BiggerPockets Money Podcast - 246: Finance Friday: I Want to Cash Out My 401k Early, Should I?

Episode Date: November 5, 2021

“Should I cash out my 401k?” That’s a question you never want to ask in an online financial independence forum. It’s been a well-known rule to never cash out retirement accounts due to withdrawal penalties, tax implications, and the possibility of throwing away your retirement plans. But, what if you had a substantially larger amount in real estate and other assets, what would you think then? Kate is in this exact predicament and has done a phenomenal job at growing her wealth over the past decade. Kate and her husband have acquired $1.8 million in rental properties, bringing in gross rents of over $10,000 per month! She’s currently sitting on half a million dollars in rental property debt and is wondering whether cashing out her 401k to pay off the debt would make sense. Because Kate is in such a high cash flow position, she may be asking a question that’s not so obvious. Mindy and Scott spend time walking through calculations that allow Kate to visualize what her life would look like with paid-off rentals as opposed to a fully-funded 401k account.  In This Episode We Cover Why a mentor can help spur you onto to make better, more aggressive investing decisions  Moving to a different part of the country to take advantage of higher salaries How to calculate whether or not you should withdraw your 401k funds  Switching your job to a more flexible schedule without giving up your salary Travel hacking and using credit card points to pay for your vacations The benefit of using financing to buy your primary residence or rental properties And So Much More! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome to the Bigger Pockets Money podcast show number 246, Finance Friday edition, where we interview Kate and talk about cash flowing rentals, 401K contributions, and calculating your actual retirement date. I met a mentor who had 100 single family residences. And from a small town girl, I lived in a very rural community, that blew my mind. It absolutely, I mean, we went from thinking, hey, this is a nice, supplemental income, once we retire when we're 65, we'll have a nest egg to wait a second, this might actually change our entire life. Like, we can do this. We can make the cash flow and we're smart enough. We work hard enough. We can make this happen. And that completely changed everything. Hello, hello, hello. My name is Mindy Jensen. And with me, as always, is my cash flow loving co-host, Scott Trench. We're really running out of net new intros, aren't we, Mindy? The fountain is full.

Scott and I are here to make financial independence less scary, less just for somebody else. To introduce you to every money story, because we truly believe financial freedom is attainable for everyone, no matter when or where you're starting. That's right. Whether you want to retire early and travel the world, go on to make big time investments in assets like real estate, start your own business, or reallocate your capital and figure out if you can retire right now. we'll help you reach your financial goals and get money out of the way so you can launch yourself towards those dreams. Scott, I am super excited to bring Kate in today because she has done it. She's way past wherever she needs to be in her retirement of plans, in her single-family rental portfolio, and she's really, really, really doing great.

But she needs a second set of eyes, or I guess two second sets of eyes on her numbers to help her really solidify her plans. And I, I love her number. She's got a great salary. She's got 23 rental properties. And she's really just crushing it. Yeah, and we get a chance to hear a little bit of background of that story. It would have been a great money story show as well to hear how she got to this position because she is so successful with it. But what I think was really fun about this episode is she's so in command of her finances with a couple of things, but with a couple of tweaks on a couple of key assumptions. I think she can make a huge difference and realize her goals, potentially much sooner than the four-year, five-year timeline we had discussed as her goal at the

beginning of the episode. So I think it was really a fun discussion and it was cool to see a couple of light bulbs potentially going off. I'm interested to see what happens next for her. Yeah, I really like these shows, the Finance Friday episodes that we do and release every Friday because this episode just embodies what we're trying to do. She has it in her mind that this is her plan. And that's great. It's a great plan. But when you come in and you look at it from a slightly different angle,

one of not in the exact middle of it, you can see different ways to look at things. And that's something that I think you excel at, Scott, is just, hey, what about if you thought of it this way? And you could see that light bulb go off in her head. She's like, oh, I think she had some. several moments like that. And like her plan, her original plan that she came in with today was fantastic and absolutely viable. But this other plans, the new ideas that we gave her to

think about are just, I think, going to help her realize her goals even quicker. Absolutely. Should we bring her in? We need to hear from our attorney, Scott. The contents of this podcast are informational in nature and are not legal or tax advice. And neither Scott nor I nor Bigger Pockets is engaged in the provision of legal tax or any other advice. You should seek your own advice from professional advisors, including lawyers and accountants regarding the legal, tax, and financial implications of any financial decision you contemplate. I think that actually comes, is really highlighted today. I think that she could benefit from a session with a tax planner or a CPA to look at

the different options that she has. Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture, including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. And if you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going, and more importantly, where your tax refund can make the biggest impact. Because the goal isn't just to look backward, it's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch. Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments, net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your

phone or your laptop. Feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch subscription with the code Pockets. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves the needle. Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch,

the all in one tool that makes money management simple. Use the code Pockets at Monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at Monarch.com Code Pockets. I love Matt, said no one ever. Nobody starts a business thinking, you know what would make this more fun, calculating quarterly,

estimated taxes. But somehow every small business owner ends up doing it. Your dreams of creating, selling, and growing get replaced by late nights chasing receipts, juggling invoices, and wondering if that bad sushi lunch with Scott counts as a write-off. Change all that with Found. Found is a business banking platform built to take the pain out of managing money. It automatically tracks expenses, organizes invoices, and even preps you for tax season without you doing the heavy lifting. You can set aside money for business goals, control spending with virtual cards, and find tax write-offs you didn't even know existed. It saves time, money, and probably a few years of life expectancy. Found has over 30,000 five-star reviews from owners who say,

Sound makes everything easier, expenses, income, profits, taxes, invoices even. So reclaim your time and your sanity. Open a found account for free at found.com. That's F-O-U-N-D.com. Found is a financial technology company, not a bank. Bank. Banking services are provided by lead bank, member FDIC. Don't put this one off. Join thousands of small business owners who have streamlined their finances with Found.

Audible has been a core part of my routine for more than a decade. I started listening years ago to make better use of drive time and workouts, and it stuck. At this point, I've logged over 229 audiobook completions on Audible alone, and I still regularly re-listen to the highest impact titles. Lately, I've been listening to Bigger Leaner Stronger for Fitness, the Anxious Generation for Parenting Perspective, and several Arthur Brooks' audiobooks that have been excellent for mental well-being. What makes Audible so powerful as its breadth. Beyond audiobooks, you also get Audible Originals, podcasts, and a massive.

massive back catalog across business, health, parenting, and more, all accessible in one app. If you're looking to turn everyday moments into real progress, Audible has been indispensable for me over over 10 years. Kickstart your well-being journey with your first audiobook free when you sign up for a free 30-day trial at audible.com slash BP money. Kate makes a great salary. She owns 23 single-family properties in her Midwestern hometown and move to the East Coast to increase her income, a prospect that paid off for her very well. Her goal is to retire in the next

four to five years, completely living off her rental income back in her hometown. She's looking for a review of where she's at and some of her potentially controversial investment choices. Kate, welcome to the show. I cannot wait to jump into this episode. Thank you so much. I'm so excited to be here. Well, let's start off with your income. What do you make in and where do you put it? Sure. So my current salary is right at 180K, and I am also in a bonus pool for 15% bonus each year. Okay. That's not bad at all. I like that very much. Any other sources of income for you guys? So my husband and I do have these rental properties, and my husband worked for quite a few years, but now he manages our investment properties.

