Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - GABRIELLE, 10, LAST SEEN NEAR MALL: WHERE’S GABBY?

Episode Date: January 21, 2026

Authorities double the reward to $10,000 for anyone who has information regarding the disappearance of 10-year-old Gabrielle Terrelonge. Call 954-493-TIPS (8477).  Gabrielle was reported missing when it was discovered her mother was incarcerated in Florida. Gabrielle’s father pleads for help, saying he is desperate to bring his daughter home.  Gabrielle, 10, has been missing since June. Gabrielle's father, Gordon Terrelonge alleges he believed his daughter to be with her mother, 34-year-old Passaha Davis, who inturn says Gabrielle is with her father.  The dad reports her missing Oct. 29, 2025. Gabrielle Terrelonge - 10 now and at time of disappearance DATE OF BIRTH: June 25, 2015  MISSING SINCE: October 2025  HAIR: black  EYES: brown  HEIGHT: 4 feet 8 inches  WEIGHT: 100 pounds  Joining Nancy Grace:  Brian Fitzgibbons - Director of Operations for USPA Nationwide Security, Leads a team of investigators specializing in locating missing persons, website: www.uspasecurity.com, Instagram: @uspa_nationwide_security, former Marine and Iraq war veteran  Dave Mack - Investigative Reporter, 'Crime Stories'  See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

This is an I-Heart podcast. Guaranteed Human. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. A 10-year-old little girl is missing. Where is Gabrielle? Please join us in our search for this 10-year-old little girl, joining me to incredible guests. Straight out to Dave Matt, Crime Stories, investigative reporter. What can you tell me about Gabrielle?

Nancy, Gabrielle, Teralong, is a 10-year-old little girl. who has a very up until recently overprotective mother in Pasha Davis. We do not know where Gabrielle is right now. And her father, Gordon, has been looking for her ever since the middle of October when he saw that Pasha Davis, Gabrielle's mother, was in jail in South Florida. And he called and said, where's my daughter? Who has my daughter? And they said, we don't know about a daughter.

Tasha Davis has been silent ever since. You know, this is an eerie reminder of when Top Mom Casey Anthony's parents, Georgia Cindy Anthony, confronted her behind bars about where is Kelly? And she went through the roof. I don't know what's going on my entire life has been taken from me. Everything has been taken from me. You don't, you guys are not understanding my side on this and I'm sorry. They don't want to go.

Can someone let me, come on, Casey. The fact, Dave Mack, that she is not answering her husband, guys, a missing Margate girl's father says he confronted the mom. There she is. There's Gabrielle in a jail house visit. Now, that occurred on Thanksgiving Day. he hoped he could get answers from her and try to find his daughter. Did it work? Brian Fitzgibbons is joining us, Director of Operations, USA, nationwide security.

He leads a team of investigators who go around the world looking for missing people. See, one problem we've got among so many trying to find this little 10-year-old girl, if you have any information regarding her disappearance, If you think you've seen this beautiful little child is 10 years old, please dial 954, 493, 847. There is a $5,000 reward and it is climbing. Fitzgibbittins, one of our problems is we've lost a lot of time. Absolutely, because Nancy, it's important to remember the last verified sighting of Gabrielle goes all the way back to June 30th. when she was seen at a Greyhound bus stop with her mother, Pasha.

So that's June 30th, 2025. You know, she wasn't reported missing until late October by her father when her father realized that the mother was incarcerated. But that's, you know, that's a four-month gap of time. It's very similar, as I said, to top mom, Casey Anthony. We're not really sure how much time had passed before little Keeley was really. reported missing at least a month. Same thing in a case that's going on right now. Melody buzzard, a gorgeous little girl, last seen with her mother on a cross-country trip. Never seen

again. It does not bode well. Dave Mac, why is mom behind bars? It goes back to two different things, Nancy, but she was first arrested for shoplifting food from a dollar store on October the 17th. It was during that incarceration where Gordon Terralong finds out she's in jail and calls and says, where is my daughter? Well, the police go to Pasha Davis in jail and say, well, where is your daughter? And she says, oh, I gave Pasha to her father back in July. So they actually cut her loose right then. $200 bail to get out.

Well, a couple of days go by November 4th, they realized she never gave Gabrielle to her father. The father is saying, I'm looking for her. And they rearrest Pasha Davis again, this time on November 4th, for child neglect and for withholding information about where her daughter is located. They even charged her with providing false information to police. You know, you were commenting about how she did not reveal the truth to the dad. It turns out that the mother was living pillar to post. And no particular. place and dragging the little girl, Gabby, along with her. Gabby, according to reports, was last seen sleeping in an alleyway, sleeping in an alleyway, a 10-year-old little girl.

