Cold Case Files - Manhunt

Episode Date: July 14, 2020

From 1999 to 2002, eleven young girls and women were sexually assaulted in a similar way. Despite these cases spanning across five states, in all of them, the same man kept popping up as a suspect. The problem wasn't figuring out who had committed these crimes. The problem was figuring out how to catch him. Manage your online orders with ShipStation! Try ShipStation FREE for 60 days when you use code COLDCASE at www.ShipStation.com  Run your business with NetSuite! Receive your FREE guide – “Seven Actions Businesses Need to Take Now” and schedule your FREE Product Tour - at www.NetSuite.com/ccf  Get a quote online at www.Progressive.com in as little as 5 minutes and see how much you could be saving!

Thank you for listening to this Podcast One production. Available on Apple Podcasts and Podcast One. seven actions businesses need to take now, and schedule your free product tour at netsuite.com slash CCF. You'll have the agility to compete with anyone, work from anywhere, and run your whole company right from your phone. Join over 20,000 companies who trust NetSuite to make it happen. NetSuite surveyed hundreds of business leaders and assembled a playbook of the top strategies they're using

as America reopens for business. Receive your free guide, seven actions businesses need to take now, and schedule your free product tour at netsuite.com slash ccf. Get your free guide and schedule your free product tour right now at netsuite.com slash ccf. netsuite.com slash ccf. In the fall of 1999, Sarah Jones had an experience in the middle of the night, one that she'll never be able to forget. She was nine years old at the time and at first thought she was dreaming. A man picked her up and carried her outside, and he told her that her house was on fire.

And then I put my foot down to see if I was actually outside. And I just woke up and was like, this can't be right. She wasn't dreaming, though. She was fully awake, and the fact that she was being carried away into the night by a strange man would become the lesser of the evil she'd be exposed to that night. He laid me on the ground and told me to take my shorts off, and I started screaming and yelling, and I told him no. And then he put some kind of leather glove in my mouth.

And then, since I wouldn't take my shorts off, he took them off for me. Sarah's life had been changed forever that night, and she wouldn't be the only one to fall victim to this particular perpetrator Over the next five years, he would assault over nine other women and girls Continuing to stump detectives as he chose his next victims One third of all murder cases in America remain open Each one is called a cold case And only one percent are ever solved.

This is one of those rare cases. From A&E, this is Cold Case Files, the podcast. Sarah's mother, Melissa, for some reason decided to look in on her daughter that night. Not because their house was on fire, that was a lie told by Sarah's attacker, but rather because she was a mother, and that's what mothers do. When she discovered that her nine-year-old daughter was missing, she was worried, but managed to focus on finding her rather than panic. She got into her car and drove around looking for Sarah, shining her headlights into hard-to-see places. Nine-year-old Sarah was assaulted in a nearby field. She screamed and she cried, but that didn't evoke any sympathy in the man who forced himself on top of her. In fact,

it spurred the opposite. At that time, I was screaming and fighting and trying to just break free and get home again. And then he told me he was going to kill me if I didn't quit, so I quit. And I let my defenses down. The attacker got up and told Sarah to be quiet and wait for him. He was going to get a friend, but he'd be back. Sarah didn't listen, and as soon as the man was out of sight, she ran as fast as she could toward her neighbor's home. She was found by her mother. Her hair is just everywhere. She's got leaves on her hair. She has on a sports bra, and that's it. She's barefooted.

