Entertainment & Celebrity News Today | 2 Min News | The Daily News Now! - Asimov's Star Trek Critique: The Final Frontier
Episode Date: March 15, 2026Isaac Asimov, a renowned science fiction author, had a love-hate relationship with Star Trek, particularly its fifth movie, The Final Frontier. He criticized the film for straying from the franch...ises intellectual roots and embracing too much action and questionable themes. Despite his disappointment, Asimov appreciated Star Treks handling of social issues and respect for smart characters, making it a meaningful series beyond just adventure. Support the show:Get a discount at https://solipillow.com/discount/dnn. Advertise on DNN:advertise@thednn.ai This is an automated, high-level news summary based on public reporting.Report issues to feedback@thednn.ai. View sources & latest updates:https://sources.thednn.ai/2b26b2700dfb0244
Transcript
Discussion (0)
I'm Corey, and this is your entertainment pulse.
Entertainment and Celebrity News today,
Isaac Asimov, the legendary science fiction author,
had strong opinions on Star Trek,
especially its fifth movie, The Final Frontier.
He reviewed the script before release
and called it a major letdown for the franchise.
Directed by William Shadner,
without Gene Roddenberry's direct input,
the film strayed from Star Trek's smart science-based roots
into too much action and questionable themes.
Roddenberry shared the script with Asimov for feedback, and the writer was blunt in his memos.
He worried it abandoned the rational approach that defined Star Trek and tackled sensitive topics in a way that could upset many viewers.
Asimov felt the story just did not fit the intellectual spirit of the series.
Fans and critics largely agreed with Asimov after the movie came out.
It earned a low 5.5 out of 10 on IMDB and drew plenty of backlash online.
The films and balances and odd plot choices made it one.
of the weakest entries in the franchise. That said, Asimov loved Star Trek overall.
In a 1973 convention interview, he praised its handling of real social issues, respect for smart
characters, and ideas like the Prime Directive. He saw it as meaningful sci-fi beyond just
adventure. Asimov's mix of praise and tough critique shows his honesty as a fan and thinker. His
words still sparked discussion among Trekkies today, reminding everyone that even beloved series
have weak spots. We'd like to thank
our sponsor for making this episode possible.
It is a pillow that plays your podcast and music without earbuds, built for listening in
bed, soli, solelypillow.com.
