Behind the Bastards - Part One: Narendra Modi, And India's Weird Nazi Obsession
Episode Date: March 31, 2020Robert is joined by Sofiya Alexandra to discuss Narendra Modi.Footnotes: The Delhi pogrom 2020 is Amit Shah’s answer to an election defeat What Happened in Delhi Was a Pogrom Hitler Film Reveals Ind...ia's Nazi Fascination World's Biggest Toilet-building Program in India Gets Mixed Results Hitler’s Hindus: The Rise and Rise of India’s Nazi-loving Nationalists Humble Beginnings: The Early Years In pictures: Narendra Modi's early life Blood and Soil in Narendra Modi’s India PM Modi turns 69: As a child Narendra Modi joined NCC, wanted to serve in the Army Modi: From tea boy to India's leader Personal Life Story Narendra Modi: man of the masses Modi to youth: If you don’t make sacrifice in battle today, history will curse you tomorrow The Unbearable Loneliness of Narendra Modi Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Alphabet Boys is a new podcast series that goes inside undercover investigations.
In the first season, we're diving into an FBI investigation of the 2020 protests.
It involves a cigar-smoking mystery man who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse look like a lot of guns.
But are federal agents catching bad guys or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date, the time, and then for sure he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you that much of the forensic science you see on shows like CSI isn't based on actual science?
And the wrongly convicted pay a horrific price?
Two death sentences in a life without parole.
My youngest? I was incarcerated two days after her first birthday.
Listen to CSI on trial on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
What's in quarantine, my GOP legislators?
Hello, dear friends. I made the previous joke about Ted Cruz quarantining and then being exposed again and immediately reself quarantining.
Back in an earlier distant age when such things were a little bit more funny-saming.
We are not in a position where that's super funny right now.
So I would like to replace the bit that Sophia and I did about that with this new bit, which is a joke.
So there's this pirate and he walks into a bar and the bartender looks at the pirate and he's got like a steering wheel in his pants.
And the bartender's like, hey, what do you got that steering wheel in your pants for?
And the pirate responds, yarr to his driving me nuts.
That is the joke. Please enjoy the rest of this episode.
I'm Robert Evans. This is Behind the Bastards podcast about terrible people here with me.
Sophia Alexandra. Yeah, I'm so excited to be here.
Thanks for having me, Robert and Sophie. Thank you.
I did a musical intro for you, just doing mouth sounds.
I noticed it and it was good and you didn't like malfunction like a broken robot like you did last time when you tried to intro.
So this is really a step up.
I've decided to turn a new leaf professionally because I think it's important to be professional.
So in the spirit of professionalism, do you want to play with this switchblade?
A stranger sent me in the mail. Yes, please.
I've got a switchblade.
So every time I come back to LA, I get new fan packages and this one was just a switchblade.
So that's pretty fun.
We've been carrying it around playing with it.
Didn't know how to close it for a while. So I was just waving it around.
Sophia is trying to figure out how to close it now. It's a good time.
Yeah, I'm excited to figure this puzzle out.
Chris got it in like three seconds.
Chris immediately, Chris, our editor immediately figured out how to close it.
The rest of us were in, particularly me, shamefully couldn't figure it out.
So I was just, I was just waving an open knife around for a while, which I believe.
I know there's like a pinching situation. I'm just like, where?
We're good with OSHA, right, Sophie?
Okay, Sophie says everything I do is fine.
So, Sophia, have you heard about Narendra Modi?
No.
Oh boy. Well, he's the Prime Minister of India.
And you heard about how like a couple, couple three weeks ago,
there was that Pagram in New Delhi where like mobs of angry Hindu extremists
were chasing Muslims through the street and killed dozens of them.
Not as familiar as I should be.
Oh boy. Yeah, that happened.
And we're going to talk about everything that led up to that happening.
So this is going to be a fun one.
You know how sometimes countries are like functioning democracies for a long time
and then a fascist gets in charge and you realize that like,
oh man, everybody was still way more racist than I gave him credit for, shit.
You know how that happens in some countries?
No, what do you mean? Like, oh, and where?
I don't can't relate to that at all.
Yes, today we're talking about something that has only happened in India and nowhere else.
And it's currently not ongoing anywhere near or around us.
I love talking about things that every single person listening to this podcast
hasn't experienced in their own country.
That's my favorite thing to talk about on this podcast.
Oh man. Good times.
So yeah.
Hey, just a quick question.
How many dead babies in this episode?
I just need to know how much to steal myself for this.
There's like one paragraph where we talk about a couple,
but other than that, it's mostly discussion of murdered adults.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's pretty light on that.
Okay, do you like me more or less now that you're only having me,
now that you're not having me on only dead children episodes?
You know what it is, Sophia. I feel like, I feel like, you know,
when you get into a new relationship with somebody,
like you stay with what's comfortable for a while,
and so we stayed on the dead baby train for a little while.
Because it made you feel safe.
It could make me feel safe,
but now I'm willing to experiment with fascist foreign political leaders.
Oh, you want to invite a fascist into our relationship?
Yes, yes I do.
Okay.
There's always a point in every relationship
where you invite a fascist strong man in.
You freaky, let's do this.
That's why they keep winning, actually.
Because you just want to fucking bring him in.
Yeah, you can't keep him out of your bedroom.
You just like to dom, and I appreciate that about you.
Oh boy, this is going to feel so much less comfortable
after we get to all the murdered people.
I mean, that's why I'm really getting it in right now.
So, I'm going to start by talking a little bit about Nazism in India.
As you know, big fan.
Big fan of Nazism in India, huge.
Just anywhere, really.
As a Jew, nothing wars my heart more.
So, Nazism in India have a long, strange history
that's really, really difficult to talk about.
As we discussed in our Savitri Devi episodes,
the OG Nazis were obsessed with India
as the homeland of the ancient Aryans that they idolized.
And the SS Ananerbe, which was like the SS Archaeological Division,
actually sent expeditions into Tibet and northern India
to seek out the origins of their mythical supermen.
So, like...
How heartwarming that they had enough time
to like follow this beautiful thread.
They really did.
While they were like murdering all across Europe.
It's just so sweet that they were like, you know what?
Let's explore a little bit of something mystical.
Yeah, this was, when they were sending this out,
was like kind of the slow murder period where they were,
like they hadn't, because there weren't that many like Jewish people
actually in Germany proper.
So, they really hadn't ramped up the killing yet,
and they were mostly doing weird shit
and murdering their political opponents.
Is this pre-crystallized?
No, but it's pre-invasion of Poland and stuff.
So, it's like pre the start of actual hostilities.
So, they're definitely killing a lot of people,
but like by Nazi standards, they haven't really got into
what they're getting into. It's more like an amuse-bouche.
Yeah, yeah.
Let's have a little bit of archaeology
with our murder appetizers.
Just like a slow ramp up.
Yeah, yeah.
I'm not gonna make an edging comment here.
So, while the ideological underpinnings of Nazism
did not get really any purchase in the Indian subcontinent
during the 1930s and 1940s,
many Indians saw Nazi Germany as a potential ally
in their battle against British imperialism.
So, one of the tough things to understand,
and this is also true to a different kind of extent
with like Ukraine, is there was a number of folks in India
who supported the Nazis during the period
where the Nazis were in charge,
not because they cared about Nazism,
but because they hated the British Empire,
which is like, yeah, okay.
I mean, everybody hates the British Empire.
