Blank Check with Griffin & David - Joker
Episode Date: October 13, 2019HA HA HA! On the week of its release in October of 2019, Griffin and David discussed Joker. Together they examine all the unearned controversy surrounding the film, Todd Phillips' career, the performa...nces of Joaquin Phoenix and Robert De Niro, the portrayal of a gritty 1970's New York City and more! Music Selection: "Entrance of the Gladiators" by Julius Fučík
Transcript
Discussion (0)
I used to think that my life was a tragedy, but now I've realized it's a podcast.
It's a podcast.
I believe he says in the movie, he says a fucking tragedy or a fucking podcast, right?
Doesn't he say fuck?
Maybe.
You guys just saw it.
I already forget it.
I used to think that my life was a fucking tragedy, but now
I realize it's a fucking
podcast.
Hold on, let me just sit
like concaved,
completely like falling in on myself.
But you know that's the thing, that skinny people always
sit in the most grotesque ways possible.
That's true.
They always sit in a way that looks incredibly uncomfortable.
Yes, and they become clown murderers.
Right, and splays their rib cages, shoulder blades ripping out of their flesh.
But they're very funny.
Well, and can I say it?
Dare I say it?
I don't know.
A little bit.
Twisted. A little bit. A little bit. Twisted.
A little bit.
A little bit.
Or twisted.
All right, we're done, right?
Welcome to the episode.
Thank you all for listening.
That's all people wanted.
Thank you, thank you.
This, of course, is Blank Check with Griffin Diggs,
a podcast about filmographies,
directors who are master successful around their careers.
I give you a series of blank checks
to make whatever crazy passion projects they want.
Sometimes they laugh. And sometimes
they cry, baby. And
we somehow backed our way
into doing a weird Erstas
miniseries. Erstats
miniseries. Erstats, yeah. I'm decelerating
us out of it, though. Yeah, you know what the
great irony is? Yeah. We were
trying to decelerate already, right?
A hundred percent. Which is why we skipped. We didn't do
Shazam. And I now kind
of view that as a regret. Yeah, that's a good
move. It made... Well, we could do like a...
I know. We'll do it somewhere sometime. I don't know.
But like, it
was because of scheduling, because of how long Burton
was and Dumbo was already going to come out
four weeks after it was released. Right, it was depatting.
And we were like, eh, we're maybe
down-throttling the DC thing in general.
But here's a thing.
Here are two things I never could have predicted.
If you had told me on the outset of this year.
One,
you will find more value
in Avengers Endgame than Joker.
Two, you will find more value in Shazam
than Joker. Right. Three, you will find more value
in Aquaman than Joker. I guess that's
just on the line. Aquaman, I'm enough of a James Wan fan. Okay, okay, fair enough, you'll find more value in Aquaman than Joker. I guess that's just on the line. Aquaman, I'm enough of a James
Wan fan. Okay, okay, fair enough. You'll find more value
in Maleficent 2, Mistress of Evil than Joker.
Sure. But I will say, well, she
is the Mistress of Evil. I will
say, post
Infinity War, I felt totally
burned out on the MCU. You mentioned it on our
Patreon episodes, patreon.com slash blank check.
Please subscribe. Please. And
so I was like, fucking done.
Don't want to see Endgame.
Dreading it, right?
Yeah.
And likewise, I was like, Shazam looks like diarrhea.
Don't know what DC's doing.
Silly.
Don't love Chuck.
Right?
Sure.
And two of my favorite superhero films in years.
Those two.
Yeah.
And I think interesting films that are actually sort of
moving the sub-genre
forward a little bit.
Shazam in particular, I was very
astonished by the balance of
actual dark shit, not
performative dark shit. Yeah.
But also psychologically.
We talked about, on our Patreon episode,
about the scene with his mother.
Yeah. All that stuff.
I mean, our Patreon episode of Black Panther.
Right.
That's where we discussed this.
So we were like, maybe we're done with the DC movies, but I guess we've got to do Joker
because Joker seems so weird.
Sure.
And you and I, a year ago, after being completely flummoxed when they announced this film,
started to come around to like, you know what?
I mean, you know, they cast De Niro and there were those location shots of them
on the subway
and everyone was like,
and Maren was in it.
Right.
And we're like,
I don't know.
Maybe it's good.
And we were also like,
you know what?
I like the idea of making
like just fucking one movie.
Sure.
Right, right.
Which is actually
what DC is basically
a thing that Warner Brothers
is planning with these
comic book movies
going forward.
Which I think is smart.
Which is smart
and is different from the Marvel thing.
The thing that you have to give Todd Phillips all the credit in the world for.
All the money in the world.
Well, please.
Not a single penny.
Was that the line?
Sure.
Nothing.
Nothing.
Absolutely nothing.
No money in the world for you.
Yes.
That movie is essentially the Mr. Burns joke of like where he's like, we don't have anything to spare.
And then all the jewels fall on him and he's like, this house is falling apart.
It should have been called none of the money in the world because that's what he said.
How much do you want to pay for your grandson?
How about none of the money in the world?
He holds up an egg.
Yeah.
One goose egg.
But no, yes, I think we were kind of in on the
idea of that. Oh, no, that's what I was
going to say. Todd Phelps
to his credit
says now, and who knows if this is retroactive
mythologizing, but this matches with the stories I had heard.
He was feeling very
frustrated by the lack of impact
that War Dogs made.
Oh, oh no, I'm so sorry, Todd.
We don't make shitty movies. I agree and we'll get
to that later. Okay. For the rest of
this episode we will get to that.
But he was like it's fucking
all this superhero shit.
How do we use like how do I
work within the system? Because of course comedy
had been cancelled. They couldn't make comedy movies anymore.
Oh yeah Griffin pointed that out
before the movie started. Well the the film begins, of course,
with the mass execution of all comedians.
Comedians get executed. In the town square.
And also, they take...
The guillotines drop. They take also
the famous, the masks of drama and comedy.
Right, right. And they rip them apart
and they smash the comedy one to the ground.
And it's only drama. Right. And they're holding up
and they go, this is all you can make!
The Golden Globes, of course, they pretend to have the two, but then it's only drama. Right, and they're holding up and they go, this is all you can make! The Golden Globes, of course,
they pretend to have the two,
but then it's a massacre.
We knew.
All the comedians
are just led off to slaughter.
We should have seen it coming.
I mean, this is how,
this is why they gave
the award to The Martian
because they're trying
to push comedy out.
And look, I know we've all-
Space poop, though!
We've all been going along with it.
What if I had been interviewing
Todd Phillips when he went on the Cancer CulturekullTrat and I was like,
What about the Martian?
Jesus, Todd.
Most financially successful comedy in the last five years.
What are you talking about?
Is this a comedy at the Globes?
Maybe it is.
That would be the ultimate joke.
I mean...
That would be pretty good.
You know who would love that?
Ricky T.
This one best comedy at the Globe.
Ricky T. Ricky T. Ricky, that? Ricky T. It's one best comedy at the Globe. Ricky T.
Ricky T.
Ricky, Ricky, Ricky T.
Oh, God.
The comedy is canceled.
It's probably the reason why Joker got so twisted.
Because he can't make jokes anymore.
Yeah.
And the movie calls it out.
It calls it out.
And I sighed very loudly.
I love that moment when...
I love the duality of him being like,
I should be able to joke about anything,
but everyone in society has been mean to me.
Totally.
It's really cool.
Right, it's weird.
It's almost like there's this correlation
between the people who claim
that they're being oppressed by society
because they can't tell the jokes
that they want to make about oppressed people.
It's almost like there's something there.
There's this great scene in Joker,
a film we're going to discuss today,
where he pushes some boundaries.
Yeah, here's a great boundary.
Sometimes he misses.
That's the end of those jokes.
I have to stop making them.
They're too easy.
This is a moment I love in Joker
is when, spoiler,
he complains about the fact
that people are so sensitive
you can't make jokes about anything
and then shoots a man
point blank in the face.
And he's right.
We cancel murderers left and right these days.
We're always fucking canceling murderers of talk show hosts.
You know, it's uncomfortable.
We got to talk about it.
Spoiler alert for this film, by the way.
There's no room for murder in woke culture.
Because murder is one of the least woke things there is.
It's very unwoke.
And that's why Joker's my hero.
David, what were you going to say? Sorry.
I thought it was a great scene when Joker did a podcast
with his friend and they ranked the races.
And how funny they are. Or how tragic they are.
Yeah, you're right.
I used to think ranking the races
was a comedy.
Now I realize it's a podcast. Okay, what. I used to think ranking the racist was a comedy. Now I realize it's a podcast.
Okay, what I was going to say is
Todd Phillips goes to
Warner Brothers and goes, what if
DC does the one thing that Marvel can't
do?
Marvel has built this
very airtight, interconnected universe
and you've been trying to do the same
and failing miserably.
So let's take advantage of the fact that we failed.
Because he's got this overall deal at Warner Brothers.
He's one of like four filmmakers who has the golden keys at Warner Brothers.
Right?
Clint.
Yep.
Nolan.
Nolan.
Yep.
I'd argue Phillips and now maybe Bradley.
Beaky.
BC.
Right.
Yeah.
Producer of the film Joker.
Yes. But they've. Yeah. You know, you serve the film Joker. Yes.
But,
but they've talked about,
you know,
as a Warner Brothers has become more and more of a corporate culture that the
only three people they give that level of control to are Phillips,
Nolan,
and Clint.
Yeah,
sure.
Those are the three.
Yeah.
So he says,
I got an idea.
What if you make like a black label series of DC movies?
You do one offs.
You do things that are completely removed from continuity
where you sign bigger talent on,
you do it more prestige,
you take big genre swings.
Here's my example.
I'd love to do the Joker like a 70s Scorsese movie.
And they go, here's your blank check.
Pretty much.
I mean, I believe almost literally
in the Vanity Fair cover story about Joaquin Phoenix says, like, you know what?
I'll find the quote.
Please do.
Because it's actually worth it.
But basically, I think the movie cost.
60?
He says $55 million, which is, you know, a chunk of change.
It's not Justice League money.
It is very expensive for a drama.
It's expensive for an R-rated drama
Inexpensive for a comic book movie
which I think was the selling point. Right
and he says in pitching
the movie to Joaquin Phoenix, Phillips said
think of this as a heist movie. Yes. And Joaquin
was like what are you talking about there's like no action in this
movie. Yeah. And he was like
now my friend made a little
joke. He said
we're going to take 55 million dollars from Warner Brothers and do whatever we want.
And then he was promptly canceled because jokes are illegal.
Also, podcasts are fading.
Joaquin, of course.
Yeah.
He's a good citizen.
Called the police.
He did.
And they came and they guillotined Todd Phillips.
The citizen's arrested.
And that's why this movie was directed by Todd Phillips, head in a jar.
Oh, God. But, yes. I mean, here's the thing why this movie was directed by Todd Phillips, head in a jar. Oh, God.
But, yes.
I mean, here's the thing about this movie.
I don't like it.
I was...
Not a fan?
Not a fan.
And I gotta say, I was a little surprised and frustrated by the ways in which I didn't like it.
Okay.
Because I was trying not to preload him with expectations, but I kind of thought I knew how I was going to feel about this thing.
Well, so I think that's fair because this film has been accompanied with a lot of discussion and hype.
More than pretty much any movie this year, right?
Right up there, certainly.
Arguably more than any movie in years.
And so first, let me talk about myself for a sec because I'm very important and you're trying to cancel me.
But first, I saw the movie first
on like the way,
on like wave three of hype.
Whereas I feel like you saw it
on like wave six or whatever, right?
Venice is the premiere.
The film premieres at Venice.
First wave of reviews.
People,
a few of my critic friends saw it,
other critics see it.
The reaction was pretty positive,
but I would say American critics
were more mixed and more like,
This might be a little dangerous.
Right, right, right.
Liz is bad for the culture was sort of brewing out there.
Right.
Not are people going to shoot up a theater dangerous, but is this bad for the culture dangerous?
So that all happens.
That's all resolved.
Then I'm at the Toronto Film Festival where Joker will premiere in a couple days.
I am getting ready to see Pain and Glory, the wonderful Pedro Almodovar movie.
Retired bit. And I'm just scrolling through my phone. Scrolling away. in a couple days. I am getting ready to see Pain and Glory, the wonderful Pedro Almodovar movie.
Retiredit.
And I'm just scrolling through my phone,
scrolling away.
Scrolling, scrolling, scrolling.
And it's like,
oh, the Venice Awards
are being announced.
Oh, and Lucretia Martel,
famous comic book hater.
One of our finest
living filmmakers.
A great filmmaker.
She was the jury chair this year.
And it's sort of like,
it's one of those things
where, you know,
the winners get invited
to the ceremony and people are like joker is there so perhaps like
joaquin won an award yeah and it's sort of like the awards like start winnowing it's like oh no
joker didn't win that one right joker didn't win that one and then we got to the scenario where it
was only roman polanski's movie and joker were left the exact scenario you want to be in roman
polanski's movie won the runner-up. Joker won the Golden Lion.
Of Venice.
The first studio movie to win, we were looking at it in quite a long time.
1990?
I think it was 80.
Was it 80?
I thought we found one other thing.
80, it was Gloria and...
And Atlantic City, right?
Right, tied.
Wasn't that the duo?
They tied in 1980, but I thought we found one other one
oh Michael Collins
thank you
96
so
but yes
at that point I'm like
a festival that rarely
awards American films
and even more rarely
awards studio films
right
so I'm like
I mean
I start to have it
I'm like
maybe it's good
like maybe like
I know people are
kind of creeped out by it
and I get them
but like
what if it's like
really good
I want to be very
I like 70s Scorsese movies
I want to be very clear about something right here
all three of us would love
nothing more than to love this movie
oh sure
me especially
well no me especially
but I think all three of us for different reasons
have been holding on to this little hope of, like, what if it's great?
