Endgame with Gita Wirjawan - Mahfud MD dan Kekecewaannya Terhadap Hukum
Episode Date: April 30, 2025Mahfud MD dan Gita Wirjawan membahas bagaimana kita dapat membangun negara lewat hukum. Juga menyentuh topik terkait korupsi, posisi hukum dalam demokrasi, prinsip keadilan hukum Islam, hingga pendidi...kan dan tatanan dunia.Mahfud MD adalah Guru Besar Hukum Tata Negara yang pernah menjabat sebagai Menteri Koordinator Bidang Politik, Hukum, dan Keamanan; Ketua MK; Anggota DPR; dan Menteri Pertahanan.#Endgame #GitaWirjawan #MahfudMDCatatan dan referensi tambahan episode ini:https://sgpp.me/eps214notesJelajahi dan jadi bagian dari komunitas kami:https://endgame.id/Untuk ajakan kolaborasi dan kerja sama, hubungi kami di sini:https://sgpp.me/contactus
Transcript
Discussion (0)
We're going to get in jatty-dry and
the kind of of people who are in fact.
I'm sorry.
I'm sorry to have a lot of
the lawcum.
Hucom is always calh with politics.
Why?
Because,
because the lawcum is a product politic.
There's no harm to.
Hucom is the person who's part.
Democracy,
without a human, is,
and anarchist, but the
if not,
if it's not,
if you're not
un-in-lawful,
democracy,
to perassarat.
The right-it-not-law-y-oddoh,
why, pake democracy,
that's what's
doing-buylis-swara.
Now, in our country,
that's all,
Aristotle, has said,
we've got.
We've got to
Mavut.
From 13 May,
19, 757,
Sampang,
Sampang,
So, after the next
is what for Pamhub?
No, there.
So, I'm going to
go to-in.
I was, I'm going to
get-cit-citania, but
tibbao-tie, but
in the, there's al-alil
this. If Allah
Allah, menhendagi
something to do,
it's justa-culte
to do.
Hello,
I'm here,
we're to get-a-Mafud
M-D.
Pat Mahmhud,
thank you very.
Thank you, thank you, thank you.
I'm here.
I'm one of many of people who
not know why
why the name of Bapakut MD.
Can you be jolasked,
yeah,
it's a lot of
but this is I'm going to
I'm from
in Madura,
in Madura,
umumnia,
uh,
NU,
that's,
the name-nama to
use the
is that,
I'm very in there,
by Joyo, Rome, Suyanto,
that's,
Mahfut, Ahmad,
Hamid,
Arab,
Arab, all.
And I'm,
and I'mhapput.
Now,
the name Mahfut,
is popular.
Mahfut,
if in in
Basa Arab,
are people
that are people
perpeler,
that's,
kind of,
that's a lot
so,
so in a certain
When I was when I was in the school
Lanjutoran first,
the school in the first
that's the name's
the education from
because the education is
student,
Llan,
LSD, I'm Degh,
Llan,
there,
three, Mahfut.
Dullo,
I was in the
time I was in
2001,
I'm in
P.
If you,
if you're going
to come upsen,
absent, right?
Namann, absent,
the absent,
first, one,
when it's about
Mahfut,
that's the
Mahfut, that's
because it's
same.
Mahfut, Mahfut,
and then,
my guru,
it's,
me name name
Sementara,
you know,
Mahfut A,
you,
B, you
C,
did-tul-a-
D,
Ch,
Mavut-A,
K'A,
Mafud-C, the
And then a week
then I guru
I said
Wow,
this is not
name I'm
okay I'm
B, C
just like you
know of the
name of your
name of you
yeah
that's what
yeah
Oh, the
A
to namah
Mhufu
Mhufah
Mhufu B
who's what
Namaurangh
Mhudh
Jadil
Jadilhhh
Jadilhhh
Mhhhhhh
Mhhhhh
Mhhhhhh
Mhhahahah
myahahahahahah
myahahahahahahahahahahahah
if you, if you, if you're called,
to, it's just gung
name of the ones
each and then.
Then I'm aghackal.
I, like,
I'm a little bit more than rematch.
That, why,
name Mahmoudin,
is, if you're getting,
with Mahfut.
Mahmoud, Mahmoudin.
Then, what,
disingka, don't.
Mahfut MD.
Okay,
I, I'ma,
Maphot M.
Dillah,
Kata, said,
Rangh,
I'm,
I'm not,
this is,
this is not,
Masha.
Massu,
IJASA. IJASA,
in the
one of the
one.
It's been
from Jakarta.
So if you
cannot be
being made
get to get
that.
Sudden,
number seriness
that,
not be able
because it.
That's the
name
and then,
it's
the name,
and it.
So,
so,
the DOSet,
so,
the guru
be able to,
even,
even the
even the
M.D.
So,
that's
the name.
So,
that's,
that's,
RASM.
NAM.
RAS.
But,
but
not
name
small,
when they're not asme
as much.
Many people
mayer
that's
people,
that's,
what,
that's,
what,
medical doctor?
Yeah,
medical doctor.
There are
who are
who,
this,
this,
this,
the minister of
defense.
In fact,
that,
people,
people,
people,
people,
this,
this,
motto,
the motto,
the motto,
motto,
I don't
puto,
I'm specific
that,
but,
ajaran,
ajaran
yeah peddoman in
in life that,
yeah,
he'd up,
soderhanna,
what is,
that's juster.
If you're
you're just,
you know,
you're, you,
you can't,
but if you
don't do
you're,
you can't
make sure,
that's,
not a mutton
that's specific
in one
kind of,
that's ajaran.
So,
so,
so, I'm,
I'm,
the status
Twitter or
what,
I,
if I'm not,
Muth,
M.D.
If you're
jujure,
you'll
come to
mucur.
If you
don't
you're
all just
that's much
that's
that's
that's
ajaran
about
my own
my
decision.
Keputusan
Bapa,
for school in
Jokja
Yeah.
Who?
The
person or
Bapa
and so
guru.
So,
so I'm
so.
I'm right.
I'm
I'm living in
the kuntran,
Madurra, can.
Cita,
I,
that,
I mean
to be
guru
agama.
Why?
Guru
Agama
is a
government
that's
the gaudy
by the
country.
Now,
so,
there's
school
to be
guru
agamah
called
education,
the
time when it
year,
the
school
education,
there's
also
there's
also,
I'm
also
to
education
guru
agam.
What
Chita-
Jita?
J.
J.
Gita?
Gert,
that,
If you're going to do to teach in Shurau,
that's not just a different.
But when I was in SMP that,
PGA,
at the time,
the end of the SMTP,
the PGA,
the SMTPs,
not three-torn.
Because,
they're going to be
the Gawai Negrie,
I'm,
I'm,
d'ilal again,
to,
in qualification
the three murids
the three murgues,
the other
The one of the best of carisidanean, it's,
they're giving to Jukja,
what's school.
What is the school.
What is the school.
It's called.
I'm going to go back again, this.
This is a good.
It's a good.
It's a good.
It's a king.
Want to be haqeim Islam,
right?
Now, in the penidication of Islam,
this, this is MA.
Guru, gurusheran, jacsa,
and aces,
I'm chakia,
I'm,
I'm,
by the law.
Wow, this
is a good
that's good
for the
reason why
because I'm
going to make
the faculty
of the law
because of
notep,
it's not
be't in
the SMA
as to
the hakeem
agamah
that maybe
that's
the level
that I
want
faculty
of that
I'm
because I
must be
law
U.I.
Joghaka
University
Islam
Indonesia,
Jukhaka.
Now
there, I
Kaguam
to the
Dossens
moda
that
activist.
This is
there has a docene
that's
Pinter like Artijio Al-Costar
to Hakeem Agong
that's
Kuroh,
that's great
this.
Oh, hebat,
me.
People who are
not-gared,
but I'ma-buck-buck-buck-
about.
If I'm
like, I'm
just, I'm
like,
GUR-A-Gama,
not,
A-K-M,
but,
other than,
so.
So,
so.
Cita-Cita-Cita-Cita
my,
the last
the last
, the last
the last
D-Cult-s-Cult-s-Cum,
Tuts-Cult-C-Cum,
just because of that.
I've got to be a student,
so many people,
in the faculty of the lawy,
Jobbjah.
But, when S.
1, while I'm at
faculty in the fuliae,
I'm at UGM,
jurusan sastra Arab.
Because I can learn
with Arabic, Arab, too,
since I'n't, man,
when, if the BASA Arab,
I'm going to rank up in UGM,
in Sastra Arab.
Now, so I'm A.
So, I'm Rangap,
I'd be a class.
But, but, again,
then,
mas, we're at a titic
back,
from the life
I'm going to
move to
politics.
