Fantasy Football Today - 0.5 PPR Mock Draft Review! When Were the Rookies Selected? (04/13 Fantasy Football Podcast)

Episode Date: April 13, 2020

Finally we get to draft some rookies, even if we don't know which NFL teams they'll be on. Today we discuss our 0.5 PPR mock draft after we reflect on the XFL (3:25) which might be finished after a h...alf season. What would we like to see the NFL borrow from the XFL? ... Getting into the mock draft, let's take a look at when the rookie RBs (5:00) and WRs (12:00) were selected. Is there a scenario in which a rookie RB becomes a workhorse this season? Also, how did our strategy change in the 0.5 PPR format (18:03)? When should Michael Thomas go (22:04)? And we reveal our teams and strategies (26:33) ... We bring on a very special guest Robert Thomas who moderates our Facebook group (41:00). Robert asked our listeners questions about this draft and we reveal their answers. Best picks. Worst picks. Best teams and more ... Email us at fantasyfootball@cbsi.com and tweet us with #AskFFT 'Fantasy Football Today' is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Stitcher, Google Podcasts, Castbox and wherever else you listen to podcasts. Follow our FFT team on Twitter: @FFToday, @AdamAizer, @JameyEisenberg, @daverichard, @heathcummingssr, @YardsPerGretch, @BenSchragg Watch FFT on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCviK78rIWXhZdFzJ1Woi7Fg/videos Join our Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/FantasyFootballToday/ Sign up for the FFT newsletter https://www.cbssports.com/newsletter To hear more from the CBS Sports Podcast Network, visit https://www.cbssports.com/podcasts/ To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports. Here we go! Email us at fantasyfootballatcbsi.com. Here we go! It's time to dominate your fantasy league. Let's go! Now, here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, and Heath. Welcome to another Mock Draft Monday on Fantasy Football Today.
Starting point is 00:00:24 Mock Draft Monday across CBS Sports. You can watch CBS Sports HQ and get some Mock Draft Monday on Fantasy Football Today. Mock Draft Monday across CBS Sports. You can watch CBS Sports HQ and get some Mock Draft Monday. You can listen to the Pick 6 podcast and get some Mock Draft Monday. Real players, not fictional players. I'm Adam Azer, Dave Richard, Jamie Eisenberg, Heath Cummings here. Three episodes this week, three episodes every week. For now, hope we're keeping you entertained. What's up, guys? I had a really fun weekend. I played, in case you're wondering, I played Family Trivia via Zoom. It was awesome. I recommend it to everyone.
Starting point is 00:00:52 How was your weekend, guys? Anybody have a fun weekend? Yeah, it was great. Yeah? Did you do anything? We bought a new slide for the pool, so the kids enjoyed that. And a lot of bike riding. Is the slide blue? The slide is blue and white yes every slide is blue new slide huh all right let me know when
Starting point is 00:01:13 when i can come over and test it out anytime you want buddy yes after the quarantine is over heath guess what what love your team from this draft. There's really like I was just going to say the names of the players that I drafted and then just not offer any other analysis because I think it pretty much speaks for itself. This is maybe the best team I've ever drafted. Well, we'll see about that, but it's
Starting point is 00:01:38 a good team. It's a half PPR, 12 team league. We don't talk all that much about half PPR, so I'm really looking forward to today's show. Also today, Robert Thomas is joining us. For those of you in the Facebook group, Fantasy Football Today, you know who Robert Thomas is. For those of you who listen to Matchbox 20, might think you know who Robert Thomas is, but this is the real one. He basically, along with Shraggy B, moderates our Facebook group. He posts a lot of topics. He's the man. He's going to come on and he posted some topics about this draft in the group. And he'll tell us what the Facebook users think.
Starting point is 00:02:13 Best team, worst team, best picks, stuff like that. And we'll also have some fun with it. Some of the more fun topics that we've had in the Facebook group, Fantasy Football Today. So getting into the draft here, I just, oh, speaking of the draft, you know, our NFL draft contest, give you a chance to get into the podcast league. Well, we are giving away our first spot in the 2020 Listeners League, and we're going to do it through Facebook. Either go to the Facebook page, Fantasy Football Today, just search for that, or click on the link in the episode description. It'll take you directly to the
Starting point is 00:02:48 post, or at least take you directly to the Fantasy Football Today group. I'm not sure when exactly we'll post the contest, because I know you probably want to submit those picks closer to the draft. But basically, you predict the top 10. That's all you have to do. Predict the top 10. But it has to be in order. You can't just
Starting point is 00:03:03 say, hey, I got eight of the 10 people who were drafted in the top 10. It has to be in the order they were drafted. I recommend waiting a little while. No need to get these in that early, but we're going to do it through the Facebook group this year. Whoever gets the most right is in the group
Starting point is 00:03:16 and we'll have to settle any ties, probably randomly. And Friday, we're going to talk about the wide receiver prospects for the draft. I didn't have a lot of news and notes, guys, but it does appear that the XFL is going to be done. And quite frankly, Dave, I think you might share. I'm sad about that because I really enjoyed the XFL.
Starting point is 00:03:33 I thought it was good. I enjoyed it, too. I watched a lot more of it than I thought it would. I thought it was fun. I thought the play was better than the AAF and the XFL the first time around. And I liked a lot of the rules. I hope the NFL takes a look at some of those rules and starts implementing at least the Sky Judge this year and maybe some other ones. I know that there's a rule proposal for instead of an onside kick, you can have a fourth and 15 play from your own 25.
Starting point is 00:04:03 I'm interested to know how that one does and if that one passes this year. That would make things fun for an onside kick replacement late in games in 2020 and beyond. Would you guys want NFL players to be interviewed on the sideline during the game as the XFL players were? No, I want NFL coaches interviewed on the sideline like xfl coaches were i want a sideline reporter in bill belichick's face i want to know what that what that sounds like and whether or not he just you know just straight up stiff arms them or if he actually gives a thoughtful answer spoiler alert yeah have you ever seen uh g Greg Popovich during in-game interviews? I think he can give you a preview of what that would be like.
Starting point is 00:04:49 But Pop's so funny. Those are cherished. Belichick would not be funny. He wouldn't say anything. Maybe equally as forthcoming. Or he'd mumble a few words. I mean, you've heard him at halftime interviews. He doesn't say anything. Yeah. And he used to do those. All right. Hey, let's do this here.
Starting point is 00:05:04 Half PPR draft, 12 teams, three wide receivers and a flex, two running backs, one quarterback, and this time the rookies were eligible to be drafted. The first rookie was Jonathan Taylor. He went 35th overall, and he was basically the only rookie taken in the top 60.
Starting point is 00:05:20 You had DeAndre Swift go 58th. You had Cam Akers go 61st. Did I miss anyone, Jamie? I think he was the only one in the top 57 picks, Jonathan Taylor. I think so. Okay, because DeAndre Swift would make sense as the second rookie off the board. Once we got to basically the end of round five, about 60th overall, 58th was Swift, 61st, Akers, CeeD CD Lamb, Jerry Judy, J.K. Dobbins,
Starting point is 00:05:47 all in round six not long after Cam Akers went. So it took about 60 picks before the rookie started coming off the board other than Taylor. Would you like a funny story about that? Oh, yeah. Yeah, sure. So we were doing our – every Monday we do this mock draft for CBS Sports HQ, NFL mock draft.
