing with.
And this allows them the safety and dignity
of being able to just tell one person
what they can and cannot do and keep their job.
So I'm all for it.
That part's fantastic.
I guess what scares me is you're already trying
to do something that can't be choreographed in life.
And you're trying to do it in this really crazy situation
in which there's cameras, there's 15 people in the room.
So already for me, I'm fighting against the mechanization of this thing you're hoping to
capture. I agree with everything you're saying and I hope that I've always been really
responsible and kind and I've always just chatted with people beforehand,
but I just fear this layer of, okay, now this whole thing has already been talked about,
decided, how on earth will this look natural and fluid?
I think though it can be adjusted and it can change,
but there's one person who knows the safe word.
Like you might go to the intimacy quarter and say,
I wanna fuck.
Well, you might go to the intimacy quarter
and say that, but you might say,
nothing's off limits for me.
I'm completely comfortable and I have nothing
that you need to know about.
And so there's no work around there.
They're not like, well, you're not allowed to do that.
It's just like if somebody else has boundaries,
something that they don't want to show,
something they don't want to touch,
the intimacy coordinator protects that
without it being obvious to the rest of the crew.
Nope, so-and-so won't do that.
They have a personal history.
But the truly great thing about it, though,
is because you are simulating something,
you have to sell it for that lens.
I might be doing what I think,
but it's not translating because of where the camera is.
So it's not selling that this thing is actually happening.
And one of the things I thought was so valuable
with intimacy coordinator is she could help you sell it
to a Frank.
Jay and I both know that I'm giving him a blow job.
We're fine with that and we know what that might look like
and what that might ask each of us to do,
but we don't know how to simulate a blow job.
Totally.
How do you not make it look like you're bobbing for apples?
How do you create the proper tension?
And now this is a job that's been around for a while.
When intimacy coordinators first came on the scene,
you're like, you were a PA yesterday. What do you mean you're the
intimacy coordinator? It's like the COVID officers too. You're a COVID safety officer
based on what?
Because you had the Purell?
Yeah, right. So they were these kind of made up jobs to meet a moment. But now these jobs
have become really fulfilled and filled by skilled qualified people. And we really relied on her expertise.
It's incredible.
I'm blown away with your performance.
I want to tell you one, it's not an intimacy coordinator,
but it's one sex scene story of mine.
I was doing something where I got to the point
where the lawyer's talking about what can be shown.
I'm not shy at all.
My deepest insecurity though,
is that anyone would see my butthole. I don't want anyone to see my butthole, and I'll show shy at all. My deepest insecurity though is that anyone would see my butthole.
I don't want anyone to see my butthole
and I'll show you everything else.
Zero self-consciousness.
And I get into the scene, we're walking,
okay, you're gonna be on top of her.
And I go, and where's the camera?
And I see it's on the floor, looking up at the bed
and I'm on top and it's gonna see my feet first.
And I'm like, they're definitely gonna see my asshole.
I know cameras work.
And I'm like, oh my God, they're gonna see my asshole.
We do a take, it's a long take.
And then I lay down for take two,
I'm certain the whole crew just saw my butthole
and the director comes in and he takes the sheet
and he moves it up just to cover my asshole.
And I'm like, okay, that's confirmation.
The entire gang just saw my butthole.
See, the intimacy coordinator would have known.
Might have been like, hold on.
I think we might just need to bring the camera up just a bit.
So hard too, because you know that that monitor is going out.
There's taps all over set.
There's daily...
Some editors like, I might...
The studio.
We have butthole here.
Cut, okay.
I just felt these sheepy,
pushed up between my black jeans.
Confirmation of your worst fear.
Truly, I've learned throughout my life.
I've been delusionally unaware that I'm 6'2",
that I'm white, that I'm all these things.
And so when the crew sees my butthole,
I'm not in danger.
There's nothing to be that afraid of for me.
And so it is a completely different dynamic.
Like I can laugh about that,
but it's a different scenario that for years
I didn't really even take time to consider.
Now I see like the worst thing that can happen to you
on a set is that you're gonna be embarrassed.
Embarrassment, we can live with that.
The stakes aren't as high as they are in real life.
Look, the stakes are high because you wanna do a good job
and you wanna get another job
and you wanna continue to have a livelihood,
but embarrassment we can live with.
Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
The last thing I wanna say about the sexuality in the show
is what occurred to me midway through was,
oh, this is distinctly female.
I've grown up watching tons of different sex scenes
in different movies and they have almost been
exclusively written by men or directed by men.
And there was something very unique and tangible
about this whole journey that felt definitively female.
Thank you, that's what we were going for.
We were like, is there such a thing?
Because the camera is the male gaze,
and is it even possible to make a camera a female gaze?
So that was definitely something that was on
our mind while we were making the show.
Yeah, you accomplished it. It's a completely different version
of this tale than I've ever seen.
That was the defining thing is that it
was clearly all women making this.
And the defining dangerous genius of Liz Merriweather.
Yes.
Because when you're making a show,
the scripts keep coming.
You sign onto a show,
but you don't have all eight episodes.
You don't know what the heck's gonna happen.
You've got one episode,
and you're kind of crossing your fingers.
She just hits them out of the park.
Script after script, we're shooting,
she's show running and writing and editing,
all these things that go into the title show runner,
and then delivering these scripts.
Yeah. Unbelievable.
It's crazy.
To me, where the comedy is,
is this intersection between your fantasy and reality.
I feel like that's constantly explored.
One after another, you have an idea of what's going to be great.
Then where the rubber meets the road,
there's just so much comedy.
I've thought about, what is gallows humor?
It's not really laughing at something or
making a joke because something is sad.
The humor is ever-present.
It's just the ability and the desire to locate it, to say, I want to attach laughter to this
experience.
Because you could just look through the whole thing darkly.
You could just say, ugh, this didn't go the way I wanted it to.
This didn't go the way I wanted it to.
And I'm dying of cancer.
And the real-life Molly, in the podcast, she has this totally innocent bemusement
about the situations that she would find herself in,
and also a complete lack of judgment
about what people wanted to do
and what their bodies craved
and how she was a part of that
and how it made her own body feel.
