Behind the Bastards - Part Two: Inside Fox News with Katy and Cody
Episode Date: March 16, 2023We continue the story of Dominion's lawsuit against Fox.See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information....
Transcript
Discussion (0)
The Mantoar Caves
I say the Lord works in mysterious ways
A brand new immersive fiction podcast
Well, he ain't got nothing on the devil
Starring Westworlds Jonathan Tucker and Eddie Cthege from Twilight
Every minute I remain in Mantoar County
The thick of the fog gets
Tune in to uncover what happened when three boys entered a Tennessee cave
But only one returned
This is the exact spot where we found the body's jewelry
The Mantoar Caves
M-A-N-T-A-W-A-U-K
Listen to the Mantoar Caves now on the iHeartRadio app
Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to podcasts
What's up y'all, this is Questlove and you know
At QLS I get to hang out with my friends
Sugar Steve, Laia, Vontigolo, Unpaid Bill
And we, you know, at Questlove Supreme like the nerd out and do deep dives with musicians and actors and politicians and creatives
People that we feel really deserve that attention
We learn, we laugh, we fall down rabbit holes
Listen to Questlove Supreme on the iHeartRadio app
Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts
SUPREMA!
What would you do if a secret cabal of the most powerful folks in the United States told you, hey, let's start a coup?
Back in the 1930s, a marine named Smedley Butler was all that stood between the U.S. and fascism
I'm Ben Bullitt
I'm Alex French
And I'm Smedley Butler
Join us for this sordid tale of ambition, treason, and what happens when
Evil tycoons have too much time on their hands
Listen to Let's Start a Coup on the iHeartRadio app
Apple Podcast or wherever you find your favorite shows
What's someone who should probably not be allowed out in civil society?
My Tucker Carlson!
Cody, Katie, guests of Behind the Bastards
We've not done a BTB on Tucker Carlson
Cody, you basically did
You had a massive Some More News episode on the guy
It's a big one, yeah
Why is Tucker Carlson, I believe?
Yeah
That's what it's called
We've done like a follow-up or two
One of our better titles
But, yeah
Yeah, he's a guy, man
Yeah
I would say all you need to really know about Tucker Carlson
Aside from like the Swanson airship and all that kind of stuff
And his, what, his son Buckley, I think?
Anyway, this is my guy
Oh my god
Really?
His letters to, yeah
I've never met a Buckley that we needed in the world
And also, you know that he doesn't shorten it to Buck
It's Buckley all the time
Wrote a letter to Hunter Biden thanking him for like
Helping him his son get into school
Anyway, that's one of my favorite Tucker facts
When Tucker was working in print journalism
He was getting a, he called it a
Takeout Hot Dog
Is what he called it
My god
Yeah, you know, he's literally wearing the bow ties
He's writing this, I'm sure
So you gotta take out
Of course
Take out Hot Dog
Yeah, the man of the people
Yeah, and somebody in the office was basically saying
They need somebody to go on TV
To talk about the OJ trial
They need an expert in the OJ trial
To go and talk about it
And their OJ expert can't do it
Can you
And he was just like, yes
And in the book he's like
He didn't know anything about the OJ trial
Wasn't following it at all
I immediately said yes to get on TV
And then he did
And that's like the start of his career on television
And I think it's just so illustrative of like
Who he is
And his like his entire career
Is just that moment of like
Who's an OJ expert to go on TV
Oh, I am, I'll do it
After getting a Takeout Hot Dog
You know, I am
Years ago for the nonfiction book
I wrote A Brief History of Ice
I talked to one of the two guys
Who coined the Dunning-Kruger effect
And I also talked to the author of a paper about
I think the title of the paper
Was the Evolution of Overconfidence
And it was kind of
It's part of this body of research
Is trying to answer the question
And I think people are broadly familiar
With the Dunning-Kruger effect
Which is a fairly durable finding
In neuroscience
That people who are least competent
In given tasks tend to overestimate
Their own competence the most
That's kind of the briefest way of describing it
And so there's this question
That people, scientists in this field
Have which is like
Why, right?
Because it does
It kind of seems
If you're just kind of assuming on its surface
That like
It would be a bad trade evolutionarily
To be overconfident
Because then you'll get yourself in situations
That you can't handle
And you'll die horribly, right?
Right, right
But I guess it could be like
Psychologically protective
You know?
But like that's not
I don't know if that's enough, right?
There's the point that was made to me
As I was trying to like
Understand why this still exists
Is that if you've got a resource
That two different individuals
Are competing over, right?
And they're more or less evenly matched
Or at least they can't know
Whether or not
Because right, if you're like
Standing next to a guy
Who wants to fight
Who is roughly your size
You have no idea who's going to win or not
Unless you're like, you know
They're a black box, right?
You don't know who is better
At fighting or whatever
So if you...
The individual that is more confident
In their ability to take that resource
If they just go for it and grab it
One of two things will happen
Either the other individual
Will fight back
In which case they either win or lose the fight
Or the other individual chooses
Not to fight and you get the resource
And statistically
That's a pretty good bet to make
Enough of the time
That overconfidence is an extremely common trait
Not just among human beings
And I think it's also interesting
That that is how fascism works, right?
They just keep grabbing
And until you fight back
They're just going to keep taking more and more
Which is why, you know
We could talk about certain shootings
That have occurred recently
In the city of Portland
But I think that like
Fundamentally, Tucker is a perfect embodiment
Of that fact
Both in his career
Where it's just like
Well, yeah, if you just try to do shit
That you're not competent to do
And hope that you can bullshit your way through it
Sometimes you will
And then you make tens of millions of dollars
And also if you just keep pushing
Further and further as a fascist
And trying to incite more violence
Against your enemies
And no one stops you
Then you get everything you want
Which in Tucker's...
It's literally fuck around
And find out
Just like evil
It is really evil
It's interesting
Because I wonder what he's saying in his texts
You know, in 2023
But in 2020
There's a degree of which you can see
Like fear in him of what he's doing
Which makes sense
Because he doesn't know if it's going to work out
For him or not
But it does
There's a degree to which I find it
And maybe he's more confident now
I don't know
There's a degree to which I find a little bit of it comforting
Because it's like
Oh, he knows he could lose
Like he doesn't actually know how this is going to work out
And he's second guessing himself
And his colleagues
And maybe that means that there's hope
Maybe not, you know
It's 2023
It's never a good idea to bet on hope
Because he's in it, right?