Like, what if it's actually kind of an important work?
Yeah.
I mean, I love Joaquin.
And it would be nice to see those elements come together in a way that crystallizes like a movie that speaks to our times.
I'm not saying it has some sort of fucking message.
But even beyond that.
Yeah.
Even if it was just an effective thriller, like with sort of
throwback-y aesthetics, don't have to love it,
but I liked it. Any number
of ways, I think, any
combination of the three of us could have been very satisfied
by this one. We had a
blankie meetup with fans at the Toronto
Film Festival, and it was like the day before I saw
Joker, and I was very much throwing around the
like, maybe it's good concept
to people. Then I saw Joker at Toronto, and I was very much throwing around the like maybe it's good concept to people then I saw Joker at Toronto and I was like oh that was a slog it's incredibly one note I was
really disappointed with it and I was like oh what the fuck like I was genuinely surprised at
myself for sort of getting you know swept up in the hype because I was like oh well that's that's
my thing.
Talk about the waves of this thing.
Since Toronto and since the Venice win,
it has just become this breathless cycle of
debate largely between people who
have not seen this movie.
It's just on and on.
The worst conversations have been happening between the people who have not seen the movie
and this sort of discourse about
oh fuck, we're going to put security guards in theaters because
there's 100% going to be a shooting, which
to me, especially after seeing this movie,
I think
and we are out of the opening
weekend of this film, right?
No incidents reporting other
than people vaping in the theater being
kicked out. Thank you everyone on Twitter for tagging
me in any of those stories.
But there have been zero stories
of anything happening at a Joker screening
that would not have happened at an
Olympus has fallen screening. Right?
Sure.
Or even a good boy's screening.
Yeah.
Joker or bad boy?
In a certain way, that is true.
The original bad boy comedy.
Just pointing that out.
In a certain way, it feels like that was more dangerous.
Was the sort of like, it almost felt like the news media was trying to will into existence
some sort of large calamity connected to this movie.
And then you watch it and it feels kind of like empty, half-hearted provocation.
That's how it felt to me.
Yeah.
100%.
Yeah.
Right, so then, right, we see it at Toronto.
I feel like the buzz at Toronto was a little more mixed.
The movie comes out.
The reviews in America are very mixed.
It's certainly not.
And then two boys, Griffin Newman and Ben Hosley, not David Sims.
Sure.
If we introduced this podcast, we did.
We did.
We did.
Griffin Newman.
Yeah.
Went to see it, you know, one lovely morning. If we introduced this podcast, we did. We did. We did. I'm Griffin. Yeah.
Went to see it, you know, one lovely morning.
Went to see the Joker.
We saw 1030 a.m. screening.
I would like to point out we were sitting next to a young man drinking two Coors Lights Tall Boys.
1030 in the morning.
To make it very clear, it was 1030 in the morning.
We got that cool, cool matinee pricing.
Yep.
But we sat there and kind of...
I
truly... Did you see any good trailers?
What did we see? We
saw... The Michael G.
Borden movie?
Ben's
very excited for Just Mercy. I tried to tell
him... It's very
okay, unfortunately.
It's sort of regular. Just Mercy is just kind of perfunctory. It's like okay, unfortunately. It's sort of regular. Just Mercy is
just kind of perfunctory. It's like
that guy, really good
guy, the movie's like, he's good. And you're like,
yes. Then you walk
out and you're like, what a good guy.
Which is fine. He is a good guy.
We saw the R-rated Red Band
trailer for... Just Mercy?
No, for what? Unrated, out of control.
For Zombieland 2 Double Tap, which I found very funny.
I point out to Ben.
It has the chyrons from the director of Venom.
Sure, right, right, right.
And the writers of Deadpool because those are the jobs that those –
They went on to.
After making Zombieland.
It's not like they were hired to revamp.
They're the Zombieland guys. They're the Zombieland guys. I would say from the writers and directors making Zombieland. It's not like they were hired to revamp. They're the Zombieland guys.
They're the Zombieland guys.
It should say
from the writers and directors
of Zombieland.
Right.
And instead,
it's like
everyone involved in Zombieland,
a movie that is
fine.
Yeah, it's fine.
I saw it on theaters
and was like, okay.
But everyone involved since then
has had at least
one colossal hit.
Well, it almost,
it should be like from the director of Zombieland, but also Venom.
Right.
But also Gangster Squad.
Right.
It should be apologizing.
But you know what I'm saying?
It's like Eisenberg, Oscar nomination.
Harrelson, two Oscar nominations.
Love him.
Stone, two nominations, one win or three?
Three, Birdman.
What's the third? La La Land, what's the favorite oh right of course great performance three nominations
one win yeah abigail breslin i guess is the only person she already had her was already she
right she was coasting in to zombie land as the oscar winner of the cast and it was and academy
award nominee abigail breslin oh right she doesn't have a win she had the and. It was and Academy Award nominee Abigail Breslin. Oh, right. She doesn't have a win. She has the nomination.
No, no, no.
Right, and it was like,
that was like the spec script
that got,
what's their names?
Rhett and Wernick,
the screenwriters on the map.
That was Ruben Fleischer's
debut film.
It was like,
everyone went on.
I love how it set you
on this tangent.
It's a great tangent.
Had this big career,
and I love them just being like,
hey, you loved Venom and Deadpool.
It's a weird time though
to like be sitting in a theater
seeing a packed...
A serious Golden Lion winning Joker movie.
Joker movie that just opened
in nearly $100 million.
And the trailer beforehand
is boasting its connection to
Deadpool and Venom. Right.
Two other, like, you can't
make a movie out of those characters. Sure, two other
That material doesn't
work. These are three
characters that are ostensibly kind of anti-heroes
at best and absolute
villains at worst. Sure. Psychopaths
at worst. Who are not, you know,
they exist to bounce off of people.
And instead they all got their own movies.
Right.
Like three characters where you're like, you cannot make a movie in which they are not standing in juxtaposition.
The whole point is they're the opposite side.
Especially Joker and Venom.
Especially Deadpool.
And Deadpool.
He's riffing on the series.
He's riffing.
David, can I tell you something?
Ben, be just...
Have your trigger finger ready.
Okay, like on SNL when like
Jenny Slade is saying
frag a lot or whatever and you gotta...
Richard Pryor's hosting.
Okay.
David?
I'm ready.
Deadpool knows that he's in a movie.
Okay.
What am I supposed to do
cheer
yeah great rise to your feet in fear
oh boy
no but it was just one of these things where I was just like
yeah I mean you remember how much we were all clowning on the idea like
they're gonna make a fucking Gambit movie with Channing Tatum
and now I'm like make literally anything at this point I guess make a fucking Marrow movie with Channing Tatum. And now I'm like, make literally anything. At this point,
I guess-
Make a fucking Marrow movie.
I don't know.
I guess all of them work.
Yeah, sure.
Pick any one.
I guess any one of them.
Maggot?
Remember Maggot?
Make a Maggot movie.
We could do it.
We could do it.
Do you know,
can I tell you about Maggot?
One of the most,
the most 90s X-Men ever.
He was in like eight issues
and people were like,
get this guy out of here.
He might be the single weirdest superpower ever. Because there in like eight issues and people were like, get this guy out of here. That might be the single weirdest
superpower ever. Because there are ones that are
sillier, but they make sense.
He's a big boy. He's kind of blue.
Blue skinned. He's from South Africa
for some reason. He's got like white hair.
He's got a whole look. He's got like red goggles,
white hair, he's blue skinned, he's all over the place.
He's in that post-Gambit phase where he's got the long
trench coat. He's not wearing like
a uniform. He's wearing like, He looks kind of like the crow.
Here's his power.
He doesn't eat food with his mouth.
He has two metal creatures that look like trilobites that he calls maggots that can eat anything.
They come out of his tummy.
They come out of his tum-tum.
They eat whatever they want to eat, and then they go back inside his tum-tum. They eat whatever they want to eat and then they go back inside his tum-tum and like, you know, give him the
food. You know, a straight line.
A very clean,
understandable superpower. And the
X-Men introduced this guy. That's not a superpower though.
I mean, it's a mutant power in that it's
sort of like, sort of a curse, you know,
like classic. Oh, okay. Here he is.
I guess the idea was, the power
is like, oh, the maggots? See him?
If there's a brick wall, the maggots could eat through the brick wall.
That was kind of all he had to offer.
Right.
And they introduced him as like, get ready.
The next X-Man is here.
Maggot!
Like, you know, they were like rolling out the red carpet for maggot.
So let's make a maggot movie.
Todd Phillips, get him on the horn.
Yeah.
Well, unfortunately, Marvel doesn't have a black label.
Marvel doesn't have a black label.
Isn't this also like
AMC Presents?
It's like the AMC
Fine Art.
The movie's making
a gajillion dollars.
Yeah, AMC Artisan is now any movie
with a budget under $100 million.
That's what's crazy,
right?
Extensibly?
Any movie that just is like
not in a cinematic universe.
It can be a comic book movie.
But I feel like
AMC Artisan
was slapped on
almost every trailer
we saw today.
It might have been
on the fucking
Zombieland 2 trailer.
It was on everything.
Phillips apparently
actually was like, we should come up with a
different name. Oh, really?
We should have like a fucking studio imprint
and call it like DC
Black Label or DC Vertigo
or whatever. Like Marvel Knights or whatever.
Right.
It doesn't have the DC logo? I forget.
It does? No. No, it just has
the great 70s Warner logo.
Right.
The red.
And your big question you had.
It's cool.
Since you saw it.
Oh, it doesn't have the Golden Lion imprint.
It does not have the Golden Lion imprint.
Fuck that bullshit.
Sorry.
Sorry.
So mad.
It's such bullshit.
Usually whatever film wins the Golden Lion has like a title card before the movie where
it says like winner golden line and the
festival logo.
We usually see that in independent
and foreign films that win major
prestigious European
film awards. They want to celebrate that.
It's a brag! A huge brag!
But it was just the idea of
oh man, this is the first studio film to win
the golden line in 20 years. How cool would it be?
20 plus years,
if a movie being released on 3,000 screens
opening weekend starts with the Golden Line, Brad?
Whatever.
I feel like The Shape of Water probably didn't either,
did it, or Roma?
Did that win the Golden Line?
Mm-hmm.
Huh.
Yeah.
I wonder if, I guess it probably didn't either.
I guess I put-
Fuck that.
I feel like unless it's for-
Brag!
You won the award! Everyone should brag, I wonder if, I guess I probably didn't either. I guess I put. Fuck that. I feel like unless it's four. Brag.
You won the award.
Everyone should brag, and they shouldn't be humble about it.
If this movie ended with Joker getting the golden lion, maybe it wouldn't kill Robert De Niro.
Well, in a certain way, it wasn't the most twisted thing Joker ever did.
It was getting the golden lion.
All right.
All right.
We went to see a screening of a different movie last night called Gemini Man, which we will be talking about next week on this very podcast.
Yes.
Much better.
And I said to you— Better than Joker.
Do you agree?
Yes.
Okay.
And you asked me if I had seen Joker yet, and I said no, and I am relishing my final hours of not having an opinion on this movie.
It was this thing where, like, honestly, honestly truly despite being someone who's something of an
omnivore and likes to be part of the conversation
I found it so fucking exhausting.
It's nice to not have to have an opinion.
If we were not doing it on this podcast
I would have waited six months for it to end up on
fucking HBO Max or whatever.
Because I just was like you know what
this all just feels like
a fucking nightmare.
And then to see it and feel like there's not much there there. I just was like, you know what? This all just feels like a fucking nightmare. Right.
And then to see it and feel like there's not much there, there.
There isn't much there, there.
And the key to this entire movie, which was my big take that I was going to come in with,
and then I believe Sam Adams over at Vox beat me to it.
No, at Slate.
But yes.
At Slate, sorry.
At Slate, sorry.
The key to understanding this entire movie is that Todd Phillips' career started...
Ben's going to like this.
Oh, Ben's ready to jump into this.
He has seen the film itself.
I never wanted to.
It seemed awful.
It's disgusting.
No, thank you.
What's the title again?
It's called Hated.
Hated.
Documentary. Toddated. A documentary.
Todd Phillips' first feature.
Todd Phillips as an NYU student.
About Gigi Allen.
Adored Gigi Allen.
Booked him to perform at NYU.
Made a documentary
with his participation
that was finished after
Gigi Allen died.
And so it stood as this final kind of testament.
Because there's a quote I want to read. Gigi Allen is like a racist punk rock guy
who was really, really on the fringe of that scene,
that subculture,
and definitely is, for example, the best show,
sort of used him as a comedic foil very often
because his act was so gratuitous,
disgusting.
He would smash bottles on his head.
He would poop on stage.
He would shit on the stage
and throw it at the audience.
And his idea was he was so punk rock
and his shows,
the pits were so crazy
that you could die
if you went to his show.
Right.
It was the ultimate act of provocation.
But it also was...
And his music was bad right and racist
right and but it was sexist it was all just to stir up anger every every button he was pushing
i'm assuming was just to get people right and he was a incredibly manic heroin addict yes you know
i mean it was like he died because he had too much heroin right right like he od'd too much heroin. Right. Right? Yeah, he OD'd too much. Which will lead to the quote I'm going to read,
but he was sort of
the like
nihilistic,
antagonistic
shadow of
like someone like
Daniel Johnson.
Right?
Where it's like,
here's this weird
outsider artist.
Okay.
But Daniel Johnson
is this sort of like
sweet kind of
like lovable energy
to him.
I said the shadow version.
