Dateline NBC - Deadly Circumstances

Episode Date: November 16, 2022

When a Tennessee resident is murdered in her bedroom, investigators struggle to find answers with little evidence at the scene to link any possible suspects to the crime. Could it have been a burglary gone bad? Or, something else? Andrea Canning reports. Originally aired on NBC on April 20, 2018.

I just knew that she was gone. She was a bright, young mom-to-be. She was beautiful, confident, strong. It was a smile that really got me. Moving on from a messy divorce, jumping into a new romance. No one could believe it when they found her. They're saying it was a homicide. Then, police found something else. into a new romance. No one could believe it when they found her. They're saying it was a homicide.

Then police found something else, revealing recordings. Everything changed, like, instantly. It's weird. Brittany's essentially speaking from the grave. You could see the emotions that she went through. Could she point police to her killer? I mean, Sean gets scared to death. Could she point police to her killer? Here's Andrea Canning with deadly circumstances. Imagine all of your phone conversations being recorded for posterity.

How would you feel? What secrets would they tell? Why are you talking like you're trying to hide something? This story begins here at a suburban office outside Knoxville, Tennessee. Looks a lot like any office in America. But when workers here talked on their desk phones, every word was captured. She always looks like she's about to kill somebody. And oh, the stories they told, unfiltered and intimate, with details about office romances. And in one heartbreaking case, maybe even clues about a murder. This was a real whodunit. Norman Clark loves sports. His mother, Estella, says he was a top athlete and a good son, too. He was a loving, hard worker, caring person.

As a boy, Norman had dreams of playing in the NBA, then studied sports management in college. But by his mid-20s, he was working here, Vanderbilt Mortgage and Finance. 23-year-old Brittany Eldridge started there the very same day. She was beautiful, but it was the smile that really got me. That winning smile got to a lot of people. Brittany's big brother, Jeffrey, says she embraced life with a contagious enthusiasm. She liked to cheerlead and she liked to play soccer. She was a girly girl and a tomboy at the same time. She was really big about living in the moment. At Vanderbilt

Mortgage, Norman and Brittany were collectors, calling people to make sure they kept up with their house payments. What was it about Brittany that you formed this instant connection with? She was very good at the job, so I actually used her as a tool at first to teach me. So she helped me out a lot, and that's when we started talking more and more about different things other than work. And what do you think she liked about you? I think she liked that I listened, that I actually cared about what she had to say. So it was just strictly platonic, you know, strictly friends. But then it just developed

more probably eight months later. It developed a lot more. They became lovers, and that's when things got complicated. Norman was single, but Brittany, it turns out, was married. Her husband was a man named Terry Eldridge, a truck driver who drove his rig at night. What did she tell you about her marriage? She was happy, but she wanted children, and he did not. Were there any other issues, or was that the only one? They didn't spend a lot of time together because of their work schedule. She worked during the day, he worked at night, so they didn't see each other a lot. A married woman having an affair with a co-worker, not exactly the script for a fairy tale romance. So for obvious reasons, Norman and Brittany kept their relationship on the down low.

We never went out in public, you know, out to eat or anything like that, maybe but one time. But if colleagues could have heard their recorded inter-office phone calls, they would have discovered some suggestive, flirty banter. I could use your big, strong, manly muscles. You know, we all good. More than a year after their affair started, Norman and Brittany were still keeping things quiet. Then, in February 2011,

their secret affair became not so secret. Brittany's husband found out, and not long after, she moved out and a divorce was in the works. Did things start to get a little too serious and real? Actually, I don't know because she didn't even come to me and tell me they were getting a divorce. She just told me that she was moving out and that he had found out that we had been having an affair. Not long after moving out, Brittany delivered some unexpected news to her mother, Robin. She was pregnant, and the father was her co-worker, Norman Clark. When Brittany told you that she was having a child with Norman, what did you think? I'm kind of shocked at first, surprised, didn't know how to feel.

Did you think it was a mistake, or were you just, it's a blessing to have a baby? It was a blessing to her, and so I guess when the shock wears off, you're just happy for her, and you're just there to do whatever you can to support her. Norman says the baby certainly wasn't planned, but he says Brittany was still his best friend, and he took the whole thing in stride. I was happy for her because I knew she wanted to have a baby. But at the time, she was still married. So this is starting to get a little messy.

