Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - Mom says she killed girl because she was too busy to handle daughter; Dogs left to freeze in arctic blast

Episode Date: January 5, 2018

An Ohio mom tells cops she killed her 5-year-old daughter because the child became too much to handle after a visit with grandparents. A confession video shows Mingming Chen complaining she didn't hav...e the "4 hands" needed to discipline little Ashley, so she killed her and told her husband to "deal with it." The dad stuffed the child behind a freezer in their restaurant before calling police to report her missing. Nancy Grace digs into this case with journalist Jane Velez-Mitchell, psychologist Dr. Pat Saunders, private investigator Vincent Hill, lawyer & child advocate Ashley Willcott, & Crime Stories co-host Alan Duke. Nancy and guests also look at animal cruelty by dog owners who leave pets out in the cold to die during the arctic blast. Learn more about your ad-choices at https://www.iheartpodcastnetwork.comSee omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 You're listening to an iHeart Podcast. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace on Sirius XM Triumph, channel 132. I can't find my daughter. Okay, how old is she? Uh, five. She just turned five. Ming Ming Jin eventually admits that she beat her daughter to death in a fit of rage in the kitchen of their home in North Canton. I'm just kind of pretty well choked up.
Starting point is 00:00:30 There's like no words. Like, I don't even know how, you know, you describe that. A little five-year-old girl. Ming Ming struck the girl's head against the floor. Her father cleaned her up and then unsuccessfully tried to revive her. So many regulars to this business. So many people who interacted with this little girl. They told me she was happy and social and always talking to customers. So many of those customers made connections with this precocious little five-year-old and they were trying to help police find her.
Starting point is 00:00:59 To have a child five years old die at the hands of the person that we all believe is the one person that will protect us no matter what. It's just unfathomable. I remember when Lucy and John David were five years old. I wish they were five years old again. I wish I could start it all over again because it's been the best ten years of my life. But they were so tiny and so precious. I look back at the pictures of them at age five. And that makes it very difficult for me to reconcile a gorgeous little five-year-old girl murdered and found hidden in a Chinese restaurant. How are you hidden in a Chinese restaurant?
Starting point is 00:01:57 I mean, how can that happen? What, they hide the little girl's dead body under a table and nobody notices? How do you hide a child in a Chinese restaurant and she's not found? When I first heard about this child's disappearance, we got on it. The little girl, Ashley, missing. Hidden in the family restaurant of Ang's Asian Cuisine in North Canton, Ohio. I'm Nancy Grace. This is Crime Stories. Thank you for being with us. We want justice. I don't want Ashley's murder and the hiding of her body to go unnoticed,
Starting point is 00:02:46 as if it never happened. Her being just another statistic that goes on the FBI list of how many child murders there were. Somehow I want her name to be remembered because I'm going to remember it. Let's start at the beginning. Joining me, my longtime friend, Jane Velez Mitchell, founder of janeunchained.com, journalist, animal rights activist, and investigative reporter. Dr. Patricia Saunders, psychologist, joining me out of Manhattan. Vincent Hill, a private investigator. And Ashley Wilcott, lawyer, child advocate, and founder of Child Crime Watch. You can find it on Facebook.
Starting point is 00:03:37 Alan and Jackie, of course, everyone, thank you for being with us as we dissect the case of little Ashley. Let's start at the very beginning when Ashley goes missing. Alan, what happened? How was she reported missing? Well, there was a 911 call saying that she's missing and it started a search. Hold on, Alan, before you go any further, let's take a listen to that 911 call and see what we can learn. When's the last time you seen her? This afternoon, probably. Around what time? Three, maybe four. What? Five.
Starting point is 00:04:35 You saw her at five? What was she wearing? Oh, okay. What? What was she wearing? She's wearing a purple winter coat. I don't know what those things are called, but they're not jeans. They're like leggings?
Starting point is 00:04:51 Yeah, yeah, yeah. What color were they? Gray-ish. Okay, and you haven't seen her in five hours? About, yeah. I mean, she was there sleeping. Where was she sleeping at, in the restaurant? Yeah, yeah.
