Fantasy Football Today - Dynasty February Rankings Update, Rookie Thoughts & Hard Questions with Dan! (Fantasy Football Podcast 2/11)
Episode Date: February 11, 2025Dan Schneier is back, and we're diving into some key February updates for Dynasty Fantasy Football! We discuss early rookie thoughts, top February movers, and answer tough questions on Anthony Richard...son (7:25), Travis Etienne vs. Tank Bigsby, and the future of Chiefs (14:40) WR1. Plus, we answer your chat (47:40) questions, don’t miss out! Fantasy Football Today is available for free on the Audacy app as well as Apple Podcasts, Spotify and wherever else you listen to podcasts Watch FFT on YouTube https://www.youtube.com/fantasyfootballtoday SUBSCRIBE to FFT Express on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fantasy-football-today-express/id1528634304 Follow FFT Express on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/6qyGWfETSBFaciPrtvoWCC?si=6529cbee20634da8 SUBSCRIBE to FFT Dynasty on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fantasy-football-today-dynasty/id1696679179 FOLLOW FFT Dynasty on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/2aHlmMJw1m8FareKybdNfG?si=8487e2f9611b4438&nd=1 SUBSCRIBE to FFT DFS on Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fantasy-football-today-dfs/id1579415837 FOLLOW FFT DFS on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/5zU7pBvGK3KPhfb69Q1hNr?si=1c5030a3b1a64be2 Follow our FFT team on Twitter: @FFToday, @AdamAizer, @JameyEisenberg, @daverichard, @heathcummingssr Follow the brand new FFT TikTok account: https://www.tiktok.com/@fftoday Join our Facebook group https://www.facebook.com/groups/FantasyFootballToday/ Sign up for the FFT newsletter https://www.cbssports.com/newsletter You can listen to Fantasy Football Today on your smart speakers! Simply say "Alexa, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast" or "Hey Google, play the latest episode of the Fantasy Football Today podcast." Visit the betting arena on CBSSports.com for all the latest sportsbook reviews and sportsbook promos. To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Transcript
Discussion (0)
You hear that?
Ugh, paid.
And... done.
That's the sound of bills being paid on time.
But with the BMO Eclipse Rise Visa Card,
paying your bills could sound like this.
Yes!
Earn rewards for paying your bill in full and on time each month.
Rise to rewards with the BMO Eclipse Rise Visa Card.
Terms and conditions apply.
Welcome to Fantasy Football Today. Dynasty, I am your host, Heath Cummings, joined once again
by Dan Schneier, and we have a fantastic show for you today talking about dynasty movers rankings risers and fallers over the month of January and early February what changed in the playoffs some of
these things are playoff performance related some of them are just all of the
like we've had a lot of news during these playoffs so some things changed
because of that but we can't start with anything other than giving
the Philadelphia Eagles their flowers, Dan.
What a fantastic performance.
I've been thinking about this a lot, obviously, for obvious reasons.
I'm not sure that there is a truly great team.
They showed that Super Bowl performance, one of the best performances I can remember by
an individual team in the Super Bowl, a truly great team that had to
overcome as many doubters like teams that win the Super Bowl often say, nobody believed
in us, but I might as any coach that's won as much as Nick Sirianni been doubted as much
as Nick Sirianni has as any quarterback who's accomplished as much in five years as Jalen Hurts been doubted as much as Jalen Hurts has. Saquon Barkley even came into the league as
the number two pick in the NFL. And all we did was talk about how a team shouldn't use a pick that
high on a player like him because of the position he plays. Then the Giants couldn't ever win with
him. I mean, just a fantastic performance. Vic Fangio got fired from the Dolphins last year. Like it just
goes on and on and on. So congratulations to the Eagles.
Congratulations to all of those Eagles fans out there. Dan,
what do you have to add as someone who's spent a lifetime
hating the Philadelphia Eagles?
And not just going to overnight be happy for them. I mean, I am
happy for them, I guess, but it was a rough Sunday for you and
I, Heath, you especially, I didn't want to see
the Eagles win a second Super Bowl. But the reality is, like
you said, we've never seen a team doubted this much. And I
think from a football standpoint, from a fantasy
standpoint, I think about it like this, they have provided at
least in my mind, a different blueprint, it's not necessarily
one that I think will be replicated, because it's so hard
and there's so many more variables, but they've at least given those teams that don't have one hope
that you don't need one of those.
And I know this is going to be controversial.
Elite quarterbacks to win.
That is just like, I was hopeful.
One of my favorite things that we do here on FFT dynasty is all of them in elite quarterback
give Dan a chance to eat his own words.
It doesn't happen very often.
Dan has a lot of great takes, but occasionally there's a Trey McBride take that Dan must
eat.
I have plenty of bad takes.
And I went back, you'll remember this probably, because I got skewered for it on Twitter four
years ago asking whether you'd rather have Jalen Hurts or Trey Lance in a dynasty league and everybody wanted Trey Lance because look what he could be.
And listen, if you win more than almost any quarterback, if you go to two Super Bowls
in your first five seasons, if you perform like he has in those two Super Bowls against
Spags who eats every other elite quarterback alive.
I know people don't like stylistically the way that Jalen
Hertz gets it done, but if you produce more yards, more touchdowns,
more wins than the other quarterbacks around you, I don't know how he could
be anything other than elite.
He's also currently on a hall of fame track.
That's fair.
And I think you make great points.
And I think one thing I
really appreciate about his game to me, he's not one of the elite quarterbacks in the NFL,
but I have a very high bar for elite quarterback. You need to be able to have a rhythmic passing
game almost all the time. And I don't really see that from him. With that said, I agree
that in both of their, in both the last two or three seasons, Jalen hurts played his best
game clearly and by far on tape and broadcast
in the biggest moment in the Super Bowl.
And all the points that you just made Heath
are a little funny to me
because you're kind of describing a case
that was made for Eli Manning
and I know you're not an Eli Manning guy.
So I just think it's funny now
how we see all the talking heads like
Josh Allen can't get it done,
Lamar Jackson can't get it done,
Jalen hurts.
And this is not you who I'm putting in this, but the people we're seeing the
same people who said Eli Manning doesn't belong in the hall of fame for
beating Tom Brady twice in the two biggest moments of the NFL and beating
Bill Belichick, the hardest defensive coordinator to scheme against are also
now taking it out on Josh Allen, Lamar Jack.
I think there's a lot of.
Misconcept.
I just think it's a very uneven argument when it comes to them.
When we try to value it, quarterbacks, me, you, whoever, it's a very difficult
thing to do who's elite, who's not elite.
I should reconsider it at the very least.
If I believe he's one of the, you know, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson,
Joe burrow, Patrick Mahomes here.
I should reconsider it.
Heath.
I really should, because like you said, he's became up
biggest in the biggest moments and he looked good.