Right, exactly. I'm saying they're the polar opposites, right? Sure, sure, sure. Where it's the same kind of like sweet kind of like lovable energy. I said the shadow version. Right. Exactly.
I'm saying they're the polar opposites.
Right.
Where it's the same kind of thing where it's like you're going to watch this bizarre thing and try to engage in this thing.
And these guys exist in their own weird universes.
For sure.
And Daniel Johnson is all about craft.
Right.
It's all about like, oh, to most people, this might sound like childish music.
But if you actually are listening, his songwriting is like incredibly intelligent right his compositions are incredibly
intelligent and you're watching a man let you into his brain natural genius right and ggm is like i'm
throwing everything at you my music is ostensibly garbage and i'm just spewing hate but the what
you're watching is pure, unfiltered id,
in a way, in both cases, that is fasting to people.
And Todd and a lot of other people that sort of, I guess,
supported Gigi Allen as they looked at it as performance art.
Yes.
Correct.
I have no opinion on that.
I think that's stupid.
Sort of a weird line. Why would anyone want to go to a show and potentially get murdered and pooped on?
I mean, the Gigi Allens of the world i guess we're after that i mean isn't a famous story that like when they premiered the movie he was still alive they like shot more after he died and like
at the premiere he like threw a bunch of beer bottles injured a woman yeah and then ran away
because the cops were called like he was he was stupid stupid it was annoying but also he was like
this is a good movie but this is also where the Daniel
Johnson comparison comes in I've been thinking about Daniel Johnson
a lot because he passed away recently
was an artist I loved but in both
cases I feel like
those guys were erroneously
framed as
performance art
where Daniel Johnson is doing so weird
because he is
a mentally ill man
and he's not concerned
with the same sort of
trappings of presentation
that most of us are
that people were like,
I'm not watching him play,
I'm thinking about
the larger context of
this quote unquote
simple man
with his cassette recorder.
Right?
When really,
if you want to take
that guy seriously,
you can take his music seriously.
There is art there, right?
Absolutely.
And G.G. Allen is like the opposite,
where it's like, oh, all this shit is performance art.
He's making a point.
It's like, no, this is a mentally ill man
who is being encouraged
because people think there's some sort of meaning
in the fact that he is like shitting in a way on stage,
that he is causing violence,
that there's some sort of statement here all right
let's let's move out i want to read though because it's very important okay this is from the sam
adam slade article and he said hated ends with alan's funeral after a fatal heroin overdose
and rather than express sorrow at alan's death because todd phillips is the narrator
of hated i know okay phillips i'm not gonna watch that movie you'd never have to uh until we Because Todd Phillips is the narrator of Hated. I know. Okay? Mm-hmm.
I'm not going to watch that movie.
You never have to.
Until we do our Todd Phillips answers. Honestly, David, seriously don't.
Okay, I won't.
Because there's stuff I now have seen that I can never forget.
Sure.
Phillips mourns that he went out in such a hackneyed rock star manner.
It's true.
Right.
Quote, personally, Phillips says,
I always hoped he would go out in a more glorious fashion.
Onstage suicide, five dead fans,
something rock and roll could never ignore.
And as Sam Adams says,
that sentiment jibes dangerously with both Joker itself
and the people who have used the occasion of its release
to threaten public despise of violence.
Todd Phillips once thought murder-suicide was a joke,
now he's made a movie about a man who laughs at it.
And it kind of is the whole fucking thing, right?
Like, it's sort of this perfect bookmark of his career.
Can we do a brief amount of Todd Phillips' career context since we're in this quarter?
Brief, yes.
Okay.
So he makes the Gigi Allen Hayden documentary, which gets some attention because Gigi Allen gets attention.
He is a topic of discussion.
It's probably one of the many reasons he made it.
Much like the Joker of his time.
Yes.
Then he made Frat House.
Right.
So his follow-up is he makes a documentary about Frat House culture, which people loved.
It premiered at Slamdance?
Yeah.
No, it was at Sundance.
It was at Sundance.
And I believe it won some kind of documentary award.
And then there was a lot of controversy over the fact that some of the footage in it was
staged.
Yes.
And so documentarians got mad about it and it wasn't aired on HBO
it was supposed to be. But also I think
that many of the people
the subjects of the film
sort of fought against the release of it.
I'm sure they did. I think there was a mix of both
that some of it was staged and that some of the
people caught doing
you know. Yeah but there's
like these scenes of hazing that were
that Phillips made up.
Right.
And like, I mean, he paid people to stage them.
And he was like, well, Michael Moore does it.
And everyone was like, okay.
I mean, like not the greatest defense in the world.
Right.
He also started like an underground New York film festival.
That was him being like, the real shit isn't being screened.
And it was a lot of fucking documentaries on taboo subjects.
I am too. Yeah. Yeah. shit isn't being screened. And it was a lot of fucking documentaries on taboo subjects, right?
I am too, yeah.
Yeah.
But Frat House leads to him making Road Trip,
which is a direct result of American Pie and the sort of resurgence of the Porky style
80s sex comedy.
He met Ivan Reitman, friend of the show,
future guest.
Yes.
Who as the director of Animal House
and sort of the progenitor of that genre.
He met him at Sundance when he had the Frat House movie.
Right.
Montecito Pictures, the Ivan Reitman company, has a first look deal at DreamWorks.
And I think they sort of go in the wake of American Pie.
Ivan, you should be the guy.
Make an American Pie.
Anoint a new dude.
Find a new.
But I think it's also just like make a movie like that.
Make a college comedy.
Exactly.
Make a college comedy for us.
At this point, Reitman's out of that. Reitman's. Yeah, exactly. Make a college comedy for us. At this point,
Reitman's out of that.
Reitman's like,
Dave,
six days,
seven nights.
But they're like,
find a new guy who's like you,
who has the anarchic spirit
that you had
in the 80s
when you were producing
Animal House
and when you were directing
Meatballs and all that shit.
American Pie came out,
I think,
July 99.
Road Trip is like,
May 2000.
So it's like,
you know,
I think just the minute
it came out,
they were like, just.
Direct response.
Round some people up.
Have some teens.
Right.
There's sex.
Who do they like?
Tom Green.
Put him in the movie.
Yeah, whatever.
And of course, American Pie directed by a friend of the podcast, actual friend of the podcast.
Chris White.
Chris White.
Chris White.
Who we've talked about that movie with him both on and off podcast.
And the way he talks about is very fascinating where he and his brother had been working screenwriters for a long time, really wanted to direct something.
Right.
And he was like, I'm very uncomfortable with sexuality.
I was very uncomfortable with the idea of directing love scenes.
It was not our type of material, but it was like the one – like we'd been fighting so hard to get the chance to make any movie and that was the thing they offered us.
And I feel like if you go back and watch the original American Pie, it is a lot less
raunchy than people remember it being.
It has like...
Yeah, it's very much... It kind of feels like a lot
of those 80s ones where it's like
kind of not raunchy and then it'll be like
moments of sort of like contained
raunch, right? Like little set pieces.
It's weird how much of that movie
is emotional.
Yes, it's sort of a half sweet movie.
Because it's the guys who wanted to be making
About a Boy are trying to put as much
of that into that movie.
Road Trip is about a douchebag
who cheats on him.
I mean Breckin Mayer who's like
we enjoy Breckin Mayer. He's a sweet
faced man. But like he cheats on his
girlfriend. But that's a classic example.
Has to catch the video before it reaches his girlfriend girlfriend that is a classic example of that type of comedy casting
where it's like cast an eminently likable sweet-faced man right to play a character who
is written as a reprehensible douchebag so that the audience kind of roots for them because their
innate charm yes overcomes the actual we can't talk too much about this stuff, but exactly.
This is all important.
How much do you want to talk about the Joker?
Well, we can talk about it a little bit,
but my favorite thing about Road Trip is that Sean William Scott is in it.
Yeah.
It's Stifler, basically.
Yes, right.
Like, they don't even, they're like, oh, it's my friend, like, Iftler.
Like, I mean, like, it's just the same character.
And Tom Green had just popped, and they were like,
can we shoot, like, one week with him?
He just does a set basically.
He just does weird monologues. He's the guy
who doesn't go on the road trip. Yeah, he just talks to
people. He narrates the movie and most
of it he's just in a room by himself.
And who else is in it? DJ
Qualls. His breakout of course became
our next great movie star. What's his name?
The guy who played the
anamorphic.
And then he was in Joey.
I don't know what he's been doing since then.
He is in
Joey's in the Postcards, his best performance.
Of course, of course.
So there was that. I guess it did well.
It did well. It did.
And that sets him off. Old School,
which I think is the most
sort of purely
functional Todd Phillips movie.
That is the one
where, and I've been a little afraid
to re-watch Old School in the last couple of years,
but I think you got those three
guys just at the moment where they're totally
honing in on their movie star personas.
He sort of reclaimed Vaughn
from the post-Swingers wilderness.
It's the first real strong
Will Ferrell movie role,
which then leads into Elf later that fall, and it's like first real strong Will Ferrell movie role which then leads into Elf later that fall
and it's like Luke Wilson getting to be
like his perfect sort of straight man character
right? And it's got
the right level of like the Todd Phillips
anarchy while also feeling like the movie has
a soul and not
a performative soul. I don't like that movie
old school. I was a big fan
of it. I don't like it. I've not seen it. I've never liked it
I mean I never, I didn't hate. I was a big fan of it. I don't like it. I've not seen it. I've never liked it.
I mean, I never, I didn't hate it.
I thought Will Ferrell was funny.
I'll say this.
I always thought it was like just okay.
I always really liked it.
I liked it.
I remember like. That was my favorite of that.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I get it.
Like Wedding Crashers, which I despise.
I'd always be like, Old School's the one that for me actually works.
There is a scene where.
Old School's probably better than Wedding Crashers.
Unquestionably better there's mud wrestling
and an old man
has a heart attack
and dies
but they're all like
old blue
is that his name
but it's like
sort of set up
where it's like
well he died
with a boner
so I don't know
if
alright look
with that
with that
hey I'm Tom Power
I'm the host
of the CBC podcast
Q with Tom Power
I get to talk to artists from all over the world, writers, musicians, actors, directors, all kinds of creative people.
And we try to have the conversations you have with really, really good friends.
The conversations you have when you share a love of something, about ideas, when you want to hear about everything.
I feel really lucky to have these conversations.
Cue with Tom Power.
Available now on CBC Listen or wherever you get your podcasts.
If you're a Mohawk College grad, get ready to make your diploma, certificate, or degree work even harder.
Connect with the Mohawk College Alumni Association today and you can win one of five great prizes.
Connect to exclusive benefits, discounts, contests, career support, and networking opportunities.
Update your contact information
today to win one of five great prizes
including a $500 gift card.
Then, get busy making your Mohawk
alumni network work for you.
Enter today at mohawkcollege.ca
slash alumni win.
Alright, so, yeah, road trip,
okay, old school, okay. Okay, right.
Starsky and Hutch, he makes like sort of a big star studio comedy.
America's favorite studio head, Harvey Weinstein, goes,
Todd Phillips is the new guy, signs him to a three-picture deal, I believe.
They do Starsky and Hutch, which does pretty well.
Yeah.
I've seen it.
I don't remember it that well.
It's fine.
It's, like, totally whatever, right?
Then he did School for Scoundrels, correct?
Which is his one big flop. Yeah. It's like totally whatever, right? Then he does, he did School for Scoundrels, correct? Which is his one
big flop. Yeah. Is that
Thornton, Billy? It's Thornton
and Heater. John Heater.
Billy Bob Thornton has talked about how like
after Bad Santa,
like studios are just like, just keep doing this.
You're gonna play a horndog. Woodcock? Woodcock,
this, Bad News Bears, like right
you'll just play like the bad man.
Right, he did his run there. And this was
the peak of that and the peak of everyone going
like, how do we fucking make John
Heater a movie star?
Yeah, God. Luckily, finally
America snapped out of that one.
The bottoms fall out on both of them on this
movie, and the movie makes no impression
at the box office, and
Philip seems a little down and out.
Right? His Weinstein deal had kind of crashed,
and it was like, wasn't that supposed to be
the next big studio comedy director?
And he starts going through this crisis.
He sets up a movie with Jack Black called Man Witch.
Great.
That is about a grown, slacker, School of Rock-esque man
who finds out that he is, in fact, a wizard,
gets sent to a Hogwarts-type school.
That's what's...
Okay.
So the premise was, imagine Jack Black in a high fantasy school environment, whatever.
Ha ha ha ha.
Right?
So it was like a...
Oh, the jerk is back.
A very broad sort of PG-13 family comedy studio premise,
and Jack Black pulled out very late in the game,
and Todd Phelps is like,
I don't know what I'm fucking doing anymore.
I'm waiting around for movie stars.
No one's let me make an R-rated comedy.
Right?
And he makes the big career decision of his life.
Which is, Vince Vaughn was down.
Will Ferrell had not been a movie star yet.
Well, I guess he...
He had supporting roles, but that was really his breakout.
Oh.
You mean old school?
Yeah, that's what I'm saying.
Oh, okay. Right. I get you now. He? Yeah, that's what I'm saying. Oh,
okay.
Right.
I get you now.
Okay.
Cast of Road Trip,
I discovered a lot of people.
I have some history of finding people,
making some comedy stars.
I want to do that,
and I want to make a dirty R-rated movie again.
I want to make a movie where there's not the same level of studio interference I've had
from the last couple of projects I've made,
and the ones I've tried and failed to get made.
Yeah.
So he finds the script, the hangover.
And he goes, this is funny.
And he goes to Warner Brothers and he says, I want to cast whoever the fuck I want.
We've talked about this.
Legendary co-signs.
They basically like thirded his budget in return for you'll make money on it if it works and you get to cast who you want.
I mean, you got to give him credit.
