Behind the Bastards - The Class that made 200 Child Nazis
Episode Date: February 11, 2021Garrison Davis is joined by Robert Evans to discuss The Third Wave.FOOTNOTES: https://web.archive.org/web/20150202082041/http://www.thewavehome.com/1976_The-Third-Wave_story.htm https://en.wikipedia.o...rg/wiki/Ron_Jones_(teacher) https://web.archive.org/web/20110719004549/http://www.ronjoneswriter.com/wave.html https://www.27east.com/arts/ron-jones-talks-about-his-50-year-old-experiment-in-fascism-that-inspired-the-one-man-play-the-wave-at-bay-street-theater-2-1336315/ https://timeline.com/this-1967-classroom-experiment-proved-how-easy-it-was-for-americans-to-become-nazis-ab63cedaf7dd https://www.theguardian.com/education/2008/sep/16/schoolsworldwide.film https://www.sfgate.com/performance/article/In-The-Wave-ex-teacher-Ron-Jones-looks-back-3274503.php#photo-2424107 https://www.amazon.com/Lesson-Plan-Philip-Neel/dp/B076KS3CCS/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=lesson+plan+video&qid=1605288537&sr=8-1 Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Transcript
Discussion (0)
Alphabet Boys is a new podcast series that goes inside undercover investigations.
In the first season, we're diving into an FBI investigation of the 2020 protests.
It involves a cigar-smoking mystery man who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse look like a lot of guns.
But are federal agents catching bad guys or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date, the time, and then for sure he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you that much of the forensic science you see on shows like CSI isn't based on actual science?
And the wrongly convicted pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences in a life without parole.
My youngest? I was incarcerated two days after her first birthday.
Listen to CSI on trial on the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcast, or wherever you get your podcasts.
That was terrible.
Hi, I'm Robert Evans and you're listening to Brian the Bastard, the podcast about the worst people from history.
That doesn't sound like something I'd say.
It's me again on the podcast.
It's another coup episode.
Garrison's helping me out because I have once again taken on enough projects that I'm terrified about my life.
So yeah, we're doing another coup episode.
We're doing another episode of Trump's Coup.
In honor of Trump's Coup.
It's amazing how we keep recording these and coups are still relevant each time we record.
Oh, coups are always relevant.
Didn't you say Trump's is not technically a coup because no military?
Yeah, I mean so far.
I do think we're splitting hairs a little bit, but either way, I love a good coup.
So we're going to have us another podcast.
Podcast.
Coupcast.
Robert, how do you feel about Nazis?
Lukewarm.
How do you feel about child Nazis?
Also lukewarm.
Okay, because we're going to be talking about child Nazis.
Yay, oh man.
I was holding back a little bit.
My favorite kind of Nazis are child Nazis.
I mean, if we're going to have them, which we shouldn't.
But if we are, if they're little baby teenagers.
Little baby teenage Nazis.
Then that is kind of the funniest.
Like you're, Garrison brought over his little baby kitten and it's very cute and I'm imagining the kitten with a swastika.
With like a little armband.
No, you're not.
No, you're not.
It'd be so, to be so terrible.
I know.
I'm irony-poisoned.
I can't stop.
I did not, I did not like that.
But more, are we talking like JoJo Rabbit?
Like what's the situation here?
Oh, for kind of kid Nazis.
Oh, no.
Okay.
So today we're going to, we're going to dive into one of the things that got younger, Garrison, to actually start to realize that fascism is like an ongoing and active problem.
And way more complicated than just weird people hating Jewish people.
And what we're going to be learning about and the thing that I learned about a few years ago that, you know, got me, you know, to learn more about fascism and kind of got me interested in the topic is the accidental five day social experiment done on a group of teenagers in a California high school.
And this experiment is referred to as the third wave.
Some people may be familiar with this.
But if you're from Germany, you are because they force you to learn about it.
But with the dubious ethics aside, looking at how a charismatic high school teacher got a small group of impressionable teenagers in the 60s to grow into a group of dedicated, of 200 like dedicated fascists.
Yeah.
Over the course of just five days.
That's it.
It's something we can, it's something we can learn from.
And, you know, is like still, is still relevant, even though this was an experiment done in the 60s.
I mean, it sounds like, first off, this is an incredibly, a story of an incredibly ethical teacher who did nothing wrong.
Yeah, like, that's why I started this by saying ethics aside, because yeah, it kind of messed up a lot of kids.
Yeah, it sounds like it really fucked up some people, didn't it?
A lot of, yeah, like one of the people that the high school teacher became friends with is Philip Zimbardo.
Zimbardo.
Zimbardo.
Zimbardo.
He did the Stanford Prison Experiment a few years later.
So yeah, they're buddies because they both did highly unethical experiments.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Philip Zimbardo is my favorite psychologist because he decided long ago that it was way more valuable to do things that were interesting rather than things that were morally defensible.
And I think that's beautiful.
Yeah.
And I mean, yeah, I mean, same thing kind of kind of happened here.
All right.
Well, let's, let's start this motherfucker, Garrison.
You do know when you do giant pours of liquid, it does show up.
Yeah.
Well, the audience wants me to have coffee, Sophie.
I mean, I want you to have coffee because without coffee, you're just Evans, not Robert Evans.
I'm a Nazi.
You're just Evans.
Yeah.
As soon as I get coffee in the morning, I stop understanding the benefits of national socialism.
That's the thing that really gets to have the academic understanding.
The best part of waking up is no longer believing that Nazism is morally defensible.
Yay.
Well, I mean, we're going to be learning a lot about that today, which is great.
That was so funny.
Speaking of Nazism.
Yeah.
When people first learn about like the rise of fascism and particularly the Nazis, usually one of the first questions I hear people, you know, talk about and ask is like, how could everyday Germans been so complicit?
Why did so many people just like let things happen?
And then, you know, when you're learning about stuff, at least when I did, you know, the thought in your mind is like, oh, surely I would have done something to stop this from happening.
But I mean, if we look at the last American election, it's pretty clear that a lot of people, if not the majority, like would not take direct action against a rising fascist power in this country, let alone.
Oh, no, really?
Let other countries.
I have a feeling.
Yeah.
I have an inkling.
But with that in mind, let's look back to the late 1960s and the high school classroom of one Ron Jones and how he quite by accident made 200 child fascists.
First, a little background on Jones himself, since usually different types of fascism have unique elements drawn from their central leader.
Ron Jones started teaching in 1966, having recently graduated from Stanford University.
He became a high school teacher in Coverley High School, right outside of San Francisco.
Jones quickly became the favorite teacher due to his unique and unconventional teaching style.
He was young, very charismatic and attractive.
Jones did not just follow regular curriculums and just give lectures.
He would often bring in guests.
Students recall him bringing in communists, Klansmen, members of the American Nazi Party, and he actually got on the phone with Chairman Mao in his class.
How did he get on the phone?
Could you just call Chairman Mao?
I don't know.
Did he just have like?
I'm not sure.
That seems like it would be a lot of work to get Chairman Mao on the phone.
It's a lot of work.
It also got all these great ideas.
I don't think bringing a Klansman into your class is necessarily the best.
I don't support bringing a Klansman or a Nazi into your class.
Or some tankies even.
As a rule, if you can get a world leader on the phone in your high school class, that's kind of cool.
He brought in other Soviet Union stands from America.
I'm more fascinated by how the hell he got Chairman Mao on the phone.
He just says he did.
I cannot find any explanation how.
See, I feel like that's a whole episode.
How do you, okay, well, I'm very frustrated by this man.
Because I want to know how he got Chairman Mao on the phone.
How did he get Chairman Mao on the phone for his class?
He followed lots of unconventional teaching.
With the guests, he would do like historical simulations in his class,
like trying to replicate historical events, as we see here with the Nazi thing.
A quote from Jones is, if you can feel something and work with it,
that's better than just reading about it.
So he likes a lot of learning that's not just reading in a book.
He likes actually getting people to feel stuff.
Which, I mean, successful on the Nazi experiment.
He messed up a lot of kids.
Yeah, I mean, I agree with the basics of what he's saying,
which is that kids learn, everyone learns best by doing.
And if you can give people some sort of direct experience
with the things they're learning about, that's good.
Now, the problem is that he's teaching them about Nazism.
And I don't know of many ethical ways to give people experiences with Nazism.
It's kind of a bad idea.
Yeah, it seems like it.
And Jones probably should have known better,
because he was a left-wing activist back in the 60s, and still is now.
He was a member of the New Left Students for Democratic Society.
Saying back in the 60s, lots of people recall him being very supportive
of the Black Panthers and participated a lot in the anti-war movement
in the 60s with Vietnam going on.
So he should have kind of known better.
But I think his intentions were good,
but it very quickly spiraled out of control with this.
