BiggerPockets Money Podcast - 432: Hesitant to Invest? How to Avoid Running Out of Money During Retirement

Episode Date: July 21, 2023

Terrified of running out of money in retirement? Countless people share the same fear. With so much recent discourse surrounding inflation and a looming recession, you may have a tighter grip on your money than usual. Today’s guest is here to help cool some of your concerns. In this episode of the BiggerPockets Money podcast, we’re joined by David Stein from Money for the Rest of Us, who believes there are reasons to be optimistic about the economy and even more reasons to stay on the straight and narrow when it comes to investing. If you’re easily overwhelmed by the thought of investing or choosing the right asset classes, David’s message is clear: investing doesn’t need to be difficult. There are plenty of tools the average person can use to invest, grow their nest egg, and have enough money for retirement. Don’t let fear stop you from putting your money to work! Whether you’re a novice or long-time investor, you’re in for a treat with today’s episode. Tune in as David addresses several issues—including the current state of the economy, whether we should brace for a recession, and the markets he’s investing in. He also talks about the benefit of steering clear of individual stocks in lieu of ETFs and index funds, as well as when it might be smart to buy an immediate annuity! In This Episode We Cover The four-percent rule and how to avoid running out of money in retirement How current returns on real estate compare to those of other asset classes The benefit of buying exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and index funds in lieu of individual stocks Diversifying your investment portfolio to include non-U.S. markets Three important principles to focus on when deciding where to invest Buying annuities to lock in an additional income stream during retirement And So Much More! Links from the Show BiggerPockets Money Facebook Group BiggerPockets Forums Finance Review Guest Onboarding Join BiggerPockets for FREE Mindy on BiggerPockets Scott's Instagram Grab Scott’s Book, “Set for Life” Listen to All Your Favorite BiggerPockets Podcasts in One Place Apply to Be a Guest on The Money Show Podcast Talent Search! Listen to The Real Estate InvestHER Show Join The Real Estate InvestHER Community on Facebook Register for an Upcoming InvestHER Event Money Moment Choosing the Right Investment Type for Your Goals with David Stein Check Out the Latest Five-Year TIPS at TreasuryDirect Click here to check the full show notes: https://www.biggerpockets.com/blog/money-432   Interested in learning more about today's sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email us: [e-mail] Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Welcome to the Bigger Pockets Money Podcast, where we interview David Stein from Money for the rest of us and talk about the state of the economy, asset classes, including some we've never discussed before, and what to do if you're overwhelmed with your investing options. Hello, hello, hello. My name is Mindy Jensen, and with me as always is my fellow rest of us co-host, Scott Trench. Thanks, Mindy, great to be here. Scott and I are here to make financial independence less scary, less just for somebody else. To introduce you to every money, story because we truly believe financial freedom is attainable for everyone, no matter when or where you're starting. That's right. Whether you want to retire early and travel the world, going to make

big time investments in assets like real estate, start your own business, or learn investing principles from investors who have managed tens of billions of dollars in assets will help you reach your financial goals and get money out of the way so you can launch yourself towards your dreams. Scott, today's money moment is, are you traveling internationally? If you have an unlocked phone, consider purchasing a SIM card at your destination instead of using your cell phone carrier's international plan. Local SIM cards typically offer much better rates and larger data and allowances than US carriers. And this is actually a really timely tip because my daughter is getting ready to go international

and she doesn't have an international plan. So thank you to our producer for sharing that because I need that. Do you have a money tip for us? Email MoneyMoment at biggerpockets.com. All right, Scott, I am super excited to bring back David Stein from Money for the Rest of us. This is a great episode. We talk about a lot of things.

I want you to listen to this episode today. And we're talking about annuities near the end. This is a four-letter word in the investing community. However, maybe it's not. And David has a really great way to think about them, to look at them. And I am going to be rethinking my... my position on annuities after his description. Definitely time for some, uh, some education and deep dives into what that all means. Yeah, I,

I think he's got a great take on the economy. I think he's got a great take on portfolio management. And, uh, like you mentioned, I think, uh, in this episode, you and I kind of maybe finish, uh, the start of a process that has transformed annuities from a bad word that we're going to stay completely with to a tool with certain specific use cases for certain specific individuals. Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture, including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. And if you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going and more importantly where your tax refund can make the biggest impact.

Because the goal isn't just to look backward. It's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch. Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments, net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your phone or your laptop. Feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch subscription with the code Pock. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves the needle.

Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch, the all-in-one tool that makes money management simple. Use the code Pockets at monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at monarch. com code pockets. I love Matt, said no one ever. Nobody starts a business thinking, you know what would make this more fun? Calculating quarterly estimated taxes. But somehow, every small business owner ends up doing it. Your dreams of creating, selling, and growing get replaced by late nights chasing receipts, juggling invoices, and wondering if that bad sushi lunch with Scott counts as a write-off. Change all that with Found. Found is a business banking platform built to take the pain out of managing money. automatically tracks expenses, organizes invoices, and even preps you for tax season without you doing the heavy lifting.

You can set aside money for business goals, control spending with virtual cards, and find tax write-offs you didn't even know existed. It saves time, money, and probably a few years of life expectancy. Found has over 30,000 five-star reviews from owners who say, Sound makes everything easier, expenses, income, profits, taxes, invoices even. So reclaim your time and your sanity. Open a found account for free at found.com. That's F-O-U-N-D.com. Found is a financial technology company, not a bank. Banking services are provided by lead bank member FDIC.

Don't put this one off. Join thousands of small business owners who have streamlined their finances with Found. Audible has been a core part of my routine for more than a decade. I started listening years ago to make better use of drive time and workouts, and it stuck. At this point, I've logged over 229 audio book completions on Audible alone, and I still regularly re-listen to the highest impact titles. Lately, I've been listening to Bigger Liener Stronger for Fitness, the anxious generation for parenting perspective and several Arthur Brooks' audiobooks that have been excellent for mental well-being.

