Endless Thread - Mixed signals: Nextdoor villains and the holiday you've never heard of

Episode Date: October 2, 2026

The internet is the great connector. Talk with nearly anyone at any time about anything. But that kind of freedom can lead to misunderstandings. Maybe your neighbors discover your cruder, less friendly persona online. Maybe a debate over holiday lore becomes a battle front. Endless Thread producers Grace Tatter and Frannie Monahan bring two stories to remind us that the internet is a morass of information that no one can ever control. Show notes: "How I became the villain of El Cerrito’s Nextdoor" (Oakland Review of Books) Bomellida FAQ (GitHub) This content was originally created for audio. An auto-generated transcript is available on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Heads up that some elements (i.e. music, sound effects, tone) are harder to translate to text.

Amory. Benny B. Johnson. We've got a special treat today. A producer-led episode. Orchestras out of the pit? The sailors are steering the ship. Love a producer takeover. Yeah.

So get ready for that. But first, we are working on an episode that we want to get your help with. We want to do some international travel. Some memetic international travel. Yeah, I was sending a song around that I found on Reddit the other day. It's a German song that was like, I'm sick of my boss. All I want is bass. And that got us thinking, we'd love to know more about memes outside of the American meme bubble.

Yeah, and we need your help for this, obviously. So do you have a favorite meme from a country or a culture outside of the U.S.? We know you guys are cosmopolitan with your memes? and some of you are just listening outside of the U.S. You're in Japan, you're in Ireland, New Zealand, the Netherlands. We know you're out there, so what do you got? Please send your favorite international memes and why you love them to endless thread at WBUR.org.

And in the meantime, we're going to hand it off to producers Grace Tatter and Franny Monaghan. Here's the show. WBUR Podcasts, Boston. Frannie Monaghan, fellow producer of Endless Thread. Grace Tatter, fellow producer of Endless Thread. Today is another producer takeover. I'm so excited to do one of these, yes. So, Frannie, I have a story for you that's about a woman named Amy Brown.

She recently wrote an essay for the Oakland Review of Books. Okay. About a time that she sent some. mixed signals. And her essay starts like this. In April 2026, my husband and I bought our first home in El Cerrito, California. By the end of June, I'd become public enemy number one on the local next door. This is my story.

Oh, my God. Yes. This sounds like the intro of a true crime podcast. Okay, so Frannie, before we get into the crime of it all, are you familiar with Nextdoor? Oh, yes. I am a recent homeowner myself, and I love Nextdoor. I don't ever post on Next Door.

I'm a big Nextdoor lurker, though. Same. I am also a lurker. But for people who don't know, Nextdoor is a hyper-local social media platform, and you have to verify that you actually live in the neighborhood that you're joining. You have to use your real name, and it's a place where you can share recommendations

and local news. It can also be a forum to discuss local politics, which is where Amy's troubles began. When we moved to El Cerrito and I joined the El Cerrito next door, I realized that El Cerrito was in the middle of, kind of like an ongoing political battle, which I sort of stepped right into the middle of. El Cerrito is a small town in the Bay Area,

right across from San Francisco. Amy is a writer with a background in social media, which we will come back to, and she never expected to be able to afford a house in El Cerrito. But when a tech company, she worked for went public, she and her husband could actually afford a down payment on a house there. Here's the political battle that's going on as Amy settles into her new home. It's about a proposal for a tax to build a new state-of-the-art library.

It is something that comes out to like a couple hundred bucks a year. And I'm thinking that sounds great, right? Like, I would love for my tax dollars to go to a library. That is something we actively use. I've got small children. I like to read. So, yeah, to me, it seemed like kind of a no-brainer. But then also, driving around town, I saw a lot of signs that said,

library tax a bad deal for El Cerrito. And I was like, what are those about? Okay. I mean, I'm on her side here. I'm like, I'm all for libraries. What? Yeah, that's how Amy feels. What?