But basically, he was basically just the cool new hip teacher,
and students really did trust him,
and lots of students really did like him.
So at the last quarter of his first year of teaching,
in a 25-student sophomore world history class,
Jones was talking about Nazi Germany.
They were coming to the end of their kind of history section on the Nazis.
And a student asked the question, the most of us do at some point,
which is, you know, how could every German's been complicit?
Why did people just let things happen?
And Jones says he didn't really have a good answer,
so he thought up a short experiment.
Now, this is where kind of learning about the wave gets a little bit tricky.
There is a lot of, you can, when you're trying to research this,
there's kind of a different accounts of what happened,
because no one really was able to, you know, document this as it was happening,
because the people that did all got beat up by the fascists
of who were trying to, you know, the people who were writing stuff down
all got kind of beat up.
And I'm pretty sure that actually Jones tried this experiment
in three classes at the same time.
But usually when people talk about the wave,
they focus on, like, the one first class.
But there can be a lot of conflicting information
when you talk to, like, students of this.
So we're going to kind of treat it as just focusing on this one class,
but there may have been two other classes doing this experiment concurrently,
but it's kind of unclear.
So they were learning about Nazis.
But because this happened, Jones didn't know.
He thought of the experiment the next week.
So, like, the Monday after, because this experiment ran five days,
when students came into the class on this Monday,
Jones had set up all the chairs in five by five rows,
which is weird for Jones, because he usually had a very loose setup,
because he, you know, he was, like, the new hip teacher who had, you know,
students in a circle or had people on the floor or whatever.
But, like, coming into his class and seeing, like, five rows of chairs
was kind of weird.
Music by Richard Wagner was playing.
A German composer.
Wagner Garrison. It's important to pronounce things correctly.
Wagner. It's C-W.
Richard Wagers.
Our wags.
Students were ordered to all sit in perfect posture
with their hands by their side,
and on the chalkboard, Jones wrote,
Strength through Discipline.
So we can kind of see where this is going to be going.
Yeah, that sounds healthy.
Yeah.
The class on the values of strict discipline,
speaking on the efficiency of, like, a regimented system.
To quote Jones,
I lectured on the beauty discipline, how an athlete feels,
how an athlete feels having worked hard and regularly successful at a sport,
how a ballet dancer or a painter works hard to perfect a movement,
the dedicated patients of a scientist to pursue an idea,
its discipline, its self-training, control, the power of will,
in exchange for physical hardships,
for superior mental and physical facilities, the ultimate triumph.
Now, all the text I'm quoting Jones from
is written from him and himself, so all typos are his fault.
But yeah, obviously...
Fair enough, Garrison.
It's not my fault. He wrote this, and I fix some typos.
Yeah, Garrison's blaming a...
Don't blame me. Blame the teacher who made the Nazis.
Basically, Jones...
That's pretty good...
Pretty good summary of Nazism
without using any of the Nazi terms,
like, yeah, the Strength through Discipline stuff.
That's very much like a lot of Hitler-Jugend-like shit.
Jones was very familiar with fascism.
As we see, he'll be talking...
He'll have sections later on when he talks about fascism.
It's like, yeah, he understands what it is very well.
So what Jones was doing on the first day,
he basically changed his personality.
He made him...
He was way more open, playful...
Oh, no! No!
Robert, look at my cat!
Oh, no!
The cat now has a Nazi band tied around it.
Someone put a Nazi band on my cat!
Tied around its torso, so it is a Nazi cat.
It's now a Nazi cat.
How?
How?
Someone who is in my own business.
Mysteriously has given my cat a Nazi...
My cat's name is Chairman Miao,
and now it's moved to a different type of authoritarianism.
Either way, it's the responsibility of millions of deaths.
Well, now it's a very cute little Nazi cat.
God, we would post pictures of this online, but we should not.
Nope.
Don't do it, but...
Not gonna happen.
This is really great audio content, y'all.
People are really going to enjoy this audio content,
that there is now a Nazi cat in the house.
Walking with a leash.
Walking with a leash.
It is a very cute kitten.
Like, oh my God, this little kitten, y'all.
You gotta...
You should see this kitten, but not...
I mean, you can see the kitten on my Twitter,
not wearing a Nazi...
Not wearing a swastika, yes.
I'll take that off.
That's so cute, though.
Again, this is very good audio content.
Yeah, the little kitten doesn't know that it's wearing...
It doesn't know it's tied to millions of deaths.
Oh, little buddy.
Oh, it's just chilling out now.
No, it's just chilling with a swastika.
That's healthy.
Yeah.
Okay, sorry, Garrison.
Yeah, so basically, Jones adopted a very strict personality.
He told the class to only address them as Mr. Jones,
as opposed to Ron, as I usually called him.
He made rules about how many words you could use
to answer verbal questions.
He said that students should arrive five minutes before class
and wait in seated position.
He talked a lot about posture
and how better posture leads to better learning,
which is dubious, but he knows that.
He was just trying to make this disciplined environment.
Jones had his students line up outside the class
and have them enter the class to get into perfect seated position,
and they drilled this over and over and over again with a timer,
having everyone go inside and everyone come back inside
and trying to get into perfect seated position very quickly.
They drilled this until everyone was perfectly in sync
and got in and sitting under five seconds.
He was trying to introduce this kind of...
the rules of discipline and listening to authority
and things without really any reason,
but just listening in this disciplined environment.
As all of Jones' experiments, grades were based on participation.
If you wanted to opt out, you could just go to the library.
On the first day, everyone participated very willingly.
No one seemed to make a connection to the German history classes
that the class had just completed.
The idea was to give students a peek into what it was like
to be a regular German under the Nazis
in the World History class into just a one-day fascist state.
That's all it was.
It was supposed to just be a one-day simulation, and that was it.
The next day, the plan was to have a discussion
over what the experiment was.
That was all Jones wanted to do,
which is this one-day kind of experiment
into getting used to an environment of discipline
and following a strict leader.
That's kind of all it was.
Not super harmful.
First day, kind of all right.
It's just a fun one-day thing.
But as Jones entered class the next day,
all the students were waiting inside the class
five minutes early,
and they were all sitting in perfect posture inside all the rows.
In unison, they all chanted,
Good morning, Mr. Jones!
Jones began to wonder how far he could take this,
and he walked over to the chalkboard
and wrote down, Strength Through Community.
Uh-oh.
This is...
He saw everyone had like...
He saw the students were very into this,
and he's like, Huh?
I wonder how much he can turn them into fascists.
He just decided to do it.
It was just like a spur of the moment decision
because the experiment was over.
He's just like, Huh? What if it isn't over?
See, this doesn't speak well for him as a person.
Although, I guess maybe it doesn't speak well for anyone as a person,
because maybe the lesson here is that, um,
that there's something intoxicating about fascism
that can draw anybody in.
Jones talks about this later,
how he actually got pulled into the experiment himself.
Don't like that.
Yeah.
That's very Zimbardo of him,
which doesn't make it okay.
Which is why they're friends.
Yeah, because they're both kind of not great people.
Okay.
So, Jones wrote Strength Through Community
on the chalkboard next to Strength Through Discipline
to quote Jones here.
Well, the class sat in stern silence.
I began to talk, lecture, and, uh,
ceremonize, that's a weird word,
about the value of community.
At this stage in the game,
I was debating in my mind
whether to stop the experiment or continue.
I hadn't planned on such intensity or compliance.
In fact, I was surprised to find that the ideas of discipline
were enacted at all.
While debating whether to stop or go on with the experiment,
I talked on and on about community.
I made up stories from my experiences
as an athlete, a coach, and historian.
It was easy.
Community being something bigger than oneself,
something enjoyable,
they really bought onto that argument.
So, students were,
I mean, like Jones, by all accounts,
was a very good lecturer.
He was very engaging,
both when he was more like relaxed and charismatic,
and both when he was, you know,
putting on this more strict dictatorial character.
Jones had the class all chanted together,
strength through discipline, strength through community,
echoing between pairs of students,
getting the whole class in unison,
starting with one person,
then adding on another person each time,
just a whole bunch of, you know, like community drills
of doing this, you know, fashion chant.
I don't enjoy this at all, Garrison,
and I know where it's going,
and it's just progressively getting
more sentence by sentence.
It is kind of predictable.
Yeah, this might be,
I don't want to be like radical here,
but this might be why you shouldn't experiment on children.
Impressionable children?
Yeah, perhaps.
I mean, I've carried out some experiments on a child,
and it worked out pretty well.
But...
That was a Garrison joke.
Yeah, because I tear gas.
I mean, look at me now reading about
fascism with my cat with a swastika band.
Yep, everything's going great.
Yeah, this was his plan from the start.
You know what won't convert a kitten
to national socialism?
Define folks who make those chips.
Yep, Raytheon.
