Criminal - The Man Nobody Killed

Episode Date: July 11, 2025

On September 15, 1983, Michael Stewart was on his way home from a nightclub when police arrested him. Thirteen days later, he was dead. Elon Green’s book is The Man Nobody Killed: Life, Death, and Art in Michael Stewart’s New York. Say hello on Facebook, Instagram and TikTok. Sign up for our occasional newsletter. Follow the show and review us on Apple Podcasts. Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more. We also make This is Love and Phoebe Reads a Mystery. Artwork by Julienne Alexander. Check out our online shop. Episode transcripts are posted on our website. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Support for Criminal comes from Squarespace. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform designed to help you make a great website. Whether you're just starting out or trying to grow your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to choose a URL, show off what you're selling, reach more customers, get paid, and do it all while looking professional. Everything in one place. Check out squarespace.com slash criminal for a free trial, and when you're ready to launch, use the offer code criminal to save 10% off your first purchase

of a website or domain. At Sobeys, our 100% fresh guarantee couldn't be easier. We guarantee freshness store-wide in our produce, bakery, meat departments, and beyond, or your money back. Yes, it's that easy. Visit sobes.com to learn more. Restrictions apply. See in-store online for details.

Visit sobis.com to learn more. Restrictions apply. See in-store online for details. In 1982, Madonna was shooting her first music video in New York City. It was for the song, Everybody. The idea for the video was that she would be performing at a nightclub. The room would be mostly dark with a spotlight on her and a crowd of people dancing to her music. She'd been given a budget of $1,500. A friend did her makeup for the video. Friends of friends came in to fill the dance floor.

I would hear stories of people in the East Village, you know, either going to parties with Madonna or their roommate would be dating Madonna. She would come up in just about every conversation and it would get to the point where I would get suspicious if somebody didn't bring up a connection to Madonna, because I thought to myself, were you really living in the East Village in 1983? I have my doubts. Elon Green is a journalist and writer.

One of the people in the music video was a young man named Michael Stewart. You can see him for a moment, about two minutes in. He's wearing a hat and a vest over a t-shirt, dancing near the front of the stage. And who was Michael Stewart? How did he fit into the whole East Village scene? Michael Stewart was a young black man. He was tall, 5'11", about 140 pounds. He was gorgeous.

He was modeling for Diane Brill, the queen of the night. Diane Brill was a popular New York City fashion designer in the 1980s. She'd hired Michael Stewart to model. She said he always gave good faces. Michael had grown up in Brooklyn. His mother said that he started drawing on paper napkins and writing stories as a child. He went to City College for a year and then attended the Pratt Institute for a summer class. He worked at the phone company and later as Pratt Institute for a summer class. He worked at the phone company and later as a bus boy at a nightclub.

But he was eventually fired for not being assertive enough to push his way through crowds to bus tables. One of the reasons he stuck out, aside from his looks, was that he was a quiet, contemplative person who did not talk unless he had something to say. And frankly, that was something that was out of character for a very loud, brash era. Michael ran in studio space in an old theater. When he didn't have the money for rent, he paid with his artwork. His landlord described Michael's art as, quote,

slashes of color. I thought that he was trying to leave proof of his own existence. You know, when it came to art, well, he was, you know, by definition of where he was. He was on the avant-garde. In 1983, Michael was still doing modeling jobs and was starting to DJ for big parties.

He was 25 years old. On September 14th, he met two friends to go to a party at Keith Haring's, but they couldn't get in. So they went to a place called the Pyramid Club instead. The Pyramid Club was sort of the center of the universe. Anybody who was an artist or filmmaker in the East Village would orbit around the space, whether it be Jean-Michel Basquiat,

Thurston Moore of eventually Sonic Youth, the artist David Wanarovitch. A typical night would be there were two floors. Downstairs was kind of where the action was because that's where the regulars and the staff would hang out. And, you know, one of the features or non-features of the pyramid was there was really no velvet rope. It was an incredibly egalitarian place when it came to race, gender, sexuality. I think anybody who is anybody would pass through there in the same way that they would pass through Studio 54 or Dance Interior or any of the places that were probably

more well known to people outside of the East Village. And what was the East Village like in the 80s? A total dump. It was likened to me like post-war Vienna, basically. Most of the buildings were uninhabited or uninhabitable. There were lines coming out of these empty buildings for people buying heroin. Just whole blocks essentially being dark. In the 1970s, New York City's government ran out of money. The city froze transit workers' wages, and they cut the budget for park maintenance. Between July of 1975 and November of 1979, the city hired no new police officers. The city even borrowed money from the Teachers Union Pension Fund.