What makes Audible so powerful as its breadth. Beyond audiobooks, you also get Audible Originals, podcasts, and a massive back catalog across business, health, parenting, and more, all accessible in one app. If you're looking to turn everyday moments into real progress, Audible has been indispensable for me over over 10 years. Kickstart your well-being journey with your first audiobook free when you sign up for a free 30-day trial at audible.com slash BP money. David Stein teaches people about money, how it works, and how to invest it in his popular

podcast, Money for the Rest of Us. Money for the rest of us is Stein's primary platform for teaching thousands of individuals about money, investing, and the economy. The show has been featured in Business Insider, Forbes, and U.S. News and World Report. David, welcome back to the Bigger Pockets Money podcast. I'm so excited to talk to you. How have you been? Wonderful. It's great to be here. Thanks for having me back. David, for those of us who didn't hear you on episode 86 all the way back in 2019, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and your podcast? Sure.

So my background is institutional investing. So I spent over 15 years as an asset manager working mostly with Endowments and Foundation. I was a chief portfolio strategist at our firm. We managed over $20 billion in assets at the time. But I sort of was in my mid-40s and was tired of being a much. money manager and wanted to try retiring early and seeing what that was like. And so I did that. And as part of that, I realized I missed teaching about investing in the economy. So I launched money for the rest of us in 2014. And it's a weekly show. And it's expanded. We have the free podcast.

We have a premium membership community where we provide additional education. We have some other software tools called Asset Camp. And now it's very much a family business. So both my sons, our partners and we work together and our daughter works part-time. She had his podcast. So we were enjoying teaching and helping others while learning about business. I love it. Your podcast has such a great name, money for the rest of us. How did you come up with that? And how does it sum up your mission as an educator? The name came from a really good marketer, Bernadette Gewa, who's a friend of mine. She's based in Australia. And she just wrote a, me one day and says, you need to write a book and here's the title, money for the rest of us.

And I thought, that is actually a good title. I wrote a book and realized I have no one that will actually buy the book because I don't have a platform or an audience. So it was around that time that I, you know, podcasting was getting more popular as people had free data plans on their phone. And so I launched the podcast to basically grow an audience and teach and ultimately. wrote a second book with that title. I didn't come up with a name, but as it evolves, to me, the rest of us would be those that

don't work on Wall Street. So it's individual investors. It's those that are just trying to understand the world of finance and money in the economy and don't have really an informational edge. We're all on this investment journey together, and that's sort of what it conveys is it's the rest of us trying to figure it out. So how has your relationship with money changed, maybe since the last time we talked? Has anything evolved or has your viewpoint shifted or anything? Yeah, I think I'm even more patient. So since we spoke last, we had a pandemic, as you know, and we had central

banks be even more proactive in combating the economic turmoil. And so we've since then, like immediately. So if you recall the pandemic, it was March 2020. That's when it really, everything shut down. And that next month, the Federal Reserve was out buying bonds. They were buying non-investment grade bonds. So junk bonds that have been formerly investment graded, it got downgraded, and they were providing massive liquidity.

And so, you know, my approach of investing has always been to be willing to make adjustments if risks go up. And so in our model portfolio examples, for example, we pulled back risk. We reduced equity exposure. But then within three months, we had this massive rally. And so I'm much more wary of how quickly central banks are willing to act to avoid really market turmoil. And so in that environment, you don't want to make a whole lot of changes. You want to understand what drives asset class returns. And, you know, especially if you're a younger investor, you can ride out many of these storms. And even as an older investor, it doesn't make a lot of sense to take extreme positions either in or out of the market. We can make adjustments. And I've always invested that way, but I'm even more wary of what they call fighting the Fed. Like, you don't want to fight the Fed because they basically, we had 15,

trillion of money outstanding, if we call that cash, checking and savings accounts. And now we have $23 trillion of money outstanding. And if we wonder, know why housing prices popped and everything else went up. Dramatically, it's the amount of liquidity and cash that flowed into the system as a result of quantitative easing, the buying of bonds by central bank, along with massive, federal budget deficits. You know, you need both in order to create money and create wealth. It's just given to people that they went out and spent. And that dramatically has changed the financial markets. And we're still seeing the repercussions of that. Yeah. So, okay, so low interest rates,

massive federal government spending and quantitative easing, which for those who aren't aware, is when the Federal Reserve buys bonds, usually from institutions and injects cash into those institutions balance sheets, thereby increasing the money supply here. And so that inflated asset values over the last decade or so. And how are things changing for you now that that has stopped now that we're seeing interest rates rising and we're seeing monetary tightening policy coming from the Fed? Is anything changing about your perspective now? You know, you're talking about not fighting the Fed. Do you believe that investors should be more cautious as the Fed signals their to continue raising rates, for example?

No, not necessarily. So, for example, in our models, we're about 5% underweight stocks. You know, that we've collectively, collectively everyone's been waiting for this recession for two years now. Like they've been forecasting that. We've not seen that.

Inflation is coming down. A big part of, at least in the U.S., the consumer price index, is things that aren't even really measured. It's, you know, a third of CPI is home-related things and a big portion of home-related. Most people own their home. And so the Bureau of Labor Statistics goes out and asks people, what do you think you could rent your house for? And that gets added to the inflation numbers. So if we look at the latest inflation numbers, you know, the headline inflation number is coming down as oil prices fall.

But that housing element, which is part of core inflation, remains sticky because it takes people a while. to realize, hey, my house isn't appreciating 20% a year anymore. It's actually maybe has fallen back a little bit, and I don't think I can get as much rent. And so there's a lag when you look at some of the inflation statistics, but they are coming down. But once you get into a high inflation cycle, it's hard to exit because people get used to higher inflation. And so they start to change their behavior. They start to perhaps to hoard. They start to think they can get more of rent for the house.

they're willing to pay higher prices. So instead of changing what they buy and substituting, it was like, well, you know, everything's going up. I'm going to just buy the most expensive marinara sauce out there because it doesn't matter at this point. And so this, this behavior changes is what central banks fear the most because then high inflation expectations become anchored. Now, I don't think we're going to stay at six, seven percent inflation. It will eventually come down to to four to three, but it could be many years before we get two percent inflation like we had. And as a result, higher interest rates, and that can put pressure on some asset classes, such as real estate that, you know, bigger pockets focuses a lot on because higher interest

rates means there are other asset classes that are competitive. If you can get 5 percent yield on your cash, why would you buy a building, that has a 5% cap rate, which many, many apartments were sold at in the last three to five years. And so that's why you're seeing some corrections in commercial real estate values, including multifamily housing, because now cap rates need to go up because the risk-free rate has gone up and appears that it will stay up for some time. So you have a long track record as a professional asset manager. You use the word underweighting, to refer to underweight to refer to something related to stock portfolio earlier.