Starting point is 00:06:04 So that was going on at the same time of our fantasy mock draft. And there was, I think, at least four people in this mock draft that were either tied up to that or doing some other stuff and not paying attention. So I queued up a bunch of rookies and I was making picks for a couple of teams and myself. I like Cam Akers a lot. I think he's going to be really good. But I thought Dobbins was taken when I took Akers over Dobbins. So I would have taken Dobbins over Akers. I was wondering about that.
Starting point is 00:06:33 Okay. That was trying to do too many things at once. And if it was a real draft, obviously, I would have probably said something. But since we're just having fun. When did you realize it? Because Dave took Dobbins 10 picks. When Dave took Dobbins. Oh, okay. Oh, if it were a real draft, I would have... I thought he was gone. I was,
Starting point is 00:06:51 you know, like I said, trying to do too many things at once. Well, if it had been a real draft and you had noticed 10 picks later, I don't think we would have honored it. As the commissioner, I would have just changed it myself. You would have just given Dave Akers or what? No, Dave could have had another pick.
Starting point is 00:07:08 I would have just said, you guys can go to hell if you don't want to do the league. Well, that seems fair. I like that. Well, what did you think about that, guys? I mean, I know we have to wait to see where he goes, but if Jonathan Taylor goes to a team that's, you know, it seems like it's obvious they're going to make him their workhorse, he's going to go a lot earlier than 35th i would imagine so let's start with that heath and taylor going 35th that was like after chris carson after leonard fournette what'd you think of that well i
Starting point is 00:07:36 think and i wrote about this in terms of best ball adp um taylor's actually out of the top three rounds right now for best ball adp and i think it's it's because there's still a lot of risk I've seen multiple mock drafts where Jonathan Taylor is not the first running back taken I've seen a couple of mock drafts where Jonathan Taylor is not in a situation that I really like now yeah I like let's just say if somehow he gets drafted by Tampa Bay or even by the Chiefs, I think there's a chance he could be a borderline first-round pick by the time we get to August. But if he goes in the third round to a team like the Lions, then he might be a fifth-round pick. So I think everyone's kind of hedging, and that's why it's so it's so difficult
Starting point is 00:08:27 in redraft even in dynasty it's hard but in redraft especially it's so difficult to place these rookies before they've actually been placed a guy that i was really high on last year before the draft and a lot of people were too it wasn't just me hakeem butler and then nobody in the nfl wanted him. And then he just didn't even play. He was on injured reserve all year. So the draft will tell us some things that we don't know right now about what 2020 is going to look like. Okay.
Starting point is 00:09:00 So I don't want to spoil Friday's show because it's our wide receiver prospect preview. But first I'll just make a point about running backs. I mean, look, if a running back gets taken in the top 10, like Barkley, like Zeke, like Fournette, like McCaffrey, you pretty much know in most cases they're going to get a lot of work and they're going to get it early. Week one, right? Teams are going to be committed, but we're not going to have any of that. We might not have a running back taken in the first round this year. So you might have a, sometimes you see a more gradual, like Nick Chubb. Nick Chubb didn't have any work until they traded Carlos Hyde. He might have a more gradual ascension into that role.
Starting point is 00:09:30 Like Miles Sanders. Yes, exactly. The thing you're rooting for with the NFL draft right now is Miami's third pick. You want the Dolphins to take a running back with their third pick. Well, do you? Because they have Jordan Howard now. I don't care about Jordan Howard. I care from a fantasy perspective.
Starting point is 00:09:45 I think Jordan Howard being there means they're going to be – but they're not taking a running back with a third pick. No, he's saying with their third first-round pick. Oh, okay. 26th overall, I believe. Yeah. Okay, I'm sorry. That's what he meant.
Starting point is 00:10:00 They don't even have the number three pick. They have the number five pick in the first round. Yeah, no, no, no. Their third first number three pick. They have the number five pick in the first round. Yeah, no, no, no. Their third first round pick. If you're looking for – that would show you that a team is aggressive to go get somebody to be their guy. You're not worried about Jordan Howard in that regard? They signed Jordan Howard to a one-year deal. He's on his third team in three years for a reason.
Starting point is 00:10:21 He couldn't finish the season last year because of a shoulder injury. I mean I understand that he's going to take some work, but any of these guys going to situations are going to, no one is walking into a featured job on day one. There's just no openings right now. Even Tampa Bay, Ronald Jones is not just going to sit. Right.
Starting point is 00:10:36 Can't say the same thing. Right. You know, so no, no, none of these rookies are walking in to the scenario you said of Fournette or Barkley or Zeke. They're not stepping into, here's 25 touches.
Starting point is 00:10:47 It's just not realistic right now. But if you see a situation, like to me, Miami is the opening of openings in terms of somebody can take the job. Tampa Bay could be the same thing. I don't disagree with that. But I think that will take some time. So if you see, because to me, Miami is the one that makes the most sense without a team trading in. Yeah. Okay.
Starting point is 00:11:09 But I also think Miami will use multiple backs. Okay. That's the point. Hashtag Patriots. That's the point. I think you're going to see a scenario of they're all going to share work. Right. But it's which team is prioritizing that position. And so if it's Miami taking one in the first round, they're putting some emphasis on the position because they have a lot of capital and it's a need.
Starting point is 00:11:31 I just think Jordan Howard, he's a very good back. He's proven to be good when he's gotten work, but he's not special. And so he's, as we saw last year, whether it was the injury that opened the door for Miles Sanders, which is probably the case, or Sanders is just that much better and it would eventually have happened. I think the same thing will happen in Miami, more so from a talent standpoint, that eventually somebody will take the job from Jordan Howard. I know what you're saying, Adam, that for fantasy, it's not the most ideal situation, but I just don't see a most ideal situation for any of these rookies. Well, that's pretty interesting.
Starting point is 00:12:02 And I think that's shaping, that's framing where these running backs were backs were taken if only one of them going in the top 50 picks uh what was your just your thought process with the wide receivers because last year was a good year for wide receiver for rookie wide receivers but even in a good year for rookie wide receivers you know they're they're usually not they usually don't have the same impact that those rookie running backs have i think that's fair to say and um you know they didn't go they went around six cd lamb and jerry judy i think they went back back to back so after the top 60 picks uh dave what was your just your thought it's a three receiver league plus a flex and it's half ppr so you need some receiver depth for sure uh were you surprised that where the where the rookie wide receivers went?
Starting point is 00:12:45 What were you thinking going in? I was definitely surprised. I thought that that was a little too soon for Lamb and Judy, especially ahead of guys like Debo, Jarvis Landry, who may not be ready for the start of the season. We'll see what that looks like come August. Even Julian Edelman. I thought it was a little surprising that they went ahead of Edelman
Starting point is 00:13:04 in a half-point PPR. We don't know. Fit matters so much for all these receivers. They're great talents, okay? Lamb is amazing. Judy is amazing. I know a lot of people love Henry Ruggs. I think his speed is amazing.
Starting point is 00:13:18 But until we know what type of a situation they're going to be in and we can gauge what their target share might be, I think round six is preposterous. And I think round seven might be the absolute earliest I would consider one. So what I've been thinking all along is that Philadelphia is the landing spot, right? Like if Miami is going to be Jamie's spot for a running back, I think Philadelphia is the landing spot for a receiver. I'd love one of those top three guys. And even one of the other guys, Mims, Rager, Jefferson.
