Disturbing History - Warren Harding: Corpse Of An Administration

Episode Date: June 3, 2026

The nation wept for Warren G. Harding in August 1923. The funeral train crawled home through crowds that stretched for miles, mourners singing hymns by the tracks, certain they were burying one of the... most beloved men ever to hold the office. They had no idea what they were really putting in the ground. Within a year, the floorboards of that respectable house started to creak, and the bodies that had been piling up around the president began to make sense.This episode walks you back into the White House and down into the rot. We start with Harding's sudden death in a San Francisco hotel room, the autopsy his widow refused, and the papers she burned in the fireplace afterward. From there we meet the Ohio Gang, the cronies who understood that the presidency could be sold off one favor at a time out of a little green house on K Street. We sit with the wounded men of the Great War, gassed and shaking in their hospital beds, while Charles Forbes turned their bandages and their medicine into bribe money and bled the Veterans Bureau of more than $200 million.And we follow the oil. Teapot Dome is famous in name, but the truth is dirtier than the half-memory: a broke Interior secretary named Albert Fall, the strategic oil reserves of the U.S. Navy handed in secret to two billionaires, $100,000 delivered in a black bag, a herd of cattle, and a Senate investigator from Montana who would not let it go.What ties it together is not the money.It's the man at the top. Harding wasn't evil. He was kind, generous, and weak in the one place a leader can't afford to be, and he filled the chairs that controlled oil and veterans and justice itself with the friends who flattered him instead of the men who would have made him better.He told a friend once that his enemies never gave him any trouble. It was his friends who kept him pacing the floor at night. He died before he had to watch them dragged out of his house, and he got the easiest exit of anyone in this story. The administration he left behind died slower, and uglier, exposed piece by piece long after he was in his grave.Have a forgotten historical mystery, disturbing event, unsolved crime, or hidden conspiracy you think deserves investigation?Send your suggestions to brian@paranormalworldproductions.com.Disturbing History is a dark history podcast exploring unsolved mysteries, secret societies, historical conspiracies, lost civilizations, and the shadowy stories buried beneath the surface of the past.Follow the show and enable automatic downloads so you never miss a deep dive into history’s most unsettling secrets.Because sometimes the truth is darker than fiction.

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 Some stories were never meant to be told. Others were buried on purpose. This podcast digs them all up. Disturbing history peels back the layers of the past to uncover the strange, the sinister, and the stories that were never supposed to survive. From shadowy presidential secrets to government experiments that sound more like fiction than fact, this is history they hoped you'd forget. I'm Brian, investigator, author, and your guide through the dark corner.
Starting point is 00:00:30 of our collective memory. Each week I'll narrate some of the most chilling and little-known tales from history that will make you question everything you thought you knew. And here's the twist. Sometimes, the history is disturbing to us. And sometimes, we have to disturb history itself,
Starting point is 00:00:47 just to get to the truth. If you like your facts with the side of fear, if you're not afraid to pull at threads, others leave alone. You're in the right place. History isn't just written by the victors. victors. Sometimes it's rewritten by the disturbed. Welcome back. I'm glad to see you made it through security, which is more than I can say for the last three people who tried. The Secret
Starting point is 00:01:21 Service agent out front gave you a long look, checked your name against a list that may or may not exist, and waved you through. Last time we were together, we were out in the Georgia woods, picking through the wreckage of Corpsewood Manor. Tonight, we're somewhere else. Tonight we've come back to and we're standing in the White House, and I want you to notice something while your eyes adjust to the light. This building is beautiful. The chandeliers, the portraits, the long carpets that swallow the sound of your shoes. It's the most respectable address in America. And respectable addresses are exactly where the worst things happen, because respectability is the best disguise a crime ever wore. So let me set the scene for you, because the scene is the whole story. It's the early 19-19-year.
Starting point is 00:02:09 The Great War is over. The boys came home, or most of them did, and the country is exhausted in the particular way a country gets exhausted after it has asked too much of its people for too long. People want to stop. They want their porches and their paychecks and their Sunday afternoons. Into that mood walks a tall, handsome, silver-haired man from Ohio with a warm handshake and a voice like a Sunday sermon, and he promises them the one thing they want more
Starting point is 00:02:37 than anything. He promises them normal. His name is Warren Gamaliel Harding. He will become the 29th president of the United States. He will be, by most accounts, a kind man, a generous man, a man who genuinely liked people and wanted them to like him back, and he will preside over what historians still rank among the most corrupt administrations in the history of this country. But here's the thing. He won't live to see most of it come out. He'll die first. He'll die suddenly, far from home, with no autopsy and a grieving widow burning his papers in the fireplace. And only after they put him in the ground will the floorboards of this respectable house start to creak. And the bodies start to surface. And the country start to understand what its beloved president had been sitting on top of the whole time. Let's start at the
Starting point is 00:03:29 end, the way all the best dark stories do. It's the summer of 1923, and Warren Harder, is tired. Not the ordinary tired of a man with a hard job. Something deeper, something that follows him from room to room. The presidency has worn grooves in him. He's been hearing whispers. The kind a man hears when he's surrounded by friends who used to be loyal and have lately gone quiet. He started to suspect in that sick, gut-level way, that some of the people closest to him have been doing terrible things in his name. So he does what a tired man does. He puts a tired man does. He plans a trip. He calls it the voyage of understanding. The idea is simple and a little sad. He'll cross the country by train, shaking hands, giving speeches, reminding the people who he is,
Starting point is 00:04:17 and reminding himself why he wanted the job. And he'll go all the way to Alaska, the first sitting president ever to set foot in the territory. New scenery, cold, clean air, distance from Washington and from the men in Washington who keep needing things from him. The trip starts in June. He heads west, and the further he gets from the Capitol, the worse he seems to feel. People who travel with him notice it. He's distracted. He plays cards late into the night, hand after hand, because card games keep the silence away.
Starting point is 00:04:50 And silence is the one thing Warren Harding can't stand right now. Somewhere on that journey, according to the man who would later become president himself, Harding turned to his secretary of commerce, Herbert Hoover, and asked him a question that should never come out of a president's mouth. He asked Hoover what a man should do if he discovered that his friends had betrayed him. Should he expose them for the good of the country, or protect them and stay quiet? Hoover told him to expose it. Publish everything.
Starting point is 00:05:19 Take the credit for honesty. Harding didn't answer. He just looked sick and changed the subject, and that was the end of it. Whatever he knew, he carried it back into his cabin and shut the door on it. Alaska did him some good for a few days. It was a genuine milestone. The first time a sitting president had ever traveled there, and the territory turned out for him.
Starting point is 00:05:41 And for a little while, the clean, cold air and the unfamiliar landscape seemed to lift him out of himself. He gave speeches. He shook the usual hands. He stood at the edge of the country and looked out at a frontier almost nobody back in Washington had ever seen. But the relief didn't hold. Even up there, telegrams kept catching.
Starting point is 00:06:02 up with him. Dispatches from the Capitol, and the people closest to him said that one of those messages, the contents of which nobody ever fully learned, seemed to hit him hard. Whatever it said, it knocks something out of him. He came back down from Alaska a more haunted man than the one who'd gone up. Then the trip turned south, down through Canada, where he became the first president to set foot on Canadian soil as well, and on into Vancouver and Seattle, and that's where his body started to give out in earnest. There's an old story that he ate some bad seafood, crab maybe, and got food poisoning. Historians have argued about that story for a century, and most of them don't buy it anymore.