Raytheon would never do that,
and neither will the other sponsors of this podcast.
During the summer of 2020,
some Americans suspected that the FBI
had secretly infiltrated the racial justice demonstrations.
And you know what?
They were right.
I'm Trevor Aronson,
and I'm hosting a new podcast series,
Alphabet Boys.
As the FBI sometimes,
you gotta grab the little guy
to go after the big guy.
Each season will take you inside
an undercover investigation.
In the first season of Alphabet Boys,
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver.
At the center of this story
is a raspy-voiced, cigar-smoking man
who drives a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse was like a lot of guns.
He's a shark.
And not in the good-bad-ass way.
He's a nasty shark.
He was just waiting for me to set the date, the time,
and then for sure he was trying to get it to heaven.
Listen to Alphabet Boys
on the iHeart Radio App, Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Lance Bass,
and you may know me from a little band called NSYNC.
What you may not know
is that when I was 23,
I traveled to Moscow to train to become
the youngest person to go to space.
And when I was there,
as you can imagine,
I heard some pretty wild stories.
But there was this one
that really stuck with me.
About a Soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring him down.
It's 1991,
and that man, Sergei Krekalev,
is floating in orbit
when he gets a message that down on Earth,
his beloved country,
the Soviet Union,
is falling apart.
And now he's left defending
the Union's last outpost.
This is the crazy story
of the 313 days he spent in space.
313 days
that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet
on the iHeart Radio App,
Apple Podcasts,
Apple Podcasts.
What if I told you that much of the forensic
science you see on shows like
CSI isn't based
on actual science?
The problem with forensic
science in the criminal legal
system today is that it's an awful
lot of forensic and not an awful lot of science.
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences
and a life without parole.
At the very least, I was incarcerated
two days after her first birthday.
I'm Molly Herman.
Join me as we put
forensic science on trial
to discover what happens
when a match isn't a match
and when there's no science
in CSI.
How many people have to be wrongly convicted
before they realize
that this stuff's all bogus.
It's all made up.
Listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeartRadio app,
Apple Podcasts,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
And we're back.
All right, Garrison.
The Nazi armband is off the kitten now.
The kitten has got it off himself, so it's good.
The kitten has been de-radicalized.
It's a little edgy fascist kitten.
Aww.
Most podcasts don't even radicalize the kitten,
so we're really very productive today.
That's great.
I'm going to ask Anderson.
No, Anderson is a committed anti-fascist.
He stands fast in his beliefs.
Yeah, Anderson, she's a free thinker, you know?
Speaking of committed fascism,
um,
so after all of the chanting together
in unison and stuff,
at the end of the class,
Jones made a terrible decision,
and that decision was to make a class member salute.
Oh, no.
Oh, no.
Someone really should have talked to him.
People did. He had, like, read by his colleague
and threw out this whole experiment,
and Jones is like, no, don't worry, it's just an experiment.
They're like, okay, yeah.
I don't like this. It's not great.
So, the salute here.
Jones made...
Students were commanded to give each other,
both in and out of class,
like, whatever two students met,
they were supposed to, you know, salute each other,
both in school, out of school.
Jones called it,
and now the experiment was also called the third wave.
Jones claims the third wave is not a reference
to the third rite.
He claims it has to do with, like,
waves and beaches, and how, like, the third wave
is, like, the strongest wave,
but I don't really buy that.
No, because it also sounds too much like
a third position, like, there's a lot of...
There's a lot of third...
A lot of fashy things that involve a third, yeah.
Don't ever count to three.
Never for fascists. Skip two to four.
Skip three or right to four if you're going to count,
if you don't want to, you know, enable Nazism.
To make the salute, you brought up your right hand
towards your right shoulder in a curled position.
He called it the third wave,
or, you know, just the wave because the hand
resembled the wave of the shoulders.
Like, I do buy that part for calling it the wave,
but the third part, I mean, is just, you know,
that's just...
Come on, come on, come on, buddy.
But just like how my cat removed its fascist
armband as now an anti-fascist,
day two is where we also got to see the start
of an anti-fascist resistance
forming within the school.
So, like, the really cool thing about this experiment,
even though it's highly unethical,
is that we've got a really good microcosm
of how fascism develops and how, like,
anti-fascism develops beside it.
By the end of the second day,
a student in the class got up and said,
Mr. Jones, why can't we just say what we want to think?
Why can't we express our own opinions
about what we think about the third wave in the experiment?
And Jones very quickly said,
you to the library for the rest of the semester.
So this is the first time a student got banished
from the class.
I say first time, it's not the last time.
This student went to the library
and the librarian asked
why the student wasn't in class.
Based on what Jones had told the students,
the student thought that, like, the whole staff
was in on the experiment, which they were not.
So the student was actually scared
to tell the librarian what happened
and why she was there.
Now, it just so happened to be
that the librarian was born and raised
in Nazi Germany.
Oh.
This is actually good.
When the student finally told the librarian
what happened, the librarian was very alarmed
and very concerned.
The librarian told the student that she has
to do something to kind of stop this.
Stop this from spreading to other students.
The librarian thought this was very dangerous.
So the student went home and talked to their parents
about what they should do.
Their first idea was to make posters.
That night, the student's father drove her
back to the school.
Because of how hot the area is around the school,
like the town, all of the hallways
are technically outside of the school,
just with a canopy.
The student was able to plaster all of the walls
with anti-third wave posters.
So they filled up the school
with anti-third wave posters.
The next morning,
within an hour of school starting,
all of the posters had been torn down.
Students admitted to
like, we tore down the posters
because they were anti-third wave.
They made a little Portland.
Little poster wars back and forth.
Later that night,
on day three, we're skipping ahead
for this, the student returned with a ladder
to put up the posters up where they couldn't
be torn down.
The student had titled
their anti-third wave resistance,
The Breakers, which is again
another wave reference because
waves break. It's all very silly.
But like, this student is traumatized
and you can hear the student talk about this experiment
later on. They are very
clearly traumatized by this experience.
You love to see it.
Yay!
By day three,
this is Wednesday. So yes,
the first day was strength through discipline,
second day was strength through community.
By day three, the class had
gained 20 extra students who were interested
in participating in the experiment.
That's not how classes are supposed to work.
Why was this allowed? Oh, it gets so much worse.
Eventually people from other schools joined the class.
It's bad.
And no one's, no one's,
the school administration is just like,
yeah, he's recreating fascism in our campus.
They let it happen. This is fine.
So the class
had gotten from like 25 students. God, it's just like
America. Okay. Yeah, I mean, yes.
Yeah.
So the class had grown from 25 students
to about 60 students
by day three. That's not how schools are supposed
to work.
It really isn't.
When Jones went into class,
the new phrase he wrote on the chalkboard
was strength through action.
So this doesn't get any better.
No, it doesn't sound like it does, Garrison.
Jones announced that he was
issuing third wave membership cards,
which were just,
they were just index cards he found
in his desk. Because again, he didn't
plan this at all. And it was just
kind of like going with it.
So he found these index cards and he's like,
huh, I should give them membership cards. And he's like
without a second thought for how bad this is.
Jesus Christ.
So he gave everyone
third wave membership cards
to every student who decided to continue
the experiment. All students were still
continuing at this point.
Three cards,
Jones secretly marked with a red X,
which meant that these students were informants
and were instructed to
tell Jones if any students were not following
the third wave rules.
Or as a student referred to them as
in a documentary,
the third wave community values.
Jesus Christ.
It's really bad.
This doesn't seem good.
So like, if
one of these informants saw someone
not salute them in a hallway
or not do X, not do Y, they were
supposed to tell Jones.
Great. Awesome thing to do to kids.
Jones lectured the
class on direct action.
And in Jones' own words, how discipline
and community were meaningless without action,
which is definitely not something
Hitler would say. He then gave the class
different direct action assignments
varying from passing out
third wave flyers and posters,
outreach to other students and other schools
and setting up info tables
in the hallways.
Sorry.
I shouldn't be laughing, but it is
kind of terrible. To quote Jones,
to allow students to have the experience
of direct action, I gave each individual
a special verbal assignment.
It's your task to design a third wave banner.
You are responsible for stopping any student
that's not a third wave member from entering the room.
I want you to remember and be able to recite
tomorrow the names of each
member and addresses of each member.
I want you to
This is good.
You're assigned the problem of training
and convincing at least 20 children in the
adjacent elementary school that are sitting
posture is necessary for better learning.
It's your job to read the pamphlet
and report on its entire content of the class
tomorrow. I want you to give me the name
and address of one reliable friend that you think
will want to join the third wave, etc.
Basically a list of all these terrible things
you got students to do.
To conclude the session on direct action,
this is still quoting Jones here.
I instructed students in a simple procedure
for initiating new members. It went like this.
