Calm Parenting Podcast - Defiant, Disrespectful Child: A Script to Repair Your Relationship #464

Episode Date: March 30, 2025

Defiant, Disrespectful Child: A Script to Repair Your Relationship #464 You have a challenging child who says disrespectful things to you. You would be justified in punishing this child, but that won���t fix the underlying relationship that’s strained or broken. This is a powerful real life story with a script and action steps to repair this relationship with a strong-willed child. Share with Dads. These ideas are from the No B.S. Program, part of the Get Everything Package now 50% OFF with our Spring Sale at https://celebratecalm.com/products AG1 AG1 is offering new subscribers a FREE $76 gift when you sign up. You’ll get a Welcome Kit, a bottle of D3 & K2 AND 5 free travel packs in your first box. Go to https://drinkag1.com/calm HAPPY MAMMOTH Get 15% off on your entire first order at https://HappyMammoth.com with the code CALM at checkout.  ONE SKIN Go to https://oneskin.co and use code KIRK at checkout for an exclusive 15% off your first purchase. COZY EARTH Wrap yourself and your kids in Cozy Earth luxury…with 40% OFF! Visit https://cozyearth.com/ and use my exclusive 40% off code CALM.  HUNGRYROOT Get 40% off your first box PLUS get a free item in every box for life. Go to https://hungryroot.com/ and use code CALM. IXL LEARNING Get an exclusive 20% off an IXL membership when you sign up today at https://IXL.com/KIRK. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

So I'll start with a confession that many of you have heard me say before I did not like our son when he was young He was so challenging everything was hard putting your shoes on eating going to bed doing schoolwork He was really emotional with these really intense meltdowns and all it did was provoke my own immaturity It was not his issue It was my issue and it forced me to grow up. And so, but I'd spent the first like seven years of his life just trying to fix and change him until I finally discovered that I was the one that needed to change. But in that process I nearly destroyed our relationship and I

nearly destroyed our son. So how can you recover from this when you and your strong willed child are opposites? Or worse yet, you're just alike. Or maybe you have a spouse who just is not connecting with your strong willed child and you can see this divide starting to happen or it's well along its way. How do you repair that?

That is what we're going to discuss on this episode of the Calm Parenting Podcast. So welcome, this is Kirk Martin, founder of Celebrate Calm. You can find us in our big spring sale at CelebrateCalm.com. So many, look, we've been through this, that most of the outbursts from your strong willed child are going to sound an awful lot like defiance and disrespect. And sometimes they are. But as we've seen, sometimes the root of it is anxiety. Anxiety,

right? An anxious child is nervous about unknowns, doesn't want to go to that new place so they lash out, you're stupid, I hate you. Tae Kwon Do is stupid. And that had nothing to do with being defiant. It was just an anxious kid. And so we can use that insight to build a closer, more trusting relationship with a child and give your child tools to overcome their anxiety. But sometimes the defiance is caused by a broken relationship.

And so I'm going to reference some bad language in this episode just one or two times. I won't actually say the word so it's not gonna be that bad but I just wanted you to know as a heads up if you have a child who has been hurt or feels like an outcast in your home or misunderstood think about sharing this episode with them because it may open up some conversations. Totally up to you. So this is a true story. It's one that's honestly been repeated since the very beginning of time.

It's the story of a father with two sons. And one is the prodigal or strong-willed son, and the other one is the more compliant golden child. And this happened right in middle America, right in Minnesota. Now it doesn't sound a lot like Minnesota nice in the moment, but this is reality and it happens in a lot of our homes. So let's set the stage. Mom, dad, and two sons are having dinner. By the way, this could be a mom and daughter, a mom and son, a dad and daughter, but this is just the way it rolled, right? So we've got this family sitting down and we've got the typical strong-willed child, like many of us have, who's never really lived up to parents' expectations, always does things the hard way,

argues, makes everything difficult, has his own opinions, doesn't like school, and he just kind of struggles. And then you've got the more compliant good child who does everything that's expected of him. And the relationship between dad and the strong-willed child is strained. And the relationship between husband and wife is also strained because mom's been the mediator managing the emotions of her son and her husband for years, managing, kind of taking the emotions of her son and her husband for years managing taking the temperature of the home and running interference and that will cause a lot of problems in your home it will cause resentment will cause adrenal fatigue and it's not sustainable so there's

always this underlying tension in the family and then you can throw in all the self-doubt between the parents like oh are we letting this strong will child get away with things? Why can't he be just like his brother? What would our parents have done in this situation? What are we doing wrong? And look, people are gonna judge you. All those things come into the mix.