Because the East Village was such a sort of desolate place at a time when New York City had not recovered from the financial crisis, it tended to attract a certain type of person who did not mind those kind of conditions, who wanted dirt cheap rent, and was often creative and who were all either artists or aspiring artists, and were perfectly happy to endure those conditions in order to be able to do what they loved. On the night of September 14th, 1983, Michael Stewart called an acquaintance, Patricia Pesce, and asked her to meet him at the Pyramid Club.

According to Patricia Pesce, after about an hour, they left. What do we know about what happened after Michael Stewart left the Pyramid Club that night? He and Patricia start walking, and eventually it's time for Michael to go home in Brooklyn. He lived in Fort Greene with his parents, and so they get in a cab and Patricia and he part ways at 14th Street and First Avenue where the L train is. And they have a fairly chaste kiss. He walks down the stairs and that's the last

that she would see him alive and well. And here's where things get a little murky. A transit policeman named John Kostick, who's just come on shift there, allegedly catches him defacing the wall of a subway with a marker and promptly arrest him. So he's led upstairs and he and Officer Kostick are standing next to the booth which houses the token clerk. And depending on who you ask, Michael either runs up the stairs towards the street or walks quickly. Either way, by the time he gets up there, he's, you know, quickly followed by Officer Kostick and other officers are called to the scene.

A man named Robert Rodriguez was working at a blimpy sandwich shop that night. He was also an auxiliary police officer. He saw what happened next. And he watches as Michael is led, you know, onto the street. He is not able to identify who precisely is doing the leading, but he testifies and in fact tells an NYPD officer the next day that he sees Michael assaulted as soon as he is taken up the stairs. So the one version is that Michael running up the stairs trying to escape the arrest at the L station and Robert Rodriguez sees some sort of scuffle where he's,

Michael is thrown to the ground or assaulted. That's correct. Michael is then driven to a transit police station at Union Square. Officers would later testify that he began to make trouble on the ride over. He was kicking the seat, essentially being uncooperative. Now, when Michael is removed from the car, the officers would later testify that he made a run for it and sprint it. And in doing so, runs into another officer and it sets off

what can only be described as an assault. The station at Union Square was also just a block away from a dorm for first-year students at the Parsons School of Design. Many of the students had their windows open that night. We started hearing this kind of crying out, help me, help me, police, help me, over and over and over again. It was a gut-wrenching, screaming, you know, life and death sound that brought us to the windows. I heard this blood curdling scream

that was just, you had to look to see what was going on. It was right down on the pavement. There were a lot of cops down there, a lot of cops that I, you know, maybe 10, 12, something like that. They had him on the ground and he was screaming and they would try to take turns. It'd be one officer that would be on him and then one would get up and another one would get down

on him and, you know, start hitting them and beating them. And they had clubs. This one police officer kneeled right up by his shoulder blades, put a billy club underneath his neck, and pulled up, you know, really hard, violently. I just felt sick. I was like, oh my God, this poor guy. It seemed like they could have just put him in handcuffs and taken him away, but then they tied him up, and it was horrible.

They picked him up, you know, literally his hands and feet were tied behind his back and they just tossed him into this little paddy wagon they had and they just threw him in there. And then they just left him. They just sat there and talked and it was a big group of cops and they were all just hanging out. There were perhaps 40 witnesses. Not one of them went to the phone.

Elon Green interviewed many of them years later and asked why they didn't call the police. Some of them, who had only really heard stories about what New York City was like, felt, well, you know, this is what we had been led to believe would happen so it's not really a big deal. Others would say, well, because he was handled so violently, he must have murdered somebody and tacitly deserved it. While others were just sort of confused about what to do because could you really call the police on the police?

I'm Phoebe Judge. This is Criminal. We'll be right back. Support for Criminal comes from Quince. This summer, if you're looking for something new to add to your wardrobe that you'll wear for many seasons to come, you might want to consider Quince. Starting at just $30, Quince has 100% European linen tops, washable silk dresses and skirts, and sleeveless sweaters. Great warm weather pieces you'll find yourself wearing

or putting in your suitcase over and over. And the best part is, all Quince items are priced 50 to 80% less than similar brands. By working directly with top factories, Quince cuts out the cost of the middleman and passes the savings on to you. Recently I've been wearing their linen shirt dresses. I got two new ones last month.