Got a baby. She's now divorcing her husband, who found out about you. Well, I wouldn't necessarily say it was messy. It a baby. She's now divorcing her husband who found out about you. Well, I wouldn't necessarily say it was messy. It was complicated. This wouldn't be Norman's first experience with parenthood. A year earlier, he had a baby girl with a Nashville woman he'd been seeing. Norman helped to support his daughter and says he was ready to do the same for Brittany. What's it like for you being a father? Is that something that you cherish? It's the best thing in the world. I became a better man, a better person, and I worked hard to become a better parent for

her. Had you always wanted more kids? Yes. Brittany was excited about becoming a mother and thrilled to learn she was having a boy. She even picked out a name for the baby? She did. What was the name? Zeke. Ezekiel.

She was just working and being happy about the baby and waiting for it to come and getting things ready for it. Brittany decided to keep working for as long as she could. December 13, 2011, was just two weeks away from her due date. It's a day her friend and co-worker Andrea Ray will never forget. Brittany, uncharacteristically, was late for work. She should have been there at 8 30. I was one of the only people that knew anything about Norman. I went over there to Norman's desk and I said, can you get in touch with Brittany's mom? So I called her and asked if she had heard from Brittany and she said, can you get in touch with Brittany's mom?

So I called her and asked if she had heard from Brittany, and she said she hadn't, so she'd go check on her. Was your first thought that, oh, my gosh, maybe Brittany has gone into labor? It was. That was, I think, everybody's first instinct was, oh, she went into labor and she's in the hospital having the baby. Robin went to Brittany's apartment to be sure her daughter was OK. But when she called Norman, it wasn't happy news about a new baby.

It was a very frightening phone call. She was very upset. She was crying. And I'll never forget how she sounded on the phone. Robin was frantic, and her world was about to be turned upside down. When we return, an awful discovery inside Brittany's apartment. I ran out of the apartment because I'm scared, and the 911 operator said, go back in there.

Oh, God, please, ma'am. Okay, we are. Okay, ma'am in a flash, her life just changed. Robin Owens will never forget the day she learned her pregnant daughter Brittany did not show up for work. That's unusual for her because she always showed up even if she didn't feel good. She would be there. So I just knew something was wrong. Her fear became a terrifying reality the moment she stepped into her daughter's unlocked apartment. The whole place is just a mess. I don't see her anywhere and I'm calling out for her and I'm scared to death. Without taking another step, she called 911. My mom's got an emergency. What is it? My daughter. Her wife just called me and I came

over to her apartment and it looks like it's been trashed. I ran out of the apartment because I'm scared, and the 911 operator, she said, you know, go back in there and see if you can find her. Inside the front door, seen here in this police video, Robyn saw Brittany's new flat-screen TV lying on the floor. Oh, my gosh. What? Ma'am, what? Next to the living room couch,

the scattered contents of her purse. Then, Robin heard the sound of running water coming from the bathroom. Oh, God. Ma'am, talk to me. So I hadn't been everywhere

except for the bedroom, and it was back in the back, and I didn't want to go in there. And I get to the doorway of the bedroom, and I just got a glimpse of her, and I just knew that she was gone. She's in the floor, Ted. Are you sure? She's naked. In where? What room?

In her bedroom. Okay. Oh, God, please, ma'am. Okay, we are. Okay, ma'am. Hold on, honey. Hold on. I ran straight out of the apartment,

and by this time the ambulance and police and fire department and all the emergency crews are coming. Robin was in shock. The pain was more than she could bear. At the scene, a police cruiser's dash cam captured an officer trying to console her. Oh God, I just can't believe this happened. Why did it happen? Why? It's the worst horror a mother could ever have to witness. It is, and you wouldn't think anything like that would happen in a million years.

And all at once, just in a flash, her life just changed. Brittany Eldridge had been strangled and stabbed in the throat. Police found her on the floor next to her bed, her naked body partially covered by lingerie. She was just 25 years old. The unborn boy she had named Zeke was gone too. After the shock has worn off, you must be thinking, who did this?

