Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - DIDDY VERDICT WATCH: It's All Down to 12 Jurors

Episode Date: June 28, 2025

After a month of testimony, and more than 30 witnesses, the jury will get instructions by a judge on Monday. The prosecution laid out a case that took nearly a month.  The defense took less than ...30 minutes.  Now how long will it take the jurors to decide Sean Combs fate? Will he be found guilty or acquitted? How did we get here? See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. We are in a verdict watch here at Crime Stories as we wait for the Sean Cone's jury to hand down a verdict. Let's go straight to the courthouse standing by Lauren Conlon, investigative reporter, host of Pop Crime TV. Lauren, thank you for being with us. What exactly happened? Mark Agnifilo's closing argument had a much different style than the government's. He spoke to the jury kind of like he was talking to a friend.
Starting point is 00:00:39 He really thanked them for their time. And his first really big statement here was, this case or this trial is the tale of two trials told by the mouths of the witnesses, text messages, videos, and evidence. That's one trial. The second trial is different. The second trial is told by the mouths of the prosecutors. And he also went on to say that this case The second trial is told by the mouths of the prosecutors.
Starting point is 00:01:05 And he also went on to say that this case is so very badly exaggerated. What do you see from evidence? You see personal use of drugs, you see personal nights with girlfriends, nothing else. And the prosecutors have charged this man with the most complicated charge on the books here, Rico. So he again, he goes into a lot of different detail and he goes out of order a bit with the charges. He went over the kidnapping predicate and then skipped over to the arson predicate before he finished the kidnapping predicate. So I think for some of us, it was a little tough to follow.
Starting point is 00:01:48 And really the points he was trying to make on a lot of these, the kidnapping, for example, he really tried to disprove Capricorn Clark saying that Sean Colmes had a gun. And he said, look, I'll give you five reasons why he didn't have a gun. And the biggest reason here is why would he have a gun? You know, Capricorn Clark didn't need a gun to go with Sean Cohn. She said she had a crush on him. And he also said the biggest reason was actually
Starting point is 00:02:17 because Kid Cudi on the stand testified that when Capricorn called him, she never said that there was a gun and that would be really important. He also brought up the fact that she told Lauren London on the phone she wanted to escape the car, but she was scared of mountain lions, not the gun, but mountain lions. He also went pretty hard on Cassie.
Starting point is 00:02:40 He admitted the domestic violence. He said, yes, that is awful. And this was a regrettable action. I'm paraphrasing. But he also said, if you're looking at this case, who's the winner here? Cassie's sitting on $30 million, and Sean Combs is in jail. He also said that Cassie really was Sean Combs' match, and that she knew what she was doing at certain times,
Starting point is 00:03:04 like when she was dating Kid Cudi at the same time, he said, you know, Cassie, Kid Cudi said that Cassie played us both and that's that. Now he also talked about the Sert team search and he was extremely sarcastic in this and he said, ooh, look at all the baby oil they seized. The world is a better place. The streets are safer because of all of this astroglide. And the jury seemed to be laughing a bit and smiling here. What else?
Starting point is 00:03:33 Oh, he talked about how the domestic violence that Cassie experienced at the Intercontinental Hotel. He actually said that, you know, this is a misdemeanor here. And the government actually had an objection to this during the break and said, yeah, they misstated the law. And Agnifilo said, look, all I'm trying to say here is that this is a state charge. This is not federal. Additionally, during the break, Maureen Comey did also raise two other issues she had, besides misstating the law. She cited that there was a time during the kidnapping discussion
Starting point is 00:04:11 that Mark Agnifilo looked at the jury and said, why would the government, why would they charge him with this? Why would they do this? Well, Comey said he's not charged with kidnapping. This is a predicate act under Rico, and he misstated that. And also she kind of said, you know, it's not the jury's job to surmise over what he was charged with. It's their job to decide whether or not that he's guilty. Mark Agnifilo said,
Starting point is 00:04:37 you know, I think it's fair to that I am sarcastic. You know, I will tie everything together. But initially the judge decided that he would give these instructions right when the jury returned. Although Alexandra Shapiro argued that these instructions for the jury to disregard Mark Agnifilo asking them why the prosecutors charged Sean Combs with kidnapping. They asked that these instructions should be given after he's finished. However, the judge disagreed, Maureen Comey disagreed, and he gave them immediately when the jury returned.
Starting point is 00:05:09 He said, I will give the charging instructions later. You follow what I say. This is clearly, you shouldn't be, or basically the defense doesn't have the right to ask you why you think someone was charged. Again, he didn't say that, I am paraphrasing, but it was it was a moment. It did feel like he was he was getting scolded. The trial that has taken weeks culminates with closing arguments. Let's just revisit what happened. The raids by the feds, by HSI, Homeland Security investigators, much of the PC probable cause was gleaned from multiple lawsuits
Starting point is 00:05:52 filed against Combs. Now that's not just from what we're learning. Combs' own lawyer spoke out in a very unfortunate statement for Combs. You never reveal your thinking prior to a trial but the lawyer did. What are they saying that all these victims are lying? I mean think about it. No one wants to see the demise of a superstar but are superstars to be held above the law because I say no. This is what we know happened.
Starting point is 00:06:29 Listen to Sydney Sumner, Crime Online. Large teams of law enforcement led by Homeland Security investigators raided three homes belonging to Sean Diddy Combs in Los Angeles and Miami as part of a sex trafficking investigation stemming from accusations leveled against Combs in five separate lawsuits brought against him. The latest suit filed in February by music producer Rodney Lilrod-Jones details frequent drug use, a shooting,
Starting point is 00:06:54 and several accounts of sex assault while working with Combs on the Love album. But there's more, and I can tell you this much. When the feds roll up in armored vehicles wearing Kevlar, that's not good for you. That's not good at all. We're hearing a lot of whining this morning by the defense about, oh, they messed up
Starting point is 00:07:16 the inside of his house. Boo hoo! Listen to Dave Mack, Crime Online. In the 73 page document, Jones claims that Combs forced him to solicit sex workers and perform sex ex with them as Combs looked on. Jones also alleges the rapper threw parties he called freak-offs, during which underage girls and sex workers were given lace drinks and assaulted.
