Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - 28-year-old spoiled brat dismembers parents when the money stops

Episode Date: October 15, 2020

By all accounts, Joel Guy Sr. and Lisa Guy were loving parents, getting ready for retirement. When Lisa Guy doesn't show up for work, police make a gruesome discovery. The couple was found dead, disme...mbered in their own home. Who killed the Guy family?Joining Nancy Grace Today: Wendy Patrick- California Prosecutor, Author of “Red Flags” & Host of "Live With Dr. Wendy" on KCBQ Radio  Dr. Angela Arnold - Psychiatrist, Atlanta Ga. Steven Lampley- Former Detective, Author of the upcoming book, “12 and Murdered” Dr. Tim Gallagher - Medical Examiner for State of Florida Yvonne Thomas - WBIR TV, Knoxville, TN. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Everybody looks forward to Thanksgiving. I know we do. And I do the whole nine yards, the turkey, the dressing, the cranberry sauce, the sauteed green beans. I invite everybody over and we have the happiest time. And I want those memories for my children, John David and Lucy. How can something so wonderful for so many Americans go so wrong. How wrong? Well, let's just say mom and dad get murdered and mommy's head gets severed and ends up boiling in a pot on the stove. How much more wrong can it go? How did it all go wrong? Take a listen to our friend at CrimeOnline.com, Dave Mack.
Starting point is 00:01:11 Joel Guy Sr. and Lisa Guy were preparing to enjoy their retirement. In just two weeks, the pair were planning to move from Knoxville, Tennessee, to Joel Guy's hometown of Sir Goinsville, about 77 miles northeast of Knoxville. Guy had recently bought the home of his deceased mother. The Thanksgiving holiday was just ahead, and plans were in the works for a major family gathering for Christmas. But after the Thanksgiving holiday, when Lisa Guy didn't show back up at work, her co-workers were worried. They tried calling, they didn't get her, so they asked police to do a welfare check. That's how it all started. You were just listening to Dave Mack, our friend from CrimeOnline.com, but with me, an all-star panel, and you know them well.
Starting point is 00:01:52 First of all, Wendy Patrick, California prosecutor, author of Red Flags, and host of a brand-new program live with Dr. Wendy on KCBQ Radio. She's at WendyPatrickPhD.com. Dr. Angela Arnold, renowned psychiatrist, joining us out of the Atlanta jurisdiction. You can find her at AngelaArnoldMD.com. Stephen Lampley, detective, author of upcoming book, Twelve and Murder on Amazon at Stephenhenlampley.com. We often speak to medical examiners for various jurisdictions, but how often is there one guy, one doctor in charge of an entire state? With us, the medical examiner for the state of Florida, Dr. Tim Gallagher at PathCareMed.com. But first, a special guest joining us.
Starting point is 00:02:49 It's Yvonne Thomas out of WBIR 10 News in Knoxville. Yvonne, it's so great to have you with us. I wish we were meeting under better circumstances, but when I hear double murder, I got to know all the facts. Tell me, first of all, I'm imagining myself going to a crime scene and I take it all in. At every red light, I look around. At every turn, I check it out. I see the grocery stores. I see the buildings. I see if anybody's running up to me at the corner trying to sell me crack cocaine. Tell me about this area, because everything I found out that this was, what did we say, West Knoxville, Jack?
Starting point is 00:03:32 West Knoxville, where all the rich people live, which means low crime. Probably because they have all these private security guards rolling around. But tell me about the area, Yvonne Thomas. Nancy, you're absolutely correct. I mean, imagine this, a beautiful, nice neighborhood. Golden View Lane is where the home sat, where the crime did take place. But a neighborhood where you could freely walk your dogs, you knew your neighbors. And can you imagine them coming to this area where crime really just doesn't happen very often
Starting point is 00:04:05 and neighbors look outside? They see caution tape everywhere. They see police. They see detectives wearing hazmat gear going into that home. It was indescribable, unfathomable for many of those that were watching this and trying to figure out what in the world was going on. Yvonne Thomas, you just got my attention when you said hazmat gear. Guys, this is a beautiful area of Knoxville.
