BiggerPockets Money Podcast - 142: Ask Us Anything: Questions From the Audience with Scott & Mindy

Episode Date: September 14, 2020

Scott & Mindy sit down today to answer questions sent in by listeners. They address topics all over the board - from student loan repayment and early retirement account withdrawal under the CARES act, to the best high-yield savings accounts, and planning for the gap between early retirement and traditional retirement age when you can access your retirement accounts penalty free. Scott & Mindy also discuss different investing platforms as well as retirement planning, taxes, and even how inflation might affect your retirement future. They take a couple of calls from listeners to chat about the best current use of retirement funds.  This episode will help clear up some of the questions you may be having on your road to early financial independence. Links from the Show BiggerPockets Money Facebook Group BiggerPockets Forums Robinhood Facing Multiple SEC Investigations Into Its Business Practices How to Access Retirement Funds Early What Is a Self-Directed Brokerage Account? BiggerPockets Money Podcast 119 BiggerPockets Money Podcast 116 with JL Collins Check the full show notes here: https://www.biggerpockets.com/moneyshow142 Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome to the Bigger Pockets Money podcast show number 142, where Scott and I answer your most pressing questions. Understand if it's really changing the math for you or setting them into a new bucket where it really does change your approach or whether it's having a very modest impact and it doesn't really change what you're doing. If you're going to pay them off early, you continue paying them off early. If you're not going to pay them off early, you were going to invest anyways. And this just confirms that even more. Hello, hello, hello. My name is Mindy Jensen. And with me, as always, is my astonishingly well-rounded co-host, Scott Trench. Man, well, these introductions are just coming full circle every week, Mindy,

thank you. Scott and I are here to make financial independence less scary, less just for somebody else, and show you that by following the proven steps, you can put yourself on the road to early financial freedom and get money out of the way so you can leave your best life. That's right. Whether you want to retire early and travel the world, go on to make big time, investments in assets like real estate, start your own business, or just have simple money questions answered. We'll help you build a position capable of launching yourself towards those dreams. Scott, today we have a different kind of show. We don't have a guest today. It's just you and me answering questions that come directly from our listeners. They had some great questions,

and some of them are questions that we hear over and over again. So we hope this helps clear some of these things up. You can always ask a question in our Facebook group, which is filled with people just like you. And you can find that at Facebook.com slash groups slash BP money. Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture, including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. And if you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going. And more importantly, where your tax refund can make the biggest impact. Because the goal isn't just to look backward. It's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch.

Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments, net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your phone or your laptop. Feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch subscription with the code pockets. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves the needle.

Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch, the all-in-one tool. that makes money management simple. Use the code Pockets at monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at monarch.com code pockets. I love Matt, said no one ever. Nobody starts a business thinking, you know what would make this more fun? Calculating quarterly estimated taxes.

But somehow every small business owner ends up doing it. Your dreams of creating, selling, and growing get replaced by late nights chasing receipts, juggling invoices, and wondering if that bad sushi lunch with Scott counts as a write-off. Change all that with Found. Found is a business banking platform built to take the pain out managing money. It automatically tracks expenses, organizes invoices, and even preps you for tax

season without you doing the heavy lifting. You can set aside money for business goals, control spending with virtual cards, and find tax write-offs you didn't even know existed. It saves time, money, and probably a few years of life expectancy. Sound has over 30,000 five-star reviews from owners who say, found makes everything easier, expenses, income, profits, taxes, invoices even. So reclaim your time and your sanity. Open a found account for free at found.com. That's F-O-U-N-D-com. Found is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services are provided by lead bank, member FDIC.

Don't put this one off. Join thousands of small business owners who have streamlined their finances with Found. Audible has been a core part of my routine for more than a decade. I started listening years ago to make better use of drive time and workouts, and it stuck. At this point, I've logged over 229 audio book completions on Audible alone, and I still regularly re-listen to the highest impact titles. Lately, I've been listening to Bigger Leaner Stronger for Fitness, The Anxious Generation for Parenting Perspective and several Arthur Brooks' audiobooks that have been excellent for mental well-being.

What makes Audible so powerful as its breadth. Beyond audiobooks, you also get Audible Originals, podcasts, and a massive back catalog across business, health, parenting, and more. All accessible in one app. If you're looking to turn everyday moments into real progress, Audible has been indispensable for me over over 10 years. Kickstart your well-being journey with your first audiobook free when you sign up for a free 30-day trial at Audible. Scott, before we even start with the questions, I want to give a huge shout out to Anita, who is paying down her debt. She posted in our Facebook group, Hey, Mindy, another debt paid off, $2,800 balance in the books. Thanks for caring, guys. And what I really like about that is it can kind of seem

braggy to tell people in real life, hey, I just paid off another debt. And they're like, wow, whatever, I just racked up more debt, you know? And which, oh, that's so judgy of me. That sounds kind of snotty. But we understand what a huge accomplish. That's okay. I don't think it's snotty. Well, like, oh, I just read it. We're a money show. We want to talk about it. We don't like it when you take on more debt, right? Yes, unless it's a tactful, a strategic debt, like a mortgage. But, you know, we do understand that this is a huge accomplishment. So nice job, Anita. Congratulations on paying off another debt. And I can't wait to hear you say, I am totally debt-free. That's right. Yeah, I saw that post as well. Liked it, gave her a shout-out. And, you know,

I also want to give everybody in the Facebook group a shout-out for selfish reason. Mindy posted that it was my birthday a few weeks ago in there. And 100 people sent me very terrible and awesome jokes that, you know, there was one about a pickle that I particularly relished. And there's a lot of really good. It was just thank you, everyone. I want to give a shout-ups. Did you say it was awesome or awful? Both. They were horrible jokes. But yes, happy birthday, Scott.