Starting point is 00:07:38 Combs' son Justin, producer Stevie J and associate Brendan Paul, allegedly supplied the women and drugs for the parties. The suit goes on to say that Combs access to major celebrities, athletes, and even British Royals such as Prince Harry gave him and his followers legitimacy. With me, an all-star panel to make sense of what we know right now, but first straight out to Kayla Brantley joining us, investigative reporter DailyMail.com. Kayla, thank you for being with us. Tell me what
Starting point is 00:08:05 happened because we saw simultaneous raids. A lot has been made of that. Hold on just a second, Kayla. Let me go to Neema Ramani joining us. High profile lawyer and more importantly, former federal prosecutor, president of the West Coast Trial Lawyers Association and author of Harvard to Hashtag. Neema, thank you for being with us. A lot has been made and a lot of whining and ee ee ee ee ee crying because there were multiple raids
Starting point is 00:08:34 that went down simultaneously. Boo hoo. The reason that happens is so when you get raided in LA, you can't call your peeps in Miami and go, quick, quick, quick, hide, one, two, three, and four, destroy, five, six, seven, and eight, and P.S., run for the hills, as if you had seen a monster. That's why it's got to be very carefully orchestrated and timed,
Starting point is 00:08:59 very organized to go down at the same time for that very reason, Nima. Well Nancy, that's exactly right and the raid in Los Angeles took place about a mile from where I'm sitting right now. I live close to Diddy's home and you know I also know Aaron Dyer. I used to work with him. I respect him but I think he's making that argument for the court of public opinion more than the courtroom and you're right there's three reasons why federal agents go in and they go aggressively. One, there's always a threat of violence and Diddy reportedly has a lot of weapons. Agents need to make sure that no one flees the jurisdiction, evidence isn't destroyed. That's why the raids are executed simultaneously when they are. Individuals are
Starting point is 00:09:41 removed from the home, they're cuffed, they're detained, no one was arrested, but Diddy was treated just like any other criminal defendant or target of an investigation when these search warrants are executed. Guys, what do you expect? The HSI Homeland Security investigators to be the minute made and clean up after a search? That's not happening. Guys, it's amazing what people will do to
Starting point is 00:10:07 hide contraband or evidence. What evidence am I talking about? I'm talking about videos, potential videos of underage girls and boys in the middle of sex acts. Now number one, an underaged child, some jurisdictions under 18, some under 16, some under 15, cannot consent to sex activity. So even if they appear to be willing in a video, does anybody remember R. Kelly for Pete's sake where he urinated on a teen girl? Yeah, that's not consensual. I don't care what she said at the time. Videos that could easily be hidden, even if they are in physical form, for all I know,
Starting point is 00:10:54 they're just on a computer. That's why every computer, every laptop, every phone, every iPad, every everything has to be seized. Sean Combs arrested by the feds in a Lux Hotel in the dark of night, now in federal custody. I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime Stories. Thank you for being with us. Today I'm announcing the unsealing of a three-count indictment. Charging Sean Combs with racketeering conspiracy, sex trafficking, interstate transportation for prostitution. The indictment alleges that between at least 2008 and the present, Combs abused, threatened, and coerced victims to fulfill his sexual desires, protect his reputation, and conceal
Starting point is 00:11:38 his conduct. As alleged in the indictment, to carry out out this conduct Sean Combs led and participated in a racketeering conspiracy that used the business empire he controlled to carry out criminal activity including sex trafficking, forced labor, kidnapping, arson, bribery, and the obstruction of justice. And we have just gotten our hands on the federal indictment. But first, let's talk about what went down in the dark of night. Sean Puffy Combs seen out
Starting point is 00:12:11 on the street in New York just 30 minutes before feds break into his luxury suite at the Park Hyatt Hotel on 57th Street and arrest Combs and proceed to shred that hotel room. Looking for evidence. Joining me right now at the hotel just outside the Park Hyatt is CrimeOnline.com investigative reporter Angelica Martinez. Angelica, thank you for being with us. Tell me what happened right there. Yes, Nancy.
Starting point is 00:12:43 We are currently outside the Hyatt Hotel, the Park Hyatt Hotel, where Sean Puffy Combs was arrested. He was arrested following an indictment that was returned by a grand jury. Guys, joining us, Angelica Martinez at the Park Hyatt. We understand that Feds pursuant to warrant went into Combs' room right behind you up on one of the penthouse levels and arrested Combs last night. He had no idea it was about to happen. We've also heard reports the arrest was to go down at least 48 if not 72 hours later but something triggered the feds to make the arrest. Combs actually spotted out on the street and videoed BSing with fans and friends just before literally minutes before the feds arrested him. I know
Starting point is 00:13:32 they were poised outside the Park Hyatt Hotel where you're standing right now Angelica waiting for him to come back in with eyes on Sean Puffy Combs the entire evening Angelica. Yes so apparently negotiations for Sean Combs' for render had been in the talks for a while. And like you said, Nancy, something triggered this arrest. Something happened that caused them to move it from allegedly later in the week. He was allegedly arrested right in the lobby
Starting point is 00:14:02 and he was not expecting that, according to some sources. Angelica, I think I know what may have prompted the early arrest. You know you're about 20-30 minutes from Teterboro, private airstrip. Combs has money. You can get on a private plane without a passport. Now where you can land without one is a whole other can of worms. But if they got wind that he was leaving with all of his money and access to private planes, that's the time you make the arrest ahead of time. Joining me there at the Park Hyatt Hotel in the heart of Manhattan, Angelica Martinez,
Starting point is 00:14:38 let's open it up to the panel. The last few moments, we caught the lawyer, the defense attorney, Agnefellow, and he states his client is going to be released. Do you really believe that Sean Puffy Combs is going to get out on bond straight out to high profile lawyer Nima Romani, former federal prosecutor, president West Coast trial lawyers and author of Harvard to hashtag. He is an expert in federal law.
Starting point is 00:15:09 Neema, thank you for being with us. Quick question regarding Bond. Now we know that Combs was held overnight and he is with the feds right now. You know his lawyer is going to make a big play for him to get out on Bond and make a big show. lawyer is going to make a big play for him to get out on bond and make a big show. Probably walking along Park Avenue maybe Fifth Avenue wearing his fur coat as if he has it. A worry in the world. Why do I say that? Because when you don't know a horse, Neema, look at his track record. That has been his M.O. since the
Starting point is 00:15:41 get-go. Hey, you ready to my house? No problem. I'm out surfing water sports with my family, living it up with some champagne. Yeah, that's him. That's his MO to act like nothing is wrong and give the illusion of complete innocence and carefree. We are in a verdict watch for the Sean Cone's jury to hand down a verdict. Let's just revisit. What happened? P-Deadie, we saw the video of you brutally beating and kicking and dragging Cassie. And now? You apologize? Now? Apology not accepted. I'll see you in court. My behavior on that video is inexcusable. I take full responsibility for my actions in that video. I'm so sorry.
Starting point is 00:17:15 But I'm committed to be a better man, each and every day. I'm not asking for forgiveness. I'm truly sorry. I don't know about you, but he looks like he's reading to me all that I'm sorry. Technical legal term. BS. He's not sorry he did it. He's sorry he got caught. Have you seen the video?
Starting point is 00:17:46 Now how is it at that time no charges were filed and you know hotel security saw the whole thing? Do you believe his apology? Is it not a day late and a dollar short? Well, apparently other people agree with me. Listen. According to Ernest Owens, Sean Diddy Combs is only apologizing because he got caught. Owens calls Combs' apology another pathetic move, pointing out that Combs does not acknowledge Cassie Ventura by name or directly apologize to her.