So from W2 income, it's my income plus our rental income. Okay. And then what's the rental? income. So rental income averages, I think, around 11,000 a month. But that is, that's minus management fees and management expenses that go through the management company. So it's a little bit, it's probably more like 14,000 a month, something in that range. How about net cash flow? Just, and we'll, I'm sure we'll dive into the portfolio at some point. Of course. So net cash flow from rental properties, like I said, that rental income minus the management fees and management expenses that go through the management company, that net's 11,000 a month. And then beyond that, we have other

expenses, for instance, taxes and insurance and mortgage payments. And those equate to about $7,000 a month. And so current net cash flow from the rentals is around $3,600 a month. $3,600. Okay. Awesome. And how much do you spend per month after all that income? Yeah, sure. So we have a few expenses. So right now we rent and sit when we do not own. And so our rent is $1,800 a month. And so with rent and utilities, that average is about $2,100 a month. We spend around $460 a month in groceries. And we have a family of five. So it's myself, my husband, and three kids. We usually eat out on about $100 a month. And then on average for two used vehicles for gas and insurance, et cetera, the average is around $380 a month. We do have charitable donations that

we do contribute to, and that's about $100 a month. And then we have kind of an other category of vacation or kids stuff and doctors, and that's about $300 a month. So monthly expenses total would be around $4,000 a month. Awesome. How long have you been tracking this and how comfortable What do you feel about that number? So I have been tracking this hardcore for the last three years. And I have a spreadsheet and literally going every month. And I have a Mint account. And so we keep track of it there.

And then I log it in Mint. And then on my spreadsheet each month. So I'm pretty comfortable. Yeah, pretty comfortable. Let's go through your net worth. What are your investments and liabilities against those? Okay, sure. So we do not, like I said, we do not currently own.

our primary residents. We do have 23 single-family rentals, and so those are worth approximately 1.8 million today. We have two used vehicles. That's like 22K. We have long-term care policies and life insurance policies with surrender of around 150K, which I'm sure that seems so high, and I'm happy to chat about those too. I also max out my health savings account each year, and so we have approximately 30,000 in there right now. We have a cash position of 75K, and then we have 90K and a Roth, 400K and 401K, 90K and a rollover IRA. We have 529 plans for our kids with 26K, and then a very small balance on a credit card. We pay off for liabilities each month and rental debt currently at 550K.

So that's about net worth of 2.1. Awesome. So you're crushing it here with it with this. And you have essentially no consumer debt, very clean financial profile here, very diligently tracked expenses, significant net worth, heavy real estate allocation. Love it. That's bigger pocket style. And things seem to be going pretty well, I think. Yeah, it is. And it's been a lot of learning through the years to get to this point. But we've done a lot of research. We spend a lot of time, my husband and I talking about it and planning for our futures, and it's feeling like we're in pretty good shape right now. Can I pivot from the way we usually do Finance Fridays here for just a second?

And could we do a five-minute or seven-minute overview of your money journey to how you became how you got to this position and got to this net worth? Yeah, happy to. So my husband and I met around, I don't know, 2008. And at that time, he was just finishing grad school. and we, I did not have very much school debt. I had maybe $10,000 when I got out of school. And so I paid that off fairly quickly.

And then when my husband and I got married, we had around, I want to say, 90,000 total in school debt. And so we lived very small and put everything we could towards paying off that debt. And we paid that off in two or three years between my income at the time, which I made $50,000 coming out of, out of school. and my husband was some around 60,000. So between the two of us, we just lived very small and paid it all off. And then after that, we bought our first rental property in 2014.

And our goal at the time was to buy 10 properties total, one property each year for the next 10 years. Where was this property located? And where were you living at that time? Yep. So when we first found the property, we were living in the Midwest and the property is in the Midwest. best. Okay. Yeah. And so, you know, we had this goal of buying, like I said, 10 total, one per year for 10 years. And among that, you know, part of it with buying rentals is you have

to have the cash. And so for me to maximize my salary, we made the conscious decision to move our family. And so when we did that, my salary went up from, you know, I had been making a 5% or so increase each year. But I made a 30% raise when I made that decision to move from the Midwest to a different state. And so when we did that, we bought our first two properties over a period of two years. And I met a mentor who had 100 single family residences. And from a small town girl, I lived in a very rural community. That blew my mind. It absolutely, I mean, we went from thinking, hey, this is a nice supplemental income. Once we retire when we're 65, you know, we'll have a nest egg to wait a second, this might actually change our entire life.

Like, we can do this. We can make the cash flow and we're smart enough. Like, we work hard enough. We can make this happen. And that completely changed everything. So we went from, you know, we bought our first couple in 2014. And then, you know, we bought one in 2015. And then after that, it was like three or four per year.

Just hacking at it when a good deal would come on the market. You know, we were ready. we had financing ready. I shop financing really, really hard. But before you knew it, we just had, we'd acquired, you know, these properties. So it's, it's been a lot of fun, but it was definitely not the plan from the beginning. How long ago did your husband leave work to manage the portfolio? So that's a great question.

That was in 2016. So we were married in 2011. So about five years of us both working when we could, working on the rentals, when we would be back in the Midwest, et cetera. And then in 2016, we were starting to have children, and we made the conscious decision that he could manage those rentals, and we could live on my W-2 income, per se, and start working harder on the rental side of our business. I want to take a moment here to just highlight the fact that you have an enormous income, and you choose specifically to live in a high cost of living area. You choose specifically to rent instead of own in that high

cost of living area, and you choose to still invest in real estate. I get a lot of people in the Bigger Pockets forums and in our Facebook groups that are asking, you know, ooh, is it okay that I rent and I want to start buying properties? Yes, it's okay if you rent. It doesn't always make sense to own a home in every single city. Like, you live on the East Coast, which is notoriously expensive. If you lived in San Francisco, owning your own home would probably not be the most financially advantageous decision for you when you could rent for significantly less per month. I'm assuming that you have, you have, what, $2,100 for rent and utilities, you're not going to get a mortgage on a house out on the East Coast for $2,100 a month.

That's just not going to happen. So if your goal is to not stay there forever, this is a great choice for you. So if you're listening and you live in a high cost of living area and you do want to invest in rentals, especially not in that high cost of living area. It's totally fine. Kate says it's fine. Kate gives her approval. I sure do.

And it's been exceptional for us. I also really like that you moved to a high cost of living area that had a higher salary, specifically to make more money. I have moved my whole life. I've never lived in a house for more than six years ever. And it would be kind of a no-brainer to go. and generate a ton of income if I had the opportunity simply by moving. And it can be scary to move. You lived, it sounds like you lived in the same hometown your whole life. And then you moved.

You're making a ton of money. When you finish your financial journey, you can move back. They have planes to everywhere in America so you can go visit whenever you want. It doesn't, it doesn't have to be this, you know, oh, well, I don't live in my hometown anymore. I guess I can't talk to anybody. Like, we have phones now. We have the internet. We have video calls. It's amazing. Technology. Who'd have thought? I also just want to continue the several minutes of compliments that we're now in here on your financial journey. Clearly, like, a great money story. Nothing unrepeatable about your money story that's happening there. Lots of folks can kind of replicate a lot of elements of what we just heard there.