Starting point is 00:06:43 What's clear is that by the time the train rolled into San Francisco, the president of the United States was a very sick man being half carried into a hotel. The hotel was the palace, one of the grand ones, all marble and brass. They put him in a suite and called in the doctors, and here's where it gets interesting. because the doctors couldn't agree on what was wrong with him. His personal physician was a man named Charles Sawyer, a homeopath from back home in Ohio. A small fellow the president had personally made a brigadier general. Sawyer thought one thing.
Starting point is 00:07:17 The real specialists they brought in, including the president of Stanford, thought another. They talked about his heart. They talked about his lungs. They gave him things to settle his stomach and things to ease his breathing. And for a couple of days, it looked like he might pull through. On the evening of August 2nd, 1923, Florence Harding was sitting at his bedside reading to him from a magazine, an article of all things that flattered her husband. He liked it. He told her to keep reading.
Starting point is 00:07:46 That's good, he said. Go on. Read some more. Those were close to the last words he ever spoke. A few minutes later, his face changed. His body shuddered, and he was gone. Just like that. A massive heart attack, almost certainly, though we'll never know for certain. And the reason we'll never know for certain is the detail I want you to hold on to. There was no autopsy. Florence Harding refused one. Flatly. Completely refused.
Starting point is 00:08:17 The most powerful man in the country drops dead in a hotel room at the age of 57. And his widow says no. You will not open him up. You will not look inside. You will put him in a box and you will take him home. And the doctors who worked for the family did exactly that. They embalmed him fast and they sealed the casket, and the body of Warren Harding rolled east on a black draped train
Starting point is 00:08:40 before most of the country even knew he was dead. Now, I want to be honest with you, because this show doesn't traffic in cheap conspiracy. There is no good evidence that Warren Harding was murdered. The most likely truth is the plainest one. He was overweight. He had a bad heart. He'd ignored chest pains for years.
Starting point is 00:08:59 and the stress of what he knew was probably squeezing that heart like a fist. He died the way a lot of stressed, heavy, frightened, middle-aged men died in 1923. But you put it all together, and you can see why the rumors started. A president who confided that his friends had betrayed him. A sudden death far from home. A wife who wouldn't allow an autopsy. And then, in the weeks and months that followed, that same wife sitting at the White House fireplace,
Starting point is 00:09:27 feeding stacks of her husband's private papers into the flames. She said she was protecting his memory. Maybe she was. But you don't burn a man's papers to protect his memory unless those papers could hurt it. A few years later, a con man named Gaston Means would write a book claiming Florence Harding poisoned her husband to spare him the humiliation of the scandals that were coming.
Starting point is 00:09:51 The book sold like crazy. It was also almost entirely invented by a professional liar who'd already been to prison, and serious historians threw it in the trash where it belonged. But it tells you something about the atmosphere, doesn't it? Within a few years of Harding's death, a story about the first lady murdering the president of the United States was plausible enough to be a bestseller. And here's why people were so willing to believe the worst of Florence Harding, instead of seeing a grieving widow.
Starting point is 00:10:20 Florence was not a soft woman, and she was nobody's fool. She was older than Warren, sharp, and far more ambitious than Warren ever was. People around them called her the Duchess, and they didn't always mean it kindly. It was Florence who had taken her husband's struggling little newspaper and helped drive it into a real business, writing the paper boys and the books, while he charmed the advertisers. It was Florence who pushed him into politics when he'd have been content to stay home. Florence who managed his image. Florence, who is sometimes said to have wanted the presidency more than the man who held it. So when he did, he did he,
Starting point is 00:10:56 died and she immediately blocked the autopsy and started burning the papers. People who'd watched her run his life for 30 years, found it very easy to imagine her arranging his death too. They were almost certainly wrong. But the suspicion grew in soil she'd tilled herself. There's one more piece to the Florence story, and it's the kind of detail that belongs in a place this dark. Years before, while Warren was still just a senator, Florence had quietly gone to see a fortune teller in Washington, an astrologer who read the stars and the cards for the city's powerful. The woman studied Warren Harding's chart and gave Florence a prophecy in two parts.
Starting point is 00:11:36 The first part was glory. She said Harding would rise higher than anyone expected, all the way to the White House. And the second part was a death sentence. She said that once he got there, he would not come out alive. He would die suddenly, in office. before his time. Florence heard both halves. She pushed him toward the presidency anyway. Make of that what you will. She was warned her husband would die in that office, and she helped put him in it regardless. And then she sat at the fireplace afterward and burned whatever it was she didn't want the
Starting point is 00:12:09 rest of us to read. For about three weeks, Warren Harding was one of the most beloved figures in American history. When that funeral train crossed the country, people came out to the tracks by the hundreds of thousands. They stood in fields and on station platforms in the August heat. Hats off, heads down, and they sang hymns as the cars rolled past. Children were lifted up to sea. Mother's wept. It was the largest outpouring of public grief the nation had seen since they brought Abraham Lincoln home almost 60 years before. They held the formal services in Washington, in the east room of the White House and then at the Capitol, with the new president and the cabinet and the whole machinery of government standing at attention over the casket.
Starting point is 00:12:53 Then the train carried him the last leg home, back to Marion, Ohio, the little town where he'd run his newspaper and courted his wife and sat on that front porch, promising the country a return to normal. They buried him there while the town he came from wept in the streets. Everybody who stood at that graveside in the summer of 1923 believed they were laying a great and beloved man to rest. Not one of them knew they were also closing the lid on the worst kept secret in American politics, a secret that hadn't even finished being kept yet. And the man they were grieving was, in a lot of ways, exactly the kind of man you'd want to grieve. Warren Harding was genuinely likable. He remembered names. He asked after your family and
Starting point is 00:13:38 met it. He'd grown up in small town, Ohio, in Marion, where he bought a struggling newspaper called The Marion Star and built it into something successful through plain hard work and an easy way with people. He liked golf and poker and a good drink, even though he was the one who was supposed to be enforcing prohibition. He liked the company of women, which we'll come back to, and he liked the company of his friends, which is the part that's going to get him killed in the history books. He had this wonderful, ridiculous way with words. He loved the old Ohio term Bloviate, which he'd picked up in his youth and which to him just meant to loaf around and gab about nothing in particular. He didn't coin it, though he often gets the credit. He used it so much and gave
Starting point is 00:14:23 such long, windy speeches that the word ended up fused to his name, until Bloviate came to mean exactly the kind of grand and empty talking he was famous for. His speeches were famous for sounding magnificent and meaning almost nothing. One critic said his sentences reminded him of a bunch of pompous phrases marching across the landscape in search of an idea. And Harding knew it. He once admitted to a friend that he wasn't fit for the office, that he was a man of limited talents from a small town, and that he didn't know what to do about it. Stay tuned for more disturbing history. We'll be back after these messages. So how does a man like that become president? Here's where you need to picture the room, because the room is the thing. The summer of 1920,
Starting point is 00:15:12 the Republican Convention in Chicago. The party is deadlocked. The leading candidates have beaten each other bloody and nobody can get the votes. And so, late at night, in a suite at the Blackstone Hotel, a small group of party bosses gathers to solve the problem
Starting point is 00:15:28 the way party bosses always solve the problem. Behind closed doors, over cigars, in a haze of smoke so thick you could lose your hand in it. That's where the phrase comes from, by the way. The smoke-filled room. It was born that night in that hotel about this man. The bosses needed a candidate who was inoffensive, who looked the part, who'd go along to get along, and who came from a state they needed.
