Crime Stories with Nancy Grace - Trial Looms for Scorned Hairstylist Accused of Hiring Hitman to Murder Ex & His Teen Daughter

Episode Date: August 24, 2025

Jaclyn Diiorio, 26, a hairstylist, and her police officer boyfriend broke up after dating for nearly a year. The relationship had been contentious, with both filing protective orders. After the breaku...p, Diiorio began dating again and turned to Tinder. During conversations with a match, Diiorio said she wanted her ex dead and asked if he could carry it out, noting that her ex was a Philadelphia police officer. The Tinder date was a police informant and contacted county prosecutors. Detectives notified Philadelphia police, who then informed the officer and identified him as the target. The officer told investigators he met Diiorio when she cut his hair. Authorities arrested Diiorio in Gloucester Township, New Jersey, after the informant reported that she offered him $12,000 to kill her ex and his 19-year-old daughter.  Joining Nancy Grace today: Greg Morse - of Morse Legal; Current CJA Counsel (Southern District of Florida); Former West Palm Beach Public Defender’s Office; Author: “The Untested” Dr. Shari Schwartz - Forensic Psychologist (specializing in Capital Mitigation and Victim Advocacy),  Author: "Criminal Behavior" and "Where Law and Psychology Intersect: Issues in Legal Psychology;" X: @TrialDoc John Pizzuro -  Former New Jersey State Police Investigator, Currently the CEO of RAVEN, an organization focused on eliminating child exploitation and trafficking Baron Li - Shot nine times by teenage hitmen hired by his ex-wife: Now, he channels his second chance at life into powerful advocacy for father’s rights and foster care. Socials: FB/Insta/TikTok @baronbli.ckmd YT: @RealAsian50Cent, Rodrigo Torrejón - Crime and Courts Reporter at The Philadelphia Inquirer; X/Twitter: @rodrigotorrejon, Instagram: @rodtorrejon  See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is an I-Heart podcast. Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. Did a scorned hairstylist hire a hitman on Tinder, of all places, to brutally assassinate her ex-boyfriend and, wait for it, his teen daughter? This, according to cops, I'm Nancy Grace. This is crime stories. Thank you for being with us. A New Jersey woman is accused of attempting to hire a hitman off popular dating app Tinder.
Starting point is 00:00:39 Could this be? Did the scorned hairstylist want revenge so badly? She wanted to assassinate her ex-boyfriend and his teen daughter. How did the teen daughter get roped into this? You know, I've got an all-star panel to make sense of what we know right now. but joining me in addition to an all-star panel is a very special guest this is a man a former husband a father who endured a hit shot nine times when his ex-wife wanted to gain control of money that was meant to raise their son joining me baron lee shot nine times
Starting point is 00:01:27 all ordered by your wife. Now, I've always been amazed, Barron, if I may call you that. I feel like I know you. We've discussed your case. I've talked to you and thought about you so many times since the incident. What went through your mind? As you were lying there, I'm sure you couldn't process all of the facts that here you were, just out in a parking lot, minding your own business.
Starting point is 00:01:53 And why you, of all people, why were you assailed by unknown, guys and shot nine times. What went through your mind? I realized I could have died at any moment. And then I was wondering, you know, who actually at the time, I knew who was ordering a hit on me. I just didn't know who the shooter was at the time. I mean, you were shot point blank. I will never forget it. All in a bid by your ex-wife to gain control of that money set aside to help raise your son. How has your son reacted to what happened to you, Baron? Well, my son's non-mobile, non-verbal. So fortunately, he doesn't have the trauma to deal with like other kids would have had to. So he has no idea what happened. You know what? Thank goodness that
Starting point is 00:02:46 this did not weigh on his mind on top of everything else. And that was a considerable amount of money to help raise him to secure his future, which he is going to need. Why did she do it, Baron? You know, I ask myself that every single day. I just say pure cividity is what comes down to it. Guys, a guy that lived through a similar hit. But to the case in chief, Baron, don't move. I want your take on this.
