Cold Case Files - REOPENED: Burning Desire

Episode Date: May 23, 2023

A California Highway Patrol officer spots a fire in an olive orchard and pulls off to investigate. He finds a woman's body, shot and set ablaze. It doesn't take police long to develop a theory on who did it... but why, where, how, and who else all remain a mystery. Sponsors:  Angi: Download the free Angi mobile app today or visit Angi.com. Jordan Harbinger: Search for The Jordan Harbinger Show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, wherever you listen to podcasts, or go to jordanharbinger.com/subscribe  Progressive: Quote your car insurance at Progressive.com to join the ov er 29 million drivers who trust Progressive.  Nutrafol: You can grow thicker, healthier hair AND support our show by going to Nutrafol.com and entering the promo code FILES to save ten dollars off your first month’s subscription – this offer is only available to US customers for a limited time. Plus FREE shipping on EVERY order.  Zocdoc: Go to Zocdoc.com/CCF and download the Zocdoc app for FREE. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours. 

Hey, Cold Case fans, we have something special for you. We're bringing you double the episodes every week. We know you dedicated fans need your fix in between new episodes. So every Thursday, we are back bringing some of our best episodes from previous seasons. Let us know which classic episodes you'd like to hear again in the comments. And don't worry, we'll see you back here every Tuesday for all new episodes of Cold Case Files 2. Now, on to the episode. She was still alive at the time. I mean, you know, she had this very, very distinctive,

like, breathing going on. He had this look in his eyes. I won't forget that look. It's just like the stare that you stare down a victim and if you say anything, you can be one too. Late on the night of July 4th, 1997, a California Highway Patrol officer spotted flames whipping up from an olive orchard just off the highway in Northern California.

When he went to investigate, he found the body of a young woman. She'd been murdered. Her body had been dumped and set ablaze. Why was this woman killed? And how did she end up in this orchard so crudely disposed of? In order to determine any of that,

detectives first needed to figure out who this mystery woman was. Then, eventually, they might be able to figure out what person, or persons, should be held responsible. From A&E, this is Cold Case Files, the podcast. I'm Brooke, and here's Bill Curtis with a classic case, Burning Desire. We're on State Route 99, and we're in the area where Fresno County and Madera County meet. Ben Grasmuck is an officer for the California Highway Patrol. Just before midnight, Grasmuck sweeps his beat, a lonely stretch along Highway 99.

And when we were still on the freeway, I happened to glance over there, and I saw a fire. Grasmuck follows the flames into a nearby olive orchard. There, he discovers a body. The torso was on fire, and I could see her, I'll never forget, her two legs sticking up out of the fire towards me. I immediately knew it was a woman, and I immediately knew she'd been murdered. It appeared that she was relatively young.

Detective Kathy Starr responds to the scene. There was extensive burning to the body. The victim was lying on her back. Her legs were up and open. There aren't any homes in this area. This is not a widely traveled road here. So to come in here, dump a body, set the fire, very unlikely that you're going to be noticed.

Starr combs the orchard for clues and happens upon some footprints in the dirt. There were two sets of footprints. One appeared to have been wearing socks. The other was clearly a bare footprint. The prints and nearby tire tracks are photographed. The other was clearly a bare footprint. The prints and nearby tire tracks are photographed. Meanwhile, at the morgue, the pathologist determines the victim was shot twice in the head. Starr believes the victim was shot dead, then set on fire in an effort to cover up the crime.

The detective's next order of business, ID her victim. If we didn't know who the victim was, we weren't going to find out who the suspect was. Starr puts out an APB on her Jane Doe and then begins the waiting game. There are a lot of missing persons cases. It's the Fourth of July weekend, so we were real uncertain as to how soon we were going to be able to identify this victim. I know, like I started to feel like something is wrong. Ruth Pimentel has an uneasy feeling. Her best friend, Andrea Bourne, is missing. Annie called me at seven and said she was on my way to my house, our house, and she was with Jay, and she never came home. And I think Jay's done something to her.

Jay is J.L. Travis, Andrea's boyfriend, and the last known person to see her alive. I knew his history, like I knew he was in jail. You know, I knew that he had guns and that he held them to Annie's head in the past and that she had told me that. So I really, I really thought that something was wrong. And I told that to the police. What comes to mind when you picture the perfect roommate?