He made great throws in this game outside the numbers, the back shoulder to AJ Brown,
the one that was called back.
I personally have a feeling that if this game was played outdoors, it would have been a
lot closer.
Personally, that's my belief, but it wasn't.
It's played indoors and is our good conditions for everyone.
And so, you know, look, I got to give credit to the Eagles, to Jalen Hurts.
It's time gotta give credit to the Eagles,
to Jalen Hurts, it's time to give credit.
Saquon Barkley, he didn't really do all that much
in the Super Bowl, I'm just kidding, I'm just kidding.
I will say, like, there are a few differences
between Eli Manning and Jalen Hurts.
Jalen Hurts' regular season-like production
through the age of 26 is much more impressive
than Eli Manning's.
I don't like to compare production error to error.
But I do agree that he even relative to his relative.
He was a better quarterback.
Yes.
And I'm having had an incredible four and oh run at age 26, the same age Jaylen hurts
is to win a Superbowl.
That was the only year that he won a playoff game
in his twenties.
Yeah, yeah.
No, and look, and all this just goes back
to the whole argument.
And we don't have to spend too much more time on this.
Like team versus quarterback, team versus quarterback.
Eli Manning never had anywhere near the team
that the Eagles had this year,
anything even remotely close.
And a lot of quarterbacks won't get that.
But that's the reality situation.
You can only play with what you got.
So I'll give him the credit.
If you want me to put him in that elite tier
with Allen burrow, Mahomes and Lamar,
give me a little bit of time.
Maybe I'll reconsider.
So we are on today's show,
mostly going to talk about the guys
who have moved the most in the rankings.
I will also say I did a one QB rookie mock yesterday. And so a little later in
the show, we'll talk about that and I'll just kind of tell you how that went. And then if you have
any questions, anytime we have Dan on, I like to open up the chat. People want to get into the mind
of Dan. And so we'll give them an opportunity that will answer your questions at the very end of today's
show. But first, I have three questions for Dan and I actually changed the name of the
segment. It's three very, very difficult questions for Dan.
I don't know the answers to these questions. And so I hopeful he can help us.
Number one, how are we supposed to evaluate Anthony Richardson in
either redraft dynasty or real life?
It's a great question.
And I, I saw this on the rundown and I was like, you know what?
This might give me a nice little off season project.
Maybe I will go back and watch Richardson tape because I think what's most important
to, to evaluating Richardson is looking within the Shane Sikens scheme and seeing
what, and cause you can get an idea based on watching a lot of tape, what he's
asking of the quarterback and seeing how far he progressed
given what Shane's asking him to do.
For example, like, is he going through this progression there?
Is he understanding this concept?
Is he getting the ball out fast and quick game?
How does the feet look?
Are they connected?
The feet and the upper half, the lower half
and the upper half, all these things that we knew
he'd have to work on when he got to the NFL
and we knew he's been working on,
how much of the progression there?
Because we've already seen the Colts make a decision at some point where they're like,
look, he doesn't give us the best chance to win.
And they put in Joe Flacco, they quickly went back on that, but it's something they've done
already.
And it's the NFL and we're entering year three now for Richardson.
So I don't think this leash is as long as maybe you would expect for someone who was
drafted this high.
You know, the good teams are the ones who are willing to move on, in my opinion, fast from quarterbacks.
The bad teams are the ones who will do the Daniel Jones thing, like the Giants did for six years.
So I don't think the Colts are locked in on Richardson.
So to me, really, when it comes to the fantasy value, it is often from it,
and I'm speaking from a dynasty standpoint strictly, Heath,
it is often tied to how long do I think his leash will be
and how many chances will he get to start in the NFL?
And the question we have to ask ourselves, Heath, is if the Colts move on,
will another team give him a starting opportunity in the NFL?
Um, I have to watch the tape to really give you a good feel on it.
But from the outside perspective, looking in, just looking at the numbers and how
we track this week, the week in fantasy, I don't think he's made enough of a
progression as a passer yet. And as a, and by passer, I just mean quarterback,
like doing the job of quarterback. So I think there's still a lot, a long way to go for
him.
Yeah. My most recent rankings update, he is QB 14. I have no confidence. I would not argue
that any with anybody who said he should be higher because of his upside. Cause I do think
his upside is as high as almost any quarterback in fantasy
football, or maybe he'd be lower because he's going to lose his job next year.
Maybe he is.
I will tell you the three quarterbacks that I have ranked directly above him
are Kyler Murray, Bo Nix and Drake, Drake May.
The three quarterbacks I have ranked directly behind him are
CJ Stroud Jared Goff and Dak Prescott now
Goff and Prescott almost impossible to compare because they're 30 plus and he's 23
And these are for your dynasty rings, correct? Yeah redraft. Yeah, the one case
I will make and I think this applies a little bit more to redraft
But I think you can make the case for dynasty too.
If you view this in this game and I think it's important to do so sometimes as like
you're, you're trying to accrue assets and you're trying to gamble and you're taking
risks and I do believe that he will be priced around this point and in redraft as well.
He's not going to make the top 12.
I don't think at any point in August to a point where it's worth the gamble because
you're not essentially you're not like in dynasty right now, you're probably getting him for a price that's not what it
near what it was last off season, right?
Where people were making crazy trades for Richardson at that point, it becomes worth
the gamble because you're not giving up essentially it's like way what's what you're losing in
that trade and what could be gained.
And from a fantasy standpoint, all I think you really need to do Heath is get better as an actual quarterback.
And I don't mean like, it's hard to explain,
but I just like doing what the coach wants him to do
to stay on the field long enough.
Cause if he's on the field for 17 games, Heath,
we know that the floor is there.
Look at Justin Fields two seasons ago, I believe it was,
when we all ranked him low, like 18, 19,
I'm talking redraft and he had that crazy year
and there was no expectation for him to do so.
And a lot of it was based on the rushing total.
So we still know that that is there if he just gets enough snaps, enough reps.
But that's been the problem.
Year one was the injury year two was being benched and then an injury
toward the end of the year.
Question number two, difficult question.
Number two, early one.
I don't know how to, how you Richardson Travis ETN or tank Bigsby
as the lead back in Jacksonville.
This one's a little less difficult for me specifically.
And I think those who have listened to me a lot
on this podcast will know that,
but I love and I mean love Tank Bigsby for next year
and Redraft and for Dynasty.
You can get them really cheap right now.
I mean, you look at some of the numbers
before he first had an injury last year, Heath.
And I think he was never quite the same after it just from watching him.
But those numbers were unbelievable.
I don't have them up with me.
I wanted to find these, but I couldn't find the tweets, but he was like
tracking top five enforcement's tackles yards after contact, all the advanced
elite metrics we like he was pacing Travis ETN in that regard.