Starting point is 00:05:10 She was sleeping there, and I picked up my older daughter from school. We all saw her sleeping there. So, and, you know, we went to work, and, you know, we let her sleep. And we got busy, and then after it got busy, you know, we started cleaning up. And then, you know, we opened the door and she's not here. Okay, Alan, as I'm listening to that 911 call,
Starting point is 00:05:31 I am looking at photos of little Ashley and it's just killing me. I want to go to the discovery of her body. Exactly where was her body found, Alan? It was found in her parents' restaurant. And it was in the kitchen.
Starting point is 00:05:56 It had been there during the whole search. Right by the freezer. Yes. And there had been a statewide search for it. Jane Velez Mitchell joining me. Jane, this brings back so many memories of the whole state turning into a nationwide search, looking for this five-year-old little girl, just absolutely beautiful.
Starting point is 00:06:19 The long, dark hair, the big brown eyes, the big smile smile the perfect little teeth the whole state was looking for her she's right there in ang's chinese cuisine the whole time how is it jane her parents didn't find her well because the mother killed her And the confession video is absolutely chilling, Nancy. And it is just creating just a firestorm of outrage around the country because she's talking to the investigator like, oh, a misplaced order or where she didn't get the order right. And she just casually says, I just killed her. And I told my husband to take care of it. Literally emotionless. What's so shocking is how casual she is. And it doesn't take long for this investigator to break her.
Starting point is 00:07:14 And you're right. There are such chilling parallels to the Casey Anthony case. A mother's saying, please look for my child. And all along, she knew exactly where the child was and was so blase and casual Ashley Wilcott lawyer and child advocate founder of childcrimewatch.com on Facebook Ashley have you listened to this woman's confession I have the mom oh gosh and there's no emotion it is absolutely crazy to listen to because she does just say it like it's another day in the park and it's not a big deal and she also states she didn't say she even hid the body or had her husband hide the body instead she said oh i told my husband to dispose of the body like a piece of trash you know it's amazing to me luckily joining me is vincent hill private investigator and Dr. Patricia Saunders, a well-known psychologist
Starting point is 00:08:09 out of New York. Guys, before I go any further, I want you to hear exactly what they're talking about. Take a listen to this shocking confession. I know that you're not crying. You said I don't have nothing left. Isn't that what you told me? You don't have no tears left. You don't have nothing left. Ming Ming, your daughter is dead. What happened? How did she die? Just kill her and then she died. Did you hit her? Yes. Dr. Patricia Saunders, boy, do I need to shrink right now and so on so many levels but let's just start with this confession her affect is so flat pat and another thing that really struck me with what jane velez mitchell said was like it was like she had a misplaced order at ang's asian cuisine
Starting point is 00:09:02 it was just so casual i think there's a tiny piece of this that is cultural and has to do with the differences in language, especially if she's from the provinces. Chinese cultural people tend to handle anxiety by freezing up and by presenting a bland, blank face. But nonetheless, it's still cold as ice. It seems like this is a mom who simply did not bond with this child. And the fact that it was a girl child in China makes her garbage.
Starting point is 00:09:40 You know what? You just said something I don't understand. You don't bond. Oh, and another thing that Jane said earlier, you know what when you just said something i don't understand you don't bond you don't oh oh and another thing that jane said earlier she said this reminds her of tot mom reminder tot mom never asked anybody to find kelly it was the grandmother okay so i'm wondering uh vincent hill private investigator why bothered to call 9-1-1 i mean she killed a little girl and she was hidden there in her own restaurant as people were eating i mean she they were looking for her for a long time
Starting point is 00:10:10 and as people were ordering chinese and eating and cooking and all that the little girl's body was in the restaurant yeah nancy i think that call was based strictly on nothing uh but guilt she knew what she had done knew she had to report it before it went too long because too many people would start asking questions. She went ahead and placed a 911 call. And I too have seen the confession video and I've sat across an interrogation table from some very hardened criminals who had more emotion than this mother showed who had killed her little five-year-old. I just couldn't believe it. Let's take a listen to more of that confession, that chilling confession.