She could have been sold and worse. So, Dave Matt, you stated that at first, mom was arrested for theft by shoplifting. Then the little girl. is spotted sleeping in an alley, would the mother rather her child be dragged from alleyway to alleyway to home to home to man to man rather than let the father take care of her. Look at this girl. I don't know if she's dead or alive. Nancy, you're absolutely right when you say what was she willing to do to keep her daughter to herself and away from Gordon the father. I do want to back up. The picture you see of Gabby on the cardboard in the alleyway,

that photo was taken by Gordon Terralong's sister. They were looking for Gabby and for Pasha to find out where they were so they could bring them home. They have places to stay. Gabby has plenty of places that her mother could take her to stay in comfort. But Pasha just refuses and doesn't want to relinquish any control of Gabby to, any of Gordon's family. So after they took that photo of Gabby in the alleyway sleeping on cardboard, that's when she got back together, Pasha Davis got back together with Gordon briefly. Then they had an argument in Casimi, Florida, and she had Gordon thrown in jail. She takes off then.

That's where this case has continued to back and forth is that Pasha Davis keeping Gabby to herself and away from everyone else up until the point where we last seeing them getting on that bus together on June 30th. Because you know what, Nancy? Seven days later, July 7th, 2025, Pasha Davis is seen getting on that bus alone. Gabby hasn't been seen since June 30th. You know, Dave McGett sounds very much like the case of Melody Buzzard, where Melody was seen with her mother who is wearing a son get up with a wig and different clothing. in a car rental. And that's one of the last times Melody was ever seen.

It's around transport with the mom. And somewhere along the way, the child just gets lost or given away. You're telling me, Dave Mack, that there were places for the child to stay, but the mom refused. Absolutely. And that's the part that really breaks your heart, Nancy. Gordon Taralong, the father of Gabrielle, he has consistently, made a way for Pasha Davis to be with Gabrielle in a safe area, safe environment, whether it's a hotel in Orlando or a home in South Florida.

She's had places. She's chosen to, as you said, drag this little girl from Pillar to Post. And by the way, Nancy, Gordon has tried to, in the past, get Gabby involved in school activities. But as soon as he would, Pasha would grab her back and has repeatedly said she's been homeschooling her daughter. She's kept Gabby out of public interaction to the point where when she is last seen on June 30th, with plenty of other options to go, we don't see anything. I do want to mention something, Nancy. October 17th when Pasha Davis is actually incarcerated for the stealing of food, Gabby's not there with her.

She's good in jail, and that's when Gordon finds out, hey, man, Pasha Davis is in jail. Where's my daughter? You mentioned that Gordon had visited Pasha Davis in jail. He did. He went on Thanksgiving Day. And said, please, just tell me where my baby is. This man has been doing everything he can. He has stood and looked for his daughter.

And Pasha Davis flat out refuses to communicate at all with anyone about Gabby. Brian Fitzgibbon is joining us, Director of Operations, USPA, nationwide security, who leads a team of investigators locating people around the world. I'm going to circle back to you about what we need to do now to find Gabrielle, also known as Gabby. She's just 10 years old. But I want you to take a look at this video

that we obtained from our friends at NBC6. This is mom in court. Mom still refusing to answer any questions about Gabby's location. She has been uncooperative from the start, refusing to discuss where her daughter is. She even refused to give her name. name to the police stating that I don't think it's fair. I have to give my name.

Brian Fitzgibbens, is it unusual or is it SOP, standard operating procedure when you see a missing child has been cut off from friends or relatives the way the mom here has cut her off from her dad, from school, from extracurricular activities, and isolates her. I'll tell you, this is more common than you would think, especially with very contentious custody issues, as you saw Gabrielle's parents had. And then you add in, you know, mental health, problems with the law. This is, this is not outside the realm of possibility. And one thing I will add, there has to be hope here that Pasha handed Gabrielle off to some associate or person known to her or her family. family and that there's that's the reason that they're they're not providing this information.

I think that's the greatest hope right now for for Gabrielle and that this word can get out there and they can realize that she is indeed missing and that people are looking for her. Isn't it true, Brian Fitzgibbittance, that very often domestic feuding can get in the way of finding your missing child? Yeah, because, you know, you have people on all sides of this. And, you know, let's say hypothetically that Gabrielle is staying with an associate of Pasha right now. They're feeling righteous in their actions, you know, putting a roof over her head, feeding her, providing her clothing and things like that. So they feel that they're doing the right thing.