It has ended up being one of the smartest
career decisions a director has made in modern studio
history. He said, what is the number
where if it is under that budget,
you will let me cast whoever I want? And they said
$27 million. And he went,
great. And he picked Bradley Cooper,
who had been the best friend or the
rival boyfriend in a bunch of movies, but was
not a leading man. He picks Ed
Helms. Who's sort of the 14th guy from The Office.
Right.
And Zach Galifianakis, who we knew was one of the funniest people alive
and who I think a lot of people had been like,
someday he should be a movie star.
One of those whispered about all comedian guys.
And also was a good actor.
When he would appear in movies, he was a good actor,
but he rarely had large roles.
And he makes the movie and it explodes.
And because he asked for no money and demanded that kind of control,
his director salary was like $10,000
or $100,000 or whatever the fuck it was
and he ended up making like $80 million.
It was his George Lucas Star Wars deal.
It was a big deal.
That's true.
But I think it's important to say
that Todd Phillips has like $100 million in the bank.
He's a rich man.
Okay?
He's one of the most
financially successful directors.
So, of course,
he does two Hangover sequels
to diminishing returns.
Although Hangover 2
makes bonkers amounts of money.
They make money, yes.
Even three crossed 100.
Right.
But people are kind of going like,
People get sick of it.
They went back too many times.
Do you guys have those steelbooks?
For the Hangover trilogy?
Yeah.
I'm waiting for the 4K re-release.
Okay. He also made Due Date, which you're a fan of. I'm a big
fan of, and I will get to that in a second.
We're like an hour in, we haven't talked about The Joker!
You said I don't want to talk about it!
No, come on, man! Don't fight with me.
We gotta talk about this movie.
We're gonna talk about it, okay? But I think
the Phillips of it all is the most interesting thing
about this movie. Yeah. For better
or worse. Yeah,
sure. Okay. Yeah, go on, go on,
go on, go on. I don't like the Hangover movies.
No. I think the first one's really gross
and the thing I think is really gross about it
is it's like the worst of both
worlds where it's
all about depravity, but the whole movie's about
like, but actually they're nice guys.
Yeah, that's what, I don't like those movies.
Yeah.
And then the third one tries to be in on the joke or whatever, but like, at that point, get out of here.
Which is the one thing I find kind of interesting about it.
I like it the most of the three in a franchise I don't like.
But the first two, it's like, well, they didn't really mean it.
They were drunk, whatever, you know?
But it's about like fucking having your cake and eating it too.
The whole movie's about how can you give everyone the thrill of watching seedy behavior but saying actually but they're good guys and they don't remember doing it and they don't know what they're doing.
It's also just not that funny.
It's just not that funny.
That's my main problem with that movie.
Just not that funny.
Don't find it funny.
I saw it in theaters.
I was very excited to see it.
I didn't laugh.
Okay.
Due Date is I feel like the only Todd Phillips movie that actually has something to say about the human condition.
And it is, I think, a movie kind of about him.
And that's a movie about how every single person lives directly in the damage or the benefits of the presence of their father or lack thereof.
Sure.
That everyone is very much defined, especially men, let's say, right?
Sure.
I haven't seen due date.
Men in society are very much defined by their relationships with their father and trying
to come out from under the shadow or overcome an abusive father or negligent father or an
overly doting father.
become an abusive father or a negligent father or an overly doting father.
And due date is two men with two completely diametric relationships to their fathers who are both completely damaged by them, stuck on a road trip while one guy is trying to
get back home in time for his son to be delivered.
And it's him sort of reckoning with the fact that he had a shitty father and he's a shitty
person.
He's probably going to be a shitty dad.
It is a dark movie, but it is one of his only movies
if not his only movie that I think
is actually trying to say something about that
darkness rather than just using
it as window dressing for
fucked up shit. Okay?
So that's what I kind of like about it. It's
Downey Jr. giving his only fucking non-stark
performance and I think the most reined in
and the most human they've ever come
up with a
Galifianakis movie character
in his sort of leading man
era. Yeah, for
sure. Right, but he goes from that, he does
the Hangover sequels, he does War Dogs, which
is like, I'm trying to make this step to Scorsese,
people kind of shrug it off, and
then he takes his big swing with Joker. Have you seen War Dogs?
I've watched the first three months of War Dogs
on HBO Go.
And I fell asleep and I never finished it.
It's not very good.
It seemed fine.
It seemed completely whatever.
It's just the characters are awful people.
Yeah, it has that issue, a little bit of the cake and ate it, which is a classic Phillips issue.
It's got this Jonah Hill performance that's fairly compelling.
He's playing a monster.
He's a great actor.
Everything,
I mean,
Teller is kind of god awful in it
and his stuff is bad
and,
you know,
his whole thing of like,
you know,
I just kind of got sucked
into being an arms dealer.
It's so unbootiful.
And you're just like,
one,
I don't believe you.
Two,
I don't care.
You know,
like,
why am I paying any attention to you?
Bradley Cooper shows up near the end.
Much like in Joy,
he's kind of good.
And suddenly,
there's like a little bit of energy.
You mean Bradley Cooper, producer of Joker?
That's right. PGA?
Yeah. But like
it was a shitty movie. And right, so he's like
oh God, what am I going to do now?
I guess I'll make a gigantic blockbuster Joker movie
about murder. Well, and also you can't make comedies anymore
because comedy's cancelled. That's why all the funny
guys stopped doing comedy. Yes, I know.
There's zero funny guys left.
I will say this, though.
Yeah.
Dan DeVito locked the gates this week.
Well, that's where Marin talked about Phillips, right?
And kind of laid him out.
He did a great fucking job.
He kind of locked his gates.
Mark Marin's got his one-scene role in this movie.
It's pretty good.
Mark Marin hates superhero movies. He's been shitting on them.
He made it very clear. I took this movie.
I wanted to work with Bobby. That was it.
I got one scene with De Niro. He's one of my idols.
I want to work with him. But I don't like
superhero movies. I'm kind of
depressed that I'm in one.
It's a comic book movie. That was his other
justification. It's barely one of these.
I picked it because of De Niro. We're hopefully
trying to do something different. Whatever. I have one
scene. And the
movie comes out and Todd Phillips
goes on the defensive as these people
always seem to do. When they're successful?
And have been able to do everything they want.
This is the whole thing. I'm like, you're doing great, buddy.
You're doing great. Pure blank
check status. If you want to make a comedy right
now, you can make it, Todd.
His producing partner, his shingle at Warner Brothers, is him and Bradley Cooper.
It's two of the only four guys at Warner Brothers who have carte blanche, are united together.
They can do whatever the fuck they want, especially post-Joker.
But somehow these people always seem to think that everyone's preventing them because they're saying that they don't like the things they make.
Which is free speech.
Alright, enough.
We're going to talk about Joker now.
Marin went on this
incredible run explaining
you're allowed to say whatever you want
and people are allowed to respond however you
want and if
you feel like you can't be funny
while thinking about other people's rights
then you're probably just not that funny.
Right.
Then you probably aren't that good at comedy.
Or you need to work harder.
Right.
Or the only things you find funny
are at the expense of other people.
I have no sympathy for Todd Phillips.
It doesn't matter.
He made The Joker.
Yes.
Joker.
Joker.
Joker.
When you introduce me,
can you call me Joker?
Yeah.
Okay, so the movie opens with what?
Him at the meeting with the social worker?
Oh, it's him with the grease paint.
Him doing the smile.
So he works at a clown store.
Works at a clown.
He's like a rent-a-clown.
Clown factory.
And they're playing one of eight songs that invoke clowns or smiling or laughing in the title.
I know.
Because they do send in the clowns.
Typed clown into Spotify.
They do smile.
What are the other ones they do?
They do everything that's in any way adjacent.
Make them laugh probably is in here somewhere.
Sure.
You know, whatever.
But also in the white room
and fucking Gary Glitter rock and roll part one.
The thing about, okay, so there's been, you know, the like 18th sub controversy about
Joker is that it features a Gary Glitter song.
Gary Glitter is a confected pedophile.
One of America, I'm sorry, one of the world's most notorious and successful pedophiles.
And so people are like, how dare, you know, like literally he's going to make some money
off of this.
Which is true.
Beyond that, it's a terrible use of the song
it's completely unnecessary absolutely it's the hackiest fucking choice you could make yeah it's
literally just him dancing on the steps yeah to like you know to rock and roll part two which is
just like basically like clip art guitar riffing right you know what i mean it's just it's like
generic guitar riffing when anything when it kicks in i was like oh my god did someone shake the iphone why is this
playing now i forgot i even had this on my itunes boy anyway weird weird so yes i mean
here's what's messy about he's a clown arthur uh fleck to look it up at jack he's a clown
but he's also mentally ill which means he's not to be trusted well look this this movie has a lot
of nuanced things to say about mental illness such as if you go off your pills you'll shoot a talk
show host right i mean like again one of the 14 subcontroversies people aren't even getting to it
yet they'll get to it this movie is horrible about that stuff.
It's, like, absolutely off-base on anything relating to this.
I would argue that is the element of the movie that—
It's the most distressing element.
And it's actually the one that's kind of dangerous.
Sure.
I don't think that, like, fucking, you know—
Considering that there's, like—
It'd be one thing if it's, like like he's crazy and he goes to the asylum
lots of Hollywood movies
have painted with that brush
but like the scenes
with the social worker
him going off his meds
like you know
having it all like
he didn't go off the meds
society took the meds
away from him
you know whatever
you're right
society's the real joker
but also
he is not only
a man who suffers from
a fucking catacomb of undefined mental illnesses.
The laughter is like an unnamed mental illness where he laughs when he's nervous or whatever.
But he's got 18 medications and there's a bunch of shit that they never name, that they never point a finger on.
That's just a fucking side effect, right?
That's a symptom of whatever his neurological issues are.
On top of that, he is also a victim of abuse.
Right, right.
Right?
And to me, that is the area in which this movie feels wildly irresponsible.
Where it's like, I honestly don't think this film is coherent enough or tapped into anything enough to make some fucking Jordan Peterson fan be like,
fuck, I gotta get my gun and run through the streets
right now, right? Sure. I don't think
it will rile anyone up to that degree.
I don't think it is
successful enough, dramatically,
to be able to do that. Because
that would involve some sort of coherence
of viewpoint. It doesn't really have
a very coherent political message.
It doesn't. And look, even something like
the fucking... It sort of
yells things. Right.
It felt to me like
Birdman. And that is a movie where every scene
it makes five observations.
Have you noticed that this is a thing?
Sometimes this happens. This is a problem
in society. Anyway, moving on.
It's like all set up with no punchline.
And
something like The Matrix is endlessly fascinating because it has encouraged so many of the worst corners of the internet in a wild misreading.
That could not be further from what it is very clear.
Exactly. People complained at the time, was overly didactic in a tiny lister, flipping the cover
down on a detonator and going like, we will not let this man define it.
Sure.
And people were like, oh, the movie's sermonizing.
Oh, weighing it on a little thick.
And yet for 10 years, people still took all the wrong lessons and were like, the point
of that movie is the Joker fucks, right?
I would say that's the reason that I don't really, watching the movie, it's neither here
nor there how people react to it.
Totally.
Because you never know how people are going to react to it.
That's my whole point.
You never fucking know how people are going to react.
Okay.
Okay?
So I don't think the film's coherent enough.
Okay, but what do you think?
But I do think this movie, in the same way that every time there's a mass shooting,
our politicians, our elected officials go,
well, it's not a gun problem, it's a mental illness problem.
And they use the boogeyman of mental illness
as just a giant undefined umbrella
to say there are crazy people out there
and you don't want crazy people
doing crazy things.
But also,
we have no infrastructure
to help people
who suffer from mental illness.
I mean, that stuff
is really irritating.
Like, yeah,
the sort of social,
like portraying the failure
of a social safety net
as part of a fucking
comic book villain's origin story.
You know, I like—
But here's the thing.
If that's actually what that movie wants to say—
Well, sure, but it—
No.
No.
Get out of here.
But that is a credible movie.
If you want to do a movie about someone who has actually failed by society,
not someone who feels like they are being shit on by society,
but the second you're getting into, oh, the social worker is losing funding,
so he can't afford his medication anymore.
That's a fucking thing.
That's an evil in this world.
That is a tangible thing that people don't tell stories about.
That's a path you could take.
Here's another path that haves and have-nots, right?
The idea of Thomas Wayne potentially being someone
who has bought himself out of culpability and responsibility for a child is something that has a little meat on the bone potentially.
Sure.
You know what does not have any meat on the bone?
His mom was crazy.
She made up lies.
Also, she beat him over the head and tied him to a radiator.
Also, yes, but also what this movie is doing is it's not letting anything be true or not true.
Right.
You can watch and be like, wow, I think that's in his head and that's real.
So who gives a shit? Nothing matters.
Well, it sounds like you just tapped
into Todd Phillips' viewpoint.
Which is the whole fucking problem with this movie.
But beyond that,
so say there's
Split, the Shyamalan movie, right?
Which also sort of plays around
very wildly with depictions
of mental illness. And I had those problems.
But it leans in the other way where it's like, this starts out realistic.
And then by the end, it's like, this is fantasy comic book shit.
Right.
Whereas this is starting with fantasy comic book shit, but then being like, but really
like this is real and gritty and human and personal.
Like, you know, it's like trying to lean away from the... He's a comic book character.
Now, look. I mean, Alan Moore's
whole fucking thing about the
killing joke, which he wrote, and this is
somewhat inspired by... It was the first time they gave
Joker a sort of detailed
origin and made him
a failed comedian.
