Crime Fix with Angenette Levy - Woman’s New Boyfriend Murders Her Former Lover Outside Ritzy Yacht Club: Police

Episode Date: November 21, 2025

Christopher Millwater was found stabbed in the heart and lungs on November 10 in the parking lot of the Stony Brook Yacht Club on Long Island. In the months before Millwater was murdered, his ex-girlfriend, Kacy Corso, posted on Facebook about him calling Millwater a "grave robber" and accusing him of vandalizing a memorial. Now Corso and her new boyfriend, Victor Panebianco, are accused of cornering Millwater in the parking lot and murdering him. Law&Crime's Angenette Levy goes over the allegations in this episode of Crime Fix – a daily show covering the biggest stories in crime.PLEASE SUPPORT THE SHOW: If you’re ever injured in an accident, you can check out Morgan & Morgan. You can submit a claim in 8 clicks or less without having to leave your couch. To start your claim, visit: https://www.forthepeople.com/CrimeFixHost:Angenette Levy  https://twitter.com/Angenette5Guest: Dave SarniProducer:Jordan ChaconCRIME FIX PRODUCTION:Head of Social Media, YouTube - Bobby SzokeSocial Media Management - Vanessa BeinVideo Editing - Daniel CamachoGuest Booking - Alyssa Fisher & Diane KayeSTAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:Watch Law&Crime Network on YouTubeTV: https://bit.ly/3td2e3yWhere To Watch Law&Crime Network: https://bit.ly/3akxLK5Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: https://bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletterRead Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: https://bit.ly/3td2IqoLAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lawandcrime/Twitter: https://twitter.com/LawCrimeNetworkFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/lawandcrimeTwitch: https://www.twitch.tv/lawandcrimenetworkTikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@lawandcrimeSee Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Wondery Plus subscribers can binge all episodes of this Law and Crimes series ad-free right now. Join Wondry Plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Hey, guys, we just did the box opening with Shela. And I'm on day two. I didn't wash today, but we are going to put some of the hair-fitting defense in. That was Christopher Milwater. On his Facebook page days before, he was murdered at a marina on Long Island. Now his ex is accused of murdering him.

I go through the stunning case and the social media posts that will likely play a big role in the case. I'm Ann Jeanette Levy, and this is Crime Fix. Morgan and Morgan wins a lot. That's why they're one of America's largest personal injury law firms. The firm has more than a thousand lawyers who have recovered $25 billion. for more than 500,000 clients. In the last few months alone, a client in Florida got $12 million

when the insurance company offered just $350,000. In PA, another client was awarded $26 million. That's 40 times the insurers offer. Morgan and Morgan makes it really easy to fight for what you deserve. You can even start a claim from your phone. So if you are ever injured, you can start a claim at for the people.com slash crime fix. Click the link below or scan that QR code that you see.

See right there on your screen. Casey Corso is accused of teaming up with her boyfriend to murder her ex-boyfriend Christopher Milwater. The case is out of Suffolk County, Long Island, just outside of New York City. Christopher Milwater was murdered in Stony Brook early in the morning on November 10th. Casey Corso is now charged with second-degree murder in Christopher Milwater's death, and prosecutors say her current boyfriend is her co-consumcision. Spiritor. His name is Victor Paine Bianco. Corso and Millwater had been a couple at some point,

but that relationship appears to have ended in the summer. When exactly, we don't know for sure. But over the summer, Casey Corso, she posted many, many things on her Facebook page about Christopher Millwater. There was one post on July 15th where Corso talked about relationships and how they can end. Corso wrote, The monster you saw at the end of the relationship that, it's who he was, not the sweet words he said in the beginning, not the charm, the affection, or the promises that kept you hooked. The version of him you met when things stopped going his way, when you stopped tolerating the disrespect, when you finally started choosing yourself, that version was the truth. Because love doesn't vanish overnight, real love doesn't turn cruel,