Could you explain what that means and what kind of portfolio concentration your ideal portfolio looks like in today's environment, how it might have shifted from a few years ago? Sure. So when I say underweight, what I'm saying is so we have some static, let's say 70% stock, 30% bond portfolios that own a couple Vanguard funds. So that's sort of a starting point. And then we show, then we have some portfolios where we include, you know, more of a value tilt on the stock side, more small cap. And, you know, as part of that weighting, you know, we're maybe like 65% stocks. And the point of mentioning it at all is not so people go out and, you know, follow our models

because they can, but it's not, that's not the point. The point is we're not overly bearish right now. So we're not saying that the world is going to pot, that we should be completely out of stocks because valuations for stocks outside of the U.S. are not expensive. And there are still opportunities in dividend yields, for example. I mean, they're attractive. And so there are elements. And so when I say underweight, I'm just saying that we're not fully allocated.

We have a little less, you know, more in cash, a little less in stock. a little less in stocks, but we're not overly bearish. It's just recognizing that economic trends have deteriorated, but they haven't fallen off a cliff either. And we've been sort of waiting around for two years. And so in that environment, you don't want to get overly bearish. And, you know, as younger investors, probably not bearish at all because the time horizons are so long, 30 years or more.

One of the things you talk about on your podcast is the economy. And I'm not an economist, but I'm wondering if there's anything you're currently keep, any factors in the economy that you're currently keeping an eye on that those of us who might not pay so much attention should be paying a little bit more attention to. Well, I mean, we talked about inflation. So certainly, and I don't know to what extent people pay attention to inflation, but it's certainly something we look at on a monthly basis just to understand, you know, is inflation coming down? We also spent a lot of time on the podcast talking about leading economic indicators. So, you know, one, for example, is purchasing manager indices or PMI. These are surveys that are done around the world. So they're just asking businesses, how's business?

Now, how are your new orders? What's your inventory like? What kind of prices are you paying? What about your employment in terms of who you're hiring? And these things are adjusted to where if it's above 50, it signals an expanding economy. And if it's below 50, it basically normalizes to an economy contracting. And it's one of the main signals that we use just to kind of get an understanding where we are economically. And there's the manufacturing element and the services.

Now, does a typical investor need to follow that? probably not, but it's a simple tool and it's a helpful tool because it's so comprehensive, then it's one number. And so if, you know, most of the economies are above 50, then things are going well. And we're sort of kind of right around 50 right now, which is why it's not like in March 2020 when the PMI data plummeted to 42 or even into the 30s, like during the great financial crisis. And so it's sort of just one signal.

And we want to simplify investing as much as possible. But if someone's interested in where are we in the economy, then looking at, you know, what's known as the JP Morgan, you know, global manufacturing PMI or the global services PMI and just kind of know where that's at can be helpful. And there's there's equivalent in the U.S. There is a U.S. PMI, you know, market or as S&P provides it as well as ISM does an analysis of that. So, you know, when I hear your overall position is, hey, the economy's fine right now. You know, everyone's claring, you know, a lot of people are out there declaring doom and gloom in a lot of things. But like it seems like it's, you know, right, you know, neither good nor bad.

And if anything, I'm just going to shift literally 5% of my portfolio more to debt, probably just because interest rates are higher and the returns are a little better in the debt space now in the bond space, but still keep in the market from an equity perspective. I read that, first of all, is that an accurate assessment? And then second, if so, that's bad news for real estate, right? Because I would presume in that case you would not expect interest rates, for example, to come down in the near future if that's your read on the economy. Yeah. So I would say that, so one of the things that we look at, when we look at overall investment conditions, we rate them red, green, or yellow.

And, you know, one out, you know, overall investment conditions. which include asset class valuations, it includes the economy or economic trends, and it includes what we call market internals. It's just a level of fear and greed in the market. And they're low neutral. So, you know, not overall, but the economy-wise, it's been read for eight months now. And so some of this, like this PMI data hasn't fallen off the cliff, but it's not been above 50, right? So that is some warning sign, but you're right. Because there isn't really a housing bubble or a debt bubble or a global pandemic where we have no idea, you know, what mass casualties would be at the time in early 2020, no, it's sort of a, it's a correction and economic contraction. You know, if we get a recession, it probably won't be very deep or very long.

and the markets are so forward-looking, they're already looking for the recovery and earnings. And we're actually seeing that on the earnings front. Like, earnings have not, have fallen over the past year, but analysts are expecting earnings to improve. And so, but it also means inflation hasn't come down. Because we haven't had a deeper session, there's a lot of money out there. And people still have a lot of savings that they're spending. You know, now they're going traveling. If you look at airline flights, everybody's going to Europe.

I mean, people that have income, discretionary income, they're all traveling. And so that's not an environment where, right, that the economy is going to fall off a cliff. And it is an environment where interest rates could stay higher. And you're seeing sort of this slow correction in real estate. Only half the people are going back to work in major cities. They're not in their offices. But there was just a building that sold in Fort Worth at a premium in the past week. Well, what kind of building was it? It's a Class A building. So people are sort of upgrading to the nicer buildings, and the buildings that are suffering are those that, you know, B class aren't as nice. And they're seeing their valuations marked down. And you're seeing basically the equity holders walking away and turning the keys over to the bank. And so you had this sort of ongoing correction. But that doesn't mean everything in real estate is bad. There's things that have done very well. Because that's why real estate is. As you know, it's incredibly.

innovative and things change over time. But if you have the wrong building, one that's not as nice in the office space, then, yeah, you're potentially suffering there. On the apartment front, one of the things that concerns me is the sheer number of apartments coming online. So there's a million apartments under construction right now. And so if you own multifamily housing, such as maybe in the southeast or southwest, there's a potential concern because you can't, Those rental rates are starting to fall a little bit, at least stagnate because of the ongoing supply. You've mentioned a couple of reports, and there's reports that come out every month or every quarter, the consumer price index, the inflation, the jobs report, the GDP, the non-farm payroll, the consumer confidence. Which reports are really important to pay attention to for the average investor, and which one should they just kind of gloss over when the radio announcer starts to reading them off?