Starting point is 00:15:56 Warren Harding checked every box. He looked like a president. Central casting couldn't have done better. Tall, dignified, silver hair, a voice that carried. The bosses picked him not because he was the best man in the party, but because he was the most agreeable. the easiest to manage, the least likely to cause anybody trouble. And that, right there, is the seed of everything that follows. The country didn't elect a leader in 1920.
Starting point is 00:16:24 It elected a face. A reassuring, handsome, handshaking face, attached to a man who knew in his own heart that he wasn't up to it, and who responded to that fear the way a lot of insecure men do. He surrounded himself with people who made him feel safe, old friends. loyal cronies, men from back home who'd known him when, men who told him he was doing great. The campaign itself was almost a comedy of low ambition. Harding's people were terrified of letting him out on the road to give too many speeches, because the more he talked, the more chances there were for him to say something foolish. So they had him stay home. He ran what they called a front
Starting point is 00:17:04 porch campaign, literally sitting on the porch of his house in Marion, Ohio, while supporters and reporters and delegations of voters came to him. They'd gather on the lawn and he'd come out and say warm, vague, comforting things about peace and prosperity and getting back to normal. And then everybody would go home feeling good. It worked beautifully. In the fall of 1920, the country handed him one of the largest landslide victories in the history of presidential elections. They didn't just elect him. They buried his opponent under him. The man who knew in his heart he wasn't fit for the job won it by the biggest margin anybody had ever seen. To be fair to Warren Harding, he wasn't a fool about everything.
Starting point is 00:17:47 When it came time to build his government, he actually made some genuinely first-rate choices. He put Charles Evans Hughes, a brilliant former Supreme Court Justice, in charge of the State Department. He put Andrew Mellon, one of the richest and most capable financiers in the country, in charge of the Treasury. He put Herbert Hoover, the famous engineer and humanitarian, who would one day, be president himself in charge of commerce. These were strong, serious, accomplished men, and on the days Harding listened to them, his administration did real and competent work. Here's the thing that should bother you, though, and it's the key to the whole tragedy. Harding had said during the campaign that he'd surround himself with the best minds in the country,
Starting point is 00:18:31 and in some chairs, he did. But in the chairs that mattered most for what we're talking about tonight, the chairs that controlled oil and veterans and the machinery of justice itself. He didn't reach for the best minds at all. He reached for the most familiar faces. He gave the Interior Department to his poker buddy from the Senate. He gave the Veterans Bureau to a charming man he'd met on a vacation. He gave the entire Justice Department to the political fixer who'd gotten him elected. The same man who could recognize talent when it came to Treasury and State
Starting point is 00:19:04 went completely blind when it came to the friends who flattered him. And that selective blindness is exactly the gap his predators climbed through. There's a line about Harding that a famous newspaper man named William Allen White claimed the president once said, and whether the words are exact or polished a little in the retelling, they capture the man perfectly. Harding supposedly told him that his enemies gave him no trouble at all. He could take care of his enemies. It was his friends, his own friends, who kept him pacing the floor at night.
Starting point is 00:19:36 He knew. On some level, this kind, weak, trusting man knew exactly what kind of people he'd let in close. And the knowing kept him awake, and he still couldn't bring himself to throw them out. They had a name those men. The papers gave it to them later, after the smoke cleared and the bodies turned up. They called them the Ohio gang. I want you to throw out the cartoon. When you hear gang, your brain probably pulls up Tommy guns and pinstripe suits.
Starting point is 00:20:05 That's not these men. These men went to church, shook your hand, and called you by your first name. The Ohio gang didn't rob banks. They did something smarter, and in its way, much worse. They figured out that the federal government is the biggest pile of money and favors in the world, and that if you control the right offices, you can sell access to that pile one piece at a time. They turned the presidency into a franchise, and the man at the top of the franchise was Harding's oldest political friend and his Attorney General, Harry Daugherty.
Starting point is 00:20:38 Dardy was a lawyer and a political operator from Ohio, a backroom man, a fixer, the guy who knew where everybody was buried because half the time he'd helped dig the hole. He's the one who'd spotted Harding years before and decided, more or less single-handedly, that this handsome nobody could be made into a president. He managed the campaign.
Starting point is 00:21:01 He worked the bosses in that smoke-filled room. He delivered Harding to the White House. And when they got there, Harding rewarded him by making him Attorney General of the United States, the top law enforcement officer in the entire country. The man who'd spent his career fixing things in back rooms was now in charge of the federal government's entire machinery for catching people who fix things in back rooms. It's like hiring a cat burglar to run the locksmith's union. Dardy himself was never personally convicted of anything, and I want to be fair to the historical record.
Starting point is 00:21:33 He went to trial twice and beat the rap both times, with juries that couldn't reach a verdict. But the men around him, the men who used his name and worked out of his orbit, those men did not get off so easy, and the most important of them was a soft, nervous, devoted man named Jess Smith. Jess Smith was Dardy's shadow. They were so close they shared an apartment in Washington. Smith had no official government job, no title, no salary from the people. What he had was access. He had the Attorney General's ear and the Attorney General's trust,
Starting point is 00:22:10 and he set himself up as the man you went to see if you needed something from the federal government and weren't too particular about how you got it. You want a permit to pull medicinal liquor out of a government warehouse during prohibition? There were millions of dollars of bonded whiskey sitting in those warehouses, and the right paperwork could turn it into cash. Jess Smith could help with the paperwork for a price. You're a criminal who'd like the Justice Department to lose interest in your case? Jess Smith might be able to put in a word.