And we hear on Finance Fridays here a ton of people at various stages along that journey. I like to think that where you're at may be an inevitable outcome for a lot of folks who are willing to take a lot of the steps that you've taken there. You have complete command over your spending. Three years, hardcore tracking of those numbers. I'm sure that the tracking or the control of those expenses lasted long before that as well to some degree with this. You've got a great incomes or you have a great income and it sounds like a conscious decision was made for your husband to begin building assets. while you live off of essentially one income in that move, a lot of decisions here that are going to give you a tremendous amount of optionality in your life. So I guess the million dollar

question is, or I guess two million dollar question in this case is how can we possibly help you from here? But all of this is going so well. Well, I sure appreciate all that feedback. It's been a lot of hard work, but to your point, it's something anybody can replicate. You know, I think you do need some sound principles to start with where you understand what your strategy is. Like, we almost bought one in cash in the beginning. And that would have been a really poor decision for us because we wouldn't have had cash flow to then put a 20% down payment and buy our second, third home. So you do have to have some basics, I think, to start and put something together on paper to say, how can we create the cash flow to get started? Because then it becomes

this engine that churns. And the longer it goes, you start snowballing. and paying them off, which is what's happening now. And, you know, you see that upside five to ten years later. So to your point, Scott, on, you know, what help do I need or what advice would I request? I have a couple crazy ideas. And I think you guys are the perfect sounding board to either confirm I'm crazy or potentially get me some advice. And so the first question I really have is I'm thinking about cashing out my 401K.

Nope, that's crazy. It depends. It depends. But a great answer. Okay. So you, first I want to caveat this with you have 23 rentals that are more than paying for their expenses and kicking off a significant amount of cash every month. With that caveat, I will say, I will listen to why you want to cash in your 401K.

Yeah. So it's crazy. So, you know, back to the numbers. I think I have right around 400K invested in index funds in my 401k. And we also have Roth worth 90K. So the Roth, we could cash out the proceeds, I think, without paying any tax. So we've contemplated, I want to say there's like 40 or 50K there, that we could take out technically and with no tax consequence.

And so we've contemplated that. But the big bogey is really this 400K sitting in my 401K that. Right now, it feels that I can't access it until I'm 65 or older, and that seems like a lifetime away, you know, if I plan to retire when I turn 40 years old. I've done some research. I'm definitely not an expert here, but I understand when you cash it out, you do have to pay a penalty potentially, and then you have tax consequences. But I've really just a good portion of those proceeds were company matched dollars.

So I don't know if this is right way to think about it, but in my head it's kind of free money that I'd be potentially losing from taxes for that portion. And then for the remainder, I just think about if we could either apply, let's say, two-thirds of that to additional rental properties, the cash flow from that, you know, could really significantly affect our lives for the next 30 years versus waiting until we're 65 to see any of it. So before you get into the answer to this, what are the specifics of your goals in a broader sense outside of this 401K decision? Where do you want to get to going forward? So that's completely fair.

I am not trying to, and my family, we are not trying to maximize lifetime earnings. That is not our intent. So what we're really trying to do is at 40, give time back to my family and my kids while they're at home and, you know, while we have that ability to spend more time together. So my our main goal is at 40 to have no more W-2 income for the rest of my life, unless I choose to. I don't think I'm going to choose to, but I don't know. Maybe something will change in the future.

So no born WF. And that's four years away? That is four years away, yes. Okay, awesome. And so the bigger question is, how do we get to make sure that we're in that position in four years? And then I think that that's where you focus on the 401K. And the 401K is the 20 of the 80-20 in answering that question at this point in time.

Is that right? Sorry, I'm not checking your 80-20. 80-20 rule. what's 80, what's the, what's the, what's the 80% of my situation that matters or the 20% of the activities I can do that will have 80% of the outcome? It looks to me like 80% of your net worth or roughly 60, 70, 70, 80% is in this real estate portfolio and 2030, 4040 is in this, this 401k or taxable accounts. Is that right? That's exactly. That's exactly correct. Yes. And so we've also thrown around keeping it in the index funds, but then once I retire, do like a, what's

What's it called self-directed? Do a self-directed and maybe take that 400K and go apply it to a whole bunch more rental property, keep 100K in cash reserves, right, and grow your portfolio that way. But the problem there, when we think about it, that would be if I want to maximize lifetime earnings. I can't, we cannot touch any of that cash flow until we're 65. And so that's where it just doesn't. If you can achieve the goal of retiring at 40, why wouldn't you want to then maximize lifetime earnings in a mostly semi-passive state? Is there an aversion to that or is it it can't come at the cost of being able to retire at 40? It cannot come at the cost of retiring at 40. And I think where I struggle is, based on our rental debt of 550K, we're also going to purchase a primary house when I retire with the intent of living there for 30 years. So assuming we move back to the Midwest, that's going to cost approximately 300K. So we will not be debt-free, completely debt-free when I turn 40. and I struggle with, am I okay with that? If as long as the cash flow pays for everything,

or would I prefer to just be debt-free and not worry about it? So here's my suggestion for framing the discussion. I think we should start with the real estate portfolio and back into various ways to get that to where you want it to be and then discuss the 401K. And I'll give one mental model for that going in, and I think that's the case. if you know and I'm going to use maximizing lifetime earnings which I know you don't want to

which is not your goal but I want to I want to start there anyways because if you have a paid off rental portfolio in the Midwest I think you're going to average 7 to 8 percent returns annualized on that property portfolio and I think you're going to get 8 to 10 percent in the stock market over a 30 year over 30 year period in index funds at least those are the those are assumptions I apply to my own life in making these decisions. The return profile increases from real estate when you're using leverage. That's not your goal with that. You're doing that, but I think if you can get your rental portfolio to a place where you're going to be able to retire comfortably on it without the 401k at all, leaving that money in the 401k or that type of,

you may find that that actually compounds really nicely. And a lifetime away today is going to be reality in that one lifetime for you when retirement age you hits. And so that's just one, that's just where I'm framing the reluctance on there. Now, if the math works out differently and we got to get to the back into the goal of four years from now, because that is the stated goal, then we can figure out how to apply it. We can figure out how to get creative from there. But the easiest option is to solve it without that and then go back to that if we need it. Does that make sense how I'm framing the thought process on that? Yes, I think it absolutely does. And I think something that we need to consider is,

this doesn't have to be a one-time decision either. So let's say the cash flow makes sense when I retire. Everything's fine for a year or two, but a couple years there's a hiccup and we need something. You can also incrementally take some of those 401K proceeds out at that time if we needed to in a worst case scenario, similar to the Roth that's sitting there, you know. Exactly. And there's a Roth conversion ladder component as well that you can also get into if you want to do that.

Because with a real estate business, when you do a big acquisition one year or 1031 or whatever it is, there's a chance you're going to have heavy losses that's going to enable you to do that conversion ladder or pull it out with that. So I think that's another really good point with thinking about it with that. But let's go into your portfolio right now. If you, let me ask you this question. Let's use a present day scenario. And then let's project into the future.

You have a $1.8 million asset value on that portfolio with $550k in debt. Is that right? That's correct. If you sold a portion of that portfolio today and paid off, used the proceeds of that to pay off the remaining debt, how much cash flow would you generate? I don't know. How would you do that math?

Is it simply the, I feel like the generation would go the other way, wouldn't it? Because you'd sell properties so your cash flow would go down. But you'd pay off your remaining 550K in rental debt. So your immediate cash flow would jump on a net basis because you'd pay off, you would no longer have any principal and interest payments. Does that make sense? Yeah, it does.