They're easy to wear and perfect for the season. You can give your summer closet an upgrade with Quince. Go to quince.com slash criminal for free shipping on your order and 365 day returns. That's q-u-i-n-c-e.com slash criminal to get free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash criminal. Support for Criminal comes from NetSuite. It's an unpredictable time to be running a business. You might need to move more quickly than you once did, especially when problems come up. That's something NetSuite can help you with. NetSuite by Oracle is an AI-powered business management suite that more than

42,000 businesses use. NetSuite can help you look at your shipments around the world, the impacts of tariffs, and where your money is moving in real time. It has forecasting tools that will tell you what's stuck, what it's costing you, and how to pivot fast. NetSuite puts your accounting, financial management, inventory, and HR systems all in one place. And its AI tools can help you automate many of your everyday tasks so you can let your teams put their energy and talent towards what you hired them for, moving the business forward. If your business's revenues are at least in the seven figures, download the free e-book Navigating Global Trade, Three Insights for Leaders at netsuite.com slash criminal.

That's netsuite.com slash criminal. The transit police officers brought Michael Stewart to Bellevue Hospital. A nurse wrote in her notes that he was face down, handcuffed in a prone position on a stretcher, and that he had obvious head trauma and battle signs. He wasn't breathing. Doctors tried to resuscitate him, but they had to wait for the police to look for the keys for his handcuffs. The doctors and nurses observe bruising. He has clearly been through some kind of, you know, ordeal.

They begin to hear stories about what has happened. The nurses even begin to suspect that, you know, a cover-up is in the works. What they don't find, though, are classic signs of strangulation, and that would later become important. Michael Stewart was admitted to the intensive care unit and put on a ventilator. He couldn't breathe on his own. He also received a CT scan. Two neurologists looked at the scans and noted there were no blood clots or lesions and no skull fracture.

But one of the doctors saw swelling on the left side of Michael's head, something that could happen if he'd hit his head very hard against something. The doctors tested Michael's reflexes. He showed almost no response. Did he ever gain consciousness again? No, never. Two Transit Authority officers went to see Michael Stewart's parents in Brooklyn.

The officers told them their son was in critical condition at Bellevue. Michael's mother then called a woman named Suzanne Malouk. Suzanne Malouk was, was Michael's on and off girlfriend and also the on and off girlfriend of Jean-Michel Basquiat. Suzanne Malouk had met Michael about a year earlier at the Pyramid Club. They had lived together for a while, but eventually Suzanne asked him to move out. She said she was still in love with Bas-Guyot.

But they were still close. They'd seen each other the day before Michael's assault. Michael's mother asked Suzanne to meet them at the hospital. According to Suzanne, when she arrived, no one would tell them why he had been arrested. She tried to see Michael. She said she was his fiance, but the nurses wouldn't let her. A doctor said Michael was brain dead. A detective approached her and asked if Michael did drugs or if he was known to be violent. Suzanne came back to the hospital the next day. She went and borrowed a camera and put on kind of a dowdy conservative dress and talked

her way into Michael's room at Bellevue, which was no small thing because, of course, he was in custody. Even though he was comatose, he was by law handcuffed to the bed. And she proceeded to take photos of him with the tubes coming out of his mouth and the bruises all over his body. And she did this extraordinary thing of documenting the wounds at a time when nobody else thought to do this. What kind of investigation was being done after Michael Stewart's hospitalization? It wasn't really an investigation in the traditional sense.

You know, the NYPD was not handling the case as an ADA said to me, nobody was going to trust the cops. And so it was the investigators of District Attorney Robert Morgenthau, who were going around Union Square looking for witnesses. And they went floor by floor in the Parsons dorm and started to talk to the students until they were able to dredge up dozens who had seen the incident. You know, in the hours after the assault, investigators went to talk to each of the policemen. Internal Affairs was asked to investigate the case.

And that was something that they did routinely when there were complaints of police malfeasance. And for reasons that remain mysterious to me, they refused, which was something they almost never did. The police charged Michael with criminal mischief, resisting arrest, attempted escape, and possession of marijuana. A newspaper wrote that a Transit Authority spokesman said Michael, quote, went berserk after officers tried to arrest him for writing graffiti on a subway wall. They said that he had been drawing three-foot-tall letters, by some accounts, RQS, by others, RAS.

