Fantasy Football Today - 05/14: Mock Draft Review - When did the Rookies Get Drafted? (Fantasy Football Podcast)
Episode Date: May 13, 2019Getting into our first mock draft after the NFL Draft with our rookie analysis. First, what were the best and worst picks of this draft (2:30)? It's rare we talk about a QB as the best pick, but that'...s the case today. We've also got some news and notes (8:25) to catch up on. Any reasons to be concerned about Carson Wentz? Does Ben Watson matter? ... Let's talk about the rookies (14:00)! Josh Jacobs ahead of Aaron Jones? David Montgomery and Miles Sanders with basically the same value? Who catches the most passes in this group of rookie RBs? And we also talk about the WRs and TEs who were drafted ... Adam discusses the Round 4 conundrum he was faced with (33:20) and we talk about our favorite teams (39:30) and least-favorite teams (46:20). We also get into a spirited debate about rostering two QBs (50:00) and give our thoughts on Sunday's Game of Thrones episode (55:00) ... Email us at fantasyfootball@cbsi.com To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports.
Here we go!
Email us at fantasyfootballatcbsi.com.
Here we go!
It's time to dominate your fantasy league.
Let's go!
Now, here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, and Heath.
Box Draft Review.
When did all those rookies get drafted?
The answer is whenever Jamie was picking.
Welcome to the show, everybody.
Jamie drafted a lot of rookies in our 12-team PBR mock draft that we did last week.
And we're going to talk about the draft.
I don't think we're going to go pick by pick, but we'll tell you where the rookies went.
We'll give you the best pick, the worst pick, the best team, the worst team, and the strategies that were involved.
Happy Monday, Dave and Jamie.
Hope you guys had a great weekend.
Good Mother's Day.
Good to speak to you again.
Good to hear your voice.
Mother's Day was good on our end.
My mom boarded a cruise ship in Los Angeles.
She and my dad are going to check out the Panama Canal.
Really?
Setting stuff there, yeah.
That's cool.
Whereas my wife and I, we had brunch on the beach, walked on the beach. i we had brunch on the beach walked on the beach
kids complained about being on the beach left the beach and then had all you could eat steak
for dinner it was amazing jamie good weekend yeah a lot of sports a lot of sports my uh four-year-old
won his t-ball playoff game so we uh live to fight another day. We will play tomorrow.
Or tonight, excuse me.
Monday night.
Then he scored a goal in his soccer game on Sunday.
And my seven-year-old, I think he hit three or four baskets in his basketball game.
Ooh.
Sunday.
No athletes.
No.
Points, rebounds, assists, fouls.
He had a couple key...
It was funny.
We had...
Considering the Raptors game, we had a buzzer beater called off.
Oh.
Oh, my gosh.
I almost woke up the baby last night watching that game.
I freaked out with that shot.
Did you watch it live and then watch Game of Thrones?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Oh, man.
I wonder how many people did that.
It was crazy.
I was following the game on Twitter while I was watching Game of Thrones.
Oh, why?
What's wrong with you? It's so obvious was following the game on Twitter while I was watching Game of Thrones. Oh, why? What's wrong with you?
It's so obvious you watched the game live.
There are two live events that you can deal with.
Game of Thrones has to be watched live.
Fine.
Dave, do you know the palindrome for the Panama Canal?
No.
A man, a plan, a canal, Panama.
Very cool palindrome.
You're welcome.
Okay, best...
You just looked that up right now?
No, I knew it, but I had to write it out to make sure I was right.
Best pick and worst pick.
We're going to Dave Richard for the best pick of the 12-team PPR mock draft that we just did.
I thought the best pick was Andrew Luck at 79th overall.
Insane value.
You know, it's strange for us to go with a quarterback
when we talk about best and worst picks.
I was surprised you went there.
But went there I did.
Damn it.
It might have been
the best pick because I would have taken him
at 80th overall. He's my number one
quarterback. I think he's going to be amazing this year.
Getting him in
round seven.
Look, I'm all for waiting on a quarterback. That think he's going to be amazing this year getting him in round seven. Look, I'm all for waiting on quarterback.
That's just insanity.
So what was it you said? 79th overall?
79. Aaron Rodgers went
60th.
Mahomes went early.
Mahomes went 30th
or something like that. Right around 30th.
So yeah.
50 picks later. 49 picks later. Andrew Luck over Patrick Mahomes. Mahomes right around 30th. So, yeah, 50 picks later, 49 picks later,
Andrew Luck over Patrick Mahomes.
Mahomes went exactly 30th.
30th, yeah, good for me.
Man of plan, Canal Panama.
Jamie, what was the worst pick of this draft?
I have three.
Oh.
One was one owner decided to take a chance on Rob Gronkowski
with the thought that he may play at some point this season.
Yeah.
Didn't like that.
That was round 11.
That's an early drop.
Huh?
That's an early drop.
Yeah.
That's an early drop, yes.
Second one was Damian Williams round three.
That was a great pick.
Hated that one.
And the third one was, it's escaping me right now.
Oh, taking both Jarvis Landry and
Brandon Cooks ahead of Kenny Galladay at the
3-4 swing. Worked out
for me. I took Kenny Galladay. Yes.
What about Sammy Watkins going ahead of
Kenny Galladay?
I can somewhat justify that. I don't
like it, but look, if Tyree
kills out, Sammy Watkins is going to
get a ton of upside.
Alright, so Dave took Damian Williams,
which he does every draft we do.
And in every write-up, I go, I hate Damian Williams.
So wait, that's 36-5-4-3.
32nd overall, Damian Williams.
And it only took him one second to make the pick.
One second.
I absolutely knew I wanted him.
It took Jamie one second to hate the pick. All right, so took it. Absolutely knew I wanted him. Took Jamie one second to hate the pick.
All right.
So discuss.
I knew it was coming.
Go ahead, guys.
But one draft, you took him in round five.
I thought that was good.
Round four.
Round four or five.
Sure.
If I can get him in round four, even better.
I didn't think he'd make it back to me.
You could have gotten round four.
Well, I know you might have taken him in round four.
No.
You had two picks before I made my next pick.
So did I.
We're going to talk about Damian williams for the next three months he's going to be polarizing on this podcast i like
having the lead running back in a powerful offense like kansas city's if uh potentially
sure because we don't know about tyreek hill but even if tyreek's not playing
hardman got rave reviews at their rookie minicamp.
Let's see how he progresses.
Carlos Hyde is, you know, I think he's on the wrong side of his career.
We'll see what they've got in Darwin Thompson.
Not ready to hitch my wagon to him.
I liked what I saw from Damian Williams last year.
The funny thing about it is that I can make the argument against Damian Williams, too.
Well, yeah.
Just as easily as i can
make it for him he looked great last year he's an andy reed running back he should be the lead guy
like i i was thinking about it this morning i i think i could make the argument against him as
well i just don't want to well jamie's got more ammo against me of course every time we bring him
up no you uh look you can make an argument for and against most players there are a few guys who
don't have any downside but i would say there are a few agree or disagree i know dave's gonna agree
there are a few players with the upside of damian williams he could be he could perform like the
number one player in fantasy absolutely he'd be great it's just oh i don't think he'll be the
number one player no but he could there's a lot to like about him. I certainly see the potential there.
But, you know, again, I just think there's enough downside
that I wouldn't take him that early.
I still think he's the best of Kansas City's trio of running backs
coming into the season.
It's all about value.
I just don't think the value is there for him in round three.
Okay, I'm trying to just do some math.
14 plus 18 is 32.
So here are the PPR fantasy points scored by Damian Williams
in the final six games of the season, including two postseason games.
18, 29, 24, 12, 25, 32.