The average investor. You know, the average investor, they could probably... The rest of us. The rest of us could probably ignore it, right? Because they can buy their target date funds or their index funds and just focus on saving and increasing their income. Oh. One is focused on, you know, is interested in the economy than the two that I mentioned,

the PMI surveys in the consumer price index. You know, part of it is... just understanding the narrative. And so we're not, we don't forecast. So we're not here predicting the economy is going into recession. We just want to know what the market's temperature is so we know if we should get out of the way. And the reality is you hardly ever have to get out of the way. Like 2008 doesn't come very often. Now we've had two. We had 2008 and we've had a global pandemic, but it's infrequent. And so it's helpful to know where we start. I think investors should probably be more focused on is the market expensive or not,

as opposed to trying to figure out whether we're going to have a recession or not. And so one of the things that we have recommended for a number of years is to have less in the U.S. stock market because the U.S. stock market is so expensive relative to its average. Whereas the non-U.S., which has much higher dividend yields of 3%, so they're generating more cash. The earnings growth of non-U.S. versus U.S. isn't that different. And the valuations are cheaper. And so if, if think about on a real estate basis, would you rather have a building that has a higher cash yield that has comparable, you know, rental growth to a lower cash yielding building, but it's also cheaper? That's where you want to invest. And it's, it works the same way for the stock market. We can look at the cash flow. or is the cash, you know, how fast is that cash flow growing in terms of earnings? And what are we paying for that cash flow in terms of the price to earnings ratio? Tax season is one of the only times all year when most people actually look at their full financial picture,

including income, spending, savings, investments, the whole thing. And if you're like most folks, it can be a little eye-opening. That's why I like Monarch. It helps you see exactly where your money is going. And more importantly, where your tax refund can make the biggest impact. Because the goal isn't just to look backward. It's to actually make progress. Simplify your finances with Monarch.

Monarch is the all-in-one personal finance tool designed to make your life easier. It brings your entire financial life, including budgeting, accounts and investments, net worth, and future planning together in one dashboard on your phone or your laptop. Feel aware and in control of your finances this tax season and get 50% off your Monarch's subscription with the code pockets. What I personally like is that Monarch keeps you focused on achieving, not just tracking. You can see your budgets, debt payoff, savings goals, and net worth all in one place. So every decision actually moves in a needle. Achieve your financial goals for good with Monarch, the all-in-one tool.

that makes money management simple. Use the code pockets at monarch.com for half off your first year. That's 50% off at monarch.com code pockets. You just realized your business needed to hire someone yesterday. How can you find amazing candidates fast? Easy. Just use Indeed. When it comes to hiring, Indeed is all you need. That means you can stop struggling to get your job notice on other job sites.

Indeed's sponsor jobs helps you stand out and hire the right people quickly. Your job post jumps straight to the top of the page where your ideal candidates are looking and it works sponsored jobs on indeed get 45% more applications than non-sponsored posts the best part no monthly subscriptions or long-term contracts you only pay for results and speaking of results in the minute i've been talking to you 23 people just got hired through indeed worldwide there's no need to wait any longer speed up your hiring right now with indeed and listeners of this show will get a seventy five dollar sponsored job credit to get your jobs more visibility at indeed dot com slash bigger pockets just go to indeed dot com slash bigger pockets just go to indeed dot com slash big Pockets right now and support our show by saying you heard about Indeed on this podcast. Indeed.com slash bigger pockets. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring, Indeed is all you need. When you want more, start your business with Northwest Registered Agent and get access to thousands of free guides, tools, and legal forms to help you launch and protect your business all in one place. Build your complete business identity with Northwest today. Northwest

Registered Agent has been helping small business owners and entrepreneurs launch and grow businesses for nearly 30 years. They are the largest registered agent and LLC service in the U.S. with over 1,500 corporate guides who are real people who know your local laws and can help you and your business every step of the way. Northwest makes life easy for business owners. They don't just help you form your business. They give you the free tools you need after you form it, like operating agreements, meeting minutes, and thousands of how-to guides that explain the complicated ins and outs of running a business. And with Northwest, privacy is automatic. They never sell your data. And all services are handled in-house because privacy by default is their pledge to all customers. Visit northwest registered agent.com and start building something amazing.

Get more with Northwest Registered Agent at northwest registered agent.com slash money free. Okay, you said non-US market, and that made me think of Scott and his Uber successful investment in a Chinese juice company a couple of years ago where I believe his current holding value is zero dollars. So which non-U.S. markets are you more favorably leading towards and which would you say, maybe not? Well, when I say non-U.S., I'm saying buy all of it.