Starting point is 00:22:40 You want a pardon, an appointment, a contract, a problem to go away. There was a price for that, too. The gang ran their operation out of a couple of houses, and one of them has become legendary. A little greenhouse on K Street. That's where the deals got done, where the liquor flowed even though liquor was illegal, where the poker games ran late and the money changed hands and the air filled up with smoke and quiet conversations about who could get whom, what. It was a marketplace, plain and simple, except the thing for sale was the United States government, sold off a
Starting point is 00:23:15 piece at a time by men who treated the public trust like inventory. Prohibition was the gift that kept on giving for these men, and the hypocrisy of it is thick enough to cut. Remember the times. Liquor was illegal across the entire country. The 18th Amendment had shut the bars and dried out the saloons, at least on paper. And Warren Harding's own party was the party of the dries, the moral crusaders who'd made it happen. Harding had voted for prohibition as a senator. He was officially the chief enforcer of a dry America. And in private, the man kept a well-stocked supply of bootleg liquor upstairs in the White House and poured it freely for his poker friends, who'd gather around the table in a fog of cigar smoke with the whiskey flowing. The president of
Starting point is 00:24:03 the United States breaking the very law he'd sworn to uphold in the people's house with the men who were robbing the people blind. One of Washington's sharpest observers said the air up there was blue with smoke and the trays were loaded with bottles. So much for normal. But the real money and prohibition wasn't the drinking. It was the permits. The government kept enormous stockpiles of legal liquor locked in bonded warehouses, whiskey that could be withdrawn for so-called medicinal and industrial purposes if you had the right paperwork. A permit to pull that liquor out was a license to print money because you could turn around and sell it on the black market for a fortune. And who decided who got those permits? Men in the orbit of the Justice Department. Men like
Starting point is 00:24:49 Jess Smith. The Ohio gang didn't need to bootleg the liquor themselves. They just sold the keys to the warehouse and let other people do the dirty work. Bootleggers needing protection. Distillers needing permits. Criminals needing the Justice Department to look the other way. All of it flowed through that greenhouse. All of it had a price. And the man whose name made the protection worth buying was the nation's top law enforcement officer, sitting in the cabinet, sworn to enforce the law he was quietly auctioning off. And here's the genius and the horror of it. Most of what they did was almost invisible. There's no dramatic moment, no smoking gun on the floor of the Senate. It was a thousand small betrayals, a thousand quiet handshakes, a slow, steady draining of public money and public faith into private pockets.
Starting point is 00:25:39 Harding, the man whose name made all of it possible, the man whose trust they were spending like a credit card, mostly had no idea, or didn't let himself know. He was off playing golf, playing poker, being beloved, while the men he'd given real power to turned his administration into a money laundering operation. When the gang finally got dragged into the light, it was a woman who lit the match. After Harding died and the Senate started digging, the investigators called a witness named Roxy Stinson, who had been married to Jess Smith, the dead fixer. Roxy Stinson knew where the greenhouse bodies were buried, because she'd been close to the man who buried them, and she sat down in front of the Senate and started talking. She described the deals, the money, the favors changing hands, the whole machinery of
Starting point is 00:26:28 the operation. Her testimony turned a pile of rumors into a public spectacle, and it put Harry Daugherty, the Attorney General himself, squarely under the lights. The case that nearly got Doherty involved something called the American Metal Company. During the war, the government had seized a fortune in property belonging to a German-linked company, and after the war, somebody wanted that property released and the money handed over. A man with a claim on it paid out around $400,000 in bribes to get the right strings pulled, and a good chunk of that money seemed to wash through the hands of Jess Smith and the people around D'arty. When investigators came looking for the paper trail, they found a problem.
Starting point is 00:27:10 Doherty's own brother ran a bank back in Ohio, and the relevant ledgers and account records from that bank had been destroyed, burned, gone. The very documents that might have shown exactly where the money went had conveniently turned to Ash. Doherty was put on trial twice for his part in defrauding the government, and both times the jury hung, unable to agree, and he walked away a free man. He beat it partly by refusing to take the stand in his own defense, and the reason he gave for refusing is one of the great cold-blooded moves in the history of American scandal.
Starting point is 00:27:46 He claimed he couldn't testify because doing so might require him to reveal confidential matters concerning his dead friend, President Harding. He wrapped himself in the corpse of the man he'd helped ruin and used it as a shield. He survived the trials. He did not survive the new president. Calvin Coolidge, who had stepped into the office when Harding died, had no patience for the stink coming off the Justice Department, and in 1924, he forced Harry Dardy out. The man who'd made a president and then helped rot a presidency,
Starting point is 00:28:18 was finally shown the door, never convicted, never quite cleared, just gone. But the Ohio gang and their liquor permits, the bootleg favors, the small graft, that's the appetizer. Because two of the men in Harding Circle weren't content with selling whiskey permits out of a greenhouse. Two of them aimed much, much higher. One of them went after the most vulnerable people in the entire country. And the other went after the ground itself. I need you to remember who came home from the Great War. A whole generation of young American men went to France between 1917 and 1917,
Starting point is 00:28:53 and 1918, and a lot of them came back broken. Not just the obvious ways, the missing legs and the burned faces, though there were plenty of those. This was the first great war of poison gas and high explosives and machine guns. Men came home with their lungs scarred from mustard gas, coughing up pieces of themselves for the rest of their lives. They came home shaking, sleepless, screaming in the night from what they'd seen in the trenches,
Starting point is 00:29:20 from what we'd later learned to call by its right name and what they called back then shell shock. They came home blind and limbless and ruined, hundreds of thousands of them, and a grateful nation made them a promise. The promise was simple. You gave your body for us. We'll take care of you. We'll build you hospitals. We'll give you medicine, beds, doctors, a pension, a chance to heal.
Starting point is 00:29:47 The country created a brand new agency to keep that promise. and they called it the Veterans Bureau, and they put a vast amount of money behind it, hundreds of millions of dollars, one of the biggest pools of cash in the entire federal government. Stay tuned for more disturbing history. We'll be back after these messages. And Warren Harding, in his easy, generous way,
Starting point is 00:30:11 handed control of that money and that promise to a charming fellow he'd met on vacation in Hawaii. A man named Charles Forbes. Forbes was good company. That's the thing that keeps coming up. He was likable, energetic, a great talker, the kind of man who lights up a room and makes everybody feel like the most important person in it. Harding met him, liked him, and decided he was just the man to run the Veterans Bureau. There was no real vetting. There was a handshake
Starting point is 00:30:40 and a feeling. That was how this president made decisions about the lives of disabled soldiers. And here's what Charles Forbes did with the bodies of wounded men. He stole from them. He and the men around him bled the bureau on a scale that's genuinely hard to wrap your mind around. By the time a Senate investigation finished counting, more than $200 million had been looted, wasted, or stolen out of an agency built to heal soldiers. And remember, this is 1920's money, so multiply it in your head by a frightening number. He did it in two main ways, and both of them turned my stomach a little more every time I lay them out. The first scheme was the hospitals. The country, The country wanted to build hospitals for these veterans, good ones, all across the nation,
Starting point is 00:31:26 and Forbes was in charge of the contracts to build them. So Forbes did what corrupt officials do with a pile of construction money. He took kickbacks. He'd steer the contracts to favored builders. The builders would pad the prices. The government would overpay by a fortune. And Forbes would get his cut quietly under the table. He even managed to get personal money flowing back to himself out of land deals,
Starting point is 00:31:50 choosing hospital sites not because they were good for sick men, but because somebody was paying him to choose them. So the hospitals cost far more than they should have, got built slower than they should have, and in some cases got built in the wrong places. Also, a few men could skim the cream. Every dollar that stuck to Charles Forbes's fingers was a dollar that didn't go into a bed, a bandage, a doctor's salary, a place for a gassed and shaking young man to lie down and try to get well. But the second scheme is the one that should make you genuinely angry, because the second scheme wasn't just greedy. It was cruel. The government had warehouses full of medical supplies left over from the war.