Starting point is 00:04:31 First time I went to Knoxville, Jackie, was for the World's Fair, and it was incredible. I think I was in law school at the time and took a weekend and went to Knoxville. Beautiful. People go there because the leaves change up in the Tennessee mountains and it's beautiful, scenic. And this would be, I guess, the most beautiful area of a beautiful area. You don't expect to see crime scene tape wrapped around one of the mansions and people going in and out
Starting point is 00:05:05 with hazmat suits. But happy Thanksgiving. That's what that's all about. Guys, take a listen to this. Guy Jr. spent Thanksgiving 2016 with his family. It was typical. Guy Jr. spent a, quote, smattering of holidays in this very house. This was his home. When Lisa didn't show up for work after the holiday, her coworkers were worried. You know, it's my understanding to you, Yvonne Thomas, WBIR, that the son, Joel Guy Jr., age 32, studying to be a plastic surgeon, he says,
Starting point is 00:05:42 and his two or three sisters all came home, and this was to be a plastic surgeon, he says, and his two or three sisters all came home. And this was to be their last Thanksgiving in the family home, the family mansion, because mom and dad, Lisa and Joel Guy, were getting ready to retire. It's my understanding they were both engineers. They'd worked their whole lives and they were finally retiring and they had bought Joel Guy's mother's home. She was deceased. So they bought out their interest in the home, everybody's interest, and were moving there and unloading the mansion. So this would have been the last Thanksgiving and everybody gathers together at the old home place for Thanksgiving. Do I have it right so far? Yes, and picture this. The last Thanksgiving in that home, they took a family photo that day to
Starting point is 00:06:32 commemorate there where the grandchildren are in the photo. Joel Guy Sr., Lisa Guy, Joel Guy Jr. were all in that last family photo at that home. But yes, they were preparing to retire. Joel Guy Sr. and his wife, Lisa, had already purchased that home in Sigourneyville, and so they were ready to make that move. You know, I'm just thinking about that. I've got to see that. Yvonne Thomas, WBIR, you've got to send me that picture.
Starting point is 00:07:00 I haven't seen that last family photo with everybody in it. And, you know, to Dr. Angela Arnold, psychiatrist joining me out of the Atlanta jurisdiction, I hope that my children, John, David, and Lucy, go to college locally because I want to be with them. I don't want them to go away. Of course, if they want to go away, fine. I'm not going to say anything. Yes, you will. Yeah, okay. You're right. I've already been saying, what about this? What about that? You know, just first of all, I've got to get them through middle school. That's my goal right now. Let me tell you, math and science are a challenge. But the only reason, I hope you're sitting down. You may need to lay down for this one, Dr. Angie. The only reason, correct me if I'm wrong, Yvonne Thomas, don't be afraid. The only reason Lisa Guy kept working is to support her son, Joel Guy Jr. Now,
Starting point is 00:07:57 this guy is 28 at the time, had been going to college at LSU for about a decade. He says he's working, he's studying to become a plastic surgeon. I've looked and looked and looked. I don't see that he's in med school. I think he's taken 10 years to get through his undergrad, not judging. It took my brother, I think, how many, six or seven years. He'd take off a quarter and he'd work. Then he'd go back.
Starting point is 00:08:27 Then he'd go back. He finally finished. So not judging. It could be any number of things, reasons why. But he was the only reason she kept working to support him. From what I can tell, he's never held down a job. He's 28, almost 29. And he's okay with that.
Starting point is 00:08:49 What human being is okay with that, Nancy? I don't know. When I moved out, I never asked my parents for another penny. Oh, when I bought my first house, I asked them. They offered to give me a down payment, and I paid them back pronto. Wow. them. They offered to give me a down payment and I paid him back pronto. But 20, almost 29 years old, never held down a job. What is that? Well, he certainly was enjoying. I mean, I think it's lazy. I think that he doesn't have any drive inside of him, and he had become very accustomed to this.