So buy a, can buy a world XUS ETF that has thousands and thousands of companies in it. Because one of the, so we don't purchase, we don't recommend individual stocks. I don't invest in individual stocks because when you, you know, it's easier to invest in an individual building, right, because it's appraisal base. You can get comparables. When you're investing in an individual stock, you're competing against Wall Street. You're competing against all these analysts that are looking at the company, coming up with earnings estimates. And so when you buy an individual stock, you're saying, first off, the price is wrong, that everyone else is wrong. The consensus that's buying and selling the stock and estimating earnings is wrong. And so in order for the stock to do well,

it's got to do better than what everybody expects. It has a surprise to the upside. And this is critical when it comes to stock investing individual stocks because we don't have the rest of us an informational edge to say, no, the market's wrong, all the investors are wrong, Netflix is going to do better than everybody expects. And so my stock will outperform the SP 500 because it's going to do better than everyone expects, which is why if you buy an exchange trade of fund or an index fund that has hundreds of thousands of holdings, what you'll see is some will do worse than expected and their stocks will fall. But some will do better than expected, and those cancel out. So at the end of the day, what drives the returns of an ETF is the dividend yield, the cash, and the earnings growth in aggregate,

which is tied to the growth of the economy. And whether the overall stock market gets more expensive or cheaper over time, which is why in investing in a non-U.S. Exchange traded fund, such as something at Vanguard, it has a higher dividend yield. There's a 3% dividend yield versus 1.5% for the U.S. stock market. So right there, you have a 1.5% advantage compared to U.S. stocks. And if the earnings grow 5% to 6% per year over the next decade, you can add those two. a 3% dividend yield plus 6% earnings growth, that's a 9% return for non-U.S. Stokes. Whereas if U.S. stocks has a 1.5% dividend yield and 6% earnings growth, that's 7.5% expect a return.

But then we're sitting here with price to earnings ratios for U.S. stocks around 22, whereas they're 15, the P.E. for non-U.S. So it's much cheaper. And that's what I'm saying is don't figure out which juice company to buy overseas or China. Just buy the overall market and have some developed markets, have some Europe, have some Asia, have some emerging markets. And you can do it one ETF and then you're good. So how should I think about this asset, I love this discussion. I haven't really considered this.

I'm in all, my index fund portfolio is essentially all SMP 500 stocks, which are heavily U.S.-based here. I have a two-part question here. Next. One, what would you say? I read recently that the, in 2023, year-to-date returns for the S&P 500 or the U.S. stock market. I can't remember which one. But basically, they were completely inflated up to 15% by the fangs. So these are Facebook, alphabet, Amazon, and a couple of those other guys.

And those return, the positive returns from those five companies were basically lifting the market from a negative 2% return, excluding them to a 15% return. How does that factor into your thinking first? And then second, how would you kind of develop a portfolio thesis for this external? How much should I put in international funds excluding the U.S.? How much should I put in the U.S.? How should I think about that problem? So the global stock market, so if we wait, if we rate or rank all the companies by size,

60% of this global stock market is U.S., 40% is non-U.S. So if you just want to be equal to the market, now what is, you know, the consensus of the market, the size, you should have 40% of your stock allocation in non-U.S. So when you're investing 100% in U.S., you're right, because it is size-weighted and because of the whole AI extravaganza that everybody is excited about, that, which we can talk about, if you would like. You're right. You have these top five holdings that have driven the market.

If we look at the S&P on an equal-weighted basis, so every stock is equal, it's returned about 5% here to date. And if somebody's really aggressive, it's like, I got a question the other day from one of our members, and they asked, why not just the NASDAQ? So the NASDAQ 100. The NASDAQ 100 is the top 100 U.S. stocks. Well, it's 30%.

in those top five companies. And the problem with having such a big weight in the top five companies is, again, their prices reflect the consensus. And so invariably, when a company disappoints, especially when they're very expensive, then they fall. And you'd see a change in the top five companies over time. And so having 40% percent. outside the U.S. would be a good starting point. And then you could have some more, for example,

you can buy more dividend yielding ETFs, right? And they're not going to have the big allocation to those top five companies. But it also means in a year like this year that that portfolio isn't going to do as well. And that stinks when it comes to investing because there's always something doing better and that gets all the press, et cetera. And that's why we like to come back and just focus on principles. The principle is diversify as much as possible, recognize that something will always be the hot thing, and maybe we have a little bit in it, but ultimately focus, just like you do with real estate, what's the cash flow, the dividend yield for stocks or the interest income for bonds? Is that cash flow growing, and what are you paying for that?

I love it. I love the principles first focus with this. The last 10 years, I started investing when I was you know, 21, 22 years old. And bond rates were like essentially close to zero and declining to zero over that decade. That was the first decade of my life investing. So I never had any allocation to bonds until recently. And the reason I'm changing that personally is because of the rising interest rate environment. I'm like, I'm liking short term debt because I don't know how interest rates are going to move. And I don't want to have a lot of all, you know, subjectivity to that. When you think about the 35% waiting, the slight change you made to a potential portfolio, to wait a little bit more towards debt, how should someone think about getting into

that market? Should they be factoring in things like the time horizon on the underlying debt? Are there ETFs that people should look into or think about? Well, right now, first off, make sure your cash is invested. So it's just not sitting there earning whatever banks pay nowadays, right? I think we have a credit union. I looked and it's, I think they raised it to 0.2% is what they were paying on, on at a credit union. So you can, you can buy a money market mutual fund, which is a, a fund that basically at this point is investing most of their assets at the Federal Reserve is what they're getting and they're getting four or five percent. So that's the starting point. The other interesting area right now, which is the first time in a deck, you mentioned a decade for the first time in a debt. For the first time in a decade, it actually makes sense to purchase Treasury inflation protection security. So these are inflation protected bonds. Anyone can go to Treasury Direct if you're a U.S. investor and you can purchase the latest five-year tips. It is a bond that is yielding close to 2%. So that's your real rate. And then you get inflation on top of that. And you can hold it for five years and you're

going to earn 2% plus whatever the rate of inflation is. And it's, it's completely safe. And you don't have to worry about, you know, which is safer than investing in like a TIPS ETF, because for the exact reasons you point out, Scott, if interest rates go up, you get volatility because the value of that ETF can go down. But if you buy an individual treasury inflation protection security and you hold it into maturity, you lock in that yield, that 2% yield plus the rate of inflation. And people can figure out, tips are not that hard to figure out. Or Treasury Direct. It's a government bond that's protected against inflation and hold one for five years.

You know, and buy one of the newly issued ones. They do an auction about every month. And you just say, I want to buy whatever, $20,000 or $10,000 of the latest tips. And it'll take your money and you'll have. it on your Treasury Direct account. Okay. So you are, you guys are starting to get into some pretty complicated things. And I've got friends that are involved in complicated things.