And it was also the first time that someone put
a substantial amount of menace into
the Joker, who had always been sort of a theatrical threat up until that point, and it was the first time that someone put a substantial amount of menace into the joker who had always
been sort of a theatrical threat up until that point and it was the first time someone was like
that's not entirely true i can dispute that but but because he's already um you know he he joker
we didn't talk about that but it was the first it's a very dark book he paralyzes that girl in
the spot i think he'd already killed robin at that I think he'd already killed Robin at that point. Yeah, he'd already killed Robin at that point.
Okay, fair enough.
Joker in Batman was originally a very scary villain.
And then after a while, DC was like,
Batman's recurring villains are not allowed to kill
because then that would prove that Batman is inefficient at stopping crime.
Oh, sure.
And so Joker, only one-off villains were allowed to kill.
And Joker became the sort of
more caesar romero funny villain okay and for a long and then he vanished because dc hated joker
and in the 70s he came back scary yeah 70s when they were then they were like no joker was cool
let's like relaunch like neil adams yeah exactly the joker's five-way revenge which is a great
joker story and then yeah in the 80s, as everything in comic books, it escalates.
And Alan Moore writes the killing joke in which he paralyzes Baccaro.
He shoots her.
He takes naked pictures of her.
It's terrible.
Frank Miller does Dark Knight Returns.
Sure.
Yeah.
But then Alan Moore later was like, I don't like the killing joke.
Yeah.
I don't think I had anything to say with it.
Like, you know, I feel like I should have been reined in.
It's just kind of negativity and darkness.
And I feel like comic books have only
leaned more into that, which I don't like. And then he's like,
Joker doesn't represent anything. He's a
comic book character who is Batman's
opposite. He doesn't
really stand in for anything.
That's sort of his fundamental... It's tough to do
something allegorical with Joker because he's not a stand...
He's a comic book character. Which I think
is what people find so fascinating
about him and why we cannot fucking give him up as a character.
We want to keep doing the Joker.
Because it's like he kind of is just this fucking Rorschach test.
Like he's kind of this reflection of whatever the fuck we're feeling
and how much meaning you want to put onto him
or lack of meaning thereof.
The smartest way that anyone has ever dramatized the Joker
is just the Nolan game of his changing backstory.
I love that.
Right?
Like that's perfect.
That's the best writing I've ever seen of the Joker in any medium.
Aside from the quality of that performance.
Right.
Right?
It's just that is like that's it.
That's what we find fascinating about the Joker is that any one of these backstories on their own.
Would make sense for such an indefinable
creature of evil.
But the fact that
they keep on shifting
means it's maybe
one of these
or none of them
or who fucking knows
or maybe it's all a put on.
And then also
what if he put
Twisted on his head?
Right.
Well, damaged.
Damaged.
Sorry.
Fuck.
What if he laid
on the floor
around a circle of knives?
He does that in this movie, right?
Uh, yeah. That's in this one?
In Joker? He does it every night before he goes to sleep.
He lays out his Brooklyn ends and then carefully arranges
knife by knife around his head.
Does he sleep on the couch or is it like a
two bedroom? He sleeps on the couch.
Sleeps on the couch, right? Yeah. I was trying to get how
squalid his apartment is supposed to be.
Yeah. Because initially I was like, wait,
both him and his mom have rooms? Yeah.
It's alright. Also, anytime I see squalid New York City apartments initially I was like, wait, did both him and his mom have rooms? Yeah. It's alright. Also, anytime I see
squalid New York City apartments, I'm like,
that looks fine. I've lived in
apartments that are worse than that. That's the story of
New York, was that the homes were often good.
You know, they got bad, but you know, good
bones is the gentrifier
that's said. Good bones.
Or as Ben Hosley says all the time
about bones. Bones.
Also, Joaquin Phoenix, look at his bones.
He lost all that weight to get all bony.
Ben was actually making that type of sound.
He's kind of gross.
It makes me cringe.
Yeah, I know.
But you know what's fascinating?
He's done it before, right?
There's another movie he's really skinny in.
The Master, he's very skinny in.
Yeah.
And there's another one.
He definitely fluctuates.
Yes.
But I'll say this.
Here's a massive difference between Paul Thomas Anderson and Todd Phillips.
One of them is...
They only have two names?
And that's it?
And they're the same otherwise?
Equals.
Joaquin's crazy skinny in The Master.
And he's doing the same sort of weird, what you call a ham sandwich performance.
For sure.
It's a lot of mannerisms.
This is that too, in my opinion.
I mean, I prefer The Master.
I rewatched The Master for the umpteenth time a couple weeks ago. I should rewatch it.
I think it's a phenomenal film. Does it have anything to say
about the current moment we're living in?
I think so. No, I was about to say, doesn't it
obviously, I feel like it's really relevant
right now. I think it's one of those movies that's kind of
actually about everything in the way
that The Joker is about nothing.
You know? The Joker is about how society is the biggest joker of all time.
Yes.
But, but, but, but, but.
In that movie,
he's doing ham sandwich.
I think he's supported by the film.
100%.
It's a better performance.
It's just that type of,
I'm not that fond of that type of action.
I understand.
And you, yes.
And you tend to like.
I love him in like James Gray movies... I love him in James Gray movies.
I love him in...
Sisters Brothers, you loved him in?
He's really good in that.
He's actually funny in that.
Science, he's great in?
Yeah.
You like him when he plays normal guy.
I do.
I mean, the James Gray movies,
I would say are probably my two lovers.
We Own the Night.
Those are probably my favorite walkings.
I feel like there's another walking
I really like that I...
Two Lovers, he's phenomenal in.
He's incredible in Two Lovers,
which is like a sort of
quiet ham sandwich.
Like, you know?
Her, he is excellent at.
And I'm not a huge Her fan.
I don't like that movie.
I don't either, really.
But I think he is so good in that film.
Oh, well, you know,
you'll never really hear.
Well, yeah, I wasn't sure
if you liked that performance
as much as I did.
Oh, I love that performance.
He was my best actor
when of course last year.
He's also very dialed into that movie's tone in the right way.
I don't know.
I really love that performance.
He is someone who-
I had been pretty sick of him and then he gave me those.
Yeah.
He is someone who kind of lives or dies based on the collaborator.
Sure.
You know, because he is a guy who by all accounts is so sort of experimental and throwing shit
out there that he needs to work with someone he trusts who guides him the right way and
picks the right fucking footage. And this just todd phillips was telling him on a day
to day basis to do weird shit and then just compiling two hours of the weirdest shit yeah
i mean there's definitely some stuff like that the dancing yeah um is something phoenix came up with
totally he was supposed to like laugh or whatever and he was like what if i did this dance and
phillips was like oh that's good
and those moments in the movie are
something. They're not that interesting
but they're at least something. We were talking about
they feel a little different. Comedia del arte
kind of reference maybe.
And it's just sort of like something
to hold on to in that movie when most of the scenes
in the movie I was kind of just like can we get
this over with. That's why the use of his body
like he's all twisted and skinny
in the master right
and it's interesting to watch all the positions
he gets into but it's not fucking
like fetishized like it is in this
where it feels like one day on
set because of the lighting he bent
into a position shirtless and Todd
Phelps was like oh you look like a fucking
David Cronenberg creature
so now every other scene
is going to have you shirtless
in some position that no one...
Why is he sitting on the couch with his back
fully arched so that
his ribcage is...
This man is... He's a joker!
But that's the point. It's all just like...
Good joke! That's a good joke
when he does that. He's a friggin' clown!
Is there one joke in this movie?
I guess De Niro's got some zingers.
No, the sense one is okay.
What's the sense one?
I wish my...
I hope that my death is worth...
Something about sense.
Remember the sense joke?
I can't remember.
De Niro's got some zingers.
Definitely got some zingers.
I wish De Niro had just done like five minutes on Jimmy Carter or whatever.
That would have been funny.
The De Niro casting in this like five minutes on like Jimmy Carter or whatever. That would have been funny. The De Niro casting in this.
The obvious thing here is De Niro's cast because of fucking King of Comedy.
Yeah, 100%.
But it's also funny where it's like, what are the two things that Robert De Niro, one of our greatest screen actors of all time.
Reading cue cards.
I would go even more specific than this, okay?
Go ahead, go ahead.
Live televised comedy and talk show appearances.
He is famously the least articulate talk show guest.
But this is like top of the heap for him now, right?
Yeah.
Like this is his best late night talk show appearance ever.
Yeah.
He at least is, you know, he's bringing it.
It's funny also, I saw someone tweeting about how like they heard young people in the theater being like,
Robert De Niro is like not believable as a talk show host.
And it's like, oh, because now talk show hosts are like,
shots, Yahtzee.
We're just talking about Fallon.
But also Corden.
Yeah, sure.
The party game sort of like, I'm just a good guy.
I like everything thing.
Where as talk show hosts used to specifically be,
here is an ornery old man who seems to resent all of their guests.
These fucking kids in that disco.
I know I'm not allowed to say fuck, but who's watching?
And you see, like, here's another example of where this movie almost gets at something, but doesn't actually, throws in so many conflicting points that it doesn't actually land any sort of view on anything.
there's something kind of to the idea of a talk show host using the Joker in the way that like David Letterman used Harvey P. Carr or like Harmony Corrine,
where they were like, look at these weirdos.
I'm going to set them up to do weird shit and act like what a fucking freak.
Yeah.
You know, right.
There's something there.
Kind of. But it's all really just to set up the final thing.
Right. Right. It's more just plot and also i refuse to believe for a second that joaquin gets up one time at a stand-up club the entire
goes viral in 1980 gotham or whatever film his set and send it to why would he put that's not
bad enough to make it onto this guy's show yeah
right
especially not
a Carson style show
maybe like a
freaking Carson
daily show
you know what I mean
that's like
every open mic
in New York City
currently
every open mic
now
here are two points
one
every open mic
performance is
more embarrassing
than that
two
if someone got up
on stage
in an alt room in Brooklyn
and just laughed for three minutes,
people would be like,
oh, who's this guy?
This rules.
It might crush.
I feel like if this thing is set...
If you can't make it through your jokes,
it would destroy.
They'd get new faces.
This thing is set in 1980 or whatever?
Whatever.
Like, cringe comedy is not even a thing.
It's like danger field is going
on carson and being like doc talking about dr vitty boom bots like we're not ready for like
like feeling awkward and having that be funny like that's not happening yet no those kinds of videos
weren't catching on to the mainstream carson didn't like that shit in that way but can i tell
you about something david yeah what's that noise oh that that's a herd of cattle destroying
our it room a cable monkey we won't let just any animals loose on your it infrastructure cable
monkey offers high quality installation maintenance and repair services focused on your commercial it
infrastructure structured cabling camera systems access, access control, whatever you need. Cable Monkey has you covered.
Higher quality, less expense, and no headaches.
Cable Monkey.
Get your free quote today at cablemonkey.org.
So, yes, we're talking about the Murray Anderson thing, that whole element of it.
It is weird De Niro casting aside from the fact that, you know,
it's the inversion of the King of Comedy thing.
Yeah.
Because he's not very convincing
as a loose charisma
based comedian. He's not very
convincing delivering those jokes. He is
not very convincing of like the rhythms
of the power. I agree with that, but you know what?
He is compelling because he's
Robert De Niro. So when he's like hosting a late night
show, I'm like, I'd watch this. He is innately
compelling and I will say this.
I think when you get into that final
sort of showdown between him and Joaquin
and it's actually just an interview
I think he plays that very
well. Well good actor.
He's a good actor but I'm saying you could have made
him more of like a Morton Downey Jr.
Made him a more like
aggro sort of conversation based talk
show host. Or even like
you know who's the guy who used to go after Carson who was basically—
Tom Snyder.
Yeah, Tom Snyder.
The idea of making him like a fucking Borscht-Belty, like one-liner guy.
But they need it for their stupid, you know, plot set up where he is actually like Tosh.0.
Right.
And they need it to be De Niro because do you get it?
King of comedy.
Yeah.
Now here's the other thing.
I was thinking about the sort of the Scorsese-Robert Delusional movies, right king of comedy. Now here's the other thing. I was thinking about the sort of
Scorsese, Robert Delusional
movies, right? And I came up with that the other day.
I coined it TMT.
But the taxi driver,
king of comedy, sort of
like, here are these sort of delusional
loners who live in their own kind of weird
fantasy world with their
sense of, I'm the hero of my own narrative.
I'm just sort of barreling
towards this ultimate success and the validation
I believe I deserve.
And how many people vainly try to emulate
those movies? And the other one I think
of that was also a Warner Brothers film
10 years ago is Observe and Report.
Which was like, you know, there are other
examples before that and after that, but I remember
at the time that one was so big.
That got so much Taxi Driver comparison. And Rogan was saying it in the press and Jody, but I remember at the time that one was so big. That got so much taxi driver comparison.
And Rogan was saying it in the press
and Jody Hill was saying it in the
press and everyone was like, we're trying to make that kind
of morally ambiguous, anti-hero,
delusional. Everyone always talks
about those movies used to be so morally ambiguous.
Everything's cut and dry. We want to make them morally
ambiguous. And every time someone tries to do
it, you're like, they don't have
their hand on the dial in the same way Scorsese did.
It was an unfair comparison, but it maybe speaks to why this type of movie, which is so difficult to pull off, should only be pulled off by, you know, one of the greatest filmmakers of all time.
Yeah, I mean—
Like maybe it's an advanced ropes course that everyone can't jump.
But watching this movie, another thing hit me, which is that Scorsese has
a pretty deep, innate
sense of empathy.
And the thing with those movies is
they are not glamorizing
these guys. They are not making them
underdog heroes, but they also
aren't just beating up on these dudes.
