Calm Parenting Podcast - Pt. 1: How to Shut Up & Stop Lecturing (So Kids Actually Listen To You) #447

Episode Date: February 9, 2025

Pt. 1: How to Shut Up & Stop Lecturing (So Kids Actually Listen To You) #447 Do you feel compelled to lecture your kids? Do you have a hard time stopping? Do you feel like you’re being permissive if you don’t? Do you go on and on hoping your kids will finally “get it” and change their behavior? Do you lecture because you weren’t heard as a kid? You’re not alone! Kirk gives you practical tools to stop lecturing and start getting kids to listen to you!  Our Winter Sale on the Get Everything Package continues this week. Begin 2025 with hundreds of practical strategies that really work with your strong-willed kids. Visit https://celebratecalm.com/products and make 2025 DIFFERENT. AG1 AG1 is offering new subscribers a FREE $76 gift when you sign up. You’ll get a Welcome Kit, a bottle of D3 & K2 AND 5 free travel packs in your first box. Go to https://drinkag1.com/calm  HAPPY MAMMOTH Get 15% off on your entire first order at https://HappyMammoth.com with the code CALM at checkout.  HUNGRYROOT.COM Get 40% off your first box PLUS get a free item in every box for life. Go to https://hungryroot.com/ and use code CALM. ONE SKIN Go to https://oneskin.co and use code KIRK at checkout for an exclusive 15% off your first purchase. COZY EARTH Wrap yourself and your kids in Cozy Earth luxury...with 40% OFF! Visit https://cozyearth.com/ and use my exclusive 40% off code CALM.  IXL LEARNING Get an exclusive 20% off an IXL membership when you sign up today at https://IXL.com/KIRK. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

So do you ever have times where you just don't feel like yourself with fatigue or poor sleep or even night sweats just knocking you off your game? Well, let's make your self-care priority with the help of our friends at Happy Mammoth, a company dedicated to making women's lives easier through all natural products such as hormone harmony. Hormone harmony contains adaptogens that help the body adapt to any stressors like chaotic hormonal changes that just happen naturally throughout a woman's life. Hormone harmony is for any woman with symptoms of hormonal changes. We especially appreciate that hormone harmony does not compromise on the quality of their ingredients. The biggest benefit? I feel like myself again.

That's what women say over and over in 30,000 reviews of hormone harmony. It's time to feel like yourself again moms. For a limited time you can get 15% off on your entire first order at happymammoth.com with the code CALM at checkout. That's happymammoth.com with the code CALM. So let's make this the year that we give our kids tools to succeed in school by working with their natural learning style and feeding their curiosity. IXL makes that so much easier. So check out IXL.com slash Kirk now. IXL is an online learning program that enriches your homeschool curriculum from K to 12.

With IXL your child can explore any topic in any grade level. IXL has video tutorials and learning games to guide your child in the way they learn best while meeting them at their level. Kids love iXcel's positive feedback and parents love knowing specific skills that need work. Make an impact on your child's learning. Get iXcel now. Calm Parenting Podcast listeners get an exclusive 20% off an IXL membership when they sign up today at IXL.com slash Kirk. Visit IXL.com slash Kirk to get the most effective learning program out there

at the best price. So do you feel compelled to lecture your kids? Do you have a hard time stopping? Do you feel like you're being permissive if you don't? Do you go on and on hoping your kids will finally get it and change their behavior? Do you lecture because you weren't heard as a kid? Well, you're not alone. So that is what we're going to discuss on today's first of two episodes on how to shut up and stop lecturing so your kids actually listen to you and take responsibility for their own behavior. So welcome this is Kirk Barton founder of Celebrate Calm. You can find us and our winter sale at CelebrateCalm.com. So our most popular newsletter back in the day when we used to write one was titled shut up and I was always worried that people would get offended but they didn't and whenever I post a video on Instagram or TikTok or Facebook about this parents

are unusually receptive to the message and I have a lot of respect for you for being willing to change and here's why this is so important. Lecturing and talking too much makes kids more angry. It makes them less receptive to your wisdom. And it breeds resentment within your kids and inside of you. It destroys trust and relationships. It destroys trust and relationships. And the worst thing in some ways is you go through all of that and it still doesn't work. So back in December I released a video and I asked people to comment on why it's so hard to stop talking so much. And so I spent the past couple months really going through all of their responses so I could address them individually and specifically. So I'm not going to format this as like ten ways to stop. Instead I

