Fantasy Football Today - 12/02 BONUS: Mailbag (Recorded Fri.)

Episode Date: December 2, 2017

We've got plenty of Start or Sit questions, plus shady trades and revisiting the Friendship Strategy, which still has its merits. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: h...ttps://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Transcript
Discussion (0)
Starting point is 00:00:00 This is Fantasy Football Today from CBS Sports. Here we go! Email us at fantasyfootballatcbsi.com. Here we go! It's time to dominate your fantasy league. Let's go! Now, here's some combination of Adam, Dave, Jamie, and Heath. Time for your Saturday mailbag as we get your lineup set for Week 13.
Starting point is 00:00:24 We've got plenty of your start, sit questions, plus we're going to revisit the friendship strategy. Dave and I have a lot of friendship. Hi, friend Dave. Hello, friend Adam. I have a gift for you, Dave. For me? For you, for everyone, all of my friends out there.
Starting point is 00:00:40 It's the ultimate football-watching experience, and it's called Xfinity X1. Get live CBS Sports fantasy football stats in the same place you watch your games. And if you just want to learn more about it, just see how it works. It's very cool. Xfinity.com slash sports.
Starting point is 00:00:56 Xfinity.com slash sports. Yeah, you're very welcome. Good afternoon. It's Friday. We've got some injury updates. You're hearing this on Saturday. We don't have every injury update. Let's get started. Also, we've got some commissioner questions that I'm looking forward to. So, Dave, Rashard Matthews was limited in practice. Will it be a game-time decision? What and then he's limited, then he's questionable, and you just don't know until game time. I would be nervous to use Rashard Matthews given what the situation is. Not to mention given what Rashard Matthews' potential floor is. It's, you know, not that good.
Starting point is 00:01:39 Sean Lee is expected to be back next week for the Cowboys at the Giants. What's your reaction to that, tough guy? Well, it makes me not want to use the Giants running backs next week against them. Their run defense should be a lot better. Yeah, and if you're not loving the Giants running backs this week, well, I can see a lot of people dropping dark. Well, it might be a little premature. Let's see what happens.
Starting point is 00:02:02 Christian McCaffrey could be a game-time decision. Will this affect Cam Newton at all if he doesn't play? Of course. If he doesn't have McCaffreyfree that's one less guy he can throw to and actually i would consider mcafree to be one of his more reliable receivers if only because he's a short yardage target and remember they also drafted curtis samuel samuel kind of the same type of player and now he's on injured reserve so i don't't know if they can really replace Christian McCaffrey's role in the offense. I think it would be a little messy if they didn't have him. Would it help Greg Olson? Could help Greg Olson if Greg Olson plays, and I know he practiced on Friday. Yeah, okay.
Starting point is 00:02:36 Charles Johnson, same game, Carolina's defensive end. He suspended four games for a PED violation. Shame, shame, shame. Chris Hogan won't play this week, and Amir Abdullah returned to practice. But we don't want a Lions running back, right? Two players I don't want to use in fantasy. One, because they're hurt. Oh, you mean Riddick and Hogan?
Starting point is 00:02:57 No, Abdullah and Hogan. Gotcha. I'm not a big Abdullah fan. So, friend, you wanted to revisit the friendship strategy Yes What would you like to say about it? The friendship strategy for those of you who don't know Is my theory
Starting point is 00:03:10 That you could use two roster spots On draft day On wide receivers from the same team Like drafting I think one of the examples I can tell you what my two favorite were It would be like drafting Jordy Nelson and Randall Cobb. And Cobb might be pretty useless, but if Nelson gets hurt,
Starting point is 00:03:31 then you've got a stud in the eighth round or ninth round or something. I wanted to do this with Keenan Allen and Tyrell Williams because I thought Tyrell Williams would be good in the seventh or eighth round anyway. And I wanted to do this with John Brown and J.J. Nelson. So like a mid-round pick and then a late-round pick. Because I thought one of them would emerge as the best wide receiver in Arizona. And maybe that one would have worked, if not for Carson Palmer's injury, if not for all of John Brown's injuries.
Starting point is 00:03:59 Maybe I had something there. But it certainly didn't work for the Chargers. What did you think about the friendship strategy? I could only find four teams where I think it truly worked. And all the other teams, I don't think it really would have worked out that well. If someone wants to call me out on it and suggest a different team than the ones I'm going to say, go ahead. But remember, the whole point of the strategy is to, it's not to necessarily get one receiver right.
