Cold Case Files - REOPENED: A Drop of Blood

Episode Date: May 9, 2023

Indiana police are baffled by the murder of an 86-year-old woman, found dead in her bedroom with a pillow and a footstool on top of her head. With few leads and no conceivable motive the case remains unsolved for years, until a single piece of evidence uncovers Julia Gurty's killer. Sponsors: Angi: Download the free Angi mobile app today or visit Angi.com. Earthbreeze: Switch from the old-fashioned goo to something new! Right now, my listeners can subscribe to Earth Breeze and save 40%! Go to EarthBreeze.com/coldcase to get started.  Progressive: Get a quote at progressive.com to join the over 29 million drivers who trust Progressive. Simplisafe: Customize the perfect system for your home in just a few minutes at simplisafe.com/COLDCASE . Go today and claim a free indoor security camera plus 20% off your order with Interactive Monitoring.  Zocdoc: Go to Zocdoc.com/CCF and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours. 

Hey, Cold Case fans, we have something special for you. We're bringing you double the episodes every week. We know you dedicated fans need your fix in between new episodes. So every Thursday, we are back bringing some of our best episodes from previous seasons. Let us know which classic episodes you'd like to hear again in the comments. And don't worry, we'll see you back here every Tuesday for all new episodes of Cold Case Files 2. Now, on to the episode. 86-year-old Julia Gertie was matriarch of the Gertie family. She didn't have any enemies,

and she wouldn't have put up a fight during a burglary, nor was there any sign of a sexually motivated crime. So why would someone brutally murder a helpless old woman for seemingly no reason? That was the first in what would become a long list of questions asked by investigators in the case. And for nearly four years, these questions would go unanswered, torturing the police and the Gertie family, until a single piece of evidence reveals the motive and the murderer behind Juliet Gurdie's brutal death. From A&E, this is Cold Case Files, the podcast. I'm Brooke.

And here's Bill Curtis with a classic case, A Drop of Blood. On a Monday morning, Mary Lou Garty decides to check in on her 86-year-old mother-in-law, Julia. She hops in her truck and drives around the corner to Julia's farmhouse. On the outside, everything appears to be normal. The inside, however, is a different story. It looked like somebody had totally ransacked the house,

and a lot of things were really thrown around, torn up. Things were out of the cabinet. Mary Lou walks through the house and inches towards Julia's bedroom. In the bedroom, I saw on her bed, she was laying there, but there was a pillow over her head and a footstool on top of that pillow. Julia Gardy lies dead, apparently smothered in her own bed. It was just kind of like a nightmare, like something was happening, but it really shouldn't be happening.

Mary Lou races down the road to her sister-in-law's. All of a sudden, Mary Lou came across the yard screaming, Nanny's been murdered, nanny's been murdered, and somebody robbed her house or something like that. And I thought, what is she saying? And then finally we realized what she was saying, and we called 911 at that point. A call had just come in of the murder,

notifying the sheriff's department of the murder and notifying the sheriff's department of the murder. Investigator Greg Bricker of the Indiana State Police Department catches the call. There was no reason for it to happen and Mrs. Gardy probably wouldn't have offered any resistance to this person whatsoever, and it just wasn't necessary to kill her. It was a vicious cold-blooded murder, no reason whatsoever. It appeared to me to be somebody that had been doing burglaries for a long time, maybe a professional. He hit all the right spots.

Crime scene technician Thomas Kolb is called in to work the scene. Inside the house, he notices two distinct styles of ransacking. The main floor was very ransacked. All the drawers had been pulled out, dumped on the floor. Upstairs, however, there is very little ransacking. Upstairs, the drawers were pulled out. You could see things moved, but it wasn't totally dumped on the floor. The bed just had the covers moved back. So upstairs was kind of neat. And there was also

two different sets of shoe prints. So I knew there was two people. I knew one would probably be a male, the other one a female, based on the shoe print. Kolb documents the shoe prints and makes his way to the living room, where he gets a close look at the broken window, the possible point of entry. He found the rock beside the TV where it impacted. And there was curtains, so you know that when he came in, he had to move the curtains. And you always hope that you find something. So when I examined the curtains, there was a small reddish-brown spot,

which to me indicated a blood spot. As soon as I saw the blood, I said, ah, that's great. You know, we have hope now. The curtain is bagged and sent to the crime lab for testing. Meanwhile, Bricker asks Ginny to scan the house and list any stolen items. There were some TVs, there was a VCR, a phone that was missing, and also her silverware was taken. Bricker checks with local pawn shops but turns up empty-handed. Meanwhile, officers canvas the neighborhood.