I mean, that right there is good enough to be the number one running back,
you know, if he did that for 16 games which he won't uh but
yeah and so he did not have more than 13 carries in a game in the regular season in the postseason
he had 25 carries against the colts and then 10 against new england so we're not to think about
no and no competition for touches and what about catches how many catches did he get? Catches, yeah, he had a lot. He had five in each of the playoff games,
and he had four, six, seven, and one.
So he had four more catches in five of those six games.
Perfect for PPR.
Yeah, it's great.
All righty.
Andrew Luck, great pick.
Rob Gronkowski, Damian Williams, Courtney Jamie,
and Kenny Galladay went too late, basically, is what we're saying.
And we'll tell you where he went. Williams, Courtney, Jamie, and Kenny Galladay went too late, basically, is what we're saying.
And we'll tell you where he went.
In fact, I felt like the wide receivers,
at least as we got into round three, early round four,
were sort of pushing the running backs down a little bit.
Like Aaron Jones, Chris Carson, Phillip Lindsey. The best pick of the draft was Dalvin Cook in round three.
Oh, yeah, that was crazy.
That part of that was a little bit of a draft snafu.
Yeah.
That's okay.
You don't have to say that.
But Dalvin Cook.
He probably would have gone, I'll say, six or seven picks earlier.
All right.
We'll tell you where Dalvin Cook went.
I'll tell you right now.
He went 29th overall in between Diggs.
Oh, it was Diggs, Thielen, Cook.
How about that?
How are you not going to be good, Kirk Cousins?
Injuries, news and notes.
We do have some news and notes to get to.
Adam Gase said that Le'Veon Bell will be at mandatory minicamp.
He won't be at the voluntary stuff,
but he'll be at the mandatory stuff, according to Adam Gase.
Doug Peterson won't say if Carson Wentz will be ready for OTAs.
And meanwhile, Philadelphia is signing quarterback Cody Kessler.
What's your take there?
As long as he's ready for training camp.
That's it.
Get him on the field in July.
The Patriots signed
Ben Watson to a
one-year deal worth up to $3 million.
What's your take there? Was he taken
in this draft? No, but
I think Safarian Jenkins might be.
I mean, I would rather have
Safarian Jenkins than Watson,
wouldn't you?
No, I don't think ASJ was taken.
And Watson wasn't either.
I know ASJ was taken late
in our Dynasty League draft.
You know, we do a draft
with the rookies and everything.
It's not rookie only
because there's free agents.
Well, it's...
Yes, you're right.
And so he was a free agent.
Someone took him.
And then Watson signed signed the next day.
I didn't want to give the impression
that it's just a start of Dynasty League.
Yes, that's fair.
Yeah, so what do you think?
I mean, do you care about Watson?
I think it'll be a tight end by committee.
I still hope that they do what they usually do
in New England, which is go get a veteran or a player that is in a bad situation
because they've made a dynasty out of that,
and go get Kyle Rudolph,
who is not going to get a contract extension from the Patriots.
Yeah.
It's worth mentioning Ben Watson, really.
He just doesn't really move the needle.
He's had one good season and maybe like ever, basically.
It was great the first year after Jimmy Graham in New Orleans.
Yeah.
And last year we were a little optimistic that he might be able to, you know,
sneak up on you as a top 12 guy or something as a tight end.
Cause he was the previous, he was in 2015 in New Orleans.
He was like the number eight tight end.
And last year, 35 catches, 400 yards, and two touchdowns for the Saints.
Someone on Twitter floated the idea that Cameron Brait would be a good fit in New England.
Former Harvard guy, backup, getting a decent chunk of change.
Right.
A, they'd have to rework his deal.
And B, how much better is he than Ben Watson?
Better.
He's better.
A lot better?
A little better?
I mean, he's got like 10 years.
Like, is he worth the effort to trade a pick and redo his contract
when they just, you know, found Ben Watson sleeping in their facility?
I mean, if you get Kyle Rudolph for a fourth-round pick or less,
that'd be awesome.
Let's see.
Doug Baldwin appears to be retiring Game of Thrones-style, Jamie.
Yeah.
He wrote a letter to his younger self
about the life he would live, I guess.
The path he would take.
And then at the end,
he dropped the Jon Snow gif.
Jif, whatever you say.
Jif, sure.
You're the Jif master.
You should know this.
Speaking of which.
What?
Some of the things you said.
Yeah. uh speaking of which what some of the things you sent me um uh yeah uh he dropped the uh the john snow gif of uh my watch has ended i uh most most people are going with the thought of
he's retired dave i sent you the same GIF that I sent Jamie, and both of you were very shocked.
It was pretty weird.
I have a lot of fun with the GIF app.
Baldwin was a great fantasy receiver.
He was.
For a three-year stretch from 2015 to 2017, he was pretty good.
Top 12 or 13 every year.
He averaged 82 catches, 1,000 yards, and 10 touchdowns over that three-year span.
Phillip Lindsey will be limited in minicamp
as he recovers from off-season wrist surgery.
Same thing with Mahomes,
just as long as he's good for training camp.
Mahomes?
Sorry.
You mean Wentz.
Wentz.
Why did I say Mahomes?
All of a sudden, Mahomes is hurting.
Those two are the same.
That's bad.
A year ago, Carson Wentz, or Patrick Mahomes wished he was Carson Wentz.
He did?
Now Carson Wentz wishes he was Patrick Mahomes.
Or Carson Wentz.
Giants signed right tackle Mike Remmers.
A little upgrade at right tackle.
Yeah.
Jacksonville linebacker Telvin Smith is taking the year off.
Yeah. He'll hopefully get his life in order is taking the year off. Yeah.
He hopefully gets his life in order, whatever he's doing.
Yeah.
The Dolphins signed cornerback Zavian Howard to a record-setting deal.
They actually allowed the Dolphins to allow the fourth-fewest fantasy points
to wide receivers in 2018.
But pretty much all the good ones did well against them.
Not Adam Thielen, but that was late in the year.
But not Kenny Galladay. But most of the good ones did really well against them. Not Adam Thielen, but that was late in the year, but not Kenny Galladay,
but most of the good ones did really well against them.
Let me point out some examples of guys who did.
Um,
yeah,
it's,
it,
it has a chance to be one of the better secondaries in the NFL.
No,
they're going to make a Fitzpatrick takes that leap.
They're gonna be awesome.
Really excited.
They are.
No.
And they signed Mike,
Mark Walton.
Yeah.
How's their pass rush? Uh, pass rush is terrible, but again, I didn't say defense. I are? No. And they signed Mike Walton. Their secondary could be. Mark Walton. Yeah. How's their pass rush?
Pass rush is terrible.
But again, I didn't say defense.
I just said secondary.
Mark Walton, signed by the Dolphins.
Mark Walton, two months from now.
Cut by the Dolphins.
Yeah.
Hometown kid getting a chance.
All right.
We got the mock draft review.
Yes.
Agreed.
We will talk about this 12-team PPR mock draft.
Our least favorite team.
Our favorite team.
Guess what?
Dave's favorite team was mine.
Love it.
A mistake I made.
Why my team could have been even better.
A conundrum I faced.
I made a call that people on Twitter didn't like.
Talk about all that.
Where the rookies went, though, that's primarily what we're going to discuss.
We're going to do it all right after this quick break on fantasy football today.
Kick off an exciting football season with BetMGM,
an official sportsbook partner of the National Football League.
Yard after yard, down after down,
the sportsbook born in Vegas gives you the chance to take action to the end zone
and celebrate every highlight reel play.
And as an official sportsbook partner of the NFL,
BetMGM is the best place to fuel your football fandom on every game day.
With a variety of exciting features,
BetMGM offers you plenty of seamless ways to jump straight onto the gridiron
and to embrace peak sports action.