And one of the things that I really loved about your last visit with us, David, was when you spoke, you said, the first thing you should ask yourself is whenever you're investing in anything, you should be able to answer the question, what is it? this is a quote that I copied from our last transcript. You should be able to describe in detail if you were talking to a friend. I had a college client, one of my first endowment clients, he said to me, I'm not comfortable investing in anything that I cannot explain to somebody that's not on our investment committee.

So if I can't explain it, then we shouldn't invest in it. What would you say to somebody who is overwhelmed by investing, but keeps hearing that you should be investing because I yes, you should invest. You should invest in the stock market. I have a huge love of the stock market. I have huge support for the stock market. I truly believe in the future of the American economy and the American stock market going forward. I don't know anything about foreign stocks. I don't invest in anything foreign, although now I'm going to start doing research. So thanks for that rabbit hole. You're sending me down, David. But what would you give it? What advice would give to somebody who is feeling overwhelmed by all of the things that we're discussing at maybe a

higher level or things that their friends are discussing? Well, the simplest is what I mentioned earlier. So most people have a 401k plan with their employer or maybe they don't. And so they can open an account at Vanguard and they can decide which year they hope to retire and they can buy a target date fund, a 2040 fund, for example. And the Vanguard will, We'll do all that. They'll have an allocation to stocks. They'll have an allocation to bonds. And they'll have an allocation to both U.S. and non-U.S. And so you don't have to worry about it. Now, granted, we're talking, we've talked about tips. We've talked about PMI. But I'm assuming that the individuals that listen to your podcast are interested in, you know, money and investing.

And so, but for typical people, if they could just get their 401k match and invest in a target date fund and go on with their lives. Because the biggest thing is, you know, advance their career and figure out how can I save 10 to 20% of my income or whatever so that ultimately they can benefit from the compounding of these cash flows over time and especially on a tax deferred basis if you're in a 401k. And that's the starting point. And for many people, that's the ending point. That's enough. Like focus on making more money in your your career and making, you know, spending time with your family and friends, and don't feel like you have to invest in the latest cryptocurrency or you need to be adjusting your allocation.

Because most people don't. And it's just some of us that enjoy doing it. And they, you know, especially if you approach retirement, they want to, you know, eke out a little more yield or whatever. But for many of us, they don't, you don't have to. I love that. Straight from David Stein, from money for the rest of us, mouth. You don't have to invest in absolutely everything. And by the way, that was the answer I was looking for, David. I knew you were going to, I knew you were going to come through. So David, for those who are a little bit, you know, that a little bit more advanced than that, you know, and are looking to retire early in particular, what do you think is enough these days to retire? We did an episode

last week called Live Like You're Already Retired. And so the first thing is try not to retire. So you can quit your job, but like I quit my job 10 years ago, 11 years ago now. And yes, I could have retired and be frugal and not work again. Well, I'd be more than frugal, but not spend as much as I want. And retirement is a huge mental shift. If you're really going to live on your portfolio, that's hard because if you just spent 20 years collecting income, from pay and then not, it can really mess with your mind. And so I think most people should figure out a way that,

yeah, I'm going to live some on my portfolio, but I'm also going to figure out a way to generate other income. Be a side project, a part-time job, because the reality is the 4% rule is a good starting point, but there are some challenges with it, because there are many countries where it depends on what the stock market does. If the stock market returns 8, 9% per year, yeah, 4% would be fine. But if you were in Japan in the late 80s and retired and wanted to use the 4% rule,

you've run out of money already because their stock market didn't support it. And there's been studies that said, look, well, maybe it's 3%. Like, I would be more comfortable with 3% rule because, again, what you're trying to do is sort of like endowment finance. Like so your, your spending rate plus inflation to not run out of money, the spending rate plus inflation, that's what you need to earn.

So if inflation, if you're using the 4% rule and inflation is 3%, then that means your portfolio has to earn 7% to never have to run out of money. Now, the problem is people are going to die, but it's figuring out, well, what is that sort of that glide? path, how much can I spend for a 40-year retirement? And when I quit in my mid-40s, I couldn't imagine. Like, how do you plan for 50 years? And what I realize is, I don't. I just have to make it one year

at a time. So did my net worth grow after spending, did at least grow by the rate of inflation? And if you can grow your net worth through your investment income, through your outside work, and it keeps growing, to me, that's a much safer place to be if you're in your 40s retiring or in your 50s. And if you're in your 70s or 80s and you really are done, then you could, there's many things you can do. But one would be, and I'll do it. If I'm in my 70s, I'll buy an immediate annuity, which basically will pay me income for life and let the insurance company work. about investing it. Because if somebody's 70 right now, they can take, they'll get 8% on their portfolio. So $100,000, they would get 8% of that every year. So that's $8,000 right there. So if you have more than that, then you're going to get more of that. So but you get that,

and that's one way to do it. And most people that don't understand investing should be looking closer at immediate annuities. Because it meant to your question earlier, like people that are overwhelmed by investing and then they retire and they're feeling like, okay, now I have this nest egg that has to sustain me to the rest of my life. That's an incredibly overwhelming problem. That's way more overwhelming than saving for retirement when you actually have a paycheck. But when you don't have one, like consider investing in, you know, an annuity for a portion

of it if you don't have a traditional. pension plan or defined benefit plan. And this is why I'm so passionate about just teaching people to start investing. And, you know, the index fund is what we are really, really passionate about here because you just set it and forget it. Choose the index fund and just put money into it every single month or quarter, like whatever you're, however frequent you have made your decision to invest in. But you don't have to know everything. You don't have to be investing in the latest and greatest. It broke my heart to see all of those GameStop and AMC investors.