Starting point is 00:09:25 I wish that I knew some other things about his past and how he lived and how he was taken care of, but they are just aiding and abetting some very bad things. Hey, hey, hey, hold on about blaming the victim. I blame the victim. The dad wasn't supporting him. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Guys, we are talking about the deaths of a mom and dad.
Starting point is 00:10:04 How the whole thing happened at Thanksgiving. The whole family gathers in this beautiful mansion. They do the turkey. They do the dressing, the cranberry sauce, the whole nine yards, the family photo. And then the following Monday morning, Lisa, the mom, doesn't show up for work. Now, correct me if I'm wrong, Yvonne Thomas, WBIR, but didn't we just say that ending to retire, sell the house and move to the mother-in-law's house? They were retiring, right? They were finally quitting work.
Starting point is 00:10:34 That was the plan, right, Yvonne? Yes, absolutely. That was the plan, so much so that this was Lisa Guy's last week of work. She was retiring. Joel Guy Sr. was already retired, but this was the last week of work. She was retiring. Joel Guy Sr. was already retired, but this was the last week of work. And she had been hanging in there to support the adult son who had never done a lick of work. Their retirement and their move to a smaller home was not to be. Remember her boss, Jennifer, knew something was up when Lisa didn't show up for work. And after multiple calls to Lisa's home and sale with no answer, she had police go do a welfare check, which they did. Take a listen to our friend Madison Keevey at WATE-TV.
Starting point is 00:11:24 Before he's even inside the house, Detective Jeremy McCord is on guard. The door was warm. There was some kind of strange odor that I observed. I don't know if I verbalized it. I know that it was more or less just a feeling sensation, feeling very odd. There was something ominous about it. There were vehicles in the driveway. Nobody was answering the door and it was an odd situation. The door in the garage opens. They announce themselves. We're hit with heat. We're hit again with this strange odor. There is a pot on the stove, a large pot that you can tell that the stove is on, the stove top and the oven are on because of all the heat coming from that area. And it's very, it's very odd. You're hearing Knox County Sheriff's Detective Jerry McCord describing coming up to the guy home.
Starting point is 00:12:28 And it was incredibly hot. And there was a very odd smell that he couldn't identify. To Dr. Tim Gallagher, a medical examiner for the entire state of Florida. Dr. Gallagher, it's wonderful to talk to you as always. Although we somehow always end up talking about dead people. Dr. Gallagher, you know, I've told people before, when you smell a dead human body, you know what it is instinctively. Well, what is that? What makes a human body different in death? Well, you know, you're correct about that, Nancy. It's a smell that you'll never forget.
Starting point is 00:13:03 And as a matter of fact, when I did my tours through the high schools, I would bring them to the decomposition room and have them smell the actual scent of a decomposing body. And that is something that stays with them for years and years. You know, I remember going to multiple homicide scenes and actually having rookie cops, I see them start vomiting. I mean, not the sight. They hadn't even seen the sight yet, but the smell of decomp. Now, what's interesting here is you've got a seasoned detective, Jeremy McCord. This is not his first time at the rodeo, but he cannot identify the smell. And I know a seasoned detective, I mean, when you get to detective
Starting point is 00:13:46 Stephen Lampley, you're a PI, but long story short, you have to be a beat cop and then you work your way up through the ranks of police or sheriff before you become a detective. Isn't that right, Stephen? Normally, Nancy, yes. You have to spend your time on the street, which by department varies. In my case, it was three years before you could be promoted to really anything beyond a street officer at that time. Yeah, so this guy's already a detective, so I'm pretty sure he's seen his share of dead bodies. But he says it's an unusual, odd smell that he couldn't yet identify.