It doesn't matter how confident he is necessarily
Yeah, now, yes
So yeah
At any rate
We are back into the story of how Fox News
Handled the election lies
Was it well?
Talking about this document
I remember it was well
Yeah, well is a good way to describe it
Okay, good
So while Murdoch
I don't expect nothing less
Sorry, go ahead
No, no, no
While Murdoch apparently went to pretty great lengths
To curry favor with the Trump campaign
During the election
He does not seem to have
Appeared to have wanted to push the stolen election line
After November 2nd
But within Fox News itself
Murdoch had a serious problem
He had hired a stable of hosts who were
Let's say
Either crazy assholes
Or evil enough that
All they cared about was their bottom line
And they saw this as the best way to do it
There's also a degree of like fear of Trump
That they all have
Internal discussion
And these people could not be entirely controlled, right?
Rupert Murdoch has a lot of power
He does not have absolute control over Sean Hannity
Or Tucker Carlson
Or Judge Jeanine
Or any of these other people
Because they were all multi-million dollar businesses
They have a lot of leverage, you know
Although, wasn't it
Tucker Carlson at one point
Say on some radio show
He was Rupert Murdoch's bitch
Wait, did he?
Yeah, yeah
He's ruling it right now
That was more back in his shock days, though, wasn't it?
Right, right
Right now he's like
Making it
I just like that popped into my head
Yeah, yeah, I mean
A little bit, I mean
Because it definitely
The depiction you get from these internal comms
Is not one in which he's fully Murdoch's bitch
Although it's also one in which
You know, I don't know
I was actually kind of surprised by how
Comparatively toothless it seems like Murdoch was
Maybe just because of how much
Fox is a talent-driven business
But yeah, there's internal discussions
That Dominion posted
Between Fox executives that are just like
This parade of worries
Particularly that Sean Hannity
Is not, like, controllable
Yeah
They went so far
And they did take some actions to try and mitigate this
Judge Jeanine Perot's
November 7th show was cancelled
Because as Fox executive David Clark said
Her guests are all going to say the election is being stolen
And if she pushes back at all, it will just be token
And then it's like token dot dot dot
And then, like, two sentences are redacted
So I don't know what the fuck else they were saying
About Judge Jeanine
Oh, I wish I knew
I know, there's some tantalizing redactions here
And then we get to this lovely bit
Quote
As Fox producer Justin Wells described
They took her off because she was being crazy
Optics are bad, but she is crazy
So he's like, the optics of us questioning
The election lies, conspiracy theory are bad
But also this bitch is nuts
This is a situation you find
When you hire people you know are inflammatory
Just to be inflammatory, it's Pandora's box
They've opened Pandora's box and they can't control them
No, they cannot
So these mild attempts at responsibility did not extend
To letting the network call the election for Biden first
They waited until all of the other networks had finished
Viewers revolted
Rupert Murdoch complained to Suzanne Scott that the company was
Quote, getting creamed by CNN
Guess our viewers don't want to watch it
Now, this is the point at which Chuck R. Carlson
Yeah, I fucking love that
It's so funny, it's just like, yeah, they don't like the results
They couldn't, sorry, Quote
Yeah, it is remarkable
And at this point, Tucker Carlson, who'd kind of started out
On like broadly speaking team reason
Like angry at the election conspiracies, takes a turn
Carlson texted his producer, do the executives understand
How much credibility and trust we've lost with our audience
We're playing with fire for real
An alternative like Newsmax could be devastating to us
Yeah, they know exactly what's going on
Yeah, they know exactly like the shit that they're in
Yeah, they're in a bad way, bad situation, yo
The freaks we spawned might overtake us
Yeah, it's very, very funny
On November 8th, the day after the election was called
Maria Bartiromo had Sidney Powell on again
To talk about Dominion's software
Which she alleged had an algorithm
That had stolen the election from Trump
Bartiromo knew ahead of time that Powell was going to spread
Conspiracy theories about the company
Because Powell had sent her a document the day before titled
Election Fraud Info
Now, this is the core of all of the information about
The Dominion and Smartmatic or whatever
Like this is the actual nut of data that Sidney Powell has
That all of her claims are based on, right?
So basically everything that Fox is going to magnify
About the election conspiracy comes from this document
That Powell has been sent from an anonymous source
Titled Election Fraud Info
Now, for one thing, Powell describes this anonymous source
As pretty whack-a-doodle, right?
Like, and what does that mean exactly?
I bet you're wondering, what is from Sidney Powell?
What does the sentence or the statement pretty whack-a-doodle mean?
Here's how the motion describes the Election Fraud Info document
In addition to promoting lies about Dominion, the cinder claimed
That Justice Scalia was purposefully killed at the annual
Bohemian Grove camp during a week-long human-hunting expedition
And that former Fox News CEO, Roger Ailes, who died in 2017
And Rupert Murdoch secretly huddled most days to determine
How best to portray Mr. Trump as badly as possible
The author continued, who am I and how do I know all of this?
I had the strangest dream since I was a little girl
I was internally decapitated
Oh, Cody, you gotta hear this
I was internally decapitated, and yet I live
The wind tells me I'm a ghost, but I don't believe it
What?
That's right, you don't believe it
This is the source
Yeah, this is it
For all of this
This is the source that three or four billion dollars in lawsuits
Are based around
And another point in this email
This anonymous source claims to be able to
Time travel in a semi-conscious state
Which is also, I think that just means dreaming
Yeah
That is fucking incredible
To know where it all comes to
It's not even Sydney making stuff up
Or just pretending to be a black box
She shares this email with Fox hosts
So that she can inform them what she's going to bring up
So they know that the source of a lot of these election claims
Is an internally decapitated woman who the wind tells us a ghost
And can time travel in a semi-conscious state
Yeah, in a semi-conscious state, very impressive
Very
Very interesting info
Yeah, I mean, Cody, I don't think any of your sources
Can time travel in a semi-conscious state, so
I hope she includes all this in her resume
Future ones
Cover letters, which is applying to jobs
It is seedy
I can time travel in a semi-conscious state
Interestingly, our friend David Bell puts that on his resume as well
Oh, that's true, he does
That is true, he can
I'm wondering, did David Bell write this letter?
