Cognitive Dissonance - Episode 103: The Revisionaries

Episode Date: June 17, 2013

The Revisionaries: News:...

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Want to stream Cognitive Dissonance to your Android or iPhone? Buy the app. Go to DissonancePod.com and click on the link on the right-hand side of the page. Each purchase helps support the show. There once was a man named Cecil. His obsession with holes was unreasonable. He'd hang around stalls and hope for some balls, but the results would always be fecal.
Starting point is 00:00:29 Glory, glory, glory hole. Glory, glory, glory hole. Glory, glory, glory hole. Doubt even this. Glory hole. It's Ulrich from Canada again. Just thanking you guys for jumping to my defense in the debate with that pedantic guy about how many of the Ten Commandments constitute kissing God's ass. Good point about the honor thy father and mother. Some fathers and mothers
Starting point is 00:01:03 are spectacularly better or worse than others and there should be a little bit of moral relativism in that commandment. Anyway, great job. Thanks, guys. Hello, guys. It's David here from Oxford in the UK. Just listening to your 102 podcast where you say you don't know the difference between Australian and UK accents.
Starting point is 00:01:26 Well, here goes. Okay, mate. Throw another shrimp on the barbie. Okay, that's Australian. Okay, in English, this would be hello, dear fellow.
Starting point is 00:01:36 Would you mind throwing another shrimp on the barbecue? Thank you very much. There you go. Not difficult. Anyway, bloody Americans. Great show, guys.
Starting point is 00:01:42 Glory, ho, glory hole glory hole glory hey guys this is kevin from memphis love the show glory hole you guys should have a glory hole shirt by the way i would buy that i have uh not a thing that i prayed for when i was a kid but rather two amusing prayers that i did do as a kid that were completely in conflict with each other. One of them, the standard now I lay me down to sleep Christian bullshit. And the other was actually a prayer that I had ripped off of a cheap ass poster that my mom had bought me in my room, which was to a native American, uh, spirit of the wolf, uh, pagan gods and spirits and that kind of thing. I never realized the two were completely in conflict with each other.
Starting point is 00:02:31 Yeah, it was just a childhood lack of understanding. You know, what the fuck did I know? Yeah, that's it. See you guys. Bye. Be advised that this show is not for children, the faint of heart, or the easily offended. The explicit tag is there for a reason. In a world where credulity and bigotry collide, one podcast, one purpose, two men. Every week, Tom and Cecil blast anyone who gets in their way.
Starting point is 00:03:15 They bring critical thinking, skepticism, and irreverence to any topic that makes the news, makes it big, or makes them mad. It's skeptical, it's political, and there is no welcome mat. This is Cognitive Dissonance. So that was Lauren who introduced us this time, Tom, and I think that that was a very well-done movie trailer-like intro to the show. This time we are going to be reviewing a movie called The Revisionaries, which is available on Netflix Instant. So if you haven't watched it and you have Netflix Instant and you want to watch it,
Starting point is 00:03:55 pause the podcast, run over, spend an hour and 25 minutes to watch it, and then come back and you'll be clued in on what we're going to be talking about. But this movie itself is about the Texas school board and it talks about a lot of different things. It starts out really sort of following a few different members of the Texas school board, as well as following people involved in the people who are involved in sort of fighting what the Texas school board is about. And a lot of these people on the Texas school board, you find out as you watch the movie and what we'll get into more later on is they're very much have an agenda that is Christian right. That is conservative. That wants to push evolution into a, into a corner and basically say that evolution is questionable. And they also want
Starting point is 00:04:41 to push social studies things. And that was a big surprise when I was watching the movie. I had no idea that they were going to pull social studies into it until you get 45 minutes in the movie and then suddenly there's social studies. And the social studies stuff in some ways is more appalling than the evolutionary stuff that they get involved in. It's terrible. It's awful. But the movie itself progresses and shows sort of a portrait of the different people that are involved in this fight. and shows sort of a portrait of the different people that are involved in this fight. One of the women works for the Freedom Institute.
Starting point is 00:05:10 Another guy works for the Liberty Institute. Some woman works for Liberty University. Another guy, he's the chairman of the board. He's just a dentist. And so you get a chance to see and meet some of these people. And in some ways, it humanizes them. But in some ways, it really does show you the agenda that's underneath. And I think the only way to treat this movie
Starting point is 00:05:30 is to sort of talk about what happens as it happens. One of the first things that happens is they start talking about evolution in the movie. They talk about evolution and evolution in the textbooks. And the language that they want to introduce is strengthen and weaken. That was the argument. They want to talk about the weakening And the language that they want to introduce is strengthen and weaken. That was the argument. They want to talk about the weakening of the argument and the strengthening of the argument when it comes to evolution, because initially they had for, I guess, 20 years,
Starting point is 00:05:56 a questioning of evolution in their textbooks. Yeah. And, you know, it's so interesting to watch this movie and see how much the rhetoric and the language and how incredibly important that is when they're going over. So Texas is an important stepping stone in the school textbook industry. So I think it's important to note. So they are one of the largest at-once purchasers, meaning because of quirks in the way that Texas state laws are written, they buy all of their books all at once. Yeah. Every seven years. And because of that, um, in order for textbook publishers to, uh, gather that market share, They have to cater to that. And so Texas has this huge sway in what
Starting point is 00:06:49 books get published because everybody wants a piece of the Texas pie because the pie comes all at once. And it's big and it's a lot of people in Texas. Right. And whereas like, you know, other schools in other states, you know, District 202 might buy textbooks, you know, this year and District 204 might buy textbooks next year because they're all being bought at once every seven years in Texas. It means that Texas has just an absolutely inconsiderable amount of power. It's just it's ridiculous. And so they're what they're doing is they're guiding the language. It's just, it's ridiculous. And so what they're doing is they're guiding the language.
Starting point is 00:07:31 And this whole fight is about, you know, guiding the rhetoric that gets put into these books and making sure that, you know, like you're saying, like, well, we're going to have a conversation about, you know, we want to add this terminology, the strengths and weaknesses. And then later they change that to analyze and evaluate, I think. Yeah. You know, the merits and demerits of evolution as an argument. And time after time, Cecil, what struck me is these experts stand up like the experts, the opposing side. They stand up and they're and they're they're just baffled. They're like, there's no alternative, like there's no scientific alternative.
Starting point is 00:08:06 What is the alternative? If you're talking about the weakness of the argument, one woman's like, what if there aren't any weaknesses to the argument? And then somebody else is like, how are these kids equipped? I know. That's the best part. You know, to evaluate. And they're not equipped to evaluate. And we don't ask them to do that of the theory of, you know, relativity or, you know, gravity or, you know, wave theory. Like we don't ask them to do that for anything else.
Starting point is 00:08:31 We don't ask them to, we don't ask them to debate the English language, right? There's no, there's no debates like this about whether or not something is a prepositional phrase. Nobody does that. Nobody cares. I mean, people care, obviously, and you learn what those things are. And the same thing goes for whether or not you're going to use an adverb in that sentence or not. Or there's no debating when they diagram sentences. There's no debate. This is a fact. This is the noun. There's nothing else that you can do about it. And the reason why that they're pushing this, the reason why that they go after this, and you see it as the movie goes forward,
Starting point is 00:09:07 you get a chance to see the personalities of these people. The reason why is because they want to proselytize to kids. They have a captive audience to proselytize to. They have a captive audience to talk about, well, you know, science doesn't know everything, and dinosaurs and humans might have lived together, and maybe they lived on a big old ark. You never know.
