Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - GLAM PASTOR'S WIFE SHOCK SUICIDE: FBI CALLED IN

Episode Date: May 15, 2024

As family and friends hold a beachside service for Mica Miller, John Paul Miller delivers a eulogy for his estranged wife at Solid Rock at Market Common. Miller seems to cry as he talks about how he t...ried to raise Mica from the dead. He claims he laid down with his wife about 4 times and when he took a dog tag necklace Mica had given him to the mall to get it fixed, he saw a woman wearing "Mica's dress" with the same tattoo and hairstyle, he calls out "Mica!" but it was her sister, thought he raised Mica from the dead. Since the first days of the investigation into Miller's death, the Robeson County Sheriff's Office has been in contact with the FBI and the United States Attorney's Office for assistance. Based on information gathered during the investigation and jurisdiction reasons, the Sheriff's office has now requested assistance from both agencies. Mica Miller's body is found in Robeson County, North Carolina, but Mica lives in South Carolina and purchases the gun near her home in Myrtle Beach. Joining Nancy Grace today:  Sierra Francis - Sister of Mica Miller Regina Ward -  Attorney for Sierra Francis; Regina Ward Law FirmAllicia  Young -  Mica and John-Paul Miller's former friend Traci Brown – Body Language Expert & Author: “How to Detect Lies, Fraud and Identity Theft;” X: @Tracibrown37  Brian Foley –  Board-certified Criminal Defense Attorney, Former Chief Prosecutor in Harris County, (Houston) Texas; Author: “What Prosecutors Don’t Tell You” (not yet published); Instagram @brianfoleylawpllc/ Youtube – @brianfoleylawyer/X: @brianpllc Dr. Bethany Marshall – Psychoanalyst (Beverly Hills); X: @DrBethanyLive/ Instagram & TikTok: drbethanymarshall; Appearing in “Paris in Love” on Peacock; BOOK: “Deal Breaker: When to work on a relationship and when to walk away” Kayla Brantley – Reporter, DailyMail.com; X: @_KaylaBrantley, Instagram: @KaylaBrantley      See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is an iHeart Podcast. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Bombshell tonight, the FBI now called in to investigate the shooting death of Micah Miller, the glamorous wife of a local pastor who authorities say took her own life. Micah found dead in Lumberstate River Park from a gunshot wound. Her family now urging authorities to further investigate the death. This, as we learned, his ex-wife said much the same. Reports now surfacing the pastor not only posted, wait for it, intimate photos of Micah, his wife online, but then apologized for his evil question. Which evil? Good evening.
Starting point is 00:00:59 I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime Stories. Thank you for being with us. She was so creative. Everything. She was so creative. Everything she did was so creative. What's the next picture? Okay. That is the estranged husband, John Paul Miller.
Starting point is 00:01:20 We have guinea pigs and sometimes they hiccup and they go. That kind of sounds like that that is seemingly very emotional video of the pastor at solid rock ministries he actually went on to deliver his wife's eulogy and is now claiming he tried to quote, raise her from the dead. Now I'm certainly not a Bible expert, but I can tell you in the history of the earth, I've only known of one person that raised somebody from the dead and it ain't him. Okay. With me, an all-star panel to make sense of what we know right now. Hold on. I want you to hear it from the horse's mouth. Listen. I got this late next to her body and been done with her body about four times this week. And each time it still didn't hit me. I thought she was going to wake up. I even tried to raise her from the dead one time this week.
Starting point is 00:02:29 Okay, she's not waking up. Why? Because this beautiful young preacher's wife is dead from a gunshot wound. So far, we're not getting a lot of information about, for instance, trajectory path. Was the gunshot residue test run on her hands? What do we really know? We know there was a 911 call, but what more do we know? This is authorities insist this was a suicide, but friends and family insist they want the FBI to further investigate her death. And apparently that is happening. You were just seeing video from Solid Rock Ministries in a seemingly emotional eulogy. At this hour, the FBI reportedly opening an investigation after bombshells surrounding her death, including
Starting point is 00:03:27 reports that her husband, John Paul Miller posted quote, intimate. I hate to think what that is. Photos of his young wife online and then leaving no room for, Hey, did he do it or not? He apologized for his quote evil. And I want to warn everybody on the panel that we have just gotten a letter from the Russell B. Long attorneys at law threatening everybody if they say anything that disparages the pastor. But you know, it's really interesting that his former wife got a divorce because she claimed the preacher was having an affair on her, including with the babysitter. Who's the babysitter?