A new member had to be
only recommended by an existing member
and issued an ID card by myself.
Upon receiving his card
he's now a new member and had to demonstrate
knowledge of our rules and pledge obedience
to them. My announcement
unleashed a fervor.
That's how he ends that section when he talks about this.
So students
were very into it.
These are 15 year olds
in the 60s.
We're going to talk more about why the experiment
worked at the end and why it worked so well.
People were very
into this.
The result to this call to action
was recruiters at these infotables
were starting fist fights with people who didn't want to join.
Great.
There's multiple
brawls in the hallway
over people not wanting to join the third wave.
This is all
I wonder if maybe the original Nazism
was a social experiment that just got out of hand.
Hitler was like, I guess I got to
invade a couple of countries.
He was trying to keep up the act
because everyone was so involved.
Even though only three people
got the red X on their cards
way more than three people were turning in names
of people breaking the rules. Jones recalls
though I formally
appointed only three students to report a bad behavior
approximately
20 students came to me with reports about how Alan didn't salute
or Georgina
wasn't into the experiment and talking critically
about it. This instance
of monitoring meant
that half of the class members
now considered it their duty to report
and observe all other members of the class.
A student recalls
you never know
who's going to come in the next morning
and turn you in. All lines
of student communication were broken down
because of this fear.
What a good history class this was.
But I find it really fascinating
how even though
the strength of your community and whatever
they're all out of the
actual community, all broke down over fear
of people turning each other in
which is
very accurate to what
actually happened in Germany.
Sounds like again just a real good
high school history class.
Trials were
held for members that were seen breaking
rules. Oh good.
That's what I remember
my favorite part of high school was the trials
that we would hold for each other
after informing on each other.
Now with Antifa Cat
the kitten everybody
for this great audio content now has
a little antifa band
around its back. So the kitten has been
de-radicalized and it now
shows the fervor of a convert in fighting
its old ideology.
This has really been quite an arc
for a very like what a four month old kitten.
12 weeks.
12 weeks. Little baby.
Very small. Oh you're so good.
Very happy. You're so good.
Yeah.
So you didn't have trials in your high school
because again I was homeschooled and
homeschooled in the streets.
We had some show trials.
There were a couple of executions
but it was over football.
I grew up in Texas. Oh okay.
That's the one with the
nevermind.
Trials
they were held for members
scene breaking rules
members that were just joking about the third wave
or
being seen with quote
known revolutionaries. God damn it.
That's a good one. Good
good work teaching
teacher guy. Ron Jones
I can see again
it makes so much sense that Philip Zimbardo likes
this guy because they are both
monsters who view the brains of other human
beings. Zimbardo often
brings Jones into his class to teach
as well. Great. See
I love Philip Zimbardo because whenever
he comes up in a story you know things are about
to get interesting. He's that kind of character
but also he shouldn't be allowed
to teach people. He shouldn't be allowed
to do anything. No. He's a terrible person.
No.
So in these trials basically
Jones or
a senior class member would
read aloud the alleged offense. The entire
class would immediately chant guilty
all in unison and the accused
was banished to the library.
I love that there's now banishments
and again a high school history
class. Yeah. So like the library became
a concentration camp. If you weren't catching
on to where this was leading. I mean as
concentration camps go
the library is not the worst. Better than most
concentration camps. Yeah.
Thank you
for making ethical concentration camps.
Several
students elected themselves. They did not like
me saying ethical concentration camps. They're
grass fed. That's not
a great term. They're local.
By local when you buy a concentration
camp. Stop it. I mean if Powell's books
was just one concentration camp I wouldn't
complain. They have coffee and books.
Exactly. Powell's books is a large
bookstore. When the Proud Boys take over
Portland and they send me to the Powell's
books. I hate
everything happening right now. Yeah. None
of this is very good. I hate all of it.
Garrison. Oh don't worry. I can
make it much worse by reading my script. Oh
good. Yes. Please continue.
Several students elected themselves to
become bodyguards for Jones. Great. And they
made their own Black Arm Bands. So he's got an SS.
They made their own Black Arm Bands. Yeah.
So he has
spontaneously his students developed
an SS. And they made their own
Arm Bands. Yeah. Yeah.
That's great.
Like parents were
questioning their kids about why they had
Arm Bands. Like no, no, no.
It's to
protect Mr. Jones. It's just part of the experiment.
And they called Jones very
concerned. And Jones was like, no, don't worry.
We're just studying the German psyche
is what he told them. Yeah. See
I would have additional questions as
a parent. Not to backseat parent because
I've never had a kid. But I think I would
have questions at that point
in the experiment. Like
what the fuck is wrong with you?
And why are you a teacher? Raj was very
funded by the sentence you just said.
Oh, yeah.
Worst, worst, worst. Oh, my cat.
You've never had a kid.
I had a baby, but she's not a kid. All the kittens sleeping on your leg.
The kittens eyes are closed.
I know. But Antifa kitten sleeping
on my leg now.
Raj is having a rough day.
My cat is not going to be happy, but
she'll learn because I want her to raise
a kitten and teach it all that she knows.
And because all of the quotes from
Jones have just been amazing and full of
typos, but also, you know, really,
really interesting and terrible.
I'm going to do another one and this one's actually pretty long.
Okay. Many of the students
were completely into being third wave
members. They demanded strict obedience
of the rules from other students and
believed those that took the experiment lightly.
Others simply sunk into the
activities and took on self-assigned rules.
I particularly remember my student
Robert. Robert was big
for his age and displayed very few academic
skills. Oh, he
tried harder than anyone else to be successful.
I remember this for later.
This is actually very important.
But he handled
in the, he handed in
a lab, weekly reports
copied word for word from reference
books to libraries, but he just wasn't
wasn't very academically skilled actually.
Robert, like so many other kids
in school, didn't excel
or cause trouble. They aren't that bright.
They can't make the athletic teams.
They don't strike out for attention. They're lost,
invisible. And the only reason I came
to know Robert at all is that I often found him
eating lunch in my classroom because he always
ate alone. Well,
the third wave gave Robert a place in
the school. He was at last equal to everyone
else. He could do something, be apart,
be meaningful. And that's what Robert did.
Late Wednesday afternoon, I found
Robert following me and I asked him
what in the world he was doing. He smiled
and announced, Mr. Jones,
I'm your bodyguard. I'm afraid
something will happen to you.
He followed me everywhere.
Oh, God. In the faculty room,
which was close to students, he stood
silently at attention as I
gulped down coffee. When accosted by an
English teacher for having
a student in the teacher's room,
he just smiled at her and informed
her that he wasn't a student,
he was a bodyguard.
That's good.
Yeah. Child labor.
Yeah. Well, more just like
that's how the SS got started. It was
initially Hitler's bodyguard.
That's what it was and then it turned into
a state within a state.
He spontaneously generated
Heinrich Himmler.
It started with Robert and then
a group of seniors
from another one of Jones's classes
who were interested in the experiment,
they were part of the car club,
they all wore leather jackets and worked on cars
because they were cool. That does sound pretty rare.
They all became the rest of his bodyguards
putting on the black arm bands.
They just beat up random students.
Awesome.
Yeah. They were not that cool.
They kind of sucked.
We'll hear more about this at the end,
but Jones talks a lot about how the people
who really got into the wave were all the
students in the middle. People who were not
great at school, weren't terrible at school,
old people who just barely coasted by
and it gave them something to be
and something to do
for people like this
rubber person who finally was able to
like he had some kind of meaning in school.
Yeah. I mean, it's like we talk about
in the little Nazis episode. It's the little
men who
to whom Nazi appealed the most.
Yeah. That scans.
Yeah. I mean, yeah.
We'll talk a lot about this at the end, actually.
There's a lot of really interesting parallels there.
By the morning of day four,
so again, we've already had strength
through discipline, strength through community, strength through action.
We've had fistfights and hallways,
people trying to get kids from other elementary
schools to join
not even high schools, elementary schools.
By the morning of day four,
Jones started to realize that he kind of lost control
of the experiment. Earlier that night,
a father of a student
whom I believed to actually be the first
person kicked out of class and the person who
made the third wave posters, I believe
I think I'm pretty sure it was actually
her father
broke into the classroom and ransacked it
to quote
Jones. He was a retired Air Force
Colonel who spent a lot of time
in a German prison war camp.
Upon hearing of our activity,
he simply lost control late into the evening
he broke into the classroom and tore it apart.
I found him that morning
propped up against the classroom door.
He told me about his friends that had been killed in Germany.
He was holding on to me and
shaking. He pleaded with me that I
understand and I try to help him get
home. I called his wife and with the help
of a neighbor walked him home. We spent hours
later talking about
why he did what he did
and what he was feeling at the time.
From that moment on on Thursday morning,
I was very concerned
about
what might be happening in school.