When Robin Hood was doing all of that, they didn't know what they were doing. They were jumping on a bandwagon. They were throwing in money that they couldn't afford to lose. And then Robin Hood wouldn't let them sell. And all of a sudden, they lost everything that they had put in or they, they put in, you know, not the people in the beginning, but the people who started jumping in on the bandwagon or the crypto people, you know, they buy it 60,000 thinking that it was going to continue to go up and then it dropped. And I don't even know what crypto is at right now because I have

$0 in that. But, you know, just people who are making uninformed choices about their investing, I can understand why they're doing it. But it just really makes me feel sad when I see people who have lost everything or lost so much because they didn't know what they were doing. And then to hear those stories on the news and see other people say, oh, well, I don't want to lose it, so I'm just not going to invest at all. I'm like, but the stock market's different if you invest in a different way. But how do you? Right. And so, but again, it's a, it's not, we can say index funds and then people want to know which index fund. And I think there's a, there's a base level of knowledge. You can do a target date fund. There's a reason why.

Target of Adeptate funds have both U.S. and non-U.S. index funds in that. And so at a minimum, people should have, they could own VT, for example, which is a Vanguard total world stock market ETF. So it has U.S. and non-U.S. because we don't want to have home country bias. If you're Canadian, should you have 90% of your stock exposure to Canadian stocks? No. But as many U.S. investors, they figure, well, you know, Pepsi's around the world, there is a benefit to global diversification because there is no given that the U.S. stock market will continue to outperform indefinitely, definitely like it has the past decade, especially given it's more expensive than the rest of the world. So at least globally diversified index funds would be the way to go.

So I have two kind of reactions to what you said there. First, the 4% rule in the 3% commentary. I think there's a lot of folks out there that would disagree with the, hey, you might want to go down to the 3% and cite a large body of research around the 4% rule. And I would just want to comment that while there's a lot of research on the 4% rule, a lot of debate about what is the right number here, the fact of the matter is that of the hundreds of people I've now met that are to consider themselves financially independent in no personally, none of them, or maybe one couple out of that entire crew actually is retired and does not earn additional income on a true 4% rule portfolio.

So there's the theory, which I think a lot of people would argue with you, David, and say is very sound. And there's the practice, which I think you were alluding to as well. Are you going to be actually comfortable on this? Of nobody actually retiring on just that 4% rule without a few aces in the whole, be it a pension, a large cash position, a real estate portfolio on top of that, a small business or whatever. out there. Well, right.

I mean, the 4% rule is a good starting point. I was, you know, I mentioned 3% if that was, right, entire, I wasn't going to change throughout my entire retirement. But that's the beauty of retirement. We can change how much we spend each year. So if we start out the 4% rule and the market falls 10% per year for three years to where suddenly, oh, we're now spending. 8% of our portfolio, and it's only going to last 20 years at that rate, then we need to adjust.

And so I agree with you. I think, Scott, we need the flexibility to adjust the rules. We just don't want to naively say 4% is it. And no matter what, I'm going to, because if you model it out with a 4% rule, there's, you know, if you do a Monte Carlo simulation, there's about a 10% risk of running out of out of money during retirement. So who does anything with a 10% risk of ruined? And just like, I'm just going until I'm ruined. We don't do that. We adapt and adjust so that we're not ruined. And that's what most retirees do. They're flexible. They can adjust. So start with a 4% rule and be

willing to adjust if the market doesn't support it. And maybe you can spend more than that if we get, you know, an incredibly good markets for the next decade. The other thing I wanted to react, to is the comment you made around annuities. So you're one of the most sophisticated investors we talked to on Bigger Pockets Money. You manage, you know, $20 billion in assets at one point in your career and have these great thoughts. You know, until probably the last month or two, I would have kind of considered an annuity, a dirty word, a salesy word that has no, no place on the Bigger Pockets Money podcast, probably incorrectly. I read a book recently called Die with Zero by Bill Perkins, and he kind of talked about those things.

as well. And there's a certain, you know, uh, uh, attraction, I think of annuities, especially with rising interest rates and the rising, you know, I think you literally can now go out and get an eight and a half percent annuity, um, for example, um, you tape it into Google and you'll be able to find some of those things. You know, what would you say to people who kind of share that same viewpoint that I might have had a year, a month or two ago about annuities being a complete waste of time and a rip off, uh, in that context. Have recent events changed? Or should their thinking have been different all along around annuities, and they're just a useful tool and have been for a long time. Well, they have been for a long time, but I was like you. So I, in 2008 during the great financial crisis, we managed money for financial planners. So, and I went to Baltimore, one of our financial planner clients, and they had their, they had their basically retirees come in. And I presented to them. And they were,

literally shell-shocked. And because they had stock exposure and like we didn't choose the allocation for them, but we were managing the underlying assets. And in many cases, they had lost 30 to 40% of their assets. And I remember looking at them and seeing the fear in the rise and trying to alleviate it, but I walked away. It's like, there's got to be a better way. Like, who gambles the retirement on whether the stock market's going to be up or not? And so that's, I started going to a number of insurance conferences. Like, well, there's got to be a solution. And the reality is it's annuities because the benefit and there's all kinds of annuities. And there are bad annuities and there are better annuities or good annuities. So an immediate annuities is the one I was referring to is, and I've seen this with family

members where they're credibly worried about investing and they take a couple hundred thousand dollars and they buy an annuity from a highly rated company in New York Life. And then it pays them a check every month for the rest of their life. And that can be so peacegiving to an investor that they don't have to worry about that. And the reason why annuities can pay the 8% is because it's an annuiting pool. Annuities have been around for millennia because with an immediate annuity, if you give the principle to them, and then if you die within the first five years, you can get some of it back. but eventually it gets to the point where some of the people die and the insurance company then has

their money and can pay the people that live to be into their mid-90s. And so it takes out that longevity risk that for, and it doesn't have to be all your portfolio, but a portion of the portfolio should be annuitized. And for most people, that's what it used to be because you had a pension along with Social Security. And so it's a way to take some money off the table and get a check for the rest of your life and know it's going to be there. And then you can use the other part of your portfolio to basically meet, you know, increased expenses due to inflation. And they're a great tool.

They've been around for years, but most people aren't aware of them because they don't want to lose that control. It's like, why would I give an insurance company half my money? Well, you would because they're pooling it with other people and you might live to your mid-90s. and most states have insurance pools in case the annuity company goes under and you buy from an insurance company like New York Life that's been around for several hundred years or at least over 100 years. And it's a way, it's just a tool. It's one tool of many that can be used in retirement.