Starting point is 00:13:44 Do you feel that way for 2020 if they bring back Jeffrey and they're keeping Deshaun? Yes, because I don't know if Jeffrey is going to be ready to go and Deshaun isn't going to be the number one target getter in that offense. But I think a rookie could be a rookie is not going to be a number one target getter there. I think he's accurate. No. Well, OK, that's fair. Fine. So the remaining receivers, I think Lamb could do it. I can see a situation, though, just in terms of like, is it better to be... Like long term, I think Philadelphia is the best landing spot just because Jeffrey's not long there, obviously, and Jackson's 33. We don't know what our Sega white side could become.
Starting point is 00:14:20 And obviously, it's a good opening. I just wonder if for this year, we'll... I mean, obviously, if they get Lamb or Judy, I think it's a good opening. I just wonder if for this year we'll – I mean, obviously if they get, you know, Lamb or Judy, I think it's a steal. You know, and then that guy becomes what should be the right receiver. Sure, and it's totally different if it's one of the other guys. I'm just curious to see – sorry, Heath. I'm just curious to see what's going to happen if, you know, the second guy in Green Bay is better than the first guy
Starting point is 00:14:41 or the first receiver drafted. You know, like if they get Mims or Rieger or one of the guys in that range, T. Higgins, whatever route they decide to go, is that player better for fantasy than Philly or the Jets or the Raiders? Yeah, there's two things working against this class for me. It's that the very best,
Starting point is 00:15:01 the top of the class, the place you see them mocked most often is to the Raiders, to the Jets, to the 49ers, to the Broncos. None of them really excite me all that much for someone having an impact in year one. The other thing is just what's going on. Even with the optimistic football is going to start the first week of September and everything is going to happen with the season, what amount of work are these receivers, because it matters to them more than it does the running backs, going to get with their entire coaching staff and quarterback
Starting point is 00:15:33 before the start of the season? That could make it really tough on them early in the year. That's a really good point. The other thing we talk about a lot is the first two guys drafted last year were by far the best. So don't necessarily fall in love with, hey, Lamb and Judy and Ruggs were the first three guys off the board. Even if they end up in
Starting point is 00:15:52 good spots. Wait, the first two guys last year were not the best. That's what I'm saying. Nikhil Harry and Marquise Brown were not the best. So it was McLaurin, it was Metcalf, it was Debo, it was A.J. Brown. Those guys were day two, day three picks, and they ended up in better situations. Right.
Starting point is 00:16:09 And how good were they? A.J. Brown was the only wide receiver that was top 20 in either format. He was 10th in non-PPR, he was 21st in PPR, something like that. We did not have a top 20 rookie wide receiver in PPR, even though we had a pretty strong year for rookie wide receivers. But it's just hard to do. However, and again, we'll get to this on Friday, I think that the excitement for CeeDee Lamb and Jerry Judy is something we haven't had in a long time, I'd say.
Starting point is 00:16:36 I mean, at least for me, I'm really excited about those two guys. And the excitement overall for this wide receiver class is just through the roof. But I won't be on the show Friday. I'm taking the rest of the week off. Got a lot of things planned. Going to stay home for four more days. I heard you're going golfing, right? Yeah, right.
Starting point is 00:16:54 But I think that Lamb and Judy, this could be A.J. Green and Julio Jones. These could be guys we're talking about for a long time as stars, and I'm hopeful for it. So I did want to get them, and it was interesting. I took Deebo Samuel at one point. I was hoping actually to get Lambert Judy. It's interesting to hear Dave just say that Deebo should have gone ahead of them.
Starting point is 00:17:16 He didn't. I was the recipient of that, the beneficiary of that. So you would have taken one of the rookies ahead of Deebo if they had fallen with either either the last pick around six. Yeah, and here's the thing. That is sort of like I expect the Niners to draft a wide receiver fairly early. If they don't, I would take Debo. If they do, I would go with one of those rookies.
Starting point is 00:17:36 Of course, it will depend on everything that happens after the draft. Let's say they take Lam or Judy at 13. Who's the best receiver on the 49ers right now? I think it's Lam or Judy. I mean, you can't really compare them as prospects to Debo. I think they smash him in that regard. They're better long-term prospects for sure.
Starting point is 00:17:53 I would take Debo in 2020. I would agree with that. And I think Judy would be a better fit for the 49ers than Lam would. We will get into that a little bit more on Friday. Before we get Robert Thomas on, let's just talk about half PPR and how you guys approached it.
Starting point is 00:18:12 Did you approach it more like full PPR, more like standard scoring, non-PPR? Heath, what did you think with this format? I mean, I approach it more like full PPR and just discount the guys that I know. Like one of the most difficult decisions I had, and it did not end up being a decision that mattered, which is kind of funny. But in the second round, I've got DJ Moore one spot ahead of Mike Evans in PPR. I've got Mike Evans ahead of DJ Moore in non-PPR. Evans ahead of Moore in non-PPR, Moore ahead of Evans in PPR. In half PPR, I've got Mike Evans ahead of DJ Moore in non-PPR. Evans ahead of Moore in non-PPR, Moore ahead of Evans in PPR. In half PPR, I was really...
Starting point is 00:18:49 Do you like Moore of Evans? Just keep saying Moore and Evans, and we'll get it right eventually. I took Evans because it was half PPR. I would have taken DJ Moore in full PPR. Now, thankfully, DJ Moore fell to the middle of the third round, and I just took him with my third round pick. It's one of those rare times. Don't you love that though? Um, for that happens, I will say, and I said this after I made the pick and I hadn't, I'm normally really bad about answering. I like this pick. I prefer to have this pick. Um, the sixth pick is really nice because you know, you're going to get one of what i think is a big
Starting point is 00:19:27 five at running back and or michael thomas and so it was pretty easy to just take alvin camara when he came to me at number six and i would have felt the same way if it had been dalvin cook or thomas or barkley or or elliot and then the other thing is you're never waiting too long because you're right in the middle of the draft so the sixth pick might be my favorite pick this year. Did anybody else approach it like mostly PPR? I mean, maybe you approached it like half PPR. I mean, the players that are fully impacted by PPR, I'm thinking of mostly running backs here, like James White, guys like that. I wouldn't take them like I normally
Starting point is 00:20:03 would in a full ppr draft but otherwise yeah you get points for those catches it might not be as much but they still matter makes you want to prioritize receiver just a little bit more than you normally would i mean i was in a spot where i i kind of was almost you kind of your hands forced at 12 you know a little bit so i took two two receivers. Who'd you get? Yeah. I took Godwin and Hopkins. I mean, it was hard to pass up on those two guys.
Starting point is 00:20:29 I would not have done that. I would have taken a running back. I actually sort of lean toward non-PPR scoring in half PPR. I don't know that there's a right answer here, but it's still a guy like Marlon Mack, a guy like Mark Ingram, maybe even a guy like Derrick Henry, I don't know. You still kind of downgrade them because they catch so few passes.
Starting point is 00:20:52 But maybe instead of having like 50 catches as the threshold where I feel like a guy's really contributing in the passing game and there were 13 or 14 guys who did that last year, maybe it's more like 30 to 35 catches for a running back um but i would have wanted because okay in non-ppr running backs are king right in non-ppr at the top 36 players last year each of the top five eight of the top nine twelve of the top 14 were running backs not even close to that in PPR. Running backs are king in non-PPR. I don't know that I could go my first two picks without taking one
Starting point is 00:21:29 running back in half PPR. They're still... Also, keep in mind, it's a three-receiver league. It's not bad to have... I love my receivers. I don't really like your running backs. I still was able to get running backs I like. You got Todd Gurley and James Conner.