Your
self-appointed
Schuttstaffel are beating up kids
in the school. You have informants
and show trials
but
you weren't concerned then. You finally get concerned
when a Holocaust survivor tears up your
classroom.
I don't know if this is true or not
because this is something only Jones talks
about. And he seems credible.
But on day three
Jones claims
how he got the extra bodyguards besides Robert
was
the members of his car club
beat Jones up and threw him in a dumpster
and demanded that they beat his bodyguards
and he said yes. Now I have
no way to
put this in the script because I don't actually think it happened.
Yeah, that seems like
well, he doesn't seem like a credible person.
But it may have happened which I think is
like if that happened that should have been the sign
that things were getting out of control.
There are so many red flags here.
He should have
I mean he never should have started this but he certainly
like there were a lot of points
which it was clear that this was bad before
the Holocaust survivor destroyed his classroom.
Yeah.
So at this point
in the morning of day four
the third wave was nearing
100 active members
which is in how school works.
You shouldn't have
100 students in your class
that aren't part of your class.
And the experiment was also affecting Jones.
He reports feeling
like relaxed in his dictatorial position.
The character he was putting on
was becoming his default personality.
Even his wife had to like it was like getting him to be like
hey, you see
you seem a little different at home.
What's going on? Seems like you might have
accidentally recreated Nazism.
Yeah.
The way you've had taken over students lives
and how the whole school
kind of operated
Jones decided he needed to end it
but he didn't want to just end the experiment
all of a sudden. He wanted there to be
a conclusion and closure for participants.
Okay.
Jones wrote, if I stopped the experiment
100 students would be left hanging.
They committed themselves in front of their peers
to this radical behavior.
Emotionally and psychologically they'd exposed themselves.
If I suddenly jolted them back to the classroom
the reality that would face them
would be confusion over the whole
student body that would remain for the rest of the year.
It would be too painful
and demeaning for someone like Robert
and the students like him to be twisted back
into a seat and told it was just a game.
They would be
ridiculed by the brighter students
for their participation
and I couldn't let
people like Robert lose again.
Which is
I think not a terrible
Yeah, I mean once you have
recreated fascism in your classroom
and have people who have dedicated
their lives to it, you do have to
you can't just say we're done now
like yeah, you have to
de-radicalize the students you radicalized
like we de-radicalized this kitten.
But Jones' solution
to this is
very perplexing from a standpoint of trying to limit
the psychological damage and whiplash
coming from this extreme assimilation
back to the classroom.
Because I think what he did actually made things
way worse.
But it's very fascinating
what happened from an experimental standpoint
but it's again, I think this
was way worse than just pulling the plug.
In class, Jones announced
that the third wave isn't just a school experiment
it's a new national political
movement.
In Jones' words
Across the country
teachers like myself have been recruiting and training
a youth brigade capable of showing
the nation a better society through
discipline, community, pride and action.
If we can change the way a school
is run, we can change the way that factories
stores, universities and all other
institutions are run. You are a selected
group of young people chosen to help in this
cause. If you will stand up and display
what you have learned in the past four days
we can change the destiny of this nation.
We can bring in a new sense
of order, community, pride and action.
A new purpose. Everything
rests on you and your willingness to take a stand.
This doesn't sound like de-radicalization
Garrison.
He gets so much worse.
So yeah, like
no, everything he talked about
for trying to get out these students out of the experiment
this is not doing it.
No.
But that's not all.
Jones then to
balladify the seriousness of my
words, quote, his words
ordered his bodyguards
to escort
three of the more intellectually astute students
who had been dubious about the third wave.
So his, after he makes this big
announcement and big lecture, he orders
his guards to take three people to the library.
Okay.
And was
told the bodyguards to never let them re-enter the class.
Jones then
further explained that the next day
there was to be a special third wave
members only rally at noon.
There was to be a nationwide broadcast
formally announcing
the new political party and introducing a presidential
candidate, quoting Jones.
Quote, over
1000 youth groups from every part
of the country would stand up and display their support
for such a movement. There were to be students selected
to represent their area.
I questioned if they could make a good showing because press
had been invited to record the event. No one
laughed. There was not a murmur of resistance.
Quite the contrary, a fever pitch of excitement
swelled across the room.
So I really don't know what, why he thought
this would calm things over.
Yeah, no, that doesn't seem like an attempt
to de-radicalize. It's very
I think, I think, Jones'
plan here and what happened, I think made everything much
worse, made the trauma much worse.
And to make things even more, you know,
unfortunate, by pure
happenstance, a student had a copy
of the Time Magazine
from that month
and it had a full
page ad for a lumber product
but the ad was just in
big red, white, and blue lettering.
The third wave is coming.
So like, there was this
horrible coincidence that got them all to believe
this is all very legit.
With the class
convinced, Jones set a time
for this member's only rally.
It was going to be Friday, so
for them it was tomorrow at noon.
Members were told to be there 10 minutes early
waiting for press
in proper seating position and
be there to quote, display the discipline,
community, and pride that you have all
learned. The class
was instructed to not tell any third wave members about this.
So yeah, that was
Jones' idea to de-eslate things on day four
was to prepare kids for this national
announcement and this big rally on the next day.
Oh god. Not what I would have done.
I think I wouldn't have let
the experiment get to this point anyway.
No, but it seems like his attempt to
de-radicalize them was to convince them that they were
part of a national movement, which
questionable call.
But you know what's not a questionable call,
Garrison?
Buying all the dick pills. Buying dick pills or
whatever, whatever else
advertises on our show.
Products
are the only pathway to de-radicalize
Nazis. Services
breed. Free market capitalism.
The only thing that gets Nazis to become
no longer Nazis. Historically, that's true.
Capitalism
de-radicalizes fashion.
Okay, well, here's some ads.
Yay.
During the summer of 2020,
some Americans suspected that the FBI
had secretly infiltrated the
racial justice demonstrations.
And you know what?
They were right.
I'm Dr. Aronson, and I'm hosting
a new podcast series,
Alphabet Boys.
As the FBI, sometimes,
you gotta grab the little guy
to go after the big guy.
Each season will take you inside
an undercover investigation.
In the first season of Alphabet Boys,
we're revealing how the FBI
spied on protesters in Denver.
At the center of this story
is a raspy-voiced,
cigar-smoking man
with a silver hearse.
And inside his hearse was like a lot of guns.
He's a shark, and not in the good badass way.
He's a nasty shark.
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and then, for sure,
he was trying to get it to happen.
Listen to Alphabet Boys on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
I'm Lance Bass,
and you may know me from a little band
called NSYNC.
What you may not know is that when I was 23,
I traveled to Moscow
to train to become the youngest person
to go to space.
And when I was there, as you can imagine,
I heard some pretty wild stories.
But there was this one
that really stuck with me.
About a Soviet astronaut
who found himself stuck in space
with no country
to bring him down.
It's 1991, and that man,
Sergei Krekalev,
is floating in orbit when he gets a message
that he's down on Earth.
His beloved country,
the Soviet Union,
is falling apart.
And now he's left
defending the Union's last outpost.
This is the crazy story
of the 313 days he spent in space.
313 days
that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet
on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
What if I told you
that much of the forensic science
you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on actual science?
The problem
with forensic science
in the criminal legal system today
is that it's an awful lot of forensic
and not an awful lot of science.
And the wrongly convicted
pay a horrific price.
Two death sentences and a life without parole.
My youngest, I was incarcerated
two days after her first birthday.
I'm Molly Herman.
Join me as we put
forensic science on trial
to discover what happens
when a match isn't a match
and when there's no science
in CSI.
How many people have to be wrongly convicted
before they realize
that this stuff's all bogus.
It's all made up.
Listen to CSI on trial
on the iHeart Radio app,
Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.
Alright, we're back.
Okay, so
he's told his...
He's gotten scared because he recreated
fascism.
And now there's a concentration camp in the library.
And also
his students are...
He's attempted to de-radicalize them
by telling them they're part of a nationwide movement
to change the character of the country.
No notes.
Now they're going to have a big meeting
and he's going to tell them all to stop being fascist, right?
That's going to happen now?
Okay.
But throughout the week,
a school reporter was trying to find out
about the third wave.
But whenever he asked questions about it
to people, they just wouldn't talk.
Until he got a hold of the librarian.
After the rally was announced.
So basically, he got a lead about what was happening
through the librarian, because again, all the students
who were banished were sent to the library.
After the rally was announced,
two of the third wave bodyguards
went into the school journalism office
and beat up the reporter.
Telly...
God damn it.
Yeah.
He did a good job remaking Nazism.
You gotta give him credit for that.
He's the people wearing the black arm bands.
It definitely wasn't his job, but he did it.
Telly...
After they beat him up, they told him not to write about
or the upcoming rally, which he had, I guess,
learned a little bit about.