We had a team of detectives at that point looking for information as to if anybody had saw anybody out of line, if there was anybody hanging around that they didn't know or any vehicles that they could describe to us. Less than a mile down the road, investigators meet Tracy Broxson, a Fort Wayne cop. Broxson tells police that two days before the murder, she caught a strange man snooping around her house. Well, it was odd that he was trying the gate where the dogs was.

I didn't know him. We're a half mile back. Who's back here looking in the windows? Roxen opened her front door, gun in hand, and confronted the men. At that point, he started backing off the porch, and he goes, I'm really lost. I think I'm really at the wrong house type deal. And I said, yes, you are. You're at the wrong house. At this point, he turned and went at a pretty good clip through the yard here, trying to catch up to the van.

Yeah, somebody's casing the neighborhood looking for a house to break into. Bricker circulates Broxson's description of the van and waits for a break. Yeah, it was very frustrating because we weren't getting any information from the public. We had very little information to go on that we gathered at the scene. It was very frustrating. Just no tips, period. Angie's List is now Angie,

and they've made it easier than ever to get all your home projects done right. If you need help with landscaping, electrical, remodeling, roofing, or just a handy person, Angie can help you find what you need. One of our producers recently used Angie to find a much-needed plumber for a busted faucet. Using Angie, it helped narrow down the exact cause of his problem, then helped him assess if he needed to repair, replace, or install a new faucet. It made his life so much easier. Angie has over 20 years of home service experience, and they've combined it with new tools to simplify the whole process. Just bring them your project online or with the Angie

app, answer a few questions, and Angie can handle the rest from start to finish. Or help you see ratings and reviews, compare quotes from local pros, and connect instantly. Which means you can cross things off your to-do list in just a few taps. Because whether it's routine maintenance or a dream remodel, Angie is here to make it easy. So get your next project done with the help of a pro from Angie. Download the free Angie mobile app today or visit Angie.com. That's A-N-G-I.com. I don't know about you guys, but has anyone else noticed just how much plastic is being used just to store laundry detergent? The big, clunky, hard-to-store tubs?

Even for the pods now, to get the biggest container, you have to buy the jug. Who wants that? There has to be a better way, and I found it with Earth Breeze. Liquidless laundry detergent that dissolves 100% in any wash cycle, hot or cold. This means no more measuring, no more mess, and no more big plastic jugs. Earth Breeze is great for all laundry lifestyles, even sensitive skin. Their eco sheets are hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested. It's compatible with high efficiency washers, gray water systems, and even is septic safe. Most importantly, you still get a powerful clean. Earth Breeze is tough on stains, fights odors, and your clothes come out clean every time. I still haven't gotten my shipment, but it's on

the way and I am so excited to finally do laundry where I don't have to feel bad about what I'm on the way and I am so excited to finally do laundry where I don't have to feel bad about what I'm doing to the environment. Switch from the old-fashioned goo to something new. Right now, my listeners can subscribe to EarthBreeze and save 40%. Go to earthbreeze.com slash coldcase to get started. That's earthbreeze.com slash cold case for 40% off. earthbreeze.com slash cold case. Globally, humans are facing massive problems that are widely ignored by governments and the media. Like personal space invaders. I've had it with these couples that sit on the same side of the booth. Yak mouths.

Stupid stick figure bumper stickers. Almond milk. You cannot milk an almond. Hi, I'm Jennifer. And I'm Angie. We call her Pumps, and we're the hosts of I've Had It. Pumps, tell the listener where they can find us.