Starting point is 00:14:26 So what is it? What more do we know? Take a listen again to our friend Madison Keevey at WATETV6. I get in front of everybody and start clearing the stairwell to try and get an eyeball of what's above us. McCord says there are signs things aren't right. During this time there's a dog that's barking and the dog will bark and bark and bark and then the dog stops barking. That was odd to me. Most dogs when they bark and you're in their territory they continue barking. Walking through this house something he says he'll always remember. It's
Starting point is 00:15:04 terrifying because you don't know if somebody needs some help. I mean, it's just an odd situation. There's nothing downstairs that I'm observing that makes sense to me. To Wendy Patrick, California prosecutor, author of Red Flags, and host of Live with Dr. Wendy, KCBQ. You know, Wendy, I've heard it a million times, and I've felt it myself on multiple crime scenes and in other places. You get a feeling. This cop sees, this detective sees cars, cars parked in the driveway, but nobody comes in to the door. He hears a dog howling and barking plaintively, but then stops and starts again. The place is burning up hot.
Starting point is 00:15:47 The stove is on. The oven is on. The heat is on. Something is very wrong, but he doesn't know what it is yet. Have you ever gotten that feeling on a crime scene, Wendy? You know, isn't that the truth, Nancy? Because we sell ourselves short with respect to all the different experiences we bring to the scene. You know, we come in already trained by virtue of all the cases we've already done, all the things we've already read and heard about, and having been alive for as many years as we have, that we can tell when something's wrong instinctively, even Nancy, if we can't put our finger on exactly why we have the feelings we do. We can imagine how much more significant that is the number of years a trained detective has been on the police force. So that's absolutely right.
Starting point is 00:16:29 Somebody comes in and smells and hears and perceives all the different types of things that lead them to the conclusion that something terrible happened here. Now I got to find out what it is. I think of our minds like a computer, a giant computer, and we walk into a crime scene and we are processing so many clues at once that our mind may not embrace what all we're processing. Listen. Mrs. Guy's head was found in a large pot in liquid in the kitchen. The liquid in the pot had a slightly different character to it than the liquid in the plastic tubs. It didn't have the strong chemical odor. It had a slight odor of decomposition,
Starting point is 00:17:16 but it did not have the chemical odor like the bins upstairs did. And the skin that remained, the skin and flesh that remained on her scalp was different. It did not have the intact. In other words, the skin looked like it had heat artifact or what we call thermal artifact as opposed to a chemical artifact. The hair was still there as well. Dr. Tim Gallagher, we need you now more than ever. Medical examiner, state of flora, thermal artifact versus chemical artifact. I think I know what that means, but explain it to me. And regular people talk, please. Well, thermal artifact is a burn.
Starting point is 00:17:58 So when you're exposed to heat, flame, et cetera, you know, it is an actual burn created by heat, whereas a chemical artifact is also considered to be a burn, but it's more of a dissolving type softening burn. Whereas the heat artifact is a leather-like or very firm texture to the skin that occurs after it's been exposed to radiating heat. Tell me that one more time. One is leather-like? Right. The skin will take on a leather-like consistency or it'll feel like leather if the body is exposed to fire or a fire heat source. So that would be a thermal artifact. And then a chemical artifact or a
Starting point is 00:18:47 chemical defect would be one where the skin is being dissolved, dissolved by the chemical, whatever that chemical may be, acid or alkali or something to that effect. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. This mother, Lisa Guy's head, severed head, is in a pot on the stove cooking. That's what we're talking about. Let's take a listen to Dr. Amy Hawes, medical examiner. Take a listen. Like Mr. Guy, Mrs. Guy was also dismembered. There was some differences in the degree to which she was dismembered and the way she was dismembered. Her head was completely severed from her body. Her arms were disarticulated at the shoulders,