She was this observer.
Like an anthropologist.
And also, I don't wanna use the word angel,
she's like a very real person,
but she was looking for the best version of things
and sitting in a neutral space about bodies.
Even when she's talking about her cancer treatments
and what's happening to her body
and how her body is failing
and all of the secretions that a body can make
and that they're happening in tandem.
And sickness is something that is being done to your body
and your body is
acting against your own will and that sexuality is something where you can have strong ideas.
You can sort of both be in control and out of control, influenced by the other person
and then learning more about yourself in the process of it and that these two kind of bodily experiences, both full of feeling and surprises and smells, she found a way to hold both experiences right
until the very end. She was in hospice and she was still looking for ways to appreciate and love
her own body. She really loved putting on like beautiful lingerie. She would take a picture and
she would send a sexy selfie and some guy would be like, oh, that was like beautiful lingerie. She would take a picture and she would send a sexy selfie
and some guy would be like,
oh, that was amazing, thank you.
She refused to deny herself any pleasure
in the midst of all this pain.
I don't know if this is intentional
or this is just what my projection is.
It seems that she entered the experience
with the curiosity of a novel experience,
which is like what I would hope I could accomplish in that time.
Let's explore this new thing.
Yeah, because how do you know what you want
until you try it?
If you've been conditioned to believe
that a certain kind of sexuality is acceptable, okay, normal,
how do you even know what's out there?
And how do you know if you like it or don't like it
or if it's for you?
What's inherently bad or good
about a specific sexual activity?
People are like, that's bad or kinky or that's in this bucket.
But what makes that bucket that bucket?
A patriarchy?
Oh, yeah, yeah.
But things that we've inherited make that bucket that bucket.
I hope that the generational turnover is going to drain that bucket
into the bucket of, first of all, normal, acceptable, great,
pleasurable, and also personal.
Yes.
It belongs to you.
I remember I asked Nikki, I was like, what did people say?
When Molly found out she had stage four,
and she was dying, and then told everybody
that she was going on this sexual journey.
Did that open her up to any judgment where people like,
oh my God, you're never going to believe what Molly is doing.
She was like, nobody did. And I was like, that's great.
Well, she's got amazing friends then because...
Yeah.
...there wasn't chatter about it, but I think we're worried
what people would think or what people would say.
Or there's some notion of what you're supposed to do
at the end of your life.
Yes, the right way to do it.
Her refusal of that and also her desire to control it,
to know what it was and to say when enough was enough.
Childbirth and death are like these portals,
but they're so medicalized, but that in each experience,
you have the ability to say,
I've experienced enough pain
and my body is done with that aspect of this,
but to know the timelines of things. We know, oh when your water breaks you'll probably go into
labor and 30 sours, but death just isn't a part of our conversation. We don't know
the bodily function of it and we don't see it. For me that was the greatest
source of anxiety both with my dad and my stepdad, which is what's the timeline?
You're trying to prep yourself for how long is this experience? How often do I visit?
That unknown is so powerful.
It almost overrides the actual thing itself.
My dad was a blessing because it was small cell carcinoma.
So it's like, it'll be dead in three months.
Do it all.
That was great in retrospect.
My stepdad was like two and a half, three years of prostate cancer.
So it's like, when do you plan the trip?
When is it too late for this?
It's really hard to come up with that game plan when you
actually don't know what amount of time you're dealing with.
Right. And also the hope that what if there's more and
the treatment cycles that a person has to go through.
I haven't been with somebody at the end of their life.
That's not something that I know intimately,
but I know that the information is
so powerful to have hospice care.
You can have a death doula in the same way that you used to have a birth doula,
but somebody who really supports you and walks you through and helps you do it on
your own terms and it helps you understand end-of-life care. I know
somebody actually who switched from being a birth doula to being a death
doula. That place is so information rich. There's so much encoded
stuff about really how to live and to be witness and to give that person the experience that
they want in their body.
I think we are starting to look at it correctly. There seems to be a movement like Atul Gawande
where it's like, don't just look for longevity. The goal shouldn't necessarily be 11 months
instead of nine months. It should be, what do we want to do?
That's like a bigger question and maybe more important
than are we gonna try to get 11 or nine?
Squeeze every day out that we can.
Measure it a little differently
or evaluate it differently.
Also the irony of we're so obsessed
with the timeline of death,
we don't know about any of us.
We can just go through life as if,
well, that's far away,
but our timeline could be any minute.
Yeah.
Well, it's great.
I just want to call out one scene that's incredible.
When you talk about this dark and dangerous sense of humor,
the fact that you break your leg kicking Rob Delaney
in the dick, what a swing.
Good job.
What a swing is right.
I had a very small target to hit.
Yeah.
You're expecting one hilarious moment
and then this other thing happens
and you're like, holy fuck, this is a train wreck.
Yeah, they were like, no, no, it's safe.
He's wearing a cup.
Just swing as hard as you can and just hit the cup.
I was like, you really trust me to do this?
Again, back to the poking someone in the eyes.
It's hard enough to just kick and make sure you hit that.
And then act at the same time.
I was like, okay, it's just gonna be like hitting a mark.
And then Jenny's fucking great.
Jenny Slade is so great in it as Nikki.
It's fantastic.
I hope everyone watches it.
This has been a delight.
You're invited on a bus ride whenever you'd like.
Yes.
You could even follow behind in a smaller motor home
and you're like, well fuck if he's gonna make it.
I'll make it in this size one.
We have a minivan which I pretend is a motor home.
I treat it like a motor home.
We've got survival, you know, we've got all the like snacks.
Yeah, we got all the stuff.
It's my starter motor home.
Yeah, your escape pod.
Yeah, it really is.
Damn, I just wanna be on that bus.
Do you ever podcast from the bus?
Do you ever go like, on the road?
I do fact checks from it.
I'll probably do some this summer.
You figured it all out.
But you're a delight, most powerful smile in real life.
We've been wanting to have you on for years and years
and years so we feel very lucky.
And thanks for trusting us.
I know this isn't necessarily your cup of tea.
It feels flattering.
It feels like a gift you gave us.