Ready for another season of gridiron glory?
What are you waiting for?
Get off the bench, into the huddle, and head for the end zone all season long.
Visit BetMGM.com for terms and conditions.
Must be 19 years of age or older.
Ontario only.
Please gamble responsibly.
Gambling problem?
For free assistance, call the Connex Ontario helpline at 1-866-531-2600.
BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGamingOntario.
Okay, Jamie, where'd you draft all the rookies?
Every pick.
Pretty much.
My strategy.
I basically followed the NFL draft.
I took Kyler Murray in round one.
I'll probably be aggressive with Josh Jacobs and a lot of drafts.
Now we'll see what happens come August and September, but, uh, I took Jacobs and I've
done this in, in a couple of magazine publications that I'm drafting in as well.
So I took Jacobs at the turn, uh, the start of, start of round four.
Um, I was picking 11th.
So, um, I kind of had the idea of after taking receivers in my first two picks that if he was there early round four, I would take him.
And sure enough, there he was.
So I took Jacobs in round four.
I took Montgomery in round six.
Again, similar scenario of I like the value of him compared to some of the other running backs on the board.
And he was my third running back after going two receivers, two running backs in the tight end in round five.
And then Daryl Henderson was an easy choice for me where I took him,
I believe it was round 10, round nine.
So right before round 10.
And that was also right in front of the Todd Gurley owner.
Ah, yes.
As well.
So I did not think, and again, picking 11th,
I did not think at the two next picks after me that I would get Henderson back.
So I just liked, again, the value for him there.
I had a strange draft with how I sort of built this team, which we can get into in a little bit if you want.
But those are three rookies that I took.
I think if you look at most people's rookie ratings, rankings for seasonal and dynasty.
For the most part, I think you'll see Jacobs, Montgomery,
and Henderson in the top four.
So, Jacobs, you took 38th overall.
That was the second pick of round four.
And you took him after Devontae Freeman and Leonard Fournette were taken,
but you took Jacobs ahead of Aaron Jones.
Yep.
Dalvin Cook was the one in round three that really stood out,
29th overall.
Aaron Jones in round four, it was very surprising that he was there.
It was the same situation.
We'll just explain it.
We had two picks that were made, and people didn't see it.
They were pulled back for whatever reason.
It kind of screwed up the draft for him a little bit.
That's going to happen when we're doing drafts this early,
when we're still working through some things.
So Cook would have probably gone round two.
I would imagine Jacobs would have gone maybe a few spots earlier.
Jacobs or Jones?
Excuse me, Jones.
And again, like I said,
I'm aggressive with where I'm drafting Josh Jacobs.
In a month from now, I have them, I think, back-to-back in my rankings,
Jacobs and Jones.
I may flip that.
Marlon Mack is another one.
Kerryon Johnson is another one.
So all three of those guys were three that I would kind of put in the same scenario the way I have it ranked.
Okay, Dave.
What did you think of Josh Jacobs going ahead of Aaron Jones, Chris Carson,
Phillip Lindsay, Marlon Mack, guys like that.
I thought it was a little early,
but when you've got conviction in a player, you take the player.
It seems pretty simple to me.
I do like the chance for Josh Jacobs to get three or four catches a game.
I think he can do that,
and I think he's got 12 carries at minimum every week locked up already.
So lead back in Oakland, going to catch a few passes on top of it.
If you want them bad enough, that's kind of where you go with them.
Maybe even leaking into late round three.
Like if you, like Jim, if you were picking ninth or 10th,
that was your draft spot in the odd rounds.
Do you think about taking Jacobs that early because you want him that bad or do you hope
he makes it back to you a few spots
later than where you actually took him?
So what I probably would have done if Fournette
wasn't there because that's the guy I took in round three
then I probably would have gone
with the
yeah I probably would have taken Jacobs
but then you wouldn't have had Fournette
right so what I probably would have done I would have taken
Jacobs and Jones or Jacobs and Marlon Mack or Kerryon Johnson, one of those two.
Okay.
And then we go to David Montgomery for the Bears.
62nd overall, second pick of round six.
David Montgomery went after Lamar Miller just before Darius Geis
and Miles Sanders, the other rookie we'll talk about here.
So Montgomery and Miles Sanders going with the second and fourth picks
of round six.
And I took Sanders. Jamie took Montgomery. I took Sanders. This pick was the hardest one for me.
I would have taken Sanders if Montgomery was gone.
Yeah, I was a little surprised they lasted into round six. So that was 62nd and 64th overall.
This, to me, was the mistake I made.
I took Sanders and was hoping, hoping that a tight end would come back to me in round seven,
but before my next pick,
obviously a lot of tight ends were already off the board.
O.J. Howard went, Hunter Henry went, Jared Cook went,
and I'm really weak at tight end,
and I don't want to be weak at tight end this year.
So I'm not sure I would do that.
I might take O.J. Howard or Hunter Henry over Miles Sanders.
But, yeah, it was a good opportunity.
The next running back off the board, there was kind of a wait,
and then it was Tevin Coleman, like seven picks later.
Which is good value.
For Coleman?
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, but we, yeah.
But now, running backs, then it's Jarek McKinnon,
LaShawn McCoy. So,
that's the appeal of getting Montgomery and Sanders.
Guys who could play a big role,
have really good rookie seasons in the 60s.
You know, I don't think I made a bad
pick necessarily taking Sanders, but I do think
I should have taken a tight end over him.
And I'll say, in retrospect, if I knew I was
getting Montgomery in round six, I would have
taken more of a sure thing with Jacobs or
Mack or Kerryon Johnson, one of those guys that
are proven at the spot where I took
Jacobs just again because of what the security
is given from those other guys.
And I think I feel
the same way about Montgomery as you do
about Jacobs, where I don't mind getting
him, I don't mind reaching up for him a little bit,
probably into round five in a PPR for David Montgomery.
It's just a matter of whether or not you have that conviction.
Like I said, Jamie's got it for Jacobs.
I'm feeling pretty good about Montgomery.
Oh, I love Montgomery.
And I think if I didn't see Evan Ingram on the board in round five,
I was taking him in round five.
And having him fall to your lap in round six.
Right.
That might have been up there for best pick in the draft, too.
Well, but it is PPR.
And, you know, Jordan Howard caught 20 passes last year.
Different player.
Yeah, but they still have Tariq Cohen.
But they still have Tariq Cohen, obviously.
They do.
So what's going to happen in Chicago.
They also have Quoterell Patterson.
Don't rule that out.
They're going to just mix and match these guys
all the time, and
I'm sure what they're looking at is almost
every single situation, they're not
going to care which running back is in the game, whether
it's Montgomery, Cohen, Davis,
Patterson, but I do think
at the goal line, they will care.
I think you'll see a little bit more of Montgomery down there than
you will the other guys. Yeah, and Trubisky was on
a radio interview this past week, and he said, we have a three-headed
monster. I don't think Davis is going to get just completely
punted and is a break glass in case of
emergency type of guy. I think he's going to get work, too.
He could be the one working at the goal line. Wouldn't be a surprise if that's the case.
They could all get
reps inside the five.
We saw Cohen inside the five last
year. Yeah, I don't think you want to overvalue
Montgomery, but late round five, early round six is a good spot for him.
Okay, so if you take Josh Jacobs for Oakland,
David Montgomery for the Bears,
Miles Sanders for the Eagles,
rank them in terms of catches.
I'd probably do it like that.
Yeah, Jacobs, Montgomery, Sanders.
Okay.
I still want to see what Philly's backfield looks like once they pare everything down.
So was Paris Campbell the first receiver taken, rookie receiver?
He might have been.
He's my favorite rookie receiver, so it's not like I was really paying attention to anybody else.