No, he was never internally decapitated
That's right, that's right
He would have shared that
No, he sends me a CAT scan of his neck every single week
So I can confirm he has not been internally decapitated
So, Bartarimo, Jesus, what a stupid last name
Was aware of the email and stated in her deposition
That she knew that it was nonsense
But at no point on air did she mention that this email
Was the source of Powell's claims about Dominion
Which had aired on Fox to millions of viewers
As Tucker Carlson texted that night
The software shit is absurd
Half our viewers have seen the Maria clip
Not wrong
The most interesting stuff in here to me
Is this behind-the-scenes glimpse at how Tucker communicates
When he thinks he has a reasonable expectation of privacy
Because he seems equally preoccupied with how dumb the conspiracy is
As he is with lambasting his colleagues
For not adequately furthering the conspiracy theory
He's pissed about both
He's angry that this conspiracy is taking off
And he's even angrier when his colleagues don't back it up on the air
What a weird position for a giant asshole to be in
It's a bad, it's a bad, sticky one
That would be his position though, wouldn't it?
Of course, because there's no personal responsibility
There's nothing like, be angry about everybody, the options
But what are the options here?
There are no breaks on this ride he's on
He wants the drivers to guide it a little better
Yeah, it's good stuff
That's so interesting
He's definitely not stopping
On November 9th, Carlson told Suzanne Scott, Fox's CEO, directly
I've never seen a reaction like this to any media company
Kills me to watch it
Scott took that message down the line
Attacking her colleagues for having the arrogance to call Arizona
She expressed that it was astonishing that a top executive had signed off on the Arizona call
Given that every executive's first job was to, quote, protect the brand
Oh, that's their first job
Oh yeah, it's your shit not reporting the news, Katie
No, definitely isn't that
I'm gonna continue from the motion
And on that day, day one, as Scott termed it
Fox executives made an explicit decision to push narratives to entice their audience back
Scott and Lachlan Murdoch exchanged texts about the plan going forward
Scott, viewers going through the five stages of grief
It's a question of trust, the AZ call was damaging
But we will highlight our stars and plant flags letting the viewers know we hear them and respect them
Murdoch, yes, but needs constant rebuilding without any missteps
Scott, yes, today is day one and it's a process
Oh, so fun
Pretending they respect their audience is very funny
Yeah, and that respecting their audience means embracing the lie their audience thinks
Yeah, exactly, easing them off the lie maybe
We've got to respect our audience
That's so funny
I think one of the things I find really compelling here is that like
The most honest any of them seems is when they are distraught that the audience is losing trust in them
And so it's like, I think they do feel bad that they didn't embrace the audience's insane conspiracy enough
That like, oh, we let them down
They expected us to be as batshit as they are and we really fell down on the job there
Yeah, yeah, I mean, yeah
Feeling upset that they can't, that they're in this situation and they can't, yeah
Yeah, that they failed their audience
Yeah, we should have gone in harder at the outset
So we're not struggling right now
We should have been dumber and faster
I do say that a lot myself
But you know who's as dumb and as fast as it's possible to be
Sponsors
Our sponsors
They are as fast as, I don't know how to finish that sentence
Anyway, here's our fucking ads
This case has all the markings of a ritualistic, occult murder
The Manowar Caves
A brand new immersive fiction podcast
No, he ain't got nothing on the devil
Part psychological thriller, part supernatural horror
The truth?
Sometimes it's revealed in the intersection of facts
Sometimes it's hidden to the lore
Starring Westworld's Jonathan Tucker and Eddie Cthigge from Twilight
I wouldn't go digging around, stirring up trouble if I was you
Tune in to uncover what happened when three boys entered a Tennessee cave
But only one returned
This is the exact spot where we found the potty's joint
The Manowar Caves
M-A-N-T-A-W-A-U-K
A production of I Heart Radio
Blumhouse Television and Psychopia Pictures
Every minute I remain in Manowar County
The thick of the fog gets
Listen to The Manowar Caves now
On the I Heart Radio App
Podcasts or wherever you listen to podcasts
about stories behind their life journeys
And their works of art
I love QLS because of the QLS Team Supreme
They're like a second family to me
You're a fan of deep diving into music, everything
All-manacking your musical history
And learning things about hip-hop artists and things you never thought
Then you're a lot like me
But you're also a fan of Quest Love Supreme
One of the things I love the most about this show is that
We get to learn from the masters
And look at being on this show as my graduate program in music
Listen to Quest Love Supreme on the I Heart Radio App
Now the podcast or wherever you get your podcasts
Supreme!
What would you do if a secret cabal
Of the most powerful folks in the United States told you
Hey, let's start a coup
Back in the 1930s, a marine named Smedley Butler
Was all that stood between the U.S. and fascism
I'm Ben Bullock
And I'm Alex French
In our newest show, we take a darkly comedic
And occasionally ridiculous
Deep dive into a story that has been buried for nearly a century
We've tracked down exclusive historical records
We've interviewed the world's foremost experts
We're also bringing you cinematic, historical
Recreations of moments left out of your history books
I'm Smedley Butler and I got a lot to say
For one, my personal history is raw, inspiring, and mind-blowing
And for another, do we get the mattresses after we do the ads
Or do we just have to do the ads?
From iHeart Podcast and School of Humans
This is Let's Start a Coup
Listen to Let's Start a Coup on the iHeart Radio App
Apple Podcast or wherever you find your favorite shows
Ah, we are back
On November 9th, Neil Cavuto cut away from a White House press conference
Where Kaylee McEnany made unsubstantiated claims about election fraud
Neil told viewers that he could not in good conscience air her claims
Unless she had evidence to back them up
Which is honestly more of a principled stand
Than I think any of us ever expected from Neil Cavuto
Absolutely surprising
Yeah, shocking
The brand team at Fox panicked
Raj Shah, who headed the brand team
Notified senior leadership that Cavuto represented a brand threat
Tied in with all this, and with Tucker's reaction
Was an ever-present fear of Newsmax
What's built over into the course of November
Fox execs and talent seem to see Newsmax as a mortal threat to their continued profitability
Which is funny, because didn't it just get dropped from like...
What is it?
Was it Newsmax or the One News?
