Behind the Bastards - Part Two: John Ronald Brown: The Worst Surgeon Ever
Episode Date: January 16, 2020In Part Two, Robert is joined again by Sofiya Alexandra to continue discussing John Ronald Brown. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener ...for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Alphabet Boys is a new podcast series that goes inside undercover investigations.
In the first season, we're diving into an FBI investigation of the 2020 protests.
It involves a cigar-smoking mystery man who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse look like a lot of guns.
But are federal agents catching bad guys or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date, the time, and then for sure he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio App, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Did you know Lance Bass is a Russian-trained astronaut?
That he went through training in a secret facility outside Moscow,
hoping to become the youngest person to go to space?
Well, I ought to know, because I'm Lance Bass.
And I'm hosting a new podcast that tells my crazy story and an even crazier story
about a Russian astronaut who found himself stuck in space.
With no country to bring him down.
With the Soviet Union collapsing around him,
he orbited the Earth for 313 days that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet on the iHeart Radio App, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Episode start begin now, Robert Evans, behind the bastards podcast.
Part two, John Ronald Brown, Sophia Alexandra, guest, Private Parts Unknown, Introduction Bad.
How are you doing, Sophia?
Good. Just you didn't mention my other podcast, 420 Day Fiancé.
420 Day Fiancé.
On this network with Miles Gray.
It's really fun.
I forgot to include 40% of the actual words necessary to make that salad not gibberish,
so of course I forgot your second podcast too.
That's fine.
That was a disaster.
A disaster.
I think you will keep having a disaster until you commit to going back to the old ways.
That's my wise.
I have committed to getting fired and then becoming a corrupt small time cop.
I think that's the path I want to go with.
Did you watch Jaws recently?
There's a scene in the second Jaws movie.
No, I have not seen it.
Oh man, it's great.
There's a scene in the second Jaws movie where Sheriff Brody gets out of his police car
and is preceded by 40 or 50 beer cans tumbling out onto the ground around him.
That's a pretty classic joke.
I saw that and I was like, that's exactly what I want to do for a living.
Just rolling around in a police car, drunk as shit with a gun,
no accountability on some beach town in the middle of nowhere.
I'm glad that you're going to be a corrupt small town cop
because as we discussed in the previous episode,
I will be performing unauthorized surgeries
and at that point, I'm going to need a friend in the police department
and you will be that friend.
Yeah, this is the plan.
Hey, would you like to be the non-doctor conman veterinarians
Dr. Spence to my doctor?
Ronald.
I feel like I can round.
No, not you, Robert.
She was Sophie.
You're the cop. You already have a role to play.
Would you, Sophie?
I'll partner with you on anything, my friend.
Perfect. We got a clinic going.
Robert, keep us out of the papers.
Well, that's good.
Sophie, it's complicated.
I feel like I want to know more about Spence
because this is not just a simple man pretending to be a doctor.
This is a man pretending to be a veterinarian who pretends to be a doctor
and that's like a whole different layer of scaminess.
Oh, it's hilarious that he needed to first fool himself to step one.
He's like, no, pretending to be a doctor.
He's like, I can't do that. That's too much lying.
First, I'm going to pretend to be a vet
and out of there pretending to be a doctor.
That's not that far. I can do that.
Yeah, it's amazing. It's really amazing.
Can we pull up a picture of him too?
I didn't even look up his picture.
Because I'd like to know what the faces of that firm were.
Not for the doctor's clinic.
But he died in a ditch.
That is my assumption that he died in a ditch
overdosing on something horrible.
Well, if the world is in any way just in which it's not,
he would have died in a ditch.
So, let's start part two.
Now, as I mentioned in the first episode,
John Ronald Brown didn't only have sad stories in terms of his patients.
He had some happy customers.
One of them was Patrice Baxter.
She was a long-time client and she calls him
one of the best surgeons in the United States.
Even though by the time she met him,
he was no longer legally allowed to practice surgery
in the United States.
Still, Dr. Brown illegally gave Patrice a tummy tuck,
a facelift, and breast implants.
She was so happy with the results that she had him
cut into her granddaughter's ears.
Quote, they stuck out.
The kids on her track team called her Dumbo.
Why don't you just fly? He did her nose too.
Patrice claims the surgery went well enough
that her granddaughter went on to work as a model.
So, she clearly admired the man.
But even Dr. Brown's number one fan acknowledged
that he had some faults.
She's also not a good person
if she's getting the ears of her fucking granddaughter cut.
We haven't even gotten into what a bad person she is.
Okay, great. Well, I sense that right away.
She said he was brilliant, but he had no common sense.
He would walk through plate glass doors.
He couldn't balance his checkbook.
I've walked through a screen door before.
That is embarrassing and shameful.
Now, Patrice...
So, he's just quietly whispering me too,
and it's very cute.
That's...
Tusk, tusk.
Tusk, tusk, who says that? No one.
She acknowledged that his bedside manner
was not exactly great.
Sometimes, he would grab a magazine,
mid-conversation, and start reading.
He would hold frequently, and he never held his patients' hands.
Still, Patrice insists he was more of a hero than a villain.
He only charged $2,500 for a sex change,
and half the time, they didn't even pay.
Now, before you take Pat Baxter's commentary too seriously,
you should know that she wasn't just a satisfied customer.
She was also a surgical entrepreneur,
which is one of the most terrifying phrases I've ever heard.
Oh, wow.
He lived in San Diego and ran a shady-ass clinic in Mexico.
She and John Brown became business partners
and worked together for years.
She urged John to expand his repertoire
beyond basic plastic surgery and gender reassignment.
There was, she told him, a vast, untapped market
in men who wanted bigger dicks.
So... Oh, man.