cold, or careless when questioned or challenged. But manipulation does, ego does, control does. man who only treats you well when you're quiet, obedient, and putting up with his behavior isn't loving you. He's using your silence as comfort and your loyalty as a cushion. And when that loyalty runs out, when the lies stop working and the mask slips the rage, the gaslighting, the emotional withdrawal and the cruelty are not a bad moment. That's who he's always been underneath the surface. You were just too in love, too hopeful, too forgiving to see it. And that's not your shame to carry. It's your strength because now you do see it. The way he spoke to you when he was angry, the way he blamed you for everything, how easily he could walk away, how quickly he replaced

love with hate, those weren't glitches in his character. Those were the parts of him he was always hiding. And the truth is, you didn't lose a good man. You let go of a version of him that never actually existed. So don't question your worth because of the way he treated you at the end, if anything. Let that version be your closure. Because the man who truly loved you would never have become the villain in your story. He would have been the one who fought to protect you, not destroy you, when the story stopped going his way. Remember, the mask always falls. Believe what you saw when it did. Now, is this post about Christopher Millwater specifically? We don't know for sure, but we do know she posted about him on July 26th, 11 days later. On that date, Corso posted. Whoever knows,

knows Christopher Milwater. He is a grave robber who T.F. steals a marker to a person's final resting place because he can't accept no for an answer or won't accept. I don't want to be with him. As you can see, PsychoMuch, if anyone knows him better, talks some sense into him before it's too late. Now, under the post, there are photos of some type of memorial with a marker near a play set. It looks like a brick. There are also what appear to be messages from Christopher. Christopher Millwater to Corso. One says, I play for real. You should get it in time, knocking on a set of doors, knocking on heaven's doors. Let's play a game just for pretend, could we play a game? You have the weekend. Another screen grab of a message says, got money for road trips all of the sudden. Keep rubbing it in. Keep trying to push me over the edge. Casey Lee Cowell. Casey Cowell appears to be a name used by Casey Corso. It's part of her Facebook page's URL. Christopher Milwater, he was loved by his family and friends, and they spoke very highly of him on social media. He loved the water and he loved to fish. Sadly, on November 8th, Christopher Milwater posted on

Facebook, plenty of time to rest when I'm dead, so now it's a quick shower and gym time. Less than 48 hours later after that post, Christopher Milwater was dead in the parking lot of the Stony Brook Yacht Club. The complaint charging Casey Corso with second degree murder states the defendant in the parking lot of 21 Shore Road, Stony Brook in the town of Brookhaven, Suffolk County, New York, on or about November 10th, 2025, approximately between 336 hours and 340 hours, with intent to cause the death of another person, Christopher Milwater, caused the death of Christopher Milwater in that the defendant while acting in concert with Victor Payne Bianco, date of birth, 821, 1993 did stab Christopher Milwater multiple times with a sharp object, causing the death of Christopher Milwater. The defendant prevented Christopher Milwater from escaping by blocking his motor vehicle with her motor vehicle and thereafter, crashing her motor vehicle into his motor vehicle. Suffolk County prosecutors said during Casey Corso's arraignment that Victor Payne Bianco stabbed Milwater in the heart and lungs after asking him about his past relationship with

Corso. That's according to a report in the New York Post. Prosecutors added that Payne Bianco stabbed Christopher Milwater in the heart and lungs several times. Now, days before, Christopher Milwater was murdered. He posted a video for a product he was advertising on Facebook. Here it is. Hey, guys, we just did the box opening with Shayla. And I'm on day two. I didn't wash today. but we are going to put some of the hair thinning defense in. Let's give this a rep. My lovely assistant, Shayla. Guys, it's one dropper full for my head's definitely going to be enough.

