Canadian True Crime - 66 The Murder of Sina Parsi

Episode Date: May 1, 2020

TORONTO, ONTARIO - In 2015, successful construction entrepreneur Sina Parsi left for a soccer game, but didn't return home. An unexpected story would unravel.Thanks for supporting my sponsors!See the special offer codes hereFind out what perks you can get as a patron:www.patreon.com/CanadianTrueCrimeCredits:Research and writing: Stephanie Moore and Kristi LeeNarration, music arrangement: Kristi LeeAudio editing: We Talk of DreamsAll credits and information sources can be found on the page for this episode at www.canadiantruecrime.ca/episodes. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Hi everyone, I hope you're doing well. Well, as well as can be expected right now. It's crazy time, so I hope you're going easy on yourself and practicing a bit of self-care. Remember, you're no good to anyone else unless you take care of yourself. So, I'm coming to you with my tail between my legs. Right after I promised that I would never make you wait

for two weeks between multi-part episodes again, it turns out that the next case is also a multi-parter. I can definitely do one of these a month, but I can't do two of them right now while my kids are at home because it might put my marriage in jeopardy. So, today's episode is a Patreon episode. It's a fairly straightforward story,

so that's why it's a shorter episode, but it's every bit as heart-wrenching as all of the other cases. And this allows me to buy myself some much-needed time to plan a bit better, which I've never had. And then, on May the 15th, we'll be part one of the next two-parter, which again, will only be a week apart.

So, for two months in a row, you will have three episodes of Canadian True Crime. Now, if you're a patron and have listened to today's episode already, I apologize, but head to Patreon to find out what's next for you. And I'm sorry for being annoying. I do have the best intentions

and I'm always trying to improve, but at the end of the day, I'm still an indie podcaster and I really underestimated how much this whole virus thing would cramp my style. So, as always, thanks for your patience and your understanding. And on that note, it's on with the show. This podcast contains course language, adult themes,

and content of a violent and disturbing nature. Listener discretion is advised. MUSIC It was June 9th, 2015, in a village called Kleinberg, about 45 minutes' drive northwest of Toronto. Roya and Sina Parsi, a married couple in their early 30s,

each had plans for the night. Roya was planning on an overnight visit with her family and her husband, Sina, was headed out to a game with some friends. He was an avid soccer player and fan. In fact, they were both soccer fans and enjoyed watching games together. By all accounts, they were a happy, loving couple

who'd been married for five years and had plans to start a family. But now, they were enjoying some independence. Roya said goodbye to Sina. Although her husband would be home later, she was staying the night with her family, so they knew they wouldn't be seeing each other again until the next day.

As Roya left the house, Sina told her that she looked beautiful and complimented her on the smell of her new perfume. The next day, Roya couldn't get hold of Sina. She had returned home, but he wasn't there. She was worried, and so, too, were the employees of the successful roofing construction firm that he owned.

When Roya found out that Sina hadn't turned up for work either, she knew that something must have been terribly wrong because everyone who knew Sina knew it was out of character for him not to be where he said he was going to be. She found out that Sina had been at the soccer game and had left as usual, but no one saw him after that. When Roya got hold of Sina's family to tell them that she hadn't heard anything,

they immediately suspected her of being involved in his disappearance. Roya was taken aback by the allegations and immediately called the police to report her husband missing. She explained that Sina worked hard at the success of his firm and that this just wasn't something he would ever do.

She feared that some type of great harm had come his way. This is Christy, and you're listening to Canadian True Crime, Episode 66. The police took the situation very seriously and started chasing leads to see if they could find the missing entrepreneur. They traced his cell phone signal

and the next day it led them to the parking lot of a strip mall in the city of Toronto, about 25 minutes drive south of where Sina was last seen. There, close to the Tim Hortons, they found his black Dodge Ram pickup truck. With this discovery, they had to strengthen their efforts in the investigation. The homicide unit took over even though at that time

they still considered it a missing person's investigation. The unit began tracking 32-year-old Sina's whereabouts, first by looking at security surveillance footage taken from Tim Hortons. He parked his car and then footage showed him walking through the parking lot past his truck and down the road towards a wooded area. This was at about 11, 20 p.m.