Welcome to the other side of 30. Our first call in is from David Perret. Let's go ahead and play his question. Hey, Scott and Mindy, it's David Peret. So John and I were talking after I saw your Facebook posts, we wanted to know why people think the VA loan is worthless. Okay, obviously that's not our joke. I was curious to hear your thoughts on the trend,

going around where real estate investors, at least some, are trying to convince people to liquidate their TSP or 401k under the premise that, quote, stocks are risky. And just curious, what you guys think is the best balance there, because I believe both of you are in the fire community where you believe that stocks have their place in a portfolio and 401Ks, and I would love to hear your thoughts. So thanks. We're calling in from sunny San Diego, California out here in Camp Hamilton. done. So have a great day. Well, this is a tricky question, I suppose. I think that we've interviewed

hundreds of people on this show alone. I've met with hundreds more for coffee. I've interacted with thousands of people online. The vast, vast majority of the folks that I see building sizable portfolios are doing so with a combination of both real estate and stocks on bigger pockets. That's specific to the bigger pockets community, which skews real estate. Some of the louder voices in the community, the folks who, you come on bigger pockets and you post 10,000 times to our forums, right? Are you going to have a bias towards real estate investing? Yes, you are, right? That's why you post 10,000 times to our forums. That's why you might come on our podcast, right? Those are the types of people who really eat, you know, breathe and sleep, real estate investing. And so if you listen to our shows

and those kinds of things, the skew of our guests, I think is going to somewhat reflect that investor who's more concentrated in real estate maybe than the silent but very large majority of investors on the Bigger Pockets platform. So as a general framework, I'd say that most of the people I've talked to tend to have a balanced portfolio with real estates and stocks involved in there. Real estate's great, but they're not probably as concentrated as maybe it might appear from some of the content that we consume on Bigger Pockets in general. So that's first. So the question then, should I liquidate my 401k because stocks are risky and go into real estate? You know, I don't think so, and I don't do that personally.

I'm keeping the money that I've gotten my 401K and my after-tax stock brokerage accounts. And I'm investing in those index funds for the very, very long run. And I'm not touching them. I'm not liquidating them. I'm not changing it. I'm accumulating. I have my strong savings rate and I accumulate savings every month. And I apply some of that to additional.

incremental stocks within those 401ks. Well, I really, I really contribute mostly to a Roth IRA, not a 401k anymore. That's a whole other story. We can certainly get into that, though. And then my after-tax brokerage accounts, in addition to, you know, piling up some money to be able to invest in real estate on a regular basis. So I think there's a balance. And I think it's, personal finance and investing is personal, as you like to say, Mindy. But that would be the framework, general framework I would respond to in responding to David's great question there. Okay, I have a little bit more that I want to say about that because I can't believe anybody is recommending liquidating your 401K or your TSP. The TSP, for those of you who are not in the military, is basically the military version of the 401K.

And actually, I found out that's the government employee version of the 401K. I thought it was just for military, and I learned that that's not the case. But anyway, I want to mention something about the dramatic price drop in March, which is, you know, COVID and coronavirus and all this is where. this is coming from, all the rebounded growth since March is practically back up to the top. Yes, it's hovering around and moving. We've got some volatility in the stock market for a variety of reasons. But if you saw the market peak in December of 19 and pulled all your money out and put all of your money back in at the bottom in like mid-March or April,

You're a genius. Do you know how many people listening did that? Zero. Not zero. Point one or one, even zero. Zero people listening to this show did that because you can't time the market. And that's, I'm not saying anybody is silly for suggesting. You know what? I am saying they're silly for suggesting this. You can't time the market. Everybody says this. Jim Collins, J.L. Collins was on episode 116, which was titled Long-Term Investing, COVID Changes Nothing. If you are investing for tomorrow, you probably shouldn't be in the stock market at all. But if you are investing for long term, which is what we're all doing, the stock market is going to have its ups and downs, but it almost always goes up and to the right. That's right. Long term, nothing changes. I think about my investing core philosophy, right? I'm going to invest in those next months for the very, very long term. I'm not selling. I know I'm going to get markets like the COVID environment over. the next 30 years in which I plan to invest. So I'm patient. We've discussed that at length. I think now that I'm thinking about it, I think what David's really trying to get at is the, hey, I think Congress in March passed a resolution that says you can withdraw money from your 401k or TSP that normally would incur a 10% penalty. But that penalty is being waived. And look, when you

withdraw, let's say you withdraw up to $100,000, I think is the limit from your 401K, knowing now that you can't, you're not going to have to pay that penalty. I think you have three years to pay back those taxes and replace any money that you took out under that that rule. Should I take that out of my 401k and invest in real estate? It maybe is more specifically the question that maybe is more nuanced there. And to that, I'd say, I don't know. I think that would depend on an investor-specific situation. I could see a situation in which someone's sitting there and they've got most of their net worth in home equity in their 401k. They don't have much liquidity in the form of cash with which to invest in real estate. They've spent hundreds or hundreds of hours, maybe even a thousand

hours reading content around real estate investing and feel ready. Maybe under that circumstance, this is a reasonable opportunity to attempt your hand at real estate investing. If you kind of feel it you really clearly understand the rules around that withdrawal, are willing to pay the taxes on that and feel that you can get that excess return while still having a balanced portfolio. What do you think about that one, Mindy? That's a controversial topic that I think hasn't a clear answer. That is a good point and not what I took from David's question, but I can see now that you're saying that that maybe that's what he was asking. Okay, so I would say, is there a time limit that you have to withdraw these funds? Do you have to withdraw them in 2020? I'm not

quite sure. That I do not know. Okay. Let's see. The devil's in the details, right? The devil is in the details. Let's just say that you have to withdraw in 2020. If you don't have a place to put the money, then no. You should not withdraw the money. If you are watching your market and you're seeing deals and you find a smoking hot deal and you don't have the funds for it and the funds are in your 401k and you know your market, like you said, you've done the research, then I can see an argument that that would make sense, that you pull the money out because there's no penalty, you pay taxes either over the course of three years or all at once in three years, but keep that tax bill in the back of your head because you are going to have to pay taxes on it

unless you have an incredibly lucrative career, you may not have the money in your prepaid tax amount to the government and you will have to come out of pocket to the government to pay that tax bill. make sure you have the funds to do that in advance so you're not scrambling. I think it's as long as you're in fitting a pretty specific set of circumstances, right? That person who doesn't have, is responsible financially, has that financial foundation, but just has most of their liquidity in their, or most of their net worth, maybe in their home equity in retirement accounts, hasn't built up the high savings rate or the