Yeah, and if you're like a Hindu nationalist
or an Indian nationalist and like a reasonable person
like 1930, you know, you could look at the Nazis and be like,
well, I'm sure they've done bad stuff,
but that's basically what the British Empire's been doing, right?
It's a long history of being terrible.
Yeah, a lot more reason to be concerned.
So, that's part of the support here.
And that aspect of it,
the part where it's like kind of understandable
support of the Nazis,
reached its height with the Indish Legion
or the Indian Volunteer Legion of the Waffen SS.
This was an all Indian military force
aimed, formed at the guidance
of Indian nationalist leaders, Subhas Chandra Bose.
The forces were initially formed out of Indian POWs,
captured fighting against the forces of the British Empire.
So, like, they would beat a British army
and they would capture a bunch of Indian soldiers
that the British had taken in.
And then they would be like,
you guys want to like invade India
and free it from British domination?
And these guys were like, yeah, of course.
That sounds good.
You guys want to build a snowman?
Yeah, it was a little bit like that.
So, the idea was that like these Indian soldiers
would invade the German army into India
when it was time to invade the subcontinent.
And Germany wound up collecting
well over 10,000 Indian soldiers that way.
So, there were like 10,000 Indian,
Hindu and Muslim Indian soldiers in the SS.
That's wild.
Yeah, most people don't know this story.
It's so wild.
It's really weird.
They were eventually stationed in France
just in time for the Normandy landings.
And they never wound up taking part
in much meaningful combat,
like it's this really weird story.
So nuts.
Imagine how confused you'd be
when like an SS officer came to take you away
and he was Indian and you'd be like...
Well, they didn't do that really.
Like they weren't doing normal SS stuff.
Like they even had in their...
You don't get to take people away?
No, they're not really persecuting anybody.
And why even be in the SS?
I don't think they knew what it was.
I think they were like, you guys hate the English
and we hate us some English.
Yeah.
It's a real comedy of errors.
You could get a...
Yeah.
And it's weird because there's photos
of Irwin Rommel
reviewing parades of these guys.
And you can see
fucking Rommel
like pinning medals on the chest
of guys with turbans.
It's a very strange chapter of history.
But they did have a clause
in their contract that said
they were not used for offensive operations
anywhere but India.
So like they did kind of have written into their contract.
We're not like fully on board with the Nazi thing.
So I wouldn't call...
I don't know. Like it's weird.
That's kind of cool. Do other...
Have other people who have joined like armed
things
gotten a chance to be like, you know what?
This but not this.
Like all the way up to the killing but not the killing.
You don't get to do that, right?
Yeah. This is the only time I've heard about something like this happening.
Yeah. It seems unusual.
It's a weird case from the war.
Can you imagine if that's what soldiering really was?
You sign up but you get to say no things
many times. That's actually how
the German army works today.
Really? As far as I know, the only one
where if you are a German soldier
you have a right written into like
the law of the nation that says that
if you have a moral issue
with a deployment or something, you get to say no.
I wonder why that's there.
I wonder why they have that rule.
So
after the war
India gained her independence on the back
of a fundamentally peaceful movement.
Mahatma Gandhi, one of the chief architects
of independence, was assassinated though
by a member of the RSS
a Hindu nationalist political party
with ties to Savitri Devi
the birth mother of Esoteric Hitlerism
who we talked about a few weeks ago.
India and Pakistan split apart
due in large part to fears by Indian Muslims
that they would be dominated by Hindus
and the democratic system.
This mass migration resulted in what some have
termed a mutual genocide killing well over
a million people possibly like as much as
three million people. Holy fuck!
It was a horrific, horrific like the split of
India and Pakistan was just unbelievably violent
and it's one of those things where like
you'd be really hard pressed to like lock down
like a side that was like mutual.
I've never heard again the term mutual genocide.
I was just going to say mutual genocide is an
insane name and also the name of my death metal band.
Yeah, it is a good name for a metal band.
And it's this is all
a very complicated history
but there so you can see there's like
this huge tension between so India
is simultaneously has more Muslims
than any other country on earth but is also
up the vast majority of people in it are
Hindu and
this has been a
problem for a while in terms of like
violent
differences between the two groups
in part because like at different
points one group or another has like ruled
the nation and the other people particularly
like for a long time the
like there was like a Muslim conquest of India
and the Mughals ruled and it was like
so this is like a lot of history
here that we're not going to get to cover in
enough depth but the fact that like the
partitioning of India and Pakistan goes as
violently as it does
says something
about the state of affairs at the time
and it's worth noting that like a lot of that
also goes on the British because there were
ways to have handled this that were smarter
and more
understanding and would have resulted
in less death but England was just like
ah fuck it we'll just here
we drew a map like this seems good to us
you guys figure out how to
implement it
but we already drew the map
we can't change it just because people are dying
the map is already drawn
yeah
and it's probably worth noting that
it's unlikely any of this would be happening
if the British hadn't ruled India for
a couple hundred years
but
Anderson gets angry when
I talk shit about the British Empire
she's a big fan of that
she's dressed in a really smart like British
tweed right now
and she does not fuck around when she's
dressed to the nines
is Royals the show about the British royal family
can I give her a treat
is that the one everyone's watching
anyway
so in the decades
since the partitioning of India
the nation of India
lurched forward to take its place as the planet's
largest democracy
elections and crises came and went and India took
its place again as an independent power on the world
stage Americans grew
increasingly obsessed with the subcontinent as a
sorts of ancient wisdom and as a great vacation
destination and at the same time
Indians grew well
can I tell you something nothing has changed look
at any white girls Instagram
it's pretty cool
one of the neat things about going to India
particularly to New Delhi
is how many
young American like 19
and 20 year olds you meet there having like
massive existential crises
because New Delhi is a hard fucking city
to land in like it is it is a shock
there's so many more people than
you'd expect it moves so fast
it is so polluted
and so like
like people just have massive panic attacks
and there's like this whole industry based on
like you see some rich panicking kid
who like didn't realize what it was really
going to be like to be in a city like that
and you like come up to him and be like you want
to get out of of of Delhi right you want to visit
like one of these vacation spots and he's like yeah yeah
and they're like all of the trains are shut down there's no
buses leaving the town but I got a bus that you can
charter and then like they've paid $3,000
to rent a bus for a week oh my god
what a sweet fucking hustle
it's it's pretty fun to watch
I'm learning so much
yeah so at the same time
as all of this happened
Indian or a number of people in India
grew increasingly obsessed with the theories
and iconography of Adolf Hitler and his Nazi
movement and the reason behind
this was complex and confusing it ranges
widely from more or less harmless