want to read through the actual questions and comments and then provide my honest feedback because I think that will be really really instructive and I think you'll hear your own fears and anxiety in this as well. So here goes Oh, I'm gonna ask you this too. I may be a little bit harsh at times in this and I don't mean to offend you I'll be very direct but always know I don't do blame or guilt any of those things But sometimes I will be a little bit tough. So one of the best questions was this it's like I'm actually having a hard time identifying when or if I'm lecturing. I have no idea what qualifies as a lecture so let's start there. What is a lecture? So to me a good way to discern that is this if what you are

saying is tinged with or born of your own parental anxiety then your kids will sense that and resist that. When we lecture it feels like we're being compelled out of anxiety to talk. I hope you know what that means it's kind of like well I kind of need to tell them I really need to tell them because if I don't tell them see that kind of like, well, I kind of need to tell them, I really need to tell them because if I don't tell them, see that kind of uneasy feeling inside, and I know you know what that feels like, because I can think of probably a hundred times in my life when I've said something to someone

out of feeling compelled and it never works. And so it definitely feels more like nagging than teaching. And we tend to go on and on when we lecture, right? It definitely feels more like nagging than teaching. And we tend to go on and on when we lecture. If you've listened to our discipline program, you know that the fewer words you use, the more confident you sound when you discipline. When you go on and on, it's like you're trying to talk yourself into it. You're trying to justify it.

And I don't know any strong willed kids or actually many humans who like to hear someone's voice drone on and on. Lecturing repeats itself over and over. Well, I don't think you heard me the first 53 times I told you, so I'm just going to try again and say it in a different way. And see, we often excuse it because, well well we just love our kids so much and we want the best for them and if I'm being honest lecturing is more about you satisfying your own need your own anxiety your own desire to talk and to prove something it's it's prioritizing that over their behavior. It's more about your own control issues

than it is about ultimately helping them. But teaching sounds different. See, teaching sounds confident. I'm not entangled with my child and their emotions. I'm not entangled with feeling compelled like I have to get through to them. My expectation is very different. I'm allowing the child to own his or her choice or choices rather than trying to convince them to do it for me or for any other reason. I am saying,

hey, here's what I have found in life. Things tend to go better for me when I do X. Hey, I could show you a different way to try this in case you want to do it and then I show them how I would do it but without a lot of words or expectation that they will immediately do it my way. See there's a big difference in that lecturing because I'm trying to convince and I really need you to listen to me and I need you to do what I want You can you feel that versus saying hey, I'm a grown adult. I've been around for a while I'm gonna show you I'm gonna teach you and I'm going to trust that you will get this see Teaching tends to be more decisive and non emotional. It puts the onus or responsibility on the child taking responsibility.

When you are lecturing, you are too emotionally invested in it. You are an equal part of the equation. It's like, well, I'm doing my part by lecturing you over this again and again, explaining things, and your job is to do what I tell you to do. See teaching is modeling. It's dropping wisdom, then stepping back and letting your kids own their choices.

You just have to relinquish control over how they accomplish certain things and I know that's hard. So a very common feeling is, well I just feel like I have to say or do something. I really want you to practice this this week. Give yourself permission to say nothing. Stop filling that space. Give yourself permission to know that it's not your job to fix your kids, it's not your job to fix every situation. You've heard me say this, sometimes when we try to fix situations we escalate, we make it a lot worse. So if nothing else this week, I

would write this one down, give yourself permission that in this particular instance I'm not gonna fix it and I'm not going to say anything and that's gonna drive you crazy for a little bit but just watch how your kids respond. Now here is another comment. I'm Italian so we just talk a lot and I'm going to be both sincere and a little offensive here. So look you can't make excuses for this because I could say the same thing well I have ADHD I'm neurodivergent, and that just means I talk all the time. Well, I know that's in my wiring, but it's also an excuse that I'm also hurting relationships by doing that, right?

I also have some Scottish and Irish background. Does that mean I'm destined to be an alcoholic and drink a lot? So in my notes when the person had said this I'd written like oh I'm Italian and my response was like no you're just being annoying and I love my Italian friends and I love your food and I love your big personalities but it's clearly irritating your kids so why would you keep doing that? And yes, I do want you to feel guilty about this. I do. I want you to regret this.