Yeah, Direct TV just dropped Newsmax
Because it didn't get enough people watching it
Well...
It's interesting
Yeah, maybe Fox was...
I don't know, it may have just been that like in the moment
Newsmax was experiencing a surge
But it clearly didn't last
They're not doing well right now
Which is very funny also
Fuck all of those people
Quote
Prior to November 8th, Fox executive David Clark
Testified that Newsmax was not a credible media outlet
Because, quote
Their hosts were extremely one-sided
Ignored the facts
They did not seem to care about telling the truth
They seemed to invest truly in conspiracy theories versus fact
Yeah, I mean, that'll do it
Wow, imagine a news agency being like that, David
Fucked up, huh?
On November 10th, Scott pointed out to senior Fox executives
A note from analyst Kyle Goodwin on Newsmax's ride
Fox executive Porter Berry responded
Just pulled up Newsmax's show and they're hitting Cavuto
They're just whacking us
Smart on their part
Lauren Peterson added
They definitely have a strategy across all shows
To try and target and steal our viewers
And this is also really compelling to me
Just because like at number one, obviously at no point
Is even ideology a primary concern
Like the concern is the competition, right?
Like it's pure business
And there's almost this like
I can respect the degree to which they're good at fucking us over
Yeah, we would do that too
We would do that too
And it's a shame to us that we weren't smart enough to do it faster, right?
Yeah
Fox executives talk about Newsmax
The rest of us talk about Fox
Which is one of the most entertaining things in the document
Fox president Jay Wallace describes Newsmax as truly an alternative universe
That can't be ignored
He then adds in a message to Suzanne Scott
That he is trying to get everyone to comprehend
We are on war footing
And again, that's also
From the point I'm making about like ideology
Doesn't seem to come into it with these people
They're not at war with the Biden White House or Democrats
They're at war with other right-wing media that might steal their thunder
Yeah, who's outfoxing them
It's very interesting
I'm proud of you, Cody
You know what? Let's get on a call with the t-shirt people real quick
Yeah, let's go and print one of those
The t-shirt people
Everything that Fox does next is influenced by this feeling of being at war with Newsmax
This is what causes Tucker to make common cause with Sean Hannity
In order to push the false claim that Dominion was the core of some grand fraud
The express purpose of backing this conspiracy theory was to bring viewers back from Newsmax
Hannity told Carlson and Ingram on November 12th in one week in one debate that destroyed a brand that took 25 years to build and the damage is incalculable
Tucker responded, it's vandalism
The hosts also discussed the possibility of competition to Fox emerging
Hannity told them, serious money with serious distribution could be a real problem
IMHO, they need to address, but what I don't know
Tucker, that could happen
So, yeah
Feel that fear, folks
Yeah, feel that fear, it is nice to know that he can be afraid
It's a little brain bug moment there
Putting your hand on the goop stick that Tucker Carlson uses to suck the brains out of your aunts and uncles
Yeah, it's afraid, it's afraid
Normally, I feel a little bit of empathy when an unlikable character, when you realize that they're afraid
You humanize them, nah, not this guy, be afraid
I would not feel empathy if Tucker Carlson's asshole got sucked out of his backside by one of those sucker things in a swimming pool
In a grain silo or something
Yeah, or a grain silo, yeah
Let's grain silo the fucker
Did you guys grow up with that at your local pool?
That there was like, oh, yeah, a kid got their whole, all their guts sucked up
And then like a Palinuk short story, right?
Was it a Palinuk short story?
I think he ended up doing a short story about that urban legend, which I think was an urban legend
Yeah, I would definitely say, Cody, if there's a short story about getting your guts sucked out of your butt through a swimming pool, Chuck Palinuk wrote it
It would be Chuck Palinuk for sure
Literally called guts, actually
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah
Beautiful
Okay
But for the record, I would think it was funny if that happened to Tucker
So, yeah
That same day, Laura Ingram's producer Tommy Firth texted a Fox executive responsible for overseeing her show
He complained, this dominion shit is going to give me a fucking aneurysm
As many times as I've told Laura it's BS, she sees shit posters and Trump tweeting about it
The next sentence or so is redacted, but the Fox executive responds, this is the Bill Gates microchip angle to voter fraud
The next day he messages Firth again, asking, how's it going with the kooks?
Oh, wow
So they're both being like, oh yeah, Laura's, you know, she's watching these shit posters, she's tweeting about nonsense
But the executive's like, yeah, you know, this is something we can work with, it's this Bill Gates microchip angle, but applied to voter fraud
Yeah, we can make it work
Yeah, how's it going? Are the crazy people biting?
This feels, you're not done telling this story, but this all feels really damning
It's very damning and evil
It feels like people should be locked up
Like, we have fun, we make our jokes, but like, honestly, the real life repercussions of this shit
Families destroyed, people killed themselves over this, there was just another like, suicide of an entire family over this shit
Like, this has destroyed so many lives, like, I don't know, these people, like, money is not enough
I don't see, on a moral level, I don't see any argument as to why a lot of this shouldn't be criminally liable
But none of it is, obviously, or ever will be, because it's fine to do this
It's not fine to like, yell at the Atlanta police after they shoot a guy, then you get charged with domestic terrorism, but this is cool
Yeah
So, also on November 12th, Lou Dobbs took to the airways with Rudy Giuliani as guest
After Giuliani repeated his litany of false allegations against Dominion, Dobbs said on air, it's stunning
They have no ability to audit meaningfully the votes that are cast because the servers are somewhere else
This looks to me like it is the in-game to a four and a half year-long effort to overthrow the President of the United States
While Dobbs dug that hole deeper, Laura Ingram, Sean Hannity, and Tucker Carlson were in a group text thread together
And, boy, that sounds like the worst group text I could imagine
I want only that
You want that?
I want to see it all
Every breaking news story that happens, I want to see just everything
I don't want to be on that thread in any way, but I would love to read it, for sure
Yeah, I don't know, I'd like to be on there, be like, hey guys, you know, it's Friday
I got some beers
The liver of a child that was drowned to death in amaretto
You guys want to come over, you know, have some brews, eat a little bit
I assume when Laura Ingram, Sean Hannity, and Tucker Carlson hang out together
They eat like the human equivalent of an orderlon
That's the only thing that...
