Consider This from NPR - Your covid vaccine questions answered

Episode Date: September 3, 2025

The one thing certain about the COVID vaccine right now is that everything about it is changing.The Food and Drug Administration recently approved the next round of COVID-19 vaccines for the fall season, but it’s significantly changed just WHO can get it.That move comes amidst a broader effort by the Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. to change policy and guidance around many vaccines. At this point — we’re guessing you have lots of questions about vaccination in general, but especially around COVID shots.That’s why we asked our NPR listeners to submit their questions about the FDA’s new COVID vaccine guidance.UCSF infectious disease doctor Dr. Peter Chin-Hong answers your questions. For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org. Email us at [e-mail] episode was produced by Brianna Scott. It was edited by Courtney Dorning.Our executive producer is Sami Yenigun.Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoicesNPR Privacy Policy

One thing's certain about the COVID vaccine right now is that everything about it is changing. New rules are now causing some confusion over who can and cannot get the updated COVID-19 shot. Growing confusion over the COVID vaccine. CVS, the nation's largest pharmacy chain, is now limiting access to the vaccine in some states, even as COVID cases rise. CBS told us that you do have to have a prescription from your doctor to get the vaccine. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and other top Trump, administration health officials say that at this point in the pandemic, most people have so much immunity, they don't have to keep getting shot after shot after shot. So the new updated COVID

vaccine shots have so far only been approved for people who are at increased risk of getting really sick from COVID. That's been defined as people who are 65 or older or any young people who have other health issues that make COVID especially risky. Health experts like Michael Osterholm are concerned. These vaccines can save lots. We have demonstrated time and time again that they are very important in reducing serious illness, hospitalizations, and deaths. And that, in the end, is a very, very powerful tool to be used, not to be restricted. This is unfortunately another disaster waiting to happen. On Wednesday, California, Oregon, and Washington State launched a new West Coast Health Alliance.

The goal, the governors of those states say, to provide clear and transparent communication about all vaccines. So consider this. comes to the COVID vaccine, it can be hard to know what to do, especially as the guidelines evolve and leadership in public health changes. Coming up, a physician answers your questions directly to help you navigate this moment. From NPR, I'm Juana Summers. It's consider this from NPR. The changing FDA guidance has probably left many of you with questions about vaccination in general, but especially around COVID shots. So we asked our NPR listeners to submit their questions about the new COVID vaccine guidance.

And we called up Dr. Peter Chen Hong to answer those questions. questions. He's an infectious disease expert with the University of California, San Francisco, and we started our conversation, looking at how this new guidance differs from the past. In the past, it was just very simple. It was simply those who were six months and older, regardless of health status, regardless of health access to talking to a provider. It was pretty straightforward. You can go up to Walgreens or CVS, rule up your arms, and you can have it. I think one thing that a lot of people, including myself, I have to say, are wondering is just how big of a risk is COVID right now? Well, COVID is existing in two worlds. And I think that's why it's hard. For most people, it's not a big issue, not like 2020. But for some people, it's like it's 2020 all over again. Those are the people I'm still seeing in the hospital. They tend to be older, particularly older in 75. And they might have gotten a lot of vaccines early in the pandemic, but didn't get one in the last.

last year or so. All right, I want to bring in our first listener question, and this is a topic that we got multiple questions about. Let's hear from Karen Moore. She's 68 and she lives in Wisconsin. I know that all of us over age 65 need to be vaccinated twice a year. How does the FDA deem that an under 65 adult is high enough risk to be worthy of getting the vaccine? So just simply put, why ages 65 and older? Well, that's the people who are still driving death. and hospitalizations. It's kind of like influenza in a way or other serious respiratory illnesses. Even though the rest of the population have very high immunity, those who are older than 65 have a immunity that drops very quickly. And that's why we need to continue to remind the

immune system at least once a year. If you can do it twice a year, that's even better. But once a year is the minimum time, I think person older than 65 should have their immune system. Remember what COVID looks like. All right. I want to bring in another listener question. Now, Doctor, this is Sarah Corsi. She's 36 years old and lives in Maryland. What counts as a pre-existing condition given this new guidance for anyone under 65? My son had reflux as a baby. And I have been diagnosed as pre-diabetic. Are these pre-existing conditions? Do I qualify for my booster? So just to scope this out here, what health problems constitute the ability to get a COVID vaccine? If you're outside of those age groups that are listed. Yeah, so it's estimated that up to 30 to 60% of Americans, when you look at