Yeah, I went Campbell and Hardman, two picks apart.
And I took Geronimo Allison in between them.
I hate you.
Dave took Paris Campbell.
I took Geronimo Allison, and Chris Towers took Mikko Hardman.
And it's so funny because Jamie can guess every one of my picks.
He always knows who I'm going to take.
It's so frustrating.
And the funny thing is I was looking at your roster at the time,
and I don't remember exactly off the top of my head what it was through the first six picks
but I was like oh he may actually not take Allison here oh because I had three wide receivers right
something like that I think so yeah and I did I did so sorry about that no I think I'm not sure
we'll go over my team because Dave loved it and I have no problem talking about myself uh yeah
what do you think about camp Campbell and Hardman going in the seventh round?
So I don't know when that was in the draft.
It's the right spot because you look at the other receivers that are there.
I like Allison better, but it's not by much.
I think you can argue the upside for all three of those guys,
Campbell, Allison, and Hardman, and the downside for all three of them.
After that, it's Shepard.
I mean, we talked about this.
Is he the best Giants receiver? Maybe.
D.D. Westbrook was
the fourth receiver there, or fifth receiver there.
So Campbell, Allison, Hardman, Shepard, then
Westbrook's in round eight.
Kiki QT in round eight. That's a reach in my opinion.
Fitzgerald, Golden Tate.
So when you're starting to look at these guys, that's
kind of where it comes out. Now, we did do this draft
before the Doug Baldwin
news happened,
which was when he was released. I do think that you're going to see, just because of the
opportunity for Metcalf, no matter what the scenario is, at least right now, he's still
coming off the combine where everybody knows his name because of the pictures that were released
and the numbers that he ran. And he was expected to be such a high first-round pick. That did not happen.
I would not be surprised if he's the first rookie
receiver drafted. Ahead
of Campbell, ahead of Hardman. I wouldn't do it.
I know Dave and you wouldn't do it, Adam, but
I think you're going to get that happening
a lot. I might.
No, I think I'd take Hardman.
And I've talked about
Paris Campbell and just how
it's been so long since there have been two wide receivers who have been good for the Colts.
Because luck just spreads the ball around so much.
You know Hilton's going to get his, but you also know the tight ends catch a lot of touchdowns.
The running backs catch balls out of the backfield.
So I think it was Reggie Wayne and T.Y. Hilton in Hilton's first year of his career or something like that.
The last time you had like two 800-yard receivers.
Gosh, I'm sorry I don't remember the stat off the top of my head.
But the takeaway was –
Yeah, it was the Bruiserians year.
It was 2014, I believe.
The takeaway was it's just Andrew Luck has not given us a number two wide receiver
that's been good for fantasy since either his rookie year or Hilton's rookie year
or whatever it was.
And, of course, the argument is like they haven't had Paris Campbell.
I get that.
But, I mean, if you use Ebron last year as the – But I don't use that because you know what he does with tight ends.
I mean, you know where he goes in the red zone.
He goes for everybody.
I'm in agreement with you.
I think, again, this is a good spot for Campbell,
but I wouldn't necessarily overvalue
Campbell as a guy who's going to be a starter for a fancy team
unless you're talking about three receiver sets. Now, Hardman
has a little bit of a higher ceiling
because of the Tyreek Hill situation and who's not
going to be there if he's not there.
Yeah. Okay.
And then we also had
Nikhil Harry and Marquise Brown
going in round nine. Did I take Marquise Brown going in round nine.
Did I take Marquise Brown?
Yes.
I think I did.
And, you know, I like to say that I said it on the Monday show after the NFL draft.
On the Friday show, I basically trashed the Marquise Brown pick from a fantasy standpoint, you know, by the Ravens.
And then on the Monday show, I said, well, you know, thought about it.
Let's give the guy a chance.
He's so explosive. Give him the ball, get him in space, and said, thought about it. Let's give the guy a chance. He's so explosive.
Give him the ball. Get him in space and let him do his thing.
I've come around there.
Then Nikhil Harry, certainly
opportunity with the Patriots. Those guys
went in round nine.
More rookies were drafted after that. Daryl
Henderson, DK Metcalf.
Again, I think if the news had happened
a day earlier,
he's in that same round seven, round eight range with Hardman and Campbell.
And the only rookie quarterback taken was Kyler Murray.
So I think that covers the rookies, right?
We're good?
Well, no, we had the tight ends.
We had one owner drop both rookie tight ends, and he did it. It was your favorite person to pick on, Matthew Koka.
He took Noah Fant first in round 10, and then Hawkinson in round 11.
Did they both finish the season strong with Iowa?
Probably.
Why, is that something he says?
Yeah, it was his reason for taking everyone that he took in the draft.
Curtis Samuel.
Yeah, he finished the season strong. Yeah, I didn't like it, but if one hits, he's in the draft. Curtis Samuel. Yeah, he finished the season strong.
Yeah, I didn't like it, but
if one hits, he's in good shape.
Yeah, that's why I do like him.
But there are other guys on the board that were better.
At tight end? Vance McDonald in particular for me.
What's the upside with Vance
McDonald? Chris Herndon was another one.
What's the upside with Chris Herndon?
Delaney Walker was another one.
They're all proven
and rookie tight end struggle the track record of rookie tight ends is very clear there's no
doubt about it but i like the opportunity that both of these guys are going to get
and if you're if you're just gonna look squarely at all right i'm probably gonna end up cutting
this tight end anyway give me somebody with some upside i yes you can make the case for vance
mcdonald you can maybe make the case for a couple other guys. Yes, you can make the case for Vance McDonald.
You can maybe make the case for a couple other guys.
But I think you can make the case for both of these rookie tight ends as well.
You can.
It's just time and time again, everything shows us rookie tight end struggle.
There's been one in the last five years that has been good, and it was Evan Ingram.
Right.
And so you have a track record with Matthew Stafford with a high-profile rookie tight end,
which was Eric Ebron, and he was terrible.
Who, would you agree, wasn't quite ready for the NFL when he came in?
Ebron?
I don't remember at the time.
No, I wouldn't really.
He was more athlete than refined prospect and pass catcher.
That's probably fair, but still.
It's still a situation of quarterback that hasn't leaned on tight end.
When he had one, that was supposed to be great.
That's not necessarily true.
What tight end has he made good?
Brandon Pettigrew.
He had like over 100 targets with him.
And he was great?
For a couple seasons.
He was good enough.
He was top 10 in fantasy.
I'm not looking for him to be the number one tight end.
He's not going to be.
Congratulations, Matt.
You just drafted the next Brandon Pettigrew.
But if he's a top 10 tight end by the end of the year,
I don't
think it's that bad of a pick. When did he take him?
Round 10? Round 11?
It's late. You're taking shots on
players then anyway, and if you whiffed
on the stud tight ends. But there are other guys there that are
better. I don't know if they're necessarily better.
I can't say that.
I can't say that with Hawkinson.
I think he's ready.
I can certainly see it,
but I personally will take my chances
on the targets coming from
Roethlisberger in that offense,
then the targets coming from either Joe Flacco or Matthew
Stafford for the two rookies.
This whole time I've been trying to find a stat
about rookie-t rookie tight ends and I
can't find it, so
we're not going to give it.
Jamie just gave it. Yeah, but there's
more to it. Okay, we've had four
top 16 tight ends
in the last three seasons.
So Hunter Henry,
OJ Howard, Chris Herndon
were usable.
But as Jamie said, only Ingram was top 10.
Yeah, I think you'll get usable production from those guys,
but it'll be one of those situations where, for the most part,
they're going to get drafted as secondary options.
Like I think if you're telling me that Coca took Proven Guy and Hawkinson.
Proven Guy.