They don't even hide their shame from God, though
Tucker knows he's more powerful
So, yeah, while Dobbs dug that hole deeper, Laura Ingram, Sean Hannity, and Tucker Carlson are in their group chat
And Carlson shares a tweet by Fox reporter Jackie Heinrich
And Jackie was one of the, like, three or four people at Fox who had a shred of integrity
And Trump tweeted about Dominion, like, sharing the Sidney Powell conspiracy
And Jackie Heinrich fact-checked it
She noted, there is no evidence that any voting system deleted or lost votes
Carlson shares this and tells Hannity, please get her fired, seriously, what the fuck?
I'm actually shocked, it needs to stop immediately, like tonight
It's measurably hurting the company, the stock price is down, not a joke
Tucker then adds, I just went crazy on mead over it
Hannity responds that he had already sent to Cezanne with a really?
He then added, I'm three strikes, wall is shit debate, election night a disaster
Now this BS? Nope, not gonna fly, did I mention Cavuto?
They're so pissed, they're so pissed
Is this satisfying?
Yeah, it does feel good a little bit
I can just see him
Yeah
Now Hannity next texts Suzanne Scott, who reached out to Fox's SVP of corporate communications, Irina Briganti
Quote, Sean texted me, he's standing down on responding, but not happy about this
And doesn't understand how this is allowed to happen from anyone in news
She, Heinrich, has serious nerve doing this
And if it gets picked up, viewers are going to be further disgusted
By the next morning, Heinrich had deleted her fact-checking tweet
So I guess, look, again, Heinrich had a little bit of, what do you say?
Courage or whatever
A little bit
But not so much that when her bosses yell at her, she doesn't delete the tweet
Oh yeah, as soon as Tucky shows up
Yeah, yeah
Winding little texts
I don't know, maybe one thing you could take from that is that like, if you get caught telling the truth in right wing media
There's not like a job open for you in normal media
Whereas if you get caught lying in mainstream media
Oh yeah, you got a long career at it
Exactly
Yeah, I was putting myself, trying to put myself in that position
And it's like, yeah, I could see how you get intimidated
I would like to think I wouldn't because I would make those series of choices where I was working at this place
But, you know
Yeah, you know, there's this term you hear because of Hannah Arendt, the banality of evil
And she was talking about like Holocaust perpetrators, but it gets used a lot
I think it, I prefer to think of things a little differently, which is that like, it's not that evil is banal
It's that the vast majority of evil is perpetuated so that people can pay their mortgage
And that's what's going on here
And that's even what's going on with like, like Tucker doesn't have a mortgage or whatever
But it's very much just about the bottom line, right?
Like if the money for Tucker had been in being a liberal or left wing media personality
He would have been just as fine doing that, he doesn't care
Like, yeah
While this is going on, Dominion representatives are frantically contacting Fox News to try and correct these false allegations
In the first like two months that followed the election, they sent 3,600 messages to Fox representatives
Fox executive David Clark tells a colleague on November 14th, I have it tattooed on my body at this point
LOL super aware that we're, we're, we're lying criminally about a corporation
LMAO, yeah
LOL
Hope they don't sue us for $1.6 billion
Tee hee hee
Kissy face, yeah
One fun thing I learned reading this is that Fox does in fact have its own fact checking department
Now, that's an astonishing thing to hear if you have watched a lot of Fox News
You know what they call themselves?
Tucking losers
No, no, what do they call themselves?
The brain room
Shut up
I mean don't shut up, but oh no
The brain room
Yeah, incredible, love it
What facts are they checking?
They'll check the facts so that they know
Can we report the opposite?
I would love to answer that question for you, but as soon as the motion notes that Fox's fact checking department is called the brain room
The next two full paragraphs are redacted
What?
Reckless redactions
Again, there's some, there's some juicy shit that's black barred in this
It's the funniest place to put redaction
It's, it's, it's really, there is a degree of comedic timing from some of these dominion lawyers
Some of it's like intriguing, something like, wow, what are you saying there?
It's like, no, no, no, the brain room is soft
The brain room?
Yeah, we can't talk about what happens in the brain room
So immediately after
Stays in the brain room
So immediately after those two full paragraphs of redaction comes this paragraph
Fox continued to broadcast its lies about dominion as it nervously eyed Newsmax
In a November 16th email, Rupert Murdoch told Scott to read a Wall Street journal piece about Newsmax
Telling her, these people should be watched if skeptically
Trump will concede eventually
And we should concentrate on Georgia, helping any way we can
We don't want to antagonize Trump further
But Giuliani taken with a large grain of salt
Everything at stake here
It's so funny
The paragraph
Yeah, what a hard time
So the paragraph that follows this is also redacted
And immediately after all that redaction comes this line
Carlson told his producer Alex Pfeiffer that night
Sidney Powell is lying, fucking bitch
It's so good
Having a rough one, huh buddy?
Let me out
He continues to complain about this regularly up to November 18th
When he tells Laura Ingram that Powell is crazy and Ingram responds
Sidney is a complete nut, no one will work with her
Ditto Rudy
Carlson responds
Holy shit, check this out, Carlson responds
It's unbelievably offensive to me
Our viewers are good people and they believe it
Why do they believe it, Tucker?
Why do they believe it, Tucker Carlson?
Why do these good people believe it?
Let's take it a step further, man
Yeah, it's so...
There's almost like a schizophrenic quality to reading through this
Because there's this mix of Carlson responding
The way a regular person should
This is unbelievably offensive, it's fucked up
But also like, you're doing it, Tucker
Yeah, it's like, look what they're making me do kind of stuff
Like, look at the situation I'm in and what I have to do
But I respect the audience so much, they're such good people
But I have to
No, they respect what the audience means for his bottom line
But again, it's just not surprising in any way, but you know
An inability, a psychologically incapable of seeing any accountability
No, absolutely not
Nightmare to be married to
Tucker, you're doing it, you're doing it
Yeah, Tucker, the lies have come from inside the you
The false coming from inside you
This is entirely your fault, Tucker Carlson
But you know what's not, what isn't Tucker Carlson's fault
The joys of cooking pre-prepped meals
That are delivered straight to yours
Hello, friend
I bet I can make it, we could find a case for how that's his fault
No, you know, he actually, this is very exciting
Delivered straight to your door
Very exciting
We've got a couple of sponsors, we've got a food box company
And a mattress company sponsoring us
And as a result, we're now offering our listeners for a limited time
A mattress completely stuffed with tacos
A taco mattress
Unrefrigerated, no preservatives
It'll, just a larger quantity of food than you can eat
Stuffed in a mattress that you have to cut open to get the food out
Does this benefit you in any way?