Starting point is 00:09:25 You never know. At the end of the movie, I know I'm jumping ahead, but at the end of the movie, the dentist, chairman of the board, whatever, when he's doing the thing where he walks in the field, he's teaching obviously like a Sunday school and he goes in this field. He's like, all right, everybody, you know, there's some debate about, you know, whether or not all the animals, including the dinosaurs, could have fit on the ark. And he grabs four cones. And he's like, come outside.
Starting point is 00:09:48 And he puts the four cones out. He carefully paces out the size of the ark. Right. Carefully paces it out. Yeah. That's the scientific method of my shoe's about this big. Yeah, right. And my pace is about this long.
Starting point is 00:10:00 So this is a fucking cubit. Right. Well, Noah, it's possible to do if you know Noah's height and stride length. Right. And we know this because we found Noah's bones. Well, certainly, yeah. Right next to, he was hugging a T-Rex
Starting point is 00:10:16 when he died. They were spooning a T-Rex. Yeah, but he, anyway, he paces this thing out, and then he starts naming different. He says, name an animal, name an animal. And then at the very end, you know, because obviously the kids can't name every goddamn animal. Right. At the very end, he's like, yep, and they all fit on the ark.
Starting point is 00:10:37 Right. And then he's got that model boat where he shows this, like, cardboard model. And he's like, so it's a real ingenious system. You see, what they had was they had the bottom deck was for all the poop. And the middle deck is for all the animals. Is that ballast? And wouldn't you just throw the poop overboard? Why would you save the poop?
Starting point is 00:10:57 Why would there be a whole deck dedicated to poop? It's just... Oh, it's the poop deck. It's the poop deck. It's just... Oh, it's the poop deck. It's the poop deck. Can you imagine when they're building the lower deck and it's like, you know, you're one of Noah's sons and you're fucking sawing away at these timbers.
Starting point is 00:11:14 You've been sawing away at these fucking timbers in the desert, which where did the wood come from in the desert? So you're sawing away at all these timbers and you're like, this is so much work. We've been doing this for like 72 years, Dad. What is this one for? It's poop storage. Why are we storing the poop, Dad? Someday we're going to need to build an island.
Starting point is 00:11:34 Storing the poop? In this giant, giant ocean that God created. Fucking stinkiest voyage ever. Oh, my gosh. The Noah's Ark thing comes up in this movie several times. And the thing is that they're all trying to talk about creationism because most of the people that are for
Starting point is 00:11:51 the changing of the language, they're not, I don't even think that they're, I don't even attribute to them intelligent design. I think of, because I think that there's something to be said about intelligent design if somebody's like, look, you don't know how original life happens. And there's a fucking scientist in this is like, yeah, I don't make claims about the original life. Right. He's like,
Starting point is 00:12:12 I just don't make claims about that. He's like, because it's okay to say, I don't know. He's like, that's an okay statement to say. So even a scientist is like, I don't know. I don't make claims about the original life. Okay, cool. You know, but instead these people, like when, when somebody comes up and let's say they're intelligent, they believe in intelligent design, they're like, yeah, well that beginning spark was God. Okay, fine. You want to name it God. You want to name it whatever you want. Or, you know, they say, well, you know, when, when things started getting rapid and changing, that's when God, you know, shifted and touched his hand to it or whatever. That's fine. The people who actually work within the framework of science and put their God in there, I don't have any problem with those people normally.
Starting point is 00:12:50 I don't care. I don't think that it's scientific, and I don't think it should be treated as scientific, but I don't care that somebody, just a random person who looks at evolution and goes, yeah, you know, whatever, God started the whole process and he's a watchmaker or whatever, the deist sort of view. That doesn't bother me. It's not scientific, and I don't think it should be taught, but I also don't have a problem with somebody thinking it.
Starting point is 00:13:13 I do have a problem with somebody thinking that Noah's Ark actually exists. I know. This is indefensibly stupid. That is just a stupid idea. It's a stupid idea to think that there was just one man and one woman on this planet at one time and they banged a bunch and we're all here. They banged a bunch and then they fucking drowned
Starting point is 00:13:32 most of them. It's not even that they banged a bunch and we're all here. It's that they banged a bunch and then they drowned most of them. So that shit just makes me crazy when somebody's like, we need to teach intelligent design, but what they're really saying is we need to teach people that fucking T-Rex was getting fucking ridden into battle by cavemen. I would totally fucking joust on a T-Rex.
Starting point is 00:13:56 Oh, man, that'd be awesome, wouldn't it? That would be the greatest jousting challenge possible. On the way it gets hungry and just bites your joust in half. It turns around and eats you because it's a T-Rex. Right. You're like, I should have domesticated this first. Yeah. This was definitely a bad decision. Yeah, you know, like, I don't want to talk about that for a second because, you know, it's important to note that evolution doesn't speak to a biogenesis, right? Evolution doesn't
Starting point is 00:14:23 speak to the origin of life. It speaks to the development, the change of, you know, of life, common ancestry. That's what evolution speaks to. So, you know, it, you know, like, like you said, and like the, there's a, there was a Methodist minister who's a scientist, who's the one you're referring to in this documentary. And he's, he's very upfront. He's like, you don't need, it's okay to say I don't know that, I don't have that answer yet. That's not an inappropriate thing to say,
Starting point is 00:14:52 but that doesn't mean that you have to fill that in with that's a weakness of the evolution argument. Because evolution doesn't speak to fucking a biogenesis. So if it doesn't speak to it, it's like, well, I mean, it'd be like saying, you know, well, your theory of gravity doesn't explain orange juice. Well, it doesn't purport to. Yeah, but isn't that a weakness of the theory of gravity? No, because it's not a fucking unifying theory of everything.
Starting point is 00:15:19 It'd be the same thing if somebody. It makes me crazy. Well, it'd be the same thing if somebody was like, you know, the theory of gravity doesn't explain the origin of the universe. Yeah, cool. Yeah, cool. Yeah, okay. That's totally fine. That is true. And the guy's quote, I wrote it down because I thought it was so good.
Starting point is 00:15:31 He said, it's not a weakness to say, I don't know. It's not a weakness to say there's a gap in the evidence. And I think that that's something that people don't want to, we don't want to admit on our side, right? We don't want to admit. And on our side, when I say our side, I mean the science side. Right. Not just, you know, the side that I like. It's the side that's fucking, you know, has the facts with it. Sometimes people want to say, well, you know, there's no gaps in the evidence. Well, maybe there are, but that's not a weakness of the theory if there's a gap in an evidence. It doesn't matter.
Starting point is 00:16:06 The evidence, there's a preponderance of evidence. There's so much evidence that is pointing towards evolution, and there's no evidence whatsoever pointing the other way. There's none. And the thing is, is like even when they're doing the debates, these people are all saying, point me to one peer-reviewed journal that has, you know, point me one thing. And they can't do it. They can't do it. But they still want to insert it into these textbooks. They talk about, a lot of times in this, they talk about healthy debate.