And she's screaming my name, just in such a voice that I've never heard it before. Would never hear it again if I could. Melissa was appropriately concerned for her daughter's safety. But because of the way she found Sarah and her state of undress, she had feared that Sarah had been assaulted. She was taken to the doctor where her mother's suspicions were confirmed. An examination of Sarah revealed the nine-year-old girl had been raped. The DNA evidence was sent to the crime lab and an investigation into the perpetrator of this crime began when the sun came up the next morning. The perpetrator came up here. The window wasn't locked and he just raised it. The young lady was just inside there laying on the bed. We done what we call a neighborhood canvas. We went to each residence and talked to them kind of just in a real quick manner,

just to find out who lived there, who was there that night, and any new people in the area. Captain Gerald Moody and his team focused in on a neighbor, James Selby, who had previously had charges of sexual assault brought against him, though he wasn't convicted in that case. The police looked into Selby, and he quickly became their number one suspect. That is, until he left town without a trace. Here's investigator Rhett Burnett. We did have enough information that made him probably our number one person to look at and try and eliminate. And when he took off off just just pretty much solidified it in our mind that he was probably our guy. With their number one suspect missing and no other obvious leads detectives

were forced to shelve this case and wait while a family and a nine-year-old girl herself were also forced to wait wondering if she would ever feel safe from the man who attacked her. For a while, for the first year and a half or so, that's all I thought about. Because it was kind of scary and it interfered with all my sports and all the things I did around with my friends and my family. Another lead was coming, though. Unfortunately, it was coming in the form of a frightened 12-year-old girl who had been attacked in her bedroom in Nevada.

If you sell stuff online right now, you need to keep up with demand. Enter ShipStation, the number one choice for online sellers. They're the fastest, easiest, and most affordable way to manage and ship your orders. I work for myself. It's a lot to keep up with. And anytime I can find a way to streamline a task, I go for it. That's why I love what ShipStation offers. Right now, go to ShipStation.com and use code COLDCASE for a free 60-day trial. If you sell on Amazon, Etsy, or your own website, ShipStation brings all your orders into one simple interface. They work with FedEx, UPS, Amazon Fulfillment, and other major carriers so you can find the best shipping solution for you and your customer. And right now,

Cold Case Files listeners can try ShipStation free for 60 days when you use offer code COLDCASE. Make sure your business is ready to meet the demands of delivery culture. Get started at ShipStation.com today. Click on the microphone at the top of the homepage and type in cold case. That's ShipStation.com. Then enter offer code cold case. ShipStation.com. Make ship happen.

The law of unintended consequences is a simple but often misunderstood rule of the universe. Flashback from the iHeartRadio podcast network in Aussie is a chart-topping new podcast that reveals the surprising stories that the history books never told you about. Aussie's Sean Braswell takes you on a journey through history that will change how you look at the world today. Discover how the invention of air conditioning changed U.S. politics, how Henry Ford instigated the Oklahoma City bombing, and how the YMCA kickstarted the black market and cigarette smuggling. Listen to Flashback on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Sparks, Nevada is a community of around 70,000 people, including a 12-year-old girl who had the grave misfortune of becoming the assailant's next victim.

This 12-year-old wished not to be named, so out of respect, let's call her Jane. All victims deserve to be supported and remembered as individuals, not just as an unwilling participant in a lewd act. Jane was sleeping in her bed. The front door to her apartment was unlocked, and so the suspect easily made his way inside. He found Jane and pulled her blanket and pillow over her face so she couldn't see him. It sounds terrifying to me as an adult, but she was only a child. She didn't get a look at him, and though she was scared and alone, she didn't dare call out. Here's Sparks detective Tom Miller. She indicated that the suspect told her, don't scream or anything like that, and I won't hurt you.

The police believe that because of the precision in which this crime was carried out, that the perpetrator must have had knowledge of the family's schedule and the apartment's layout. They looked into the men that have access to those things and discover that the maintenance man for the apartment complex didn't show up for work that day. His name? James Selby. They run a background check on the missing maintenance man and discover something interesting about his past. Back in 1998, he had a case where he abducted a former acquaintance, a female. Unfortunately, state-to-state police communication wasn't perfect, so nothing in the background check points them to the fact that Selby was a suspect in the 1999 attack on nine-year-old Sarah Jones. Police go to Selby's apartment to see what evidence they

might find, but unfortunately it's mostly cleared out. They do, however, find a toothbrush that's been left behind, meaning they'll have a way to gather and analyze his DNA. They send the toothbrush off to the lab. On July 2nd, DNA analyst Jeff Rollins attempts to strip DNA cells left behind on the toothbrush. He wants to get a DNA profile to compare to that of the attacker. I'll put the bristles into a tube, and obviously I want as many as I can

because we want to get a full DNA profile off of that. And he does it. He's able to extract a full DNA profile from the cells on the toothbrush. The next step is for Rollins to compare the DNA to the attacker and determine what the odds are that the DNA from the semen found at the crime scene matches the DNA found on the toothbrush. It turns out the odds were pretty good.