Apple, Spotify, Amazon, or wherever you get your podcasts. Nailed it. See you next Tuesday. In the weeks that follow, Bricker tracks down known burglars and brings them in for questioning. One by one, each is eliminated. We had some leads on people who were burglarizing homes in the area and we interviewed those subjects. They all had alibis, so we came up cold. Now Bricker turns to the crime lab and pins his hopes on science.

I obtained a small portion of the curtain with a reddish-brownish stain present. Leslie Harmon is a DNA analyst with the Indiana State Police. On a Monday afternoon, she takes delivery of the Gardy evidence and examines the curtain. I took a small portion of that cutting and started my analysis. The stain is confirmed to be blood. Harmon eventually extracts a DNA profile and puts it into the CODIS database. The first time that we ran it, there were no hits.

There was absolutely no leads on this case. And every lead we did get was a dead end. I just ran out of things to do, places to go, people to look at, and I put the case, I suspended the case until further information came up. Julia Gardy's case

is shipped to the cold files, where it will stay for three and a half years until police track down a woman who is ready to point a finger at a killer. shipped to the cold files, where it will stay for three and a half years, until police track down a woman who is ready to point a finger at a killer. I remember him grabbing the pillow and I said, No, don't do that. I knew what was going to happen. Three and a half years after Mary Lou Gertie discovered her mother-in-law smothered in her own bed, the case was cold. Much to the investigators' and the Gertie family's frustration, every lead seemed to dry up.

One suspect had literally walked up to Officer Boxton's front door, only to evaporate when no one fitting the description had turned up. The single promising piece of case evidence, drops of blood found on Julia's curtain, had been tested and run through CODIS, and it came up empty. With no new evidence, no motive, and no leads, investigators were forced to put the Gertie case on the shelf and wait for a tip or lead to come up to them. Then one day, investigator Mark Helfelfinger received a call that would break the case wide open. I got a call from my boss. I remember sitting on the couch and she called me and said, hey, Mark, you know the Gardy case? Mark Heffelfinger is a detective with the Indiana State Police.

On October 24th, he takes a call about the Julia Gardy case, now nearly four years cold. She says, well, we got a DNA match from the blood that was taken from the curtain on the window of that house. It comes back to a guy by the name of Donald Hauser. Indiana periodically runs its cold cases through CODIS, the state's DNA data bank. It was during such an exercise that the name of Donald Hauser, a convicted burglar, came back as a match. The DNA was a start. That's a starting point and somebody to look at. That in and of itself won't necessarily get you conviction. So what I needed to do at that point was establish what can I find out about Donald Hauser.

Heffelfinger digs through the file and pulls out a name, Angela Stone, Hauser's ex-girlfriend and former burglary accomplice. Within a day, Heffelfinger tracks down Stone and brings her in for some hard questions. This is team number two, continuation of the interview with Angela Stone. On October 26th, Detective Heffelfinger sits down with Angela Stone and presses her about Julia Gardy's murder. At this time, I truly believe she was a witness. I really believe that. The bottom line is, of course, in this house here, a lady was killed. Heffelfinger believes Julia Gardy's murder was a burglary gone wrong, and that Angela Stone might have been in the house when it happened.

After almost two hours of back and forth, Angela Stone comes across with the details of how her ex-boyfriend killed Julia Gardy. I remember him grabbing the pillow, and I said, No, don't do that. of how her ex-boyfriend killed Julia Garde. in the bedroom? No, in the living room. And he was standing like this. He took the pillow off the chair and stepped into the bedroom and held that over that lady's head. And you said you yelled at him? Yeah, I did. Because what I heard was her saying, No, sweetie, no, sweetie.

I am excited as can be. I am surprised because I didn't think she'd be that good of a witness. But actually, if she turns out to be more than a witness, she's an accomplice. That just really helped seal the spot for us. Stone confirms her story with a set of silverware, stolen from Julia Gardy's house and given by Hauser to his mom as a Christmas gift. After recovering the stolen item, cold case detectives are ready to talk with Donald Hauser.