Um, and to the point where they started giving him more touches and more of a
role than Travis again, then he got hurt.
Now we have a new coaching staff in here, a completely different system than Doug Peterson. What I'm really big fan of with Liam Cohen. I think he designs
one of the best run game in the NFL last year. Bigsby to me is the better runner. He's more
explosive. He's better at understanding in my mind, pacing and just understanding how to set
up his blocks. Travis was drafted by two staffs ago at this point.
I think Bigsby is the guy.
I don't think it's gonna be, you know,
he runs away with the job.
We've seen that Liam Cohen likes to use three backs at times,
but I think that running game is gonna get going fast.
And I think Bigsby is gonna be the lead back
in that run game and specifically in the red zone.
So I like him a lot for dynasty.
Couple of things, just counter points,
cause that was a pretty one sided answer.
And I'm glad, I'm glad that one of these was, was relatively easy for you. I, I don't know
if this means anything or not, but when Liam Cohen was talking about all the pieces that
they have in Jacksonville, he did say Travis ETN's name before he said tank Bigsby's name.
Okay. The other thing is we saw how much Tampa Bay threw the ball to their running backs last year. Tank Bigsby
has in two seasons, 16 targets and he has caught eight of them. He has been pretty awful
as a pass catcher in the NFL. I'm not sure he's been a whole lot better in terms of pass
protection. So in my dynasty rankings, which are based on full PPR leagues, I have ETN at 21 and Bigsby
at 23, but they're basically tied in value.
It's like I said, the reason I gave Dan these questions is because I don't really know the
answer.
We do know that targets matter a lot more for fantasy production than rush attempts
do.
So that would be the only counterpoint.
I don't necessarily argue that I I think Bixby's a better
rusher. We've seen teams more and more in the NFL though not want to tip their hand as whether it's
a run or pass play by who they have on the field. I think maybe one of the problems with Tank Bixby
is you kind of do that. When he's out there, he's probably getting the ball on a rush attempt.
I think that's fair based on his track record so far, but he did have 51 catches
in his last few years at Auburn. So I don't think he's a total non-factor in the passing game.
Sometimes you'll see like, for example, like Jonathan Taylor coming out of Wisconsin had like
nine, there's something crazy. And even he's kind of, yeah, go ahead. No, I think at a good point.
And I think this is another regime change thing that could help him. I don't know if you remember or not,
but if you'd go back and watch the film on the couple of targets that he got in his rookie season,
I think four actually, he caught one of them and I believe two of them turned into interceptions
because they went off of his hands. And so the team was just like, no, we're not doing that anymore.
So maybe there's a little bit more patience now with what has happened
in that regard.
Last question.
When everyone is healthy, Rashi rice or Xavier worthy as the wide
receiver one in Kansas City.
Such a tough question.
There's so much uncertainty.
I feel good with this chief's team going into this next year.
I'm sure you can speak to it more.
And I'm just meaning with where the direction of this
offense is going to go.
I mean, they have a big issue. First of all, they don't have a left tackle and I don't of this offense is going to go. I mean, they have a big issue.
First of all, they don't have a left tackle and I don't know how they're going to get,
I mean, I guess soon.
What's their plan there at tackle?
Do you know what they're?
I would guess it will involve the 31st pick in one way or another.
That's never a good, in my opinion, because just expecting a 31st pick rookie tackle
to step in is rare.
Ram check did it for the saints.
Very few examples.
Well, they might be able to trade the 31st pick for yeah but I look at that like it did hold them back
in that game and I and I think about it though and I'm like I know it was garbage time but like see
if you're worthy looks so good in that in that Super Bowl and he did what I expected him to do
all year stretch the field but he can also work. I am just going to lean Heath on my evaluation of both players coming out of college. And I loved Worthy more than I loved
Rashid Rice. Worthy to me was someone who had this billing as a John Ross type. I've talked about this
before, but when you actually put on the tape of Texas, it's like, wow, he's working in breakers.
Wow, he's doing the tough, dirty things underneath. I think we've seen a little bit of that his rookie
year with the Chiefs. So I'm betting on the talent here. I'm betting I'm worthy, but I think a strong case can be made that it's a bad
bet based on just how dominant Rashid Rice was the,
the backend of last year and the beginning of this year.
I think what Travis Kelsey decides could influence this question a lot,
cause you could just move rice into Kelsey's target share and that would work
pretty well. Um, as of right now, I have Worthy as wide receiver 17 in dynasty, Rice as wide receiver 18 in
dynasty. I would probably lean that the answer to this question is Rice. I just have a little
bit of concern about his knee injury that is not quite as simple a fix as I maybe originally
thought. And then a little bit of concern about, I mean, if he only plays eight games next year or 10 games next year and worthy gets
that on ramp to being the number one for the first half of the year, is he just
the number one for the whole year?
Um, so we'll, we'll see what the health is like, what the suspension is like,
but really a difficult question, both top 20 guys though.
And let me ask you a question just to follow up on that
really quick about, as I'm just curious as we move forward,
as somebody who follows it even more closely than I do,
and this is one of my favorite teams in the NFL,
I know it's weird to say because everybody hates them now,
the Chiefs, but I love watching them
and I've always loved Mahomes.
Is this, is like, is Mahomes playing at the same level
you feel that he's always played
and there's just other circumstances
that have kind of held him back? Because to me, it just doesn't look like the same
version of Mahomes that was throwing 5k. To me. So early, like throughout the season,
I would say no. Okay. But every time they needed him to, he did. So it was like the first three and
a half quarters he was not. And then, oh, there he is again.
He misses throws he never used to miss from a, from a ball placement standpoint.
And then I think in the Superbowl, it, we just saw like, you don't very often see all
time greats look like they see ghosts, but it happened a couple of times with Brady.
It definitely happened with my homes.
He just, like you get in that situation where you feel like there's always two guys coming free and yet there's seven guys in coverage.
Right.
And there's not, there's nothing any quarterback can do in that situation.
I bought the throws that I know it doesn't matter.
The game was over.
It was garbage time.
I'm not that throw.
He made for 70 yards to Xavier worthy for a touchdown.
That was an absolute dot.
Yes. I think it's all still there. It wasn't as good a season as he's had.
Okay. Here's the better question. And that one doesn't help us for dynasty or fantasy. This one
might. Do you see them going back to that style of offense at any point? Cause it seems like they
waited until then to the Superbowl down a million to finally start opening it up a little bit.
But because that I've always in dynasty kind of lean toward like, give me somebody tied
to my homes.
Like I've got a lot of Rashid Rice, a lot of Xavier worthy.
But I ultimately now look back at these last couple of seasons.
And I'm like, is it was it made sense when Andy Reid was like opening it up with my home?
Does it still make sense with this conservative kind of offensive approach we've seen of late?