If,
from the judute
emotional,
in the year
71,
I've got
to come
mat to politic
because
the people
my parents
to,
the people,
but
also,
activist,
Nhatotululululah.
Nade Tullu Lama
that,
at that
is a party
political
in 2007
not
not always
not always
I'm not used
I'm in
I'm not
I'm sorry
I'm
I'm sorry
to have
what I'm
I'm
why I'm
learn about
I'm
I'm
I'm in 828
183
I'm
I'm 828
I'm 3
I'm tewapua
I'm sorry
I'm
but I'm
there's not
there's not
goodnation
When that,
I was already
merbac corruption,
merbach
to rebeck to rebecca
under law,
I'm learning,
RANDASAR,
to have HAPA, KUHP,
SUND, KUHP,
I've done,
I'm doing HAPIS,
I've been,
in this country
this.
So,
I'm going to
do you,
law political.
S-duan
into the
public.
In UGM.
In UGM.
In,
UGM.
Now, in SITU
by,
Guru Beem,
A.
R.S.
is,
Guru,
I'mah,
Yahya Muhammad, Muhtar Masut,
Afan Ghafar,
especially Mbidivk,
so I'm being like,
soing the kisimulah,
because the symbolion,
because the fuling,
because the,
kum is always
calh with politics.
Why?
Because,
the, the,
product politic.
There's no,
the, the,
that's nother
same.
Huckum,
is,
that's the
person,
the power of
that's,
that's,
that's,
Lalu,
I'm telling
why,
why,
Mah, Mavot,
the,
people,
the,
is always
bingong.
Because
the wrong
who's not
know
the
know of the
people,
but he
don't know
about the
law law
that he's
only can't
be able
by the
power
political.
That's
because I
also S-3
in the
bidang
the
public
public
public,
and I
hadaping
two
that,
the
other,
the
way,
it's,
it's
the word,
so,
that's
the word
Lus S-3
and
made
get
guru-besar or professor in the
bit of the political-hook.
When I was, I, the first and one-one,
guru-besar, the law-politic-hook.
That's been took-to-le-le-nagued-in-a-nagued.
Because, when it was a-lombo-bancke,
if you're doing-bilang-il-politic,
there, there's-hook-n-hout-pment-politic,
that.
Maka, there is a-lotech-h-hook-n,
naman. And I'm
then I'm then
dulae
in the
year
and then
then I'm
musulkan
matakulia
new in
Fakultas
Hucum, I
came in
Mhurtukh
Mata Maja
yeah.
When that
he was
he's in
Lournard
but
the
court
but he
did you
gettukes
Mata
Kulia
in Perguranting
that was
I was
usul to
do you
know
political
Hucm.
Why?
The person
Hulang is
always
I'm beingonged,
they're going to be called
by politics.
Not it's
the law
policy.
Not can't be.
I'm used
dissertation.
Methodology
of the methodology
the hukum.
And if
in the faculty
hukes,
there's sociology
that, there,
budaic hukum.
Why,
politics,
the law,
there's,
there's,
it's just,
this, this
is made,
this year,
since
the year 24,
the maca
of the S.2,
I,
I'm lulue,
I'm just,
I'm just,
musul,
I'm going to,
I'm going to
become.
I'm going to
give a guru
teacher
public
huk.
Now, I'm
too,
because
before it,
if you're
before it,
if you're not,
the law,
government,
government,
administration.
I'm the
first,
I'm a
political
hukes.
I'm
about legal
policy.
The
policy,
the,
the reason,
what should be
what,
and what
what's
what is
what, what
make sure,
what
So,
I'm going to
I'm going to
know that
if you
career academic
and I
think
I'm
really,
the job
my,
this is the
this is the
part of
that's what
that's
about,
that's
I've got
decision,
that's
standard cita-cita-s-
and I'm
under the
good
and the
director
too.
director,
that's,
I mean I'm not
there.
So,
I'm going to
jabata
jobatting
job at
that.
If you,
in the
law,
there,
there is
there is
a stilap
Petita.
Ultrapetita
is one
giveerer
on the
out of the
court,
that's
that you
can't,
but
Mr.
Utak
I, Pat
I'm Gugat
I,
Mahfut,
to,
you,
you,
it,
So, so much
This is the sumloughly
$100,000,
miscellar,
as well,
as it was already
the perlady,
the money,
the tax,
the money,
to $125,000,
$125,000.
Hacim that's
$1,000,
but that's
$1,000,
that's not
ultrapetita,
more than
the one thing
than what they're
saying,
but as soon as
that,
the namenation,
it's,
that's,
it's,
Tibba,
after tibre,
after the MNTRA,
after DPR,
to DPR,
to DPR,
KETA,
so I'mgues,
I'mgap,
this ultra-petita,
need,
ultra-petita,
Pemberian-N-TUHan
than I'm
Minta.
I just need to,
and it's all right,
and it's all right,
yeah,
this is all right,
this is all right,
I'm back to India
again,
that's,
standard,
cita-cita-sai
can,
this, now,
now,
now,
I'm back to
see,
MNko,
Volhul-Hukam.
That.
What?
What?
What?
Cita-Cita.
So, it's just
be a-u-bha-hubal.
I don't have
one cita-cita-cita-tungal.
Bapac-N-Baphae,
philosophy,
Hukum Islam and
constitution
Pancasila and
other,
for the
people,
to,
how,
to try,
there, is,
there,
is,
there,
there,
can't,
so,
the,
Antar the Fulcum or Philisavat Hucum Islam
with Pancashila.
Yeah, so, so...
Yeah, so, so...
It's, we're going to...
It's...
...itoumptuking
and perumusan ideologu and constitution.
I want to say,
we're going to be thank
to...
...theirder and generation Norholish-Majid...
Yep.
...in the time...
80s and
conciliations,
reconsiliates
the abuant,
because this,
in the year,
in the year,
when it's,
it's,
it can be
indirical,
there,
a clompo that
not want
the country
Pancasila,
there,
a clompoe
that not
not,
the,
partankation
that's,
and pertentangangance
to,
that's,
that's been
not in
the 45,
the,
partentangang
between
Nasir and
Muhammad
and Bungarno
in
28,
Pant poll maker,
Nassir,
Minta, because
when it's been
Merdick,
already be jangy-in'r-
there's-
there's-bay-an-mer-deka.
Sukarno,
not-Busa,
we don't be in-
dirrica-agam.
Nasir,
the, the
thing, the
country-N-N-N-A-N-Slam,
this,
did-baw-N-Process
the process
the form-tok-n-Merd-Sah
that,
that was-sid-Mew-Y,
yeah,
since the month May
until Augustus,
it's
interlipat
pertentangan ideology
one of the
Islam,
two clompo nationalists
who nationalists
is Islam
hebat,
hebat too,
yeah.
Bungarno,
is,
more than
Kiyahe,
menurotya,
Bung Hatta
also.
Yamin
but he
want a
not agara
not
not Gala,
the reason why
the government
and the
same as much
not GARY,
but
NACA,
but Nassir N'A,
If if we're
agamah,
yeah,
a country
also.
So,
and Nasir
this is
this is
not a good,
and then
because of
the problem,
it's
comepromy
by the
Agam
Jakarta,
right.
Now,
maybe
as a
kind of
people,
people,
in UN
is,
is wrong,
the Rammat
N.
N.U.
It's
since
during
N.
N.U.
Justru,
the most
the most ginkar
to beaurembuds
just to be
gestur
lulled
re-niquation
because
because
when you
until
M.U.
M.U.
M.
Mottetia
Mottetrikan
Mottedat
Maldi who
Motha,
I'm not.
I'm also
not,
not the other
government
Agamah.
Lacka and Racka
Racka is
Kahlame
this,
he's going to
talk to
because of
Turkey just
when they're
moving to
make sure
that's
compromise,
yeah,
compromise,
yeah,
this because
there's a
government,
and the
kingdom Jakarta
this
is a
end up
the end up
what,
which is a
consulksuctor
to give
the government
and the
government and
the government
that's
the termed
umum
now,
that we are
penganoet
Nagar Gehousan,
that is the
generation of
Gurd, and
Norholis Majid.
Lalu also
there
that's the
M.H.
Inouin Najib.
PAD,
there was,
there,
came in Raiis,
there,
come,
people,
people,
people,
people,
national,
more academic,
not pertentangangue.
If you're
patentakan political,
if you're
five, nine,
can be a lot,
winging the
Islam and
other,
that one is,
the country
so that's not
defoting
bercal
even being
not there
not there's
men who are
mengues,
if they're
when it's
people,
the country
has been
to make the
two per
three,
and this
not ever
three,
this is not
ever three,
this is not
ever get paid
president.