Starting point is 00:04:31 Micah. Okay, back to our panel. Joining me, a special guest right now. This is Micah's sister, Sierra. Sierra Francis with us. Sierra, first of all, we are so sorry about what you and your family are going through. A lot of us on the panel have been victims of violent crime, including myself. And I think the worst possible thing that could happen is to lose your child. You're suffering from losing your
Starting point is 00:05:06 sibling. And what a beautiful, beautiful girl on the inside and the outside. Tell me about your sister. Micah was amazing. She was energetic. She was funny. She was always trying to make sure everybody around her was happy and she was always trying to include everyone. She was very passionate about her missions trips to Kenya and nutrition. She was just an all around wonderful, God fearing woman. When did she meet the preacher that became her husband? It would have been probably in 2007, 2008, when our family moved to Myrtle Beach. Collectively, our stepfather and mother moved our whole family there. And we began to attend Solid Rock when it was a smaller congregation of maybe 30, 40 people.
Starting point is 00:05:53 How old was Micah at that time? Probably around 13 or 14. Is that when she met the preacher, John Paul Miller, that she would marry? Yes, that would have been around that time. Is it true that at that time he, John Paul Miller, was her youth minister? I believe so. I know that he was involved in pretty much every aspect of the church because it was such a small church. I'm very curious also about everything was said in the eulogy. You know what? I'm very curious about how all this is striking you, Sierra, Micah's sister. Take a listen to this. While Micah Miller's family and friends hold service
Starting point is 00:06:32 beachside for Micah, John Paul Miller delivers a eulogy for his estranged wife, Micah Miller, at Solid Rock at Market Common. Miller seems to cry without any tears while talking about how he tried to raise Micah from the dead. Claims he laid down with his wife about four times and when he took a dog tag necklace Micah had given him to the mall to get it fixed, he saw a woman wearing Micah's dress with the same tattoo and hairstyle. He calls out, Micah! But it was her sister. Thought he had raised Micah from the dead.
Starting point is 00:06:59 To Sister Sierra, did that really happen? It did and I was carrying my children at the time and my son was very afraid. And he said, we have to go right now. Why was your son afraid? Because we're very open with my son. Micah has come to my house multiple times to get away from her estranged husband. So my son is very aware of the dangers surrounding him to the point where whenever Micah passed away and my son came home and I had to tell him that she had passed away, he said, this is all John Paul's fault. I've had a lot of women that have reached out to me about situations of abuse.
Starting point is 00:07:38 And I just want to tell you what a lot of people have told me lately and reminded me because I think I forgot. I knew, but I pushed it in the back of my head just because of my situation. But you are the bride of Christ. God hates divorce. But why? According to everybody I've asked and the scriptures that I've found, it's because it hurts people. But does abuse hurt people? How do you think God feels about that? Joining me right now is another special guest, Tracy Brown, who is a body language expert, author of How to Detect Lies, Fraud, and Identity Theft. You can find her at bodylanguagetrainer.com.
Starting point is 00:08:27 Tracy, thank you so much for being with us. I know you have studied Pastor John Paul Miller's movements, his speech. I was referring earlier to the hiccups, which apparently was a facsimile of crying. And I also noticed that one of his assistants came out and gave him a box of hankies. And he went, no, I don't need that. Because there didn't seem to be any actual tears. Just the sounds. But I'm just a lay person.
Starting point is 00:08:59 I'm just a trial lawyer. What do you, the body language experts, see? Well, we didn't see tears. We didn't see eye redness. And the most important thing that we saw is that the emotions, the sadness got shut on and off like a light switch. And that's not how emotions work. Emotions are chemically based. And so they build slowly and they dissipate slowly. Like the chemicals have a half-life. And so this is the first indication of faked sadness here.