Starting point is 00:32:32 Sheets, towels, gauze, bandages, soap, drugs, surgical supplies, brand new and stockpiled in places like a depot in Perryville, Maryland. These were exactly the supplies the veterans' hospitals needed. This was the inventory. This was the stuff you'd put on the... beds and over the wounds. Forbes sold it. He declared it surplus junk, worthless, and he sold mountains of it off to private companies at pennies on the dollar. Bed sheets that had cost the government over a dollar each went out the door for a few cents, and he didn't do it for the government's benefit. He did it because he was getting paid on the side to do it. He was getting
Starting point is 00:33:11 a kickback to dump the veteran's own supplies for almost nothing. And here's the part that turns it from theft into something closer to a sick joke at a wounded man's expense. While he was selling off the existing supplies for pennies, the Veterans Bureau was turning right around and buying the same kinds of supplies new, at full price, sometimes from the very same people who just bought the cheap ones. So the taxpayers got robbed twice. Once when the good supplies went out cheap, and again, when replacement supplies came back expensive.
Starting point is 00:33:44 And in the gap between those two transactions, in the time it took to empty one warehouse and refill another. There were sick veterans in those hospitals who didn't have what they needed because the man in charge of caring for them had sold their care out from under them for a cut of the action. That's the moral center of this whole episode, and I don't want you to lose it under the more famous scandal we're about to get to. Corruption is not an abstraction. It is not just money sliding from one rich man's account to another.
Starting point is 00:34:13 Corruption has a body. In this case, the body below. to a 25-year-old kid from Indiana, who came home from the Argon Forest with one lung working and a tremor in his hands, and who lay in an underfunded, overpriced, undersupplied hospital ward because the man Washington had trusted to look after him, was busy turning his bandages into bribe money. It started to come apart in early 1923. People inside the government noticed the supply sales, noticed the warehouses emptying out at fire sale prices, and started asking questions. Word reached the president, and for one brief moment the kind, weak Warren Harding
Starting point is 00:34:51 showed a flash of something harder. There's a story, and it's a good one, about Harding finding out. Supposedly he summoned Forbes to the White House, and a visitor walked in on the president of the United States with his hands around Charles Forbes's throat, shaking him like a rat, shouting, you double-crossing bastard, or words a lot like it. Whether the details are exactly right. The core of it is true. Harding confronted Forbes was sickened by what he'd learned and gave the man a chance to slip away quietly. Forbes resigned and got himself across the ocean to Europe before the worst of it broke. It didn't save him. The Senate launched an investigation, the kind of slow, grinding, sworn testimony investigation that turns over every rock,
Starting point is 00:35:39 and under the rocks, the bodies started to turn up, literally. The Veterans Bureau had a lawyer, the agency's general counsel, a man named Charles Kramer. Kramer was tangled up in all of it, knew where things were buried, and as the investigation closed in, he couldn't take it. In March of 1923, Charles Kramer went into the bathroom of his Washington home and shot himself in the head. And here's a detail that's almost too perfect for a noir story, except it's real. Kramer left a suicide note and he addressed it to the president of the United States. Warren Harding refused to open it. Whatever the dying man wanted him to know,
Starting point is 00:36:18 Harding decided he'd rather not. So the first man to die for the scandals of the Harding administration went out with a last message for the president in his hand, and the president wouldn't even read it, while he was still alive and well in the White House, a short drive away. Forbes came back from Europe to face the music, eventually, because the music followed him across the ocean, and there was no point hiding from it.
Starting point is 00:36:43 A Senate Select Committee hauled the whole operation into the open, witness by witness, and what came out was almost more brazen than it was secret. This wasn't a man hiding his thefts in the margins of a ledger. Forbes had toured the country inspecting hospital sites like a king on progress, throwing lavish parties, traveling with builders and contractors who had business in front of him, picking sites and steering deals while the champagne flowed. When you start adding up the construction graft and the construction graft and the supply giveaway and the general waste, the figure investigators landed on was somewhere around
Starting point is 00:37:18 $200 million run through, lost or stolen out of an agency that existed for one reason, to heal broken soldiers. He was tried, convicted, and sentenced to two years in the federal penitentiary at Leavenworth, plus a fine. He served his time and got out and lived a long, quiet, unremarkable life, which is its own kind of insult when you think about the men whose care he sold. Two years. That was the price in the end for $200 million and a generation of wounded men left waiting for beds that came late and supplies that never came at all. Now, we go after the oil. This is the famous one. This is the scandal whose name everybody half remembers from a history class, the one that became shorthand for government corruption for the next 50 years. Teapot Dome. People know the name the way they know the names of old movies they've never actually. seen. So let me tell you what it actually was, because the truth is stranger and dirtier than the
Starting point is 00:38:19 half memory. It starts, of all places, with the Navy. In the years before the Great War, somebody in the United States government had a smart idea. Warships were switching from coal to oil, which meant that in any future war, the Navy was going to need a guaranteed supply of oil, and it couldn't afford to be at the mercy of private oil companies in an emergency. So the government, set aside several big underground oil fields as strategic naval reserves. Don't pump them now. Leave the oil in the ground, locked away, an insurance policy for the next war. There were three main ones. Two were in California at Elk Hills and Buena Vista, and one was in Wyoming, under a strange rock formation shaped like a teapot, which is why they called the field,
Starting point is 00:39:07 and eventually the whole scandal, teapot dome. Now here's the setup. These reserves, belonged to the Navy. They were under the control of the Navy Department. The oil in the ground was supposed to stay in the ground, in trust, for the country's defense. Enter Albert Fall. Albert Fall was Harding's Secretary of the Interior, and he is the dark heart of this whole story. He was a former senator from New Mexico, a frontier character, a rancher and a lawyer with a big hat and a big mustache and big debts. He owned a spread called Three Rivers Ranch down in New Mexico. And he loved that ranch, and the ranch was in trouble. He hadn't paid his property taxes in years. He was a proud man going broke, watching his land slip away. And that
Starting point is 00:39:54 combination, a proud man and an empty bank account, is the most dangerous combination in any story about money. Fall wanted those oil reserves, not for the country, for himself, or rather for the men who'd pay him to hand them over. And the first thing he had to do was get control of them, which meant prying them loose from the Navy. So in 1921 and into 1922, Fall worked a quiet bureaucratic maneuver. He got the naval oil reserves transferred out of the Navy Department and into his own interior department. He needed the Secretary of the Navy, a man named Edwin Denby, to go along with it. And Denby did, either because he didn't understand what was happening or didn't care enough to stop it. An executive order got signed. The reserves
Starting point is 00:40:41 changed hands. And just like that, the strategic oil insurance policy of the United States Navy was sitting in the desk drawer of a broke rancher who'd already decided to sell it. Then came the deals, and they were done in the dark. Fall leased the Elk Hills Reserve in California to an oil man named Edward Doherne, one of the richest men in America, a wildcatter who'd struck it big and never looked back. And Fall leased the Teapot Dome Reserve in Wyoming to another oil baron, Harry Sinclair. the founder of the Sinclair Oil Empire, the company with the green dinosaur you've probably seen on a gas station sign somewhere. No public auction, no competitive bidding, no newspaper notice.
Starting point is 00:41:24 Two of the most valuable oil fields in the country handed to two private men in secret without the public getting so much as a chance to bid. And in return, the money flowed back to Albert Fall. From Edward Doheny, it came as a loan. $100,000 in cash. No interest, no real paperwork, no note that any honest banker would recognize. Dohaney later said it was just a friendly loan between old friends, and here's the detail that makes it perfect for our show.