Starting point is 00:21:47 I mean, that could be really good. It's a lot of work. And Cam Akers, although that should have been J.K. Dobbins. Yeah, and Edwards Hilaire and Kenyon Drake. No, not Kenyon Drake. I mean, excuse me, Cream Hunt. I just went about collecting guys. It's almost the same thing.
Starting point is 00:22:01 Okay. Michael Thomas went third overall. What did you think about that? You know what I'll say. I don't hate it. It's really tough once you get past McCaffrey to say you should definitely take one of those running backs over Thomas. It's also really tough to choose which running back to take over thomas and so
Starting point is 00:22:27 i like it's a much easier choice to just take michael thomas in that spot so you don't get the full credit for each catch there's a chance that those targets could go down emmanuel sanders is there i know you don't think much of emmanuel sanders i don't know where did he go in this draft he was a top 100 100 pick. They could add another player there. A lot of people on this podcast think Alvin Kamara is going to keep up his role. Strubeary is going to throw 650 times. It's possible, but I wouldn't bet on it. I would easily take a running back over Michael Thomas at two, three, or four,
Starting point is 00:23:00 and probably even five in the half PPR format. In this format. He was the third best player in this format last year. He was, but he averaged about the same amount of points per game as Derrick Henry, and he had 131 more catches than Derrick Henry. Henry had nine more touchdowns. Michael Thomas scored more fantasy points than Saquon Barkley per game last year, even if you take away the Tampa Bay game in which Barkley got hurt.
Starting point is 00:23:26 And it wasn't even really close. He scored one and a half more points per game than Barkley. But Barkley scored a lot more fantasy, probably about two more fantasy points per game, 1.8 more fantasy points per game in 2018 than Thomas did in 2019. Kamara averaged about two points per game more in 2018. Actually, no, it was two and a half more points per game for Barkley. Whatever.
Starting point is 00:23:51 They both walloped Thomas in their best seasons, put it that way. And got walloped by him last year. Yes. But what I would say is the ceiling for Michael Thomas, I don't think he can do better than he did last year there's it's almost no chance i think it's much more likely he finishes like he did in 2018 he could have a season where he scored like there's no reason to think that michael thomas won't have a season where he scores 12 touchdowns i guess so but still like he's i would expect him
Starting point is 00:24:21 to lose 25 catches and yards too. Oh, if you're talking expectation, sure. I just don't think we should act like expectation is the same as upside. Well, and the other thing to factor in is that you're talking about a position that doesn't get injured as much. I mean, we saw Barkley last year. That's the one that's the comparison. I think those are the top three players, McCaffrey, Barkley, and Thomas.
Starting point is 00:24:45 Dave took Zeke. He likes Zeke better, so I get that. But, I mean, I think, you know, if you get all these guys in this format playing at their best, Thomas replicating last year, I think he'll be better than the old guy. I don't because I think we've proven that Barkley at his best was a lot better than Thomas. Kamara at his best was a lot better than Thomas. Kamara, at his best, was a lot better than Thomas. That's just based on 2018 versus 2019. The running back that's... The elite running back is better than the elite wide receiver in this format. And it's actually...
Starting point is 00:25:16 It wasn't even close if you compare just Michael Thomas to what we saw from Barkley and Kamara and McCaffrey the last few... 2018. I'm curious, Heath, what's the projection that you have for Michael Thomas? The projection that I have for Michael Thomas is 130 catches for 1500 yards and nine touchdowns.
Starting point is 00:25:43 And that puts him where overall? That in half PPR, that would put him. Sorry. It's okay. Looks like a fourth. So third was way too early. Yeah, obviously. Right. Okay. So third was way too early. Yeah, obviously.
Starting point is 00:26:07 Right. Michael Thomas is more likely to hit his projection than a running back is. Yeah, that's fair. So let's bring Robert Thomas on in about 10 minutes. Until then, let's just talk about our teams and how we built
Starting point is 00:26:24 our teams and if we liked our teams and what we would do differently. Okay, so again, half PPR. We'll go in order of pick and I'll just be really quick with my team. I had the first pick. So I took Christian McCaffrey one. I took Adam Thielen and Juju Smith-Schuster in rounds two and three. Yeah, I don't know. I didn't really love it. I think maybe I could have taken Leonard Fournette there instead of one of those wide receivers because, well, I like both of those wide receivers. And in their best case scenario, Thielen and Juju, those are great picks at 24 and 25 overall. But there are obviously a lot of question marks about those guys. Age and health for Thielen, a lot for Juju. We just don't know.
Starting point is 00:27:07 Fournette was the next running back off the board. He had the seventh most carries, the fifth most catches among running backs. He had 1,674 total yards. Only Michael Thomas had even 1,400 yards among receivers. But Fournette obviously scored only three touchdowns, which was crazy. So maybe I could have gone with Fournette there. Rounds four and five, I took Damian Williams and Devin Singletary. Those gave me my second and third running backs,
Starting point is 00:27:29 Williams and Singletary. This is the lesson I learned here. This is the first draft or one of the first drafts we did with the rookies. When you put in rookie running backs, that gives you some better options in round six. I didn't pick again until the very end of round six.
Starting point is 00:27:48 And usually at that point, I would expect Ronald Jones and David Montgomery to be gone, but they were actually there. So maybe I didn't need to take both Damian Williams and Devin Singletary because when you factor in DeAndre Swift, Jonathan Taylor, J.K. Dobbins, Cam Akers, pushes down some of the other running backs. So I probably could have waited to get my third running back
Starting point is 00:28:15 until round six, and it could have been Ronald Jones or David Montgomery, and I would have been happy with that. Round six or seven, Russell Wilson and Deebo Samuel. I really loved getting Russell Wilson 72nd overall. And after I took him, there was a little bit of a run on quarterbacks. Kyler, Dak, and Deshaun went before my next pick. So I definitely feel like Wilson was the right pick there. Debo is my third wide receiver.
Starting point is 00:28:37 I took Darwin Thompson to back up, uh, to back up Damian Williams. And I still think Darwin Thompson is the guy to get. Maybe there's nobody to get, but I still like Thompson better than DeAndre Washington. I took Jared. Why? Because I think DeAndre Washington is, he is what he is.
Starting point is 00:28:55 I mean, he's... Very good when he got a chance last year. No, he really wasn't. He really wasn't. His yards per carry was bad. He actually just... He was on a bad team. He was on a bad team.
Starting point is 00:29:05 I mean, Josh Jacobs had no issues running on that team. He's not Josh Jacobs, obviously. I mean, he's going from a mediocre team to a great team. When has he been good? What makes DeAndre Washington good? Last year, he was a good fantasy quarterback. He was not good. He was good because he scored.