Starting point is 00:09:32 Now, what's more important is when I profile people, because I listen closely and I want to understand what does this person want me to know about them the most? And what he's doing throughout this whole eulogy is selling how much he has tried to please her over their life together and also what a good guy he is. So this is the subtext of this is more of a sales pitch about what a great person he is. Now, if we dive deep into his exact words, what he does throughout this, and here's one of the statements, and this is a quote, everyone knew how beautiful she was on the outside. Only a spouse, okay, so he didn't say him, he said a spouse, that's distancing. Only a spouse knows how beautiful that person is, that person, again, distances, how beautiful that person is. That person, again, distances. How beautiful that person is on the inside.
Starting point is 00:10:30 So he has statements similar to this throughout the eulogy where he distances himself from her. Another one is imagine being married to that. Right. Which is another psychological, emotional distance statement that we see from him. And what's missing, because the other thing that I do when I profile people is I go, okay, what's missing here? What's missing are the typical things that you would hear in a eulogy from a husband, right? Which is how much he misses her, how shocked he is. Cause what he says is it
Starting point is 00:11:07 hasn't hit me. He says it hasn't hit me. He says it, uh, two to three times in there. And so we don't, he's not revealing any emotional attachment to what happened now. Um, he, he also says that, um, he's, he's not, he's not talking about how much he loved her. He doesn't talk about any of those things that would be typical in a speech such as this. So all these things really add up to someone who is not being genuine in their emotion. Now, we don't have a smoking gun with what he said. I'd like to see an interview with him specifically about this, like a police interview, which I haven't seen. But we have some disturbing behavior here. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace.
Starting point is 00:12:05 Isn't it true to Sierra? This is Micah's sister who is literally speaking to us through her tears, real tears. At one point, he was trying to apologize for posting nude photos of her. I assume they were intimate, so I can only guess nude online. Instead, he wanted to quote, attack and cause pain for Micah. He, you know what? As many arguments as my husband and I have had over the years, especially since we had children, I've never wanted to hurt David. And I can honestly say he's never wanted to actually hurt me in any way, even when we're angry about some issue. But to write out, apologize for posting nude photos of your wife online and say, I'm sorry, I wanted to attack and cause you pain. Yes,
Starting point is 00:13:01 that's very normal behavior for John Paul. He's always done that to her. He's very open about it. Why do you say that? That's what he always does. If he can't get his way, he will act as a child. He will throw a tantrum, he will cause a scene, and he will make sure that the other person suffers. And like you said, there's emails proving it. I've had a lot of women that have reached out to me about situations of abuse. And I just want to tell you what a lot of people have told me lately and reminded me because I think I forgot. I knew, but I pushed it in the back of my head just because of my situation. But you are the bride of Christ. God hates divorce.
Starting point is 00:13:51 But why? According to everybody I've asked and the scriptures that I've found, it's because it hurts people. But does abuse hurt people? How do you think God feels about that? You know, I want our body language expert, Tracy Brown, the body language trainer to listen to this more of the preacher. And remember everybody, he sent a legal threat letter stating, don't talk about me. Okay. Let's listen to the words from the horse's mouth. I can't wait to see her again one day she was so creative she just it was just always just coming out of her imagine being married to
Starting point is 00:14:33 that it was like that in our house all the time dear lord in heaven okay um heaven. Okay. That is a seemingly emotional video from Solid Rock Ministries. You know, I've got so many questions for Sierra, but to our body language expert, Tracy, here's a few things I noticed having put literally thousands of witnesses on the stand for direct and cross-examination. For instance, the pacing back and forth, the smiling inappropriately during the eulogy, the wiping tears over and over that don't exist, the rubbing of the hands repeatedly throughout, the touching the head, touching the hair. There's nothing to adjust. His hair is like that long. What is he doing? The clapping, the clapping and the seemingly endless, I don't know what, what is that? There's small repetitive movements that we'll all do when we need to let off stress.