Because I want you to feel that so, and forgive me for this, so you effing stop already. It's just after a while sometimes, and this is the hard part of this that I warned you about, it just becomes selfish Because it becomes more about me and my need to express my anxiety And what you're doing wrong and that's selfish and selfishness never works in life. It's not good So forgive me if I was a little too rough on you, but you probably needed that so cut it out stop it so here's the really cool thing and here's the here's the first negative thing right if you continue doing that

you're just teaching your kids to be as annoying as you are not having any self-control or self-discipline because you're just impulsively blurting out lots of words that don't help. But the cool part is if you do learn to master this and you can, you will be teaching your kids how to have constructive discussions and handle conflict with their future spouse and kids one day rather than just feeling justified to say stuff because you're the parent, you're the authority figure, right? Like think of all those excuses, well I have ADD, I talk a lot, I'm Italian, I'm the parent, I'm the authority figure. Those are just

excuses and it doesn't change the fact that it doesn't work. Now for most of us where we get stuck is that we just get worried about our kids future, right? I so it's about this you have to control your anxiety over their future. And I go back and listen to the podcast from early January on controlling your own anxiety, because we have to stop projecting into the future and thinking your child will always be like this because we start that when they're three or four in pre-k and they can't sit still they're getting in trouble or they're sitting in a hoodie sweatshirt when they're tweens playing video games all the time we project into

the future we have to stop that and be more confident so changing some of your own expectations and working with your child's nature will help a lot now here is another good one from these are great comments from all of you. So thank you I get overwhelmed the mom said the most challenging part is I've got three young kids under the age of five and it's all the Stimulation I get all day long and by the end of the day the yelling and screaming can really set me off And if I say to them I need a minute or two one of my two-year-olds will cry for me. Look, of course this would set you off. That would set me off as well.

You're a completely normal human being. It would be weird if you had a bunch of loud, noisy little kids demanding your attention and you were just happy-go-lucky all the time and it didn't bother you. This is completely normal. But here's a challenge, something I want you to practice and this is for if you have teens as well. In those moments when you're just overwhelmed and there's all that chaos and noise, turn on some music in the background. Music has an amazing way of kind of modulating moods and emotions in the environment. And then sit down. Just sit. Start reading a book. Color. Lay out a

jigsaw puzzle. Start playing with Play-Doh. Begin creating something or building something. The closer to the floor you are, the better. Learn how to modulate your child's behavior without using words because our words just add fuel and confusion and chaos. Really practice this. I learned this because we had 1,500 kids in our home over the course of a decade. It's usually 10, 12, 15 kids at a time. They were all loud. They all did all this stuff and I either could learn how to do this or I would murder children And I didn't think that was a good idea

So I learned how to become kind of that calm quiet but very engaged Adult they were drawn to see talking and conversing Requires a lot of energy from you Talking and conversing requires a lot of energy from you. Coloring is really therapeutic and relaxing. And I would add this, you can try this with teenagers as well. Do you know how grounding it is to be a teenager filled with raging hormones and all the social media swirling around them and for them to just sit and color and be next to someone who's calm, who's in no drama. Try that this week. It's a really

cool thing that will help you stop lecturing and help help change the entire environment. So guess who's been stealing my AG1? Mrs. Calm. She's trying to make that transition from so much caffeine or smoothies in the morning to starting her day with AG1. And she said, I feel good knowing I'm starting my day putting really healthy ingredients in my body. It's a quick, easy habit. There's no cleanup. There's no cleaning blenders. And that's huge to her. I've noticed an uptick in energy and mood and that's why I've been enjoying and partnering with AG1 for so long. Look, Valentine's Day is coming up. Why don't you and your spouse create a healthy

habit together? It's more likely to stick that way and it's great modeling for your kids. AG1 is offering new subscribers a free $76 gift when you sign up. You'll get a welcome kit, a bottle of D3 and K2, and five AG1 travel packs in your first box. So make sure to check out drinkag1.com slash com to get this offer. That's drinkag1.com slash com to start your new year on a healthier note.