So yeah, that was the state of that.
If you're trying to keep a
Telly going on how well the fascism
is working.
So day five, Friday morning, the final day,
the school auditorium
was plastered with third wave banners
and posters, like everywhere.
By 11.30,
third wave members began already arriving
and filling up the seats.
At noon, the auditorium held over
200 third wave members.
So again, this class started with 25 people
and it grew to an auditorium
filled with 200 Nazis.
Over five days.
So they were waiting to hear
the national announcement of the new political party
and their presidential nominee.
Jones had several of his friends
in the room posing as reporters, taking pictures.
And he also set up a TV
in the middle of the room.
As the clock struck 12,
the bodyguards closed all the doors
and were stationed in front of all the exits.
I don't know why this happened,
but everyone reports that it did, so it probably happened.
Jones says, quote,
he says to the class,
before turning on the national press coverage,
which begins in five minutes,
I want to demonstrate to the press the extent of our training.
He then moves his arm up to salute.
200 arms follow.
Oh God.
All at the same time.
Apparently also one student on day four
suggested they all wear white shirts,
which they did on this last day.
So it's like, you know,
very unite the right-ish with 200 people
all wearing white shirts.
Doing this Nazi salute.
Yeah.
Jones says, strength through discipline,
and the students all in unison repeat back.
The phrase gets recited over and over
each time getting louder.
At 12.05,
Jones orders the lights turned off,
walks over to the television set and turns it on.
The white static illuminates the room
just enough to see the faces of the students.
Robert the bodyguard is standing beside Jones.
Jones tells him to watch the students' faces closely.
Minutes pass.
Nothing, nothing happens.
The TV's on, minutes pass, there's nothing,
nothing's turning on.
The students are in a trance watching the television.
Eventually one student stands up and yells,
there is no party leader is there.
The class turns in shock to look at the student
and then looks back at the television.
The other 199 students were all silent.
Some of them, but some of their posture
was relaxing back to normal.
Jones turns out the television
and says to the students, there is no leader.
There's no such thing as a national youth movement
called the third wave.
Let me show you your future.
Jones turns on a projector right beside the TV
and on the wall images and a film
flash on the wall of Hitler,
Nazi rallies, third Reich marching
with their trained discipline.
People being put into train cars
off to death camps.
Jones begins
lecturing
as this
film about the Nazis
plays.
Are the kids just completely quiet
just watching this?
Some of them are, they're completely quiet
right now. Eventually they all start
break down and crying.
Wonderful.
No one protests.
Everyone's
very kind of
feeling bad.
As Jones is starting
his lecture, the film
finishes and freezes the halt on a single
written frame that says,
everyone must accept the blame. No one can claim
they didn't in some way take part.
Jones says to the class,
you and I are no better
or worse than the German Nazis that we've been studying.
You thought you were better than those
outside this room. You bargained away
your freedom for the comfort of discipline
and superiority. We will watch
our neighbors be taken away and do nothing.
We are just like those Germans.
We would give up our freedom for the chance
of being special.
Jones then, I think,
as you should have expressed
his remorse and apologized to the class
for all the trauma that he had
caused.
But he decides to give one kind of
final lecture to kind of, I don't know,
trying to smooth things over, which again
this has already gone way too far
and has made too many bad choices up to this
point. But this is the last
thing he does for this experiment.
Here's
a paragraph
from Jones here.
Through the experiment the last week, we've all tasted what it was like
to live and act under Nazi
Germany. We learned what
it was like to create a disciplined social
environment to build a special society,
pledge allegiance to that society,
replace reason with rules.
Yes, we would have all made good Germans.
We would have put on the uniform and turned
our heads as friends and neighbors were
cursed then persecuted.
We all know in a small way what it feels like
to find a hero, to grab
a quick solution, to feel strong
and in control of destiny.
We know the fear of being left out, the pleasure
of doing something right and being rewarded, to
be number one, to be right,
to be taken to the extreme
as we've seen and perhaps felt what those actions
will lead to.
We each have witnessed something over the past week.
We have seen that fascism is not just something
that other people do. No, it's right
here in this room. It's in our own personal
habits and it's in our way of life.
Scratch the surface and it appears something
in all of us. We carry it like a disease.
The belief that human beings
are basically evil and therefore unable to act
well towards others. That's what fascism
breeds on. It's the belief
a belief that demands a strong leader and
discipline to preserve a social order.
Which
is not a terrible
thing.
It's a weird thing to say
after creating
fascism,
but he's not wrong
about the thing that he created.
Yeah.
He finishes up
this small talk
the same way this all started.
He asks the class
if they, like the regular Germans,
will claim ignorance and claim
non-involvement.
Quote, if our enactment
of the fascist mentality is complete
not one of you will ever admit to being
at this final third wave rally.
Like the Germans, you will have trouble admitting
to yourself that you've come this far. You will not
allow your friends and parents to know that you
were willing to give up individual freedom and power
for the dictates
of this social order and unseen leaders.
You can't admit to being manipulated
to being a follower.
You're accepting the third wave
as your way of life.
You won't admit to participating in this madness
and you'll probably keep this
this day and this rally secret
a secret that I will share with you.
Which Jones was eventually wrong about.
Jones himself wrote about this
in semi-detail
about like four years later after meeting a student
while shopping
who gave him a third wave salute and they kind of got him upset.
Then he wrote down like...
Oh yeah, he got upset about the fascism that he made.
Yeah.
Then he wrote an essay about it.
But students definitely do talk about it.
We'll hear from some students
in a bit.
Great.
But Jones turned off the projector
that still had
everyone must accept the blame.
No one can claim that they weren't involved
or no one can claim that they didn't in some way take part.
So he turns out the projector
then he sees
Robert who was sobbing
as many other students were as well.
Jones hugged Robert as he was crying
and slowly students left the auditorium.
And that's the experiment.
So that was what happened.
That was the five day...
Sounds like he may have permanently damaged some kids.
He did.
There's a lot of kids
now they're like adults in their 50s
and 60s.
A lot of people think
it was a good experience for them as a kid.
But a lot of people say
no, this did an irreversible damage to it.
Yeah.
It's an interesting experiment
and a useful one if you want to study fascism.
But it's bad that he did it to small children.
Yes.
15 year olds mainly.
So now we're left wondering
why was the experiment so effective?
Especially for being only five days.
Now I do think Jones had a pretty solid understanding
of fascism in some ways
and he actually explains a lot of it
well.
This is a quote from Jones.
You have to understand the times
there was a radical...
No, sorry.
There was racial integration taking place in the high school
for the first time.
And that threw the school kind of upside down.
And all of the young men were facing the draft
when they graduated.
I was basically promising
I can make you safe again.
This was written before Trump ran.
So the whole...
Yeah.
A good thing to think of
was the whole I can make you safe again thing.
Multiple students...
Yeah.
Multiple students bring up
Vietnam as a
heavy contributing factor for why they
fell into this.
Especially bought into the whole national movement thing.
And as well, of course,
Jones had a lot of natural charisma
and strength as a leader.
This is a quote from a student.
A big reason I went along with it
was my trust for Jones.
And I was just beginning to feel bitter about Vietnam.
And the experiment seemed like we could change the government
responsible for hurting us.
There was a feeling that something really remarkable
was going to happen
going on throughout the whole country.
And the movement was going to change politics,
change the structure of the school.
The combination of everything just made it happen.
And a lot of the men
who talk about what it was like in the experiment
bring up the fear of Vietnam
being a pretty
heavy factor for why they
bought into the whole national movement.
Yeah, you're growing up into a world
that seems dangerous and
unhealthy for you.
And so you
embrace a strong man
in a hope that he can bring things back
to an imagined past that you barely remember
from your childhood.
Yeah.
Yep, okay.
The other thing that Jones makes a note of
is who really thrived under the wave.
It's those people like Robert,
the ones that neither excelled in school
nor caused much trouble.
Quoting Jones,
I was accustomed to two very intelligent girls
and the troublemakers in the back of the room.
But what the wave generated was a major rule
for the great majority
who stayed quiet and barely got through school.
I realized that as a teacher
I had probably ignored them for the most part.
And all of a sudden this great massive energy
took place and they were all brilliant
in their own way.
That were neither really good at school
nor terrible.
Just as people kind of barely
getting by.
In another interview, Jones says
it was the middle group that became energized.
They became the winners for a brief moment.
And that's the thing that's also
the two things that come up the most often
when reading about this from students
and other teachers and the principal
was one being
Vietnam, oh yes also Jones being
very charismatic.
The other one was like it gave
this middle group that were kind of being ignored
at the time release something to do
and that's what they really latched on to.