Starting point is 00:41:55 The cash was delivered to fall in a little black satchel, a bag carried by Doheny's own son. $100,000 in bills walked over and handed across like a sandwich. When you have to deliver a loan to a cabinet secretary in a black bag carried by your kid, you both already know exactly what kind of loan it is. From Harry Sinclair, it came in a more roundabout way, dressed up to look like business, cash, government bonds, and in a touch I love because it's so specific, a herd of cattle and some breeding stock for that struggling ranch, that Fall loved so much.
Starting point is 00:42:31 Hogs and horses and a fancy bull, on top of a great deal of money. All told, when investigators finally added it up, Albert Fall took in some of the same. something like $400,000 in exchange for handing over the nation's emergency oil. $400,000 in 1920's money to a man who couldn't pay his taxes the year before. And that, friends, was Faw's mistake. Not the bribe itself, the lifestyle. Because here's a rule about corruption that has held true from the Roman Senate to last week's headlines. The crime is usually invisible.
Starting point is 00:43:07 What gets you caught is the spending. Albert Fall could have taken those bribes and quietly stashed them, and maybe nobody would ever have known. Instead, the broke rancher who hadn't paid his taxes in years suddenly paid off all his back taxes, bought the neighboring ranch to expand his spread, stocked it with brand new livestock, and started making improvements like a man who just won the lottery. His neighbors noticed, and one of those neighbors mentioned it to the wrong person, which in this case was the right person. and the question started to travel up the line.
Starting point is 00:43:40 Where did Albert Fall, who was broke last year, suddenly get all this money? It's worth knowing how the thing cracked open in the first place, because it almost didn't. The leases were secret, but secrets that big leak, and this one leaked through the people fall had cut out of the deal. Oilmen out in Wyoming heard that the teapot dome field, which a lot of them had wanted a crack at, had quietly been handed to Harry Sinclair with no bidding and no announcement. They were furious, and they complained to their representatives, and word of the secret arrangements started trickling back to Washington. In the spring of 1922, the Senate passed a resolution demanding to know what on earth had
Starting point is 00:44:20 happened to the naval oil reserves and by whose authority they'd been leased. That resolution is what opened the door. Behind it walked Thomas Walsh. That question of where Fall got his money landed in the lap of that same senator from Montana named Thomas Walsh. and Thomas Walsh was exactly the wrong man for Albert Faw to be standing in front of. Walsh was a grinder, a serious, humorless, relentless lawyer of a senator who got hold of the teapot dome question and would not let it go for two solid years.
Starting point is 00:44:51 He held hearings. He chased paper. He subpoenaed records and dragged oil men in front of the Senate to sweat under oath. Stay tuned for more disturbing history. We'll be back after these messages. For a long time, he got nowhere. because the principals lied and the records were buried, and the whole thing looked like it might just be the rumor-mongering it was accused of being.
Starting point is 00:45:16 And then Walsh found the thread that unraveled it. He found out about that $100,000 from Doheny. He pinned down the spending. He proved, piece by piece, that money had flowed from the oil men to Albert Fall around the same time the oil leases flowed from Albert Fall to the oil men. And once you can show the money and the favor crossing in the night, you don't need a confession. The arrangement speaks for itself.
Starting point is 00:45:42 The hearings became a national sensation. This is the early 1920s, remember, the age of the tabloid and the radio just coming in, and the country sat riveted while the story came out. The strategic oil of the United States Navy sold off in secret, a cabinet secretary on the take, cash in a black bag, it had everything.
Starting point is 00:46:06 The phrase teapot dome, went into the language and stayed there. The damage spread outward from fall like a stain. The Secretary of the Navy, Edwin Denby, the man who'd signed away control of the reserves, came under such heavy fire for letting it happen on his watch that he resigned, even though nobody ever proved he'd taken a dime. He hadn't necessarily been on the take,
Starting point is 00:46:29 but he'd certainly been careless, which in the middle of a scandal that size was close enough to ruin him. And the leases themselves, the whole rotten arrangement, eventually went all the way up to the Supreme Court of the United States. In 1927, the court looked at how those oil fields had been handed over, smelled exactly what it was, and threw the leases out. The justices ruled that the deals had been obtained through fraud and corruption, canceled them outright, and ordered the oil reserves return to the government where they belonged.
Starting point is 00:47:00 So in the end, after all of it, Sinclair and Dohani didn't even get to keep the prize. The country got its oil back. It just had to crawl through years of hearings and trials and one suicide after another to get there. The legal aftermath is where the story turns from outrageous into genuinely absurd, and I have to walk you through it because it tells you something true about how power protects itself. Albert Fall, the man who took the bribes, was put on trial for taking bribes. He was convicted. He became the first member of a presidential cabinet in the history of the United States
Starting point is 00:47:36 to be convicted of a felony committed while in office. He was sentenced to a year in prison and a $100,000 fine, and he went to prison a sick, broken, disgraced old man, and he lost the ranch anyway in the end. The thing he'd sold his honor to save, he lost. Now hold that in your head. Fall was convicted of taking a bribe from Edward Dohaney. Edward Dohaney was then put on trial for giving that same bribe to Albert Fall,
Starting point is 00:48:04 and Edward Doheny was acquitted. The same $100,000 in the same black bag, carried by the same son. The man who received it is a convicted felon. The man who handed it over walks free. A jury looked at the identical transaction from the other side and decided that taking the bribe was a crime, but giving it apparently was not, at least not when the giver was one of the richest men in America
Starting point is 00:48:29 with the finest lawyers money could buy. Harry Sinclair, the other oil baron, also wriggled out of the bribery charge, though he did go to jail for a while, but not for the oil. He went to jail for contempt of the Senate and for hiring detectives to shadow the jurors at his trial. So Sinclair didn't do time for stealing the nation's oil. He did time for getting caught tampering with the people who were supposed to judge him for it. That's teapot don't.
Starting point is 00:48:56 Strip away the funny name and what you've got is a broke government official selling the country's emergency oil supply to two billionaires for cash and a bad. bag and a herd of cattle, getting caught only because he couldn't resist showing off the money, and watching the men who bribed him walk free while he went to prison alone. The little guy who sold out took the fall, which, given his name, the newspapers had a field day with. Let's go back inside the house now and turn the lights down, because I've been telling you these scandals one at a time, neatly, like chapters. That's not how they happened. They happened all at once, on top of each other.
Starting point is 00:49:34 in a single terrible season, and the man at the center of it could feel them closing in, even if he couldn't yet name them. The spring of 1923. Picture it from inside Warren Harding's head, if you can stand it. The Forbes thing has just blown up in his face. He's confronted the man, choked him in his own office by some accounts, and watched him flee to Europe. Charles Kramer, the Veterans Bureau lawyer,
Starting point is 00:49:59 has just put a bullet in his own head and a house Harding used to own. The whispers about Albert Falls' sudden wealth are starting to circulate, and Harding's oldest friend, Harry Dardy, the Attorney General, the man who made him president, is the subject of uglier and uglier talk about what's really going on in the Justice Department and out of that little greenhouse on K Street. And then there's Jess Smith, Dardy's Shadow, the soft, nervous fixer who'd been selling government favors out of the gang's back rooms.
