Cold Case Files - REOPENED: Favor For A Friend

Episode Date: January 16, 2025

A husband and wife fall victim to a seemingly random shooting... and the key piece of evidence stays buried for more than a decade. This episode is brought to you by BetterHelp: Visit BetterHelp.com/COLDCASE to get 10% off your first month Greenlight: Start your risk free trial today at www.greenlight.com/coldcase  Homes.com: Everything you need to know about buying a house, all in one place

A March 8th, 1987, Ray and Rita Dumel enjoyed drinks and music at their local VFW. The couple left around 8pm and headed home in their van. Ray seemed a little off though. He pulled over near the Blanco Bridge and then passed out. Ray's wife Rita shook him and yelled his name, but she couldn't get him to wake up. It was before the time of cell phones, so Rita tried to flag someone down for help. A man in a dark-colored pickup truck stopped, and she was relieved that help had arrived. She wasn't relieved for very long, though. The man fired two bullets through her husband's window.

Less than an hour later, this call was made to 911. from A&E. This is cold case files. Rita had finally managed to get someone to stop and help her. They placed the 911 call and Detective Dana Peterson was dispatched to the location where the Dumel's van had been parked. He discovered Rita crying hysterically and 49-year-old Ray shot to death. This is Detective Peterson. Mr. Dumel was in the vehicle. He was in the driver's side. The side window of the driver's door is broken.

I recall one bullet hole through the roof and the other bullet had entered Mr. DeMell from the left side. Rita DeMell told the detective that her husband had passed out. Then she explained that the man she thought was coming to help was the one who had shot her husband. He may have been able to wake Mr. Duhamel up because the van rolls and contacts the suspect vehicle. The suspect gets real mad, according to Mrs. Duhamel, and starts shouting, no mother****** can run into my van,

or something along that line. The detective believed that the shooter broke the window with the butt of his gun, and that caused him to accidentally fire the first shot. Yeah, I think he would have just hit it and broken it this way, and that first round as his hand passed through that he shattered it,

it put the first round up through the top of the roof, and then he just continued down. Mr. Duhamel was probably leaning away when he was shot and that's why he was in that position. The crime scene evidence appeared to support that theory. Investigators collected two 45 caliber shell casings inside the van. The tire tracks at the scene seem to show a second vehicle pulling up close to where the Jumel's van was parked, consistent with Rita's story. One last piece of evidence discovered was a small address book

that was laying in the dirt close to where Ray Jumel was shot. This is Detective Gordon's own. Sometimes bad guys make silly mistakes, and that's all to our benefit, you know. So when we found the address book we figured, well, this has got to take us someplace. In the same way that I might call a person's contacts in a found cell phone to identify the owner, the police started contacting the people listed in the book. This is Detective Peterson.

But we just basically started calling the people in the notebook. Tell them we found this notebook. Basically, we're trying to identify who owns it. The book belonged to a local man named Norman Baird. He was 27 and, according to his friends, owned a dark gray pickup truck. The detectives paid him a visit to ask if he was missing the book. We just made a casual contact with him, non-accusatory, saying we just found this lane out in this area and do you recognize this book? His ears, and he was able to identify it as his.

We told him that we were involved in an investigation and we needed to ask him some questions on his whereabouts the day before and he indicated he'd not been out of town, that he'd not gone out by the Blanco Bridge, which is where the crime scene was, but he couldn't explain how his notebook had gotten to the crime scene. The detectives didn't totally trust Norman Baird's story, but they didn't have any evidence that would support searching his home or truck. So they went back to the address book and made contact with someone who identified

himself as Norman Baird's oldest friend. We're calling him Ron. We did everything together. You know, if you've seen one you've seen the other. If you had to hide from one, you better hide from the both of them. Ron told the police that he had been with Baird on the day that Ray Dumel was killed. They were at a party together. No, there wasn't nothing particularly bothering him. There was a lot of time spent over by his pickup with a few other people. But no, there wasn't nothing that stood out. Then Ron told detectives that Baird left the party to go to a job interview in

Marina, meaning that he would have been driving down Blanco Road when Rita Duhamel was looking for help. Ron's statement conflicted with what Baird had told detectives. This is Detective Stone. That was just another confirmation that Baird was not being truthful. And the more inconsistencies and the more lies you can catch a suspect in, the better for the investigation. The investigators developed a theoretical timeline for Baird's actions on the night

of the murder. Baird had been drinking at the party and might not have been as reasonable as he could have been. Maybe he had a little road rage incident and took it too far, shooting Ray Dumel and dropping his address book. The detectives filed for a search warrant and less than two weeks after the shooting, they were able to search Norman Baird's home and then his parents home. They started with the truck. Here's Detective Peterson again. We looked to see if there were any paint transfers on the truck, any damage or freshly repaired areas, and we found none.