Starting point is 00:10:51 Did you hit her? Yeah. Okay. How did you hit her? How? Yeah. Do you intend to do that? Okay.
Starting point is 00:11:05 You know, Ashley Wolcott, you know very well that the state never has to prove motive. I mean, the law does not require a prosecutor to climb into the mind of a killer, wander around, and figure out why. That's just not part of the burden on the state. The state is to show who did it in the correct jurisdiction and hopefully how. That's what the state has to prove. But practically speaking, Ashley Wilcott, don't you believe the state needs to show motive as a practical matter? Sure. And I think that everybody wants to know why, because you also want to know in the future, how can we help prevent these kinds of crimes? And here's what's fascinating in this case. This mother states, oh, she was overwhelmed because the child was disobedient.
Starting point is 00:11:54 And she even says, hey, you can't control yourself sometimes. So I guess that's her motive in this case. You know, it's just overwhelming to me that that could be her motive. But you're exactly right. Take a listen to what murder mom says. I don't have four hands. I'm not four hands, girl. I'm two hands. I don't want to do that to Ashley, but you can control yourself sometimes. I don't have four hands. I'm not four hands, girl. Did she just say that, Dr. Patricia Saunders? I don't have four hands? I'm afraid so.
Starting point is 00:12:35 She expected a five-year-old to help out in the restaurant. But listen to this. Listen to this. Vincent Hill, private investigator. The mom who murders her little five-year-old girl blames the grandparents the grandparents she ships a little girl back to china i think for the summer and says she comes home and is disobedient maybe she didn't want to come home to a mom that beats her maybe that's's why she's disobedient. And when you beat a child,
Starting point is 00:13:05 what do you expect is going to happen? What do you think is going to happen? Yeah, absolutely, Nancy. I mean, that was the biggest scapegoat, if you will, that I've heard. She was sent to her grandparents' house and she came back disobedient. I mean, when my kids were younger, they went to my grandmother's house. Did they come back acting different? Absolutely. That's what all kids do when they go to their grandparents' house because they get spoiled. But that does not justify it, nor does that mean you can just snap and lose it all because you have a disobedient child. That's part of being a parent. Children don't always listen to what their parents say. Let me pause just briefly and thank you for joining us here on Sirius XM 132. It means so much to us that you are joining us in our quest for justice.
Starting point is 00:13:57 I also want to thank our partner, LegalZoom. What will your story be in 2018? Now the holiday rushes over, LegalZoom can help you make this a memorable year before all the distractions take hold. Make this the year you finally get serious about launching and running your own business. Rest easier knowing your family's future is squared away with the right estate plan. LegalZoom's been helping people like us take care of dreams and responsibilities over 16 years. They're not a law firm, but they've got the resources to keep you on the right path, including advice from a nationwide network of independent lawyers all at your fingertips.
Starting point is 00:14:41 Whether you want to take your business to the next level or take control of your family's future with an estate plan, LegalZoom plugs right into your life so you can take care of things that matter most. Get off to a strong start in 2018 at LegalZoom.com. Do it today and get special savings when you enter N-A-N-C-Y, code Nancy, in the promo box at checkout. LegalZoom, where life meets legal. LegalZoom, thank you for not only being our partner here today on SiriusXM 132, but helping so many people across our country. Thanks, LegalZoom. Police say they got a tip of where the
Starting point is 00:15:25 reported missing girl might be. I know she didn't wander off on her own. I knew something was wrong. I just was not expecting this. It's heartbreaking. It's very heartbreaking. She's got a pretty well choked up. There's like no words like I don't even know how you know you describe that. A little five-year-old girl. One thing we wanted at the end of the day was to recover that girl alive. Police say Chen struck her daughter, Ashley Zhao, with her right fist multiple times. So hard it killed her. I'm just shocked. Just his personality, he just does not seem that way.