And Jody Hill
likes making fun of delusional people,
and Todd Phillips likes making fun of delusional people and Todd Phillips
likes making fun
of shitty behavior
and this movie
feels like
so you're not
an Observe and Report fan
I like it
okay
it's okay
I think it has stuff
in it that I find interesting
I don't think it's
a very good movie
but I think it has
very interesting elements
now to your point
it was also just sort of
like at the time
it was like Seth Rogen
was playing mostly
Sweethearts
and it was
it felt very much
it was exciting to see someone
what else
it just felt like him being like you know I want to make something that's going to kind of freak you out it was nice Seth Rogen was playing mostly Sweethearts and it felt very much it just felt like him being like
you know I want to make something that's going to
kind of freak you out. It was nice to see a movie star trying
to push boundaries
and sometimes they miss. To your point
think of the comedy set
in King of Comedy. Right.
That is really good writing.
It's really subversive
comedy. He makes a joke
he's like he makes a joke about Clifton, New Jersey,
and then he's like,
oh, we got anyone in the house here?
Anyone would be from Clifton, New Jersey?
He's just, well, yeah, I guess I would say yeah.
But this was the thing I was thinking about watching this movie,
which it's like, it is so deftly handled in King of Comedy, the level of skill he has as a comedian.
Where it's like he will never make it.
But he's not complete.
He's not like this where he's actually like shouldn't even be allowed.
He has just enough competency that you believe that he thinks he's going to make it, which is the very specific line.
And the movie isn't asking you to constantly be like
what a fucking moron
for thinking he can do this.
So this movie begins.
I mean just because this is exactly
he's meeting with his psychiatrist.
I have a joke book. Yes, I'm gonna write a diary. I started writing a joke book.
His joke book slash diary
I told you that I want to be a comedian, right?
He talks about how he's gonna be a comedian.
She's like, okay.
She opens up his joke book and it's basically just like
he's scrawled like murder, murder, death, death.
I am a Freudian nightmare.
He's just sort of like...
He's cut headless bodies
out of porn magazines.
It's riddled with misspellings.
He's like illiterate. It's the most hacky
fucking like, you know,
SNL version of like the diary from seven or
what, right?
Like it's just like draw a serial killer diary for me, right?
Like that's messaging three things at the same time.
You're going, A, this is like the evidence of a psychopath after he commits his crimes,
right?
B, these are bad jokes.
They aren't funny.
They're badly constructed.
This guy doesn't get jokes.
And C, he's a moron.
Right.
Because every time they cut to a sentence in his book, it is so wildly misspelled.
Right.
He uses the wrong word.
You know, always.
The other thing I want to point out is.
There's a point where he says have like H-A-V-E and it's written as half.
Like I have to go do this or whatever.
I know.
So he's like.
Okay, go on.
Well, Taxi Driver, which was written by paul schrader
a good movie that is well written sure yes uh was inspired by the diaries of arthur brammer who was
this guy who tried to shoot uh george wallace right or maybe did successfully shoot yeah he
shot him um and like so you've now filtered this like four times, right? It's like that, that genesis of an idea of like, right.
The diary of a madman and like Paul Schrader, right.
He was like working as a taxi driver and going crazy and like writing this screenplay in
the back of a car and right.
Like that sort of like the energy that's driving that movie notoriously.
And you got three very academic thinkers, De Niro, Scorsese and Trader.
And here's another big element that movie has working for it.
Those three guys were all actually living with palpable frustration about their careers and what they felt they were destined for.
Sure.
And they also lived in the actual 1970s.
Right.
They knew that shit.
Right?
But even if they're exaggerating it to like a violent psychotic degree, that movie is funneling the energy of Scorsese, De Niro, and Schrader each going,
I know I have the goods.
Why isn't anyone letting me do the thing I can do?
Especially at that point, Schrader.
Very much so.
So then this, we have this.
This movie is kind of like a taxi driver prestige.
Kind of.
Plot-wise, it's more taxi driver because it's about a guy who eventually commits this act of violence.
He's under the boot.
And is kind of regarded as a hero in a weird way.
He keeps fucking everything up.
Everyone keeps on fucking him over.
Right.
And he's got this diary, which Taxi Driver has this diary concept where he's talking in his head and all that.
And this is just such a like such a like
boulderized version of that and um it's uh it's not very profound it's a bad movie it's also that
thing when like people say like why don't they make movies like that anymore right it falls under
uh lindsey ellis who is a film critic and thinker is very very good on YouTube, posted a video that I think is great.
That's such a good counter to the argument where people say like, you couldn't make Blazing Saddles today.
Like you'd never get away with it because of PC wokeness.
And her whole retort to that is Blazing Saddles may be my favorite comedy of all time.
A film that she loves as well.
She says, you couldn't make Blazing Saddles today because there's no reason to make Blazing Saddles today.
Blazing Saddles is a product of the time it was made.
You know?
It was based out of a righteous feeling that was existing underneath the surface of society.
Its transgressions were interesting because they had never, those lines had never been crossed before.
There was no reason to make it today.
It would be regressive.
What you could do is make the film that is the equivalent for our times as Blazing Saddle was. No, no, no. You have to
make Taxi Driver again. That's the fucking problem.
Is that people go, I want to make a
movie like Taxi Driver again and rather than go
okay, let's like adjust the compass
and figure out what Taxi Driver is for 2019.
Well, they did.
And they decided that it was Joker
because now we make comic book movies.
So that's what they did. That's what he did.
Right? That's like he did. Right?
That's like,
he's like,
there's another line in that Vanity Fair profile
where he's like,
if I can't make comedies,
I'm going to make something like that.
You know,
where he's like,
fuck you.
There's a lot of fuck you energy.
It's about the weird fucking energy
of straight white men online
feeling like they're the persecuted class.
Well, that's what everyone was picking up on it,
you know,
as it started to gain steam.
Not so much that this is a movie about a guy who looks at the camera
and is like, in cells, march.
But it's just more that it has this very Taxi Driver-esque subplot
in which he likes his neighbor down the hall played by Sassy Beats.
And they have this relationship that i immediately was like
this is in his head and then later in the movie it's basically revealed like yeah he that was in
his head right he was talking to nobody you go either this is in his head or this is the single
worst film ever made right this is an inept piece of characterization even by the standards of this
movie right but it's not it's in his head. It's the Sybil Shepard thing again, basically.
Like, again, a sort of bolderized version of it, right?
From Taxi Driver.
What the fuck does any of this mean?
I don't know.
He's the clown prince of crime.
I don't know.
This guy puts makeup on a fish.
So it's like...
You know what I'm saying, though?
Not what does it mean in terms of, like, how do I read this? I mean, like Not what does it mean in terms of like how do I read this?
I mean like what does it mean in terms of like
does any of this matter? Is any of this
of any consequence in this movie?
Oh like the Zazie Beetz stuff
or whatever? We're spending this much time on multiple
dates with Zazie Beetz where I'm like you
on a scene by scene basis are
doing nothing to convince me that this could actually
be happening. So I'm watching
and going you're to fucking pull the
rug on so these scenes are a waste of time.
As you've been pointing out sort of various
ways, like yeah, the guy is too much
of a sort of weirdo, sort of idiot.
He cannot even do an impression
of a normal person. He's not a functional human being in any
way, so it's impossible to imagine. A thought I had
is it's revealed that
his mother and her boyfriends would
beat him. Like he was a kid
who was abused. And then what does he
do kind of right after finding out information?
He breaks into his girlfriend's
apartment and terrifies her and her
daughter. That doesn't make sense.
In a scene that also they kind of like
leave dangling and
you don't quite know what happened after that.
Like did he kill her? Did he just run away?
It's already a movie where you have, like, the fucking weird...
There's going to be 50 fucking posts on the internet that are, like, definitive evidence
that he kills her in that scene.
Or that she lived and that she kills him.
But I love stuff like that.
The rest of the movie is his death dream.
David, don't you love stuff like that?
Like, remember when Joker and the Batman met?
Did you love that?
Yeah, sure.
What'd you like about it?
What's your favorite part?
I don't know.
I mean, I love the Joker.
He's great.
And when he sees a little boy
who's Batman, Bruce.
Oh, we're talking about this.
Okay.
Okay.
All right.
So look, look, look.
Cause this is the thing.
This is the thing
I actually have to talk about.
This is the thing that
we all have to talk about.
There's almost something here.
Oh, I don't know about that,
but it looks so much.
I don't think the movie
does it at all.
I'm watching this movie.
I'm watching this movie.
And I know that Thomas Wayne is in it, played by Brett Cullen,
which I thought was hilarious because he's in The Dark Knight Rises.
This is a different character.
And really, you can cast a slightly wider net, but whatever.
He's the fucking congressman that the Catwoman kidnaps.
Right, of course.
I knew he was one of the suits.
And so he's playing Thomas Wayne
and like it turns out
Joker's mother was
who worked for the Wayne family
and believe Thomas was Joker's father.
Maybe she made that up
or maybe it's true.
Who knows?
The Joker's crazy.
And that's why he's fixated on.
And there's a scene
with little Bruce Wayne
played by some little boy. you're like oh it's
Bruce Wayne he does magic tricks and he'll be the Batman his fingers in the little boy's mouth
and the security guards mad at him I mean Joker's like I was just trying to and I'm like is the
movie supposed to make me feel sympathetic for I thought that guy was supposed to be Alfred
yeah maybe yeah yeah that was my take which I thought was kind of, well, I'll get to this.
Bad job by Alfred.
Yes.
Don't let him near the gates.
But I understand the entire point of the movie is this guy's fucking weird and twisted.
But when he put his fingers in the kid's mouth, I was like, this is bad.
Don't do it.
No good.
Don't put two fingers in his mouth.
And at this point, this movie has had this progression
of terrible events
happen to the Joker
I'm just gonna take us
through the plot very briefly
that's where it just feels like
fucking
we need to
so like there's the early
he's beaten up on the street
by a bunch of kids
who are not white
that's true
because most of the people
of color in this film
are either clerks
they're either angelic
or
service workers
nameless
or hooligans who are later referred to
as savages. But then
Joker gets a gun and it goes
off in one of the better scenes in the movie.
At the hospital.
That's just weird.
No, when he has the gun
and he fires it and it goes off.
That's a scene that's loaded with some actual
tension that feels like
He's watching the musical on TV. some actual tension that feels like he's watching the musical on TV
yeah and it feels like it's about a person
who would you know be sort of on their way
to committing acts of violence
not the most interesting thing in the world but at least
like a small scene that has tension
I was hoping that he was going to go are you laughing at me
are you laughing at me
okay and then
he's harassed by
Wall Street bros on the
subway. One of whom played by the great Ben Warhite.
Great New York comedian.
Who sing Sondheim at
him. Well, they're huge Sondheads.
And he shoots them. They're coming straight
from
a performance of Marilee Weaver.
You got that in the subtext, right?
Sondheim! Sondheim!
It's a little night music.
I believe you sing this into the clown.
I'm pretty sure.
I know that a little night music is sending the clowns.
I'm saying they know the whole body of work, David.
They're into all of it, right?
They go deep.
They just saw passion.
Yeah.
No.
So these, it's the Bernie Getz.
It's the most obvious, like, you know, 80s parallel, right?
It's the Bernie Getz subway shooting where Bernie Getz was this sort of unhinged,
whatever, couldn't take it anymore guy
who shot some kids who were hassling him on a subway
in a very racialized crime,
but he became a weird sort of folk hero to certain,
you know, it's a very,
it's a part of New York's history
that is loaded with all kinds of tension.
Todd Phillips sort of takes the basic imagery
and puts it in Wall Street,
bro-singings on time, kind of robs it of any kind of meaning, but whatever, that takes the basic imagery and puts it in Wall Street for singing Sondheim. Kind of robs
it of any kind of meaning. But whatever.
That's the Joker's first big crime. Well, because I think he's
trying to marry that to a thing. Yeah, the whole
violence against the rich, you know.
Eat the rich. It's sort of
10 years too late Occupy
Wall Street shit where it's like
this is something that could radicalize
a city, right?
So vague. But yes, then it starts to radicalize the city
and there's a masked Joker on the loose
and everyone's got that on their lips.
And there's almost something interesting
to the fact that they are Wayne employees.
If you're dealing with the mythos.
He's coming back to Wayne,
which is just like the big business of the-
He's also running for mayor
and he's running in this Bloomberg Trump-esque way
where it's like,
I actually know how to help everybody
and people are debating
whether we need some rich guy coming and solving problems. Businessman thing, but also he's like, whatever actually know how to help everybody and people are debating whether we need some rich guy
coming and solving the problem. Businessman thing, but also he's like, whatever.
He's going to be hard on crime.
At some point, his
version of deplorables was calling people
clowns, which got everyone upset.
I didn't even remember that. They say that in the script
that he was like, these clowns on the street
and that became the deplorables
which his opponents have been weaponizing.
So then you've got like,
you know, you got like the scene
that he takes the gun out of the children's hospital.
I mean, kind of a good gag.
Funny five comedy parts.
What kind of a clown has a gun?
I thought that was kind of a funny line.
Gets fired from his clown job.
Yeah.
He's a clown for hire in,
this movie's loaded with like comedy seller guys.
It's like Gary Goldman is in it. Sam Morrell.
Sam Morrell is in it. I'm forgetting.
Greer Garson. Not Greer Garson. Greer.
I'm forgetting his last name. Greer Barnes.
Who's one of the other clown employees.
Yeah, yeah, yeah. It makes sense if he's
pulling from Marin and whatever. I mean,
I don't know. I even thought the club
looks kind of comedy seller. It does. It has that vibe.
It looks very comedy seller. And he does the bad set
of the club, gets made fun of by Murray Franklin on TV.
Yeah.
This is all.
He loves it.
And it's totally believable.
She's a real human.
She's a real person.
Not him.
Bad year for Zazie.
We've seen this guy as well.
What a talent.