after tax assets with which to invest. And that, you know, and has also put in those, that long, log of hundreds of hours listening to the Bigger Pockets real estate podcast and lots of books and those types of things and fuels ready to invest. Maybe in that very specific circumstance, we've got a good case to go ahead and withdraw early because you're not just going to spend it on a boat. You're going to put it into something that maybe even can produce excess returns over the next 30 years far better than the 401K. That's a pretty specific situation, but I could see that be in a reality for some people. Yes. I, completely agree with that. So let's recap, if you are well educated and well capitalized with an eye

on the tax bill that you will be paying on any funds that you don't return to the 401k before the three years is up, then it and a smoking hot deal, it could be argued that that's a good move. If this is your first property, if you're not well educated in real estate investing, if you just see a property that's cheap, then no, you should do more research. And, you know, it's always better to lose out on a potential investment than to make a really bad choice. Yeah. And I'd be really uncomfortable the entire time I'm going through that process, even if I am reasonably close to that mold that we just described in that specific circumstance. It's just once the money goes into the 401k, for me, I don't, it's gone. I don't touch it again until I'm at retirement age, and I know that, right? And that's,

That's my philosophy all along. The 10% penalty can be that or the removal of that 10% early withdrawal penalty could be the catalyst to put in a couple of very specific situations in a position where that makes sense from a long-term perspective. But I think you're going to have to be really honest with yourself and critical about whether that's a good move before you do it. So how's that for a very thorough answer to David Paray's great question there. Yes. Yes. I think that we've covered that one. Okay. Next up is George. George has a question that I actually hear very frequently, so I'm super glad that he sent it in. He says, what type of account would you suggest using for your savings to buy your next investment

property? It needs to be liquid within a year, for me at least. I currently use Betterment's big purchase savings account. So far, the growth has been very good, but I would love to hear Mindy and Scott's advice. So I'm going to take this one first and then let you chime in later, Scott. But in this environment of super low mortgage interest rates and super low interest rates in general, you're not going to be finding a great deal on a savings account. So when he says that he uses, or so far the growth has been very good, I should have asked him for further clarification, like what does very good mean? I have what I consider to be a high yield savings account and it pays me 0.8%.

So high yield used to mean double digits in the 80s. but you're not going to be finding these super good deals. And frankly, I'd rather have a 30-year mortgage at 2% than a high-yield savings rate that their savings account that pays me, what, 2%, 1%. I'd rather have that mortgage. Yeah, I keep my savings. I don't think I have a wonderful answer to this question, frankly. I wonder if I should go and check out Betterment's big purchase savings account.

So it's not sponsored by Betterment, I don't think. But, you know, I don't use that. Maybe I should go check it out. my money in ally savings account. Alli is also not a sponsor of this show. We're just plugging all of these things that I use. But yeah, I keep my money in ally in my savings account. And I get probably around that 0.8%.

The interest rates have lowered up recently because of the lower interest rates from the Federal Reserve. So look, I think the answer is like, if you're saving up for your next investment property and the timeline is pretty short, some kind of high yield savings account, maybe a money market account, maybe even like a CD or something that was up with one year return. I mean, it's just, it's just, I don't think there's a lot of good options right now

for savers that are looking for a lot of, a very stable, low volatility way to earn yield on your savings. I just, I don't think it's a good environment for that. And we're talking about the difference between maybe like a 0.75 and a 1.25, maybe up to 2%, if some listeners can get creative. But let's go ahead and post this in the Money Facebook group as well and see what some of our listeners come back with. Maybe we'll get some more good suggestions about that. Yes. And Scott, you mentioned the big one that is always recommended. Ally Bank is an online bank. They don't have any physical locations, if I remember correctly. So they don't have to staff it with people in their physical locations and they pay the highest

rate, which right now is 0.8. Before it dropped, it was 1. You're just not getting a really great high yield. I mean, they call it a high yield savings account, but high yield is definitely a misnomer here. But yes, we will post this in the Facebook group. And if you have a suggestion that pays you higher than 0.8 currently, please chime in and let us know. Okay, back to taxable accounts. Ryan writes in, I was planning on using a taxable account to bridge the gap between early retirement, semi-retirement, and age 59 and a half. After listening to episode 18, I'm really interested in the Roth conversion ladder approach as well. When using the Roth conversion ladder, can you only withdraw your original contribution after five years, or can the growth be

withdrawn as well? Episode 18 featured the mad scientist, so I went to him directly and asked him, and he confirmed that you can only withdraw the converted amount. And he shared a link to his epic tell-all article called How to Access Retirement Funds Early. We'll include a link to that in our show notes, which can be found at biggerpockets.com slash Money Show 142. Scott, do you want to give a little bit about the Roth conversion ladder for people who are listening? And they're like, what is that? You know, the Roth conversion ladder at the highest level is this concept of putting money into a tax

deferred retirement account, like a 401k, and then let's say that you earn $100,000, $200,000 a year, high income, relatively speaking, just help me articulate this example better. So you're earning a high income, you're in a high tax bracket. Every dollar you put into the 401k, which is tax deferred, you're deferring income while you're in a high tax bracket. Then suppose that you take, you retire early or you take a year and travel the world. That year, or in those years after you leave your job, you're now in a very low-income tax bracket. So when you, maybe you were, maybe you were at a 35% income tax bracket while you're earning money, right? So every, every dollar, 35 cents that is gone to the federal government. Well, when you retire, maybe you're earning very low,

a low amount of income in your tax brackets closer to 20%, right? Well, that's when you would remove money from your 401k and convert it into a Roth. You can do that penalty free, but you incur taxes, but your taxes now are being taxed at a 20% tax bracket in those later years, right? That's the basic, basic framework behind the idea of why this Roth conversion ladder is a powerful approach. Getting into more specifics on this show, I'm going to overwhelm, and I'm not the expert. I have never done it before. That's why we call the mad scientist, and he is the expert and has a wonderful article about it. Go check out that article.