You guys, stop, stop.
I hope I've lived up to the seat on the couch.
Can I do a podcast where I interview you guys
because it's so weird to have so much attention
on oneself and your whole life.
You don't take a trip down memory road
and look at your life very often.
Yeah.
It's not a good thing to do really.
Little indulgence.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
So you can come here and get it out.
Next time I'm gonna make you guys walk through.
I wanna open up your roads.
Anytime.
All right. Adore you.
Good luck with everything.
Thanks for coming.
Thanks for having me.
I sure hope there weren't any mistakes in that episode,
but we'll find out when my mom, Mrs. Monica,
comes in and tells us what was wrong.
Do you smell something?
No.
Why do you smell something?
What's happening differently here?
Oh, interesting.
What do you think it is?
There is something different.
I don't know.
You like it?
Yeah, you look great.
But I don't know if you just like,
you were at a photo shoot beforehand.
Oh no.
Good job, Rob got it.
What'd he say?
Eye makeup.
Is that what it is?
Is it lower eyeshadow?
I'm wearing eyeliner.
This is a dingles.
Really good job, Rob.
I was looking specifically at the darkness there
and wondering is that all that's happening.
Okay.
But major dingles,
cause last night I hosted, Charlie and I tried to do old movie night
for his kids and my kids.
And then Charlie's so much younger than me,
he hasn't seen a lot of classics.
Sure.
He hasn't seen Raiders of the Lost Ark.
Okay, neither have I.
Last night was Pirates of the Caribbean, the original.
We were watching it,
and Captain Jack Sparrow is so fantastic in it.
And he looks so fantastic in it.
And he looks so sexy with eyeliner. Oh, eyeliner, uh-huh, he does.
And it's more than that,
it's like smudged all the way down.
And I said out loud to Charlie, I'm like,
God, I wish that was a more acceptable look for guys.
I would love to have that look.
Why don't you try it?
I think we should try it first with brown eyeliner on you.
I think black is gonna look really,
let's work our way up.
Okay, we'll go in steps,
but I definitely had it for Wednesday.
Oh yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, that's fun.
Yeah.
Okay, now walk me through why now,
eyeliner at this late stage.
I posted a picture of my mom and I on Mother's Day.
Did you see it?
No.
Rob, do you wanna put it up?
Yes.
Okay, great.
I gave Rob something else to put up too.
This is gonna be very visual heavy.
You better go to that YouTube.
Yeah, I guess people,
I read a lot of people wanted to see the haircut,
which delighted me.
Of course.
My mom is wearing eye makeup,
she's wearing under eye makeup in it, or whatever,
she's wearing eyeliner.
And I was like, oh, it looks so nice.
And I used to wear it.
Yeah.
And I decided to-
When did it stop?
Oh, well also the majority,
I would say like 99.99% of the comments on that picture
are about how I look exactly like her.
Interesting.
Yes.
Yeah, yeah.
I take it as a major compliment.
Are you wearing eyeliner baby Monica in this photo?
No.
Okay, look at the size of your eyeballs relative.
That's like Vinnie.
You've got a similar ratio.
Oh, that's the dream to look like Vinnie.
Yeah, your head is only like three extra eyeballs size,
which is unique.
But her eyes are very big too.
They're huge and banging, yeah.
Yeah, and so anyway.
Big eggs, that's a way,
that's how you can tell someone has big eggs.
Okay, the size of their eyes.
Yeah, they're correlated.
Anyway, so she is wearing eyeliner,
if you can see under her eyes,
and I thought it looked really pretty,
and so I wanted to bring it back.
I think she looks like Alana Glazer too.
What?
That feels, that feels, that feels left field to me, but.
It does?
Yeah, yeah.
Well, she looks so cute.
We love Nermy.
She does look so cute.
My dad.
And you look like a little guy, like a little boy.
She got a little boy.
Okay.
Nobody wants to hear that.
God, your compliments have gotten so bad.
I have some photos of me I'll share with me carrying,
you know, I carried a purse for like two years.
And so I'll get you some of those and you can go,
oh, what a beautiful little girl.
Well, I'm not gonna.
Okay.
Okay, I wouldn't say that. I'm not gonna, okay? I wouldn't say that.
I'm not trying to hurt your feelings all the time.
Anyway.
Anyway, it's very cute pic.
Anyway, so that's what the eyeliner is about.
Cause you saw your mom in it and you're like,
well, why aren't I wearing it?
And I thought it looks pretty.
And since we look the same, I was like, oh yeah,
I should start doing that again.
Right.
Okay, I have a few things to talk about.
I know, we're in this situation where you,
I know you have a story for the last two days,
but we were waiting for the fact check.
Yeah.
Which I guess is, I guess it's not a complaint.
That's fun.
I have something to look forward to.
Yeah.
But it is crazy to know you, you're like,
oh, you know what, I'll just wait.
And then I'm like, oh God, wow, I can't hear.
The anticipation.
The anticipation.
The anticipation just also,
it's so foreign for someone to say,
I have this great thing and you have plenty of time
and then you go, but I'm not gonna tell you for two days.
And you just sit in silence and don't say it.
Okay.
Okay.
You went back to Atlanta, is it involving that?
Yes, but before I get into my story,
I just wanted to remind,
people have missed the Mo episode
because they didn't know who he was,
I recommend to go back and listen to that.
It's a really good episode.
Kate Mara voice messaged me today.
She did.
Uh-huh.
I just saw her in Friendship.
Oh, I'm dying to see it.
I wanna see it this weekend.
Is it great?
It's great.
It's crazy. I mean, do you see it, Rob? Yeah, I went to the V dying to see it. I wanna see it this weekend. Is it great? It's great. It's crazy.
I mean, do you see it, Rob?
Yeah, I went to the Vista and saw it.
By the way, go to the Vista.
That's what she said.
We went on a Saturday.
I saw Sam Richardson.
Oh, fun.
I actually felt like, oh my God,
I live in a neighborhood with a neighborhood theater
and I actually know people.
Like it was a very heartwarming experience.
And the Vista was sold out on a Saturday afternoon.
That's awesome.