Greater than one in 500 billion. Without a doubt, it was Selby. We've talked about a lot of cold cases, but I don't know that we've covered one yet where the perpetrator has been the sole suspect all along. A warrant was issued for Selby, but it didn't really matter because he slipped away again and traveled west. It turned out, his days of assaulting little girls were over. Unfortunately, though, his days of assaulting grown women were just about to begin. It's every woman's worst fear,

is to be in the safety of your own home and then have somebody come in and not only violate the security of your home, but then to violate you. I can't imagine anything being worse than that. That was Detective David Dolan. He and his partner, Detective Jack Nish, specialized in sexually motivated crimes, where they were based in San Diego.

Specifically, at this point in 2001, they were hunting for a serial rapist who had assaulted three women in their own homes in just nine weeks. The victims were all young, in their 20s. The attacker would gain entry into their homes through an unlocked window or door. He'd threaten them and assault them and leave. He'll confront the victim, usually when they're asleep, and immediately blindfold them or put something over their face so they can't recognize who he is, and then he sexually assaults them. And then would make them get into the shower

or go to a secluded place within the house, and you could usually tell him to count to 1,000, and then he'd flee. The method, the MO, sounded eerily familiar to the crimes we were just speaking about. These detectives didn't know that, though, so they kept coming up empty, and more women were being assaulted. By fall, four women, all connected by DNA, had been attacked by the same man. We had no idea who we were chasing. We didn't even have a race.

We resorted to using psychological profiles, geographic profiles, submitting information to the Department of Justice, State of California, and even with all that, we were still coming up empty-handed. The attacks in San Diego had all taken place in effluent neighborhoods and, though unfair, this afforded them an increased amount of media coverage. Police were pressured to do more and investigate harder. They camped out in a local park,

basically a tent city for the homeless and transient. They came up empty, though, and the attack stopped altogether. It was anxiety-provoking, not knowing if the perpetrator was gone or just waiting until the time was right to move in on his next victim. On October 5, 2001, Tiffany Nakajima, a student in Tucson, Arizona, left home to rush to the grocery store. But when she returned around 2 p.m., someone was there that she didn't expect. I opened the front door, and I went in, and there was someone in my house, and he came up from behind me and put a knife to my throat. The man told Tiffany that he just wanted to rob the place as he blindfolded her. Then he let her down the hallway into her bedroom. I knew he had a knife, so I stayed very calm and just followed what he wanted. He had me lay down on the bed, and then next thing I knew he was on top of me and reaping me.

Though to Tiffany it must have felt like forever. The assault lasted about 20 minutes and ended with a man confronting Tiffany. He asked if she was going to say anything about what had happened and when she told him that she wouldn't he slashed her throat two times and said no you're not going to say anything. He thought she was dead and he left, but she wasn't. Tiffany was alive. I was just thinking, I'm going to die. I'm not going to see my family again. I just need to survive.

I went out the door and I screamed and he was walking away. He turned around, looked at me, and then he began to run away. He was a Caucasian man, kind of sandy brown hair. He was wearing a black T-shirt and blue jeans. Detective Mary Game takes the case and discovers that a similar incident had taken place in the house right across the street from Tiffany's. There were two college-age girls living in the house right across the street from Tiffany's. There were two college-age girls living

in the residence, and one had been confronted by a male in her bathroom, and he had grabbed her by the throat, told her he was there to rob her, and not to give him any problem. The man is described in a similar way that he was described by Tiffany, so the police make a composite sketch to pass around campus. The investigators pass out the sketch and ask questions, but they don't find any leads. Then, three weeks after the initial attacks, another woman has reported being assaulted. It would appear that Detective Game had a serial predator on her hands. The attacks in Tucson appear to stop, but three months later, another attack is reported. In this case, the victim isn't a woman, though. She's a 14-year-old girl.

