Dear Hank & John - DHJ434: Curt’s Fleas

Episode Date: December 3, 2025

Why don’t John and Hank live in the same state? Where does the chapstick go after I apply it? When my phone runs out of battery, why can't I plug it in and immediately use it? If aliens lan...ded on Earth long after the sun has died, would there still be signs of former human life? …Hank and John Green have answers!If you're in need of dubious advice, email us at hankandjohn@gmail.com.Join us for monthly livestreams at patreon.com/dearhankandjohn.See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 You're listening to a Complexly podcast. Hello, and welcome to Dear Hank and John. Lord, I prefer to think of it, Dear John and Hank. It's a podcast where two brothers answer your questions, give you dubious advice and bringing all the week's news from both Mars and AFC Wimbledon. John, do you know how an elf blows out a candle? I don't. Just going...
Starting point is 00:00:27 Why is that funny? I didn't have a joke ready. Oh, it was absurdist humor, like Dadaist. I don't know. I don't think it was, I don't think, if anything, it was. Oh, Marcel Duchamp would have been doubled over with laughter. Well, yeah, I was inverting the frame of the joke by elves, actually, of course, blowing out a candle and the only way that one could. Yes.
Starting point is 00:00:49 This reminds me of my all-time favorite joke. It's a knock-knock joke. You start it. It's so good, knock-knock. Who's there? That's it. I put that joke in looking for Alaska. I always thought it was such a funny joke. And I first started it in high school. And so I thought it would be appropriate for looking for Alaska. And I cannot tell you over the last 20 years how many emails I have received from people who are like, I do not get the joke. Please explain the joke to me. And I'm like, well, I guess it doesn't work that well over text. Maybe I should have considered that. There are a number of things I regret about my previous novels. But that knockout joke is definitely on the list. No one had had gotten in touch with me before published. a book about how mad I'm going to be about certain parts of the book. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that you're really going to want to take it back and you can't because
Starting point is 00:01:38 it's out and lots of people have read it. And if you take it back, it almost makes it weird because then like once you take back one thing, people are like, why don't you take back other things? And you're like, well, because if I took back everything, I regretted about the book, I would have to unpublish the book. It wouldn't be any book left. Man, would I rewrite that first page? Really? Oh, yeah. Yeah. it's okay people love it people love it well sometimes people like stuff that you don't like and that's okay like you know ultimately the job of the book is to resonate with an audience more than it is to resonate with the author of the future so like if parts of those books don't resonate with me
Starting point is 00:02:14 anymore as long as they're resonating with an audience that's all that matters i was just listening to an author talk about being an author and they were talking about the the feeling of you know knowing the ways that people are going to critique your book even before you publish it yeah you're like I know what people are going to say. Right. And like, and there's like either a limitation. Like there's a reason why I can't solve that problem or I don't want to solve the problem because I'm doing something else.
Starting point is 00:02:39 But you know it. You like are putting it out knowing exactly the criticism you're going to receive. Teenagers don't talk like that. Oh, yeah. Really? I didn't know. Thanks for the info. Thanks for the heads up.
Starting point is 00:02:50 Do teenagers talk like in Romeo and Juliet with her first 14 lines or whatever are just a sonnet back and forth to each other? Do they talk like that? How do they talk? Is Romeo and Juliet bad? Then there's the meta-criticism, which is fair, which is, did John Green just compare himself to Shakespeare? No, no.
Starting point is 00:03:09 Look, Shakespeare was just a man, you know? Or possibly several people. Oh, he was just a man, but one heck of a writer. I don't know. I've never really resonated with it personally. Are you serious? For clarity. I definitely want everyone to interpret that as a criticism of me, not Shakespeare.
Starting point is 00:03:27 There's a lack of generosity in the reader rather than a lack of. of generosity and the writer. I like that. Well, it's just, it seems to take a lot of a lot of work. Well, it's a lot of work because it was, yeah, it was a different, it was definitely a different time. Yeah. So if that's your concern, you should read Marlowe because Marlowe sounds even more dated. What's Marlowe? Never change, golden boy. It's not what I went to school for, okay? Clearly. Is Marlowe a Shakespeare play? I have not heard of that one. No, it's a writer.
Starting point is 00:03:59 It's a writer who was a contemporary of Shakespeare. Oh, there was another person doing it back then? And who got murdered in a pub, if I remember correctly. Did he get a death note? No, I don't think so. I'm not sure how that works. Okay. He probably knew it was likely.
Starting point is 00:04:17 I mean, it's never that far away from a possibility, is it, Hank? Let's move on to some questions from our listeners. Let's do it. Let's start with this question from Grace, who writes, Dear John and Hank, I'm wondering why you guys don't live in the same state. I understand John loves Indianapolis and Hank lives near the DFTBA warehouse, but wouldn't living closer together outweigh these pros long-term? Is it something you've never considered?