Starting point is 00:04:28 It's to have a good receiver on your team plus somebody else in case that main receiver doesn't come through. So we could argue that the Keenan Allen, Tyrell Williams strategy was a success because Keenan Allen, especially the last couple of weeks, has been really, really good. Right. But the whole point of it was you been really, really good. Right. That's true. But the whole point of it was you're basically handcuffing the wide receiver.
Starting point is 00:04:49 The whole point of it was to get a great player, that you assure yourself – you try to assure yourself of one great player. And maybe you have one great player or one useless player, but it doesn't matter. You sort of have – Because you've got the one great player. Right. So the best example, if you had drafted Diggs and Thielen, right? That would have been the best.
Starting point is 00:05:09 I think that's the absolute best one, not only because you would have had one great player, but you would have had two great players. And for a while, that was the case in Houston. If you had gotten DeAndre Hopkins and Will Fuller on the same squad, those two guys were tearing it up with Deshaun Watson. In Detroit, if you have Marvin Jones and Golden Tate, I think both of them were attainable with picks around slash outside the top 50, depending on your league scoring system.
Starting point is 00:05:37 And Carolinas, if you had began the year with Calvin Benjamin and Devin Funchess on your team, you were probably moderately happy. And then when Benjamin got traded to Buffalo, this is before he hurt his knee, you would have been jumping out of the room because you would have had two great receivers on two different teams. But those are the only four that I found where multiple receivers on the same team
Starting point is 00:06:02 have been good for fantasy purposes. But again, the point wasn't necessarily that they both had to be good. The point was that one of them had to be great. multiple receivers on the same team have been good for fantasy purposes. But again, the point wasn't necessarily that they both had to be good. The point was that one of them had to be great. And I think you got that with Carolina. You certainly got that with Minnesota. What were the other ones? Sorry.
Starting point is 00:06:16 Detroit and Houston. Yeah, Detroit, yeah. But you didn't have to do it with Houston. And this is part of the problem with it is that the great receivers that you took early, they're great. You don't need to have the backup to them. No, you don't. But if that guy had gotten hurt, then you would have had a great player there. And that was kind of my point. It's like, not only are you drafting a player that you think in the mid rounds could be good, you know, that's what I thought about Tyra Williams. I was dead wrong. But you also got a guy that if the first guy you drafted got hurt, well, all of a sudden now you've got a much more valuable player
Starting point is 00:06:49 than the one you drafted in the mid-rounds. And I'll tell you another one that could have worked, Mike Evans and Deshaun Jackson. It could have worked. Right? Because if Evans had gotten hurt in week two, then you could have had a really good receiver in Deshaun Jackson that you got in like the sixth or seventh round.
Starting point is 00:07:02 How about, I mean, unfortunately, Brandon Marshall clouded this up, but Odell Beckham did get hurt. If you had taken Beckham and Sterling Shepard, that could have worked out. It didn't really work out because they both got hurt. Shepard certainly stepped up. Right. I wonder if we could spin it forward a little bit.
Starting point is 00:07:16 We know the fantasy playoffs are coming. Are there receivers whose handcuffs, quote-unquote, we could go and pick up as far as stash options go. And the one that comes to my mind is in Detroit, where if Marvin Jones were to go down, don't you think Kenny Galladay would get an uptick in playing time, targets, catches, yards, and touchdowns as an outside receiver replacing another outside receiver? Yeah, I guess. And he's a pretty good player, too. He doesn't get a lot of targets. He's raw.
Starting point is 00:07:46 He's raw, and I wish he had more targets. He certainly started the year off great. I actually still think Tyrell Williams is interesting. I mean, if Keenan Allen got hurt. Yep. Yeah, I mean, Corey Coleman, no. I'm just trying to think off the top of my head here. The problem is that I don't think you can pick up Coleman and Gordon off the waiver wire so easily.
Starting point is 00:08:07 Galladay is going to be out there in a lot of leagues. Right. Even in the leagues that I'm playing in. Is there a guy in Dallas to replace Dez? No, absolutely not. I don't think there is. But – I don't think there's a guy in Denver who you feel comfortable.
Starting point is 00:08:21 No. Cody Latimer. The poster child for this would have been Cooper Cup. We saw last week Cooper Cup at 100 yards. Sammy Watkins had a touchdown because Robert Woods went out. Is DeeDee Westbrook that guy in Jacksonville? I don't think so. I think you've got to get better passing games.