Starting point is 00:18:18 Combs has previously denied Ventura's allegations repeatedly, but this latest caught-in-the-act video has changed his tune. Owen says it is hard to take anything Diddy says seriously following several prior written attacks on his accusers. Now, what written attacks are we talking about? I gotta tell you something. There are a lot of criminal defense attorneys out there. This one will win your case.
Starting point is 00:18:43 Ben Broffman. That's where you go when there's nowhere to go. Ben Brafman. He's representing Sean Combs, aka Diddy. Listen. Cassie Ventura's lawsuit against Diddy includes a very specific event from March of 2016, where Ventura alleges that Diddy became extremely intoxicated and punched Ventura in the face, giving her a black eye. Diddy's lawyer Ben Brafman tells people in a statement that Combs vehemently denies these offensive and outrageous allegations and alleges that Ventura is filing the lawsuit after first demanding 30 million dollars where she would write a book about their relationship. Brafman says Ventura is seeking a payday.
Starting point is 00:19:25 Now remember, the lawyer is the mouthpiece for the defendant. The lawyer doesn't say anything that the defendant doesn't want said. So when you hear Brafman saying, oh Cassie Ventura, she just wants money. Nothing happened to her. This is BS. Yeah. Yeah. No. We've seen the video.
Starting point is 00:19:49 And all of his denying and claiming. And remember, this is important. That's what he says about all the women that are claiming he abused them. They all want a payday. I don't believe that anymore. With me in All Star panel to make sense of what we know right now. But first straight out to Kayla Brantley investigative reporter DailyMail.com on the case from the beginning.
Starting point is 00:20:14 You know I think this is just the beginning Kayla. But bring me up to date as of right now. Absolutely Nancy. And as you said Diddy is only apologizing right now because he got caught. Everyone sees right through that apology, including Cassie Ventura, who released a statement via her lawyer, who called Diddy's apology pathetic, essentially. He's saying that he's only, Cassie's saying that he's only compelled to speak out now because of this damning evidence.
Starting point is 00:20:42 And as you very well may know that abusers, it's not just an isolated incident. We can assume that this has happened before. Cassie did speak about this exact incident back in her lawsuit from last fall. She said that there was an incident at a hotel where he came into the hallway, abused her, and that Diddy allegedly paid $50,000 to the hotel to get the video and for it to never be released. Obviously, now we know CNN has now had that video released to the world, which now compelled Diddy to apologize.
Starting point is 00:21:15 Kayla Brantley, I think you're exactly correct. Listen. Cassie Ventura escaped Sean Combs by getting on the elevator at the Intercontinental Hotel, leaving the hotel and going to her own apartment. At her residence, she fears Combs will be even angrier at her for running away, so Ventura returns to the hotel, intent on apologizing to Combs. As she returns, hotel security staff urge her to get back in the cab and go home. They've seen the security footage of Combs beating Ventura and throwing glass vases at
Starting point is 00:21:42 her in the hotel hallway. In her lawsuit against Combs, she claims he pays the hotel $50,000 for footage of the hallway assault. Again, joining me in all-star panel in addition to Kayla Brantley from DailyMail.com, straight up to Sam Dordullian, sex assault lawyer and former LA County sex crimes felony prosecutor, founder of the Dor Deulian Law Group. Sam, thank you for being with us. You know, before video was pervasive, no matter where you go, there's a camera on you. Very typically, the defense would say, you can't prove that. Now we have a video, so the fallback is, let's see, the video was doctored, the video was tampered with, or
Starting point is 00:22:27 I'm sorry, I'm a different man now, I'm praying for forgiveness, I'm praying to be a better man, I got counseling, really? You know what's disgusting Nancy is that's what you hear all the time is that I'm sorry, but why did he have to go and attack the victim in this particular case? If he truly took responsibility for what he did, if he truly was disgusted as he claimed in his video, his supposed apology, then why did he call her a liar in public? Why did he say she's just looking for a payday and only when he got caught, now all of a sudden he's sorry. He's just looking for a payday and only when he got caught, now all of a sudden he's sorry. Joining me out of Florida, a high profile private investigator, former federal task
Starting point is 00:23:09 force, US Department of Justice, also with the DEA. Joining me, Robert Crispin from Crispin Special Investigations. Robert, I'm sure you, having dealt with this same scenario many many times as a PI and with the feds People pay off hotel staff all the time and right now the word We're getting from inside the ditty camp is that they are fast and furious Trying to make sure other video surveillance will not emerge. What about it, Crispin? How easy is that to do? Well, you know, listen, money talks.
Starting point is 00:23:49 And this is probably not the first time it's happened in his camp. And if you go back, there's the allegations of they paid $50,000 for the hotel security to get that video out there in LA. So I wouldn't doubt that they're fast and furious going after every single one of these allegations and every single one of these victims that they know of, they're back covering
Starting point is 00:24:07 their tracks. It's an old trick. It's money talks and people like money. So there's a lot of people that do some bad things to cover some bad things, sadly enough. So you think it's relatively easy to pay off hotel security or really any security, get rid of surveillance, it gets quote taped over, it gets lost, nobody can find it, it happens over and over and over again. But the kicker is they are not at a hotel security office, they are not under the same
Starting point is 00:24:44 duty as officers of the court. is they are not at a hotel security office. They are not under the same duty as officers of the court. It's their private video. If they want to tape over it, they can, unless somehow they realize they're hiding evidence. And why would they tape over it if they didn't know they were doing it for a nefarious reason, Crispin? It's tampering with evidence. Carl Blanchett, it's tampering with evidence. And anybody who gets involved in this case moving forward, who already has knowledge, I mean, how do you not have knowledge of this case?
Starting point is 00:25:15 And you find a prosecutor or law enforcement or an agent who can prove through text messages or undercover surveillance or anything that you paid somebody off to get a video, you're catching an obstruction charge and you're doing a and you're also catching a tampering with evidence charge. Now back in 2016 when they got that video, none of this probably got reported yet. That's why they work very fast and they threw $50,000 at these people to get that video thinking it's not out there thinking that nobody kept their own copy and Everybody keeps a copy of their own videos. Trust me to you. Kayla Brantley joining us investigative reporter dailymail.com 50 grand that's like $10 to me. It's like nothing
Starting point is 00:25:57 To combs. I mean, what is his net worth? Well as Cassie said in the lawsuit that this the example of paying Well, as Cassie said in the lawsuit that this the example of paying $50,000 was absolutely nothing to him and it just shows his power and his influence now reportedly Diddy's a billionaire and he has so many different lines He has Sean John he has revolt and not only is he a music mogul He's a fashion mogul and has been a legend in this industry So his net worth is estimated around a billion dollars. Now with all these legal blows,
Starting point is 00:26:27 who knows how much it's gonna go down to. Combs allegedly planned and controlled the sex performances, which he called freak off. Sean Puffy Combs spending the night behind bars and whining incessantly through his lawyers. We are analyzing evidence that has come out in court. You know what? After the judge heard this, he had a snowball chance in H-E-L-L of getting bond.