Starting point is 00:04:38 Thinking about shared space, grace. Well, John, I think it's very important for us to not murder each other. See, this is Hank's take all the time. He'll be like, the reason we can't live in the same place is that we would murder each other. And what he means is that he would murder me. I like Hank a lot. I could hang out with Hank like twice a week and be very happy. Hank would murder me.
Starting point is 00:05:01 No, I mean, we hang out twice a week already. And, you know, not in physical space. Yeah. This is one. And then there's probably another, you know? Yeah, we have a conversation twice a week. That's not quite the same thing as a hang session, but I hear you. I agree.
Starting point is 00:05:12 I've thought about it. I've thought about especially, like, living in Indianapolis for, like, a while every year. Yeah. And then we could, you know. Oh, man, we would crush the amount of content that we could make together. It would be good for the content. Great for the content. I mean, think about, like, how good Rhett and Link have it, you know, living in the same town as they do.
Starting point is 00:05:33 You know, another thing that I like about this, I was just thinking, like, Indianapolis needs the love. It does. I'm about to hit you with an idea. Here it is. Are you about to run for governor of Indiana despite never having lived here? No, I'm going to move to Indiana so I can become the vice president. Oh, of the United States. Yes, because that's where they're all from.
Starting point is 00:05:54 No, that was not my idea. Especially if you don't want to become president. we had an astonishing run of six consecutive vice presidents from Indiana who did not become president. That's great. Yeah. That's very Indiana. Well, I'm being a little presumptuous about Mike Pence, but I do think that we can rather put him in the past category. That would be a weird, that would be a weird direction for the Republican Party to go. Technically, I think Dan Quail is still alive. So he could also run. He could do it. He could also run for president. Yeah. I mean, look, We've only ever elected boomers in my life except for Obama.
Starting point is 00:06:30 That's true. John, the idea is this. We have people come in and then we create, we create like an experience. And then part of the experience is that like you give a little lecture downtown in Indianapolis. Yeah, like an artist and writer's residency where you do a public facing thing once. Yeah, but then there's also like a bunch of like really nice, you know, other things. that happened to you. You do realize that this is what Sarah and I are starting, right? Yeah. Okay. I just wanted to make sure you knew that we were doing that. I didn't know that there would be a
Starting point is 00:07:04 public facing part of it. But then also I think that like it can be at a, you know, a thinkers and intellectuals and all yeah. Sure. Sure, sure, sure. Yeah, I'm all for that, Hank. That's a good idea. Mostly because it would mean that you would move to Indianapolis, which would make me very happy. Like, I don't really want to move to Montana because of the sky high housing prices. combined with the complete lack of inability to get anywhere other than Montana. It's lovely there. That could be a huge perk sometimes. Do you have non-stop to New York?
Starting point is 00:07:35 We have lots of non-stops to New York. Do you have non-stops to L.A.? We do. Do you have non-stop to Europe? We have one non-stop to Europe, yeah. Where does it go to? Dublin. I'm in!
Starting point is 00:07:46 I know. It's pretty good. It's not bad. It's pretty good. That air lingus, they've got a good flight. Air Lingus, what does Lingus mean? I think it means air, um, air, air, air travel. Oh. Air language. It means fleet. Oh, so it's their air fleet. That makes
Starting point is 00:08:02 sense. So anyway, point being, I would love for you to move to Indianapolis. You're very welcome here anytime you want to. Full disclosure, I might leave for part of the year at some point. We've kind of got all of our systems set up in the places where we are, you know? That's true. And deep roots. I mean, the real answer, Grace, is that once you have deep roots and once you have your people, it's very hard to move. It's very hard to move and dislocate your kids from their school and leave behind your dentist. I mean, I love my dentist. I don't love my dentist. In fact, I don't have a regular dentist. I was like, man, it's going to be a bummer when your dentist listens to this podcast. What a way to find out, you know? I keep going back to the same
Starting point is 00:08:39 dentist that I ultimately do dislike now. Okay. So you just don't, you just, you just, you just, you just, you just, you just, you just, you just, you just, I just go. I just go to whoever is available on the day I'm available. I know what school Oren would go to. You'd have a great life here. And your cost of living would cut in half and you could fly to New York or L.A. anytime you want, and anywhere else for that matter. Yeah, but I do not trust that they will be serving me good coffee. Well, there is that. The coffee situation is not as good in Indianapolis as it is in Missoula, but on the upside, you do own a coffee company. Yeah, I can make it good at home. but I do love a nice coffee shop.
Starting point is 00:09:20 Yeah, I get it. We have a nice coffee shop now. We got one at 54th in Illinois. It's quite nice. It's just there this morning, actually. All right, so we're going to move to the same state, Grace, all because of you. Thank you. Hank's moving to Indianapolis.