I'm thinking, how in the world could somebody murder a young lady that's eight and a half months pregnant? You know, how could somebody be so cruel? I'm thinking, why? That's the question that's never answered, is why? Were you the one who broke the news to Jeffrey? Yes. That must have been extremely difficult. It was very hard. Jeffrey, Brittany's older brother, was at the gym.

When I got back to my locker and I got my phone, I had like 40 missed calls or something. She said, somebody killed your sister. Did you immediately ask who did this? I never thought about it. All Jeffrey could think about was that Brittany was gone, the kid's sister who had always filled him with pride. She often talked about becoming a mom. Now, that dream would never be realized,

and in its place would be a murder investigation. It was a very closed-off scene. They had, of course, crime scene tape around. When reporter Jamie Satterfield of the Knoxville News Sentinel heard about a body being found, she went straight to the scene. Are police talking to you? Are they telling you anything about what's inside? No, no. The major crime folks came later, as did the crime scene folks. What investigators found was a ransacked apartment, suggesting a burglary that was interrupted and had turned violent. In fact, there had been a series of burglaries in the area in recent days.

For Jamie Satterfield, there were things to speculate about in those early moments, but nothing concrete to report. Other than just punches and all that, we just didn't have anything to go on. Did you have an open mind as to the scenarios of what might have happened, who could have done this? I didn't focus in on any one person. I just wanted to know who did it and why. Yeah, I never had a specific person in mind that could have done it. I didn't have a clue. There weren't many clues, but there were so many questions. And in this case, there would be no easy answers.

Coming up. I know my baby. I understand. My family's out there. I understand. I'm sitting in the back of the car. I know my baby. I understand. My family's out there. I understand. I'm sitting in the back of a police car. I can't even breathe. The father-to-be, from grief to disbelief.

I understood that they wanted to ask me questions. I just didn't understand why I was sitting in the back of a police car and being treated like that. When Dateline continues. When Norman Clark heard about Brittany Eldridge's murder, he left work and rushed to the scene. What's going through your mind as you're racing to Brittany's apartment? That it's not real. That this wasn't going on. This wasn't really happening. When I got there, there was police officers there.

So I pulled up to her apartment, parked right in front and jumped out of the car, and I was heading into the apartment. Here's Norman at that exact moment, captured on a police dash cam. What did you say to that police officer? I told him that that was my baby that was in there, needed to get in there. I was thinking that the baby could still be born. That was what was going through my mind the whole time.

Norman says officers blocked him from entering the apartment. And in a matter of minutes, they had him in the back of this police cruiser. I'm in trouble? No, sir, you're not in trouble. No, sir. So tell me more, please. Just update me, because I'm really confused right now. The police were asking questions,

and so was Norman. So you're telling me this is Norman? Yes, sir. This is protocol, sir. But why for me? You're the boyfriend. And I sat there for a while. I'd say probably for an hour.

I was in the back of the car. Did you wonder why you were sitting in the back of the car for so long? I was. And I understood that they wanted to ask me questions. I just didn't understand why I was sitting in the back of a police car and being treated like that. I was just going to ask you, how were you treated? To me, I felt like I was treated unfairly,

especially voluntarily answering every question. I feel they just automatically did jump to a rush of judgment on who I was, you know, for showing up there. We have to talk to the people that know her because we have to figure out what's going on there. That was my baby. I understand. My family's out there.

I understand. I'm sitting in the back of a police car. I can't even grieve or do anything because I'm so worried about it to my friend and my child. Do you start to think maybe I should get a lawyer? The fact that the tone they're taking with me? No, ma'am. Why not? There was no reason for me to have a lawyer. I was innocent and I was answering every question that they wanted to know.

Detectives had more questions for Norman downtown at police headquarters. You have the right to consult with a lawyer and have a lawyer present with you while you're being questioned. He didn't ask for a lawyer there either. I just want to make sure that you're still willing to talk to me. Norman says he had nothing to hide and tried to be helpful. He told detectives he did have plans to see Brittany the night she was killed, but ended up going straight home after work and then spent the night with a friend. He gave police his phone, said they could search his car,

and when they wanted DNA from him, I'd like to get a saliva sample from you. He let them take a sample immediately. That night, detectives drove Norman to his house to collect the clothes he wore the night before. Then it was back to headquarters for another round of questioning. It had been a very long day. Norman felt he'd cooperated every step of the way. But by now, he'd reached the end of his rope. I'll give you anything you want. I've given you everything. And we appreciate that.