Starting point is 00:03:13 First of all, take a listen. They were together for approximately a year, and there was clearly problems in the relationship. During the detention hearing, Camden County Assistant Prosecutor David outlined a screenshot of a text message where DiOrio negotiates the price for the hit. Another text message has the defendant discussing a prior attempt to hire someone to kill her ex. Recorded conversation between DiOrio and the informant was also submitted. That from our friends at CBS News 3, joining me, as I said, an all-star panel straight out to Rodrigo, Terahone,
Starting point is 00:03:49 crime and court reporter at the Philly Inquirer. Rodrigo, thank you for being with us. How did this whole thing start? It's my understanding that the would-be killer is a scorned hairstylist, and we heard Elliot at the get-go say, there were problems in the relationship, but Rodrigo, there are problems in every relationship. My husband, as I like to say, my current husband, and I never had an argument until we had the twins. And then we immediately started arguing about how they would be raised, practically every decision, what time to go to bed, how many bottles, what you go in the bottle, you name it, okay?
Starting point is 00:04:26 And that goes on today. That's our sole source of argument. What is best for our children? So, yes, every relationship has ups and downs, but really? Prosecutors say that the relationship, like the Camden County prosecutor mentioned earlier, between Jacqueline DeOroo and Officer O'Hanelan started around a year ago and quickly turned pretty volatile. You know, there was a few months that seemed like the relationship was going. And around August, there was an allegation of restraining order that was filed by the officer against
Starting point is 00:05:04 DiOrio. So things turn sour relatively quickly. The next month, the officer reported that his house was damaged by a Molotov cocktail that was thrown at it. There has not been any sort of clear link between the ex-girlfriend. Hold on. Hold on just a second, Terahon. You're putting the cart before the horse. I've got to get into it, okay? I know about the Molotov. I know about the beginning of the relationship,
Starting point is 00:05:33 but what I don't know about is the intricacies of that relationship. What went wrong? Why did they break up? Why couldn't she just move on, as my grandmother said, man, no offense to you. Of course, Rodrigo. that men are like buses, a new one will come along every 15 minutes. So why does she fixate so much on the boyfriend to the extent she wanted him dead and
Starting point is 00:06:00 wanted his teen daughter dead too? How did that come about, Rodrigo? Yeah, so that's unclear still. Like I said, there was a few months where everything seemed to be going smoothly. And from one month to another, there was some sort of volatility between them, some sort of tension to say the least. And there was a restraining order filed by the officer against the Oreo. And the attorney for the Oreo later said that there was also a restraining order that she filed against him that was later withdrawn. Oh, hold on.
Starting point is 00:06:35 Straight out to Greg Moore's, following up on what Rodrigo Terahan just said, Greg Moore's high-profile lawyer joining us of Morse legal, currently counsel to the C-I-A, well, you've got your hands full. Greg, dueling TROs, don't you just love that? And, of course, I'm being sarcastic. When a real victim comes into court for a temporary restraining order, and what does the other one do, race back in to go, uh-uh, uh, it's not, I'm not at fault, it's them, all of this going on. When I see dueling restraining orders, that's a bad.
Starting point is 00:07:12 sign. It's not going to get any better, Greg Morse. Dueling TROs are a defense lawyer's dream. It means both people are claiming to be victims. Both people are claiming to be the abuser. It shows a history of back and forth. So this is a volatile relationship from both folks in this situation. You know, my guess is there is no evidence that the victim was volatile. The victim was volatile. The victim was a cop, by the way, but that said, he's not the one that ordered a hit, according to police. He's not the one that went on Tinder a dating site, if you want to call it that. That's a hookup site.