Starting point is 00:09:33 This is an announcement. This next question comes from Cherise, who asks, dear Hank and John, every night I put on chapstick before I go to sleep. And when I wake up, my lips are dry and chapped. Where does the chapstick go? Autumn leaves and morning due, Cherise. Can I guess, Hank? yeah you can i think it goes into your lips i uh don't i think it goes into your mouth what what do you mean
Starting point is 00:09:56 it goes into your mouth you think it crawls up and floats its way into your mouth no could you think of another way it might happen no your tongue oh you lick your lips throughout the evening no way no that's wrong when you're sleeping you pull them in and like no that's wrong i think that's what happens Nope. I think what I will say, Sherees, is in looking at this, there are actually some ingredients and lip bombs that can dry out your lips.
Starting point is 00:10:24 Oh. So you want to... That's how they get you. It's addictive. They always need to put on more. It's a bit of a fool's game, the chapstick. It's a poisoned chalice. So what you want to do is start out with the real basics.
Starting point is 00:10:41 So move from whatever is in whatever you're by and that's fancy and and nice and smells good to something very simple that's just like you could just use vaseline no i'm a no on that one aqua for them really yeah how would i like my bert's bees of course you do but you know who owns bert's bees so like unilever or something the enemy john Oh, big, big lip chap. Yeah. Big lip chap owns all of the big ones. Who owns Bert's Peas?
Starting point is 00:11:23 I'll tell you, who doesn't own it anymore is Bert. That guy's living the dream. Oh, oh God, Bert's Peas is owned by Clorox. Is it really? Yeah. I would have thought Clorox was owned by something else, but no, Clorox is its own company with 8,000 employees worldwide. Based in Oakland, California. Oh, I didn't know that.
Starting point is 00:11:40 Yeah. They've got 420 people there at Burtz, so that's a sizable portion of Klorox. Wow, they make a lot of stuff that people use every day, like the Britta water filtration system. The Klorox company does? Yeah. And Formula 409, that like cleaner? Yeah. Mm-hmm. They make cat litter? Sometimes people are like, I can't believe that you're in the sock business and the household cleaning products business and the soap business and the coffee and tea business. And I'm like, have you Googled Chorox? Because Chorox makes KC Masterpiece the Barbecue sauce. And they also make liquid plumber.
Starting point is 00:12:20 Yeah, I don't. I actually don't want that to be the same company. Like, what if there's a mixup at the factory? Are you guys more in the mood for sort of a Hidden Valley ranch dressing? Or more of a pine salt? Because we got both here at the Chlorox. Company. Do you want some glad trash bags or some Kingsford Charcoal? It's good. It's good. They got everything, man. It's what they call consumables is what they make. Well, Wikipedia only has their
Starting point is 00:12:52 net sales up to 2020. So somebody's not on it at the Klorox Company updating their own Wikipedia page. Their revenue in 2025 was $7 billion. And if we could get good store there, I think we could call it a success. We could call it a day, Hank. I don't know why we can't. I just don't, am I not ruthless enough? I don't know what the issue is, but Good Store is very successful in the sense that it's given over $11 million to charity, but it's not nearly as successful as Hank, and I think it should be. It's a little bit like Vlog Brothers in 2007, where we were baffled that we only had 86 subscribers after 85 videos.
Starting point is 00:13:27 And we're on to something with Vlog Brothers, and maybe we're on to something with Good Story. It's just going to take some time. That was Clorox when it was eight years old, you know? That was in like 1910, so I don't know. but all your holiday needs can be met at Good Store where we do not sell bleach. No, and we don't sell lip balm yet,
Starting point is 00:13:44 but maybe I should put my money where my mouth is and make a very simple lip balm that is a single ingredient that all it does is make sure it prevents evaporation from the lips. Can you make it smell better than Vaseline? Vaseline does not have a smell. I mean, you have never in your life said something more wrong.
Starting point is 00:14:03 Aquifer does not have a smell. Okay, maybe. That's what I use. is aquifer. And there are other very low ingredient lip balm that you can try, Cherise, is all I'm saying. But I do think that as time goes on, like the lip balm stuff does not evaporate. And I don't think that it, maybe it does. I didn't look into this, but I don't think that it gets absorbed into the body. I think it does. I think it absolutely gets absorbed into the skin because the skin dries out over time. Yeah, but it's not, it's not water. It's, the lip balm stuff is
Starting point is 00:14:32 very specifically not. I can't wait for a lip balm scientist to write in and say that you're wrong. I can't wait to issue this correction. And honestly, if you do know what you're talking about, maybe we can make a product together. I got. Thanks. Thanks getting into a new business, everybody. Look, look if Klorox can do Burt's B's. What's it going to be called?