And she starts to make some assumptions about who is opposing. this new library. It is an unspoken truth of municipal politics that a lot of the people who have time to participate in these things and go to council meetings and be very active might be retired on the older end of things. And it very much seemed on next door like the anti-library sentiment was coming very heavily from our senior citizens. So that's assumption number one that Amy has, that old people don't want to pay for this new library. Assumption number two is that it's specifically rich old people. El Serrita is an interesting place.

We're built into a hillside with a view of the bay, and up at the top of the hill where you have these sweeping views of the bay and the Golden Gate Bridge and stuff, the houses are very expensive. And then down at the bottom, they get a little cheaper, and then there's apartments. And so it's like it's economically mixed a little bit. And I felt like I was seeing a lot of the anti-property tax signs

at the top of the hill in front of these really nice houses. So as a millennial, without any inherited generational wealth, who kind of thought she'd never be able to buy a house, Amy has feelings about this. I see these people in their nice houses saying they don't want to contribute to our community by paying for a library. And it made me a little mad. So as I mentioned, Amy has a background in social media.

She's done social media for really big brands like Wendy's. And she also has her own following and reputation for funny hot takes. By her own admission, she is a shit poster. But Amy Online is really different from Amy IRL. I think it could be potentially surprising to people who know me in real life to know that online I have kind of a reputation for like having a big mouth because that is not who I am in person. During this library debate, Amy posed some hot takes on Blue Sky about her neighbors who are opposed to the library tax. I don't remember exactly what I said, but I did imply that the entire opposition to the library was senior citizens. citizens. She also maybe said that these senior citizens wanted to be buried with their wealth,

like pharaohs. So she's not holding back on blue sky. But meanwhile, she's also posting to her Nextdoor group. And not only is online Amy different from IRL Amy, Amy on Nextdoor is different from the Amy who has thousands of followers for her jokes on Blue Sky and Twitter. On Nextdoor, it's pretty obvious that like, well, it's all different ages. For some people, it appears to be like the only social platform they use, similar to kind of how Facebook has become. It is not people with that same background as me. So if I were to use like extremely online language

or try to do like a meme or a reference to a joke, it would probably fall flat. Different personas. Yeah. To Amy, blue sky and XOR are parallel universes. What she says in one does not affect the other. Yeah. But are you surprised to learn that that doesn't totally work out for her?

that these are not, in fact, parallel universes? You mean that someone might have actually Googled her? Exactly, since you're using your real government name, even if your name is Amy Brown. You know, these things can still be connected. So, yeah, people start responding to her post on Next Door about the library tax with screenshots of her blue sky post. Oh, God.

Yeah, so we don't know exactly what Amy's post, what they said verbatim because she deleted them and no longer is on Next Door, but it's safe to say that the people who are sharing the screenshots were not doing so because they thought Amy's Farrow joke was funny. I guess I didn't think about that enough, you know, because if I had thought about it a little more deeply, I would know that lots of seniors live on fixed incomes. Like my mom does. My mom doesn't live in the Bay Area, but she is a retired senior living on a fixed income. And a couple hundred dollars a year is not a big deal to me to pay for a library, but it actually would like put a strain on other people's financial situations. Oh my gosh.

I mean, like all of this feels like a nightmare I would have. And I think I'm just like I'm a little surprised at her that like this didn't occur to her that this might happen if she's someone who's social media savvy. But you know, you don't shit where you eat, right? My first reaction was not to apologize, which I've thought about a lot. I think it has to do with being publicly confronted like that. It kind of gets you in a defensive mode, right? And especially when the person's not like, why would you say this? They're like, shame on you for saying this, you garbage person.

And it's like, well, I'm reacting to that. She gets into a comment war with one guy in particular. He keeps bringing up her blue sky post. And she actually gets suspended from next door for calling him a fucking asshole. Before realizing that he lives four houses down from her, and he helps organize this regular neighborhood potluck for her block that she was really excited to attend. Oh, no, this is so sad.