Starting point is 00:16:33 There's many people that they talk to and the people that they're following around. The guy, the main guy who's a dentist, of course he's a fucking dentist, right? Like the guy is more annoying than the drill he's putting in your mouth. He's terrible. He's, I mean, you know, he's like nails on a chalkboard annoying. And he basically sits people down in his dentist chair and now he's got a captive audience to sing to him, to tell him stories about the Bible, to ask him about their religious views. I'm like, this is the most uncomfortable dentist. Not only do I have to get my fucking teeth drilled while I'm there, but I've got to listen to you, which is 10 times worse than what you're doing in my mouth right now. The whole time I'm watching it, I'm thinking the only way to sit through that is to request no Novocaine.
Starting point is 00:17:17 So the sound of your own screams would drown out his babbling incoherency. Exactly. Like you just tell him like, look, just put me in the back room with a pair of pliers. That's better than what you're going to do to me. And he's a terrible singer, too, as an aside. At one point, he turns to somebody because he sits down and he's singing like, I'm a man of cards of constant sorrow, like they're a hillbilly club meeting or something. He's at the Yeehaw meeting.
Starting point is 00:17:44 I know, right? He's at the Yeehaw meeting. I know, right? He sits... Bib overall convention. He has to take the straw out of his mouth to start singing like, Hang on, Maul. Hang on, Paul. It's their porch-sitting convention. Get me an armadillo.
Starting point is 00:18:03 Where's the peach cobbler? He sits down next to some other fucking yokel. He lassos some other person next to him. And he's like, this is why I like being a dentist. You know, captive audience. And he starts singing. And you're like, nobody would listen to you otherwise. Not only are you singing this fucking gospel music bullshit, you're bad at it.
Starting point is 00:18:27 You're aggressively tuneless. It's almost like he is angry with the very idea of holding a tune and so refuses to do it for even a nanosecond. Hey, Tom and Cecil. This is Tabiso. I'm actually from Bulawayo, as you said. The proper way to say it would be something that sounds pretty funny to you guys. Bulawayo. of people who take buses all over the place, especially going to other countries. And there's all kinds of stories, like what I heard when I was really young, about if you take a certain bus from Zimbabwe to Mozambique, never fall asleep on it. Otherwise, when you wake up, everyone on it will be goblins, and they basically eat you and sell your organs. I don't know why goblins need money, but that's neither here nor there. Anyway, that kind of story perfectly showcases one of the big problems in Africa,
Starting point is 00:19:33 which is a conflation between super religious views and sort of tribal mythology. And it's really hard getting past that for a lot of people, but hopefully you get past it in the future. Anyway, glory hole. Have a good time. Hey, guys. This is Jason from Houston. I wanted to mention the weirdest thing I've ever prayed for.
Starting point is 00:19:57 When I was a kid, I really hated bowel movements. I didn't like stopping what I was doing to go to the bathroom, so I would just hold it forever. And then invariably I would become constipated, and it was a very painful bowel movement. So I would pray for God, if I can get through this without laughing too much. I would pray for God to make my asshole the same shape as my poop, so that it would just fall out effortlessly and not be as painful.
Starting point is 00:20:37 It never quite happened. I just had to suffer through, and it's a big reason why I lost my faith. Anyway, glory all. I just pray over this equipment. We speak over the PowerPoint presentations, all of the video projectors, and we say, devil, we know what you love to do in meetings like this, and we say you will not, in Jesus' name, you will not prevent this message from going out. No microphone problems in Jesus' name.
Starting point is 00:21:08 You know, the idea of discourse works its way throughout this thing. But, you know, there's another thing that really, really ticks me off, and they show it four or five times. And they're praying before they fucking start the fucking deliberations. I know. before they fucking start fucking deliberations. I know. And you see them begin all of these city council or state board meetings, state board meetings, city council, state board meetings with a prayer.
Starting point is 00:21:34 And it's like you stack in the deck to start with. I know. Here we are. We're going to have, and they say this so many times, both sides always says the same thing. Like this is one of the most important things we do as a state board of education, right? Is we have these students in our classrooms. They are the captive audience. Like they're not getting their teeth drilled, but they are a fucking real captive audience.
Starting point is 00:21:54 And this is an incredibly important debate. And we really want to have this debate, but let's go ahead and start it with a prayer. You know, that's, that's like saying, you know, Hey, we're going gonna have this basketball tournament. It's a seven-game tournament, and they're all home games for me. Yep. So it's a totally level playing field, but every game is a home game for me, all
Starting point is 00:22:15 the time. But it's a level playing field. We killed all your starting players. Right! Yeah, no kidding. You get no fans to cheer for you. You guys all have to fucking hop on one leg. Yeah. You know, and the ball will automatically deflate when you touch it. It's a basketball tournament.
Starting point is 00:22:31 We're using NBA players. You're using Hobbits. Okay, go. Hey, those are rigors. As long as the Hobbits are jumping on a bat, I bet you they can dunk, though. Well, the problem is they have to take a break for elevensies in the middle of the game. Then they've got to cry their way through the fucking game. They ride an eagle to the basket?
Starting point is 00:22:52 But, you know, I think that, you know, not only is that prayer an example of this, but the deliberations that go on. And I think that the use of rhetoric shows you the dangers of putting politicians in charge of something like this. It feels to me, and I understand the dangers of putting educators in charge of something like this, because an educator can use the argument from authority and be like, well, I'm a history guy and this is how it should be. And then basically teach exactly what they think should be taught only through one person's view. So I understand the danger of putting an educator in that position. But clearly we have seen the danger of putting a politician in charge of this. And I would much more err on the side of the educator,
Starting point is 00:23:41 somebody who's spent a lot of time teaching something like this, instead of somebody who's, you know, Bob the dentist, or, you know, Sam the butcher bringing Alice the meat or whatever, you know what I mean? Like, right, like, there's a there's a feeling there that, you know, these people aren't qualified, but they are good politicians. And the rhetoric they bring to the table can work its way into the curriculum. And that is really the only thing that the side that is against science has, is rhetoric. Because they keep on talking about, oh, well, don't we want to have debate? Don't we want students to try to figure these things out on their own? And all these things sound like good ideas, right? We want to teach kids critical thinking skills is what
Starting point is 00:24:25 they'll say. Teach them critical, but you're not teaching them critical thinking skills. You're not teaching them to think critically because you're telling them that science is faulty. In a science classroom. Right. Right. Like how am I supposed to take anything seriously in a science classroom if every theorem and fact and demonstrable experimental result is open for fucking debate, what it is is a fundamental misunderstanding, mistrust, and disrespect for the processes of science as a technique for learning about your world. as a technique for learning about your world. If you open up for debate whether or not something is true in a science classroom, what you're saying is truth is determined by consensus and committee. And that's not how science works.