While searching the homes, the detectives found a.45 caliber gun, but it didn't match the slugs that had been pulled from the crime scene. Having not found any physical evidence during their search, the detectives tried to question Baird again. The suspect wouldn't talk to them though. He requested an attorney. With no physical evidence tying Baird to the scene, they weren't able to make any charges stick and the case went cold. This is Detective Peterson. We needed a little something more to relate the suspect to the victim. We really just

don't have enough. We're just right there at the cusp, but not quite enough to push it over. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Imagine starting out on a road trip, the endless possible destinations waiting for you to discover them. What if you could navigate this journey with a skilled co-pilot, someone who helps you read the map, plan your route, and discover unexpected roadside attractions you never knew existed? Like an experienced road trip companion, therapy helps you explore the winding roads of your inner landscape. It's not about taking the fastest route, but understanding

the scenic detours of your emotions, making the meaningful rest stops of your experiences, and charting a course towards personal growth and self-discovery. I've found therapy to be extremely beneficial in my life. It gives me a sense of perspective that isn't always easy to find on my own. It's like having a GPS that shows the entire journey instead of just the next turn ahead. BetterHelp is fully online, making therapy accessible and convenient and serving over 5 million people worldwide. With a network of more than 30,000 credentialed therapists with a wide range of specialties, you can find the right match for your unique

needs. And if you ever feel like you need a change, switching therapists is easy and comes at no extra cost. So why wait? Start your journey today with BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com slash cold case to get 10% off your first month. That's betterhelp.com slash cold case. Homes.com knows that when it comes to home shopping, it's never just about the house or condo. It's about the home. And what shopping, it's never just about the house or condo. It's about the home. And what makes a home is more than just the house or property. It's the location and neighborhood.

If you have kids, it's also schools, nearby parks, and transportation options. That's why Homes.com goes above and beyond to bring home shoppers the in-depth information they need to find the right home. And when I say in- depth, I'm talking deep. Each listing features comprehensive information about the neighborhood complete with a video guide. They also have details about local schools with test scores, state rankings, and student to teacher ratio. They even have an agent directory with the sales history of each agent. So when it comes to finding a home, not just a house, this is everything you need to know all in one place. Homes.com. We've done your homework.

This message is sponsored by Greenlight. As we approach 2025, you're probably thinking about your family's plans, from exciting vacations to important budgeting decisions. But have you considered how to prepare your kids for their financial future? Looking ahead is important for your family and as your kids get older it's important to teach them valuable life skills like financial literacy. It's easy to do it too with Greenlight. Greenlight is a debit card and money app for families. It's designed to help kids learn about saving, investing, and smart spending in a fun and engaging way. One of my favorite features is the chores section. You can set up custom tasks for your kids, whether it's a one-time job or recurring

responsibility. When they complete their chores, you can reward them with an allowance right through the app. It's a great way to teach the value of hard work and money management. Plus, our house has never been so clean. With 2025 just around the corner, now is the perfect time to get started with Greenlight. It's the easy, convenient way for parents to raise financially smart kids and families, to navigate life together. Plus, you'll be joining millions of parents and kids who are already learning about money together on this platform. Start your risk-free Greenlight trial today at greenlight.com slash coldcase. That's

greenlight.com slash coldcase to get started. Greenlight.com slash cold case. 13 years passed, but Detective Peterson never forgot about the unsolved Duhamel case. It was always personal with me. It was the first homicide I'd worked that I really had a major role in. I always felt that this case could be solved, so it always bothered me. Peterson became the head of the County Robbery Homicide Division and in October of 2000 sent one of his detectives, Fred De Los Santos, to a seminar on cold cases. When Detective De La Santos returned, he was eager to put what he had learned to use.

Peterson suggested he look into the case of Ray DeMell's shooting. Here's Detective De La Santos. Detective Sergeant Peterson, at the time, always felt that the key person in this thing was going to be a friend of the suspect. De La Santos decided to re-interview Ron, hoping that time might have made him a little more open to the suspect. De La Santos decided to re-interview Ron, hoping that time might have made him

a little more open to the questions. When Ron was originally interviewed, he said that he didn't know anything that happened after Barrett had left the party. And he answered the door and told him who I was and what I'm investigating and told him that I needed him to come down to the office and he agreed to do it. The two men went to the police station and De La Santo started the questions. Here's some audio from the interrogation. I know you didn't shoot the guy. You're not the murderer, you're not the guy I'm looking for. Okay? And so today I just want a truthful statement from you as to what Norman told you. He told me something that happened out there, you know.

I crashed into his truck and some... State of mind was very erratic, crying, talking too fast. He did not know if he had hit anybody or anything like that, but Teddy had fired the weapon into the vehicle and he didn't know what to do. Ron said he took the gun from his friend not knowing what else to do in such an intense situation. In a situation like that where do you want the gun? Your hands or his? His hands, the whole public's in trouble, maybe. My hands?