And Tarantino did a fucking awesome job
with like the popcorn stand, everything's retro.
So it's like the old cartoon.
Did you go to Pam's coffee?
Nope, just to the movie,
but the popcorn, Nathan's hot dogs,
the way the signage is, is very nostalgic.
It's awesome.
Yeah.
And it's an insane movie. And it really, it tests how much you can fuck
with the historic role of a protagonist.
Like in Aristotle's laws of story.
Because this, it's Tim.
Yeah, Tim Robinson.
Tim Robinson.
And he's being very Tim Robinson.
He's going berserk.
Yeah.
And you kind of want everyone in his life
to just get rid of him,
but he's your hero, so it's like this.
Mm, interesting.
Right, Rob?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, he's insane.
Yeah, and some of the biggest laughs
in a theater that I've heard.
Oh, I cannot wait.
I can't wait to see it.
And Paul Rudd is just, what a champion
for taking that role
and leaning into all of his Paul Ruddness in a great way.
I love him. Love him.
Kate messaged me that she was listening to the Mo episode
and that she loved it and that it was really beautiful.
And she didn't know him before
and now she's gonna watch the show.
Oh, wonderful.
Yeah, most of the comments are people saying
I wasn't aware of him.
This is one of my favorite episodes.
Yeah, great.
So check it out if you haven't seen that.
All right, listen to that.
Okay.
Or seen it, you can say that now.
Or seen it or listened.
Another thing before my story.
Yeah. Two things.
Oh my gosh, so much foreplay.
Ding ding ding, Easter egg.
Easter egg.
Easter egg spurt.
Egg spurt.
That's what I said, Easter egg spurt.
Easter egg spurt, okay.
Wow.
But wait, why is Easter in there?
Because it's an Easter egg.
Oh right.
Oh my God.
Okay. Easter egg spurt.
That is perfect, it just took me a while to compute. Yeah. Okay. Easter expert.
That is perfect.
It just took me a while to compute.
Yeah.
Okay.
This morning I was on Instagram
and I saw Mandy Moore had like,
she posted something and it was when she was young
and it reminded me of the hunked episode.
Where she destroyed my house.
Yes, and I had to watch it.
Oh wow. Yeah, like got in my head. And it was on YouTube? Yes, and I had to watch it. Oh, wow. Yeah, it got in my head.
And it was on YouTube?
Yes, and I watched it this morning,
and it is so funny.
It is so funny.
That's the only one I ever broke in,
I think I told you that.
When did you break?
I don't think I was prepared
for the level of devastation that occurred.
They dropped this fucking steel I-beam
on this mobile home
and it flattens it like a pancake.
And I'm watching it, looking at it and the cameras,
and then I have to turn and act like I'm like emotional
and I am laughing.
I'm like, I'm like worried I'm not gonna be able to,
because you know I love when stuff breaks,
like when a car drives through a window or something,
that's my specific trigger.
Yeah, and I had to turn around for a minute and like regroup.
Oh, is that when you said I have to go see
what the damage is?
No, I think I had gotten it together by then.
What an insane bit that was.
It's really fun for me to see you before I knew you.
Tell me how.
God, I guess this might sound like one of your compliments.
Oh great.
One of your horrible compliments.
Because I know you so well.
Yeah.
I think sometimes I forget the obvious things about you.
Like?
Like when I'm watching it, I was like, God, he's so funny. Oh, wow, thank you. Like? Like when I'm watching it, I was like, God, he's so funny.
Oh, wow, thank you.
That's a great compliment.
I didn't see that coming.
But I know that about you, obviously.
You're funny every day.
I'm around you.
But you forget like I was a comedian at one point.
I don't know.
I was just like, oh yeah, oh yeah.
Dax is so funny.
Oh, thank you.
And really good.
Maybe stop there,
because that's great. I could float on that. No, I wanna go is so funny. Oh, thank you. And really good. Maybe stop there, cause that's great.
I could float on that.
No, I wanna go on.
Okay.
I wanna ruin it.
And like same, if I watch Parenthood,
I'm like, oh yeah, he's so good.
Oh, thank you.
But then when we're here and I'm like, you know,
annoyed by you cause you're doing like free, you know.
Cause I'm your brother and your father.
Exactly, then it's like a weird dissonance.
I kind of don't think of that person as the person I know.
As again, I have a couple friendships
where I juggle both things.
I juggle what I feel about them on screen
and then the reality of them in person as a friend.
Right.
But even now, if I see you on screen now,
ever since I've known you.
There's no magic, right?
It's like just disillusioned.
I mean, I could still see objectively like,
oh, that's funny or oh, that's good,
but I'm not, it's not the same.
I totally get it.
It's weird.
Yeah, I can imagine even if I turned in a performance
that was funnier than Frito or the grocery store movie,
I did,
whatever that was called. Employ the Month.
Yeah.
Which for my money, I think is the best I ever did.
If I did something that was like,
we could measure it was the same,
you just wouldn't tickle you
because you sit on a couch with me.
I think it would tickle,
I would have different feelings about it.
Right.
I would have different feelings about it. I would have more like,
oh, like my friend did a good job feeling.
As opposed to like just blind, like, oh, that's so funny.
You can click into me being a stranger basically.
Yeah.
Yes, yes, yes, yes.
That makes sense.
Yeah.
And then, and I always have this weird, like, you know,
it ended and I was like, I can't believe that's him.
Like, I can't believe I know that person the way I do.
Life is weird.
Yeah.
Because I watched Punk'd.
Right, but that was a completely different life ago, right?
Yes, yes, it's so strange.
Yeah.
Life is strange.
Yeah, it feels like a different life ago.
Even like what I do now,
it's almost as if I am now a roofer
and I used to be a car mechanic.
Like there's something.
Yeah, you changed industries sort of.
Well, definitely in that like the goals are so different.
Yes.
The goals on Punk'd were like,
be as funny as reality will permit
and find the line and try,
we'll try your hardest to be right there.
Right.
And that was just such a specific mindset.
And then that's not what the mindset is in here.
For now, which is crazy, you know, we're going on,
well, we've already passed my longest job ever.