Starting point is 00:26:56 I mean, you got to know this. All the judges, they all have lunch together in a big room. Sometimes the law library, their court clerks are in there they see each other day in day out how's this judge gonna look at the other judges in the eye go yeah I gave Diddy a bond that was me in there because I don't have a spine now listen to this this is what I learned in court now we've all seen the Cassie Ventura video of her running away from Sean Combs. In public in a hotel corridor, he comes out practically butt naked wearing nothing but a towel.
Starting point is 00:27:35 He doesn't care. That doesn't bother him. So entitled. Chases her down and beats the H-E-L-L out of her, kicking her, kicking her, kicking her, dragging her. Listen to this. We have gotten a hold of, through prosecutors, texts that he immediately sends her. Listen to this. To Cassie. Call me. The cops are here. I got six kids. Yo, please call. I'm surrounded. You gonna abandon me all alone? You're gonna abandon me all alone? This as we are learning that Cassie Ventura was running from a freak off. Yeah, there was a sex worker in the room with Diddy and I
Starting point is 00:28:27 guarantee he was trying to film it. The sex worker forcing Cassie to have sex. The defendant, according to prosecutor Emily Johnson, knew he had done something that could elicit police response. Well, that's a nice way of saying, he getting busted. Okay, so she texts back saying she still had horrible bruising from the assault. Says I'm not a rag doll. Now I want to point out that they are now the defense attorney desperate is now saying Cassie Ventura was running away because she was jealous. She was jealous because she looked at Combs' phone and saw he texted another woman. Right.
Starting point is 00:29:16 She's so jealous she runs out barefoot trying to get away from him and the sex worker that was still in the room. Let's just start with that. Okay? What judge in his right, his or her right mind can go sit down to his tuna fish sandwich and eat lunch with the other judges looking at him going, yeah, we know what you did.
Starting point is 00:29:39 You let this a-hole out on bond. Listen to this. Sean Combs is back inside the walls of Metropolitan Detention Center after U.S. District Judge Andrew Carter Jr. denied Combs live at home, alone, in Florida, monitored by a 24-7 security team. Combs offered to give up any access to his cell phone or internet. In the end, Judge Carter Jr. agreed with Judge Tarnowski
Starting point is 00:30:15 that quote, there is no condition or combination of conditions to ensure he will not obstruct justice or tamper with witnesses. Music mogul and rap star Sean Diddy Combs hit with lawsuit after lawsuit after lawsuit but attorneys claim no matter how many suits are filed Combs is innocent. Innocent. Okay he's getting paid plenty of money to say that, but the defense attorney is completely deluded. He is even claiming that Combs, Sean Combs, Diddy,
Starting point is 00:30:51 has had to go into therapy because of the allegations made against him. Sean Combs is now the victim. Listen. For bail, appeal hearing, Agnifilo submits an amended bail package. Combs agrees to have no communication with women outside of Damley members and the mothers of his children, to have no contact with known grand jury witnesses, referring to victim one, Cassandra Ventura, to use a private intelligence agency to monitor him 24-7. Sage Intelligence will ensure he has no cell phone or internet access,
Starting point is 00:31:28 administer weekly drug tests, and turn over a daily visitor's log. Are they crazy? With me is Irv Brandt, former senior inspector, U.S. Marshals Service. Those are the guys that go all around the world to bring back felons for trial or that have absconded. Author a whole series of books about Solo, last one, Forever Solo, Night of the Dragon. Hey Irv, really? They're gonna have the same security guards, protect Diddy, that would take these women to hide out so they could wait till their bruises healed before they went into public. The same ones that got sex
Starting point is 00:32:09 workers from all over the world the country to come in and rape women that had been drugged on video. Those guys and they're also going to perform weekly urine tests. You want to tell me they can't go take a leak in a cup and put the name Sean Combs on it? Really? Are they insane? Have you ever heard anything like this bond package? I have not, Nancy.
Starting point is 00:32:32 And it's not surprising that the defense was doing everything they could to convince the judge because the burden shifted from the prosecution to the defense because of the nature of the charges and how much time that he was facing. So it's obvious that the defense was just coming up with anything that they could think of, any sorts of conditions that might convince the judge to release him on bond, and it just didn't work. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Verdict watch. Let's just revisit the trial. What happened? Diddy's $10 million defense starts this as we learn the jury is in fear of sitting on the Ditty Trial.
Starting point is 00:33:30 I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime Stories. Thank you for being with us. Cassie Ventura is set to take the stand with prosecutors expected to highlight a 2016 hotel assault caught on video This trial of Sean Combs started early in a Manhattan courtroom Joining me an all-star panel to make sense of what we know right now straight out to Lauren Conlon Joining us co-host pop crime TV Lauren, thank you for being with us. Tell me about what happened first thing. Court began with Diddy asking the judge for more water
Starting point is 00:34:08 or the judge said something like, do you have enough water? And he said, could I have some more, Your Honor? Diddy appeared to be wearing a light cream colored sweater, which I thought was a great choice for a defendant. He had his glasses on. He was looking through some paperwork at the beginning of the morning
Starting point is 00:34:25 And he would turn around to smile at his mom and wave to his family who were in the front row He gave a thumbs up at one point. I actually saw Janice Combs his mother in the lobby She was wearing an all-black suit a black purse and she looked like she was going to a funeral to be honest I also want to point out that when the jury walked in Diddy did not take his eyes off of them he watched their every move. This as we are learning the jury is actually in fear in fact the judge was afraid to impound on jury on Friday thinking they would back out with cold feet over the weekend listen. The original plan was for jury selection to be completed on Friday but Diddy's lawyers asked for a delay,
Starting point is 00:35:08 raising concerns more jurors would get cold feet between Friday and Monday. The court received an email from one potential juror asking to be left off the panel for issues of personal well-being, according to the Combs team. Prosecutors strongly opposed the delay. Judge Arun Subramanian agreed with the defense. Okay, to Eric Faddis, veteran trial lawyer joining me out of the Denver, Colorado jurisdiction. Partner, Varner, Faddis, elite legal former prosecutor. That's not good when the jury is afraid to be in the box, the jury box. Yeah, yikes. I mean, this is a high profile case.
Starting point is 00:35:47 There is a ton at stake. And Nancy Amsturro recalled the judge actually declined to give Diddy bond because there were concerns that he was engaging in witness tampering or witness intimidation. Those same concerns could translate to this jury and it could cause them to get gold feet or otherwise be considering that when they're deciding the case, which is obviously a problem. It wouldn't be the first time that a jury had been harassed, put in fear, or tampered with.