stuff like the term Hitler has become a common
Bollywood insult for characters who act
badly like you know you're
yeah yeah like like just sort of being a
total Hitler in a total Hitler right now
yeah that's so awesome
yeah we should do this we should do that
one more but it
it kind of hints at something which is that
like Hitler and the legacy
the Nazis isn't really seen
kind of the same way over there as it is here
because it's way more distant right like
all of that those politics
are more distant to people there so it kind
of like you get some weird
examples of
like every couple of years there'll be a story of just like
some shop opening up in Delhi or some other
city in India that's like got a huge
swastika on the front or like a picture of
Hitler and it's like
usually when you read articles interviewing the
shop owner he's like well I didn't really know
anything about him I just thought like the imagery
was cool it's like
it's very strange
so
crossword an Indian bookseller sold
25,000 copies of Mein Kampf in three years
J. Co another Indian
book merchant sold 100,000 copies in seven years
Hitler's manifesto was translated
into Gujarati
Hindi
Malayalan
Jesus I'm so sorry
to all of the people of Southeast
Asia that I'm going to be
butchering words from
Bengali and Tamil and it sold
solely across the subcontinent so you have this
I totally hear about Da Vinci code man
yeah in the night's Templar
we don't want that going over there
yes you have
this weird thing where like there's this mix of
the history of
Nazis and being less immediate in India and so
like people
adopt the term Hitler as a general insult
and but also this weird phenomenon
of like Hitler's actual words
selling very well in chunks of India
and what makes this unsettling is that
the book is not being sold there as a historic text
instead Mein Kampf has
achieved popularity in India as
a sort of self-help book a guide
to success for Hindu businessmen
oh my god that's not great
what the fuck
a guide to success
yeah he's like their Tim Ferriss
you know not their Tim Ferriss but like
a subculture within like the
the Hindu business community he's like a
Tim Ferriss type figure like a great
productivity
guru
like set a timer
for 30 minutes and then when it goes off
you kill all the Jews
I found a CBS news article that interviewed
Tarun Sinkhal
a management student at New Delhi's Institute of Technology
it was like without the final solution
I would have never passed my marketing cause
Jesus
we need a final solution to get in these products off the shelves
I'll tell you what
so this guy Tarun
read Mein Kampf as an undergraduate and he founded
inspiring and he told CBS quote
it serves as a reminder that nothing is unachievable
he said
no matter how many millions of people you dream of killing
from how many different kinds of groups
you got this
you want to kill three
you want to kill six you want to kill eleven
you got this after that point
you go girl yes queen
yes
this does come back to my frequent refrain
on this show that like people should not as often
as they are be encouraged to follow their dreams
some people's dreams are garbage
yeah some people's dreams not good
so yeah
he said it serves as a reminder that
nothing is unachievable and he added
that he was able to separate
that message of
empowerment from the books
pervasive anti-Semitic ideology
so you got to cut out all the
Jew hatred but then there's some good stuff
the old I read playboy
for the articles defense
I read Hitler for the management advice
exactly
yeah what are you talking about Mein Kampf
I mean sure there's some Jew stuff in there
but mostly what I thought
about was efficiency
yeah mostly it taught me how to really set up an organization
yeah it taught me management skills
how to talk to people
before you kill them obviously but
you know it was very helpful
you know in luring people to their deaths
it really helped
it's wild because like if you actually look into how
the Third Reich was managed
it was a complete shit show and Hitler was terrible at it
and the only reason they had
as much military success as they did
is decades of primarily
Prussian military ingenuity that like
but it was like
he wasn't good as a manager is the
core of the point but I guess
people miss that
so in 2010
Bollywood director Nullen Singh
announced his plan to produce a movie titled
Dear Friend Hitler
which was
shall we say a different take on Ole it off
I mean I guess
I don't need to register my script
with the WGA anymore
oh that's a shame
someone's taken my idea
Hitler
not so bad
that was also another version of
I mean that was a musical
I have an idea for a script
do you want me to just throw it out here
nobody steal this it's called reverse Hitler
the Hitler with the heart of gold
and it's about a clone of Hitler
that's his opposite
and it can either be
I actually think this might work best as like
a Netflix miniseries his goal is to get
6 million Jewish couples pregnant
oh my god
how about anti-Hitler
anti-Hitler
we can workshop the title
and you know what else we can workshop
I really like to be on board with this project
let's make this happen
I don't want this to slip away
no we can make some bank off of this
dude anti-Hitler hunters is popular
it's so bad
it's so bad it's like
it's like written by people who I think
had heard of Jewish people but aren't
and I know the guy involved is Jewish
and the guy starring in it is Jewish but I don't understand it
why are they calling the grandparent softa
that's a
Hebrew word
that would never be the thing
it would be Yiddish it just doesn't make any sense
it's like just have one fucking real Jew
look it over
just one it's so bad
Al Pacino is so horrible
what about the fucking accent on the grandma
sorry no no it's good
it's good this is a terrible show
but you know what's not terrible and also
hunts Nazis these goods and services
exactly exactly
every single one of them
nailed it
I love that
during the summer of
2020 some Americans
suspected that the FBI
had secretly infiltrated the racial justice
demonstrations
and you know what they were right
I'm Trevor Aronson
and I'm hosting a new podcast series
alphabet boys
as the FBI sometimes
you gotta grab the little guy
to go after the big guy
each season will take you inside
an undercover investigation
in the first season of alphabet boys
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver
at the center of this story
is a raspy voiced
cigar smoking man
who drives a silver hearse
and inside his hearse was like a lot of guns
he's a shark and not in the good bad ass way
he's a nasty shark
he was just waiting for me to set the
date the time
and then for sure he was trying to get it to heaven
listen to alphabet boys
on the iHeart radio app
apple podcast or wherever you get your podcast
I'm Lance Bass
and you may know me from a little
band called NSYNC
what you may not know
is that when I was 23
I traveled to Moscow to train to become the youngest
person to go to space
and when I was there
as you can imagine
I heard some pretty wild stories
but there was this one
that really stuck with me
about a soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down
it's 1991
and that man Sergei Krekalev
is floating in orbit
when he gets a message that down on earth
his beloved country
the soviet union is falling
apart
and now he's left defending the union's last
outpost
this is the crazy story of the
313 days he spent in space
313 days
that changed the world
listen to the last soviet
on the iHeart radio app
or wherever you get your podcasts
what if I told you
that much of the forensic
science you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual
science
the problem with forensic
science in the criminal legal
system today is that it's an awful
lot of forensic and not an awful lot of science
and the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price
two death sentences and a life without
parole
my youngest I was incarcerated two days after
her first birthday
I'm Molly Herman join me