You can find a link to it at biggerpockets.com slash money show 140. two. Perfect. Okay. We are now going to hear a call from Lanny. Lanny has a question that kind of tag teams off of this one. Hey, Scott. Hey, Mindy. This is Lanny from Oahu, Hawaii. I'm currently 25 years old, and my job doesn't offer a 401K plan right now. So my wife and I both have IRAs, but we're not max in the amount currently. Our plan is to do $3,000 a year in each of them. And instead, we're putting the bulk of our savings into a brokerage account, currently using the Robin Hood app. My fear of maxing out the Roth IRA instead of putting more money into the brokerage account is that we want to retire in 12 years when we're 37 years old, and since I won't be able to pull

the bulk of the money from the Roth IRA until we're 59 and a half, would it make more sense to do what we're doing now and put the bulk of our savings into the brokerage account, or would you guys advise me to max out our Roth's IRAs and put the remainder into the brokerage account? Thanks for you guys' self. Love your guys' show. Bye. All right, Lani, thank you very much for the great question.

Look, this is a tricky one, right? And there's people who are going to feel very strongly and there's a really intelligent and lively debate about what the right thing to do here is. Your question is, I think, a really good one. If I put money into the Roth, I can withdraw my contributions to the Roth, tax and penalty-free, early, but I cannot withdraw the gains from my Roth IRA, tax and penalty free early, right? And so,

if I invest all of my wealth into a Roth IRA, and let's say I have a million dollars in my Roth IRA at 37, you know, or whatever, you know, at age 37 when you plan to retire, I can't actually withdraw on those gains and actually live out my early life of financial freedom, right? So what's the correct balance here between putting money into the Roth? IRA and building up net worth in the brokerage account, right? And, you know, look, I kind of in set for life, I'm plugging myself, I don't like to do that too much, but in set for life, I kind of, I think I address some of that conundrum, basically, with the retirement accounts where they exist, their good tools to build wealth, but they also are not real in the sense of contributing to

early financial freedom, unless you kind of think about, unless you have a good bridge in the meantime, to support yourself and your family between the time at which you leave your job and then ultimately go on to reach traditional retirement age. That's a great problem because we're building wealth early in life in the financial freedom and financial independence movement, but a real problem that does need to be addressed. So look, there's a set of complicated mathematical calculations that you can do to figure out the right balance towards that. Or what I kind of recommend is, look, if you want to retire at age 37, I think the maximum you can contribute to a Roth in like in 2020 is $6,000. What's the maximum?

You know what the maximum? I think it's $6,000 if you're under age 50. Yeah. So we can create a difficult problem here or we can potentially create an easy problem, right? And so what I would recommend, what I would challenge you to do is I would say, look, run some math and figure out what the right balance is in the near term. But if you want to retire at age 37, you and your spouse are going to need to accumulate more than $12,000 a year in savings, much sure.

much more. So ideally, you should be able to put the first $12,000 into that Roth within a year or two after you kind of build out your budget and savings rate, max that out, and then have plenty left over to invest those after-tax brokerage accounts. So you're building a tax-efficient portfolio that can be what you use after each traditional retirement age and also a significant post-tax, I guess they're all both post-tax, just a normal brokerage account, right, and have money in there that you're accumulating and building and investing that you can withdraw on in the period between 37 and traditional retirement age. So how's that for a framework to go about answering that, Mindy, do you have anything to add? No, I don't. I still max out my Roth every year because once I

stop working, will probably be before 59 and a half, and then I will have something to withdraw on that I have already paid taxes on because the Roth, you're not paying taxes on when you withdraw it. Yeah, I love the Roth IRA. We have a Roth 401K at bigger pockets. I maxed that out every year now. I did not when I was first getting started because I was saving up for a house hack and building that initial liquidity.

That first $25,000 in personal net worth above the zero mark for me, I thought I could put to better use in the form of a house hack than in maxing out my Roth IRA. At the time, I did not have a Roth 401k through work at the time I was doing that. But I felt that that was a better option for me.

And if I look back, I would do that, again, I would not max out my Roth in that first year. I'd save up for that house hack. But once I got to a position where I was able to accumulate more than like $25,000, $30,000 a year regularly through my savings rate, I began to max out my Roth every year from there on out. And so I really think the reason I like the Roth IRA is because, and excuse me for getting even close to the political spectrum here, but I will, I just wonder if there's a reality which exists. 20, 30 years down the road where tax brackets are not higher. It just seems so obvious to me that we're going to have to increase taxes on the wealthy or the folks, you know, wealthy being people

that achieve five or high income earners downstream. And so any money in a Roth IRA that is not taxable seems like a really powerful investment to me. And so I really like that. Even though I'm in a high tax bracket now, I still choose to invest in the Roth IRA rather than the 401. because I think that the tax brackets will be higher downstream, which maybe I'm wrong, maybe I'm right. I have no idea, but that's how I'm putting my money right now personally. Yeah, I don't think that's political. I think that's a statement of fact. You can't increase the deficit indefinitely. We're either going to inflate our way out of it or tax a way out of it. One helps real estate investors. One helps Roth IRAs, right? Yes, and that's not a political

statement. That's a statement of fact. Okay. Mike has another similar-ish question. My question is about investing platforms. I'm in the early stages of my investing and to this point mostly use Robin Hood. I also have brokerage accounts with TD Ameritrade and Vanguard, although these accounts are not yet funded. I like Robin Hood because of the option to purchase fractional shares. I find that if I can invest any amount, I do it more regularly. I may not always have the $160 to $180 to buy a share of VTI, but I do purchase. just smaller increments multiple times a month. Would I be better off holding out for full shares and buying direct from Vanguard? Alternatively, I believe that Charles Schwab just began offering

fractional shares and know that they come highly recommended by many in the fire community. Although I am not sure if they offer VTI in the fractional variety, and at this point, I am below the VTSAX buy-in requirement. I saw an article on Forbes this week, and it has me second-guessing my choice in Robin Hood. I'd like some advice on my best option for an account that I plan to hold for several decades. So first I want to say that the article that he shares will be linked in our show notes. And I want to note that VTI and VTSAX are the funds that are specific to Vanguard. But those exact funds or so similar you can't tell the difference are available in the other platforms as well. They aren't called VTI because what does VTI stand for? Vanguard.