Yeah, I, I think like there were with Brady,
like there were with Rogers during,
back when he was elite,
like there's going to be ebbs and flows.
Brady had a couple of years where he threw for 28
passing touchdowns, like multiple times,
and then all of a sudden he throws for 50,
or all of a sudden he throws for 5,000.
I think these things just ebb and flow.
And like, we're not gonna talk about where he's ranked.
Right now I've got Patrick Mahomes at QB4. not going to talk about where he's ranked right now.
I've got Patrick Mahomes at QB4.
We're going to talk about the guy I just moved ahead of him right after the break.
Get ready for Las Vegas style action at bet MGM, the king of online casinos.
Enjoy casino games at your fingertips with the same Vegas strip excitement.
MGM is famous for when you play the classics, like MGM Grand Millions or popular games like Blackjack, Baccarat, and Roulette.
With our ever-growing library of digital slot games, a large selection of online table games,
and signature Bet MGM service, there is no better way to bring the excitement and ambiance of Las
Vegas home to you than with Bet MGM Casino. Download the BetMGM Casino app today.
BetMGM and GameSense remind you to please play responsibly.
BetMGM.com for Ts and Cs, 19 plus to wager.
Ontario only, please play responsibly.
If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
or someone close to you, please contact Connex Ontario
at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge.
That MGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.
So, some of these changes that we've got in the rankings are because of performances in
the playoffs.
And you could say that with Jaden Daniels.
He had a lot more success against the Eagles defense than Patrick Mahomes did.
Or because of breaking recent news. I, there hasn't really been
enough of that for Jaden Daniels.
But some of it is.
I just went through my early, early, early projections process.
The quarterback projections are already on the website, put those out on Monday.
So through the rest of this week, we'll get running back wide receiver
and tight end projections.
And those do have, it's a bigger impact that they have in August than they do right now.
They do have an impact on the dynasty rankings.
And I don't know how closely you looked at the quarterback projections that I sent you
Dan, but Jayden Daniels came out as QB1.
And that sounds ridiculous, except when you look at what he did as a passer and a runner, as
a rookie quarterback, and know that most quarterbacks get better in year two and year three than
they were as rookies, and the expectation that the number two option next year is probably
going to be better than Zach Ertz.
Good gosh, we hope it is.
Go get him a number two wide receiver.
And so regardless, he's in that tier for me in the projections.
And he was for most of his rookie year in the, in the four to six range at quarterback.
He is currently my dynasty QB three only Josh Allen Lamar Jackson ahead of him.
Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, Jalen Hertz right behind him.
And those guys are all in the same tier.
Is that too high, too low or just right for Jayden Daniels?
I think it's, I think it might be a little too high.
And I'll tell you why.
I think we tend to think that quarterbacks do get a little better in
year two and three, but I don't know if that's true.
And I would actually like to take some time this off season when we're slow to do some
kind of study on this because just from, you know, recency bias, it feels like it's been
the opposite with that.
CJ Stroud takes a step back, even like lesser candidates like Daniel Jones and Davis Mills
who flashed in rookie year became like nothing the year after.
It's to me, from what I've heard from a lot of people talking through the NFL throughout the NFL. It's like the opposite. It's once DC's get a whole off
season and at least eight games to take away the concepts rookie quarterbacks use, it becomes
harder because a lot of what Washington did, and this is not like unique to them. It's
every rookie quarterback. It's lean on a lot of concepts, lean on a lot of the same concepts
in the passing game. Shroud. This was the case with Shroud and Slowick last year as well.
And it works because, you know, they don't have a lot of tape on it.
They don't find a way to take it.
Spend an off season.
They take it away.
The defense does different things.
They trick the quarterback into seeing fronts at pre snap that, that, that, you
know, rotations from the safeties post snap and things get a little more difficult.
I could see that happening for Cliff and Jayden.
It's wouldn't be the first time, right?
Like Cliff had that, that problem with Kyler Murray in Arizona.
Things were looking great, they were going well,
teams adjusted to what the scheme was
and it almost fell apart completely.
I think Jayden Daniels is a better quarterback
than Kyler Murray, I wanna make that clear.
And I think there is the possibility that,
and this happens with all the greats,
Burrow, you look at all the elites,
they don't have that second year regression.
He may be that elite, honestly.
So this may sound really dumb, but I think there is that inherent risk that he could
take that step back.
So it may be a little bit high.
And then from a dynasty standpoint, QB3, I like it.
It's aggressive.
But the main issue, again, I've always brought this up, but the main issue I had with Jayden
Daniels didn't just go away after year one.
And it's that there is no history of quarterbacks sustaining long
levels of play at sub 200 pounds.
He may be an outlier.
We've seen Derek Henry is an outlier.
Say one Barclay is an outlier.
There are plenty of special players who are outliers in the NFL.
He very well may be that, but there is that risk factor that I want to bake in to his
dynasty value, at least somewhat.
So I wonder what his actual playing weight will be entering next year because he was
able to for the combine get just up over 200 pounds, right?
Very fake 200.
Right.
A very fake 200.
But if you can get to a very fake 200, then you're not that far.
Like, it's not like he was 175 pounds.
Right.
And most guys, as you and I can testify, as you move through your 20s, you start putting
on a little bit of weight just naturally. Like food just, I don't know about you, but
I could not under any circumstances get over 160 pounds in high school. I say now is a
different story, but it didn't take very long after I got into my 20s, so it wasn't that
difficult to get over 160 or 170 pounds. And so I would anticipate, especially with an off season in an NFL weight
training program, I wouldn't be surprised if he is 200 next year. Just something to
keep in mind because he wasn't that far away from it.
And I, and I don't, I think that's definitely possible. And I don't want to be like sitting
here with you being like, he's got to get to this 200 magical number. I don't think
it's necessarily that.
I do think looking at his frame though,
Heath, at six four with the legs that he has,
I don't think there's that much room to gain really,
like for his frame.
Like it's funny, cause you could look at Kyler Murray, right?
And he had the ACL, that was kind of just unlucky.
He stepped wrong and it was non-contact.
But other than that, he's been pretty healthy
for the most part.
And I just think he has that,
and same thing with Russell
Wilson throughout his career.
They just, they're, they're smaller.
They weigh less than Jayden, but they have that thick lower
base and it almost helps them.
Jane and Daniels doesn't look like he has the base to me that really
is ideal for holding up, but look, he could be an outlier.
He avoids it.
He does an amazing job in my opinion of that already.
So much better than he did at LSU at least.
And I'm talking about in the pocket and when he's not, when he's breaking pocket, that's when he kind of gets
a little reckless with it as a runner. But yeah, I don't want to use that against him,
but I do want to fact that in a little bit.
We had Deshaun Watson as the biggest quarterback faller since the start of January. And it
didn't, wasn't actually that much because he was already pretty low. I had him QB 27 coming into January.