Starting point is 00:07:56 That's what that is. But that said, he didn't go on Tinder and pretend he was looking for a date and goes, oh, by the way, can you meet me at Wawa's grocery so I can pay you to shoot my ex? That wasn't him. that's hermors so don't tune up first thing I ask you about TROs
Starting point is 00:08:17 and you try to say it's the victim's fault does it never end with you no it's not they're both victims they both had TROs and people withdraw them all the time
Starting point is 00:08:26 because they get back together and then they have a volatile situation how was he the victim could you just explain what maybe you know let me direct you
Starting point is 00:08:35 to Webster's dictionary and I don't mean online you need the hard copy what do you think victim means. How is she a victim? He goes to get a TRO and she like races to the courthouse. I'm first, I'm first judge. Call on me first. How is she the victim? He broke up with her and she could stand it in order to hit to kill him. Have you ever been to a murder scene? Have you ever smelled coagulated blood? Because I have and I hope I
Starting point is 00:09:07 never do again. That's what she wanted. I've been to quite a few and I've got Plenty of not guilty of murder cases. We have, in this case... How you managed to merge a dead body with you getting a not guilty? Excuse me, Jackie. Could you toot his horn for him? No, he's doing that himself. You have to...
Starting point is 00:09:28 I'm asking you about how he's the victim. She wanted him dead on the ground with his team, daughter, dead. Nancy, you have a CI on their own for four days creating this story potential. The defense has something to work with here. When have you ever heard of a CI doing their own kind of case on Tinder and then all of a sudden going to the police four days later? That creates opportunity. Okay. Well, you know what?
Starting point is 00:09:56 I've got a wonderful answer for you. Okay. And her name is Dahlia DiPolito. What? Are you actually asking me, how does a CI confidential? You know, I'm not impressed by you throwing around cop talk. Everybody that's watching crime stories knows a CI is a confidential informant. But thank you for trying.
Starting point is 00:10:22 Okay, next, what are you going to throw a Latin phrase at me? That said. No, but you're looking at, you're looking at, you're looking at, you're looking at, no, the Bolito is different. For a CI to go online to trap a killer, because it's not. Is that what you're saying? No, but it doesn't seem like from the police report that the police were involved in this the first four days. So what?
Starting point is 00:10:42 They have a meeting in a car. Well, thank God in heaven. They did get involved. No. I'm going to put your feet to the fire at Morse because you said what CI, which is an arm of L.A. law enforcement, goes online to trap a killer. Who would do that? Hey, listen to this. No, no, no, no.
Starting point is 00:11:07 No. No. No. Do you know how many times that I've watched that. There's a longer version too, which I will absolutely play. Okay, Dahlia DiPolito hires a hitman to murder her husband to murder her husband. And as in this case, with the Molotov cocktail that Rodrigo Teddohan was telling us about and prior attempts, it wasn't her first try. According to L.E., she tried to poison her husband in a Starbucks.
Starting point is 00:11:57 I'm not even going to mention that she was a hooker, okay, because that's neither here nor there before she got married. And he took her away from all that. Anyway, they sting her. Why did they stinger? Because they had L.E. Law enforcement as the would-be assassin. Same thing as here. And Morse, you're acting like you've never heard anything like it,
Starting point is 00:12:23 like it's a big entrapment. To John Pizorro, former New Jersey State Police Investigator, 25 years. You know, there's a lot going down in New Jersey. Homicide, organized crime, cartels, commander of the internet crimes against children. It goes on and on. Currently, CEO of Raven, focused on eliminating child exploitation and trafficking. John, you've certainly seen it all.
Starting point is 00:12:49 But did you happen to hear Greg Morris, who is a veteran defense attorney, as he so timidly put forth, I've won a lot of cases, he says. Did you hear him say how odd it is for L.E., law enforcement, an agent, a CI, to be part of a state? I mean, who is this woman going to hire to kill her ex? A nun, a priest, a virgin? No, somebody that acts like a hitman. Yeah, we use them all the time. I mean, informants.
Starting point is 00:13:22 And by the way, I love the entrapment argument because that's the first thing defense counsel does entrapment. But the reality is, I can't tell you how many times people actually came up to us, you know, in an undercover capacity, and to hire a hit person. I mean, the only difference between years ago today is that there's a There's apps to do it where you don't have to go to the yellow pages. It's a little easier just to ask someone to do something. Jacqueline DiOrio is a 26-year-old New Jersey woman accused of attempting to murder her cop-ex boyfriend
Starting point is 00:13:58 by hiring a hitman off Tinder. We know these two lovebirds met when the defendant, the suspect, the hairstylist, was actually, doing the victim's hair. That's how they met. Let's see what more we know. Listen. Jacqueline DiOrio 26 lives in Runnymede, New Jersey, making her living as a barber. She hits it off with one of her clients, a police officer, twice her age.