Like if he took Vance McDonald in one of the rankings,
you'd have a different deal.
I hate using Vance McDonald as an example because he hasn't exactly been
great,
but it's just opportunity for him.
But if he doesn't,
he,
I don't think he's going to know in this scenario.
And I know Dave,
you've advised us,
we talked about this last week.
If you take both these guys,
you're not going to know which week to start them because they'll have the
good week.
And then you'll say,
okay,
maybe now's the opportunity for him.
And then it'll go away.
Cause that's just what rookie tight ends do.
As opposed to Vance McDonald or Chris Herndon
or any of these other late-round tight ends
that have shown just years of consistency.
But they're in different offenses that will have the opportunity to use them,
I think, a little bit more based on quarterback play
that have used those tight ends a little bit more
and offenses that have used the tight ends a little more.
Adam Gase with his tight end track record,
however you want to nitpick it.
Does he really have a tight end track record? What was the track record in Miami?
Julian Thomas was great.
Miami was terrible.
Chicago, he had a top 12 season out of his guys.
He had a good tight end.
Out of his guys?
Martellus Bennett?
Wasn't that his tight end in Chicago?
Maybe I'm wrong.
The thing about Adam Gase is Peyton Manning was Adam Gase's quarterback.
I don't want to go back on Adam Gase's track record because you don't know how much was Gase and how much was just Peyton Manning.
Sure, which is why you go off of what you saw in Miami versus what you saw on other stops along the way.
Although I will give him credit in Chicago because, I mean, John Fox wasn't calling the play.
I think Jamie's argument is good with McDonald.
I think the real knock on Vance McDonald is that he's old and he breaks down.
And outside of that, if he stays healthy for 16 games, then you know what?
He might be a good, consistent fantasy tight end.
And you might wish you took him ahead of the rookies.
Who did take Vance McDonald in this draft?
You did.
Oh, that's right!
And what round did you take him in?
I don't know. You tell me. Round 11. Hey, that's right. And what round did you take him in? I don't know.
You tell me.
Round 11.
Yeah.
Hey, round 11.
After both rookies came off the board.
How about that?
Would you have taken one of the rookies?
No.
Well, if McDonald were off the board,
I probably would have taken Hawkinson.
Yeah, I could see myself taking Hawkinson.
Yeah, that's fine.
Yeah, but I would have gone with McDonald over Hawkinson.
Yeah.
All right, guys.
We'll take one more quick break here.
When we come back, we'll talk about some of our favorite squads.
And, yeah, I'm interested to get your thoughts on the round four conundrum I had.
I thought I made the right pick, but Twitter did not agree.
We'll be right back on fantasy football.
Fantasy football.
This is football.
Fantasy football today.
Stick around.
Did you know that across Ontario, utility damage happens 19 times a day?
That's over 4,222 incidents a year.
Don't let your next dig be one
that causes costly delays or safety risks.
Before you break ground,
make it a point to request a locate.
It's not just the law.
It's a step to keep your team and community safe.
Visit OntarioOneCall.ca and avoid unnecessary
damages to get the job done right data sourced from the orcga 2023 dirt report okay so yeah round
four right what do you do here if you're old adam azer you took james connor in round one
you took levy on bell in round two did not did not expect, did not really like to go running back,
running back with my first two picks, but oh well.
Two years ago, Kevin Colbert loved your draft.
Dave Gettleman loved my draft this year too, Kevin Colbert.
Yeah, so I got the Steelers guys and the former Steelers, Conner and Bell.
Round three, I took Julian Edelman.
And round four, do I take Kenny Galladay or Aaron Jones?
I took Galladay to get my second wide receiver.
And most people thought I should have taken Aaron Jones.
In a PPR league, to take three receivers with your first four picks,
or to take three running backs with your first four picks,
I didn't really want to do that. I wanted a little bit more balance. Did I make the right call? What would you have done there? I was in the exact same boat you were in.
I was picking right after you,
and two of my first three picks were running backs.
And I was hoping for Galladay to fall into my lap,
and you took him one spot ahead of me.
I would have taken Galladay ahead of Jones if I had my choice between the two for the reasons you laid out. You want to
have a nice balanced team, but I couldn't pass up the value of Aaron Jones. I can start him in my
flex in the event that Damian Williams is not who I think he is. I've got Aaron Jones ready to go
at a, at a moment's notice in my lineup. But what would you have done, Adam, if both Jones and Galladay were gone?
As they should have been.
Let's take a look.
Let's just say, like, Watkins was picked ahead of both of them.
So I'll give you three guys.
He shouldn't have been.
Three guys.
And Landry, Cooks, and Watkins.
I would have taken, I probably would have taken Brandon Cooks or Marlon Mack.
Well, he had the
shot at Mack. Actually, why am I
not considering Watkins there? I really think
I probably should take Watkins there
because we don't know what Tyreek Hill's situation
is, obviously. The only thing
the knock on Watkins, which is
obvious, is his health. If you just look at his
numbers over, we talked about this,
what a 16-game pace would have been
if you take out the games where he didn't finish.
He would have been exactly what Odell Beckham was
in 12 games last year, or 13 games last year.
Okay, but do you think
he... Yeah.
His numbers are pretty
damn good. And his targets should go up.
However incremental, they should go up.
Okay, wait, wait, wait. Let me
go to his numbers again, because I messed that up.
I typed in Tyreek Hill. His numbers were very good, but Sammy Watkins were not as good. Okay, wait, wait, wait. Let me look at his numbers again because I messed that up. I typed in Tyreek Hill.
His numbers were very good, but Sammy Watkins were not as good.
Okay, so I don't know if Sammy Watkins deserves to be a round three pick.
If he stays healthy and Tyreek Hill will play. No, round four.
Round four pick.
If he stays healthy and Tyreek Hill were playing, you know,
didn't have this situation.
I don't think – I think it would be a late round four, early round five pick. If Tyreek Hill were playing, you know, didn't have this situation. I don't think I think it'd be a late round for early round five pick.
If Tyreek Hill is playing.
Yes.
Oh, no way he's going this high.
Right.
That's what I'm saying.
So that's not the only knock on him is not injury.
It's also we don't know what Tyreek Hill situation is.
No, but we're going with the assumption as a site that Tyreek Hill is not playing.
Are you?
Because then I feel like...
We don't have him ranked.
Okay, but are you really doing that on draft day?
Because if that's the case, then this is probably a steal.
Okay, let me phrase it this way.
39th overall he went.
Do you think he went 39th overall, Sammy Watkins, with the idea of Tyreek Hill not playing at all?
Not playing at all.
If Tyreek Hill were suspended for the season or cut by the Chiefs, this is where you'd
take Sammy Watkins, 39th?
I would not take him ahead of Galladay Jones.
Maybe Mack and Kerryon Johnson, but then he's in this range.
Okay, because I was thinking he'd go earlier.
No, because you have to build in
the Sammy Watkins injury factor.
He hasn't played 16 games since his rookie year.
Last year he missed time with two separate injuries.
It's just the nature of who he is as a player.
We could have this argument.
We can rewind 2015 when he
had a decent rookie season.
We've had this talk about Sammy Watkins all the time.
I don't know if I'm taking him in round five,
even if Tyreek Hill doesn't play this year.
I've got it ranked that way.
I don't have Tyreek Hill ranked,
so that means I don't think he's going to play.
So where's Mahomes' numbers coming from then,
if you don't like Sammy Watkins?
Because I think he spreads it all around.
It's not that I don't like Sammy Watkins.
I think he'll be good enough to be taken in round six.
I think Hardman is going to play a role i think travis kelsey is going to
explode you think kelsey's going more i think he could be even better than what he was last year i
think he could be a monster and i think the running backs are going to catch a lot of passes
all right well you must like damian williams though so uh as as mentioned let's uh talk about
our favorite teams.