So dad asks his strong will child to do something for him after dinner and his request is not met with the requisite enthusiasm that dad wants and expects that he gets from his other child. So the dad says, I don't know why you have to make everything so difficult son, your brother never gives me any problems. To which the strong willed child replies, F you dad and storms off from the kitchen table and goes and slams his bedroom door. Now he did use the actual F word there and dad of course begins yelling and threatening and taking away all privileges and mom and the compliant son are once again caught in

the middle of this drama. So a few thoughts. I know these kids are tough, I do get it, but you absolutely must work through your own issues and learn how to accept your strong willed child on a deep level. And I mean to truly accept them, not just tolerate them, not just put up with them. You're going to have to learn how to understand them and really accept them as they are. And I'm not talking about putting up with abusive behavior, letting them do whatever they want, staying on screens all night.

I'm not talking about that. I mean on a very personal level, this has to happen. Otherwise, it will result. What will happen is the death of self-confidence, the death of self-acceptance, the death of vision and motivation, and ultimately the death of the relationship. And you know what else is going to happen in homes like this? This teenage boy will shut down and grow angry because he knows and kind of is internalized, I'm the bad kid, the black sheep, the one who's always been difficult, who's never lived

up to your expectations, even though he's probably a very bright, insightful, and even good hearted kid to others. That's part of the struggle for us, right? As parents, as you see these things in your kids and you're like, this is a kid who will stop on the street and give all of his possessions to homeless people or who's really good with animals and maybe little kids who, when other adults talk to you, they're like, oh man, he is such a great kid, he's so responsible, so respectful. And yet you don't see that in your home.

And so some kids will turn this anger inward and self-sabotage their lives. Sometimes they'll do it to get back at the parents. See, you've always thought I was a loser, never the good one. Well, now you're going to get exactly what you thought and wanted and I'm gonna live down to your lowest expectations. What are you gonna do about it? Take away my screens? Fine. I'll just sit in my room and do nothing for the next six months and you can't force me to do anything. Sure, send me to military school.

I'll try to escape and get kicked out and I'll be right back here. So look, this dynamic, it'll also kill your marriage. There's no way around this. I know these kids are challenging, pigheaded, don't always listen. They push the limits. They're mouthy. Got it. You're justified in feeling frustrated and angry at them. But we're the grown adults and this is the most important job of your lifetime. If you don't find a way to repair this relationship, to accept this child as he or she is, they will seek your elusive acceptance well into their 50s and 60s and it can be devastating. So back to our scene. Was this defiance and disrespect shown to the dad? Yes, of course. Do we just excuse it because the child is

upset and hurt? No, but we do have to understand context. This reaction by this child is driven by pain. There's a pleading nature to the tone. Listen how he said it, F you dad. See what I hear is, you've never accepted or liked me dad. You've always liked my brother more. I can never live up to your expectations. So just F you, right? That's a pleading tone. That's the voice of a broken relationship and you have to distinguish between these things. And so in this instance, it is not the defiance and disrespect that needs to be addressed primarily.

Rather, it is the underlying pain. It is the underlying broken relationship that needs to be addressed. See, once you take care of that, everything else kind of falls in place. And we've dealt in other podcasts with just pure outright defiance. I think there's one from May 2024 on outright refusal. Listen to that one. It's fantastic. I've been through other ones. We have an entire program called Stop Defiance and Disrespect, but that's not

what is happening here. One of the reasons I'm so proud of you as moms and dads is you're working so hard at this. And the dad who told me the story reacted at first. He was wrong. And what I used to do back in the day was double down on this. Well, I've already messed up. I may as well just vent all of my resentment and frustration at this kid, and I'll turn this into a 16-hour fight and I want to caution you with that because when I was immature before I changed I had a lot of resentment toward our son and when he would even do one small thing wrong oh I would be like oh I'm gonna take advantage you know

what you leave your stuff all over the place you don't study for school you talk back to your mom and all of this will come out. And there was this, it was kind of sabotaging my relationship with him. And I just want you to be aware of that and work on your own resentment underneath. Again, we're not talking about excusing behavior, but we do want to understand the root of this.