We appreciate cooperation. Detectives spent hours with Norman that day. But after that second interview, he was released. Norman was relieved that there would be tough days ahead. Just one day later, he attended a candlelight memorial vigil for Brittany. How were you received at those vigils? Oh, with open arms from the whole family. You know, they knew that I had just lost two people that I loved also.

Brittany's family buried her a few days later, still not knowing who was responsible or even who would want to harm her. Of course, there was someone police knew they needed to look at. The man Brittany had recently divorced, Terry Eldridge. Brittany was 17 years younger than Terry. She was only 22 when they got married. It wasn't long before their marriage was in trouble. Really, he started to fall apart because she was getting antsy

and just really, you know, wanted to have a family and kind of settle down, you know. And he was just out driving a truck all the time. You know, she just kind of felt like this is not right for me anymore like, you know, like it used to be. The final straw was when Terry found out Brittany was having an affair with her co-worker, Norman Clark, and was pregnant with his baby. Given that basket of facts, the police investigating Brittany's murder knew it was time for a talk with her ex-husband. Coming up, investigators uncover secrets from Brittany's life. Everything changed, like, instantly. And from someone else's.

How many women were you seeing at the time? Maybe 15 to 20. After more than two decades covering murder investigations, reporter Jamie Satterfield knew this one was a no-brainer. The husband, who discovered his wife was having another man's baby, was someone detectives needed to investigate. Did you wonder immediately about Brittany's ex-husband? You know, the ex-husband is always your first suspect. Their divorce had not been very pleasant. It was a little bit ugly. So detectives questioned Brittany's ex-husband, Terry Eldridge. Terry was looked at by the police.

They did take a DNA sample. And it did cross my mind. What if Terry did do this? You know, you have to think about all the different possibilities. You know, could this person have done this? Would they have done it? What would there have been the reason to do it? But when the results of Terry's DNA test came back from the lab, it didn't match samples from the crime scene. Police also found out he was nowhere near Brittany's apartment at the time of the murder. His alibi was airtight. He really ended up not being much of a player in the case once they ruled him out. Eldridge was cleared of any wrongdoing. Norman Clark had been questioned and released too. If police had any leads, they were holding them close.

I was curious why they were being so particularly tight-lipped about it. I think my primary concern was that this was just a case that was going to get shelved. That's exactly what Brittany's family feared most, too, that she and the baby she was carrying would be forgotten. We are her boys. We have to keep her memory alive. A full year passed, then two, with no arrests. But investigators were still working the case, in part because they heard from someone with inside information,

someone unexpected, the victim herself. Vanderbilt, this is Brittany. Can I help you? Remember, Brittany's employer recorded every call she made on company phones. It was done for quality control, but now investigators could listen to her conversations. And those calls explained a lot about her relationship with Norman Clark. How are things going with you? Well, very odd with Norman. Brittany's conversations with friends made it clear the oddness

with Norman began the day she told him she was pregnant. He was emailing me like normal and then as soon as I told him everything changed like instantly. Yeah I mean it's weird. Andrea Ray, a close work friend, says Brittany often gave her an earful about Norman. I think that she had hopes that he would respond to her pregnancy in a positive way. And that that would somehow bring them together. But that was not the response that she got. I can't take the wishy-washy like bipolarism. I don't know if on a daily basis he's thinking about all this.

I mean, how can you not, for one thing? He's a guy. That's why I'm not. Brittany was still in love with Norman and pregnant with his child. She seemed desperate to figure out her future as a mother and how Norman would fit into her life. Norman, to put it mildly, was not acting like he was ready for a commitment. Investigators had access to all of Norman's recorded work calls, too. They were very revealing. I wanted to ask you, you ever get with a... Oh, yeah, I banged that out last week.

Did you really? Yeah. Yeah, yeah, that was my second time seeing her. Congratulations, dude. Oh, thank you, thank you. You wild, man, you wild, dude. Norman, it turns out, was in other relationships at the same time he was with Brittany. When we sat down with him, Norman said he loves sex and women.