total? Yeah, I think one is the mutual fund and the other is the ETF and they're the basically equivalents, right? So I believe that the large, the mutual fund is VTSAX and VTI is the ETF. So if you're investing through Vanguard directly, you're going to be able to buy VTSAX through your Vanguard account. If you're not, you don't have a Vanguard account, you're going to buy a publicly traded security called VTI, which is the equivalent of that mutual fund, right? It's called an exchange traded funder ETF. Yes, but VTSAX, what I wanted to say is VTSAX is the Vanguard total stock market exchange. There are others. Fidelity has a fidelity total stock market exchange. I don't know what that's called right off the top of my head, but it's the same thing. It just has a different name because

you're buying it at a different place. So I'm going to let you answer the question about investment. many platforms because I just use one. Yeah, I guess there's two parts here that I'm getting, right? One is... What's the best platform? Yeah, one is, should I use Robin Hood, given the little bit of controversy they had earlier this year? And the second is, should I buy in fractional amounts, or should I save up to buy whole shares and purchase less frequently, right? Look, I think the answer, let's start with the second one first, you know, the one about the increments versus whole shares. Look, I don't think this is a high-stakes decision, frankly, from my point of view. I think it doesn't really matter.

You're not going to look back in 30 years and detect a noticeable difference in your net worth by investing in smaller increments more regularly or in larger increments once a month. If I'm going to try to get my mathematical braid in this and go really, really analytical, I suppose that buying in smaller increments more frequently is actually better than buying in large increments once a month. because you're getting a little bit more money, a tiny bit more money into the market a little faster, right? So if you're looking for the optimal approach, you're having more time in the market if you're buying smaller increments faster. I just do it once a month because it's easier and that's just my cadence that I have for investing.

So look, I don't know what the, you know, I don't think it really matters either way there. I think you do you. And if you're excited to get more money in the market right away, great. That will encourage more savings habits and keep you with less cash to potentially spend on something else. I think that's how I would answer that first question. The second question is about brokerage accounts and specifically Robin Hood and some of the controversy that happened with that. We'll link to the article referenced in the show notes, of course.

But basically, I think the way I understand it as it happened, and please someone correct me if I'm wrong here, but I basically understand that the Robin Hood app crashed or was inaccessible during a period in which the market was tanking back in March, right? when maybe it was high, you know, who knows what caused that crash or what caused that inability to access the account. But people were unable to trade temporarily because the app crashed, right? So does that mean that, you know, and I think it sounds like there's being some sort of SEC or FINRA investigation into that outage, basically, right? So does that mean I should no longer trust this major brokerage with millions of accounts and instead go to like a

Charles Swab and E-Trade, a Vanguard, or another brokerage. You know, look, I use Robin Hood. That news alarmed me slightly. But, like, honestly, it's just a little bit of a pain to sell all of my stuff in Robin Hood and switch over to another brokerage, right? And I'm not super concerned about that because it sounded to me like the outage was a technical thing that affects traders. I'm not a trader.

I dump money in once a month, and I let it sit for 30 years. So for me, that's not really a major concern, but I certainly recognize that as maybe like a growing pain of a new entrance into this space. And so, you know, I think that investors should factor that outage in somewhat to their decision-making if they're choosing a new brokerage. There's a lot to like about Robin Hood. It's easy. But there's also other good brokerages like Charles Swab, Vanguard, Fidelity, e-trade, you know, all these guys that I think are reasonable options out there. There's no, and again, I don't think that the brokerage account for me, is a high-stakes decision. I would be very happy using really any of those. I just pick one and put it all in there for ease of use and ease of consumption. What do you think, Mindy?

I think that that is what I was thinking about saying right as you were saying it at the end. You don't need an account in this brokerage and this brokerage and this brokerage and this brokerage. I also misspoken said I only use one. I actually use both Fidelity and Vanguard. But that's because when I was setting up the accounts, they were whoever I was setting them up with, was either Fidelity or Vanguard. I'm not sure why we have both, but we do, and it's no big deal. It's easy to track with two. Once you get all of these things going, it's harder to keep track of where they are. Look at the fees being charged. Find the one that you're most comfortable with. Frankly, I like Fidelity best. I think their customer service is fantastic. And when I said that VTSAX

has an equivalent at Fidelity, it does. It's called FSKAX, which is, doesn't quite roll off the tongue as easily as a VTSAX does. But don't let that stop you from investing with Fidelity just because their index fund initials don't roll off the tongue so easily. I find that they're both equally easy to use. Great. Yeah, so pick one. And like you said, with Robin Hood, they were down for 17 hours on March 2nd.

March 2nd, for those of you who don't remember, was not the free fall day that we had on the stock market. It was beginning. The market was starting to soften for sure. But like Scott said, this wasn't a malicious outage. This was an overflow of members and growing pains of a new company, I would say. You wonder if just people were starting to panic. And so everyone was checking their accounts and log it in or trying to trade or whatever.

And that overwhelms. I don't know. Who knows, right? You just wonder about those types of things. I imagine that if I'm wrong. Robinhood and I'm this billion billion dollar company, multi-billion dollar company that I'm going to make damn sure that that never happens again on my portfolio. And look, maybe I'll get screwed at some point with that, but I just don't see the need to show. I like how easy it is to use it's

on my phone and I buy my stocks with it. So it may not be the best choice. It is for me and I use it. Exactly. Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture, including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. And if you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going, and more importantly, where your taxed refund can make the biggest impact. Because the goal isn't just to look backward, it's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch. Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments,

net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your phone or your laptop. feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch subscription with the code Pockets. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves in Edle. Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch, the all in one tool that makes money management simple. Use the code Pockets at Monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at Monarch.com code pockets. You just realized your business needed to hire someone yesterday.