She wakes up to a male subject laying in the bed with her, one hand over her mouth and the other on her throat, telling her not to scream. Her hands were swabbed for potential DNA evidence and tested, and it matched our other two cases. The DNA was uploaded to CODIS, which is an acronym for Combined DNA Index System. The FBI uploads the DNA of every adult convicted of a felony into this system. No matches were returned, though. So all Detective

Game could do was wait. I don't know what the process is for entering something into CODIS, but it seems like it might be time consuming. It wasn't until this point, years later, that the CODIS manager for the San Diego Police Department, Brian Burrett, entered the DNA information for the four unsolved assaults in their area. Once we uploaded to the national database, then we started getting the matches with Arizona. The connection was made, and the detectives in San Diego and Tucson were able to work together. But that connection didn't come soon enough to be useful to Tamara Faust, a 27-year-old woman living in Tucson.

As soon as I entered my bedroom, I was grabbed from behind. The man said, if you scream, I'll cut your throat. Tamara had taken a shower. She was getting ready for her day. But when she entered her bedroom, she was surprised when a strange man grabbed her from behind and threatened her. He told her if she screamed, he would cut her. Tamara stayed quiet.

He said, I'm just here for your car and for your money. I just caught my girlfriend cheating on me, and I just killed her and the man that she was with. So I'm on the run from the police. Not going to hurt you. The thoughts that were going through my mind were that this might be my last day alive. And so my mind was only thinking about remaining as calm as possible because I knew that if I stayed calm,

that would help him remain calm. He tied her up and made her lay on the floor. She gave him her money, her ATM card, and keys, hoping that it would encourage him to leave faster. But it didn't work. He had everything he needed to make a successful getaway. But he still wasn't leaving. That's when she realized he hadn't been honest about his intentions, and he attacked her. He was talking to me. He was asking me if it felt good, if he was of adequate size.

So I knew that even though I was a victim in the moment, I knew that after the assault was over, if I could survive the assault, I wouldn't be a victim anymore. I would be a survivor and I could take control of my life again. Then, in a sickening turn of events, the man tells Tamara that he wants to spend the day with her, as if they've just completed

some act of love and not a brutal assault. Tamara tells him no. She tells him that she's late for a meeting at work, and she'll be missed and has to leave. The man tells her to close her eyes and count to 100 before getting up. He says by the time she finishes, he'll be gone, and it'll be safe for her to leave. Tamara flees from her home and runs to a neighbor's house where she calls the police. Detective Mary Game gets the call and is immediately on her way. I think that when I first heard the call and was being sent over here,

I pretty much knew it was the same guy. Unlike the other cases, there's a piece of physical evidence beyond DNA linking the perpetrator to his crime. A way to track him. Tamara's ATM card. The card was used just 30 minutes after the perpetrator left Tamara's home, and the bank sent the photos from the machine immediately. The problem was, the person using the card hit his face with a brochure while making the transaction.

The link turned out to be not so useful after all. At this point, though, another connection was made, in another state. It turns out there was another DNA hit. This time, it was connecting these assaults with an assault committed on a nine-year-old girl. A girl that was removed from her home and assaulted in a field in Oklahoma three years earlier. Thank you. and schedule your free product tour at netsuite.com slash ccf. You'll have the agility to compete with anyone, work from anywhere, and run your whole company right from your phone. Join over 20,000 companies who trust NetSuite to make it happen.