Next, someone found Sina's wallet in that wooded area, which is known as Smith Park, and turned it in. Bank records showed that $400 had been withdrawn from his account. On the Friday, three days after Sina was last seen, police released details to the public, asking anyone with information to call York Regional Police or Crime Stoppers.

Sina was described as Middle Eastern, five foot six inches tall with a tanned complexion, a slim build and short black hair. When he was last seen at soccer, he was wearing a blue polo shirt and black jogging pants, but police said he may have had a change of clothes with him. Investigators went on to say that they believed Sina didn't have his cell phone on him.

He hadn't made contact with friends or family since he was last seen. Sina's wife, Roya, spoke to the media at the scene on Friday. This is a very, this is a very weird situation that he would come 1130 right after soccer game to this area and walk in this area because the camera shows that he parked the car in the truck

and he walked south towards the park. And that was the last scene from the camera. She said she was trying her best to stay positive and hopeful. Quote, he's my husband, my best friend, he's everything to me, I just want him healthy and alive. I'm not going to think of anything else, I just want him healthy. Meanwhile, police had been gathering CCTV footage

from the area to track Sina's movements after he looked to be going into the wooded area. They soon spotted him near the park where he met up with two people. In the footage, you could see they began walking together and he was then seen willingly entering an apartment building with them. It didn't take long before police found out the identities

of the two people that Sina was seen with. They were a couple called Sabrina and Clyde and had been living in an apartment together on the eighth floor of the building for about two years. First priority for investigators was to get into that apartment. No one was home, so they had to force entry and what they found inside the apartment

both shocked and alarmed them. It was the body of Sina Parsi. After devastating Sina's wife and family with the news that his body had been found, the police needed to move fast to locate Clyde and Sabrina. They also had to find out how the couple knew Sina, why he was there in the first place

and of course what had happened to him. They announced to the public that Sina's body had been found and that arrest warrants for first degree murder had been issued for two people who were on the run. Clyde Marshall was described as 36 years old, six feet tall, 145 pounds with brown hair, blue eyes and a tattoo on the right side of his neck and arm. His companion, Sabrina Schuart,

was described as 27 years old, five foot seven, 130 pounds with brown hair. Clyde was originally from New Brunswick and Sabrina from Quebec. Police said they were believed to be traveling together and might also have a large breed dog with them adding that there was more information to come. They urged the public to contact police immediately

if anyone saw them or knew where they were. Social media posts from law enforcement agencies started using the hashtag Sabrina and Clyde and media soon followed suit. Public interest in the case was high. The next day, the police staged a press conference. This is Detective Sean Mahoney from the Toronto Police Service.

Good afternoon. We're here to update you on the investigation into the death of Mr. Asinah Parsey. We are releasing video surveillance, a footage on this video surveillance is captured the two offenders that are depicted as they walk the hallway in that building. These two are the wanted parties,

Sabrina Schuart and Clyde Marshall. We have come to learn that Mr. Marshall is also uses the name Marcus, Marcus Marshall. We've had numerous tips and sightings of these two individuals. However, we have not verified at this time any of those sightings. We are asking for people to pay attention

to the clothing of these two offenders as this is the clothing we believe they are wearing at this time. The footage shown of the hallway was taken on the Wednesday morning at 4.10 a.m. Remember, Asinah had last been seen walking into the wooded area at 11.20 the night before, just five hours beforehand.

