Consider This from NPR - Israelis Working 24/7 to Identify Hundreds Killed in Hamas Attacks

Episode Date: October 17, 2023

At a military base south of Tel Aviv, Israeli soldiers and medical examiners are working around the clock to identify remains of hundreds of people killed in the Hamas attacks earlier this month.NPR's Ari Shapiro visited the base and spoke with those conducting the work about the challenges of identifying so many bodies.Email us at [e-mail] more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy

People who survived the surprise attacks by Hamas in Israel can still recount vivid images of the carnage of October 7th. It was like an apocalypse, like everything ruined, like with bodies laying around. Dan Alam told NPR that militants killed more than 100 people in his community, a small kibbutz in the south of Israel. He lost neighbors, friends. The pain is overwhelming. I'm just grieving for my friends, my parents' friends, my community.

So I just don't know how to deal with it. But we just know we've been slaughtered and nobody came to help us. Another survivor, Noy Katsim, lost their brother in the attack. It's tough days. We're sitting here, Shiva, you know. It's seven days after the funeral. Judaism, where you sit and everyone comes and shares their condolences. But for those whose loved ones haven't been identified,

that mourning process may be on hold. Consider this. Forensic experts are still trying to identify hundreds of people killed in Israel in the Hamas attacks. Coming up, my visit to an army base in Israel where soldiers, medical examiners, and rabbis are working around the clock to identify people's remains. From NPR, I'm Ari Shapiro. It's Tuesday, October 17th.

It's Consider This from NPR. We are on an army base south of Tel Aviv, and the sun is sinking behind low clouds as the smell of eucalyptus fills the air. A man in uniform wearing a kippah is leading us to see this place that the remains of people who were killed in the massacre have been brought for identification. I ask you to respect this place. I ask you to respect the dead. Like many members of the Israel Defense Forces, Leahy is only authorized to give us her first name. She wanted journalists from all over the world

to see something that medical examiners, doctors and rabbis have been bearing witness to over the last week. And a warning, the descriptions her colleagues gave are graphic and not suitable for some listeners. We as a people can't remain silent for something like this. Colonel Chaim Weisberg is head rabbi of the IDF. A military spokesman named David translates for him.

Rabbi Weisberg has spent nearly 20 years in his position. He says, usually when a Jew dies, a family member says a Kaddish, this prayer for his parents. But here, we have entire families that no one's going to be able to say Kaddish for them. More than a thousand bodies have been brought here, truck after truck, full of human remains. People who were murdered when Hamas stormed across the border from Gaza into Israel on October 7th. Rabbi Weisberg breaks down as he describes in detail the conditions some of the bodies arrived in,

burned and mutilated. Young girls, elderly women, raped. Soldiers and citizens whose heads were chopped off. Many of the people identifying and caring for the dead are military reservists. They have day jobs as civilians. But since the attack, they've been here. Like a dentist named Mayan. She identifies people's remains by their dental imprints. Next to the identification place when we take place, there is family room to say goodbye to the loved ones,

to say their last goodbye. So while identifying, we can hear the screams and we can hear the cries of a woman bearing her child, of child losing his parents and stay orphan. And we hear the cry and we hear the screams and we're still identifying tirelessly. losing his parents and stay orphaned. And we hear the cry and we hear the screams and we're still identifying tirelessly, uncompromisingly, to give these fallen the last respect that nobody gave them. We walk towards the brightly lit white tent

where soldiers have been doing this work. It is difficult work and the details, as you'll hear, are brutal. One of the soldiers is handing out a packet of masks because the smell is very strong. People have been working in a 24-7 shift since the massacre began. Even now, more than a week later, there are still bodies that haven't been identified. The rabbi said they have three ways of identifying bodies. One is a loved one, visually recognizing the person. Another is dental records.

And the third is DNA identification. And he said, in too many of these cases, we have had to use DNA because the body has been so mutilated, he said, even in the case of children. There are about a dozen shipping containers refrigerated side by side, and men in white coveralls have just opened four of the shipping containers, and inside, stacked four high, are body bags. And some of the body bags are very, very small. And the rabbi says, usually when we're here we don't speak.