5 July,
5.
9.
Now,
some time,
well,
many years,
many years,
people,
people,
people,
Like Nurholismajid,
Gisdur, who's
who said,
that's not
the government
and agamah
it's not
be pertentang-k
because
the country
it's in-Norot-ul-ul-
not-N-A-N-Loh.
There's not
men who-Negarate.
Can't get-it-cuh.
Just, yeah,
there's-d-old,
must-e,
there organization,
which, there,
There's penguasance, there
Raiatna, that's a
Rhaqa, that's
In the other, in the
Islam,
there's bountingusputan
negarah, there
kata, there's
kata, there kata balaat,
yeah, can?
There's kitha.
There, there kitha.
Now,
so, so,
the country can't beasasasak.
But, this,
the, the, you know,
the, that's
the most of the
, there's
not a gooderushan
we're to
indirical,
we're not
the country,
the,
The country that's
the bentonowning
but what's
secular,
be a reubleauze,
be resettance,
be resettualization,
can't centralization
which isentralization
which is important
in order to
the country that
is just
need to be able
but it,
but what's in
the country that
whatever,
the country
republic,
the country,
the country,
but there's five
hal
yeah,
which is called
what namani
Makosit Aschari
name it.
Setiap.
It's not even
people are you
want to be able to
one of the
whole.
One,
melendunging
the same
each and
yeah,
right,
melendungy
resamilat
the human rights,
and will
end up
people,
willunding
kusatown
and
and melenduny
curing,
geturion,
in Indonesia
there's
there's always
there,
Kutuzudan Karnur
Kuh,
you've been
indunging,
you know,
more agam,
should beindunging.
You,
your people,
there's a
human,
there's a
agar
keturran you
have been sure
there's a
agarotemu
not rustic
and you're
just be atured
food and
mannuman
that if you
don't
be bad
there,
there's
there's
there's
there's
so there
is already
islamy
now that
that's
that's
that I'm
that I'm
that I'm
that I'm
think back
in the
I'm like that.
I'm at the latter-belaghanes.
So, I know,
thinkeran,
the kind of
of the kind of
of the country
and bea-nac-ne-negarer
and bea-mastraked,
and then I'm going to
the law-and-negare.
Now, this,
Mr.
Mahfut,
can make,
make-lac-a-
or reintegration
or reintegration
on the
hum-um-and-hook-agam
and the
so-game.
So,
I'm going to
I'm
constructsing
a
country and
agamate
one,
one,
the one,
the
one of the
lawgum
but
the form
the form of
different,
what is,
what I'm,
what I'm
first,
in the
al-Kur-an
and
hadis,
there
not the
public,
not there
kata-d-
democracy.
I'm,
can't-
-monarchy,
can-a-
-a-a-a-a-a-sha-sard.
There's, I'd say, what there?
In the Al-Quaan or Hadis as a sub-primir,
that's a good, that's a democracy,
or carajan, or monarchy, that.
There's, no, there's, no, there's.
And, man, right?
And, you know, man, man,
why, not endirical a country
like Nabi muhamma.
Ah, ha, hamphab, too,
hughan, the humonging the country,
like, gagat, or not?
Why, Pah Mavut,
said,
"'Pak, ma'ud, too,
the landerick,
the right,
you know,
because there
Dalai,
you know,
you can
help,
if,
uh,
what,
name,
put on the two
hal that I'm
kind of,
this,
this,
this,
if you,
want to
get two
this,
that you,
can't,
you can't
make the
un-N-N-N-N-A-N-B,
but,
the,
other,
there,
harta,
the
So,
the
whole
arus
chilafah
because
the chilafat
is a
name in
al-Quran,
there's a
kata,
there kata,
there kata,
there,
there's sultonia,
there,
other,
Emirat,
Emirate,
yeah,
can,
unia emirat,
that's
not a
agamah
also,
yeah,
yeah, there,
also, there,
also,
the,
soalal,
soal,
it'serer,
but the principle
five
hal it's,
there,
there,
the
one,
I'm,
I'm,
I'm not a landericant of a
abe.
Why?
So, I'm,
so I'm,
even if I'm
massit
Islamic Center
in Newyok,
Samsi Ali,
yeah,
Nulis in Twitter.
Wow,
that's,
that's,
that's,
in Twitter,
I'm going to
do,
two years,
last, I'm,
I'm going to,
I'm going to
be, I'm
again,
about,
you know,
about,
you know,
not there,
not there,
the debate
with,
the debate I,
the question,
I'm about it. I'm
because
the country
is the
people, the
head of
the power of
the people,
the way,
the humonging
from the
abe.
The time
nabes,
there's not
there hakim.
There's
the lembaga
legislative
DPR.
Executivs,
there's
there in nabbe
all.
Who's
now who
want
who want
to be
the
people?
I'm
because
not arm,
the right
you can't
you,
you know,
you have
you
new.
Padal
in the
adi sunah
y'al Jamaa,
Nabi is
that's been
tutu'u.
So,
because of it,
since other
the other
people,
Abubakar,
namah
Holifah.
Yeah,
can?
It's who
malherka
Khulah
Khah,
Nameshah
Amir.
So,
because it
is called Amirulmian
not disbuit,
not disbue
al-N-Mirah
Emirate,
now,
Lakhir,
now,
now,
Ali,
indirical imam,
Imam Ali,
is about Gautman.
Yeah,
Usman,
Horifah,
the same.
But,
but the system
pemilhani,
he's already.
Paki Ahlulhaliwal Agdi.
Ali is called Imam Ali.
Lakhirlah,
like,
Iran, now.
So, so,
so that's from
Jaman,
all Islam.
Usma.
Now,
now,
now,
asked Usman, can,
the,
the way of
the,
if abu-Bakar
is democracy
long,
Right.
But, right.
But, but...
But he's.
This, um, this,
democracy,
berubak, um,
rumored.
Umar did tune.
Oh, yeah.
If I'm gonna be able,
Khabakar,
who's,
who's monarchy,
penunjukan.
But,
but when I'm gonna
land,
he's made,
he's,
name-al-hali-al-Aqi.
If I'm-
myel-l-A-Q-T-
I mean,
nancy,
nine people.
It's already
like in the parliament
to,
like the parliament.
If you're
like ayes,
then we're
like the same
after the
birth, republic,
and what,
the country
Islam,
that's not,
if now,
if now,
per-hary
this,
there are 22
of the
people,
the organization
confernice Islam
to,
can,
the,
can't be
different,
different.
Now,
so,
so I'm not
I'm
Bernigara in Islam,
what we're using
into a country
Pancashila
with the United States,
it's already compatible
with ajaran Islam.
That is termed
ajaran al-Qa-Kur-an and Hadis
for the need of Indonesia.
So, why we're we live
in a country
Indonesia with data
the law
that we're
under
constitution we
where the
nilai,
nilalai
Islaman it
that's up
in the life
without
to be in-nature.
TANpa
must be
part of Islam
this,
the law,
this,
not without
not even
a lie-in-
-l-l-in-a-
so.
So,
I'm not,
but,
yeah,
dalil-in-n-
-lety-lety-
I-l-l-l-a-l-l-a-l-l-lis-a-l-l-l-lis-lum
if,
if you want to
want to make
ajaran
Islam
that's
you,
make sure
substances
what?
Al-Ibrough,
I'm
I'm sorry.
I'm sorry.
Because you
ask you
about Islam.
Al-Aibro
is,
Phil Islam,
Jahar,
La Bilmathar.
If you
want to
build the
Islam,
amelah
Ibrough
with substance
it,
not the
not function it.
Substantincipin'
Islam,
to,
to the
adilance,
the jujurans,
anti-corruption,
democracy, okay,
yeah,
right,
if you know,
democracy,
that,
the,
the,
and it's,
the same
the world,
in the five
hal that.
That's Islam.
And,
by the way,
that,
the country
Indonesia,
to,
until,
time,
yeah,
until the year's
it's been called
as a country
Muslim
the world
from the sudet
but if you're
not wrong,
the pastel
because of
Pakistan,
yeah,
more than Indonesia,
yeah,
it's 90%
we're reproductions
yeah,
yeah,
we're 8,7%
from
from the
Pakistan,
90%
more,
the people,
the people
more,
and the
number of,
because if
only,
if just 90%
Azerbaijan,
also Islam,
I was a lot.
It's not,
it's all of
people.
Yeah, but
but there's
almost not
there.
But,
Islam, they're
if they're
if they're
like it.
Now,
now,
now,
now,
kind of,
yeah,
that's
big,
that's
paradoxal,
who,
that's about
Abubakar,
that is
caliph
pericutna,
that,
it's,
it's,
too,
democratic,
and technocratis.