Yeah. And one other point that I think, you know, Bill Perkins would make or made in, and I was zero, is this concept of many investors have a lot of trouble, like let's say you have a million dollars. you're going to have a lot of trouble spending 8% of that million, $80,000, if it's invested in your investment portfolio because of the rational way you'd think about spending that money. You wouldn't spend the target return. You're going to spend something considerably lower than that. If you have an annuity, you're going to spend all of it, right? Or you're much more likely to spend a bigger chunk of it and feel very good about that spending

to a degree. So there was kind of a psychological benefit of it in a way that I had never really fully grasped. I have not owned any annuities, and I'm not sure I actually will, but I am no longer kind of like, they're a dirty word that we're going to, you know, stay away from here on BP money because I think there's some valid use cases for that point and the ones that you brought up. Well, you shouldn't. I mean, at your age, you should not have an annuity. You buy an annuity when you're 70 or 65 and you're tired of investing in real estate or retire or whatever, right? and you just want to basically lock in an income stream for your rest of your life,

which allows you, as you point out, to potentially be more aggressive with the rest of your portfolio because you don't have that fear. Like, I can't spend my money because it's all dependent on the stock market. Well, if I know that I have Social Security and I have an annuity and whatever, I get some rent from a building, then maybe I can go buy a flyer, a juice company or a crypto, you know, just, or something interesting just for fun because I'm not so fearful that I'll lose all my money because potentially you only lose a part of it, the part that you speculated on. Is there an age minimum that you can start collecting on your annuity?

No, you can do it at any age, but the way that the math works, because they're paying, they're paying the payment for, again, this is immediate annuities, so this is separate from variable annuities or fixed annuities. straight up, income for life, immediate annuity, single premium. So you pay the premium once, and then you start collecting the income. So the older you are, the higher the payment because your life expectancy is going down. So if you're out, you know, if you're 40, you're buying an immediate annuity, it's going to be a much lower payment because your life expectancy is 50 years. And so the two drivers of annuity payments are life expectancy and an interest rate. So as interest rates have

gone up, annuity payments have also gone up. So if you're retired at, you know, 60 or 70, now's a great time to buy an annuity because interest rates are very high. And so annuity payouts are high, higher than they were five to seven years ago. Awesome. Well, I think we should do an episode at some point on annuities, Mindy, because I think that they're an interesting topic and a tool that we really haven't covered too much in the past. And that I think is a valuable one for especially our older listeners that are hearing retirement age and can benefit from potentially much higher payments. So that sounds like yet another good reason to, you know, try to do everything you can to take care of your health here as well, because you're going to get a better financial return on the annuity. Oh, right. Exactly.

Yeah. If you're able to live longer. So lots of interesting things here. And again, it's something a world I got to wrap my mind around and learn more about. I absolutely agree that we should do an episode on that. I was thinking of the way that Joe Sal Siahe explained life insurance and whole life versus term life. And when I asked him which one was better in that episode, he's like, well, it isn't one is better than the other. It depends on what you need. And like Scott, I have always thought that annuity is a four-letter word.

Why would you invest in an annuity? That's silly. But the way you described it, David, was. made me rethink it. Yeah, you should do an upset on it. I appreciate your information. That was very helpful. David, thank you so much for coming on the show today.

Are there any other parting thoughts you'd like to leave us with before we adjourn here? No. I think the theme is that investing doesn't have to be complicated, that there are tools that we can use, target date fund, index funds, global diversification, immediate annuities when you get of age, that it doesn't have to be in real estate if you want to do that. Or even, you know, we didn't talk about equity reeds, which is a simple way to invest in commercial real estate. And those are tools that are out there that we can use and not feel overwhelmed.

Awesome. David, where can people find you online? So our website is that money for the rest of us.com. We also have a new project we're working on at assetcamp.com. and then I'm occasionally on, well, at Jady Stein on Twitter, but I haven't spent a whole lot of time with social media. You can also find me on LinkedIn. You can reach out there.

Wonderful. David, thank you so much for your time today and we will talk to you soon. Thanks for having me. Okay, Scott, that was so much fun. First of all, David is such a good teacher. I love the way that you can throw any question at him and he can smoothly answer it. I am very excited about learning more about annuities and also that global ETF thing he was talking about. I have a new deep dive to do.

Yeah. I mean, immediately after the conversation, I googled index funds that exclude U.S. stocks and was able to find a few, including from Vanguard, that I'm really interested in. You know, I'm not going to stop investing in U.S. stocks, but I might add more of that international exposure to my portfolio in the context of my stock portfolio following this conversation. So I think it was just a really good thing. Probably should have done it years ago, frankly, because it's probably just best practice, but something that I'd been ignoring personally in my portfolio and we'll probably rectify it in the near future. Yeah, same.

I'm going to have a big old conversation with Carl after he listens to this episode and see what allocations we're going to, what allocation changes we're going to make to our portfolio. Yeah. So two easy ways to do that. If you're brand new, you could go with a total international index fund. You can Google those and find out more about them. We're not going to recommend specific things for obvious reasons. Or you can Google for index funds that exclude the U.S. stock market if you already have a lot of the U.S. stock exposure.

So there would be two simple ways to begin thinking about if you're interested in international stock exposure. We're not recommending or not recommending that. That's just a path for you to go down and explore if you'd like to look at those things after this podcast. That was very helpful, Scott. Thanks for sharing that. All right, should we get out of here? Let's do it. That wraps up this episode of the Bigger Pockets Money podcast. He is Scott Trench and I am Mindy Jensen saying, time to scoot, little newt. If you enjoyed today's episode, please give us a five-star review on Spotify or Apple. And if you're looking for even more money content, feel free to visit our YouTube channel at YouTube.com slash Bigger Pockets Money. Bigger Pockets Money was created by Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench, produced by Kaelan Bennett. Editing by Exodus media, copywriting by Nate Weintraub.

Lastly, a big thank you to the Bigger Pockets team for making this show possible.