And the word here is they have to come forward. If your housing Gabrielle right now, you've got to call authorities, you've got to come forward, and we need to make sure that this little girl is safe. We're getting conflicting reports. Dave Matt, Crime Stories, Investigator, reporter. Other reports are stating that Gabby,

Gabrielle Teralong, was last seen near a mall, the Florida mall. We can't even pin down the last known siding, can we? That does not bode well for the search. Actually, you know, when Orlando and the mall that they're talking about there, that is actually near where the bus was. Gabby was seeing getting off a bus with Pasha Davis

at the Florida Mall, which is in Orlando. She had been living previously in the months before in the Orlando area, and at one point in time with her father, Gordon Terralong and Pasha Davis and Gabby were in a hotel in Orlando. But again, all of that end, June 30th, right there at that bus stop, where you see her getting off of a bus with her mom, and then a week later, you see Davis by herself getting on the bus.

Take a listen to Gabriel's father, begging, begging for the public to help find his daughter. I'm here to talk about my missing daughter, Gabrielle Taralong. If anybody has heard anything or can give us anywhereabouts, I've seen them anywhere, please. I beg. I'm begging from the bottom of,

of my heart. I just want to find my daughter. I want her to come home. If she's out there and she can hear me now, we're going to find you. Just hold on. That from our friends at Fox 35, Orlando, he states it has been a nightmare searching for his daughter. Tonight, we don't know her last known sighting. We don't know if she has been given away, if she has been sold, if she was put on a Brayhound bus and sent to God only knows where. Has she been taken in by misguided people thinking they're doing the right thing? All I know tonight is mom is not cooperating and dad is begging. What now, Brian Fitzgibbon's USPA nationwide security?

The family, Gordon's family needs to continue to push to get the word out about Gabrielle. That is the most pressing thing right now because I believe that the, The greatest chance that Gabrielle is alive and okay is that she's being harbored by an associate or a family member of Pasha. What about it, Dave Mack? Tell us what's happening now. I have not seen this covered anywhere. It's like Gabriel never did exist. She's missing. A 10-year-old little girl is missing, Dave Mac. Not just missing, Nancy, but we actually have a documented timeline that we can start with from June 3rd. 30th through July 7th. I think that's the key period to look at because that's the time we see her getting off the bus with her mom and then we see mom getting on the bus without her daughter, Gabby.

Then we go forward, as we've mentioned now, from the time that Pasha Davis was arrested in October on the 17th, she has been not just uncooperative, but she's lied to police about the whereabouts of her daughter. She has ignored the child's father, Gordon, who is just asking, tell me where my baby, is. And here we are. All these months later, Pasha Davis, still in jail and still not talking. She's the only person who could know what she did with her daughter, and she's still playing her story. I gave Gabby to her dad back in July. That's her story, and she's sticking to that. That is a very eerie reminder of cult mom, Lori Vallow. When a welfare check was made at the insistence of relatives of JJ and Tiley, her two of her children. She told police,

she told authorities that the children were with relatives and actually even gave an address. L.E. goes to that location the following day. They're not there. They circle back to cult mom Lori Vallow and she has actually moved out. She's gone. The remains of Tiley and J.E. were found in a pet cemetery on the property of her new husband, the so-called prophet, Chad Daybell. Both of them are convicted in those murders now. But it's a clear case of hide the ball, Brian Fitzgibbons. Dave Mack is right.

The little girl, Gabby, Gabrielle, last thing we, think at a mall with her mom. She's vanished. The mom says she doesn't know where her daughter is. Gabrielle Terrell Long, 10 years old, last seen getting off a Greyhound bus with her mom at the Florida Mall, Orlando. When asked later, where is Gabrielle? She says, she says, with her dad. She was not with her dad, like in the case of Colt Mom Lori Val. and it was at that point her dad reports her missing shortly after the FBI issues a missing child alert. We are joining Gabrielle's father in our plea to you. Help us find Gabrielle. There is a $5,000 reward for anyone with information about Gabrielle's whereabouts and breaking right now.

That $5,000 reward has done. now being raised by Broward County Crime Stoppers to $10,000, $10,000 for information leading to Gabrielle. Just think about it. This little girl is 10 years old. She could be out on the streets alone. Hungry? Alone in the elements? Please help us find Gabrielle. The tip line again.

954-493-8477. Repeat. 954-493-847. Thank you. This is an I-Heart podcast. Guaranteed human.