Starting point is 00:15:39 This is a high stress moment for him. Now, we also saw what I thought was really interesting. And what you don't see from a lot of preachers or a lot of people that are used to speaking is his hand in his pocket. And I was, I looked at it pretty closely and it might even be in a fist and his, and that's, that's when we're holding something back. We're holding back information or we're holding back emotion. If that hand indeed is in a fist, that says anger. So all of these things add up to something that our mind sees and it goes, wait a minute, something's not right here. Something's not right here. And that's because the emotions are not genuine. And I'm not going to speculate as to why they're not genuine, right? Body language
Starting point is 00:16:27 tells you what's on someone's mind. It doesn't tell you why. You could put together a list of that. I think there's plenty of evidence that other folks have for that. But what we're seeing is disingenuous behavior. I pray for your healing. Circumstances would change. I pray that the fear inside would flee in Jesus name. I pray that breakthrough would happen today. I pray miracles over your life In Jesus' name In Jesus' name Micah contacted police after her estranged husband posted an indecent photo of her on a Facebook group called Big Boobs and Nice Curves.
Starting point is 00:17:23 Police told Micah since the photo was posted anonymously, there was nothing they could do. John Paul Miller apologized to Micah via email, telling her, I'm sorry for putting a picture of you on the internet. He added, I just wanted to try and hurt you. He also included, it was evil of me to do that. Evil of me to do that. Okay, curious. After an intimate photo of his wife, unclad, was posted online by him and he admits it, why no charges? But I don't understand why no charges, why no arrests, but that's not all. Listen. Just weeks before her death, Micah Miller calls police for help when she finds a tire on her car is flat. Police discover a tire deflator is used on the tire. Micah goes to East Coast Honda in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina to get a new tire where John Paul Miller shows up.
Starting point is 00:18:13 The two get into an argument. Video shows John Paul Miller aggressively walking around Micah, threatening to post a picture online, while Micah says, walk away. A mechanic later shows Micah a GPS tracking device had been placed on her car. I'm very disturbed about this. Kayla Brantley joining us, along with Micah's sister, Sierra Francis. Kayla Brantley, investigative reporter, dailymail.com.
Starting point is 00:18:38 Kayla, we have two incidents. One admitted, one observed, that they're both illegal. Posting photos of a woman or anyone online where they are nude or partially nude against their consent is illegal. Placing a tracking device or cutting someone's car tires,egal. Why no arrest, Kayla Brantley? Well, according to police, they allegedly told Micah that despite all this evidence, that the photo that she allegedly sent him, once you send a photo, it's now no longer your property and that now belongs to her husband. And also that in the photo, there was actually muzzing around any parts that would make it fully nude, which then means that it apparently does not
Starting point is 00:19:32 count as revenge porn. So basically when Micah came to them, they told her that there was nothing that they could do. Okay. To Regina Ward, she was the lawyer for Micah on the divorce proceeding. Now here with Micah's sister, Sierra. Regina, that's not true. When you post a photo of someone without their clothes on against their will, that's illegal. Yes, in more ways than one. What I don't understand is why there weren't any charges. I guess that's my question to you.
Starting point is 00:20:09 Why weren't there charges? As far as I know on that, the police took the position that it was posted anonymously, as I understand, therefore not enough, quote, evidence to say that it was him. I don't think he made an admission until later. So it'll be interesting to see if they'll follow up now with that crime and pursue it. Sierra is joining me, Micah's sister, Sierra.
Starting point is 00:20:35 Your sister, Micah, never gave him permission to post that photo of her. He has apologized. He has apologized for the car incident. Why no charges? Like Regina said, I would hope that the police will follow up now that there is proof of these alleged crimes that he was keeping his hands clean up and making it so difficult for Mike to prove. And now that he's admitted that he did commit these crimes, I see no reason why they cannot hold him accountable at this point. To Brian Foley joining me, high profile lawyer, former chief prosecutor, Harris County, Texas, and author of What Prosecutors Don't Tell You. Brian Foley, let's just break it down. Typically, when somebody posts revenge porn, they won't send it from their account. They come up with a fake account.
Starting point is 00:21:31 They do it at the public library some way that it can't be easily traced. But guess what? It can be traced. That's what the police or the sheriffs are supposed to do. Trace it and prosecute it. Not say, oh, it was anonymous. Sorry. That's not how it works, Foley. Well, in some instances, it's because the image itself doesn't qualify.