Police confirmed that Asinah was inside the apartment when Clyde Marshall and Sabrina Schuart left and walked down to the elevators, although they wouldn't confirm whether he was dead or alive at the time. In the footage, Sabrina was seen walking down the hall towards the elevator, wearing baggy black pants, white sneakers with red laces,

and a bulky blue anorak-type jacket with a hood. Clyde was first seen walking behind her, wearing a black hoodie and baggy jeans, and they had a brown bull mastiff dog with them on a leash. They both had backpacks on their backs. In the footage, you can see Sabrina go back into the apartment quickly, seemingly to get something she'd forgotten

while Clyde reaches down to tie his shoelace. Sabrina gets what she'd forgotten and then walks back down the hall towards him. The camera shows clear, high-resolution, close-up shots of their faces. Detective Mahoney went on to say he believed Asinah entered Clyde and Sabrina's apartment at around midnight,

but refused to discuss his cause of death, implying that it was whole-back evidence, which is, of course, information or detail which is unique to the investigation and would only be known to the killer or killers. Detective Mahoney also refused to comment on how Asinah and the fugitive couple even knew each other.

He went on to say, These individuals aren't terribly sophisticated and added that they likely wouldn't leave the country. He did mention they'd been unverified sightings of them further north in Ontario and then in Winnipeg, Manitoba. And because they had the large brown dog, they would be easier to spot, he said, although this would mean that they couldn't travel

by bus or train, so would likely need to hitchhike. He also added that Clyde had an extensive criminal record with a long history of violence and both were to be considered armed and dangerous. The police warned the public not to approach them. Behind the scenes, the fact that the couple didn't attempt to hide or dispose of Asinah's body gave police a new concern.

This is often common with suspects that go on a crime spree and the fear was that this murder was the beginning of a spree killing. The dog being with them was a positive as it made them more identifiable. But it was soon discovered that they'd already abandoned their dog in Toronto within blocks of leaving their apartment.

Several days earlier, the dog had been taken to animal services in West Toronto after a passerby saw it tied to a post outside a shop along with a bag of dog food. It didn't take the police long to match the dog with the one that Sabrina and Clyde had been seen with. And without their dog, the couple could move more freely. In the meantime, Sabrina's father, Marciel Schuart,

spoke to the media from his home in Quebec. Tearfully, he described his daughter as sweet and caring and of good moral character. He added that this was before she met Clyde Marshall. He stated that he found it hard to believe that she would be involved in the violent death of another person. And the only bad thing he could say about her

was that she had bad choices in boyfriends. Marciel said he and Sabrina were very close when she was a kid. But the last few years, they'd had a tense relationship. He added that Sabrina had completely changed. According to Marciel, Sabrina met Clyde when she worked at a Tim Horton's restaurant in Ottawa that was near a homeless shelter.

He described Clyde as street smart. Clyde was controlling and abusive towards Sabrina and he tried to keep her away from her family. Marciel said that he hadn't spoken to his daughter for about four months because Clyde controlled all aspects of Sabrina's life, including how and when she interacted with her family. The last time he spoke to her

was when she had sneaked out of the apartment to call her father from a payphone and wish him a happy birthday. Marciel Schuert went on to say that Sabrina would often have to call him on borrowed cell phones, so Clyde didn't see his number show up on their phone bill. I'd just like to tell her that I love her

and I always will love her and then I'd like her to give herself a hand and face the consequences of what she did. I think it's the normal thing you do. She cannot run forever. So Sabrina, please give yourself a hand. You can't hide as we hurt. You just can't do it.

You just can't hide, sweetheart. When asked how he felt about Sena Parsi's family, Marciel said, I feel very sorry for that family. I feel very, very sad for them. Nothing new came from the case for the next few days. The public speculated. Some people had the theory

that it may have been a drug transaction gone wrong because Clyde Marshall was known to sell drugs. However, Sena's family and friends insisted that he was not an illegal drug user. They said there had to be another motive for the crime. On Monday, June the 22nd, 13 days after Sena was last seen, the Toronto Police staged another news conference

to renew interest in the case. This is Detective Sergeant Michael Patterson. Since last week, we've learned quite a bit about Clyde and Sabrina. Clyde has a long history of violence when he's been in custody and out of custody. Clyde is not afraid of authority and has used violence against officers in the past.