Yeah.
Because,
it's
the most
senior,
the,
capable.
Yeah.
TURUN-temurun it's in Saudi.
Yeah.
The system of the government is the government of the
system of the intermentally that exists as a democracy.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Which is it to be able to,
technocratic, like, technocratic, in the time you know,
in terms of tip.
That's a little paradoxal, right?
Yeah, because
this is
asudah
Nabi Muhammad
Waffat,
can then
Umat Islam
rubbed to
how this
how
how much
how much
the way
there
also
there's
that you
if that
umaraj
people
the people
who are the
one
one,
usul
Ali
because
Kata
Ali is
Kuturan
Nabi
and there
some
somecabab
Abi
that,
actually, if I'm not
there, Wahyu, this
Ruiu'i,
so there's people who are
saying, there's Ali.
The one said,
has Umar.
But there's umar
said,
no, this is abu-bacar.
Because, what,
Abu Bakar?
If, Nabi,
if, Nabi,
there's a mani-en-medin'ad.
Yeah.
Palling senior,
yeah.
Yeah, can.
Yeah, who's-in-law,
Ab-Bakar.
Ayy, Bayat,
all.
So, yeah,
but, but,
but,
but,
not
not yet
to the
other
the other
the
and then
then came out
that's
the same
this isbut
this
this is the
and then
mutuahulbaid
that
abu-bacar
Umar
that
that's
men's churry
jabatans
this should be
ali this
this is the
whom shah
which then
then beckmang
in Iran
so back
now, so
so,
yeah,
until 10,
20 years
Lally,
if Khad
in Iran,
Konon,
the word
that's
what's,
what,
how many,
per kutuk,
Abu Bakar
and
Umar,
yeah,
can,
he'll beulang,
and,
even,
even,
the,
of,
Kisya,
that is called,
Palsh,
in Iran,
that,
the,
people,
the,
people,
the,
people,
Si,
So,
the development.
So,
so,
the politics,
the statenegaraan
and hukum
in the world
Islam,
it's come
from
tafsir.
Right.
The ayat
same,
right,
the way,
the way,
talcouran is
that.
Bissue,
can't do you,
can't make a
kaisaran,
in many,
man,
but, but,
but, but,
but,
because,
menurot Agamah,
you dovet,
you dovetel
It's as well-to-beautuan
Bank Samu.
If you,
if in the
in the other
there's a kind,
La Yung Karu
Tawoyurul-A-Kam,
Bita-Jiril-Azman,
well-h-h-h-h-h-h-harm.
It's not be incurred.
It's beenarue by,
it's been a bit-w.
When-Nabat,
when, bed.
If the place
is, the,
Hukom Islam in
Maruco,
which-n-n-N-N-N-N-N-N-N-is-h-h-Lam.
Because it,
because it,
Hukom Islam and Fiki
that.
Fikki,
which is
huking
in Maruco
better than
the law
the way,
the way,
the time,
the place,
the world
the world
Indonesia,
to have
the,
has,
so in
this
this,
Islam
be coming
melalue
in the
geracan
that,
which
that did
belong
by Wali-Songue
can,
D'u-
Kethan-Gar-
KATH,
we Islam-
Dunnian
this
melalue, what naman
Islam can
Islam can
Islam,
while wayang.
Yeah,
can,
the carer of
Chalachau
d'uogu
so,
so,
so,
she's,
people,
people,
people,
people,
people,
jacah,
but,
but if
sub-and-
sometimes,
about,
time,
sub-sub-
,
I,
know,
I'm-n-
-d-l-
-w-w-
-w-w-a-
What? What? I want to-geng sunan.
I want to solat.
Yeah, sure, silh.
Not gertin, what sort?
Why, set-up wayang, he pamid,
solat.
Leru-lid, and then,
sonan, what,
is?
Solat, that,
menhembaugh-in-uasa.
God.
So, that's what?
There's a wayang,
lacon calimusot, to.
Kalimu-Sahadat.
He'll tell-la.
That, that,
that's, that's the power.
Besson you go, I should
I quit, Iqqat, Iqat,
two, three,
until, after Islam
menjebara.
Now, that's
kind of predekatan
buddhae.
So, again
we don't be
making a worda
that, there,
there's not that
there's not,
there can,
not be able,
Al-Assman,
well-A-Wal-A-Wa-Wai,
and buddai
that,
can be used to
be used to beckar-carned
and then,
the country
is based
the need-bucked,
so-tem-est-e-est-e-e-s.
So,
so it's not
not
the world,
and we're
not,
nesting,
nesting,
nomen.
That'ser in
apopun,
it's
kind of
nilai,
and
the end of
education.
Yeah.
Now,
this is how,
in the country
that's
the IQ-n't
there's
there's,
the quality
tafsirn't
that.
Okay,
so,
if,
if,
if,
it's,
there,
in the
people,
the,
there,
too,
agamah,
the politicians,
to be given
a person.
If you're
being in the
kind,
this,
this,
it's just
just,
yeah,
kind,
I'm,
the co-n-
the law and
because,
that's the
effect that,
we're,
it's,
we can't
be democracy
with bad,
and
the economy, and
the
so-goy-
if-an-
-s-s-
-s-s-l-
-mas-a-
-l-mas-
-re-n-s.
That,
We're not even though I,
how it's
how it's
it's
making
it's
making a
action
and much
like much
to make
the country
that's
the end up
the endgattal
from
generation
to the
generation
to the
generation
where we're
making much
if Indonesia
might be much
708 yeah
728
yeah
Singapore
Korea
Southan
105
1060
Ashkenazi,
Yehudi,
14.
They're rata
not creative,
not innovative,
and yeah,
just,
this is,
it's just,
can't be fatalist
too,
can't be.
It's,
it's not,
it's not from
God,
not much,
we're doing
we're not much
we're,
but,
but I'm
optimis, yeah,
generation
we're not
our generation
we,
can be
much more
much,
the IQ-N-
because,
because,
since-s-
-U-Merd-N-Dak
this can
be
mobility
social
vertical
that's
dark
yeah
yeah
before
we're
back in
I'm
school school
school
SMP
but
before
school
SMP
I'm
from
people
is
there
can
there
there
there
there
school
umum
that
school agama
that's exclusive
not be in
not
be able
not be
not
there's
there's
there
People, the people islam it is,
even the time of the
penjazzhan Belanda
be cashinged.
But,
but when it's
merdeka,
there's a good
people,
people who,
people who are
people who are
people who
want to be in
the country,
the minister,
Wahit Asim,
from A.N.U.
and Bahadir Johan.
That's the
school in SMA
is same with
Aliyah,
I'm, iftidda,
it's, same
than SEDA
NECI, so
so that's
schooling.
That's the
to bejointed
in the 20s.
Town 60s
when
there's
many sarjana
mud,
sirsia
work in
20,
many sarjana
hukum,
doctor insin
from the
personterian.
The personterian,
the
people who are
not being
the time
in the end up
jettelon
1,
Eselonah
so,
so in 90s
than in
the kantor
in the
kentor per
time,
and seagin,
and sogation,
and sogany
Now,
many
now,
universities
Islam-Negri
that not
only only
only have
other than
other than
U-U-N
University
Islam-N-N-Negri.
Not only
just bele-le-Pik,
BASA,
but it's under
doctorate,
sociology,
or what,
mach-mach-mach-a-sit-t
that.
It's already,
what?
The mobility
social
our,
that,
it's,
big,
good.
And,
and this
will be
and mendongra
to keep
plan plan
the end up
unthinkated
IQ,
in order I'm
because
the end up
the end up
sure and then
the set-sarat
to make-an-a-kew
since
embryo-manusia
that's
now now
now by
the government
to be
hinders-kind
to bring
stinti
and,
man-erang-
k-miscanan
can,
at the
kind of
can be
giving
kesehatan
on
the piranti
ripiranti that we need to be
people who are people. We've
already made up to exist as
democracy. If we're
we're making aced to theory
or ajaran from Aristotle
he can't makebang can
there 3 to 6
type of the
people of the main.
The three that's one, the first
monarchy.
Dikwasked, be controlled
by one person.
The second, aristocracy,
by control
by several
people.
Three,
polity,
the control
by many people.
Now,
democracy,
this,
polity,
right.
And,
what,
how do you
see,
quality of
democracy
in Indonesia
and in
the world?
Okay.
Maybe I
try
to talk about
observation
that's the
electorate
we,
93%
to
the,
the,
the,
the,
the,
the,
room
and the
38%
the
pedicat
not
up to
so
how much
quality
they can
make
them
make a
issue or
people
that
to be
non-democratization
to the
front.
Okay.
This
discussion
is a
little bit
yeah.