Obviously we got the news that he's probably not going to play next year.
He is down to QB 32.
He's still not even 30 years old yet, but do you think it's just completely over?
Is QB 32 even too high for Deshaun Watson?
Great question.
Well, I think the best thing that could happen to him is the Browns release him.
And I think that's where it's trending. So it's, I mean, for his dynasty value, that's the best thing that could happen to him is the Browns release him. And I think that's where it's trending.
So I mean, for his dynasty value, that's the best thing about them.
So let's start there.
And then he would need to join a situation that is essentially in my mind, this is how
he could revive his value, like the lion situation.
That's how that's a type of situation.
I'd really truly believe he needs to join out.
First of all, he's got to go indoors.
And this is the thing with Deshaun Watson, like he played at Clemson, then he played
at Houston with the Texans at Houston.
He's never had like elite, elite arm talent.
He's one with anticipation and accuracy and the willingness to make big throws into
tight windows. Those are things that kind of all went away in Cleveland.
I just I think he's going to need a really good situation.
I would probably drop him even, even further than that.
And I think the bigger problem is like so much of his success was what he could do with his legs.
Right.
And like we've, we've seen it with somebody like Dak Prescott where he just kind of stopped running.
I wouldn't, I don't know how much more we'll see Deshaun Watson as a running quarterback. Yep. So that, that is, it might be time to just sell low even still on Deshaun Watson.
One guy I think that provides a pretty good sell high opportunity is my biggest
riser, and I think we actually talked about this in January, DeAndre Swift.
When Ben Johnson was hired, is this a good thing because Ben Johnson runs one
of the best offenses in the NFL?
Is it a bad thing because Ben Johnson preferred to give so many more carries
to Jamal Williams? There seems to be a little bit of pushback coming from the Johnson slash
Bears camp that there's some sort of problem between him and Swift. Like it seems like,
I think that they, they are at least on the same page. Now Swift, when I went through
the projections process again, I'm not projecting him as a complete workhorse running back. I'm going to publish the full
running back projections a little bit later this afternoon, but I do have him right. I mean,
right now there's really not much choice. They don't have a ton of extra draft picks.
It's very possible that he's their lead back. He's my current RB 18 for this season and RB 18 for dynasty was RB 24.
Um, in January, is that too high for Deandre Swift?
I don't think so.
Actually, I think I'm on the same page with you with Swift.
He's a different player than he was earlier in his career.
Now I'd have to go back and watch the tape to really confirm that this
year and things were really bad there.
But the way I look at it, like the Bears aren't going to be able to immediately overnight
have an amazing offensive line.
They're going to do their best to make progress on that this off season.
That does trust me as a Giants fan, that doesn't always work.
We've tried many of off seasons to improve the O line and the result sometimes is the
same or about the same or at times worse.
So what's a solution to that?
If you're Ben Johnson, it's designing things for Caleb Williams to get the ball out of
his hands fast.
And that could really be benefit to Deandre Swift in the passing game.
So why I'm really thinking I like Swift early this year is that I think his role in the
passing game could take a nice evolution this year.
It's not something we saw Caleb Williams do a lot of at USC or with the Bears. But with that said, if you're a coach and you know you have a bad old line, it might be better to
design things to get the ball out of his hands. So I'll see, I need to see how the entire thing
works. First of all, I think the blocking, the run scheme is going to be bad. It can't be worse.
You cannot have a worse run scheme than the one that Shane Waldron runs. So he's going to get a
big boost there even without the offensive lineup grade. So that will help his game as well from an efficiency standpoint. So,
and I want to think the Bears offense can't be as bad as it was this year, Heath. So there's a lot
of things working in his favor. I don't think the price you named it's, I don't think it's baked in
already all the things we mentioned. So I do like him as a slight one. So when we look at,
there's three running backs. And I said that Swift is currently my RB18. There's three running backs who will be 26 years old that are ranked between RB13 and
RB24 in my updated rankings.
A lot of the guys are either way younger or it's the McCaffrey's and Henry's of the world
that only contender rosters.
These 26 year old backs are kind of unique.
Chuba Hubbard, DeAndre Swift, Travis ETN. How would you rank those three in dynasty?
I would go Hubbard, Swift, ETN,
even though ETN is the youngest.
He's, you know what?
I think I'm too low on ETN.
I'm gonna go, I'm gonna change that to Hubbard, ETN, Swift.
And why is Hubbard one despite, you know,
having the least fanfare coming out of the draft,
even though he had some really nice production in college. It's the NFL tape. He's really good player at the NFL level, too. However,
he just understands in my mind how to get in and out of little spots to get him like
how to set up the blocks and how to get, get the run game or I shouldn't say this, how
to stay in sync with the run game. That's how I want to describe that as he's really
in sync with what they do. I can't say the same about ETN or Swift.
In a lot of ways, it's almost the opposite.
They rely on their athleticism.
I think that's something the Panthers have appreciated.
They resigned him.
And obviously now with the Jonathan Brooks second major injury late in the year, we could
be looking at what 10, 15, 10, 12 games of Hubbard just as a pure workhorse with an improved
offense as Bryce Young has taken the step forward.
There's a lot to like about Hubbard, not just for redraft, but for dynasty.
He came out as my number 11 running back in the redraft rankings
when I did the projections.
So yeah, I definitely agree.
I do want to say one thing you said, uh, you, you made the choice.
I'm too low on ETN.
You put ETN over Swift because of the age difference.
Yeah.
I wasn't sure cause I thought maybe I had it wrong in my system, but I, I'm confirming
Travis Etienne is 12 days younger than the Andre Swift.
Oh, wow.
That's crazy.
I thought he was much younger than Swift.
Okay.
So we're going to go back to Swift over Etienne, I assume.
No, no, it wasn't just the age thing.
I think about Etienne, he still has really good metrics from a force
and his tackle rate standpoint.
And that was true of his days at Clemson.
I still think he's a talented runner.
I just don't really know.
I don't think Jacksonville is the best fit for him.
So there is a guy who in my January ranking.
So I kind of elevated up because I felt like everybody
was higher on him than I was.
And then I went through the projections process
and I didn't like him again.
And so I've dropped him back down.
Maybe you can just sell me on being too low on this guy.
Another 26 year old running back,
but he's not in my top 24.
He's barely in my top 34.
Brian Robinson Jr. falls from RB 28 to RB 33.
That's an interesting case.
Obviously I've loved his tape.
I've loved his talent,
but the roles seem to get worse as the year went on from a fantasy standpoint there. Evolution of that Washington offense as we move
forward with Cliff Kingsbury and Jayden Daniels, I think it'll be more pass heavy like you said,
especially if they do make the play. I think they will and make it bring in a big pass catcher.