as we put forensic science
on trial to discover
what happens when a match isn't
a match and when there's
no science in CSI
how many people
have to be wrongly convicted before
they realize
that this stuff's all bogus
it's all made up
listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeart radio app
Apple Podcasts or wherever
you get your podcasts
we're back
and we're talking about Nazi
ism in India so in
2010 this Bollywood director Nalan Sing
announces that he's going to make Dear Friend
Hitler and CBS News reports that
he was quote genuinely shocked
that this created controversy
genuinely shocked
the media expressed disdain
Jewish groups were horrified and his lead actor
threw a bit baffled by the reaction
quit while such a response would seem
if anything understated in much of the world
Sing had reason to believe his film would not
generate even a ripple of scandal in India
here Hitler is not viewed as the
personification of evil but with an attitude
of morally ambiguous fascination
he is seen as a management guru
akin to Machiavelli or Sun Tzu
by business students and an object of wonder
by people craving order amidst the chaos
of India imagine a 50 cent
did his own version of mine comf
instead of
part of war yeah
that would be a bummer I feel like
Kanye maybe
new Kanye
new Kanye so
that last line there about
people craving order amid the chaos of India
that brings us to like the real problem
because while many of the Indians who created weird
like Hitler themed restaurants and clothing stores
did so because they thought the imagery was neat and they just
didn't know that much about the Second World War
there were a number of people who knew precisely
what Hitler stood for and some of them took
deliberately took advantage of their
countryman's ignorance of the Third Reich to whitewash
Hitler and mainstream fascist politics
I'm sorry whitewash Hitler
yeah it's pretty funny
is that even possible
kinda
I found a really interesting article on Haritz
a left-leaning Israeli news website
and it documents this it was called a Hitler's
Hindus Nazi-loving nationalists on the rise
and it starts with the author's recollection
of their time in a cycling expedition
through India in July 2008
they found themselves in Nagpur
a city in the exact middle of India and one of the
hotbeds of the Hindu nationalist movement
in Nagpur they found a pool parlor named
Hitler's den complete
with this definitely Nazi
swastika on the sign
I mean obviously what are you going to take pictures in front of
yeah I mean Hitler's den of course
we all need a Hitler's den shot
so Hitler's den was not just the result
of good-natured ignorance about European history
for you see Nagpur happens to hold
the headquarters of an organization
called the Rashtriya Swam
ah boy
Swayamsevak Sang or RSS
it's a far-right Hindu fascist political
organization originally founded back in the 1920s
and this is the group that like
the guy who shot Gandhi was a former member
of the RSS so there
fuck cool dudes
one of the co-founders
or ideological founders or whatever
of the RSS is a fellow named V.D. Savarkar
and V.D. Savarkar
had a brother who was a big fan of the Nazi priestess
Savitri Devi and like wrote a forward
in one of her books and V.D. Savarkar himself
was a big fan of our old buddy
Adolf in 1940 he addressed
a group of Hindu nationalists by saying
there is no reason to suppose that
Hitler must be a human monster because he passes
off as a Nazi Nazi has improved
undeniably the savior of India
just passes off as a
wow passes off
as a Hindu extremist
V.D. Savarkar's primary motivation
was a desire to see India turned into a
Hindu stand that's the term here
at the time a nation completely dominated
by Hinduism and Muslims in
particular completely purged and excised
from society at that same
gathering he stated if we Hindus
in India grow stronger in time these Muslim
friends of the league type will have to play
the part of the German Jews instead
you
yeah not a nice guy
and V.D. Savarkar
coined the term Hindutva for
his new ideology he argued that ancient
Aryans who'd settled in India formed a Hindu
nation hindunist stemmed from
geographical unity racial
unity and a common culture which pitted the Hindus
of India against all others and there was
like a cast angle to it too he was like a
Brahmin and I think in his view of it
and it's become sort of more
egalitarian fascism
in the modern era but like initially
there was like a very strict like racial
hierarchy within Hinduism too I think that's
less of a factor now but I'm not an expert on it
another
early RSS leader M.S.
Golwalkar was nicknamed the guru
of hate he was another big Hitler fan
in his 1939 book we are
nationhood defined a seminal RSS
text he wrote this something amazing
about being the guru of
hate it's like any pepper tones the bitter
Buddha you know
I mean not suggesting he's a Nazi
he's a very funny non
Nazi comedian yeah not a Nazi
just repeating again probably not
a Nazi probably
so he said this in his book German
race pride has now become the topic of the day
to keep up the purity of the race in its culture
Germany shocked the world by her purging the
country of the Semitic races the Jews
a good lesson for us in Hindustan
to learn and profit by
it's so cool that when my
grandpa's I mean my grandma's family
was all shot to death it was like a really
good lesson it was a really good lesson
and it it goes to show
kind of this thing that I don't think is talked about
enough which is like fascism
functions very similarly to a cancer
and World War two can be
seen as a really aggressive dose of chemo
but we didn't fucking get it
all and that's why this is all happening all
over the world right now is these little bitty
like pockets of it
it's not possible to get it all
I maybe it is
maybe I think there's
an argument to be made about the nature
of our society and that and this will come
into play later here and that if you live in
a system that is as completely dominated
by by capitalism and
moneyed interests as ours is because
that's always a factor in the rise of all these
movements is is the business leaders
in those countries even the ones that don't
really like the fascist party
prefer it to socialism and that's a huge
factor everywhere fascism seriously takes
hold is just like these rich people being
like well I guess I prefer these folks
to giving up a big chunk of my fortune
and so there's an argument to be made that
if you have a state with a
strong social safety net already
in place and with strict limits
on how much power the wealthy can exercise
it seriously cramps the ability
of these movements to get off the ground
nobody's ever eradicated
fascism from the human race so we can't know
what the solution is but if I'm
theorizing that would be a suggestion
I would make
I'll take it under advisement
the next time you're trying to eliminate fascism
maybe give that a shot
not all the way in but I'll think
about it well it's all on you specifically
so I hope you do
but yeah as you know
people have been waiting for me to
eliminate fascism really solve this
yeah we're all waiting
so another one of the founders of the RSS
was a guy named Hedgewar
and he deliberately patterned
the RSS after the fascist parties he'd
watched rise to power in Germany and Italy
Hedgewar dressed his stormtroopers in khaki
uniforms patterned off Mussolini's fascists
he marched them through the street in an
Indian equivalent to the goose step
and he gave them like a weird little salute
that's like kind of like a modified
Hitler salute that they still do to this day
Hedgewar
modifying which way
if you look up RSS salute
it's like a little bit less
of the hand motion
just like less noticeable
what do you want me to look at?
are you getting something?
yeah yeah it's like
your arm kind of like over your
with like your fist over your heart
you can sort of see the inspiration
but it kind of looks
if you do this it's like a
it's an almost Hitler
yeah it's a little bit of a subdued
oh do you have to keep your arm straight though?