Starting point is 00:19:56 and her legs were disarticulated at the knees. So in comparison to Mr. Guy who had his legs disarticulated at the hips, Mrs. Guy's legs were at the knees. so her thighs were still intact. Her thighs were still attached onto her body, but her head was completely severed and her arms were completely severed. Much like Mr. Guy, the skin of her back was still relatively well preserved compared to her front where there was almost no skin left. And just thinking about this woman as a person, Lisa Guy, she worked her whole life as an engineer, had two girls and a boy, raised them, was married to one person her whole life, and just as she is set to finally stop working and enjoy the rest of her life, well, there's no nice way to put it. Her head ends up in a stew pot on the stove. But what about
Starting point is 00:20:57 her husband? Listen to Dr. Amy Hawes. The first thing to note with Mr. Guy is his rib veins had been dismembered. The arms had been removed at the shoulders. The legs had been removed at the hips. His head was completely skeletonized and there was some area of defect of the bone of the forehead. The bone in that area was in such poor condition that it was impossible to tell whether that was from the chemicals in which the the skull had been or whether it was from blunt trauma. There was skin remaining primarily on the back of Mr. Guy,
Starting point is 00:21:51 approximately from his lower neck around his buttocks, and the remainder of the skin was gone. The remainder of the skin had been dissolved by chemicals, and with the skin being gone, it basically exposed bare muscle. Is it the work of a madman? Or is it highly planned? Someone that is in complete control of all their faculties? Listen to what else we learn about the body of the dad, Joel Guy Sr. On the skin of his back, he had what I identified as 34 sharp force injuries. And sharp force injuries are either stabs or cuts.
Starting point is 00:22:43 These sharp force injuries, again, extended from up near about the area of his shoulder down to his buttocks. They were on both sides. The wounds ranged from about one inches in length to about seven inches in length and the maximum depth was about six inches. Associated with these stab wounds identified injuries to the liver, lungs, and kidneys, and ribs. Again, there likely was more because of the dismemberment process. It was some of the cuts, it was difficult to tell if it was part of the dismemberment process or actually a sharp force injury that occurred while Mr. Guy was still alive. She mentioned 34 sharp force injuries to Mr. Guy's back. He had a total of 42 stab wounds to his body and his wife suffered 31 stab wounds to her body. The work of a madman? Someone insane? Or was it highly planned?
Starting point is 00:23:48 First to you, Dr. Tim Gallagher, medical examiner, joining us out of the state of Florida. Many of us have seen Dexter and other similar shows on television or cable where it seems like a piece of cake to dismember someone. It's not that easy, Gallagher, not at all. Explain. Oh, certainly not. This is a process that will take someone who's uninitiated hours and hours to do, even if they know where to cut,
Starting point is 00:24:17 even if they know where to cut through the joint instead of cutting through the bone, especially if you're using handheld instruments, you know, as opposed to an electric saw or something like that. But this is a process that takes quite a long time and expends quite a bit of energy. To Yvonne Thomas, WBIR 10 News in Knoxville. Of course, the killer had not finished cleaning up the scene because it's my understanding when law enforcement goes in, they find a severed hand in the upstairs exercise room just lying there. They absolutely did. And how terrifying can you imagine that being?
Starting point is 00:24:55 See hands not attached to a body in a room surrounded by blood, blood splatter, pools of blood on the carpet. I'm just trying to take that in. And of course, as law enforcement goes in, they don't know if the killer is still in the home. You hear a dog barking in the distance and have no idea what you're the stove. It's almost incomprehensible to us talking. You know, we're looking at it as trained analyzers of fact. That's what all of us on the panel do. We're lawyers, we're prosecutors, we're a medical examiner, a psychiatrist, a detective. But I wonder how this strikes a lay person. Now, it's been argued that whoever did the deed must be insane. But what about a notebook? A notebook that is found in a backpack in the back bedroom
Starting point is 00:26:12 of the home. Listen to Leslie Nazios. Flush chunks down toilet, not garbage disposal. No evidence, ladies and gentlemen, that he did that. The next line, get plastic sheeting for disposal process. There is evidence that there was plastic sheeting at the scene on the bed where Joel and Lisa Guy slept. Get hollow point bullets just in case we'll be seen buying bullets just use computer room gun check to make sure there are bullets last resort there were no gunshot wounds to the victims he's not alive to claim her half of the insurance money, all mine, $500,000. What more do we know in that notebook full of detailed instructions about how to commit the double murder? Listen again to Leslie Nazios.