Starting point is 00:08:35 You're talking about some pretty bad passing games. Yeah, I think Hogan would be a good one. I got one for you that you'll love. What? Michael Floyd in Minnesota. No, I don Hogan would be a good one. I got one for you that you'll love. What? Michael Floyd in Minnesota. No, I don't think so. I don't think so. I mean, because then you bring the tight ends into the equation, right?
Starting point is 00:08:53 Like if you had paired Odell Beckham and Evan Ingram, you would have seen the benefits of that as soon as Beckham got hurt. Okay, so anyway, it's interesting. I'm not abandoning it. I think there's some merit there Of course, a lot of fantasy football is Guessing right and guessing wrong I guess wrong with the Chargers guys
Starting point is 00:09:11 So, you know, that happens But doing it with the Chargers guys Didn't hurt you so bad Because you still had Keenan Allen Of course not He's lasted the whole season, he's healthy And he's been really good lately I dropped Tyra Williams.
Starting point is 00:09:25 It was no big deal. He didn't crush my roster. And I would say you swung and missed with the Cardinals, but at least those guys didn't cost you big-time draft picks. Like if you whiffed on both the Chargers, Allen stinks, Tyra Williams stinks. You're talking about a guy you took in round three and another guy in round seven.
Starting point is 00:09:44 That's not fun. No one wants that. But the two Cardinals wide receivers, you miss on them, so what? You took them after round eight. Yeah, I will say that some people are probably listening to this going, Keenan Allen was kind of a dud for like 11 or 10 weeks. So I do get that. But, yeah.
Starting point is 00:10:01 All right, let's wrap that up. He's good now. That's what matters. I do want to tell people that I've had a bit of a software change on my computer. I'm getting this annoying audio issue, and you're probably hearing it, and I am sorry. At best, I'll be able to fix it by Wednesday, I think. No, at worst, by Wednesday. Is that when the plumber comes back to the house?
Starting point is 00:10:21 That's when I'll be in the Fort Lauderdale office to be able to have someone take a look at it. But I know it could be a little annoying, and I apologize. Let's just get through it. Let's read some emails and tweets. FantasyFootball at CBSi.com. From Rob in Pittsburgh. Dear Acer, Richard, Eisenberg, and Cummings.
Starting point is 00:10:37 Those are fantasy analysts. Three fantasy analysts. I previously stashed Rodgers on IR. I have Wentz, and I have Cousins. I'm considering dropping Cousins in hopes that another playoff team picks him up and uses him. Overthinking? Dumb? Genius?
Starting point is 00:10:53 Interesting. Yeah. Because I am nervous to have Kirk Cousins as my number one quarterback after what we saw on Thursday. You could do it. I think you can. I don't think it's a must. I don't think I would encourage everyone to cut Kirk Cousins just because of one game. But I might do it after two or three.
Starting point is 00:11:14 This is an email from Brian. Then it might be a little too late. Brian is in a 10-team PPR league. Start two. Tate, Shepard, Cup, Sanders. I love Cup. And I think Cup has to be the first guy to start, believe it or not. I just think the matchup is great for him against Arizona. And I think Golden Tate's the safer option as the second guy.
Starting point is 00:11:35 I know that we don't feel good about him after what we saw last week, seven yards on four catches. I don't know if I could get seven yards on four catches if I played in an NFL game, but I'd like to think I could come close to seven. I think so. I mean, if you had four catches? Yeah, I think so.
Starting point is 00:11:53 I'm not talking about four targets. I might need like 15 targets to get to four catches in an NFL game. I think you could do it. 20 of them to play Florida's under center. Strange performance. All right, this is from Abraham. Where's he from? Galveston, Texas.
Starting point is 00:12:06 Ted Ginn or Jerick McKinnon? Half PPR. I like Ginn this week. I like the usage the last couple of games. 17 targets. He's caught 13 of them. Hasn't had a big blow-up game, but he's taking it on Carolina. Their secondary is banged up, and that's the weakness of their defense.
Starting point is 00:12:21 And he's playing at home. I think that there's a lot to like about Ginn, and I think it's going to be hard for the Saints to run on Carolina. So Brees is going to have to throw a decent amount, so I'll take my chances with Teddy Ginn. Here's an email from a guy who has something in common with the following people. Arians, Bowen, Bochy, and Grodkowski. Hmm.
Starting point is 00:12:43 He has vowels in his last name. Bruce. I know what it is. I know. I know you know, buddy. Stuck in running back mediocrity. PPR. Let's see how many does he need.