Lots of women. How many women were you seeing at the time? Maybe 15 to 20. Norman, that's a lot of women. I was single, and I'm a very friendly person. They knew that I was not looking for a relationship. So friends with benefits. How do you even meet that many ladies? Through work, online dating sites. Were you sleeping around with multiple co-workers? Yes. Did that ever get messy?

No, ma'am. Seems a little odd that all these women were okay with you sleeping with all these other women. I wouldn't be okay with that, but maybe I'm old-fashioned. Well, I mean, with the different women that I met, they accepted what it was, because I was honest up front. This is what I'm looking for. Fifteen to twenty different women at the same time? Hard to believe Brittany would be okay with that. And Norman didn't quite fit the image of a playboy. To save money, he was living in his parents' basement, yet was still barely staying ahead of debt collectors who would call him at

work. You're still due for September, October, and November. For the payment? Yeah. Investigators might have simply written off Norman as a low-budget Don Juan, except for this. Three days before Brittany was murdered, after months of ignoring her, Norman suddenly showed an interest in her and their baby. I'm trying to figure out this text Norman sent me last night. He said, I will be back Sunday.

Stay pregnant till then. Promise. And she said, what do you think that means? And I said, I have no idea. And she said, well, I guess he wants to be part of this baby's life. Well, he doesn't get a trophy for that. No. Why the sudden interest?

What was Norman thinking? Investigators believed an entry from Brittany's diary provided a hint. She wrote that she planned to take Norman to court to get child support for her baby. She knew that he had a child with someone else and that he did participate there. So why wouldn't he hear? Andrea says the night before the murder, she was on the phone with Brittany, who was texting with Norman at the same time.

She says he wants to meet Monday after work, and I said, tell him no. But Brittany said yes. Norman insists he blew off their date and did not go to her apartment Monday, the night she was murdered. But her family didn't believe him. They'd grown very suspicious of Norman and wondered why police hadn't moved in on him.

How frustrated were you that he was walking around? Very frustrated. I even called the lead investigator at one point and told him if you don't come get him, I will take care of him myself. Were you being serious? Oh, I was being dead serious. Despite the family's frustration, the case was moving forward. And almost two and a half years after Brittany was killed,

prosecutors presented their evidence to a grand jury. It charged Norman Clark with the murders of both Brittany and their unborn son. Clark was arrested on May 14, 2014. He pleaded not guilty. When you're arrested for something you didn't do, and then there's no evidence to even show that you should have been arrested, that's when things really hit hard. That's when I really got scared. Norman Clark had reason to be scared. If convicted, he could spend the rest of his life behind bars. Coming up...

They've taken a good young man and they've destroyed his life. Norman Clark on trial. And on the stand... I thought he was my boyfriend. Girlfriends, many, many girlfriends. But where was the stand? I thought he was my boyfriend. Girlfriends. Many, many girlfriends. But where was the evidence? He gave DNA. He gave hair samples. They all came back negative.

When Dateline continues. In August 2015, nearly four years after Brittany Eldridge's death, Norman Clark, a man who'd never been in trouble with the law, went on trial for murder in a Knoxville, Tennessee courtroom. How nervous were you going into trial? Your life's on the line here, your future. I was extremely nervous and scared to death. The prosecution told the jury Norman Clark strangled and stabbed Brittany because he didn't want her to have his baby.

Reporter Jamie Satterfield. She believed it was the baby that was the target, that this baby was going to ruin Norman's life. And so he killed Brittany more to kill the baby. And she was collateral damage. Prosecutor Leslie Nassios painted an ugly portrait of Clark, a man having trouble paying his bills, a playboy trying to juggle relationships with more than a dozen women.

Who was rightfully the nature of your relationship with him? I thought he was my boyfriend. I loved him with all my heart. The jury heard all about Norman Clark's prolific sex life as several of his lovers took the stand. At some point, did your friendship with him become intimate? Yes, ma'am. I don't mean to embarrass you,

but did he have a particular way of referring to a part of your anatomy? Yes, ma'am. In what way? What did he say? Ownership was his. He must have been stretched so thin to be attentive to 15 different women. That is one of the reasons that the prosecution said he was just, he broke. And now here's this baby and Brittany's saying, I'm going to take you to court. Next, the prosecution established a timeline to place Clark at Brittany's apartment at the time she was killed. Here's Brittany leaving work at 8.05 p.m. The medical examiner estimated her time of death as early as 8.30. An FBI cell phone expert testified that Clark's phone pinged off a tower near Brittany's apartment at 8.28 and again at 9.05.