So I think that's a fair ranking of just the situation as we move forward. I do like the
talent though. Some guys who are older than him that I have ranked higher than him. Tony Pollard, Ramondre Stevenson, free agent, Najee Harris. Would
you take Brian Robinson over any of those guys? Except for, uh, we named them again.
Sorry. That's okay. It's, uh, I've got, uh, Tony Pollard, all of them except for Pollard,
who I like more than him.
You like Pollard more. You take him over Stevenson over nausea.
Harris.
I'm very interested to see what happens with Stevenson this year.
I think Stevenson could get another boost and listen, Harris is one of those
guys that if he lands in the right spot, what, what if Ben Johnson decides, you
know what, nobody wanted nausea Harris.
He's pretty cheap.
Nausea Harris looks like a pretty interesting Jamal Williams comp. Let's bring him onto our team and give him
17 touchdowns this year. I could see Harris's value going. He's right around my RB 32. I could
see him inside the top 24 running backs when we get to August, if he gets to the right landing spot.
And I could see him outside of the top 40 if the NFL is just like, nah, we don't really. Aren't that interested?
Tyree Kill was a guy who rebounded in the February rankings.
He was my wide receiver 35 in the dynasty rankings, moved back up to wide receiver
30.
Now an interesting case because I do kind of have a rule that sometimes gets proven
wrong, but I do kind of have a rule that sometimes gets proven wrong, but I do kind of have a rule
that if a 30 year old wide receiver looks like he's in decline, believe him.
Now we've what we've, what we've found out since the end of the season was that Tyree
Kille was playing with a broken wrist and Tyree Kille's, um, it wasn't really a trade
demand, but it was kind of like a trade demand seems to have gone away and he's making nice with the Miami dolphins.
Wide receiver 30 Dan puts him just behind a DJ more, a Terry McClure and a
DK Metcalf just ahead of Devante Adams, Chris Godwin, Brandon, I, you, does that
sound about right for you for Ty
Rekill?
I think it's fair.
I think obviously it just depends where you're at as a team.
You could, if you're a team playing for the championship, you can make, you can probably,
you know, move them a little higher or just give up more capital to acquire him or value
him higher.
I wonder what's going to happen this off season with Miami for a lot of reasons.
Like if you're McDaniel, you'd probably have to go back to the tape and be like,
look at the things that we did right in this offense for years.
And then we tried to do a different offense this year.
What were the reasons for us having to do that?
Is it because this is the new reality with Tua and you got to get the ball out
fast or is it because there were issues on the offensive line?
I'm hoping it's the latter and there were issues on the offensive line that they
can fix because they need to get back to that style of offense that's vertically challenging
you at all times. And then you can snap off an in breaker, Tyree kill over the middle
of the field and hit him for 15 and he has so much space. And so the offense to me is
the biggest factor for his fantasy value.
And I think like I almost put John O Smith in the tight end section, but it's a similar
argument just in reverse with him because if Tyreek Hill rebounds to what he was, a top five wide receiver in fantasy,
John O. Smith's probably not going to be anywhere close to what he was last year, a top five
tight end.
I mentioned a couple of guys that I currently have Tyreek ahead of. Chris Godwin falls from
wide receiver 29 to 35. Brandon Iyuk falls from wide receiver 31 to 35. Brandon Iuke falls from wide receiver 31 to 39. Now,
I will say when it comes to Iuke, I think I have almost for his entire career been lower
on him than consensus. And I've maybe just been bailed out by circumstances, by injuries,
but now he's like in his prime entering his age 27
season.
And I don't think we can expect him to be a fantasy starter next year
coming off of that injury.
Well, I'm much higher than you on IU.
I know it's what you said is true.
Maybe for next, I'm speaking more dynasty by the way, just down the line.
I know for, you know, with the year off the ACL, probably be better the year
after next, uh, but his fit in that system is so perfect. The way that Shannon runs that offense
is better than Debo's always has been. He's a great route runner and that helps him on
those. And the whole Shannon offense is like intermediate in breakers and that helps him
on those. And so I still think he's, he's the, he's like the best fit for that system.
Also for Brock Purdy and his skillset as a passer,
break off the inbreakers, break off the outbreakers.
He runs them both really well.
So I like him from that standpoint and he's still just 27.
I'm a little higher in him.
I guess I should be a little more concerned next year.
For me, the one you name that really stands out is Godwin.
Like I am gonna be way lower on consensus with Godwin.
The way I look at it as another major injury for Godwin
for a guy that was not winning with athleticism
in the first place.
And if they, if he does lose just that one half step or step from, from what he had,
it could be, we could be looking at like an Alan Robinson type rest of his career.
Well, I think, I think Godwin's really interesting because like it was two years ago, right?
That he was coming off of the ACL.
Yes.
And entering his age 27 season.
Similar to Ayuk.
Right.
Had shown us like the sky high ceiling,
but there's like, how,
what's he going to be when he comes back?
And we got about half a season
where he was almost unplayable.
Right.
And then we got a half of a really good season
and then we got another injury.
And so, yeah, I think with AyukQ you are, I always look at these things
from, okay, who would rather have Brandon IUQ on their roster? A team that's a
definite contender next year or a team that's a rebuilder next year? I don't
know what the answer is. Like if I'm a contender, IUQ's not the guy I'm
necessarily prioritizing. I don't know if he's going to help me win a
championship next year.
Kind of like buying low on him. You know, if, if you're a rebuilt, more of a rebuild team.
And that might be, that might be the angle to take. It's just that if you were doing that and
you're thinking he's going to be better next year, well, you should definitely be buying low because
you might be buying a two year window of elite production and then he's 30. Yeah. So yeah, really.
he's 30. Yeah. So yeah, really. And the final thing about that is like with the 49ers, I Uke's most dominant seasons, he had 114 targets in 17 games and 105 targets in 16 games.
It's all efficiency based. Yeah. It's all like major, major efficiency based. And so
he did have jumps from a volume standpoint when Dibo was out. And I don't think we expect Devo to be a member of that team much longer.
It does seem like that's the direction it's moving.
One final wide receiver before we get to a couple of tight ends.
I don't think we'll get to the rookie talk today, but we will answer a couple of your
questions.
If you're watching on Twitter, go over to YouTube to ask the question in the chat and
we'll get to that today.
If you're in the chat right now, be a good time to fill the chat up with those questions.
Christian Watson, another guy I've mostly been lower on
suffered the devastating injury.
We hope that at some point we get to see
a healthy Christian Watson,
but he fell all the way to wide receiver 94 in my rankings.
Do you have any hope of a buy low for Christian Watson?
I do, but remember I am resident Christian Watson lover on this
podcast, besides Jacob Gibbs.
We, you know, I, this is my first baby that I found on beyond the box score.
Love this tape in North Dakota state.