Starting point is 00:14:52 So it's not Burt's, but it is a man's name and an animal. Everybody write in your suggestions. I think it's Kurtz D's. Kurtz-D's nuts? Yeah. Doesn't that? sound like a wholesome, low-ingredient, eco-friendly lip-home? Kurtz-D's nuts.
Starting point is 00:15:14 Hey, I really like this lip-eye. It's in Kurtz-Flease. Where'd you get it from? Oh, I got it from Kurt's Fleeze. You know, it's like Bert's B's, but it's actually lower ingredients and better for the environment. It's called Kurt's fleas. It's called Kurtz-Flease.
Starting point is 00:15:30 Oh, man. Oh, we could bring back Kurt the punk rock nerd fighter to be the spokesperson. We could. He's probably not, never had fleas. we could bring him back. I mean, that's a deep cut, Hank. That's a 2007 cut. Yeah. All right. Let's go on to this question from Caroline who asks, Dear Hank and John, or Dear John and Hank, rather. I just accepted a new position and we'll be working from home for the first time. I have a good desk set up in our guest room, but it still doesn't feel like a workspace. You two seem like work from home guys. Are there any home office recommendations that could help me get in the work mindset? Home suite, Caroline. You got to get the thing that feels most worky. Yeah. And put it in a frame.
Starting point is 00:16:05 Oh, like a picture of your dog or whatever? No. Oh, like a picture of your printer. Yes, exactly, yes. Print out a picture of your printer on your printer. So you can look at your printer all the time while you're at work and be like, well, this definitely ain't home. Yeah. Any accolades, you know, your degree, a picture of your degree antiperspirant.
Starting point is 00:16:33 Sure. That's a good one. Your degree next to your degree. Yeah. Yeah, make it meta. I mostly work from bed. And so I'm probably the wrong person to ask about this, Caroline. I can transform any space into a workspace just by being anxious.
Starting point is 00:16:49 I am the opposite. I work mostly in the office where I am sitting right now. And it is like, it feels like a workspace to me, even though it does not, of course, look like a traditional workspace. And I think that that is simply because it is dedicated. for work, which is a luxury. Like, it's not easy to do to have that. And I have my fidgets.
Starting point is 00:17:13 Is that a weird thing to say? That helps. Yeah. And by fidgets, I mean these nail clippers, my Allen wrench set. 99% audio podcast, Hank. Nobody can see you. They know what nail clippers look like, John.
Starting point is 00:17:27 They're not unusual nail clippers. I don't. I have Afantasia. I can't picture anything in my mind. John, when you see a tree, Yeah. Do you think the word tree or do you have a feeling? I have a feeling of the tree.
Starting point is 00:17:41 I have a feeling of the tree. Okay. I'm just trying to figure out how inner monologues work because I don't have one and people do. I have an experience of the tree. You don't have an inner monologue and I don't have an inner picture producer. Between the two of us, we are pretty, pretty, pretty cold to the world, pretty far away from being able to engage with the universe as we find it. Yeah. Another thing that you might want to do to make your office feel more like an office is just like stuff a bunch of panty hose full of cotton and then form it into this shape of a co-worker that's just there that's just there.
Starting point is 00:18:17 Yeah. You know, and they're always there. And eventually, like, you could like install like a raspberry pie connected to a fart sprayer so that every every like three weeks it'll fart and you'll be like, oh my God. That's a good idea. That really feels authentically like having a co-worker. That's going to feel just like having a co-worker. I think the other thing you can do is invite one of your friends over to work next to you from nine to five, you know? Just do that.
Starting point is 00:18:45 That way you don't have to do code a raspberry pie. Still get the pleasure of the fart smells, but without having to do any coding. Without all of the code. Yeah. Yeah. But you could have like a snack drawer. Yeah. That's kind of a nice way.
Starting point is 00:19:01 actually have a snack drawer. Do you really? I do. Maybe that would get me out of bed because I definitely don't eat snacks in bed. That's one of my only rules. This, do you see what I got for you, John? No, I don't look at you when we make the podcast. I look at the question document. Turkey sticks. Oh, gross. That's in my snack drawer. Just in case, you know, just in case turkey sticks.
Starting point is 00:19:24 Yeah, sure. That's what our turkey stick brand is going to be called a good store, actually. Just in case? Just in case. Can't wait until we make turkey sticks to go along with our soap. That would be amazing. I'm going to throw it out there that I don't love being in the meat business. Yeah, I'd rather not be in the meat business, honestly.
Starting point is 00:19:38 Yeah. Hard to do well. Yeah. I think we should. I like the hard pivot to lip balm, though. I think that's a good hard pivot. What about, would it be, would it feel more like a workplace if you did like a 15 minute stand up?