Starting point is 00:29:20 He got a ton of work, and he scored touchdowns. I guess he won't score with the Chiefs. That's probably a bad team to go to if he wants to score touchdowns. Maybe, but I'm not saying... Hard to score touchdowns when you're on the bench. I'm not saying... No, no, this is if Damien's gone. Yeah, I'm not saying for sure
Starting point is 00:29:36 that he's... Washington's good. I don't really think he is. I think Jalen Rashard's better. But, like, Darwin Thompson, while I still am drafting him as an upside pick is a sixth round pick who just averaged three and a half yards per carry on the chiefs then don't take either of them i guess is the lesson there that that's the lesson all right my starting lineup russell wilson christian mccaffrey and damian williams feeling juju and debo devvin Singletary at flex. Jared Cook at tight end.
Starting point is 00:30:05 It's okay. Could have been better. Who had the next pick? Me. Dave, go for it. I was two. Dave and Heath had two of my favorite teams, by the way. Go ahead, Dave.
Starting point is 00:30:15 Very nice. I like Zeke better than everybody other than Christian McCaffrey, so I took him at two. And then Jamie mentioned that some people were busy doing a mock draft while doing this fantasy draft there might not be a better person to have your back uh in a fantasy draft than Jamie because he he knew who I liked and he took them for me in rounds two and three Miles Sanders one spot ahead of Adam Mazur by the way thank you very much and then Kenny Galladay is one of my
Starting point is 00:30:42 favorite receivers so I got him in round three and then I was able to pick up the draft from there uh I took receivers after that I was thrilled with having Zeke and Miles Sanders as my top two running backs and when I feel that way I don't mind charging hard after wide out so Robert Woods Terry McLaurin those were my second and third receivers to go with Galladay very happy with. Dobbins fell to me at around six, even if that had been Cam Akers or maybe David Montgomery would have been the pick there. I probably wouldn't have been as excited about Montgomery or Akers as I was with Dobbins,
Starting point is 00:31:15 so I'll take the lucky break that I had there. And then Adam took Russell Wilson at the end of round six, and Kyler Murray was still on the board. Kyler's my number three quarterback. I feel like anytime I can get them as a number four quarterback or later off the board in a fantasy draft, it's a steal. I did that. Kyler Murray was my quarterback round eight.
Starting point is 00:31:34 Tyler Higbee is going to be my pick pretty much every draft I'm in from here on out and Justin Jefferson in round nine. So while CD lamb and Jerry Judy went in round six, and I felt like that was too early in a league where catches count. I think Justin Jefferson's great to target in that round nine range. And he could end up going in round eight, maybe even round seven if he goes to Philadelphia. But he's an NFL-ready slot receiver. I don't think he's going to be anything more in his career than a very good volume-based
Starting point is 00:32:00 type of wide receiver. But he can do it now almost with any team that he goes to. So I'm really thrilled to have gotten him there in round nine. And if we were playing this league out, he might be my flex week one instead of J.K. Dobbins. The rest of the team, Noah Fant in round 10, that's just getting great value on a tight end. And in case I'm wrong on Tyler Higby, he's a good backup plan. Tony Pollard in round 11 to back up Zeke. And, I mean, there really isn't much to talk about with the rest of the team.
Starting point is 00:32:28 Deontay Johnson's on my bench at receiver. One of my favorite handcuffs to swipe in the double-digit rounds is Gus Edwards. Because of that Ravens offense, we know they love to run the football. Mark Ingram's 30. I think Gus Edwards isn't a bad lottery ticket to take if he falls that far in the draft.
Starting point is 00:32:45 Love the team, man. So what's your starting lineup? Kyler at quarterback, Zeke and Sanders at running back. That's why you like the team, Adam, because I've got Miles Sanders. Well, I think you did great with your wide receivers considering your first two picks were running backs. When we were doing mock drafts before adding the rookies, I felt like I was never comfortable with the three receivers that I take.
Starting point is 00:33:07 But this one I did. And it was Galladay, Woods, and McLaurin. I feel even better about Woods now that Brandon Cooks was traded. Woods should be locked in. I don't know how many targets you haven't projected for Heath, but it's got to be a minimum of 130 because he's gotten that each of the past two seasons. Higby at tight end with Fant behind him. And Dobbins is currently my flex, but I can go with Jefferson.
Starting point is 00:33:29 Maybe Deontay Johnson is a big camp. Maybe he's my flex to start the year. Maybe Fant is my flex to start the year. I've got all kinds of potential there. I really, really love this team. Okay. I forgot to mention that I have Raheem Mostert and Marquise Brown. Those are actually two of my favorite picks.
Starting point is 00:33:45 They're bench players for me, and now I feel better about my team. All right, Heath, you had the sixth pick, and you had a great team. You did very well. Go for it. Yeah, it's like I talked about earlier. The sixth pick was pretty easy. I just waited to see which of the elite players was going to fall to me. I got Alvin Kamara at sixth overall, which I absolutely love,
Starting point is 00:34:04 and half PPR and non-PPR and full PPR, whatever. Mike Evans was a tough choice in round two, but it didn't matter because DJ Moore came back to me in round three. You took Mike Evans over Nick Chubb, Josh Jacobs, Miles Sanders, specifically
Starting point is 00:34:19 Chubb, because I know you like Chubb. So was that just because it's three receivers or what? Yes. Yeah. I didn't really want to get to round Chubb, because I know you like Chubb. So was that just because it's three receivers or what? Yes. Okay. Yeah. Sorry. I didn't really want to get to round three without a receiver. And again, I think Evans is more likely to be what we project of Evans than those running backs are.
Starting point is 00:34:37 Okay. DJ Moore in round three, I think even if you're discounting him for Robbie Anderson, the middle of round three is a great place to go get DJ Moore. The fourth round was probably the pick in this entire draft that I'm least certain about. I took Melvin Gordon. I think he's probably going to be a fine number two running back i'm a little bit uncertain about the situation in denver a little uncertain about the situation with philip lindsey and whether lindsey is going to get an eckler amount of touches or if he's going to be closer to a 50 50 split but the way they've talked like there's also a chance that melvin gordon's the top 12 running back and philip lindsey just
Starting point is 00:35:18 doesn't even matter so this could be a great pick but but i was like i struggled in deciding between melvin gordon marlon mack even damian williams who you took a little bit later um there was no struggle in round five because and this happened a couple of times zackerts went two picks before me in round five i'd rather have mark andrews than zackerts so it was very easy for me to take Andrews there in top five and get my number three tight end in the fifth round. Round six, again, a similar situation. Will Fuller, DK Metcalf, Tyler Boyd, three receivers went off the ward right in a row at the start of round six.
Starting point is 00:35:59 I like DJ Chark better than all of them. And so I took him as my third wide receiver. A guy that I think has top 12 upside. Just some uncertainty about the situation. Very similar situation in round seven. You took Russell Wilson. Dave took Kyler Murray. I like Dak Prescott better than both those guys.
Starting point is 00:36:18 Thought it was a good time to take him, who's my number three quarterback. Hey, by the way, this was done before the Brandon Cooks trade, right? Because Cooks went round 11. So, yeah, you heard Will Fuller go in round six. He might still go there, but that was before the Cooks trade. Yeah, I don't think he'll still go there. And then I took my flex, Marvin Jones, who I think is really underrated. And he's on the last
Starting point is 00:36:45 couple of years with matthew stafford we should expect that when he's healthy he's going to be a top 25 wide receiver he's my fourth receiver and my flex later round picks i'll kind of gloss over there's i was very happy to get tevin coleman in round nine continue to build on running back depth with chase edmunds a guy that i think i've taken every mock. Then Devontae Freeman, Alexander Madison, and Justice Hill. Running back upside, but I have two good starters. What do you got? What's your lineup? It is Dak Prescott, Alvin Kamara, and Melvin Gordon. Mike Evans, DJ Moore, DJ Chark, Mark Andrews, and Marvin Jones.