But real quick, Dave, I wasn't planning on bringing this up,
but we may as well.
What did you think about going running back, running back with your first two picks?
Oh, no, you didn't.
I didn't.
You had two running backs going into round four,
but they were your second and third round picks?
Correct.
Yeah, okay, okay.
And so did I like taking a third running back there?
Is that kind of what you were getting at?
Yeah, sure.
Because you did take Aaron Jones there.
So you had Julio Jones, Joe Mixon, Damian Williams, and Aaron Jones.
That's actually a pretty sexy team.
I know.
Thank you.
That's pretty sexy.
That's good stuff.
Who's your number two wide receiver?
Jamie thinks it's three quarters sexy.
Not all the way sexy.
I don't like it really that much. Really? Yeah. Why? Because it three quarters sexy. I don't like it really that much.
Really? Why?
Because it's my team.
I don't like Damien Williams.
That throws it off me. The first two picks are great.
And then
I don't like Calvin Ridley where he took him either.
And I'm a big fan of Ridley.
You know what I did though
that I think is a big no-no?
And Dante Pettis too.
I took four Falcons.
I took four Falcons.
That's okay.
I have four Falcons in my starting lineup.
I think their offense is going to be on fire this year.
Yeah, let me tell you something.
I took three Chiefs in the Superflex League that we did last year,
and I was like, I don't know about that, and I made the finals.
Right.
It works out when the team is good, but, I mean,
any one of those guys gets hurt,
and it pretty much hurts the upside of my entire team.
Okay, Dave, come and see how good I look.
Talk about how great my team is.
I liked your team a lot.
If I could trade with anybody in this league, team for team,
I would trade to get your team.
Bell and Connor as your top running backs,
I think is outstanding.
Edelman and Galladay at wide receiver.
You did what I would have done,
which is take the second receiver
over the third running back.
Cooper Cup is your flex.
If we're assuming that he's ready to go
for the start of the season,
we talked about it last week,
just how good he could be.
Sean Watson at quarterback,
great value when you got him.
Potential to be the number one quarterback in fantasy.
You always want to get somebody who's got that type of upside.
And I like your bench, too.
I like that Miles Sanders is there.
Allison's there.
Hollywood Brown is one of my favorite bench receivers.
Just a guy to have on standby.
My least favorite pick is probably Delaney Walker.
But who cares?
Because you got him late.
My second tight end, yeah.
Yeah, he's your second tight end.
Like, if you're going to draft a second tight end,
I don't know if Delaney Walker is the best one for it.
Maybe in PPR it's okay because if he is his old self,
he'll catch six passes a game.
Yeah.
I don't even know if he'll do that, though,
because they have A.J. Brown and Adam Humphreys.
He got hurt in the middle of week one,
and he had four catches for 52 yards on seven targets.
Is he still going to be that security blankie for Mariota now that Mariota's got two other short area guys that he can dink and dunk to?
I don't know, but I do think that Delaney Walker could sneak his way into the top 12 at tight end this year.
Okay.
Well, who cares?
He's going to be on your bench to start the season.
I think McDonald is a great streaming option to begin the year.
I like your team a lot.
Thank you.
And I have Deontay Foreman,
Miles Sanders,
and Jamal Williams as my bench running backs.
I don't know that you need five running backs in a PPR league,
but I like the value.
And Foreman is probably,
at least right now,
somebody I'm going to be taking a lot.
Because I feel like if they didn't address running back,
and that means that, to me, Deontay Foreman's going to have a role.
And then that means he's going to have the opportunity
to be better than Lamar Miller,
which I think anyone could see that happening.
Yep.
So I'm going to be taking...
Let me just see where I took Deontay.
In round 12.
Yeah, okay, I like that pick.
Great.
It's a good pick.
Okay.
Jamie, did you have a favorite team?
Outside of the Gronkowski pick, I thought George did a nice job.
Let's take a look at George's team.
What did you like about it?
It's one of those things where when you're making picks at the time
or you're seeing picks happen at the time, it's not the best.
I hate this team.
Wow.
You do?
Yeah, I hate it.
You do?
I don't think it's a team worth hating.
I just think I hate it.
Well, his flex is LeSean McCoy.
His flex is terrible.
I hate his bench.
His bench is not appealing.
I would say his flex is going to end up being Carlos Hyde.
But I do like Larry Fitzgerald and Andy Isabella in PPR.
I think Isabella is going to be the best rookie receiver for the Cardinals.
And I don't think Fitzgerald's done.
Okay, his team is Patrick Mahomes, who he took in round three.
He's got a top three quarterback, a top three tight end,
a top three quarterback, a top three tight end, a top three receiver,
and I like his top four running backs
of Lindsey, Henry, Hyde, and McCoy.
Okay, here's the team for George.
Mahomes, Derek Henry, and Phillip Lindsey,
Devontae Adams and Mike Williams,
Zach Ertz,
LaShawn McCoy,
the Rams, and Harrison Butker.
On the bench,
Damian Harris.
That's the rookie running back for the Patriots. Actually,
we didn't talk about him. Did we? Oh, yeah,
you did at the beginning. I'm sorry.
Carlos Hyde for the Chiefs, Chris Thompson,
Larry Fitzgerald, Rob Gronkowski,
and Andy Isabella. Yeah, I don't know. I don't
like it. I looked
at where he took Gronk. If he doesn't take Gronk
there in round 11, he takes Anthony Miller
or he takes Tyrell Williams,
I like the receiver depth a little more.
He doesn't need the second
tight end. No, Gronk was just the...
He's got hurts.
Couldn't he have waited at least two more rounds
to take Gronk anyway? No, he just didn't have to take him.
I think I don't like the Mahomes pick.
I don't like where he took him either,
but again, when you look at the finished product,
if Mahomes doesn't lose much from last year
and Ertz is the same guy
and Adams is the same guy,
those are three dominant players.
He got Phillip Lindsey in round four.
I believe he got Derek Henry in round five.
He did.
He took Derek Henry one pick before Mark Ingram.
So I think that that was good value on the running backs,
and that kind of saved him.
Yes.
So let me just say this, and everybody,
this could be the thing that we clip and play over and over again,
and people can kill me for it,
but Patrick Mahomes is definitely going to lose a lot from last year.
Of course.
That was going to be the case no matter who he was.
This is what you're worried about, people killing you?
So don't say if Patrick Mahomes doesn't lose much because he's going to 100%.
No, he's going to lose.
But again, when you look at the finished product of what he has as a team,
I don't think you're going to see a lot of people have Patrick Mahomes
ranked outside of a top five scenario.
Right?
No, for sure.
Okay. Zach Ertz is going to be ranked among of a top five scenario. Right? No, for sure. Okay.
Zach Ertz is going to be ranked among the top three tight ends.
Devontae Adams, I'm assuming, I'll say top five.
Should be number one.
Right?
And then the rest of it, just from a starting standpoint,
yes, his flex could be a little bit weak.
But Lindsey and Henry, to go with those other guys,
I think Mikes is a very
good third receiver with the chance to be a number two guy with the bump and targets that he should
get without tyra williams there so look there are holes there are holes in all these teams i don't
think there's a great team in this league i just want to remind you we've talked about this before
if you take 10 off of what mahomes did last year he still would have been qb1 if you took 20 off
of what he did last year he would have been qb2 if you took 25 off what he did last year, he still would have been QB1. If you took 20% off of what he did last year,
he would have been QB2. If you took
25% off what he did last year, he would have been
QB5.
If you think he's going to be three-quarters
of what he did last year,
he's going to be great.
He's going to be worth taking as a top
five quarterback. I just think
if you want to take a top
five quarterback, you can wait a little longer than round three if you absolutely have to cinch in one of those five.