Starting point is 00:25:19 Like methodologically speaking, science is not determined by committee. Science is determined through experimentation, observation, and a careful analysis of results, right? Those are the bases of science. So when you introduce this like, well, we want them to be critical thinkers. We want them to evaluate and analyze the evidence. It's like, no, you don't. That's not at all what you want. What you want is for them to fucking take a vote on what they wish were true and then decide that that's how truth
Starting point is 00:25:50 is determined. See, the thing is, though, later on in the movie, that woman from the Liberty University stands up in front of everybody. And I disagree. They don't want truth by committee. She says specifically, she says, truth is not a thing. And I wrote that down because it sounded like something Tom would say. Truth is not a thing. Because she says that. Truth is not a thing. It is a person. It is Jesus Christ. That's what she says. So the thing is, is like, they don't even believe in truth as a concept to be voted on by the majority. They believe in truth as dictated by God down to us. That's it. That's the only thing she thinks is true.
Starting point is 00:26:32 So the very fact, and there's a point too, where the dentist is standing up in front of everybody and he's pointing at, you know, why we're not a secular nation. And he says like the constitution was founded on truth and a creator and we were bound, we were imbued by our creator, you know, with these inalienable rights. And he puts down there, secularists don't believe there's a truth.
Starting point is 00:26:54 He's like secularists and humanists don't believe there's a truth. So you can tell already that what they're saying is it's not about voting. It's about what's handed down by God. And I think that's the most insulting thing about it. Yeah, no, you're right, man. You're right.
Starting point is 00:27:11 And that same guy, I mean, I just want to point out too, like, one of the things that upset me about that is the experts that they called. Right. Right. You know, one of the other points of tremendous disrespect for for figuring out how things are true. Right. Is evidenced by who they call on their side. And there was a whole debate about this in the movie, you know, where they said, like, look, and I think it was a radio like a announcer who pointed out. He's like, look, in this process that we're going through, an expert is somebody any two people agree is an expert. That's ridiculous. That's not an expert. So they've got people standing up and giving testimony in this debate, in this very important debate about what goes in a science book. And, you know, who do they call for experts? Well, they can call anybody they fucking want. So they call the flashiest rhetoricians. That's who they really are. And as long as two people who already are, you know, arm and arm with one another will
Starting point is 00:28:14 agree that this person is an expert, they don't have to be a scientist. They can have a degree in the history of science, which is what one of them had. Like one of the key speakers that they kept bringing up had their degrees in the history of science, which might be very valuable, but it's not a scientist. It's not the same thing. It's like that Simpsons thing, like, ask this scientist. Your crazy friend's not ignorant.
Starting point is 00:28:40 Your crazy friend's just crazy. I totally agree. And one of the things I was thinking while I was watching this is I would love it if every time they hired a brand new school board, they had to take some sort of test. Yes. A test to at least show that you understand what the words that you are writing down mean. So define theory. Right. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:29:07 Define theory in a scientific context. Hypothesis. Yeah. Go. Tell me what you, you know, like these certain things, you know, just, I mean, it would just be a basic test about scientific knowledge, not about, and you don't even have to tell me about what you believe or any of that stuff. I just want to see if you know what fucking theory means because specifically they're using
Starting point is 00:29:28 the colloquial version throughout the entire movie i know i know and you know these you know i've i've said this a million times i strongly believe in minimum competency and prerequisites for public office educational prerequisites are a fucking necessity. They are an absolute necessity. And it's a damn shame that we don't have them because there are incredibly bright, well-qualified people who could be making these decisions. You know, Cecil, who should be making the decision about what goes in a science book are three people, writers, educators, and scientists. Those are the only people who should be able to weigh in on that subject. The same is true of the social studies book, right? It should
Starting point is 00:30:12 be writers, educators, and historians. Those are the people who decide what goes in the books. The writers because they have to write it, the educators because they have to teach it, and the scientists are historians because they're the subject matter expert. Right. Everybody else is necessarily only going to interject superfluous political fucking meandering into the process. And that's precisely what this shows that they do. And the problem isn't limited to Texas. The problem is that what Texas does, the rest of the country gets trickled down to them. I found that amazing. They said in the movie, they said that both Texas and California are the two biggest textbook buyers, and they're the ones that people pay the most attention to.
Starting point is 00:30:59 Right. And I kept wondering to myself, I'm like, and so do the Texas books go to the red states and the, the California books go to the blue states then? Like I, it just, you know, I wonder, you know, cause I can't imagine somebody in California wanting to use these Texas books. Yeah. I, you know, I don't know. I, that's a good question. I hadn't thought of that. Cause I remember, I remember thinking that and I've heard so much about this Texas school book thing. This Texas thing comes up, you know, comes up every fucking seven years, you up every fucking seven years when they debate this stuff. And I've read about this time and time again, and I know this is a problem.
Starting point is 00:31:34 It's curious to me. I wonder if the California—but, you know, California is an interesting state, too, because while it's a blue state, it's a very divided state because of its size and economic structure. But, you know, the other thing that struck me real hard watching this, and it's said several times by the guy who's the chair of the committee, is he says, somebody has to stand up to all these experts. He says this several times. He says it in several speeches. Somebody. And he's impassioned when he says it. The thing is that he believes this is true.
Starting point is 00:32:10 Somebody has to stand up to all these experts. And it's like, you know who stands up to the experts? Other experts. Right, other experts. That's how science works, right? That's the beauty of it. It self-corrects. So if an expert stands in front of you and says, you know, this is what a fucking pulsar is and they're fucking wrong, the person to correct them isn't a dentist.
Starting point is 00:32:32 Right. You know, it's another astrophysicist who's like, I have another idea about what a pulsar is. And let's look at your evidence and we'll look at my evidence and we'll see which one is born out there. We'll fucking robot fight the evidence. Right. And we which one is born out the fucking robot fight the evidence right and we'll see who wins robot fight the evidence it just makes me crazy that that that gathers applause when he says it like somebody has to stand up to these experts it's like it's it's such a spit in the face it's this anti-intellectualism culture how can you be part of the anti-intellectualism culture. How can you be part of the anti-intellectualism culture
Starting point is 00:33:05 and be one of the guys approving textbooks? I think the part of the movie that shocked me the most, because they get through the rhetoric portion of the science evolution debate, pretty, I think, you know, we can all agree that, you know, that they did okay in that aspect. They didn't do bad. They did okay. And I think the reason why is because they had the experts there to sort of talk and figure things out for them. And there was back and forth discussion with the experts during breaks. And people finally figured out that the language that they were trying to put in there was damaging.
Starting point is 00:33:45 And so that was cool. That was, you know, I thought that that turned out okay. But then, you know, the chalkboard that is the sort of scene entry, it's the title screen basically as a chalkboard. And they started, they wrote social studies down and I was a little shocked. What is this? And the social studies part is the most disheartening part. And the stuff that they were trying to take out, they're trying to take out.
Starting point is 00:34:11 The one thing is that the guy who is the head honcho in the beginning of the movie, he's the school board president or whatever, is demoted. He basically loses his chair position and he's put back down into the regular board and they have to bring somebody else up. And, you know, obviously they don't bring up anybody who's going to disagree with Rick Perry, right? They bring up a person who obviously Rick Perry likes, but they bring, they put him down. And I guess he even said that he had an opportunity then to introduce measures where he didn't as the chair. And the things he's introducing when they start – I mean, shocking.