I'm kind of excited about where this is going.
Oh, yeah, yeah, I know. This is going in a fun direction.
And it's one of those things we've just been talking about
the most vulnerable people in the world
getting screwed over by this guy.
And I was just due to want bigger dicks.
There's really no victims in this story.
Yeah, I feel less bad about this.
I'm just kidding.
I'm just kidding.
Yeah, okay, yeah.
So Dr. Brown got into the penis extension business.
In 1986, Penthouse Forums sent a writer to Tijuana
to investigate Brown's practice.
Now, the good, not a doctor
had started claiming in advertisements
that he could add one to two inches to a dick
by cutting the suspensor ligament
that held the penis root to the pubic bone,
which I wrote as public bone,
but I found funny.
The article titled The Incredible Dick Doctor
portrayed Dr. Brown
actively as a horrible driver
who frequently backed into other cars.
He pointed out that his pants fell down
once in the OR.
At one point.
Oh, my God.
That's like a cartoon.
That's so tight.
Imagine right before a doctor
starts cutting into you, his pants fall down.
You're like, okay,
I have to cancel the surgery.
Yeah, I know.
If you step on a banana peel next,
I am fucking telling everyone.
An anvil just falls on his head.
That's ridiculous, dude.
Yeah.
At one point in the article,
he accidentally cut a patient's penile shaft
sending blood spurting all over the room.
His quoted response to this fuck up was,
I made a boo boo.
Oh, I was going to guess it was oops,
but this is worse.
Yeah, that's definitely worse than oops.
So someone from Inside Edition
must have been reading Penthouse for the articles
because three years later,
they sent a team to investigate Dr. Brown.
The resulting documentary, The Worst Doctor in America,
was filmed with Brown's oblivious consent.
At one point, it showed him
performing scalp surgery on a trans woman
who was supposed to be sedated.
But the sedation didn't take,
and the patient screamed and cried while the team recorded.
Brown called this nothing unusual.
There's a special segment of one
interview that I think is worth me reading in full.
Inside Edition.
This is them narrating.
But to Brown, failure is no reason to proceed
with caution, and he continues to experiment
on humans whenever he develops a new procedure.
And this is Brown talking.
Back in the developmental stage,
I remember several times asking myself,
is it really right for me to be doing what amounts
to experiments on some of these people?
After thinking it all through, these people knew what I was doing.
They knew it wasn't a proven experiment.
They were all willing.
She was like, I thought about whether
I have any more responsibility,
and I decided no. No, I don't.
Am I a soulless ghoul? Nah.
So, Cherie,
the young woman whose
sister got a sex change with Dr. Brown
definitely considered him to be a dangerous
kook, but acknowledged he gives you
a vagina at a fair price.
Competent doctors charged $12,000
to $20,000 for a vagina at the time.
Brown's fees were reasonable enough
that hundreds of women chose to gamble on him.
In spite of the fact that his new nickname,
Butcher Brown, was by far the worst yet.
Not as good as Tabletop Brown.
Not as good as Tabletop Brown.
Now, during my research,
I came across a tremendous resource
called the Digital Transgender Archive.
This wonderful site includes pictures, articles,
and scans of entire issues of
various zines and newsletters distributed
by the trans community going back
like decades.
And I came across one from 1989
called 20 Minutes.
And a few pages in it featured a cartoon
drawn by someone named Aradia.
And Sophie, you want to show her
the political cartoon of Dr. Brown?
Yeah.
It's a little small, so hold on.
Creep on it.
Yeah, that checks out.
Yeah, it's him.
That's pretty much just a portrait.
Yeah, he's dressed as like Jason
from the Friday the 13th movies
with a hockey mask covered in blood
and a chainsaw above a patient on a...
And it says he's back.
Yeah.
Now, that cartoon was followed by
a furious article about Dr. Brown
titled Mac the Knife.
And I'm going to quote from it now.
A patient, no more like a victim
of the nefarious Dr. Brown presented herself
with the aid of a companion at the emergency room
of San Francisco General Hospital today,
November 4th, 1984 for life-saving medical assistance.
Just a week earlier in Mexico,
she had the misfortune to fall
into the not-so-tender clutches of Dr. Brown.
By the time she arrived at SF General,
she'd lost more than four pints of blood
and was well down the road to being another
not-so-fortunate statistic of the infamous meat cutter.
From information available,
she is but one of 10 recent victims of Brown's.
For those of you contemplating surgery,
don't go to Mexico for it,
and above all, don't let Dr. Brown do it.
Admittedly, his price of $3,000 is attractive,
but the pain, anguish, and post-surgical complications
are not worth the trivial amount of money saved.
So, 20 minutes had written warnings
about Dr. Brown before,
and he'd actually had someone from his office respond to them.
Since his potential clients read this magazine,
and since he knew no one from the AMA
or law enforcement was reading trans community newsletters,
he felt secure in just lying
shamefully to these people to try to convince more of them
to let him commit surgery on their groins.
And here's his
representative's response.
Many of you have heard about Dr. John Ronald Brown MD,
some of it positive, some negative.
This letter is intended to set the record straight
and to inform those interested in his work.
It goes under account
Dr. Brown's educational history,
all the different hospitals he worked at,
notably leaving out his repeated failures
to actually pass his surgical exams.
Then it gives this justification for the fact
that his clinic had to be in Mexico
rather than the United States.
Due to the temporary revocation of his license
to practice in California,
his clinic has been moved to Plyas, Mexico.
This statement of his California license
but states that even when he is eventually vindicated,
his practice will probably remain
in Mexico for various reasons,
especially the reduced problems of doing transsexual surgery.
The reduced problems
meaning like the reduced laws
governing what you can do
to people you're performing surgery on.