Starting point is 00:19:51 You know what a standup is, John? You're not very corporate. No, what's a stand up? This is where you have, like, have a quick meeting where everybody's standing. You know, like, go into like a person's office and there's like six people. and they like stand there and they are you allowed to sit yeah you can sit okay well that's nice as long as you're allowed to sit i remember when i worked at booklist like i would drop by someone's office and stand and they would sit and we would chat for a minute is that a stand-up yeah usually
Starting point is 00:20:16 it's a bunch of people get called together but you're so it's a scheduled meeting it's just a shorter meeting it's a short meeting and the idea is that nobody sits to keep it brief and you can't keep it you can't keep it brief enough it should it it it it's it it's it it's it It should be shorter than it is. That's the only thing I know about stand-up meetings, just like sit-down meetings. I've been in some good stand-ups, but you're going to have to do this by yourself. So what you're going to want to do is like do it like Happy Slip, where you play all the different parts of the different characters in the office. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:20:50 Like Natalie Tran used to. Yeah, we're doing more YouTube deep cuts here for people who've been around forever. But yeah. And go around in a circle and you're going to want to create a. bunch of office personas. And you can base them on, like, your favorite sitcom or something. Sure. And you're going to go around in a circle and you're going to talk about all the things
Starting point is 00:21:08 that everybody's going to do that day. And then you're going to record that. You're going to record that. You're going to edit it together. You're going to upload it to YouTube. And then you're going to quit your job and become a YouTuber. Absolutely. And then you're going to find that you wait, wait a second, still work at home.
Starting point is 00:21:23 Still work at home. Still need to, still need to, like, gaze longingly into that picture of your printer. Which reminds me that today's podcast is brought to you by that picture of your printer that you keep next to your desk to remind you, this is work. This podcast is also brought to you, of course, by Kurt's Flee's Lip-Bomb, All-Natural, Low Ingredient. And today's podcast is brought to you by Indianapolis, soon to be the hometown of Hank Green. And this podcast is brought to you by everything I'd like to change in my two novels. everything I'd like to change in my two novels. Oh, not an insignificant number of things.
Starting point is 00:22:05 Yeah, but you just got to let it go, man. I just got to let it go. I mean, the truth is those books will be out of print eventually anyway. Look, yeah, the sun's going to explode, John. Yeah, no offense, but your books are going to go out of print before then. I hope so. Dear Hank and John, what I've always loved about laptop computers is that you can use them immediately after plugging them in when their batteries die.
Starting point is 00:22:27 Why don't phones do this? Electricity and elephants, Aden. I love this question. This is super weird and I had never thought about it. This is my favorite kind of question, John. A thing that is a normal part of my life. Yeah. That is, there's obviously a reason, but I've never even noticed it's a thing.
Starting point is 00:22:43 So if your laptop runs out of battery, you plug it in and you just like turn it back on and it works again, your phone runs out of batteries. You plug it in and you got like some amount of time. Yeah. Sometimes like 10 minutes. I'm going to like weird too. And I'm like, can I please? I need to finish watching that reel. Give me that juice.
Starting point is 00:23:04 How I'm going to survive for 10 minutes without my binkie. That's what they should do, Hank. I'm just going to stop you right there. You should be forced to call your phone your binkie. You should be, that should be like a criminal offense if you don't call your phone, your binky. And see if that, see if that affects your phone use at all. It's got to be something.
