Consider This from NPR - How Parking Explains Everything

Episode Date: May 9, 2023

No matter how you measure it, there is a lot of parking in the U.S. According to some estimates there are as many as six parking spaces for every car. Put another way, America devotes more square footage to storing cars than housing people.Henry Grabar walks through how we got here, and what Americans have sacrificed on the altar of parking. From affordable housing to walkable neighborhoods to untold hours spent circling the block, hunting for a free spot. His new book is Paved Paradise: How Parking Explains the World.In participating regions, you'll also hear a local news segment to help you make sense of what's going on in your community.Email us at [e-mail] more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy

Hey there, it's Scott Detrow coming to you on Black Friday, historically the day when the most Americans are outdoing shopping, which means that the huge parking lots around malls and shopping centers are as full as they get. So we thought we would take this opportunity to share an encore episode about the hidden costs of all that parking. This episode originally aired in 2023. It was hosted by my co-host, Juana Summers. The wrong parking spot can really ruin your day. Amy Kandyan learned that. the hard way one afternoon last August. She was picking up her daughter from an appointment in downtown Washington, D.C., got there a little behind schedule. I said, you know, we will just go back to the car and go home. Sorry, I was late.

And then I began walking and realize all of these garages look the same. That's when Amy realized she had no idea where she'd parked. She paid cash, so she didn't have a ticket or receipt. Her phone hadn't loved the location. She did have one photo of her parked car. I usually do that so that if I get lost when I get back to this garage, then I'll have an idea of where it is in that garage. Not thinking that I would lose the actual garage. So for three hours, Amy and her daughter went from garage to garage checking with parking attendants, looking for her car.

I began to unravel because I feel like. like a terrible mom. I feel like a terrible human. And who loses their car? Eventually, she gave up, had her husband come pick them up. The next day, she started calling garages, and her husband drove downtown and kept hunting. Nothing. Amy posted about the ordeal on Facebook. The post got shared, and soon she started getting messages, online sleuths from Washington and all around the world. I mean, when people from Scotland are saying, oh, you know, I'm so worried about your car, you start to think, is this really happening? Eventually, someone on the internet recognized the garage. A woman named Brandy said she worked nearby

and could scout it out on her break. And she did, and she took a photo of the car. And I just could not believe it was kind of like a game show almost. The thing is, losing a car like this isn't that uncommon. When the Washington Post wrote up Amy Kandyan's story, they called it a rite of passage in D.C. And sure enough, a nearly identical saga unfolded again just a couple months ago. A Washington visitor lost their car for four days before a crowdsourced Reddit search helped find it. There really are just tons of garages in American cities. A lot of them are owned by the same companies, it's kind of like Starbucks. It's like they're all over the place and some are across the street from each other.

You know, it's easy to sort of get lost in them. Consider this. Parking is such a fact of life that you can overlook how much it shapes the places we live. Parking is the largest single land use in many American cities. If we were designing society from scratch, would we have placed car storage on the pedestal that it now occupies? Coming up, we'll hear from a writer who argues that the way America handles parking is costing us time, money, and housing. From NPR, I'm Juana Summers. It's consider this from NPR.

Parking tends to bring out strong emotions, whether it's in a neighborhood meeting or a fight over a curbspot as documented on Seinfeld. Hey, what are you doing? I think I'm parking my car. You can't do that. You can't just sneak in from the bank like that. I'm not sneaking. Henry Grubar says that's not surprising when you think about how profound parking actually is. Parking is nothing less than the link between driving, which we all do every day, and life itself, whatever you came into the car to do in the first place.

He's been thinking a lot about parking, philosophically and practically for his new book. It's called Paved Paradise. how parking explains the world. And it is an argument that parking is broken in the U.S. And that if we fixed it, we could fix a lot of other problems, too, especially the nation's housing shortage. That's where my conversation with Henry Grabar starts. You know, one of the things that immediately jumped off the page for me when I was reading your book is the fact that, by square footage, there is more housing for each car in this country than there is housing for each person. And on its face, I have to say, that statement feels incredibly problematic, but is it? I don't think it's that surprising when you start to think about it. I mean, there are more, we build more three car garages in this country than we build one bedroom apartments.

Almost every jurisdiction in this country requires parking as a part of every single building type, whether you're building a school, an apartment building or an office or a restaurant. The law requires a certain number of parking spaces. So we have parking minimums in every jurisdiction in this country, whereas for housing, we often have maximums. We say on this plot, you can only put one unit of housing. You can only put two units of housing. So the fact that we've ended up with a surplus of parking and a shortage of housing is no surprise. In fact, it's by design. Another thing that you pointed out in the book, an example that I just found fascinating, is that if the Empire State Building had been built to the minimum parking requirements of a modern American city, its surface parking lot would include 12 whole blocks. I really find that relationship between parking requirements and density fascinating.