Starting point is 00:34:51 One of the ones that I wrote down was he wanted to replace hip-hop with country music. He wanted to replace religious – he wanted to replace at one point racism and slavery. They wanted to take that out, strike that from the record. There's so many things that they start going through and they're like, strike that from the record, change this. I want to add these people. They're talking about adding Thomas Aquinas. I know. I was hoping you would bring that up. I was thinking about you when they were talking about enlightenment philosophers, and they get rid of Thomas Jefferson, and they throw in fucking 13th century religious philosopher
Starting point is 00:35:35 Thomas Aquinas, and they get called out on it. Right. They call her out on it, and they're like, wait a minute. Thomas Aquinas? That's from the fucking 1200s. The motherfucker died in like 1274 or something. Yeah. You know, like, really?
Starting point is 00:35:52 Yeah. And she just, I mean, bitch doesn't bat an eye. I mean, this is a guy who did the, I want to say it's the ontological proof of God or something like that. It's one of the proofs of God. Like, this is a guy who decided to prove God. It's a circular argument, and it makes no sense. And if you follow Aquinas, you'll find out that he's just full of shit.
Starting point is 00:36:12 But the idea is, is this is a guy whose life is steeped in religion. This isn't a guy who's thinking of starting a new country and breaking out of the kingly mold that we had. This guy wasn't an innovator in that sense at all. What is 500 years
Starting point is 00:36:28 pre-enlightenment? The whole section that they're discussing is enlightenment philosophers. The motherfucker is 500 years pre-enlightenment. You might as well just use Augustine at that point. What difference does it make? It doesn't make any difference.
Starting point is 00:36:44 And the justification that they haul out is like, well, it's very influential. And they're like, well, fucking Plato had a lot to say about the building of a republic. It was great. And it doesn't go anywhere. And like the country and Western music versus hip hop, I love to, they call it country and Western. So like, they're like, yeah, we got to get rid of hip hop and insert country and Western. And this one guy's like, wait a minute, do you even know what hip hop is?
Starting point is 00:37:07 Why? Why get rid of it? And they don't even bother to answer him. No. They don't even give the guy the courtesy of an answer. They just kind of smile like, it's fucking Texas. Right. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:37:18 What did you expect? Right. You know, because you were, you know, there's no reason for us to have any culture but white Anglo culture. Yeah. I mean, that's really it. I mean, that's what you're putting forth. You're saying, I mean, and, you know, the name of the movie is perfect. The revisionaries, right?
Starting point is 00:37:37 Like the idea here is that they're basically revising history. Totally. It's not that they're revising science because the science gets bounced back and forth. You can look at the thing, well, hey man, we're not going to change the science. Okay, fine. But this is, I mean, they're revising history saying, you know, I mean, to go into a classroom and then deny that, I mean, it's not denying, but just not mentioning slavery or not mentioning, you know, not mentioning the racism that happened, you know, throughout our history, segregation, not mentioning the racial tensions that were involved after segregation was lifted, not mentioning, you know, the idea that hip hop exists. Yeah, it's cutting, you know, it's cutting minorities out.
Starting point is 00:38:21 It's cutting out, you know, the struggle for civil rights. It's cutting minorities out. It's cutting out, you know, the struggle for civil rights. It's cutting out, you know, it's cutting out anything that doesn't fit into that comfortable Judeo-Christian white narrative of, you know, happy pilgrims on Thanksgiving Day. Anything that doesn't fit into that liar's narrative that tells a story of a country that never was. They wanted to add. Gets popped. They wanted to add Hussein to Barack's name. I know.
Starting point is 00:38:51 I know. That's it's just it's so obviously political. It's so obviously political. about ensuring that your political views are enshrined into the minds of young people through this, you know, indoctrinal process. And I mean, it is so cynical. It's so unbelievably cynical that you would just say, my politics are more important than honesty. And they all have this smug, I mean, really, like they all have this smug little smile of self-satisfaction with each win that they garner. Right. And you look at it and my heart just sinks.
Starting point is 00:39:34 Yeah. I'm full of fury. I just want to fight the whole room. It's like, line up. Just line up. I want to fight you. Hey, Cecil and Tom. This is Robbie from Chicago. First off, super
Starting point is 00:39:47 congratulations on your fifth episode. That is really fantastic. I'm really proud of you guys. It's a big milestone. I thought I would share with everyone and ask if anyone else has received this in the mail, because I received a rather curious piece of mail the other day in a white envelope addressed to me or current residents. So maybe it wasn't specifically sent to me. When I opened it, inside was a book with the title, Ten Amazing Muslims Touched by God, by, I'm going to butcher it, Faisal Malik, with a picture of a sort of chubby dude with glasses on the cover. Anyway, it came with a letter, and I thought I would read just a small snippet to you guys. I'm very curious if anyone else has received this in the mail. Dear Muslim friend, As-salamu alaykum.
Starting point is 00:40:36 You're probably wondering why you've received this book, Ten Amazing Muslims Touched by God. You may be asking who this man is on the cover. Who are these ten amazing Muslims, and what is so amazing about them? My name is Faisal Malik, I was born and raised about Sunni Muslims, and I was touched by God on July 3rd, 1994. I'll let you guys handle that joke. Please accept that this book is a gift in token. My favorite part is when he says,
Starting point is 00:40:58 These stories are of 10 Muslims, mostly Sunni, some Shiite, and their faith in Allah, the Quran, and their amazing encounters with the God of Abraham. The men and women in these pages come from a wide demographic of Muslims, from zealous jihadists to peace-seeking leaders, from humble Bedouins to dedicated scholars of the Quran and the Hadith. Some are simply ordinary Muslims in search of answers from God, all committed followers of Allah, blah, blah, blah. I thought it was rather interesting to start off with, from zealous jihadists, as if that was the selling point that was going to get me to continue on. Anyway, I'm really curious to see if anyone else has received this in the mail. I have no idea what that mailing list is and how it came to my door.
Starting point is 00:41:37 Again, it's 10 Amazing Muslims Touched by God. If anyone else has received this, I'd be really interested to know. All right, take care, guys, and glory whole. else has received this i'd be really interested to know uh all right take care guys and uh glory father and i ask that you would forgive us for taking prayer out of the schools father when that happened secular humanism flooded in father it began to penetrate every part of the curriculum. But today, Lord, we reach up into heaven and we say, on this day, your kingdom come, your will be done in public education once again. We draw the line in the sand today.
Starting point is 00:42:27 And we say no more. Lord, I ask that you would invade our schools, invade our country, invade our homes, invade our churches with your presence. That we would truly be hunger for righteousness and for truth. Because truth is not a thing. It is a person, and it is the person of Jesus Christ. And your word tells us that if you be lifted up, you will draw all men unto you. And so, God, that's what we do right now. We repent on behalf of our nation. We repent on behalf of ourselves and our families, God, and we lift you up, and we want to see you exalted, God. They hate secular humanists. I mean, they really cannot stand them.