When you open the doors, you see that small sack. That's a baby. A light rain is starting to fall. A TV cameraman suddenly hunches over, sobbing. We walk in the misty drizzle to a small covered picnic table, the smoker's corner. And there, we sit in the dark with a woman named Avigayel. Like others, the IDF only authorized her to give her first name. It's hard to remember these days, but I work in high tech.

In Judaism, as in many religious traditions, there are rules for how a body is supposed to be treated before burial. For many years, Avigayel has done that preparation for burial as a reservist for the army. There's a concept of respect for the dead. It's treating every dead person with the dignity and respect that we'd want, the same as we'd want when we're living. We're also very conscious of, is the woman exposed on the table

and to try to cover up when possible. Any part that was part of the human being, we bring it to burial with the body. So if there are ashes, we're very careful not to lose any of the ashes. If there's skin that was torn away, certainly if there's blood, if there's flesh, we collect everything so that it's all buried with a body. When I ask what the last week has felt like to her,

more than a thousand bodies to be identified and prepared for burial, from babies to elders, she says for most of the last week she has felt very little. Blocking out feelings was the only way to do the work that needed to be done. Despite the fact that I was only sleeping about two hours per 24-hour cycle, and I was hardly eating, I felt like I had the energy. I don't know if it's adrenaline or the mission, the importance of the mission, and just keep going, keep going, do the work,

understand that it's horrific what we're seeing, but do our best to get the correct identification for each of the murdered women and prepare them for burial in the most respectful manner once they've been identified. I think in the last day

we've been slowing down just a little. We're making a lot of progress and so I think it's catching up with me a little. You're a lot of progress and so so i think it's it's getting it's catching up with me a little you're starting to feel the feelings the the exhaustion but it's not really the physical it's maybe part of it is the physical exhaustion it's the mental exhaustion we're talking about it a little more we have some psychiatrists and social workers that are talking to us after shifts but i think think it's starting to build up.

So yeah, I don't know if that answers your question. I don't remember what it was. How you're feeling. And it sounds like for a while you weren't feeling much and now you're really feeling a lot. Yes. As somebody who has done this work in the army for a long time, you've seen people killed in violent ways.

How has this been different from the deaths from violence that you have already dealt with over many years? I think it's different in two ways. The numbers are like mind-boggling. I still, you know, I'm at it and at it and I can't wrap my head around it. I go through the lists again and I'm like, wow, and I can't believe that I can't remember from two days ago what exactly. Was she the one that was in her cute pajamas or was she the one that was you know uh i don't know what the numbers are incredible and it's not just knowing the numbers it's seeing the amount and and the smell intensifies it's something that that i've never

you know seeing horrible deaths i've never had to deal with a smell at this intensity. And the other is, it's never felt this cruel. I mean, we're seeing bodies that were mutilated after they were already dead. What, like, why is, you know, it's harder to, I feel, wrap my head around it. This experience has obviously changed you. Has it changed your view of humanity? Has it changed your view of humanity? Has it changed your view of people? I think it's, it shattered something in my sense of security. It's certainly, you know, something in the sense of the equilibrium of the world, of the balance of good and evil. You know, I kept, for years

growing up, I thought that the world is improving. As a human being, as a woman, I felt like things were progressing in the right direction. I can't think that anymore, and that's shattering. Over our heads, Israeli military jets rumble through the sky. And as we drive away from the army base, a siren blares through the air. Every car on the freeway pulls over to the shoulder. People huddle on the blacktop from the threat of incoming rockets. Reminders that while people are still identifying the bodies from October 7th, the war and its death toll only continue to grow. Tuesday night, that death toll grew dramatically in Gaza.

An explosion hit a hospital. Hundreds of people were killed. Egypt condemned what it called, quote, a deliberate bombing of civilian facilities. The Palestinian ambassador to the UK called it a massacre and war crimes, posting an image of the building on fire. And the Palestinian Authority declared three days of mourning. The Israeli military

blamed Islamic Jihad, saying the hospital explosion was a failed rocket launch. It's Consider This from NPR. I'm Ari Shapiro.