Now, in that letter,
Dr. Brown's representative also brags about
a revolutionary new technique he developed,
taking bowel tissue to make the new vaginal canal
for his patients, thus ensuring them
a lubricating vagina.
20 Minutes notes that, as a result of his failure
to actually do this competently,
more than 70 of his patients
had received permanent colostomies.
And I found a quote from MITRE D'Alessedini on all this.
In the 1990s, Brown came to favor
invasive surgery in which he would graft
the neovagina to a section of resected colon.
His results had never been good.
The groin area of a Brown patient
typically looked as if the penis had been
split lengthwise and sutured to the groin
with a simple hole between the split halves.
The patient would then go up with colostomies.
Several of Brown's girls danced topless,
using scarves to conceal the bags attached to their sides.
When he started going into the peritoneum,
things got really scary.
Patients would return home smelling of rotting flesh.
Often they would return to Brown,
going again and again for revision,
each time paying large sums of money.
Many eventually wound up in emergency rooms,
and I dare say some ended up dead.
Now, it's hard to imagine just how fucking horrifying
receiving surgery under these conditions would have been.
And there are very few first person accounts
of Dr. Brown's victims, and none that go into
a tremendous amount of detail.
I did find the experiences of one trans woman,
Canary Kahn, who received her gender
recidement surgery in Tijuana.
And she went with a better doctor than Dr. Brown,
one of the better doctors in the area.
So as I read this story, I want you to remember
that what Brown's patients would have woken up with
was actually worse than this.
So this is like a better case scenario
than Dr. Brown, and it's still
pretty fucking horrifying.
Somebody, please, please come here.
I tried and reached for the button, keeping it in my hand.
A peculiar wet feeling was gathering around my legs.
At first, I was too frightened to peer under the sheets,
but as the chill increased, I reached
for the chain over my head.
With the light on, I lifted the sheets, then I panicked.
The sheet under me was a pool of blood,
and more was flowing from between my legs.
I pressed the button again and again,
and began to scream for help.
Thinking about detaching myself from the bed,
I propped myself on one arm, but then fainted and fell back.
When I woke up, some 10 or 15 minutes later,
the blood had made its way down one side of the bed
I was weaker now, and the pain didn't matter.
I was bleeding to death.
Sobbing, I began to pray aloud.
Then I screamed again and again until my voice faded into hoarseness.
Grabbing a book from the table, I tried to throw it through the window,
but it fell from my fingers into the pool of blood.
The chills had changed to small convulsions
as I tried to calm myself.
Bending my head, I looked once more at the side of the bed,
half covered with my life's liquid.
It looked pretty somehow, red on white.
I couldn't help thinking how ironic it was
that I had worked and saved all this time to pay for my own death.
I would be my own executioner.
Again, this is someone waking up in a clinic.
So this is someone getting surgery
from one of these doctors
who actually does provide aftercare.
Dr. Brown's patients
typically woke up in hotels or cars
undergoing the same thing.
Not attached to a bed,
not in, like obviously Canary
eventually did get medical help.
It just took a while for I think the clinic
to realize what was going on.
But what a nightmare, you're bleeding to death
and you know it and you paid for your surgery
and it's just like, so brutal.
Yeah, yeah.
And in the case of Dr. Brown's patients,
this is happening in like the back of a Ford Fiesta.
It's hard to imagine.
So,
despite the fact that he'd moved his practice
to Mexico, presumably because he couldn't legally
perform surgery in the US,
Dr. Brown still repeatedly performed surgeries
in the United States throughout the 1980s.
In 1984,
he was arrested for giving a presentation
where he offered penile lengthening surgery
to a group of men in San Diego.
He only received a slap on the wrist for this
and continued traveling around California
to perform minor surgery.
Cherry recalled,
he'd shoot silicone anywhere you wanted it.
For $200, he'd do breast surgery.
For $500, he'd do cheeks, breasts and hips.
After injections, you had to lie flat on your back
for three days so the silicone wouldn't go anywhere.
He plugged the holes with crazy glue.
He's a big fan of crazy glue.
Yeah, I was saying these are like the people
that have been busted for doing this stuff.
Who don't know.
In Los Angeles County,
one patient filed a complaint against Dr. Brown
for a breast enlargement procedure he had performed on her.
It turns out that,
rather than performing any kind of surgery,
he just shoved a needle into her breasts
and injected them with raw silicone.
He then closed the holes with crazy glue.
Another patient, a genetic female named Mona,
complained that after Dr. Brown gave her a facelift,
face peel, eye job and breast implants,
he did not do a good job.
During the facelift,
a nerve in her face leaving her with a permanent crooked smile.
Her implants failed,
which caused the breasts to rot and leak a fluid
her boyfriend described as smelling like cat piss.
Then they fell off.
To his credit,
Dr. Brown performed some aftercare for Mona.
She recalled that at one point
he showed up to inject her with painkillers,
wearing only one shoe.
Oh my God.
Wow, what a good sign to not let someone doctor
on you when they're wearing just one shoe.
Yeah.
You're going to inject someone with medicine
and you couldn't get your shoe game
on point for the day.
Let's just go ahead and extend it to the whole outfit.
If you're missing anything from the outfit,
you're on a time out
for doctoring for the moment.
It's like a guy trying to shoot you up
with insulin while wearing board shorts.
Like, no, no.
I'm going to go ahead and pass.
Now, despite all this horror,
it was the Inside Edition episode
that finally drew some serious legal attention
to John Ronald Brown.
The FBI went after him, confiscated his money,
shut down his clinic,
and charged him with practicing medicine without a license.
He had previously been convicted
for prescribing narcotics with revoked license
and practicing under a false name.