Starting point is 00:14:26 They begin dating their relationship lasts just over a year, but not without problems. Problems so bad that DeOrio asked for and got a restraining order put in place. She later dropped the complaint. After the breakup, DiOrio started looking at dating apps, specifically Tinder. A match is made, and DiOrio makes plans to meet her new friend for the first time at a Wawa. They exchange numbers and communicate through text messages and phone calls. Okay, to you, John Pizarro, former New Jersey State Police, 25 years. Wow. Okay. Pizarro.
Starting point is 00:15:04 I've heard of first dates, and I always advise people when you meet online. and you should meet somewhere public. But wawas, that should have been a tip-off right there. My sister in Philly used to live in a building on top, at the bottom of the building. It was in grad towers at the Wharton School. There was a Wawa. I mean, that's not really a romantic setting for your first date.
Starting point is 00:15:28 Is it? Was that a tip-off? I mean, Waw-Was? Well, it is Tinder, Nancy. So, I mean, you know, and there is a lot of wawas in New Jersey. So I guess the old Starbucks is out. these days. You know, to Dr. Sherry Schwartz now joining us. She's been chomping at the bit hearing all of this. She's a forensic psychologist and she specializes in capital mitigation
Starting point is 00:15:49 and victim advocacy and you can find her at panther mitigation.com. She's the author of criminal behavior and the one I like the best where law and psychology intersect. Dr. Sherry Schwartz, I mean, this could be a total case study for you because, for instance, what led up, what fueled the hatred in this hairstylist's heart that she wanted not only her boyfriend, for Pete's sake, they're not even married. They don't even have to divide property. They don't have to fight over custody. They don't have to decide who gets the pots and pans and who gets the crock pot.
Starting point is 00:16:30 None of that. But it's so contentious she wants him dead. And not just thinking, Dr. Sherry, oh, I could just kill him. Not that. Actually, going online and hiring someone to commit double murder and on a teen girl, a little girl. What is that, Dr. Sherry? It's pure unadulterated hatred fueled by the fact that it seems like he broke up with her. The relationship was volatile.
Starting point is 00:17:06 He didn't want to have a relationship with her anymore. and it sounds like she probably arrived at the conclusion that if I can't have you, nobody will. I don't understand why his teenage daughter had to be involved in that unless she thought it was possible the teenage daughter could later identify that she would be the one trying to have him murdered, but this is somebody who has no regard for human life. Guys, what happens? They start up a romantic relationship. It goes sour. They break up.
Starting point is 00:17:41 She files for TRO and then almost immediately drops it. What was that about? Was that a way to play the system? But it progresses. Listen. During the Orios text conversation with her Tinder date, she reveals she's not really looking for love, but rather a hit man. An informant who was working with law enforcement stated they recently met a female on a dating app Tinder,
Starting point is 00:18:06 the female identified herself to the informant's. which was later identified as the defendant's tinder name. The defendant and the informant then met her a while out and running meet. Subsequently, the defendant and the informant exchanged numerous text messages and phone calls. During these text messages and phone call conversations that the defendant told the informant that she wanted her ex-boyfriend killed. I'm trying to figure out when love turns into hate and when hate turns in to the desire for murder. and when that desire leads you to commit an act.
Starting point is 00:18:41 Now, to Greg Morse joining me, who has won a lot of cases, is named partner at Morse Legal and also current counsel to the CIA. Greg, in an attempt case, an attempted murder or an attempted anything, there are very often conspiracy charges. A conspiracy cannot be proven, as you and I have argued in court many times, unless you have an overt act like I can sit around all day and think oh I want to kill Greg Morris so bad how would I do it what would I do that's just wishful thinking that's daydreaming talking about it doesn't rise to conspiracy but you must have an overt O-V-E-R-T act in order to
Starting point is 00:19:30 prove your case and here that overt act is going on Tinder, meeting someone that's still not enough, but then persuading him to do a hit. There's your overt act right there in a conspiracy charge. Well, there is an overt act there. However, again, those first four days when she's interacting with this guy on Tinder and they're talking, that leaves a lot of room for argument for the defense, just like they seem to be indicating.