Starting point is 00:36:16 Listen. John Gotti earned the nickname Teflon Don after he was acquitted in multiple trials, likely due to jury tampering and witness intimidation. This seems to be confirmed when a juror who helped acquit Gotti in a racketeering case was convicted of taking a bribe. Jimmy Hoffa was also charged with unlawfully, willfully, and knowingly conspiring with six co-conspirators to influence members of the jury. He was accused of offering $10,000 to the families of two jurors for an acquittal
Starting point is 00:36:46 vote and offering to get the police husband of another juror a promotion. Clarence Darrow was in the company of his chief investigator when the two men were arrested for bribery. Darrow was defending brothers on bombing charges. Police say Darrow's investigator passed $4,000 to a prospective jury member for a not guilty vote. You would have to be living under a rock, in a cave, on the other side of the world, not to know that there are allegations that Sean Combs ordered a hit, a murder, on Tupac Shakur. Listen.
Starting point is 00:37:22 Dwayne Keefe D. Davis claims credit for Tupac's murder on BET and in his memoir. He says Puffy Combs wanted Knight and Tupac's heads after their diss track hit him up. When Davis offers to carry out the hits, Combs agrees to pay him $1 million. Davis, Anderson, Terrence Brown, and DeAndre Smith stake out the club where Shakur is performing. But Tupac's a no-show. Driving down the strip, they spot Knight and Tupac stopped in traffic. Brown flips a U-turn in their white Cadillac, Davis passes Anderson the gun, and Anderson leans over Smith to shoot Tupac. We don't wipe the a** out quick, you know.
Starting point is 00:37:57 It's nothing. Who brought up the amount of one million dollars? F**k. He did. Puffy did it. Biggie ever involved in any of these conversations about hitting Tupac? No. $1,000.00. He did it. Puffy did it. Biggie ever involved in any of these conversations about hitting Puffy? No.
Starting point is 00:38:10 As long as it's just Puffy said it. This is all Puffy's doing. Straight out to Robert Crispin joining us. Private Investigator, former Federal Task Force Officer, USDOJ, also with DEA. Now at Crispin's Special Investigations.
Starting point is 00:38:25 Crispin, thank you for being with us. Your estate out in front of Diddy's home there in Florida where it all started with the bust. I want to hear how the neighbors are taking today, but more important, you think if this jury has seen the Cassie video and they all have an opinion on it, you think they don't know about the hit on Tupac Shakur? Yeah, that's going to kind of tie it in, isn't it? And they're going to wonder like, well, that's kind of interesting. But you know, Nancy, I'm coming to you live out in front of Diddy's house here in Star Island in Miami Beach. And if today is any indication of what's going on in Diddy's world as his trial starts, it's
Starting point is 00:39:10 a dark rainy day. The neighbors, they're really happy that there's no more attention. There's no more late parties, three, four day benders, the drugs in that white gate behind me. That's where the feds went in with their search warrant. That's, the drugs in that white gate behind me. That's where the feds went in with their search warrant. That's where the drugs came out. That's where the electronic evidence came out. That's where everything started to unfold for Diddy before he got indicted.
Starting point is 00:39:35 I just find it very difficult to believe that if the jury has seen the Cassie video already, which they're going to see at trial anyway, that they don't know about the hit on Tupac Shakur. Which gets to my point, Crispin, that jurors, one juror, backed out and said he was afraid for his own and his family's safety, got cold feet and went off the panel. And that's the one that would speak out. Have you ever had a case where jurors or witnesses were actually afraid? Oh, absolutely.
Starting point is 00:40:09 And that's a very real fear because if he's found guilty, revenge is best served on a cold plate. And these people are going to be looking over their shoulder all the time. In drug cases in Miami, same thing. You want to sit there and look a drug lord in the eye and convict him when you have a wife, kids. These are everyday people that get jury subpoenas and end up sitting on these high profile cases. And there's a lot at stake when you hit either that guilty or that not guilty box on that
Starting point is 00:40:42 jury form. That's an issue. And I would be afraid. To Dr. Bethany Marshall joining us, a high-profile psychoanalyst out of the LA jurisdiction, author of Dealbreaker. You can see her currently on Peacock and find her at DrBethanyMarshall.com. Dr. Bethany, I think that the jury wants to do the right thing. I think in their heart of hearts they want to serve on the jury. They want to be impartial. But the reality is, when you have a family at home, children, it's not just about you anymore. I've had jurors on gang-related cases, gang cases, say right up front, I've heard about the case, I can't sit on this jury, I've got children.
Starting point is 00:41:25 They were in inner city Atlanta, Fulton County. I don't know if they're being upfront in the Deedee trial, but I do know that one juror said, I want off the panel because I'm afraid. I think they want to do the right thing, but when push comes to shove and it's going home to their children and their family, I don know what do you think this is real very often Bethany you hear me say that's BS that's just in the movies that's in a book you know that's on a TV series that doesn't happen in real life this actually happens I know for a fact Nancy this is no fairy tale this is no novel
Starting point is 00:42:01 this is a real-life story and yes jurors want to do their civic duty. I think we all do. But as I tell my patients in my practice, your duty is always to your family first. Above all, your spouse and your children, your job is to keep your family safe. If you abdicate that role, who is going to be there for them?
Starting point is 00:42:23 And not only are the jurors at risk, the judge is at risk. You and I have covered many cases where judges and their families have been targeted. And then what about when the case is over? These jurors forever will be known as the people who either vindicated or convicted P. Diddy. And there are people on both sides that will love and more importantly hate them. And finally Nancy, what about all those celebrities?
Starting point is 00:42:54 Joining us in addition to Lauren Collin at the courthouse, Sydney Summer joining us, Crime Stories investigative reporter also on the case. Sydney, I understand that first thing this morning, Combs comes in, demands a whole nother pitcher of water. I wonder why he's got dry mouth. But that said, his mother, his mother, Janice Combs, also came into the courtroom. In the past, she's been very flamboyant in her dress, but she's taking a page out of Sean Combs' playbook and it dressed like she's
Starting point is 00:43:25 going to a funeral, Sydney. That's right, Nancy. Dressed all in black. And Combs' mom isn't the only family member in attendance today. Six of his children are also in the courtroom and they're dressed very similarly. All of them walked in in sunglasses and all of their clothing is black and white. They all had on sunglasses in the courtroom? At least as they were walking in. I want to go back to the fact that
Starting point is 00:43:49 Sean Combs, that we know of, is laying at 10 million dollars for his defense. But jurors in fear. Back to Sydney Sumner joining us. Crime Stories Investigative Reporter. This is a big deal, Sydney Sumner. We know Crime stories investigative reporter. This is a big deal Sydney Sumner. We know that one juror, as I said earlier, asked the judge, begged the judge to be taken off the jury panel because he's got a family and got quote cold feet. But I know the defense struck a juror that said they had seen the Cassie video and that Combs looked angry and hostile. They struck that juror. Yes, that juror is gone. They commented on that video said Combs looks angry and
Starting point is 00:44:32 hostile, but the government has struck a candidate who said he heard about the Combs case on Joe Rogan's podcast. So we've already had a tit for tat. As if the jury didn't know about the Tupac Shakur hit, the alleged hit, where multiple witnesses say Combs ordered a million dollar hit for Tupac Shakur's head. And he got it. What about the fact that these jurors have seen, they've already seen the Cassie Ventura beat down video? Listen.