Starting point is 00:27:18 Bring blender and food grinder. Grind meat. grinder grind meat well we will not show you that he did grind any meat but we will show you that he brought a blender and that in his vehicle that was searched after his arrest in Baton Rouge he did have a food processor in the trunk get bleach denature proteins well there was, several tubs of bleach in the kitchen. Get plastic bin for denaturation process. And I guess that means for dissolving your parents. It does not matter where they're killed.
Starting point is 00:28:01 Just get rid of bloody spots to prevent evidence of time of death, not the mattress or couches. Get rid of bodies inside the house, there and my DNA already there. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Guys, we are talking about the death and dismemberment of two wonderful people, loving parents, grandparents, Lisa Guy and Joel Guy Sr. Set to retire, leave their jobs, start a new life together. There was only one fly in the ointment. Lisa had been supporting her grown son, who had spent nine years at LSU, never held down a job, and still didn't have a degree.
Starting point is 00:29:02 That was the only reason she had kept working. What more does the notebook reveal that was found in a back bedroom in a backpack? Listen. And they found the notebook. And in the notebook, there was a writing. And I want to go through it with you a little bit, because it's kind of hard to see like this. But we'll start from the first line. Get killing knives. Quiet. Multiple. Get carving knives to make small pieces. Get sledgehammer. Crush bones.
Starting point is 00:29:44 And of course, there were multiple knives found at the scene. You will hear there was a knife in the guest bathroom, a knife in the sink in the master bathroom. The crime scene, horrific. The crime scene techs having to wear hazmat outfits. Back to our friend Yvonne Thomas, WBIR 10 News. When police come into the mansion, they very quickly see two blue tote tubs full of chemicals. What else are in the tubs? Full of chemicals and body parts of Lisa Guy and Joel Guy Sr.
Starting point is 00:30:27 Even a torso was found in one of those bins. What can you tell me, Yvonne Thomas, WBIR, about the mother, Lisa Guy's cell phone, set to send a text or phone call a few days later, such as on Sunday or Monday? Yes, the phone was set to send a text message, phone call or so to her son, Joel Guy Jr. Who by that time was in Baton Rouge. Yes. It's all fitting together for me because he is there over Thanksgiving weekend. He is about to be cut off financially. The mom is finally quitting work. He's going to have to fend for himself. Someone sets mom's phone to text him or call him in Baton Rouge. Thereby, Stephen Lampley, detective and author, setting up an alibi for him in Baton Rouge when
Starting point is 00:31:23 he picks that phone up, right? That's true, Nancy. But unfortunately, apparently he's not smart enough to know that that can all be traced back and figured out. I guess his intent was to commit the perfect crime, but he wasn't smart enough to do that. That was him that did this, that committed the crime himself. And another note that I noticed when they were reading off the notebook, that he said in his writings, it says that my and their DNA is already, this perpetrator's DNA be on the scene already. So that tells me that this is somebody in the family or a friend of the family
Starting point is 00:32:06 who has been to this home before. You know, it tells me to Wendy Patrick, California prosecutor, author of Red Flags, timing is everything. I believe that the son, Joel Guy Jr., 32 years old, had planned to be in Baton Rouge to pick the phone up, have a fake conversation with his mother who's dead, then go back to the scene. See, he's in Baton Rouge. The scene is in Knoxville. Retrieve his notebook, finish cleaning up the scene because in the list of things to do, it said to take his mom's nails and scratch his dad's arm to get dad's DNA under her fingernails. So clearly he was setting up the scene. What he didn't count on,
Starting point is 00:32:58 I think, Wendy, is that the security, the welfare check would happen before he could get back to get that notebook. That's what I think happened, Wendy. His timing was off. Yeah, no, that's exactly right. You know, in this kind of a community, they were very vigilant, learning when somebody was missing, being concerned. And a timeline, in and of itself, sometimes is the deciding factor for a jury, being able to put everything in a line and see somebody's mental processes as they go through. And here, this homicide journal, as with other cases, notebooks speak volumes. These silent pieces of evidence detail exactly what somebody's going to do. And
Starting point is 00:33:36 in this case, it was accurate, it was corroborated, and it was consistent. And those things together are very important at this particular crime scene. You know, to Dr. Angie Arnold, Dr. Angie, Stephen Lampley pointed out that the notebook said, my DNA is already here. But he's correct, giving away who the perp is. But it also says even further identifying who else's DNA is there, but who else is going to benefit. It says assets, and it lays out the mom's assets and the dad's assets. The mom had a $500,000 life insurance policy. And it says, it'll all, it'll be all mine. His words, not mine. It will be all mine with dad dead or missing. So who's the beneficiary? The son, Joel Guy Jr.