Are you crushing your bills? Defeating your monthly payments. New Year on a Healthier Note. your credit card bill in full and on time every month. Level up from bill payer to reward slayer. Terms and conditions apply. So the most common comment on that Instagram post was, well I keep lecturing because I hope that if I keep talking and lecturing I'll eventually get through and they'll kind of get it. Right one comment was I think this was my friend Jess from New England was because we think if we keep going we might help them reach an aha moment with their behavior. Look your kids are never gonna say mom dad I hadn't really thought of that before but after you lectured me for the 18th time the light bulb finally went off and I

realized how much wisdom you have. Yeah that's not happening. Jess you'd be better off just going to Dairy Queen and getting a blizzard. Way better use of your time than lecturing. So now right like now that you reminded me of that for the 18th time I'm gonna get some insight. It doesn't work that way. They have to learn by touching the hot stove and learning it themselves. Another comment. Well I want to make sure they get it. Well that guarantees that they don't and they won't get it. Well strong willed, mom said a strong willed parent raising a strong willed child. I think if I keep lecturing one of these days my son will get that light bulb

moment, there it is again, with whatever the lecture is about it's always from a place of love, but man it doesn't sound very loving Really good insight there mom right it is from a place of love you want so badly to help your kids But it doesn't sound loving because you know what it sounds like it sounds like this sounds You're not really capable of being successful So I just keep have to telling you have to tell you again and again and again and you're really not capable see Inadvertently, that's the message that we ends end up saying so a person said for me It's because I feel like my message is not getting through so I'm trying to explain and re-explain Into what for them is a lecture for for me it's just trying to get

them to understand. But talking about endlessly won't work. Discipline means to teach. So think about this instead. Instead of a lot of words and lectures, how can we show and teach kids a different way to handle situations? You know we talk about giving kids tools to succeed. So I give them a challenge. I create a success and then I give a lot of energy to, oh that was really good choice. Love how you handle that. Remember the rewind and replay example for younger kids. Your little kid walks into the room, steals something from his brother and instead of that long lecture, you know, I don't know how

many times I have to tell you it's not nice to take things from another person in our home, we share, we don't do that. See, all those long lectures mean nothing. But instead you could say, hey, that's not working. But here's what we're going to do. Rewind replay and rewind is kids have to walk backwards out of the room because that's kind of fun for little kid and then they walk back in the room and you can show them physically show them how to handle it and how to ask their brother for that

toy or handle it in a different situation how to talk to you in a different way and I encourage you as parents do rewind and replay when you're lecturing too much just say up you know, you know what? That's all about me. That's my own anxiety. I'm going to rewind and replay. And so you walk out of, you walk back out of the kitchen where you were just lecturing and you walk back in and you notice something positive that they're doing. You, you, you affirm them for something. See, that's modeling. That's really cool. Role-playing is real. That's part of role- See, that's modeling, that's really cool. Role playing, that's part of role playing.

It's really, really effective when you do those things. So you know, you can add an apology to that because I just thought about this. There was a time, I remember Casey came down the stairs and he was younger and I was immediately on him. Like, hey, did you get your schoolwork done? Why'd you wait till the last moment? And then I realized that was all about the fact

that I was behind on my own work. So I stopped and I said, Case, I apologize. That wasn't about you. That was about me. And see, I'm modeling for him how to handle my own behavior. Practicing this sometime, I love that. Child comes to you and says something. And instead of responding with the immediate,

oh, let me give you lecture 43B on how to make good friends. Instead you say, hey, I appreciate you sharing that with me. Hey, right, and inside I'm saying, right now I want more than anything to launch into my three favorite lectures so I can help you avoid making bad decisions. But instead I'm going to go work on something in the garage, the basement, the kitchen.

So instead you say, hey, I appreciate you sharing that with me. I've got some ideas about that if you want to come grab me later. See and then you walk away and I'm demonstrated, I hear you, I do have something to say, but I'm going to give you power over when and if I share that. It's in your court now as the child instead of me dumping all my fear and anxiety on you. That is very, very powerful.