Yeah. And there'll be a point where, you know, we're going on, well, we've already passed my longest job ever. Yeah.
And there'll be a point where, you know,
I'll have done this as long as I acted,
which is a crazy thought to me.
Yeah, and this is, does that make you feel good or bad
or does it matter?
Well, good in that, oh, fun,
I got to experience so many things.
Yeah. Bad in that,
well, this last 10 years was much quicker
than the formative 10 years, right?
Like, punk to, like, 2003 to 2013,
punk to end of parenthood is, to me, feels very long.
Right.
This show feels like we've been doing it for three years.
Yeah, yeah.
And that part's alarming.
Right.
Yeah, but I did have a dream last night
that I was acting in something.
Oh. Yeah, it's kind of like my a dream last night that I was acting in something.
Oh. Yeah.
It's kinda like my relapse dreams.
And I tell you, my relapse dreams are always the same.
I'm like, I'm out of town and I'm drinking a few beers.
Uh-huh.
And I realize, I remember,
oh, I always drink a few beers when I'm out of town
and it always works.
Hmm.
And then when I wake up, I literally have to go like,
you never drank in a few years when you were out at,
and no, I haven't.
And then similarly last night, I was like taking a roll
and we still have this.
So it was like, I was having to juggle both things.
But then I had been doing that for a long time.
Weird.
Life is curvy and swervy.
It is, it's got curves and swerves.
And I wonder, I don't know,
who knows how long we'll be doing this.
Right?
Unknowable. Unknowable.
But I think what's weird for me is sometimes I wonder like,
this potentially is your acting.
Like this is my first life.
Yes, of course.
And there might be for me, not likely,
there will be another thing after this.
Exactly, so imagine fast forward 12 years to my age
and you've now been doing something longer
than you ever did the podcast.
Yeah, I know it's wild.
But it feels like a third of the time.
It's just very confusing.
Yeah, weird.
Anyway, it was really funny.
If you wanna check that out, it's on YouTube.
While you're on YouTube,
go ahead and head over to the armchair expert.
And subscribe.
We've never asked anyone to subscribe.
I've always been really adverse to asking that.
Go ahead and subscribe.
Go fucking subscribe,
even if you're never gonna watch it.
You should watch it. Another, you should watch it.
Another, okay, I guess I've just been taking in
a lot of you on accident.
Oh, so sorry.
Because, well, I've been down a Malcolm Gladwell rabbit hole.
Yeah, just for fun.
Because I-
Remembered how great the show is.
Yes, after I listened to the Joe Rogan one
and then the RFK one, I was like,
fuck, this show's so good, I forgot.
And I thought, oh, I'm sure I've missed
a lot of these episodes,
so I should go back and look at some.
And he did a bunch before Revenge of the Tipping Point,
or during that time.
We had him on for that show,
so I don't think I was paying much attention
to Revisionist history then,
but I was like, oh, I'll check this out.
And there's one, I just have to really, really commend him.
Actually one's a ding, ding, ding,
because it's about him basically saying
there's a section in the tipping point
about the broken windows theory,
which comes up in an upcoming episode for us,
which is funny.
And he comes on and he says,
I was wrong about that.
He straight up says, I was wrong, this is why.
And it is so interesting to hear someone just come out
And it is so interesting to hear someone just come out
and be like, this thing that got a ton of traction for him
is wrong. Because it extended into stop and frisk.
Yeah, but it now looking at it over time,
crime went down, went down after stop and frisk
was taken away.
And all these people, Giuliani, Trump,
and they use the phrase, right?
They use broken windows.
And he's like, that's not why,
but they use it as a scare tactic.
He said, I believed it.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
And now I know it's not true.
And it was really funny.
He plays this clip from Giuliani
and then he plays a clip of Trump saying it.
And he says, sometimes I stay up at 3 a.m.
And I think, oh God, did he read the tipping point too?
And everyone read it.
And that's such a weird thing to think. You wrote something that everyone read it and that's such a weird thing to think. Like you wrote something that everyone read
and was persuaded by the pressure.
That's a lot of pressure.
Yeah, and again, you can't really consider that
when you're writing.
Yeah, you can't, but it's just wild.
Anyway, so then he has a couple of episodes
on the varsity blues, the kids who, the parents who paid for their kids
to go to Ivy League universities.
And you are in those episodes.
I am?
Yeah, you're a voice actor.
Oh, when they get to the-
The trials.
Oh, shit.
Yeah.
I did, wow, that's funny.
I never listened- You did hear.
I never listened to that.
Me and Britt Martley?
Yes.
Funny, because I listened to when we redid
the Little Mermaid, but I didn't listen to that.
That's crazy.
I was really, it was so weird,
because I was just like listening to these episodes
and all of a sudden he's like,
and to play blah, blah, blah, these lawyers.
He's like, my voice actors, Britt Marling and Dax Shepard.
And I was like, oh my God, what is going on?
Infiltration.
Yeah, full infiltration.
And then you go into your bathroom and go, hi.
You talk to me through my speaker.
Anyway, so that was great.
I'll try to keep it coming.
I'll try to do some more.
You're just popping up all over the place.
Yeah, more surprises.
I gotta get on a makeup tutorial.
I gotta get on a fashion podcast.
Yeah, you do.
I gotta get on Elizabeth and Andy.
Exactly.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Okay, now I have a story.
Okay.
I was home to visit my mom for Mother's Day
and I heard the craziest story
and I was like, maybe I shouldn't bring it up
because it's like kind of, it is sort of political
but it's wild and I feel like I have to share it.
My friend's sister lives in pretty rural Georgia
and she is a kid in preschool
because the public schools really aren't very good.
What's like the PC term for that?
Whatever, they're not good.
Underperforming?
Yeah, I guess so.
She sends her kid to a private school in rural Georgia
and it's pre-K through 12.
Okay.
So for some, I don't know if it was Halloween
or some thing, they threw this like big assembly event pre-K through 12. Okay. So for some, I don't know if it was Halloween or something,
they threw this like big assembly event and each grade
had to dress up as a theme.
And so the pre-K was like, you know, superheroes
and princesses, whatever.
Yeah.
Standard theme.