This is
this.
Theory
about
the form
of the
government
that
or the form of the government that
the government that's
that's
that's
that's
it's going to
continue
there's
there's
the endings
but it's
not being six
can't
monarchy
one person
one who
aristocracy
only
only people
but
and before
before
politic
there before politic
it was
there's
oligarchy
oligarchy
plutocracy
yeah
oligarchy
and political
and democracy
then democracy
and democracy
and there's no mary
again
that's bento
now
in order
aristotels
yeah
democracy
that's
not
not by aristotle
that's
that good
aristocratsy
digabung
with democracy
because
democracy
is perassarat
if you
if you're
people who
people
right right
not right
not that's still bodok,
why,
Pucket,
democrys,
that's what
that's actually
the world
in the world
that's,
that's all
that's
said,
I'm going to
why.
This, this,
this,
this,
why I'm,
why I'm
not,
I'm not
the democracy,
Catea,
without
diggugugughey
with
aristocracy or
polity,
political,
to,
what,
it's,
it's,
it's,
you're,
constitution, why
I don't, I don't
not agree democracy
only because
in democracy
it only
can be margoc
demagoc
is a politicus
politicus who
pintar-numong
but
actually she didn't
know what
what you're doing
do caretackan
I was
just before
with a friend
if people
if political
now that
because demagog
wrong
if I'm
if I'm
if I'm
if I'm
there's
school,
bebas,
not use
pay.
I've been
not able to
make sure.
That's the
name of
demagok.
He's not
gittonged
too.
Numbong.
If you're
not much
like,
Jullo,
Jolla
Rada Baru,
there are
people who,
if I'm
there's a
time,
I'm going,
the
people, if
there,
there's,
there,
there's not
there,
there's a
thing,
there,
no,
the,
not the
sungion
that,
that's,
it's,
it's,
and it's
many,
and it's
many
Indonesia.
Now,
because
democracy
so much
so you're
going to be
arisocrat.
Aristocrat
is elite
elite politic
class menhengal
like,
like we
like we're
like we're
that you
have to
the situation
where
the level
the level
people
people,
the
kind of
the economy
of the
pedatone
the patuiono
the president
we're
when the
group
before
during
the
thing
what name
democracy
it
by the result of penitian
in different
in different
in different
in different
democracy.
Democracy is
never ever
ever
before
the end up
capital
in capital
minimum
$5,000
$500
US dollar
if it
not can
there
democracy.
People
must be
sell
the swarar
people
people
have been
democracy
must be
money
soar
soar
so far
and
they're
intimidation
now
per day
per day
the
the endapitant per capita
that's
about $470.7.
$4,700.
$4,700, right?
So,
so, if you're
going to be able to
$5,500, what?
In fact, $1,000,
is not?
Oh, before.
Yeah.
Before that, it
was to be 5,500.
Now,
muddha, muddha.
Yeah.
Now, if it's
that, then,
democracy we can be
good.
I'm going to,
I'm going to,
yeah,
pandan
democracy
is the day
day of
this is
the day
there are
making,
the country
be able to
make
because
democracy
not just
not just
just a
batisubusian
decuasion
but
but he has
to manifest
in
redistribusian
public goods
and
including
the seahteran
Yes.
Cesehatan,
intellect,
Nile moral,
Nile social,
whatever,
but this is
many,
the country
that's claimed
as a democracy,
not can't
redistribus
and this
impelis.
If we can see,
Gini Co-efficient
ratio,
in the country
maju,
in the country
bebeang,
in the country
miskin,
the more
encuat
to the
tension,
and it's
level.
Cesehatan,
not redistribusied.
Even in the country
like America and English,
quality health care or
or the planan of
CASEATAN.
Not as good in Singapore.
Now,
I've had a year
this,
argumentation
that's like
Singapore, that
patut be pertimbang
as a democracy.
Because he
has been
doing room,
more to
opposition,
to make
room to media.
But they're
they're
more
abysribus
public goods
intellect
and
health,
health,
social,
people are
not semarang
in,
buang somebawak
in the
moralitas
there, too.
And,
the pre-hatinan
to the
social justice and
the general
justice and
so it's,
if I'm
more than
resetties,
democracy.
Rescissue
democracy.
Now,
this,
back again
to the
time time
I'm saying
I mean I think that's about 8,8% of
from all of the homeatangue in Indonesia,
that's not have been making
the education S-1 to the top.
93% from electorate.
I see justro there's
there's a plurption
with quality of guru.
Because when a person
anna, out of the room,
one-sathinger to be able
to, to,
to get-cognition,
that is a guru.
Because the people-tweigh-n't-A-1.
Yeah.
Yeah, right.
I mean,
there's a way
to make upuracy
or democratization
with peningatting quality
guru in school.
And I'm looking,
this Indonesia
has been exist
as a democracy
is quite
but we're still
not redistribus
public goods.
How about that?
Yeah.
Yeah,
it's
confirmation
actually the theory
lamani.
Tari lamani
that I'm
I've gotakar Aristotle,
when we're talking about
in democracy
it, many
come up,
demagog,
if the
people who are
people who
want to democratized
it's still
under, and
they don't know
what,
they don't know,
they don't know,
because of that,
well,
because,
then,
then,
then,
it's because
because,
because,
because,
because,
and,
there,
and,
there,
and,
And the
the bigiaghan
Endinging
for
the stature of
guru,
and pergurant
thing,
and the
other than
the constitution
minimum 20%
from APBN
has used
for the
education,
right.
So,
the
to answer
that
to be
that the
the
education this
better
better than
the
kind of
the
kind of
more
more,
the
number,
but the
number
that, but
there are
because, because,
because of the
major just.
Because because
the government
bad, but
it's not,
not be able to
be better better
better than bad,
but more than bad,
but also,
like,
the whole,
we have a
country, and
we can
continue to
continue.
Now, one
thing that
men are putting,
democracy
it will be
being
liar if
if not
the kind of
being bad.
So,
I mean,
I was going to
there's a
doggyum
that's
which I'm
again.
We're going to be
this.
Yeah,
we're in the
government
but
democracy.
But democracy
and democracy,
and then
anarchist.
That's theory
aristotel
again.
Democracy,
if you're
beingar-k
can't,
can't,
can't,
if you're
tyranny.
Tyrannu
Dirani,
the tyrannu
the war-
murkikikikki-
can get,
the cyclis,
the course,
the theory,
Yunnanicuno, that.
Now,
so,
democracy,
without
the law,
is liar and anarchist,
but the law
if not
did build on
democratic,
it's so on-un-un-un-an.
Yeah,
right?
This,
we allame
all,
the time,
the start
all-a-wale-
with democracy,
so many,
people,
many,
many,
this,
many, this,
so,
so,
so,
so,
the,
so,
the,
order-
The new part of the time we're
back to the country
to thegak, can't,
constitution,
kind of,
that's,
now, this,
then,
constitution is,
by the power of
the power by
the power by
the power by
the power of
the power of
the democracy.
It's been
unangue
and then.
If you
democracy
there's too
too,
the country
not stable,
the people,
not maju-majue,
ma'u'am
and you're
backus,
we've got to beattac
we're,
we've been
building,
and the
Hucum,
the kendalik.
Lull,
then you
can't
come to
form of the
form of
repressive.
Now,
the task
to, this,
this,
this,
this is
un-imbanked.
Hucum
if, if
in the
language,
the abasasas
the
un-dak-a-
law-n-n-
democracy.
Democracy-c-c-d-d-lata-
and the people, nomocrats,
democracy, and
democracy, it's,
more than democracy,
it will be able to
be iraqis,
the hum can matriety.
But if,
if the lawmuffs,
the rightatting,
that's repressive.
That, that's
easy to contokan.
This is...
Parlivenu, yeah?
Parliamu,
you know,
James Robinson,
who's two
hours of Nobel,
with Darren Asimovlu.
He,
That's, he's,
the narrow corridor.
Mm-hmm.
Corridor that's...
And he, too,
and he, too,
...and there's a few
scenario.
Mm-hmm.
...that,
if the atas,
it's too quite
than the one of the
the other,
the community-louas.
Mm-hmm.
It's tendency despotic.
Yeah.
This, he,
gambarked
with, what,
yeah,
metaphor leviathan,
or naga.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The one that's too
the top is too
in the bottom
it's
this
ispotic
If it's
depotic.
If
the bottom
it's
too
yeah
too too
yeah
that's not
too
water leviatan
so it
not to
not
to where
but
he
might make
important
if it's
shackle
terbel
two-due
two-dway
two-in-
two-in-bbing
but
the kunccuncini
that is
that is
that is
the
can't
That's the penaghan who can.