Starting point is 00:45:04 As potential jurors are questioned about their ability to maintain impartiality, an obstacle quickly rears its head. The video of Combs attacking Cassie. Numerous potential jurors have seen the video and formed opinions on it. Of those who have watched it, only a few were able to say they did not think it would affect their impartiality. The Cassie beat down video from our friends at CNN. We expect that particular version not to be introduced at trial. Why? Because the defense said it had been sped up and it wasn't in its original, pristine
Starting point is 00:45:36 form. Well, be careful what you ask, my dear, for you will surely get it. Now, the jury will probably see the entire version in its entirety and in regular motion. Right? At regular speed. They'll probably wish they had kept the sped up CNN version. You know, Robert Crispin joining us there at Sean Combs' mansion in Florida. So they know about the Tupac Shakur murder hit, the million dollar hit.
Starting point is 00:46:05 They know about the Cassie beat down video. They've seen it. We've got one juror begging off the panel because he got cold feet. The jury is afraid. They don't care that Sean Combs is spending ten million dollars on a defense, a slick defense. Yeah, well I think what the jury is starting to think is, wow, these are some violent people. What have I gotten myself into? Like I said before, that video was a gift to the prosecution. But what that video does do, it gives a look inside Diddy's real world when he thinks nobody's watching, nobody's around, and it's just him and his victim,
Starting point is 00:46:46 or him and an ex-girlfriend, or him who doesn't agree with him. Explosive surveillance footage allegedly showing Combs assaulting Ventura has been admitted into evidence. The jury was finalized in the Sean Combs federal indictment trial at 9 45 a.m. straight out to Lauren Collins standing by at the courthouse. Lauren what happened? The opening statements for the prosecution said that we are going to hear from Cassie this week along with another witness named Jane. They said we're going to hear or we're going to see videos of these freak offs and it's
Starting point is 00:47:25 going to be very uncomfortable for a lot of people. The prosecution also said things that I had never heard before. They said things like Cassie was forced to allow an escort to urinate in her mouth at one point and this was per the instructions of Sean Combs. The other witness, Jane, is going to testify that she and Diddy got into an altercation where he allegedly stomped on her face and that she would run into every single room, lock the door, he would chase after her and kick the door down and it was it was very graphic. Straight out to Lynn Shaw, founder director Lynn's Warriors committed to ending sexual exploitation of girls and women. What it sounds like he's going to college. He's
Starting point is 00:48:17 wearing reading glasses. Have you ever seen Sean Combs wearing reading glasses? Oh Okay, that's fake and the sweater the white shirt the khaki pants What is he a freshman at Harvard Linshaw? Well, he's pretending to be one dirty ditty Listen, none of us are fooled anymore. None of us we can all see through this. He's reading, wearing reading glasses. I'm sure it's plastic in the frames or clear glass. Nobody were New Yorkers. This is a New York jury. We do not get fooled, especially about this case. He has been for decades now since the early 90s. On the lips, I'm telling you of New Yorkers. So many people here
Starting point is 00:49:03 know about him already. I don't know what he thinks he's doing. None of this is going to help him. Let us keep the focus on victims, survivors, and not only the alleged ones of this case, but of all victims and survivors of all of this exploitation, because Nancy, they are seeking some kind of justice from this case. They want some answers. They want somebody powerful money who has been flaunting this in everybody's face, this, this case. They want some answers. They want somebody powerful, money who has been flaunting this in everybody's face, this exploitation. They want somebody held accountable. And I say dirty Diddy going down. This is the case. To Eric Faddis, veteran trial lawyer, former prosecutor joining us out of Colorado. Eric, I mean, what's next? A wheelchair and a neck brace? He can't go
Starting point is 00:49:42 in there wearing a bejeweled cape or something, right? This is court. And another take on it is that he doesn't wear ditties at all. Fattis, yeah, we would never want him to reveal his true self. I mean, have you seen the Met Gala pictures? That's the real Sean Combs. Right there. With the cape, going down the steps.
Starting point is 00:50:04 There you go. Yeah, so you just said, Fattus, he can't go in wearing a cape. Well, why not? Because that's what he normally wears. So you're going along with the eye tricking the mind with him dressed up like a Harvard freshman. No, I'm not sure that's what's going on here. Look, he doesn't have the stylus on retainer anymore. That's obvious. But on top of that, maybe this is Diddy's true self currently. You know, he is no longer this high profile, powerful mogul with all these resources. He is incarcerated. He is facing a serious federal trial. And so his life has changed. He has gray in his hair. My understanding is his appearance has been drastically transformed. And part of that could just be a reflection
Starting point is 00:50:46 of what's going on around him of the current state of his life. This is who he is today. That's who those jurors are seeing. To Dr. Bethany Marshall joining us, high profile psychoanalyst, Dr. Bethany, it seems trite, very trite that visual tricks are being used on the jury. Khaki pants, you know you heard Faddis say he doesn't have a stylist. I bet you anything he does have a stylist. Those outfits were carefully chosen, very carefully chosen. Have you ever, ever, time immemorial ever seen Sean Combs in a pullover sweater and khaki pants.
Starting point is 00:51:28 Think back. Use that time machine. I mean all the way back. Whether he's on stage at the Met Gala, walking around LA or where Chrisman is joining us down his Miami mansion. Never once. These are serious charges, Bethany. I have seen women rape victims, much less with it videoed in front of a whole crowd of people while they're
Starting point is 00:51:56 drugged according to the prosecution, that basically stay indoors the rest of their life. There is a profound impact on rape victims. And there is Sean Combs and a fake pair of reading glasses. What's he doing? Reading Proust? War and Peace? I don't know. It's BS. It's a trick.