Does it do nothing but cause problems for you?
Yes, of course, just like Fox News
So, use promo code
I would like a pile of rancid tacos stuck inside my mattress
And, yeah, we'll be back in a minute
This case has all the markings of a ritualistic, occult murder
The men who aren't caves
Say the Lord works in mysterious ways
A brand new, immersive fiction podcast
No, he ain't got nothing on the devil
Part psychological thriller, part supernatural horror
The truth?
Sometimes it's revealed in the intersection of facts
Sometimes it's hidden to the lore
Starring Westworld's Jonathan Tucker and Eddie Cthigge from Twilight
I wouldn't go digging around, stirring up trouble if I was you
Tune in to uncover what happened when three boys entered a Tennessee cave
But only one returned
This is the exact spot where we found the bodies, Julie
The Mental Walk Caves
M-A-N-T-A-W-A-U-K
A production of I Heart Radio, Blumhouse Television, and Psychopia Pictures
Every minute I remain in Mental Walk County
The thick of the fog gets
Listen to the Mental Walk Caves now on the I Heart Radio app
Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to podcasts
What's up y'all, this is Questlove
And you know, at QLS I get to hang out with my friends
Sugar Steve, Laia, Vontigolo, Unpaid Bill
And we, you know, at Questlove Supreme like the nerd out and do deep dives
With musicians and actors and politicians and journalists
We give you the stories behind all your favorite artists and creatives
That you have never heard
I'm talking about stories behind their life journeys
And their works
I love QLS because of the QLS Team Supreme
They're like a second family to me
You're a fan of deep diving and music, everything
All monacking your musical history
And learning things about hip hop artists and things you never thought
Then you're a lot like me
But you're also a fan of Questlove Supreme
One of the things I love the most about this show
Is that we get to learn from the masters
I look at being on this show as my graduate
Program in music
Listen to Questlove Supreme on the I Heart Radio app
At the podcast or wherever you get your podcasts
Supreme!
What would you do if a secret cabal of the most powerful folks in the United States told you
Hey, let's start a coup
Back in the 1930s, a marine named Smedley Butler
Was all that stood between the U.S. and fascism
I'm Ben Bullock
And I'm Alex French
In our newest show, we take a darkly comedic
And occasionally ridiculous
Deep dive into a story that has been buried for nearly a century
We've tracked down exclusive historical records
We've interviewed the world's foremost experts
We're also bringing you cinematic, historical recreations of moments left out of your history books
I'm Smedley Butler and I got a lot to say
For one, my personal history is raw, inspiring and mind-blowing
And for another, do we get the mattresses after we do the ads
Or do we just have to do the ads?
From iHeart Podcast and School of Humans, this is
Let's Start a Coup
Listen to Let's Start a Coup on the iHeart Radio app
Apple Podcast or wherever you find your favorite shows
So, on November 18th, SVP of Primetime Programming and Analytics
Ron Mitchell sends a message to Underlings
R.E. Newsmax
The lack of any meaningful editorial guidance may be a positive for them, at least in the short term
For example, last night on Stitchfield at 8 p.m.
The show sourced websites like Gateway Pundit while talking about voter fraud
This type of conspiratorial reporting might be exactly what the disgruntled FNC
Fox News Corporation viewers looking for
Mitchell concluded that viewers are watching less Fox News and suggested fixes
Do not ever give viewers a reason to turn us off
Every topic and guest must perform
No unforced errors in content
Example, abruptly turning away from a Trump campaign press conference
Yeah
Dad's gonna run a news network
Give them the slop that they want
Feed the piggies
Gobble, gobble
Keep fucking people's relatives up
This is it
To have them ruin, bring down a society to its knees
It sure is
So, um, yeah, following this guidance on November 19th
Fox broadcast the entirety of a press conference
With Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell
Now, you guys probably all remember this as
Press conference where Rudy's hair melted off of his face
I do, I remember that
What an incredible moment for this country
Made up
It's AI art, it was a lie, it didn't happen
I want to be like frozen so that a thousand years from now
I can help journalists make a documentary about America
And I want to cut straight from like
The battlefield at Gettysburg, thousands of corpses
A nation fighting with its past in order to like
Finally write like the evil at the center of its existence
And cut immediately from that
To like Rudy Giuliani with his hair melting off
Just leaking from his skull
Nothing else is important, we can cut the rest of
American history between those moments
From Gettysburg to Sidney Powell and Giuliani
The two most pivotal points in American history
Absolutely no questions
Yeah, um, I have
A little detour at Four Seasons Total Landscaping
Sure, we can throw that in there too
Yeah, yeah, I think we might even be like
Morally obligated to have a little detour
Into Four Seasons Total Landscaping
Okay, I'm going to play a little segment
From that clip
Because I know a lot of people enjoyed Rudy's head melting
But I think fewer people actually like
Actually listen to some of the claims being made
This is a particularly powerful moment
From that press conference
And I'm going to play it in just a second
Outrageous situation now
I don't think most Americans know
But our ballots get calculated
Many of them outside the United States
And are completely open to hanging
Completely open to change
And it's being done by a company
That specializes in voter fraud
Oh, let's try that too
Oh, he does not look well
Also, Sidney Powell is very tall
Yeah, and wearing a leopard print sweater
Real school armor bags
Interesting choice
We are really feeling
We are uncovering more by the day
Massive influence of communist money
Oh, she did it
Let's start, Ruby
Reference of our elections here in the United States
The Dominion Voting Systems
Smartmatic Technology Software
And the software that goes in
Other computerized voting systems here as well
In just a minute
Were created in Venezuela
At the direction of Hugo Chavez
To make sure he never lost an election
Oh, my God
I do love the way she says Venezuela too
Yeah
The crude oil leaking from his brain
Really distracted from the things that she said
Which it should not have
Yeah, it really should have
Maybe we could talk about afterwards
Maybe it was a tactic, maybe it was planned
Yeah
Ruby is much more cunning than we give him credit for
He has, you know, some species of lizards
Can shoot blood out of their eyes
To, like, distract an attacker
Ruby is able to do that to the entire nation
With his head oil
Developed over millions of years
And distracted himself with a symbiote
Do my little trick
This is how Rudy's Giuliani
Wished to survive at the fringes of the world
For the last 65 million years
Since the death of the rest of their race
I consider Rudy to be the same species as the dinosaurs
In the original Mario movie
You know, the one with Bob Hoskins
Oh, my goodness
You could just put Rudy in that movie
Oh, yeah
Immediately, the same way he dresses
You sure he wasn't in that movie?