One who comes when you call? One who doesn't forget to lock the doors? One who doesn't steal your milk just a little bit at a time, hoping you won't notice? At Apartments.com, we understand that when it comes to roommates, a pet can be your best bet. They're easygoing, eat when you serve them, and never clog the toilet. That's why we have the most pet-friendly rental listings on the internet. And with instant alerts, you'll know the moment your perfect pet-friendly place becomes available. So, when you need a place that's pet-friendly and human-tolerant,

check out Apartments.com, the place to find your pet-friendly place. We've got a very different kind of sponsor for this episode, The Jordan Harbinger Show, which is a podcast you really should be listening to. Jordan's show, which Apple named one of its best of 2018, is aimed at making you a better informed, more critical thinker so you can get a sense of how the world actually works and come to your own conclusions about what's happening, even inside your own brain.

In one episode, Jordan talks to a hostage negotiator from the FBI who offers techniques on how to get people to like and trust you, which sounds useful and disturbing at the same time. Another episode tells the story of a cinematographer who discovered a lost city in the jungle and made one of the most important archaeological finds of the century. Some episodes I think you'll love are The Conversation with Danielle Mestianak and The Conversation with Marina Nemet about surviving inside an Iranian prison. The episodes are loaded with bits of wisdom that you can use to legitimately change your mind

and improve your life right away. Search for The Jordan Harbinger Show, that's H-A-R-B, as in boy, I-N, as in Nancy, G-E-R, on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. This episode of Cold Case Files is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Most of you listening right now are probably multitasking.

Yep, while you're listening to me talk, you're probably also driving, cleaning, exercising, or maybe even grocery shopping. But if you're not in some kind of moving vehicle, there's something else you can be doing right now. Getting an auto quote from Progressive Insurance. It's easy and you could save money by doing it right from your phone. Drivers who save by switching to Progressive save nearly $700 on average. And auto customers qualify for an average of seven discounts. Discounts for having multiple vehicles on your policy, being a homeowner, and more. So just like your favorite podcast, Progressive will be with you 24-7, 365 days a year, so you're protected no matter what. Multitask right now.

Quote your car insurance at Progressive.com to join the over 29 million drivers who trust Progressive. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. National average 12-month savings of $698 by new customers surveyed who saved with Progressive between June 2021 and May 2022. Potential savings will vary. Discounts not available in all states and situations. Angie is the go-to place for everything home.

And they've made it easier than ever to connect with skilled professionals to get all your home projects done. If you own a home, you know how much work it can take. Whether it's everyday maintenance and repairs or making dream projects a reality, it can be just hard to know where to start and it really does seem never-ending. But now, all you need to do is Angie that and find a skilled local professional who will deliver the quality and expertise you need. Angie has over 20 years of home service experience and they've combined it with new tools to simplify the whole process.

Bring them your project online or with the Angie app. Answer a few questions, and Angie can handle the rest from start to finish. Or help you compare quotes from multiple pros and connect instantly. Which means you can take care of just about any home project in just a few taps. Because when it comes to getting the most out of your home, you can do this when you Angie that. Download the free Angie mobile app today or visit Angie.com. That's A-N-G-I dot com. Fresno police take down the missing person's report and compare the details to Star's bulletin about the burning body.

They have here is a white female adult in her 20s, 5'9", blue eyes and blonde hair. And that matched the information that we had taken so far on our Jane Doe. Dental records confirm the body to be that of Andrea Bourne. You just kind of, like, your mind can wrap around this and say, okay, this is what happened to my beautiful, happy, sweet daughter. Gloria Barnes is Andrea's mother. On July 7th, Detective Starr tells her Andrea is dead. She said, well, we have made a positive identification on the body,

and I'm really sorry to tell you that it is your daughter, Annie. And I just started to cry. They said, well, her body was burned beyond recognition. As a mother deals with her pain, Kathy Starr gets on with the business of finding Andrea's killer. She starts with J.L. Travis. Okay, the date is July 6th. My name is Detective Kathy Starr. In a small interview room, J.L. Travis tells detectives he had nothing to do with Annie's disappearance.