Starting point is 00:20:02 It's not something that, you know, this guy becomes a CI after the four days, not before. And that creates opportunity. You also can argue the $500 is no bird act, although paying for hitman on layaway is odd, but that seems to be what the prosecution is alleging here. You know, Greg Morse, when you say that leaves a lot of wiggle room, can we just get real about what you're arguing? I believe trying to read the tea leaves of what you just said, that you're trying to argue that it was the informant's idea that we can somehow claim entrapment. In other words, she would never have come up with the plot to murder her ex and his teen daughter, but for the CI luring her into it. That's what entrapment means. I would never have done this, except the cops planned
Starting point is 00:20:53 it, they lured me in, and now they're prosecuting me. I would never have done this on my own. That what entrapment is. Are you trying to blame the CI, the confidential informant? Well, the defense has to do something in this case. And like you pointed out there, there was a little stuttering there when you're trying to come up with the argument. What? Listen, this is, you have four days of a civilian being on their own. And then they go to the police and say, hey, this lady wants to kill her husband. But who knows what that guy's trying to work off in his past or why he presented himself to the police to be used. But as far as all accounts, Nancy, this guy
Starting point is 00:21:29 was a civilian like you and I for four days. He packaged this and then brought it over to the law enforcement. So, yeah, I would live and die in those four eight days as a defense lawyer and see what I could use to. You know, you got a little problem, Greg Morris. You got a little tiny
Starting point is 00:21:45 incy bancy fly in the ointment. Here's the problem. Rodrigo Tedderhon, isn't it true? that the defendant actually wrote texts to the CI that prove what she wanted. It's not just his word against hers. She wrote texts.
Starting point is 00:22:10 They're clearly from her phone about the hit. Yes, the prosecutors at the last hearing did read back text messages between the CI and the Oreo, where DeOrio allegedly goes over, prove. She asked for proof because, in her own words, she said that she had been sent fake pictures before, which alludes to prior attempts to carry out this hit. Excuse me. I just choked just a tiny bit. Wait, wait, hold on. Can I see Greg Morse right now as Rodrigo? Okay.
Starting point is 00:22:47 Could you repeat that, Rodrigo, what you just said? She said what in her text to the confidential informant? Yeah, prosecutor's read text between the CIA. and DeOrio, where she mentions that she needs hard proof for this hit that she wants carried out and alludes to having been sent fake pictures in a prior attempt. This is, of course, through text messages that were read out in court at the detention hearing two weeks ago. Ouch. That's got to hurt, Morse. That really has to hurt. She's sending him text describing how a previous hitman failed her and burned her by sending her fake photos of the hit.
Starting point is 00:23:25 people become defendants because they're not that bright. However, people text a lot of things. It doesn't mean they're going to act on it. In the news right now is NFL Hall of Famer, Shannon Sharp, he has some negative text in the lawsuit against him. He wasn't going to, he said, I wasn't going to choke anybody. So people text a lot of things. You know, so you have to look at that and try to turn that around as a bluster and just talking. A woman from New Jersey attempted to hire a hitman off Tinder to kill both her cop, boyfriend and his 19-year-old daughter for just $12,000. Joining me an all-star panel, we'd be going back and forth with Greg Morse about his theory
Starting point is 00:24:10 that it's all the CI Confidential Informant's fault that this woman, Harris stylist, scorned lover, really would never have ordered a hit on her boyfriend if not for the CI luring her into it. But those text messages that she sent the CI that she met at Wawa's on a date when he gets there, she goes, guess what, I don't want a date. I want a hit man. How about you? Those text messages are damning. And not only are they damning, they make a great identification. Listen. The defendant then told the informant that her ex-boyfriend is a Philadelphia police officer and provided his name. The defendant also provided the informant the telephone number of the police
Starting point is 00:24:54 officer's teenage daughter. The informant then met with Detective Durham of the Camden County Prosecars Office Major Crimes Unit and the informant provided Detective Durham with a picture of the defendant from her Tinder profile. The informant also provided Detective Durham with the defendant's telephone. Wow. Rodrigo Terrihan joining us from Crime and Courts reporting at the Philadelphia Inquirer. Rodriguez, again, thank you for being with us. So she didn't even use a bird. burner phone. She used her own phone to text with who she thought was a CI, therefore giving up her identity, unless she wants to try to claim somebody else had her phone or somehow impersonating
Starting point is 00:25:38 her. She used her own phone, Rodrigo. Yeah, that's what it seems like. Prosecutors said that the phone number and a photo of the Oreo were both shown to the officer that she had allegedly tried to have killed through this hitman. And he confirmed both that it was her in the photo and that that was the number that they had used to communicate. So this, according to what prosecutors have dug up, was her own phone number. Well, it gets worse for her. Listen.