Starting point is 00:52:19 And there's serious charges here, Bethany. We know not only is it a trick, but it's manipulative. And we know that if the allegations are true, Huff Diddy is a manipulative person and may have hired manipulative defense attorneys. And jurors are not stupid, Nancy. They do see through this. Jurors can feel bored, offended, devalued, treated like they don't have minds and they can't think. They are not going to like that. And you know what they also wouldn't like, and the defense knows this, to see a man with carrots and carrots of diamonds around his neck in the form of a cross of a cross, who then uses his power to exploit other people. That is a very unsympathetic character, Nancy. And of course, the defense wants to hide that. The other thing is that I think
Starting point is 00:53:14 ordinary people tend to look at very wealthy people with a suspicion that maybe, you know the saying, behind every great fortune lies a great crime. The jurors can see that too, that how did P. Diddy get to the top? How did he accrue all this wealth? Why is he hanging around with people who are some of the most vulnerable people, you know, in society? So, hey, these defense attorneys have a lot to camouflage, and these jurors are going to see through it. I guarantee that. Joining us at the courthouse, Lauren Conlon. Lauren, tell me about the challenge Sean Conlon's defense team made to these jurors. He, the defense team, the lead attorney, argues that African Americans were systematically excluded
Starting point is 00:54:10 from the jury for racial reasons. What happened? They started with the jury strikes and the defense pointed out that the feds or the government struck seven black jurors out of nine. So the prosecution gave their reasoning behind these strikes and it was very valid. I mean some of these jurors they they had said something like they were going to lose 30% of their income by being on this trial but that wasn't a concern for
Starting point is 00:54:40 them which actually led the prosecution to say, well, I have questions about their intent here and the fact that they might want to be here for ulterior reasons or they might have an ulterior motive. Eric Faddis, this argument is as old as dirt and it has been addressed by the US Supreme Court in Batson v. Kentucky. B Brother A-T-S-O-N-V Kentucky. In that case, the prosecutor was accused of striking from the grand jury panel of 80 to 100 people in order to get 12 for the petite jury of 12, striking for racial reasons, which is unconstitutional. Therefore, whenever you strike anyone, anybody, whether they're white, they're black, they're Asian, doesn't
Starting point is 00:55:32 matter, you better have a good reason for striking. When I struck juries, typically my defendant was black, my victims, usually there were more than one, were black. There was no real racial undercurrent going on in the courtroom. So I didn't have a lot of Batson arguments against me. But what the state has to do, and I'm sure that they did, you have to write, I would keep the jury list. And what that is is a huge printout. I don't know if they do them the same way in your jurisdiction. I'm
Starting point is 00:56:08 sure they do, Fattis, where you have the juror's name, whether they're married, maybe where they work, whether they live to ensure they live in that county or that jurisdiction or else they're not qualified for the jury. Maybe a little bit more identifying information. But that said, I would put notes, my notes, beside each name. So if there was a challenge, I could say, well, I struck him because he doesn't have a job. And if he can't show up to a job every day, then why do I think he's going to show up to court and pay attention?
Starting point is 00:56:46 Or juror fell asleep in voodoo or jury selection. Or let's see, here's a good one. Jurors husband convicted of rape. If I'm trying a rape case, yeah, I don't want her on. So I would always keep notes, brief notes beside each juror whether I wanted them or didn't want them, of my impressions of that juror as we were striking the jury, as I was questioning them on Voedeyer. So Batson v. Kentucky. Easy solution to have your reason as to why you struck the juror when the
Starting point is 00:57:23 challenge arises. Way in on Batson v. Kentucky, Fattus. I'm sure you faced it in court. Yeah, no. Great minds think alike, Nancy. That's exactly how I did it when I was a prosecutor because here's the thing. That's freezing a Batson challenge is kind of a big deal because it's really insinuating that the other side is kicking somebody off based on their race. That's inflammatory and problematic. And so
Starting point is 00:57:46 you need to have a race neutral reason for excluding those folks. This wouldn't be the first time that the defense has brought up race. And historically, race has played a role in the justice system, let's be honest. And so is the Ditty team sort of using that as one potential argument to this jury in terms of why some rich black man is facing these federal offenses? I think they're going to take that round in some form or fashion. The trial is just getting started, expected to last eight weeks with shocking testimony from accusers and insiders on deck.
Starting point is 00:58:24 Witness three is still missing. The court was informed last week that prosecutors have lost communication and cannot locate her. In fact, prosecutors cannot reach her attorney either, meaning they are not sure Victim 3 will show up in court. The woman does not live in New York. TMZ reports the woman never wanted to appear in court at all, refusing to cooperate and never agreed to testify against Diddy.
Starting point is 00:58:49 Prosecutors said victim 3 would disclose very personal and explosive details concerning abuse she suffered under combs. Plenty of respect to Harvey Levin over at TMZ, but they had to speak to her at some point in order to put her on the witness list. Right now the state is down a victim. Victim gone. Even though we know at some point she had to speak to the feds, even the lawyer is not responding to calls.
Starting point is 00:59:19 Joining me there at Diddy's Mansion in Florida, where the neighbors are happy this thing may finally be put to rest, Robert Crispin joining us. Crispin Special Investigations, former Federal Task Force officer, US Department of Justice. Robert, a witness, not just a witness, but a victim is in the wind. I've had it happen to me on a child sex trafficking case the victim Disappeared and was in no show the first day and a half of trial Let me just say I was out all night Literally with my investigator going to every flop house in inner-city Atlanta trying to find the girl
Starting point is 01:00:01 We found her and went forward then I would try the case all day long. We found her. Not so easy in the Diddy case. This victim could be anywhere in the U.S. and the lawyer's not picking up the phone. Yeah. We call that being scared to death. That's exactly what that is. This person doesn't want to testify. She's already related to the government that she doesn't want to testify because if she testifies And he's found guilty she's damned if they find him not guilty She's damned because they let a alleged sexual predator back on the street It's it's a lose-lose situation for a victim and it's very intimidating Very intimidating even though you're a victim with all the victims
Starting point is 01:00:45 rights and the victim advocates. When it comes down to you getting up and sitting in that chair and raising your right hand and actually telling your story, it's very intimidating. Not only is it intimidating, it brings up bad past in your mind and in your heart. It's really something that a lot of people, they don't want to be part of anymore. Crispin, Crispin. It's time to go away. Intimidating.
Starting point is 01:01:07 They all know what happened to Cassie Ventura. And that was at a public hotel. They know what happened to her. No wonder she's disappeared and the lawyer's not picking the phone up. And we know that even from behind bars, prosecutors have produced evidence. Combs is tampering with witnesses. Listen. Prosecutors say even behind bars, Sean Combs has an uncanny ability to get others to do his bidding. Diddy has been accused of obstructing his sex trafficking case by paying off witnesses
Starting point is 01:01:40 and even enlisting his own children in a public relations campaign. You want to tell me he hasn't tried to get to the victims? Listen. Prosecutors say evidence from Sean Combs' cell shows the accused rapper made relentless efforts from jail to contact potential witnesses, including victims. These methods reportedly involved three-way calls using other inmates' phone access codes, a third-party communication service and directing family members to contact potential witnesses. The aim?
Starting point is 01:02:11 To blackmail victims and witnesses into either silence or to provide testimony helpful to Combs. Speaking of getting to the victims, straight out to Sydney Summer joining us, crime stories investigative reporter Sydney, Isn't it true? Prosecutors are planning to introduce evidence that Sean Combs forced one of his victims to undergo an unwanted medical procedure. I mean, was it an abortion? I don't know.