I was hopeful Heath that, you know, he said in the off season, he did some weird
surgery to shave down his hamstring and he was going to, or whatever body part
that was, and he was going to hopefully be healthier and he's running evenly.
And I feel like the injury he got this year was more bad luck.
Obviously it's an ACL, it's non-contact, but you know, we're looking at players
25 coming off a major injury on a team that didn't ever factor, feature him
the way we wanted, like for some of us that were hopeful, Jacob, for example,
it was, wow wow look at his numbers
uh prior to this year in the red zone and how many targets he got he is their weapon in the
red zone he wasn't their red weapon in the red zone at any point this year so and then he's just
they haven't figured out a way to utilize him on in any of their rhythmic passing game it's really
just those deep shots so what are we looking at it feels like we're looking at like a Will Fuller type prospect almost.
And those don't tend to pan out for dynasty.
And I think like we're kind of at a crossroads for Green Bay as well.
We've talked about like the what direction the chief's going to go, but that Matt Liffler
has been very insistent that he just hates the idea of a number one wide receiver, which
is terrible for Christian Watson.
But what might happen is that he decides, you know what, we should have a number one wide receiver, which is terrible for Christian Watson. But what might happen is that he decides, you know what, we should have a number one wide receiver in a year
that Christian Washington's not necessarily available. And so then they go get a real
number one wide receiver and Watson doesn't necessarily get that opportunity. I would
send a 2025 third for Christian Watson. I would not send a 2025 second.
Completely. I think we're aligned entirely on that.
Let's take our second break, get to the tight ends and then we'll answer your questions.
Two tight ends to talk about and they moved in opposite directions and actually passed
each other while they were doing it. Two ships passing in the night. Theo Johnson from tight
end 17 up to tight end 13.
I was excited about Theo Johnson coming into the NFL.
He didn't do anything last year to take away that excitement.
I am expecting that they are going to have better quarterback play in 2025.
I'm very, very hopeful that it's going to be Jamis Winston,
because there'd be nothing more fun than a season of you and Adam Azer processing the experience of Jamis Winston as your starting quarterback. The hope
and the disappointment that comes at the same time from that. But what you watched more Theo Johnson
than anybody at FFT, I'm certain of it. What were your takeaways if Theo Johnson is tied in 13 too
high in dynasty rankings? I don't think so. So first of all, I want to make it clear.
And because we have the proof and the receipt to back it up, we did a
dynasty show probably 15 months ago at this point where I said to you, I
had a surprise tight end too.
And it was the Johnson.
This was months before the giants draft them.
So I want to make that clear.
It's not because the giants drafted him and it's the movement skills.
It's the insanely freakish athletic profile that compared to Jimmy Graham on an
RIS score, relative athletic score standpoint.
And what I loved about his rookie season Heath is that it was really slow to start.
He was clearly somebody out there who they are like throwing into the fire, playing a
ton of snap.
He's not playing fast.
He doesn't really know where to be.
But as the season went on, things changed.
He caught that long touchdown from Daniel Jones just before he was benched
Forgetting which team the home game. I'm forgetting which game that was now stupidly, but it was someone it was a 40-yard touchdown
And then after that you started to see him just like work the intermediate middle work the middle field have some right before his injury
He made an explosive play after the catch where he's like leaping defenders bouncing through people
You saw what the Giants saw what people who had him as tight end to in the draft saw
Flashes up now. Can you put that all together?
That still remains to be seen
But one thing we know is they really believe in him like they played him almost 100% of the snaps or 85%
The snaps as a rookie who was clearly a raw player that they knew coming in that shows their level of belief in him
So I think you know half the battle for tight end is just getting snaps and getting targets. He's going
to have that opportunity and he brings that athletic profile
with him. A lot will depend on what you said at the start.
So like, will they actually improve their quarterback play
this year? I think I've got Jamis is my favorite free agent
target as well. Besides Rogers, who is a controversial one that
a lot of Giants fans are not happy that I'm in on, but I
don't care. And for me, the real thing is, look at what Jamis
did for new joku for Tillman before his injury for Judy, even Eli Moore was ripping off
explosive plays once like Jamus will challenge intermediate deep middle of
the field, he'll force defenses to cover deep and open up space in the middle.
And he throws with anticipation, which I think 80% of the NFL
quarterbacks don't do a good job of.
So it depends if they can get a quarterback like that.
And pretty much,
I would love to see Aaron Rogers and Brian Dable and post game press
conferences after losses. That would be a lot of fun.
You can throw the football. He's, you know, I know you do this whole concept of
like, like the problem is that if that happens,
then all of a sudden Malik neighbors is the wide receiver three behind Devontae Adams and Alan Lazard.
That's no good for Malik neighbors.
I do not like that at all.
The tight end who fell just a little bit and it's just, it's Isaiah likely.
It's just a reminder that when you factor in projections, the idea of what Isaiah likely
might be, it's turned back into the reality
of what can you project for him in an offense that throws the ball 450 times and has Mark Andrews
and the team really rallied around Mark Andrews after his disastrous playoff drops. I fully expect
that both Andrews and likely are going to be on the Ravens next season, which means you've probably got at least one more year that you have to wait for Likely to be a must-start
fantasy tight end.
In a vacuum, if it didn't matter who was in front of him, I think Likely is an easy top
12 tight end.
But Reza right now, he falls from 12 to 15.
Do you agree, Theo Johnson over Isaiah Likely?
I agree, Theo Johnson over Isaiah Likely, but Likely is actually one of my favorite buys and dynasty right now for reasons you kind of just went
over the first being yes, Mark Andrews is on the team next year, but the year after
he's a free agent and it seems highly unlikely they're going to bring him back just given
the age at that point, the position and their cap situation. And then with the, with the
past, you know, the past breakdown situation, how much longer do we have a Derek Henry at this point? Is he going to be doing this in 2026?
He might, he's a freak of nature, but I don't know. So what I'm seeing is a really talented
player who's shown crazy levels of fantasy production on small sample sizes tied to Lamar
Jackson with the player ahead of him likely to move on after this year. No pun intended.
And then the run and then actual offense to evolve in a different
way once Derek Henry leaves this football team.
So yeah, for redraft, I don't have much faith, but it may be
wait even longer because his value could tank even more so, but you can
get him really cheap right now.
And I think it's like one of the few upside plays at the position
that you can buy cheap right now.
Let's say you have Jake Ferguson Ferguson or likely.
I think I'm taking likely for the upside. buy cheap right now. Let's say you have Jake Ferguson, Ferguson or likely.
I think I'm taking likely for the upside.
Okay.
We already said the O Johnson over him, Jatavian Sanders or likely
likely Kyle pits or likely.
Oh God.
I don't even want to ever be asked another question on Kyle pits. It's, it's sadly for me somehow Kyle Pitts and, and I think I'll ever quit this guy.