I mean,
this movie is a huge hit.
So I mean,
that's good.
She is a huge talent.
Yeah.
And,
and then there's the scene,
as you say,
where he puts his finger in a child's mouth.
Yeah.
No, no.
This British man comes out.
His mom has a stroke.
She's hospitalized.
No, but here's the big thing.
The British man comes out.
It's Alfred.
It's Alfred.
Yeah, sure.
And he goes, look, I'm Arthur Fleck.
Yeah, I'm Thomas Wayne's son, you know.
Right.
He goes, oh, my God, you're Penny Fleck's kid.
Right.
And there's that sort of like bone chilling, like things go moment right and then he says like you don't know your mother's
fucking crazy she made up this delusional lie she was institutionalized not only that you're adopted
right he can't be your father and anytime he learns his information he's always like your mom
is crazy and your life is bad. No person, like empathy.
A moment, like this is a stranger.
You're not going to ruin a stranger's life.
You're twisted.
You're damaged.
They should tattoo it on your forehead.
He goes to the Arkham Asylum.
Yeah, talks to Brian Tyree Henry.
Another incredibly wasted.
Pretty good in the scene.
I mean, one of the best working actors.
His mom had a stroke because the cops.
Remember, remember.
The cops.
Right, Bill Camp and Shea Whigum interrogated her too hard.
And she had a stroke, right?
He goes to Arkham Asami, looks at the file,
and then Brian Tyrianne sees something that makes his blood run cold.
And he goes, like, you can't see this.
Because the file details all this.
Abuse he suffered as a child.
Because Joaquin steals the file.
And he sees that.
And not only that, he sees the clear adoption paper.
Right? Now there's almost
something in this.
For me, okay? And I don't think the movie
gets anywhere close to it, but for a second I went
oh fuck, is this what they're trying to do?
Because it is talked about a lot
in hacky stand-up routines
that Batman is kind of this
weird Republican fantasy.
Sure.
That he is an insanely rich man
who uses his wealth for good,
doesn't need the government meddling,
and takes care of the actual crime,
which tend to be a lot of crazy people.
Right.
But I mean, like,
that kind of commentary,
which, as you say,
happens all the time,
is kind of like,
you know,
Batman was not initially
developed that way because it was like the 40s and, like you know Batman was not initially developed that way
because it was like the 40s
and like the costume heroes
just meant a different
but yes.
That's stuff that comes with
a character existing for 80 years.
Okay the character's gonna end up
taking every possible dimension
it possibly could.
So here's
But here's what I want to say.
I'm sorry.
I know you have a point
you want to make as well.
I want to set them up
as dual implants.
Alright, alright, alright.
What do you want to make as well. I want to set them up as dual implants. All right, all right, all right. What do you want to say?
The latitude this movie potentially has by being a Joker movie,
by being black label DC,
by being out of continuity,
is because Batman is not the hero of the film and is barely in it.
Sure.
A movie could kind of actually try to grapple with that sliver of Batman's legacy.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
The weird power fantasy and money fantasy of Batman, right?
And get your government hands off of, this guy can take it himself.
And the idea that someone like Thomas Wayne would have complete impunity
to pretty much take advantage of anyone he wants
and could probably use the law
and money on his side to cover it up in any way he wanted to okay someone like this could
impregnate i know what you're saying yeah i know what you're saying okay have her institutionalized
i get it i get it i get it i get it but then well okay so now i and i know the movie wants to exist
in the gray area but it also feels like that's just a kind of like a a red
herring to set up no actually he is just the most crazy and abused child of the most crazy sure
right i mean well and again as we said it doesn't it just can't pick a thing right and instead wants
to do this sort of like look i don't know what's true and what isn't yeah which like already joaquin
and todd have sort of dropped that kind of in a few interviews as well where they're like
hey maybe Joker made
that up. Okay. Who cares?
Fine. Yeah.
But then. Yeah. The Joker
we love him. Yeah. Can you just call him Joker
in fact. When you introduce him call him Joker.
First he kills a couple
he kills a couple guys or just one guy
who visits his apartment. There's that
scene. The bloody murder of the you know the big kills a couple guys or just one guy yeah who visited his apartment there's that scene uh bloody
murder of the you know the the big big clown guy the little person stuff is it's just so i think
that's patronizing and stupid yeah not only that you saw it at a screening at a film festival
we saw it at the amc 25 and their their audience lost their fucking shit at the fact that the little person could not reach the locks.
And they literally started yelling out, oh my god, he can't reach the locks because he's a midget.
Yeah, right, right, right.
That's what I found just kind of.
Yeah, so that was a moment where I wanted to sink into the depths of hell.
Where the Joker lives?
Where the Joker lives.
sink into the depths of hell.
Where the Joker lives?
Where the Joker lives.
So there's that scene,
which is another,
this movie doesn't have a lot of violence,
but it has these brief sort of flashes of violence that are somewhat effective, I guess.
It's a slick looking movie.
It looks pretty.
In my opinion,
really bad score that is incredibly over the top
and sort of like doing that whole like,
can't you tell this is serious?
Yes.
Like sort of thing.
Yeah.
It goes.
The costuming, the cinematography,
and the production design in this movie
are kind of unimpeachable.
And also just a lot of great location shooting,
which I really appreciate just generally,
but especially for this kind of a movie.
The graffiti on the trains,
like capturing that era of New York.
Todd Phillips acquired Scorsese's producers.
Although Scorsese's actually not on it.
Right.
Which I think that was probably
because he saw where this movie was heading
and was like,
I don't want to get tied to a thing
that doesn't actually know what it's saying.
Maybe.
I have no idea.
I mean, the official excuse was something
along the lines of like,
oh, he's got too much going on.
But he used a lot of Scorsese.
Martin Scorsese,
who everyone likes to fucking yell about
all the fucking time on the fucking internet, the souvenir this year like you know please check out
his like world cinema stuff that's on uh margaret criterion channel he goes to bat for other
filmmakers a lot and he is incredibly generous there's another great movie he produced this year
fuck what is it i gotta find it now gotta find it don't you agree that i have to find it a thing
that martin scorsese does that I like a lot.
Scorchese.
A thing that Martin Scorchese does that I like a lot is he knows how much clout he has.
Uncut gems.
Oh, right.
So if he is working with a filmmaker who is taking a step up in budget or studio or whatever,
he will often negotiate that he gets final cut.
Because he knows they will not give the director final cut.
And he will just say,
for example, Joanna Hogg,
give me your cut, and I'll tell A24
this is my cut.
And I think he doesn't want
to extend
that kindness
to films that don't need it.
Sure, maybe that was was it I don't know
I mean he certainly
Could have put his money
His name on this thing
Made a bunch of money
But anyway
But Todd Phillips
Did use a bunch of his team
Sure
And they're the best
Especially at
Working in New York
Right
Yeah
So Joker goes on the talk show
He shoots Murray Franklin
Look
Shoots him in the eye
Yeah
Bang bang with a gun
Kind of a striking scene in and of itself.
Certainly a disturbing and striking scene in and of itself.
You're watching two...
Doesn't really have anything to do with anything in this movie.
Really.
It just didn't feel like the movie had built to this in the correct way at all.
It feels like a scene from a different film.
But when you're watching it, it's tense.
And I'll say this.
It felt like the creepiness of watching something like, what's his name, Bud Dwyer.
You know?
Yeah.
Oh, God.
Very depressing.
But that feeling of watching a very creepy, grainy video on YouTube of like, you know, a TV tape.
Right.
Right.
What's the movies about Christine?
Right.
Right.
Like those things.
Those weird urban legends.
I mean, not urban legends, but like.
Those horrible sort of like
violent acts on TV.
The faces of death.
Yes.
During this sequence,
I went,
this is actually
bottling something
for me
that I don't think
the film has earned up
until this point.
I don't think it knows
what to do with
after it's done.
But.
That's the slickness
right it's like yeah it'll get it'll get a rise out of you but watching something very weird about
why is this man wearing clown makeup on this talk show watching it from the vantage point of an
audience who has no context and isn't watching a joker movie and when they cut out to the grid of
tv screens i go this is kind of an argument for trying to make a quote-unquote gritty Joker movie is how scary would it be if in the real world some guy came on the fucking David Letterman show and seemed like he was Tiny Tim and then got weirdly morose and then shot a guy point blank.
Okay, so then what happens after that scene is like a riot breaks out, people wearing Joker masks.
Diet breaks out.
People wearing Joker masks.
It sort of gets tied up, as you say,
in this kind of half-baked Occupy Wall Street sort of like,
the poor are rising up against the rich.
He's already become a cult hero just as...
Because he shot a couple suits in his subway trip.
And now he's taken credit for it,
and there's a name on his face.
And, you know, look.
Ricky T.
While this is all going on,
a couple of rich guys and their kids
decided to go see Zorro at a fucking
theater and then we watch for the
millionth time as
Thomas and Martha Wayne
are gunned down that was the first
run of their son down to the
pearls you beat
me to my job down to the fucking pearls why
what's your joke I was gonna say David that's
true but they add something to the equation that hasn't
been in any of the depictions before, which is the pearls
being pulled off.
Because it's crazy that everyone feels the need
to not only show this fucking scene,
but get the fucking
pearl insert as well.
But it happened not in an alleyway in the other
movies, right? Yeah, no, right.
In the other movies, it happened on an escalator.
I mean, yeah, no.
David, also, massive correction.
They don't get killed walking out of a screening
of Zorro. They get killed walking out of a screening of Zorro
the Gay Blade. Zorro the Gay Blade. The George Hamilton
comedy that is What If Zorro
Was Gay, where it's 90
minutes of the kind of
very subtle, nuanced, thoughtful
gay jokes
that only like 1982 could bring
that Todd Phillips sensibly loves.
The cancel police came for Zara the gay blade.
And they drove him out.
It's true. You can't be a gay blade anymore.
You can't be a gay blade. It's a reason
all the best gay blades have given up.
When that happened
I had no idea that they were going to do that.
I neither. I threw my hands up and I looked at them
and I went are you fucking kidding me?
So you were not spoiled.
I did not know that was going to happen.
You were fear.
You had told me,
you confessed that you were afraid something had been spoiled for you.
Someone tweeted something about the Thomas Wayne Joker's mom thing.
Oh, I see.
No, that's not.
I just could not believe when I was watching this movie that had been so
laboriously like,
we're not a comic book movie where,
you know, this is really a standalone so laboriously, like we're not a comic book movie where, you know,
this is really a standalone.
Then I'm like,
Oh,
but you had to kill the Wayne family for the 50th time.
Yeah.
And then like,
I guess suggest that like,
like,
you know,
cause like classically in any Joker origin in the comics,
especially in killing joke.
Yeah.
He,
Batman is tied to his origin.
Yes.
He's robbing a place, a chemical plant in both the fifties origin. They kind of gave him in Killing Joke. Batman is tied to his origin. He's robbing a place,
a chemical plant, in both the 50s origin
they kind of gave him and then the 80s origin.
Batman's already at large.
Batman is there to catch him and he dives into
the chemical plant or falls in a way.
That's why he's always
focused on Batman. That's sort of like
the original. And so now I guess
it's just like
they're tied together in that way like Batman
either they're brothers or
or yeah
let me ask you this
it's just it feels like the movie
like having this final like how profound
and you're just like I don't think
that's anything well here's the thing
I think if they were actually
the legitimate and
illegitimate son of Thomas Wayne
the movie could make some kind of statement
about nature versus nurture.
But it's not gonna
No, it's not doing it.
And it wouldn't do it with nuance.
It's really not doing that, right.
It wouldn't do it with nuance.
What else were you gonna say?
What I was gonna say is
correct me if I'm wrong
I believe Joaquin Phoenix is 49 years old.
Sounds about right.
And the boy who plays Batman in this looks about
I don't know, 10? He's 44 years old. Okay. And the boy is 49 years old. Sounds about right. And the boy who plays Batman in this looks about, I don't know, 10.
He's 44 years old.
Okay.
And the boy is 10, sure.
The boy is 10.
So you're saying like Bruce Wayne would have,
Thomas Wayne would have had to be like 20?
Right.
Right, something like that.
I mean, Batman never becomes Batman, right?
Bruce Wayne never becomes Batman canonically younger than like early 20s.
Sure, right.
So even then. He he's gonna be chasing around
an old joker at his absolute youngest the first time he puts on the cal joker 60 here's something
joaquin phoenix said i am sorry to report it because not that it matters because what i know
but i do want to actually just tell you that he said this where he's like what if this movie is
like like the j Joker of the comics like
sees this and it's his
like origin myth like so it's like
this is not about like the comic book
Joker okay it's about like a guy
in clown makeup who does this thing and becomes
like a notorious figure
and the other Joker's like drafting off of that
or something I don't know he said this in an interview
the final scene is him talking
to that's April Grace, right?
Is it?
Who I love. And he's in the
Arkham
or whatever. Because the movie ends
with the fucking
cops have him in the back.
Johnny C. and Tempo.
It's April Grace, yeah. Johnny C. and Tempo
one of the best stunt
coordinators in the business worked worked on The Tick but also worked on most of the Fast and Furious movies and is my source for all the Vin Diesel stories.
I will never tell on Mike.
Plays the cop who's driving the car and is like, you fucking freak.
Where do you get off?
But then some clown in an ambulance crashes into the police car and they pull his body out and they raise him to the rafters and he gets a standing ovation.
And I went, okay, you know what?
Fine. That's what you want. That's what you want for this
movie. He takes his bow. He finally gets his
recognition. And then the movie tacks on
this extra scene that is just
here he is institutionalized.
That I've seen a couple people
suggest like, what if that's the only real
scene? And everything else was in his head.
Man.