Starting point is 00:43:12 And at one point, the woman is praying in front of the Washington Monument. She almost sounds like she's crying when she's praying. She's almost weeping. She's so sad that secular humanists are there. And one of the things she says is, secular humanists flooded in. They flooded
Starting point is 00:43:28 in. And I'm thinking, it's better than fucking water. God's good for fucking, you know, at least God sent people that can think instead of, you know, more water than he did early on when Noah saved what? Eight fucking people. Yeah, it's, I actually did laugh because it sounded
Starting point is 00:43:44 like she was crying. Like she was crying like she had that she had that i'm so earnest that i can't control my emotions voice that fucking put upon false voice that liars will often use when they're trying to you know garner emotional sympathy it that that shit makes me fucking wild when i hear that it just makes me hate somebody like anytime they get the quiver voice i'm'm just like, I kind of hate you for that. I just fucking hate it. You're a liar. You're lying to me. You're fucking building a soundtrack into your own
Starting point is 00:44:12 bullshit. And it's not just it's not just that they're using rhetoric. It's that they're using other means to influence people. They're trying to they're using the methods of theater to influence people. They're trying to, they're using the methods of theater to influence people.
Starting point is 00:44:28 Right. One of the things that I started laughing about is they called, and this is getting back to the secular humanists, they called colleges left-wing seminaries. I remember that. The guy said it out loud. And there's so many moments
Starting point is 00:44:45 where you look at this guy and he's on camera. I mean, he's being filmed. He knows he's being filmed and he shits these things out and you're like, dude, do you realize you said that out loud? Do you realize? You just said that out loud. Left wing seminaries?
Starting point is 00:45:01 Really? But you know, the thing is, like, these guys believe it. And that's something, too, that comes through in this documentary, I think, very clearly. Because one of the opponents is like, look, I respect the guy. He's talking about the chairman of the, you know, and then later becomes a board member for the State Board of Education that's choosing the books. And he's like, look, I respect the guy. I think he's wrong, but I respect him. He's always treated me kindly. He's always treated me with respect. It reminds me of George
Starting point is 00:45:27 Crabb, right? Yeah. George Crabb said, you know, I was making fun of, I think Kirk Cameron or Ray Comfort or somebody. And we had George on the show once. And George said something effective, like, this is a guy who'd help you change your tire on the side of the road. Like he's a nice guy. I'm sure this dentist is probably a fucking nice guy. I'm sure he would give you the shirt off his back. But he also wants to influence how and what history and science children are taught so that they can control the political future of the country. He's a nice guy, but he's a shithead. And he's being dishonest in order to, to garner political favor.
Starting point is 00:46:10 And it's, it's, you watch this and it, and like you say, it's like, you're, you, you aren't keeping that to yourself.
Starting point is 00:46:16 You're going to say that with your mouth. You're not going to say it in your heart. Right. In my heart. I believe it. No, you got to do a quiver voice. Yeah. In my heart, I believe it. No, you got to do a quiver voice. In my heart, I believe it.
Starting point is 00:46:28 Tom, you just convinced me. I did. I'm selling. The one thing I thought when I was watching this, because that bald dentist does go up for re-election. And when I was watching it, I thought for sure he was going to win again. I was watching
Starting point is 00:46:44 it and the other guy was saying stuff and I'm like, that guy's not going to get elected. You aren't garnering any support here at the tea party convention, basically being like, I want educators to decide. Like, I have no idea how he won. Like I was like, I was shocked. And obviously they're editing it, right? So they're editing it for me. This is a documentary with a message. It's not that they're telling you the unbiased truth here. They're presenting an argument to me, and I recognize that. So this guy could have said some cuckoo fucking for Cocoa Puff stuff, and they just edited it out because they wanted to make sure that the bald guy was more kooky than the guy who looked a little more straight-laced. Sure.
Starting point is 00:47:23 Who wound up winning his job. But I was shocked at the way it was presented. I was just like, oh my goodness, there's no way that this other guy is going to win. And the other guy wins, and the first thing I thought is, I wonder if the dentist prayed to win. Yeah. Well, you know, I don't know that he did, because there's a really funny part in it where he's getting made fun of on the radio.
Starting point is 00:47:46 Like there's radio. And he says something, and I'm going to paraphrase, but he says something like, well, I don't just go around telling everybody I'm up for election. That's not how you live your life. And I thought, that's actually exactly how you live your life if you're trying to be elected. I yelled at the TV at that point.
Starting point is 00:48:04 I'm like, what do you mean you don't go around telling everybody you're up for election? That's how elections work. You're like, ah, those debates. Those are for people who want to get elected. That's for talking about ideas with people. What the fuck?
Starting point is 00:48:20 It was a strange, it was a bizarre exchange. That dude is a weird, bizarre man. It would not surprise me at all if he didn't pray to win because he wouldn't want to tell God he was up for election.
Starting point is 00:48:36 You don't just tell everybody. How would God know if you didn't send him an invitation of some sort? You know, like a frilly invitation. Or just a Facebook invite would be fine. A Facebook invite. It's all good. Just text him.
Starting point is 00:48:50 Hey, God's in the 21st century. It's fine. The Liberty University parts of this are also crazy. And when you see the Liberty University portion of this, and, you know, Liberty University is a place that Liberty has no place in. It's one of those crazy, it's like a Christian school, but it's like the crazy, it's the biggest evangelical school in the United States. And it's for the clinically insane. It's for people who are just absolutely nutso about Jesus. Welcome to Bedlam University.
Starting point is 00:49:29 Oh, man, it is just cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs. But those people are, you know, they're rabid Christians and they're ready to, you know, proselytize. And this lady's a law professor there and she's on the school board. That's a place that, you know, it almost deserves a visit. Like, I almost want to go to Liberty University just to see what it's like, just to walk around the campus there and just see. I mean, just want to pretend I'm Christian for a day and wander around there and just see what it's like. You know, I saw that, and I thought immediately, I mean, I did. I thought that is one of the scariest places in America.
Starting point is 00:50:06 Like it's a fucking it's a it's a madrasa. It is. It's total madrasa. I mean, it is Al Qaeda headquarters, basically. Drone strike Liberty University. But I mean, it really is. It's just a it's a place for people. It's an echo chamber for bad ideas and for, you know, this sort of revisionist history. Like these are people who really would believe a lot of these ideas, you know, that that are being put forth.
Starting point is 00:50:36 I mean, wholeheartedly, like this would be all that they were presented with. One of the things that's particularly a virtue of the university system is that even if you're a student who grows up in buttfuck Oklahoma and you've had this mediocre education and you've had this mediocre amount of exposure to culture and to the outside world, attending a university breaks you out of that mold. You're now going to be surrounded by people who have different thoughts, different opinions, different religions, different educational backgrounds. You know, that's one of the great advantages to one of the democratizing forces to a university educational system. All of that is stripped away and fucking shed on at Liberty University. It's a place for homogenous white people to sit around and be pasty white and jerk each other off. Like, that's all that it exists for. What I thought was really funny was how they wanted to strike hip hop from the books,
Starting point is 00:51:42 and yet the song for Liberty University was a hip hop song. I know. I know. It's so funny. That song is so bad. Hip hop in the loosest sense of the word here. I mean, this is not Jay-Z performing. This is definitively, it's J-Y.