Not entirely
No, no, we just don't know
So while this beautiful, beautiful scene was unfolding
Rupert Murdoch sent out an email with the subject
Watching Giuliani exclamation point
The text of that email
Real, really crazy stuff
And damaging...
If only you had the power to stop this, Rupert Murdoch
It's like watching a train crash
And also, you have the Superman-like ability
To stop any object in motion
With a moment's notice
It's the trolley problem, but there's one track
Yeah, it's the trolley problem, but you're God
Yeah, it's very funny
White House correspondent Kristen Fisher
Did at least fact-check some of the claims
Made during this press conference
Her boss, Brian Boyton, called her
And told her emphatically that he and his bosses
Were unhappy with her and that she, quote
Needed to do a better job of, and this is a quote
Respecting our audience
Fisher texted a colleague about being punished
For doing my job shortly thereafter
Real lion's eating faces party moment
Oh no!
I like that this is their phrase
That's the way they're respecting our audience
I know we've covered this, but yeah
Lied to our audience
It's very fun, it's also like
You get these people like Kristen Fisher
Who is like, well, it's good that you were doing your job
As a journalist, but also like
You did work at Fox
Like you did choose to work there
Yeah, this isn't the first thing
Yeah
Like a first questionable move
Yeah, you didn't have a long career there
Without any kind of moral qualms
This is just like, happened to be
The time that there were a bunch of depositions
Maybe this is the only bad thing they've ever done
Maybe this is the only bad thing they've ever done
That's possible, Dodie
We don't know, we just can't know
So the fact that there was regular spirited resistance
Within Fox to the increasingly unhinged Dominion conspiracy
Is very compelling to me
At one point, Fox anchored Dana Perino comments
That Dominion would probably be able to sue
Over the comments made in that press conference
This prompt CEO, Suzanne Scott
To send an email saying
You can't give the crazies an inch right now
They are looking for and blowing up all appearances
Of disrespect to the audience
Scott separately noted
The audience feels like we crapped on them
And we have damaged their trust and belief in us
We can fix this, but we cannot smirk
At our viewers any longer
I'm not positive
What is being argued for here
She's saying like
We can't give the crazies at Fox an inch right now
They're looking for
Any opportunity to like
Blow shit up, but also
The audience feels like
We're shitting on them when we correct this stuff
And that's damaged their trust
So we have to, it's again
They're being pulled
Exactly
It's this impossible situation because you're evil
Like
You're evil, but you don't want to be
Your choices and the scenario that you've created
That you know is bad
But you also need in order to continue
The crew of the Hindenburg
Got themselves into an impossible situation
When they exploded
We don't want to explode
And yet we love this explosive thing
What an impossible situation
We don't respect the explosion
Yeah
We're not respecting the audience
If we don't explode properly
The audience being
Hydrogen
So internally
Fox executives like Ron Mitchell
Laughed at the clowns
Rudy and Sidney who had put us in a terrible place
He even asked a colleague jokingly
If Sidney was going to mention the
International crime conspiracy
To steal the election featuring
Jero, Chavez, Antifa, Cuba and China
It's noted in the conversation
That silly as these allegations are
They put Fox in an awkward place
Where we're going to need to thread the needle
You're actually not in an awkward place
You don't have to be
It's okay
You don't have to do this
Yeah, nobody's making you do this
You can help, you can make things better
On November 20th
Dominion sins Fox's general council
A cease and desist
The state has fretted over how reckless it was
To keep giving Powell air
But she continued to guest regularly
On Fox prime time shows
Including Dobbs and Hannity that same day
This continued into December
On December 2nd, Bill Salmon
Fox's DC editor messaged a colleague
It's remarkable how weak ratings
Make good journalists do bad things
It's good stuff
I quibble with that
Some of the bad journalists at Fox
Were expressing a fear of where the recklessness might lead
Suzanne Scott said
Privately, I had a number of conversations with Sean
Where he wanted the president to accept the results
And Hannity had understood that Joe Biden
Legitimately won the election for
Some time
He admits this in his deposition too
On November 19th, after the Giuliani-Powell press conference
Carlson very carefully
Tried to thread his own needle
On one hand, he said publicly on his show that
What Powell was describing would amount to
The single greatest crime in American history
But she never set us any evidence
Despite a lot of requests
On the other, however, he did not say
What he believed privately, that she was lying
Instead, he closed by saying
Maybe Sidney Powell will come forward soon
With details on exactly how this happened
And precisely who did it
We are certainly hopeful that she will
And this is the
Most minimal pushback you can get on this
Still too much for Fox viewers
The motion citing internal Fox communications
Notes that there was a massive
Viewer backlash to Carlson on this
Which caused him to mobilize
With Raj Shah from the brand team
Shah messaged a number of executives
Including Lackland Murdoch and Suzanne Scott
About this, but we don't know precisely
What was said because the next full page
Or so is redacted
Again
Super curious as to what was said there
When the black bars end, we come to this
Shah also texted with producer Alex Pfeiffer
On November 22nd, Shah wrote
Shit is so crazy right now
So many people openly denying the obvious
That Powell was clearly full of it
Pfeiffer, she is a fucking nutcase
Now, November 22nd
Is the day that Trump finally disavows Powell
Noting that she did not represent his campaign
This appears to have been on the behest
Of Tucker Carlson, who messaged Ingram
That day that dealing with Powell
Totally wrecked, he spells it
R-E-C-K-E-D
My weekend
This is Tucker
Wow, I had to try to make the White House disavow her
Which they obviously should have done long before
Ingram responds
No serious lawyer could believe what they were saying
Carlson replies
But they said nothing in public
Pretty disgusting
Oh, it's disgusting that they didn't say it
In public
Oh
It's also interesting because the White House
Does disavow Powell after this
Carlson, that's just kind of evidence
Of the whole that he does have
January 6th
Came as a surprise
To everyone involved at Fox
At least based on what the Discovery
Documents suggest
It seems to have done something to set up
A sense of stakes for guys like Carlson
But he was still too afraid of losing
His audience to reverse course
Late on January 6th, Carlson texted
With Pfeiffer that Trump is, quote,
A demonic force, a destroyer
But he's not going to destroy us
On January 6th, Carlson invited his leading
Sponsor, Mike Lindell, on the show
Where Lindell spouted these same conspiracies
On air after previewing them for Carlson's staff
During a pre-interview
And again, this dichotomy
Between the almost panicked awareness
Of how much trouble they're getting into
By defaming Dominion and inciting
An insurrection
It exists on every level of decision-making
At Fox, and the last quote I'm going to read
You from this motion is this
On January 5th, Rupert Murdoch told
It's been suggested our primetime three
Should independently or together say something like
The election is over and Joe Biden won
And that such a statement would go a long way
To stop the Trump myth that the election is stolen
Scott forwarded the email to Cooper
Stating, I told Rupert privately
That they are all there. We need to be careful
About how using the shows and pissing off the viewers
But they know how to navigate
They did not know how to navigate
And in fact refused to
But it's interesting that
They were aware
As this suggests that Murdoch is aware
We do have some sort of duty
To use our reach to try and quash this
Might be seen as like
Evidence of
Guilt
Yeah, I mean
They're not unaware
Yeah
It's interesting what lines they
But again, you're saying like they didn't do it
Yeah, they didn't do it
The line is like
Considering doing something
Yeah, I guess
Anyway, that's where we are folks
That was
A real treat
It was a treat, wasn't it?