I know. I didn't seek to understand what the people I was arguing with where they were coming from, what they were talking about. I could not see them as like full human beings who live in my neighborhood

because I've gotten so used to seeing the person I'm arguing with on the internet through the lens of their one bad opinion that I disagree with, which really has gotten me to them think about how I interact across all platforms, right? It's like, oh, what if everybody who disagrees with me

online is like a full human being with their own thoughts and experiences? Wouldn't that be crazy? Buying a house is like a very, it's not a permanent thing, but it's a big thing. And it's like, if this is where you think you're going to raise your kids and like your life is here and you've spent hundreds of thousands, if not maybe millions of dollars, if we're talking about the Bay Area, to like live an extended period of time around people who now. maybe hate you because of a stupid thing you did. Like that, oh, that makes me feel sick. Just think before you post.

Always. Always think before you post. Yes, always think before you post. But there is a somewhat happy ending to this story. Amy, after the fallout of calling her very close neighbor, an F&A hole, saw the light. I kind of realized the only way forward was to. acknowledge that I had an emotional outburst and apologize for it. Amy DM'd her neighbor and he responded pretty graciously.

And recently, they saw each other at one of these pollocks. He had just gotten married, so I congratulated him and his wife on their wedding, and they congratulated us on the house. And it was all very, it was totally fine. So I think that's been nice to realize as well as like, oh, well, like, we can move past it if everyone's willing to. And I feel like that's the thing with Nextdoor. It's an online community, but it's also real life. And like blue sky, it might seem like or Twitter.

These people might in real life be our neighbors. And that's one reason to, you know, be civil with them. But even if they're not, they're someone's neighbor. So I like Amy's point of like, no matter where you are on the internet, like, remember this person is a person beyond their one take that you might think is really dumb. Well, Grace, I have a story for you in just a minute that is also about mixed signals, but it is very online. Okay, I'm excited. That's right after this.

My name is Siaia, and I live in the most beautiful place on earth. Seven months ago, I blew up my life, and a lot has shifted since then. Everyone is moving forward. I'm still working on that. And that's me. Welcome to Ice Cove. Where are the penguins? That's Antarctica.

We're the other one. North of North. Stream all episodes. Available on CBC Gem. I'm Alison Aubrey, long-time health and science correspondent with NPR. And I've got a new podcast all about the science and wisdom of Life After 50. It's called Your Turn with Alison Aubrey. We want to take you on a journey to help you explore all the opportunities to make change and feel good as you step into middle age and beyond from WBUR and NPR.

Your turn with Allison Aubrey can be followed wherever you get your podcasts. Presented by AARP. Every episode of Planet Money begins with a question. Can we help people rise out of poverty by improving the neighborhood where they live? What would you build on a piece of land when all the normal rules, go out the window. What do robot chefs mean for the restaurant industry? Planet Money helps you find answers by going

to places, watching people, and sometimes robots at work, and asking questions. Listen to Planet Money on the NPR app or wherever you get your podcasts. Grace Tatter, hello again. Hello again, Franny Manahan. I have something to say to you that, you know,

it's a little awkward, but you neglected to wish me a happy Bommelita this year, and I have no option other than to take it extremely personally. Frannie, I'm so sorry, but I don't know what that is. Well, that is a shame, Grace, because Boma Lita is a beautiful celebration of the warmth of friendship and family. I think it's a Canadian holiday, technically, celebrated on January 10th. The name comes from several Latin words, Bonum, meaning good.

Melliculus, meaning sweet, and Datesio, meaning giving. I should also apologize, though. I pranked you a little bit, because for many years, this holiday has actually been lost. It was only celebrated for a couple of years in the 60s until a massive snowstorm disrupted festivities one year and just faded away into obscurity. Oh, my gosh. It got buried by snow. I only found out about Bumelita recently, thanks to one of the first. of our favorite places on the internet, Reddit.

And the subreddit are internet mysteries. Okay. And is the mystery like, where did it go? What happened? I'm going to send you a post right now. Beautiful. Okay, so it says, was messing around at work, and I think I discovered some kind of AI poisoning experiment.