And then one of the themes for like a youngish grade,
look to me like third grade, I saw pictures of this,
was Hurricane Helene, that was the theme.
Oh, interesting.
Yeah, yeah.
Which is-
Like what do you play, Wind, Broken House?
Well, exactly, so some people were like the Hurricane.
God, that's a, they got fucked.
What one girl was a FEMA check.
Okay.
Uh-huh.
And-
I mean, that's on-
But like-
Story.
But why do Hurricane Helene?
Yeah, why?
Oh, because, well, if they were in Northeast Georgia,
I know that- It ravaged that Asheville's very close to there
and it got submerged underwater.
It ravaged Augusta.
Right.
But that's also why it's weird, right?
If we did the fires.
Exactly, exactly.
Like it impacted that area.
Okay, one more chance at generosity here.
Remember I was saying the time 100,
like first 40 are so easy.
Oh yeah, that person knew Dodgable.
That actor, the last 15, you're like,
he had a great golf swing.
You know, you don't even.
So 12th grade, maybe they just got to third grade last.
And they're like, we have used every category.
Well, you haven't heard the knockout punch here.
There's another grade.
The theme was the Trump assassination.
And this is real.
This is almost impossible to believe.
Exactly.
And yeah, forget politics,
just like the assassination of anybody.
I know.
And all these boys are dressed up as like Secret Service.
And then there's one boy dressed up as Trump.
And he has this, the full mask.
He's like wearing a mask, a Trump mask.
And like, you know, his ears all bandaged up.
And then there's like, you know, kids,
kids fifth grade-ish looking kids in MAGA hats.
And it was really, it was like, oh yeah.
And also what my friend, my friend, she was like,
this is how it happens.
Like if you have any questions about like how,
if you're like, you know, living in California
and you're like, I just don't get it.
This is how.
It starts so young.
Yes, yes, yes, yes.
Like, isn't that wild?
It is wild.
And I don't know why this is my compulsion.
I don't want you to be mad at me.
I know, I don't want to get mad at you
and I don't want it, and it's fine if it's your compulsion,
but I would, I mean, these, my friends who are also,
like my friends who were shocked by this, right?
They're Georgia people.
They're not like what you would say is-
Coastal city elites.
Exactly, and they're like, there's no way that's real.
So I think that's very extreme.
Yeah. And I think it's very extreme. Yeah.
And I think it's bonkers.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And they are in rural Georgia,
hearing about a real case here in LA,
where a child identified as a cat,
and they put a litter box in the bathroom.
Okay.
So I only say that to just say,
if we focus on the crazy ones,
like they're on both sides
and neither are really that representative.
But no school here is doing dress up like a,
be it, pretend you're a cat day.
No, but they're putting a litter box in the bathroom.
That's truly craziness.
That's, I mean, look, that's one story you heard, right?
Like that's not a sweeping thing.
This person is our president.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
He was elected.
Well, no, I'm only talking about the school's decision.
I'm hoping that that's as rare as the litter box
in the bathroom.
That's all I'm saying.
Because I'm just, my optimistic self is hoping that that is rare is the litter box in the bathroom. That's all I'm saying. Cause I'm just, my optimistic self is hoping
that that is rare.
I don't know.
I mean, it's a private school.
Right.
Here's what I would hate is someone,
here's the litter box story, right?
They're in Georgia.
You know, he's fucking California school.
And I just would go like, well, hey, just,
my kid's school isn't like that at all.
It's public. Sure.
But that is part of why, like a public school
isn't able to do things like that.
Don't go that crazy.
Yeah, and then I was thinking, like,
if I lived there, what would I do?
These are the options?
A very underperforming public school
or this, like this is a bad situation
for people making decisions.
You'd probably have to live somewhere different,
which is like the Sedaris thing.
It's like, yeah, if you're a gay in a small town,
go to the city.
But you might not have the money.
Like, I mean, there's just a lot of factors here
that make it for me.
Like, I understand this is hard.
You can live low income in all states, right?
You could be up in Oregon or Eastern Washington.
There's equivalencies in liberal states,
if that was your desire.
Was the parent, they were like,
what the fuck's going on?
Mortified, yeah.
And what did their kid have to dress as?
Like Superman or something.
Oh, okay, great.
Thank God.
But that's what I was like, now this kid is in a,
let's say this kid was of age,
of one of these horrible themes, right?
And his mom, my friend's sister is like,
no, you're probably not gonna dress up as a FEMA check.
Then he might be like, well, I'll be an out cat.
This is so-
The pressure.
Yes, it's upsetting.
It is, it is, it is.
Cause I know me.
And an opportunity.
Like my mom would say to me,
what do you think of all these kids
calling each other fags on the playground?
What do you think it's like to be gay and hear that?
Yeah. What do you think it's like to be gay and hear that?
What do you think it's, you know,
like my school is all Christian.
We didn't go to church on Sunday
and other people that, you know, like, well, what do you,
it's also not bad to be an outcast and to be,
it's a character builder.
And if your parents are engaging you on it,
then that's an opportunity.
Guess you're right.
It's just hard, it's hard to be an outcast.
It's really hard.
I went to church with my friends.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Cause you know.
Can I say one thing?
It's actually weirdly related to your story.
Yeah.
Rob, will you put up the thing I sent you?
I just stumbled upon this.
This is Quirky Maps, I guess is the source.
I follow a few different infograph accounts on Instagram
and they're so fun.
Now this is a country-wide breakdown
of largest employers by state.
Interesting.
And what's undeniable about this map is
you can quite clearly see the states
where Walmart's the number one employer
is almost universally a red state.
And then lo and behold, the states where the university's
the number one employer, which is several,
they're all without exception also blue.
They vote blue.
Yeah. So it's interesting of all, without exception, also blue. They vote blue. Yeah.
So it's interesting, of all the employers, really,
there's just three categories, or really four.
There's either you work for Walmart,
you work for a healthcare, like a hospital system,
or a university system.
And there are only two that are like manufacturing.
Michigan, General Motors is the largest employer
and then Boeing in Washington.
But I just thought this was a very informative entry.
Like in Colorado, the largest employer
is the Denver International Airport.