Starting point is 00:26:07 The informant was interviewed and told the Detective Dern that the defendant was adamant about killing the victim. The informant stated they spoke about money and that the defendant stated he would be willing to pay $12,000 in cash. During the conversations, the defendant also told him. told the informant that she wanted the victim's teenage daughter killed as well. The defendant told the informant she could pay $500 up front and the rest via installments. Dr. Sherry Schwartz joining us, forensic psychologist.
Starting point is 00:26:35 Dr. Sherry, the defendant, the hairstylist, the scorned hairstylist, reiterated over and over. She was sure she wanted the hit to go down, adamant, adamant, insistent that it happens. And again, I must compare it to the Dahlia DiPolito case, where she says that I believe she's 5,000 percent sure. She wants her husband dead. And it's all caught on tape. Of course, listen. If we're now and when it's done, you know, you're not going to have an option to change your mind, even if you change the mind. No, there's no like the time that's already.
Starting point is 00:27:17 I'm positive, like, 5,000 percent sure. 5,000 percent sure. That's my friends at ABC 2020. What does that mean, Sherry Schwartz? I mean, the CI gives the defendant, opportunity to turn back, opportunity to go, you know what, this is crazy talk. I don't want to do this. But instead, they are adamant. They are hell-bent on murder.
Starting point is 00:27:43 That's exactly what it is. She wanted the job done. she was willing to pay for it she did in fact put a down payment on it and that is an indication that you are serious and you want this done and like it was previously mentioned this is somebody who by her own admission made a prior attempt and was duped according to her so this is somebody who's had some time to think about it and is 100% certain that she wants this done joining us is a survivor, and that doesn't begin to describe what he went through. Baron Lee is with us.
Starting point is 00:28:23 He was shot point-blank range, shot nine times by teens hired by his wife to murder him. As I recall, you were going to your car, and they swarmed you. You were shot nine times and lived all over money. that was meant, that was earmarked, to raise their disabled son. She wanted that money. At any point when you two were having a contentious split, did you ever get the sense that she would want you dead? Yeah, I actually had gone through a couple of incidents
Starting point is 00:29:03 where she tried to run me over with the vehicle. And so when I was shot, I already knew it was her who was behind it. But when you say that you knew she was behind, it. Let me refine my question. When did you get a sense or an inkling that she wanted you dead? As you were lying there on the pavement, bleeding out, you knew at that moment that she was behind the hit. You weren't robbed. You weren't sex molested. You know, wasn't a carjack, nothing like that. This was obviously a hit on you specifically. And you knew then, as you were you, you know, you were bleeding out who did it.
Starting point is 00:29:47 But leading up to that, was there a moment where you were actually afraid or thought, you know, she wants me dead? Yeah. I mean, like I said, we had a five-year, you know, contention of custody with my son. And during that time, she had attempted to run me over twice during child exchanges. So, you know, after the first time, I, you know, just chalked it up at first. I was just being angry. But when she tried to run me over the second time, I realized that, yeah, definitely she wanted me dead.