How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use Indeed. When it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. That means you can stop struggling to get your job notice on other job sites. Indeed's sponsored jobs helps you stand out and hire the right people quickly. Your job post jumps straight to the top of the page where your ideal candidates are looking. And it works. Sponsored jobs on Indeed get 45% more applications than non-sponsored posts.

The best part? No monthly subscriptions or long-term contracts. You only pay for results. And speaking of results, in the minute I've been talking to you, 23 people just got hired through Indeed worldwide. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit

to get your jobs more visibility at Indeed.com slash bigger pockets. Just go to Indeed.com slash bigger pockets right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash bigger pockets. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring. deed is all you need. When you want more, start your business with Northwest registered agent and get access to thousands of free guides, tools, and legal forms to help

you launch and protect your business all in one place. Build your complete business identity with Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They're the largest registered agent and LLC service in the U.S. with over 1,500 corporate guides who are real people who know your local laws and can help you and your business every step of the way. Northwest makes life easy. for business owners. They don't just help you form your business. They give you the free tools you you need after you form it, like operating agreements, meeting minutes, and thousands of how-to guides that explain the complicated ins and outs of running a business. And with Northwest,

privacy is automatic. They never sell your data and all services are handled in-house because privacy by default is their pledge to all customers. Visit Northwest Registeredagent.com slash money-free and start building something amazing. Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at Northwest Registeredagent.com slash money-free. When the weather cools down, Golden Nugget Online Casino turns up the heat. This winner, make any moment golden

and play thousands of games like our new slot Wolf It Up and all the fan-favorite Hoff and Puff games. Whether you're curled up on the couch or taking five between snow shovels, play winner's hottest collection of slots. From brand new games to the classics you know and love. You can also pull up your

favorite table games like blackjack, roulette, and craps, or go for even more excitement with our library of live dealer games. Download the Golden Nugget Online Casino app and you've got everything you need to layer on the fun this winter. In partnership

with Golden Nugget Online Casino. Gambling problem call ConX Ontario at 1-866 531-2,600. 19 and over. Physically President Ontario. Eligibility restrictions apply. See Golden Nuggetcassino.com for details. Please play responsibly. Leslie sent a note in, what does it mean to have a

self-directed investment account? And we throw around the term self-directed solo 401K, self-directed IRA, rather frequently. I actually have a self-directed solo 401k. My husband is self-employed and I work with him. And if you are self-employed with no other employees other than your spouse, no other full-time employees, you can have a self-directed solo 401K. If that is an option for you, I highly recommend looking into it because it can expand your investment options. Scott, we both work at Bigger Pockets.

Bigger Pockets offers a 401K. Do they offer every single investment option there is under the planet in their 401K? No. Most 401K options are fairly limited. Here, you can choose this fund, this fund, this fund, or this fund. And that's it.

And that's just because a fund manager, a 401k fund manager is going to have to keep track of all that stuff. It's way harder for them to do all that. They just offer smaller options. Is that fair, Scott? That's right. Yeah, the 401K offered through bigger pockets is not self-directed. We choose from a pool of funds, maybe 20 or 30 funds, one index fund or one or two index funds. I dump it all into the index fund with the lowest fees, of course, you know, and go from

there, right? The, a self-directed account, this is where we get confusing, but like my, my Robin Hood app or e-trade or fidelity, if you choose whatever we're a brokerage app, that's probably going to be a self-directed brokerage account, which means that you can just choose any publicly traded security, basically, and type in the ticker symbol and buy or sell shares and maybe even options, depending if you set those, that, that up, you know, stock options, those types of things, puts in calls. So that is a version of self-directed. Sometimes we also use the word self-directed to talk about a retirement account in a sense that goes even beyond that, where we talk about, hey, in addition to being able to buy any stock

through your retirement account like a ETF or a specific company or whatever in a brokerage capacity, there's also options with your retirement accounts just to confuse you even more that allow you to buy things like real estate or alternative assets or private investments with your retirement account money. And that's where you might need to talk to a self-directed IRA company or custodian to give you that enhanced optionality even above and beyond what you get with like an e-trade account on your retirement account. You can go to e-trade and you can set up a brokerage account that's after-tax with just any dollars you have left over. You can go there and set up an IRA. You can go there and set up a Roth IRA. You can set up all these different options.

but perhaps with some of these big brokerage, it's a little bit more difficult to buy a rental property, for example, or invest in a private company or those types of things. And for those options, that's when you'd want to go and think about a self-directed 401K or a plan like that. Yep. And if that is an option, if the self-directed is an option for you, I would definitely recommend checking it out because we have additional benefits available to us as solo entrepreneurs that aren't available to Mindy the W2 employee and that 401K. So it's a great thing to look into more. I have a good article from motleyfool.com that I will link to in the show notes as well that

gives a little bit more information. Now, I want to get, I want to nerd out here for one more second here because I enjoy talking about this stuff. So luckily, this is my job also. All right. So let's talk about that. So we have these concepts. Let's say that you are, huh, that's interesting. Scott said, you know, maybe I can convert my 401k into a self-directed 401k or something like that, where I've got a little bit more control. I hire a custodian, something with the paperwork. What should I invest in with that? Well, I've mentioned this before on the podcast, if you listened in the past. So excuse me, if I'm repeating myself. But I think like an asset like real estate is actually a relatively speaking, poor place to invest money within a 401k. Why do I think that? Because real estate,

estate is already tax advantage, right? You're already getting depreciation. You can defer taxes with a 1031 exchange. You can cash out refi. This is a great plate. Real estate investing is a great thing to do, in my opinion, with money that is not in your retirement account, with money that I just save up outside of that, after tax dollars. Within the retirement account, I like the idea of investing in assets that produce more taxable income. So what might that be? Maybe like note investing would be an interesting thing to do with a self-directed retirement account because, you know, that note is going to produce a private note or a hard money loan or something like that might incur a 10% interest rate. That's all ordinary income if you're lending that out of your after-tax savings. It's going to be

taxed at a very high rate if you're doing that. But inside your retirement account, you can earn that very high return and you get a much better tax advantage from that. So just think about as you're framing this out and whether you want to do with your retirement accounts, if you've got a large number of assets in retirement accounts and you're interested in some of those things, just kind of formulate an approach and maybe talk to your CPA or something like that or your CFP and understand where the biggest advantage

for investing in different asset classes might come relative to the tax consequences of investing in your 401K and outside of it. Oh, good idea. Scott, what do you think about syndications? I have done private loans and syndications in my self-directed solo 401K as well as a mobile home park. Great. So syndications, let's do this. I invest in a syndication.