It's used only on the scout. So what we're going to do is we're going to just slowly pour it in. I'm going to get it all over the scout. Gentlemen, ladies, it's that simple. So joining me to discuss this case is Dave Sarny. He's a retired NYPD detective, you know, just across the river from Long Island. So Dave, your first thoughts about this case and the homicide, the murder of Christopher Milwater. Dave, I have me.

it's such an odd case. I mean, to get to the level of anger that must have been to commit this murder, and against all speculation and everyone you're innocent of proven guilty, but the reality is just the whole amount of circumstances is just very confusing because it doesn't seem like there's a real, I don't know where the hatred comes from

because usually when these type of incidents happen, there has to be especially stabbing, stabbings and shootings and the amount of stab wounds. You know, one time is usually a mistake and then there's repeated stabbings. You know, this is something that's serious. You're shocked at the fact that the violence toward it and the anger that was developed. And the anger transferred, not from the, just from the woman, but to the boyfriend now to do this.

It's mind-boggling when you look at these type of cases and don't see a real connection to reason as to why you would want someone dead like this. You know, it's confounding to me because obviously something was going on. In the summer months, something was happening. Casey Corso is posting these things on Facebook, which is really wild to me, that she's posting this stuff, and there's messages from Christopher Milwater, you know, that we believe he sent to her or to this victor. We're not 100% clear. But there's this allegation almost that he did something to a memorial site, and it looks

like it's near a playground, but he seems to be kind of like saying, like, leave me alone or whatever. So I'm very confused by what was actually happening between these two as their relationship appeared to end. Yeah, because, you know, we don't get a lot of social media on what the relationship was. We see that as an anger, but there must have been some sort of intimate relationship of some sort. Somewhere along the line, it had to be some sort of relationship where you can get to that anger. And that's the thing. And it was back and forth. And usually it's surprising. And I think that's why this case went the way it did because they were able to find them relatively quickly because there had to be some sort of connection that they had, either of maybe

text messages that they might have had back and forth that just developed this. But to see the online confrontation, it doesn't make, I mean, the social media confrontation, it doesn't make sense to create this type of incident to demurter someone based on that. But we don't know what they were doing together at one point because, you know, that's the surprising part. You don't have anything socially media-wise on that, but there had to be some sort of relationship to create that anger. And when she called them a grave robber, and you don't really understand as to why the grave robbing, what grave did he rob?

And then her new boyfriend gets feisty about this, gets angry about him, too. So I don't know what he could have done, what the victim could have done so much to create that, but you have it. And the good thing was they apprehended the people relatively quickly. Yeah, it does seem like they apprehended them relatively quickly. It sounds like from everything we're hearing from Suffolk County police that Victor and Casey went to North Carolina. And then Casey returns from North Carolina.

And they pick her up. They scoop her up on a Wednesday night. And then she appears in court on a Thursday. And then Victor, they've got him in custody in North Carolina, and they're going to bring him back and charge him with second-degree murder. I mean, second-degree murder, that's in New York, in New York State. That's an intentional murder. So there is no like, I mean, it doesn't sound like they think that this was, at least the prosecutors don't believe this is like a self-defense case or anything like that. No, because I guarantee you that's the thing.

They come back. And when anytime these old confrontation take place, you know, look for injuries. They left the scene. And again, this is the, I'm going to tell you, the Suffolk County is very big. Police department there is very quiet. They don't tell you anything, which is good because you want to keep these type of cases quiet. You don't want to leak out of information. But the information you have, I guarantee you they probably went to the cell phone. They had everything. They went to cell sites. They went to all this, that part of it. So they were able to connect the connectivity to her to him. And interviews with family and friends

of Christopher probably also helped them lead to this, to this instance with this girl, with course out, which is just, it's still, you know, they, it's amazing that they got, I mean, they stabbed this guy repeatedly for some, uh, action he did. And it doesn't make sense to this. It's that's, and that's why it's an intent death cause death. Just kill them. They block her from leaving and they kill them. Well, yeah, that's the thing, too. And, and I kind of want to pull up the complaint because the complaint details of what they believed happened. And this makes me think, potentially that they may have surveillance video of this confrontation. I mean, these days, Dave, there are cameras everywhere. You can't go anywhere. You can't walk up to somebody's front