yeah I think you have to keep it straight
that has a very Hitler look
it's got a Hitler look to it yeah
and Hedgewar's fundamental belief was that
centuries of domination by the British Empire
had emasculated the Indian man
and they needed a violent fascist paramilitary
force to restore their manly pride
so I noticed you picked up the knife
just sort of
by reflex that's a good reflex
to fascism
so the RSS was from the beginning
profoundly anti-Muslim
they preached that India's Muslims were descended from Hindus
who had been violently converted and thus were not
authentically Indian
non-violence and plurality were all equally
faithful to the men of the RSS
including one Natharam
Vinayak Godsi the assassin of Mahatma Gandhi
after Gandhi's murder
the party was banned but not for long
the centrist powers of India never quite succeeded
in wiping it out and as a result it hung out
in the margins of political society for years
waiting for the right time to re-emerge
bit by bit it grew to hold influence
over ever greater swaths of Indian society
in 2004
the Gujarat State Board issued textbooks
that described Adolf Hitler as a hero
with social study textbook
chapter titles like Hitler, the Supremo
and internal achievements
of Nazism
the Supremo
what a bad breakfast sandwich
Hitler the Supremo
yeah that does sound like a terrible
there's like a lot of hair in it, just mustache
yeah it's mostly like really greasy
pork and like boiled eggs
yeah greasy pork and boiled eggs
is the Supremo Hitler
yeah the mustaches
or the bread is moldy
it's like
I mean I prefer it to subway but not by much
and it's
less fascist than subway but not by much
subway
if you sponsor our show I'll take all this back
and we will eat fresh
seriously
so yeah from that social study textbook
there's a section called ideology of Nazism
and in that chapter it notes
Hitler lit dignity and prestige
to the German government
and the ideology of opposition
towards the Jewish people and advocated
the supremacy of the German race
so you can kind of see something happening here
yeah
sympathizers in the state of Tamil Nadu
succeeded in sliding pro-Nazi messages
and do a 10th grade social studies textbook
in 2011 including chapters praising
Hitler's inspiring leadership
achievements and how the Nazis only ordered
the persecution of the Jews in order to
maintain a German race with Nordic elements
Nordic elements
in 2012
10th grade students at a private school in Mumbai
were asked to complete a sentence starting with
the words I admire
9 of the 25 students in that class picked
Hitler a 2002 poll
conducted by the times of India found that
17% of respondents listed Hitler
as the kind of leader India
ought to have
so given all that it would be fair to say
that India's issues with Nazism
go just to skoosh behind simple
ignorance of history
it would in fact be fair to say that a number of
very motivated people have spent decades attempting
to mainstream Nazi ideology
and push the ideals of fascism on the people
of the world's largest democracy
and it would furthermore be fair to say that those same
very motivated people have seen terrifying
success no individual
has seen more success with this than
Narendra Modi the current prime minister
of India and the man who was governor of
Gujarat in 2004 when the province
added that pro-Hitler curriculum to its
textbooks so
we're gonna talk about Modi now
now we're into the past preamble
I'm ready I'm stroking my knife
good that's the right response
oh look he let me call it my knife
what's up it's now my knife
I'm kindly stroking my knife
it's the coolest thing I've heard all day
yeah let's get a couple of knives
more knives in here Sophie
Narendra Modi was born in Venagar
a small town in north Gujarat
Minsana district on September 17th
1950
the third of six children and he was not born
into wealth or privilege his family was
of the ganchi caste which put them about as
low on the cultural totem pole as one could
go without literally being an outcast
traditionally members of this caste pressed
vegetable oil for a living but Narendra's
father supported his family by running a small
chai shop at a local railway station
the Modi family were incredibly poor
and lived together in a 40 by 12 foot
single story house when Narendra
was old enough he worked at his father's tea
shop to help support the family he would get
early to work alongside his dad and then
cross the train tracks to head to school later in the morning
the modern political propaganda
around Modi often emphasizes the fact that
he is unmarried and chased
essentially portraying him as something of a monk
dedicated purely to his work on behalf of
India a man who sacrificed even love
for the love of his country
as we know being chased doesn't always work out
nope actually
it can be a real problem maybe some people should just
fuck yeah people should just fuck maybe
yeah
but this whole like presenting himself as
like a chased monk it does kind of
it keeps with a broad trend
propaganda around Modi for example this is how his
website NarendraModi.in describes
his childhood as a child
Narendra Modi balanced his studies
non-academic life and his contribution to the
family tea stall his schoolmates recall
Narendra as a diligent student with a penchant
for debating and reading he would spend hours
and hours reading in the school library among
the sports he was very fond of swimming
Narendra Modi had a wide range of friends from all
communities as a child he often celebrated
both Hindu and Muslim festivals considering
the large number of Muslim friends he had in the
neighborhood yet his thoughts and his
dreams went way beyond a conventional life that
began in the classroom and ended in the environs
of an office he wanted to go out there and make a
difference to society to wipe tears and suffering
among people at a young age he developed
an inclination towards renunciation and
asceticism he gave up eating salt
chilies oil and jaggery
so that's kind of how he's portrayed
in his official propaganda right
so they also know he had tons of Hindu
friends or Muslim friends he's not racist
and so dude
if your God doesn't want you to eat chilies
abandon your God
it's not that because like obviously
chilies are like a traditional Hindu
food it's this idea that like
um
they are better than people because you don't
eat chilies that because you sacrifice
the comforts of the flesh you're a holy
man like that's kind of what make and that's
not just Hinduism that's like a huge in
Christianity and Islam like this idea
that I'm saying like
if you're not fucking at least have chilies
if you're not fucking at least have
chilies you don't have hot sauce what do you
even have that's a t-shirt you're not fucking
you have some chilies
yeah you gotta mm-hmm anyway
chilies or fucking ideally
both to avoid fascism yeah
uh so it
was however revealed during his first campaign
for prime minister that Narendra was legally
married and had been virtually his entire life
uh he was like
married it as a child
the couple actually moved in together at the age of 17
but the only cohabited for three months
then Narendra abandoned his wife to wander around
the Himalayan mountains on a pilgrimage and he never returned
haha second wife
oh till death drew his part
just kidding no until I wander
away forever it's it's a little bit
weirder than that because I can't
put this on Narendra because he didn't get to like
choose to marry his wife
it was like um his family
like his family was very traditional
um and they thought that like they should um
do kind of the traditional thing for people
in their culture
which was like you marry off the kid pretty young
like it was an arranged marriage sort of thing
and so like this partner was picked for him
when he was three or four and they were just
like engaged to be married and then at
17 they moved in together and he kind of
immediately knew like I don't want this life
and so he left and I
can't really put I mean I can put the whole
becoming like a fascist on him
but deciding that you don't want to marry
this person your parents hooked you up with when you were
like four that that can't be on him
how did his wife feel though
I don't know if I can wander away
yeah but that's I mean
I can't blame him for like not wanting to be married
when he didn't choose to get married
I'm sure she didn't want it either but she was
just trying to play along for a second
I don't know what happened to her I don't know that anybody does
okay good we should research that
yeah that would be next time to know
yeah so anyway
what I'm getting out is that like
this guy's backstory is a little bit
complicated and we don't have
like a really clear idea of how he spent his
youth or his childhood we have a lot of propaganda
and a few bits of like hard facts
that are sprinkled in here and there
um
yeah so it's it's weird
or not weird it's just it's
not what we're used to and it's hard to like
like a lot of this is hard to kind of square with
the way things are in the US like here in the US
like politicians are supposed to be
like family men and like
to the point where like our current president
literally bragged about his dick size during a major
political debate and it's kind of hard as an
American to get your head around somebody bragging
that like I don't fuck I have no
partner and like I don't bone at all
but
now I get that it makes you holier than other
people exactly yeah
and in a kind of position
you need to come
yeah I don't I don't
for me coming as politics
and that's a good thing
it's just different
um so
Narendra's childhood coincided with an interesting time
in Indian politics the congress party the party of
Gandhi basically held power for the first 50
years of his life they stood for
for secular democratic values
and were directly opposed to the RSS
as you might expect from a violent fascist movement
the RSS was initially
a high caste endeavor
organized by wealthy men but in order to expand
their membership base after the partition
of India the RSS quickly found itself
recruiting new members of lower castes
and one of those recruits was a young boy
named Narendra Modi and it's hard to say
when he first got involved with the RSS
I've heard some sources that claim he was 8 or 9 years
old when they when they went with him