I don't know. I don't know. I think that would be a good exercise to go through because the reason you're not, your portfolio is not paid off is because you're choosing to allocate the capital towards building towards growth mode. In four years, you will have that decision about whether you want to de-leverage the portfolio or not as well. And at that time, you can see, you don't have to necessarily pay off the whole portfolio

or not via your, your job income or the cash flow that you're stacking from the portfolio, you can choose at that point to sell or reallocate the capital if you'd like to become debt-free on your portfolio at that time. And it will boost your cash flow because you won't have any debt. It'll hurt your turns to a certain degree long term, but that's not your state of goal. So I just want to point that out as another framework for that. To kind of trigger the discussion with that. And then so with that, what is your portfolio going to look like in four years on your current track? What is your math telling you? So rough math is right now we apply about 10,000 of additional cash flow to paying

down that 550K of debt. So that would be approximately 120,000 a year. Three more years would be 360,000. So we're looking at maybe a rental debt balance of around 200K. One thing that's really cool about our investment strategy is we refinanced a good portion. Maybe I can't think exactly the number, but a pretty good amount of that loan within one to one mortgage company. And we have an agreement with them that if we pay down a large lump sum, that they will reallocate the mortgage payments to make them smaller over time versus just paying the same, you know, to rental debt. So like if we pay 70,000 or $100,000 against that loan, the mortgage payment the following month goes down by, let's say, $600 a month.

That's awesome. So they reset the amortization table every time you make a large one-time payment or a periodically. Yes. Awesome. So, you know, like we're talking about if we pay down $320,000 in debt, let's say, those mortgage payments, you know, which now we pay around $4,600 a month, that may only be, I don't know, $2,000 a month or $1,500 a month by the time I'm at retirement age. So cash flow is going to change dramatically that way as well, Scott.

Okay, awesome. So what is your current, what is the current cost of that, of the principal and interest portion of that debt on a monthly basis or annually? I'd have to go run the numbers. I know our current mortgage payments are around $4,600 a month, but that includes taxes and insurance for some of those properties. So it's something less than $4,600, maybe $3,000. $3,500 a month, something like that.

$3,500 a month on 23 loans? So we do not currently have 23 loans. So we have three loans, I think, with particular loan companies, and then one loan for some of the debt. The remainder of them, Indy, we paid off over time. So when we first started, we did Freddie Mac loans up to six or seven for each, my husband and myself. And so when we started paying down debt, we picked the highest interest rate or the lowest

balance. We kind of flip-flopped on strategy, to be honest, and started paying those down dramatically. So we do not have 23 mortgages today. We just have a, like I said, maybe three or four with mortgage companies and then one where we've consolidated the remainder of the debt. Many of them are paid off debt-free. Okay. I just want to point that, you know, so we don't know the specifics, but you have a mortgage,

a principal and interest portion of your mortgage that's between 3,000 and 3,500 a month right now. And if you pay that off, your cash flow net net jumps from that $3,600 number to 66 to $7,000 a month. That's exactly right. And that's probably what you're backing into is game over with that because you only need $4,000 a month to live with that. And that's assuming you have a mortgage payment that is about that 2100 level. level with that, which could be, that could be, you know, that may not even be the case. You may be able to buy a house for cash, depending on how things play out with this. So what I, again, what I wanted to point out, again, with my thought exercise earlier,

is that the game is over when you get to $4,000 and you're at $3,600 right now, essentially, right? Now, you want a buffer. That's not enough margin to safety to be right at that level, I'm sure. But we need, we need a buffer, plus we have to pay for health insurance out of pocket. And so I literally went on healthcare.gov and figured out for a family of five, what our premiums are going to be between now and my husband being 65 and myself being 65. And it averages pretty closely between the premium plus the deductible around $30,000 a year. So that averages an additional $2,500 a month to think about as well, assuming you have to pay that

full premium. And what's weird is when you go on health care.gov, it talks about additional qualified premiums you may be able to achieve that would reduce that total premium and deductible, but to be honest, I don't know enough about it, so I just put in worse case for everything.

And that means I need to get to about $5,200 a month cash flow to be able to cover everything. All right, $5,200 a month in cash flow. I think that if you do the math and you sold a portion of your portfolio today and

redid and paid off that that balance, you'd be very close. You may not be quite where you want to be to, but you'd be very, very close. And so again, that framework, I think, will be really helpful as you think as you back into your four-year, four-year plan with that. You don't have to sell off any of the portfolios. It'll be close enough anyways, because you're, especially since you get to reset the amortization table with this, with this creative loan structure, that's awesome.

But yeah. Okay. So with that context. I want to jump in there, Scott. Sorry. I want to jump in and say, we can make up the rest of the. that by taking your 401k, leaving it where it is right now. And then once you no longer have income, you can do a Roth conversion ladder, which will allow you to convert up to, and don't

quote me on this, I'm going to give you a research opportunity. I believe it's $40,000 that you're not paying any capital gains taxes on. Wait a second. I think I'm mixing up my things. So you can, So you take $40,000 out of your 401k. You pay the taxes on it and you're converting it to a Roth IRA. So now all of the taxes are paid and there's no penalty because you're not taking possession of the money yourself. That goes into a plan that you can then withdraw in five years. And you do that again the next year with another $40,000.

and I'm stuck on $40,000 and I can't remember why. You can do it with however much you want. You're just going to move up the income tax brackets as you realize more income with that. And I think careful tax planning could be in the Roth conversion ladder could be a really viable option for this strategy because you know, you're certainly going to produce taxable income on this rental property portfolio, at least if things are going reasonably well with that. So I don't think you're going to get around.

I would imagine, you know, you're probably going to have some realized income, especially with a paid off portfolio of this size. But it may be very low and there may be years, again, when you have major rehabs that can be fully depreciated in year, those kinds of things that you'll be able to have very low income and do that strategy. And that would be a very good way to bridge the gap. I think, I think Mindy's spot on with that thought process. And you're remaining gaps at the end of that. Yeah. And that is, there's an article from the mad finance. called how to access retirement funds early. If you Google mad scientist access retirement funds, it pops right up.

He's really good with the SEO. There's three different methods that he highlights here. He makes sure that you know that there is a 10% early withdrawal penalty. He talks about the Roth conversion ladder in much more detail than I just went into. The 72T method is substantially equal periodic payments. You basically just determine for, oh, when you leave your your job immediately roll your 401k into a traditional IRA, determine how much you think you'll want to withdraw from your retirement accounts every year until you turn 59 and a half, which is when

you can start to access them early. It doesn't have to be 65. So now we've only got 19 and a half years to cover instead of 25 years. Slightly less than one lifetime. Yeah. So he's got a lot of information there about that. And his third option is just paid the penalty. I don't like that option. So I'm going to disagree with him on that and figure out ways to do this. So once you do the Roth conversion letter, you take the money, you convert it into your Roth IRA, you pay the taxes now, which will be significantly less because now you don't have your high income job.

And then you wait five years. You can withdraw the amount that you put in there. So let's call it $40,000 because I'm stuck on that number. You can withdraw all $40,000 and pay no penalties and no taxes because you already paid the taxes. Now, when you withdraw that money, you can only withdraw the 40, but maybe that 40 has grown to 45 or 500, whatever it has. That still continues to grow in that account. I'm not sure when you can access that part, but it doesn't matter because you already have that 40,000 that you already did. And you can do this every single year for, and then for five years, you've got another

buffer of income. So, and I say five years, you can do this forever. I like that option a lot. Your 401K comes with a 50% match. I can't remember if we said that on the show, up to 10%. So you can, you're making 50% return on every dollar you put in there. I'm a big fan of the 401K. I don't know if you have a Roth 401K option.

can you make the same contribution? You're shaking your head, so I guess there is no Roth 401k option. I would still, I mean, you've, now we're in that case where does really reducing your income, your taxable income by $20,000 do anything for you on the taxable income front? No, I'm talking about the match. And I would continue to contribute to get the maximum match until you found another way to make that kind of money. Because you're only going to be there for four more years.

What is that? 10% of your income is... 18,000 a year. 18,000. So you're already almost maxed out anyway. That's another $9,000 a year. So, I mean, in the whole course of $180,000 a year, what's another $9,000? But hey, if you don't want it, I'll take it.