Starting point is 00:16:00 She was a little more reserved than him, but again, nowadays you never know. When this type of revelation comes about, it is really devastating and just more so sad for that little girl. A gorgeous little five-year-old girl murdered and found hidden. How do you hide a child? Hidden in the family restaurant of Ang's Asian Cuisine in North Canton, Ohio? The little girl, Ashley. We now know that the father of the little girl, Lang, tried to revive the child.
Starting point is 00:16:39 What do we know, Jane Velez Mitchell, about the cause of death of this five-year-old little girl who was then stuffed in a corner and hidden in a Chinese restaurant. Well, it was a fatal brain injury, and you're right, Nancy, after it happened. And prosecutors said it's not premeditated. She had essentially a fit of anger and hid her child, and then they tried to revive her. And when they couldn't revive her, the wife says to the husband, take care of it. And then he hides the body. So he's also in big trouble and we'll do time. But what's really interesting is this woman's backstory. She came here from China as an illegal immigrant. She said she was persecuted in China because she's a member of a meditation group, Kalamgang, and they are basically persecuted in China.
Starting point is 00:17:28 And then she starts this restaurant. So I think she had a very hard, hard life, not to make excuses for her. But I think a part of her just shut down at a certain point, and her values became confused. Keeping the business running was her obsession and the daughter came second third or fourth and the prosecutors also said that the husband was abusive to both the wife and the child so on top of everything else she's really is that what they say that's what the defense says well then of course here's what her defense lawyer has to say. There's a tremendous amount of pressure that was put upon this couple and the family. This led to violence in the home.
Starting point is 00:18:12 And the unfortunate byproduct of this violence was the death of Ashley. Surprise, surprise, surprise. Not to steal a line from the late, great Gomer Pyle. This is the way I see it. America gave her asylum. They gave her the opportunity for a better life. She married a bright young man. And I'm looking at their wedding photos, which actually are better than my wedding photos.
Starting point is 00:18:45 And she's got on a faux mink, white mink jacket, beautiful pink roses. She's gorgeous. He's dressed up in the white jacket tuxedo with the black pants with a matching flower boutonniere on his chest. They have a family business that they own and operate. And then they get the greatest blessing that God can give, I believe. And that is a child, a beautiful child. She has it all. Everything.
Starting point is 00:19:23 That's the way I see it, Ashley Wilcott. Completely agree with you, Nancy. And I have to say this, while there are some allegations that the husband was abusive, she does not, in her confession, act like what we typically see as a victim. Now, this doesn't mean all victims act the same, but she doesn't present as a victim or someone who's been beaten and physically abused and a victim of domestic violence. She seems very certain and sure of herself. Now, I'm no doctor, but I would just take that into account. You know, I worked at the Battered Women's Center
Starting point is 00:20:01 for nine years while I was a prosecutor. And I fully understand the Battered Women's Center for nine years while I was a prosecutor. And I fully understand the battered women syndrome. And I side with battered women who don't have a way out of their home life or can't see that they have a way out. That in no way justifies murdering your five-year-old little girl. No way! And to bring that up to me, in my mind, is an insult to this five-year-old little girl. I'm not having it.
Starting point is 00:20:34 I'm not accepting that as an excuse. Listen to this. I know that you're not crying. You said I don't have nothing left. Is that what you told me? You don't have no tears left said I don't have nothing left. Isn't that what you told me? You don't have no tears left. You don't have nothing left. Ming Ming, your daughter is dead.
Starting point is 00:20:51 What happened? How did she die? Just kill her and then she died. Did you hit her? Yes. Okay. How did you hit her? How? Yeah. Do you intend to do that? Okay. How did you hit her? How? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:21:08 With your hands to do that? Okay. I only take care of it from the restaurant. I only have two hands. I'm not four hands, girl. I'm two hands. I don't want to do that to Ashley, but you can't control yourself sometimes. I told my husband not to kill me. Okay. So you're telling me that you told your husband? I told my husband to kill me.
Starting point is 00:21:34 Both parents arrest him after the horrific discovery, and it sounds like Mommy's blaming everybody but herself. But again, back to Jane Velez Mitchell's observation that when she called in on 911, she acted like she, you know, maybe lost one of her orders, one of her Chinese food orders. Well, the judge had harsh words for her. I find it difficult to imagine the horror for your child Ashley barely five years old barely five years old the void of love the, the horror of being beaten by her own mother. And I use the word mother with great pain, I find, when talking to you.