With all of that on his record,
you might expect him to serve some serious time.
That seems like a significant crime, right?
Mm-hmm.
He was sentenced to three years in prison
and served 19 months.
Oh my God.
18 months.
So, for a brief period of time,
about a year, he worked as a cab driver
on Coronado Island,
which is possibly the only job he ever did
that he might have been qualified for.
No, he wasn't. Remember, they said that he got
constantly re-arrended people
and got into car accidents.
He actually went into the only other profession
he could kill people.
Like, that's not okay.
That's not okay.
You are absolutely right.
He picked the one other job that he was
dangerously bad at.
We have gotten him
to be like a Walmart greeter.
That's the job for this guy.
You know?
Yeah.
I feel like as a Walmart greeter,
he would have gotten people killed.
Just directing them to the wrong aisles?
Yeah.
Just throwing peanuts at kids with allergies.
So, Paul Sciotti interviewed John
about this period in his life,
and Dr. Brown insisted that the time in jail
didn't deter him from his chosen calling in the least.
He said that he decided long ago
to rebel against what he saw
as the unjust medical establishment.
I didn't like some of the things
that organized doctors were doing, so I rebelled.
Later, I didn't like what the government
was doing in support of the medical organizations,
so I rebelled.
I chose to ignore the laws.
He's a hero.
He's a hero, Sophia.
After a year,
John was able to put together enough money
to reopen his surgical practice in Tijuana.
For a couple of years,
he continued chopping into whoever would pay
primarily servicing the trans community
if you can call what he did a service.
By 1996, he had carried out an estimated
600 gender reassignment surgeries.
That is the year
he met Greg Firth.
Now, Greg was a
psychoanalyst.
It's never good when you meet a Greg.
You meet Greg with two Gs,
three, actually.
This is even worse than the regular Greg.
There are five letters
in Greg's first name and three of them are G.
It's a disaster.
This is going to not end well.
It does not.
Now, Greg was a psychoanalyst from New York City.
In addition to being a well-respected
mental health expert, Firth also suffered
from a rare condition known as epitymnophilia.
Have you ever heard of epitymnophilia?
No.
The person who coined that term
in 1977, John Mone,
described it as an extreme sexual fetish
wherein victims desire to sever
their own limbs so they can have better orgasms.
What?
Yeah.
Why do the limbs get in the way of a good orgasm?
That's a great question.
We're going to talk about epitymnophilia
a little bit more in a minute.
But you know what won't sever your limbs
to give you better orgasms, Sophia?
The following goods and services?
That's exactly right.
That is the guarantee we make,
is that none of these products will sever your limbs
in the pursuit of an orgasm.
During the summer of 2020,
some Americans suspected that the FBI
had secretly infiltrated
the racial justice demonstrations.
And you know what?
They were right.
I'm Trevor Aronson,
and I'm hosting a new podcast series,
Alphabet Boys.
Sometimes you got to grab the little guy
to go after the big guy.
Each season will take you
inside an undercover investigation.
In the first season of Alphabet Boys,
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver.
At the center of this story
is a raspy-voiced,
cigar-smoking man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse was like a lot of goods.
He's a shark.
And on the good-bad-ass way.
And nasty sharks.
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and then for sure
he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you
that much of the forensic science
you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual science?
The problem
with forensic science
in the criminal legal system today
is that it's an awful lot of forensic
and not an awful lot of science.
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest, I was incarcerated
two days after her first birthday.
I'm Molly Herman.
Join me as we put
forensic science on trial
to discover what happens
when a match isn't a match
and when there's no science
in CSI.
Many people have to be wrongly convicted
before they realize
that this stuff's all bogus.
It's all made up.
Listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Lance Bass,
and you may know me from a little band
called NSYNC.
What you may not know is that when I was 23
I traveled to Moscow
to train to become the youngest person
to go to space.
And when I was there,
as you can imagine,
I heard some pretty wild stories.
But there was this one
that really stuck with me
about a Soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down.
It's 1991
and that man Sergei Krekalev
is floating in orbit
when he gets a message that down on Earth
his beloved country,
is falling apart.
And now he's left defending
the Union's last outpost.
This is the crazy story
of the 313 days
he spent in space.
313 days that changed
the world.
Listen to the last Soviet on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
We're back!
We're talking about how there should be a legal limit
on the number of Gs allowed in a name.
And I'm going to put it,
I'm going to say zero.
All right.
All the Greggs are just rays now.
Sorry to the 30% of our audience
with Gs.
That's what I'm saying, they're just rays now.
Yeah, exactly.
There's a good name.
Yeah, just Reh.
Deal with it.
Okay, what are they saying?
For me, sexuality is being comfortable with my body.
Inside, I feel my legs don't belong to me
and they shouldn't be there.
There's just an overwhelming sense of despair sometimes.
I don't want to die, but there are times
I don't want to keep living in a body
that doesn't feel like mine.
Now, Firth seems to agree with this more or less,
insisting in interviews.
It's not about sex, it's not about getting off with someone.
This is about becoming able-bodied.
So these,
the people suffering this will claim that like,
it's not, I don't want to get it removed
because it's hot to lose a limb.
I feel like this isn't my body part
and I can't be comfortable in my own body
while I have this armor leg
because it's like an alien limb.
But they're not capable of realizing that
that's like a disorder or are they?
I think they are, but I think a lot of them
would say that the treatment for the disorder
is to have the fucking leg removed
or whatever.
I'm not going to come down on this one way or the other,
this is just what they will say.
Yeah, I think I've heard of this before,
but I'm like...
And there are some people who definitely,
there are amputation fetishists and stuff too,
so it's complicated.
I think some people will argue
that folks like Greg just have an amputation fetish.