Starting point is 00:37:25 You want a little tease for Wednesday's podcast, Adam? Yeah. Marvin Jones was on pace to finish as the number 14 wide receiver in PPR through nine weeks last season. Yeah, and he's a touchdown guy. We're going to talk about the first half guys
Starting point is 00:37:42 from last year. Marvin Jones is one of them. So I second Heath's suggestion on Marvin Jones as a great flex. All right, Jamie, you had the 12th pick. So you had 12 and 13. You went with Chris Goblin and DeAndre Hopkins. You passed up Mixon, Eckler, Drake, Aaron Jones, Nick Chubb, et cetera, to take two wide receivers. Tell us about your team and if you think that was the right call.
Starting point is 00:38:05 I think it was the right call. I think it was the right call. I started with three receivers with Godwin, Hopkins, and Ridley. I started stockpiling running backs after that with Gurley, Connor, Akers, and Clyde Edwards-Hilaire, with Kareem Hunt and Justin Jackson mixed in as well. I waited on quarterback and tight end and ended up with Aaron Rodgers and Hayden Hurst. That's the gist
Starting point is 00:38:28 of my team. Let's take a look at Jamie's starting lineup. Aaron Rodgers at quarterback. It's funny to be like, I waited on quarterback. I got Aaron Rodgers. That's how it should be this year. James Conner and Todd Gurley at running back.
Starting point is 00:38:43 Obviously, a lot of scenarios there. Chris Godwin, DeAndre Hopkins, Calvin Ridley at wide receiver. That's certainly the strength of the team. Hayden Hurst at tight end. Flex could be Cam Akers. Could be... Probably Cam Akers. Kareem Hunt,
Starting point is 00:39:00 Justin Jackson. You're hearing Edward Solaire link to Tampa a lot in round two or three, depending on where he falls. That could be fun. But he doesn't look like a... He comes in, Clyde Edwards-Solaire comes in as a third down back, right? Or a passing down back.
Starting point is 00:39:21 Passing downs back, that will steal touches on the ground as well. I mean, he's not just going to play only on passing downs. Right. He could potentially be a downs back. Passing downs back, that will steal touches on the ground as well. I mean, he's not just going to play only on passing downs. Right. He could potentially be a lead back. I mean, he was basically the primary back for the national champions. Yeah, I'd be surprised if he's the lead back, but given the fact that Ronald Jones isn't the best of the running backs in the NFL, that could be a good landing spot for anybody, even if it's him.
Starting point is 00:39:45 Well, all right, not to be a jerk, but I would not feel great about a team where my running backs were Connor, Gurley, Cam Akers, a bunch of rookies, basically. You don't have to say not to be a jerk when you criticize someone's team besides mine. You don't mind being a jerk to me. Just be a jerk to Jamie. Jamie, your team sucks, man.
Starting point is 00:40:04 You're running back. Maybe so. Maybe so on draft day, but I still beat your ass like I normally do. I don't know. I got McCaffrey. What else do I need? I got Chris McCaffrey. That was a tough pick for me. I think I made the right call at number one. All right, cool. So those are our teams.
Starting point is 00:40:18 You can check out the draft. CBSSports.com slash fantasy slash football. I wanted to tell you where the rookies went. A lot of rookies went, but most of them went beginning late round five. There was only one that went before that. And there you go. Half PPR with some rookies.
Starting point is 00:40:35 So our Facebook group is awesome. Join it. Fantasy Football Today. There's a link in the description or you can just go to Facebook and type in Fantasy Football Today. One of the reasons why it's awesome is Robert Thomas. He moderates the group.
Starting point is 00:40:48 He keeps it going. He brings up interesting topics, and he's going to join us now to tell us what our Facebook listeners or our Facebook friends had to say about this draft. So let's bring him on. Robert, usually I don't let a man with an Ohio State hat onto this podcast, but I love J.K. Dobbins this year, and I love all the work that you've done for us, including your military service. So thank you. You are a Marine, I understand. Thank you for coming on. How are you?
Starting point is 00:41:17 And thank you for your service as always. I'm very good. And thank you very much, Adam. I appreciate it. You've been so important to our Facebook group and to our fantasy football community, and you do such a great job, and you're so dedicated, and you're helping us out on fantasy baseball today in that Facebook group as well. So you asked the listeners in the group, what were the best picks from this draft,
Starting point is 00:41:40 what were the worst picks, and who had the best team? Obviously, nobody said Jamie. But what were the best? Let's start the best team obviously nobody said jamie but what were uh what were the best let's start with best picks let's start with best picks robert uh sorry jamie not to be rude who were some of the best picks according to our listeners are you talking and i wasn't listening he was apologizing again twice in five minutes. So the best pick in the draft, Mark Ingram. Running backs were definitely high on the list of the listeners. Mark Ingram in the sixth, David Montgomery in the seventh.
Starting point is 00:42:22 James Conner was one of those ones that you either loved him or hated him. James Conner in the sixth. Also, Aaron Jones, Ben taking Aaron Jones. And somebody had brought up taking Derrick Henry and Aaron Jones back to back and said that was a huge upside. So big, heavy on running backs was everybody's favorite picks. Yeah. Yeah. So that's Shraggy B had the eighth pick. He took Derrick Henry. And then in round two, he took Aaron Jones. And guys, you see Austin Eckler and Kenyon Drake go right in front of Aaron Jones. And I wonder if in non-PPR, that's probably not going to happen. In PPR, I'm not sure. I mean, I guess there are a lot of places where you could see Aaron Jones go.
Starting point is 00:43:10 I feel like he went ahead of both of them in full PPR, but not in half PPR. But we're talking back-to-back-to-back picks. Eckler, Drake, Jones. Yeah, Eckler definitely went ahead of Jones in our PPR, because I took Eckler in the first round. I thought Jones went 12th in that draft, but I must be mixing up our drafts. Yeah, I took Eckler 10th. Okay. You know, they're going to be
Starting point is 00:43:30 the same range, I guess, but in half PPR, Heath, how would you rank Eckler, Drake, and Aaron Jones? Eckler, Jones, Drake. I think they're very, like, there's a lot of similarities. I don't, I think it's an interesting question.
Starting point is 00:43:47 Who is going to... Do any of those three guys get to 300 touches this year? Drake might. If he's truly the only guy in that backfield, then I think he's got a chance at 300 touches. Aaron Jones will come close. Jones will come close, but they're going to still share a little bit. I'd put my money Aaron Jones will come close. Jones will come close, but they're going to still
Starting point is 00:44:05 share a little bit. I'd put my money on Jones more than anyone. Mark Ingram in round six. How does that happen? He went one spot ahead of Kerryon Johnson. That was Ben Schrager again. How is Ben Schrager's team not my favorite team?
Starting point is 00:44:21 That to me seems insane. Mark Ingram in round six after Daryl Henderson. Now you're not loving it. I don't dislike it. I just I think that's about right in anything that reports any type of like we made fun of Ben Gretch a lot last year for the Mark Ingram hate and Ingram continuing to keep it up.