Any team that really screwed the pooch?
Chris Towers' team.
I don't like very much.
He took Juju.
He could have had Odell or Michael Thomas.
He took Watkins.
He's the one that took Watkins in early round four.
I like the Kelsey pick.
I'm not feeling Devontae Freeman.
His running backs
are Freeman, Miller, Darius
Geis. He got Ito to go
with Freeman. I guess that's smart.
He got the other Freeman, Royce Freeman.
Those are his running
backs.
He's got Hardman to go with Sammy Watkins.
He drafted very responsibly.
This is not a good team.
He also has Dak Prescott.
You know what?
This is almost like a better best ball team.
With one exception.
His quarterback is Dak.
He likes to wait on quarterback.
It's the only quarterback he's got.
Yeah.
On the surface in a traditional fantasy league It's the only quarterback he's got. Yeah.
On the surface, in a traditional fantasy league like the one we just drafted,
I don't like his team.
Right, and that's the thing.
It's like Chris likes to wait on quarterback, but I think he takes it too far.
And to be fair, once he got Amari Cooper, Dak was certainly usable.
I mean, he was pretty good.
18, 22, 14, 30, 15, 30,
6, 18, and 41 fantasy points. He had three
humongous games in nine
games with Amari Cooper.
He unfortunately had
five
pretty
not necessarily bad, but
18 or fewer fantasy points, and then he had
22 against the Eagles.
But right, like wait on quarterback.
Sure, wait on quarterback.
Don't wait that.
Cam Newton went in the 12th round.
You could have done that instead of Dak in the 13th round.
That could end up being the best pick in the draft.
Could be, definitely.
And to Chris's point, before week one, if he wanted to,
he could cut Prescott.
Here are the quarterbacks who were not taken,
because I always think this is interesting, especially in our drafts.
Big Ben.
Garoppolo.
Josh Allen.
Cut Dak right now for Garoppolo.
Trubisky.
Cousins.
Lamar Jackson.
Does anybody have?
Josh Rosen.
Cousins will be picked up at some point.
Does anybody have Dak ahead of Garoppolo?
Yes, as of now.
I believe I do, too.
Really?
Interesting.
Why?
Tell me why.
I think Dak's numbers with Cooper were good.
Yeah.
They were.
I think Gallup gets better.
Jason Witten's a difference maker.
I think having Travis Frederick back will help.
Offensive coordinator is a big plus, too.
I like the new OC.
If you look at Amari Cooper, the nine regular season games with Dallas,
he had 53 catches, 725 yards, and six touchdowns.
He had 397 yards and five touchdowns in two of those nine games.
And in the other seven, he had 327 yards.
That's fewer than he had in those two big ones and one touchdown.
A little feast or famine going on, yeah.
A little bit, but then he had two good playoff games.
He had seven catches for 106 yards against Seattle
and six for 65 and a touchdown at the Rams.
Kind of screwed up the narrative a little bit.
You do wonder what kind of player you're going to get there.
I think he'll show better consistency.
I think the targets will be there for him.
He'll get used better in Dallas than he did in Oakland.
And I'm okay with Dak Prescott round 13 pick.
I'm not okay with Dak Prescott, your only quarterback on your roster.
I have no problem with it in a league like this.
Because of who's on the waivers?
Why would you need to spend another pick on two guys?
So you have the second guy.
I'm pretty sure they face the Giants in week one
because they always face the Giants in week one.
They do.
So that should be a good opportunity for Dak.
He's got four receivers on his bench.
One of them is Tyrell Williams.
I'd much rather have Tyrell Williams
than second quarterback.
Yeah.
I don't know.
I've got Juju.
I've got Watkins.
I've got all these other guys.
When am I going to use Tyrell Williams?
When are you going to use another quarterback
unless Prescott snakes in week one?
You go out and get somebody else.
I just want to have them already on my team.
For what? You just said all these him already on my team. For what?
You just said all these guys are on waivers.
Why?
Because I'm never going to start Tyrell Williams.
Okay, but if you're believing in Dak Prescott
as your number one guy, what's the difference?
You'd much rather have running back
and receiver than the second quarterback.
I'd rather have the second quarterback
just in case Dak doesn't do what I think he is capable of doing,
which is finishing toward the bottom of the top 12.
Being a good quarterback. I think that you could... doing, which is finishing toward the bottom of the top 12. Being a good quarterback.
I think that you could...
I've got an unusable receiver.
I don't see how, even if you like...
You have an unusable second quarterback.
Don't draft Dak if that's not the guy you like.
If you don't like Dak,
or if you do like Dak better than Garoppolo,
I still think that Garoppolo clearly, to me at least,
has more upside.
So, I mean, Dak, to me, I think you should have a second quarterback.
I just don't think that Prescott has, like, league winner upside.
He can get a second quarterback.
It's very easy for him.
But if Garoppolo goes off in week one, then you're not getting a second quarterback.
Somebody else is going to get him.
Okay, then whoever's taking that guy is dropping somebody that, A, you can use at a different spot,
or there's probably going to be another guy that goes off in week one, too.
Probably a guy like Tyrell Williams
is who he'll drop. Could be.
Or he could drop Meikle Hardman,
who may stink. Or he could drop Darius Geis, who may not be
100%. Or Deshaun Jackson doesn't have
one of his big boomer bus games. There are lots of guys he could
drop. No one's dropping
Deshaun. He could drop Dak.
He could drop Dak. I mean, it's very easy.
You don't take two quarterbacks in this type of format.
I don't agree with that blanket statement.
You're right.
It should not be a blanket statement.
If you have a guy you believe in, you don't need to take two guys.
Let's just say, how many teams do you think have two quarterbacks in the draft we just did?
Three.
Four.
I'm looking.
It's four.
Yeah.
I'm on fire today.
And those quarterback combos are
Wentz and Rivers, makes sense.
Wilson and Brady.
Cam Newton and Kyler Murray.
Andrew Luck and Jared Goff.
So the last one obviously stands out.
Why would you take...
But honestly, Jared Goff has QB1 upside.
So I'm okay with this.
Jared Goff is actually a quarterback that you might be able to trade
and get some decent quarterback.
Who is trading?
How many leagues have you played in the last five years, Adam,
where you've traded a quarterback that's not Dynasty?
I couldn't say.
You've traded a quarterback.
You would know.
Trading a quarterback or getting what you think is good value?
Trading a quarterback.
I don't know. I've traded a quarterback. I don't know.
I've traded quarterbacks.
I don't get what I was doing.
Give me an example of a quarterback you traded.
I've done it in a two quarterback league.
I won't count that.
Two quarterback or super flex doesn't count.
That doesn't count.
Two years ago, I had Deshaun Watson
and another quarterback,
and I traded the quarterback for a bench running back.
And then Watson got hurt,
and I was scrambling a quarterback the rest of the way.
That's not a cautionary tale about quarterbacks.
The real cautionary tale is if you get that second quarterback,
you're not going to get fair value for him.
It's been that way for years,
ever since the position's been as deep as it is.
So then why would you want to carry two?
Because you want to have as many chances as you can to have a top 10 quarterback.
That's why.
It's exactly why you might carry two tight ends if you're streaming tight ends.
You want to have as many, just like you're drafting as many running backs as you can.
That's the point of those late round picks.
If I'm taking my chances on Sammy Watkins as a starting receiver or Darius Geis as a flex option.
I would rather have backups at those positions
than I would at quarterback,
where we've just named five guys
that are available on waivers,
not including Kirk Cousins and Matthew Stafford
and Derek Carr and other guys
that could have the chance to all be in the same range,
maybe not top five, but certainly 10 through 15.