Okay, I invest in multiple syndications. Syndications are often available only to accredited investors in a traditional sense. An accredited investor earns over $200,000 a year as an individual, $300,000 a year as a married couple or a couple. has over a million dollars in assets. There's also been a recent release from the SEC that says that they're going to, I don't know if this is out yet or whether we have it yet, it was kind of unclear, but there's going to be some sort of certification that folks who do not meet those two criteria or the other less common criteria for the definition of accredited investors to basically take a certification or class of some sort so that they can get the accredited investor certification.

I'm thrilled that that's going to be an option, although I think the details are still very vague. on that. That was big news a few weeks ago. Okay. So with that, if you're an accredited investor, you can invest in a syndication. Syndications can be a wide variety of things, right? The syndications that I've invested in so far are generally large, real estate, you know, basically apartment buildings. So we buy an apartment building, not me, the operator of the syndication, buys an apartment building. They finance the acquisition, just like you would, a rental property with a equity piece, a down payment, and then a loan, right, which is often a bridge loan, they then go in and rehab the property, right? So the equity piece is what they're raising from an

investor like Mendeer or myself, right? Then they'll go in and fix up the property, raise rents, reduce expenses, whatever, and then stabilize and sit on the asset, the apartment complex for a few years, and then either refinance it, use that refinance proceeds to pay off investors or sell the asset, right? So, okay, I'm getting a really complex here. But what happens when this happens is the investor, me, I put money in and there's a big loss in the first year. Why is there a big loss? Because we have to pay fees to purchase the asset. There's a brokerage fee. There's a financing fee. So in all the rehab and expenses go into fixing up the property. So there's a big loss off in the first year or two of the hold. That can be great for you because it can help offset other

income from other investments that are similar, right? And then in later years, that's when you begin realizing the gains. So there can be a lot of really good tax advantages just, you know, from syndication investing. And so I invest in syndications with after tax dollars, or at least the syndications of that I just described. I may invest in syndications that have completely different financial profiles through my 401k in the future because they're likely to realize large amounts of income right away in ways that I cannot apply tax advantages to. But for that basic framework, that's why I like to invest in syndications with after-tax dollars at this point.

You know, another type of syndication, sorry, I'll get going for 60 more seconds, then I'll move on. All right. But another type of syndication might give you what's called a preferred return. So in this syndication, I just described, I'm a common equity investor. I get a big loss at first, and then over the years, I'll be getting increasing amounts of income, ultimately a large payday when they sell the asset. But with a preferred return, what happens is you invest money into an asset and they're going to pay you what's called like maybe an 8 to 10% preff preferred return. That's basically income to you.

So you get it, you loan up, you know, let's say you loan $100,000 to this person or invest $100,000. You get an $8 to $10% pref, right? That's an $8 to $10,000 interest payment per year on that money that you invested. That is going to be very highly taxed. It's going to be very consistent high-taxed income. That would be a good thing to invest with your 401K. So I'm getting really complex here, but hopefully that framework is helpful to those of you who are thinking about the future and what to do with the money in your 401K versus the money

that you had saved up outside of that, maybe in your just bank account or after-tax brokerage account. Sermin over. No, I think that's very helpful. That can be confusing if you're not ready to invest at that level. But there are people who are investing at that level and explaining it or ready to invest in that level explaining that's really helpful. Thank you, Scott. Great. Okay. Anthony sent in a really great question.

And frankly, I want your opinion on this as well, Scott. Anthony says, what do you think about investing into a 401k up to the time that the estimated future value of that account will be funded to 25 times the estimated standard deduction at the time of withdrawal with a goal of minimizing future taxes. Any retirement contributions above and beyond this 401k strategy would be in Roth IRAs or real estate investments with their own tax benefits. And then Anthony ruined it by saying, I love the show, but I love the jokes more. Love it. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you, Anthony. I appreciate that. So those jokes will never retire. All right. Now, we are going to talk about, I think the way the question is worded might be confusing to some listeners.

So let me reword the question. When I pay my taxes every year, I get what's called a standard deduction. I may also get deductions for if I'm married, I'll get deductions, if I have dependents, those types of things, right? So there's a standard deduction. The standard deduction, if we all remember, just changed when the Trump administration changed the tax code a few years ago. Okay? So what Anthony is asking here is, should I just create a 401K contribution? such that my income that I withdraw when I get to the time of a traditional retirement age

is around that deduction threshold or close enough to it where I'm not incurring a hefty tax burden and then shift my approach to a Roth IRA or some other savings approach so that I can maximize tax benefits. And Anthony, I'd say that's a really smart concept. I think you're really thinking through this critically and have something there. But I would just challenge you with a fatal flaw in your assumption or planning in this that would make me not want to address that is the fact that those standard deductions could change. And who knows what that tax code is going to be in 2030, however many years it is to retirement age. So, you know, if you're just a few years from retirement age, maybe that's a potential thing to plan on.

But you're still going to be, you know, hopefully if you're retiring in 65 even, hopefully you're still going to live another 30 years. And over that 30 years, the tax code could change multiple times. So I think that planning around a specific event like that far into the future is likely to backfire and in a way we can't predict. And so what I would do instead is I would think generally through am I in a high income tax bracket now? Am I in a low income tax bracket now? Will I be in a high income tax bracket at retirement age? Will I be at a low income tax bracket at retirement age? And what is the best set of approaches there? I'm sitting here. I'm an overconfident now I guess 30-something year old. And I think I'm in a high-income tax bracket now. I love my job. I love

my career. I think I'm going to be in a high-income tax bracket at retirement age. Therefore, you know, instead of investing, and I think tax rates are going to go up, right? So that's why I'm investing in a Roth 401k with the vast majority of my retirement account use and not in a 401k because I believe that tax rates will go up over time and I'll be in the same or higher tax bracket at retirement age. So I think that that would be a better framework to approach your retirement planning from than the standard deduction as it currently exists and a mathematical computation against that. I'm getting going. Wow, Scott, do you like talking about this? Yep.