that's early as well that's real fucking
early yeah
his official biographies
don't agree with this
and they state that he was like after he went
on pilgrimage to the Himalayas that he
he came back and he joined the RSS
we don't know
the official biographies talk about
you know stuff like when he was 9 years old
there was flooding in a river and he built a food stall
to donate the proceeds to relief work
and that during a war with Pakistan
and his youth he engaged in acts of charity
serving tea to soldiers passing through the railway
station that's what they focus on in the official
biography that he's like this very patriotic
kid who dedicates a lot of his time
and effort to helping his fellow
Hindus and it's
entirely possible that if he did any of this
stuff it was actually at the behest of the RSS
and he was doing it as like a child activist
I really don't know it's kind of impossible to
tell whatever the precise truth
we know that at age 17
Narendra abandoned his wife and left on a pilgrimage
of spiritual enlightenment when he
came back he set up a tea cart at a bus stand
to make ends meet and began working for the
RSS in an official capacity
as a pracharik
which was essentially a street propagandist
did he holler at his wife when he got back
I don't think so I don't think they
saw each other again
that's so rude dude
we just come by and say like hey it's gonna be
weird I'm selling tea in town
I'm back you know
sorry I'm kind of a dick but probably
you don't want to be with me anyway so this is for the
best but if you see me in town
if you see me in town slinging tea to the
Nazis don't
don't feel weird about it don't make it weird
I have to say I've never fucked
so
this is critical for me I'm still pretending we never
fucked so
they may not have he might be completely
honest about the whole
chasteness thing like well it's kind of hard
to tell because it's hard to get like a real
hint of what the man is but he might
actually be like
a no-nut sort of dude
like really committed to that proud boy
don't come sort of thing
fascist hate coming
I know so weird
so yeah
he starts work as a pracharic which is basically
like a street propagandist like he's giving speeches
and stuff to try to like rile people up
and get them involved in this nationalist movement
and really teaches them how to like stir up
a crowd and work one
and pracharics like Modi were expected
to remain chased living like monks
and dedicating their every waking hour to the party
so when Modi was not delivering
speeches and spreading the RSS gospel of intolerance
against non-Hindus he cleaned out
the living quarters of senior RSS officials
in interviews today
and claims that finding the RSS basically saved his life
quote
I got the inspiration to live for the nation
from the RSS I learned to live for others
and not for myself I owe it all to the RSS
so
fascist parties like the RSS de facto
idolize the military and leaders in such
organizations either have to have a military
background of their own
or like as we saw with people like Hitler and Mussolini
or they need to come up with a very good
excuse as to why they did not
serve that still reinforces their bonafides
as like a lover of the military
I was busy not fucking
I was busy too busy not fucking
jerking off to the military
you got to fucking the military
we kind of see this with Trump's bone spurs
and in his bizarre insistence that
the time he spent in the military school was essentially the same as being in the
military like you've got to find a way
to like kind of connect yourself to the
military if you're going to be this sort of
authoritarian strong man
and Modi never served but his biography
really tries to thread that needle
from it right now
as a child Narendra Modi had one dream
to serve in the Indian army
for many youngsters of his time the army was seen as the ultimate
means of serving mother India
as luck would have it his family was dead
opposed to the idea Narendra Modi was very keen
to study in Sainik school located
in nearby Jemnagar but when the time
came to pay the fees there was no money at home
surely Narendra was disappointed
but fate had different plans for this young boy
who was disappointed on not being able to wear
the uniform of a jaw on a soldier
over the years he embarked on a unique path
that took him across India in pursuit of the larger
mission to serve humanity
so he wanted to be a soldier but like
they couldn't make the funding work out
and stuff and thankfully he
found another way to serve that's just like
being a soldier but doesn't risk him getting
shot in a border war with
Pakistan so that's cool
so just like that though just like
that it's the same it's the same only
he doesn't die anonymously
in a trench being ordered to charge a
machine gun that's cool that is very
but it is the same it is the same exactly
the same but very fortunate for him
so in 1975
when Modi was 25 years old
India went through a period of economic collapse
in the attendance civil unrest that comes with it
the RSS saw this as an opportunity
to recruit and to stir up dissent against the ruling
Congress party prime minister
Indira Gandhi responded to all this by
suspending parliament and instituting emergency rule
a widely unpopular and illegal
move that was rightly condemned by many
during her time as de facto
dictator Indira Gandhi had RSS leaders
arrested and persecuted and the organization
itself was banned. Modi went
into hiding at this time dressing as a
Sikh in a turban and what appears to be a fake
beard I've got a picture of him in disguise
and I'm almost certain that that's a costume
piece he's wearing let me see the beard
look at that it's the little line
on there that makes it look like it's a fake
weird or he's just like
got like a thick
version of a chin strap going
yeah I can't really say for certain
if it is a fake beard or not but it's the only
question that can sense me. It's a wild choice
either way. I think
the mustache is real. You can almost see the
mustache is real but you can almost see the tape
yeah it's weird it's a weird look
sunglasses help. Yeah they do help
I mean it's not a bad disguise. Do you think he just couldn't grow a beard
or? He has one now I think so
and what the fuck dude? I mean he was younger
then some men it takes a while before it comes out
right yeah I'll accept that
so Indira Gandhi's period
of emergency rule eventually ended and the RSS
was unbanned and rather than being harmed
by their period of persecution Gandhi's
targeting of the group legitimized him in the eyes
of many Indians who had not identified with the
organization previously. The RSS
began to grow and the loyal
Narendra Modi moved up the ranks quickly
in 1987 he
joined the
Bharatiya Janata Party or BJP
and the BJP is the
electorally political. I'm also a member of
the BJP.
What's up dude?
I feel like BJ's sorry.
Yeah but it's the, in this case
the BJP is the electorally
political wing of the RSS.
You don't gotta tell me about the BJP Robert
Robert's uncomfortable it's great.
You can all join
the BJP
that is so cute.
Oh lord in heaven.
Robert you're adorable.
You know what else is adorable?
Job. That's exactly
right. All of these companies
will blow you in the capitalistic sense
by sending you products in exchange for
currency.
During the summer of 2020
some Americans suspected that the
FBI had secretly infiltrated
the racial justice demonstrations
and you know what?
They were right.
I'm Trevor Aronson and I'm hosting
a new podcast series
of Alphabet Boys.
As the FBI sometimes
you gotta grab the little guy
to go after the big guy.
Each season will take you inside
an undercover investigation.
In the first season of Alphabet Boys
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver.
At the center of this story
is a raspy voiced
cigar smoking man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside this hearse was like a lot of goods.
And on the good badass way.
And nasty sharks.
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and then for sure
he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart
Radio App, Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Lance Bass
and you may know me from a little band
called NSYNC.
What you may not know is that when I was 23
I traveled to Moscow
to train to become the youngest person
in the world of space.
And when I was there,
as you can imagine,
I heard some pretty wild stories.
But there was this one
that really stuck with me.
About a Soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down.
It's 1991
and that man, Sergei Krekalev
is floating in orbit
when he gets a message that down on Earth
his beloved country,
is falling apart.
And now he's left defending
the Union's last outpost.
This is the crazy story
of the 313 days
he spent in space.
313 days that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet
on the iHeart Radio App,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you
that much of the forensic science
shows like CSI
isn't based on actual science?
The problem
with forensic science
in the criminal legal system today
is that it's an awful lot of forensic
and not an awful lot of science.
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest, I was incarcerated
two days after her first birthday.
I'm Molly Herman.
Join me as we put
forensic science on trial
to discover what happens
when a match isn't a match
and when there's no science
in CSI.
How many people have to be wrongly
convicted before they realize
that this stuff's all bogus?
It's all made up.
Listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeart Radio App,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
We're back.
So,
Modi has just joined
the BJP
which is the political wing of the RSS
and he started at the bottom of the party
but his skill as an organizer ensured that he rose rapidly.
By the 1980s
he had become a senior figure in the BJP's
Gujarati chapter.
At the time, the BJP was still
definitely fringe. It had only two seats
in parliament. The party leadership looked out
at the political situation in India
and found that they needed a cause to crystallize
the divisions between Hindu and Muslim in the country
and they found this cause in the city of Ayodhya.
That holy city had a mosque
called the Babri Masjid
which had been built
by the Muslim Mughal Emperor Babur
in 1528.