Starting point is 00:12:55 He needs just one. Danny Woodhead. Kenyon Drake. Jamal Williams. Latavius. Quiz Rogers So here's the deal If Jamal Williams is the only guy in the Packers backfield
Starting point is 00:13:12 I.e. Aaron Jones is inactive Then I'm going with him And I think I'm going to go with him Even if Aaron Jones is on the field Kenyon Drake is a guy that just continues To perplex me I don't know if I can trust the Dolphins to give him that big workload, even though he's the main running back against Denver.
Starting point is 00:13:29 The matchup keeps getting better for him. It looks like game script is going to end up helping Drake. The Broncos are going to be without D'Amato Pecco on the defensive line. He's been one of their best run stoppers. Derek Wolfe's another one I don't think he's expected to play. And the Broncos are going to be without two of their starting linemen, including Ron Leary, who's their best lineman.
Starting point is 00:13:49 And so everything is kind of starting to set up for the Dolphins to have a conservative type of approach and game script, and that would really help their run game. They need a good run performance. They haven't had one all year? Could he get to 20 touches?
Starting point is 00:14:06 That's not true. It's not completely untrue, but week two at the Chargers, Jai had 100 yards, I think. Drake broke off that big run against the Panthers. You're going with Williams anyway. I think I'm going to end up going with
Starting point is 00:14:21 Williams regardless, but Drake is someone who I might change my tune on positively before Sunday's games kick off. Okay, we got Rob from a Jersey suburb. Edison. There's some combination of Robert, Jimmy, John, and John. Is that Zeppelin? That's what I was thinking.
Starting point is 00:14:45 It's the Robert and the Jimmy that make it Zeppelin? That's what I was thinking. Yeah, I only know two. It's the Robert and the Jimmy that make it Zeppelin. Right. Okay, well, here's the question. Who should I start at flex, PPR? Anthony Collins? I think it's Alex. Yeah, Alex Collins.
Starting point is 00:14:58 Hunter Henry, Juju, Derek Henry, or Deshaun Jackson? Jamie picked Alex Collins as the start of the week, and I think he did it because the matchup is so favorable. And I don't know if I can count on five-plus catches from Henry, from Smith-Schuster, from Deshaun Jackson. You know Deshaun Jackson's been above five catches twice with Jameis and Winston, seven games. He's only been five catches or more two times in those seven.
Starting point is 00:15:25 I'm going to go with Collins, and I'm going to hope that he catches a couple of passes to pad his stats, but I think he can score, and I think he can get a lot of good yardage in the game against the Lions. And here's an email from Ben. Dear Joey, Ezekiel, Malik, Marshawn, Carlos, and Bradley. Those are going to be Ohio State alum. Yeah, it's got to be, yeah
Starting point is 00:15:45 Should I start Freeman over Devante Parker? Richardson or Murray? Notice that you didn't put Cardale Among the Ohio State players in his email Alright, so it's Freeman over Parker Richardson or Murray? I'm with you on it I would do it
Starting point is 00:16:02 I'd start Freeman over all of them Over all of them? Okay. We talked about it on FFT on Friday. You can go back and watch the video on CBSSports.com. Freeman isn't guaranteed a ton of carries. If you look at the four games before he got hurt, he was somewhere in between nine and 12 carries and one to three catches per game. And believe it or not, in three of those four games,
Starting point is 00:16:22 Tevin Coleman outscored him in non-PPR fantasy leagues. Four single-digit fantasy point performances from Freeman. But I'll still take a mirror over the other guys that you listed. This is Jordan in Kansas City, 12-team PPR. Big matchup, Dave, against the top seed. Are there any not-big matchups left? It's Week 13. No, I've got two matchups that mean absolutely nothing.
Starting point is 00:16:44 So you don't think they're big? No, because I'm locked into playoff spots. Okay. So you don't even care. You shouldn't even bother... I care, but I care more about next week. That's why I already picked up a DST for next week. Make sure you do it. Alright, 12-team PBR. Matt Ryan
Starting point is 00:16:59 or Derek Carr? That's the first question. Ryan over Carr. And two flexes. Cooper Cup, which he's leaning towards. Kenyon Drake. Sterling Shepard. Juju Smith-Schuster. Yeah, Cup and Drake.
Starting point is 00:17:14 Cup and Drake? Okay. Cup and Drake. Non-PPR? No, PPR. PPR. Oh, it is PPR. So you've got Cup for sure.