Starting point is 00:51:58 It's K-Y. K-Y. You know, the saddest part of this movie is the end when they write on the board that this is going to be in effect. The things that passed just recently in the last couple of years are going to be in effect until 2020. I know. I immediately did the math and I thought, holy shit, like 2020, how old is my kid going to be? Yeah. My kid's going to be exposed to those textbooks.
Starting point is 00:52:26 Yeah. You know, and all that means is that, you know, parents who want to responsibly educate have to look at the textbooks, read the chapters their kids are being assigned to, and supplement that with good quality material. You know, because if, especially the social studies, I agree with you, the social studies was much more damning than the science debate. Much more damning. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:52:48 I mean, you get to paint with your own brush what the history of the United States is like. And, you know, just because, you know, not mentioning it and omitting it is just as bad as saying something else happened. Oh, yeah. You know, because if you don't teach the students about what happened after segregation was lifted in this country, and they don't get a chance to see the hardships that the black Americans went through when they had rights technically,
Starting point is 00:53:19 but in reality had no rights whatsoever still, and the dichotomy that existed in their own lives and how they had to survive and how they had to act. Sure. And how they had to fight to get every bit of right that they had. Yeah, lynchings and Jim Crow and all of that. When you take that out and you don't mention it, suddenly you're 18 years old and you don't really
Starting point is 00:53:45 experience it. And then when somebody on the internet starts talking about affirmative action, you're like, what the hell do they deserve affirmative action for? Right. Because you don't have any context. You don't have any kind. You're like, well, affirmative action. What's that?
Starting point is 00:53:55 Who cares about it? And you're like, well, wait a minute. You know, you don't understand that what they went through and what they still go through is bad. It's not a, it's, This is not a benefit to society. And affirmative action is neither here nor there. I don't want to get into a fucking debate about affirmative action. Don't send us your fucking emails because I'm not ready to debate it.
Starting point is 00:54:15 I'm just telling you that there's reasons why people are insensitive to plights of other people, and it's because they just are ignorant of it. Yeah, I know, man, you're totally right. And you can't even have the larger point is you can't have a reasonable conversation about a subject for which you don't own the context. You know, if you don't have context to to put that subject into place for, you know, how are you going to even have that debate? How are you going to have that conversation in a meaningful way? Instead, you're just going to be reacting.
Starting point is 00:54:51 You're just going to be, you know, going through these sort of knee-jerk reactionary stages and responding with, you know, call signs and buzzwords. I mean, it's building a talking point culture instead of a really critical thinking culture at all. I mean, history is so fucking vital to our ability to identify our narrative as a people and, and to know who we are and to put into context our struggles and our successes and failures. And then they want to wipe out all the failures, man. It's fucking rose-colored glasses. Hey, this is James from Arkansas. In response to your call for stories about stupid shit you prayed for,
Starting point is 00:55:35 I got something of a doozy. My best friend in high school, she is still my best friend to this day. But, you know, and when I was a junior, she came out to me. It was, it must have, you know, she, according to her, it took her months of working up the courage to tell me because I was, my plan at that time, my college plan was seminary. at that time. My college plan was seminary. So, it would have been awkward to begin
Starting point is 00:56:10 with, but then I, of course, thought she was kidding. And so I just really laughed at her, which must have been the absolute worst thing to possibly fucking do to somebody who was coming out to you. Anyway, I didn't believe it. I thought she was just kidding around
Starting point is 00:56:26 until I actually saw her walking around school with her girlfriend. Well, this... This, you know, I mean, I didn't end up treating her any different. This didn't change anything in our friendship. But the stupid shit that I prayed for was I prayed that she would
Starting point is 00:56:45 not be gay. Now, I've never told her this, and I'm very glad that she's still the just badass lesbian that she is today. But still, it's just, man, man, you can't do that. Oh, and by the way,
Starting point is 00:57:02 no, no, no, you guys still don't get it. Sierra Mist is to Sprite as Mellow Yellow is to Mountain Dew. You see, one of those pairs is clear. The other one is yellow. That's how you tell the difference. Anyway, glory hole and keep up the good work. glory hole and keep up the good work this doctor practiced in an open circle in a dusty spot he wore no shoes was semied, used a lot of bones that he threw around. I would bet that all of us would agree that his science is a sugro science.
Starting point is 00:58:00 We would not have respect for his science and the practice of his science that would concern me because if we were able to declare what i have verified for myself is something that has some validity to it i mean the stuff the man told me about my history. Yeah. Yet, if I closed my mind when I saw this man in the dust, throwing some bones on the ground, semi-clothed, if I had closed him off and just said, that's not science. I'm not going to see this doctor. I would have shut off a very good experience for myself and actually would not have discovered some things that he told me about what I needed to go and do when I got home.
Starting point is 00:59:00 So the movie itself is from, you know, they're talking about 2012 at a certain point in the movie as if it's in the future. So the movie's from a couple of years ago. It is. But it still is obviously relevant because, you know, things like this happen all over the country. is in Louisiana, recently there's been a big push down there to try to repeal Louisiana Science Education Act, LSEA, which is, and I'm going to read directly from the article, is stealth legislation that creates a loophole for creationism to be stuck, to be snuck in public school science classes. And it allows classroom use of supplemental creationist materials that critique evolution. So this is something that is at this point still happening in, you know, even though in Texas, it seemed like
Starting point is 00:59:58 there was some blowback there. The other states are still debating this. And I mean, you know, we're talking about Louisiana, Louisiana is still debating this. Oh, yeah. I mean, this is not this is not over by any stretch of the imagination. You know, in Louisiana, that same article, it just talks about Suzanne Passman, who runs creation evidence dot info. And she testifies in support of the LSEA, Louisiana Senate Education Committee on her website, she testifies. She's one of their experts. This is a person who thinks that dragons were real creatures, that people saw dinosaurs walking around.
Starting point is 01:00:36 You know, Bobby Jindal, the Louisiana governor, who should fucking know better, right? Because this is a guy who went to an Ivy League university. Brown University. Has a degree in biology. What? How do you do that? And still is basically pandering. I mean, that's all it is. It's gotta be.
Starting point is 01:00:53 He's pandering to his party by basically doing that old canard, you know, like, hey, we want everyone to have the best education possible. And if they decide... Yeah, he says like, you know, if they decide that that's creationism then that's creationism best science best facts best science the best facts not those mediocre facts the three videos that are on this are are pretty great the first video is where the
Starting point is 01:01:20 legislator is talking and he's this old guy dressed like Colonel Sanders. And he's talking. And one of the things he starts to say is he's like, well, if you were just to say that pseudoscience doesn't have any place in a science classroom, let me tell you, I went to a doctor that drew a circle in the ground and threw some bones on the ground.
Starting point is 01:01:43 And they told me some stuff about myself that I didn't know before that I hadn't, that I didn't even mention. And that real experience wouldn't be available to somebody else. And I'm thinking, you're right. Like that is a subjective moment of your life that you are trying to say, since something happened to me, that was a subjective moment of some charlatan tricking me into thinking they know more about me than they actually do, now you're going to mandate that in textbooks. Yeah, I know. You're going to be able to take that out and say, you know what? We're not going to say anything bad about some jackass who's going to roll some chicken bones in a fucking dirt circle.