Starting point is 00:30:18 I guess this case is bringing back a lot of bad memories because, according to reports, this is not DiOriot's first attempt. We've got the Molotov cocktail incident that many attribute to her that has not been proven in a court of law, and she's innocent until proven guilty. Then we have her telling the CI, don't burn me. I've been burned before. with fakes, with lies by a hitman. In your case, there were multiple attempts as well. Did you feel invincible? Did you believe you would never be killed? No, of course not.
Starting point is 00:30:57 But, you know, this woman sounds just like my ex-wife. It looks like she's not going to stop until she could get the job done. Even after my ex-wife had got shot and she found out that I survived, she was actually working with the teenagers to have them come back for a second attempt. So I'm sure this woman has the same kind of mindset that, you know, if left to her devices, she was going to get this job done one way or another. During the recording conversations, as well as previous conversations with the informant the defendant discusses her desire to have teenage daughter of her ex-boyfriend killed, first followed,
Starting point is 00:31:33 then followed by the victim of the ex-boyfriend. The reason that the defendant gave as the order of killings was that she wanted to kill the victim's teenage daughter because the killing of a police officer would draw too much scrutiny from law enforcement while not as much law enforcement resources would be dedicated to investigating the death of an officer's daughter. What? Did I just hear that incorrectly to Rodrigo Tehran joining us from Philadelphia Inquirer. Rodrigo, that's why she wanted the teen daughter killed. At first, when I started investigating the case, I thought it's because she was jealous of attention or love given to the teen daughter. It wasn't that at all.
Starting point is 00:32:11 This woman might as well be a lizard. Her blood is cold. Explain why she wanted the daughter killed first. Sure. So according to what prosecutors said and you heard it right there, she was very methodical about the order in which she wanted these two people killed. She knew, according to prosecutors, that the assassination of a police officer would bring unwanted attention. So she made it very clear, according to prosecutors, that she wanted the daughter killed first, the teen daughter killed first, and then the Philadelphia police officer to mitigate the attention that would be focused in on these hits.
Starting point is 00:32:51 Amazing the way she planned this out. Dr. Sherry Schwartz, that is some cold blood methodical planning right there. her reasoning as to why she wanted the girl killed first? That's what she says. I actually think there's a darker motive for why she wanted the daughter killed first. I think that she was looking to hurt her ex-boyfriend and she wanted him to suffer before she ultimately had him murdered. Wow.
Starting point is 00:33:23 To increase the suffering of the boyfriend. How is it again, Dr. Sherry, I can understand all the hatred that must brew must percolate and boil over and say a long-term marriage. But here, there was no property division. There was no custody argument, no pots and pans, no dog to argue, nothing. How could you develop such intense hatred and just a brief dating relationship? I mean, this is somebody who maybe came to the relationship with that level of hatred. It's hard to say.
Starting point is 00:34:01 There isn't anything specific that I saw. researching the case that cites a reason that he did something to her that maybe would cause her to have such bitter antipathy toward him. But sometimes people come as they are, and that may be a reason that the relationship didn't work out. The most concerning aspect of the facts of this case involving the fact that this appears not to be an isolated attempt by the defendant to contract with someone to kill the victim. As evidence in S-4, which is a text message screenshot, between the defendant and the informant. The defendant states that she had people look at her in the eye and lie before
Starting point is 00:34:40 and how is she going to get proof. She also says that fake pictures could be sent to her and how is she going to believe that the victim was in fact dead and how she said someone previously sent her fake pictures before. Jennifer Emmy, a well-known lawyer defending animal rights, now has to defend herself against allegations. She ordered a hit on her ex-husband's new girlfriend. After the couple's nasty divorce, a hand at Emmy's nonprofit ranch went to the police with a recording of Emmy asking if he knew anyone who could take care of her ex's much younger new girlfriend during which she said, no one will miss her if someone could help me get rid of her.