Starting point is 01:02:40 But what can you tell me about that? If he could force a victim to undergo an operation, a medical procedure, what makes the state think he's not trying to scare or intimidate the victims in this case, Sydney? No, that's right, Nancy. Prosecutors intend to introduce this evidence, and we don't know yet what that unwanted medical procedure was. You're completely right. And definitely could have been an abortion going along with the fact that Diddy coerces all of these women into unwanted sexual encounters and then
Starting point is 01:03:16 doesn't want to keep relationships with them. So prosecutors are introducing this to show that pattern of behavior, to show the level of control that Sean Combs exerted over his victims. So that could be really powerful in front of the jury. It was exactly 10 20 a.m. this morning that the jury came into the courtroom with Sean Combs standing at attention to impanel and swear in the jury. This is a day that's been long and coming. The state claims that decades of abuse of women and so-called free coughs have
Starting point is 01:03:55 occurred. Finally, will there be justice? This as one of the victims disappears. Can't find her or her lawyer. Straight out of Sydney Sumner joining us, Crime Stories investigative reporter. I understand in light of victim number 3, a no-show, the state has added victim 5 to the roster. Now, victim 5, who is not mentioned in charging documents, will not be able to just replace victim 3.
Starting point is 01:04:26 Judge Subramanian has ruled that they will not be able to include all of the intended testimony, only part of it, because this victim is a similar transaction. This victim will also not be granted anonymity. We know that one of the victims is not asking to testify under a pseudonym. It's Cassie Ventura. Cassie Ventura is heavily pregnant at this juncture. And her cross-examination by the defense is going to be very tricky. Listen. tricky. Listen, when you have a pregnant lady, a mom, up on the stand, I mean, you
Starting point is 01:05:07 know, how cruel can you be? You can't really shred her on the stand. That my friends at Tooby and of course Mark Garagos gave me a very vague answer on that. But Eric Faddis, if the defense team comes across as bullying Cassie Ventura, that's going to totally play against Combs. That's going to rub the jury the wrong way. Absolutely. I mean, you know, not only do you have this superstar already sympathetic victim, but there's a video of her being brutalized. And the person being brutalized is going to be on the stand pregnant telling you how she was verbally and sexually brutalized. And so it's going to be a delicate dance here. The defense has to kind of approach this in a sensitive fashion, but also be firm enough
Starting point is 01:05:57 to get their points across. And so the balance to be struck here cannot be understated. Well, I got to say this to Dr. Bethany Marshall. Cassie Ventura is going to be able to handle whatever they throw at her. She is the one that broke the whole thing wide open when she filed that civil lawsuit. And basically, the feds had a red flag waved in front of them like a like a bull had a red flag waved in front of them like a like a bull because it was out there and they were left looking emasculated. They had done nothing and here's this video. Let's take a look at the video everybody. This is coming into
Starting point is 01:06:38 court in a different iteration. There you see Cassie Ventura. Oh and here he comes. Thank goodness that towel didn't slip. She's trying to get away reportedly from a freak-off. Now, Garagos tells me it wasn't a freak-off at all. That she was the aggressor. She, Cassie Ventura, is the aggressor in this video. She, according to Gyarrago, was angry when she saw Combs had gotten texts from another woman. Okay, she looks like she weighs about a hundred pounds soaking wet in that video, but yet Gyarrago said with a straight face, this is from our friends at CNN by the way, a straight face that she was the aggressor.
Starting point is 01:07:32 Now okay, Dr. Bethany, Garagos, his daughter is on the defense team, Tenny, Garagos, is saying that you're not seeing what you think you're seeing. She's actually the aggressor in that video. Really? Are they actually gonna say that to a jury? 100 pound Cassie is giving Diddy the beat down? I sound like a broken record,
Starting point is 01:07:59 but Nancy, jurors are not stupid. And jurors can feel like they're being kind of manipulated or mistreated. And I think the defense should be very careful with this line of reasoning. You know, the truth is, you see this young Cassie Ventura running for her life with bare feet. The allegations that he was on the phone doing business deals while he coerced her into having sex with somebody else while he was watching could phone doing business deals while he coerced her into having sex with somebody else while he was watching, could come out. He kicks her in the back. She has to pretend to play dead. He drags her back down the hallway. And then the jurors see
Starting point is 01:08:35 this beautiful, resilient woman who has reestablished her life, probably has a new relationship, is going to create a family. This is a woman to be admired. She rose above the trauma. She did the work, whatever she did to reconstitute herself. She is a very admirable witness. So they are going to hang on every single word, Nancy, because most victims do not establish themselves like this. Bob Shell in the courtroom. The defense is actually going to argue that Cassie Ventura was the aggressor. That she was the one giving Sean Combs the beat down.
Starting point is 01:09:18 What juror is going to believe that? Especially in light of this. My behavior on that video is inexcusable. I take full responsibility for my actions in that video. I'm disgusted. I was disgusted then when I did it, I'm disgusted now. I went and I sought out professional help. I had to go into therapy, I had to go into rehab. professional help. I had to go into therapy. I had to go into rehab. I had to ask God for His mercy and grace. Second verse, same as the first. So if he didn't do it, why is he apologizing for it? And that song comes as official Instagram. I wonder if they're going to play that. We know the Cassie Matero tape is in.
Starting point is 01:10:26 Straight back out to Lauren Collins standing by. I understand the courtroom holds about a hundred people and I guess it was packed, right? Okay, we'll get the answer to that. You know, I'm hearing Lynn Shaw Combs in that video stating he wants to be a better person, he's disgusted with himself, he's going to rehab, but yet, that's out of one side of his mouth, out of the other side of his mouth, he's actually going to argue to the jury that Cassie was the violent one.
Starting point is 01:10:59 Please stop, Nancy, because I'm getting sick. I'm getting sick. Watching that video over and over again, we have to remember people are visual. Once they see that video, this will stick in their minds. Now listen, we work with a lot of survivors and victims at the Warriors. What do they tell me repeatedly? When they are being attacked, they play dead, they do not move. They don't want to further enrage that person. They don't want
Starting point is 01:11:24 more beatings. So they remain very still. Where is her video of her beating him? That's what I want to know. Why is this playbook the same thing? We're in court a lot. Flipped on putting it on the victim. Oh, it's their fault.
Starting point is 01:11:38 They caused me to do it. That's consensual. You know what? The jury again, like Dr. Bethany said, like I'm saying as a New Yorker, New Yorkers are smart. They're not going to buy this. And you know what? The jury again, like Dr. Bethany said, like I'm saying as a New Yorker, New Yorkers are smart, they're not gonna buy this. And you know what? Dirty diddy going down.
Starting point is 01:11:49 We are in a verdict watch as we wait for the Sean Cone's jury to hand down a verdict. Nancy Grace signing off. Goodbye, friend. This is an iHeart Podcast.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.