That's really wild.
Yeah, like MGM resorts makes sense in Nevada.
But just all these university systems,
that's pretty fascinating.
Well, but North Carolina is the university system.
And North Carolina is-
It's purple.
It is far more liberal than the surrounding states.
Yeah.
And it does make sense for like your bread and butter,
like people are pretty loyal to their bread and butter.
Yeah, that's interesting. Ours is- That's kind that's interesting. Ours is the university system, CLA or UC, I guess.
The UC system.
New York is the university.
It's like, you talk about the elites and the coastal.
It's like, oh yeah, that's, well, there's
pretty obvious reason.
A lot of it's healthcare.
Yes, 16.
So 21 states, the largest employer is Walmart.
16 states, the healthcare is the largest.
Eight for education and five for others,
of which there's really no pattern.
21 states, Walmart is the largest employer.
Wow.
Yeah.
Wow.
Anyways, I guess find quirky maps.
I liked that.
That's cool, I like that.
Yeah.
All right, Fax?
We're gonna transition into Fax now.
Okay, great.
Yeah.
Ha ha ha.
Stay tuned for more Armchair Expert, if you dare.
Okay, Michelle Fax, Larry Mantle. Oh, great.
He deserves this.
He is a man.
Tul.
Okay, Larry Mantle is an American radio talk show host and journalist on the Southern California NPR station
LAist, LAist?
LAist?
Mantle hosts Air Talk with Larry Mantle,
which is the longest running daily talk show
currently on Los Angeles radio.
Air Talk, that's the show Kristen's obsessed with.
Okay.
Yeah.
There's a picture of him we have up here.
He's 66.
Mm-hmm.
He was born here in LA.
He has a great origin story.
I wanna say like he applied at NPR and he didn't get it.
And then he went to another station and he started
and he was so good then they brought him in.
There's some kind of fun.
Let me read you.
Oh, you know?
Let me just shave the sides.
No.
Okay, go ahead.
Impulse control issues.
They say it's part of ADHD.
I got a little bit, but that's okay.
Oh my God.
Oh my God, okay.
While in graduate school,
Manta was living in Pasadena
and listened to NPR's All Things Considered on KPCC.
He knew that KPCC also produced
a daily one-hour local news program
and used community volunteers
and Pasadena City College students
to supplement a small professional staff.
Mantle started volunteering at KPCC
and was soon anchoring newscasts and
providing play-by-play of college and high sports carried by the station.
Later, Mantle became the first local morning edition host for KPCC. After
briefly working for CBS News Talk affiliate,
KPI never shine, Mantle returned to KPCC as news director in 1983. Two years
later, he launched Air Talk with the intention of combining listener calls
from an analytic and news savvy audience
with local experts and newsmakers.
That's all it says.
Yeah.
It doesn't say that he struggled.
Okay.
Sounds like a rocket ship, right?
Of success.
Because of his enormous talent.
Yeah, it's true.
He has a son.
That's a long time.
Did you say 1983?
He returned as the news director for KPCC in 1983,
two years later, so 1985.
Okay, so 40 year anniversary for him.
Wow, that's cool.
Dude, congrats.
Very big congrats.
Okay, she said it was a tough day for MPR.
That was Friday, a couple Fridays ago, I guess.
He had the day before Trump had issued an executive order directing the
corporation for PBS, well, Public Broadcasting's board of directors to
cease federal funding for NPR and PBS.
Yeah, so let me just say, A, I hate this.
This is fucking ridiculous.
But I will say I was a little comforted when I read,
not PBS, I think that one's really largely federally funded,
but NPR is only getting, I wanna say the number I wrote
was like 2% from federal funding.
So I am a little relieved that potentially
they can survive that.
Yeah, hopefully.
Is much of a ridiculous.
Hopefully people.
Like what do we spend money,
the shit we spend money on is like,
let's trim out all this stuff that's so low impact.
I know.
Doesn't move the needle at all.
And we lose all of our favorite things
from the public funding.
Yeah, I know.
And we also-
The Sesame Street and everything, you know.
Yeah, and it's making sure that media stays divisive and private, and that's like the
opposite of what we need right now.
I mean, I do my best to give the argument a fair shot, right?
There are many left-leaning media outlets, right? There are many left leaning media outlets
and there's right leaning media outlets.
PBS is not, like when they have the election
and they do a two hour thing on Hillary
and they do a two hour thing on Trump,
they are equally hard hitting.
Yeah, I know.
But I was trying to think, is NPR left leaning?
Maybe.
But is it left leaning because people on the left are listening like that's not a fair
Assessment, I guess though his his point would be if if all of Americans are funding it and half of Americans are conservative and half
Our liberal it's not fair that the output is leaning left. That's fit. That's a fair
critique now that the output is leaning left. That's a fair critique. Now, cut it entirely or try to correct that
is two different arguments.
But is it left leaning because it's telling the truth?
There's some truths that are happening right now
that maybe Republicans would say are left leaning,
but they're the truth.
No, I more mean like if they're gonna do,
KC or W is gonna do a story on Unhoused.
Is it gonna be the liberal version of Unhoused
or is it gonna be the conservative version?
And I do think probably more often
it is the liberal point of view.
I don't know.
I don't know about what they.
I know I listen to NPR and I like it.
So I'm inclined to think it probably is a bit more left.
I guess that's my gut intuition about it.
But again, is it what you're attracted to
is that it's true facts being told?
Well, like I'm pro game marriage.
So when that was all being talked about,
everything I'm hearing on there is the experts talking
about the reality of that situation.
But I'm pro that union, right?
There's not, they're not gonna give 30 minutes
to a Christian saying that God says this is wrong.
They're not gonna do that on NPR.
But your argument might be that that shouldn't,
you're right, and that shouldn't get 30 minutes on NPR.
But I guess if it is federally funded
and it has to be reflective of all the people
that are paying for it, then maybe it does.
I don't know.
Well, my guess is, yeah, maybe I just don't know,
but I assume they do cover both sides.
Like I think the daily, often you hear
the other point of views.
They will interview people who are on both sides,
so you can hear what everyone is thinking.