NetSuite surveyed hundreds of business leaders and assembled a playbook of the top strategies they're using as America reopens for business. Receive your free guide, 7 Actions Businesses Need to Take Now, and schedule your free product tour at netsuite.com slash ccf. Get your free guide and schedule your free product tour right now at netsuite.com slash ccf. netsuite.com slash ccf. Support for today's episode comes from Progressive Insurance. Fun fact, Progressive customers qualify for an average of six discounts when they sign up for Progressive Auto Insurance. Discounts for things like enrolling in automatic payments, insuring more than one car, going paperless, and of course, being a safe driver.

Plus, customers who bundle their auto with home or add renter's insurance save an average of 12% on their auto. There are so many ways to save when you switch. And once you're a customer with Progressive, you get unmatched claim service with 24-7 support online or by phone. It's no wonder why more than 20 million drivers trust Progressive and why they've recently climbed to the third largest auto insurer in the country. Get a quote online at Progressive.com in as little as five minutes and see how you could be saving. Auto insurance from Progressive Casualty Insurance Companies and Affiliates, home and renter's insurance, not available in all states. Provided and serviced by affiliate and third-party insurers.

Discounts vary and are not available in all states and situations. Captain Gerald Moody, from the Cleveland County Sheriff's Office in Oklahoma, was the most recent investigator to be put on now 12-year-old Sarah Jones' case. She was the nine-year-old girl who had been removed from her home and attacked in a field outside of her house. Her case had basically gotten cold until Captain Moody attended a conference for investigators. One of the instructors was from the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation telling about they were going online with CODIS, and if we had any cases that were pending, and I asked her, I said,

it's just one of the cases that really bothers me. I would really enjoy it if you would put this one in. And I says, I think it can be solved through CODIS. I says, that's going to be the only way. Shortly after going online with CODIS, I got, that's going to be the only way. Shortly after going online with CODIS, I got a telephone call from Tucson, Arizona. They told me that they had the same profile on the DNA as we had here in Oklahoma.

At that time, I told her, I said, well, I believe it to be James Selby. As a result of the hit and the suspicion that James Selby was the culprit behind these attacks, his name was run through the system to check if he was wanted in any other areas. It was determined that he was. In Nevada. There was a warrant for his arrest for the assault of a 12-year-old girl based on DNA collected from a toothbrush.

The toothbrush DNA was then compared to all of the outstanding rapes in California, Arizona, and Oklahoma. The detectives finally had all of the pieces of the puzzle, the name, and the evidence to convict him. James Selby was their rapist. The manhunt for James Selby began. Checking into some history, he'd been in the military, in the Army, had done some time in Desert Storm. He had apparently gone to the VA here locally for some unknown medical reason. So that information was put out through the Marshal's office to the VA. So in case he turned up at another VA facility, we could

be notified. We're going to shift scenes for a minute to Colorado Springs. A homeless program at the Veterans Affairs Clinic is a place where veterans who are down on their luck go to get a helping hand. Debbie Fowler is working to assist those in need at the time, and she gets a visit from a Gulf War vet by the name of James Selby. He has a simple enough request. Shoes. That's all he needed was shoes because his was cracked on the soles at the bottom.

And he said that he couldn't find a job unless he had some shoes to wear. As hard as she tries, though, Debbie can't seem to find shoes that fit Selby. So he makes another request of her. He needs to refill a medication that had been prescribed to him from the Tucson VA's office. Debbie makes the call, and she's shocked by the information the person on the other end of the phone shares with her. And he was sitting in the chair in my office, and I called Tucson, and then the lady in Tucson said, do you know who you have in your

office? Oh my God, she said. I had the U.S. Marshal on the other line. She said, he is a rapist. And I said, you've got to be kidding. U.S. Marshals get on the line with Debbie in an attempt to calm her and help her through the situation. They tell her help is on the way. Debbie's understandably nervous for her safety, but also because she doesn't want a rapist to get away before he can be taken into custody. She paces from the phone to the waiting room, asking God to help her stay calm and for things to go smoothly. I'm not going to debate the existence of a higher power, but whatever the reason, it worked. James Selby, a man wanted in connection with nine violent sexual assaults in Arizona,