Elon Green says it's never been clear whether that was true or what those letters could have been referring to. Michael Stewart died on September 28th, 1983, 13 days after his arrest. How quickly did the story of what happened to Michael Stewart make the news? quickly did the story of what happened to Michael Stewart make the news? Well, the first story appeared certainly within 24 hours in the tabloids. And the turning point for the story, because this otherwise I think would have been treated as a routine police brutality case because, of course, they were routine. But the case got the attention of Gabe Pressman.

He was a TV news reporter. In fact, he essentially invented the job of being a TV news reporter, and he became immediately obsessed with the case and began investigating every facet of it. And a New York Times reporter told me that nobody else would have cared about it if Gabriel Pressman had not cared about it first. And once he got on the story, it began to make the cover of every tabloid for days and for weeks. In a TV segment that aired on the day of Michael Stewart's death, Gabe Pressman reported that the Transit Authority would only say that Michael had gotten a cut over his eye. And what was the reaction from Michael's own community, from his friends, the artists,

from his family, parents? Rage. Even before Michael died, that September, there was a protest held in Union Square, as far as I know it was the first and it was organized by a man named Howie Montauk. Howie Montauk was a doorman who worked, a famous doorman who worked at the Palladium and Studio 54 and Dance Atia and all sorts of places. He also was a man who had an activist streak going back to his childhood. And as soon as Michael was hospitalized, he and Suzanne Maluk and some others began to organize the protest in Union Square. And David Wanarowicz created these beautiful flyers

to advertise it. And those were hung from lampposts in the East Village. The poster showed two skeletons and police uniforms, hitting a faceless figure with his arms handcuffed behind his back. Madonna headlined a concert to raise money for Michael's parents to pay for their legal expenses. They'd hired a lawyer and experts

to look at Michael's medical records and autopsy and to make sure the city was investigating. Madonna said that Michael made one really strong impression on me, and that was that he was really fragile. Keith Haring donated the proceeds from some of his gallery sales to Michael's family. Haring, who was white, said he'd been arrested four times for graffiti and had always been let go.

He was even arrested once on camera, drawn on a wall in a subway station, while a news crew was following him for a profile. He may do as many as 30 such drawings in a day. He puts them down here so that millions can see them, and millions do. You don't have to know anything about art to appreciate it. But he's got to be careful, because technically what he's doing is illegal graffiti.

I'm under arrest for graffiti on the subway. Herring doesn't think he is defacing anything. He believes it is art, and many subway riders seem to agree. But the law is the law. For Herring, the arrest is always short-lived, and it's worth the temporary humiliation for him because he wants ordinary people, subway riders, to see his stuff. Art for the people.

All for the price of a subway token. You know, later Jean-Michel Basquiat would wander over to Herring's studio and leave a painting on Herring's wall of a silhouetted black figure, you know, surrounded on both sides by sort of blue pig-faced policemen. Keith Haring later cut out the part of the wall Boscat had painted and put it in a frame over his bed. Boscat never named the painting, but based on writing on it, Keith Haring called it Defacemento. but based on writing on it, Keith Herring called it defacemento. It was later displayed at the Guggenheim and called defacement, and then in parentheses, the death of Michael Stewart.

On September 29th, the day after Michael Stewart's death, his body was autopsied, and there was a press conference. There was mounting pressure for the city to release their findings about the cause of his death. The chief medical examiner of New York, Elliot Gross, declared that the cause of death was cardiac arrest with survival for 13 days, bronchial pneumonia pending further study, which is one of the statements that is both true but also meaningless. Elliott Gross told the press, quote, while there was evidence of healing injuries on the body, the autopsy demonstrated no evidence of physical injury resulting or contributing to death.

When asked by a reporter about Michael's injuries, Dr. Grove said that Michael Stewart's wrists showed abrasions, consistent with injuries caused by handcuffs. But he said that the other injuries could have been caused by other things, like a fall. A doctor who had assisted in the autopsy later told Elon Green, of course they did something to cause his death. A lawyer representing Michael Stewart's family said that one of the doctors who was serving as a witness to the autopsy had said that Michael Stewart's eyes showed signs of strangulation or choking.