Starting point is 00:50:29 By the spring of 1923, Jess Smith was a frightened man. He'd heard that investigators were starting to circle. He'd heard maybe that he wasn't welcome on the upcoming voyage of understanding, that the president wanted distance from him, that the protection he'd counted on, was being pulled away. For a man whose entire existence was built on access and the president's good graces, that was the ground opening up under his feet. On the 30th of May, 1923, just weeks before Harding left on the trip he wouldn't return from, just Smith was found dead in the apartment he shared with Harry Dorety, a gunshot, his head in a metal waistbasket, a pistol nearby. The official ruling was suicide, and that's most likely what
Starting point is 00:51:14 it was, a terrified man choosing his own exit, before the investigators could choose it for him. But the timing, the closeness to D'ardy, the fact that some of Smith's papers seem to have been gone through before any one official arrived, all of it has kept the question alive for a hundred years. Did Jess Smith kill himself? Or did somebody help him before he could start talking? We don't know. We probably never will. But you can imagine what it did to Warren Harding to learn that a second man in his orbit was dead by gunshot, with scandal closing in, on the eve of his big trip. So now you understand the man who got on that train in June. He wasn't taking a victory lap. He was running. He was a frightened, exhausted, heart-sick president fleeing a city that was filling up with
Starting point is 00:52:01 his friend's secrets and his friend's corpses. And he carried all of it west with him into the long card games and the sleepless nights and that haunted question he put to Herbert Hoover somewhere out on the rails. What do you do when your friends have betrayed you? He never had to answer it. His heart answered it for him in a hotel room in San Francisco on the 2nd of August. And here's the bitter perfect irony at the dead center of this whole story, the thing that makes it worthy of the name, the corpse of an administration. Warren Harding died at the exact right moment to be loved.
Starting point is 00:52:38 He died after the scandals had begun to torment him in private, but before they'd broken in public. The country that mourned him so enormously, the hundreds of thousands weeping along the train tracks, had no idea. They were burying the kind handshake and the silver hair and the promise of normal. They didn't know they were also bearing the head of the most corrupt circle of men ever to run the executive branch.
Starting point is 00:53:02 Within a year, they'd know. Within a year, the Senate hearings would be front page news every day. Teapot Dome and the Veterans Bureau and the Ohio gang all spilling out at once, and the same newspapers that had run the funeral on the front page would be running the indictments. Harding's reputation, which had been sky high in death, fell faster and further than almost any president in history. He went from beloved to a national punchline in the space of about 18 months, and the dark joke of it is that he accomplished this entirely from inside his coffin. He didn't have to do a thing.
Starting point is 00:53:38 His friends did it all for him. The way they'd done everything for him, except this time what they delivered wasn't the presidency. It was the ruin of his name. There's one last image from all this that I can't shake, and it belongs right here. In the years after Harding died, the people of Mary, and admirers around the country raised money for a tomb worthy of a beloved president, an enormous circle of white marble columns, grand and solemn and built to last a thousand years. But it took years to finish, and by the time it was ready, the scandals had all come out.
Starting point is 00:54:13 The beloved man it was built to honor had become the punchline. And so the great marble monument sat there, completed, waiting, while everybody in Washington tried to figure out who could possibly stand to dedicate it, without the whole thing turning into an embarrassment. It sat unused for years. When a president finally did show up to dedicate it, it was Herbert Hoover, years late, standing in front of that gleaming marble,
Starting point is 00:54:39 giving a speech that had to walk a razor's edge. He praised the man while all but admitting out loud that the man had been betrayed and disgraced by the people he trusted. A monument built for a hero, dedicated with an apology. That's the truest headstone Warren Harding ever, ever got. I told you we'd come back to Harding's appetite for the company of women, and we should briefly, because it's part of why his widow stood at that fireplace feeding his papers to the flames, and because it adds one more layer to the strange afterlife of this man.
Starting point is 00:55:12 Long before he was president, Warren Harding carried on a year's long affair with a woman named Carrie Phillips, the wife of a friend and fellow Marion businessman. He wrote her letters, lots of them. Long, ardent, embarrassing love letters. The kind no public man should ever put on paper. And Carrie Phillips kept them. During the Great War, when Harding was a senator, Carrie Phillips had grown sympathetic to Germany,
Starting point is 00:55:37 and the relationship got tangled up in some genuinely dangerous territory. The story goes that when Harding ran for president, the party quietly arranged to get the Phillips couple out of the country and keep them comfortable and quiet through the campaign, because the letters could have sunk him. Those letters survived, sealed away for decades by court order, and when they were finally open to the public, they confirmed everything. They're real.
Starting point is 00:56:03 The president of the United States wrote them. Then there was Nan Britain. Nan Britain was a young woman from Marion, more than 30 years younger than Harding, who'd had a schoolgirl crush on him and reconnected with him as an adult. She claimed they began an affair, that it continued right into his time in the White House, that they met in hidden corners and by her account, even in a coat closet near the Oval Office
Starting point is 00:56:28 while the Secret Service kept watch. And she claimed something more explosive than that. She claimed that Warren Harding had fathered her daughter, a little girl named Elizabeth Ann, born in 1919, the year before he was elected. After Harding died and after his estate refused to give Nan Britton or her daughter a penny, Britain did something almost unthinkable for a woman of her time.
Starting point is 00:56:51 She wrote a book about it. The president's daughter, she called it, published in 1927, naming Warren Harding as the father of her child and laying out the whole affair in detail. The Harding loyalists savaged her. They called her a liar, a gold digger, a fantasist, and they kept calling her that for the rest of her life and long after her death.
Starting point is 00:57:14 The official keepers of Harding's memory insisted it never happened. but it did happen. In 2015, DNA testing on Harding's descendants and Nan Britton's descendants settled it for good. Warren Harding was the father of Elizabeth Ann. Nan Britain had been telling the truth for nearly a century while the world called her a liar, and she didn't live to be vindicated. I'm not telling you about the affairs to wag a finger at a dead man's private life. Plenty of presidents have kept secrets in the dark, and that's a different show.
Starting point is 00:57:45 I'm telling you because the pattern is the same pattern. The same Warren Harding who couldn't say no to a friend asking for a favor, couldn't say no to a woman, couldn't say no to a drink during prohibition, couldn't say no to a poker game when there was a country to run. It's all one weakness, expressed in different rooms. A man who lives his whole life avoiding the hard, no, the uncomfortable conversation. The moment where you have to disappoint someone to your face is a man who will sign whatever ever's put in front of him by people who've learned exactly how to put it there.