Insisting, he took her to a pool party on the 4th of July, then dropped her safely at home. So I kissed her, and she got out of the car, and she shut the door. After that, she started walking to her door. She opened the door up, and I drove off. He was avoiding eye contact. His body language suggested that he was not wanting to open up and be truthful with us. It was very hard to believe him because he wasn't consistent. Even when he was trying to act as though he was grieving for his lost girlfriend,

it was so transparent, it was almost laughable how little he cared. Detective Starr and Ginder question JL for hours, probing his story and searching for a motive. Eventually JL takes the bait, telling detectives that just weeks earlier, Annie had met someone new. You had become aware of Annie's involvement with another person. Can you tell me about that? I had paged her, because I put I love you in her pager. Then she had paged me back, and she told me, don't page her no more because she has a new boyfriend,

and he don't appreciate me paging her and i said oh i didn't know you had a boyfriend jealousy i think the victim was going to leave jail and i think he was having a hard time coping with that. Jealousy makes people do some strange things. Theories aside, detectives need more to put the cuffs on J.L. Travis. Starr then asks her suspect for a look at his feet. I was looking for anything on his feet that would be consistent with walking out in that orchard. We have abrasions in his feet and

small puncture wounds which could very well have been made by the debris in that field. Along with the abrasions, the size and shape of Travis's feet match up to the bare footprints found in the orchard. There were similarities, yes. The shape of the toes, the way the toes overlapped, the size of the big toe. With the evidentiary trail heating up, Starr decides she wants to examine Travis's car. We compared the tire tracks, and they didn't match in size or tire impression to what we had at the crime scene. There was no blood, even on the windshield. There was negative for blood. Nothing in her car. Detectives have an intriguing circumstantial case, but not enough for an arrest.

After more than 12 hours of questioning, Starr releases JL Travis. We knew we had our guy, and now it was just building the case so that we had enough evidence that we could convince a jury of that. We continually were trapping him in lies and inconsistencies. He was just not trustworthy. J.L. Travis has talked at length about the day that Andrea Bourne was killed. Now Starr takes her suspect's statements and tries to find the holes. He had mentioned to me that after leaving the pool party and driving Annie home, his cousin Kevin Mitchell was with him. So we went looking for Kevin Mitchell.

Mitchell repeats the same story J.L. Travis told, save one small detail. He was the one that initially told us that they were in Tracy DeVaris' car. Tracy is J.L.'s other girlfriend. He has two children with her. There was no reason to not think that she had been murdered in that car.

Even if she had been transported in that vehicle, there would have been trace evidence that would have been left. Starr pays Tracy a visit and asks to see her car. Her story is, well, I'm sorry, my car was stolen. How convenient that her car is stolen three days after Annie's homicide. And that she forgot to mention to us the fact that she had loaned that car to jail that time. Detectives don't believe Tracy Tavares any more than they believed her boyfriend.

Starr has Tavares pegged as a jealous and perhaps violent girlfriend. She wanted Annie out of the way, and we felt that she had the influence over J.L. that she could make that happen. I think we tried every tact we could take with her to try to get her to fess up, to crack. Detectives believe the best way to crack Tracy is to find her car.

Within weeks, the vehicle is recovered in the garage at Kevin Mitchell's mom's house. We're thinking, we've got our car, and we're going to find the trace evidence in this car. When we searched the car, this car was pristine. It was cleaner than anything you would get off a showroom floor. Tracy Tavares' car yields no connections to the murder. After three months, Starr gets pulled off the case and on to fresh homicides. It was very difficult to let go, yeah. Especially being so close, being so close and having to let go of it.

Andrea Bourne's murder slips into the cold files, where it will stay for three years until J.L. Travis's cousin resurfaces with a story to tell. Millions of Americans experience thinning hair. It's more than common. It's normal. But it's not openly talked about, especially amongst women. Going through it can feel lonely and frustrating. It's time to change the conversation and join the thousands of women who are standing up for their strands

with Nutrafol. Nutrafol is the number one dermatologist recommended hair growth supplement clinically shown to improve your hair growth, thickness, and visible scalp coverage. Not only that, but it supports healthy hair growth from within by targeting the five root causes of thinning, stress, hormones, environment, nutrition, and metabolism through whole body health. They have three unique formulas to support women throughout all stages of life, including postpartum and menopause. Each formula is physician formulated using natural, drug-free, medical-grade ingredients in consistently effective dosages, so you get the most reliable results. In a clinical study, 86% of women reported improved hair growth after six months. You can grow thicker, healthier hair and support our show

by going to Nutrafol.com and entering the promo code FILEZ to save $10 off your first month subscription. This offer is only available to U.S. customers for a limited time. Plus, free shipping on every order. Get $10 off at Nutrafol.com, spelled N-U-T-R-A-F-O-L dot com promo code files. Hi, everyone. This is Jillian with Court Junkie. Court Junkie is a true crime podcast that covers court cases and criminal trials using audio clips and interviews with people close to the cases. Court Junkie is available on Apple Podcasts and podcastone.com. See what's streaming free all month long during Amplify AAPI Voices on Pluto TV.