But just don't be offended if they come in later, okay, what are your stupid ideas? Because that's what it may sound like. And you can drop wisdom on them. One of my favorite phrases you've heard me say is like, hey, you know, I've discovered something in life. It's that when I do X or when people do X, it tends to work out a lot better. And then I tend to walk away or change the subject and I give them space to process that themselves rather than dumping it into a long lecture with

all this pressure. So dig into this a little bit. Why does their behavior make you feel like you have failed or you are doing something wrong? Why does their behavior trigger you so much? Why do you have to fix their behavior or how they do things? And I just saw this comment on Instagram about an 11 year old boy getting out of the shower Leaves his wet towel and clothes on the floor. And I mean, what do you expect? This is what kids do They aren't grown adults. And yes I know the wet towel makes his comforter wet and it will be uncomfortable later and that bothers you so much. And this is hard because you're thinking inside,

this isn't so difficult, just hang up your towel. It's not hard, son. But for some of you, it's that when your child goes to take a shower the next day, the towel is still going to be wet and that icks you out because who wants to dry off with a cold, wet towel? And so you see it's easily fixable and you mention it, but it's just wasted words.

Well, won't he grow up to be a slob? In my experience, no. Unless your home is a wreck and you're a hoarder, but at some point your child's gonna live on his own and either make it orderly or someone will make fun of him or a girlfriend We'll call him a slob and at 23, he'll become a neat freak, right? But but if he doesn't who cares it's not like any of your lectures really help and I've mentioned before our son was Was horribly messy as a kid and he's completely

Organized now as an adult. That's just your own anxiety completely organized now as an adult. That's just your own anxiety. Look, I'd rather you not lecture a nag and instead when your child is at school just go in and pick up the towel, tidy up for five minutes. Everybody will be happy. No one will have gotten lectured. Well, aren't I enabling him by picking up everything for him? No, not unless you do that in every area of his life, but just going in quietly and happily to make yourself feel better and do this is a form of modeling and it just works better. So chill a little bit.

Another comment, hey, I do it because nothing's working. It's hard because we don't believe they're listening when a negative pattern continues and I completely get that. And that's why I'd rather isolate the behavior and think what specific tools can we give our child to make different choices in this particular situation? And maybe you break it down into smaller parts and create a success or get a small win. Look, if you're asking your kids do three chores

and they don't do any, start with one. Make it a challenge, make it a fun, and then affirm them for that. But let's move on, and then you can move on to another pattern, but keep modeling. A mom had said this, I just asked my 13 year old daughter this question because I was curious what her response would be and I said how does it feel when we're lecturing you and she said it feels terrible and it doesn't help and mom asked well why do you feel like it

doesn't help? Listen to the response from the daughter because you're talking and talking and it doesn't fix anything and it just makes me feel Worse, you're just telling me things instead of helping That's really good insight and we talk about that all the time It would be better to not say anything at times even to say, you know I don't know what to do right now, and give it time and space. But too much talking when kids are upset makes them even more upset. They need action steps, not more words. When your kids are doing something wrong when they're upset, don't be moved by it.

Don't be surprised that kids are acting like kids. Instead, you come alongside and acknowledge and then give an action plan. Yeah that stinks for sure. Hey here's something to think about. Hey I found it often works best when I do this and then you walk away and give them space to process it. The only real time you should be talking a lot is if your kids ask you questions but even then I start out short and sweet. Or when you're in a, look, if you're in a genuinely good two-way discussion

that isn't driven by your anxiety or your agenda, by all means, talk, talk, talk. But another way to tell if you're lecturing or teaching is if you feel like you have an agenda or outcome you are emotionally invested in. I really really want my child to hear me so they do X or Y. See that's kind of a red flag that it's going to backfire and that's when I try to back off and then invite them and I give action steps. So let's let's end there. I hope I fit a lot of things in

for you to begin thinking about this week, begin practicing, and then in the next episode I'm going to go through, well, what happens when my teen isn't saying anything and I need to break the silence? What about feeling like I'm being permissive if I don't say something? Some parents have said it's how I process

or let off steam. I was never given a voice as a child. So we'll go through that. But this week, next few days, let's practice this. Give yourself permission to not say anything or fix things. Work on your own anxiety. Practice sitting and leading kids to a calm place. Do the coloring thing.

Try that thing this week of like, hey I've heard you, I've got some thoughts on that, why don't you come grab me later and I'll be glad to share with you. Try that this week and just watch how it works. Moms and dads, if we can help you, let us know. I thank you for working so hard at this, thank you for breaking those generational patterns and love you all. We'll talk to you next time. Bye bye.