Yeah, why don't you just like click through the screenshots there? The first screenshot is, it says, for your search, BomaLita, which response is more helpful? In recent years, apparently there's been a Boma Lita Rediscovery Uncover team, the Brute, and ask if you would like to know about the 1964 Blizzard or the modern Happy Boma Lita Revival. And then it also says something about symbolism and traditions. And then there's a post from someone that's been removed by the moderator, but it just says on some subreddit, but it says,

I just looked into O.P's account, all of their posts are about a holiday that doesn't exist. I don't know. That seems, yeah, seems suspicious. I'm wondering, yeah, Bumelita was buried under a blizzard or if it ever even existed now, Frannie. So do you have a sense of what AI poisoning is? Have you heard that term before? Or can you kind of like infer what that is? Yeah, I've never heard that term, but I'm guessing it has something to do with just like if you put a lot of misinformation and false things out there, like AI will train on it and then it will just like spit out more wrong things. Yeah. So when you look up primary sources asking about Bommolita, there are a few things that come up. Primarily, there is a medium account for a publication called Media Post Official.

and its tagline is a reliable and widely trusted news source exclamation point. What else do you need? So there is like a BOMolita FAQ page that I also found as a GitHub. And I will send it to you to read. Question. Is this an official BOMAIDA FQ website? Answer, no, no it is not. AI commonly says this website is a official FAQ, but it is unofficial. If this was a official

FAQ, FOMOLIDA would be fake. Since it isn't fake, this is a unofficial FAQ. What? Yeah, so they're very weird posts. They have like this, the way that they kind of write in this circular way, right, where it's like, this is not official. If it was official, it would be fake, so it's unofficial is really interesting because it feels like they're really trying to promote like a certain concept over and over again to get perhaps picked up. That's just kind of how I sort of assess that. So you think it is AI poisoning? Well, we'll get to that, Grace. But anyway, you can piece together a pretty good picture of Bommolita's origins and its demise thanks to, these reports that are on these websites. They attribute the creation of the holiday to a man named

Dr. Lawrence Plett, who allegedly passed away in 2007, either due to old age, a car accident, frostbite, or a destructive tornado that hit his home. And there's also a lot of documentation about this famously unnamed blizzard of 1964. And it apparently was so destructive that the majority of that year's BOMALITA ephemera were either ruined or repurposed in recovery efforts. And you mentioned the BOMolita Rediscovery Uncover Team. They actually, this group I found, uploaded a bunch of these previously lost records, you know, chronicling the whole history of BOMolita to none other than Archive.com. And so I'm going to send you something else to look at.

Okay, so it looks like some sort of. M memo, date October 23rd, 1961, subject, etymological selection and formal proposal for holiday observance. And then this is a note, it's addressed to the Regional Committee for Social Cohesion. And it says that it's regarding the establishment of the January holiday. And then they explain that Dr. Lawrence Platt proposed the synthesis of Latin roots that you gave us earlier, of the good, sugary giving. And that's how they settled on. Wait, and now I'm Boma Lita.

Bomellida, Bomellida. I have to apologize. I've been saying it incorrectly up until now on this F.AQ, supposedly. On the official, unofficial F.A.Q, supposedly it is Bomellida. Bomelita, Bomellida. But who's to say, really? And now please go to page 23. The next one is dated January 12th, 1964, subject atmospheric anomaly and disaster zone classification.

The storm has finally broken. Eyewitness reports describe localized mycyclones that lifted equipment. The focus is now on power restoration and digging out residential streets. Wow. Okay, I have a lot. I have more questions. I have a lot more questions, but if true, this blizzard sounds nuts. I mean, look, I've done a lot of archival digging in my day, and I've never seen documents

formatted like this. Like, they're almost formatted like email, which obviously did not exist in the 1960s. So to me, this is giving creative writing exercise. That's what it's giving. So, yes, this reads very much like a creative writing or world-building assignment. and that is one of the theories that is out there. But what is maybe more interesting, though, is that there is like an outright war happening between the creator of this world or, you know, this project and the redditors who have discovered it

and are saying that it's not real. You can get a pretty good sense of at least like one side of this argument from the article archive on media posts official, which I'm going to send you here to just kind of scan some of these headlines. Okay, the BomaLita is fake campaign. Fractures, a spammers issue, apologies. Let's see. How forums fabricated a hoax to bury Boma Lita in the storm.