Yeah, the next
step I did after doing all the research
for the third wave stuff
was just doing a brief
reentry
into fascist studies
to kind of see if I can pick up any other
similarities between
what Jones did and what
these people talk about as being the traits
or passions of fascism.
So I was looking at Robert
Paxton's work
for the underlying passions.
Yeah, an author of Anatomy of Fascism
which is one of the best academic
treatments of the subject.
Yeah, and almost every
passion he has, his
theory is that
fascism
is caused by these
feelings that we have in humans
and then that causes us to do different actions.
And all the passions that he
talks about that kind of cause fascism to happen
are all present in some degree
for the third wave.
We obviously had the supremacy of the group
which is one of the traits.
The Vietnam War was definitely
the overwhelming crisis that traditional
solutions couldn't fix for a lot of the men
at least there.
For all the teenagers who were facing the draft
and who didn't want to go.
There was a little bit of group
victimization with the warring poster wars
but not as much.
We definitely had an authority
of the male leader
which was Jones.
We definitely had
superiority of the leader's words
over abstract and universal reason
in his announcement of the third wave
like rally and Jones even says
during his final lecture that
in times of uncertainty it's easy to replace
reason with rules. So yeah, it's like this
thing
that we replace our
natural logical thought process with this
undying devotion to this leader
no matter how crazy things they say
is that you still believe it because
they're offering you something in exchange
which of course we can also
tie it to the president and stuff.
In terms of the love of violence
the violence was minimal
but it was definitely there.
There were fistfights on the hallways
they beat up that school reporter
if I call it minimal.
It could have been worse I think.
It could have been what happened
in Nazi Germany.
From the perspective of this
being a high school history class
I don't know how much worse it realistically could have been.
You're right.
In terms of a high school history class
there were five days there was a lot of violence.
The other two passions
that Paxton talks about
are dread of the groups decline
in their corrosive effects of
individualistic
liberalism
and the need for closer integration
into a pure community.
This is where things get a little bit more complicated
because a defining aspect
of fascism is that it's self-contradictory
and ideologically inconsistent
and the way that I often see
that surface in fascism is that how
fascism is both heavily individualistic
and heavily group oriented
and community driven as we see from
a community
chance and stuff.
But I think part of
how this works is that
the idea of community
and the idea of being
in this special group
basically gives you the opportunity to pursue
being an individual hero.
It's this fake support system
that lets you be this individual
person.
It's the same thing we see with the proud boys
and with these other sort of like...
Yeah, it's the same thing with the police.
If you look at the warrior training they do
it's both like, no, you have to help other officers
when in like a moment you can't question them
it's part of this very community driven thing
but also they're training to be the individual warrior
sitting on a rooftop with their cape
flying in the wind.
It's both of those aspects.
The good old fashioned cult of the hero
that is kind of central
to American culture
because it's very easy to market
because you can sell people body armor
and all the gear that they need
to make themselves into a hero
but then they don't have anybody to fight and kill
because that's what we say heroes do
so they start going out into the streets
and finding people to do it too.
Yeah, it's great. It's very good.
Speaking of cult of the hero
which is the other kind of main scholar of fascism
which Umberto Eco
one of his 14 traits of fascism is the cult of the hero.
Yep.
And then the next after I looked into Paxton
the other I looked over
Umberto Eco's 14 traits
and tied a few of them pretty clearly.
Some of them don't fit as perfect
because of how
small and young the third wave was.
Like it didn't, you know
a lot of Paxton's trait
and a lot of them Eco's traits
are for like actual political parties
which they didn't quite get to
but you can definitely see the seeds being planted there.
Yeah.
Of course we have the cult of tradition
with the third waves emphasis
on creating discipline
and creating those traditions themselves.
Rejection of modernism
and going back to the old strict teaching style
and away from the loose modern style of the late 60s
and the style that like Jones was really into
which is like you know the very loose experimental thing.
The cult of action for action's sake
was basically the focus of the whole day
remember the whole straight through action day?
Yes.
So that definitely happened.
Disagreement was absolutely treason as people were banished
to the library for just you know
and as Jones mentions
there were appeals to social frustration
with the new racial integration in the school
and the looming draft.
Jones writes of fascism
quote fascism is always a possibility
because it's so simple and people are frustrated.
They lose their jobs, their dignity, their sense of worth
and someone comes along and says
hey I've got this answer.
So the rest of
the rest of Iberdeco's traits
like the fear of difference, obsession with the plot
between me being strong and weak, contempt for the weak,
life as warfare, machismo and weaponry,
selective populism and Newspeak
again those get into a little specifically
they do those get a little too specifically
into national politics
to make really easy comparisons to the third wave
but I can definitely see the seeds being planted there
with like Jones talking about the third wave
like national party and stuff.
I think those would have absolutely developed very quickly.
Especially I think
you can even you know machismo and weaponry
to some degree with like the whole car club
and the bodyguards themselves
and there was definitely
a little bit of Newspeak going on.
Now Jones does regret
doing the experiment
as he says in almost every
interview when he talks about it
saying it was way too dangerous and way too damaging.
Yes.
Yeah.
Yeah.
But he still recommends people actually study and learn from it
since it did happen
you may as well focus on it
but he does he does he does
regret doing it.
In fact
reading a book on the waves actually required
reading in Germany for like all schools
they're required to
read a whole book about the waves
because Germany actually cares about not
fostering a culture of fascism.
Yeah.
It's just a fun little circle there
from learning about Germany
and their world history class.
You fucked up so badly
that Germany decided
to make what you did
a cautionary tale about fascism.
Like a required thing for school.
Yeah.
That's good to be in a teacher.
Congratulations.
You did it.
Many students look back on the experiment as a positive learning experience.
One student
who became a filmmaker
made a whole documentary on the topic
and interviewed a lot of students.
But there are many many students
and a lot of parents who are very upset
at Jones for the experiment
and thought it was way too damaging for their young psychies.
Oh no way.
Yeah, so big shock.
Two years after the experiment
ended
Jones was denied
tenure at the school and was fired.
Wow.
That took too long.
But here's kind of the twist.
Jones was fired under pressure from the conservative parents
conservative school board
who accused Jones of indoctrinating students
into radical leftism
instead of just teaching them.
He was fired for being a socialist
and he was fired for his links
to his anti-war activism.
Oh.
So not for recreating Naziism.
He wasn't fired for the experiment.
He was fired for being a political activist
and quote unquote indoctrinating students until being like
leftists.
Yeah.
There were actually huge student protests
that Jones was being fired
because he was still by far the most popular teacher
in the school.
God, all of this is so bad.
All of this bodes so ill for the human condition.
Awesome. Fantastic.
I...
Oh.
Like the thing he should have gotten fired for
is the fascist experiment.
Was making a concentration camp
in the library or maybe when his body guards
were beating people.
He shouldn't have been fired for
turning kids into commies.
But like not by experiment.
I mean, I would say this.
He should have been fired for turning
children into... Into fascists.
Into anything really. Like you shouldn't be
ideologically brainwashing children
either way. Yeah.
But the communism wasn't the problem.
No, and he wasn't doing experiments to lead people into communism.
He was just teaching...
He was just actually...
He was fired for just teaching a history class
and actually learning about
the labor movement and stuff like that.
And conservative parents didn't like that.
And the principal says...
The principal says he fired him
because he was...
The way he was teaching students
about
radical movements,
students were becoming too sympathetic
to these racial justice causes
and labor rights causes.
So that's why he was fired.
The third wave has since been adapted
into a few books, an 80s TV film,
a focus of multiple documentaries,
one of which being made by a student.
They made a whole German live-action film
on it, and a German TV
show, because again, they care about this in Germany.
And Jones also wrote a musical
based off the third wave.
They don't... Great.
So...
And since...
Jones has spent his time...
I mean, after in the 70s,
he became a very... He had a brief stint of being a punk rocker.
Which is just fun.
Great.
And then he became, just to go writer,
written about 30 books, including some children's books.
Oh, good. He should be
influencing children's minds.
He's actually an award-winning author.
And he's currently a teacher
for special needs adults
in disability schools.
And that's the third wave.
See,
I wouldn't let that guy around kids anymore.
No, he's not around kids. He's teaching adults
Oh, okay. Well, alright.
I don't really want him around adults either.
Yeah, I don't...
By all means, he is a very, like, good teacher
when he's actually teaching.
But as long as he doesn't turn all the
adults with special needs into Nazis,
then I don't know...
It does seem like he did that once
and might again.
So, what's your kind of
insights? Because, like,
you read about fascism
on an often basis.
Scans. Like, the terrifying thing
here is how quickly
it happens and how easy
it is to get children on board something like that.
Because all you need to do, like, he's right.
Like, the thing that he observed
is very obvious, which is that
when you have... when you create,
like, you go into a system that's
kind of static, like, you've got this high school,
everybody has their places in it, everybody has
kind of their places in the social order.