He's known to carry a knife at all times and will use it if confronted. He should be considered armed and dangerous. We've had hundreds of tips come in and we're still following up on many of them. At this point, none of the tips have amounted to a confirmation of the whereabouts of Clyde and Sabrina.

We're asking the public, do not engage in the practice of picking up hitchhikers. It's already a dangerous enough practice, especially with these two on the loose. And this message is directly to Clyde and Sabrina if you're listening. There's only one way to end this properly and that is by turning yourself in.

Get yourself a lawyer, take their advice and come and talk to me. I'm willing to listen to your side. He went on to say that Clyde Marshall had a dark history and came from a family riddled with violence and abuse. Sabrina didn't have a criminal history, although police said they learned some pertinent information about her family background

that they weren't willing to share and they never did. It was confirmed that the police believed she was a willing participant in Cena's murder. The police released the footage which showed Cena, Clyde and Sabrina walking from the main road and into the apartment building at around midnight. Sabrina walked between the two men.

They looked friendly and it was clear that Cena was entering the apartment freely and without coercion. Detective Sergeant Patterson confirmed that when the couple left the apartment four hours later, Cena was dead. Police hoped that by showing what Cena was wearing and that he was with Sabrina and Clyde,

it might jog the memory of anyone who may have encountered them along the five to seven minute walk from the parking lot to their apartment. The public were again asked to come forward with any information they might have on how Cena and the couple might know each other. They knew from their investigation

that Cena went willingly with the couple but they were still unsure of the connection between the parties. Police also said that they were still investigating a motive and whether or not the murder was planned or spontaneous. They indicated that Clyde and Sabrina were involved in drug trafficking but couldn't say whether that was related

to the motive for Cena's murder. On Monday, June the 22nd, 2015, almost two weeks after Cena passing was last seen, there was a breakthrough. A shopper was at a Walmart at Niagara Falls, about two hours drive from Toronto and spotted Sabrina and Clyde shopping in the store. Niagara regional police were called

and the fugitive couple were arrested without incident and charged with first degree murder. Toronto police then drove down, picked them up and brought them back to Toronto. It was discovered that the day they were seen fleeing their apartment building, the day they ditched their dog, they hopped on a bus to Niagara Falls

and had been camping in a tent in a nearby park ever since. Do you have a passion project that you're ready to take to the next level? Square Space makes it easy for anyone to create an engaging web presence, grow a brand and sell anything from your products to the content you create and even your time. When I launched this passion project six years ago,

I needed some kind of online hub to manage all the non-podcasting tasks that come with podcasting. I chose Square Space because it's an all in one platform that seamlessly helps me achieve multiple goals. It's important to have a website that looks good and I was inspired by Square Space's wide selection of clean and modern templates.

They can be easily customized with pre-built layouts and flexible design tools to fit your needs. And you can even browse the category of your business to see examples of what others have done. I use the built-in blogging tools to create a new page for each episode and there are so many intuitive options from embedding an audio player

so listeners can stream episodes to scheduling posts to be published on a certain date, an easily moderated comment section and automatically displaying recent episodes on the homepage. Every Square Space website and online store includes SEO tools to help you maximize your visibility in search engines.

And I love the powerful insights I can get from the analytics tools, helping me better understand who's visiting the site, where they came from and how they're interacting with it. Do you have a passion project or business idea or something to sell? Go to squarespace.com slash ctc for a free trial and when you're ready to launch,

use offer code CTC to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. That's squarespace.com slash CTC with offer code CTC and get your passion project off the ground today. The next day, after Clyde and Sabrina were arraigned, Cena's wife, Roya, and her lawyer gave an interview outside a Toronto courthouse. Her lawyer, Jeff Pollock, began the interview

with Roya content to just stand beside him. He stated that she and Cena were a happily married couple for five years and hoped to start a family together someday, which made burying Cena just one day before father's day, especially difficult to bear. He went on to describe how Cena and Roya were living the Canadian dream, with everything to look forward to together,