the old criteria in any way, would have a pre-existing condition. They include things like obesity or asthma, even depression, diabetes, certainly. The problem is we are not really sure if that will be ratified but the new advisory board to the CDC in the upcoming meeting. And secondly, even if you have a comorbidity and your younger, how is it going to be enforced? Would the pharmacist just allow you to attest it and check off a box? Would you be needing a prescription? So those are the questions that I have, but again, you know, we will get more information in the upcoming weeks. This is a question that we actually got from James Holsey. He's 61 and from Missouri on that same theme. Will a doctor's prescription

be sufficient or will additional documentation be required? I mean, we know that for people who are outside of the FDA's recommendations, they may be able to get a shot prescribed by their doctor, but is that enough? Yes, so you can get a prescription from your clinician to get a vaccine, what we call off-label. But there are several issues with that. First of all, you need to have somebody write you the prescription. Secondly, the pharmacist has to accept that. They probably will, but again, we need more guidance.

But yes, the idea is that clinicians can give several things off-label historically, speaking, but it depends on the clinician, depends on the pharmacists. So there are a lot of what ifs in that statement. There would be some variability. And that's why a simpler rule is oftentimes better in the vaccine world. But nevertheless, some people will be able to get it that way. I want to move to a different population. And this is a question that's come up a lot in my own social circles. Let's hear from 41-year-old Bridget Valdez Kogel. She lives in Washington State. Are we able to get our children vaccinated with the new version of the COVID-19 vaccine this fall.

Now, Valdez Kogel has two kids, and we heard from a lot of parents who are really concerned about whether or not they're going to be able to get their young kids vaccinated. What would you say to parents like Bridget? At this time, we believe that kids 18 under will be able to have vaccines in the updated formulation. However, you need to have a conversation

with your health care provider first, and that's called informed decision-making or shared decision-making. So if people don't have access to health care provider, it may be a little bit more difficult. It will be seeing how the pharmacists will interpret that conversation to be able to give that vaccination. You may have many people getting vaccinations again in the pediatrician's office like before. The other issue around that is payment. We know that the FDA has already approved those who have co-morbidities who are younger,

but for healthy kids, even after a conversation, it may not be covered very easily by insurance. It needs to be seen whether or not various insurance companies will accept this. I want to bring in one more question, and this one comes from Jeffrey Seaman in Indiana. He is 62. I care for my wife who has several diagnoses that make her vulnerable for COVID complications. Are caregivers under 65 eligible for COVID-and-19? flu vaccines. Also, are nurses and health aides eligible for vaccines? Dr. How do people who care for a work with vulnerable immunosuppressed populations fit into this current FDA COVID vaccine guidance?

That's a great question. Right now, if you're a healthcare worker, you're under 65, you have no comorbidities. You will not be able to get the vaccine unless you have a prescription and it's prescribed off-label. This is different from some other countries. The American Academy of Pediatricians do recognize that people who live in households with immune compromise or vulnerable population should be a group that, you know, should get the vaccine. But, again, that's not what is available under the current FDA guidance. And then I do have to ask you a basic question that we got from a lot of people. How can a person actually go about finding a COVID vaccine in their area?

Again, that guidance is going to be changing as different alliances get set up, the West Coast, the East Coast, conglomerations, health systems, et cetera. But, you know, right now it's going to be the same system we've used, depending on your area, you know, looking at Walgreens, the CVS, talking to your healthcare systems. And again, it's very confusing right now. And, you know, we're looking for guidance as in the next few weeks. we've been able to offer a lot of advice to specific listeners questions. We've talked about a lot of specific guidance. But before I let you go, doctor, I just wonder, do you have any words of wisdom for people out there right now who might feel confused or lost given a lack of clear guidance? Again, what I try to tell my patients is that although it seems that a lot of things are changing and they are, some things are not changing. And that's really, those who are 65

Rhinola. It's very simple. You can still get your vaccine. It will be covered. Please get the vaccine. I'm seeing people like you in the hospital and it's completely preventable. And the next pearl is don't forget about early antivirals. Even if you couldn't get a vaccine and you're very sick, we still have Paxilovid, remdesivir. We can give those easily. You need to get an early diagnosis. And the third pearl is don't forget the ABCs of just any respiratory virus prevention. wearing that mask, if it seems risky, thinking about ventilation, washing your hands, and staying home if you're sick. Dr. Peter Chen Hong is an infectious disease expert with the University of California, San Francisco.

Thank you so much for coming on and answering some of our questions. Thanks so much, Warner. This episode was produced by Brianna Scott. It was edited by Courtney Dorney. Our executive producer is Sammy Yenigan. It's Consider This from NPR. I'm Juana Summers.