Starting point is 00:44:41 But I mostly agree with him. I was just being a troll. Yeah, but round six. I mean, even Ben Gretsch would have taken him in round six. Yeah, I'm not saying it's bad in round six. I think that's a fine place to get him. I don't think it's necessarily a big steal. He's going to probably top out around, what, 220 carries?
Starting point is 00:45:01 He's probably not going to maintain the same touchdown rate since he never had before in his career he caught five touchdown passes on like 12 targets or something no okay but mark ingram was worthy of a second round pick last year so to get him not by you know in retrospect yeah i think i think it's around around too late i think round five is a good time to get ingram okay he was the number 11 running back in full ppr last year so the people like the running back values robert what were some of the worst picks in this draft i will tell you uh consensus worst pick in the draft was aj green oh all right. Where did AJ Green go? People just do not like AJ Green, where he's at.
Starting point is 00:45:50 They don't trust him. That just seems to be everybody's thoughts. He went right before I took DJ Moore. Yeah, right after Galladay and Fournette and before Mahomes. 28th overall. Before Allen Robinson, before Cooper Cup, before Calvin Ridley.
Starting point is 00:46:08 Yeah, I think the people are right. Yeah, that's the Chrissy Teigen, that meme. That's what that is, having him go 28th. I'll give you the answer to why it happened. it happen because uh so what we started doing on on the site is uh ben gretch has been doing a q a with us after the drafts uh he's calling him an exit interview exit survey and uh that was uh jack capitardo who made that pick and it was uh he's one of our producers in cbs sports hq so here's the question was uh ben says I like AJ Green as a bounce-back candidate this year, and you seem to agree,
Starting point is 00:46:48 grabbing him with the fourth pick in the third round. What made Green the pick over other options you were considering? And here's what Jack said. I feel like there are a lot of question marks with the round three wide receivers taken in this draft. Beckham, is he bouncing back? Cooper Cup, what does the Rams offense look like? DJ Moore, they added Robbie Anderson. Allen Robinson,
Starting point is 00:47:04 never trust Mr. Trubisky or Nick Foles. AJ Green obviously coming off a lost year. I just picked Mike Poison, but I'm really high on the Bengals wide receivers this season, expecting Joe Burrow to get them the ball. I honestly wanted Leonard Fournette there, but he got taken just to pick ahead of him. It's a pretty reasonable answer.
Starting point is 00:47:20 Right? I mean, if you're not sold on those guys, you know, and you have a feeling on someone he probably could have gotten around later that's the thing yeah you know it's just it's just the spot that now look if aj green come the middle of august is you know looking like he's got a great rapport with joe burrow everything's fine hunky dory maybe he gets a new contract um this is where he's going no he's not going ahead of more beckham or robinson but he may be going toward the end of that he's not going ahead of rid, he's not going ahead of Moore, Beckham, or Robinson, but he may be going toward the end of that. He's not going ahead of Ridley.
Starting point is 00:47:47 He's not going ahead of Kup. But those guys could also go a little bit higher, maybe in a PP, maybe in full PPR. But I would expect him to be a top 30 pick. Everything is perfect. So here's the receivers around later in that same, well, I guess not the same range, but in the spot where he was picking.
Starting point is 00:48:05 So he could have taken – he took Marlon Mack in round four. Tyler Lockett was the next receiver off the board, Robert Woods. I'm still taking those guys over AJ Green, but that's the range where he'll creep up to if things work out well for him. Yeah, I think if we are going to be optimistic about AJ Green in July, it's a round earlier than where we'll take him when we're optimistic. It's two rounds or more too early now for me. But the thing that I didn't like about this, when I said no, it's not a good reasoning, is there's a lot of questions about all these guys,
Starting point is 00:48:36 so I'm going to take the guy who has more questions than all of them. But he also has more upside. He also has been better than all of them except Beckham. If you're getting peak AJ Green, yes. But that guy's gone. How do we know that guy's gone? Look, I'm not saying I disagree.
Starting point is 00:48:56 I'm just questioning. He told you about the receivers needing rapport with their quarterbacks. The quarterback needs the most rapport with his receivers. So for him not to have any time, whoever it may be, not to have any time with a guy that's probably not going to show up whatever offseason work they're going to get until training camp, I mean, that's going to hurt that start.
Starting point is 00:49:17 And so plus you have to factor in he's 31 and hasn't been healthy for two of the last three seasons. Look, like I said, I don't disagree. But we also, it's not like we can just sit here and assume that these guys aren't going to play football together until like September. I mean, you know. No, but why would he have more upside than Allen Robinson? Because he's always been better than Allen Robinson, except one year. Like, A.J. Green's been one of the best wide
Starting point is 00:49:46 receivers in football. DJ Moore hasn't been that yet. Cooper Cupp hasn't been. Cooper Cupp was that last year, but that was nothing compared to what Green used to do in his prime. You know, I mean... That was half a decade ago. It was, no. It was two seasons ago.
Starting point is 00:50:01 For his games that he played, he was great. Like, the eight games he played, not was great. Like the eight games he played, not counting that stupid ninth game where he barely played, what were his stats? You just double his stats from two years ago, 2018, you're talking almost 1,400 yards and 12 touchdowns and 90 catches. That's almost the projection that Heath gave Michael Thomas earlier in the show. It is. Oh, not the catches, but gave Michael Thomas earlier in the show. It is.
Starting point is 00:50:25 Oh, not the catches, but yeah. Not, but everything else. He has more touchdowns than he hasn't projected for. Yeah, his first eight games of 2018 before he basically missed a season and a half, AJ Green was great. I do think that if you're going to draft him that high, you're really buying into him hitting those numbers, which I think as of now,
Starting point is 00:50:45 you look at that and you'd have to be loony to think that that's a certain. Well, I mean, look, we, we, I think consensus wise, we'll always tell people if you like a player,
Starting point is 00:50:54 take him. But I think he said it best. Don't take him two rounds too early. Take him one round. Right. Robert, who had the best team according to our listeners? So it was either Ben or RJ.
Starting point is 00:51:09 I would say people loved the running back strategy. Ben Schrager, right? How many people voted in this? Let's see. Just Ben and RJ. Okay. Let me see here. I guess I can go through the teams.
Starting point is 00:51:31 The teams. It looks like we had a couple Bens and a couple RJs. All right. Well, I did have RJs as one of my favorites, but let's compare Ben and RJ here. Ben Schrager. Schrager has Josh Allen, Derek Henry, and Aaron Jones
Starting point is 00:51:49 with Mark Ingram at flex. Allen Robinson, Cortland Sutton, and Michael Gallup at wide receiver. Johnny Smith at tight end. Also, Ronald Jones on the bench. And Jamal Williams to back up Aaron Jones. I mean, this is a very good team.
Starting point is 00:52:06 That's probably a playoff team. Yeah, it's a good one. I really liked RJ's team. He has Mahomes. I mean, look at this. Come on. Nick Chubb and Dalvin Cook. Stefan Diggs, Devante Parker, and CeeDee Lamb.
Starting point is 00:52:21 Evan Ingram. And he has David Montgomery at Flex. So, he has Mahomes, Chubb, Cook, David Montgomery at flex so he has Mahomes Chubb, Cook and Montgomery at running back Diggs, CeeDee Lamb and Parker at wide receiver he also took Parker a little too soon he took Parker in round 4 imagine if he has Lockett or Woods
Starting point is 00:52:36 Evan Ingram tight end it's another good team I didn't think there was a consensus best team did anybody think like oh wow this is the best team that's pretty good. Yeah. I think Dave's is my favorite. That's my favorite.