Starting point is 00:23:24 Something's got to make this embarrassing. No, I need my little passie. I'm sorry. I can't go on for 30 seconds longer without my passie. Yeah. All right. Go back. Go back to what you were saying. So it seems, and I would love, again, if there's experts who know more about this, but it seems that it is totally possible for a phone to do this, but it requires extra circuitry. So the way that a laptop works is that it can charge the battery and run the computer at the same time through that power port. There's enough power. coming in and the electrical system is set up in such a way that it can route that power intelligently so it doesn't overcharge the battery and it doesn't send too much power to the other thing or if the battery is done charging it can it can stop sending power to the battery and it can send it just one place it could do all this stuff and that just requires circuitry it requires systems and phones are so packed full of stuff that that circuitry isn't worth
Starting point is 00:24:21 the space that it takes up in the phone for it to be able to run the whole phone from the power port and so all of the power the systems is only dedicated to getting power into the battery and then the phone only can use electricity from the battery not from the power port wow i mean that's not what i would have guessed so that is really interesting did you have a guess um just because the phone's a little crankier it's just that was going to be my guess one more temperamental a little piece of crap yeah yeah but that's a that's a better answer than the one i was going to proffer. So very impressive. It was like going to a very short, not quite as good technology connections video. Indeed. All right, we got another question from Rachel, who writes,
Starting point is 00:25:04 Dear John and Hank, when people write in for advice, you sometimes talk about how none of us are going to be fine in the long run because eventually the sun will die and make life on Earth impossible. Sometimes we do do that. Rachel, it is kind of my comfort answer, you know, like we're going to be okay in the long, long run, just in the sense that we won't be here. My question is what would remain to be discovered by others. If space traveling alien archaeologists landed on Earth long after the sun has died, would there still be signs of former human life that would be discoverable? My name is most of the letters in archaeology. Rachel YG. Rachel, I have terrible news. We are very likely going to be engulfed by the sun before it dies. Yeah. So we'll become part
Starting point is 00:25:49 of the sun. We'll get baked into little bits. So I made this podcast. called the Crash Course the Universe with the great astrophysicist Katie Mac. And in the last episode, she talks about the long-term future of the universe, which also is in trouble, just for the record, Rachel, it seems anyway. And she talks about how there's a very old star that she saw once that had a weird chemical signature in one part of the star. And how that weird chemical signature, there was this paper that argued that weird chemical signature was probably a planet that the, Star had swallowed when it was a red giant and how, like, that's what's going to be left of us is a weird chemical signature in a dying star. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:26:35 Ew. Thanks for coming to the party. I mean, it's not a bummer to you, Hank, or is it kind of, to me, it's not necessarily a bummer because we aren't working for forever anyway. Like, I guess, like, my ambition doesn't extend to forever. My ambition really extends to now. Like, I'm very worried about now. I'm so worried about now I don't have time to be worried about forever.
Starting point is 00:26:58 I think that if I look at myself, I think that now is a kind of forever. Like, I don't actually distinguish those things in my monkey brain. Like, I get it. I get that those things are different. And then when I am confronted with the reality that they are different, that is the uncomfortable thing. Right. So this is a thing that I have with philosophy in general, where I just, I think that we
Starting point is 00:27:20 mostly don't operate with truth in mind, you know, with like, with like the, the truth of the structure of reality in mind. We operate with like our biology in control where it's like, you know, I love these people and these things because I do, not because of any structures or systems or like deep understanding. But I have found a lot of joy and inspiration and connection and excitement around the weird thing that is life and the weird thing that is humanity. Yeah. And so because I have that affinity and that amazement about that very long history of chemistry that I am part of, I am kind of loath to think of it being finite. I hear that and I can definitely empathize with it.
Starting point is 00:28:16 But I guess the reason I'm not as concerned about it being finite, I mean, there's two things. One is that it's very strange. I mean, we are the only creature probably on Earth and indeed in the known universe that is finite and can conceive of infinity in a meaningful way and can even kind of describe infinities and describe the strangest thing of all, which is that there are different sizes of infinities and so on. Yeah, and just being aware.
Starting point is 00:28:42 Just being able to think of the infinite from within a finite space is a very strange and to me lovely thing. And I guess I don't need it to last forever as long as we can conceive of forever. I certainly don't need it to last forever. Well, good, because it ain't gonna. Yeah, I'm comfortable with that. But there's just something,
Starting point is 00:29:04 I think the universe is better with life in it than without. Yeah, there is something sad about thinking about the universe itself dying, much more sad than thinking about any of us dying or thinking about even humans dying. Right, yeah. It's not just that the universe, is better with life on it, right? Like, Earth is so much better with life on it. Earth is so
Starting point is 00:29:22 blisteringly, stunningly, constantly alive. It's the overwhelming, like, process that Earth is undergoing all the time. And it is strange to think about that being a chemical signature inside of a dying star. Yeah. Yeah. We have, like, a word for when individual things die, and we have a word for when a species dies. Yeah. But like the idea of like the whole system dying. Yeah. Like that's that's the big one.
Starting point is 00:29:51 And like it may have happened on Mars, you know? Like we like our solar system may have already seen that thing. It seems likely that it happened on Mars, albeit in a less dramatic way, maybe. Yeah, I'm not ready to give likelihoodnesses to it. Maybe I am. I don't know. It's exciting. It's exciting times.
Starting point is 00:30:09 It's pretty exciting. This is an interesting thing to me. I've gotten some feedback from folks that are just like saying, hey, you know, you're talking about life on Mars and that's great and everything, but that's not really what we're interested in. We're interested in aliens. You know, we're interested in life that like has trombones, you know? So-called complex life. Yeah. Well, it's a different thing. Cultural life, technological life, you know, life that does the things that we do. And what I didn't realize that I would have to kind of make the case for why a set. second system of chemistry, it would be a very big deal. Well, here's the way you made the case to me early on in the podcast that really resonated
Starting point is 00:30:48 with me. You were like, look, either it evolved in exactly the same way with DNA and RNA, which is very interesting and very strange, that it would evolve separately twice with the same chemical structures, or it evolved in some other way, which is very, very strange and exciting. Yeah. Yeah. Or there's a third thing where it could have, if it's Mars, it could have come from Mars to Earth, then we are the same system or from Earth to Mars and we are the same system. Yeah. Which is also really beautiful and exciting. It means we're already a multi-planetary system. Yeah. And also like that it probably isn't difficult, though this would just be kind of an end of one, but it probably isn't difficult for life to travel between planets. Yeah. Strange. Regardless, all three of those possibilities are incredible.