When I go in to talk to Donald Hauser, I got just more ammunition. You know, he can't say, no, it wasn't me. Your girlfriend at the time says you did it. She saw you do it. Donald Hauser was brought back to DeKalb County with the jails just across the street there. One day after his conversation with Angela Stone, Detective Heffelfinger meets with Donald Hauser

in a small interview room. We'll be right back. you can find it from a doctor on ZocDoc. Thousands of medical professionals on ZocDoc are there to help you. They listen like a friend and give you the expert care you need. ZocDoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient-reviewed, take your insurance, are available when you need them, and treat almost every condition under the sun. When you're not feeling your best and just trying to hold it together, finding great care shouldn't take up all your energy. That's where ZocDoc comes in. Using their free app that millions of users rely on, you can find the right doctor that meets your needs and

fits your schedule. Book an appointment with a few taps in their app and start feeling better faster with ZocDoc. Go to ZocDoc.com slash CCF and download the ZocDoc app for free. Then find and book a top rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours. That's Z-O-C-D-O-C.com slash CCF. ZocDoc.com slash CCF. This episode of Cold Case Files is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Hey, Cold Case Files listeners. Whether you love true crime or comedies, celebrity interviews, news, or even motivational speakers, you call the shots on what's in your podcast queue, right? And guess what?

Now you can call the shots on your auto insurance too. Enter the Name Your Price tool from Progressive. The Name Your Price tool puts you in charge of your auto insurance by working just the way it sounds. You tell Progressive how much you wanna pay for car insurance, then they'll show you a variety of coverages that fit within your budget, giving you options. Now that's something you'll want to press play on. It's easy to start a quote

and you'll be able to choose the best option for you fast. It's just one of the many ways you can save with Progressive Insurance. Quote today at Progressive.com to try the Name Your Price tool for yourself and join the over 29 million drivers who trust Progressive. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Price and coverage match limited by state law. Hey, Cold Case Files listeners. Spring is in bloom. And you know what comes next? Vacation season. But before you pack your bags, be sure to secure your home with SimpliSafe Home Security. With SimpliSafe, enjoy greater peace of mind knowing that your home is monitored around the clock

by trained agents ready to act to defend against break-ins, fires, and other threats. I know I'm going on a cruise this summer, and I am so relieved that I finally got set up with SimpliSafe. Ever since I got SimpliSafe, I have never had to give the safety of my home a second thought. So this summer, I'll be in the middle of the Caribbean, not worrying about my home.

Only SimpliSafe offers Fast Protect technology, enabling monitoring agents to visually verify the threat is real. Conveying eyewitness evidence to 911 dispatch for fast police or fire response. With the top rated SimpliSafe app, stay connected from anywhere, anytime. Arm or disarm your system remotely. Check your cameras to make sure everything is okay, even unlock the front door to let a guest in. SimpliSafe ships to your door and it's easy to set up yourself in about 30 minutes, or you can have SimpliSafe certified technicians install it for you. With financing through Affirm, you can secure your home today and pay over time in installments that fit your budget.

SimpliSafe has been named the best home security of 2023 by U.S. News and World Report and is CNET's editor's choice for home security. Customize the perfect system for your home in just a few minutes at simplisafe.com forward slash cold case. Go today and claim a free indoor security camera plus 20% off. Don Brunholzer Jr. He's coming down in about a minute. He sat right here at this table in this chair, and I sat at that end of the table. Initially, when he came in, he was the calmest, coolest, no emotion whatsoever. Heffelfinger has a game plan.

He tells Hauser he's really out to get Angela Stone and tries to pin him against his ex. When you and Angie were together, okay, there were some other burglaries, okay? I'm trying to figure out what her involvement was in some of this stuff. Okay, if you were in prison, I don't care. You know what I'm saying? But I'm trying to figure out why she's not. Yeah, that's a good question.

