Consider This from NPR - Are Trump's military picks based on merit or loyalty?

Starting point is 00:00:00 Before he was even tapped by President Trump to lead the Department of Defense, Pete Hegseth laid out how he thought the incoming administration should overhaul the armed forces. There's a chance to course correct it, but it would take the new Trump administration going after it really hard. This was on the Sean Ryan Show podcast. And at the top of Hegseth's list? Well, first of all, you've got to fire, you all, you've got to fire the chairman and joint chief. That would be General C.Q. Brown, who was the nation's highest-ranking military officer

Starting point is 00:00:31 until Friday night, when he was fired. Hegseth had attacked Brown for promoting diversity initiatives in the armed services. In his book War on Warriors, he questioned whether General Brown got the job because he was black. On Fox News, over the weekend, Secretary Heg Seth said he has quote, a lot of respect for Brown but that Trump had the right to dismiss him. There is civilian control of the military. Nothing about this is unprecedented.

Starting point is 00:00:59 The president deserves to pick his key national security and military advisory team. Other presidents have fired high-ranking generals, though none has fired a chairman of the Joint Chiefs. They serve four-year terms, often across administrations, and though they do serve at the pleasure of the president, they take an oath to the Constitution. Some Democrats say Trump's move undermines that. They want everyone in DOD to be holding to the president, not to the Constitution. That's the top Democrat on the Senate Armed Services Committee, Jack Reed of Rhode Island, speaking there on ABC's This Week. They want everyone there to do what they're told, regardless of the law. And Senator Reed had this question for Brown's successor. Will he have the ability to speak truth to power?

Starting point is 00:01:51 Consider this. The Trump administration says it wants a military built on meritocracy. Critics say it's building one governed by political loyalty. From NPR, I'm Mary Louise Kelly. It's Consider This from NPR. So this weekend saw six senior officers ousted by the Trump administration, including the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Also included the top lawyers for the Army, the Navy, and the Air Force.

Starting point is 00:02:33 And Trump named his new pick for chairman, retired Air Force Lieutenant General Dan Cain. To get a sense of what this shakeup at the Pentagon will mean for the military, I spoke with Frank Kendall until about a month ago. He was a top Pentagon official as Secretary of the Air Force. Secretary, welcome to all things considered. Hello, Mary-Lise. Good to be with you. Hey, so to be clear, your departure was part of the regular turnover when a new administration takes over, right? No, that's correct. Okay. The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, as you well know, this is the highest ranking officer in the US Armed Forces.

Starting point is 00:03:09 They are appointed to serve four-year terms. They also serve at the pleasure of the President. So just, it is within a President's powers to pick a new head of the Joint Chiefs, correct? It is. I've never seen it done before quite this way. Normally, Chiefs carry over from one administration to another very smoothly without any interruption. As far as I know, there was no reason not to do that in this case. You have concerns about General Brown being fired. Just lay out for us what they are. Sure. First of all, General Brown is one of the, if not

Starting point is 00:03:44 the finest officer I've ever worked with. One of the things that stands out about the military services in the United States is the apolitical nature of all of our officer corps. And I've been through a lot of transitions and I have seen in every case, very smooth professional transitions where people, they adapt to the policies of the new team in charge,

Starting point is 00:04:06 they follow orders as they should, and they give good advice. I wanna play a little bit of what, this is Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who went on Fox yesterday and spoke about CQ Brown. Here's what he said. I have a lot of respect for CQ Brown. I got to know him over the course of a month.

Starting point is 00:04:22 He's an honorable man, not the right man for the moment. Hegseth has in past shared his view that the Pentagon needs to be purged of, and I quote, the woke stuff. And he said that doing so would start with firing CQ Brown, who I will note is black. How do you think, Secretary, that this may fit into the stated overt efforts by the Trump administration to scale back DEI? I don't really understand the connection, quite frankly. I also don't understand the the obsessiveness about wokeness, whatever that is. You know, it's perfectly within the purview of a new secretary and president to change policies, and that's perfectly fine. And

Starting point is 00:05:04 I think all the officers who serve would carry out those orders to be a lawful order, it'd be no problem. There isn't much there to actually remove. There's a few hours of training a year. And again, I don't know what they mean by wokeness. I'm not sure what they mean by that at all. The impact of what they've done is to politicize these positions to agree that I've

Starting point is 00:05:27 never seen before. These officers serve a politically they are loyal to whoever's in power, they carry out their policies. And what been created by doing this is an environment in which career officers suddenly have to worry about their political alignment. And just to stay with the questions about wokeness, I hear you saying you don't even understand what that means. I think the Trump administration would argue that means diversity initiatives have been pursued at the expense of performance. In your long experience at the Pentagon, did you see that? No, absolutely not. We did pay attention to disparities in the Department of the Air Force. We had some studies that were done under the previous Trump administration that showed significant disparities,

Starting point is 00:06:12 but we never lowered any of our standards about moving people into positions or promoting them or anything else that was competitively selected. Do you know General Kaine, President Trump's pick for chairman? Is he qualified? I do. I have no reason to say that he's not qualified, except for the fact that he does not have the experience that is normally associated with that job. Normally, and by law, a person who goes into the chairman's job, chairman of the Joint Chiefs, should have served as a four-star general in another major command, either as a head of one of the military services or as a head of one of the major component commands around the world. General Cain has not done that. I also want to ask about

Starting point is 00:06:55 the removal of some of the Defense Department's top military lawyers in this purge. This is not generating headlines as big as removing the chairman of the Joint Chiefs. Why is it worth paying attention to? I find that more troubling in a way than removing the other individuals that have been removed. He seems to want to have JAG officers who will say yes to whatever operational people want to do. Judge Advocate General's, which are the lawyers in uniform, basically. They're the people who administer the Uniform Code of Military Justice, the criminal law that applies to people serving, and also interpret things like the laws of armed conflict, or the laws that would restrict the use of the military against American civilians. So they have a very important role to play. They're professionals. They're not political appointees at all. So to just reach down within the structure and

Starting point is 00:07:49 remove the legal authorities that would constrain the behavior of the military, ensure that the military follows lawful orders, is very troubling to me. Retired Air Force Secretary Frank Kendall, thank you for speaking with us. Thank you, Mary Louise. Good to be with you. This episode was produced by Jason Fuller and Connor Donovan. It was edited by Courtney Dornig and Nadia Lancy. Our audio engineer is Ted Mebane. Our executive producer is Sammy Yenigan. It's Consider This from NPR. I'm Mary Louise Kelly.

Consider This from NPR - Are Trump's military picks based on merit or loyalty?

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.