Watch shows like Kim's Convenience with Simu Liu and amazing movies like Meet the Patels and Jason Momoa in Braven. Plus, Pluto TV has hundreds of channels with thousands more movies and TV shows, available on live and on demand. Download Pluto TV on all your favorite devices for free. Pluto TV. Stream now. Pay never. You've been stewing about a health problem you have. You almost resort to texting your group chat to get your friend's opinions.

You're extremely unlikely to find quality medical advice in your group chat, but you can find it from a doctor on ZocDoc. Thousands of medical professionals on ZocDoc are there to help you. They listen like a friend and give you the expert care you need. ZocDoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance, are available when you need them, and treat almost every condition under the sun. When you're not feeling your best and just trying to hold it together, finding great care shouldn't take up all your energy. That's where ZocDoc comes

in. Using their free app that millions of users rely on, you can find the right doctor that meets your needs and fits your schedule. Book an appointment with a few taps in their app and start feeling better faster with ZocDoc. Go to ZocDoc.com slash CCF and download the ZocDoc app for free. Then find and book a top-rated doctor today. Many are available within 24 hours. That's Z-O-C-D-O-C dot com slash C-C-F. ZocDoc.com slash C-C-F. After Andrea Bourne was murdered in the summer of 1997,

it only took the original detective, Kathy Starr, a few days to come up with the suspect, Andrea's boyfriend, or possibly ex-boyfriend, J.L. Travis. His story is rife with inconsistencies. It only took a few weeks for Detective Starr to truck in the car where she theorized that Andrea was killed. But the car was clean, and without any further evidence, it only took three months for Detective Starr to get pulled into other cases, and for the Andrea Bourne case to go cold. It would be three

more years before another detective, Vince Zavala, would bring new life to the case and be able to track down an eyewitness. Every case deserves attention. This one cried for attention. Vince Zavala is a one-man team working the oldest and toughest cases on the books, the cold cases. Well, whenever fresh eyes look at a case, they may see something that the original investigator didn't see. In 1999, Zavala picks up the unsolved murder of Andrea Bourne and digs in.

The Madera County Sheriff's Department had focused on three individuals, Jacob Lee Travis, Kevin Mitchell, and Tracy DeVarez. When I reviewed the case file from the Madera County Sheriff's Department, naturally those three people jumped out at me as being primary suspects. In 1997, the three were caught in a web of lies. Travis and Tavares had been interviewed on five different occasions and given five different stories. Kevin Mitchell had been interviewed once and gave a completely different story.

Zavala begins the process of reexamining evidence and tracking down leads. Two months later, he gets his first break. I later discovered, by interviewing several people, that Jacob Lee Travis, by his own admission, did in fact possess a.25 caliber handgun. So he had the same type of weapon that was used to murder Andrea Bourne in his possession less than 24 hours before she was murdered. This began to put the wheels in motion. Next, Zavala turns to Tracy Tavares' car.

Tavares claimed it was stolen just days after the murder. Police at the time believed the theft report to be bogus. A set of prints lifted from the vehicle, however, provides Zavala with an opportunity. The prints were recovered during the initial investigation, but they were never compared to anyone. So we compared them to Kevin Mitchell. The prints belonged to Kevin Mitchell, putting him in line for a potential charge of Grand Theft Auto. Unless, of course, Mitchell is willing to talk. And they were like, well, you're running for Grand Theft Auto. And I'm thinking, oh my God. I just started crying and I was just telling him, look, I'm going to tell you guys the truth. We look for the truth. Kevin, of his own free will, wants to explain

the truth as he knows it. Am I correct, Kevin? Yes, sir. On March 15th, Kevin Mitchell sits down with cold case detectives and begins to talk. He was very willing to talk. In my opinion, on one hand, he was relieved to get it off his chest, and of course, on the other hand, he felt if he was truthful and cooperated with us, perhaps the arm of justice wouldn't hit him as hard. Mitchell tells Zavala, on July 4, 1997, he went to a pool party, then caught a ride home with Andrea Bourne and J.L. Travis. They were always talking. I mean, I couldn't hear them because the music was up loud in there in the front.

And could you see if it was a normal conversation? No, you know, it didn't seem like they were arguing or anything. According to Mitchell, the conversation between Andrea Bourne and J.L. Travis appeared to be normal. Until J.L. pulled a gun. It was all, it was close to her head, she tried to move his hand and she like screamed, J. And then it was too late. I can't stop him. That was basically the defining moment in the investigation.