Okay, then great
I don't know the movie means less than it already
means yeah I don't know maybe
he's telling he said isn't that
where he says someone you wouldn't get the joke he's
laughing and he says you wouldn't get the joke and then you
see him running away and he's leaving bloody
footprints before he says you wouldn't get the joke
it cuts to Bruce in the alleyway with his
dead parents. Oh, yeah. Implying that the thing
he is laughing at is...
I mean, it's pretty funny. The orphaning of a young child.
What a funny movie. And then he's got
bloody footprints suggesting that he killed April Grace
as well, I guess. And he's dancing and then
they chase him. I liked
it when there was the old Warner Brothers logo.
I did too. That was the high point of the movie for me.
Joker. Joker. You want to do the box office game? No, I too. That was the high point of the movie for me. Joker. Joker.
You want to do the box office game? No, I mean
I was trying to think of a more interesting thing
to do. I mean, we're recording
this very soon after.
It was released, obviously.
I mean, we could try guessing, but I just feel like it's going to be boring.
Come on, give me the five. You know what's another thing I realize
where I often struggle more with things that came out
in the last couple of months than older releases?
It's because so much of my box office memory
is tied to the time and place of when a movie
came out, and when that is indistinguishable from
when we're recording, it hasn't made the
imprint yet. Yeah, but give me the five. Okay, number one is
Joker did 96. 96.
More than Justice League. Yeah.
Number two...
What is it? Would be whatever
was number one last weekend. And what was that?
And was it number one only for that one weekend?
Correct.
And it was, we're talking about October.
It dethroned Hustlers.
Yeah.
It was something of...
It actually dethroned Downton, really.
Oh, of course.
Which is number three.
Downton, suplexed it.
And Hustlers is number four.
It's been a robust October.
It has.
It's been quite a robust October.
Number five is the
very high grossing
September film
but
it chapter two
yes
finishing out September
did you see it chapter two
I did not
did you see it chapter one
I did
okay
here's the thing
I decided this year
and I'm trying not to be a grump
but it's just a thing
I decided
I am not
forcing myself
out of obligation
to go see the big movies that I know I'm not going to like
so I like it chapter one just fine
and I heard such roundly negative things
about it chapter two that I went I'm going to
prioritize seeing smaller things that I
think I might like and I will
I'll watch it at home sometime they don't need
my money I don't need to vote with my dollar for that
I don't think I'd enjoy seeing it that much
but what is number two?
defeated down to this is weird because it's like for that. I don't think I'd enjoy seeing it that much. But what is number two? Number two. Defeated
Downton. This is weird because
it's like I've seen marketing for it and I'm like
this exists? Yeah.
It exists.
I made little impression.
In two weeks it's made 37 million dollars.
And I already forget
that it exists.
Downton Abbey beat Rambo
and Ad Astra. Which are
Ad Astra's 7th and Rambo's
8th here. And this was number
one. Ad Astra unsurprisingly
has a fairly comfortable worldwide
total because of Brad Pitt's stardom.
This weirdly might unlock it
for me. Can you tell me
what this film did
in its first weekend, its number one weekend?
I believe it made around $20 million.
That's correct.
20.6.
20 on the nug.
Mm-hmm.
20 on the nug.
All right.
Seems like that didn't help.
No, it didn't.
I thought it would.
What a generic number one performance.
Yes.
All right.
I'll tell you that it's a children's film.
Of course.
Yes. And I'll tell you that it's a children's film. Of course. Yes.
And I'll tell you that it seems to be sort of geared towards an international audience.
Abominable.
Abominable.
Yes.
He's the snowman.
He is.
Yep.
You have Rambo.
You have.
Wait, he's that serial killer?
Yes.
He's the snowman.
He gave him all the clues. He gave him all the clues gave him all the clues
if only Joker
had given us some clues
Good Boys
is still hanging out
in the top 10
what's Good Boys up to
is it cracked to 100
82
oh wow okay
but 100 worldwide
107
Lion King
did quite well
but ended up
basically
it was the number one
high school
new new give it some time I think it's gonna get there yeah it's gonna need It did quite well, but ended up basically a Desert Beauty and the Beast number. It was the number one high school in the world.
No.
No.
Give it some time.
I think it's going to get there.
Yeah, it's going to need to hang around.
Hobbs and Shaw seems to be done at about 173,758 worldwide.
Which we disagree about this.
It did very well.
Yeah.
But it is a big drop from the mainline Fast and Furious entries.
Is it?
What did Fate make?
Fate was humongous.
Fate, I believe, made $1.2 billion.
Yeah, it did.
But I think, given that
they're trying to launch
a second franchise, I guess they're probably happy about it.
It's not like they cut... It's a terrible movie.
It's not a great film. It's not like
they cut the budget a ton. Often these spin-offs
it's about coming up with a cheaper satellite.
A movie I have not seen
that made $18 million.
That's more than
The Goldfinch.
Right?
It's more than
The Farewell.
Great movie.
Are you talking about
the highest grossing
independent film of the year?
Yes.
The Peanut Butter Falcon?
The Peanut Butter Falcon.
A weird box office phenomenon
that I'm not seeing discussed
anywhere.
It's feel good movie
that was at Sundance
but made no impression
right
stars Shia LaBeouf
and Dakota Johnson
Bruce Dern
that's right
John Hawks
about a boy
who likes wrestling
I believe
who runs away
he's got Down Syndrome
he runs away from his
sort of assistant living home
or something like that
and he's sort of got a
rural river guide
yeah and runs into
and they have like an inspirational
story. I've only seen the trailer once.
I have not seen the film. I saw the trailer once.
I'm sorry, it was at South by. Okay, I saw the trailer
and I went, wow, I will never think about this movie again.
And it's done pretty well.
98% on Rotten Tomatoes,
the highest grossing independent
film of the year. Weird! Has outgrossed
many studio releases. Yeah!
That's all. Do you know a single
person who's seen the Peanut Butter Falcon? No.
Now, here's my thing.
I must know a critic who saw it. I don't know.
But I've never talked to anyone about it.
And it's weird. I guess, at some point,
I guess I gotta say, I guess Peanut Butter Falcon's
getting nominated for Best Picture this year.
Best Peanut Butter! Right.
But it premieres at South By. It doesn't win.
I feel like people are like, oh, a charming light film.
Right.
Yeah.
Roadside picks it up.
I see the trailer.
I go, oh, cool.
That film is going to make four thousand dollars.
Right.
It's not like Shia LaBeouf.
Yeah.
Is box office gold.
But weirdly, Roadside Attractions has kind of cornered a market.
Yeah.
On selling Indy to the heartlands.
Yeah, right, right, right.
And I think they wisely recognized
this is another mud.
Right.
Mud, a much better film,
I presume,
a film I love,
but that kind of surprise
out-of-the-box success
where that was a movie
that played at eight festivals,
no one bought it,
wasn't seen as commercial,
and then did 20 million plus.
And Roadside has also
had more success
selling faith-based films than
most studios and studio arms.
So I think...
Right, I think Peanut Butter Falcon is
just not targeted to us. I think
we're the coastal elites. We're the
Thomas Wayans and our ivory towers.
So the Jokers of the world are...
I don't mean to
slander the Peanut Butter Falcon.
We need to cut it out with the coastal elitescon we all know that the Joker's favorite movie is
Joker that is the only movie
he would like
I'm sure Murray Franklin
did like a road to movie or whatever right
like he did like a sort of Bob Hope movie at some
point in his career
what if De Niro is like off the success of
Joker I'm gonna make a Murray Franklin
franchise off the success of Joker, I'm going to make a Murray Franklin franchise.
Off the success of Miami nomination for playing Robert Mueller in SNL,
I will join the cast of SNL full time.
We're going to use the de-aging technology
from the Irishman to make
The Young Adventures of Murray Franklin.
Is it Murray Anderson?
I don't know.
Whatever.
No, it's Murray Franklin, I believe.
Okay, whatever.
Final thoughts.
Don't like it.
Best one of the year.
No, I was like,
I mean, I was watching it. I was like, I mean, I was watching and I was like,
I think this is a four for me.
I think there are enough individual elements
that I can respect
taken on their own that I can't completely
throw the movie out.
But I don't think the movie
in and of itself has
any real weight or thought
or value. I was kind of astonished
by how little there was.
And as I was saying to you right before we recorded,
I was like last night in my bathroom being like,
I think I know what my final summation on this movie is going to be.
Right.
Having not seen it, and I watched the film,
and all of that was thrown out.
Because I thought I was going to watch a film that was well-made
and was dangerous in sort of its intent.
Right, yeah.
And instead, I saw a movie that kind of is just shitting on the stage
and throwing shit at the audience and going, like,
if you don't get this, you're a fucking square.
And then just basically poking at all, like, truly scary people out there.
And also saying, this is art, you have to take this seriously.
Yep.
Right.
Yeah.
So, I mean, we were talking to producer Rachel,
and she was like, how is it, do I have to see it?
And we were like, no. And she's Rachel, and she was like, how is it? Do I have to see it? And we were like, no.
And she's like, is it what I think it is?
And we're like, it's a movie that yells at you that it is what you think it is.
But it's not a very convincing argument.
You know what's a better story that's like this?
Read Franz Kafka's Metamorphosis.
Yes.
Metamorphosis.
Metamorphosis.
Watch Taxi Driver.
To watch Taxi Driver to watch Taxi Driver
you know what's a great work we were talking about as we were walking in
Stephen Sondheim's
Assassins the favorite musical of those
three bros that Joker killed on
that subway train is a musical
about presidential
assassins and
it is very messy
it was controversial at the time people thought they were
glamorizing unsavory people but it is very messy. It was controversial at the time. People thought they were glamorizing, unsavory people.
But it is a work that actually tries to grapple with the psychosis of people on the fringes of society.
Love, love a sense.
That is a master artist actually putting a lot of thought into what they're saying and the weight of what they're making.
Because that's the whole thing. When Todd Phillips goes, oh, it's a heist movie, we're using the Joker as a shield
to be able to get a $60 million drama made within the studio system.
The thing he is not thinking about is
the vehicle you're using to that end is a huge fucking franchise.
It is a character that has a lot of cultural weight
and a lot of cultural messiness.
The most cultural weight.
And as one would say with
great power comes great responsibility right and if you're gonna fucking use the joker to make your
big movie you kind of got to think about what you're saying now todd phillips does not care
about that he doesn't right that's what i'm saying not at all i'm saying that's what you're saying
that to todd phillips i can just imagine the extent to which he would jerk off uh invisible
penis so rigorously.
Viciously. No, I'm not
saying I twist my face. I'm saying one
should think about that.
Yeah. And he doesn't.
I don't know. That's the Joker. We're done with that.
I don't know. I mean, it's like, do we ever cover
a DC film again?
No. Yeah, I love
that idea. Let's not do it anymore. I'm out.
I actually took
Birds of Prey
which looks
you know at least
like something
I think it looks like something
off the schedule
yeah
I'm done talking about these movies
I guess
well the real question is
that's the question
it's like Aquaman 2
and Wonder Woman 2
Aquaman 2 and Wonder Woman 2
are sort of
and the
well don't forget
and we like James Gunn
alright so fine
let me clarify
we like James Gunn's tweets we don't. Let me clarify. We like James Gunn's tweets.
We don't have to set hard and fast rules for ourselves.
But like, Birds of Prey is one of those things
where I'm like, that looks like
a pretty
fun or somewhat competent movie.
Like, it's sort of that thing
where I'm like, yeah, I don't know if I'm automatically
like, you know,
it's going to be so bananas that we need to talk about.
What I found interesting was the shambling mass of DC trying to make a cohesive thing.
And that is gone.
For the better, probably.
If anything good comes out of the Joker, I hope it is that they greenlight some fucking Elseworlds movies.
That they let someone make Superman, Red Son, or President Luther.
What about Jokers?
There's many.
I mean, you joke, but...
That's probably going to get pitted.
My point is, what I don't want to see is like...
I don't fucking know.
I don't want to see Abel Farrar's freeze.
You know?
With walking, maybe?
That sounds good.
That sounds actually great.
I don't want to see the twisted version,
but there are great standalone DC stories
that could make good $60 million
more high-end dramatic films.
And it would be nice
if the success of this movie
encourages them to do that.
I worry it will just be more
empty provocation.
Yeah.
Let's never speak of Joker again.
I love that idea.
Great.
Wrap it up.
Wait a second.
Are you telling me?
Yeah, you can.
We're raising it to the rafters.
Yes.
Oh my God.
Retired bit.
It's up there.
Ricky T.
So long.
Sayonara, sucker.
Thank you all for listening.
Please remember to rate, review, subscribe.
Thanks to Andrew Gooder for our social media lead
and Mike Irving for our theme song.
Pat Reynolds and Joe Bowen for our artwork.
Next week, Gemini Man.
A very, very different movie.
Lovely movie compared to this.
Yeah.
Very optimistic and sunshiny movie in a weird way.
We got Ant-Man and the Wasp coming up on the old Patreon feed.
Blink-Tick special features.
I think we have Whisper of the Heart first.
Oh, we got Whisper of the Heart with our old friend Ramona Head.
Legendary member.
That just posted.
So yeah, we will have Ant-Man and the Wasp.
Of our trivia team walking penis.
Look, it all ties together.
And then Ant-Man and the Wasp coming at the end of the month.
Yeah, we just posted that.
So, right.
Look forward to Ant-Man and the Wasp.
Next week, Gemini Man, goodbye.
Never want to speak of Joker again.
Yeah.
Did you guys think Joker's kind of like Trump?
No, no, no.
Enough.
Enough.
Stop.
No, seriously, it's retired.
But can I just say, to end our episode as we should, formally. Ah. And as always.
I'm still around.
What?
Remember me?
No.
Richard T. Bain.
No.