Starting point is 00:34:34 He was quite the planner too, wasn't he? Yeah. What does that mean? Remember in the Robert Blake case, Blake and his henchmen had these long detail lists. Got to get lye, got to get tarps, got to get this, hammer, shovel, everything a killer needs. Somehow they managed to explain it away to a gullible California jury. Sorry, Wendy Patrick. But, I mean, there's a certain thing, there's something to be said about overplanning
Starting point is 00:35:00 when you're making this meticulous list of murder to-dos? Well, and also, Nancy, have you thought about that it might have even been giving him some sick? I see we've got another guest joining us at the Canine Variety. It may have been giving him some sick. You know, I don't mind if we appeal to the canine listeners and viewership. Dr. Angela Arnold, I think you were about to say making the list. Like when I take the children on, say, our RV trips or camping trips, I make exhaustive lifts because I don't want to be out in the middle of nowhere and not have what we need. But I also enjoy planning it. Well, you know, Nancy, I think, I mean and I don't believe this is too far out there.
Starting point is 00:35:47 I think this guy could have been getting some sort of sick pleasure out of making the list and thinking and brooding and plotting about what it was going to feel like when he was doing this. When he was actually following through with everything. I made the very tenuous analogy to planning an RV trip, how you enjoy making your list and planning what you're going to do. I think you're right, Dr. Angie. I think he enjoyed making this list because I've actually looked at the list and it is like single spaced pages and pages and pages. Am I right, Yvonne Thomas? Absolutely. This was not just a front and back list like you
Starting point is 00:36:31 make to go to the grocery store. This was details of pages on pages of things that someone had to do to get done so that this murder could actually happen. Dr. Tim Gallagher, I know you go through all these procedures and you're strictly by the book when you perform an autopsy. This guy totally dismembered two bodies. And do you know what? Do you know that the dad's limbs were almost skeletonized? He had had the body parts soaking in chemicals. His evil plan was actually working, Gallagher.
Starting point is 00:37:06 Well, it could be true. I mean, depending on what he was soaking them in, the bones could have over the course of time, and we're talking about a year and a half, maybe two years, but totally liquefied. And there would be very little evidence left to ascertain whether this was the person or not. You could probably use teeth information, but apparently that would not be possible with the mother. Remember he said he had a sledgehammer to destroy what was left of the bones. But also he had turned the heat up, left the oven and the stove on to intensify the heat to hasten the decomposition process. But also he had gone to extreme measures to get rid of being any
Starting point is 00:37:55 semblance of identification. You'll be happy to know a jury found him guilty, no doubt about it. So when is the sentencing set to go down, Yvonne Thomas? Well, he was sentenced that day that the jury made their verdict for the first-degree murder count. He will be sentenced on November 19th for the abuse of a corpse charges. Mm.
Starting point is 00:38:21 We wait as justice unfolds. Nancy Grace, Crime Story, signing off. Goodbye, friend.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.