Elliot Gross said that he had found no signs of strangulation. He said they would be conducting further tests, including an examination of Michael's brain and spinal cord. And the next day, he removed Michael's eyes. Matthew Feeney And he puts them in a solution called formula, which is a preservative, and the removal eventually gets out. And it is widely interpreted as an attempt by Dr. Gross to engineer a cover-up on behalf of police. Beth Dombkowski Why, what could the eyes have shown?

They could have shown particular hemorrhages, which is often an indication of strangulation. The doctors the Stewart's had hired said they hadn't been informed that Dr. Gross had done this procedure. I mean, when those initial autopsy results came out, what was the reaction? Anger, justifiably so. Because certainly the idea that Michael's cause of death was cardiac arrest was seen as a passing of the buck, an abdication of responsibility, an endorsement

of the idea that the cops were not at fault. Protesters gathered outside the office of the chief medical examiner, chanting, Dr. Gross lied. We'll be right back. Thanks to Squarespace for their support. Squarespace is the all-in-one platform designed to help you make a great website. Whether you're just starting out or trying to grow your business, Squarespace gives you everything you need to choose a URL, show off what you're selling, reach more customers, get paid, and do it all while looking professional.

Everything in one place. No matter what you're working on, whether it's a podcast, a special event, photography services, or a consultation business, you can customize your website to reach the right people. If you're creating video content, like online courses, tutorials, or workshops, Squarespace has built in ways to support that. With Squarespace, you can upload your videos into an organized, paywalled library, and they make it easy to collect payment with thoughtfully designed invoices and online payments.

Plus, they have tools that make it convenient for people to keep in touch with you. Tools that help you send emails to potential customers, or that let your customers schedule their own appointments. Check out squarespace.com slash criminal for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use the offer code criminal to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain. Can't stop, won't stop, get quop, 10 white toes and then Tory flip flops. This week on Network and Chill, I'm joined by Saweetie, the Grammy nominated recording artist and entrepreneur who's turned her hustle into an empire worth millions.

From attending USC to pursuing music to securing major deals with McDonald's and Matt Cosmetics, Saweetie breaks down how she transformed her icy girl persona into cold hard cash. A money goal is to have passive income in the millions. Listen wherever you get your podcasts or watch on youtube.com slash your rich BFF. Early 80s in New York, are there a lot of these kind of interactions between the police and citizens? Is this happening often? It happens often enough that in 1983 there are 400 reported police brutality incidents over a two-year period. In the days after Michael

Stewart's assault there also happened to be a congressional hearing being held in Harlem on police brutality. Mayor Ed Koch refused to attend. Mayor Koch's attitude towards police brutality was to act as if it did not exist. As he once put it, it was to him a phony false issue. I think at the time, just as now, many people were in thrall to law enforcement. And I think that he did not want to believe that the NYPD and the housing policeman and the transit policeman might be routinely assaulting Black New Yorkers. Quote, people would get the baton to the head and have to have a neurosurgeon,

a doctor at Bellevue Hospital remembered. In 1980, New York City's crime rates were the worst they'd ever been. There were over 1,800 murders reported that year. the worst they'd ever been. There were over 1,800 murders reported that year. A few years earlier, people visiting New York received pamphlets at the airport titled, Welcome to Fear City, with a skull looking out from a hood. It listed nine rules to survive the city without being killed or robbed, like not going out after 6 p.m. and to never take the subway. The pamphlets had been created by a group called the Council for Public Safety. In response to the city laying off police and firefighters, the group was made up of their unions.

A year after Michael Stewart's death, a white man named Bernard Goetz got on the 2 train. He sold electronics in Greenwich Village. He'd been mugged a few years earlier and had started carrying a gun. He was wearing it under his windbreaker. He gets on the subway, and in the subway car along with him are some teenagers. Their names were Troy Canty, Barry Allen, Darryl Cabby, and James Ramseur. All four were black and around 18 years old. At one point, Troy Canty asked Bernard Goetz for $5.

And these kids, perhaps they looked at him funny. One apparently smiled. And Bernard Goetz pulls a gun, you know, out of his windbreaker and without provocation, shoots them all. All four survived, but Darryl Cabe's spine was severed by a bullet. He was paralyzed. Bernard Goetz got off the subway and left the city. He went to Vermont where he burned the windbreaker he'd been wearing and buried his gun.