Remember, Clark's alibi was that he was at a friend's house the night of the murder. That friend, Leanne Hahn, was actually one of his many girlfriends. Clark was at Leanne's that night, but her testimony seemed to shred his alibi. Your testimony is that he comes into your bedroom without calling you, without any notice, and you recognize the time as... Around 10.30. The prosecutor said if Clark was at Brittany's at 8.30 and arrived at Leanne's two hours later, that gave him plenty of time to commit murder, stage the crime scene to look like a burglary, and clean himself up.

After presenting a circumstantial case, the state rested. Norman Clark's defense attorney, Greg Isaacs, derided the state's case as all theory. They had no physical evidence, no eyewitnesses, no proof Clark was a killer. He gave DNA. He gave a statement. He gave hair samples. They all came back negative. The defense aggressively attacked the state's case and witnesses, starting with Leanne Hahn, the woman Clark says he spent the night with. The question was, when did he get to her house? You have no idea when you saw him at 1035 as to what time he arrived, correct?

I do not. And you were asleep with your television on, correct? Yes. The defense drove home the point. Since Leanne was sleeping, her testimony about when Clark arrived was meaningless. Isaacs said Clark actually arrived much earlier and watched Monday Night Football alone before getting into bed. The defense argued there was no way Clark could have committed a violent murder, cleaned himself up and the crime scene, staged a burglary, and then made it across town,

all in less than an hour. The state's FBI expert said Clark's cell phone signal placed him near Brittany's apartment the night she was killed. The defense countered with its own expert, who said the state got it wrong. We had one of the nation's preeminent experts on this. He and the FBI should testify against each other all over the country. It feels like this is almost one of those scenarios where the experts kind of cancel each other out. Exactly. It was a rush to judgment to pin the killing on Norman Clark, the defense said, claiming investigators overlooked the most obvious explanation for the crime.

The killer was a burglar who was caught in the act. There were 12 break-ins that occurred within a three- to four-week period in a very close proximity, and 10 of the 12 involved flat-screen TVs. Also, there was a break-in in that very same complex four days before the homicide of Brittany Eldridge. So, very powerful. Why not take the TVs?

We don't know. Maybe the person got startled. Maybe they couldn't do this. That's law enforcement's job, not mine. Finally, the defense said there was powerful evidence to support the burglar theory that would prove Norman Clark's innocence. Irrefutable physical evidence. There were two unknown DNA samples on the lingerie that covered Brittany's body in her

bedroom where she was found murdered. DNA from an unknown male contributor, not from Norman Clark. All they have done since day one at 1234 is focus on Norman Clark. As the trial drew to a close, defense attorney Isaacs told the jurors to focus on the evidence, not Norman Clark's womanizing. This is not a place for moral judgments. There's a guy upstairs that does that in a different court, more majestic than the road. Clark did not take the stand, but he says the state did not prove its case.

The prosecutor said that you had the means, you had the opportunity, and you had the motive to kill Brittany. And I feel all that is wrong, definitely far from the motive, because it doesn't make any sense.

An opportunity, it's pretty much impossible. Well, it's not impossible. To me, it seems impossible to get that done in that short span. You're the boyfriend. The motive from law enforcement's perspective was very clear. You didn't want to be in a relationship. You didn't want this baby. You wanted it to go away so you could continue to live your lifestyle. Right. I don't understand how they could say that when, if you know my lifestyle, then you know that I love children. I take care of my own child and I wanted more children.

Well, there's the other side of your lifestyle too, that you're sleeping with 15 different women. Right. Which has nothing to do with the murder. During the trial, Norman Clark's mother was in the courtroom supporting her son. As the jury started deliberations, she was anxious and bitter. They've taken a good young man and they've destroyed his life. Brittany's brother, Jeffrey, was certain the jury would return the verdict he'd wanted so badly. I thought 100% we got this. There was no doubt whatsoever that they were going to come back and return a guilty verdict. But nobody on the outside really knows what happens in a jury room. And after deliberating for six hours, this jury gave up.