Peneguang can,
the one is the same and the above
to make actualization
any of what,
the value,
the way,
the way social,
the way spiritual,
the way technology,
whatever.
It's a imbalance,
yeah,
the law.
How about,
sir.
I agree.
So,
so.
Pembangunan
the law
for the longung
to the
two of the country that's
the theory,
that's true,
can't,
if you're in people,
the law,
the law,
don't,
bang.
One, legal substance,
that's,
the,
aturances,
like what?
The law
law is,
what?
The three,
legal culture.
Now,
in Indonesia,
it's actually,
if you're
being,
yeah,
I'm,
I'm going,
the theory of
what,
the theory of,
what,
the theory of
the law,
the theory of,
the law,
in the lawcum we have,
but legal structure
the law-as.
In the place we're
the peneguacan hook.
And peneguacum
not only policy
but also bureaucracy.
Sehary-hary,
it's a pernaguer atuhran,
pedagueran,
in-law-uncturant,
if you're not-of-cuhcum,
policy-penegat-hook,
he, the, if there are
percara.
But, the day-h-h-hru-cum
must be-gallat.
It's a pyrotra-a-cura-s.
Now, this is bad,
penaggaken
the law,
the law
law,
law,
law,
the law,
the United States
is going to
be a problem
big up.
I'm going to
sell,
buy the hook
by the
people,
the people,
this is in
the same,
and it's
people,
not have
a,
not have been
money,
that's
people,
it's always,
they're
in the
bureaucracy,
which,
which,
not the
government,
but,
but,
it's,
but,
it,
Yeah, right?
It's all
until
now,
it's like,
people are
going to
how much,
yeah,
we want to
the country
to make sure
to make sure
them to make
economic if
let me end
if you,
let's say
what,
yeah,
usah,
partamangang,
usah
what,
that,
it has
newap.
Or,
the job
the government
make
the business
and then
then
give us
the
Yeah, I'm going to know
about this.
When I was going to be able to pill press.
Cawapres, that's,
that the people,
to come to say,
I'm going to be sure.
Why?
We're going to do not,
in Indonesia,
Minta I mean to do you know-sha,
to make $4,000 not out.
Mudal our money,
to murat-marit.
Dimintai Uang.
If we're paying,
then we're telling youwag.
If we're not paying,
we don't give an issue.
So we're, we're trying to do.
This is what happened in Indonesia
now this.
And, yeah, we're trying to,
President, muponged the rightan
new, this is
to be dislesiqan
this.
So, so, the question of this.
So, there's, there's,
not there, pa, in the place of it.
There's, no, pa,
I've been napeasurer from Singapore
with a person,
I said,
I'm going to investation
the government
of the
fact of the
fact that you
don't have
under the
money to make
money,
the way of the
money,
from the company,
come back,
you know,
you know,
you're doing
backer the
money,
and you can
not have
no,
I'm,
how I'm
so this
money,
but it's
give in
the law,
but the
back in the
back to,
but there,
can't be
there,
because I'm,
because I'm
not put in-
undak,
not,
not-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-d-pat-a-taped.
This is quite impious, if I'm, if I'm
if I've written, 30-tawner
pre-economian or economy
of the economy,
that's a numbering
up 10-lapen,
the end-pennapent.
And Asia-Tengara,
just 2.7-taly.
This is because of four attributes.
First, investations in the
Hong Kong, which is a lot more
bigger.
The two, investations in infrastructure.
or more much more
than in Asia
Tengara.
Three, governance.
Titic-temuantara
between power
with talent.
In there,
it's more
optimal.
Penselectsian
talental,
it's more
based on meritocracy.
Not based
on loyalty and
or patronization.
In RR.C.
Yeah.
The RR.C.
Yeah.
Dio-sahing,
to, inuk,
the number of
idyllis that
is the amount.
Tijuana,
the time,
10 per-1-1-1-1-Dawass.
people are people.
Oh, that's.
Asia, Tengara, just one.
But if we're cupas,
more than,
Philippines and Indonesia,
the I mean usahans
that's not 3.
0.3.
Per 1,000 people
per 1,000 people.
Now, I'm looking,
this is to-sikapy to the
if we're going
more be able to
be better,
if we're more
more,
and I'm
and I'm
that, I'm
if it's-pac-up
we, if we can
be-c-a-a-pick-
to make up
the world
and activity
economic
Yeah.
Good,
it's
from
the people
people
in the world
in the
law of
it's not
making that
this problem
the problem.
Right,
World Bank
also
says a
bank also
asset a
bank that
the
which,
the asset
that is
tangible,
can be
hitong,
in Rabat and
There are asset
intangible.
The intangible is
223.
The intangible
74.
44
from 77 is
penegucus.
Asset sub-negare.
How do you
want
to make
themate
a country?
If you
koukut,
it's
also
men'ttooking
44%
from
the
resigning.
SEMERDA
Alam
and
macem,
that
But if the law you're
you're not, it's going to
to be much, it's going to
to be much.
We can't look
portrait in Asia Tengara,
so it's the penaneming
which isa
Asia Tengara
every time,
to $200 million.
$200 million.
From $200 million
dollars,
who, who,
who,
population, population,
population, $6,000.
That's in Indonesia,
25-1-31-1,
per-tourn.
With population,
$280,000.
Yep.
Thailand, Malaysia, Philippines, Vietnam,
masing, masing,
10 to 20,000.
People are not because
there's batu barra
or because ideology
because,
because location
that's strategist,
because
perception
on the
of the
so if they're in Singapore
to
they're sure,
more,
even more
even,
even,
in Indonesia, Filipina, Malaysia, and in anywhere.
Now, that, if, if we're,
we're saying, we're so,
can't be incapable of the economy.
Yeah.
And, I've seen, if we're,
yeah, with the cranker that,
that we're in-tanker,
if we're in time,
that we're trying,
three percent, yeah.
Three percent from economy,
1.4 trillion,
it's only 40 million dollars.
That's, yeah?
Yeah, right?
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
1.4 trillion, it's
more than $40 million.
So,
just to find
just the
penanemal
from $31 million
to pay to
$71 million
that's even
$1,000,
that's
$1,000 to
$140.
So,
that's pretty,
to make sure
to make sure
per cent.
But,
not as
gampangang it
too.
Birocration
is lelet.
There,
there,
there,
there,
there,
this,
this,
this,
this, this,
this,
this,
this,
Right, right.
Right.
Right.
It's right.
It's not,
it's a question.
Yeah, right?
What,
it's the president.
It's,
it's just,
this,
this,
here,
it's,
that's,
there's
there,
there's
things,
like this,
like this,
right,
so,
point I'm
saying,
this is,
not a mustahillan.
Yeah, can.
Many people are people think, wow, this not
can't make sure
this is a lotematis,
because,
I think it's very
because the money
there's in the world.
It's just around.
If you're justicruh
justic-groom,
if you're going to-Mustahil,
only people
dung.
It's stiller-Germo.
But we're too
too far, like,
saying,
the people.
Now, there
also
scholar from Singapore,
namen-Y-N-U-N-U-N-U-N.
He has been
some book also.
The last
he's
he
called the
Gilded Age of China.
So,
the georgiaan
China,
it's not
better than
what what
the American
States in
and I'm
ma'am
system
corruption or
the pola corruption
in America
in the
the end of
the last
the end of
what it's
the time.
And he's
corruption, there is a
the pola corruption that is
called,
the name's speed money.
So,
the people are
to facilitate concessy,
but it's,
but there's theft,
there also,
grand theft.
Now, he,
mottabulation
some of
the country that
can't with theft
or grand theft,
and
with speed money.
Now,
the commasuan
economy in
in a couple
in the other
corruption, if there
is more
related with
theft or grand theft.
Sorry,
with speed money.
So, if
people or investor
is just who's
money, they're
okay okay just
as,
so, they're okay,
so, they're
kawal,
so,
until the penelisain
project.
But,
there's also
that's been
it's not
but not
it's
it's like
the same
and what like
to the other
yeah
yeah
yeah
this yeah
this yeah
this UN UN UN
Eng
he's professor
at Johns Hopkins
yeah
yeah
and in
Indonesia
we yeah
we're
we're
we're
we're seeing
undergela
like
people
people
who invest
people
say
payer
okay
now
yeah
but
before
before
so before
so
before
so I'm
it's like
again
But this, there's not
there's no, there's
no other
that's the
right,
that's
from the
termination
in the
back,
I'm,
now,
I'm,
I'm,
what,
what,
what,
who's,
what,
that's,
the,
that's,
in position
positivistic,
instrumentalistic.
This,
this,
backalah,
back,
back,
2009,
I'm,
2009,
I noticed
about it.