So the cool thing is is this dad handled it differently after he first messed up. So Mrs. Calm told me yesterday, I wish I had begun drinking AG1 sooner. My stomach has felt so much calmer and I'm more regular. My AG1 in the morning provides some consistency I really crave. And that's one reason I love my AG1. It's an easy, healthy, daily routine. No messes, no blenders. We put one scoop of AG1 into a bottle of water, shake it up, and start our day with 75 vitamins,

probiotics, prebiotics, and whole food sourced ingredients. Check out a special offer at www.drinkag1.com slash com. Look, I've got more energy, better mental clarity, and AG1 supports my immune health and that's why I've been partnering with AG1 for so long. Be an AG1 couple like us. AG1 is offering new subscribers a free $76 gift when you sign up. You'll get a welcome kit, a bottle of D3 and K2, and 5 free travel packs in your first

box. So check out drinkag1.com slash com to get this offer. That's drinkag1.com slash com to start your day with a win. You are going to mess up. So the dad said, I come home stressed. There was talk of layoffs at my job. And so I took that shot at my son at the table and I knew instantly I'd stepped in it. And I, and so I reacted, I did my yelling routine, but then I remembered your

voice saying reset and moms and dads, I want you to have a reset routine. So that dad said, look, I'm just learning this. So my new routine is I go to the garage. It's a quiet space. It's my space. I move things around to work off the stress. Organizing some shelves gives me something I can control in that moment,

since apparently I can't control my mouth or my son. And I like that humility there, right? And so he said, I just, I pulled up your app on my phone and I pushed the button, it's always a good reminder. And you were mentioning humility. And that's such a tough concept for me. It's foreign to everything I have been taught. So I had this war raging inside me, beating myself up, but also so angry

at this kid and also feeling a little bit helpless. But I knew I had to take the humble approach or we'd have another blowout. And look, this dad would have been justified in laying into his son because the kid had just dropped the f-bomb on him, right? Isn't this parenting awesome? Isn't this what you pictured when you were planning your family? But being justified doesn't mean it's right and it will never work because humility breaks down walls. So I want you to know wrestling with these ideas is normal. You're coming up against like what you were taught as a child. You're hearing your parents think like you're letting this kid get away with things.

What would have happened when you were a kid when this happened? So this is all normal moms and dads. You're not doing anything wrong with this. But what you can do is something entirely different, which is what this dad did and it was awesome. Okay, so let's picture this. Stand there with the dad in the garage with that war going on in his head.

You have been there. You may be there later today. So let's walk with this dad. Just picture this as he trudges upstairs to talk to his son. The weight of years of a broken relationship, all these words between them, making every step heavy with regret and anger

and foreboding. And now picture what's happening on the other side of this bedroom door. Your child feels the same thing. He knows he shouldn't have said that to his dad. And now dad knocks on the door and this is a subtle act of respect for his son's privacy even though it's not warranted after just what happened right this dad have it ever had every right to march up those stairs barge through the bedroom door that he paid for because it's his home and because of what his son had just said to him but this isn't about being right or proving your point or disciplining your child. It's a relationship. That is your child on the other side of that door.

So the dad knocks on the door. And this is such a subtle act of respect and humility for a son who doesn't always warrant that. And the dad stays outside the room because walking in through the door in this situation it's just too much tension. It's too heavy. It's too much. Neither of them can stand to look at each other right now. So the dad does the smart thing and he stands outside the door and I guarantee this is what the dad said is going through is, oh man I'm the adult. I'm owed

an apology right here. I shouldn't have to be doing this right now and he's right about that but he humbles himself anyway and says, son, I'm sorry I yelled at you and said those things. I was wrong. And I'm sorry for how I've treated you so differently. Look, I'm gonna go leash up the dogs right now and go for a walk. And if you want to come join me, I promise I won't lecture you and I'll listen to you.

That's what we talk about all the time. And the dad had told me when he was in the garage, I promise I won't lecture you and I'll listen to you. That's what we talk about all the time. And the dad had told me when he was in the garage, he was like, oh, okay, I'm trying to remember now. Motion changes emotion. Invite my son to be with me because his whole life I have sent him to his room, whether I told him to go or we had a blow up and he ran there himself.

We've always been disconnected and I remembered no eye contact. I don't need to have a face-to-face discussion with him. So the dad came up with this of like, oh okay I'm gonna walk the dogs and invite my son. So the dad told me he walked away and he felt this war still raging inside. You're going to feel conflicted. He felt humiliated because the kid is supposed to respect him as the authority figure and he shouldn't have to be doing that. That's not how we were raised by our parents, but he was also proud of himself for handling it this way. So he leashes up the dogs and he's standing outside in the Minnesota cold wondering why should I be

the one apologizing? Why isn't this kid down here already? What am I going to say to him? But he stays there and he waits and after a little while his son slinks outside just as uncomfortable, just as awkward, just as embarrassed and of course not wearing a jacket just as hoodie. This kid knows that when he dropped the f-bomb on his dad that there was going to be heck to pay for that so they begin walking with years of tension between them and Because the dad had taken the humble approach the son actually broke the ice Dad, I feel like you don't like me as much as you like my brother." Boom! There! That, look, this hurting kid finally said what had been hiding under the surface for years. Right? You