9,000 is still $9,000. And that's just another bunch of money you can contribute to your 401. I really like that until you can figure out a different, like if you've got a rental property that you really want a hardcore pay down, maybe that would work. But you've got a big buffer in your between your monthly income and your expenses right now. So you could already pay that down. I don't know. I think what you both have really, yeah, I think what you both have really been able to help me see a lot better is that it's okay to have options. we don't have to act on those options now, right? So we have good planning in place between the

HSA. So we max that out every year and I keep a spreadsheet keeping track of those expenses. You know, there's cash accessible there if we need to get to it. There's cash within the principle towards the Roth that if we need to get to it, to Mindy's point, you know, do a conversion into the Roth so you have more cash accessible. You can't tell like the thing on the top of my mind is do we have enough cash? Like is cash flow going to be okay because we don't have W-2 income. And I think maybe it's enough to have a plan and continue to put yourself in a good situation where you have accessibility to cash, but keep it in vehicles where it can maximize, you know, it's, it's in its earnings potential. And in some ways, at least it is

differentiating away from real estate a little bit because it's in index funds versus being 100% in real estate. I think that's probably a benefit as well to think through. I'm nodding vigorously. Yeah, these are all, I think I completely agree with everything you're saying there. I think that if you need cash, the most, the obvious place to go for that cash is a line of credit against your rental property portfolio, right? So that's where if you need the cash early in the next four years, that's where you want to get to. I hear you that your goal is game over by 40 with that, with those types of things. I think you'll be close enough just by following your current strategy and continuing what you're doing here. I think you've got a huge margin of safety probably built into that that's hidden in numbers we can't see.

I bet you're not projecting your salary increasing a ton or the rents increasing in your portfolio or like stock returns being a certain way or whatever with that. So I think there's probably a lot of very reasonable margin of safety built in. You can always pull that money out and pay that penalty later. but I like, in your case, I think that you're actually going to get a higher return potentially in the stock market, you know, historically, over a long-term average, anything could happen the next four years and everyone has their opinion about that. But, you know, over long-term average, I'd be betting that the averages in that 401K will actually surpass the portfolio return and the real estate, all things considered with that. We could see, you know, with a de-leverage portfolio.

And then I just want to chime in on the real estate concept inside the 401K. I don't like real estate investing inside of the 401K as a rule. If you're going to invest in notes or debt or those types of things, that can be a good vehicle for it because you're going to generate a lot of taxable income from the interest and that kind of stuff. But real estate is inherently tax advantaged. And one, one, a paid off rental property portfolio. is not likely to produce a very strong return relative to some other asset classes like stocks

or other types of businesses with that. It's a leverage component that we can more reasonably use leverage that drives a lot of that. And I don't think, I think that you're going to miss out on a lot of the tax benefits. And it's going to be a lot more complicated to manage that with a self-directed plan. You can do it. I just, as a rule, like that with the after-tax stuff. and then the pre-tax or tax-deferred investments,

those I like for the, personally, I put those into index funds and those types of things. Or if interest rates were to rise, I would be put a lot of fixed, I would get a lot of that type of stuff in those, in my retirement accounts as well. Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture, including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. If you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going,

and more importantly, where your tax refund can make the biggest impact. Because the goal isn't just to look backward. It's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch. Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments, net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your phone or your

laptop. Feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch subscription with the code, pockets. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves the needle. Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch, the all-in-one tool that makes money management simple. Use the code pockets at Monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at Monarch.com code pockets. You just realized your business needed

to hire someone yesterday. How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use indeed. When it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. That means you can stop struggling to get your job notice on other job sites. Indeed's sponsored jobs helps you stand out and hire the right people quickly. Your job post jumps straight to the top of the page where your ideal candidates are looking. And it works. Sponsored jobs on Indeed get 45% more applications than non-sponsored posts. The best part?

No monthly subscriptions or long-term contracts. You only pay for results. And speaking of results, in the minute I've been talking to you, 23 people just got hired through Indeed worldwide. There's no need to wait any longer. Speed up your hiring right now with Indeed. And listeners of this show will get a $75 sponsored job credit to get your job's more visibility at Indeed.com slash bigger pockets. Just go to Indeed.com slash bigger pockets right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash bigger pockets. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring, Indeed is all you need.

When you want more, start your business with Northwest Registered Agent and get access to thousands of free guides, tools, and legal forms to help you launch and protect your business all in one place. Build your complete business identity with Northwest Northwest Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They're the largest registered agent and LLC service in the U.S. with over 1,500 corporate guides who are real people who know your local laws and can help you and your business every step of the way. Northwest makes life easy for business owners. They don't just help you form your business. They give you the free tools you need after you form it, like operating agreements, meeting minutes, and thousands of how-to guides that explain the complicated

ins and outs of running a business. And with Northwest, privacy is automatic. They never sell your data and all services are handled in-house because privacy by default is their pledge to all customers. Visit Northwest Registeredagent.com slash money-free and start building something amazing. Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at Northwest Registered Agent.com slash money-free. I'm not an astronaut. I don't need an astronaut. Audiences have spoken. Project Hail Mary is an awe-inspiring masterpiece. So I met an alien.

If you've fallen out of love with going to the movies, this one will bring you back. Ryan Gosling, in the first must-see movie of 2026. Project Hail Mary, only Beaters March 20th. I have a question about your job. So do you have the kind of... job where you could go back and do some sort of consulting if things got really tight? Or do you have the kind of job where you need to be there constantly to keep up on the day to day in order to be effective to go back? I think had you asked me this question two years ago, the answer would have

adamantly been, no, I need to be in the office. But I do think that industries are changing. And though my current job does require me to be in the office, I think there would be the to do consulting if I needed to in the future and do some of that remotely. So you have a job that pays you, your base salary of 180 pays you 45 months of expenses every year. So if there's some sort of, you know, let's say you're a CPA and in April, it's really, really busy. Is there any sort of cyclical thing in your job where you could come in for a month or to and, you know, and these are more like just planting seeds because maybe there's a project you can help consult on that your experience and expertise is uniquely qualified to, you know,

generate $180,000 over three months. That's the kind of tradeoff that I think would be worth looking into, especially if you could do it from your Midwestern hometown instead of being in the place where you're at now, you know, after four years and you've come. completely retired. And they're like, hey, Kate, come back. We want you to, you know, consult on this one project for three months. Oh, you know what? This could be interesting or, hey, I'm done. I'm out completely. So, you know, I think keeping, keeping your options open is always really the best course of action. Yeah, I think that's a great thing to keep in mind. I just, I like what Billar Mindy's going with this as well with the thought process is, you know,

if we use the 4% rule, right, and we're not, we, this is not going to apply specifically to a real estate portfolio with this. But if we use that, you'd be, you'd say, I'd need to spend $60,000 a year. So that's a $1.5 million net worth. Um, at 50, 5,500 with, with that. So, you know, 1.5 to 1.6 million dollar net worth. You're, you've soared past that from a net worth perspective. Um, and so you, you, and again, I bet that you're conservatively valuing your portfolio to a certain degree. Is that, is that fair? I think the value of 1.8 is probably accurate, but I think the cash flow and the expenses are for sure ultra, ultra conservative compared to what it would be like if we could manage them ourselves. Oh, so if you were to move there and manage yourself, that would completely change the profile.

I'm sure you'd increase your rents by at least 10%, but what should flow right down to the bottom line. Of course, you have to work to manage that. But I assume you've got to do something once you retire from this and move out there. So that would be, that would make sense. Is that right? Is that how you're thinking about it? Yeah, somewhat. So right now we do have a management company.