door without being on camera. So because they have all these details in the complaint that I'm going to put up on the screen right now, it makes it sound like they know exactly what happened. So this complaint that I've got right up on the screen right now, it basically says that Victor Payne Bianco stabbed him with a sharp object causing his death and the defendant, Casey, she prevented him from escaping by blocking his vehicle in with her vehicle and crashing her vehicle into his vehicle. So those are some very specific details that the police are laying out in this complaint. So that leads me to believe they potentially have license plate reader data on this? They potentially have surveillance footage that shows this. I mean, am I on the right path here?

Yeah, I would definitely look at that. And is there any witnesses they have available? It comes down to is how they know he was going to be there at that time. And that's what I was looking at, you know, as an investigator, you look at why now, why then? Could there have been an attempt to meet up or something like that? That's how they were able to meet or did they know he was going to be there? So you're going to look at everything. You're going to go scour at his. information, the victim's information, to a victimology. You're going to go into his phone. You go up on his phone, look at his cell phone, any cell phone messages, anything, any phone calls that are made. You're going to look at the, you know, post-event, you're not going to have that,

but you're going to have a pre-event. You're going to look at the pre-event, what led up to that. And that's what they're looking to do. And that's, I gather that they have probably some video on that, video surveillance, what they probably have on that, alongside any witnesses they have. and you know we only see a little bit of what corso has on social media what was how did they know they went you know the north carolina thing they moved down there so they had her phone they probably were tracking her phone also and sell site searches that you're doing in that area what cell phones are on that area at the time and those things you know if they're on we can find out that way too um you know one thing that is very interesting to me is the fact that Christopher milwater he was a fisherman i mean the photograph on his obituary shows him holding a big fish. And from looking at his Facebook page, it looks like he often potentially went to the yacht club or went out to the water in the early morning hours. I mean, that's when a lot of these people who fish like to go out fishing. I guess that's when the fish are most active. If I'm wrong about that, fisherman, you know, sorry, forgive me.

But I'm just saying, like, maybe they were aware of that, aware of his habits, or potentially the allegation might be that they were following him, which is really scary. And I'm like, what is going on here? Like, oh, there is just a lot. We don't know. But they either knew his patterns and knew his schedule. Maybe he was a creature of habit or they were following him. Yeah, that's the thing. You know, it's just that that's why all this will come out as the, as the case continues onward. Because, you know, when you make the arrest, it's not just the arrest, but the investigation that follows. Because we don't, no case ends with just the arrest. So you're going to follow up with the investigation.

So you're going to hear more about this as it goes through, if it goes to trial at all, because sooner or later, once the prosecutor has all their details, they forward it to the defense attorney. And the defense attorney is to decide whether or not to, we'll keep on this case. We'll fight this case. We'll fight at a trial or maybe we'll plea out. But it comes back to the same thing. It's like, what did he do that created such an anger that you would then want him dead? And you don't really see that right now. but the fact is someone is murdered and as in best as cops saw we we concern ourselves about the facts and the totality of circumstances and it led to find out that that chris is murdered by allegedly by corso and the boyfriend yeah i mean it's just really uh really bizarre and you know the cops obviously are being tight-lipped but in court the prosecutor said that victor pain bianco stabbed