Just over a week after the shooting, he turned himself in. He confesses and is thoroughly unapologetic and implies if not outright says that he would have killed them you know if he hadn't run out of bullets. And what's the public response like? He is greeted as a hero and one of the reasons he's greeted as a hero is because much of the reporting about what he had done was incorrect. He was portrayed as having responded to this imminent threat to his life. The teenagers were supposed to have been brandishing, sharpened screwdrivers. And this did not turn out to be true. These kids actually did

have screwdrivers, but they were blunted. You know, they were used to, you know, apparently like break into vending machines. And in any case, they were in their pockets. Bernard Goetz could not have seen them. And the great tabloid reporter, Jimmy Breslin, is perhaps the first person to write about what the actual story was. But by the time Breslin does this, it's basically too late. New York City has embraced Getz as a hero. AMT – A white man shooting black teenagers on a subway.

BD – Yes, and even substantial portions of the black community in New York supports Getz, to the palpable consternation of the black newspapers. Lylea Cudone-Sandberg Bernard Getz was eventually acquitted of attempted murder but served eight months for criminal possession of a weapon. On January 28, 1985, the New York Times ran an article with the headline, Lawyer Says Getz Does Not Feel Remorse Over Subway Shooting. That same day, an article about Michael Stewart also appeared in the newspaper on the front page. Family of Victim Levels Charges of Deceit, an autopsy conclusion.

A month after the autopsy, Dr. Gross had held a second press conference and changed the cause of death to, quote, an injury to the spinal cord in the upper neck. But he didn't classify it as a homicide. One of the doctors hired by the Stewart family told the New York Times, this is not the sort of injury you could give yourself. On June 1st, 1984, the New York County District Attorney Robert Morgenthau

announced a grand jury found enough evidence to bring charges against some of the officers who had arrested Michael Stewart, John Caustic, Anthony Piscola, and Henry Borner. Man slaughter in the second degree, criminally negligent homicide, reckless endangerment in the second degree, assault in the third degree, hindering prosecution in the second degree, and official misconduct. But soon it came out that one of the jurors on the grand jury had attempted to conduct his own investigation.

So Ronald Fields was a French teacher and just an intensely curious, inquisitive person to a fault. And he decides that what they've been presented, the case they've been presented by the prosecution, is incomplete. He feels that there must be more to the story than what they've been hearing. And so he decides to do his own investigation. Host- Ronald Fields read press releases from the medical examiner's office while he was serving on the jury. He also went to Union Square to take photos of the crime scene. And this is kind of unorthodox for someone to be going out on their own.

PETER Yes, it's not only unorthodox, but it may even be against the law, because he takes these exhibits essentially, you know, back to the grand jury, and, you know, shows them to the prosecutor and who promptly admits them as evidence. But you are not allowed to bring in outside information that has not been vetted by the prosecution. You're not allowed to do this because there is a process by which evidence is vetted.

And you can't have certainly one juror be privy to outside information. I mean, as the judge overseeing the grand jury said, you know, this will be grounds for overturning this. Did he apologize for interfering? Was he remorseful for... Not to me. He was always very unapologetic. The New York County District Attorney is forced to go through this grand jury process again.

You know, dozens of witnesses over however many weeks are made to testify again. And you know, at this point, these freshmen at Parsons are no longer freshmen and in many cases no longer living nearby and you know, they've been subpoenaed. They have to trek back to Manhattan to tell the same story over again. In February of 1985, nearly a year and a half after Michael Stewart's death, the district attorney announced that a second grand jury had voted to indict the officers again with

new charges. Instead of manslaughter for recklessly causing Michael's death, the officers were charged with criminally negligent homicide for failing to prevent his death. The DA said, What this indictment means is that when a police officer makes an arrest, he's responsible for the prisoner in his custody. If he beats him up or he permits some other officer to beat him, he's now going to be held legally responsible.