And there's a lot of people who aren't special,
who don't do well in school, or athletics,
who aren't popular, who are just sort
of there. And you provide them
with a way that they can be
better than everyone.
And it's by embracing
this new movement. Like, that's the thing
that you do. It's the thing that Trump did, is you had all these
people who didn't really have
any kind of, like, they...
You know, our society
has been increasingly stratified. There's
an increasing gap between the rich and the poor.
And there was a large chunk of people who didn't
really have anything to feel
good about. Like, they were struggling at work.
They didn't like their jobs. Their education
hadn't gotten them anywhere. They were
bogged down with debt. And then Trump comes
in and says, hey,
I'm going to give you a chance.
I'm going to, like,
make a new thing that you can reinvent
yourself as a part of. Like, that's where all these
proud boys came from. It's where a lot of these,
like,
like, Patriot coalition, Patriot prayer
types, they're these people who
didn't really have anything
to do. And suddenly, fascism
gave them a way to
be special in a group of people to attack.
Which is what you need.
And it's a group of people that's the thing that,
you know, separates that from, like, what Bernie Sanders did.
Yeah. Is that
Trump's
solution was regressive. And going
back to a fake history.
Whereas, you know,
movements in the left usually try to move
forwards. Now, when movements on
left gain an authoritarian leader and move forward, that still,
you know, ends up bad. Because
that's what authoritarianism does.
But fascism is so insidious in that,
you know, it's way more comfortable
to people because it's appealing to this
past sense
of society. And usually the past
isn't as scary as, like, a new thing
in the future. That's why a lot of people
get hooked on it. Yeah. And you see, what you
saw in this experiment was, like, as soon as
you get, as soon as
these kids realize, as soon
as, like, the people who kind of embrace this,
like, start to
feel attached to it. Because it's
given them a way to be special. It's given them
a place. It's given them something to fight for.
They will use, without
thought, violence to protect it.
Because they can't, they
are, like, horrified at the thought
of going back to the old
order in which they weren't special.
In which they didn't have a place.
Like, that's the
thing that also scares me about
what's going to happen in 2021. Like, as
we've been talking about this on
Twitter, somebody posted a picture of, like,
one of the people heading to DC
this weekend for the big Trump rally.
And it was, like, it was a guy who had, like, a
Spartan helmet that had Trump 2020
on it. It was in blue and red. And he had, like,
a Trump 2020 Make Liberals
cry again shirt and, like, board
shorts that had Trump's face
as Captain America on them. Like, right over the
crotch, which was weird. And then a
Trump 2020 flag that he was wearing
as a cape. And it's, like, yeah, the
movement, this fucking
fascist movement that Trump created
in the United States, gave this guy
something that makes him
feel special, that makes him feel like, things
can't be going all that well for that dude.
Which is not to say that, like, only because, obviously,
Trump's voters tended to be higher income,
more often than lower income. But, like, he was
not happy with things
before Trump. Trump gave him
something to feel like a part of and something
to struggle against. This vague idea
of the left of liberals.
So he has an enemy and he has
a purpose. And he's
not going to just, like,
you know, it's the thing that, it's the problem
that the teacher had with
the wave, is that, like, well, now that you've built this
thing, how do you go back? You can't just
stop it all of a sudden. Yeah, it's going to fuck
these people up. And they're either going to wind up
weeping, which is the best case scenario,
or getting violent.
Yeah. And, you know, the week after the wave happened,
they basically sent, in his
class the week later, it was basically just a week
full of therapy. Yeah.
That was what he did. He did not, they didn't, like,
just move on to Russia.
It's like, no, like, they spent a whole week basically doing
therapy because they were all, you know,
very messed up. Yeah.
I mean, we could use some of that
here, but it won't happen. Instead, they'll just
buy more guns, which is why ammunition
is sold out. But they could
buy 4,000 rounds of
blanks by accident. There was that guy on 4chan
who bought 45,000, 4500
rounds of 5.45 by 39
blanks and thought they were real bullets
and then was very sad, which is quite
funny. He's the best case scenario.
He lost money and got useless bullets. Yeah.
He lost money and got bullets that he can't use
to kill people. Yeah.
Yeah. Unless it's Bruce Lee. Sorry. Oh God.
Yeah. So that's kind of all I have here on the topic.
Yeah.
I'm trying. Yeah. That's kind of,
that kind of hits all of the boxes I wanted to talk
about. Yep. Well, Garrison,
thank you for
coming me out. Normally, it's my job to bum
other people out. It is great. We'll return to that
next week. I'm two for two on
child abuse for my episodes.
What's up with the theme, Garrison? Oh,
I mean, those are all the best episodes
is where children get abused. That's what people
come to the show for, is to watch kids
be traumatized. Yeah. I mean, it also
I guess I'm good for writing
that because I am previously
a child. You were a child
unlike Sophie and I. Yeah. I thought
they came for your sparkling personality, Robert.
No, no, they come
for the child abuse.
But I mean, as someone who was
as someone who was like more
conservative when I was like 15,
the same age as all of these people, I can
I can easily see
if I was in this scenario,
I would have also absolutely followed suit,
which is why when I read
this book as a 15 year old, I'm like, oh,
wait. Oh, no.
There's some problems here, which
eventually, you know, got me to
not be conservative anymore and learn
more about fascism. Well, that's good.
So I guess it's all it's good then that
he traumatized those kids. Yeah, because
the weird thing about this is like, I read
this book as part of a Christian homeschooling
curriculum and I don't know
why they included it because everything else
was kind of just opposite to this.
So I'm not sure why they included this
book, but I mean,
thanks, I guess
they included this book and one
book on the history of
labor in the 20th century.
And those were the those are the books that got
me. I mean, I still had like hundreds of
hundreds of other books that were just like
conservative propaganda, but they included
these these were the only two books that had
like a left bent and they and they kind of
they got me. They're like, oh, wow, this was
a new thing that's different from everything
else I was reading and was kind of more
interesting and made more sense.
Yeah, I don't
know. They should if
from their perspective, they shouldn't include
the book, but I'm very happy they did.
So, yeah.
Great. Yay.
Well, Garrison, you got anything to plug before we roll out?
I guess my
Twitter, if you want to see
occasional street reporting, occasional
probably around stuff.
Oh, and my kitten. Yeah.
And now also I'll be offering occasional
kitten content
for those
obliged also soonish.
I'll be releasing like a 10 minute short
documentary about
Portland protests on my YouTube channel,
but I've been putting off doing the editing
on that for like a month because I'm
busy and lazy. So eventually
that'll be out so you can go go to my
YouTube as well. But mainly
Twitter. Yeah.
At Hungry Botai. I guess I should say it.
That'd be useful. Or you can just Google my name
because that's all you need to do.
Yay. Well,
everybody, this has been a fun episode
of the podcast.
It hasn't. But I had
I had a lot of laughs. I'm glad you had a lot
of laughs. I'm bummed.
I'm going to go to the gym and cry
and get COVID.
Don't act like that's different from yesterday.
Yeah. Anyway,
thanks for listening to the podcast,
everybody. Now go
find a high school class to radicalize
and then haphazardly
de-radicalize
for questionable
academic benefit. Zoom
bomb them and turn them all into fascists.
Yeah. Zoom bomb them in the Nazis.
Or find a kitten and give it love.
The kitten is asleep
in my lap now. Oh my God.
His little heads just
hanging over my hand.
Bloody.
That's the episode's done.
Alphabet Boys is a new
podcast series that goes inside
cover investigations.
In the first season, we're diving into an FBI
investigation of the 2020
protests. It involves a cigar
smoking mystery man who drives a silver
hearse. And inside his hearse was like a lot
of guns. But are federal agents catching
bad guys or creating them?
He was just waiting for me to set the date,
the time, and then for sure he was trying
to get it to happen. Listen to Alphabet Boys
on the iHeart Radio App, Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcast.
Did you know Lance Bass
was a Russian trained astronaut?
That he went through training
in a secret facility outside Moscow
hoping to become the youngest person
to go to space?
Well, I ought to know. Because
I'm Lance Bass.
And I'm hosting a new podcast that tells
my crazy story and an even crazier
story about a Russian
astronaut who found himself stuck in space
with no country to bring
him down. With the Soviet Union
collapsing around him, he orbited
the earth for 313
days that changed the world.
Listen to The Last Soviet
on the iHeart Radio App, Apple
Podcast, or wherever you get
your podcasts.
What if I told
you that much of the forensic
science you see on shows like CSI
isn't based on
actual science?
And the wrongly convicted pay
a horrific price?
Two death sentences and a life without
parole. My youngest,
I was incarcerated two days after her first
birthday. Listen to CSI
on trial on the iHeart Radio
App, Apple Podcast,
or wherever you get your podcasts.