And I think some sufferers
of epitaminophilia will say,
it's not a fetish,
it's like a body dysmorphia sort of thing.
This is not my limb and I need it removed.
And there are people who will be like,
you're just saying that so you can try to get surgery
because you think it's hot.
I don't know, I'm not a fucking expert on any of this.
Well, I mean, it doesn't really matter though,
but it makes me think of anorexia or something.
It's like you're looking in the mirror
and you see something that it's not right.
So you're like, no, I have to keep getting thinner.
I'm not thin, it doesn't look right.
I'm not going to feel happy until I'm this thin.
But it's ultimately something that
you recover from if you work on it,
but I guess not.
I don't know if it doesn't work like that for this.
I have no idea.
I'll tell a little bit more
and we'll see how we feel.
Definitely, Greg actually does seem to
have a bit of a recovery.
But yeah, we're building to that.
So for years,
Greg Firth had sought to have his legs surgically amputated.
And there are some reputable surgeons
who will do this for people with apatymnophilia.
Unfortunately, the one Firth tried to contract
had to back out of doing the surgery
after the public hospital he worked at
rescinded his privileges due to bad publicity.
There were actually protests in Scotland
against voluntary amputees
being legal at all.
And when this all blew up in the news,
Firth's doctor, the guy he tried to go with,
complained that banning safe voluntary amputations
in hospitals would only make the problem
worse for his patients.
Quote,
They may lie on a railway line
and get run over by a train.
They may use shotguns and shoot their limbs off.
They really are quite a desperate bunch.
And
the doctor's kind of proven right
in some of this.
That like,
when someone has this kind of
and it's tough because a lot of doctors will say,
it's immoral
fundamentally to do this because your job
isn't to remove
healthy tissue.
I think other doctors might claim
that these people clearly aren't healthy
so you are helping them by doing this.
It's a very complicated realm of medical ethics.
Or at least it seems complicated to me.
Let us know if you're a doctor
if you would remove someone's leg voluntarily.
Hit us up.
Now,
once his plans to remove his leg
legitimately with a real doctor
and a real hospital fell through,
Greg Firth started searching around for other places
where he might have his alien leg removed.
In 1996,
he read a story about an underground surgeon
based out of San Diego.
Despite the man's nickname,
Butcher Brown,
He's like, that sounds good to me.
That's what I'm looking for.
A good person to reach out to.
And Dr. Brown was, of course, only too happy to help.
Stacey Running, the DA who
prosecuted Brown for what later happened, said,
He saw it as all the same.
You cut off a boob, you cut off a penis, you cut off a leg.
Sounds like a quality doctor.
No difference between any
of those things.
Now Firth negotiated with Dr. Brown
and eventually they managed to settle on a price.
In 1997, he flew down to Mexico
to finally lose his alien leg.
But when he showed up at Brown's makeshift OR,
the Mexican doctor Brown had hired
to assist him realize that he was
about to help sever a healthy leg.
Firth recalled, he kept saying,
This isn't right, you don't want this.
Eventually the Mexican doctor left
the building and Brown was forced to cancel
the surgery since it turns out
amputating is a little bit of a two-man job.
So Brown agrees, Firth flies
down there and Brown gets an actual
doctor in Mexico to help
and that guy is like, he tricks him basically.
And once he realizes what's happening,
he's like, I'm not going to do this.
This is fucked up.
So good on that doctor.
A year later in 1998,
John Brown called Firth with what he
called good news and bad news.
The good news was he had
the good news was he'd found
another doctor. The bad news was
it would now cost $10,000.
By this point, Firth was less convinced
that he even wanted to commit to the surgery.
But he decided to give it a shot.
His good friend and fellow alien leg sufferer,
Phillip Bondy, scolded him for
considering bailing on the opportunity, telling him
you'll regret this the rest of your life.
How ironic because you can't
undo amputating your leg, but
you can always undo having your leg.
These people are not
super rationally thinking
about this problem. I don't
feel. Not to
appatimnophilia shame them, but
I don't think you should do this.
And I think given what happens next, I'm right.
So Firth traveled
to San Diego and took a taxi to the clinic
in Tijuana. By the time he arrived,
he concluded that his compulsion to have his
leg removed was gone.
He told Brown absolutely not.
And this would kind of tend
to suggest that like, actually, yeah, you shouldn't
have your legs removed if this is the kind of thing that's
seeing how horrible the OR can like
remove you of your compulsion.
Anyway, here's how LA Weekly
sums up what happened next. Thinking
perhaps that Firth was merely nervous, Brown offered
him a sedative. But Firth testified
he didn't want to be sedated. He wanted out of there.
Before leaving, however, he suggested that
what he thought would be a win-win solution for
everyone. Even though he no longer wanted the operation
himself, he knew someone else who did.
Maybe we could switch it around, said Firth.
Philip could take my place.
And it turned out that Philip Bundy's
appatimnophilia was much stronger
than Firth's. He flew right to Mexico.
And on May 9th, 1998,
Dr. John Brown severed his leg.
Normally, surgery like this
would be an inpatient procedure.
You would not want to...
But if you know John
Ronald Brown, you know he doesn't do
inpatient procedures. No.
Instead, he drove
the freshly amputated Philip
Bundy 15 miles into the desert
where Dr. Brown tossed his leg
out of the car to be eaten by coyotes.
Oh my god!
Why was that his first
idea?
How is coyotes the first
idea you have for getting rid
of a leg?
That's not even my number 5!
That's not even my number 5!
That is crazy!
Nurse Coyotes
will be assisting in the procedure.
Oh my god, dude!
That is crazy.
They're medical coyotes.
Oh my god.
Those are probably the only people
that worked in this clinic that actually
were there.