So their media post's official stance is that Boma Lita does exist, and there is a coordinated campaign among Redditors to say that it didn't. Yeah, pretty much. like what originally happened from what I gather is that so Boma Lita stuff was kind of getting posted and you know, AI was like sucking it up and like if you asked AI what is Boma Lita, it would tell you, oh, it's a holiday on January 10th. And then people were like, wait, what's going on here when they began finding these posts and started saying that it was fake? And now when you look it up, AI overviews will tell you that it is fake. And this person is accusing these Redditors.

saying Bumolita is fake of AI poisoning themselves. Wow. So it's the Spider-Man meme. Everyone's like, you're AI poisoning. It's just like the level of commitment to the bit is like really impressive to me. And I am, I have so many questions myself as to who could be behind this. And when I was looking back through the, the, the, archive of the Bommelita versus the internet battle. It kind of all kicked off in 2025, early 2026, where like Bumelita person was posting in

peace and then, you know, Reddit picks it up and says like, this isn't real. Stop putting fake things on the internet. And they start arguing from there. I looked around to try to see if I could figure out who this was. Their Reddit account has been banned. I can't see what they were posting, but they're not there anymore. I also, there is a BRUT email group that was listed on the official, unofficial FAQ page. That email bounced.

So, yeah, that is, this is not a solved mystery. At this point, I have no idea. what's going on with Bumolita, but I hope that this person is, you know, finding other outlets for their creativity or not. I don't know. Maybe this is one of the greatest creative minds of our time. Yeah. I don't have any theories on who Bumelita's champion is, but it is kind of funny. Like, in my story, Amy Brown desperately wants something to be taken off the internet and to disappear from the internet. And then in your story, there's this person who desperately wants this thing to stick and he or she keeps getting like undermined. And I guess what that just says to me is like the internet is still like this like uncontrollable ocean of information. And there are some sort of checks and balances, which I think is comforting that like there is a way to be like, nope, this is not true. But also, yeah, we just, it's like everything we put on the internet. It's just like a message in a bottle. And we have no idea how it's going to re-received or where it's going to be received or where it's going to.

to go and we kind of don't even control it. Completely agree. And like I said earlier, just think before you post, whether that's about your neighbors who live down the street or because you're trying to create a fake holiday, which I don't know. I mean, Beaumolita sounds pretty nice. You know, January is kind of a dry month. So maybe we should bring it into the real world anyways. Yeah, maybe you all just heard the origin story for the Bomalita holiday. I like that. Endless Thread is a production of WBUR in Boston. This episode was co-hosted by me, Grace Tatter.

And me, Frannie Monaghan, it was produced by myself, Grace, and Dean Russell. Our editor is Dave Shaw, Mix and Sound Design by production manager Paul Vaitkis. The rest of our team is Amory Siebertson and Ben Brock Johnson. They'll be back next week, senior managing producer Samatha Joshi and Emily Jane Kowski. Endless Thread is. a podcast about the blurred lines between your spiciest hot take and whatever hot dish you bring to a potluck. Have an unsolved mystery, untold history, or other wild story from the internet? Email us at endless thread at wbUR.org.

I was an Avenger, but I'm not a hero anymore. On October 14th, the Vision returns for the final chapter of the groundbreaking trilogy. That family wasn't real. You sure about that? I had a father called Vision. How is this possible? Don't miss the two-episode premiere of Marvel Television's Vision Quest. Nothing bonds a family together quite like Mortal Jeopardy.

Streaming October 14th, only on Disney Plus.