Starting point is 00:58:20 His charm was real. His kindness was real. And both of them were doors that the wrong people walked straight through, in the bedroom and the cabinet room alike. Now put Florence Harding at that fireplace again. Her husband is dead. She knows about Carrie Phillips, almost certainly. She may know or suspect about Nan Britton. And she knows, because by then everyone close to the president knew
Starting point is 00:58:44 that the administration is sitting on a powder keg, a financial corruption that's about to blow. So she burns. She burns letters and papers and records, sorting through her dead husband's life and deciding what the future is allowed to see. She told people she was protecting him. And maybe, in her own grieving and furious way, she believed that's what she was doing. But every fire she lit is a piece of evidence we don't have. Every document that went up the chimney is a question we can't answer. The autopsy she refused, the papers she burned, the conspiracy book that came later,
Starting point is 00:59:20 all of it adds up to the same frustrating, fascinating fact. The truth about Warren Harding's death and the full truth about what he knew went into the ground and the fireplace with him. And we are left, a century later, standing in this dim and respectable house, picking at the ashes. So let's pull back you and I before we leave and ask the question this whole episode has been circling. Not just what happened, but what it means. Because Teapot Dome is famous, and the black bag is a great story. And the cattle on the ranch make a nice, grim detail.
Starting point is 00:59:55 But underneath all of it, there's a harder lesson. And it's the reason this episode lives in disturbing history. And not in some cheerful trivia show. Stay tuned for more disturbing history. We'll be back after these messages. Warren Harding was not an evil man. That's the trap, and I want you to avoid it. If he'd been a villain, this would be a simpler and less frightening story.
Starting point is 01:00:21 The disturbing thing about Harding is that he was decent and warm and well-meaning, and that none of it mattered, because he was weak in the one place a leader cannot afford to be weak. He could not say no to the people he loved. He could not stand to be disliked. He filled the most powerful office on earth with men who made him comfortable, instead of men who would make him better, and then he looked away while those men went to work. power doesn't require a strong man to do damage.
Starting point is 01:00:49 It just requires a weak one in the right chair, surrounded by the wrong people. Harding handed the keys to the kingdom to his friends, and his friends were predators, and they did exactly what predators do when you hand them the keys. They ate. They ate the oil reserves. They ate the construction contracts. They ate the medicine off the wounded men's beds. And they would have kept eating until there was nothing left,
Starting point is 01:01:12 because there was no force at the top of that. house strong enough to make them stop. You want to see the contrast in a single picture. Look at the man who came next. When Harding died, the vice president was Calvin Coolidge, a flinny, plain-spoken New Englander, who was just about Harding's opposite in every way that counted. Coolidge was at his family farmhouse in a tiny Vermont village called Plymouth Notch, when the news came that the president was dead. There was no telephone in the house. a messenger had to drive up the dirt road in the middle of the night to wake him. And so, in the small hours of the morning, by the light of a kerosene lamp,
Starting point is 01:01:51 Calvin Koolage took the oath of office as president of the United States, administered by his own father, who happened to be a notary public, in the family sitting room. Then Kulage, by his own account, went back to bed. The contrast is almost too neat. Harding's power had flowed through smoke-filled hotel suites and greenhouse, on K Street and cash in black bags. Coolidge took his, by lamplight in a farmhouse from his father, and the first thing he did with it was start cleaning out the rot Harding had left behind. A president is not just a face. The difference between the two men is the difference between a
Starting point is 01:02:29 government that gets eaten and a government that doesn't, and it lived entirely in the spine. That's the real corpse in this story, not Warren Harding's body, embalmed and sealed and rolled home on a black train. The corpse is the trust. A whole government's worth of public trust. Killed quietly while a beloved man shook hands and played cards and didn't ask the questions he was afraid to hear the answers to. The Forbes scandal and Teapot Dome and the Ohio gang
Starting point is 01:02:57 weren't three separate crimes. They were three symptoms of one disease, and the disease was a vacuum at the very top, an empty space where a leader's spine should have been. And into that vacuum rushed every hungry, grasping man who could get close enough to feed. And the people who paid for it were never the people in the greenhouse on K Street. The oilmen kept their fortunes. Forbes did his two years and lived a long, quiet life. Dardy beat his charges and died in his bed. The people who actually paid
Starting point is 01:03:30 were the ones who never make the headlines. The taxpayers who got robbed twice over on bedsheets. The young men in the underfunded wards coughing up their ruined lungs, waiting for for the care a grateful nation had sworn to give them, while the man entrusted with that care turned their bandages into a satchel of cash. That's where I want to leave you. Not with the oil. Not with the black bag, satisfying as it is. With the wounded men in those beds. Because corruption always sounds like an accounting problem, columns of numbers, money moving from one place to another, and it is never, ever just that. It always lands on somebody. It always has a bad. It always has a body. And the whole grim point of standing here in this beautiful, respectable house tonight
Starting point is 01:04:15 is to make sure we never let anybody tell us otherwise. Warren Harding got the easiest death of anyone in this story. He died beloved, mourned by millions, before the worst of it touched him. Maybe his heart gave out from the strain of what he knew. Maybe it was just a bad heart and a heavy body, the way the doctors mostly think. Either way, he got out clean, ahead of the verdict, and left his friends and his widow and the United States Senate to sort through the wreckage he'd presided over. The administration he led didn't get out clean. It died slower and uglier than the man himself,
Starting point is 01:04:52 exposed piece by piece in the hearing rooms, a corpse that kept surfacing long after they'd buried the president, the corpse of an administration, rotting in plain sight in the most respectable house in America, while the country it betrayed finally, slowly, learned to look. And the name stuck. For half a century, when Americans wanted to talk about a government gone rotten, about cronies and bribes and a White House you couldn't trust,
Starting point is 01:05:19 they reached for two words, teapot dome. It was the gold standard of presidential corruption, the thing every later scandal got measured against. It held that title for 50 years, all the way down to a summer night in 1972, when some men with a different kind of greed broke into a building in Washington called the Watergate and gave the country a new word to be ashamed of. But that's another walk through this house, on another night.
Starting point is 01:05:47 Tonight belongs to the oil men and the wounded soldiers and the greenhouse on K Street, and to the kind, weak, frightened man who let them all in and then died before he had to watch them be dragged out. That's the end of our walk through the White House for tonight. Mind the step on your way out. The guard at the gate will pretend not to notice us leaving. The same way the country pretended not to notice what was happening in here for the better part of three years. Funny how that works. I'm going to leave you with one last thing to carry home. The next time somebody tells you a scandal is just politics.
Starting point is 01:06:22 Or that the money was only moving around between rich men and nobody really got hurt. I want you to picture a hospital ward in 1923. Picture the empty supply shelves. Picture the young man in the bed who could. came home with one good lung and a promise and got the empty shelves instead. That's what corruption costs. It always has a body. We'll meet again soon, back in the dark corners of history, where the respectable people do their worst work behind the heaviest doors. Until then, watch who your leaders surround
Starting point is 01:06:54 themselves with, watch who gets rich while they're in office, and keep your eyes on the warehouses. One more thing before you go. Notice that nobody in this story thought of them as a monster. Charles Forbes thought he was a charming guy who deserved a little extra. Albert Fall thought he was a hard luck rancher just trying to save his land. The men in the greenhouse thought they were doing business, the way business gets done, the way it's always been done. That's the quiet horror underneath all of it, and it's the reason this episode lives here and not in some museum exhibit about the 1920s. The rot never announces itself. It shakes your hand. It remembers your kids' names. It sits on the porch and tells you it just wants to get things
Starting point is 01:07:39 back to normal. And by the time you understand what it really wanted, the oil's gone, the supplies are sold, the warehouses are empty, and the only honest man left in the building is the one in the coffin. That's the true disturbing history.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.