Huckom,
to,
Now, I've got to
the time of the
time of the
time in order
of the
new year,
why we're
doing reformation?
We're doing
reformation because
in the
time in order
the new
is the
human being
function,
posivistic,
postivistic,
instrumentalistic
that,
and it's
making
the
people, if
didn't
be made,
doact can
the
the time
reformation
at the
time 2009
this,
this,
there,
there,
so,
not the
not the
people,
but the
people,
but the
the people
the
Mahmachan
Constitution,
all the
that's all
until 2009, it
and it's
that's going to
like corrupts
that,
and
many,
and much,
so,
soing that
the
law,
the fact
of the
government,
and it's
the
people, and that's
saying
this,
has
to do not
the
this is
this is
the end
after the
end up
bad for the
president
make sure
even before
even before
not sure
the
what the
and then
it's not
the way,
or it's
the
protest
massacacat
not used
to be
there.
It's
like
like this.
Corruption.
Corruption.
This is
we're
we're able to
like that
it's like
it.
It's
can't
We can't, don't,
the penance corruption.
What name is,
what's the president
still one gagasan
mental, and president,
I see,
President,
he's not,
not,
not,
sungue,
I'm sure,
because he's
being, so,
I think,
he will,
be sure,
he can,
usul,
agar corruptor
do you know,
dischar,
and,
down,
down,
the money,
the country,
how?
Where,
where is,
in the
world,
this corruption,
sure
come back
dim-dial.
Who's who
can't be able to
give-same?
He's in-mally-
how-in-law-
see.
Charrant-neux-en-
back-and-shi-
if you're
doing.
Can we're
good?
Corruptcy,
you know,
well, that's,
that's the
law,
the reason,
there's a
arapasan
asset,
that,
asset-negara
be back,
the,
the,
the,
the,
Le,
pengadilance,
too,
can beamedically
asset.
If you're
down to be
hucked up,
the money of
the same thing,
but the problem.
But,
the problem,
there are people
who, it's
been right,
that's right.
So,
the asset what?
The reason is
the result
that's all right
is a passal that
not relevant.
And,
there,
there, there
there that
there's,
there,
there,
there, there,
the undang
kastana,
where the indiaeatine
it's
putecan
melalue
process
denda dendah
laloo badamai
it's there in
the lawcum
there but it
not in the
lawcum
corruption
it's in
in the
lawmic
that in
the down
economic
there under
undang
law
under peregation
undang of
pabbing and
undang biaect
it's just
that
one of the end of
Bidana economy, it can't use dendah,
if you're in the way, if you're inundup,
the bia-cukai,
so, you're going to pay youkoyne,
$12 million.
Why, you just pay $7 million?
Now, the $7.
This is not going to be didana.
This is just, it's just,
not, up to bea-cum-crups it.
Hukes, it's not,
about,
compensation.
Compensation.
Yeah.
You, yeah.
You know,
$7 million,
$7 million, from
14 million.
The 7, this
is it.
If you're in 5xal
5xed.
If you're
able to do you
can't do you
do not in the conduct
corruption,
in the time
the end up
the law
undang of usus.
Now,
now, now,
it's going to
do not over
under
under the
un-undang-kexan.
There,
not, but
hussusus
for it.
Oh,
but,
but for
Pidana Economy.
Why,
now,
now,
now,
now,
I'm going to
to the piddana corruption.
Now, I'm in order to do.
No, no use to have beenjara.
Yeah, can beabaskan just
people.
Yeah, can, sure damay.
Padhaal,
what is the sumla corruptor
in Indonesia?
If there, there's other
the alasance, too,
the DPR.
Wow, that,
that, president.
That, positivistic, insumatic.
Mencari,
car elisan hushin to,
to, make sure.
That, that, president.
Now, this, prosypensara
our capacity.
So, really, it's debasksks,
and ambiluang-loang-not-said.
I said, people are,
I'm saying,
not, data,
people who are people who,
until in the middle-2-23,
I'm still in Minkopalhuka.
That, penguins-injara
to be so many,
263,000 people,
people, people-in-pennarer in Indonesia.
It's,
even, it's over-capacity,
already, d'baw,
and, so-gand-sableness.
But 50%
than 260,000
people are
narcoba,
corban narcoba.
50%.
Then,
the 48%
more,
it's other,
the jihadan,
penjury,
penurion,
pambuance,
which,
which is,
not until
1,000%.
Cuma.
1,300
people,
from 2,
260,000.
Why, this is to bebeaskskan
with the alasan penjura pen.
Justrook, if I'm
backuncant penjura
for corruptor
which is more
than the penjara
for maling-mang-al-a-am,
bombun-and,
peggalan,
that.
Now, that,
I'm getting
haughtier.
There is a
for penagakan
of the law in
Indonesia,
is like,
the country,
like,
Singapore,
yeah,
can,
minimum to
to make up
perception
that
the
penaggan
the
penaggan
in the
law
in the
yeah
there's
there's
there
there
there
is there
let up
on the
janggy
constitution
that
this
democracy
democracy
it's
always
to give
a point
to
for the
person
to
circulation
to make
the
kind of
there
but
there
but
the
situation
Now,
now,
maybe
maybe
it's
probably there.
Can,
massaract
is more
longer than
people who
may be
un-asas
and there
is a lot of
people,
and menuntut
to be able
process
process that
is a
democratic,
it will
be a
process
penaring
cashing
and
and that
but I
think I,
that's
the important
that is
leadership,
which
the
the leadership
to
to makepercepat it
all.
Agar
harapan
that
not will
not over
the way
there.
Can
democracy?
If
the heart
about
abys,
yeah,
can,
liar,
he.
Mere Rulner,
democracy
that's never
to try
the way,
people who
have been
the product
pedigation
that's
not a
business.
It's not.
So,
School of Ska,
Biasa just.
To the
Getsk, if,
if we're
if we have
to look
to look at
system
our system
our own
product
product
Ponditken and
kogniziness can be partang-jolk.-waping.-dice, and, and,
it's not-a-capacit-a-cuit-er-cuit-er.
Yeah,
pasty.
...cestraan
that's suor-sucur
can be distribusically
as far as
how, ma'am.
I'm not,
I'm not.
I'm not
theory, theory
about it
that's more
in the quash
people who
end up
it.
This is how
curriculum
how much,
model
the model
the same
how much,
it's always
always be-
thinker-
and always
be made
in the
government
that but
I'm going to
aspect the
of the
fact of the
unlawful
people are
important and
be called by
peneguacan
human because
a person
and the
government and
the country
that's
about 20
percent that
that's
that's big
for the
and for the
people
and the
people are the
people
people who
should be
people who
there's
there who
there's been
there in Bappenas
there
some
let us
let us lookan
Like that.
Because many
Macymachem
There,
there are
that there
can't
we're going
to work
pediguan
people,
there's
some of the
result,
nationalists
not much
there's
that's a
product
of our
not bampu
bershain
because
lemah in
the bidang
in the
problem
because
economy we
we're
not,
economy
we're left
because
they're
just
Miscan, miskin, gurus yeah, not professional.
Now, this we're not-tata-smua.
But if, if you're in a good-
I'm not-
How much more?
I'm more than-curekullum?
I'm more sure to be able to be sure.
I'm more than-cureculem.
Because, kind of, curiculum, it,
not, also, not-dipake, that's the problem
my own.
If I was a guru
that innovative,
especially if
if I'm going
about what
I'm talking about,
the world
of our country
and moralities
we're lemma
now,
now,
now,
per-gueseran
that.
When I was
school,
during,
now I
heard that
in where that
the,
the,
the,
the police,
police,
it's
when he was
the
young,
the,
the,
the,
yeah,
Wow, that's how,
gurus'nialed,
deprecaritan,
peniariation,
unan,
unan, perlindulcan
anna.
And it's
many times
in Indonesia.
Guru is,
do bully
by the murid,
dilawan,
that.
Jaman,
I don't,
if I'm
not, if I'm
back,
the school,
the school,
and I'm,
people,
I'm talking,
I'm,
I'm talking to,
people,
if I'm,
if I'm raised
people,
and then,
I'm sorry,
to bring up,
there,
I'm sorry,
you can,
So, so.
So,
the guru,
with the
work-tah
to bekerjas
same,
to make sure
another.
Now,
the moral
that's wrong
that's wrong,
the law,
undang,
perlendunct,
un-undang-
un-and-a-
upon,
what,
we're,
we're,
we're
getting-a-n-a-
d'i-a-l-
people, and
the, and
the, and,
not-Mut-N-N-N-P-Pul-Rus.
Sorry,
I'm-nugnugn-s,
but,
he, is-bullet
selectssslexi-gur-s,
from top 20%
from institutions perguron
or institution of education
for intinginging.