For a variety of confusing reasons
a number of local Hindus had grown convinced
over the years that this mosque was built
over the site of an old Hindu temple
and some of these people began to claim that
Ram and Avatar Vishnu had been born
on the spot. And I'm going to quote now
from a New Yorker article laying out what happened next.
In September 1990
a senior BJP member
named L.K. Advani began calling
for the Babri Masjid to be destroyed
and for a Hindu temple to take its place.
To build support for the idea he undertook
a two-month pilgrimage called the Ram Rath Yatra
across the Indian heartland.
Traveling aboard a Nissan Jeep refitted to look like
a chariot. He sometimes gave several speeches a day
in flaming crowds about what he saw
as the government's favoritism towards Muslims.
Sectarian riots followed in his wake
leaving hundreds dead. Advani was arrested
before he reached Ayodhya, but other BJP
members carried on, gathering supporters
and donations along the way. On December 6th,
1992, a crowd
led by RSS partisans swarmed the Babri Masjid
and using axes and hammers began
tearing the building down. By nightfall
it had been completely raised.
So they destroyed this mosque.
Well, and
Narendra Modi was still pretty low
on the totem pole at this point, but his skill
organizer earned him a place organizing
the Rath Yatra, that liked chariot march
across the country. It was his job to organize
the Gujarat section of the chariot march.
And the Ram Yatha sparked
a series of horrifically bloody Hindu-Muslim
riots all across the subcontinent.
The violence took weeks to die down
and it was particularly bad in Mumbai,
one of India's largest cities. Muslims
were forced either by mobs or by basic
self-preservation to move out of neighborhoods
their families had occupied for generations.
Many moved into what were effectively ghettos.
The riots and dislocation caused by the
Ram Rath Yatra's aftershocks contributed
to the growing violent polarization
of Indian society. One survivor
the New Yorker interviewed reported feeling
as if Mumbai had been transformed by all this.
That is the first time I ever really
thought about my identity. Our entire
neighborhood, our friends, were going to kill us.
And all this
was fucking bank for the RSS.
By 1996, nine years after
Modi joined, the BJP had grown to become
the single largest party in parliament.
As it ever does, the rioting and racial
hatred sparked by this fascist organization
convinced more people to join it.
As they grew to consume the Indian political system,
a few forward-thinking academics
began to study the party and its members.
One of these was Ashish Nandi,
and I'm going to quote again from the New Yorker here.
A trained psychologist, he wanted to study
the mentality of the rising Hindu nationalists.
One of those he met was Narendra Modi,
who was then a little known BJP
functionary. Nandi interviewed Modi
for several hours and came away shaken.
His subject, Nandi told me, exhibited
all the traits of an authoritarian personality,
puritanical rigidity,
a constricted emotional life, fear of his own
passions, and an enormous ego that protected
annoying and security.
During an interview, Modi elaborated a
fantastical theory of how India was the target
of a global conspiracy in which every Muslim
in the country was likely complicit.
Modi was a fascist in every sense, Nandi said.
I don't mean this as a term of abuse.
It's a diagnostic category.
Cool and good.
Only diagnostics that.
I'm sorry.
This is just going to come back to the BJP.
It's really no way.
Sometimes all you can do is laugh about
blowjobs when you're talking about fascism.
Yup. Because they hate blowjobs.
It's a diagnostic category.
That's what she said.
Yeah, that's what this psychologist said.
Look, I'm not just being like, you're a fascist.
I'm being like, fascism is a mental disorder
and I am diagnosing you with it.
Yeah.
Interesting.
So,
in September 2001,
a month in which nothing else of historical
import occurred, Narendra Modi was
appointed to be the chief minister of the
government of Gujarat, which the RSS and BJP
had begun to dominate in a series of elections.
Modi's rise to power was not
due to his own electoral success, though.
It was due to basically his ability to
politic internally.
And he basically undermined another rival
of his in the BJP, a guy named
Keshubhai Patel.
I am so sorry about the names here.
BJP, yeah, you know me.
Yes, yes, yes.
So, yeah, I found a quote
from a guy named Vinod Mehta, which was the
former editor of an Indian news magazine
called Outlook, who remembers
Modi turning up at their office in the year
2000 with a bunch of documents incriminating
this rival of his, Patel, in a scandal.
Quote, I immediately felt this man
was bad news. There was something sinister
about him and the way he spoke, and I felt deeply
uncomfortable in his presence. He complained
about Patel and talked about corruption.
He came back a couple times, but I didn't run the story.
Before I knew what had happened, he was back
in Gujarat as the chief minister and Keshubhai's
place. So Narendra, like,
basically fucks with this other guy.
He sees his rival, succeeds in kind of
maneuvering him out of power, and he winds up
as the man in charge of Gujarat
on February 27th, 2002,
when a passenger train stops
in the city of Godra after departing
from Ayodhya. Many of the people on board
the train were Hindu pilgrims who had been
visiting the destroyed Babri Masjid mosque
in order to advocate the building of a Hindu
temple over its remains. Most of them were
members of the RSS.
Somehow, Muslim residents of Godra
realized that this train was filled with RSS
activists, and they began to shout in
Jirat them, and the Hindu partisans inside
began to shout back. The train stalled
as it began to depart, and this provided
time for the confrontation to escalate.
No one knows exactly what happened
next, but someone threw something
on fire into one of the cars,
possibly like a Muslim shop owner
tossed a stove in there. It's really
not known for certain, but one of the people
in the crowd outside tossed something on fire
into the train.
I've been on a lot of Indian trains.
They're incredibly crowded, and a lot of people
wearing long flowing cotton garments
and also carrying piles of
clothes and stuff with them,
like what they own and whatnot.
It's incredibly flammable in there,
and this catches, like members
of the group inside catch and the fire spreads.
And it's just this horrific
fire, and really like before
anyone knows what's happening, 58
people had either burned to death or suffocated
on board the train. Holy shit.
And blame quickly settles
on Muslims in general for this horrible
tragedy. So members of the
VHP, the religious wing of the RSS,
the group that most of the people in the train
had been a part of, petitioned Narendra Modi
for the right to parade the burnt corpses
of their members through the streets of
the largest city in Gujarat.
What? Yeah, they're like,
we want to really
make the most of this tragedy.
So we want to carry the dead bodies
of our members who got burnt to death
and march them through the city to try to
spark a fucking riot. That's the goal here.
Excuse me, I got to say that
I was like, oh, I'm with them.
I'm with them. They're grieving.
Wait, what? Yeah.
So I feel like that really went
from zero to 100 real quick.
Yeah. And the home secretary
of Gujarat warns Modi that allowing
them to do this will spark another
violent riot, telling him things will go out
of hand. But out of hand is exactly where
Modi wanted things to go. And sure
enough, he allows them to march the corpses
of their dead members through the street, and this provokes
mobs of furious Hindus to take to the
streets all throughout the cities of Gujarat,
shouting, take revenge and slaughter the
Muslims. Rioters cut open
the stomachs of pregnant Muslim women and murdered
babies. Hundreds of women were gang-raised.
Yeah, this is where we get to that.
This is where you fucking got me. This is that paragraph.
All right. Okay. Touche, you son of a bitch.
There's mass gang rapes.
At least one Muslim boy is forced to drink
kerosene and swallow a lit match.
It's bad. It's a bad set of riots.
Can you swallow a lit match?