I'm not trying to work off their surgeries.
You know what?
The coyotes did their job properly.
They were the most common...
The only ones there who did, yeah.
Competent people, yeah.
Now, after throwing
his patient's leg out of a car window,
John Brown
drove his patient into California
to a Holiday Inn, gave him
a 10 minute lesson in walking with crutches
and drove off into the sunset to count his money.
Oh my god.
Oh god, it's a nightmare.
Two days later, Greg Firth went to check
up on his friend in the Holiday Inn
and found him dead. An autopsy revealed
that gas gangrene from an improperly
sterilized leg stump had been the culprit.
Philip's death would have been an
agonizing, almost unimaginably
painful affair.
This was the case that finally
made the law treat Dr. John Brown
as the minister to society that he so clearly was.
It's telling that he had to finally
kill a straight man before this happened.
And I'm not just saying that to score
woke points. After the police started
digging into Dr. Brown,
the detective in charge of the case made
a point of looking into some of Brown's other patients.
And I'm going to quote Paul Cioti with the
LA Weekly again.
When DA investigator Basinski, a tall
outgoing former cop with a shaved head
and a big gray mustache began calling on
the people on Brown's patient lists,
a lot of them just hung up on him. Some were
hookers, he said. Some thought they were in trouble. Some just didn't like the police.
I called one woman and an older woman answered.
Why do you want my son? She said.
He committed suicide two weeks ago.
As Basinski later learned,
Christina, formerly known as Eddie, had
mortgaged her house to pay for a total of
10 surgeries by Brown. But according to legal
documents filed by Running, the skin grafts
that Brown used to line Christina's vaginal walls
were so thin that they tore during intercourse.
When Brown removed Christina's lower ribs
to give her a narrower and more feminine
waist, she subsequently developed an abscess
as big as a basketball. Christina's nose
job turned out so poorly that she ended up with
different sized nostrils, one of which turned
up like that of a pig. Christina complained
to Brown that he'd made her vaginal entrance too small
but when Brown enlarged it, Christina felt
he'd ruined her. Today, Brown says he feels
badly that he didn't better explain the
procedure to Christina, but when he called to tell her
he was refunding $500, her mother told him
that her son had just hanged himself in the garage.
According to Running, Brown took the news
quite calmly, noting merely that transsexuals
had a high suicide rate. And I should
note, I'm reading a quote from an article there,
Seade consistently
correctly genders Christina,
Christina's mother
misgenders. The one that misgenders, yeah.
Those are her quotes on the matter though.
Yeah.
So,
there you go. That's so fucked up.
It's super fucked up. Also
removing the ribs, like, yeah,
that's not okay. Yeah. I mean,
and it's kind of buried a little bit, but the most
fucked up thing there is that when Dr. Brown learns
that one of his patients has killed herself.
He doesn't care. Just like, that's what it is.
He's just like, oh, a lot of my patients killed themselves
actually. It happens constantly.
Yeah.
It's amazingly terrible.
And it goes to
show that like John is usually shown as like
having killed one person, Bundy,
but he killed a lot of people.
Yeah. They just, the law didn't
care about them.
And oftentimes as that story shows, their parents
didn't either.
And also just like the fear of
whoever,
the fear of whoever it is
calling and checking on you means like you're not
really getting the full
information anyway.
Yeah. Yeah. Because like a lot of
these patients were sex workers and they're
not going to talk to a fucking cop. Yeah, exactly.
Even if the cop legitimately cares about
what's being done to them, like, it doesn't
matter.
So, Dr. Brown was arrested and police
searched a San Ysidro apartment.
They found bloody shoes and pillows, used needles,
vials of silicone,
dozens of empty tubes of crazy glue,
bloody towel, soaking in bleach,
and dozens of returned advertising brochures
for his horrible clinic.
One of the brochures, read as follows.
Oh boy, this is going to be unpleasant to read.
The prettiest pussies are John Brown pussies.
The happiest patients are
John Brown patients because
number one, each has a sensitive clit.
Number two, all 99%
get orgasms. Number
three, careful skin draping gives a natural
appearance. Number four,
men love the pretty pussies and the sexy
response.
Yeah. Well, all of that is- Obviously not
true. Yeah. Huge lies.
Yes. Horrible, horrible lies.
Now, also found in Dr. Brown's
apartment were videotapes of the bad doctors
operations. These videos were given
names that reflect the level of professionalism
I think we've all come to expect from John Brown.
Oh god.
I'm trying not to laugh, but it's like
one was titled
Jack has a new piss hole behind his balls.
Again- Okay.
This is how the doctor labeled
his surgery tapes.
Yeah.
While bizarre, that video
was not what hit prosecutors the hardest.
In Brown's stash, they came across
a recorded sex change surgery
which showed Brown using a scalpel so
dull he had to use it like a saw,
jerking it back and forth into the patient's
flesh. Wow.
Uh, yeah.
As the media's chief expert on
tabletop Brown, Paul Sciolo spent a lot of
time talking to the detectives and prosecutors
trying to put Brown away. They showed
him some of these videos, and here's how he describes
one. In the video's opening
shot, which is reminiscent of that famous scene
from the crying game, an attractive Asian girl
and the soon-to-be Las Vegas stripper
is shown standing naked from the waist up,
quietly chatting with Brown who is off camera.
She has nicely formed breasts and
abundant black hair that cascades down her shoulders.
Then slowly the camera moves down her body
and suddenly you realize she has a penis.
When the actual surgery starts, I find
it so unsettling that I have to turn off the tape.
All the men had the same reaction, says
running. The judge asked, do I have to watch this
video? I said, well, yes, you do. You're the judge.
Yeah.
Jesus.