Starting point is 00:17:22 I think I might go Shepard over Drake at this point. All right. I reserve the right to change my mind. Well, this is kind of the last. You have to check the rankings. Check them Sunday morning. All right. This is from Justin.
Starting point is 00:17:32 Where's he from? Pensacola, Florida. Sit one in PPR. Sit one. Michael Thomas, Devin Funchess, AJ Green, or Doug Baldwin? I'm sitting Funchess. From Logan in California, Ben Roethlisberger or Josh McCown? It's close.
Starting point is 00:17:48 I'm going to take Roethlisberger based on what we've seen the past couple of weeks. From Eric, dear buddy, Walter, and Papa Elf. Pretty sure that's Elf. That's from Elf, right? Yeah, I think that's Elf. You ever see the movie Kicking and Screaming? No. A very underrated movie.
Starting point is 00:18:07 Very underrated. Like legitimately funny. Not just a kid's movie. And it's got Ditka in it. Yeah, good for Ditka. You don't seem interested. Come on, Dave. What?
Starting point is 00:18:21 Be interested. Fake it. Okay, I will run out to the Red Box and watch Kicking and Screaming if they have it. It's funny. Is it on Netflix? Probably not. Danny Woodhead is available in my league, says Eric. Standard scoring.
Starting point is 00:18:36 Looking to pick him up for Week 15 against the Browns. My current number twos are Alfred Morris at Oakland and Darkwa against Philadelphia. Should I drop Darkwa or Landry or Shepard for Danny Woodhead? It's standard scoring. He's got the Browns. What makes you think he's going to have a big game against the Browns? Yeah. No, I don't think so. I don't think game script will help him.
Starting point is 00:19:04 Just like it hasn't really helped him that much so far since he's been back. Yeah. I'd stay put, although you're not going to start Darkwa against the Eagles. No, he would be the first guy I would cut from Landry, Shepard, Morris, Darkwa. You're cutting Darkwa. I don't think you can cut the other three. I don't think you should want to. You don't want to let those guys hit the waiver winner.
Starting point is 00:19:25 You can't cut Morris. You can't. No, he already played. You literally can't. Oh, yes. I don't know. Maybe he's on a site where you can. Maybe. Buck wants you to pick one in standard. Mixon, Burkhead, or Henry? Mixon.
Starting point is 00:19:43 In standard. Austin in O-L-A-T-H-E Olathe, Kansas, there's no way I think it's Olathe Olathe, Kansas Dear Comet, Donner, Blitzen, and the Elf Comet is the dog from Full House This must be Full House
Starting point is 00:20:00 He misspelled Tanner when he wrote down Just kidding everyone Long-term dynasty league do you value elite wide receiver or elite running back because wide receivers have more long-term value what do you think i think wide receivers make more sense because of what he says you want to have elite receivers that are staples in your in your lineup you'd like to think that running backs can do that and be a staple in your lineup, but there just aren't that many that you can really count on being a staple for you for more than two, three years at a time.
Starting point is 00:20:35 Receivers tend to stick around longer, too. They don't have that expiration date that running backs do. And you all need to listen to me now because you're not watching football and playing fantasy properly unless you're using Xfinity X1, the ultimate football watching experience. Go to Xfinity.com slash sports for more details. This is just a better way to enjoy NFL football and fantasy football at the same time. So here's how it works. You don't have to look at your phone anymore to check your scores to get your fantasy info.
Starting point is 00:21:05 You don't have to miss any moments because you were on your laptop or your phone or whatever. You just do it all right there on your TV with Xfinity X1. You get a voice remote, and you look at the voice remote, and you pick it up, and you say fantasy football. And then the remote will pop up. We'll put everything on your screen, excuse me. Right there on your TV screen, you're going to get a very cool display of your CBS Sports Fantasy Football scores, your weekly projections, your roster trends, all of it right there on TV. It just makes it easier.
Starting point is 00:21:32 It's perfect for our listeners. I really think I know what your habits are on Sunday. You're watching the game, and you're looking at your phone. You're looking up your scores, but you want it all in one place. So Xfinity X1 is the best thing for you. Get all of your CBS Sports Fantasy football stats in the same place you watch your games. So, again, the URL, just you want to take a look,
Starting point is 00:21:51 Xfinity.com slash sports. Xfinity.com slash sports. More emails for you from Matt in a city over 5,000 feet above sea level. It's got to be Aurora, Colorado. It's Denver. He is from Denver. Hey, Frodo, Samwise, Merry, and Pippin. Hmm.