Okay, no, I have nothing to add. I think that's great. Scott and I are in different places in our life. We are in different ages. So I am still contributing to a traditional 401k, and I am maxing out my Roth IRA because the Roth will like tide me over until we get to the traditional or 59 and a half where I can start pulling out from the traditional 401K. I also have after tax investments that generate income such as the co-working space in my local hometown. It doesn't generate a ton of income right now. but I don't have to have it generating a ton of income right now.

But even still, it's probably 50% of my monthly spending just in that one investment. And there will be other things that we invested. But we're also, you know, we have an eye to the future. Where am I going to retire at? And once I do, you know, I've got plans in place. So as I have plans in place so I'm not going to starve. And so hopefully I don't have to pull a lot out of my 401K until retirement age. And if you're young right now is the best time to be thinking about this, what are different ways that I can fund the gap?

Yeah, I think there's no one right approach. I just think it's all about the framework that we have and what position in life you're in and what position you want to be in a retirement age. I just I would specifically recommend Anthony not to specifically plan around the standard deduction for what's right now just because, look, I don't know what's going to happen in 2020. with the election. I don't know what's going to happen in 2024, 2028, whatever, but I just would feel reluctant to plan around what seems like a changing and moving target around the tax code and standard deductions. Yeah, I think that's a fair bit of advice.

Okay, our last question comes from Connor. I think this is a really great question, very timely. Should I continue paying student loans while they are in forbearance? and I want to jump in here and say if you have the money to make payments while they are in forbearance, I would say do that. You want to get your student loans away as soon as possible. And what does forbearance mean in the context of student loans?

Because I don't have any, I didn't really pay much attention to that part of the, was that the CARES Act, where all federal student loans are incurring no interest. for this set amount of time? Is that correct, Scott? I think it's something like that. I need to go and double check the specifics of that. But again, I think like this for me comes down to frameworks and having an approach in mind about how you want to do things and run your money, right? And I, look, when I think about paying off debts, forget student loan debts in general, look, I use a framework of there's a don't pay it off early. You'd be better off investing your money or figuring out a way to at to at least get some sort of spread between your debt and investing.

And maybe we call debts with zero to three percent interest in that category, right? Maybe there's definitely pay off that debt. It's a really high interest rate. Maybe that's anything above seven or eight percent interest rate at this point in time, right? It's going to be very hard to invest for a risk-free return, which is what you're getting if you're paying off a seven or eight percent interest debt early to get that anywhere else in the investing world at this point in time, right? And then you have this gray zone in the middle of like, let's call it,

four to six percent, right? Four to six, four to seven, whatever. Those zones are going to change for the individual investor, depending on how confident they are as an investor and how much they hate debt. If you hate debt, a 1% interest rate debt is going to be in the no-go zone, right? But what the student loan forbearance situation has created, in my opinion, is it has taken student loans and it has effectively reduced their interest rates temporarily, right? And so, perhaps if they were in that definitely pay zone, they're now in a gray zone for you, where you're not sure whether to pay them off or whatever, do you have a hard decision about, is it five and a half percent, do I pay it off or do I invest? It's close. I don't know.

Maybe they're now at zero percent temporarily, and that makes the decision easy for you to invest elsewhere or whatever. But maybe they're going to go back to five and a half percent soon. And so all that's really happened is it's gone from five and a half percent interest rate to a five percent interest rate long term because you're getting a temporary reprieve from that interest rate. Does that make sense? So I'm getting going on this, but I guess the answer I would have is understand if it's really changing the math for you or setting them into a new bucket where it really does change your approach or whether it's having a very modest impact and it doesn't really change what you're doing. If you're going to pay them off early, you continue paying them off early. If you're not going to

pay them off early, you were going to invest anyways. And this just confirms that even more. Oh, and I'm coming from a point of in a typical loan payment, a portion of it goes to the principal and a portion goes to interest. And right now, none of your payment is going to interest. So the entire amount would pay your principal. If you were, so I guess tag teaming with you, if you were planning on paying them off early, now you can get just an even bigger jump. So I guess it's only a benefit no matter which way you look at it, right? if it's not, in fact, accruing any interest, which I believe is the case, but I have to double check. But if it's not accruing any interest, then it's just a benefit no matter what, right?

And so it's just going to help you accelerate pay down faster if that's what your goal was. It may change the long-term interest rate profile of the debt in a minor fashion because you have a 5% interest rate, long-term debt that is temporarily for a few months at zero. That may move it to, again, 4.5, whatever it is, that reduces the long-term interest rate effectively on that loan. but it probably is not changing the ballpark of what you're trying to do in a meaningful way. It may just shift it slightly from one category to the next if you buy it my framework. Perfect. Well, Scott, this was a lot of fun. We should do this again.

If you were listening and you have a question for us, please call and leave a message at 877 BPM show. That's BP Money Show. Or 877-27-276-7469. or if you would rather remain anonymous, email money at biggerpockets.com. Or to reach either of us directly, he is Scott at biggerpockets.com and I am Mindy at biggerpockets.com. Anybody who posted a question today or sent us a question or called in, feel free to email

me or Mindy directly if you have any follow questions about what we described in the show here. Also, you can go on to the Bigger Pockets Facebook group, right? Right, Mindy? Yes. And post questions there? Yes, that is Facebook.com slash groups slash BP money. We had a lot of links and additional information that we referenced in this episode today. The links can be found at www.biggerpockets.com slash money show 142.

Okay, Scott, should we get out of here? Let's do it. From episode 142 of the Bigger Pockets Money podcast, he is Scott Trench, and I am Mindy Jensen, and we got to scoot, little newt.