Starting point is 00:21:48 Like, for example, in Texas, we have a rule that says the person's face has to be identifiable. You have to be able to say it's a specific person. So if you cut out the face, it's no longer under that statute. It sounds like there was some blurring that happened to these photos in particular. And the police keep doing, you know, in the original investigation and I guess in this revenge porn investigation, they keep following the law, which I as a defense attorney, I think it's a good thing. OK, hold on. Let's let's find out more about that photo. Sierra Francis, this is Micah's sister. Tell me about the revenge porn that was posted of your sister. What was it? So John Paul had assumed basically Micah's identity while he had her hospitalized.
Starting point is 00:22:31 He took her Facebook, her cell phone, her laptop, her iCloud. He took everything. And he was pretending to be her, texting people, emailing people, posting on her behalf as though he was her. And at one point, he posted a topless photo of her, her face in the picture. And he added some sort of hue over it. Like if you took a highlighter across the front of her chest, um, just to barely cover, you could still see what, what exactly what it was. But I guess he knew that since he posted it one off of Micah's account against her will without her
Starting point is 00:23:04 permission, he thought he would get away with it. And to this point, he has. And there's the issue of the flat tires in the GPS tracking device, which he apologized for, reportedly. Of course, he is claiming and insisting that he is not guilty, has not been named as a person of interest or suspect in her death. Guys, I want to go on quickly to the bombshell now, the FBI reportedly being called in to investigate her death. To Sierra, this is Micah's sister. What is it you want the FBI to do? So we know that Robeson County has said that the FBI is investigating, but we don't know exactly what their investigation will pertain to. I would love for them to go and investigate what the cops were able to discover and everything leading up to her passing away.
Starting point is 00:23:59 Because as everyone has uncovered, there's a lot more to the story than what meets the eye. And even an earthly spouse who's a good spouse, when they know that their bride is being hurt, just imagine what an earthly spouse does. What do you think your heavenly spouse does when you're the bride of Christ and he sees his bride going through abuse and hurt. What do you think he thinks about that? John Paul Miller's ex-wife, Allison Miller, filed for divorce from John Paul Miller after finding out he was having an affair with their babysitter and his best friend's wife, Micah. Micah Miller was married to John Paul Miller's best friend, Jeremy Deese, whom Micah married when she was just 18. Wow. Okay, so let me understand. To Kayla Brantley joining us, investigative reporter with DailyMail.com,
Starting point is 00:24:55 the other wife, the previous wife, Allison, I've been reading her affidavits in her divorce and in her affidavits, she states that John Paul Miller, who is threatening anybody that, let me see, defames him. So let's just commit to speaking the truth. I'm down with that. The first wife says that church leaders demanded he seek counseling for sex addiction. But when he refused, the majority of the church left the congregation. She also states that he was having multiple affairs and that trying to dodge alimony payments. He showed up in court in a wheelchair and claimed he fell out of a tree and broke both legs. That's the first wife. And I'm getting this from her affidavits and her claims. What about it, Kayla Brantley?
Starting point is 00:26:01 Yeah, that's right, Nancy. So DailyMail.com, we obtained that affidavit and there were bombshells after bombshells in it. Now, she accuses him of having a porn addiction, accus pressured him to do so, which then led to a lot of his congregation leaving because obviously you don't want to have a pastor who's accused. She does also go on to say that Micah was their babysitter and that they started having, you know, a relationship while they were married. And of course, he's 14 years older than Micah. So when she's saying that he groomed her, if they did meet when she was 13 years old, he's 14 years older than Micah. So when she's saying that he groomed her, if they did meet when she was 13 years old, he's 14 years her senior, an adult with children married.