Starting point is 00:22:18 Is that Lord of the Rings? It's a lethal weapon. It's a lethal weapon. I'm not a Lord of the Rings guy, Dave. No, it's Lord of the Rings. Yeah, I didn't like's Lethal Weapon. I'm not a Lord of the Rings guy, Dave. No, it's Lord of the Rings. Yeah, I didn't like it. It's an excellent series to watch once. Commissioner question from Frodo here.
Starting point is 00:22:32 Okay. 12-team keeper league. You only get to keep one player. I don't think that's relevant here. One of our owners has quit on the season and stashed everyone good on IR so he can decide what's the best value over the summer. Because of this, he started Chris Thompson in a game with huge playoff implications. He's also currently having an empty running back spot and has Carlos Hyde on the bench.
Starting point is 00:22:58 Literally no one else on his team is not on IR at running back. So he's five and seven. He's not going to make the playoffs. And he did this last week too, but he won. So it didn't have a negative effect. But should I, as commish, cut Chris Thompson or maybe Ben Watson, put Hyatt in the starting lineup and pick up the best running back and play him in Thompson's place? Should I put it to a vote? Basically, he's trying not to gift someone a win by allowing this owner
Starting point is 00:23:24 to put everybody on IR and not set his lineup lineup what should the commissioner do here when somebody's not setting their lineup well there's a difference between not sending your lineup and creating a strategy to better your keeper options for the following year i think it's a little crazy what this quitting owner has done to stash all these IR guys. But if that means that he's going to have a lineup with a bunch of zeros in it, part of me wants to let him do it. I don't want to be a micromanager as a commish and say, no, you've got to have a lineup full of healthy players who are active. And you have to go out there and give it your best shot because this is a keeper league keeping players is part of the strategy even though this guy quit on the season i would
Starting point is 00:24:11 imagine that he is committed to next season if something like this went down in my keeper league i would probably request that he either change his lineup so that he does have at least a majority of players who are going to put up some points or, and maybe and or, pay me next year's dues in advance so that I know he's committed to playing. And does it alter? Yeah, but like... Is it unfair for the teams that aren't playing against this guy? Yeah, it is unfair.
Starting point is 00:24:40 So you're going to let him leave his lineup as is? I might let him leave the lineup as is. Let's put it this way. I don't want to be the one changing it for him. I'm not here to set your lineup. So tell him to set his freaking lineup. But the guy can say, all right, I'm setting my lineup. I've got a quarterback in the quarterback spot.
Starting point is 00:25:02 It might be Aaron Rodgers. You can't, but he's got Chris Thompson at running back. Listen, I understand. I understand. He doesn't care about it anymore, and he's trying to find a keeper for next year. I don't like it. He's hoping one of these IR guys gets the job done. I don't like it.
Starting point is 00:25:18 I'm wondering. Here's what I really want to know is what happened to all the players that he had on his team before he decided to do this did he just dump off eight ten guys that are he's got a decent lineup because he won last week but still the commissioner doesn't want him starting chris thompson i don't blame him i think it's wrong and i think you know i think i do think that every fantasy owner should be more of an unwritten rule you You're obligated to be competitive. You're obligated to set a lineup. It's for the competitive balance of the league. It's not right.
Starting point is 00:25:50 So I don't think that what this guy is doing is right. I disagree with having an empty roster spot and Carlos Hyde on the bench. Carlos Hyde's got to be in the lineup if you have an empty running back spot. And if you're a commissioner who wants to make that fix, fine. But I hate the idea of looking over everybody's rosters and making sure they're all legal and i do oops now i've got to be the one to go and change it for you and you've got to go and tell them no i want i want the owner to make the changes and the commissioner should go to him and say don't be a butthead set your best line i agree
Starting point is 00:26:21 i agree you want to stash a bunch of guys on IR, that's your prerogative, but at least put up your best lineup possible. Okay, I'm totally on board with that. Next email is Jake from State Farm. Dear Michael, George, and Christian. Michael, George, and Christian. Oh, I can give you another hint. Baby, I can pay you to a kiss from a rose on
Starting point is 00:26:49 They're all seals? No, they're all Batman actors What was that song? It was from Batman Returns, I think I don't like that song, man I know Bad memories I know what happened
Starting point is 00:27:04 I'm not talking about it. You said you would. No, I never said I would. You said, ask me on the mailbag. I asked you questions about Jamie's wedding on the mailbag. Okay, fine. I just want you to know that this song has been in my head all day, and I've been thinking of clever ways to sing it to you.