And because we have a larger portfolio, we negotiated several management companies against themselves. We were able to get a 7% versus the 10% rate. But there's also a one time a year, like a resigning kind of with the management company, that there's an additional fee there that's pretty hefty. So I think what we would do is renegotiate again. I don't know if we can do better than 7%. Like I'm pretty happy with that.

And I like the ability to have a management company doing the any sort of rental tenant communication. It's worth it to me for 7% to not have to manage that piece. But we do pay right now. If something breaks, we have to pay someone significantly to go fix it. And my husband and I love that aspect of the job. Like we, I dream about summers putting up gutters on all of our properties. Like this is my dream to take our kids to school and go build decks and gutters.

that is like my dream job. And so I feel like, you know, we pay a significant amount of expenses right now that my husband and I will be able to, to be able to reduce. And Mindy, do your point, it's kind of like having a part-time job if we choose to. You know, only we can invest it back in our own company potentially versus going back to some sort of W-2 type employment. So I love it. Everyone has a different dream.

I certainly do. I don't want to build decks with that. But, no, that's awesome. And so here's what I want to point out is where I think Mindy was heading with some of those questions or where I think that's going is you're way past the finish line for all this kind of stuff. You make a couple of tweaks the way you capitalize your portfolio. You don't have to wait until 2024 to go do this. And if you're going to go and build decks on your rental properties in the summers, you're probably going to stack another $50 to $100,000 in net worth every year on top of that. in addition to the cash flow.

So that would be the framing, you know, I would reframe, reorient the conversation away from like, I don't think, I first, I don't think you need to move the 401K out of there. I think if, you know, it might be too aggressive. It's everyone needs the margin of safety that they're comfortable with. And yours might be another few years down the road. But I think a lot of people would feel really comfortable. And I would say they're very reasonable to turn it right now and go and do that kind of of stuff, especially if you're going to manage the property yourself and, and, you know, add value on a

part-time basis to these properties with, with construction work, which is incredibly high value work in 2021 in particular with it. So what's your reaction to that thought process? My mind is blown, actually. So I think because we're so risk-averse and because other than the one mentor I mentioned who has 100 doors, I don't have like a lot of folks to run this by to say, am I, like, are we crazy. Like this math, you know, it's snowballing. It's making sense as we're paying down this debt. So I'm just really thankful to be here today to talk it through and to think about the various options for us. You've got to be sure that you're going to be happy on that $4,000 a month in spending. That's that's a lot or $5,200 when you include that. But if you are, then then I think

that that's that's the key assumption in this. I think that is, needs to be tested with that. And then you, you know, what's the management stuff going to turn out? How is the, how are those rehab or maintenance costs going to come down with that? You know, those are all things to consider. But I think, and then, you know, does that tweak slightly if I pay down the property with that? If your goal is to get there as fast as possible, I think you can, you could do it a lot sooner than four years, depending on what your comfort level is. That'd be amazing. Yeah, that's, that's, that's, uh,

My thought, too, after we started talking, I'm like, why are we waiting four years? So here's something to think about. My husband was very risk-averse. He didn't want to leave his job. He was making a very good salary. And he had grown up financially insecure several years of his life. And he's like, why would I walk away from such a great job? That's so silly.

And it was, it helped him sleep at night that I had. had a job that covered all of our expenses. It helped him get the confidence to go into his boss's office and say, I want to work three days a week. And his boss was like, fine. Like he was, it's like building it up and building it up. And his boss is like, yeah, that's great. I don't care. Like, we want you to do this much. So instead of working full time for the next four years, what would it look like if you went to four days a week and you had Fridays off? Or you went down to three days a week and you had Mondays and Fridays off. Would that...

And can you go back to full-time work at a similar salary, maybe a 10%? Would the worst case be you get like a 10% or 15% cut and pay if you took a year and then tried to come back to the same field? I don't know. But what would that worst case be from a job planning perspective with that? I think given my current situation, the most probable thing that could happen is I need to rethink about the math. and maybe I'm two years out and not four from thinking about flipping the switch.

And maybe, you know, maybe there's opportunity to do it before I turn 40, which is just, it's hard to even say it out loud to be honest, but maybe there's opportunity there and we need to think about it. So I'm coming from this at a fairly unique perspective in that I am slightly over 40 and I watched my husband go through this same thought process that you're going through. Oh, it's a few more years. It's a few more years. And I'm sitting here having spoken to, you know, 50 people about this, you know, about their finances.

And I'm thinking, yeah, you could pull the trigger. I mean, if I was in your position with the 23 rentals that were kicking off, let's look at this. If you paid off all of your mortgages, that's giving you $14,000 a month. And yes, there's expenses and, you know, whatever. But you only need five. So that's, I'm not. saying quit your job today. I'm saying this is, you know,

if you've listened to the show, you've heard me say this a lot. Personal finance is personal. And you have to be able to sleep at night once you go in and give your notice. And that is, I mean, we hit our fine number and he still worked for three more years. And it was just this, or maybe two more years, I don't remember. No, I think it was three years. And it was just this like, oh, I'm not ready. I'm not ready.

And he stepped down to part time. and he was like, okay, I can do this. And then he quit. And two weeks later, two weeks after his last day, his whole project got shut down. And I am so glad that he quit on his terms instead of, oh, I'll just do one more year. And then the project gets shut down.

And he would constantly be waiting for, you know, ooh, should I get another job? Was I really ready to go? And as soon as he quit, he's like, oh, my God, I should have done this years ago. And Mindy, how is your family's position advanced or declined since that departure date? I think it's either two or two and a half times our net worth has increased two or

200 or 250 percent since then. And the stock market's been on a tear. We sold a house and made a lot of money off of it tax-free because we lived in it for two years. So there's, he was always really nervous. and once he cut the cord, after he came to the realization himself, once he cut the cord, he was like, should have done this years ago. So I'm just sharing that I think your numbers are awesome.

Thank you. I appreciate that. And I think we do have other grand plans for our family. You know, I think travel, vacation, like those kinds of expenses are going to go up, but not so much that I think it will offset what our future income is going to be. Yeah. Yeah. And that brings us back to like, you got to be really clear on that $4,000 or $5,200 number because that is, if that number goes to $10,000 with that, that's $120, now you're going to need $3 million in order to hit that number on a monthly basis.

And a lot of people would reasonably want a $10,000 a month spending threshold for those types of things in that. So not a number, like your number is reasonable, $6,000, $8,000 is reasonable, $10,000 is reasonable. but whatever that is for you, that's a key assumption for a lot of this stuff. Now, the good news is that if you work part-time, you know, or something like that, you could easily snowball this, like, like, that brings me back to the earlier point that I was trying to discuss when we were first getting started is you say, I'm not interested in lifetime wealth and that kind of stuff. But I think that if you set this up correctly with this, there's almost, if you do part-time

work, build in decks for your rental properties, again, you're going to increase your net worth by another incremental 50 to 100k probably per year by doing that kind of work. Or that's going to be savings that's not baked into your model completely here. And your other assets are going to continue to grow. And so I think that's what you want. You want to be retired with this margin of safety. And that margin of safety means that your purchasing power and wealth should, on average, you know, recessions and depressions excluded from this.