Starting point is 00:35:33 It's amazing to me. Amazing in the sense that when you go to the snake house at the zoo, you look at the snakes through a thick glass wall or looking at a tarantula in a box. Amazing in that sense. That not only according to the state, of course, DeOrio is innocent until proven guilty. According to the state, she wanted not only her boyfriend, ex-boyfriend, but his teen daughter
Starting point is 00:36:05 dead too. In the case of attorney Jennifer Emmy, she wanted the girlfriend of her ex murdered. That's a whole different psychopathy. And in this case, Greg Moore's, you've got both, according to prosecution. Now, a great defense attorney like you may be able to convince the jury. Oh, this was all just talk. She didn't mean it. She didn't really want it to happen.
Starting point is 00:36:34 But we do have her, according to the prosecutors, handing over a down payment of $500 at Dollar General. She picks the places right where you know there's going to be surveillance video. The handover is at Dollar General and Wawa's. They're like Vegas for Pete's sake. They're covered and, oh my goodness. Yeah, there. They're covered in security video. I guess you didn't think that part through.
Starting point is 00:37:08 But the desire to have not only your object of hatred murdered, but then an innocent person who's getting dragged into it. I'm sure you could probably argue to a jury's all just talk. She didn't really want it to happen. She didn't know what she was saying. Don't prosecute her. Don't send her to jail. I can hear it right now. But that's a whole another layer of evil.
Starting point is 00:37:33 You don't just want your hate object dead. You want people around them dead. Well, I think you're right. And what we said before, it was probably to harm the ex-boyfriend to see his daughter killed first and then, you know, he has to suffer that. But you also, you know, you have a situation. here where folks, what they think in their head, it's going to be like when they pull a trigger or in this case try to hire someone to kill someone. The reality, though, of that and how that
Starting point is 00:38:07 plays out is totally different, as we see in all these cases, whether it's DiPolito, whether it's DiOrio, they're on surveillance cameras, they have phones registered in their name. These are folks that aren't making the smartest choices, right? So, but I also think that. It doesn't make the victim any less dead, Morse. Well, there's nobody dead here. And maybe it was because she was on the, what was it, a lousypam that was found in her car. She's charged with that also, drug count. So, and she also offered $500.
Starting point is 00:38:44 Please put him up. Please put him up. You're actually trying to argue that the illegal use of drugs is somehow a defense, as a defense. as opposed to an additional felony charge. We all know, all the legal eagles know, that voluntary use of drugs or alcohol is never a defense. No, no, no, but it doesn't mean it can't lead to some break with reality or there's some impact on her.
Starting point is 00:39:11 She was acting weird. Anyone that's had a loved one who's been under a lot of anesthesia knows when you come out of it sometimes, you're going to have some mental issues. You're going to see the world differently. You're going to see the world wrong. Maybe she had an impact on that. Are you somehow comparing this to when I videoed the twins after they had the wisdom teeth cut out?
Starting point is 00:39:31 No. Because, I mean, it never ends with you. You're actually giving me a headache right now. What medication? Well, she takes the medication. What medication does? Good luck with that. Rodriguez, Tedahon, joining us from Philadelphia Inquirer.
Starting point is 00:39:46 Where does the case stand now? What's happening? Sure. So there is a next hearing scheduled for middle of June. Right now, DeOriot. is in custody without bail. So she's basically in jail until her next court hearing. I've attempted to reach the officer that is allegedly the target of this hit attempt,
Starting point is 00:40:10 have been unable to reach him or his family. And that's really where it stands. You know, the detention hearing was basically to figure out if she would be released because she has no prior criminal record. Of course, the judge sided with the prosecutor's office and said, We're going to give no bail and she's going to be in custody until her next year. If you know or think you know anything about the alleged attempt on the officer's life or his daughter's life, the case is still being built by the state. 856-2-25-5-1-27. Repeat.
Starting point is 00:40:47 8-56-2-25-5-1-27. Now, we remember an American hero. police officer Christopher Kilcullen, Eugene P.D., Oregon, shot and killed in the line of duty. Twelve years with law enforcement leaving behind widow, Christy, daughter, Sydney, and Katie Ann. American hero, Officer Jay Christopher Kilcullen. Nancy Grace signing off. Goodbye, friend. This is an I-Heart podcast.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.