Starting point is 00:27:22 But I made a song about peanut butter and jelly to the tune of Seal's Kiss from a Rose, but I won't sing it. You want to, though. I don't. I can tell. I can see it in your mouth. I forgot the lyrics. Eight-team PPR league. Eight teams.
Starting point is 00:27:39 I needed some advice about what to do about a recent trade that happened in my league. It occurred less than 20 minutes before the trade deadline. Antonio Brown and Deshaun Jackson for Doug Baldwin and Jarvis Landry. It's an eight-team league. Every team's already loaded. The team that got Antonio Brown and Deshaun Jackson for Landry and Baldwin is the number one seed.
Starting point is 00:27:59 The other team has one win. So the one-win team gave up Brown and Jackson. The best team in the league got Brown and Jackson for Baldwin and Landry. Is this a fair trade? What are your thoughts? And it's not a keeper league? It's a – not that I see. You can't allow this trade to happen.
Starting point is 00:28:16 And, again, this is micromanagement of being a commissioner. This is part of the reason why I hate being a commissioner. But you really shouldn't let teams, even though it's technically allowed, you shouldn't let teams that are out of playoff contention in non-keeper formats make deals involving the best, best players in the league. I don't think they should be able to make any deals. I think once you've been mathematically eliminated, you should not be able to trade. I think that's fair.
Starting point is 00:28:41 I don't really think this is that bad of a trade, because you're not starting Deshaun Jackson ever in an eight-team league. So it's Antonio Brown for Baldwin and Landry in PPR. It's really not that bad. It's not, but it's still... You still don't like to see a team with one win
Starting point is 00:28:57 trading the best receiver in fantasy football to a championship contender. I completely agree. When there's no ramifications for the one-team owner. And Jake from State Farm, thank you for the email. Nice khakis. All right, rapid fire to finish it off. PPR from Ben, Duke Johnson or Marshawn Lynch?
Starting point is 00:29:16 Lynch. Travis from Queens, half PPR, Tariq Cohen or Jacquez Rogers? Cohen has more upside. From Matt, Cam Newton, Jared Goff, or Keenum? Who do I start? Goff. Cam, I thought, no? That was my knee-jerk reaction.
Starting point is 00:29:35 Let's change it to Cam pending injuries in New Orleans and in Carolina. All right, this is Alan from Pittsburgh. Vic or Ryan? Just kidding. Pick one. PPR. PPR. Corey Coleman, Orleans is Alan from Pittsburgh. Vic Orion. Just kidding. Pick one. PPR. Corey Coleman, Orleans Darkwa, Corey Davis. It's Coleman.
Starting point is 00:29:52 I love what Vic Orion has become. It's great. It's our secret. It's like a secret handshake to let us know that you've been listening for a long time. Yeah, it's cool. This is from John. What are your feelings on handcuffs as it gets later in the season? Would you drop Booker or Gore for Cadet since I'm the McCoy owner? Yeah, it's cool. Sure.
Starting point is 00:30:11 Yeah, I like it. If you think that the handcuff is going to be better than the other guys on your roster that you never start, I think it's a good strategy. From Matt, PPR. Kareem Hunter, Doug Baldwin. Baldwin. Latavius Murray, Collins, or Hunt? PPR. Collins. From Tyler.
Starting point is 00:30:30 Can I comfortably start two running backs from the same team? In this case, the Saints. Yes. I wouldn't do it from pretty much any team with crappy running backs, obviously, but the Saints are not one of those teams. Do not use both Seattle Seahawks running backs. From Jeremy. Same league, same lineup. Pick two in a standard scoring league.
Starting point is 00:30:49 Alex Collins, Latavius Murray, Lamar Miller. I would sit Murray. From Doc. Should I bench Melvin Gordon for Alex Collins? It's got to be one of those two for a spot I got to be 100% honest with you He also has Fournette Like
Starting point is 00:31:09 I kind of want to sit Fournette I kind of do too I think I'd probably start him over Collins I could make that decision I have them both in one league I'll stick with Fournette I'll say Collins Over Fournette?
Starting point is 00:31:23 Yeah From Captain Trips Hunt or hide It's a touchdown heavy league I'll say Collins. Over Fournette? Yeah. All right. From Captain Trips, hunt or hide? This is a touchdown heavy league. No points until 80 rushing yards or receiving yards. Hunt or hide? Or seven catches? Hide. All right.