California, Oklahoma, Nevada, and soon to be realized, Colorado, is taken into custody. Selby's processed by the Colorado Springs Police Department, and though the detectives from all the states that Selby's left in his wake are lining up to talk to him, Detective Leslie Malik-Madani, a Colorado local, is the first to speak with him. She notices that Selby's M.O. matches the M.O. of an attack that happened more than a year earlier in Colorado to a 55-year-old woman. He performed oral sex on her first, and then he had vaginal intercourse with her. What we ended up having was a stain on the shirt, a sperm stain that he had used to cover her face. There was a stain on the shirt, and that was the only evidence we had. Since the woman hadn't been able to identify her attacker, all they had was the DNA profile. Detective Malik Madani talks to Selby for over five hours trying to get him to confess to the Colorado assault, but he just doesn't do it. His answers are controlled. He never lets the

conversation stray too far from the topics he wants to discuss. Even though he doesn't confess, the DNA evidence is a match. James Selby is convicted of sexual assault in connection with the rape of the 55-year-old woman, and then sentenced to 20 years to life in prison for the Colorado attack. He's next transported to Tucson, Arizona, where he'll be tried for nine more counts of sexual assault and one charge of attempted murder. Before the trial begins, Selby grants an exclusive interview to a reporter, a woman named A.J. Flick.

She focuses on Selby's life circumstances and what might have brought him to this point in his life. She asks him about his time in the service, noting that he had served a year in the Gulf War and raped his first victim seven years later. What made you change, though? Just being in war made you change, though? Just being in war made you change? Seeing things you don't ever want to have to see,

doing things you don't ever want to have to do. It's a cold feeling when you have to shoot someone that you don't know. You change your whole outlook on life. I think he was definitely broken down. I don't know that he was so much making excuses. I think he really believed those things. And I think that's what made him snap. She also asked about Selby's decision to forego an attorney and to defend himself.

Why do you feel that, you know, instead of having an attorney that you're working with, why is it so important to you to do it yourself? My feelings with public defenders are they are nothing more than an extension of the district attorney's office. You touch that furnace and it burns, you want to learn not to touch it again. What do you think the outcome's going to be? Obviously you think you have a good chance of...

No, I don't. I don't think I have a good chance at all. I think that there's so much immediate attention. There's no possible way that I'm going to get a jury that isn't tainted. It's hard for me not to be biased against a proven rapist, but he does have a point. With the way information travels in today's society, it's frequently hard to find a jury that isn't familiar in some way with a high-profile case. On September 28, 2004, Selby's trial began and all the women he had violated came to confront their attacker. I wonder how they felt. Was it traumatizing?

Or did it provide the closure that they needed? You know, I guess you would imagine a rapist to look very scary, intimidating, unattractive, grotesque. And he was just an average-looking guy. I'm very happy they found him. I just wouldn't be able to go on in life knowing that he's still out there. It was just not right. Suddenly, the boogeyman that had been haunting me had a face.

And it was... He looked so normal. After five days of representing himself, and after Tiffany Nakajima's testimony, he asked for a public defender. He asked me if the person who had cut my throat was left or right-handed. He asked me if his voice sounded familiar to me. I told him that it made me nauseous. Yes, his voice sounded familiar to me and it made me nauseous. Two weeks later, James Salby was found guilty and sentenced to spend the rest of his life in prison.

That same day, he was found dead in a cell with a homemade noose around his neck. Let's not talk about justice. Let's not talk about justice. Let's not talk about the value of this man's life or time. Let's listen to Tamara talk. I think she says it best. In some ways, it closes a big door for me because I don't have to think and wonder about what he's doing in jail, how he's being treated in jail, what he's

thinking. Should I go and visit him? Should I write him a letter to try to learn more about him and understand why he did the things that he did? Thank you. were edited by Steve Dolomater and distributed by Podcast One. Cold Case Files Classic was produced by Curtis Productions and hosted by the one and only Bill Curtis. Check out more Cold Case Files at aetv.com and by downloading the A&E app.