when his life was tragically cut short. Roya then decided to speak. The utter devastation was written all over her face as she began by thanking the police and the public for helping to catch the people allegedly responsible for her husband's murder. Cena was a wonderful man. He was caring, he was love of my life,

he was my best friend. It was everything to me. He had a very great sense of humour, and I missed him so, so, so much. Behind the scenes, Roya Parsi had suffered greatly in the days that followed her husband's disappearance. Her in-laws at first believed she'd murdered Cena and disposed of his body,

and even when they discovered that there were other people involved, his family believed that they were hired by Roya to kill her husband. The next day, Sabrina's father, Marciale Schuert, called in to the Toronto Sun with his thoughts after his daughter and her boyfriend had been caught. Quote, it's a numb feeling.

You watch things unroll, you feel numb, it's not my daughter, it can't be her. It's just numbness, I guess. I was worried for her well-being. Besides that, I could imagine that it might be a bit of relief for the Parsi family. He had travelled to Toronto to pick up the couple's dog that had been abandoned,

saying that he liked knowing that he had Sabrina's dog. It gave him a feeling of being close to her. He didn't know the dog's name, so he was calling it Sab until his daughter could tell him the dog's real name. He stated his reasons for adopting the dog. Quote, to make Sabrina feel a little better that her dog wasn't abandoned, that somebody from the family has him.

I suppose that would make her happy, not that it's going to change anything in her life right now. In April of 2016, nearly a year after Clyde Marshall and Sabrina Shuart had first been arrested, the police announced that they had laid additional charges on the pair, possession of an access to child sexual abuse images, or child pornography. The images were discovered when the police had reviewed

the couple's electronic devices and computer hard drives as part of the investigation. As we know, often the details of the police investigation, including motive and what actually happened, don't come out until the trial. So still, the public and no doubt Roya Parsi and Sena's family still didn't know exactly what was going on.

In September of 2017, over two years after Sena Parsi's murder, Sabrina Shuart and Clyde Marshall both pleaded guilty to murder, Clyde to first degree murder, and Sabrina to second degree. In an agreed upon statement of facts, the Crown lawyer, Sean Horgan, shared the long-awaited details of the night that took Sena Parsi's life. It appeared from the evidence that Sena had placed an ad on Craigslist, looking for a couple to help fulfill a fantasy of his,

to engage in a threesome, which was to include light elements of bondage with himself in the submissive role. The Crown explained there was no indication that he'd done this before, and unfortunately, he encountered the wrong people with deadly and tragic consequences. Sena had little in common with the couple

other than a mutual desire to engage in consensual sex with strangers. Unbeknownst to his wife, Sena had made secret arrangements to meet up with Sabrina and Clyde in the parking lot of the Tim Hortons near their apartment. They instructed him to leave his pickup truck in the parking lot, and he followed their instructions from there. The Crown shared that while Sena thought he would get a night filled with pleasure, he instead got a night of being robbed, tortured, bound, and extorted.

The Crown started with the story at the beginning of the night when Sena was out with friends after a soccer game. He abruptly left after getting a message from the couple in response to his personal ad on Craigslist. From the video that was released, the public already knew he met the couple at the Tim Hortons, the first time they'd ever met, and the three of them walked together back to their apartment.

Text messages revealed that the agreement was for a threesome, with all parties consenting and with Sena agreeing to have his wrists bound to the bed. After the consensual portion of the sexual activities were over, Clyde unexpectedly attacked Sena. The Crown lawyer stated, quote, The Crown went on to discuss Sena's injuries. The rope was tied extremely tight, restricting blood flow to his extremities. Sena was also viciously beaten in the face, head, chest, and abdomen.

Some of his injuries included a broken nasal bone, a broken neck bone, and bleeding on the brain. The Crown also stated that while it was Clyde Marshall who killed Sena, it was Sabrina Schuart who aided and abetted him in confining the man, knowing full well that Clyde's likely intention was to kill him all along. At some point they forced Sena to give up his pin number, and they withdrew $400 from his bank account before going on the run for 11 days. It's unknown if robbery was the motive all along.