Christopher in the heart in the lungs several times. I mean, that is, that is a heinous, heinous, heinous, up-close, personal type of crime, Dave. I mean, that takes some, I don't know, it takes some hutzpah to, to carry out something like that. I just can't even imagine. Yeah, it's, that's the whole thing. And that's, you know, where did he get his anger from? I mean, he obviously transferred from the girl from Corso to him. And like, to just go, out there and a person you probably never met, and I'm going to say this, I don't know if the boyfriend had any interaction with him other than maybe social

media-wise, but to that level of anger, to go in and block him from leaving, like, you're growing, the allegations are she's blocking him in, he gets out of the call and stabs him repeatedly. And violent. I mean, there's no stabbing

that's not violent, but this is a violent death. And it's tragic in the sense that this shouldn't have been avoided. All you've got to do is stop talking and the relationship's over ended and it's an over relationship they're ended and it was a continuance somewhere and i'm not a psychologist or a psychoanalyst but she harbored such anger toward christopher for whatever malfeasance he is alleged to have done to her to get to this level is just still you know there are people's lives that are crushed by this you know

christopher's family even you know i don't know who course those family is but now they have to deal with this victor's family if they have a family if he has relationship so much lives get damaged over whatever is believed to be a there's nothing there that seems to be reason to kill somebody well and you know what dave is so interesting to me too these posts from july is where she's calling him a grave digger and all of this crazy stuff in july i mean that's months ago we're we're now in november that's we're talking for almost four months later so that's a that's some time that has passed i mean we don't know what if any anything was going on behind the scenes, but it certainly sounds crazy to me.

Yeah, like I said, relationships end, however they are, friendships end, but they end and you walk away. She didn't want to walk away. And I don't know if Christopher egged it on by whatever, any interactions that he had with her that we don't know about, but she harbored such hatred for him for some reason that to do that doesn't make sense you know people do things crimes of passion this is a crime of anger you know this is not a passion whether you're a jilted lover or anything she's called him a grave robber and something along the line that drove her to this level to then create that adam that hatred that

blind that rage hatred that she wanted him dead and not only do i want this guy dead i want to have my boyfriend do it that's just still getting all allegations until you know this goes through, but this is what you got right now. And it doesn't, in the world of investigations, we investigate the case as it is. But when you look at the reasons as to why, it doesn't make sense. Yeah. And the allegation that basically she blocked him in to prevent him from escaping, that almost makes it sound like he tried to escape, which is just really horrific and sad.

You know, I don't care how angry you are at a human being. Good God. this is the allegations here are horrific obviously these people are innocent until proven guilty but there is a lot of evidence on social media that it looks like they've created that could show some level of premeditation definitely premeditations i mean this is going on for july so that's why what they're going to do now is you have them in custody obviously they have attorneys you're now still going to do the more workup on both of them on victor and on victor and her and you're going to see other things. They're going to probably do search wants on their residences, obviously,

to continue on this investigation. It doesn't end with the arrest. That's why people have to understand we have probable cause to arrest. But when it comes to trial, we've got to prove that these people did this beyond a reasonable doubt. And right now, you're innocent to proven guilty in a court of law. So they have time to defend themselves. But the police also have time to improve this case to get to that level beyond a reasonable doubt. No doubt. Well, we will keep a close eye on it. It's just a really terrible case and a man is dead and shouldn't be. Thank you so much. Dave Sarni for your time. Appreciate seeing you as always. Yeah. Thank you very much. Stay safe. Now, a go fund me has been set up for Christopher Milwater's funeral expenses. It reads, my name is Corrine Millwater. Those of you who know me realize that one of the most difficult things for me to do is humble myself. My family and I are in need at this time. We have suffered a lot of loss over the past few years, this loss being the great. greatest. My brother, Christopher Michael Milwater, was violently murdered on November 10, 2025. Those of you who know him know that he showed up for anyone in need. At this time, my family

is in need of donations solely to cover the costs of funeral expenses. We understand that not all are able to donate, but would appreciate that you share and also pray for our family that justice is served. Casey Corso is in the Suffolk County Jail, and Victor Payne Bianco is in custody in North Carolina, and he will be returned to New York sometime soon. And that's it for this episode of Crime Fix. I'm Ann Jeanette Levy. Thanks so much for being with me. I'll see you back here next time.