You can't get it back. Can I ask you, did you destroy the gun? No. Did Norman give you the gun to get rid of it for him? If I was to answer that, it would incriminate me of it, wouldn't it? Detective De La Santos believed he was very close to being able to find the gun that had killed

Ray Jamel. He had started to waver by saying, you know, if I say something, is it going to incriminate me? And I kept assuring him that he was helping me in this investigation. So as he spoke to me, I could tell that he wanted to tell me something, and he knew where the gun was. He doesn't push though. He just continues his conversation with Ron. Well, you got an address I can go get the gun in?

I'll just drive over there and pick it up. It's, it's, it's not out of my address. Is it buried somewhere? Yes, sir. But I wanted to get rid of that gun. I didn't want it around where he could come back and get it. Is it buried somewhere? Yes, sir. But I wanted to get rid of that gun. I didn't want it around where he could come back and get it. So I disposed of it.

I buried it in the side of a mountain. Is it Old State Road or San Juan Road, San Juan Grade Road? I guess it would be Old State. Okay. Can you point it out to me? I hope so. Ron told the investigators that he had put the gun in an ammo box and buried it in a field next to a tree. The problem was the field was an entire acre and had around a hundred trees.

I thought we're never going to find it. This was just something, another thing that's going to end up being a dead end. Detective De La Santos was discouraged, but he didn't give up. He decided to ask for help from a group that was known for their expertise in finding things, the Treasure Hunters Society of Santa Clara Valley. It was formed in 1976 by a few friends who liked to use metal detectors and hunt for treasure to share their common interests. The group size increased and a lot more than just a few friends had become members.

On January 30, 2002, 24 treasure hunters with their metal detectors came to help search the field. This is Warren Whited, one of the treasure hunters. It was just hard packed cow pasture ground and we were coming up with bullets, nails and all kinds of other pieces of metal. As I got up closer to the trees I thought in my mind if I was going to hide something I'd need a landmark. These trees look like they'd be a perfect spot. I took off the scraper and scraped away about maybe three or four inches of leaves

and then started bringing down maybe three to four inches of dirt and I could make out the outline of an ammunition box. And so I gave a good holler, got a target over here and the lead man got hold of the officer and up they came. Detective De Los Santos confirmed it was an ammo box, like the one Rana described. They'd been buried for more than a decade. When they opened the box, they found a.45 caliber gun and cartons of ammunition. The investigators were able to lift fingerprints from the gun, even though it had been in the ground for over a decade. They sent the fingerprints out for analysis and waited to see if their treasure hunt had paid off.

After all that time, they got back a match. The fingerprints belong to Norman Baird. A fingerprint match alone wouldn't be enough to satisfy the prosecutor. It only proved that Baird had touched the gun, not that it was used to kill Ray Dumel. Investigators still needed to place the gun at the scene of the crime for the fingerprint evidence to even be useful. So, detectives sent the recently unearthed gun to the ballistics team to compare with the shell casings found in the Dumel's van.

The team was able to confirm that the gun in the buried box and the gun that killed Ray Dumel were one and the same. Fifteen years after Ray Dumel were one and the same. 15 years after Ray Jamel was shot to death, Norman Baird was charged with second degree murder. Baird pled no contest to the charge, meaning he wasn't admitting guilt, but acknowledged there was sufficient evidence to convict him.

He received a sentence of 15 years. Ron was conflicted about his role in the conviction. You never feel good about anything like that. Doesn't matter how much weight's off your shoulders, you still feel like hell. Because you participated in it, period. Whether it was brought to your door or not. Ron was a lot younger when he took his friend's gun and buried it in a field. But as he matured, his priorities changed.

When it happened, it was just me to worry about. Since then, you have a child, you get married, you have a second child, you buy a house, you got a mortgage, you got responsibilities. Life grows bigger and better and fun. And like that, somebody else's actions can bring you down. Rita Jumel attended the sentencing hearing in 2004. Six years later, she passed away at the age of 72. Norman Baird was denied parole in 2011 and will not be eligible to apply again until

2021. Ray and Rita's two surviving daughters still attend Norman Baird's parole hearings. Cold Case Files, the podcast is hosted by Brooke Giddings. Produced by McKamey Lynn and Steve Delamater. Our associate producer is Julie McGruder. Our executive producer is Ted Butler. Our music was created by Blake Maples. This podcast is distributed by Podcast One. The Cold Case Files TV series was produced by Curtis Productions and is hosted by Bill

Curtis. Check out more Cold Case Files at aetv.com or learn more about cases like this one by visiting the A&E Real Crime blog at aetv.com slash realcrime. and the sitcoms like Frasier. And re-watch cult classics like Higher Learning. Whether you're in the mood to solve a little crime before bedtime with NCIS or Tracker. Or curl up with a surefire hit like Forrest Gump. Pluto TV has thousands of movies and shows all for free. Pluto TV. Stream now, pay never.