Starting point is 00:31:40 exciting. Yeah. And basically two of them would mean that life is plentiful in the universe. Which is exciting in its own way and also a little terrifying, but encouraging ultimately because it means that we are not alone. Yeah. Well, here's the here's the thing. I mean, there's so many different worries here, but there's there are people who think that it's very, it would be very worrying for life to be common because it would mean that what we are is very uncommon, which means that what we are is probably very fragile. Yeah. Well, I mean, I already knew that. You know what I mean? Well, I actually don't. Like, I'm not, I'm not there. I think that, like, we may be way more resilient than we think. And there's, there's arrows pointing in that direction. But there's arrows pointing in the other direction, too.
Starting point is 00:32:28 I mean, we've had about 80 years maybe where we could cause the extinction of humanity ourselves. Yeah. That's not that long of a run. That's not that big of a sample size to be like, we're good. We did it. We made it. We made it one human lifetime. So I continue to be pretty, pretty worried about our fragility. I think we are a very resilient species. We've proven that over 300,000 years, but this is a very precarious situation. There's no getting around it. And I think to pretend otherwise is to lose a little bit of what's beautiful about it. And also, if we think that it's easy, then it is more likely that we'll suffer the consequences of that, you know? I mean, think about it, there were hundreds of millions of years of dinosaurs where there is no evidence that they meaningfully use technology. Yeah. Hundreds of millions of years.
Starting point is 00:33:21 We've been around for 300,000 years, and for most of that time, we use stone tools. Yeah, look, I actually am getting really interested in the extent to which we overweight the stone tools because they're the ones that stick around. Right, as opposed to wooden tools and stuff. There's wood, there's, there's a huge amount in cordage and textile and fiber and all that stuff that doesn't last. Sure. A lot of innovation goes there. We were very sophisticated, but we did not have nuclear weapons. Well, no, but I think that we were kind of advancing the whole time.
Starting point is 00:33:54 And I think the biggest way we're advancing was communication. So language didn't start like it is now. You know, it was evolution. It had to evolve on its own as well. and possibly along with physiological well definitely along with physiological changes in our bodies and probably physiological changes in our brains so that took time though that work was all done by the time anatomically modern humans showed up we think yeah yeah that was done 300,000 years ago yeah and I agree that we've been advancing the whole time and I used to believe that the rate of
Starting point is 00:34:28 change is changing argument was ludicrous and involved a lot of recency bias I don't think that I've changed that perspective over the last 10 years. I think the rate of change is changing. Maybe you're just getting old. Maybe I'm just getting old. You're just thinking about that rotary telephone you had when you were a kid. I am thinking about that rotary telephone I had when I was a kid for sure. For sure. Well, Hank, we've spent so much time talking about the end of the world. Yes. And thank you, Rachel, for allowing us to indulge our eschatological anxieties. We've spent so much time talking about the end of the world that it is now time to transition to the news from Mars in AFC Wimbledon.
Starting point is 00:35:06 First, can we read this from Wren who says, Dear Hank of John, I understand, Hank has made the hard pivot to balls, but consider longest chains, longest chain of paper clips, longest chain of twist ties, longest chain of zip ties. Each person who visits
Starting point is 00:35:21 gets to add to the chain, or maybe it becomes like a curtain of sorts. Yes, I love this, because it's going to have to go up and down and you can walk through it. Though, I don't know, we've got to make sure that people don't vandalize our chains. Balls are hard to vandalize, whereas chains could maybe be easier. Each addition can be different colors, sizes. People could add more than one if they like. And I'm going to add to that. You got to make a donation to partners in health
Starting point is 00:35:43 to add to the chain. I love it. It's a great idea. It's a really good idea. It's a million dollar idea that also would be a beautiful expression of human compassion and collaboration. Yeah. I don't know, John. Someone should do it. It's not going to be me. I'm not having people over to my house. It's not going to be at my house. No. No, but there's got to be some warehouse somewhere where people can start out and change. Well, you know what Indianapolis has, Hank? A bunch of those rooms. A bunch of them abandoned.
Starting point is 00:36:10 Indianapolis is going to be the world's largest ball of balls. The world's largest chain of chains and the world's largest ball of balls. Visit Indianapolis. Take that hard pivot to balls. All right, John. What's the news from AFC Wimbledon? No, it's terrible, Hank. We knew that this couldn't last.