During sentencing, Justice John McMunn explained that Sabrina Schuart was complicit in luring Sena Parsi to his death after promises of casual sex with her and her live-in boyfriend Clyde Marshall. The judge believed that the motive was to torture Sena and extort him out of his ATM card and pin code, which enabled them to withdraw the $400 from his account. Justice McMunn called it, quote, the brutal, sadistic killing of a defenceless, naked, and bound man.

The terror he must have felt in the hours before his death is unimaginable. He didn't die a quick and painless death. He went on to call Sabrina a willing accomplice who lured him to his death by the offer of sex. But ultimately it was Clyde Marshall who caused Sena Parsi's death by ligature strangulation and blunt force trauma to his face and body. Justice McMunn discussed the pain and repercussions they both caused to Sena's wife, Roya, stating,

her life has become a nightmare that won't end. Her husband's family has wrongly blamed her for his homicide and disowned her. She's completely without blame, and those who wish to blame her should take a look in the mirror. Clyde Marshall decided to give a statement and spoke directly to Roya Parsi at his hearing. He stated, an innocent man died a painful, brutal death

and his widow's life was destroyed. Your husband did not deserve what happened to him and part of my reason for pleading guilty was to avoid you further suffering for having to go through the trial. I wanted you to know why this happened, but I can't explain it to myself. I did a horribly terrible thing. For that, I'll go to prison. During a moving victim impact statement,

Sena Parsi's widow Roya stated in part, I was accused of murdering my own husband. People made up versions of the story. Sena's family abandoned me after his passing, blaming me for not being a good wife and not doing enough to save him. It was out of my control. I loved my husband dearly and do so today and every day from this day forward, but he was the unfortunate victim of a heinous act

at the merciless and vile hands of Clyde Marshall and Sabrina Schuart. No amount of apologies and explanations from the deranged and twisted minds of these two could ever ease the pain and suffering I'm going through. Sena was my best friend and my love and he will be in my heart forever until we meet again. I learned a lot of good things from him and even with his absence, he helped me transform my life to be a better and stronger woman. Roya Parsi stated that because of this horrific event, she lost her vision of a future family,

her share in a roofing business that her husband spent 10 years building from scratch, as well as her dream home in the countryside. She stated that she thinks of the night her husband died often and it upsets her greatly. She also told the court, My heart and soul would ache in unbearable pain when I would think about what happened to him that night when he was taken away from me. I won't be the same person again and the absence of Sena's love in my heart will be with me until I die. She also told the court that she thought about taking her own life many times

but a good friend talked her out of it. And with that concluded, Justice McMahon passed down sentencing. 38-year-old Clyde Marshall was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for 25 years. 30-year-old Sabrina Shewat was also sentenced to life but her parole ineligibility period was 13 years because she had pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of second-degree murder. In a statement to CBC Toronto, one of Clyde Marshall's lawyers, Alana Page,

said that he had the most tragic history she'd ever heard. She didn't expand on why or what that had to do with the murder of Sena Parsi. She did say that he recognized that he did a horrible thing and then pleaded guilty in part to make sure that Roya Parsi wouldn't have to suffer through a prolonged trial and neither would Clyde's own children. She had revealed that Clyde Marshall is a father although nothing more has been publicly revealed about this. Quote,

Sadly, even after all of the events came to light, Sena Parsi's family still blamed their son's wife Roya for his death. They believed that if she'd been a better wife and stayed home that night, he never would have been in the situation that brought about his death. Nothing further has been said in the media about Roya or the case since that date. Thanks for listening. This episode was researched and written by Stephanie Moore and I, or is that Stephanie Moore and me? And the audio production was by We Talk of Dreams who also wrote the theme song.

The host of the Beyond Bazaar True Crime podcast voiced the disclaimer. I'll see you soon with another Canadian true crime story. Thanks for watching.