And while they each faced more than 20 years in prison, you know, these are substantially weaker charges. So what happens at the trial? What happens at the trial is, to me, nothing less than a complete muddying of the waters. Because the witnesses, you know, in the days after the assault and in their testimony to the grand jury tell a very coherent version

of events and maybe there are slight discrepancies. Perhaps one student sees three officers around Michael Stewart while another might see five. One of them might mistake an emergency services vehicle for an ambulance. And then what happens at the trial is, of course, what all good defense attorneys are supposed to do. He undermines every witness by finding these minuscule, piddling discrepancies between the grand jury questionnaires they'd filled out, the grand jury testimony, and then what they've just testified to

at the criminal trial. And in doing so, he discredits essentially all of them. And in addition to the students, you know, one of the most important witnesses for the people, if not the most important witness, was that sandwich maker at Blimpies, the auxiliary policeman Robert Rodriguez. And it comes out that Rodriguez had been hospitalized for, I think what would be called today, suicidal ideation and schizophrenia. And the judge allows the defense attorneys to bring this up on cross-examination. And so Rodriguez is kept on the stand for days and destroyed.

So by the time the trial ends, you know, the witnesses have to some degree been discredited falsely, I would believe. And then of course there's the matter of Elliot Gross, the chief medical examiner of New York. In the months leading up to the trial, Dr. Gross became uncertain about the cause of death. He now thought that Michael's spinal cord injury was a result of his time at Bellevue Hospital,

not his arrest. On his first day on the witness stand, he testified that he had no opinion about the cause of Michael's death. He was on the witness stand for 11 days. Dr. Gross, you know, eventually testifies that Michael Stewart's death was the result of acute intoxication, the effects of his being under restraint, and the effects of blunt force injuries. And in his closing remarks, John Caustic's lawyer says, look, this is multiple choice. If you can't even decide on a cause of death, how can you possibly convict this man?

And what is the verdict in the trial? Not guilty. For everyone? Yes. After the trial, a local magazine called the East Village Eye published an editorial about the verdict. It was headlined, The Man Nobody Killed. Do you think that things might have turned out differently if there had been a clearer autopsy that said these actions led to Michael Stewart's death from the beginning? Yes, but the only circumstances I could see where such a case would have ended in a conviction,

because of course this would have been a very big deal if it had ended in a conviction, would be if Michael had not been in a coma and had died that night at Bellevue. Because if he had died that night, there wouldn't have been 13 days for bruises to disappear, for any sort of breaks to heal, any of those really severe injuries to disappear. And I think that the jury would have had to have been confronted with circumstances that were

impossible to ignore. But that's not what happened. And I think that the minor inconsistencies about the case allowed the jury to find the cops not guilty. In 1989, Spike Lee's movie Do the Right Thing came out. One of the characters, Radio Raheem, is killed by a police officer choking him with a nightstick. Spike Lee wrote in the stage directions of the script, The officers all look at each other. They know. They know exactly what they've done. The infamous Michael Stewart chokehold.

The movie ends with a dedication to the families of victims of police brutality, including Michael Stewart. In 1990, Michael's family settled a lawsuit against the Transit Authority and the officers involved in the assault for $1.7 million. But the mayor's office said the settlement did not constitute any admission of wrongdoing. Michael's father died in 2002. His mother still lives in Brooklyn. The Guggenheim Museum paid tribute to Michael Stewart's death in 2019, showing work by

Basquiat, Keith Haring, and newspaper clippings and protest posters about Michael. They displayed several of Michael Stuart's own paintings. They were untitled. The curator said, I didn't want to make him into a myth. I thought the best way to do that was to take a step back and let him speak for himself. Criminal is created by Lauren Spore and me. Nadia Wilson is our senior producer. Katie Bishop is our supervising producer.

Our producers are Susanna Robertson, Jackie Sigico, Lily Clark, Lena Sillison, and Megan Kinnane. Our show is mixed and engineered by Veronica Simonetti. Julian Alexander makes original illustrations for each episode of Criminal. You can see them at thisiscriminal.com. Elon Green's book about Michael Stewart is called The Man Nobody Killed. You can sign up for our newsletter at thisiscriminal.com

slash newsletter. We hope you'll consider supporting our work by joining our membership program, Criminal Plus. You can listen to Criminal, This is Love, and Phoebe Reads a Mystery without any ads. Plus, you'll get bonus episodes. These are special episodes with me and Criminal co-creator Lauren Spohr talking about everything from how we make our episodes to the crime stories that caught our attention that week to things we've been enjoying lately. To learn more, go to thisiscriminal.com slash plus. We're on Facebook at Criminal Show and Instagram

at Criminal underscore podcast. We're also on YouTube at youtube.com slash Criminal Podcast. Criminal is part of the Vox Media Podcast Network. Discover more great shows at podcast.voxmedia.com. I'm Phoebe Judge, This is Criminal.