Yeah, I uh,
you know,
part of me is like, I
I kind of like
running here because he's like, yeah,
you have to watch this. You have to know what this guy
did to properly sentence
him. And like, just because it's gross
uh, you don't
get to not look at it. You would look at photos
of a murder and that's what this guy did. So we're
going to watch these fucking videos. Like, I respect
that a lot. Um,
you know what I also respect,
Sophia?
Goods and services?
Yeah, the products and services that support this show.
During the summer of
2020, some Americans
suspected that the FBI had secretly
infiltrated the racial justice demonstrations.
And you know what?
They were right.
I'm Trevor Aronson and I'm hosting
a new podcast series,
Alphabet Boys.
As the FBI, sometimes
you got to grab the little guy
to go after the big guy.
Each season will take you inside
an undercover investigation.
In the first season of Alphabet Boys,
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver.
At the center of this
story is a raspy-voiced
cigar-smoking man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse was like a lot of guns.
He's a shark. And not in the good-bad-ass way.
He's a nasty shark.
He was just waiting for me to set the
date, the time, and then
for sure he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys
on the iHeart Radio App, Apple Podcast
or wherever you get your podcast.
What if I told you
that much of the forensic science
you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual
science?
The problem with forensic science
in the criminal legal system
today is that it's an awful lot of forensic
and not an awful lot of science.
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest, I was
incarcerated two days after her first
birthday.
I'm Molly Herman. Join me
as we put forensic science
on trial to discover what
happens when a match isn't
a match and when there's no
science in CSI.
How many people
have to be wrongly convicted before they
realize that this stuff's
all bogus. It's all
made up.
Listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeartRadio app,
Apple Podcasts or wherever
you get your podcasts.
I'm Lance Bass and you may
know me from a little band called NSYNC.
What you may not know
is that when I was 23, I
traveled to Moscow to train to become
the youngest person to go to space.
And when I was there,
as you can imagine, I
heard some pretty wild stories.
But there was this one
that really stuck with me
about a Soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down.
It's 1991
and that man, Sergei Krekalev
is floating in orbit
when he gets a message that down on Earth
his beloved country,
the Soviet Union, is falling
apart.
And now he's left defending the Union's last
outpost.
This is the crazy story of the
313 days he spent in space.
313 days
that changed the world.
Listen to the last Soviet
on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts
or wherever you get your
podcasts.
We're back.
So,
apparently Brown had
intended that tape and a lot of the other
tapes to be like advertising
and training videos.
The second scene in that
tape we just described shows the doctors
in a chair wearing a white coat and explaining
the upcoming operation to the camera.
He has a microphone and his hand is kind of
shaking, says, running. You see him
reach up and grab his hand and this is his dominant
hand, the one he operates with. He holds up crew
drawings ripped out of a spiral notebook.
He says, this is the corpa, the corpa,
he's stumped on the word. He finally says it.
The capora cavernosa, the spongy tissue
on the underside of the penis. He goes off in this
vein. You can see him waving the cameraman
off when he loses a thought. The tape
was so crude you could hear dogs barking during
the surgery and music playing. The
scrotal skin was lying on a board. It had
pushpins in it. It was so dirty and dried
out it looked like it had been run over by a
tire.
Yeah. The prosecution's
chief witness was a young trans woman named
Camille. She was one of the only victims of
Dr. Brown who was willing to testify in court.
Prior to her surgery, Camille had been an
insurance underwriter. She claims Dr.
Brown botched her surgery so badly that she
was basically unemployable now.
Her surgery went down in November
1997. Quote,
he gave me an epidural. I woke up 10 minutes
prior to the end of the operation. We started
talking. Brown said, we're almost done. I wasn't
scared. I was happy as hell. I was finally
getting what I wanted. When you are climbing
Mount Everest, you don't worry about a little
frostbite on the top. But after the surgery
was complete, Camille started having difficulty
with her recovery. She developed a rectovaginal
fistula, which caused her feces to flow
into her new vagina. This was the result
of Dr. Brown experimenting with his technique
of using bowel tissue to create vaginal
walls. She said, quote, my bladder was
blocked. My lymph glands swelled up and my
skin turned yellow. Black stuff was pouring
out of my lungs. All my systems were shutting
down. All you would have to do is take one breath
and let go.
The fact that Camille survived is almost miraculous
and her testimony helped to finally put
Butcher Brown away for good. He was
convicted by unanimous decision and sentenced
to 15 years in prison.
He expressed no remorse or even
real understanding that he had committed
horrific acts that had permanently disfigured
these cases, ruined the lives of human beings.
Paul Sciolo talked to Brown several times
in prison via collect call. In their last
conversations, Brown expressed that his
entire career was part of God's plan.
He had called upon John Ronald Brown to
help the transgender community.
And next, Brown believed, God had
called upon him to invent a hyperthermia
chamber that would cure cancer,
AIDS and general herpes.
Brown described this as a chamber.
I'm sorry.
He just kind of goes off the deep end.
This is not like the other.
No.
That seems telling. That seems like he had
herpes.
He's like, the other two are for humanity.
Last one's for Papa.
This one's for Dr. Brown.
That's what it sounds like. You don't go
cancer, AIDS, herpes.
In the same race.
For equally serious dreams.
Seriously, dude. That's amazing.
Yeah.
Now, Brown described this as using a chamber
to spray a patient with hot water to cause
a healing fever.
In addition to this, Dr. Brown claimed
to have developed a prototype asphalt removal
machine, an attachment for trailers that
would make them more aerodynamic, and a book
that would provide a full explanation for
the movement of tectonic plates.
He had a lot of book ideas, including an
autobiography about his medical career,
and a book that would prove the existence
of God.