Well, now, The Daily, I don't know if you listen to it,
but I really encourage you to listen to it.
These two professors at Princeton wrote a book,
which is they have analyzed now for four years
the COVID response.
And they take all this World Health Organization
had just done a study on social distancing
for an airborne viral congestive virus.
And they concluded it doesn't work, it has no impact.
And so their point is,
and these are liberal Princeton professors,
they're like, where was the New York Times
saying what about this article? Like, we did, the
left did a bad job of being, pushing hard and pressure
testing the things we were being told. And there's now a
lot of evidence of that.
But you can't do it until you're in it and after.
Well, no, because this report that had been funded by the
WHO, it existed. It existed.
Anyone who wanted to look would have found
that they just ran this study
and that it was recommended that that wouldn't work.
Based on what though?
What pandemic?
On a airborne virus.
But that affected this level.
It couldn't have.
You'll hear them.
I wanna get them on.
I think when you hear it, you'll be very convinced,
as I was, like, oh wow.
Normally we would have heard this counter argument
to what was being proposed.
It's how the fourth estate works.
And what these two professors are saying is like,
there was an institutional breakdown,
and then we need to come to terms with that,
and we need to prevent that from happening again.
And one of the people that,
and now the Dailies brave enough to now run it in 2025,
but the Dailies would have never touched that WHO study
during the pandemic, which they just should have.
They really should have.
And we'll have the experts on it, I think you'll agree.
And there were many, it got so politicized,
the whole event, and I'm not defending the right,
the right stance was fucking ridiculous on it, right?
But there was a big breakdown and you have to ask then why.
And I think part of the explanation as do these people
is like every journalistic output became so politicized,
they're either left or right.
We need PBS, we need MPR,
we need ones that are not servicing the market.
Right.
And, you know.
That's what I said.
Anyway, that had just happened the day before,
so that's why she said that.
Uh-huh.
Now, Leonardo DiCaprio and his T-Rex.
Oh, right. we need a good reminder
of what's going on here.
Yeah, it says he doesn't own a T-Rex.
He has an interest in dinosaur fossils
and has purchased several, including a Mosasauric skull
and an Allosaurus skull.
But he is not known to own a complete T-Rex skeleton
or fossil, according to many sources.
Damn it, why did we, why am I perpetuating that?
I don't know, we want it to be true.
I'm sure he wants it.
Yeah, I hope he's not offended.
Like if anything I could get wrong about him.
The fact that I think he's got a really cool T-Rex skeleton
I hope doesn't offend him.
I hope not either.
I'd sure love to interview him.
Okay, the apex, she mentioned the apex.
That's I guess the to interview them. Okay, the apex, she mentioned the apex. That's, I guess, the new dinosaur discovered.
The Stegosaurus dinosaur fossil that is considered
one of the largest and most complete
of its species ever found.
It was discovered in Colorado,
and it's at the American Museum of Natural History.
Oh, there it is, Monica, look at that.
Wow, that's so cool.
Those plates are enormous on the back.
Yeah, they are.
That's virtually what I was looking at installing
on top of our gates.
Oh wow.
Yeah.
We're always just trying to replicate
what nature already figured out.
Yeah.
Oh, imagine getting spiked with one of those.
Yeah, but it's so clever
because they get attacked from behind.
Yep.
Good luck.
Good luck.
It's so hard for my brain to integrate that that's real.
That those things really walked this earth.
Oh yeah.
Yeah.
And like, what will be here?
What will be here?
In a billion years. Yes. Yeah. yeah. And like, what will be here? What will be here? In a billion years.
Yes.
Yeah.
Okay, now Malcolm said on this episode
of Provisionist History, the Joe Rogan one
that we talked about, he said about his dad
in the interview he did with Michael Gervais,
he said something very sweet about understanding
his dad more in death than now.
And I wanted to find that clip.
Oh yeah, I'll go back.
To not to participate in that spirit.
When I'm getting a little emotional,
I'm in danger, when I talk about my father,
I start crying.
So, yeah, what is that about?
Uh.
I don't know, he was...
I'm sorry.
I'm sorry. I'd encourage you to open it wide open.
There I was on stage in front of hundreds of people, perfectly happy.
Then my dad came up and all of a sudden I became overwhelmed and I was embarrassed.
It wasn't what I intended.
I wasn't there to bear my soul.
Didn't I just say 10 seconds before the globals are not
emotional people?
I want to move on, but Gervais won't let me.
So off we go in an entirely new direction.
I mean, I do cry every time.
He's been gone five years.
And a friend of mine said, two friends of mine said,
two very beautiful things that I've always remembered.
One was a friend of mine who was writing something
about his father and he said,
my father died 20 years ago today.
I know him better today than I did back then.
And I think about that nearly every day and night.
So sweet, so sweet.
It is so sweet.
You know, hearing that makes something for me
make so much more sense,
which is Malcolm one time randomly sent me a text
that said, I stumbled upon the thing
you wrote about your dad.
Yeah.
And I didn't know you were such a great writer.
Oh, that's nice.
And it just made me like, soar.
Yeah.
And I thought, how on earth did he stumble upon that?
But it's interesting,
because he's talking about a friend who wrote about his father who's dead.
And this definitely happened within the time that his dad had died.
Oh, right, yeah.
And it's conceivable that like he was...
On the search for stuff.
Reading that stuff, yeah.
Yeah.
Sweet, sweet Malcolm.
God, hearing him like that is so endearing.
It really is.
Oh.
We love him so much.
We do, he's so special.
We really love him so much.
But that is such a beautiful sentiment
that you can keep knowing people past their time.
And that the grieving is how you keep someone alive
is also sweet.
Yeah, that's it. That's it, that's a good one. All right, love you. Love you. And grieving is how you keep someone alive is also sweet.
That's it.
That's it, that's cool.
All right, love you. Love you.
["Wonderful Music"]
Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondry app, Amazon Music, or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can listen to every episode of Armchair Expert early and ad free right now by joining
Wondry Plus in the Wondry app or on Apple Podcasts.
Before you go, tell us about yourself by completing a short survey at Wondry.com slash survey.