Starting point is 00:52:52 Kyler, Zeke, Miles Sanders, Gallaudet, Woods, McLaurin, Tyler Higby, J.K. Dobbins, and Flex. And you know me. I'll poo-poo my own team if I, whether I'm experimenting or if I make a bad pick I'll own up to it but I would take this team in any league right now who did RJ take Lamb over
Starting point is 00:53:11 he took Lamb over Judy Landry Edelman Debo oh so Robert give us the scouting report on jk dobbins you know watching his games all year last year he just looks like
Starting point is 00:53:37 he needs a team that runs that type of offense so you, you know, having that fit is going to be key to, to where he, you know, how he plays. I just don't know. It's, it's hard to see where he's going to go now. So that's what I really hope is he gets a good fit to be a three down back. I don't know. I don't know if he could put up the numbers without being that type of running back. And that's tough in this league today. Better question. If you don't mind my asking, how old are you?
Starting point is 00:54:14 I'm 38. I just had a birthday the other day. Oh, happy birthday. Hey, happy birthday. All right, so you're definitely old enough to remember. That national championship was garbage like it was it was a bs national championship i was living in are you talking about the oh one two thousand one oh two oh three oh two sorry yeah i was living in philly at the time
Starting point is 00:54:38 and absolutely crazy it was amazing mean, it was obvious. Not for us. It wasn't amazing. Not for me and Dave. It was obvious. It was all over. Yeah, sure, sure. All right. So I asked you to find some kind of fun stuff in the Facebook group, like a throwback Thursday or something like that. What you got? What's some of the fun stuff that people that aren't in the group are missing? So one of my favorite things that we put up, I put it up in January, was it was a throwback Thursday. It was talking about
Starting point is 00:55:21 you're starting in fantasy football, what your story was, if you were any good, and if you knew what you were doing. And actually, my favorite one, the guy said, 1989, I was in sixth grade, ran my league by hand, checked the newspapers that were in the school library on Monday and Tuesdays to get stats, got questioned by parents, checked the newspapers that were in the school library on Monday and Tuesdays to get stats. Got questioned by parents, teachers, and even the local police regarding the idea that I was running a gambling.
Starting point is 00:55:54 Oh, man. Sixth grade checking newspapers at the school library. That's awesome. That is great. So, you know, I thought it would be good to bring that up to go to hear your guys's story of how you got started if you knew what you were doing and if you were any good when you first started all right jamie you want to kick it off
Starting point is 00:56:18 i got started doing this job no no, no. Fantasy football. Your first league. Oh, fantasy football. My first league was in college in 1997. And my first pick was Chris Carter when he was with the Vikings. And I ended up getting Randall Cunningham that year too. So that was a fun pairing. Did I win the win? You won your first league. Yep. You're made for this job.
Starting point is 00:56:50 Dave, how about you? I also first started playing in 97. Barry Sanders was my first pick, and I was terrible. Terrible. I was terrible for three straight years, but I didn't take it seriously. And it wasn't until I started taking it seriously in the offseason before 2001 that I started doing better in fantasy. So that's why I subscribe to you. You've got to pay attention year-round to be good at fantasy football. Heath?
Starting point is 00:57:19 Yeah, I don't remember what year it was, but I remember my first league or exposure to fantasy football was actually a fantasy football type contest in USA Today. And it was 97 or 98, and you had to go through and like – it was almost like a season-long type fan duel type thing because you had to go through and choose players but stay under a salary cap for the year and then weekly we were calculating our own points out of the newspaper so yeah i had good technology when i started i think i started in 1999 i was in high school and i shared i co-owned my team you're such a baby with uh well this my friend he was like big stats guy he got me into fantasy football, and his name is Alex Jacob. He is a Jeopardy super champ. For those of you who are big Jeopardy fans, if you know Alex Jacob,
Starting point is 00:58:11 he also won like a ton of money on the World Series of Poker. So I remember we had Napoleon Kaufman from the Raiders on our team, and my dad was so confused because he thought we must have had the wrong guy because there was another running back named Napoleon on the Raiders. There was a linebacker, Napoleon Harris. There was also Napoleon McCollum who was 1986 through 1994 with the Raiders. The Raiders have had three players named Napoleon, so I remember learning that at an early age.
Starting point is 00:58:43 But yeah, I had a good time. I don't remember how we did. That means you lost. Yes, I'm sure. But I played fantasy football with a Jeopardy super champ, and nobody else did, except Dave was a Wheel of Fortune super champ. Or almost, anyway.
Starting point is 00:58:59 Yeah. Yeah. Look at that. I've hit all the game shows. Robert, when did you start? Robert, how is this whole thing affecting you? What's going on right now? Yeah.
Starting point is 00:59:12 So I work in HR, and I've been working at home on Monday through Thursdays, and then my wife's off on Fridays, so I go in on Fridays to work, and then I'm Mr. Mom during the week. Is your office crowded? No, it's not. The building's pretty much empty when I go in. I'm just there in case anybody has to pick any paperwork up or drop it off, so social distancing. And what was your first fantasy football league? Oh, I got started right before I went to the Marine Corps in 2007. I was older when I went to the Marine Corps. I didn't go until I was 25. But 2006, I think it was, I played and I was horrible. I didn't know what I was doing. And then I got back in it after I got out of bootcamp and everything.
Starting point is 01:00:08 And I think 2000, it would have been 2010 when I really got into it. It was a non PPR league. It was the first year Vic was back and I took Vic first for whatever reason. We would have blistered you for that. Oh, I would have been crushed. I would have been crushed. But now I love the game.
Starting point is 01:00:33 I've won two leagues. I finished in second in my money league last year. I made the worst decision I've played. And kind of leading into this question, the next one I have is I played O.J. Howard over Tyler Higbee in the championship, and it just crushed me. And that was one of the questions somebody had in the group was, would you take O.J. Howard over Tyler Higbee this year?
Starting point is 01:01:03 Not me. I don't know if any of us would, but I definitely would not. The group comments were completely split. I would say it was half Higbee, half Howard. Wow. And everybody loves Tom Brady with OJ Howard. Yeah, that's so interesting.
Starting point is 01:01:17 That's good to know. I mean, you definitely, you get, you post something in that group, it's not guaranteed to get approved, we get a lot of posts, but you weigh in on a post you just get different perspective than what you're going to hear on the podcast and that's really great you know it's good to see i posted something about joe mix him i can have time to talk about it but i wanted to see how people were feeling and a lot of people
Starting point is 01:01:37 were like yeah i'd take him in round three and then a lot of people were like there's no way he's getting around three so you just get uh you get out of the the analyst mindset a little bit and just what the listeners are thinking about and it's it's different and it's interesting and it's possible because of ben schrager and robert thomas and robert thanks for coming on man great stuff thanks for helping us out thanks robert all right everybody uh dave and jamie are gonna host on wednesday and fr, respectively, I believe. And we'll talk about first half forgotten first half heroes on Wednesday. We'll talk about the wide receiver prospects on Friday and anything else that's relevant until then.
Starting point is 01:02:14 I'm Adam Azer. Email us at fantasy football at CBS. I.com. Thanks to Jamie, Dave, Heath, and Robert. Talk to you on Wednesday.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.