He's
you have to make the decision right now today, not knowing anything about next
year, Travis Kelsey or Isaiah likely.
Oh, I'll take Isaiah likely with Travis.
I think he's done.
Yeah.
I mean, I think if he comes back, you should probably expect him to be the
borderline top fire tight end he was last year.
Um, he did outscore.
And that's, it shows the position more.
So well, but it shows the disappointment of the guys who play the position.
Right.
Like he out Mark Andrews is standing in Isaiah likely his way.
Travis Kelsey outscored Mark Andrews last year.
All right.
Sam Laporta is the tight end three for everybody in the future of the position.
Travis Kelsey in this terrible he's washed season outscored Sam Laporta last year. We do. Yeah, go ahead. No, I was gonna say even Kyle, when we
were doing our rankings and Jamie does a piece right after the season, we're ranking top 12. I
was like, oh my God, who the heck can I get into my top 12? And I think I had pits at like tight end
12. Like I, NX, like who else do you put in there? Yeah, that's uh, it's not a good look We've got a couple questions for dan and i'll throw my opinion in as well if you're a contender
Would you move rushy rice this offseason worried about the injury and the suspension?
Um, if you're a contender, you're probably moving him for like a win now type player
I like that idea for sure
I think it's not just like the suspension and the injury it It's to me, the uncertainty of that passing game moving forward.
And the fact that I think worthy is a better player.
So if you could turn Rashi rice and a second into AJ Brown, would you do that?
Yes.
Oh yeah.
What about Rashi rice for, we mentioned him earlier, Tyree kill.
Yeah.
As a contender, I would do that.
Terry McLaurin.
Definitely as a contender, I would do that. Terry McLaurin. Definitely.
As a contender, I would do that.
Yeah.
There's some targets for you, Thomas.
We got another question.
One day, by the way, before we do this, Heath, I will say this and we'll get into this question.
One day I want to have a long conversation with you.
I'm sorry.
I didn't mean to cut you out.
No, about rebuilding and the actual value of rebuilding teams, because all of my teams
that I've tried to rebuild on are seem nowhere close to competing.
And I'm now of the belief that picks are not as valuable as people think they are in dynasty.
But this is for another day because I shouldn't have cut you off in the middle of the question.
I apologize.
That's okay.
That's okay.
How possible is it that the Bears draft Gentile at 10 and it's him and Swift.
How is it possible that the bears are up?
Is it possible? Oh, is it possible?
That's what I would, I would consider it highly unlikely that the bears
would that offensive line situation spend the top 10 pick at running back.
What do you think is too, like we talked about at the beginning of the show,
say, Juan Barkley, it was a mistake to draft him that high.
Um, what action Gentie is a generational prospect at running back.
We all agree on that.
What is too high for Ashton Genti this year?
For, for reject we're talking about or for dinosaur?
No, for an NFL team in the NFL draft.
Oh, I missed that.
Um, I don't personally think St.
John Barclay's year really proves anything from a draft standpoint.
Right.
So like too high, I guess for me would be anywhere in the top 10 late in one.
I can do it.
So 11, 12, 13, you're okay with that.
I like it.
I don't love it.
Right.
Would you rather have Kyron Williams or James Cook on your dynasty team? Ooh, I like that. I don't love it. Right. Would you rather have Kyren Williams or James Cook on your dynasty team?
Ooh, I like that question. That's a tough one. I would prefer James Cook,
but I'm the low to low man on the totem pole and Kyren.
It's funny because like volume over everything.
That is the thing that determines how good you are in fantasy.
And I think we should have zero doubt in 2025,
who's going to get more volume,
Kyron Williams or James Cook.
I think it's much more likely that Kyron Williams
leads the NFL in touchdowns next year
than it is James Cook again.
If Stafford's still there, yes.
There's some rumors that Stafford might be on the move.
Who knows if that's true.
But I also think volume over everything is true
if you're on a suitable offense.
Like Najee Harris got a lot of volume this year and it went nowhere.
Right.
The minute Stafford retires, what happens to that offense?
I would assume they just go get Sam Darnold, but I don't know that for sure.
And maybe Sam Darnold wouldn't work in that offense.
I think he probably has shown that he would work in that offense.
I have Kyron Hyre.
He is a top four running back for me.
I am done doubting him.
He just, all he does is put up points and he's still just 25 years old.
But I understand.
I love James Cook and he's also a top 12 dynasty running back for me.
They're both good.
I'd go Kyron.
Dan would go James Cook.
Last question from Jordan half PPR.
I'm sitting on Ken Walker, Christian McCaffrey, Ramondre Stevenson, Jonathan Brooks,
Taijay Spears and Jerome Ford.
By the way, Jerome Ford, somebody who's sneaky by I think,
cause Nick Chubb's not technically on that roster right now
for next year.
They have a lot of holes to fix.
I'm in position to draft Gentie and Hampton.
Who would you try to sell and upgrade elsewhere?
I like the idea of selling Walker right now. I really like the idea of selling Walker out of that team. Look, explosive player really talented. Just don't know necessarily like if we're ever going to get what we expect that if I'm on a consistent basis given the injuries and just kind of like the fact that Charbonneau is behind him and does some things in the run game that Walker can never do based on
his style. So that would be my play. So I'm not selling Ford or Spears. I don't think,
I think it's a bad time to sell Brooks. Yes. I am very, very open to selling Christian McCaffrey
if somebody views him as a sure fire top five running back next year.
Like if you can get one of these contenders to like, they think Christian
McCaffrey is the final piece to going and winning a championship, I'd be happy to
do that.
I, I am really, really nervous about McCaffrey heading in, well, forever now
in dynasty.
And I agree with you, like if you can sell high on Ken Walker, that's great. I'm afraid his value seems to have taken a hit when Zach Charbonnet
looks so good. And like now maybe you can't, you should be able to get at least a first
for Ken Walker, shouldn't you?
I don't think so at this point. You think you would get a first back for him? I doubt
it.
So would you sell him for just a second round pick?
I would probably be looking to sell him for a talented receiver I like
that hasn't gotten off to a hot start in his career. Okay. That's, that's very open-ended.
Let me say it's very specific, but I'm just trying to now of course I want to put a name
on it. And so if I could do like, here's an example of what I would love to do. Walker
and I don't know if you could do it straight up, but the core being
Walker and Romo Dunze, that would be something I would love to get going.
And maybe you have to give more, obviously there you give Walker and a two
or Walker and a three even, but I would love to get a Dunze for Walker type of
thing.
Outstanding job as always, Dan.
Thank you to everybody who sent in your questions.
Thank you to Thomas.
We didn't get to the rookies today.
We will get to the rookies
a lot in the next couple of months. And very, very soon. I've got some guests coming on just
specifically to talk about rookies. So we will talk to you on Friday. The Paramount Podcast.