Starting point is 00:22:37 It's insulting to mothers who do what they are supposed to do for their children. No number of years is enough. A hundred years is not enough. We can't do anything to help five-year-old Ashley now, but let me give you this number now. It's for child help. I know the ladies that, I personally know the ladies that started child help,
Starting point is 00:23:07 and I'm very impressed with them. Alan, what is the toll-free number for ChildHelp? It's their national child abuse hotline, 1-800-4-A-CHILD, or 1-800-422-4453, or find them at ChildHelp.org. 1-800-422-4453. 1-800-4-A-CHILD. It's the ChildHelp National Child Abuse Hotline, and it's dedicated to stopping and preventing child abuse. It serves the U.S. and Canada. It's staffed 24 hours a day, 7 days a week with crisis counselors and interpreters who provide assistance in over 170 languages, including Chinese.
Starting point is 00:23:55 I want to pause and thank our partner who is making our program today on Sirius XM 132 possible. Does anybody beside me worry about blood pressure? I am because just the other day, it was over the holiday. Ashley, I don't know if you saw this, but a local newscaster just dropped dead in her mid-50s from a stroke. Did you read about that, Ashley? I did. I did. I know her, knew her. just dropped dead like in her mid fifties from a stroke. Yeah. Did you read about that? Ashley?
Starting point is 00:24:27 I did. I did. I know her, knew her. I was stunned. I know. Leaving behind her family, you know,
Starting point is 00:24:33 Ashley, I cannot afford to drop dead of a stroke and leave the children to be raised by my husband alone. God bless him. I love him. He's a wonderful father, but I mean, you know,
Starting point is 00:24:44 when I come home from being out of town, nobody's brushed their teeth. It looks like a cyclone hit the home. And they've been eating McDonald's cheeseburgers ever since I've been gone. Okay, so no, no, and no, I got to keep living. Now, this is what I found out about. Everybody's talking about superfoods, which are nutritionally dense foods that benefit your health. Did you know beets are one of the most powerful superfoods you can put in your body? They're loaded with nutrients that increase blood flow, which helps your blood pressure and increases energy. But who has time to go get fresh beets, prepare them, and cook them every day? I do not. Now you can get those energy benefits from beets in a powerful concentrated superfood drink, Super Beets.
Starting point is 00:25:33 Only Super Beets made from beets grown to exacting standards, then concentrated down into superfood crystals. Super Beets promotes your body's natural ability to produce healthier circulation that gives you increased energy and stamina. If you want those benefits of a superfood, call 800-516-0683 or go to nancysbeets.com. N-A-N-C-Y-S-B-E-E-T-S.com. nancysbeets.com. Now, with your first order, you get an entirely free 30-day supply of Super Beets. Free! Plus indicator strips to see how Super Beets working for you. Plus free shipping.