don't like me as much as you like my brother. Or you just plain don't like me. And you're going to be tempted to think, no way the kid would say that but I will virtually guarantee this will happen. I was an old school dad who didn't have any of these tools and when Casey and I would have conflict guess who initiated talking? Not me, it was Casey the strong will kid who wanted to make it right. he'd say, Dad, we need to talk about this. Why? Because there was a yearning in my son. And we've talked about this in recent years together on some of our long hikes. And he told me, he said, Dad, I was desperate to have you accept me and understand me. I knew deep down, I had to have a good relationship with my dad. And man, that'll just kill you inside. When I realized that I deprived him of that with my own pride, he was desperate for my acceptance and my affection and me and knowing that I believed in him and that I was connected to him.

And he knew that on a deep level you have to have that and so he came to me so when this kid came outside and he initiated and said dad I feel like you don't like me as much as you like my brother that rings true to me so watch be there in the scene this father and son are now walking or maybe mom it's you with a son or a daughter but they're together side by side right not standing across from each other next to each other and the dad seizes on his son's confession and admits son I love you every bit as much as I love your brother I just have a hard time connecting with you and I'm sorry for that." And they walked and talked and he was able to say, I see so much of myself in you and it brings back

all the pain I've experienced and I don't want you to make those same mistakes that I made because I do love you and so I'm tougher on you. And I haven't always done this right. But if you'll, now there's where I start to choke up, right? But if you'll give me a chance, I'd like to start over. I'd like to see if we can start doing one thing together that you really enjoy. And the reason I choked up is because those are virtually word-for-word what I had said back to Casey back in the day.

And I know this sounds like a Hallmark movie but it's not. It's real life and the conversation will be awkward but the humility of the parent, of the father, breaks down the walls and his son says, Dad, I'm sorry for the language. I'm sorry I was disrespectful and I'd like to try better. And so they begin to actually for the first time have a conversation because we live, even with our spouses, we live with so many things underneath the surface that we just don't say

and day after day, week after week, week month after month year after year go by So here are a couple strategies. I pulled these from the no BS program It's in to get everything packaged to rebuild your relationship with your child Number one take an interest moms and dads take an interest in one thing your child is interested We talked about this you enter into their world instead of standing over here and saying, hey, care about the things that I care about. No, you get interested in what they're interested in, even if you hate it, which you likely will, like their video games, their horrible music, whatever they watch on YouTube,

or if they like to create or build things, your child may enjoy things you're actually interested in, so that's a bonus. You could watch movies or documentaries about these interests, ask questions, be genuinely curious. My son's interests were test driving cars and playing World War II video games, so what I would ask, hey I'm curious, what is it about this video game that you like so much? Why are you so good at it? What gives you an advantage versus your opponents? What is it about cars that interest you and make you run down the street when a Ferrari

goes by? What do you like better a Ferrari or a Lamborghini? I spent a lot of time doing that and even today look he's grown and I just went to a talk at a local brew pub on avalanche recognition because Casey skis in the backcountry and it's interesting even as a grown adult he always says dad thank you for taking an interest in what we're interested in because I went with he and his wife even though you don't ski in the backcountry. They appreciate that. What about this horrid music do you like so much? I'm kind of kidding, but what about this music? Find out why they connect with certain things. You will learn what makes your child click.

Look, we're getting along, so I'll wrap this up. Here's one more cool bonding strategy. Ask your child to teach you something because their whole lives were always showing and teaching and lecturing. But ask them to teach you something or show you how to do something on your phone or with technology or something they're good at. It lets them have a little bit of control and mastery over something. It builds confidence. When you open yourself up and let your child teach you something,

there is something very magical and beautiful that happens. Look, sometimes the worst moments of defiance can lead to the greatest bonding and learning opportunities. I nearly destroyed my relationship with Casey, but now we are so incredibly close and I think that's precisely because we worked through all of these hard issues together. We wrestled with it. We wrestled with each other. You can do this. I would encourage you listen to this episode. Listen to this episode twice. Binge past episodes. Go through our downloadable programs. Right now it comes on an app on your phone and I can give you scripts and action steps to take in the moment. It's way cheaper than therapy or divorce. Look, thank you for listening to this podcast. Thank you for

subscribing, for sharing it with others. Thank you for working so hard to change. I have so much respect for all of you really digging into this because this is the hardest work you will ever do in your life. All right, love you all. We'll talk to you next time. Bye-bye.