increase over time, giving you even more and more options way beyond what you thought you needed. Probably most folks who leave their job are doing it way too late because they could have done it with that. You can't live your life necessarily with that. It won't help you sleep at night. But it's just a model to think about. Where we looked out was early, we paid off our debt as quickly as possible. And then we maxed, we put a lot of money towards 401K. And that has been able to start compounding. So, you know, to be 36 and to have 400K between myself and my husband, of course, you know, rule of 72, even if it's 7% interest in the stock market, it's going to double three more times, I think, maybe, you know, if it doubles every 10 years. And so if it's possible to

maintain our lifestyle within the rentals that we already have and leave the 401k, then to your point, there's legacy planning, there's other things for our kids, you know, that will hopefully be intact later on for our family. And to Mindy's point, like, you know, even if that's not enough for whatever reason with it, it's going to be so close that even some part-time income is going to cover it with it. So that's, that's, I think, where the biggest, I think the biggest takeaway is, I don't think you need the 401K in order to achieve the goal and good new, all good news all around. you might have the option to do it sooner than four years,

including inclusive of not touching that if some of those assumptions play out. That would be amazing. And I think lifestyle-wise, we're so ingrained in how we live our life now, you know, that I don't see a lot of lifestyle change happening. I think, you know, a travel will go up a little bit. But then I've thought about, you know, we can still offset that with doing some side hustles or maybe we flip a house for cash

once, you know, once every couple years or, you know, we know we have the skills to do this. I think we will be able to be creative and come up with it if we if we need to for a little bit here or there to go do some some grand adventures. You know, spending wise, I really don't see us changing. So most almost all of the I would say clothes or shopping type things we acquire through rental property or through at sorry garage sales. So almost every Saturday I go garage selling and that's kind of like my favorite hobby in life, honestly. So sometimes we'll bring the kids with us. And, you know, we have those money talks with them now about, you know, do you want one toy at the store or do you want 10 toys at garage

sells that you can pick out, you know? And so they enjoy doing that. And so we've been able to to get most of our clothes and needs like that. Like I expect when the kids get older, you know, our kids are six, four, and three. So as they get older, I'm sure that will probably change when when needs change. But of course, I've, you know, I've baked in extra money in the budget to cover that eventually. But right now, or even once our kids are gone, like, I don't see our lifestyle changing beyond much of what it is today. I have a couple of points to add. So you want to travel. Let me introduce you to travel hacking and credit card opening those up and getting all the bonus points. Right now, there's not a ton of super, super lucrative ones,

but you can still find good travel hacking credit cards. We have one with Southwest because we only fly Southwest. We have one with Hyatt hotels. I have something like, because we didn't travel at all last year, I have something like 30 free hotel nights and they don't expire. And I'm staying, Hyatt's are nice hotels. I mean, for me, they're nice, not for Ramit, but that's okay. I'm not going on any vacations with Ramit.

he was on a couple of weeks ago when he was talking about, oh, I like to stay in $500 hotels. I'm like, hoo-hoo, that's not me at all. I mean, it's nice when Bigger Pockets is paying the bill, but it's never me that's paying that bill. But anyway, I digress. So find a hotel chain that you like. Get their credit card and start, that's your credit card.

That's for all the business expenses. That's for all the personal expenses. Rack them all up, unless you're, you have an LLC. and you need to keep them perfectly separate. But then have a business credit card and a personal credit card. Find the airline that you like to go to, that you like to fly, or that goes to the destinations you want to go to, get their credit card. And I mean, if with 23 houses, you have a fair amount of expenses that you can put on

credit cards and generate income. You're going to spend the money anyway. You might as well get reward points for it. And the second point I would like to make is if you're going to buy a price, I would recommend buying it with a mortgage because rights are so low right now. All the money that would be sitting in your property could be used to invest in other properties or to invest in the stock market. And that's what I do.

I got a mortgage on my house. Even though I paid for cash, I refinanced as soon as I could, pulled all the money that I could out and then put it into the stock market. And if you are going to go this route and again, a research opportunity. you have to be able to sleep at night. And if you can't sleep with a mortgage on your house, then buy it for cash. But if you're going to get a mortgage, get it before you give notice at your job. That's an exceptional point. And we have thought about that. And part of the reason why we thought about doing it is because really that's the only time that we're going to be able to keep.

Not to say my credit's going to be tarnished. I don't really know what happens once I don't have a W-2 job anymore. But for references, for everything else, you know, we can lock it in while I'm working. and then, you know, then maximize cash flow that way, too, where maybe our cash nest egg, which we keep about $75,000 in cash reserves, you know, maybe that number grows for a couple years just to make sure everything is going to be okay with the option of you can either pay down your private mortgage later if you want to or just continue to let it ride on your 30-year fixed loan. You have to talk to a lender about this, but I'd bet that we always give the advice, get the

mortgage before you leave the job with that kind of stuff. I actually doubt that will actually fully apply in your situation because you have enough rental income that I think you'll be able to qualify for that mortgage without that. You should talk to a lender before that happens. But based on when we had the discussion today, I don't think you're going to pull out a $600,000 mortgage on a property with a property with this. It's probably going to be much lower. And so that may not be an actual concern for you guys since you have so much

landlording history. Yeah, we're hoping to buy our primary house for around 300K, again, moving from East Coast back to Midwest small town and be able to do it that way. So that's a really good point about talking to the lenders. I do think the only thing that could hurt us is I think they request copies of your tax returns. And if you look at our rental properties on its own, you know, because of depreciation, because of other expenses that come off, right now they're, you know, we do make money, but not very much. It's almost break even. That's every landlord, though, and they'll, they'll do it based on a percentage of the total gross rents that are, that you either have. And if you're buying a new property, they'll do it. They'll actually allow you to include a percentage of the gross

rents of the new property, even if it's vacant, the estimated gross rents. So I think you're going to find your purchasing powers significantly. I bet you it's probably the equivalent of $120,000 or $1,000 or something like that, if your gross rents are $14,000, like $10,000 a month is what you may find you get credit for. Talk to a lender, though, before you bank on that, of course. Excellent advice. Yeah, that is really good advice, Scott. I didn't think about that. And I was just remembering the time that we tried to get a loan while we were self-employed. And it was a horrible disaster. And that was with income.

I mean, my husband worked for the government as a contractor and then, but as a W-2 employee for a contracting company. And then they said, hey, we'll pay you a lot more if you go contract with us. So he did, same job he'd been at for 12 years, same, actually increase in income. I wasn't working at the time. And the lender was like, oh, we're not giving you a loan. you're self-employed. He's like, what do you mean I'm self-employed? I work for the same company for 10 years. So just something to think about. But yeah, definitely talk to a lender. I'm trying to text my lender right now.

Hey, can we do this? But he's not getting back to me. He should just have his phone in front of him so I could ask him questions while we're recording. Yes, I think there's a lot to think about what we'd end up doing with our primary and how that's going to work out. We've also, this sounds crazy, but we've thought about buying it now potentially and putting a renter in there for two years. and, you know, just start that way. We don't have to build up our cash reserves if we wanted to. We could, you know, apply it to our mortgage or not and let someone else start paying down that mortgage of even our primary. Generally, so we've bought a few houses together, like for primaries through the years. And we have this tendency to buy the worst house on a nice street and then fix it up ourselves.

We've done this like over and over and over again. So part of it is if we're going to go buy a primary, maybe we just don't fix it up right now, right? and we let someone else live there for a few years, make sure it's a nice home, you know, in a nice area, whatnot. And then that way it's already secured. The only thing that we throw around in our head is you're not really maximizing interest rate potentially because we'd have to buy it as an investment property versus a primary residence. And so there's a couple points of interest potentially at stake there between doing that. So we've gone back and forth about thinking that through as well. Do you guys have any thoughts on that?

My thought is it's going to be a lot easier to get a loan right now than when you no longer have a job. Interest rates are so ridiculously low. I'm seeing people getting three, three and a half, four percent interest on investor loans. Yeah. So when we consolidated quite a few of the rental debt in March of 2021, we locked in 38, nine, which is crazy for investment. That's investment properties. Yeah.