This pretty much is the last nail. We have a strong circumstantial case, and now we have a witness to the murder of Andrea Bourne. I'm just basically like, I don't know what to do right now. You know, I was pretty scared, and he shoots her again. I was just sitting in the car, and she was still alive at the time, and she had this very, very distinctive breathing going on. I couldn't do anything to save her life.

I couldn't do anything. I wanted to, but I couldn't because I was scared for my life. As Andrea Bourne lay dying in the front seat, Mitchell says J.L. drove out to the olive orchard. He laid her down and he poured gas around her and then on her and then set it on fire and we left. He had this, like, this look in his eyes. I won't forget that look. He had this, like, this look in his eyes.

I won't forget that look. It's just like the stare that you stare down a victim, and if you say anything, you could be one too. Four days later, Mitchell says, JL and Tracy Tavares were back, asking for a favor. They called me over and they said, Kevin, I want you to get rid of the car. They said, don't worry about nothing, you know, it's the insurance to take care of it.

You said at some point Tracy gave you the key? Yeah, she took her key off her key ring and gave me her key. That was an important statement because we knew that Andrea Bourne had been murdered in Tracy DeVars' vehicle. Now Tracy DeVars, Jacob Lee Travis, and Kevin Mitchell have made plans to dispose of the vehicle. Mitchell tells Zavala he hid the car at his mom's house, then left town. After two years of legwork, Zavala believes his case is made. He has an eyewitness to the

murder, and finally, an arrest warrant in hand for J.L. Travis. I didn't find it unusual that he was still with Tracy DeVars. In my opinion, he felt safe that he was never going to be arrested for the murder of Andrea Bourne. They were living out in rural Fresno County on a piece of property owned by Tracy Navarro's family. On March 20th, Detective Zavala brings Travis to the Madera County Sheriff's Office and charges him with murder. He was shocked initially.

Initially, when I interviewed him, he was very remorseful. And at that point, I thought he may confess. And then he then snapped out of it and denied any involvement. J.L. Travis is packed off to jail to await trial. Meanwhile, Zavala turns to the woman he believes to be his accomplice, Tracy Tavares. Worst case scenario, I think she was involved. Least case scenario, she knew what happened and she was not truthful with law enforcement.

Zavala books Tavares on insurance fraud for falsely reporting her car stolen. She takes a plea and will serve no time. It's frustrating, but we can only do the best we can with what we have. Kevin Mitchell is never charged with a crime. J.L. Travis, however, does not get off so easy. On February 20, 2003, he pleads guilty to a charge of second-degree murder and draws 15 years to life. He wanted the best of all worlds.

He wanted this young, beautiful, intelligent woman, Andrea Bourne. He wanted the mother of his children, Tracy DeVars. He wanted his cake, and he wanted to eat it, too. I think he realized that he was losing her. And rather than... If he couldn't have her, no one was going to have her. And so that was the motive for killing her.

When you're the victim of this kind of crime, you don't have any closure. Gloria Barnes lives alone, surrounded by fragments of her daughter's life, a life that ended with a gunshot, a gunshot that gutted a mother's soul. It just never goes away. You know, it just kind of eats at you. And you try to go on with your life, and you try to find some happiness.

And then it just, it's like you're going through the motions. Jay Travis went to prison six years after he murdered Andrea Bourne, or Annie, as she was known to her family and friends. According to a website set up by Annie's family, Jay Travis had his first parole hearing on May 8, 2014. The hearing lasted about six hours, during which the two-member parole board listened to Jay and asked him questions. Annie was represented there by the California Attorney General's office. Jay said during the hearing that his other girlfriend, Tracy, had urged him to kill Annie, and on the day that they went to the pool party, he doesn't know why he shot her.

This explanation contradicts a letter Jay had written to the sentencing judge, where Jay claimed that he killed Annie because he loved her so much that he couldn't bear for anyone else to have her. Ultimately, Jay's parole was denied. His next parole hearing will be in 2021, at which point Jay will have been in prison for 18 years. He'll be about 50 years old. Cold Case Files, the podcast, is hosted by Brooke Giddings, produced by Scott Brody, McKamey Lynn, and Steve Delamater. Our executive producer is Ted Butler.

We're distributed by Podcast One. Cold Case Files Classic was produced by Curtis Productions and hosted by the one and only Bill Curtis. Check out more Cold Case Files at aetv.com.