Can you talk about that a bit more? Sure. If there's one thing that people take away from this book, I hope it's that parking takes up a lot of space and it is very expensive to build. I talked to a planner who described it to me like this. Everybody comes to the planning department and they have this project and it's like an ice sculpture. And by the time we're done whittling it down to make sure there's enough parking, what you wind up with is an ice cube. And I think that neatly summarizes the distinction between pre-parking American architecture, which is ornate and interesting and fills the whole lot and post-parking American architecture, which basically looks like a fast food restaurant surrounded by parking spaces. You walk through a number of examples on your book, but there's one that really flushes out how concerns about parking can block development of, say, an affordable housing development.

Can you tell us about the pearl in Salana Beach, California? Yeah, so I read about this in the L.A. Times a couple years ago, an affordable housing developer in Salana Beach, a suburb of San Diego, was trying to build a project for 10 families. And what happened over the course of a decade was this project was basically wrecked on the objections of local neighbors about a parking shortage, despite the fact that the developer was going to rebuild all the parking on the site at great expense and provide a little additional parking as well for the residents. And what this project shows me is the way that parking has become this kind of third rail in American politics, right? It's not acceptable to get up at a community meeting and say, we don't want any poor people to live in the neighborhood. But if you get up at a community meeting like this one in Salana Beach and you say, we are concerned about the parking supply, well, that's a legitimate excuse. I mean, and we should point out that some of the people that you write about in this book, they did say these things explicitly. One said, we don't need more diversity in this neighborhood. we already have the Mexican apartments down the street.

And it sounds to me like what they're talking about doesn't have a whole lot to do with parking at all. It's about race and class. Yeah, I think people have many reasons that they object to affordable housing in their neighborhood. But what I think is interesting about the Salana Beach project was despite the prejudices of the neighbors who objected to this project, what actually made the project fail was the requirement to provide parking and the lawsuit brought over the lost parking spaces. And Salana Beach is not alone. I mean, every suburb in America, every city neighborhood, has a project like this, an affordable housing project that's been held up or slowed down or made more expensive or reduced to fewer units because neighbors are concerned about parking. There have been studies of this, and parking adds between $30,000 and $60,000 onto the cost of every new unit of housing that's created. So that is a massive drag on our ability to create new housing, especially affordable housing,

where the bottom line on these projects is pretty thin and you really need to make every dollar count. And we should just point out to, I mean, the Salana Beach Project, it never happened. It never got built. That's right. That's the tragedy of the Salana Beach Project. Ten years of work for real people, low-income tenants who had been promised housing by the city and it never got built because neighbors were too concerned about parking. What do you think that a world, that a country with better parking would look like, and what would it mean to the way that a person walks through the world, the way that they experience their communities, the way that they relate to their neighbors and the people around them? The more parking you create, the more people drive. And the more people drive, the more parking you need to create. We have created this kind of vicious cycle of this sort of ruined urban environment at which it's impossible to do anything but drive. But there is another cycle. There is a virtuous cycle in which you create spaces with less parking, with parking that's not in front of the store but behind it, where residences are a little closer together, where streets are more walkable. And in an environment like this, it becomes possible not to drive so much. And reformers, they're not saying that millions of American households need to go car-free. I think they get it. America's a big country.

You need to drive for a lot of things. At the same time, half of all trips in big U.S. metro areas, cities and suburbs together, half of all trips are under three miles. So that's a distance that doesn't necessarily require a car. It just happens to be that we've built this environment in which it's dangerous and unpleasant and difficult to get somewhere any other way. One thing that defenders of parking say is, look, the areas that are super walkable and have really good public transit, well, they also tend to be really expensive. You've got to be either really rich or really lucky to live there. So if you just start getting rid of parking in a neighborhood before you've built that walking infrastructure, you're going to be punishing people who do not have the choice not to drive. What do you say to that argument?

Yeah, I'm very sensitive to that critique. I think that's one thing that we've seen in the last couple decades is that these sort of parking, challenged neighborhoods, which were slated for demolition in the 1950s and 60s, have become some of the most expensive places to live in America. Now, you could say that's all the more reason why we need to ensure that those neighborhoods still have plentiful parking to ensure that people who can't afford to live there can still drive there. But to me, free parking in an expensive walkable neighborhood seems like a pretty lousy consolation prize. I think the focus ought to be on creating more neighborhoods like those neighborhoods. Why are they in such

limited supply. That's the question we should be asking ourselves. And the answer is because everybody who's building a new neighborhood is confronted with the obligation to provide thousands and thousands of parking spaces. We have effectively made it impossible to build more neighborhoods like Wicker Park, like Santa Monica, like Fort Green. And it's no coincidence that those are some of the most expensive neighborhoods in the country. It's in part because they're so rare. Henry Grabar, his new book is Paved Paradise, how parking explains the world. It's Consider This from NPR.

I'm Juana Summers. Want to hear this podcast without sponsor breaks? Amazon Prime members can listen to Consider This sponsor-free through Amazon music. Or you can also support NPR's vital journalism and get Consider This Plus at plus.npr.org. That's plus.npr.org.