So that's a good point. Yeah. So maybe. And it's a portfolio. Maybe a way to think about it then is, yeah, it might be a couple points higher. But by the time we buy in a couple years, it'll probably be a couple points higher anyway, potentially. In theory. I also just want to observe that like your situation is if you're saying how do I boil into the best number in four years, we'd be going a totally different route, right?

It would be let's pull out a bunch of this cash and put it into more rental properties with that kind of stuff. So a few basis points in an interest rate are not going to make, make or break any part of this decision on this. And I think that if you're just trying to derisk the event in two to four years, we've got it down to potentially two, which I'm very happy about, you know, that's a, then, you know, that makes perfect sense to do something like that, even though it's not going to generate a ton of return. It's just derisking that future event, you know. Okay, Kate, this is a super fun episode, but we're not done yet. You have answers to our famous four questions. Is that correct? Yes, ma'am. Okay, well, we're going to just jump right into it. What is your favorite finance book?

Your money or your life? Great book. Great book. We had Vicki Robin on the show a few months ago. I think it was episode 99. She was fabulous. Yeah, it was amazing. Just the idea about thinking about your free, thinking about how to, how to think about your freedom and what work really is. It really changed our lives. And when we had it on the show, we discovered that she is a fellow house hacker. So what was your biggest money mistake, Kate? So I've had two. One was I bought a Mercedes convertible to then find out a month later, I was pregnant, and we couldn't fit three people in a two-seeded car. And so we had to, and then

The second one was we, just lifestyle inflation. At one time, we had a 4,500 square foot house and life was good. And then when we came across your money or life, when we came across bigger pockets and a lot of other great forums and communities, we realized that wasn't the life for us and then had to downsize all of it happily. Vicki's episode was number 98, not 99. Number 99 was Scott Trench, live at Camp Phi. Okay. Anyway, what is your best piece of advice for people who are just starting out? Ask a lot of questions and find mentors. So I actually ended up becoming friends with some of the mortgage brokers out there to learn how to get loans, how to price loans. And the more questions you ask, as long as you're friendly about it, a lot of people in this community are more than happy to answer your questions. That's awesome advice. That's awesome. All right. What is your favorite joke to tell at parties?

Okay, so I'm not a good party joke person, but I do have a little comic strip that I absolutely love to retell at parties. And so you have to envision a little girl in her bed and her dad's reading her a story at night. And the little girl says to the dad, can you skip to the part where the princess creates multiple streams of income, builds wealth, and invests it all in cash flowing assets? So instead of the princess story, it's this little girl where she's dreaming of, you know, cash flowing assets. And I love, love that mental picture. And you sent that to us, so we are going. I love it. That sounds like a Bigger Pockets book.

You sent that picture to us and we will include it in our show notes, which can be found at BiggerPockets.com slash Money Show 246. Kate, thank you so much for your time today. This was wonderful. When you quit in two years, not four, or whenever it works out for your timeline, please reach out so we can give an update. I would love to come back. Thank you so much. This has changed our life. I'm so appreciative of your time.

Yay. I'm so excited. Thank you so much. This is a wonderful episode and really fun. So we appreciate you coming on, Keith. Okay. We'll talk to you soon. Okay. That was Kate and her fantastic story and her amazing projections and your really great ideas for ways to look at things differently. Scott, what did you think of her story? I thought it was really fun. You know, this, this is a type of situation. where I think the strategy of how we handle our personal finances can really come into play. And like, everybody's different, right? If we were trying to build maximize returns on the current portfolio, I have a completely different approach. We'd be leveraging that portfolio to a large degree, buying a lot more property, probably,

you know, figuring out other, you know, thinking about some sort of entrepreneurial venture with that that, that can tie into that business. But like, no, Kate's goal is, I want to be done in four years. I want to be simple on a paid off portfolio or very close to it. And I want to just kind of realize the vision of your money or your life with this, which is obviously your book recommendation with that. And I think one that everyone should read. And it's perfect.

It's such a winning formula. The paradox, though, that I want everyone to be careful of is that by achieving that goal, she's going to have a rock solid financial position that's probably going to be able to sustain her for the rest of her life, and she's going to get wealthy anyways on top of that. And so failing to at least plan or acknowledge around that being a possibility, which I think is where that discussion from the 401K happened, or maybe grounded in, is I think a mistake that you can think through. You know, just because I don't care to win big downstream doesn't mean that I shouldn't

acknowledge the high probability likelihood that reasonable stewardship of. of my 401k assets or other investments, once I'm financially free, we'll probably just balloon throughout my life if I'm operating with a margin of safety with it. So I think it's a good problem. I probably used way too much jargon in there and lost myself and thought, but that's my highest level takeaway from today's show. Well, I have nothing as close to that, but listeners of the show know that you are going to lose yourself in jargon and I'm going to come in with a really happy. I agree. But I do agree. She's got a great story. She's definitely going, you don't get to her position of a $2 million plus net worth at age 36 and making $180,000 a year. And without having some

sort of momentum behind you, I really don't think that she's going to be able to quit her job and just not make any more money. I think another rental property is going to pop up in her hometown. and she's going to jump on it because it's going to be a great deal. And I think that's just going to continue to happen for her. So at 26, she has 23 properties. By 40, she's probably going to have 25, maybe 30. Maybe somebody comes to her and says, hey, I've got a whole portfolio of properties that I want to sell to somebody who's going to take care of my tenants the way that you take care of your tenants. And, you know, there's just a lot of opportunities. And what's the, what's the phrase, the rich get richer? And she's, she's,

I just see her net worth continuing to balloon. And like you said, if you don't plan for those tax, those tax implications down the road, she could have, and it's, I mean, it's a good problem to have. Oh, now I have to pay a lot in taxes. Well, you have to pay a lot in taxes when you make a lot of money. It's like you're paying your fair share. So when you have to pay a lot in taxes, that's another good problem to have. But if there are ways around it, that's when benefiting from, you could benefit from a conversation with a tax pro who can help you with the ins and outs that you and I just don't really know. But again, I think this was a great story and I had a lot of fun with her.

Yeah, she's crushing it. I hope we hear from her in a year or two and see how things are going. I wonder how things will turn out. We'll see. Yeah, yeah, maybe even in a year. Ooh, that would be great. Okay, I would like to ask our listeners a question. We love doing these finance reviews and we love

it when you apply to be on the show. We are looking for anybody to apply who has an interesting money story. We've had a lot of recent guests who are very successful in their finances, but that doesn't mean that if you have debt, you can't apply. We would love to talk to anybody about their finances, and you can apply to be a guest on the show at www.biggerpockets.com slash finance review. Thank you. I want to echo that real quick. I know Mindy was about to say goodbye to everyone, but I just want to be like super clear about that. There's a lot of folks that come on and I'll hear from them and they're like, no, I want to fix my financial position before coming on on the money podcast. Well, if you're struggling in debt and don't know exactly what to do next, this is the perfect

place, the perfect time. If you know what you need to do and you're going on it, you know, that's one thing. But if you're wondering, like, we want to hear every money story and I think we don't get enough applicants from folks that are struggling and need to build the basic, the basic building blocks of the financial position. So you're going to help a lot of people as well. Absolutely. Absolutely. We hear, I hear from people every single episode. This, I learned so much from this episode. Every single episode I hear from people. So I would love to hear your feedback, but also I would love to hear your story. Please apply. Scott, should we get out of here?

Let's do it. From episode 246 of the Bigger Pockets Money podcast, he is Scott Trench, and I am Mindy Jensen saying, see you later, Alligator.