They came close but could not reach a unanimous verdict. The vote was 11 not guilty, only one guilty. At this point, I am going to declare a mistrial and disband this jury. They come back hopelessly deadlocked. And not only that, but it's 11 to 1 acquittal. Right. You must have been just shell-shocked. Devastated. Just devastated.

Norman Clark had been held in jail for 15 months since his arrest. He was released after his mistrial, but was still an accused murderer. Do you feel like you have a cloud hanging over your head? Oh, yes, ma'am. Definitely. It's a huge dark cloud above my head. That cloud would remain because prosecutors decided they would try Norman Clark again. Same charges, same evidence, same prosecutor. Would it lead to a different outcome?

Coming up, trial number two. Norman Clark is a killer. You can destroy my character or try to, but you still are not going to prove that I was guilty. It became a very hostile room. And another surprise in September 2017. It had been six long years since Brittany had been killed. Trial two would play out a lot like trial one, but with one big change.

Clark had a new court-appointed lawyer, Kit Rogers. What was your strategy, and was it going to be different from Greg Isaac's strategy in the first trial? It didn't differ. I was basically just saying, look at the evidence. And to me, when I looked at it, it looked like a burglary that was interrupted and went bad. Prosecutor Leslie Nassios has been on the case from the very start.

When baby Zeke was born, Clark was going to be exposed for exactly who he was. The birth of this baby threatened his way of life and that his solution to that problem was Norman. She was very emphatic that Norman Clark was not only guilty, but was kind of a sleazy human being. Did you worry that the jury would just not like Norman? Absolutely. Because of his lifestyle? Yes, that was a big worry, and I addressed that from the very beginning and all the way through. I hear a lot about sex, and what I want you to pay attention to is the evidence.

After six days of testimony, it all seemed to come down to Norman Clark and what kind of man he is. You can't convict somebody in murder because you don't like the fact that he has sex with multiple partners. They did not prove their case. These murders were personal strangulation. It's a personal type of killing. It is a killing that shows control and a desire to control the victim. Norman Clark is a killer. He killed Brittany Eldridge. He killed his baby. Those same arguments had led to a mistrial before.

Incredibly, when this jury got the case, it also came down to a lone holdout. Only this time, the majority wanted to convict. We spoke to two jurors about their deliberations. The person who voted not guilty, who was not going to change their mind, what was their issue? We asked, and the response that was made is, I'm the smartest person in the room. I have a PhD. You guys are all ganging up on me. At that point, it became a very hostile room.

Yes. And we decided to call it. After four long days, they were hopelessly deadlocked. Another hung jury. You just wake up and you wonder, why is this happening? You know, why is my baby sister not here? And why can people, why can the people on the jury not see what I can see? Our family can't keep going through these trials coming out with the same verdict.

We can't do it. The family may not have to do it again. After six years and two trials, prosecutors said that was it. They decided to dismiss the charges against Norman Clark. All they were worried about was trying to show the jury that I had a lot of women, I loved sex, and that I had bills to pay. That's it. You can destroy my character or try to, but you still are not going to prove that I was guilty. Even when dismissing the case, prosecutors made it clear they believe they tried the right man

and would file new charges against Clark if they get new evidence. Did you kill Brittany? No, I did not. What do you say to those people that believe everything just adds up to you being her killer? What do I say to them? I don't say anything to them. I don't like ignorance in my life. So if you feel that way, yes, you're ignorant.

And that's very sad. And I will pray for them. Brittany's family prays, too, for justice and closure and how to make peace with a loss they will never understand. Over six years, I haven't focused on anything else except for getting justice. There's no closing the book. Me and my sister grew up doing everything together. I mean, everything. How do you say goodbye to something like that? She and I had a special bond, and there are still times that I'll think,

oh, I need to tell Brittany about this. Or, you know, you can't call her, you can't email her, you can't text her. All you can do now is go to her grave. And that's not good enough. It's never going to be good enough. That's all for now. I'm Lester Holt. Thanks for joining us.