Starting point is 00:31:37 Joshua. That's interesting. No points until you get to 80 rushing or receiving yards. That's weird. It's not weird. They're rewarding good players. They get a million points. All right.
Starting point is 00:31:49 Pick two in PPR. Kelsey, Hunt, Drake, Jamal Williams, Peterson. I'm going to go with Kelsey and Jamal Williams. From Juice. Start two in PPR. DeMarco Murray, Latavius Murray. Woodhead. Nixon. Lamar.
Starting point is 00:32:07 Deshaun. Lamar Miller would be one. And to me, it's a debate between Nixon and Deshaun. I think I would take Deshaun over Nixon in a PPR. From Jason, Juju or Drake? I'm going to go with Drake. From Kate, Drake or Burkhead? PPR. From Jason, Juju or Drake? I'm going to go with Drake. From Kate, Drake or Burkhead? PPR. I think I have Burkhead ranked higher
Starting point is 00:32:32 as of now. I could see myself changing to Drake. I can kind of feel myself leaning toward... It's the force. It's making me lean toward Kenyon Drake. I just know I'm going to regret it, but it's looking really good for him. From Jack, pick two.
Starting point is 00:32:50 Rashard Matthews if active, Ginn, Juju, Sterling Shepard. Standard. In a standard league, I think Ginn and Juju is where I'd go. Would you start Matthews over Juju if he plays? I don't think I would. From Matthew, I'm projected to lose by 10, standard scoring. So who has more upside, Doyle or Ingram? Who has more upside?
Starting point is 00:33:12 Ingram has more upside. Who I think the better option is, it's Doyle. Yeah, I don't care what your projections are. That's not that many points to be worried about. Alex Smith, Matt Ryan, or Josh McCown? McCown. From Joe, Olsen or or Josh McCown? McCown From Joe, Olsen or Clay? PPR Olsen
Starting point is 00:33:28 From Daniel, Ingram or Olsen? PPR Olsen From Chris, start or sit Adam's falsetto singing voice? I'll sit it I don't know that I've ever gone falsetto What would you classify your voice as? It's just a voice, it's not This is falsetto
Starting point is 00:33:44 I never do that You just did I just did, yeah What would you classify your voice as? It's just a voice. It's not, this is falsetto. I never do that. You just did. I just did, yeah. This is from Justin. Jamal Williams, Kenyon Drake, Joe Mixon, Corey Davis. Well, actually, let's start with the running backs. Williams, Drake, or Mixon?
Starting point is 00:33:59 Standard or PPR? I don't think it matters. PPR. Give me Williams. Williams. Okay, now a flex. Drake, Mix Mixon Corey Davis Or Marquise Lee PPR
Starting point is 00:34:07 Marquise Lee Marquise Lee It's down to Drake and Lee Marquise Lee I just slumped I just literally slumped in my chair Debating back and forth But I feel myself
Starting point is 00:34:21 Feeling like Kenyon Drake is in for a big game Oh okay Like I can almost Like by the time you hear this but I feel myself feeling like Kenyon Drake is in for a big game. Oh, okay. Like I can almost, like by the time you hear this, I'm sure he'll be moved up in my rankings. And there will be an explanation in the cheat sheet. A full-on explanation of how I really feel about Kenyon Drake in the cheat sheet. So read it on CBSSports.com. Last one here is from John Juju, Cobb, or Coleman.
Starting point is 00:34:45 Juju. Juju it is. Juju on that beat. Juju on that beat. Juju on that beat. That's not how it goes. Okay, so I hate that song. And I love you all. So have a great weekend and enjoy your
Starting point is 00:35:01 week 14, week 13. What am I saying right now, Dave? What is this? I think you're trying to say, let's go Canes. When I wake up in the morning, CBS gives out a warning about a Jai's bank of offensive line. Injury to Brandon Cooks, and before I even look, my opponent grabs his back up off the waiver wire.
Starting point is 00:35:23 It's all right, I've got Le'Veon Bell. If I lose, there's a flex. I know I'm in a mess. Well, I better do my homework tonight. Reading Jamie Sartor's sick. They say chart is legit. Heath and Adam shared a team. It was a dumpster fire.
Starting point is 00:35:41 It's alright. I've got Le'Veon Bell. It's all right. I've got Le'Veon. It's all right. Not George Le'Veon. It's all right. I've got Le'Veon. It's alright. Not George Le'Veon. It's alright. I've got Le'Veon Bell.

There aren't comments yet for this episode. Click on any sentence in the transcript to leave a comment.