And I knew that he was in prison now, currently because of a burglary he'd done in which she was there also, and she was not in jail. And I think that was going to be upsetting to him, so I kind of used that as an angle. Look, I'm not necessarily interested in you, but you're in jail, Angela's not. Why isn't she? Houser takes the bait and starts talking

about the string of burglaries he and Stone committed, but denies ever being at the Gardie house. That is, until Heffelfinger tells him about the blood on the curtain and the stolen silverware set recovered from his mother's house. She kept making up, just kept telling me that she can't, we can't leave her as a witness. Hauser switches gears, laying off blame for the murder of Julia Gardy on his former girlfriend and partner in crime, Angela Stone. How'd you do that? I mean, is that something you stood up on the bed, or what did you do? I'm just trying to... I want to lean over and put the pillow over.

Whether he was just ignorant of the fact that he was incriminating himself, or whether he didn't care, or whether he was so focused on getting Angela in jail, or what, I'm not sure. But either way, he started talking about Angela being there, what Angela's involvement was. Of course, he couldn't do that without implicating himself also. Okay, so he just held it over her face? It was quite exciting, but of course I have to be cool as I couldn't be too, and not let him know that I'm excited about the fact that he just implicated himself in a murder. The case against Donald Hauser is complete.

Six years after 86-year-old Julia Gardy was murdered, her suspected killer will stand trial. This was obviously one of the strongest cases I'll ever see. Stephen Klaus prosecutes the case against Donald Hauser. Central to the state's evidence is the DNA. This is the state's exhibit number 28 that was admitted into evidence in the trial, and it's the piece of the curtain that Sergeant Kolb collected from the house that contained Donald Hauser's bloodstain.

And right here in this hole is the place where his blood was left as he cut himself entering Mrs. Gardy's residence. And it's from that small little spot there that the case was broken. On November 11th, Hauser takes the stand and tells the jury he is innocent and that he was on drugs when he confessed. It's a story the jurors don't buy when weighed against the evidence stacked against him. We had an eyewitness who testified well. We had a confession. We had physical evidence from the

scene the suspect left, and we also had physical evidence from the scene that the suspect left, and we also had physical evidence recovered four years later from his mother's home that he had stolen. All this together really made for a great case to prosecute. After 20 minutes of deliberations, the jury finds Donald Hauser guilty of murder and sentences him to life without parole. Meanwhile, Angela Stone pleads guilty to burglary and gets 30 years. Well, it was, I was happy, happy for the family, happy for the community, happy for law enforcement that we can clear this up, and we've got somebody off the streets that's capable of killing somebody like Mrs. Gardy, because that kind of person, who knows what they could do. For the victim's family, the verdict answers every question in the death of 86-year-old Julia Gardy, save one.

It is both the hardest and simplest of questions. Why? None of the crimes in this podcast are ever justified. Few crimes ever are. But this murder in particular seems so random and inexplicable. Even with the killer behind bars, Julia's family will never stop wondering why their beloved grandma,

a woman who called her attacker sweetie until her last breath, was killed so senselessly. To me, crimes like this are scarier than any others because there's no pattern, no logic. There's nothing to explain the horrific acts. There is no justification or reasoning behind the murder of Julia Gertie.

Her murder was a snap decision, a choice made in a split second. And that split second will haunt members of the Gertie family for the rest of their lives. She was definitely no threat to anyone. But it was just really, really senseless because she would have let them have anything just to leave her alone, but they wanted one and more. And a really, really great woman was lost. Cold Case Files, the podcast, is hosted by Brooke Giddings.

Produced by McKamey Lynn, Scott Brody, and Steve Delamater. Our executive producer is Ted Butler. We're distributed by Podcast One. Cold Case Files Classic was produced by Curtis Productions and hosted by the one and only Bill Curtis. Check out more Cold Case Files at aetv.com. See what's streaming free all month long during Amplify AAPI Voices on Pluto TV. Watch shows like Kim's Convenience with Simu Liu and amazing movies like Meet the Patels and Jason Momoa in Braven. Plus, Pluto TV has hundreds of channels with thousands more movies and TV shows, available

on live and on demand. Download Pluto TV on all your favorite devices for free. Pluto TV, stream now, pay never.