Cragically, John Ronald Brown, yeah,
was taken away from us too soon to finish
the story. In 2010,
just shy of his 88th birthday,
he died painfully of pneumonia in prison.
Oh, well, that's a silver lining.
Painfully. Yeah, it's a story.
Yeah, painfully. It was a horrible death.
Yeah.
He did not get
what he deserved.
No.
He absolutely did not.
And on that note.
Yeah.
Hello, Sophia.
What would you do if you had
a leg that you hated
and desperately wanted removed because
you felt like it was an alien limb?
Like, what do you do?
I think you go to therapy and
I don't know, try to work on it.
I don't really know.
See, I was gonna go with shotgun, but yeah,
therapy's probably better.
I mean, I guess I feel like
depression in no way
is the same as this,
but it's not like depression makes
sense, you know, makes you want to kill yourself.
And if someone was just like,
okay,
here's a gun, I'd be like, oh,
that's not helping me.
You know, probably just talk me out of wanting to die.
Yeah.
That's all. Yeah.
I don't know much about apatymnophilia,
but it does sound like a thing.
I don't know. If that one guy changed,
then it's possible, right?
It is,
but maybe he wasn't as serious about it.
I don't know. I'm sure it's all a spectrum, right?
Yeah.
You can probably be really wanting your leg off
and just a little bit wanting it off.
I don't know.
The doctor who, like the legit doctor
who had performed some of those surgeries
and then lost his operating privileges,
like, there's a, like,
he didn't make a bad point where he was like,
look, some people are going to do this.
And as long as you make sure
you're only performing surgery
on the ones who are like otherwise gonna go
their own legs off or lay down on a train track,
like, you're reducing harm.
And that's, there is an argument to be made there.
It's not that it's a bad argument.
It's just that
you can try to guess
who the people are
that are gonna try it anyways.
And you can be wrong
and, you know, there's really no good answer.
If you were wrong one way,
people are gonna kill themselves
or maim themselves on their own.
But if they come to you
and you do it every time,
then there's no chance of them ever
psychologically recovering.
So I don't know what the answer is there.
I don't either,
because it's one of those things where
clearly, I think if Firth had been allowed
to perform
or to undergo the surgery,
he clearly didn't really want to lose his leg,
and he probably would have wound up regretting it.
Yeah.
I think,
but the other guy, the guy who died,
if he'd been able
to go to a real doctor in a safe OR
with a proper
aftercare, there's a good chance
he would have lived.
So it is, there's not like an easy answer
to this. I also don't know anything about the disease.
Like, does it spread? Like, after you get
your one leg taken care of, is it possible
that you'll be like, oh, well, now this leg's the alien
and I need to get this off and then you just keep going?
How does it work?
Because you can get addicted to plastic surgery.
You can probably get addicted to this too, can't you?
Who knows? You know, I assume
you can. I do think it's a bit different
than that just because, like, I think it's very
focused. It tends to be with these people.
Like, they're obsessed with this one limb.
But, you know, I'm not
an expert on it.
It's certainly
a pain,
a complicated tale.
Yes, it is.
As is the tale of
John Brown.
What are you distracted by? What are you doing?
The bad John Brown.
I'm trying to, like, there's this
screeching noise coming over repeatedly
the line and I'm trying
not to be taken aback by it because it's
horrible. Oh, that's my parrot. I'm so
sorry.
I don't think so. It sounds like somebody
is, like, fucking an old television
next to you.
That's also me.
Okay, okay.
We can't hear it on our end.
So, it just sounds like you're
wigging out for no reason.
There is Dr. John Ronald Brown.
It was a fun. One of the interesting things
about researching this was just
because I had to read a lot of old articles
and documents dealing with the trans community
is, like, kind of experiencing
the use of terminology and
what's okay evolve over the course
of a couple of decades. That was really interesting.
And I do recommend
the digital transgender archive
which is, like, a really
precious source of
you could kind of see it as an attempt to make
sure that, like, no matter what happens, what happens
with Magnus Hirschfeld's library doesn't
happen again, that these historical
documents of this community
taking care of itself and defending
itself through the decades when no one
else gave a shit about them, that that
doesn't get lost. It's a really
precious source
and I found it fascinating.
So, I recommend giving that a reedy read.
Cool.
Great.
Yep. Well,
Sophia, you got any plugables
you want to, you want to
drop down in the old P-Zone?
What's the P-Zone?
That's the plug zone.
It's not what it sounds like.
All right, my club.
My plugables are
you can
find me at the Sophia
on Twitter and Instagram.
It's T-H-E-S-O-F-I-Y-A.
And you can catch me
with Miles Gray on our podcast
420 Day Fiancé Weekly.
It's super fun. It's a game show, recap show
of 90 Day Fiancé
and it's ridiculous and we have sound effects.
And you can catch me on my other
podcast, Private Parts I Know, and about Love
and Sex Around the World.
Well, you can, you can,
you can do that.
You can catch me on
my other podcast, Worst Year Ever.
You can catch me on this podcast
every Tuesday and Thursday,
except for the Tuesdays and Thursdays
that I don't do this podcast.
And you can find
Love in Your Heart.
I hope, if not,
sorry, that's rough.
That's the episode.
Alphabet Boys
is a new podcast series
that goes inside undercover investigations.
In the first season,
we're diving into an FBI investigation
of the 2020 protests.
It involves a cigar-smoking mystery man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse we look like a lot of guns.
But are federal agents catching bad guys
or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and the time
and the time.
And then, for sure,
he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you
that much of the forensic science
you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual science?
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price?
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest, I was incarcerated
two days after her first birthday.
Listen to CSI on Trial
on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
Listen to the Last Soviet
on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.