Starting point is 01:02:26 Because that's how 2013 should work right yeah that's that's how 2013 should work you should you should definitely take the advice of the fucking half-clothed dirt-covered chicken bone thrower over i don't know like neil degrasse tyson right like if they have an option. They're like neck and neck. They're like, you know, I mean, when it comes to credibility, neck and neck. I remember, Cecil, when I was in school 83,000 years ago with dinosaurs, when I was in school, I had a professor who basically said something. He asked us to all raise our hands if we thought all opinions were equal. And a bunch of people raised their hands. I didn't because I was arrogant.
Starting point is 01:03:09 And I still am. And he said, if all opinions are equal, what are you paying me for? And this was in an English class. And I thought, like, goddamn right. Right. Because all things are not created. All ideas are not created equal. Some ideas are not created. All ideas are not created equal. Some ideas are better ideas. And the
Starting point is 01:03:26 ideas where you throw fucking chicken bones on the ground to figure out how the world works versus you know, a systematic series of tests and observation. Yeah, I'll take the science, thanks. Like the chicken bones,
Starting point is 01:03:42 that's really presented in 2013? I couldn't believe it. I was watching the video and I'm like, is this guy really hearing what the fuck he's saying? Like the chicken bones. This really presented in 2013. I couldn't believe it. I was watching the video and I'm like, is this guy really hearing what the fuck he's saying? I mean, for real. He's talking about goddamn bones. I know. I know.
Starting point is 01:03:59 He's talking about divination for crying out loud. I mean, you'd be scared to say this with all the Christians around him, right? You would think so'd be scared to say this with all the Christians around him, right? You would think so, but no. And then the other thing, we played this before on our show, but it's when this creationist senator winds up talking about people with little letters after her name. Right. And if you watch this video, this is an awesome video. Just watch it and watch her get so frustrated when the kid talks about how stuff should be taught in a how the Bible is fine to be taught in literature class because it's literature and she
Starting point is 01:04:30 has to wave her face from not passing out or I don't know pissing on the desk or whatever it is that she's stopping herself from doing she's waving her face and you're like are you fucking serious you know it's just it's not just
Starting point is 01:04:47 rhetoric like we talked earlier it's the it's the they're using tropes from theater too right and this is what's going to decide the education that that students get like this is this is what we have to look forward to this is why this is important like these are the people who are going to be making decisions when my diapers need to be changed. Yep. You know, this is what America is going to look like in 25 years, you know, and, and I look at this and it's like, really fucking chicken bone, dude. Yeah. And, and, and all the people out there that, you know, are on the, they're the, they're the Midland people. They're the people who maybe not, not believe in anything, but they're like, you know, all you loud mouth atheists, you guys are just as bad as all these other people.
Starting point is 01:05:27 And it's like, look, you know, the reason why we are vocal, I wouldn't even be – I wouldn't even care. I don't care what people believe. I seriously do not give a single ounce of fuck what people believe in any fucking – I mean, really in any context, I do not care one fucking bit what a random dude who walked past me on the street believes. It is fucking of no consequence to me. In fact, most of the time, if people are walking by me and they were to burst into flames, I would not care so much as I just don't hope I don't get caught in the flames. Like that's the only thing I care about.
Starting point is 01:06:04 No, but seriously, like I don't care what, I don't care caught in the flames. That's the only thing I care about. No, but seriously, I don't care what people think, really. And when it comes down to it, I wouldn't care what any of these other people think as long as they weren't mandating it for other people. I don't care one bit. I don't care that these people are creationists. I don't care that Colonel Sanders thinks
Starting point is 01:06:21 that fucking chicken bones can tell him the future. It doesn't matter to me. It doesn't matter at all. What I care is that he's going to stop pseudoscience from being injected into a science book because he thinks that pseudoscience is a real thing. Yeah. And that's a fucking danger. And if you're going to be
Starting point is 01:06:37 middling and you're going to bitch and be like, oh, you atheists are just as bad as the fundamentalists. Why? Because we want fucking, we want to make sure that the pseudoscience doesn't get into a textbook, then fine, I'm just as bad as the fundamentalists. Why? Because we want fucking – we want to make sure that the pseudoscience doesn't get in a textbook? Then fine. I'm just as bad as a fundamentalist then. Yeah, I'll take that. I'm fine with that.
Starting point is 01:06:52 I mean everybody is trying to do the same thing, right? Everybody is trying to safeguard like the future. Everybody wants the same thing. I want a future not just for my kids but fucking I'm selfish. I want a future not just for my kids, but fucking I'm selfish. I want a future for myself. Like I want a world that is not a piece of shit. I want a world where people come up with good solutions to the difficult problems that we're facing. And those solutions are going to come very frequently in the forms of technology and innovations in science.
Starting point is 01:07:23 That's not going to happen. It's just, we're going to fucking shoot ourselves in the foot. We're going to be a bunch of fucking apes, ooking and ocking at the obelisk. If we don't turn this around, that guy was throwing chicken bones at it earlier. No,
Starting point is 01:07:36 it's not that far off. So that ends this quasi-movie review. More of a movie viewing to jumping off point about a subject that we've done this time, talking about The Revisionaries. Be sure, if you haven't watched it and you listen to us, be sure to check it out on Netflix. I think it's totally worth a watch. It's one of those movies that will probably get your blood boiling, but maybe you can watch
Starting point is 01:08:05 Religious right afterwards and let off a little steam. It's like brainwash. And mad thanks to King of Cash Money for sending us a list to pick from. We really appreciate it. It really helped us out. So we're going to leave you with a shortish episode. No email this time because we're doing this
Starting point is 01:08:21 episode early and we don't have any email. So if you sent us something this week and we didn't read it, obviously we're not reading anything. We will read it next week. Same thing. I'm going to be playing some of the voicemails that I get during this sort of interim week, but there won't be any commentary under them and we're not going to be talking about them, but I will probably be playing a few of these voicemails for breaks in the show. But other than that, there's not going to be any email reading.
Starting point is 01:08:45 We're going to get to your emails when we come back for a new show the following week. So until then, we're going to leave you as always with the Skeptic's Creed. Credulity is not a virtue. It's fortune cookie cutter, mommy issue, hypno-Babylon bullshit. Couched in scientician, double bubble, toil and trouble, pseudo-quasi-alternative, acupunctuating, pressurized, stereogram, pyramidal, free
Starting point is 01:09:11 energy, healing, water, downward spiral, brain dead, pan, sales pitch, late night info-docutainment. Leo Pisces, cancer cures, detox, reflex, foot massage, death in towers, tarot cards, psychic healing, crystal balls, Bigfoot, Yeti, aliens, churches, mosques and synagogues, temples, dragons, giant worms, Atlantis,
Starting point is 01:09:34 dolphins, truthers, birthers, witches, wizards, vaccine nuts, shaman healers, evangelists, conspiracy, double-speak stigmata, nonsense. Expose your sides. Thrust your hands. Bloody, evidential, conc or of the local dairy council. Bye.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.