Starting point is 00:36:32 We knew that AFC Wimbled. amazing start to the season, being in fourth place or whatever, it was totally unsustainable. But also, we dreamt that it wasn't unsustainable. We dream that it could somehow be sustained, as one always does. You know, hope is the thing with feathers that perch is in the soul. Yeah, togetherness. Togetherness.
Starting point is 00:36:49 We believed that through togetherness, this was possible that we would continue on the rocket ship that only went up. But it turns out the rocket ship also comes down. and AFC Wimbledon just lost to the worst team in league one five to nothing. What? What happened? If anything, that scoreline flattered us. We played like the worst team in league one. You guys lost your togetherness.
Starting point is 00:37:19 We lost our togetherness in a big way. Now, some would say it's because we had a couple injuries. Miles Hippolytes, been out of the squad. Of course, up front, Maddie Stevens is injured. He scores most of our goals. but moo, boy, we look bad. We looked awful. We also lost to 21st place, Burton Albion,
Starting point is 00:37:38 which is not a great sign either. But it's still early in the season. The Wombles are still in eighth place, and hope is the thing with feathers. So we continue to believe that things can turn around. Yeah, you're only three points out of first place, John. That's true. After all this, we're only three points out of first place.
Starting point is 00:37:56 We are, however, out of the FAA Cup because we lost to a team in the fifth division. So there's that as well. I will say everybody lost their last game, everybody in the top of the table. It's true. It's a very strange season in League One where like the top of the table and the bottom of the table are not separated by as many points as we're used to. Yeah. Which is good in the sense that Wimbledon has a chance, but it's bad in the sense that Wimbledon isn't actually that far away from relegation.
Starting point is 00:38:22 Yeah, yeah, yeah. You could be in seventh place and still be quite close to 20th place. Exactly. Exactly, exactly. So, nervy times, but we persevere. How's Mars? Mars also had a little bit of a hiccup. So we talked recently about the Escapade mission, and it was going to launch.
Starting point is 00:38:39 It was going to launch. Yep. This is going to date the podcast. You'll see how long, I don't know exactly how long it takes between when we record and when they go live anymore. But if you were able to catch some northern lights recently, that was because the sun went kind of nutty and gave us a big burp. And that big burp was such a big burp that they were not able to launch when they wanted to. Wow. Yeah.
Starting point is 00:39:05 The sun got in our way. The sun was shooting out too much energy for it to be a safe time to put that boy up into the air. And that's great for us here in Montana. We've had some great auroras just last night. Honestly, I was looking at arroars. But that launch has been delayed because of that solar activity. and interestingly, part of the Escapade mission is to see how solar wind and other space weather it might have affected Mars.
Starting point is 00:39:34 So the sun's like, no, I don't want you to know my secrets, trying to keep us here on Earth. But this is a concern because every chance you miss increases the chance that you'll actually miss this whole launch window. Right. And if you miss the launch window, it's like a year and a half, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you have to wait until Mars and Earth get close together again. Right.
Starting point is 00:39:57 Which only happens every once in a while. Okay. So how worried should we be? How likely is it that it'll still happen? I don't know. I don't know. I think that we're okay right now. Okay.
Starting point is 00:40:06 I think as long as there's like no technical problems or no, you know, if the sun needs to chill out. But usually it does. I've been saying that about the sun. Like, first off, stop trying to eat Earth. I actually, I would love to. You're bumming out, Rachel. To get into this. But there is some thinking, there's quite a bit of evidence pointing this way, that the sun is
Starting point is 00:40:30 exceptionally chill. Oh, yeah. No, I have heard that before. As far as stars go, the sun is less violent than many stars. Which is another thing that's like, maybe our solar system's just like real good for life. Well, I mean, I would argue that it's definitely real good for life, but maybe it's like borderline uniquely good. I would, I only say borderline because one of the things I learned from Katie is that two
Starting point is 00:40:54 275 million stars are going to die today. That's how big the universe is. Yes, that's how big the universe is. Yeah. It's a big old, it's a big old wacky universe. It's a big old wacky universe. Hank, thank you for potting with me. Thanks to everybody for listening.
Starting point is 00:41:14 We always appreciate your questions. You can email them to us at Hank and John at gmail.com. This podcast is edited by Ben Svordout. It's mixed by Joseph Tuna Meddish. coordinator is Brooke Shotwell. It's produced by Rosiana Hals Rojas and Hannah West. Our executive producer is Seth Radley. Our editorial assistant is to Boki Chuck Rivardi. The music you're hearing now and at the beginning of the podcast is by the great Gunnarola. And as they say in our hometown, don't forget to be awesome.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.