No.
I know that's not the part I should focus on.
Yeah, it's not. I don't think well.
Geez. Yeah.
And also a member
of the Congress party, Assan Jafri,
was caught by a crowd
and publicly dismembered. So like, these are
really bad riots. Holy fuck.
By the time it's all over, somewhere
around 2,000 to 3,000 people are dead
and the vast majority of them are Muslims.
And we'll never get an exact death toll.
Reports began to filter out
in the immediate wake that this violence had not been
purely spontaneous, just an uncontrollable
expression of rage. And I'm going to quote from the New
Yorker again.
They appeared to have been largely planned and directed by the RSS.
Teams of men armed with clubs, guns
and swords fanned out across the state's Muslim
enclaves, often carrying voter rolls
and other official documents that led them to Muslim
homes and shops.
So they get, like, government information
on where Muslims are living in town to carry
out this stuff. Sounds very crystal
nocty. Yeah, for sure.
Modi, the man in charge of the Gujarati
government, was nowhere to be found.
But his influence was felt everywhere as he
ordered Indian Army soldiers to post up
in their barracks rather than intervene to stop the
violence. Police also received orders
to stand down. And in many areas, they just
took part in the killing.
One of the very few officers who did not go along
with this was Rahul Sharma, the top cop
in the heavily Muslim district of Bhavnagar.
He later testified that he received no word
at all from his superiors on how to contain
the riots, which lasted more than
three months. Sharma took matters into
his own hand. Oh my god, the riots lasted for
more than three months? Yeah, three months
of constant street violence.
Holy shit. Yeah,
it's hardcore.
It's a bad time.
And Sharma's one of, like, the few heroes
of this time. So he, like, is being
told nothing at all from his superiors about
what to do about these murder mobs.
And it kind of comes to a head when
there's huge organized crowd of RSS
supporters with weapons start, like, posting up
outside a school filled with 400 Muslim
children. And he eventually ordered
his cops to, like, fire into the crowd,
which is really maybe the only time I can
think of where I'm like, yeah, it's good that the police
shot at that crowd. Holy shit.
But he successfully saves all these kids.
He's a good guy. He did the right thing.
Most police did not.
The vast majority of Gujarati police let
the pogroms continue unabated.
As a general rule, this too conforms
to the standard behavior of law enforcement
during acts of ethnic cleansing all around the world.
The ones who do not actively participate
very often sit back and watch. So we
can assume anywhere there is ethnic
cleansing occurring, the police will be a part
of it actively rather than protecting the victims.
That's just true on
multiple content. Silver lining?
What's the opposite of a silver lining?
Like a shit streak? Yeah, it's like a shit streak.
Yeah. All right. Yeah.
Yeah, like a shit streak covering one of those, like, thin
blue lines. Yeah.
So Sharma was shuffled out of his job
and criticized by India's home minister
a BJP functionary named Advani
for allowing too many Hindus to die in his
district. So, like, one of the few cops
who, like, does what you would hope
a police officer do and protects the public
gets, like, basically fired
for the fact that too many Hindus died
because, like, some of his cops had to, like, shoot
at Hindus to, like, stop them from massacring
holy school children.
So, in the end, 2,000 people or more
were killed in three months of horrific violence.
More than 150,000 people, mostly Muslims,
were forced out of their homes. As with
the earlier rioting in September 1990,
the Gujarati riots left a vastly
more polarized state in their wake.
Muslims were forced out of neighborhoods they'd long
inhabited and dumped into slums for their own
safety. One of these formed in the vast
garbage dump of the city of Amidabad.
Citizens' village, as it came to be known,
hosted tens of thousands of Muslim refugees.
What little aid it received was supplied
by volunteers. Narendra Modi's
government refused to help. When he was
asked why he had abandoned these people,
who were also citizens of Gujarat,
Modi replied, relief camps are actually
child-making factories.
Those who keep on multiplying the population
should be taught a lesson.
Wow. He's a cool guy. Cool.
Not coming, dude.
The Gujarat riots were met with a
tepid response by the Indian government.
Only a few dozen rioters were ever convicted
of anything, and only one elected
official in the BJP, Maya Ben-Kudnani,
was ever convicted of murder and conspiracy.
She was cleared of all charges when Modi
became the prime minister, so that's nice.
Pretty convenient. Pretty convenient.
I'm getting ahead of myself a little bit, though.
The international community was outraged
by what happened in Gujarat, and the RSS
and Narendra Modi in particular became global
pariahs. Modi was banned from travel
to the United States or the United Kingdom.
His reputation suffered enough that his fellow
BJP members in India temporarily
disavowed him. In 2004,
the BJP Prime Minister, Atal Vajpayee,
was voted out of office,
and he blamed Narendra Modi for his loss.
So for a while,
it seemed like the Gujarat riots, as horrible
as they were, had sounded a death knell
to Modi's career and to the RSS.
But of course, those riots
would prove to be only the beginning.
And on Thursday's episode, we're going to talk
about what came next. But you know what it's time
to talk about now. I don't know.
The amazing goods and services?
No, the amazing plugs that you have to plug.
What? Yeah, we're in the P-zone!
Me and the other members of the BJP
can be found on Twitter and Instagram
at the Sophia
S-O-F-I-Y-A
and you can hear me
on my two podcasts.
One is on iHeart
with Miles Gray from Dailies,
I guess, called 420 Day Fiancé.
And the other one is
Private Parts Unknown with Kourtney Kosak
where we travel all around the world
and talk to people
about love and sex and sexuality.
Yeah! Love Kourtney.
Kourtney's the best. Love Kourtney.
Hate the growing specter of international
fascism.
Listen to Sophia's
podcast. That's weirdly on her website.
Yeah.
From you. It is. It is.
That's my only book jacket quote.
So, listen to those podcasts.
Maybe pick up a couple of knives,
a couple of other weapons.
Just, you know, get ready for
your own local
ethnic cleansing mobs.
Boy, howdy. Sophie, how do we end an episode?
You can find Robert on Twitter
and I write okay. You can find us
on the twin-stagram at at bastards pod.
You can find our sources
underneath the episode notes
if you just scroll down.
And you can
listen to Robert on Worst Year Ever.
And we have another project coming out
very soon. Look for that.
Yeah. The Women's War, March 25th.
Episode 1, March 25th.
Trailer March 18th. Look out for it.
So, boy, Sophie, the way you
handled that was so much more responsible
than just telling the audience to arm themselves
to fight against mobs of violent fascists.
That's what I'm here for.
Thank you. Thank you for that.
Over. Excellent.
Alphabet Boys is a new podcast series
that goes inside undercover investigations.
In the first season,
we're diving into an FBI investigation
of the 2020 protests.
It involves a cigar-smoking mystery man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse we're like a lot of guns.
But are federal agents catching bad guys
or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and then, for sure,
he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Did you know Lance Bass is a Russian-trained
astronaut?
That he went through training
in a secret facility outside Moscow,
hoping to become the youngest person
to go to space?
Well, I ought to know.
Because I'm Lance Bass.
And I'm hosting a new podcast
that tells my crazy story and an even crazier story
about a Russian astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down.
With the Soviet Union collapsing around him,
he orbited the Earth for 313 days
that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you that much of the forensic science
you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual science?
And the wrongly convicted pay a horrific price?
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest?
I was incarcerated two days after her first birthday.
Listen to CSI on trial on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.