Starting point is 00:26:52 And I want to point out in the legal letter that was sent to us by the preacher's lawyer, our client refutes any report that suggests he abused his wife. Recent reports claim Pastor Miller, quote, groomed his wife from the age of 10. That, in fact, she moved to Myrtle Beach at age 15. And I believe that is when he was her youth minister. Sierra, what went through your mind when you learned your sister had been shot? Instinctively, I just assumed that we would have an arrest and we would be able to finally have some closure of what she was dealing with and all the terror that she was living through. And obviously we haven't gotten that. And that's, that's pretty rough. Guys, we were speaking to Sierra Francis. This is Micah's sister. How did you discover
Starting point is 00:27:51 your sister had been shot? I got a call from my brother that Micah's roommate was trying to find out where Micah was. She said that police had showed up at her house because Micah did not live with John Paul. So the police showed up to his roommate's house or to, I'm sorry, to her roommate's house. And she then reached out to the family. And my brother called me and said, something's wrong. The police are at Diana's house. We need to find Micah. So I immediately called another one of Micah's friends and she informed me that John Paul had said that Micah was dead. So I immediately called John Paul's sister because she lives at John Paul had said that Micah was dead. So I immediately called John Paul's sister because she lives at John Paul's house. And John Paul was on the phone with the
Starting point is 00:28:31 hospital and he was seemingly hysterical. It sounded very fake. And he was saying, why would she do this, Sierra? Why was she sad? Who was she seeing in Lumberton? Micah's dead. And he was just going on and on. And I said, are you joking, John Paul? You know exactly why she would have done this if it was her. And I said that you have been making her life hell for the past couple of months. And he hung up on me. Then he texted my family and said, this is what happens when you tell someone to divorce the man they love. This is, he said, good job, Francis family. And that's how the rest of my family found out that Mike had passed away. OK, wait, would you repeat that, please?
Starting point is 00:29:07 I didn't know that. Yes. He sent a text message out to my parents and siblings. I'm not sure exactly who all was in the chat. It was a previous chat. He just pulled it up and he texted saying, this is what happens when you tell someone to divorce the man they love. Good job, Francis family.
Starting point is 00:29:24 And that's how he informed, you know, my siblings and my parents and Micah have passed away. Again, he is not a suspect in the death of Micah. It has been ruled a suicide. Friends and family are begging the FBI to further investigate. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. To Sierra Francis, I'm concerned and this is what concerns me. The alleged revenge porn for which he apologized for doing it, the slashing of the tires, which reportedly he apologized for doing, the tracking device, all of that is illegal and no charges were ever brought. Do you trust the local investigation? What is your hope for the FBI? And again, the pastor has not been named a person of interest dead end. Every time she followed a police report, every time she called and asked them a question, hey, what can I do?
Starting point is 00:30:49 How do I pursue this? She was getting basically, you know, doors shut in her face every single time. So I hope that now with the gravity of things and how extreme and how nationwide this has gotten, maybe they will look and see, you know, either one, they need to readdress some of their protocols or two, they need to look at their people and say, did you follow protocol and did you do your fullest extent? Or were you just not wanting to get involved because it's a marital dispute? Because obviously to her, it was a big deal. I pray for your healing. Circumst circumstances would change.
Starting point is 00:31:26 I pray that the fear inside would flee. In Jesus' name. I pray that a breakthrough would happen today. I pray miracles
Starting point is 00:31:41 over your life. In Jesus' name. In Jesus' name. In Jesus' name. I've had a lot of women that have reached out to me about situations of abuse. And I just want to tell you what a lot of people have told me lately and reminded me because I think I forgot. I knew, but I pushed it in the back of my head just because of my situation. But you are the bride of Christ.
Starting point is 00:32:20 God hates divorce, but why? According to everybody I've asked and the scriptures that I've found, it's because it hurts people. But does abuse hurt people? How do you think God feels about that? You're hearing Micah Miller posting about the suffering and the pain she says she was going through. Reminder, authorities have not charged her husband in any way with her death. Joining me in all star panel, but now special guest is with us, Alicia Young. Alicia is a very dear friend of Micah's and a former friend of John Paul Miller's, the estranged husband.