To gawr,
Korea's Latin,
top 5%.
So,
the way the
if there's a
a one
who'su-dawan
that's
a few
people
at someupper
at Google
or at
Citibank
or at McKinsey
or Sourouu
in Seoul National University,
the many of
I'm going to teach
at the Universities
of Seoul National University.
One, compensation is,
the beda,
different, tipis,
the two,
status social.
That's very
I'm not going to
see that in Indonesia,
or not?
In the
people,
in the other
people,
because of the
because of the
not,
Same with,
the time I was in Gurawana,
when I'm going to
curawand, I'm going to
call in faculties
to doctorate or
or Mastakabri,
right?
That's,
people who are people
people who are
kind of,
who's people,
people who are
because not
the faculties of law.
But I'm
also.
But I'm going to
get to be a
person,
not many people
want to
docent, people
who's
would be
to be
Jakarta, if you're from
Jakarta,
I'd like to Jakarta,
to get the work
in Jakarta.
At the same
there, more
menjanking
in the way,
if you're
like to be
lawy who's
like this,
what's the
client-kieln't
the,
the people,
the people,
the business,
and so-laggain
that, not
want to
be a dozen
that,
someagian
from them
there,
that,
it, and,
it's,
it's,
if you,
not,
to take it's
in place
other.
So,
not the
people who
maylay
to bele
and
deselects to
get to,
yeah,
people who
people who
have been
people who
need to
get,
that's
that,
the other
who may
marr to
that,
that's
that's
that's
not,
not,
d'n't
get to
get to
go,
to,
and it,
and that,
like,
that,
maybe,
that's,
that's,
soing of
the MOTU
our
it,
that, yeah,
not,
not to be
minimuming
to make sure
a student.
And that's
also,
guru,
can also
be good,
people,
usually,
not because
because I'm,
when I'm going to
be a good,
when I'm
that, I'm going,
I'm going,
I'm going to
keep,
when what to
yeah.
Because what?
Because,
this,
because he
pint,
because he's,
because he's,
I'm going to,
I'm going,
Right, right, and then,
right, much, like that.
Now, actually, if it's
even more than,
like in Singapore,
in Korea-Selatant,
that's, that's
it, that's,
it's been giving
good.
This is,
this is,
it's quite,
with the
importance of
our
if we're
if we're
getting
great,
this,
this is in
that,
I,
People who not too
not too
not too
know
but he
is a go
about
he's able
conversing
murid who
can't be
than people
who are not
but can't
be able to
talk about.
And
the penidikin to
my
kind of
how can
make buhackan
imagination.
Not formulation
just.
Yeah,
imaginesation
yeah.
And that
the other
people
to be
important to
them more
more than
I'm not
know how I
can't
Raba, this
all can
come to
peneguangan
Hukum.
If quality
quality of
education,
if quality
good quality
guru
that's
not disikapy,
yeah,
will be
important
we're in
the way to
the
shaked
levayat
so.
So,
naga
that
belgue
to be
there's
an
power and
the
civil society.
If
not,
can be
despotic
to water.
That,
yeah,
that,
it's,
the thing
technis
operational
in
the
Because in constitution,
it's just that.
Pendidication is important
so.
Even one of the
country is,
while the policy
about the organization
that we live
on it to the middle
and the same of it,
is a person
and rediskan
to redacted by the
and it's constitution
the undang of it
the law.
If, if,
if,
if, if,
if, parabaw,
can't be able to,
but,
not pay,
not use to be
If you're
not use
pay.
Pergura
not use pay.
We're did get
guru,
gaii,
agar be able to
bekerja
with good.
That's
kind of
at the
statement.
How much
now it
is done
do you
jadeyakal
in the
land
and agaran
on the
government
and then
they're
back back.
That's
that,
yeah,
to the
the front of
this.
This is the
last
maybe,
this,
this
this is related to
tatan
dunia
that's
more multipolar
Yeah
the birth of
our own
quite
great,
yeah,
is quite
great,
as democracy
the big
number three,
population
the number
four,
economy
the economy
the number
11.
I'm
looking,
tatan
dunia
is more
multipolar.
So,
more
difficult to
make
multilateralization.
Yeah,
Or not,
we don't know,
we're more
we can't
be lateralization
with the country
or nother
or a lot of
nother job.
This is
a good good
to docket
with the
international.
This is just
too, can't,
panang of
how you know,
what I mean?
What I mean?
What's the
case?
The situation
between
the country
should be
being,
there's been
there's been
there's been
predabaten
on territorial
integrity,
the,
batas,
the country
and
and everything. And if
even if it's
just, you
have been
articulation
with just,
that's,
what?
That's,
what,
back,
the decision,
the basis of
the law.
Yeah,
if it's,
if it's,
it's just
just, but
tarol,
if I'm
giving a
example,
extreme,
that,
the
Latina
Salat,
which,
that's,
there,
there,
we have,
the,
ha,
ha,
ha,
the,
This is to the doleotan,
and there's
hapard,
territory that's
the land.
Now,
I'm into
making it,
and I'massou
by other
other,
that's,
sometimes,
it's not,
not know,
too.
Because we've
technology
technology,
technology
persenjataan
technology,
technology,
and so,
in the
Southan,
it,
how much
try,
exploration
the world,
and,
It's been a lot of the
place in the territory
we're doing.
And we're
yeah, damn
because this
this is a new
law,
while this
should be in fact
we're in the
right,
we're haq
international, but
still just.
And much
much,
there,
there's a
story to me
when I was
to be
the,
Mentry
Partanan
when the
time,
that,
that,
Malaysia,
in Antikong
there,
there,
the people of the
one 71,
this
people are this
people who are
this is a
because he
people who are
Indonesia.
But in the
people who
people who are
they've been
because of
because of the
country that
has been
to be there
soingat
we're
getting
the kind of
area
because we're
not able
to make
this,
Malaysia
make it
Malaysia make
it.
Ambalahat
the Padan
the Padan
Digitan
that can
is one
one.
Yeah,
then in
the time
that's time
there's
there's
name
committee,
so it's
committee
together,
to make
put up,
patow,
patow,
and what,
what's,
what I'm
that,
what I'm
making sure,
if,
the,
the,
the,
the,
the,
the,
apparatus,
it's,
but,
the,
technology,
the,
,
this
bigger
that.
If that
that's
what's the
point of
my time.
Even I'm
even though
there's
there's a
need to
make more
more than
people who
national.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Which is
issues like
that.
So,
that they can
be
un-uarrackan
in the
hangangue
international,
so they can
be able
and
they're not.
And,
we're doing
about
this,
so,
so,
so,
so,
when we talk to BBB,
it's synchron with
panellation,
not we're talking about
we're talking about
when we're talking about
when we're talking about
again.
Because a al-in-na,
who bring up to
who compransive.
That's important,
well,
a al-hulcominternational
and a-luburned
international also.
We've got
talked about,
we've got.
Yeah,
from 13 May,
19, 75,
Sampang?
Sampang?
Samping.
Samping.
Chapter
Berkutne of
Pama.
No, no.
I, there.
I have, I,
I have,
a book,
written by
time,
with my
talker-wachar
with me,
the title
the title of
the,
so I'm
going to be
the chapter
perikot
about,
but I'm
because I
never
in,
such a,
such-s-
and,
to be-c-
-s-c-c-c-
-to-m-
what,
want to go
to where
and go
and it.
Like,
I've got
got a
total about
I'm going to
get a lot of
but I'm
going to be
going to be
a minister
that,
that's,
I'm
I'm going to
people,
I'm doing,
too,
Tuhan.
Yeah,
can bring.
Can be
being,
who can
think,
Mahfut
MD
is,
can be
being
MENTry,
most
much,
not
too,
not
but,
there,
Dahlil
Shaiahah,
A.
Abba.
If God
when God
Dachemned Giscush
Because of it
Dixotan
That's why
Gouddou
Degh Dhabi Dhabi
Whenal,
I'm gonna make
That's it
So,
Because I'm
Because I'm
Rangangh
And that,
Nalir,
So, yeah,
Nalir,
I'm gonna,
I'm gonna,
I'm gonna,
Yeah, I'm
If I'm,
If I'm,
I'm,
I'm back
seven,
some time
68,
I came back to
that standard
cita,
I'm doing,
this is
all being
so much
25 years
to be able to
come back
here,
now now
now,
now,
again again
again to
again,
as soon.
As a
standard
cita
resim
can,
it's
being
the
design,
so,
we're
doing the
good.
Amin.
Thank you
thank you
much.
Thank you,
thank you.
Thank you.
That's good.
That's a
man,
And that's my friend, that's Professor Macfoot MD.
Thank you.
This is.