I'm so honored you invited us
I loved it
I felt good about it. Do you feel good?
I feel great about it
I don't feel great about it
It's gonna change a lot of people's minds
That's the thing, right?
That's what pisses me off most about it
It's like, oh, here it is
People who run and are the main
Faces on Fox
That they are liars and they are lying to their audience
And they are
Doing it out of a pure cowardly
Venal desire for money and fame
And care nothing about
The degree to which they mislead people
Really, and it will never matter
Because facts, it's impossible
To convince anyone with facts
You put this in front of a person who watch
The tiny little morsel
Well, Tucker, here he is
Saying that he needs evidence for it
So he did push back
That's the game that they
Try to play
And sometimes exceed that
You can see people running cover for them already
Of like, well, no, he did
He said it
Without acknowledging
Anything else
It's this thing where
I shouldn't say
It doesn't matter at all
I just had this very shocking
Midterm upset where
Maybe
We're coming to ahead
Of how much they can get away with
I guess we'll know after 2024
But
I do know that
The people in my own life
Who have been listening to
Watching Fox religiously for years
This won't stop them
This will not have any impact
And they're not dumb people
Or are they bad people
They have gotten
Bored into their reality tunnel
Like
Digging into this, acknowledging the degree to which
They've just been manipulated
For their viewership
Would be, I think, psychically painful
So why? Why would you do it?
It's hard to accept every... We see it all the time
People that still are on the queue train
You know, like having a hard time accepting
The facts
But also
I would imagine that there's a lot of people
Who straight up
Don't even know this story
Like Fox News viewers
That won't get this information
Because it's not like this is going to be a
Breaking news segment on Fox News
You know
Yeah
I want to read more of their texts
I know, maybe their redacted parts
Yeah, I would like some of that too
There's a lot of very enticing pieces
But what's more enticing
Is y'all's plugables
Oh, that's very true
You start, Cody
Check us out on youtube.com
Slash the search bar
And type in some more news
For our video channel
We do videos and stuff
It's a podcast too, if you like podcasts
Speaking of podcasts, we also have another podcast
In that same podcast feed
Called Even More News
You go to that feed, you'll see both of them in there
The audio of the youtube show
Another one will be us chatting
With each other
And people about the news
Also, we have a patreon
Dot com
Some more news
God, you guys
Really are a well-oiled gazelle
Yeah, we are, we get that a lot
We get the oil from Rudy's skull
That's
Where we need to invade next
Is Rudy Giuliani's forehead
Yeah
Send the 10th mountain division in there
Get it out
Get it all that fuel
It really, really helps out right now
But this has been fun though
Somebody needs to cut
Like, I don't know, use an AI or something
To cut him into X files
Whenever there's one of the aliens that have the black oil
Coming out of there
Somebody make Rudy
Into an alien super soldier
On like season 6 of the X files
I feel like someone will
Yeah, yeah, I could always
Thank you in advance
Finally, we'll all get to live our dream
Of seeing Rudy's star opposite
David Duchovny
Behind the Bastards is a production of Cool Zone Media
The Manowal Caves
I say the Lord works in mysterious ways
A brand new immersive fiction podcast
Well, he ain't got nothing on the devil
Starring Westworld's Jonathan Tucker
And Eddie Gethegge from Twilight
Every minute I remain in Manowal County
The thick of the fog gets
Tune in to uncover what happened when three boys
Entered a Tennessee cave
But only one returned
This is the exact spot where we found the bodies Julian
The Manowal Caves
MANTAWAUK
Listen to The Manowal Caves now
On the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts
Or wherever you listen to podcasts
What's up y'all
This is Questlove and you know
At QLS I get to hang out with my friends
Sugar Steve, Laia, Vontigolo
Umpink Bill
And we, you know, at QLS
Like to nerd out and do deep dives
With musicians and actors
And politicians and creatives
People that we feel really deserve that attention
We learn, we laugh, we fall down
With rabbit holes
Listen to QLS
On the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts
Or wherever you get your podcasts
What would you do
If the secret cabal of the most powerful folks
In the United States told you, hey
Let's start a coup
Back in the 1930s, a marine named
Smedley Butler was all that stood between
The U.S. and fascism
I'm Ben Bolland, I'm Alex French
And I'm Smedley Butler
Join us for this sordid tale of ambition
Treason and what happens when evil
Tycoons have too much time on their hands
Listen to Let's Start a Coup
On the I Heart Radio app, Apple Podcasts
Or wherever you find your favorite shows