Starting point is 00:26:18 Hey, you're not going to get that at the vitamin store. Call 800-516-0683 or go to nancy'sbeats.com today super beats you know i've prosecuted so many child abuse cases i can't even count them all uh children so helpless they can't take up for themselves, that cannot defend themselves. Now, a spate of publicity surrounding the torture and death of another of our society's helpless, and that is man's best friend, dogs. i was shocked when i read a story about a dog found frozen solid after being left outside chained in its kennel for a month right now alan you were telling me what the temperatures are outside. What are they, Alan? It is actually colder on some parts of the northeast U.S. than it is on the surface of Mars today,
Starting point is 00:27:34 and we know that's not good. Police investigating the death of a dog chained outside a Connecticut home in bitter cold, bitter cold, and found frozen inside its doghouse on New Year's Day. The Hartford cops say the dog may have been outside as long as a month. The little dog, frozen solid, when the officers got there, according to Deputy Chief Brian Foley, it's just heartbreaking. WTIC-TV reported a veterinary assessment says the dog had been lying in fecal material, which was found frozen onto its body. Jane Velez Mitchell joining me from janeunchained.com. Jane, what happened? The dog was apparently out there for months because the dog's owner was in jail and had a family member purportedly taking care of not only the dog that was found frozen solid outside, but another dog that was found malnourished and shivering
Starting point is 00:28:54 inside the home. And neighbors say that essentially there was a burst water pipe inside the home and somehow the dog ended up chained outside because of that first water pipe. Why both of them weren't outside or both inside and kept together is a mystery. But imagine the mentality of a family member who's supposed to take care of two dogs and then leaving that dog, not just outside, but chained outside. This is a torture killing. This dog, it's seven degrees right now in Toledo, Ohio. This dog was left outside for a month and chained inside this dog. I mean, I can't even imagine it. And unfortunately, Nancy, it's happening all over the country as this extreme cyclone bomb or whatever they want to call it of cold
Starting point is 00:29:48 is enveloping a good part of the nation. We also have another case in New Hampshire of a woman charged with neglecting 22 German shepherds, leaving them in a barn with no heat and with their water bowls frozen solid so they couldn't drink the water. I mean, it's unimaginable. And I say anybody, when it comes to kids and dogs and animals in general, be a nosy neighbor. If you see something like this, call the cops, call the Humane Society before a dog freezes solid. To Dr. Patricia Saunders, psychologist joining us, how can people be so cruel to animals? And, you know, I'm seeing it more and more and more cruelty to animals, but to die in this manner. You know, Patricia, I just took the twins skating, ice skating in New York.
Starting point is 00:30:48 And it was so cold. I would make them come in every 15 minutes to get hot chocolate and warm up and had the little heating pads on their hands and over their toes. And I can't imagine leaving a pet outside like that. What's the thinking, Patricia? I don't even know if it is thinking, Nancy. To me, there isn't terribly much difference in the psychology of child abuse and animal abuse. They're objectified as things, as possessions, not as feeling, being, or thinking entities. And we know that dogs in particular have the mental functions of a two-year-old human
Starting point is 00:31:34 and that they do experience emotion. So it's unfathomable to me. Susan Hill, as a private investigator, you've seen it all. And it seems to me this level of cruelty has got to seep into the rest of your life. Yeah, absolutely, Nancy. And what I can tell you, when I was back in patrol policing the streets of Nashville, you know, it was not uncommon when I would answer a call for domestic violence against a child that you would see, you know, some animals that were just, you know, very well malnourished and just left to their own devices. But the great thing about the state of Ohio back in 2016, a unanimous vote 33 to 0 passed
Starting point is 00:32:21 the Goodert's Law, which makes animal cruelty actually a fifth degree felony. So I think these dog owners here in Ohio have more problems than they realize when they did what they did. I mean, it's very tragic and cruel that this dog was left out in seven degree weather when, you know, here in Atlanta, it's 22 degrees right now. And I don't want to step outside the comforts of the heat that I'm in right now. You know, there's more than just these two stories. The one I told you about, the one with the German shepherds that Jane Velez Mitchell told you about. There is one now out of Michigan I've just learned about. On the very first day of the new year county animals in need of homes and rescues posted about a dog found frozen to the ground at welch boulevard in flint after finding the dog which the group
Starting point is 00:33:16 named felice his injuries were addressed but he was frozen discovered frozen to the ground. At first, they thought he would lose one of his legs because of this, but he's now having to have surgery, surgery to save the leg. How can you leave a dog frozen to the ground? Alan, what do you know about that case? Well, it was on New Year's Day, and it was in Genesee County in Michigan. They found this dog. This was an older dog, and I'm looking at the picture. You see the picture of it? It looks like a dog that my mom had. It's a senior dog.
Starting point is 00:34:00 Yes, right, which I can relate to. The organization said they originally feared that Felice, which they named him, would lose one of the legs due to that being frozen to the ground. But guess what? They've given him surgery and they've saved the leg. And there's more surgery set for this week. Well, it doesn't end there. In Franklin County, that's in Columbus, there was a tragic reminder to bring your pets in during this Arctic blast. And that's according to the Franklin County Dog Shelter. They have been alerted that three dogs have been found frozen dead. It's simply inhumane.