Starting point is 00:33:02 Why are you considering yourself a former friend of John Paul Millers? So during our time there, my husband was actually the worship leader when we were there. And so we were very close with them because we were in that inner circle. And when we left the church, our friendship between me and Micah got severed because of him. And, um, our relationship with John Paul, we ended that because he didn't want to listen to anything that we had to say. Um, all the issues that we were seeing with him and the church, what issues? So with how they treat women and how I got treated at the church is basically they celebrate men and with women, women are only supposed to be seen and not heard. He didn't like when a woman had a strong opinion or was, you know, um, kind of outgoing in a way. I was trying to find a different word, but it was all about the
Starting point is 00:34:08 men in the church and that he would stay in sermons of men. You just need to go find a hot wife. Cause that's what matters. And with the women in the church, like I wasn't allowed to do anything in the church at all. He didn't want me on the platform to any capacity because of how I looked and because of how old I was. I was already in my thirties. I was heavier at the time and I wasn't some young 25 year old with a hot body. So he didn't want me at all on the platform. To Brian Foley joining us, a renowned defense attorney and former chief prosecutor Harris County, author of What Prosecutors Don't Tell You. Brian Foley, I think that authorities are dug in that this was a suicide, but I want you to listen to this. As carbon monoxide begins
Starting point is 00:34:59 to fill his truck cabin, Conrad Roy III gets out. Texting Michelle Carter, he'll do it another day. Carter texts to Roy are challenging, telling him he overthinks things. Carter texts Roy, you just said you were going to do it tonight, and now you're saying eventually? Carter tells Roy to get back in the truck. Conrad Roy III gets back in the truck. Authorities discover the body of Conrad Roy III in his pickup truck parked outside a Kmart in Fairhaven, Massachusetts the next day. He was 18. My point, Brian Foley, in that case and many others like it, which we have here to name for you if necessary. Michelle Carter was prosecuted and convicted for aiding and abetting the suicide of Conrad Roy. The texts and conversations she had with him, the messages are sickening, basically goading
Starting point is 00:35:51 him to commit suicide. So my question to you is your thoughts on defending the pastor against claims he goaded Micah into committing suicide like Michelle Carter and others. So first we start with, it sounds like everybody's on the same page. He didn't pull the trigger. He wasn't there. It was Micah who pulled the trigger, uh, ending her own life. Uh, if we're, if we're that far, then the only question we have left is, as public policy, are people responsible for the actions of others? And we have criminal culpability in some instances. If you're both committing a bank robbery, if you're actively engaged in it, JP was not actively engaged in it.
Starting point is 00:36:37 We have information from her cell phone. The police have already released it. She looked up the area in that part of the town. And we're kind of assuming that he's both bumbling around and can't keep things together. And he's obviously lying on the, you know, at the pulpit. It's a suicide. And to hold somebody else responsible, you have to think, well, we're talking about JP and airing out all of his information. If he were to commit suicide, are we responsible for that? No way. Those are individual decisions. And the Conrad Roy case is also very different. I got a call late last night.
Starting point is 00:37:15 My wife has passed away. Yeah, it was it was self-induced and it was up in North Carolina. That is from our friends at Solid Rock Ministries. And a seemingly emotional comment by her then husband. They were not yet divorced. Many people disagree with any such suggestion that there was emotion there. That said, reports to the FBI are now entering the investigation. Kayla Brantley joining me, investigative reporter, DailyMail.com. What is it assumed the FBI can do? Well, Nancy, you're looking at everything that we said before.
Starting point is 00:37:57 Why didn't the police get involved after there was a nude photo? Why didn't police get involved after the fact that he admitted allegedly to putting a tracker in her car or slashing her tire? So I think the FBI coming in is really going to push this case forward and potentially and hopefully do what the local police could not. You know, I'm curious, is it true to anyone's knowledge of what has been reported that he actually went into court in a wheelchair when he was finding alimony payments and said that he fell out of a tree and broke both legs. Kayla Brantley, is that true? Well, that was one of the things that was mentioned in the report that we did get from 2017 from his ex-wife, Allison. Now, she mentioned that she mentioned a lot of instances of abuse, of infidelity. So that's just one of many big issues that we're having here. And going
Starting point is 00:38:51 back to Micah and the local police, she reported eight times in the months leading up to her death to police with clearly no nothing to be done. We await the entry and the involvement of the FBI in the investigation of not only Micah's death, but any related facts leading up to that moment. As of now, it has been ruled a suicide. And the husband, the estranged husband, John Paul Miller, has not been named a suspect. Let's stop and remember American hero police officer Kevin Cram, just 33, shot and killed in the line of duty. Survived by a grieving wife, Laura, and children, Archer and Weston and Ira. American hero police officer Kevin Cram.
Starting point is 00:39:49 Thank you for being with us tonight. Thank you to our MSM viewers and thank you to our guests. Nancy Grace signing off. I'll see you tomorrow night, six and nine o'clock sharp Eastern and until then, goodnight friend

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.