So I think what I've sort of,
I agree with both sides here. I think what I've sort of, I agree with both sides here.
I think what I've sort of come to conclude
just by myself is that
if there's a quarterback available late
that has legitimate superstar potential,
then I have no problem
rostering that guy as a backup.
And that's what I think
the Andrew Luck, Jared Goff owner did.
And that's sort of how I see, I don't know that I see superstar,
but I see like total breakout in Garoppolo,
but I'm just, get used to it.
I'm going to like Garoppolo more than probably anyone.
And then you could maybe trade Andrew Luck and get something
and then just ride with Jared Goff in that scenario.
But again, we just don't see that.
I understand that you're going to get less value than you should for Andrew Luck,
but you still might be able to turn Luck
into something better than what's on waivers.
Agreed.
You would probably end up doing Luck
and Luck and Charter for a better start.
You're also going to probably have,
I'll say at minimum, two to three weeks of,
God, I need to drop somebody,
and I can't drop that guy.
That's true.
Yeah, that's a good point.
That's a good point.
You don't feel like, oh, crap, I can't really drop.
He can drop Jared Goff.
I went through that with Kirk Cousins,
where I think I did drop him at some point because I had to,
and it ended up not being a big deal.
I was like, God, I can't drop Kirk Cousins.
But no, I could drop Kirk Cousins.
All right, we're done with the draft.
Game of Thrones, Jamie?
Sure.
Okay, thank you for listening.
If you don't want any spoilers, last few minutes will be a Game of Thrones, Jamie? Sure. Okay. Thank you for listening. If you don't want any spoilers,
last few minutes will be
a Game of Thrones talk
and we will talk to you on Thursday.
We're going to have some guest interviews
coming up,
some beat writers on the show
like we had on Friday
with our Seattle guest, Dick Fane.
We're going to have more of that,
different teams
throughout the next few weeks,
hopefully to fill in the blanks.
Okay.
It's a good episode.
What's wrong with everybody? Why did everybody everybody hate it what's going on here it's i i think it's people didn't get what they wanted you know i kind of
did like who could not see that this was coming from her i didn't see this coming really i should
have there were a lot of signs but i did not think she was going to
become a mass a mass murderer basically uh you did not to that extent i thought once she um
i thought she was just gonna kill the soldiers like when she started going through the city
yeah i didn't expect her to go full massacre right and just completely tear the city down i also thought that maybe she would just go to the castle and burn that down too i didn't expect her to go full massacre. Right. And just completely tear the city down.
I also thought that maybe she would just go to the castle and burn that down too.
I didn't think she was going to kill Cersei though because I felt like there were more natural people to kill Cersei.
And I actually did like the way Cersei died.
Cersei and Jaime dying together.
Right.
I think there was some criticism about the Euron Jaime fight.
Like, of course, they just happened to find each other on the beach.
Sure.
Sure, but you can't complain
about not getting what you want
and then complaining about,
oh, I got what I want,
but it was too convenient.
My approach has always been,
and we've had this conversation
about season seven in particular,
that I feel like every time I watch it,
I walk away entertained.
So some of the stupidity of it, I'll overlook.
But the thing about this episode was that I liked it, but I didn't really enjoy it.
I wasn't that entertained.
I was shocked.
It was hard to watch.
And I don't say this critically.
I respect the hell out of the episode for not just taking the easy way out.
Because I had been critical of the show.
At first, it was like you never knew who was going to die. You couldn't get too attached to a character. the episode for not just taking the easy way out because i had been critical of the show like at
first it was like you never knew who was gonna die you couldn't get too attached to a character
and then it got really predictable happy ending good guy wins sort of deal and this episode went
back to to like brutal game of thrones and i like i respect the hell out of it uh and okay some
theories some theories. Some theories.
I read the New York Times review,
and I think the New York Times floated this out,
that we did not see Daenerys hardly at all
once the burning started.
And maybe the dragon did that on its own.
Drogon or whatever.
Jaime doesn't think that theory works.
No, I think that was her.
Varys may have gotten word out to someone in the north.
Right, that the one that he burned,
the letter that he burned was not the original one.
It was a decoy, definitely.
He was writing multiple.
Sure, and I do think that there's no way
we've seen the last of Tormund or Ghost or anything like that.
There's just no way.
It was a very unsatisfying ending.
Sansa, obviously, is going to be furious.
So, yeah.
I didn't know anything that was going to happen going into this episode.
I didn't know what it was going to be like.
No, I didn't either.
I didn't expect that that's how it would happen.
I thought actually it would be she goes mad at the end.
Oh, yeah.
I is going to be curious to see who kills her
because you remember the Red Woman's prediction for Arya?
Yes.
Of the eyes shall close?
Right, yeah.
You know what else has green eyes, right?
Daenerys has green eyes, yeah.
Right.
Yeah, that makes sense for her.
But the thing about Arya is that she has gotten away from revenge.
And Daenerys didn't.
Well, not really.
Yeah, she's turned away revenge several times.
She was the whole thing last night when she was going to kill Cersei.
And did she?
No.
She keeps turning away.
She didn't kill Jaime.
She didn't kill the Red Woman.
Well, if you look at most of the people on her list, she didn't kill any of them.
That's the thing.
She has grown up since her time in wherever the hell she was.
She absolutely has. That was the whole no has she grown up obviously but i still think though that if she now she's pissed but but the hound has not grown out of it and he
even said her like don't become like me and she has had several opportunities to exact revenge
on the people on her list and she hasn't done it uh but will she make an exception now when she put
daenerys basically on her list yeah i i one thing i i wouldn't be surprised if uh you know the the
whole kingslayer does john become the queenslayer dave are you finding any of this entertaining
since you've never seen the show the problem that i'm realizing is that i don't think i'm ever going
to be able to enjoy the show because now I know what's going to happen.
So when I start watching it,
you guys tell me. Am I going to be able to
understand? Or not. I'll be able to understand.
Will I be able to enjoy it knowing
that I know the fate
of so many characters and
how it's all going to end?
I think so. Not as much. But yeah, actually,
the funny thing is, when I went back... By the time you start
watching, you'll forget most of it. You will forget a lot of it.
When I went back and started watching season one again
after season seven before season eight,
I sort of enjoyed it more
because you see the way they set up.
They put the breadcrumbs out there
for you to figure out what's going to happen.
And Jamie, you've rewatched the whole series,
so I don't know if you enjoyed it.
Not yet.
You know, it's funny.
I'm at the point in season seven
where it's right before it gets a little questionable.
Yeah.
So I'm still fine with Season 7.
You don't want to ruin that?
Huh?
You don't want to ruin that?
No, no.
I'm going to finish it.
I just got tied up with some stuff.
Okay.
Anything else you want to say about the episode?
No.
So, okay.
There's some other stuff we were talking about.
What do you think happens with Tyrion?
I have no freaking idea what happens with him.
I think she kills him.
Remember what she said then.
She goes, if you cross me again, I'll do it last time.
That's true.
And then what about, who's going to, what's your prediction?
Who's going to get up on the throne?
I think Jon kills her and ends up on the throne.
I think Jon kills her and Sansa ends up on the throne.
Sansa? Yeah. Jon gives
it to Sansa.
I think she's the Warden of the North.
Okay. Alright.
Yeah!
Great stuff. Loving it. Having so much
fun. I can look forward to Sunday night so
much. But make sure you watch the live basketball
game before you watch the
Game of Thrones.
It was amazing.
It was crazy.
I watched my kid live.
It looked like it was going to
not even come close.
If you get a chance,
it's all over Twitter. Watch the crowd reaction outside
the arena.
Oh, yeah.
It's one of those moments where sports is great.
Love sports. Thanks for listening, everyone.
Talk to you on Thursday.
See ya.