Starting point is 00:34:42 Anybody that's been outside has felt the pain of their fingers freezing, their toes freezing. Dogs can't regulate their body temperature. They don't have on a coat. They can't just rush in from outside and they die. The Franklin County Dog Shelter alerted the Humane Society about the three deaths and are now pursuing animal cruelty and neglect charges. What about that? To Jane Velez Mitchell, I think the owners should be prosecuted. This shouldn't just be a sad story. This is a crime, Jane.
Starting point is 00:35:20 It absolutely is, and they need to be prosecuted. And thank you for covering it, Nancy. And I believe it should be illegal to leave your dog chained outside under any circumstances. Nobody, no sentient being wants to be chained outside on some kind of chain. It's a prescription for disaster, and it needs to end. Now we do see one arrest so far a woman charged just charged cruelty after police say her dog froze to death in the bitter cold her name michelle bennett age 50 old enough to know better michelle bennett arrested for one count of animal cruelty. Her dog froze to death in a
Starting point is 00:36:08 dog house at her home. Now, according to the police report, we also hear from a Dr. Stephanie Henry, a Windsor veterinarian. The dog was brought to her clinic around 6 30 p.m. and it was frozen solid. It was also malnourished. He was underweight and he was frozen solid. Now her bail is only $2,500. She's going to get out on bail but I'm taking a look right now at the mugshot of Michelle Bennett. Patricia Saunders, she's 50 years old. She should know better.
Starting point is 00:36:54 Just because she's 50 doesn't mean that she should know better, Nancy, that she's an adult. People are stuck in primitive thinking. Who wouldn't know better than to let a dog freeze and starve outside? Who wouldn't? To be frozen solid like a cube of ice, Patricia?
Starting point is 00:37:13 Are you trying to actually defend her by saying she didn't know better? No, I'm saying that cruelty and sadism override. I think you are. No, I'm saying that knowledge doesn't mean anything in terms of how old one is. It's a matter of your heart. And this woman has a cold, cold heart. And I think she's guilty of murder,
Starting point is 00:37:38 of animal abuse. Not only that, in Michigan, animals found frozen to the ground. Now, the other dog I told you about having to have surgery, a dog frozen to death in an outdoor dog house in Butler County. I mean, it goes on and on and on. How many more times does this have to happen? And can you imagine the pain the animal
Starting point is 00:38:07 goes through? Vincent Hill, private investigator, this isn't like picking up a gun and firing it in a fit of anger. It takes time for a dog to freeze solid like an ice cube. Yeah, it's a very slow and painful death, Nancy. And keep in mind, while this is going on, the dog still has its needs, like needs to eat, needs to drink. So not only are you freezing to death, you're essentially starving and being dehydrated to death as well. It's very sad. Alan, how can people report crimes like this or inhumane treatment of animals? Nancy, the Humane Society of the United States says that if you see animal cruelty, you can call your local animal control agency as soon as possible. Or just dial 911 and tell the emergency dispatcher because by law, any alleged animal cruelty has to be
Starting point is 00:39:06 investigated. So they say also that you should document it. Be sure to document the case with your cell phone video or take pictures, make notes of dates and times, specific details that would help the appropriate agency investigate. If your county doesn't have a proper animal welfare agency or your local police you don't think are really equipped to handle an animal cruelty case, then email the Humane Society at humanesociety.org. You'll find their address. Or call them. They have a number that's not 24 hours, but it's most hours. You can call them at 866-720-2676. 866-720-2676.
Starting point is 00:39:56 I want justice. And for people that poo-poo the feelings and the lives of animals, remember. Remember, what you do to the least of mine. So have you done to me. That's what I have to say. And I want them all to go to jail and sit there and think about what they've done. And you know what? Maybe we can let them go in without a coat.
Starting point is 00:40:25 Nancy Grace, Crime Story, signing off. Goodbye, friend. You're listening to an iHeart Podcast.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.